We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Third Level Education.

Higher education restructuring statement

Summary

The Minister outlines elements of the Government’s higher education decisions and says a fuller statement will explain them, while some details remain subject to further consideration. Exchanges focus on why the reply is more extensive than the previous day’s and whether the decisions are final; the Minister says they form the basis for a White Paper and eventual Bill.

Mr. R. Burke

Arrangements for the publication of the statement are well in hand, but it is not possible at this stage to indicate the precise date of publication.

Fruitful discussions have already taken place, and I have already met a deputation from the NCEA, and have had further discussions with its executive council. The NCEA is not being abolished, but will be reconstituted with functions in planning and co-ordination in the integrated sector, as well as validation of certificates and diplomas in that sector. I am maintaining close contact with the NCEA in relation to commitments entered into by it.

The universities will be the only degree-awarding bodies. Certificates and diplomas in the higher commercial area will be awarded mainly by the Council for Technological Education.

It can be envisaged that a regional technical college might, through the co-ordinating Council for Technological Education, make appropriate arrangements with other institutions for the development and validation of courses suitable for the award of a degree. The decision that a majority of the members of the governing bodies of the National Institutes for Higher Education will be nominated by the Government, on the recommendation of the Minister for Education, will ensure that the priorities established for the development of technological education will be maintained, and that regional technical college interests will be represented on the Council for Technological Education. The range of consultation which my Department will have with the council will be clarified in the detailed statement which I plan to publish.

Comment on this
Deputies

Farce, farce.

Comment on this

This is complete nonsense.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

Arrangements to proceed with the building of the National Institute of Higher Education, Dublin, have already been set in train.

The Government, having considered all the advice available to them, decided to initiate the establishment of the structures necessary to secure the provision of a greater degree of comprehensive education at third level.

The Higher Education Authority did not specifically advert to the matter of a binary system at all. The continuance of a valid binary component in third level education postulates duplication of structures, facilities and personnel. The Higher Education Authority advised, and I quote, "The provision of basic teaching places and laboratory facilities for a course in engineering science at Trinity College must be conditional on that college making appropriate contractual arrangements with University College and the colleges of technology whereby unnecessary duplication of expenditure on staff and expensive facilities will be avoided."

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R.P. Burke Fianna Fáil

On a point of order, surely this is not the correct way to answer 17 questions put down in a reasonable manner?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us hear the reply.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

The authority further advised as follows: "The entire field of engineering education must be seen as an integer. In that regard we would propose to keep under constant review the validity of retaining separate university engineering schools in Dublin." Since the authority's recommendation involved the building of three engineering schools, the Government failed to see how the recommendation could have any effect on the schools once the schools are built.

Comment on this

You may as well adjourn the House until 4 o'clock. Question Time in this House has become a total farce. Adjourn the House until 4 o'clock and we will do without Question Time.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

The Government have decided, therefore, that pending clarification of the extent of the overall requirements for engineering education there should be a moratorium on capital investment in the engineering school in Trinity College.

Because the Government was unable to accept that the proposal that the main centre for the physical sciences be in University College, and the main centre for the biological sciences in Trinity College, was educationally defensible, and taking into consideration the extensive capital investment that science demands, they have decided that co-ordination of the facilities for science is necessary. Details of the structures necessary to achieve this co-ordination of facilities, a joint science faculty, will be included in my comprehensive statement.

This comprehensive statement will also deal with the composition, functions, power and relationships of the conjoint board, including such relationships as may be appropriate with the Royal College of Surgeons.

Comment on this
Deputies

Resign, resign, resign.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

It will set out the reasons why the Government decided that University College, Cork, and University College, Galway, should be constituent colleges of a re-constituted National University of Ireland.

Following my policy decision announced at the INTO congress in Wexford, I initiated discussion between the colleges of education and the universities with a view to ensuring that primary teachers who had successfully completed a three year course would be awarded a university degree. Negotiations towards the achievement of this aim have reached an advanced stage. The colleges of education will become recognised colleges of the universities awarding their degrees, and will be designated institutions for purposes of the Higher Education Authority Act, 1971.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, if the Minister has disgraced himself, you have equally disgraced yourself. You have become a puppet of the Minister and you have made this Parliament irrelevant by your conduct here today.

Comment on this

Will the Minister repeat the answer please?

Comment on this

On a point of information, a Cheann Comhairle, do you really feel that that was an imparting by the Minister for Education of information to this House?

Comment on this

That was a message from the Labour Party office.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, I did not hear the Minister's reply. Would you please ask him to repeat it?

Comment on this

May I ask the Minister if the reply which he gave to this question today is different from the reply which he gave yesterday——

Comment on this

Of course, it is.

Comment on this

——and if it is why is it considering they are the same questions?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

The information available today could have been available yesterday if the Deputies had allowed Question Time to proceed in an orderly fashion.

Comment on this

The question I asked was whether the Minister's reply to-day was different from that given yesterday. Would the Minister answer that question?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

It was a more elaborate statement than that available yesterday.

Comment on this

So it was different. May I ask again why was it that the reply today was different from the reply yesterday when the questions were precisely the same?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

Out of courtesy to the House, which was in such an uproar yesterday, I thought it better, as a matter of courtesy, to try to expand in those areas where it was possible for me to expand. We have been given in this House over the last 40 minutes or so lessons on responsibility. I want to point out to the House that in respect of certain matters which were the subject of the questions it is not open——

Comment on this

Do we have to take lectures on responsibility——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister is replying to a question.

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

——to me to answer because, as the Deputies who have been in Cabinet will know, when White Papers are produced they must be submitted to Cabinet for their approval. Therefore, for me to answer some of those questions would have been to pre-empt the rights of my colleagues to pronounce judgment in certain aspects of the matter. In so far as I have been able to answer the questions I have done so. In so far as I have not been able to answer I have said so in the answer.

Comment on this

Would the Minister explain to the House what has the question of pre-empting the rights of his colleagues in Government got to do with the question I asked him and to which he purported to reply unless there has been a decision by the Government changing decision previously made and announced by the Minister between Question Time yesterday and Question Time today? Is that what the Minister is saying?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

If the Deputy had listened to my answer he would have found out the aspects on which it was not possible to give details.

Comment on this

The Deputy was listening to the Minister's reply just now which purported to be a reply to a question as to why the answer was different today from yesterday. The Minister gave one explanation and then went on to talk about pre-empting the rights of his colleagues which can only make any sense if there has been a change by the Government in their decisions, a thing of which I am not aware and which I do not believe has happened in that short space of time. Would the Minister now explain to the House why he decided, he said as a matter of courtesy to the House, to give a different answer today to the same questions that he had yesterday? Are we to take it from that that the Minister intended yesterday to be discourteous and today to be courteous?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

It is not a different answer, it is a more elaborate answer. I have already explained to the Deputy the respects in which it is not open to me to give answers to the House because of Cabinet responsibility.

Comment on this

I do not want to intervene in this rather unseemly squabble. I have not heard the Minister's reply because it was totally inaudible to everyone in the House. I must ask the Chair to press Deputy Colley's question to the Minister. How was it possible to give an infinitely more lengthy reply today to questions that got only a one-sentence reply yesterday?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

The answer is simple. If the matters which are the subject of these questions will be the subject of a memorandum to be prepared and put before the Government for further elucidation, I cannot pre-empt what the decision of the Government may be with regard to some aspects that have not yet been announced. Therefore, in respect of some of the answers I am not at liberty to reply.

Comment on this

In the Minister's original statement in relation to the new structures for third-level education he stated the decisions were final decisions of the Government. Is he now saying that these decisions were not final and that they will have to be re-examined?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I am saying that the Government decided in the matters which I published. There are other matters that are the subject of questions here which were not published and where decisions may yet have to be reached.

Comment on this

Will the Minister pinpoint the questions which refer to matters not yet decided by the Government?

Comment on this
Mr. R. Burke

I have already done so in the answer I have given to the House.

Comment on this

Just by numbers.

Comment on this