Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Third Level Education.
Contributions 1–133 of 267. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
- UCC and UCG university status 2 speeches
Wilson asks why Cork and Galway are not to become universities in their own right.
John P. Wilson
- Dublin higher education institute construction 1 speech
Wilson asks when construction will begin on the new National Institute of Higher Education in Dublin.
John P. Wilson
- NCEA future and student qualifications 2 speeches
Wilson asks why the NCEA is to be reconstituted and what will happen to students expecting its degrees or diplomas in 1975.
John P. Wilson
- Technical college representation 1 speech
Wilson asks why regional technical colleges will not have representatives on the Council for Technological Education.
John P. Wilson
- Regional college funding consultation 1 speech
Wilson asks how the Department will consult the Council for Technological Education about funding regional technical colleges.
John P. Wilson
- Validation of higher commercial qualifications 1 speech
Wilson asks which body will validate qualifications for higher commercial courses at the new institute and regional colleges.
John P. Wilson
- Regional college degree courses 1 speech
Wilson asks whether regional colleges of technology will offer degree courses through to the final stage.
John P. Wilson
- Government nominations to institute boards 1 speech
Wilson questions why the Government would nominate most members of the National Institutes’ governing bodies.
John P. Wilson
- Binary system and resource duplication 2 speeches
Wilson asks whether retaining a binary third-level system would duplicate scarce resources and whether the Higher Education Authority advised ending it.
John P. Wilson
- Dublin universities joint science faculty 1 speech
Wilson asks what structure is envisaged for the joint science faculty of Dublin’s two universities.
John P. Wilson
- Trinity engineering capital investment 1 speech
Wilson asks what it means for Trinity to have an engineering science faculty without capital investment.
John P. Wilson
- Publication of higher education proposals 1 speech
Wilson asks when the promised detailed statement on higher education proposals will be published.
John P. Wilson
- Primary teacher training arrangements 1 speech
Wilson asks about current primary teacher training and how teachers’ colleges will fit into the new third-level system.
John P. Wilson
- College of Surgeons representation 1 speech
Wilson asks whether the College of Surgeons will sit on the proposed conjoint board.
John P. Wilson
- Dispute over omnibus answers 109 speeches
The Minister seeks permission to answer 17 questions together, prompting a prolonged dispute over the Chair’s authority and whether the approach denies Deputies meaningful scrutiny. The Chair upholds the practice and urges order; the Minister proceeds, while Opposition members protest and demand separate answers.
Richard Burke, John Lynch, Seán Treacy, Deputies, Mr. R. Burke
- Higher education restructuring statement 38 speeches
The Minister outlines elements of the Government’s higher education decisions and says a fuller statement will explain them, while some details remain subject to further consideration. Exchanges focus on why the reply is more extensive than the previous day’s and whether the decisions are final; the Minister says they form the basis for a White Paper and eventual Bill.
Mr. R. Burke, Deputies, Michael O'Kennedy, Ray Burke, Seán Treacy
- UCC and UCG university status 92 speeches
Deputies press the Minister to explain why Cork and Galway will be constituent colleges of a reconstituted National University of Ireland rather than independent universities. He repeatedly defers the reasons to a forthcoming White Paper, confirms the Government’s decision while acknowledging that legislation may be amended, and does not provide the requested rationale.
Charles J. Haughey, Mr. R. Burke, Michael O'Kennedy, John P. Wilson, Desmond J. O'Malley
- End of supplementary questions 11 speeches
Wilson asks whether supplementary questions on the remaining items can continue the next day, but the Chair says the allotted time has expired and gives no assurance.
John P. Wilson, Seán Treacy, Patrick J. Lalor
asked the Minister for Education why University College, Galway, is not being established as a university in its own right.
2.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education why University College, Cork, is not being established as a university in its own right.
3.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education when work will start on the building of the new National Institute of Higher Education in Dublin.
4.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education why he proposes to abolish the National Council for Educational Awards.
5.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education the position of students in colleges of technology who expected to be conferred with degrees or diplomas by the NCEA during 1975.
6.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education why representatives of the regional technical colleges will not be represented on the Council for Technological Education.
7.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education the range of the consultation which his Department will have with the Council for Technological Education with regard to the funding of the regional colleges of technology.
8.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education the body that will validate third level qualifications for higher commercial courses of the National Institute for Higher Education and the regional technical colleges.
9.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if he envisages degree courses to final stage for the regional colleges of technology.
10.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education why the majority of the members of the governing bodies of the National Institutes for Higher Education must be nominated by the Government.
11.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education the duplication of scarce resources which would ensure from maintaining the binary system of third-level education.
12.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if the Higher Education Authority advised the Government to end the binary system of third-level education.
13.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if he will outline the structures envisaged by him for the joint science faculty of the two universities in Dublin.
14.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education the precise meaning of the sentence which states that TCD shall have a faculty of engineering science but without capital investment.
15.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education when he will publish the detailed statement on his proposals for higher education as promised on 16th December, 1974.
16.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if he will make a statement on the present arrangements for the training of primary teachers; and if he will indicate how the teachers' colleges will fit into the new third-level education schemes.
17.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Education if the College of Surgeons will be represented on the conjoint board envisaged in his proposals for third-level education.
Comment on this
Having received your permission, a Cheann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 1 to 17 together——
Comment on this
On a point of order, is the Minister correct in the preface to his omnibus answer to his series of questions, the preface "Having received your permission, a Cheann Comhairle"?
Comment on this
It is proposed to give permission again to-day. In that event, I object on behalf of my party to your giving this permission. I suggest that the very use of the words that "with your permission" the Minister proposes to answer a question in a certain way implies that that permission may be given or withheld. With due respect, I would suggest to you, Sir, that that permission ought to be withheld in the circumstances in which we find ourselves today with a Minister answering a series of some 17 question in one omnibus answer. I accept entirely that the Minister may make a comprehensive written answer to a number of questions that seek to elicit the same information. But I suggest, Sir, that you should not use your discretion to permit the Minister to answer this series of questions in that fashion, many of them seeking specific information, information of a type that, having heard as well as I could what the Minister proposed to say yesterday, is not being given. In these circumstances I suggest that the Minister should be directed to answer these questions separately, or combining a number of them, but certainly not combining every one of them. I formally now put it to you that you ought to withhold your permission to answer the questions collectively, as the Minister has asked.
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Lynch, may I say that it has been ruled on a number of occasions by my predecessors that the Chair has no control over the number of questions which a Minister takes together? For the purpose of giving a single reply to them, the request of the Minister for permission to reply to two or more questions together is merely a courtesy to the Chair and relates to the fact that the Chair calls only one question at a time. There are many precedents for this. It is a well established practice in this House over a very long period of time. In the circumstances, Deputy Lynch, I would not be justified in departing from that procedure.
Comment on this
I want to make another suggestion to you, Sir, in reply to your statement that the words "with your permission" are used only out of courtesy to the Chair, because normally he is disposed to calling questions individually. In that event, Sir, I think the words "with your permission" should be dispensed with in any case because a Minister is free, therefore, to answer as many questions as he likes in order—as is obvious in this case—to withhold information from the House.
Now, there are two good reasons why these questions should not be permitted to be answered in the form that the Minister proposes. In the first instance, as I have already indicated, there are specific pieces of information sought here which the Minister, as well as I can anticipate, does not propose to give. There is no reason why they should not be given. The subject matter of each one of these questions, in the custom of the House, will be ruled out as the subject matter of questions for a period of six months. In other words, whatever statement the Minister is going to issue at a later date may or may not contain answers to the specific questions now put. As well as that, it will mean that he will be free, without this House having the opportunity to put questions to him, to delay any statement on a matter of such public importance as long as he likes up to the limit of that period of six months before another question on the subject matter can be properly put.
I want to put another point to you, Sir. You say, probably rightly, that you have not control over the subject matter of the answer to the questions. I accept that entirely. You say also that there is ample precedent for a Minister putting a lot of questions together for the purpose of giving a single answer. I accept that, Sir, but I would suggest to you that this is done only where the type of information sought in each question is similar, almost similar or exactly similar. In these cases, Sir, I think it is perfectly justified that a Minister should seek to answer a number of questions together.
Thirdly, Sir, I want to put this to you, especially in the context of your saying that you have no responsibility for the subject matter of the answers: the Minister is responsible to this House. He was elected by the Members of this House; he was nominated by the Taoiseach, but elected to his office by the Members of this House. The Members of this House were elected to their particular positions on behalf of the people and it is not only their duty, their function, but their right to elicit answers to questions of public importance. The Minister is denying to the elected representatives of the people, in the manner in which he proposes to answer these questions, that information.
Again, I want you to reconsider, in the light of what I have said, the permission you have given to the Minister to answer these questions.
Comment on this
Many of the things to which Deputy Lynch has referred would obviously require some amendment of Standing Orders. I want to allay his anxiety in respect of repeat questions, to which he has adverted. A repeat of an earlier question is disallowed if tabled within six months of the answer to the original question. But this rule does not apply where the circumstances have changed in the meantime. For instance, if the Minister, or a Minister, takes a decision on issues or issues a statement in relation to the matters in the answer to the question or questions, questions are allowable in relation to the decision or the statement. So that if a statement or an action is taken in the interim, within the six months' period, questions would be allowable.
Comment on this
May I again respectfully suggest that that implies a situation in which the Minister will make a public statement on the subject matter of these questions. I put it to you again that the Minister is now free, within the rules of the House, to delay such a public statement for six months and that if he should not make a public statement within that period Deputies are precluded, without any redress, from putting questions of the type put by Deputy Wilson and, I suggest, by Deputy Thornley for that whole period.
Comment on this
That is the position in which the Chair finds itself. That is the usual procedure. I would ask Deputies to abide by the ruling of the Chair on this occasion. Let us hear the reply. Let us have relevant supplementaries and let us deal with Question Time in the normal fashion.
Comment on this
I appeal for the co-operation of Deputies. If there is a strong opinion that there should be a change in respect of this whole matter, I suggest that the issue might be raised at Procedure and Privileges where an agreement could be reached as to how these matters should be disposed of in the future. But the Chair is conforming with tradition, practice and precedent and does not consider itself free to deviate from that situation.
Comment on this
I appreciate your position but I suggest that you have discretion in so far as the Minister asks you to exercise discretion. You have exercised that discretion in his favour and against the interests of the Deputies who put down these questions. Yesterday, Sir, you indicated that you would not give any undertaking in advance as to the number of supplementaries that might be asked.
Comment on this
Having regard to the manner in which, normally, you exercise that discretion, we envisage that, if the Minister answers the questions in the manner he proposes to answer them, after five or six supplementaries you would proceed with the other questions and that, therefore, adequate supplementary questioning would be ruled out.
Comment on this
As there are 17 questions involved the Chair proposes to deal generously with the supplementaries.
Comment on this
I have taken issue with you, Sir, but yesterday a reasonable suggestion was made to the Minister by a Member from this side of the House. Having regard to what happened yesterday I suggest that the Minister rewrite his answers individually or, perhaps, collectively, in a more modified way. I appeal formally to the Minister to do that and to avoid further recrimination in this House.
Comment on this
I have accepted your discretion, a Cheann Comhairle, and I intend to proceed with my reply.
Comment on this
Therefore, as my protest individually to your refusal to exercise a discretion that I suggest you have, but particularly because of the manner in which the Minister proposes to answer these questions, I propose to withdraw from the House for the duration of the Minister's answer.
Comment on this
Before the Deputy leaves I would reiterate that the Chair has no discretion in respect of Ministers' replies; that the Chair never had such discretion and that it would place the Chair in an intolerable position to be made responsible for Ministers' replies or for the manner in which they are dealt with. I assure the Deputy that I am anxious to deal fairly and impartially in this whole matter but if I am prescribed by Standing Orders and precedents, Members should appreciate that situation.
Comment on this
In deference to you, Sir, I limit my purpose of withdrawal to a mark of my disapproval of the manner in which the Minister proposes to answer these questions. In withdrawing I am leaving strict instructions with the members of my party that they are to continue with supplementary questions, if necessary, on this matter but to do so in an orderly manner, as I know will be the case. In the meantime I shall allow the Minister have his way, if that is what he wants.
Comment on this
Perhaps this is a hypothetical question but if, say, there were 243 questions on the Order Paper and if a Minister proposed to answer the entire lot by way of one reply, could the Chair prevent him from so doing?
Comment on this
I understand and appreciate the procedural difficulty in so far as the Chair is concerned and I have sympathy for him in that regard. However, I tabled a set of questions which were prompted by what happened on 16th December. That was the date on which this document was issued to the Press with a great flourish of trumpets. Why, for example, is Question No. 12 included in the lumping answer while Question No. 18 is not included although the latter is on precisely the same subject?
Comment on this
I am not to have a sense of grievance but can I have an explanation as to why Question No. 12 is to be included in the lumping answer while Question No. 18 which deals with the same subject is to be excluded?
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that the Chair cannot answer these questions. They are questions, primarily, for the Minister.
Comment on this
I know that the Chair appreciates the importance of the subject matter of these questions because you admitted so yesterday. It is not my wish to incur the displeasure either of the Chair or of the House but I am in pursuit of knowledge regarding a very important issue and a short lumping answer to these questions which were framed after careful reading of the proposals will not satisfy the House nor the country. Therefore, I appeal to the Minister, through you, to give a full and adequate answer to each question individually.
Comment on this
The Deputy will recall that when financing the Government's decision on higher education I said that my immediate——
Comment on this
The Chair has ruled that the Minister may reply to the questions he has outlined in a single reply. The Chair's decision in that regard must be accepted. Therefore, I ask the House to hear the reply. Then, let us have the supplementary questions when the Chair will facilitate Deputies in eliciting as much information as possible on these questions. As usual, supplementaries must be relevant, must contain no argument and must not tend to speech-making, but let us hear the reply and deal with the matter in a responsible way.
Comment on this
On a point of order, neither I nor anybody on this side of the House wishes to come into conflict with the Chair. We wish to make it clear that we are not in any conflict with the Chair but we are in conflict with the Minister for Education.
Comment on this
As a Minister who is answerable to this House, he refuses to reply to the legitimate query of the elected representatives of the people in this Parliament. The sooner we realise that the better. The fact that the Minister refuses to stand over his proposals, refuses to answer in relation to them to the elected representatives of the people, is the greatest possible indictment of him and is a far greater indictment than if he were to attempt to answer and answer badly. Through you, Sir, we must assert our rights as representatives of the people to question a member of the Executive of the country.
Comment on this
This is the only place in which we can do this lawfully. According to the Constitution we have these rights and we must insist on being allowed to exercise them.
Comment on this
Your duty is to ensure that we, as Members of this Parliament, are given the rights which the Constitution of Ireland and the votes of the people have given us. It is your duty to ensure that we have the opportunity to exercise that right and to exercise it in a dignified and a quite fashion at Question Time. We have no wish to see this Parliament reduced to a rabble but, unfortunately, if we are not allowed to exercise our rights the Chair must accept some part of the responsibility for any disorder that may occur.
Comment on this
Would the Chair not agree that the Leader of this party made a reasonable appeal to the Minister but that that appeal was turned down with an arrogant nod?
Comment on this
Yesterday I requested the Minister to withdraw the answer in its present form and to come back in here today or tomorrow with answer to the individual questions. Again I urge him to do this. I served in that Department for three-and-a-half years and——
Comment on this
——I found that courtesy to the Opposition helped myself and the cause of education. I suggest that being courteous to the Opposition would not only help the Minister personally but would also help the cause of education. Again I appeal to him to withdraw the answer as it is at present and reply to each question individually.
Comment on this
We are now 20 minutes into Question Time. I appeal to the House to utilise the time for questions more effectively.
Comment on this
On a point of order, it has been pointed out from this side of the House that what the Minister indicated he intends doing is a gross dereliction of duty on his part and breach of responsibility to the House.
Comment on this
On a point of order, Sir, I have not had the opportunity of pointing anything out to the House yet.
Comment on this
Am I right in saying that the Minister has already indicated to the House today that he proposes to answer Questions Nos. 1 to 17 together? Is it not a fact——
Comment on this
——that Question No. 2 requires a "Yes" or "No" answer and cannot in any reasonable sense be lumped in with the other matters? What is involved here is a serious principle.
Comment on this
This is more serious than a breach of Standing Orders. It is a breach of the democratic rights of the elected representatives of our people. We do not intend to allow the Minister for Education, aided and abetted by his colleagues or anybody else, to get away with this.
Comment on this
Members must desist from speech making. Points of order have been raised which clearly were not points of order. The Chair has ruled that the Minister is entitled to take the questions in the manner outlined and I am asking that we now hear the reply.
Comment on this
The Deputy will recall that when announcing the Government's decisions on higher education——
Comment on this
Would the Ceann Comhairle agree that proposals which are supposed to be final and not subject to debate should be clear in the Minister's mind? If, as he said originally at the Press conference, he was not in a position to debate these proposals, would the Chair not agree that specific answers should be available to specific questions?
Comment on this
I have made it clear that what is involved here is far more serious than a breach of the Standing Orders. We do not intend to aid and abet the Minister in the gross breach of the democratic rights——
Comment on this
No, Sir, as far as I am concerned the Minister will not get any assistance from this side of the House——
Comment on this
I said that my immediate concern was to inform the public of these decisions and that I plan to issue a more detailed statement later.
Comment on this
According to the reasonable suggestion made by Deputy Faulkner, why could the Minister not postpone these questions until he could give full answers and thereby give satisfaction to the House and the country? This would be a very simple thing to do.
Comment on this
The Minister has taken the attitude that he will treat with contempt any questions on his proposal. Monosyllabic mutterings were the only response to Deputy Lynch's appeal.
Comment on this
I appeal to Deputy Wilson to let us hear the Minister's reply. He is in order in replying to the question.
Comment on this
On what I hope you will accept as a reasonable point of order, Sir, you indicated that you intended to allow Members on this side of the House the opportunity of asking supplementary questions. What guarantee can you give to the Members that these supplementary questions will be answered?
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that he is prepared to give answers to supplementary questions.
Comment on this
The function of the Chair is to vindicate the right of all Deputies and not just to vindicate the Minister in his undemocratic action.
Comment on this
The Minister indicated that he is prepared to answer supplementary questions. Why does he not do the correct thing and answer the questions separately? We have spent 30 minutes on this.
Comment on this
The Deputy will recall that when announcing the Government's decisions on higher education——
Comment on this
——I said that my immediate concern was to inform the public of these decisions and that I plan to issue a more detailed statement later. I propose to incorporate in that statement, which is in course of preparation, clarification in relation to the decisions already announced and the points raised by the Deputy.
Comment on this
No matter how loudly the Minister may speak or how much the Chair helps him to conduct himself in an undemocratic fashion, we will not allow him to hide behind the Chair. You, Sir, are a party to the arrogant display by the Minister. What are you going to do about it? Are you going to sit there and be guided by him?
Comment on this
The Deputy is attacking the Chair. I have explained the Chair's position in this matter which was accepted by the leader of your Party. The Deputy should not attack the Chair in this disgraceful fashion.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister a question? I gather that the Minister purported to give the complete answers to these questions. If the Chair thinks this is discharging responsibilities of this House, that an answer of that length which he seems to have attempted to give is adequate to reply to 17 questions, then the Chair must consider its responsibility to the democratic institutions of this State.
Comment on this
I am prepared to answer supplementary questions when I have finished my answer.
Comment on this
If the Minister is prepared to answer supplementary questions why does he not answer the questions of which he has had notice?
Comment on this
Because I have got the permission of the Ceann Comhairle to take them together.
Comment on this
Each question is different and should be answered separately. They cannot be lumped together because they are unrelated.
Comment on this
Does the Chair not agree that the attitude of the Minister is totally unreasonable if he is prepared to answer supplementary questions of which he has no notice but is not prepared to answer written questions of which he has a week's notice?
Comment on this
I have pointed out to the Chair before and I have to do it again, in fairness to this institution, that your duty, as Chairman of this House, is to vindicate the rights of Members of this House.
Comment on this
I will not be lectured by the Deputy. The Chair has explained his position and will not be threatened or intimidated by either side of this House.
Comment on this
I propose to incorporate in that statement, which is in course of preparation, clarification in relation to the decisions already announced and the points raised by the Deputy.
Comment on this
There is much talk nowadays about the irrelevance of Parliament. Surely, a Cheann Comhairle, this is an example of Parliament being deliberately made irrelevant and you are responsible if you are allowing it to happen.
Comment on this
Arrangements for the publication of the statement are well in hand, but it is not possible at this stage to indicate the precise date of publication.
Fruitful discussions have already taken place, and I have already met a deputation from the NCEA, and have had further discussions with its executive council. The NCEA is not being abolished, but will be reconstituted with functions in planning and co-ordination in the integrated sector, as well as validation of certificates and diplomas in that sector. I am maintaining close contact with the NCEA in relation to commitments entered into by it.
The universities will be the only degree-awarding bodies. Certificates and diplomas in the higher commercial area will be awarded mainly by the Council for Technological Education.
It can be envisaged that a regional technical college might, through the co-ordinating Council for Technological Education, make appropriate arrangements with other institutions for the development and validation of courses suitable for the award of a degree. The decision that a majority of the members of the governing bodies of the National Institutes for Higher Education will be nominated by the Government, on the recommendation of the Minister for Education, will ensure that the priorities established for the development of technological education will be maintained, and that regional technical college interests will be represented on the Council for Technological Education. The range of consultation which my Department will have with the council will be clarified in the detailed statement which I plan to publish.
Comment on this
Arrangements to proceed with the building of the National Institute of Higher Education, Dublin, have already been set in train.
The Government, having considered all the advice available to them, decided to initiate the establishment of the structures necessary to secure the provision of a greater degree of comprehensive education at third level.
The Higher Education Authority did not specifically advert to the matter of a binary system at all. The continuance of a valid binary component in third level education postulates duplication of structures, facilities and personnel. The Higher Education Authority advised, and I quote, "The provision of basic teaching places and laboratory facilities for a course in engineering science at Trinity College must be conditional on that college making appropriate contractual arrangements with University College and the colleges of technology whereby unnecessary duplication of expenditure on staff and expensive facilities will be avoided."
Comment on this
On a point of order, surely this is not the correct way to answer 17 questions put down in a reasonable manner?
Comment on this
The authority further advised as follows: "The entire field of engineering education must be seen as an integer. In that regard we would propose to keep under constant review the validity of retaining separate university engineering schools in Dublin." Since the authority's recommendation involved the building of three engineering schools, the Government failed to see how the recommendation could have any effect on the schools once the schools are built.