UCC and UCG university status
Deputies press the Minister to explain why Cork and Galway will be constituent colleges of a reconstituted National University of Ireland rather than independent universities. He repeatedly defers the reasons to a forthcoming White Paper, confirms the Government’s decision while acknowledging that legislation may be amended, and does not provide the requested rationale.
Will the Minister state why UCG is not being established as a university in its own right?
Comment on this
I have already answered that question in the basis of my reply. I can repeat the answer I have given for the Deputy. In the comprehensive statement the reasons will be set out why the Government decided that University College, Cork, and University College, Galway, should be constituent colleges of a reconstituted National University of Ireland.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if it was due to academic reasons? Was he not satisfied with the academic standards? Was it because of lack of numbers? Was he not satisfied with the number of people in the college when he put the proposals and had them accepted by the Government that UCG would not be constituted a university in its own right?
Comment on this
In reply to Deputy Haughey's question, I have said the comprehensive statement I am preparing and submitting to the Government will set out the reasons. In advance of the publication of the White Paper I am not prepared to say.
Comment on this
If the Minister had sufficient reason to recommend a certain course of action to the Government upon which the Government had acted, and if they came to decisions that will not be changed according to the Minister, why can he not briefly tell us now the reasons?
Comment on this
I have said the reasons why the Government decided to reconstitute the National University of Ireland will be set out. When the comprehensive statement is published these matters will become clear.
Comment on this
According to the Minister's statement we understand the Government have already decided that UCG will not be a university in its own right. One assumes from that that the Government on that basis discussed the considerations in this matter. Is the Minister telling us that he will go back to the Government now and advise them of the reasons that, in fact, have already been considered by the Government in coming to their decision?
Comment on this
I have already said that the reasons will be set out when the White Paper is published in the near future.
Comment on this
It is a Government decision. I have said so on a few occasions.
Comment on this
Now the Minister is saying he will submit the reasons to the Government for decision.
Comment on this
Is the Minister at this point aware of the reasons why UCG is not being established as a university in its own right?
Comment on this
Will the Deputy refer to particular reasons of which I am supposed to be aware? There are a number of reasons.
Comment on this
The Minister for Education has indicated that the reasons UCG is not being established as a university in its own right will be published in a comprehensive statement? Is that correct?
Comment on this
That is correct. I will publish a statement as soon as possible but until then Deputies will have to be patient.
Comment on this
Is the Minister at this point aware of the reasons which will be published in this comprehensive statement?
Comment on this
I am aware of a number of reasons. Other members of the Government are aware of other reasons. All of them will be published——
Comment on this
The important thing is that a decision has been taken. The reasons for the decision are not as important as the fact that the decision has been taken. It might be useful to the House if we could know from the Opposition if the decision, for example, in relation to the Dental Hospital in Cork which under their Government was not proceeded with would have been proceeded with had they remained in office.
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that he is aware of the reasons why UCG is not being established as a university in its own right. Will the Chair please ask the Minister to tell me those reasons of which he is aware?
Comment on this
The Government will publish the reasons in a paper that will be published at a later stage.
Comment on this
The Minister has taken a certain course of action. He is aware of the reasons why that course of action was taken. I submit he has no alternative but to give me those reasons now.
Comment on this
Can I dissuade Deputies from repeating supplementary questions? Repetition is not in order.
Comment on this
There is nothing repetitive about this. The Minister has indicated there are reasons. He is aware of those reasons and I am asking him what they are. I am asking him to disclose them to me now in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I have said on a number of occasions that the reasons will be published when I have had an opportunity of putting the White Paper to the Government and then publishing it.
Comment on this
Will the Minister state at what stage any suggestions arose that the colleges in Cork and Galway would form one university rather than separate universities? Will he state from whom the proposals came?
Comment on this
I do not feel obliged to tell the Deputy from whom the suggestion came.
Comment on this
Will the Minister say if the reason UCG is not being established as a university in its own right is the same reason why UCC is not being established as a university in its own right? Will the Minister not agree that there is a certain element of metropolitan thinking in the whole treatment of UCG and UCC?
Comment on this
If Deputies will await publication of the reasons they will see if there is or if there is not.
Comment on this
Will the Minister state if the Government have taken decisions among which was the decision not to have a single university in Galway? According to the Minister's statement——
Comment on this
The Government decided there should be a National University of Ireland of which UCG and UCC would be constituent colleges.
Comment on this
The Government have taken a decision whereby there will not be a single university in Galway. Is the Minister now telling us that he is about to inform the Government of the reasons for the decision they have already taken, according to the Minister's statement some weeks ago?
Comment on this
The members of the Cabinet would be aware of the reasons which led them to make a decision.
Comment on this
But the Minister is telling the House that he has to inform the Government first. This is farcical.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the staffs in UCG and UCC find the "snail" procedure attaching to the National University of Ireland idea very frustrating when they want to set up a new structure? Was this taken into consideration when the Minister and the Government were coming to this conclusion about the establishment of another national university?
Comment on this
The Government are aware of the necessity of a new National University of Ireland. The Deputies should not draw the conclusion that it will be in all respects an exact replica of the existing one.
Comment on this
Would the Minister state if he had consultations with the Higher Education Authority, Cork University and Galway University before coming to a decision to form one university of the two colleges?
Comment on this
That is the subject matter of a further question on the Order Paper. Perhaps we could pursue that one at that stage.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Minister whether or not I detect in his statement an effort by him to disassociate from what he has said is a Government decision and that he, if he were handling it on his own, would have made different decisions?
Comment on this
The Deputy should be wiser than to ask me questions of that nature. Obviously I am a member of a Cabinet and I accept the principle of Cabinet responsibility.
Comment on this
On the general question it might be helpful to the Members opposite when I refer to such things as the reasons why the Government decide in a certain fashion, if they realise that the White Paper which the Government will publish will be brought before the Dáil for its consideration at that stage. They will not alone have an opportunity of seeing what is in it but of debating its contents in this House, if they would only let me get on with the job of dealing with it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept that in his statement he referred to what was the finalised decision of the Government on this matter?
Comment on this
I said that these were not proposals for further discussion, that they were decisions and that, in so far as Government decisions are final, these were final. I also pointed out in numerous interviews that if, when the Bill is brought into this House, consequent on the publication of the White Paper the Opposition, or indeed the Government, wish to put down amendments in the light of proposals then obtaining, they could do so. Only to that extent are they final. I want to clear away any impression that might be held by the public that these were a further set of proposals for a further set of merry-go-round discussions— that in fact the Government had decided. May I point out that this matter has been the subject of discussion for upwards of 15 or 16 years and that I have only been in office about 18 months. In 18 months we have got out decisions. In the 16 years of the previous Government's tenure of office they did not get out decisions.
Comment on this
Does the Minister now propose withdrawing the word "final"? Would he indicate if any firm decisions at all have been made?
Comment on this
I have already explained that to the Deputy and there is no need to go back over it.
Comment on this
The Minister has not. Could I ask him whether or not, in respect of the statement which he made on 16th December, any decision conveyed to the public there is final?
Comment on this
In so far as the Government have decided in the matters, in so far as these will form the basis of a White Paper and in so far as the White Paper will form the basis of a Bill to be brought before the Dáil, they are final. That does not mean that the legislative processes of this State cannot amend them, as I have said on quite a number of occasions over the last month.
Comment on this
Could the Minister tell us how much the Government have decided? The Minister is engaging in gobbledegook in so far as the Government have decided. Can the Taoiseach, as Head of the Government, tell us exactly what has been decided, if anything has been decided, because that is what is very doubtful?
Comment on this
It is known what has been decided. I have already published the decisions of the Government and they are there for everybody to see.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not agree that to state that a decision so fundamental as the decision that University College, Galway, and University College, Cork, will not be made separate universities, that there can be no negotiation on that and then thereafter to suggest that it is subject to amendment on the Committee Stage of a Bill in the House is slightly contradictory?
Comment on this
Not necessarily so. The Deputy will be aware that, as I said in my reply, I am in contact with quite a number of interests, such as the NCEA, the board of Trinity College, the heads of the Irish universities, next Monday the Dublin Vocational Education Committee and others who are coming to see me. From these various people we will get an input of ideas and I will take cognisance of these, but the board parameters of the decisions are already visible and they will remain so.
Comment on this
How are decisions not negotiable but at the same time one takes cognisance of representations which may be contrary to the decisions which were not negotiable? I am a very ignorant man. I do not want to sound illogical but I do not understand the logic of that.
Comment on this
What Deputy Thornley should realise is that the decision to constitute a new National University of Ireland has been taken. The exact form of the charter, the number of members on particular bodies, what will be the recognised colleges or constituent colleges, all these matters are the subject of continuing discussions, not in fact the question of which will be the constituent colleges because one college has an option as to whether it will go into the new National University of Ireland or go in another direction towards one of the Dublin colleges. These are all matters to which I am giving urgent attention; but the broad decision, I repeat, has been taken to constitute a new National University of Ireland.
Comment on this
If, as the Minister has stated, he knows some of the reasons the Government made a final decision not to establish UCG as a university in its own right and refuses to give reasons to the House, can I ask him why he refused to give those reasons to the House?
Comment on this
Not alone do I know some of them, but I know all of them.
Comment on this
The Minister is learning. Ten minutes ago he knew only some of them; now he knows all of them.
Comment on this
Other Ministers put their input into the discussions and I put mine into the discussions. In so far as I was responsible for some of them and not for others, I am aware of all of them.
Comment on this
In so far as the Minister is now aware either of some or of all of the reasons for not establishing University College, Galway, as a university in its own right, will he tell us why he will not tell us some, or all, of the reasons? Will he give us three of the reasons, assuming there are six?
Comment on this
I hope to publish a White Paper very shortly and these reasons will be set out, as I have already said.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell us why he will not give us the reasons now? Why have we to wait six months, 12 months, or whatever it is, for a White Paper?
Comment on this
I have already answered that question on a number of occasions.
Comment on this
Because they are being set out in a White Paper.
Comment on this
After all, those Members who were in the Cabinet previously should realise the question of Cabinet responsibility.
Comment on this
As we are still on Questions Nos. 1 and 2, would the Minister say if the different social and industrial backgrounds in Cork and Galway were taken into consideration in reaching this decision? Why was it the exact same decision about the two colleges?
Comment on this
When this Government make decisions about any matter all the factors are taken into consideration.
Comment on this
Is the Minister for Education aware of, and accepting, his responsibility as a Minister to reply to questions in this House relating to the discharge of his functions?
Comment on this
My question is not finished yet. If he is so aware and does so accept, would he explain to the House why it is he feels justified in not giving to the House information properly sought which he says he has available? Could I ask him not to tell us again that the reason is he proposes to publish a White Paper which contains it, because that is not an answer? The question is this. If the Minister has the information and the question is properly asked, would he explain how he justifies, having regard to his responsibilities as a Minister, not furnishing that information to the House?
Comment on this
The short answer to that is I am not going to give the White Paper in instalments in answer to questions like that.
Comment on this
Does the Minister realise just how stupid that reply is, having regard to his responsibility as a Minister?
Comment on this
I will not take any lecturing on Cabinet responsibility from Fianna Fáil.