Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Beef and Beef Products.
- EEC consultations on beef imports 16 speeches
The Minister said the Commission discussed relaxing the import ban with the Advisory Committee but did not consult the Management Committee, and was not bound to accept advice. He cited pressure to restore trade with third countries, said the Council could amend the decision by qualified majority, and noted that a veto could not apply.
Hugh Gibbons, Mark A. Clinton, James M. Gibbons, John Callanan, Brendan Crinion
- Beef import criteria and Community supply 10 speeches
The Minister said 1975 estimates showed Community beef supply would somewhat exceed demand; the Commission nevertheless cited reopening trade channels and broader commercial policy as grounds for imports. Deputies challenged this as contrary to Community preference and the Treaty, while the Minister said the decision was within treaty limits.
Hugh Gibbons, Mark A. Clinton, James M. Gibbons, John Callanan
- Arrangements for surplus beef 6 speeches
Asked how heavy killings from August would be absorbed, the Minister cited intervention and sales to third countries; the Deputy sought to raise the matter on the Adjournment.
Brendan Crinion, Mark A. Clinton, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if the EEC Commission sought the advice of the advisory consultative committee for beef and veal on the necessity for the importation of beef and beef products in the near future; and, if so, the recommendation offered.
12.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if the opinions given to the EEC Commission by the management committee for beef and veal that the importation of beef and beef products from third countries in the near future was justified, was based on a unanimous decision.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 11 and 12 together. I understand that the Commission did hold some discussions with the Advisory Committee on Beef and Veal on the relaxation of the import ban, but my Department was in no way involved. The Commission, prior to its recent decisions, had no obligation to, and did not in fact consult the Management Committee for Beef and Veal. Such decisions by the Commission may, however, be examined by the Council of Ministers and may be amended or rescinded by a qualified majority. The Commission's decisions to resume certain imports were examined by the Council last week, as I have indicated in my reply to another question today by Deputy James Gibbons.
Comment on this
From what source do the Commission obtain their information on which to base their decision?
Comment on this
The Commission are not obliged to do any more than they have done. They have the power and the authority to do it in the way they have done, and even if they look for advice from this advisory body they need not necessarily accept this advice.
Comment on this
It appears as if they are speaking in a vacuum. Surely there is somebody amongst them who knows about the sale of beef and veal in those matters and advice can be obtained from them? Where does this information come from? I understood from the literature supplied to me that they received this information from this management committee, but the Minister's statement seems to suggest that there is still another group in the Commission's office dealing with this problem. If there is some effort should be made to identify them to the Irish public.
Comment on this
It is not entirely the supply or the sale of beef they are concerning themselves with; it is over-all Community trade which comes into the matter very much. I would say that was the main pressure.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister to define what he means by "overall community trade" with reference to beef and veal production? Is it another new phrase which we will have to be using in the future?
Comment on this
The Deputy must know that many of the member States get raw materials from some of the countries that previously sold beef or cattle to them and were excluded by the ban. They wanted this normal trade to be resumed and these were the sort of pressures that were on so that this could happen.
Comment on this
Is this not contrary to the Treaty of Rome? We all understood that while there was meat within the market this importation from Third Countries could not take place. Apparently, this big market is only at our disposal when it suits some countries but they break it when it suits themselves.
Comment on this
There is always the fear of counter measures being taken by other traders on the world scene against people in the Community, and that has to be balanced. I have opposed this to the extent that it was possible for me as a Minister representing a member State.
Comment on this
I can only put this to a vote and they are entitled to get it on a majority decision.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he has been presented with statistics by the EEC which indicate the anticipated production and consumption of beef and beef products within the EEC for each coming month to the end of March, 1976; and if he will indicate the criteria on which the justification for the importation of beef from Third Countries was based.
Comment on this
Statistics of estimated production and consumption of beef and veal for the year 1975 have been given to member governments at management committee level. They indicate that supply will exceed demand somewhat for the Community as a whole in 1975. As regards the second part of the question, the agricultural Commissioner indicated to the Council of Ministers that the Commission's decision was made to respond to the need for a reopening of trade channels in cattle and beef and to avoid triggering situations which would affect unfavourably the Community's general commercial policy.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not agree that if we are now faced with the situation where there will be an over supply of beef in the market and that beef is being imported from Third Countries, this is contrary to what we were promised under EEC conditions? Does the Minister agree that if our beef market is at the mercy of other commodities from other countries we are finding ourselves in a vice from which we may not be able to extract ourselves? This is a situation which nobody who asked the people of Ireland to vote to join the EEC envisaged at that time.
Comment on this
We did not get the specific undertakings the Deputy mentioned in negotiating the Treaty of Accession.
Comment on this
Is it not a breach of the Treaty of Rome? Are we going away from the principle which we put to the people?
Comment on this
There are times when it is hard to see where the community preference is being honoured but, nevertheless, they are not in breach.
Comment on this
What is the justification for this quid pro quo in importing so many tons of beef and exporting so many tons? How can this justify the trade otherwise? Is the Minister assured that more beef is likely to be imported rather than exported from the EEC in view of the difficulties we have of exporting beef?
Comment on this
In view of the fact that there was over-production of beef in the Community in 1974 what arrangements is the Minister making to absorb the heavy killings that will take place from August onwards so that there will not be a repetition of what happened last year?
Comment on this
In view of the unsatisfactory nature of the reply I wish to raise this matter on the Adjournment.