Beef import criteria and Community supply
The Minister said 1975 estimates showed Community beef supply would somewhat exceed demand; the Commission nevertheless cited reopening trade channels and broader commercial policy as grounds for imports. Deputies challenged this as contrary to Community preference and the Treaty, while the Minister said the decision was within treaty limits.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he has been presented with statistics by the EEC which indicate the anticipated production and consumption of beef and beef products within the EEC for each coming month to the end of March, 1976; and if he will indicate the criteria on which the justification for the importation of beef from Third Countries was based.
Comment on this
Statistics of estimated production and consumption of beef and veal for the year 1975 have been given to member governments at management committee level. They indicate that supply will exceed demand somewhat for the Community as a whole in 1975. As regards the second part of the question, the agricultural Commissioner indicated to the Council of Ministers that the Commission's decision was made to respond to the need for a reopening of trade channels in cattle and beef and to avoid triggering situations which would affect unfavourably the Community's general commercial policy.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not agree that if we are now faced with the situation where there will be an over supply of beef in the market and that beef is being imported from Third Countries, this is contrary to what we were promised under EEC conditions? Does the Minister agree that if our beef market is at the mercy of other commodities from other countries we are finding ourselves in a vice from which we may not be able to extract ourselves? This is a situation which nobody who asked the people of Ireland to vote to join the EEC envisaged at that time.
Comment on this
We did not get the specific undertakings the Deputy mentioned in negotiating the Treaty of Accession.
Comment on this
Is it not a breach of the Treaty of Rome? Are we going away from the principle which we put to the people?
Comment on this
There are times when it is hard to see where the community preference is being honoured but, nevertheless, they are not in breach.
Comment on this
What is the justification for this quid pro quo in importing so many tons of beef and exporting so many tons? How can this justify the trade otherwise? Is the Minister assured that more beef is likely to be imported rather than exported from the EEC in view of the difficulties we have of exporting beef?