Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - VAT Receipts.
- VAT receipts from Irish newspapers 4 speeches
The Minister said VAT returns do not separately identify newspaper sales, and taxpayer secrecy prevents disclosing the liability of the small group involved.
John F. O'Connell, Richie Ryan
- VAT receipts from electricity sales 2 speeches
Asked for VAT revenue from electricity charges, the Minister cited returns that combine electricity sales with other ESB activities and began explaining further accounting difficulties.
Ben Briscoe, Richie Ryan
- VAT on the ESB fixed charge 4 speeches
Lynch questioned VAT on fixed charges tied to equipment installed before VAT began. The Minister said the charge is effectively rent for equipment use and is therefore a taxable service.
John Lynch, Richie Ryan
- VAT relief on household electricity bills 3 speeches
Fitzpatrick sought VAT relief for private consumers amid sharp increases in ESB charges; the Minister did not answer, and Fitzpatrick complained that he was being ignored.
Tom J. Fitzpatrick, Richie Ryan
asked the Minister for Finance the total VAT receipts of the Revenue Commissioners from the Irish newspaper industry; and the proportion of total VAT receipts which this figure represents.
Comment on this
Returns made by taxpayers for value-added tax purposes give only the total turnover from all activities carried on by them and the appropriate tax. A return by a newsagent does not distinguish the tax liability on sales of newspapers from the liability on other goods. It is not possible, therefore, to state the tax receipts from sales of Irish newspapers or the proportion of these receipts to the total.
4.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance the proportion of VAT receipts from the Irish newspaper industry arising from the sale of daily newspapers.
Comment on this
It would be contrary to secrecy obligations in relation to the affairs of taxpayers to disclose any information about the liability of a small group of companies. For that reason the Revenue Commissioners may not and I therefore cannot supply the information requested by the Deputy.
5.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance the amount of money which accrued to the Exchequer from VAT on electricity charges for the last financial year.
Comment on this
There are practical difficulties in furnishing the information sought by the the Deputy for the following reasons:
(1) The VAT returns furnished to the Revenue Commissioners by the Electricity Supply Board state the total tax from sales of electricity and of appliances and from contract work and installation and repair services carried out by the board. Receipts from electricity sales are not shown separately;
(2) In the case of traders registered for VAT the tax invoiced to them by the board is deductible from their own tax liability on their sales of goods or services. As the tax paid by the board to the Revenue Commissioners includes these deductible amounts it represents the gross figure which is not the amount that ultimately accrues to the Exchequer;
(3) In the financial period April 1st to December 31st, 1974, the ESB paid to the Revenue Commissioners a total of £1,971,119 in respect of VAT and, in the calendar year 1974, a total of £2,334,653 but, as I have explained, these are gross figures which include VAT borne by traders registered for VAT, and also the VAT in respect of sales of appliances, contract work and so on. In addition, where the ESB themselves incur VAT on purchases, the amount involved would be deducted by the board from their VAT payments to the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain why the ESB continue to charge VAT on the fixed charge element on ESB bills in view of the fact that the fixed charge seems to relate to the capital cost of installation of equipment, in many cases equipment installed long before VAT was introduced?
Comment on this
I am not aware of the reasons or in a position to argue the case with the Deputy but the Deputy will appreciate that this tax has been so charged since the introduction of VAT.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that the element of the bill on which VAT is charged was in relation to costs incurred long before the introduction of VAT? One would assume that the ESB had paid for the installation and committed their capital outlay to these installations, including I take it receivers and things of that nature. That would not seem to be equitably chargeable at any rate.
Comment on this
The fixed charge is, in practice, a fixed rent. What it is called does not change its essential nature. It is a rent for the use of equipment and as such is a service and is liable to VAT.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Would the Minister consider giving any concession to the private consumer as regards the removal of VAT? At least part of it should be removed from the bill due to the extraordinary rise in ESB charges over the last few months.