VAT on the ESB fixed charge
Lynch questioned VAT on fixed charges tied to equipment installed before VAT began. The Minister said the charge is effectively rent for equipment use and is therefore a taxable service.
Would the Minister explain why the ESB continue to charge VAT on the fixed charge element on ESB bills in view of the fact that the fixed charge seems to relate to the capital cost of installation of equipment, in many cases equipment installed long before VAT was introduced?
Comment on this
I am not aware of the reasons or in a position to argue the case with the Deputy but the Deputy will appreciate that this tax has been so charged since the introduction of VAT.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that the element of the bill on which VAT is charged was in relation to costs incurred long before the introduction of VAT? One would assume that the ESB had paid for the installation and committed their capital outlay to these installations, including I take it receivers and things of that nature. That would not seem to be equitably chargeable at any rate.