Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Sheep and Lamb Production.
- Sheep production support schemes 5 speeches
Members asked about support for sheep producers, including winter feeding and joint lamb-fattening projects. The Minister cited existing subsidy schemes and said assistance for joint projects was planned.
Seán Walsh, Mark A. Clinton
- Common EU market for sheepmeat 4 speeches
Nolan urged the Minister to secure a common EU market organisation for sheepmeat. The Minister said he had pressed for it, but any member state could block agreement.
Thomas Nolan, Mark A. Clinton
- West Wicklow lamb-fattening station 11 speeches
Murphy sought a specially adapted scheme for a co-operative lamb-fattening station in west Wicklow. The Minister said a qualifying co-op could apply under the modernisation scheme, which he acknowledged needed amendment but could not modify unilaterally.
Ciaran P. Murphy, Seán Treacy, Mark A. Clinton
- Increase in sheep grants 2 speeches
Walsh asked when the previous increase in grant allocation occurred; the Minister said it had risen by £1 the previous year.
Seán Walsh, Mark A. Clinton
- Sheepmeat policy and EU presidency 15 speeches
Haughey accused the Government of failing to advance Ireland’s interests on sheepmeat policy during its EU presidency. The Minister said other states retained veto power, while Callanan urged continued efforts for a common sheep policy; the Minister said the Government needed no convincing.
Charles J. Haughey, Seán Treacy, Mark A. Clinton, John Callanan
- Carlow mountain lamb subsidy eligibility 10 speeches
Nolan challenged the refusal of mountain lamb subsidies to some Carlow farmers, arguing they had received payments previously. The Minister said an investigation found they did not meet the mountain-grazing rules and that some earlier payments were made in error.
Thomas Nolan, Mark A. Clinton
andMr. C. Murphy asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he will introduce a scheme for the subsidisation of winter feeding for breeding ewes.
9.
Comment on this
andMr. C. Murphy asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries whether the incomes of sheep producers in the west Wicklow area have kept pace with rising costs in the past three years.
10.
Comment on this
andMr. C. Murphy asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries the estimate, if any, of the fall in sheep numbers in County Wicklow during the past three years.
11.
Comment on this
andMr. C. Murphy asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if he will provide assistance for the establishment of co-operative lamb-fattening stations in the mountain area of west Wicklow.
Comment on this
With your permission, a Cheann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 8 to 11, inclusive, together.
A number of schemes designed to help the sheep industry are already in operation. These include the mountain lamb subsidy scheme, the hogget ewe subsidy scheme, the extension to the mountain lamb subsidy scheme and the export guarantee scheme for carcase mutton and lamb. Expenditure under these schemes in 1975 amounted to almost £3 million. In addition in the context of the handicapped areas scheme, I intend to introduce soon a special scheme for the provision of assistance for joint projects undertaken by groups of farmers for increasing fodder production in hill areas and for the improvement of hill grazing land farmed jointly.
Applications for assistance for the establishment of co-operative lamb-fattening stations from properly constituted co-operative societies will be open to consideration within the terms of the farm modernisation scheme. No separate information is available as to the relative trend of costs and incomes of sheep-owners in the west Wicklow area.
Sheep numbers in County Wicklow increased from 284,000 in 1972 to 288,000 in 1973 but declined slightly to 287,000 in 1974. The indications are that there may have been a further small decline in 1975 but detailed county statistics will not be available for some time.
Comment on this
In view of the Minister's statement that the sheep population and the income of sheep farmers are declining, would he not agree that the solution to the problem is for the Minister in the Council of Ministers to ask the Community to extend the common agricultural policy to sheep so as to give the sheep farmers a fixed income all the year round and not have this stop-go situation which means that when the French market closes we cannot sell sheep and the price of sheepmeat goes down?
Comment on this
The Deputy must be aware that I have been agitating for a common organisation of the market in sheepmeat for the past three years and that no later than the last meeting I complained that this thing was not being advanced in the way I had hoped and expected it would be. I got a definite undertaking that it would be an early item on the agenda at the March meeting, not at the February meeting because it is exclusively price-fixing.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell the House now that he hopes that his efforts, or his agitation as he describes it, will bring about the situation where we would have a common agricultural policy for sheepmeat within the next six months?
Comment on this
I am always hopeful, but it needs only one member state to object to prevent us from having common organisation for the marketing of sheepmeat.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister will agree that sheep farming in the mountainous area of west Wicklow is very specialised and needs extra attention and subsidies and should be treated as a special entity. There is no way in which the sheepmen there can maintain their lambs; they must let them go when the prices are at their worst. Would he not think a special case could be made for a co-operative lamb fattening station at west Wicklow?
Comment on this
I have already said that, if it was a properly qualified coop and makes application, it could come within the scope of the modernisation scheme and get grants.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not accept that it is not enough to say somebody should make application, but that he should be able to put forward the terms of the scheme and have the scheme specially modified to suit the conditions?
Comment on this
No, I cannot do that. I cannot decide what can and cannot be given under the modernisation scheme.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying this scheme is suitable as it is for sheep farming in west Wicklow?
Comment on this
I said in this House on many occasions that I am not satisfied with the modernisation scheme as it stands. I took no part in the formulation of the scheme. We are trying to have it amended and we must get agreement on that within the Commission.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned that the grant allocation has been increased this year. Could the Minister say when the previous increase was in the last few years?
Comment on this
Arising out of the Minister's statement about the failure to have the common agricultural policy extended to cover sheep, would he confirm that in no single way were the interests of this country advanced during the presidency of the Minister for Foreign Affairs?
Comment on this
This is not a matter for the Minister for Foreign Affairs; it is a matter for the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries.
Comment on this
I could not allow the Deputy to misrepresent the situation. It needs only the UK, France or any other member State to say: "No, we will not have any part of this", and there is power of veto.
Comment on this
The Government had the presidency for six months and the Minister for Foreign Affairs was running round the world settling everybody's problems but did nothing for this country.
Comment on this
Would the Minister make an effort to convince the Government and the officials in Brussels that it is of vital importance to the sheep industry, particularly in Galway, to have a common agricultural policy for sheep?
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries why lamb subsidy grants have not been paid to certain farmers in the Carlow area who qualified since the scheme was introduced.
Comment on this
Subsidy was not paid to some sheep-owners in the Carlow area under the mountain lamb subsidy scheme because they did not comply with the requirements of the scheme in regard to mountain grazing.
Comment on this
I should like to know what way the regulations have been changed because since the scheme was introduced by Deputy Haughey, when he was Minister for Agriculture, farmers who produced this type of lamb received this subsidy. Why have some farmers been refused this subsidy? Is the reason that the Department have not a penny, as the Minister said before?
Comment on this
My information is that these farmers did not receive this subsidy on all occasions. In 1974 they received it in error. What those farmers told the local official who was investigating this was accepted by that official but following investigations in 1975 it was shown beyond all doubt that they did not comply. I sent an official to investigate this and, following that investigation, I am satisfied that they did not qualify under the terms of the scheme. The subsidy scheme on mountain lamb was introduced in 1966 and under this scheme a subsidy is not payable unless the flock owner has grazing rights on mountain lands and has grazed all his lambs on such lands. Where appropriate, he is required to furnish a declaration and evidence to this effect. When the people concerned were asked for this evidence they could not produce it.
Comment on this
Due to the situation in the Mount Leinster-Blackstairs area it was very difficult for the Department, when the scheme was introduced, to define mountain rights and hill rights. As a result of that, in consultation with the committee of agriculture a certain area was laid down. The Minister informed me that the subsidy was paid in 1974 but I can assure him that the subsidy was also paid in 1975. Why the change?
Comment on this
I sent down an official who knows the area to carry out a special investigation and I am informed that after consultation with a member of the council, who is a former chairman of the Borris Ewe Breeders' Association, and also with the local agricultural adviser he made his recommendations to the effect that they did not qualify.
Comment on this
Is the Minister stating that the local CAO, and the chairman of the sheep breeders' association, agreed with the official that these people did not qualify?
Comment on this
I did not say the local CAO was involved; I said the local agricultural instructor was involved. I told the Deputy that after consultation with these people the official made his recommendation.