We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Sheep and Lamb Production.

Carlow mountain lamb subsidy eligibility

Summary

Nolan challenged the refusal of mountain lamb subsidies to some Carlow farmers, arguing they had received payments previously. The Minister said an investigation found they did not meet the mountain-grazing rules and that some earlier payments were made in error.

asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries why lamb subsidy grants have not been paid to certain farmers in the Carlow area who qualified since the scheme was introduced.

Comment on this

Subsidy was not paid to some sheep-owners in the Carlow area under the mountain lamb subsidy scheme because they did not comply with the requirements of the scheme in regard to mountain grazing.

Comment on this

I should like to know what way the regulations have been changed because since the scheme was introduced by Deputy Haughey, when he was Minister for Agriculture, farmers who produced this type of lamb received this subsidy. Why have some farmers been refused this subsidy? Is the reason that the Department have not a penny, as the Minister said before?

Comment on this

My information is that these farmers did not receive this subsidy on all occasions. In 1974 they received it in error. What those farmers told the local official who was investigating this was accepted by that official but following investigations in 1975 it was shown beyond all doubt that they did not comply. I sent an official to investigate this and, following that investigation, I am satisfied that they did not qualify under the terms of the scheme. The subsidy scheme on mountain lamb was introduced in 1966 and under this scheme a subsidy is not payable unless the flock owner has grazing rights on mountain lands and has grazed all his lambs on such lands. Where appropriate, he is required to furnish a declaration and evidence to this effect. When the people concerned were asked for this evidence they could not produce it.

Comment on this

Due to the situation in the Mount Leinster-Blackstairs area it was very difficult for the Department, when the scheme was introduced, to define mountain rights and hill rights. As a result of that, in consultation with the committee of agriculture a certain area was laid down. The Minister informed me that the subsidy was paid in 1974 but I can assure him that the subsidy was also paid in 1975. Why the change?

Comment on this

I sent down an official who knows the area to carry out a special investigation and I am informed that after consultation with a member of the council, who is a former chairman of the Borris Ewe Breeders' Association, and also with the local agricultural adviser he made his recommendations to the effect that they did not qualify.

Comment on this

Is the Minister stating that the local CAO, and the chairman of the sheep breeders' association, agreed with the official that these people did not qualify?

Comment on this

I did not say the local CAO was involved; I said the local agricultural instructor was involved. I told the Deputy that after consultation with these people the official made his recommendation.

Comment on this

Who was the other person mentioned by the Minister?

Comment on this

A member of the council who is a former chairman of the Borris Ewe Breeders' Association. I have not told the Deputy what they said but I have told him what the official recommended on his return.

Comment on this