We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Juries Bill, 1975 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–141 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Juries Bill, 1975
Enacted

No. 34 of 1975 ›

Section 3 provides:

The expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas.

There are hundreds of thousands of people—I know this is a sweeping statement, but I cannot be accurate— who will be ineligible for jury service because they will be unable to afford it. On the Second Stage of the Bill I, as well as others, mentioned that, in rural Ireland particularly, people will have to incur expenditure in travelling to the court, that if they have to travel the night before because the bus or train service is not suitable and have to stay in a hotel or guest-house that night, all this will be a severe drain on those who are unable to afford it. I know this problem will not arise in city areas such as Dublin, but in rural parts it certainly will arise. If somebody is called from the western part of Cork or Limerick to Limerick city or Cork city for jury service, the bus fare is at least £2. If they have to be at the court at 10.30 in the morning they will have to go the evening before and stay overnight. If the case goes on for more than a day or two these people will be under considerable expense.

On Second Stage we mentioned the word "payment" for jury service. That might convey the wrong meaning, in that I would be most anxious that legitimate expenses incurred by those who would be called for jury service would be met.

There are 110,000 to 120,000 unemployed. As well as that there are in each of the health boards a large number of people, male and female, over the ages of 18 years on some form of allowance or other. All of those would be involved. Perhaps the purpose of this Bill is not being met when we say we intend to give everybody the opportunity to serve on juries if he or she is 18 and under 65. There could be anything between 300,000 and 500,000 people who might not be eligible for jury service because they could not afford it. I am sure if the finances of the nation allowed it, the Minister would be willing to accep my point of view. It is unfortunate that at present the nation cannot afford it. Some hope should be held out to these people that they are not going to be debarred or automatically excluded from jury service because they cannot meet the expenses involved.

Comment on this
Patrick Mark Cooney Minister for Justice (Mr. Cooney) Fine Gael

It is not a question of anybody being debarred or rendered ineligible. It will be for each individual citizen to decide whether he wants to fulfil his obligation under this Bill. If he decides that in fulfilling this obligation he is going to impose an undue hardship on himself and on his dependants, he will then be perfectly free, like any other citizen who will be subject to hardship by having to fulfil his obligation for whatever reasons, to approach the county registrar and seek exemption.

I do not anticipate that the numbers affected will be anything like the number Deputy Collins puts forward. The number of people he mentions have to be considered in the national context, in a population of some millions of people. The percentage then is small. Again when you take the random balloting procedure, the number that will be balloted on to a panel for a particular sitting will be small, and the proportion of people within that panel who might be hardship cases, such as Deputy Collins has in mind, would again be extremely small. We have had people making the argument that jury service is not a privilege. I think it is and it is a civic duty. People have said that it may be a privilege and a duty but it is nonetheless a burden and we do not want persons to be burdened by it. That is why the county registrar is given the right to exempt them.

I have no doubt that a good case for exemption would be where hardship would result. You cannot argue on the one hand that we provide for meeting the hardship situation and, on the other hand, argue that this is an undue burden. All we can do is provide for the undue burden. I do not think that by doing that it can be said we are depriving people of their rights to appear on a jury. They still have their rights, and, if for some extraneous reason, they are unable, without hardship, to fulfil their rights, we excuse them from having to carry out that duty.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that many more people would be eligible for jury service if it did not impose a financial burden on them?

Comment on this

Let us not mix up eligibility with ability to attend. They are all eligible. The financial status of the person has no bearing whatever on his eligibility. There may be some cases of the type posed by Deputy Collins where, while eligible, they will be unable for financial constraints to discharge their duty. In those odd few cases the county registrar will exempt the jurors.

Comment on this

Will the Minister agree that allowing that all are eligible, of all who are eligible, many more would be able to give jury service if it was not a financial burden on them?

Comment on this

We are speculating as to how many would be unable to serve. I anticipate very few will be unable to serve on a jury because the number of such people in the total population represents only a very small percentage, and that is further diluted by the random picking of jury panels. It would be a very rare case where a person will be unable to serve as a juror because of inability to meet travelling expenses to the county town.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that anybody in rural Ireland who is called at random for jury service will have to pay his own expenses to get to the county town? In this day and age these expenses are fairly high. Unfortunately, many people in rural Ireland are on some sort of social welfare or in receipt of allowances from health boards, particularly those in the west. Many of the people called, even if they are eligible, will be unable for financial reasons to fulfil their civic duties no matter how much they may want to.

Comment on this

I take the Deputy's point, but I disagree with him when he says that many people will be unable to serve on juries because it would impose financial hardship. There is no doubt that a person in rural Ireland who gets a jury summons will have to get to the county town but that will not be a novel problem for him. He has frequently to get to the county town on business of all sorts. It is closing our eyes to the realities of life in rural Ireland to suggest that all people in receipt of welfare have no means of transport. One constantly hears about the queues of cars on certain days of the week in different areas. I do not accept that people in rural Ireland who may be in receipt of State benefit of one kind or another are not in a position to organise transport for themselves, either their own transport or as they usually organise it when they have business in the county town with the county council, the county clinic or their solicitor. It is part of their normal living to be able to get to the county town. It is unreal to suggest that to come in for jury service would impose an undue hardship on them when they are doing this on a weekly or even a monthly basis.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister that particularly in rural areas, there are many old cars, lovingly referred to as "bangers", which are used to bring families to Mass or to villages and towns. Some of these no doubt would make the 40 miles each way to the county town if petrol was a reasonable price. I can see the Minister's mind is made up on this. Perhaps he might consider issuing travelling vouchers similar to those issued by the Department of Social Welfare to those who are called to courts of appeal when dealing with social welfare cases. These vouchers would enable them to travel by public transport. The Minister might consider this when issuing his instructions, either ministerial or statutory instruments, to the county registrars when he is implementing this Bill. I do not want a "Yes" or "No" now because I understand what is involved.

Comment on this

The Minister stated there was a car in nearly every home whether the people were on social welfare or not. There are cars in many homes but it would not be available to every member of the family who is 18 years or over. If a man in that family is working he has the use of the car. A person of 18 years living in Portumna and called for jury service in Galway city would have to travel 50 miles. There is no bus service which will get him into the city in time to serve on jury duty and he has to come into the city the evening before. Unless he is provided with expenses he will be unable to serve on a jury. Expenses are even more important when a man is unemployed.

I realise that people can be exempt from jury service if they cannot afford it but I can see this being abused by people who can afford it but pretend they cannot merely to be exempt. Up to now if a person wished to be exempt from jury service he had to provide a doctor's certificate. Is that right?

Comment on this

It would not be a ground at the moment. One would not expect it to arise now because jurors are confined to the more prosperous section of the community.

Comment on this

My point is this. Who will define whether a person can afford it? I am in favour of women serving on juries but I can see very few women wanting to do this. I am worried that too many people will seek exemptions, quite apart from those who genuinely cannot afford to serve. I have never been called to serve on a jury but I know of people who have been called and they had to leave their farms at a time when they were badly needed there. Small farmers do their best to get exempted because they do not want to serve.

This may lead to a situation where juries are drawn from the affluent society because the plain people may not be able to afford to serve. I should not like to see this happen and neither would the Minister but it will happen unless there is some form of voucher system. Deputy Collins mentioned this; at least people should be entitled to free travel. In many cases they have to stay overnight. It is just not on to say that everyone over 18 years is eligible to serve on a jury when no expenses are provided even for the unemployed.

Comment on this

I cannot see that people with the means to serve on juries without any hardship would be able to fool a county registrar that it was a hardship on the grounds of means. The county registrar will have certain means of information to check an application on those grounds. County registrars are men of common sense and I have no doubt that they will inform themselves before they rule on an application. I do not anticipate that any undeserving people will escape their liability in that way.

I take the point made by Deputies Collins and Callanan that in the case of an unemployed person, particularly an urban unemployed person or a person who is in receipt of what is known as the small farmer's dole, it would be an undue hardship for him to attend at the county town. However, having regard to the way the jury franchise has been extended, the numbers involved at any particular sitting would be very few. It is up to them to make the move to the county registrar. The latter will exercise his common sense and he will have access to information —I am sure if he required information from people connected with my Department he would be assisted—and the registrar would be able to inform himself of the bona fides of an application. I am satisfied that there would not be an injustice.

It would be regrettable that because of his financial position a citizen might have to seek exemption. However, to try to cover every eventuality, to ensure that every citizen would be urged towards the jury room and that nobody would find himself unable to serve, would envisage building a large administrative structure. The question of vouchers was mentioned. It is an attractive idea but when one thinks about it one can see the snags. First, should it be on a means test basis? Should it relate to the type of assistance to the person concerned, whether it be unemployment benefit, unemployment assistance or a disabled person's allowance. There is a fair amount of bureaucracy immediately——

Comment on this

If the Minister is considering the matter, I would ask him not to have a means test basis. Have vouchers available for all on application because the buses on the roads are empty.

Comment on this

The simple voucher may not be enough to meet the needs of the person in the category mentioned. He might need more than just a voucher for transport. The position is bedevilled with problems. I think the best solution is to leave it to the common sense of the county registrar to exempt the man who would be genuinely prejudiced by a summons to serve on a jury. If a person is so genuinely prejudiced that he wants to get off, let him make the choice. In spite of the fact that the person may find it a hardship, if he wants to discharge his duty by serving fair play to him, but if he does not want to do this let him be exempt.

Comment on this

The only way a person can be granted exemption is on production of a medical certificate.

Comment on this

That is the position at the moment but the Bill will change that.

Comment on this

I know quite a number of people get exemption by producing a doctor's certificate. There is now the question of the person not being able to afford to serve and the county registrar will decide. Investigating whether a man can afford to serve will be a long job. I am convinced this is wide open. How will the investigation be carried out quickly?

The Minister referred to the matter of vouchers. It would help in one way in that the person called to serve on a jury could leave the family car at home. As a result, the family would not suffer such great hardship. I am anxious to know how it can be decided quickly who will be exempt on the grounds of not being able to afford to serve.

Comment on this

I note what the Deputy has said about releasing the car for the rest of the family. At that stage it is a question of the convenience of the community as against the family and I do not know if the family would be entitled to be convenienced at the expense of the community. Certainly there is room for argument here.

Comment on this

What happens if the man's son is working and needs the car?

Comment on this

That problem would arise if the mother had to go to the dentist. These problems have to be met and solved; they are part of everyday life. The Deputy raised the question of who would investigate the matter quickly. Under the regime proposed in the Bill the jury summons would be served four or six weeks before the jury man is wanted and there would be that interval of time available for investigation. The person will apply for exemption and he will have to state his grounds. A phone call or a letter from the county registrar to the person seeking exemption, or to some other source where the registrar might expect information to assist him in making a decision, could be done within a matter of days.

I do not anticipate that county registrars will be snowed under by applications for exemption. Because of the widening of the franchise new people will be coming in and they will be prepared to carry out this new duty. At the moment because it has been falling more frequently on a small class of citizens there was a temptation to seek exemption but I think this will be largely removed. As in all cases where a new procedure is prescribed, we will have to wait and see what teething troubles arise but I do not anticipate any in that direction.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to a person's civic duty to serve on a jury. I would cite the case of a man of modest means, or even someone on social welfare. This person makes a big effort to attend, perhaps hitching a ride early in the morning, and he finds himself on a panel. If that case continues for a few days or even a few weeks in the middle of the trial that man through no fault of his own might become physically unfit to be present——

Comment on this

In a situation like that the Deputy can be assured the man would be provided with transport.

Comment on this

The Minister said it was a privilege for young people to be qualified for jury service. What good is that if they cannot enjoy it? He said that people did not find any difficulty in going to towns from the country to do their business. He knows that jury trials can go on for as long as three weeks in the country and jurors would have to be in town at 10.15 every morning. That situation would be intolerable and impossible for a person on social welfare benefits. To travel from Skibbereen to Cork would cost him £2.50 each day and meals would cost him another £2. That could go on for five days each week.

Comment on this

With respect, a jury trial in a circuit court in rural Ireland that would last for three weeks would be extremely rare.

Comment on this

At a criminal sitting very often it lasts two weeks.

Comment on this

That would be very rare.

Comment on this

No. It happens three times a year.

Comment on this

If such a case arises, will the county registrar have discretion?

Comment on this

If there was a likelihood that a person of limited means would be empanelled in a trial lasting three weeks, I have no doubt that rather than have the jury discharged and the necessity for a further trial, the Garda would make informal arrangements to have the person excused.

Comment on this

We are satisfied if that discretion is there.

Comment on this

Has the Minister done any research on the percentage of jurors who have applied for exemption on doctors' certificates? I believe it would be very high.

Comment on this

I have not.

Comment on this

That is a pity. Doctors' certificates have been worked frequently.

Comment on this

I would not like to say that medical practitioners give certificates that are not bona fides.

Comment on this

I am not saying that.

Comment on this

I appreciate the Deputy is not. I do not think it would be an alarmingly high proportion. It is always dangerous to speak from one's particular recollections and experiences but listening to jury panels being called over I would think the number of certificates in respect of 50 or 60 jurors would be no more than three or four.

Comment on this

It is a higher proportion in my area.

Comment on this

The order that will be made on foot of this section will be a statutory instrument.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 4, line 12, after "service" to add "or is a Peace Commissioner".

My amendment is designed to exclude PCs from jury service. The present position is that PCs are excluded from service. They were set up under section 4 of the District Justices (Temporary Provisions) Act, 1923 which sets out the duties they perform. Some of those duties would probably mean that when they came to sit on juries they would have had knowledge of the preliminary proceedings and accordingly would be unable and unfit to sit on juries. Having regard to that, I submit the Minister should accept the amendment and exclude them from jury service.

There is another point. PCs do quite a lot of work for nothing. They may be called to a Garda station at any hour of day or night and they give the State such services for nothing. The least we can do in return is to exclude them from jury service. I do not think there would be any great administrative difficulty in doing so.

Comment on this

I support the amendment, nostalgically may I say, because my father was one of the first PCs in the State and he had been one of the Sinn Féin judges. They do an enormous amount of work for nothing and, as Deputy Dockrell has said, they may have remanded people at the preliminary hearings and should, therefore, not be qualified for jury service. Apart from that, they spend half their days filling in forms and for that reason alone they should be excused from service.

Comment on this

There are a fair few of them in the country now and the number is growing.

Comment on this

Since the Minister took office the number of PCs in the country is so great——

Comment on this

If we exclude them there will be nobody left to serve on juries.

Comment on this

I have been a PC for 30 years. A PC might be responsible for instance, for remanding a man for trial on a theft charge.

Comment on this

I have listened to the argument in favour of the amendment but I am regretfully unable to accept it because I think the counter arguments are stronger. The first is that the Committee on Court Practice and Procedure in their second interim report went into this question of exemption in considerable detail and had the benefit of submissions from a wide range of people some of whom had been involved in jury service, in empanelling juries. Having had the benefit of those submissions, the committee recommended that the list of exemptions are drastically curtailed, and among the people they recommended to lose exemptions were PCs. I am following the recommendation of that expert committee in that respect. Because of the general nature of the report the recommendations have to be given a great deal of weight and that reinforces me in my view that removing the exemption for peace commissioners is the correct procedure.

It was suggested by Deputy Dockrell, and Deputy Callanan supports him in this, that peace commissioners could possibly have knowledge by virtue of exercising their functions as peace commissioners in particular cases. Were that to happen such a peace commissioner would be automatically ineligible by virtue of section 15 since he would be a person who would have a connection with the case. He would have a positive duty so to inform the court and, if he did not do so, he would be subject to penalty. That is the only instance in which a peace commissioner's function would lead him into a situation where there could be a conflict and that is provided for. He would be ineligible.

Deputy Coogan suggested these men are performing an unpaid service to the State and, in return, the State should not ask them to perform this duty. Peace commissioners do not look on their office as a burden. I think they regard it as an honour. If we were to exempt peace commissioners then the same arguments would apply to notaries public or commissioners for oaths and we do not propose to exempt them. I do not see any good reason for exempting peace commissioners and it has come to my knowledge that in the recent past the motivation for seeking appointment as peace commissioner was to seek exemption from jury service.

Comment on this

Of course.

Comment on this

That indicates that some people are wrongly motivated. Prior knowledge of a case and the fact that they are already performing a duty for the State are not in my opinion sufficiently strong arguments to grant them exemption.

Comment on this

I am in full agreement with the Minister's attitude on this. If a peace commissioner is involved in a case he has a responsibility to make known that involvement and he will be automatically excused. Exemption from jury service in the past was one of the perks of being a peace commissioner. The Minister is correct in his attitude and I support him in it.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider extending the disqualification under this section? What are the Minister's views on disqualifying a person who is convicted abroad?

Comment on this

Here we are talking only of Irish nationals. Non-nationals would not appear on the electoral list. It would, of course, be impossible to have records and information which would enable us to enforce this particular suggestion. Again, what might carry a penal sanction abroad might not be a matter of any great odium within our jurisdiction. We would know the offence in which a person would be involved here but there is the overriding difficulty that we would have no records in the case of an offence committed in another jurisdiction.

Comment on this

Modern technology is very advanced and there are ways and means of getting information form other countries. I can see the practical difficulties in administration.

Comment on this

It would be a matter of having information.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

One would have to be in a position to prosecute.

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider my suggestion of the county registrar issuing certificates of exemption?

Comment on this

There would be no difficulty about that. It is not necessary to put it in the Bill because it would be part of an administrative procedure. If a person were exempted he could ask for a letter from the county registrar and he would have this documentary record for a future date. I do not anticipate he would be called again but we can arrange for what the Deputy suggests administratively.

Comment on this

The section provides

Each county registrar, using a procedure of random or other non-discriminatory selection, shall draw up a panel of jurors for each court from the register or registers delivered to him...

This procedure is vague and must be left to the discretion of the county registrar.

Comment on this

That wording was used looking over our shoulders at the decision of the Supreme Court, and we want to express it in statutory form in recognition of the principle expressed in that judgment. We wanted to use "random". This is a word which has come to have a specific statistical meaning and paradoxically in that context it is not random at all. It has a specific mathematical meaning so we have added the words "or other non-discriminatory method".

Comment on this

I presume it will be taken out of the hat.

Comment on this

Not necessarily. There are two stages involved. This deals with drawing up the panel, and when the panel is drawn up that panel is summoned. It is from that panel that the names go into a hat at that stage and only in the court.

Comment on this

On the summoning of the panel, are they not put into a hat at that stage?

Comment on this

They are not put into a hat. It could be every five, 15, 20.

Comment on this

How are you going to arrange that in a county so that they will not be picked from the one area? Take, for instance, an area in West Galway. Could it be possible that the same area would come up every time?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

How are you going to arrange that in a county so that they will not be picked from one area?

Comment on this
A Deputy

It is usually done alphabetically.

Comment on this

How are you going to make sure that they will not be picked from the one area when you are picking them at random?

Comment on this

The county registrar will not pick people from the one area because that would not be random and non-discriminatory. I will be placing in the Library for the benefit of Deputies the book of instructions that will be issued to county registrars in which the mechanics for operating this will be set out.

Comment on this

Perhaps if it is not too expensive the Minister would circulate one to each Deputy. Deputies may be asked——

Comment on this

I do not think Deputies are going to be asked. It is an internal document.

Comment on this

Will copies of that be available?

Comment on this

Yes. If a Deputy wants a copy I will be delighted to supply one to him. It will set out the mechanics of this procedure.

Comment on this

It appears that the county registrar has too much discretion. I understand from the Minister the rules and regulations of this matter. Could he give some idea of what the rules are about? Do the rules suggest to the county registrar what random system he should use?

Comment on this

I will read an extract from the instructions—they are still in draft, they are provisional instructions. Under the heading of "splitting the register" it says, and I quote :

In order to administer the provision contained in section 9 (1) (b)——

that is the three-year exemption

——of the Bill without the necessity for keeping elaborate card-index or other records, the electoral register for the county or jury district as the case may be,——

the difference between a county and a jury district is that a jury district may be part of a county in certain counties

——should be split into four roughly equal parts. By using only one of those parts in each of four successive years for the empanelling and summoning of jurors, the summoning of any juror more than once in any period of three years can be avoided in the vast majority of cases. The exceptions will be those who change residence from an area contained in one part of the register to an area contained in another part.

Comment on this

I was wondering how he picks out the jurors. Does he take every second name, every tenth name, or does he toss a coin?

Comment on this

It says :

When the bundles of booklets that comprise the register are received they should be numbered consecutively in pencil 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, etc. Each fourth part of the register will comprise about 250 booklets. The booklets that are to comprise each fourth part should be chosen by lottery as follows: the booklet bearing the first number drawn in the lottery will go into the first part of the register.

It will be a lottery, a random procedure.

Comment on this

There is nothing random about that.

Comment on this

A sort of guided random.

Comment on this

It is a lottery.

Comment on this

It is random. I use "random" in the sense of the ordinary meaning, that is by chance.

Comment on this

As I indicated, the notice will be four to six weeks. It cannot be less than two weeks because the prosecution will depend on a fortnight's notice.

Comment on this

I am not satisfied with the mode of service of the summons, with the proof of service of a summons as set out here. The Minister would be well advised to re-enact the provisions of the 1927 Act in toto to cover this question of procedure in service and mode of service and proof of service of a summons. It does not say in this section by whom the summons must be served. It must be served by hand. It does not say whose hand. It does not state on whom the summons must be served by hand. Suppose whoever serves it goes to the residence of the juror and finds nobody there, or perhaps a child three or four years of age or an imbecile. The situation is not covered by that. How is the proof of service of the summons going to be made in the case if it is a member of the Garda who must serve the summons? Suppose the garda is dead or dies in the meantime, how is the proof of the service of that summons to be proved in court?

Comment on this

It is provided for in the remaining subsections of the section as to what constitutes proof of service, but we are dealing with the actual service. It can be done in two ways, by post or delivered by hand. It is not necessary to say who will be the competent person to deliver by hand. It is enough to provide that it may be delivered by hand. It is then for the county registrar to decide who should deliver it by hand, maybe it is the Garda Síochána, or some of his own staff who could go around the town and deliver the summonses by hand, but more than likely they will be sent by post. The proof of service is provided for in subsections (3) and (4).

Comment on this

Who will it be delivered to?

Comment on this

It will have to be delivered to the juror.

Comment on this

Personally himself?

Comment on this

It will have to be personal service, because in the absence of providing for delivery to a person other than a juror it will have to be personal service.

Comment on this

The juror may not be at home.

Comment on this

Then service cannot be effected until the juror is at home. I anticipate that service will normally be by post.

Comment on this

Let me point out a very practical difficulty which will be experienced which might slow down the operation and cause great inconvenience. It will arise by serving the jury summons by post particularly having regard to the state of the register of electors. Unfortunately, in many parts of the country the register of electors is not as good as it should be. It is not as properly compiled as it should be. The most recent register of electors the Minister's party and my party had to deal with was that in the west of Ireland where it was clearly obvious to us, when we availed of the free postage facilities to send literature to all electors on the register, that many hundreds of those people were not present at their addresses. There was seasonal migration. We know that we got hundreds of those letters back and I am sure the Minister's party also did.

In my area of the south west we have seasonal migration so that many people on the register are away. We also have the practice in the western parts of the country that young people have jobs in the city and come home for the weekend but are registered at their home addresses for election purposes because that is their only base. If I am a county registrar and I post out 50 notices to people to attend for the panel of jurors, many of those people might not be there and might not get their postage for weeks. The whole thing will probably grind slowly to a halt. I know the Minister has discretion here under the section which says that it may be sent by post or delivered by hand. I ask him not to rely to any great extent on the delivery by post. The postman will deliver the letter to the house but the person might not be there.

The county registrar will not know that the person is not at home and when that person fails to turn up the county registrar will issue a summons as is his right under the measure. People will be charged in the court who were probably picking potatoes or working on the beet crops but who are on the register. If a number of people are to be called from an area or a parish, perhaps the Minister might enlist the aid of the Garda Síochána to deliver the jury summons. I know it is an extra duty to put on them but I am sure the Minister, being a practising politician, will agree that the problem I speak of exists.

Comment on this

I can well appreciate the problem put forward by Deputy Collins. I will arrange to have it drawn to the attention of county registrars because it would set the whole thing at nought if we found that our summonses were ineffective. I imagine this procedure will probably be of help to the Deputy and me at certain times of the year. It will mean that the registers will be more carefully checked before they are printed henceforth. I understand that the Department of Local Government have been apprised of the difficulties which may arise in relation to what the Deputy says. They are endeavouring to ensure that addresses will be precise and that registers will be as accurate as possible. I will draw the attention of county registrars to the need to be careful in using the registers.

Comment on this

I am opposing this section because of the difficulty, for practical reasons, of putting it into operation. During the debate on Second Stage I pointed out that the section reminded me of the parable of the man who gave the wedding feast. When his guests did not turn up, he sent his servants out to invite those on the highways and byways to partake of his hospitality. I will not continue with the parable because the Minister and Deputies are as familiar with it as I am but there is a comparison. If it appears to a judge of a court that the jury to try any issue before the court may be incomplete, he may require any qualified persons to be summoned by the county registrar in order to make up the number needed. This is the relevance of the part of the parable to which I referred. Subsection (2) states:

The judge shall specify the area from which persons may be summoned (which may be the area in the vicinity of the court) and the method of summons, whether by written notice or otherwise.

I have not been to courts as often as members of the legal profession but the few times I have been there I was not very impressed. People looked worried and were very anxious. They seemed to be preoccupied with their problems.

Comment on this

They were the lawyers.

Comment on this

They were certainly not the lawyers. If there is a breakdown, such as is envisaged under this section, perhaps it might be better to postpone the matter, fix a new date and provide under the Bill to have another jury empanelled. That is why I am asking to have the section deleted. I should like to hear the Minister's views on it. We will not disagree violently over the matter.

Comment on this

The section is to cover what I expect will be an extremely rare situation. It is possibly an ultra-cautious provision because I do not anticipate that the situation it envisages will ever arise. Suppose the panel of jurors had an inordinately large number of people who were ineligible, disqualified or had good reason to be excused or that there was a large number of challenges and several juries were required and all the challenges were used to the full. In that case one could find that the panel would be so attenuated that there would not be sufficient to form the jury or juries necessary. At that stage the parties might be in court and the witnesses might be in court. All the parties concerned with the trial might have assembled. It would be preferable at that stage to bring in more jurors rather than send everybody away, including the jurors who had come and who were not sufficient in number.

The Deputy has misunderstood the phrase "which may be in the area in the vicinity of the court". It does not mean within the actual environs of the court building itself. It refers to the town in which the sitting is taking place. "Vicinity" does not mean the actual court. It means the town, so the judge would not be under an obligation to make sure that some of the panel he has drawn in came from, perhaps, 30 miles away at the other end of the county. He could, because this is an emergency situation, take them from the town in which the sitting is taking place. I do not believe there could be any hardship or injustice caused to anybody because it would be a random sample of citizens coming in to make up the jury and try this particular issue.

Comment on this

There is a problem. The Minister has stated that this would be a very rare occasion, perhaps once in a lifetime. If that is so, that probably strengthens my argument. If it is to be as rare as the Minister thinks, he should drop it and start up afresh. If I am in my county town going about my legitimate business and am reasonably busy and I am stopped and told: "I want you"—it is like the old posters one used to see in England headed: "Your country needs you," and having a picture of a man with a moustache pointing his finger at you—I will feel a sense of resentment. I have not made provision. I have to down tools, as it were. I have not got my own house in order. I will be brought into a court and I will feel resentful. Human nature being what it is a person will say: "What is this all about? I am willing to do my duty in the proper way. Why can I not be notified in the proper way?" It might do harm to the whole system. It might do harm to the courts. This is a layman's view. Even if it will happen only rarely, I think we should drop it and start afresh. I hope I would not be unfair to the accused or cause any problems. I can see that too.

Comment on this

It is a question of balance again—of where the hardship would lie. My feeling is that it would lie with the parties if they were to be sent home and told to come back another day.

Comment on this

Is there any way in which it could be provided that the judge will have discretion?

Comment on this

That is provided in the section. The judge will have discretion.

Comment on this

Discretion as to whether or not they should do that or sit on another day?

Comment on this

The judge would have discretion because the power given is not mandatory. It says "the judge may require any persons...". If the judge decides he will not require any person to be summoned, he will discharge whoever is there and come back on another day. One further point before Deputy Haughey speaks. What we are proposing here is not a new procedure. In effect, this power has been there since 1927 and it has never been the subject of complaint even with the present limited jury franchise.

Comment on this

I find this section objectionable. Together with my colleague Deputy Collins I appeal to the Minister to drop it. What we are doing here is updating and modernising our jury system. This is a piece of modern legislation enacted by the Dáil in 1976. It is very important that it should have a modern look about it, and that it should be in keeping with the standards and concepts of today. I want to suggest that this section is not. This section is archaic and feudal in its implications and in its proposed method of operation. To me it savours of the old press-gang concept. If the State needed citizens to man the warships or to carry out any other particularly urgent task, it went out into the highways and the byways and gathered up the first people available and pressed them into service.

To me the basic concept behind this section is objectionable in that way. It is feudal in its approach. The Minister is setting up a new modern structure for the conduct of jury trials. He is setting out for us here in this legislation a sensible, practical, workable, series of proposals which conform with the recent Supreme Court decision in regard to the status of women in our society. It seems to me that the Bill is related to the circumstances of today, to the life style of today, to the way in which people have to go about their business in these times, and earn their livelihood, and so on. Generally speaking, the Bill conforms to the modern situation and is related to modern circumstances.

Here it seems to me we have a hangover from different times. In fact, the Minister gave a clue to that when he said there is nothing new about the section or about these provisions. That is precisely the point. There is nothing new about them. They are old. They are archaic. They should be done away with. I do not think that, with proper planning by a county registrar, the situation should ever arise where these provisions would have to be invoked. If some peculiar combination of untoward circumstances bring about a situation where an adequate number of juries cannot be empanelled, as Deputy Collins suggested, the trial should be postponed.

The trial of a citizen before the courts is much too important to be left to this sort of haphazard ad hoc procedure. It is a relic of the feudal past. I do not know if the Minister is satisfied that under these procedures the county registrar could guarantee that the sort of persons he will gather up for jury service in this way would be suitable and competent people. Maybe I am taking a pessimistic view but I would visualise that this procedure could throw up a very unbalanced and unsuitable type of jury. This is a sort of emergency procedure of going out into the streets, practically, and empanelling whoever happens to be available.

If the Minister looked at it from this point of view he would see this section is not in keeping with the general tenor of the Bill, or with the other modernised and up to date provisions—in particular the proposal in subsection (3) that persons who are summoned in this cavalier way will not have the right of appeal from the county registrar. All in all it is not an appropriate section in this type of legislation. I suggest very strongly to the Minister that he should discard it.

Comment on this

I should like to make a few comments on this section. I am speaking with past practical experience as a rural practitioner. I do not anticipate this will arise before a Dublin criminal session court. I could see it happening in relation to a country court. Looking at this section it is well to bear in mind that it will not necessarily be availed of at the last moment. We must remember that the summonses are out. The county registrar is getting the message back as to service, as to people looking for exemptions, as to medical certificates coming in from people who are ill and unable to attend.

Suppose a circuit judge is sitting in Kilkenny Circuit Court and next week there is a session of the Wexford Criminal Circuit Court. The county registrar in Wexford can contact the circuit judge and get a direction from him to avail of this section to make quite certain there is an adequate number of jurors. The summonses have gone out to the panel. This is something which turns up as a result of something else occurring.

I can foresee another difficulty arising. Where people are indicted and go before a criminal court there might be six or eight people up for trial. The bush telegraph says so many will not contest and will plead guilty. At the last moment somebody changes his mind and a jury will be required to try that case. That means you have to have jurors prepared for that sort of situation. In all my time practising both for prosecution and defence in criminal jury cases, it has never occurred that we have run out of juries. I recollect on one occasion where I had challenges in hand, I did not avail of them because my client wanted his trial to go on. While there might have been a doubt about the acceptability, from the point of view of the defence, of the last few jurors who were available, we took a chance and took those jurors because my client wanted his case on. It was fair enough. I had travelled 70 or 80 miles to be there for the trial; the solicitor who instructed me maybe another 30 or 40 miles, and the accused had his witnesses there.

I have instanced two things; last minute illnesses and change of plea by the accused. This does create a difficulty from the point of view of the registrar. I can say that the registrars who acted in any courts that I was in were competent men and were always able to anticipate, although there have been a few narrow shaves due to last minute changes. It will be a real hardship to the accused if this provision is not passed. It is in ease of the accused because, as I see it, it makes quite certain that there is an adequate number of jurors from which the accused can raise his challenges. I would hate to see any person in the situation I outlined where, because the accused wanted his trial on, we did not exercise our right to challenge any jurors but took the last jurors that were available.

Comment on this

I am a little confused about this provision. Deputy Esmonde was saying it would appear the judge would have to have a standby local panel in case there would be a shortage. Deputy Collins's interpretation was that when the shortage occurred the judge would have authority to send out for the jurors there and then and I would be very much opposed to that. When a person is summoned to serve on a jury he should have time to make up his mind about it and to make arrangements. If he is called in without being properly summoned, I do not think that person is in a proper state of mind to try anybody. As far as the accused is concerned, if he is a country man he might be looking for a country jury. In this case it is all townspeople, wherever the court is being held, that would have to be called in.

Comment on this

I think the section is essentially a sensible one. What Deputy Esmonde had to say is of great importance in trying to assess the arguments for and against it. Essentially it is in ease of the parties, particularly in criminal cases. We are talking about rural Circuit Courts where juries would be summoned in criminal cases only, and we are talking about the case where a defendant would be ready for his trial and the witnesses would be present. Possibly he has gone to the expense of providing for representation and then finds that his expenses are going to be doubled because there is not a sufficient number of jurors.

We have to weigh up the arguments put forward by Deputy Haughey and answer the questions raised by Deputy Callanan in deciding whether the disadvantages of what we are proposing to do outweigh the advantages which Deputy Esmonde pointed out. Deputy Callanan asked when the jurymen would be called in. Deputy Collins was envisaging that this would be an eleventh hour or even a twelfth hour procedure. Deputy Esmonde had in mind that the warning signs would come up earlier. I think the scenario painted by Deputy Esmonde would be the more likely one for the reason that the normal panel is summoned four to six weeks in advance. The signs will be available to the country registrar over that period that the panel is getting thin, that the excusals, the disqualifications, cases of ineligibility, medical certificates and so on are going to be unusually high. So that the judge should not find on the morning of the court——

Comment on this

That is not what the section says.

Comment on this

The section says:

The judge shall specify the area from which persons may be summoned (which may be the area in the vicinity of the court).

I envisage that when the court will be in session and we are going to run short of manpower——

Comment on this

May I finish? We have to try to envisage circumstances in which this is going to arise, and circumstances will arise if there is an unusually large number of exemptions for whatever reason. That information will normally be known to the county registrar a week or a fortnight in advance of the sitting. The judge will have that knowledge, because it will have been made known to him by the county registrar, and then the mechanism provided by the section will come into play.

It could be a last minute happening, for example, if there were a very high number of exemptions that did not appear in advance so as to justify warning the judge earlier. Supposing it turned out that there were a large number of challenges; if there were two defendants and the prosecutor, that would give a total of 21 challenges without cause, and if there were further challenges with cause, the panel could be suddenly attenuated. At this stage, too, this procedure would be available to the court.

It might not be possible at that stage, because of the time that would be involved, to have the extra jurors summoned there for that day. It would probably be adjourned to the next day. The judge might decide in his discretion, after hearing the parties—and they are the people for whose benefit the whole trial is taking place—that they would have to adjourn the trial until the full panel would be available at the next sitting.

Deputy Callanan raised the point as to where the jurors would be called from and asked what would happen if a country man was being tried and he wanted a jury of countrymen; if this section were invoked he thought the county registrar would be forced to go into the town because of convenience of distance. At that stage the parties to the case would be entitled to object and could exercise their challenges against these extra people coming in, or they could say to the judge that they consider such a panel would be unduly limited having regard to the background of their client and the nature of the case against him, which might have rural overtones to it. In that case one would hope that the judge would exercise his judicial discretion and say: "Very well, we will wait until the next sitting."

Comment on this

Is the challenge still there?

Comment on this

It would not have been empanelled by the time this arose.

Comment on this

Is the right to challenge there all the time?

Comment on this

It is a very limited right.

Comment on this

The judge has a discretion which is exercised in the interests of justice, that is, in the interests of the parties before him. If he, in his discretion, decides that this is not a proper procedure for this particular case, it may be adjourned until the next sitting. But if the parties are agreeable and anxious to go on, he has this machinery to invoke.

Deputy Haughey objected to it on the grounds that it had feudal overtones or that there was a press-gang atmosphere about it. I reject that analogy because the press-gang was to bring people in and send them off on war service from which they might never return. All we are asking here is that people serve on a jury for a day or even part of a day. The press-gang were not entitled to seek excusals. There was no appeal once they were on board ship. In my view, it is not a feudal idea either. It may have a certain swiftness and cutting through red tape to which we are not accustomed when providing statutory provisions, but it may be refreshing for that. The principle is the same. The people are being summoned by the court on a random basis.

Comment on this

Without notice.

Comment on this

With shorter notice. This is the difference, but the principle of summoning the citizens to perform a jury service is what is involved. The difference is a matter of procedure in that the notice is shorter. Deputy Haughey says there should be proper planning by the county registrar when calling juries. There is no planning in the sense of being able to reordain anything with regard to jury service henceforth. It will be random non-discriminatory, by lottery. That excludes any element of planning. Deputy Haughey said that bringing in people off the street would be a haphazard and ad hoc procedure. This is essentially the nature of summoning juries from now on. It will be haphazard ad hoc, random, non-discriminatory, by lottery. There will be no preplanning about it. A motley collection of citizens will eventually gather from which a jury will be picked.

Deputy Haughey said there would be a danger that suitable and competent people might not be brought in under this emergency stipulation. This Bill now proposes that all citizens on the electoral register are, by definition, suitable and competent people. To bring in a random selection from the vicinity of the court is not doing anything different from what the Bill proposes.

Weighing up the situation where the parties are assembled and the accused is anxious to get on with the case, and the hardship that would be inflicted on him if he could not get a jury for his trial, against difficulties of getting in a jury under the unusual procedure devised by this section, in my view the balance is in favour of giving the power to the court to act in ease of the parties before it, that is, acting in the interests of justice. The mechanics provided are not such as to take away from the interest of the parties or to lessen the justice they are entitled to. Should there be any element of that in it by virtue of the arguments put forward by Deputy Callanan and Deputy Haughey, the judge intervenes. That is his function.

Comment on this

Surely this section visualises a situation where people are literally brought in from the highways and the byways in the vicinity of the courts? The judge may dispense with written notice and instruct an officer of the court, a member of the Garda Síochána to go out and bring in another few dozen people for the jury panel. In the meantime, the court will be held up. Is that right?

Comment on this

Where will the Garda go? Into the first pub and then the next and the next. There are plenty of pubs near courthouses all over the country. As a result, we will wind up with 20 or 30 people who have come out of the pubs who are probably going to, or going from, the dole because they are unemployed. In this way we will not have the representative jury panel envisaged by the Minister. That would be inevitable in such a situation.

This system is too random, slipshod and haphazard. While I agree with the picture painted by Deputy Esmonde, I do not think any accused would be satisfied with that type of system. It could work against him rather than for him.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not agree that there is a discretion for the judge by the use of the word "may" in the first subparagraph and most judges would listen to the legal representative of an accused person if he had objections on any grounds? I think he would.

Comment on this

I agree completely with that, but this subsection is surely meant to deal with the situation I visualised.

Comment on this

The situation the Deputy visualised would be very extreme. Quite clearly in that situation the judge and the parties would want the proceedings adjourned because that would be unsatisfactory. One will have to rely on the judge and the parties.

Comment on this

There is no right for the parties here.

Comment on this

We have to assume on the part of our Judiciary a certain concern for the parties before them and a certain anxiety to dispense justice. Dispensing justice means keeping the interests of the parties paramount. We have to assume that what the parties would say would be a matter of great concern, and possibly the only concern, to the judge. I envisage that any situation where the person has to be literally captured in the street and brought in would be only where there was a shortage of one or, possibly, two on a jury. If a judge, in his wisdom, and with the consent of the parties, decided to make up a deficiency of five or six, I am sure he would do so in such a way that it would not bring in the type of citizenry suggested by Deputy Brosnan, although they are perfectly eligible, suitable and competent to act.

Comment on this

It is highly likely.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that whatever system a judge would decide on, he would try to get a good cross-section. The parties and the judge will have the opportunity of discussing whether they will invoke this procedure or adjourn. If the parties decide they want to go ahead with an emergency jury they should be entitled to do so.

Comment on this

I suggest the Minister is putting the situation completely in reverse to what it is. This section does not confer any rights whatever on the parties. It confers the rights in the operation of this procedure entirely on the judge and the county registrar. If the Minister is prepared to write into the section a right by the parties to object to the procedure being invoked the section would be much less objectionable from my point of view.

Deputy Esmonde made a persuasive case but I suggest it does not stand up. He was inclined to suggest that there would not be any great rush or expediency about this, that it would be known in advance and that plans would be laid. That is not what is in the section. The section has an urgency and an immediacy in its wording——

Comment on this

I am talking about actual practice.

Comment on this

It can only happen in court. The wording is quite specific. The Bill states:

If it appears to a judge of a court that a jury to try any issue before the court will or may be incomplete,...

We are talking about a jury in the court, about the judge and the case before the court——

Comment on this

The wording is "If it appears to a judge of a court...". It can be indicated to the judge in advance. He does not have to make the decision in court.

Comment on this

To me the wording clearly envisages the court being in session when this arises. I am quite satisfied that is what is intended by the section; if anything else was intended some other procedure could be invoked by the country registrar. The Bill would enable the county registrar to deal with the situation through the normal processes laid down by the Bill if the situation is clear to him in advance of the sitting. I suggest to Deputy Esmonde that the nice, safe suggestion he has made does not stand up. As Deputy Brosnan pointed out clearly, what is involved here is last-minute, emergency pressgang procedure, where the court is sitting, where suddenly at the last minute it becomes apparent that there will not be enough people to man the jury, and where the officers of the court go out to get people in from the highways and the byways. Let us be clear what we are talking about.

If we are talking about a situation that can be planned in advance that is different. However, we are not talking about that; the section is quite clear. Nothing the Minister has said makes this in any way more attractive to me. It still smacks of the old feudal idea that it is possible to go out and dragoon citizens from the work bench, from their place of entertainment or wherever they may be, and press them into the jury box. That is completely out of keeping with a modern, up-to-date piece of legislation.

The Minister is putting this before us on the basis of fairness to the accused. I suggest that is not the situation here. I suggest the position undoubtedly will be that the accused in such circumstances can have no guarantee whatever of what kind of jury will be turned up. I do not think there is anything far-fetched about what Deputy Brosnan said, about going across the road into the nearest pub or to the nearest place of entertainment and dragooning the appropriate number of people to do the job. Whatever objection the accused might have to a delay in bringing the trial to completion, he would be much more concerned with making sure he got a fair trial and I do not think anybody in this House would argue that point. Except in the case of a complete and utter recidivist, I do not think it is possible to visualise that there would be any question that an accused person would prefer the trial over and done with rather than get a fair trial. I do not think we should hear any more of that argument.

What we are concerned with here is laying down proper procedures for the empanelling of decent juries, good men and true, fellow citizens to try criminal cases. We want those procedures which we are laying down in this legislation to be suited and adapted to the circumstances of modern life. On the whole the Bill does that quite well except in this one instance. However, for some reason or other this relic of former feudal times and old legal traditions which are better done away with has survived into this legislation. I strongly suggest to the Minister that he should reconsider the whole provision.

I noticed when the Minister was defending this provision that from time to time he had to say that if there was anything undesirable about it, if it did not appear to be satisfactory, that the case could be adjourned until the next day or week. That is defeating his own argument.

Comment on this

It is not the way the court works.

Comment on this

His only argument in favour of this procedure is that it will avoid adjournment, but on three of four different occasions in putting forward these arguments he had to admit the possibility of adjournment. The Minister keeps falling back on the defence that if the parties do not like the kind of scallywags who have been pressed into service from the nearest pub they can object but there is nothing in the section——

Comment on this

We are talking about citizens. The Deputy cannot say they will be scallywags.

Comment on this

There are scallywag citizens.

Comment on this

I am sure there are but once we enlarge the right to jury service we take in all citizens——

Comment on this

This procedure is weighted in favour of having a majority of scallywags rather than decent, honourable citizens.

Comment on this

That speaks very badly for the various county towns and for the areas in the vicinity of courts.

Comment on this