We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Juries Bill, 1975 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

Contributions 142–286 of 286. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Juries Bill, 1975
Enacted

No. 34 of 1975 ›

Most ordinary decent, respectable citizens would be going about their lawful jobs and business. The Minister keeps saying that if the parties do not like it they can ask for an adjournment but there is nothing in the section about it. It is left entirely to the judge to decide whether to adopt this procedure and to go ahead with it. If the section goes through, I suggest the parties would have no grounds for asking for an adjournment. On the Minister's own evidence they would have their counsel and witnesses there and, therefore, the accused or his legal representative could not seek an adjournment because he did not like the procedure or the kind of jury turned up by the procedure. I feel quite strongly that this is an undesirable relic of olden days that has crept back into this modern legislation and it should be got rid of.

The last point I wish to make refers to the convenience of the ordinary citizen. Jury service is an onerous obligation which citizens have to undertake. It is onerous in the normal course of events but at least when a citizen gets notice about jury service on a certain day he can make his plans accordingly. However, under this procedure people will be pressed into service without any notice. That is unfair and it could result in serious inconvenience and hardship for certain people. It might not bother unduly the lads across the way in the pub, but some person going about his lawful business suddenly finds the heavy hand of the law descending on him and at a minute's notice he has to go into court and serve on a jury. I think that is very unfair. I do not think anything can be said for this section and I strongly suggest that the Minister dispense with it.

Comment on this

Deputy Haughey raised the question as to when it would come into being. It could come into play 14 days before the trial, because if the warning signs are longer than 14 days before the trial then a jury summons could be issued. From 14 days before the day of the trial this procedure will be available whether the court is sitting or not because it refers to a judge of the court and that does not preclude the judge from hearing this in chambers in another town. Cognisance should be taken in advance of a possibility arising that a jury would be incomplete to enable proper action to be taken, so the procedure might be in effect at any time for up to 13 days before the sitting of the court. This is a matter that has to be left to the judicial discretion of the court to exercise reasonably and in the interests of justice. If you had a witness coming from England or further afield and there was one juryman missing, quite clearly the proceedings set out here should be adopted. I think the Bill would be considerably lacking if it did not provide for that.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned 14 days. There is nothing about 14 days in the Bill.

Comment on this

There is provision in the Bill that in effect you must give at least 14 days' notice to a juryman. If an emergency arose at any time shorter than 14 days it would be dealt with under this section. If the county registrar knows for more than 14 days that he is likely to be short, he could deal with it in the ordinary way.

Comment on this

If the emergency arose within six days before the court why not go into the town and pick them there?

Comment on this

If it arose a week before you could go further afield. If it arose the day before, you could go into the nearest town.

Comment on this

The morning of the trial is when it is most likely to happen. The judge might find he has not enough jurymen to empanel a full jury and with such short notice he could not send somebody out. Fifteen jurors could be challenged.

Comment on this

If you are left in a situation where you are short of jurymen and you have witnesses coming from abroad, I think it would be a very bad Bill that did not make some provision to deal with that situation.

Comment on this

This ad hoc procedure will inevitably lead to the situation which we have been painting here and that would bring justice in this country into disrepute. It is made worse by the fact that there is no provision in this Bill for either the payment or the refreshment or the transport of jurors during a trial.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2 in the name of Deputy G. Collins.

In page 6, subsection (3), line 52, after ballot to insert "; and it shall be the duty of the judge to explain to the jurors the nature of the trial or the action to be heard by them and the parties thereto so that any potential juror who may have an interest in or connection with the case or the parties shall communicate the fact to the judge, if he is selected on the ballot.

I think it should be very clear what Deputy Collins is seeking in this amendment. Section 15 deals with the selection of persons to be empanelled as jurors and stipulates that it shall be made by balloting in open court. Subsection (2) states:

The power of summoning jurors under section 14 may be exercised after balloting has begun, as well as earlier, and if it is exercised after balloting has begun the judge may dispense with balloting for persons summoned under that section.

That would take care of the situation arising out of the undesirable procedure laid down in section 14. Subsection 3 is as follows:

Before the selection is begun the judge shall warn the jurors present that they must not serve if they are ineligible or disqualified and as to the penalty under section 36 for doing so; and he shall invite any person who knows that he is not qualified to serve or who is in doubt as to whether he is qualified or who may have an interest in or connection with the case or the parties to communicate the fact to the judge (either orally or otherwise as the judge may direct or authorise) if he is selected on the ballot.

I think that is a very reasonable proposal by Deputy Collins. Subsection 3 deals with the question of ineligibility or disqualification and the penalties which jurors would incur by acting as jurymen if they were not fully qualified or eligible. The judge warns them about that but the subsection does not give any indication about how they are to come to the decision that they are ineligible or unqualified. It does not help them in any way, it is totally in terrorem, if you like. It simply confines itself to the manner of their being ineligible or disqualified and Deputy Collins wants to make the judge tell us what the action is about and therefore they would be in a much better position to decide whether they could say to the judge “I think I am disqualified”.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Minister for Lands (Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

, Cavan): It is not proposed to accept the amendment. Section 15 (3) provides that, before the balloting for a particular jury is begun, the judge shall warn the jurors present that they must not serve if ineligible or disqualified. It also provides that he shall invite any juror who may not be qualified “or who may have an interest in or connection with the case or the parties” to mention the fact if he is selected on the ballot. The amendment would add a provision relating to the words quoted. The amendment would provide that it shall be the duty of the judge to explain to the jurors “the nature of the trial or the action to be heard by them and the parties thereto”, so that a juror may mention his interest or connection, if any.

Presumably the idea behind the amendment is that, unless the jurors are told who are the parties and what the case is about, they will not know whether there is any fact which they should mention. It is true that they may not know this, but the amendment is unnecessary, because clearly the judge will have to give the assembled jurors the necessary information in any event. For example, in a civil case he might give the names and addresses of the parties and say that the action is for breach of contract, trespass, libel or whatever it is, and in a criminal case he might say that the accused is so-and-so and is charged with burgling the house of so-and-so. It can be left to the judge to decide how much he need tell the jury in order to enable them to say whether they should mention any facts that might make it undesirable that they should serve on the jury.

The amendment as worded would require the judge to explain to the jurors "the nature of...the parties" to the action. This is probably only a drafting slip, as it would be clearly wrong for the judge to tell the jurors anything about a party except his name and, where appropriate, his address and any other fact essential to an understanding of what the case is about. It is not considered necessary and, therefore, it is not proposed to accept it. As the Deputy will know, a jury is often empanelled in the High Court to try a number of cases. That is a quite frequent occurrence and if a judge had to explain all about each case it would be very unwieldly. As well as that, the provision for challenging, which has been extended, should obviate the necessity for any such elaborate procedure.

Comment on this

It seems to me that subsection (3) places the onus on a juror but does not make any provision for any guidance to enable him to come to a proper decision. If, as the Minister says, the amendment is unnecessary—it is not harmful, or detrimental, but just unnecessary—then he is really compelled, I think, to accept it. It is clearly desirable, if not strictly mandatory and necessary, that the judge should—remember, these unfortunate jurors are in strange circumstances and, for the first time, perhaps, in this intimidating atmosphere—give some direction, guidance or help to enable a juror to say that, in view of what the judge has said, he realises he is disqualified or ineligible to sit.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): This subsection deals with a number of things. It deals with people who are ineligible and with people who are disqualified. They are ineligible or disqualified for a number of reasons, one of which may be that, although they are on the register, they have not attained 18 years of age, or they might be in a category declared ineligible or disqualified. These will already have been notified because it is provided that the summons shall be accompanied by a memorandum setting out those who are disqualified or ineligible. That being so, the only other reason why a person should not serve on a jury would be that he was in some way connected with the parties, had some particular knowledge or some particular association. The judge will be at liberty to give a brief synopsis of the case. The parties are always known because the registrar says: “I am now about to call the jury to try the case of So-and-So”. In the High Court in Dublin that might not convey much but in the country it will certainly convey a great deal. In a criminal case the registrar reads over the charges to the accused person. And then empanels the jury and, in those circumstances, the jury must have a fair idea and it will be open to any juror to ask the judge for further information if he has any doubt. For these reasons I believe the amendment is neither desirable nor necessary.

Comment on this

No method is provided for the selection of the foreman. I raised this on Second Stage and I asked the Minister then whether the choice would be by simple majority, by lottery, or in some other way. What would be the situation where the members of the jury could not agree on the foreman? What would be the situation where a jury was sworn to try three of four cases? Would the foreman chosen for the first case act as foreman also in the other cases?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): First of all, this is a big improvement on the procedure which has prevailed to date under which the first juror called was automatically made foreman.

Comment on this

Time will tell.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Through no fault of his own he might not have been the best qualified or, indeed, qualified at all. I believe that in future common sense will prevail The subsection merely provides:

Whenever a juror is challenged for cause shown and such challenge is allowed by the judge, the juror shall not be included in the jury.

Almost invariably the jury adjourn for a short time before the trial actually begins and I imagine the judge will say: "Gentlemen, you will select one of your members to be foreman and you will decide by simple majority." I imagine that is what will happen. It would seem to be the rational thing to do.

Comment on this

If it is a draw, what will happen?

Comment on this

Will canvassing be permitted?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I hardly think so. We must apply common sense. I imagine that if I were a judge I would say to the jury——

Comment on this

Would the Minister say to the jury, if he were judge: "We cannot make a categorical statement about that"?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We could have a long argument which might not be relevant to this Bill but which might be very interesting and illuminating. However, I imagine that the judge would invite the jurors to select one of their members to be foreman, and I suppose if it was six and six——

Comment on this

An exceptional situation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I suggest it would be a toss.

Comment on this

Very often judges do not tell them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Maybe that is a good job too.

Comment on this

You could have a situation where they could not agree upon a foreman, the trial could go on, they could reach a verdict and still be at a stage where they could not agree on a foreman, and the whole purpose would be in vain.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If a jury of 12 men were empanelled——

Comment on this

Or women.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):—— men and women mixed— and they could not agree over a foreman it is clear they would not agree on a lot of other things, and the judge would be well advised to discharge the jury and get another.

Comment on this

Over something frivolous.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It might be better to do that then than after a week.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that what I say is possible under the provisions of that subsection, that the jury could disagree on the foreman?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do, and I believe they should be discharged.

Comment on this

This is merely a drafting point. On the third line in subsection (3) should it not be "penalties" instead of "penalty"? There are two separate penalties under subsection (6).

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The subsection reads:

(3) Before the selection is begun the judge shall warn the jurors present that they must not serve if they are ineligible or disqualified and as to the penalty under section 36 for doing so;

I think it would be a separate penalty. There would be one penalty for being ineligible and a penalty for being disqualified.

Comment on this

Two penalties, and the phrase is, "as to the penalty under section 36". I am not making a fuss of it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We could look at it. I am advised it is all right.

Comment on this

Would the Minister mind answering the other question? Where a jury are empanelled to try more than one case and the foreman——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Again I am drawing on my experience. I would say there would be a different foreman for each trial. I would say it would be a matter for the jury. They could elect the same person, but procedure would have to be gone through.

Comment on this

I think it is unnecessary to make a provision where each party would be entitled to free copies of the jurors' list and collect them at the county registrar's office. It will mean a lot of unnecessary expense and confusion in the county registrar's office. In Cork there are up to 200 actions listed for a sitting. That would mean at least 400 parties, and very often there would be two or even three defendants. There could be five or six parties looking for free lists of the jurors. I consider the present system is quite satisfactory, where the jurors' list is permanently displayed in the courthouse where anybody can inspect it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Deputy Brosnan is concerned about subsection (1) of section 16 which reads:

Every person shall be entitled to reasonable facilities to inspect a panel of jurors free of charge and a party to any proceedings, civil or criminal, to be tried with a jury shall be entitled to a copy free of charge on application to the county registrar.

Comment on this

I agree with that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): You have no objection to that. It goes on—

and a party to any proceedings, civil or criminal, to be tried with a jury shall be entitled to a copy free of charge on application to the county registrar.

The only difference between that procedure and the existing procedure is that he will get it free of charge, whereas now he has to pay for it.

Comment on this

It is on display. Any member of the public is in a position to inspect the jurors' list. I think that is sufficient.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It could be abused, but it is not likely.

Comment on this

Will it not be the register of electors?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No. The county registrar will have to compose a panel from the register of electors, but on ballot or random method.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3 in the name of my colleague, Deputy Collins:

In page 7, subsection (2), line 26, after "separately" to add "or in such numbers as the judge may in his discretion decide".

The amendment is related to subsection (2) which section states that the jury shall be sworn separately. Deputy Collins' amendment seeks to make that more flexible, to enable the judge if he wishes, to swear the whole jury together. I think it is a legitimate opinion that it would add to the solemnity of the occasion if the jury were all sworn together. I think that is what Deputy Collins had in mind rather than any time saving element. If a judge wished to do so he would be entitled to swear the entire jury at once, together.

Comment on this

The time element should be taken into account, because with the increased number of challenges open to parties under this Bill that is inevitably going to lengthen the empanelling of the jury considerably. The swearing of jurors one by one separately is completely unnecessary. They should be sworn in batches, except perhaps in criminal trials on the application of an accused person.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I regret I do not propose to accept the amendment for the following reason. Section 17, subsection (2) replaces section 53 (1) of the 1927 Act which provides that in capital cases, jurors are to be sworn individually and in other trials, collectively, that is, all the jurors or some convenient number are to be sworn at one time, except that a juror who asks to be sworn individually, or who is to be sworn otherwise in the ordinary manner, is to be sworn individually. The new section requires that in all cases jurors shall be sworn separately.

Comment on this

We know all that. It is——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I want to put it on record. The change is being made in order to emphasise the importance of the duty of a juror to give a true verdict in accordance with the evidence. The individual swearing will take marginally longer but the greater solemnity of the oath when taken separately will amply compensate for the slight delay. A similar change was made by section 35 (3) of the British Courts Act 1971 now section 11 (3) of the Juries Act 1974 and had been recommended by the Morris committee on jury service. The committee said at paragraph 314: “This [collective swearing] seems to us to be undesirable, and we are greatly fortified in our opinion by the fact that the judges have expressed the view that it is convenient that each juror should be sworn separately... It seems to us that the solemn nature of the juror's duty is emphasised if each one takes the oath individually.” The Deputies who support the amendment do so on two grounds. The first is that to swear them collectively will save time. Here we have a matter of minutes involved and I do not think that is a substantial argument. The second one is that it would be a more solemn way if a number were sworn together.

I believe that the converse is the case. If each person is asked to take the oath separately it is a more striking way of doing it. It is more individual way of doing it and it brings it home to the individual in a more solemn and striking way. Another thing which strikes me, which I have seen from time to time, is that you have sometimes the man who wishes to affirm or you have a member of the Jewish community who wishes to be sworn in a different way. If you have three jurors and one wants to be sworn in a different way, you make him stand out like a sore thumb. You are taking one and three and the judge has to say to No. 2: "Sit down for the time being and we will deal with you afterwards". I always thought that was an undersirable way of doing it. It is better to take 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 individually and swear them.

Comment on this

We will not make a federal case out of this. It is just to complete my argument on behalf of Deputy Collins. There are two ways of looking at it. The concept of the jury being welded into a unit and swearing collectively at the start of a trial will have a certain solemnity of its own and will indicate that they are a composite team to get on with the trial. However, I withdraw the amendment.

Comment on this

Subsection (5) states:

If any juror refuses to be sworn or insists on being sworn in a manner not authorised by this Act or otherwise by law, he shall not be included in the jury then being sworn.

Is there some conflict between that and section 37 which states:

Any person who, on being called upon to be sworn as a juror, refuses to be sworn in a manner authorised by this Act or otherwise by law shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding £50.

What exactly is intended there? Is it intended that the person who does not wish to be sworn should be stood down and fined? What is the position?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): As I see it, there are two separate and distinct things. Subsection (5) of section 17 states:

If any juror refuses to be sworn or insists on being sworn in a manner not authorised by this Act or otherwise by law, he shall not be included in the jury then being sworn.

That clarifies the position there. He shall not be included in the jury. As I see it, he will be subject to section 37 and will be dealt with under section 37.

Comment on this

He does not serve and he is fined.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Exactly.

Comment on this

This section represents a considerable advance on the existing situation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It does; I know the Minister for Justice dealt with this during his Second Reading speech. On the civil side it increases the number of challenges from three to seven. Under existing law on the civil side each party could challenge three jurors without giving any reason and he could challenge as many other jurors as he could give reason for. We are increasing that from three to seven. It is on the criminal side that there is a more substantial change. At present the State can stand by as many jurors as they like without showing any reason. The accused person can challenge five but has no right to stand by. On the proposal in this Bill both the State and the accused will have the right to challenge seven.

Comment on this

Where the jury separates there is provision at present whereby they are put in charge of an officer of the court or a member of the Garda Síochána. This is in criminal cases. They did not separate in a trial up to now.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I understand the present position to be that it is only in the more serious cases, that is, capital murder, treason and treason felony they are not allowed to separate but in all others they are.

Comment on this

They are not allowed to separate in criminal trials. They are put in charge of an officer of the court. They are taken away and they receive free transport and a meal. There is no provision for anything like that here. I am objecting to that. Is that not right?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): At the present time it is unnecessary to keep jurors together except in the very limited number of cases which I have mentioned, capital murder, treason and treason felony. If the judge kept them together the meal was provided for them. There is no difference whatever here. In any trial with a jury the jurors may separate before considering their verdict except where the judge otherwise directs. The Deputy may take it that, if the judge otherwise directs, he will provide them with accommodation and facilities.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 9, to delete lines 50 and 51 and in page 10 to delete lines 1 to 3 inclusive and to insert "The Minister shall by order regulate the practice and procedure to be adopted by county registrars in the discharge of their duties under this Act but nothing in this section shall authorise the Minister to make an order providing that".

The existing section 27 reads:

With a view to securing consistency in the administration of this Act, the Minister may issue instructions to county registrars with regard to the practice and the procedure to be adopted by them in the discharge of their duties under this Act; but nothing in this section shall authorise the Minister to issue any instruction...

It is fairly obvious what the difference in approach is. The section says the Minister may issue instructions. Deputy Collins wants this provision to be mandatory and to say that the Minister shall. I think it is desirable that it should be so. The situation should not be that, if the Minister does not feel like co-ordinating the procedures throughout the country, he need not do so. The Bill should make it mandatory on him to so order things. Secondly, Deputy Collins wishes this to be done by order, whereas the section as framed is very loose in its approach. It simply says that the Minister may issue instructions to county registrars. I recommend the amendment. I hope the Minister will not adopt the attitude he has been adopting fairly consistently up to now that the Bill is perfect and cannot be improved, and no matter what amendments we put forward they do not matter.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The amendment proposes to prescribe by order the method by which the county registrars shall make up the jury panel. We think it is undesirable to write it down and make it a statutory obligation, so to speak. What it is proposed is to do it administratively. The circular which will be sent to county registrars suggesting how juries should be empanelled will be placed in the Library of the House. It is felt that, if we were to have a hard and fast rule as to how the panel should be made up, it could be questioned in trial after trial, and could lead to endless delays and endless litigation, all of which would be unnecessary, and would not be required to ensure that the panel was properly compiled. The panel will contain the names of many more jurors than will be necessary to try any case or all cases. For those reasons I believe that procedure adopted here is the more practical procedure and the better procedure. There are two views about this, just as there are two views about most things.

Comment on this

Apart from the wording of the amendment which I think is not very effective, does the Minister not see the need even to make it mandatory on the Minister to issue instructions; in other words to substitute "shall" for "may" in line 51 on page 9? What is the objection to that? We know enough about this Government to know Ministers will not do things unless they absolutely have to.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If I may say so, the point being made by the Deputy is a classical Opposition point and one which I would probably make if I were on the other side of the House. For that reason, I am glad to see the Deputy is settling down into Opposition so well.

Comment on this

The Minister should advert to the discussion on the Local Government (Planning and Development) Bill where we had this point on countless occasions.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I was not in on that Bill. The Deputy may take it that instructions will be issued and these instructions will appear in the Library. If for any reason instructions were not given, the Minister would have to answer for that on his Estimate.

Comment on this

Why not make it mandatory?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I think not.

Comment on this

Why not? If the Minister is assuring the House that these instructions will be issued, he must thereby mean that they will be necessary. If they are necessary, the Bill should make it mandatory on the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I would not even say they are necessary. They are highly desirable. I would not say they are fundamental because most county registrars, having read the Act, will proceed in a proper way.

Comment on this

What is the Minister's argument against making it mandatory?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The argument against making it mandatory is that it could lead to litigation. There could be questions as to whether a particular jury or juror was properly empanelled, or as to whether a particular juror trying a case had been empanelled in accordance with very rigid regulations.

Comment on this

I am not talking about regulations. I am talking about instructions.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the word “must” were put in here, the same questions could be raised as to whether the jury was empanelled in accordance with the “must” or “shall” laid down.

Comment on this

If it was not properly empanelled, would a person not have a right to sue and to litigate?

Comment on this

It would not be under this provision that he would be suing. The Minister is not dealing fairly with us. All the argument is in favour of making it mandatory and he might at least undertake to consider this.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I will undertake to convey the Deputy's strong feelings to the Minister for Justice in person. No doubt he will consider them.

Comment on this

If the jury is wrongly empanelled and instructions should have been issued, surely the person with the grievance, the person who is wronged, is entitled to sue whoever is responsible.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am satisfied that the county registrars, having read the Act, will behave in a reasonable and intelligent manner.

Comment on this

So they are all paragons of efficiency.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): No, they are not.

Comment on this

Either it is necessary or it is not.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): We are all human and we are all subject to the shortcomings of human nature. No amount of legislation we put on the Statute Book will overcome that. Subject to that, I would say they will behave in a reasonable way.

Comment on this

Will the Minister consider substituting "shall" for "may"?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I understand there is the problem that we hope the Bill will conclude today.

Comment on this

Go bhfóire Dia orainn.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): There is nothing like being hopeful.

Comment on this
Seán Moore Acting Chairman (Mr. Moore) Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 5 has been tabled to section 29 by Deputy G. Collins. The Chair rules that because it involves a potential charge on revenue it is out of order.

Comment on this

There is an obligation here on employers to remunerate their servants and their apprentices, but there is no provision for payment of remuneration of unemployed, of recipients of social welfare or any others. This is open to abuse in that employees or apprentices could be on the jury list, be at the courthouse every morning at 10.15 and not being empanelled in a jury, they would have a free day, and that situation could last as long as three weeks. There should be some method whereby the county registrar would notify the employer of the fact that the employee was not empanelled on a jury and, in other words, could do his day's work.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I get the point the Deputy is making, because the section says:

... a person shall be treated as employed or apprenticed during any period when he is absent from his employment or apprenticeship in order to comply with a jury summons.

That means, I take it, that if he is employed convenient to the courthouse and is not actually called to serve on a jury he would be expected to be back within such time as would be reasonable.

Comment on this

That he would go back for a half day.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Yes, and I think that covers it. Of course, if he has to travel 30 or 40 miles, as in the country, he would be away for the day anyway.

Comment on this

I suggest some certificate should be issued by the county registrar to his employer.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I hardly think that is necessary, because if there is a row or dispute between the employer and the employee, that will be resolved, I would say, by reference to the county register anyhow. Supposing there was such a serious row between them——

Comment on this

There need not be any row between them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If the employer refused to pay—I am using the word “row” in that sense— that can only be resolved by reference to the county registrar.

Comment on this

I am saying it is open to abuse on the part of the employee who is a juror. He could spend three weeks in Cork doing nothing and get paid for it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He would be entitled to it—if he was complying with the jury summons—

Comment on this

That is what I am saying. He would be entitled to it.

Comment on this

There is worse. He might have to spend four weeks in Cork.

Comment on this

He should not be paid.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): He would not be paid. I am saying that if he is a resident of Cork city and if he marches down every morning to comply with the summons, he will only be entitled to be paid for the days he is serving on the jury or such portion of a day as is necessary to get himself to the court and back.

Comment on this

According to that section, he is legally entitled to it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The Deputy does not get the point.

Comment on this

It is open to abuse. The Minister does not intend to change it, so it does not matter.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is not necessary.

Comment on this

It is a perfect Bill. There is no need to change anything. I do not know what we are wasting our time for here.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Let me repeat the provision in the section: “a person shall be treated as employed or apprenticed during any period when he is absent from his employment or apprenticeship in order to comply with a jury summons”. If you have a reasonable employer and a reasonable employee, there will be no trouble. If one of them is unreasonable, you will then have to refer to the county registrar.

Comment on this

That is what I have said. It is open to abuse.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): It is not.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In Part II, page 13, after line 54, to insert the following new paragraph:

"The Secretary to the Commissioners of Irish Lights and any person in the employment of the Commissioners on a certificate from the Secretary that the person concerned performs services for the Commissioners that cannot reasonably be performed by another or postponed."

I shall not delay the House very long on this amendment. The Minister will immediately see it is eminently reasonable. We are concerned here with the situation of persons in the service of the Commissioners of Irish Lights. I could subject the Minister to a long and impassioned dissertation on the service which the commissioners and their staff render to the nation and, in particular, to our merchant navy. However, I shall not do that. I shall just leave it to the Minister's common sense.

The Bill as drafted makes provision that among those who can be excused as of right are lighthouse keepers actually employed as such. That is not enough to meet this situation. My amendment is in line with the provision made for teachers, professors, lecturers and so on. I suggest that the Secretary of the Commissioners of Irish Lights be put in the same position as the head or principal of a college or university and that he would be able to issue a certificate to state that the person concerned performed services for the commissioners "that cannot reasonably be performed by another or postponed"—the same provision which applies to teachers.

There are 618 persons altogether employed by the commissioners. I am not seeking that they should all be exempt through the provisions laid down in the Schedule, but there are about 85 per cent of those who are either working on the coast or are required almost constantly to be available for duty there. The Bill as it is drafted covers lightkeepers and masters of vessels. Lightship men are in exactly the same position as lightkeepers and they should be covered, as should the crews of lighthouse tenders.

There is a cadre of building tradesmen who for most of the year are out on the lighthouses or travelling to and from lighthouses. There are quite a number of professional, technical and industrial staff of the commissioners who are required to be available for duty on the coast. The position of these people would not be met by the Schedule as framed. I recommend my amendment to the Minister as being very reasonable; I am speaking about amendment No. 6, because amendments Nos. 7 and 8 are consequential if the Minister accepts the principle.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Lighthousekeepers are exempt under the Bill and there is no problem there. What the Deputy wants to do is to give authority to the Secretary of the Commissioners of Irish Lights to issue a certificate exempting anybody he thinks should be exempted.

Comment on this

Not just that. To certify that they are engaged, the same as teachers——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Yes. I know the Deputy's feeling about this, but I am advised it is not necessary, because the lighthousekeepers are exempt and anybody else who thinks he should be exempt can apply for exemption.

As the Deputy knows, there are more elaborate provisions in this Bill than were in the legislation up to the present. Under the existing law, the county registrar has no authority to exempt anyone from answering a jury summons. The people who did not turn up in court in obedience to a summons took the chance that the judge might or might not exempt them. In this Bill the summons has to be served 14 days in advance, unless in the very exceptional case discussed earlier, and the county registrar has the right to excuse somebody from attending in obedience to the summons.

Comment on this

We know that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I am spelling that out even at the risk of annoying the Deputy——

Comment on this

The Minister is taking no risk.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan):—— for the purpose of showing that the amendment is not necessary.

Comment on this

It is necessary. This is a typical example of the way we put forward a reasonable amendment which is called for by the circumstances of this type of employment and the Minister turns it down out of hands. It makes one despair of the procedure in this House. What is the point of having a Committee Stage of a Bill if, when we highlight a defect in the Bill which is unanswerable, the Minister just refuses to accept it? As I said, it makes one despair of even trying to amend legislation.

Part II of the Bill sets out a list of persons who are excusable as of right. If the head or principal teacher in a college or university has this right about a member of his staff, surely the Commissioner of Irish Lights should have this right.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Every lighthousekeeper is excused.

Comment on this

But he is not excused, unless he is employed as such. There are other persons who are in exactly the same position as lighthousekeepers. "Lighthousekeeper" does not cover the situation. The Minister must not have been listening to what I was saying. I elaborated on the type of person concerned. A man on duty on a lightship is in the same category as a lighthousekeeper. He is not included in the Bill as it stands at the moment. The crew of a lighthouse tender, engineers, men who are travelling up and down the coast on all kinds of emergency duties, are not included. Tradesmen who go to the light stations are out there for maybe two or three months on end and they are not included. If the Bill provides this power for the head or principal teacher of a college in respect of any professor, lecturer, or member of the teaching staff of such institution, surely it is perfectly reasonable and logical to give the same facility to the head of a life and death service like the Commissioners of Irish Lights. I feel quite incensed at the Minister's rejection of this reasonable and sensible proposal which is necessary to enable a vital life and death service to function properly and efficiently.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not think it is necessary because of the powers conferred on the county registrar to excuse them.

Comment on this

If that is so, why is the head or principal of a college put in? Why is he not put in the same boat? A teacher in a secondary school in Marino will have this privilege conferred on him as of right, while a man going back and forward on a tender to a lighthouse off the western coast——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Each teacher is not excused unless he gets a certificate——

Comment on this

That is all I am asking for.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): But the people who are on an essential job are excused.

Comment on this

They are not excused. Are we talking sense here? One particular isolated category is excused— lighthousekeepers. There are engineers, tradesmen, crews of tenders, men on light ships, a whole variety of people, not included in the Bill, who are in the same position as the lighthousekeepers. The mechanism I am proposing is a sensible, straightforward, logical method of dealing with this problem. I cannot understand the Minister's refusal to accept it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): If we extended it that far, we might extend it to a variety of other people engaged in seagoing operations.

Comment on this

No, there is only one Commissioners of Irish Lights.

Comment on this

I worked in the lighthouse service for 15 years. I understand the problems and the Minister has been misled or misinformed on this occasion. Maintenance personnel operate from a depot in Dún Laoghaire to do a job—the safety of mariners. This is a very important job. A man may be sent to Blacksod today and then get a telegram telling him to go to Loophead, the Aran Islands or some other place tomorrow. He is constantly on the move dealing with problems. Every storm and every high sea create problems. There is a constant demand for engineers and technicians to maintain this vital and effective service.

I was often on a run for six weeks and got my mail for the full six weeks when I returned to my home base. I moved from station to station dealing with one problem after another. Every storm creates a variety of problems along the coast and at outlying stations and shore stations. A very special case should be made for some tradesmen who are away for several weeks. Getting mail to lighthousemen is not as simple as the Minister thinks and, therefore, in the normal way one could not be summoned for jury duty. This is a special service which demands special attention.

A lighthousekeeper on shore leave is on stand-to. Because of sickness at a station he may be called at any given moment. Every member of the lighthouse service, whether on the coast, in the depots or on the lighthouses, is on call 24 hours a day. This is one of the most important and misunderstood services in the country. Without this service, the lives of every mariner would be at stake.

On one occasion I went away to do a job that would take three hours but was away for ten days on board a lightship. I could not come ashore because of bad weather. That gives some indication of the situations that can arise. Other people have been six, eight or ten weeks on stations. There are helicopters available now but they do not bring out the mail every day so that you can get your summons for jury duty.

This amendment is reasonable and the Minister should give it very careful consideration. It reads:

"The Secretary of the Commissioners of Irish Lights and any person in the employment of the Commissioners on a certificate from the Secretary that the person concerned performs services for the Commissioners that cannot reasonably be performed by another or postponed."

Every situation is an emergency situation. It would be very serious if the lights around the coast were out because a person was on jury duty and could not fix them. I do not know if the Minister yet understands the grave problems confronting this service because of the non-acceptance of this amendment. I hope the Minister will examine the situation again and seek further clarification from the Commissioners of Irish Lights if he is not satisfied with what Deputy Haughey or I stated here. I would ask the Minister to do that rather than reject the amendment so that he may have a clear picture of the situation. By doing that he could ensure that the lives of the mariners are not interfered with by this Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I do not think the fears expressed by the Deputy will materialise. The county registrar has this power. Apart from that, if the summons is not served it is not served and there is no obligation on the juror to attend. If it is served and the juror does not turn up there will never be any prosecution. I could not see any reasonable person directing a prosecution—common sense would prevail.

Comment on this

Does that mean that if personnel from Irish Lights do not turn up they will be excused?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): I did not say that. I said common sense would prevail.

Comment on this

As Deputy Haughey pointed out, personnel who are not required for coastal duties would be available for jury service. We are dealing with personnel who are normally on call at all times. If there is a storm tonight there will be problems on the west or on the east coast tomorrow and they must be attended to immediately. Tradesmen and technicians must be transferred to the areas affected immediately in order to maintain essential services. There is a safeguard that personnel who are employed in a clerical or other capacity can be available. If the amendment is accepted it means that personnel can move freely from station to station on a certificate from the secretary. This is reasonable and if the Minister reconsiders the matter I am sure he will share my view.

Comment on this

Part II deals with persons who are excusable as of right and it sets out a large category who are thus excusable. It states:

Chief officers of local authorities for the purposes of the Local Government Act, 1941 (No. 23), health boards established under the Health Act, 1970 (No. 1) and harbour authorities within the meaning of the Harbours Act, 1946 (No. 9) and any employee of a local authority, health board or harbour authority on a certificate from its chief officer that it would be contrary to the public interest for the employee to have to serve as a juror because he performs essential and urgent services of public importance that cannot reasonably be performed by another or postponed.

Those words apply specifically and clearly to the type of person employed by the Commissioners of Irish Lights. Where is the justification for granting this procedure to harbour authorities, organisations who function on land and whose employees operate on land, and not granting it to the Commissioners of Irish Lights? The Minister's position is totally indefensible.

The next paragraph refers to the head or principal teacher of a college, school or other educational institution. The most minor educational institution has this procedure available to it—it need not necessarily be a university or a school. That head or principal has the facility afforded to him of being able to certify that a particular person is engaged on work that cannot reasonably be performed by another or be postponed. That certificate enables the person to be excused as of right.

It is beyond comprehension how the Minister, in the light of those two provisions, can deny a similar provision in regard to the Commissioners of Irish Lights. I am certain if the latter had been aware of what was happening they would have been in touch with the Department of Justice and when the Bill was being drafted the provision would have been included. Simply because we are putting it forward as a necessary improvement in the Bill it is rejected out of hand. We are lectured about the Opposition not doing their job but there has been very little encouragement for a member of the Opposition to go to any trouble on this Bill.

We have been very reasonable about this Bill. We have facilitated the Minister and we have let sections go through which we might have dealt with at greater length because we understand there is some urgency about the matter. Our attitude with regard to this Bill has been one of co-operation. Here we are highlighting for the Minister an absolutely legitimate and necessary amendment but we are not given the courtesy of it being dealt with in a meaningful way.

I cannot see how the Minister can possibly defend the situation, where the procedure is laid down with regard to harbour authorities but is not granted to the Commissioners of Irish Lights. The Minister's argument that lighthousekeepers are covered is not enough; there are countless persons employed by Irish Lights who are in exactly the same position as lighthousekeepers. If the Minister sees it necessary to include the latter he has no valid case for rejecting the procedure we are putting forward. I find it difficult to remain calm about the way the Minister is dealing with this proposal.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): The proposed procedure for excusing jurors is far more elaborate than the existing one. It goes a long way towards relieving any hardships that may be imposed on jurors. The present amendment relates purely to employees of Irish Lights. The Deputy concedes that lighthousekeepers are specifically exempted by the Bill but he wants to extend to the secretary of Irish Lights the same rights as will be enjoyed by a secretary of a Department——

Comment on this

Or a harbour authority.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan): Yes. This Bill is required urgently. It was discussed in the Seanad and in this House. I am not saying this in a complaining way but simply as a fact— the present amendment was put down late last evening. It so happens that the Minister who is responsible for the Bill was called away on urgent business and I am standing in for him. It may well be that if the Minister for Justice were here he would accept this amendment. I do not want the House to be at any disadvantage because the Minister for Justice is not here. I have the same rights and responsibilities while I am here as the Minister for Justice would have if he were in the House.

I have listened to the arguments of Deputy Haughey and others in support of the amendment. It may well be that the Minister for Justice, if he were here, would have accepted it, but my opinion is that it will not make a lot of difference one way or another, that it is perhaps not unreasonable that the secretary to the Commissioners of Irish Lights should enjoy the same privilege, if it is not going too far to call it a privilege, as harbour authorities. In the circumstances I propose to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I would be less than gracious if I did not express my appreciation to the Minister. I understand the situation in which he finds himself and I admire his parliamentary courage.

Comment on this

Amendments Nos. 7 and 8 are consequential. I move amendment No. 7:

In Part II, page 13, line 55, after "pilots" to insert "and".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 8:

In Part II, page 13, line 56, to delete "and lighthousekeepers actually employed as such".

Comment on this