Criminal Law Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–189 of 394. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1976 ›
On the last occasion I was seeking clarification from the Minister on the making of suppression orders by the Government under the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, and I should like to ask the Minister again to clarify some points in that respect. Towards the end of the necessarily brief discussion on Friday last we were seeking information in regard to the basis for the Government's opinion which would enable them to make a suppression order under the 1939 Act, which provides in section 18 a number of matters which an organisation might do. Paragraphs (c) and (d) of section 18 provide:
(c) raised or maintains or attempts to raise or maintain a military or armed force in contravention of the Constitution or without constitutional authority, or
(d) engages in, promotes, encourages, or advocates the commission of any criminal offence or the obstruction of or interference with the administration of justice or the enforcement of the law...
Section 19 has the statement "If and whenever the Government are of opinion", and so forth, the Government may make a suppression order. Obviously, such a suppression order would be made only in respect of unlawful organisations: it is clear by definition that there would be unlawful organisations in respect of which no suppression order would be made.
I take it the Minister will accept that the conditions laid down by law are that the Government would form an opinion and the Minister seemed to assume from our questions that we were suggesting it was an airy fairy opinion which did not derive from factual evidence supplied to them. However, the statutory condition for the making of a suppression order is qthat the Government would form an opinion. At that point we asked the Minister whether an opinion had been formed. Does it not imply that the formation of an opinion is something that is less than justified or warranted by any information given to the Government?
The Minister talked about the onus that would be on the Government subsequently in a court application— the onus of establishing beyond doubt that the organisation was unlawful. The Minister will recognise that under section 20 of the 1939 Act it is the applicant, the organisation which were affected by the suppression order, who would apply to the court to have their legality determined—that it is they who would have the onus to prove to the satisfaction of the court that the suppression order should not continue to apply.
I simply want clarification from the Minister. I should like him to say whether he accepts the outline I have given in regard to illegal organisations and suppression orders. There seemed to have been significant confusion, particularly on the question of the Government's opinion and the procedure in regard to the court hearing. I take it the Minister will acknowledge that an organisation may be responding to the unlawful activities of another organisation and that this has no relevance in deciding whether that organisation is unlawful.
Comment on this
The Act provides that whenever the Government are of opinion that an organisation are an unlawful organisation—that they fulfil the conditions of unlawfulness as provided for in section 18—the Government may make a suppression order. The point I wanted to make on the last occasion, and I am glad of the opportunity to make it more fully now, is that in coming to such an opinion the Government cannot do so in any superficial, casual or irresponsible way. The Government can only form such an opinion when they have sufficient evidence to enable them to do so, evidence that could and would stand up to subsequent court questioning should that arise. Whether it is likely to arise is beside the point. The fact that it is provided for in section 20 of the 1939 Act that the legality of the organisation in the context of a suppression order can be challenged means that there is provision in the Act for a full hearing before the High Court and possibly the Supreme Court on the order made by the Government on the Government's opinion.
It is quite clear from that that there would be a serious onus on the Government to satisfy themselves not by just coming to an opinion on hearsay, on newspaper reports, on general popular reports or on common belief but on evidence that would subsequently stand the test in court. It is not just open to the Government to form an opinion, full stop. In forming an opinion the Government must have sufficient material evidence at their disposal successfully to contest an application for a declaration of legality. Whether any organisation at any time should be the subject of a suppression order is something that is monitored from time to time, but the unlawfulness of an organisation, as Deputy O'Kennedy pointed out, does not depend on the Government forming an opinion as to that fact or on the Government making a suppression order. It depends on the activities engaged in by the organisation.
Comment on this
It is much clearer from what the Minister said this afternoon that he has a clearer picture of his responsibilities and duties and how to deal with unlawful organisations. I would like him to let me know if an admission by the UDA or by the UVF to acts of terrorism or criminal acts in this part of the country could not be regarded as sufficient evidence of their being involved in these acts. If so, why does he or the Government not suppress such an organisation?
Comment on this
It is a question of the terms of the admission, who would make it and how it would be made. A newspaper report purporting to be an admission from an organisation of the type mentioned by the Deputy is known to us all. Statements are published in the newspapers over the names of fictitious persons—Captain Black, P. O'Neill and so on. A statement in the newspaper would not necessarily be evidence to justify the forming of an opinion that would subsequently stand up in court. The Government would have to know and be satisfied in terms of a court action as to the actual origin of the opinion and they would have to bear in mind that they are dealing with organisations that are organised in another jurisdiction. This would add immensely and possibly insuperably, to the burden of proof that would arise.
Comment on this
Does the Minister recall saying on the last occasion in reply to Deputy Haughey that to say the Government would come to an opinion would be to imply that the Government would act irresponsibly or without due consideration or words to that effect? Only the record will show what the Minister said. He now acknowledges that this opinion must be the basis of the Government's conclusion. I take it that he is not suggesting, when we reminded him of the statutory condition, namely, that of an opinion, that we were suggesting that this should be an opinion which was not well-informed or well-based.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister acknowledged that because he was the person who took up the misinterpretation of the word "opinion". As far as I recall, Deputy Haughey was simply relying on the statute. The Minister seems to be at pains today to explain that the Government cannot come to these opinions lightly. We accept that. It has never been suggested that they should. The Government's obligation is clearly to inform themselves through the security forces and the information available to them, and come to an opinion of the type suggested.
Having regard to the well published and acknowledged activities of certain organisations, including the IRA and having regard to the type of investigation one would expect our Garda or Army to make in these activities, is the Minister telling us that he has no reliable information that would enable the Government to form a balanced and informed opinion?
Comment on this
The Deputy has strong suspicions about these organisations; so have I and the Government but it is not enough to have suspicions. I thought I made that clear when I spoke originally. It is necessary to have sufficient information and evidence that would subsequently stand up in court. One could not go to court on the basis of newspaper reports, rumours, suspicions or hearsay evidence. One would have to have hard evidence that could, if challenged, stand up in court and support the suppression order. The getting of such hard evidence in the circumstances and in the context of the organisations mentioned is most difficult. Because they are organised outside this jurisdiction that adds immensely and possibly insuperably to the burden. That is something that is available for the Government to do when they feel they can lawfully and legally do so within the confines of the statute. The Government cannot act in any way other than within the confines of the statute. If they felt able to act within the confines of the statute, and so comply with the statute, they would do so but there are great practical difficulties. As I said, it is not enough to have suspicions, rumours and know that something is a popular belief.
Comment on this
Am I right in taking from what the Minister said that he has no reports from the security forces that acts of terror have been committed within this State by the UDA and UVF?
Comment on this
The security forces may have an opinion based on information that comes to them which may fall short of legal evidence. That is frequently the occasion not merely with regard to acts committed by these people but by various unlawful organisations.
Comment on this
At least this afternoon we are beginning to get clear what is the statutory position. Without reopening old sores, I want to suggest that the Minister, perhaps unintentionally, misled the House on the last occasion when he confined his remarks to the operation of section 18 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939. He indicated that it would be necessary for the Government to move under the provisions of section 18.
That section is framed along certain lines and it is quite clear that in order for the Government to deal with one of these organisations about which we are talking they would have to be in a position to move openly in court against one of them and would have to have the evidence necessary. We are all agreed that the Government have the machinery of section 19 if they wish to avail of it. Section 19 is simple and straightforward. It stipulates that
If ... the Government are of opinion that any particular organisation is an unlawful organisation, it shall be lawful for the Government by order ... to declare that such organisation is an unlawful organisation and ought, in the public interest, to be suppressed.
I want to direct the Minister's specific attention to that wording: "If ... the Government are of opinion ... it shall be lawful for the Government ...". The Minister is suggesting here that there would be a possibility, if the Government did not have evidence on which to base their opinion, that they would be acting unlawfully. I suggest that such an interpretation does not come within the meaning of the section as framed. All that is required simpliciter is for the Government to be of opinion and everything is lawful.
The Minister then rightly directs our attention to section 20 which indicates that any person who is aggrieved by one of these suppression orders made by the Government can move in the High Court to have it set aside. The Minister must admit that, in this regard, that is irrelevant. In the context in which we are talking section 20 does not arise. That section is obviously framed to meet the situation in this part of the country where some organisation claims that even though the Government might not like their activities they are, nevertheless, legitimate and legal. Such an organisation can go into our courts and have that position established. We all know there is no question of any of the organisations we are talking about taking such a course of action. If the Government are of the opinion that one of these organisations deserves to be suppressed in the light of information available to them, that is the end of the matter. That organisation can be suppressed.
We then come to the question of whether or not the Government should suppress one of these organisations. I believe the overwhelming majority of the people in this part of the country would support the Government in suppressing one, or two, or three of these organisations by name. Not alone would they support the Government but, if they could articulate their views at present, they would demand that the Government should suppress them in the interests of public safety. I and others on this side of the House know something about the workings of the Department of Justice and the security forces in this country. I am quite certain that, in the Department of Justice, there are files and records dealing specifically with these organisations. In normal peacetime—and I use the word advisedly—the Department of Justice and the security forces here keep an eye on every sort of organisation that might conceivably be unlawful or illegal, or have some sort of deviationist tendencies. That is normal practice.
I refuse to believe there are not in the files of the security forces here, and in the Department of Justice, adequate records of the organisations we are talking about. I am quite convinced detailed dossiers have been built up by our Garda and by the Special Branch on these organisations, on their activities, and on their membership. The Minister is right when he says they are based in the Six County area and, therefore, perhaps our authorities have not the same access to information about them as if they were based here. Nevertheless, I submit it is certain that there are comprehensive dossiers on these organisations in our security files. If that is so, I am also convinced those dossiers would show clearly that the Government are quite capable of coming to an opinion that these organisations are unlawful and should be suppressed on the basis of that information.
If the Minister will state to us categorically that he believes the making of these suppression orders might do more harm than good, that is one argument. He has not made that argument. He will have to convince us and the public that there is some good security reason for not making these suppression orders. Otherwise the public will demand that they be made. I believe these different organisations are responsible for certain atrocities committed here against our people. I believe these have been organised atrocities, that they have not been isolated incidents, that they have come about as a result of the operations of an organisation and that these organisations are capable of being identified by our security forces.
We are led to believe from statements by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, who is here with us at the moment fortunately, that there is close co-operation between the security forces. If that close co-operation exists between the security forces surely there is an avenue there whereby information such as is required on these organisations can be procured, information which would be sufficient to justify the Government in coming to this opinion. We believe these organisations should be suppressed. We believe these suppression orders should be made by the Government. The Minister has not satisfied the House or the general public as to why they should not be made. The Minister will not be able to persuade us that the forces at his disposal have not got sufficient information to enable the making of such orders to be justified.
Comment on this
I have no doubt I will not be able to persuade the Opposition in this regard because I do not think they want to be persuaded, or are capable of being persuaded. Deputy Haughey raised the point that I had not put the argument as to whether it is a good or a bad thing to suppress these people. I did not, because that does not arise until such time as the Government are in a position to be able to make a suppression order.
Deputy Haughey spoke in general terms about what he thinks is in the files available to me. Naturally for reasons of security I cannot reveal what information is available to me. The Government cannot come to an opinion under section 19 unless that opinion can be based on information or evidence which would subsequently stand the test of legal challenge. It is not good enough for a Deputy to come in here and refer to section 20, a section of an Act of Parliament, and dismiss it as being irrelevant. I said it may be unlikely that such a challenge might be taken under section 20. Whether it is likely or unlikely, the point is that section 20 will not go away.
As legislators we cannot ignore what is printed in an Act of Parliament. It implies quite clearly a test before the courts, a test which can only be decided on the facts on which the Government came to their opinion. It would be irresponsible for any Government to come to an opinion unless they had sufficient information at their disposal which would constitute hard evidence, not rumour, not hearsay, not even a policeman's opinion. That is not sufficient. It has to be more than that. I can assure the House that, if and when the Government are in a position to move on any of these lines, the Government will do so, provided the interests of the nation will be served thereby.
Comment on this
In that event, could the Minister tell us what specific evidence does he require which is not available to him at the moment? Could he give us some information as to what would be necessary to enable him to come to this opinion in a way which could not be challenged afterwards? I believe the question of its being challenged in our courts is not really relevant as a practical matter. Could the Minister give us some indication of what evidence he would require which is not available to him at the moment?
Comment on this
There could be a whole range of evidence: the structure of the organisation, its nature, its hierarchy, and so on, information that the organisation as such was formally involved in the activities which would leave it within the ambit of section 18, and that the activities carried out were not perpetrated by individual members but were organised by the organisation and carried out on the direction of the organisation. Obviously these are matters the proof of which would lead to great difficulty.
Comment on this
Has the Minister availed of the co-operation which exists between our forces and the Northern Ireland security forces on this matter?
Comment on this
The Deputy can take it the Garda are in touch with the RUC on all matters of mutual concern.
Comment on this
Surely if that is so, the Minister must acknowledge to us that at least the police force of Northern Ireland have evidence about these organisations. If the co-operation is of the nature and the order the Minister for Foreign Affairs tells us it is, surely that information is available to the Minister, apart from what I am certain his own police force can put at his disposal. I cannot accept—I trust the Minister will accept this as a parliamentary argument—from the Minister his suggestion that, in these circumstances, there is not sufficient evidence available to him and to the Government to enable them to come to this opinion simpliciter. That is all that is involved.
Comment on this
Deputy Haughey is arguing from a position where he has no information on this, where he makes deductions, where he draws conclusions from what he thinks should be the case. I am in a position where the information or lack of it is known to me precisely. As of now, the Government would not be in a position to come to an opinion within the meaning of the Act. Using the words "of opinion" in their common or everyday meaning is one thing, but that is not what we are entitled to do. It is somehow a fallacious argument to suggest that the Government should be able to. It is not a question that the Government should be able to but rather a question of can the Government come to this opinion within the meaning of the Act.
Comment on this
Is the Minister telling us that the Government do not have sufficient information in relation to the UDA, the UVF, Saor Éire or the UFF to indicate to them that these organisations have been or are engaged in the commission of crime or criminal offences?
Comment on this
I must recall again that the Act provides that the Government can come to an opinion, but the point I am making is that this opinion cannot be lightly or irresponsibly reached; it must be an opinion that can stand the test of a subsequent challenge. The Government may have certain information, beliefs and sources of information open to the Government conveying facts to the Government. I am not saying that the Government have no information, that they have no beliefs or suspicions about these organisations. Every citizen has, but the legal requirements of the Act could not be fulfilled as of now.
Comment on this
In case the Minister did notice, I was not relying on the legal requirements of the Act. One of the qualifications for an unlawful organisation—it is one of five —is an organisation that engages in, promotes, encourages or advocates the commission of any criminal offence. That was why I asked the Minister if the Government have any information in relation to these organisations which would indicate that any one of them engages in, promotes, encourages or advocates the commission of any criminal offence. That is a fairly wide ambit for the Minister. We accept without any doubt that it cannot be done on hearsay or on newspaper reports. But we find it difficult to accept, in view of the stated activities, which have not been repudiated publicly, of these organisations, especially those of the last weekend, North and South, that nowhere in the information available to the Minister through the security forces is there sufficient information to indicate that any of these organisations engage in, promote, encourage or advocate the commission of criminal offences. Such information would entitle the Government to make a suppression order.
It is difficult to understand that that information is not available. These organisations did not start yesterday. It is hard to understand the Minister's statement about organisations that openly and freely acknowledge themselves to be engaged in certain activities here and elsewhere. We have to acknowledge that the Minister and the Government make the orders. They have the information and what our opinions would be are totally irrelevant. However I am relying on the Act and I am not relying under any circumstances on anything other than what is in the law. The law is clear on this matter and it enables the Minister on that kind of information to make an order. The Minister should tell us if he does not have any information in relation to any of those organisations which would indicate to him and the Government that they are engaged in the commission of crime or encourage the commission of crime.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell the House what organisations are proscribed in Northern Ireland? If a person is brought into custody suspected of a criminal offence and when in custody it is found that he does not belong to an unlawful organisation as proscribed but belongs to some of the organisations which are not unlawful are the powers of the authority circumscribed in that event?
Comment on this
I do not know precisely what organisations are proscribed in Northern Ireland. I understand—I emphasise the word "understand"—that the IRA and the UVF are suppressed. If a person is taken into custody on suspicion of being connected with a crime the fact that there is a belief that he may or may not be attached to one of these organisations does not circumscribe the powers of the Garda to deal with him. If that organisation was a suppressed organisation that person could be charged with membership of an unlawful organisation in addition to the crime for which he is in custody. The reason that he is in custody would not be prejudiced because the organisation he was thought to belong to was not suppressed. His membership of that organisation in another jurisdiction would not be an offence here.
Deputy O'Kennedy made the point that because of the wide terms of section 18 it was inconceivable that the Government could not come to an opinion but I disagree with him on that. We have to read these statutes strictly and as they are. As Deputy O'Kennedy knows, it is a rule of the construction of criminal statutes that they have to be construed against the prosecutor. It is clear from reading these sections together—they have to be read together—that it is not sufficient for the Government to believe on a newspaper article or on the basis of a report from one policeman to another that the terms of the statute are thereby sufficiently complied with to enable them make a suppression order. We may all feel that these organisations engage in, promote, encourage or advocate the commission of a criminal offence but it is not enough for me to believe that or have an opinion.
Comment on this
It has to be able subsequently to stand up in court. Whether a person is acting as a member of an organisation or whether his actions were done on behalf of an organisation or whether those actions were done by individuals loosely describing themselves as members of organisations are two vastly different things in law within the meaning of these sections.
Comment on this
I see we are not going to get anywhere with the Minister on this section although we are reflecting a high level of public opinion here. Would the Minister not agree that it would in many instances considerably assist the Garda and the Army in dealing with certain crimes committed against the public order in this part of the country because of their hit and run nature if these organisations were unlawful and the members of them could be held as a result under the provisions of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939? Would it not be of considerable assistance to our security forces in combating atrocities committed by one of these organisations against our people if the organisation was suppressed, declared unlawful, and if people could be detained under the Offences Against the State Act as a result? Does the Minister not admit that that would be so? For that reason is there not a strong case in favour of suppressing these organisations, declaring them to be unlawful?
Comment on this
I agree with the Deputy that it can be of assistance to the Garda and the Army in certain instances to be able to detain people from the other jurisdiction on charges of membership. Then there is the question of proof. Will the chief superintendent be the proving person, or will proof rely on the possession of incriminating documents, which are rarely found nowadays? These are practical difficulties. Nevertheless I can see that there could be occasions when it could be an advantage, and this would be one of the desirable objectives, if the Government could find themselves in a position to make suppression orders against these organisations. I share the general feeling of abhorrence for these organisations. The House can take it from me that when it is proper to do so, having regard to the legal requirements, it will be done. There have been instances where people from the other jurisdiction have been arrested, charged and convicted on offences here and the proceedings have not been inhibited in any way. There have been no notorious cases where culprits were let loose or escaped justice because suppression orders had not been made. There could be instances where it would be of assistance to the security forces, and this of course is also a consideration kept constantly in mind by the Government.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that bombs were placed in Belturbet which killed people, and in Swanlinbar, blowing up the church and the school, and some business premises, including some owned by the Minister's relation. The Minister is aware also that the UVF claimed to have done this. I do not want to enter into the sub judice area here, but it was reported in the papers that somebody was charged who was a known member of the UVF. Does this not indicate that the Minister could make a suppression order against the UVF?
Comment on this
In relation to the instances mentioned by the Deputy, it was common belief that they were IRA originated. In relation to the individual in custody, it was not reported in the newspapers that he was a well known member of any particular organisation. I cannot say anything more about that.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that it was generally believed that the church in Swanlinbar and the school and the business premises were blown up by the IRA?
Comment on this
On this definition section the Minister has not at all satisfied this side of the House. It is extremely difficult to accept the Minister's statement that the Garda and the Army, our security forces, have no firm information on any criminal act or terrorist act committed within our part of the country by either the UVF or the UDA. One would surely think that the frequency of these crimes would have given plenty of opportunity to our security forces to gather whatever firm information was needed to satisfy the Minister and the Government that they could suppress these organisations.
Comment on this
As is usual, recently, the Minister seems to be obsessed with the idea that violence only stems from the IRA. There are so many variations of those other organisations that it is hard to keep up with them, all being part of the pattern not to have themselves identified, and to blind the Minister and those in authority here to the fact that they are a danger to this State and to its institutions. Over the years they have repeatedly declared themselves to be bent on retaliation here. Of course this is in keeping with the Minister's statement—a statement made in the heat of the moment, which very often produces some truth —when he said that these organisations were merely a reaction to the activities of the Provisional IRA. The Minister's stance today looks absolutely ludicrous. It is clearly evident to him—and the information is available to his forces and is available to him from his collaborators on the other side of the Border—that these organisations are a real danger to our safety and to our institutions on this side of the Border. At Kathleen Falls in Bally-shannon, a medallion was found with UVF stamped on it. That was the first incident, when a man was electrocuted on top of the transformer station. Of course none of these things—Swanlinbar, Monaghan Town, Belturbet and so on—count. They do not "form an opinion" when one is obsessed and biased—as the Minister undoubtedly now is, to the point that he is completely blind to the situation.
Is the Minister aware that a place called the Border Inn was given the "once over" just a fortnight ago, and as usual the propaganda orchestration was such that the Provisional IRA were blamed? But, in a matter of hours afterwards, it was discovered that it was not the IRA but one of those cross-Border operations. Many of these organisations, far from being reaction groups to the IRA, are older than the Minister and older than I am. They were there long before the IRA, and their depredations were carried on without the light of publicity that has been shed upon them in more recent years. They were the underground people who did what the Establishment by suppression and discrimination were not capable of doing. The fact that the UVF are declared an unlawful organisation by the authorities in the Six Counties or in Britain should be good enough for the Minister. Surely this is an organisation that the Minister and his Government must have an opinion on, if only because their counterparts on the other side are of such an opinion and they have proscribed them and made them illegal.
If the Minister thinks that he can get any sort of acceptance of his outlook of chasing, day and night, imaginary and otherwise IRA, while at the same time ignoring these other organisations to the point that he does not even make a suppression order against them, he is living in a fool's paradise.
These are real threats, and the Minister must have sufficient evidence at least to have a clear opinion even if it will not stand up in a court of law. What evidence is given or sought at the moment other than the opinion of a superintendent as to who is a member of the one prescribed organisation that we have here, a superintendent who in all probability has been informed by some subordinate, who was in turn informed by some informer, who is never produced, and that is sufficient in our Special Court to convict a person charged with membership of the declared illegal organisation of the IRA. If that sort of link can be accepted and is, in fact, accepted in our courts, surely the Government—obsessed though they may be, blind though they may be, biased though they may be that violence comes from one source only, namely, the IRA—should find it possible to even things out and give the people, particularly in the Border areas, some protection from the members of these organisations that are day in and day out on our side of the Border.
The Minister has no concern whatever in that regard, no concern about what happens in Monaghan, Belturbet, Swanlinbar, Donegal, Drogheda, Louth or anywhere else. Any violence anywhere is immediately laid at the door of the IRA, despite the fact that time and time again it has emerged that the violence was not due to the IRA. I suppose these are acts of God. If it was not the IRA nobody else apparently had hand, act or part in it. These things just happened. I suppose they will continue to happen and the Minister will go along with this three-pronged package and hold himself out to be a great man in keeping law and order. Unless the Minister is biased to the degree that he is not fit to be where he is—and I am not suggesting he is not—he can have no doubt as to who were responsible for the Dublin bombs. I am talking about the earlier instances in which people were killed. Is the Minister suggesting that job was done by the IRA? Has he any knowledge of who committed the offence or from what direction it came? Is the Minister not a laughing stock, are we not a laughing stock, at the moment when the real culprits, those who can have the finger put on them, are the members of the British Army? We must talk sense about what should be suppressed and what should be illegal this side of the Border, what should be allowed and what should be proscribed.
The British Army has the record right down through the years and the Minister does not have to take my word for that, or the press publicity, or the television cameras. He has the evidence of the case he took and fought to a successful conclusion against that self-same British Army and the excesses of its members in the Six Counties. I suppose "Bloody Sunday" was something that happened out of the blue. That was something like lightning. Is the Minister aware two young people were killed near Bridgend in Donegal a short time ago? Has he any information that it was an act perpetrated by somebody from the other side of the Border rather than the IRA on this side of it? Does the Minister realise that that same army has perpetrated more violence on our people and are the prime cause of most of our trouble than all the other illegal organisations, including the UVF, the UDR, the UDA and so on?
The Minister must be living in cloud-cuckoo land when he comes in here and attempts to justify his inaction and his selectivity in the application of the law on this side of the Border. Can the Minister not feel compelled to declare these organisations to be unlawful organisations? Remember, their members in the Six Counties are in jails in the Six Counties for the crimes they have committed in the names of these organisations? Does the Minister not accept what is readily available, never mind what would be available to him from his contacts there and across in Britain, as evidence against any organisation except the IRA? Why is the evidence available of the crimes committed by these organisations not accepted by the Minister to enable him to form an opinion and present that opinion to his Government on evidence produced and adduced to the point where members of all these organisations are currently serving various sentences in various jails throughout the Six Counties?
Why is there this selectivity? We have the definite evidence of these people being in jail for their activities or interned in the concentration camps at Magilligan Point and Long Kesh? The Minister ignores this evidence. These do not belong to the IRA. They belong to half a dozen other organisations which use different names and thereby leave themselves free to circulate down on this side of the Border. The Minister knows these people exist. Numbers of them have been convicted. But the Minister takes no action because, wide as the provision available to him is, he cannot even reach the point where the Government could justifiably say they are "of the opinion". If they are not "of the opinion" in this matter I shudder to think what their attitude must be about many other more complex and difficult things facing us on other fronts. Can the Minister give us any inkling at all that he is even working towards being "of the opinion" that he could take action against the people who are our really dangerous enemies and who are declared to be such enemies? Has he even begun to think in that direction? Can we have an indication from him that he is thinking that way and that he is seeking evidence to back up what is being said day in and day out, back up the claims of spokesmen of these organisations to the point that he can go to his Government and get them to be of that opinion? If he cannot do that, then what we are doing now and what we have been doing for the past two weeks becomes an even bigger horse laugh.
It is on the conflict in the Six Counties that we are hanging this entire three-part package. It is to the national emergency declaration that we tied the Emergency Powers Bill. It is to back all of that up that we are bringing in this Bill, to supplement all our existing laws, but most notably the Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Bill. All of that hinges on the one phrase used throughout, that is, "conflict in the Six Counties", or "Northern Ireland", as the Government prefer to describe it nowadays. While those people up there and in Great Britain would like to call it "Northern Ireland"—though it is not Northern Ireland in the real sense—or "Ulster", it is to be "Northern Ireland" in this House henceforth. It is not so long ago when it was not.
Inside the confines of that territory, annexed to us, there have been and are happenings that nobody in their sane senses could attribute entirely, in all instances or even in half of them, to the IRA and their activities. We know that members of these other organisations are in jails and concentration camps in the Six Counties, their activities having been proven in those courts for whose impartiality I have anything but regard. They have found in many cases sufficient evidence to put those people away, those people who are known to be, have been recognised as and proclaim themselves to be members of those said organisations which were in existence before the Provisional IRA was even thought about, were in existence generations ago, with the link obviously continued right up to the present day.
I am sure the Minister hardly intended to convey that their existence is justified merely because as he suggested in haste the other evening, of reaction to the Provisional IRA, who came into being as a result of the reaction of the people to the suppression of the Establishment deriving from the occupation of our country by the British. If we want to seek justification for everything done, we go back to the occupiers, not merely a few years back when the Provisional IRA arose from the need for protection of the people in the Six Counties, as the Minister well knows; protection from the people who are the backbone of these various organisations under their various guises. They sought protection from their depredations and intimidations, aided and abetted by the paramilitary force known as the B-Specials, aided at times but ignored in their excesses by the RUC, who in turn have been aided and abetted and indeed outstripped by the excesses of the British Army, the army of the occupier.
We are here talking in the circumstances of today about a national emergency as a result of armed conflict in the Six Counties, directly the result of suppression by the puppet Establishment forces up there and by the occupiers—all of it stemming from them. What are we dealing with? The Minister and his Government have an obsession about one organisation only. By their propaganda they have many of our people obsessed in the same way, without seeing the wood for the trees. They should live among them. They should go up and find out for themselves. They would then bloody well soon have an opinion, and a lot more than an opinion, as to who are the oppressors and what is the danger.
Comment on this
We do not intend to oppose the section because we are prevented from so doing by reason of its being the definitions section. Therefore, it would not be very sensible parliamentary procedure to oppose it.
Nevertheless before the section passes we feel we should make it clear that the Minister has not satisfied us in this matter. He has not put forward anything like a convincing case for not making the organisation about which we have been talking unlawful and suppressing it. We feel there would be widespread public demand in this part of the country for such suppression. We feel it would very considerably aid our Garda Síochána and Army in preventing or dealing with atrocities committed by these organisations if suppression orders were to be made by the Minister. We are completely at a loss to understand his reluctance to do so. He has admitted our case: that these orders would be helpful to our security forces in dealing with such threats.
The only argument the Minister could put forward is that he has not got sufficient evidence to enable him to do so. We cannot accept—and I am speaking about the Minister now in his parliamentary capacity—that statement from the Minister that sufficient evidence is not available to him to enable him suppress these organisations, making suppression orders against them and considerably assisting our security forces in dealing with the threats they pose to our people from time to time.
Comment on this
I am not going to be able to satisfy the Opposition because they are not going to be satisfied, no one of them. All I can repeat is that when it is proper for the Government to move in this regard the Government will move.
Comment on this
Deputy Blaney's reminder of the origins of the IRA prompted me to put this question to the Minister. Can the Minister tell us if a suppression order has been made by the Government in respect of the Provisional IRA? As I understand it, a suppression order exists for an organisation known as the IRA, Óglaigh na hÉireann, as I recall the Minister said the last day. Does a suppression order exist for the Provisional IRA as distinct from the IRA?
Comment on this
As far as the law is concerned, there is just an IRA. There would be various factions in it which adopt adjectives or descriptive titles for their own identification purposes. But, as far as the law is concerned, there is just one unlawful organisation; they are all the same.
Comment on this
I take it that that was established Government policy in 1971 and 1972 that—to use Deputy Haughey's phrase—there was no convincing case put forward for a suppression order against the Provisional IRA?
Comment on this
I imagine that the suppression order that was in existence at that time covered any offshoots or particular factions of the particular organisation.
Comment on this
The Minister has again indicated that he does not have the wherewithal to declare any organisation unlawful except, as he said, the IRA, whatever sort of IRA, Óglaigh na hÉireann. He said they were all the same. The other outfits about which I am speaking are all the same as well, except more so. The Minister does not have any opinion about this; he cannot get around to it. Does the Minister realise just how ludicrous his whole effort and our performance in this House in these last two or three weeks appears?
Does the Minister realise how ludicrous his performance now stands when we are discussing a section that deals with certain penalties for certain organisations and how it appears to the general public? If there is no co-operation from the public no law can be operated successfully as the Establishment in the Six Counties have found out. Because there was not that co-operation in the Six Counties we now have the situation that exists there. Yet, we are now proceeding in this House to deal in the same kind of traffic as the occupiers in the Six Counties have done during the years until there came the point when the general public would not tolerate it any longer.
We are using a colossal sledge-hammer to crack something that is relatively small. If we selectively apply it to part of the problem only, as the Minister undoubtedly intends, let him take heed. The public will not come with him on it because people in the Border areas, and even as far south as Dublin, realise that they must also take note of the activities of any or all of the various organisation; in the Minister's words they were all of a kind, were all the same, although I would not have used those words.
We have reason to fear all those people but yet we officially ignore that fact at Government level. We do this to the point where the Minister for Justice tells us that we have not sufficient information or evidence that they are a danger to us and, at the same time, we are laid down with sledge-hammers after one organisation. People will not go along with it and when that happens it will not be possible to operate successfully any laws that may be passed. To his great disappointment the Minister will find out that his obsession and his coloured outlook in regard to this matter is not shared by the people; without their sharing his views it is obvious that what he is proposing is not only unnecessary but is a waste of good time and money that the Government have not got and that the rest of us are not in a position to give them any more.
Comment on this
This section is self-explanatory. It increases the maximum penalties for a number of offences under the Offences Against the State Act, 1939. The first offence dealt with is the offence of usurpation of the functions of the Government and the penalty is increased to 20 years.
Comment on this
Will the Minister state how many convictions there have been in the last 20 years for that offence?
Comment on this
That was my impression but I did not have the records that the Minister has available to him. I presume the purpose of imposing heavier penalties—there has been a significant increase, in one case from two years to 20 years—is to act as a deterrent against the commission of the offences. The Minister has told us that as far as he knows there have been no convictions and I think there have not been any charges although I may be wrong. Will the Minister say what makes it necessary to increase the penalty for an offence, in respect of which there has been no conviction, so dramatically from two years to 20 years?
Comment on this
It is an extremely serious offence and, next to treason, it is possibly the most serious offence known to our law. Treason is provided for in the Constitution; the usurpation of the functions of Government is something less than treason but it is an offence in that category. I do not think there is a more serious offence in the area of constitutional law. It is necessary to mark the seriousness of the offence by increasing the penalty relative to the other offences in the Bill. There has to be a certain internal proportion between offences and the penalties for them. It would be somewhat incongruous to have a greater penalty for what most people would regard as a lesser offence. It is necessary to mark the essential seriousness of the offence by having an increased penalty and, secondly, to preserve an internal relationship, to preserve proportion. We should be glad that there have been no convictions and we hope in spite of the difficult times in which we are living that this increased deterrent will maintain that state of affairs. The fact that there have been no convictions is not necessarily an argument——
Comment on this
Apart from what the Minister has called an internal relativity—this is a new phrase to me——
Comment on this
I have not heard the phrase used in criminal law. Generally the purpose of the court in imposing sentences is by way of punishment for offences committed or as a deterrent to those who might contemplate such offences. Simply to increase considerably the penalty, as has been done in one section, from two years to 20 years——
Comment on this
Section 6 (2) of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939 states:
Every person who shall attempt to do any thing the doing of which is a felony under the foregoing subsection of this section or who aids or abets or conspires with another person to do or attempt to do any such thing or advocates or encourages the doing of any such thing shall be guilty of a misdemeanour and shall be liable on conviction thereof to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
Section 2 (2) of the Bill we are discussing states:
The maximum penalty for a misdemeanour under section 6 of the Act of 1939 shall be imprisonment for 20 years and, accordingly, section 6 (2) of that Act is hereby amended by the substitution of "imprisonment for a term not exceeding 20 years" for "imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years".
That is a tenfold increase for a misdemeanour——
Comment on this
As the Deputy knows, a misdemeanour does not relate to the seriousness of the offence. It is a technical word to describe the category of the offence.
Comment on this
I am not saying that the offence we are talking about is not serious but the section we are dealing with——
Comment on this
That may be so but the Minister will recognise that in this instance there is a tenfold increase in respect of a misdemeanour for which, on his admission, there has been no conviction.
Comment on this
Therefore, this seems to be an indication of the stated intention of the Government to take a very firm line in respect of offences of a type not yet committed.
Comment on this
What is important is to ensure that whatever we do here will mean the minimum need for cases to be brought before our courts. The provision here, fortunately, has not been applied under the old Act so I hope that the Government have given serious thought to increasing tenfold, for instance, the sentences under subsection (2) and to what may be the consequences of that in so far as the existing penalty has proved to be effective in the sense that so far as we know no charge has been brought in respect of it. That is a good test of the effectiveness of any penalty. I trust that the Minister and the Government are satisfied that what they are proposing now will not have a counter effect.
Comment on this
We are so satisfied. It is inconceivable that it could have a counter effect. We cannot be deterred from doing what we consider to be right by any fear of adverse reaction from the enemies of the State.
Comment on this
The offence in question is the offence of the usurpation of the functions of Government or attempted usurpation of functions of Government. I cannot conceive of any offence more serious than that. It is in the very next category to treason which is the most serious offence of all.
Comment on this
It seems to me that the Minister is taking a very defensive attitude on this matter and that to some extent is symptomatic of his general approach to the whole Bill. Surely the situation in regard to this admittedly serious crime is that if there were a charge and conviction and if at the end of ten years' imprisonment, which is the existing maximum penalty for the felony, that term was found not to be sufficient, the functions of Government would have been usurped. In other words, if the offence is repeated despite the maximum period in prison, the function of Government would have been usurped. Therefore, is there not a point in Deputy O'Kennedy's argument that there ought not to be need for an increase in the present maximum and that to some extent there is a psychological advantage in leaving the penalties as they are?
Comment on this
I disagree and I regret that the Deputy should think I am on the defensive. However, I suppose I am defending attacks against the Bill so that by definition I must be on the defensive. I cannot avoid that. I can only repeat what I said to Deputy O'Kennedy—that the Government consider the seriousness of the offence we are talking about requires it to be marked by a high maximum penalty. These are not necessarily the penalties that will be imposed. They are the maxima and I should hope that there would not be such an incidence of convictions in relation to this offence as to bring to pass what is sought to be prevented by the section.
Comment on this
One extremely important point has been overlooked completely since we began debating this section. The section provides for increasing penalties in five separate instances. These relate to sections 6, 7, 15, 21 and 27 of the 1939 Act but to the best of my knowledge there has been no conviction in respect of three of those sections—sections 6, 7 and 15. I am open to correction on that but we have had no conviction under them since the present Minister for Justice assumed office.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister will be good enough to let us have details of those cases. Do they relate to the Herrema case?
Comment on this
The offences relating to section 7 were in respect of the Herrema case while the offence relating to section 15 was in respect of offences which occurred some time last year at Dundalk.
Comment on this
The Minister will appreciate that there were many charges in the Herrema case and that this section was not required on its own to nail down the accused.
Comment on this
In my Second Reading speech on this Bill I said it was likely that there had been a conviction under this section but that this related to the Herrema case. I said, then, that I was open to correction on that. The point I am trying to make is that when this package of legislation was introduced we were told that certain powers were necessary to combat crime and the provisions of the section of the Bill before us were highlighted by the Minister and by other Government speakers at every opportunity. I have said that the main purpose of this section is nothing more than window dressing, that the fact that we are increasing the sentences applicable for offences under sections 6, 7 and 15 will not help the situation in any way. This is unfortunate.
The doubling or trebling of sentences in respect of offences in respect of non-operative or unused criminal law legislation is nothing more than an exercise in futility and is unlikely to contribute anything to the ending of the so-called emergency in which we are living. According to the Minister for Foreign Affairs, when he spoke yesterday at Killarney, the emergency is something of a technical nature. In other words, the purpose of this legislation is merely a technicality so that the Garda can be given power to detain people without charge for seven days. Are we to doubt the words of the Minister for Foreign Affairs or are we to believe him and, consequently, to see this legislation as a piece of window dressing? It is a measure which could have been introduced last June or left until the Dáil was due to resume in October.
I would go along with the provision to increase from two to seven years the penalty for membership of an unlawful organisation. I am glad, though, that the seven years' penalty is a maximum bearing in mind that there might be cases involving young or immature persons finding themselves involved in the IRA but being affected seriously by having to serve the full seven years' imprisonment. I said during the Second Reading that we are not opposing the section providing for increased penalties but we believe they are nothing but window dressing.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us if there have been many cases under section 15?
Comment on this
I have not got any statistics. Deputies will realise it is a difficult offence to detect because of its nature. It has to be found as it is being committed. There have been indications of the offence having been committed but the bird had, so to speak, flown when the Garda arrived. It is a serious offence and it is appropriate that the penalty be increased. We are particularly anxious to ensure that this might be a deterrent to young immature persons.
Comment on this
Would the Minister say how many prosecutions there have been?
Comment on this
We can give a very clear illustration of our attitude to this package of proposals by the Government. As my colleague, Deputy Collins, has indicated, we are not opposing section 2, but there are many aspects that cause us concern.
It is somewhat laughable in reference to section 6 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939 that these increases in penalties are being proposed when there has never been a prosecution taken or convictions secured under the original Act. Somewhat the same situation applies in regard to sections 7 and 15. If some prosecutions have been taken under these sections as they originally stood, they were to a large extent marginal, so that my colleague, Deputy Collins, is correct when he says that to a great extent subsections (1), (2), (3), (4) and (5) of this section are window dressing.
The Minister has made no attempt to justify what he is proposing here and if we were simply to accept the debate as it has unrolled here we would not give the Government these additional powers because the Minister has not even bothered to argue the case. One suspects he is presuming on our goodwill in this respect. We have indicated to the Government that, whereas we do not think this section is something that anybody can stand over as it is being put before us, nevertheless we say to the Government that they have the responsibility and therefore if they say to us that they want these powers and we find that they are not particularly Draconian, then we will accept them. They are to a large extent simply increasing penalties for crimes and offences which are already on the Statute Book.
There is a difference with subsection (6). This is a proposal which we frankly find exceedingly distateful, particularly, as Deputy Collins has said, where young, immature persons are concerned. Everybody should be quite clear on exactly what we are doing here in subsection (6). We are now enabling a person to be sent to jail for seven years on no greater evidence than the word of a chief superintendent of the Garda Síochána that such a person is a member of an illegal organisation. Let us all recognise that this is a very serious and far-reaching measure which we are proposing here. Many people object in principle and in conscience to the idea that a chief superintendent could be enabled, in effect, to send the person to jail for two years simply by making a statement to a certain effect, but it is a much more serious matter when this very simple device of a superintendent giving evidence can send a person to jail for seven years. In the case of a young person, seven years in jail is a very long time and we should certainly like to see in this section some protection for the type of young, immature persons to whom Deputy Collins has referred.
Because of our history, it is not very difficult for a young person with a certain outlook very innocently to become involved in affairs of an illegal organisation or even to create the impression in the minds of the Garda Síochána that he is a member of an illegal organisation. Let us all recognise, in all seriousness, that it is a very severe penalty to commit that young person to jail for seven years on that basis.
Although we will not oppose this section, as Deputy Collins has out-lined, nevertheless we feel that it is our duty to point out to the House and to the public exactly what is involved. I do not know if the Minister has given this the serious consideration he has indicated that he gave to other parts of this proposal. I do not know if he is acting on the principle that if two years is a deterrent, then seven years is a much more serious deterrent. I would hope that he is not. I should like the Minister to say something about subsection (6). I know that the attitude he expressed here in the Dáil will not be taken cognisance of in a court of law, but it is important that the Minister should say something about this aspect.
I do not think any of us are particularly concerned about subsection (7), though again it has unfortunate implications. It affects the freedom of people to express their opinions, freedom to hold public meetings and so on, but we are applying our principle here and if the Government say that they want this power, we will not oppose it. We will not oppose any of the subsections, (1) to (7), but we have very serious doubts and reservations about them, particularly section (6). Even at this late stage the Minister should consider whether in the case of young persons some restriction should be placed on the maximum of seven years.
The Minister will, of course, point out to us that these are only maxima and that it will be left to the discretion of the court, but that is only half a defence from his point of view. Once the offence is spelt out in the statute and once the Oireachtas lays down the terms of imprisonment, they become associated and there becomes an onus, an implication, that that period of years is appropriate to that particular offence. I believe that there will be a great deal of public disquiet about subsection (6) when it is fully realised what is involved and I would hope the Minister would say something in the course of his reply to this debate to mitigate that public disquiet.
The fact that this offence can be confirmed in court simply on the statement of an officer of the Garda Síochána, to the effect that it is his opinion that such and such is the case, is a very serious aspect of the matter. To the greatest extent the rest of this section is simply window dressing, as has been suggested by Deputy Collins.
Comment on this
Deputy Haughey misunderstands or does not appreciate how heinous the offence of membership of the IRA is and misjudges public reaction to it. The public absolutely detest the IRA. In the public mind, membership of the IRA is a most serious crime and there is a general wish to see the IRA suppressed. It is important that everybody in this House would recognise that, and that everybody here in supporting this section would do so with that in mind. It should be self-evident that one of the factors in defeating terrorism must be the deterrent effect of the penalties available to those caught in acts of terrorism.
The first two acts—usurpation of Government and obstruction of Government are again self-evidently monstrous offences striking to the very root of our State. I do not know if there is a proper appreciation on all sides of this House of the absolute necessity at all times to be vigilant about our institutions and to ensure that the laws passed here take account of the need to be vigilant and take account of the continuing trust that is being placed in us to ensure their protection. The reasons for all this may be found in history. We of this generation may become blasé because our institutions appear to be solid, immovable and have a great permanency, about them. It is very important that we continue to ensure that they maintain this permanency. The offences I have mentioned—the usurpation or obstruction of Government—are so inherently dangerous and can carry such threats to the continuation of that permanency that it is only right that this Legislature should mark them as being most serious offences indeed.
Drilling and engaging in military manoeuvres is a most serious offence because, as I indicated to Deputy Brugha, very often engaging in drilling or military exercises is the way in which young people are corrupted into becoming involved with the IRA. It is very important that this should be presented to the public as a serious offence so that parents who might be careless or negligent in their duties, without being supporters of that organisation, will be extremely careful to make sure that the company their children keep does not lead them into any such activities.
It is very important that this Legislature should send out, from all sides of the House, a completely unequivocal message of determination to end terrorism, to down the terrorists. It grieves me that the acceptance in principle, which I welcomed, for this Bill is being so hedged with qualifications that it is becoming not as valuable as I hoped it would be. Membership of the IRA is a heinous offence because the IRA are a heinous organisation. Young comparatively innocent people may be recruited into it, but after they have gone through their apprenticeship a lot of the innocence will have rubbed off. It will be for the court in hearing the evidence and the defendant—if the defendant chooses to speak and recognise the court—to decide the appropriate penalty, having regard to the usefulness, age and experience of the defendant.
Notwithstanding the unusual way in which this offence can now be proved—a way to which I took objection four years ago and which, in principle, is still open to objection —and because of the seriousness of the situation we are in, I do not think now is the time to remove any of the weapons available in the armoury of the State. That weapon in the hands of the police force, subject to an unequivocal Executive is one thing, but an Executive seeking that power, when it was sought originally having regard to the history of those crimes, was a totally different context. It is important to have this point cleared up.
The essence of the matter is that membership of the IRA is a most serious offence and the public at large expect it to be so marked. I was taken aback at Deputy Haughey's protestations that the change in subsection (7)—this is the subsection which increases the penalties for taking part in a public meeting which has been banned—impedes the freedom of speech.
Comment on this
As it is on the record, I think I should clear up this point. We must remember that this section is dealing with meetings that have been banned, not for the sake of banning free speech but because they are being held by or on behalf of, or in arrangement or in concept with an unlawful organisation and for the purpose of supporting, aiding and abetting. It is inconceivably careless that any Deputy should allege that a penalty for partaking in such a meeting could be held to be an impediment on the freedom of speech.
Comment on this
Let me clear up that point. We have had the experience of a Deputy being present at such a meeting. Let us be clear about that.
Comment on this
Let the Minister not accuse me of being careless in my interpretation. I was very specific in what I said and I stand over it. I said we are supporting this if the Government think it necessary.
Comment on this
Let us all recognise that it is a further diminution of our rights of free speech unfortunately.
Comment on this
It can be, because the Minister knows full well that the original section leaves it to the discretion of an officer of the Garda Síochána to decide——
Comment on this
We will accept that but let everybody recognise that it is a further diminution of our democratic freedom of speech. Perhaps it is a necessary diminution, as the Minister says, and we accept that, but let him not be cavilling at my regret that we have to do these things.
Comment on this
It is not a diminution of free speech to stop the subversives holding public meetings.
Comment on this
If the Minister believes he should dismiss as hedging our criticisms of this section then he is very wrong. We told him this afternoon, and during the Second Reading, that we were supporting the measures in this section even though we had reservations. If we have criticism it is not right that he, even if he is unable to restrain himself from dismissing this criticism as hedging, should get away with it. Everybody on this side of the House wants and demands the suppression of the IRA and we have said that time and time again. The Minister inferred that this was not so and that it was not the unanimous wish of this House. That is very wrong as we have told him time and time again. I understand that the increases in penalties can be, and I hope will be, a deterrent to the perpetrators of crimes.
This section is increasing the penalties in three sections of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, one of which was never used in 37 years, one of which was used only once in recent times, and I cannot tell the Minister how many times the other one was used but not terribly often. These three sections of the 1939 Act have not been relied on by this Government or their predecessors in dealing with subversives. That is why we have said the increases in the penalties in this section are window dressing, to our mind, to a very great degree, but we are going along with them.
With regard to the prohibition of membership of an unlawful organisation under section 21 of the 1939 Act, the point has been made that unfortunately and tragically many youngsters of 14 and 15 years of age are in the IRA. God knows the destruction and harm they can do with explosives and weapons. They can be of an unbelievably serious nature. Lives can be lost. People can be maimed. Recognising the evil and foul deeds which have been done by such young people who unfortunately are in the IRA, we are glad it is left to the discretion of the courts to decide the sentence which should be levied on them if they come before the courts.
The Minister put forward as one of his reasons for increasing the penalties that he wanted to remind parents they must be careful of the company their children keep. I think the Minister is on record in this House as saying the first knowledge a particular parent had, in a county not too far from the Border, of the involvement of a child of his in active membership of the IRA was when the remains of a suit of clothing of that child were brought to him for identification, the child having been blown up while placing bombs or doing something with explosives. We should all like to see all parents being not alone careful but extremely vigilant of the company their children keep.
Because of our strong belief in this regard we have put down an amendment to the next section to deal with, as strongly as we think they should be dealt with, those who are getting after people under the age of 18 years and inciting, inviting or recruiting them into the IRA. I want to let the Minister know again exactly where we stand. We stand firmly and strongly against the IRA and those who support them. We have the right to criticise the provisions of this section and to describe some of them as mere window dressing.
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell me why there has been no increase in the penalties under section 8 of the Offences Against the State Act dealing with obstruction of the President? Has that section been repealed totally?
Comment on this
I did not think it had been. I want to have some consistency from the Minister on this. Since that section was brought into operation has any charge been brought in our courts of usurpation of the functions of the President? I do not think so. I think I am right about that. Will the Minister accept that there could be nothing more serious for us than that the President, the man who signs into law what we pass here, should be obstructed in the course of his functions? That being so, anyone who obstructs him or prevents him from doing what he is authorised to do under our Constitution, would be guilty of a very serious and heinous offence, to use the Minister's own words. Anyone who attempted to do so, or conspired to do so, would also be guilty of a very serious offence. I am testing the Minister's consistency. He has introduced a Bill with a penalty of two years' imprisonment for somebody who attempts to or who conspires to obstruct our President in the discharge of his functions, amongst other things in signing into law this Bill or any other Bill. The maximum penalty for that has been left at two years by the Minister.
Comment on this
No. Subsection (2) provides:
Every person who aids or abets or conspires with another person to do any thing the doing of which is a felony under the foregoing subsection of this section or advocates or encourages the doing of any such thing shall be guilty of a misdemeanour and shall be liable on conviction thereof to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
What kind of—I have to use this expression—confused if not twisted logic prompted the Minister and the Government to increase tenfold the penalty for an offence which has never been brought before the courts, that is, usurpation of the functions of the Government? The biggest increase in the Bill is for an attempt at or encouragement of that offence. Despite his protestations about the need to protect our institutions, the Minister blandly passed over section 8 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939.
I am not saying the Minister should be increasing the penalties under that section. The fact that no charge has ever been brought and no conviction has ever been registered makes it clear to me that there is no such need and that our President is safe and secure from any such attack. If the Minister can justify an increase in the penalty from two years to 20 years in respect of a charge which has never been brought, namely, attempted usurpation or the encouragement of the usurpation of the power of the Government, he should be at least similarly sensitive with regard to the functions of the President. Reluctantly I must come to the same conclusion my colleagues reached that this is window dressing. To quote the Minister's own phrase, there is no internal relativity in these offences. If there were, the Minister might have considered something else. I could refer the Minister to other matters he overlooked but one is enough to make my case.
The clue lies elsewhere because there is a complete lack of logic and consistency in what the Minister is presenting to us. A few moments ago the Minister said rhetorically: "I do not know if there is a full appreciation outside this House of the need at all times to be vigilant". In other words, the Minister was questioning whether the public are sufficiently conscious of the need at all times to be vigilant. He said that in the context of the increased penalties he is introducing in this legislation. All of us will encourage vigilance at all times, but vigilance is not always related to fear of punishment. All of our institutions have our support but vigilance is not always achieved by increasing penalties. Sometimes that may have an opposite effect.
The Government may increase penalties as an indication of their determination but that may not be calculated to give rise to the vigilance about which we are all concerned. We have little or no right to criticise the public as being less than vigilant. They have been very vigilant, indeed, and we want them to be even more vigilant in supporting our security forces. The Minister should not imply that these increased penalties are somehow necessary because the public have been less than vigilant.
I should now like to refer to the Minister's interpretation of Deputy Haughey's question about the increase from two to seven years for membership. The Minister has acknowledged that he was the one who in this House very strongly resisted—that is something of an understatement—the introduction of the section and the penalty of two years which he is now increasing to seven. He resisted it to a point of great personal principle, even to the point of there being a very definite difference between himself and his leader at the time. We are expected to accept that resistance in principle from the Minister at this time but any question from this side of the House based on the same conviction, perhaps, the same doubt and the same reasoning which prompted him, plus the fact that we are now increasing from two to seven years the penalty contained in the section he opposed strongly gives rise to a response from him that we are less than wholehearted in our support for the provisions of this Bill generally, as we indicated on Second Stage, or less than wholehearted in our opposition to the IRA.
We indicated to the Minister that our opposition to all unlawful organisations is wholehearted. That is why we expressed our regret that the Minister could be seen to be somewhat ambiguous in standing over suppression orders in respect of one organisation when the others are to be immune from such orders. Let us not talk of consistency. Let us all try to achieve what we want but if we are talking about consistency how can the Minister not acknowledge that there is window dressing involved in some of the increases he is introducing in respect of penalties for offences that have not occurred when he has over-looked and by-passed possibly a more serious one, that which would be directed at one man alone, our President? To usurp the powers of Government could be a complex matter because there are a number of Government Ministers involved and one could not do this by getting at one man but one could obstruct our President because he is one man. He could be obstructed in the performance of his function but the Minister has chosen to overlook that. Does the Minister regard that as being a less than serious offence? Does he regard it as being so less serious than the others, obstruction of the functions of Government, that it would warrant only one-tenth of the sentence that the inchoate offences under the others would warrant, namely 20 years?
Comment on this
I have been listening to this part of the debate and I note the Minister's concern about law and order but concomitant with that I note his concern to deprecate this party. I resent that because we are not disorderly; we are not in fear of the law, we always upheld the law. I should like the Minister to dwell on that point. The Minister is a different man today from what he was three years ago when we were putting through the Forcible Entry Bill in this House. We are not indulging in the obstructive tactics which he indulged in on that occasion. It would be too bad if we did being a party who had the responsibility of maintaining law and order in this State for so long. That is why Members on this side resent the Minister's ambivalent remark.
We are all concerned that law and order should be enforced through the institutions of the State but I hope we are all equally concerned with the fact that law and order can be abused in any State. It is our duty to see to it that not merely are the functions of the institutions of State strengthened but that they are strengthened in such a way that the system does not defeat its own end by bringing the law into disrepute, as happened elsewhere. I should also like to think that we are catering for organisations other than the IRA and that we have the same detestation for other violent organisations in Ireland as we have for the violent tactics of the IRA. Let us not lose sight of the fact that whatever we may do to support the institutions of State law and order can be abused by the implementation of bad law, for example, law that cannot be enforced or law which can be enforced in an unfavourable and detestable way and which can lead to methods of interrogation which bring the State which implements that law into disrepute.
I ask the Minister and the Government to take note of those facts. The Minister told us that we should strive to gain the acceptance of the hearts and minds of the people through our democratic institutions. I hope we shall continue our efforts in that direction but I wonder if we have the total support of our people. The women of Belfast have taken to the streets and so also have women down here. They are supporting a cause which we believe to be a good one. We should be careful in Parliament not to leave it to the people outside to show a lead in gaining the hearts and the minds of the people. We should not lose sight of the fact that unless the law we implement is fair and just we could bring the law into disrepute.
Comment on this
Without calling a quorum, I should like to draw the attention of the House to the fact that it is extraordinary that there has not been one member of the Government parties sitting in with the Minister on this important debate for some considerable time. Is that a measure of the concern members of those parties have?
Comment on this
I should like to support what Deputies Gerry Collins and Carter said about this section. The Minister does himself and his cause no good by these intemperate outbursts, by the reaction he has to what I consider to be reasonable view points put forward by this side of the House. My collegues and I have sought in regard to section 2 to indicate that it is not a section that we have any great liking for; it is not a section about which we do not have reservations. We have considerable distaste for certain aspects of it but that is as far as we have gone. If we wanted to deride the section we could point out to the Minister that under his proposal if an ordinary member of the public interferes with a painter of the Office of Public Works while painting a public building he could get 20 years. We could have made that case if we wanted to be destructive about the section but we did not do so. The section is full of ludicrous, nonsense things of that nature. We have not made any great fuss about them because we have said that we are following our principle through consistently, that if the Government think they need these particular powers we are reluctantly prepared to support them, but I think our attitude in that regard, and our reservations in regard to this section should be respected by the Minister.
Comment on this
The 1939 Act and all that went with it has been criticised and regarded as oppressive and so forth, and its amendment in 1972 was criticised even more roundly, and indeed that attack was lead by the present Minister. I have a concept in relation to the laws we are discussing and nothing that has been said on either side of the House has disturbed my belief that there is much more law than we need. The fact that some of the penalties that it is proposed to adjust here have never been invoked in 37 years is clear evidence that instead of adding to these things we should be deleting them. As I said, I agree with the ten times multiplication tables being applied where money fines are concerned, as between now and 1939.
Over the years in this and every other democracy, and reflected in the Governments of those democracies, there has been a tendency to reduce terms of imprisonment, to make jails and such places of detention much more comfortable and to use the time of people that are incarcerated in those places as a time for mending and correcting their ways. That is my concept, and it is generally accepted. Yet here, against the background of 1972 when the present Minister did his nut because of the extension of laws in this direction, in the amendment of the 1939 Act, and despite the repeated criticisms that I have heard over the years about the terms of the 1939 Act, we have a situation today—deriving from a phoney declared national emergency that does not exist in so far as the terms of the Constitution are concerned—where all of us on both sides of the House are trying to see which of us can outdo the other to show what law abiding people we are and how concerned we are about law and order.
This is not a competition to see who can go the furthest. In the last hour or so we seem to have lost sight of what we are here for. Ten times a 50 pence fine as against 1939 makes sense unfortunately, because that is the way money values have gone. Ten times two years, as against 1939, and transposing ourselves into 1976 is out-landish, ludicrous and ridiculous, and can only bring the law and those who make it into contempt. We can only look at what the Minister has already said in a statement on an earlier Stage of this Bill referring to this section. He said that the Government are satisfied that the maximum penalties in the 1939 Act are totally inadequate in present circumstances. What does the Minister mean by "present circumstances"? What are the dire circumstances that we are in now over and above what we were in in 1939 and any time since? How does the Minister qualify this matter of present circumstances, bringing about a situation where the maximum penalties provided for in 1939 are now totally inadequate? Are we moving into an era where we believe that more and greater sentences should be added and that all the lark about prison reform, improving the lot of the prisoners, trying to send them out better than when they came in being the obligation of society to those who err, can only be regarded as a lark? Is the answer now to multiply sentences by ten?
In the first four subsections of section 2 each sentence is multiplied by ten. Over the years the penalty of life for murder has worked out at about an average of seven years. Who are we kidding, and why are we talking about multiplication by ten? Deputy Collins has already pointed out three instances, referred to in this subsection, of offences provided for in 1939 in respect of which no case was ever taken in 37 years, with a two-year penalty where the penalty is multiplied by ten now. The charge about window-dressing surely must be near the mark. In another case either Deputy Collins or another speaker from the Fianna Fáil benches mentioned an offence that was provided for with a two-year penalty, and the law was invoked only once, and that penalty is also multiplied by ten. This of course is in keeping with our improving and enlightening ways, our social conscience about society's care for those who are jailed, so that we may reform them rather than punish them. There are other penalties that have been used very seldom. The Minister in his Second Reading contribution in an attempt to justify that situation, in reference to the total inadequacy of the 1939 Act penalties as related to present circumstances, said:
This applies not only to offences that are the subject of frequent prosecutions such as membership of an unlawful organisation——
If you did not have that one you would have nothing at all——
but also to offences such as the obstruction by any form of intimidation of the carrying on of the government of the State which are contrary to section 7 of the 1939 Act but some of which appear to be difficult in practice to prove so that prosecutions for them are infrequent.
Is that the reason for the use of the multiplication table? If we cannot take them because of difficulty in proving them is that why we decide to use the multiplication table and say the penalty will be 20 years instead of two years? That is the Minister's answer to the non-taking of prosecutions under section 7. If in difficulty, multiply by ten. The Government must be up to their ears in difficulties of all sorts because not only do they multiply sentences by ten but they also multiply fines by ten. They are apparently in severe difficulty.
The Minister went on to say:
Infrequent though prosecutions for them may be, these are very serious offences and the maximum penalty for them should reflect that fact.
Are they more serious now than they were at any time in the last 37 years? How much more serious? Why are they more serious than they were in 1972, for instance, when the Minister was doing his nut in opposing the Offences Against the State Act then being promoted by the Fianna Fáil Government? Why are they more serious than they were in 1939 when we were facing into the unknown, facing a world conflict? Are they more serious because the Government have abused the privileges and procedures of the Oireachtas to declare a national emergency? Conceivably that is the only thing that can be used by the Minister and the Government to justify this statement that things are more serious now as compared with any other time.
The Minister then goes on to say that the penalty imposed should reflect the seriousness of such offences and, for the purposes of reflection, he multiplies the penalty by ten. He says:
In providing for this, it is also desirable, as a matter of principle, to retain an appropriate internal relationship between the various offences specified in the 1939 Act.
I love the Minister's sense of relativity. It is not sufficient to trump up the situation in an attempt to justify the multiplication by ten of sentences and fines but we must also have regard, as a matter of principle, to retaining an appropriate internal relationship between the various offences specified in the 1939 Act. A nice, symmetrical pattern, I presume, far back in the recesses of the Minister's mind. This nice "internal relationship" tickles me as I have no doubt it will tickle those who will get ten or 20 years instead of two months or two years for some offence or other.
The Minister continues:
...Accordingly, if a maximum penalty of 20 years is provided, as the Bill proposes, for an offence against section 7 of the 1939 Act— an offence referred to in the sidenote to the section as "obstruction of government"—it would be inappropriate to have a lower maximum penalty for an offence under section 6—an offence described in the sidenote as "usurpation of functions of Government", even though there have been few if any prosecutions for offences against section 6. It would be inappropriate because an offence under section 6 could not in principle be regarded as of a lesser order of importance than an offence under section 7.
We are in this strange wonderland of this creation by the Minister of an internal relationship and a new principle to justify not having a lesser penalty applying to offences under section 7 as against those committed under section 6. We can expect, I suppose, as we move through the sections to find a further progression in regard to this internal relationship and this new principle, merely for the purpose presumably of keeping things tidy. The Minister comes in here with this kind of gobbledegook to justify what he is doing on the basis of present circumstances, circumstances which seem to be ten times worse than they were in 1939, and everything is multiplied by ten to convince us apparently that we are being cared for and looked after and that there is no danger to us and, if there should be danger, the Government will ensure by their multiplication tables and the symmetrical relativities that we will be safe.
The Minister goes on:
I have mentioned the offence of membership of an unlawful organisation,
I like the use of the singular noun there. That is highlighted by the clearly evident obsession not merely of the Minister but of the entire Government induced by their own propaganda or, perhaps, listening to their friends' propaganda from across the Border and the channel. I shall repeat that quotation:
I have mentioned the offence of membership of an unlawful organisation, the maximum penalty for which is two years, a maximum which the Bill proposes to raise to seven years...
It hurts me when I see two being raised only to seven in this case. I had been built up by the Minister for this as he called it "appropriate internal relationship". He has now departed from the ten times table and moved only from two to seven. Having expected the continuation of this new-found principle of the Minister, the two to seven strikes a jarring note. But then I find this is moving back a little towards sanity, even though it is draft to be talking about seven years as against two. If it was too good and more than enough in 1972 according to the then Deputy Cooney, now Minister for Justice, surely to God it is good enough today? If it was sufficient in 1939, why is it not sufficient now? Not an iota has the Minister produced to indicate why what was sufficient in 1939, again in 1972, and since then, is insufficient now to the point that two years must become seven.
The Minister continued:
I am aware that the point has been made more than once in recent times that such a proposal is irrelevant in view of the fact that the courts seldom if ever impose the present maximum.
Take good note of what follows, the most disturbing part of the whole operation of the Minister for Justice. It would indicate on the part of the Minister a state of mind very questionable as to its stability. I continue to quote him: "I mention this point because it is one that calls for an answer." One would be entitled to ask what calls for what answer. Why is the answer needed or who asked the question in the first place? The Minister continues:
I am satisfied that there is an answer and a good one and it is this...
Who asked the question? Who is concerned about the answer? At any rate, the Minister has a good one and he is going to let us have it.
The courts, when deciding on a penalty, have to take account of the fact that a particular maximum is prescribed by law and it is a fair assumption...
The first is a fact and the next an assumption, fair in the Minister's estimation and I continue to quote:
that they look on that maximum as something that ought to be reserved for the exceptional circumstances—what one might describe as the worst cases as shown by the evidence before them.
Is the Minister telling us, contrary to what I had always understood, that when we set down penalties on the Statute Book thereafter it is entirely a matter for the Judiciary at whatever level to make their own determination, not to be led in any way by the nose in so far as any asides that we, as Ministers or Members of this House, care to subscribe to the Bill or any qualification or condition they do not arise? That is what I believe to be the case.
I am not finished with this extraordinary performance of the Minister in that I wish to continue this quotation:
If, however, the Oireachtas decides to increase that maximum substantially, the courts are then discharging their functions in a new framework and they can, and I have no doubt will, take account not only of the wider discretion allowed by the new law but also of the clear intentions of the Oireachtas as to the inherent seriousness of the crime.
Here we come to the real nub. The Minister sets up the question. He proposes to answer it and goes on to answer it. All of this is preparatory to telling the Judiciary what they are to do, how they are to do it. And the reason they are to do it not because of their judgment, as judges, sitting in their judicial capacity but because of the clear intentions of the Oireachtas, by using the ten times multiplication table, increasing the sentences to be served from two years to 20, as provided for in the 1939 Act and continued in some parts of the 1972 Act.
The Minister and the Government must be near bereft of their senses. They must be very short of anything useful they could be doing about the job they properly have to do, which is to run the country other than into the ground, which they are successfully doing—if that can be called success—at a rate never before achieved even by their two previous Coalition efforts of 1954 and 1948.
I would commend that speech of the Minister as reading that should not be neglected by any Member of this House, any public person, organisation or body. Indeed, it should be made compulsory reading for the general public and would be better prescribed as reading for some of our school classes than some of the history books more recently prescribed by the Minister for Education who wants to get the Fine Gael version of our recent history through our schools by saying: "You must buy a new book this year". Anyhow that is the best piece of reading in the shortest possible space of time anybody could come across, being part of the Minister's introductory speech on Second Stage. Nothing I could say now or later could so condemn the whole proposal in section 2 or the idea behind the Bill. It is all exposed there. It is a mere lark on the part of the Government to divert attention from their inadequacies in other directions, giving a certain impression to the outside world—and their world ends at Westminster although they do travel much further on occasions—their real world, probably enviously looking at part of that crumbling empire that once was very great and of which we are no longer part. Here we have the effort of the Government, put down in three-staged movements—our declaration of emergency, our Emergency Powers Bill, followed by this gem before us. The secondary, if not the primary reason for this is to give our assurance to those who were once our masters and our occupiers that we are still their subjects and their servants, to give our assurance that we will do things that they are not doing themselves, and do them to our own people.
This is the sort of operation that this legislation will carry out. Not-withstanding anything that has been said, I am left with the ever-increasing conviction that we are trying to create something that does not exist, namely, a national emergency on the security front.
During the small hours of this morning I came through the Six Counties, into Monaghan and down to Dublin. I remember saying last week when I travelled the same way that I did not see a uniform once I left the British Army until I got to Dublin. This time I can say that I saw one garda in uniform from the time I left the British Army at Auchnacloy at 3 a.m. this morning until I came to Dublin and yet a state of national emergency has been declared.
All this gobbledegook hinges on the national emergency declared by both Houses of the Oireachtas to abuse the Article of the Constitution that has been invoked. The Government should do all they can to get our people to work themselves out of the economic dilemma we are in; they should stop trying to pull the wool over our eyes by this kind of diversionary tactic.
Comment on this
I have only a few brief remarks to make about this section because I regard it as an unimportant section and one that will have little effect. I am not opposed in principle to what is in the section. The reason I say it is unimportant and will have little effect is that the most significant increase in penalty is in the increase in the penalty for an offence under section 21 of the 1939 Act. That is in respect of membership of an illegal organisation and the penalty has been increased from two years to seven years.
I cannot quote exact figures—no doubt the Minister has them—but since early 1972 there have been about 500 convictions in our courts, nearly all if not all in the Special Criminal Court, for membership of illegal organisations. As far as I know they were all for membership of the same illegal organisation. From inquiries that I made I understand that, with one exception, nobody was sentenced to imprisonment for longer than 12 months. The one sentence that was longer was for 15 months and I understand it was the second conviction for the same offence. A great many of the large number convicted in that period were sentenced to periods of imprisonment less than 12 months. In the first two years up to early 1974, the usual term was six months.
Comment on this
The information I have is that the pattern of sentences range from three months to two years. This is from the beginning of the court——
Comment on this
I am interested to hear that anybody got two years. I cannot recall it. The more infamous—if I might put it that way—of some of those convicted, and who might on the face of it be entitled to the maximum sentence, to my certain knowledge did not get two years. I remember one gentleman who richly deserved two years, and a lot more than that, who was convicted in November, 1972, and he got six months.
Comment on this
Before and since then persons who appeared to be prominently identified with an illegal organisation did not get two years. If, as the Minister has said, somebody got two years probably it was on his second or third conviction for the same offence. The average sentence would not exceed 12 months, possibly less. It seems a little unreal when the courts have not been willing, even though they would appear to have had justification in some cases, to impose the maximum sentence of two years to expect that they will impose a sentence that is three-and-a-half times longer. In saying this I do not want to be taken as saying that a maximum sentence of seven years for this offence is too much. I do not think so in relation to certain people. There are certain leaders of illegal organisations who richly deserve seven years and, perhaps, even more. Of course, it would be a very severe sentence for a young man who had been intimidated into joining an organisation, perhaps partly against his will, who had not been there very long and who did not play a prominent part, but the courts will have discretion in the matter and will be able to take such factors into account. When we are thinking of seven years we would be as well to think of it in terms of those who have played a prominent part in the organisations and who have recruited others to join them. Nevertheless, it is only right to point out that with very few exceptions no person has been sentenced to more than 12 months.
With regard to the other offences in respect of which the penalties have been increased radically—some of them by as much as tenfold—some are quite unimportant and rather obscure. They are unimportant in the sense that in one case nobody has ever been charged with the offence and in another case there has only been one charge and that was one of a host of charges. I do not know if the man was convicted; I rather think he was not——
Comment on this
He was convicted of so many other offences that it did not really matter. The section is open to the accusation or insinuation of window dressing, perhaps, more than other sections. While it may impress people to see these very severe sentences and huge increases in penalty being written into the legislation, in practice it may not mean a great deal. Although I have this limited reservation that it is not likely to be of much value from the point of view of the term of imprisonment suffered by the ordinary prisoner, it may have some value in that some of the more prominent people identified with illegal organisations will now be liable to the kind of sentences that I, for one, think they should get. I have no objection to the section but merely wish to say in conclusion that there is an element of window dressing here which could mislead the public and perhaps mislead people abroad into thinking that these kinds of penalties are likely to be common or unusual for these offences. Obviously the sentencing policy of our courts is such that the maximum penalties being talked of will rarely if ever be imposed.
Comment on this
As amendments a1 and Nos. 1 and 2 are related the three may be debated together but with separate decisions as required.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. a1:
In page 3, line 11, to delete "expressly or by implication.".
In discussing this amendment and Deputy Collins's amendments I shall have to refer to the section because, as the House is aware, it is a section which has evoked much comment. To some extent it will be necessary for me to analyse the section. I take it that the people opposite will agree to that.
There has been much misunderstanding about what this section says and, more particularly, what it means. One of the arguments has been that the wording is ambiguous and uncertain and therefore dangerous. It is argued that somehow it poses a particular threat to newspapers. I hope to show that these arguments have no validity and that they are mistaken. I am not attacking the good faith of those who put forward the arguments but they have been put forward mistakingly.
Sometimes a word or a phrase in a Bill can be presented as being ambiguous. Perhaps somebody reading it might think it ambiguous if he was not familiar with the rules of construction. Language is necessarily an imprecise instrument. There have been many instances in which both the Opposition and I, for instance, thought we were saying the same thing only to find that we ended up in disagreement as to meaning. It is important to recall a principle of construction that I mentioned to Deputy O'Kennedy, that is, that if a word is ambiguous in criminal statute it is construed always against the prosecution and in favour of the defendant.
A second general point I wish to make in regard to this particular offence is that, in common with the vast majority of criminal offences, there is a requirement of mens rea or guilty intent before the offence is committed. This is something which must be proved by the prosecution. The exceptions relate to certain statutory or regulatory type of offences in which the law does not regard it necessary to prove mens rea that the nature of the abuse sought to be covered by that act is such that mens rea is unnecessary.
When opening the debate the debate on Second Stage I referred to section 3. If Deputies refer to that speech they will find that I was defending section 3 against the charge, not that it went too far, but that it could be argued to be unnecessary because incitement is already a criminal offence. In view of what has been said already about the section it is important that I would repeat and emphasise very strongly that incitement is a serious criminal offence. There is some doubt as to whether incitement to commit sundry offences is itself an offence, but there is no doubt in that regard in relation to the incitement relating to indictable offences. Therefore, people who are saying that this section is putting people in fear of the law or is putting them in jeopardy are not taking into account that incitement is already a criminal offence. With one possible exception, which I will deal with later, we are not in effect in this section extending legally the offence of incitement. There have been references to what has been called the vagueness of the definition of incitement in the Bill. The Bill does not purport to define incitement. There is no need for it to define incitement because that offence is already well known within criminal law.
The word "incite" is to be interpreted in its ordinary dictionary usage, that is, to urge or to stir up. People ask whether a certain statement could be construed as incitement to join the IRA. My first answer is a circular answer: if it is incitement within section 3 it already constitutes incitement under the law as it stands and is a criminal offence for prosecution. It is punishable not for ten years as provided in the section but with imprisonment for life because it is one of these common law offences in respect of which there is no upper limit laid down.
The second point in regard to section 3 is that mens rea has to be present in relation to this section, as it must be present in the ordinary common law offence of incitement. It is something that would have to be proved by the prosecution, though I should point out that mens rea can be proved sometimes by showing not just a positive intent but a certain degree of recklessness. It is not an absolute offence in common law and this situation is not being changed in the statutory wording adopted here.
It follows that a prosecution would have to prove that what was said or written was incitement in the objective sense and, in addition, that the defendant intended to incite or, at least, that he was reckless as to whether he was inciting. Consequently, there can be no question of an innocent person being caught.
In my opening speech I quoted what Professor Glanville Williams had to say about incitement. I now give a further quotation. It is from page 612 of his book Criminal Law: The General Part.
One may incite persons generally, as in a newspaper article; and the person incited need not be known. Since incitement relates to incompleted criminal conduct, it is immaterial that the words have no effect on the person solicited; but they must have reached his mind. If they do not, there may be a conviction for attempt to incite.
It is clear that a person may be incited to crime by various means. He may be incited by the spoken word or by the written word. He may be incited directly or through an agency or other persons. If an intermediary is used he could also be guilty of incitement unless he was unaware of the significance of what he was doing in which case there would be no mens rea. The words in the section which set out the various ways by which a person may incite another to join an unlawful organisation are merely explanatory and add nothing to the legal meaning of the word “incitement.”
I am referring primarily to the words which are the subject matter of the Opposition amendment and some of which form part of my amendment. Primarily I am referring to the words "directly or through another person or persons or by advertisement, propaganda or any other means." The fact that these words merely specify various means by which incitement can be carried out, and do not in any way expand on the basic meaning of "incite," does not mean that the words are pointless or unnecessary. They do not add or take from the existing legal meaning or nature of the offence of incitement, but what I submit to the House is that although they do not add to the law or essentially change the legal position, they are not unnecessary words.
I put it to the Opposition for their consideration that, therefore, the specific purpose, and I think a good purpose, is to ensure that something as important as this, that people who engage in what is popularly called recruiting, whether by word of mouth, by handbills or by any other means, would clearly be put on notice that they are committing a serious offence; and these words in the section as drafted put them on notice, whereas the use of the bald word "incite" might not contain the same message in such a highly pointed way.
What, in effect, we are doing in this section is spelling out in a clearer and more pointed way what is already an offence. Therefore, the deletion of the words which the Opposition seek to delete—I want to emphasise this strongly—would not take from the essential nature of the offence of inciting. I suggest to the Opposition that the words should be left in for the reasons I have given. I submit that the section, if they were removed, would lose the advantage of showing on its face that these kinds of activities, where they constitute incitement, are serious offences. The section does not make these things offences. It is only where people are inciting and can be proved to be inciting that the section applies. There is no basis for suggesting that the Bill is widening the law to an indeterminate extent. Incitement by any means whatsoever is already an offence.
My amendment seeks to remove the words "expressly or by implication". I think those words had given rise to most of the concern which has been expressed about this section, though as I have indicated this section does no more than restate in statutory form what has been the law for many years, that is, that it is an offence to incite somebody to commit a crime. I have moved this amendment because I accepted there was genuine concern about these words and because, as I have already indicated the words, like the other words which the Opposition seek to remove, are of very little if any significance.
I should like to explain that a little further. The reason why as a matter of law the words "by implication" add very little if anything to what the section would mean if it referred only to "incitement", and that these words were omitted, is that whether the words "by implication" are present or not, the prosecution would still have to prove that the words said or written were incitement and that the person responsible for saying them, writing them or publishing them intended them to be incitement or was reckless as to whether they were incitement.
This raises the question as to why the words were put in in the first instance, and I have answered that frankly. It is common for certain people to make certain types of speeches which the listeners or the readers of the speeches published know full well are taken to encourage people to go into the IRA. I am sure many of us have had experience of outraged citizens complaining about a particular speech and its tone. Most of these speeches are confined to language which is capable of an innocent construction—they are clever speeches in that regard—and to prove that what was said constituted an incitement and was meant as incitement may be so difficult as to be impossible because one must bear in mind that what is published must be published with the intention of incitement, not just that it was published simpliciter. There must be the intention, the mens rea, there must be the positive guilty mind or such a degree of recklessness as to constitute the same thing.
The ordinary listener may be in no doubt about the meaning of what he hears but proof of a charge beyond reasonable doubt in a court of law is a difficult and different matter. When the section was under consideration and being drafted it was intended primarily to ensure that there would be a specific statutory provision dealing with those who distributed recruiting posters and the like and those who personally sought recruits for the IRA. I am sure Deputies opposite have had the experience I have had of complaints from members of the public about posters on telegraph poles and elsewhere advocating support for the IRA, and the law has been in some difficulty about dealing with them.
With regard to recruitment, of course the main difficulty always will be to get evidence. The section may not have any value in that. It is a matter of getting definite evidence. However, the section will clear up the legal position. In reply to another Opposition amendment, I might say that the word "recruiting" deliberately was not used in the section because I was of opinion that it is or might not be wide enough to cover the people I have mentioned. I have no doubt Deputy Collins will argue that it should be there, on the ground that it is a word without a wide meaning. By reason of the strictness with which words in statutes are construed, the word "recruiting" could be interpreted as referring not to the person going abroad and holding up the attractions of being a member of the IRA but the person who does the actual signing on, and that would narrow it to a specific person.
In addition to dealing with bill-posters and such things, it was thought that the section, if it included the words "by implication", might be of some assistance to the prosecution in persuading the court to accept the kind of language to which I have referred, used in circumstances where everybody knew what was meant, and that it might enable the court to be persuaded that it, indeed, means precisely that. As I have said, it was thought the words might be of some help in this context. It was hoped they would be, but it was recognised that the effect could be quite small. Having regard to the concern these words have caused for many people—wrongly, I submit—one has to weigh that concern against the possible benefit to the prosecution. I weighed the two things and decided that my amendment was justified.
When one thinks about people who harangue crowds and make inflamatory speeches to join the IRA, it is also clear that we can consider the written word. As I have mentioned, the distribution of recruitment posters and handbills was in my mind as the principal target to be got at by the section. This, of course, raises the possible effects on newspapers. This is a matter which has been the subject of a great deal of comment and some of it has been extravagant, to put it mildly, and has overlooked the fact that incitement has to be proved and, in addition, there must be mens rea, that an innocent statement is not an offence unless it is accompanied by the guilty mind. That has been the position up to now by virtue of common law.
The law of the land already makes it an offence to do these things by the written word. Newspapers discharging their functions in the ordinary way would not be committing an offence in the absence of mens rea and no respectable and responsible newspaper would have the mens rea to commit an offence of inciting support for membership of the IRA. Newspapers discharging their ordinary functions up to now would be in no danger of being prosecuted, let alone convicted.
If this Bill were to be passed the position would still be the same. A newspaper would not be free to publish anything they like any more than at present. The Constitution which provides the freedom of the Press makes it a criminal matter to publish sedition. All section 3 does in the context of the Press is to draw attention to the fact that everybody, every citizen, no matter what his calling in life, is forbidden to incite others to crime. As I said, this is not new law; that restriction already exists. A newspaper which publishes incitement and does it with the necessary element of mens rea is committing an offence under the law as it stands. The same ingredient of mens rea would have to be proved if the prosecution should be taken under section 3 when enacted.
I mentioned that the section, with one small exception, is in effect reenacting the existing law of incitement, and the exception is to deal with this sort of situation. This is a common situation which gives rise to a fair amount of public scandal and I have no doubt it is a situation about which Deputies have received complaints. A person with a collection box is more likely to go into a pub than to stand on a street corner because it is a public offence to stand on a street corner with a collection box without a permit. If somebody comes into a private place with a collection box and calls out: "Support the IRA", it might be difficult to mount a prosecution against him. If a garda came on the scene and caught him in the act, an offence could be mounted against him. It may not be certain that he would be held under the existing law of committing the offence of incitement, that is, to be inciting people to commit a criminal offence. Section 3 would, and is, intended to make that conduct a statutory offence. It is with that admittedly marginal type situation, but nevertheless common and scandalous situation, that the section is designed to deal and I hope would deal.
Comment on this
On a point of clarification: is the Minister distinguishing between a private and public place in making that——
Comment on this
I am distinguishing it in this regard. In a public place there will be a prosecution. It could be a prosecution for making a collection without a permit, but the location of the call in the context of the terms of inciting would make no difference. Does that answer the Deputy's question? If the offence of inciting were being committed, it would be committed in a public or private place. It would not matter where it was committed. I am making that point in case somebody could say: "Could you not get him under the Street Collection Act?
Comment on this
I may have unnecessarily confused the point. If a person stands at a street corner with a collection box and calls out: "Support the IRA" and is soliciting money, on the law as it presently stands, it is doubtful if he could be prosecuted for incitement. On the law as it would stand hopefully when the Bill is passed the section as drafted would cover him as being a person supporting or assisting the activities of the IRA. The point I wanted to make was that if that person came into a public place with his collection box, the law, even at present, is not totally powerless, but only as regards the summary offence of making a collection. In that regard the section widens the existing law.
If I might recap to emphasise: the law of incitement has been with us and this section does not propose to expand it, restrict it, make it more vague, more general or alter it in any way. The words which I have moved to delete, "expressly or by implication", and the words sought to be deleted by the Opposition, "expressly or by implication, directly or through another person or persons, or by advertisement, propaganda or any other means," do not alter the legal effect of the section because, in some fashion, they have to be proved to get a conviction under the existing law. Therefore, there is no change in the law. The reason those words were inserted was to highlight to members of the public the dangers of becoming involved in committing the offence of incitement and indicating how it might be committed. If these words are removed, it would still be an offence "by advertisement" to incite. If these words are removed it will still be an offence "expressly" to incite. If these words are removed it will still be an offence "directly" to incite. If these words are removed it will still be an offence "or through any other person or persons" to incite.
I want the Opposition to consider the legal effect of these words because, as I explained, they do not add or take from the offence of incitement which is now being expressed in statutory form. What they do is give a message to the general public of what incitement can consist. As I said, the words do not add or take from the strength of the section as drafted. If the Opposition having heard what I had to say, still feel they would like those words removed, they do not take from the principle of the statute. I do not think there would be anything between us. Before they insist on seeking their removal, I would ask them to consider very carefully what I have said about them.
Comment on this
I must confess to having grave doubts in connection with the Minister's amendment. I do not consider it a genuine or concerned attempt to meet our objections or to meet the very real concern of many people outside this House about the implications of section 3. The Minister for Defence might well have been aware of this proposed amendment when he so bellicosely declared some days ago that not one iota of this Bill would be changed. In one sense, I do not think the Minister's proposed amendment materially changes the section.
Comment on this
Let me also say this, that the same could be said about the Deputy's amendment, but if he wants to insist on his amendment I will be prepared to accept it.
Comment on this
I asked the Deputy to comment on the reasons why I think he must not insist on it, because it neither adds to nor takes from the law.
Comment on this
I will give the reasons why I think our amendment is better than the Minister's and does a far better job. The word "directly" and the words following that word in the first line of the section relate to the person charged. The words "expressly or by implication" and the words following that phrase relate to the manner in which it is alleged the accused incited or invited the crime complained of.
Our prime concern in this section has been with the suggestion that a criminal offence can be committed by implication directly or through another person or persons, or by advertisement, propaganda or any other means. I do not believe the proposed deletion of the words "expressly or by implication" is enough to safeguard innocent persons. If the Minister proposed the deletion of the words "or by implication" alone and left the section reading that any person who expressly did something would be guilty of an offence, even in the extremely wide context of the remaining words in the section, this would go some way, even though a limited way, towards meeting our objections. If the whole phrase "expressly or by implication" is deleted, it is still open to a court dealing with a person charged under the section to reach a decision to convict that person by saying the implication of what he was alleged to have done was to incite or invite somebody to join an unlawful organisation.
It seems to me the reality is that the offensiveness of line 1 of the section would be diluted to some extent if the Minister confined the actions of the person charged to something he had allegedly expressly done. By deleting the words "expressly or by implication" the view is held that the Minister is leaving it open to the court to convict either way.
Comment on this
An offence has to be committed expressly. If it is not committed expressly it can only be by implication.
Comment on this
Section 21 of the Offences Against the State Act makes it an offence to be a member of an unlawful organisation, and the suppression order makes the IRA an unlawful organisation. Section 21 of the same Act also makes the offence of being a member of an unlawful organisation an indictable offence. Apart from section 3 of this Bill, the common law provision still remains that it is an indictable misdemeanour to incite someone else to commit an indictable offence whether or not the incitement is successful in persuading the other person to commit or even to attempt to commit the offence. The penalty for any common law misdemeanour is any term of imprisonment no matter how long, or any fine no matter how much, provided neither is excessive, and it is the court who decides what might be considered excessive.
The Taoiseach and the Minister for Justice said last week that this section is primarily aimed at those who recruit for the IRA. I have already commented on the fact—I accept the Minister's reason for this but I want to query it—that the word "recruiting" is not in the section and it does not appear to make recruiting an offence. One could visualise a situation where a person incited another person to become a member of the IRA but it would not amount to his recruiting him for the IRA.
Comment on this
It may shorten the debate if I say I cannot conceive of such a situation but, if the Deputy has that worry, I will accept the word "recruits".
Comment on this
I want guidance on this because I should not like to misquote the Minister, and I mean that quite sincerely. The Minister said the newspapers can carry on as they are at present. I think that is the phrase he used. If I am wrong I want to be corrected. Why then is it necessary for his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, to keep a file of letters to a particular newspaper and to use that file of letters in the way he did in his recent interview with The Washington Post? I could quote from the Official Report of 7th September the watered down version the Minister gave the House. If there was confusion, if the section was misinterpreted, the full blame must lie with the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. I thank the Minister for accepting our two amendments.
Comment on this
As one who has been concerned with the many interpretations put on section 3, I feel the House has shown commendable commonsense in amending it. When I first became a Member of this House I was often in awe of parliamentary draftsmanship and, assuming the Cabinet debated sections of Bills at length and got the advice of the parliamentary draftsman and of the Attorney General on sections of this kind, I was very loathe to question sections. The longer I am in Dáil Éireann the more I am inclined to question Bills line by line. The questioning which has gone on in public in relation to section 3 has been invaluable. The section will now read: "Any person who... incites or invites or recruits another person (or other persons generally) to join an unlawful organisation..." If that, in effect, is to be the meaning of the section it most certainly will have my support. I commend the Minister on showing a flexibility of approach in amending the section.
I recall with some surprise what the Minister for Foreign Affairs said in his contribution. He said:
In relation to this section the question of the Press never arose in its preparation, drafting or discussion.
He went on to say:
The question of the Press did not arise in connection with it at all when it was being drafted, prepared and decided. It is important that that should be said and I can assert that firmly and decisively.
I quote from columns 641 and 642 of the Official Report. It is now clear that the real intention of the Government is to ensure that any individual who incites, invites or recruits commits an offence. The Opposition's amendment is sensible enough in that regard. A person can be recruited into a movement and discover when he tries to get out that there is a gun in his back. Unfortunate people get in and have to stay in, because they cannot get out or they will be shot. The definition of recruitment in that regard would be rather interesting.
The section as amended is essential and it supplements the existing body of law. It spells out clearly to some of the extreme rhetorical godfathers of the illegal organisations that they cannot with impunity stand up in public and publicly incite in the manner many of them have been doing and then hope with the aid of clever lawyers or barristers to escape the prosecutions of the Director of Public Prosecutions. The section has been much improved. I am sure one editor of a national newspaper will sleep quietly this evening because in relation to some of the intentions of different Government Ministers I got the impression that there was almost a note of hysteria beginning to build in.
Comment on this
The Deputy attacked a person here who could be identified, contrary to the usual custom of this House last week and he was not called to order.
Comment on this
I am drawing the attention of the House to the fact that there has been a certain amount of what one would call self-incitement in relation to this section.
Comment on this
The Deputy specifically named a person in the House last week and he should have been castigated for it.
Comment on this
One journalist has been indulging in an inordinate amount of self-incitement in relation to this section and I am sure he will now have no difficulty in sleeping.
Comment on this
I should like to call the attention of the Chair to the fact that Deputy Desmond is making a meal of this. He did so last week and is doing so again this week. It is unwarranted.
Comment on this
Deputy Wilson will have his opportunity.
Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,
Comment on this
In welcoming the amendments which the Minister is now prepared to accept I was casting a cold eye on some of the more blatant emotionalism, one might say hysteria, which, in fairness, in no way characterised the reaction of newspapers or journalists generally.
Comment on this
Deputy Haughey, I have never had to go through the anguish of my conscience in a dock; Dáil Éireann is where I go through my anguish. Let us not start that kind of caper.
Comment on this
They did, and correctly so. The newspapers were genuinely concerned about it but in the case of one newspaper there was an inordinate amount of special pleading. It almost amounted to a charge of self-incitement, if such a charge could be levelled against any individual. The Minister, in accepting the amendments, has deleted the context of advertisement in the draft and taken out the words "propaganda and any other means" but he has clearly spelt out——
Comment on this
We are taking the greatest exception to a remark that has just been made by Deputy Halligan. I ask the Chair to see to it that it is withdrawn at once.
Comment on this
We are further away from the Deputy than the Chair and we heard it. I can assure the Chair that a very objectionable remark was made and all of us on this side of the House would wish to have it withdrawn. Had the Chair heard the remark, I have no doubt whatever that the Chair would similarly wish to have such an objectionable remark withdrawn.
Comment on this
The Chair certainly deprecates any objectionable remarks made from any side of the House and would always invite Deputies to withdraw same if the Chair heard such objectionable remarks.
Comment on this
It has been suggested by one newspaper that this section was a major underground effort within the Cabinet and at national level in Parliament to institute a total blanket censorship in relation to the activities of illegal organisations. Great hay was made of that. The Government have clearly let it be known that those who incite or invite individuals to join unlawful organisations have no longer any form of immunity under the law and I welcome that. If the Opposition have contributed to the clearing up of that in the appropriate amendments they have my thanks and the general commendation of the House goes to them. Without the House proceeding to make a meal of this, I should like to state that the section now is effective. It is designed to ensure that those individuals who can be clearly seen under the law to be included under this section will get their just reward of a charge being brought against them. The penalty in relation to section 10 is certainly very substantial.
Comment on this
I have no doubt that those who issue letters of invitation to individuals, or who hold meetings during the course of which they specifically invite people to join an illegal organisation, will certainly not have the legal side-stepping opportunities which were open to them under existing legislation. I am grateful to the Minister for accepting a viewpoint which was expressed not merely by the Opposition but by Members on both sides of the House and from people outside. I am grateful to the Minister for having tidied up the section and I have no doubt that in the continuing debate on section 3 we will be able to tease out further any of the other implications.
Comment on this
It would be less than gracious of us on this side of the House if we did not sincerely express our appreciation of the fact that the Minister has accepted both our amendments in regard to the recasting of this section. There will be a great amount of relief throughout the country that the Minister has done so. There is no doubt that the more one looks at the section as it was originally put before the House it was objectionable and dangerous. At first sight we had a very strong objection to the section as it was worded. We felt that the use of the words "expressly or by implication, directly or through another person or persons, or by advertisement, propaganda or any other means", made the section far too wide altogether.
Comment on this
That is the Minister's contention but I do not think we need really worry about it at this stage. I did not accept the Minister's explanation of why those words had been put in in the first instance. The Minister seemed to be on very weak ground when he said "we put them in for this reason, but on the other hand they are not really necessary". We need not concern ourselves unduly with that at the moment. We objected to the section as it was worded originally because it seemed to be cast in these very wide-sweeping terms. It seemed that people who were innocent of any subversive intent could be prosecuted and imprisoned under the section. Some time after the Bill was published our fears in this regard were exaggerated by what the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said. To our original fears was added this extra fear that the section would be used simply to impose censorship on the media. Reading the section carefully one has to admit that it is open to that interpretation, that if any unscrupulous Director of Public Prosecutions or Attorney General wished to do so he could consistently prosecute newspapers for the most innocent of contents under that section.
Comment on this
Well, I must confess that even though I qualified as a barrister I never really understood what mens rea was.
Comment on this
I know it is an essential ingredient in a criminal offence and you must somehow or other be a criminal in your own mind before the judge can convict you. I never yet saw anybody getting off a criminal prosecution by saying: "My Lord, I had not got mens rea”. I do not think mens rea comes up very often in the Special Criminal Court.
Comment on this
It does. With respect, that is a slur on the Special Criminal Court, because no court can ignore the requirement of proven intent. It is an essential ingredient in the commission of a criminal offence.
Comment on this
My own view is that if you publish something which somebody says is criminal, the very fact of your publishing it means that you intended to publish it and therefore you had mens rea and therefore you had criminal intent.
We had these two fears, first of all that it was too wide and all embracing in its scope and, secondly, we feared, after the revelation by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs that it would be used if not positively to impose censorship, at least to have the threat of censorship hanging over newspaper editors. We all had to take that from what was said over the weekend and then on top of that came this startling disclosure that one of the most critical programmes on our television network had suddenly been axed. All that seemed to many people to add up to a very serious imminent threat of censorship. It was against that background that we put down our amendment to delete all the words from "who" down to "incites". We acknowledge that the Minister has done a good day's work in accepting our amendment. As this debate and the other measure began to develop we feared that the Minister was intransigent and was not going to accept any proposals from this side of the House. The Minister has now disabused us of that impression and as the section now reads, it achieves exactly what all of us want to achieve. It will now be specifically confined to making it an offence for a person to incite or invite another person to join an unlawful organisation or to take part in, support or assist its activities.
The Minister has also accepted the second amendment. We were very concerned that this matter of recruitment be specifically referred to in this section because we feel that whatever else is involved in the field of subversion, for an older mature person deliberately to recruit a young immature person into an unlawful organisation is a particularly serious and odious offence. We were anxious that should be specifically indicated. We have achieved that by the Minister accepting our amendment. We now believe that the section could not possibly be used in any way to impose censorship or anything akin to censorship.
The Minister has pointed out at great length and in considerable detail that "inciting" is a criminal offence under the existing law. If that be so, and we accept that it is so, we have no objection whatever to accepting it in this section. We had a constructive approach and that approach has been fully justified. The words to which we objected have been deleted and our word "recruit" has been accepted. This represents an acceptable concession by the Minister to common sense and reasonableness and we would be less than generous if we did not acknowledge that he has been enlightened by his acceptance of these amendments.
Comment on this
I, too, compliment the Minister for bringing some semblance of respectability to this legislation by his adoption of a more reasoned approach to it. We concede there is a security problem but we do not concede the problem attained the proportions of a national emergency. We could accept the Criminal Law Bill but we could not accept the other legislation. We know that when difficult circumstances prevail there are people who will play on rights designed for the protection of the liberty of the individual and abuse those rights. In order to deal with that kind of situation certain measures are required and these measures may themselves impinge on such rights. The extent to which they should impinge should always, however, be commensurate with the degree of seriousness inherent in the situation. The Criminal Law Bill strengthens the legislation we introduced in our time but there were provisions in it which went far beyond what was acceptable and which, if unamended, could be dangerous. On second thoughts the Minister has adopted a more reasonable approach to section 3 and that approach considerably alters the situation despite what anyone may say to the contrary.
The phrase in section 3 "or any other means" was too wide in its scope. The Minister says this phrase and others were inserted for psychological effect to warn people as to the ways in which they could be tripped up. I am not prepared to accept that was the sole reason for the inclusion of this phrase "or any other means". Certainly the phrase did frighten people.
Deputy Desmond on Wednesday of last week at column 575 of volume 292 of the Official Report said:
In my view section 3 will pose very considerable difficulties for the proprietors of newspapers and for their staffs...
Today he seemed to deride the fears expressed by some sections of the Press.
Comment on this
All members of the Press were equally perturbed by this suggested encroachment on their liberty. Last week Deputy Desmond referred to all the newspapers and their proprietors. He said they were already somewhat circumscribed by the fact that they were owned in different ways by different people and this imposed a certain censorship. I do not believe that. Staffs will assert their rights and that is a censorship imposed on all sections of the Press.
Comment on this
They have a sense of responsibility and a sense of civic duty. That imposes a censorship but that is the only censorship. I do not for one moment believe that the method of ownership imposes any censorship at all on any newspaper. What is proposed by the Minister now is acceptable. The Minister is going a long way here towards justifying the existence of Parliament. Some of the most important statements about democratic institutions have been made outside the House but Parliament has been able to highlight the dangers that lurked within this legislation and has been able to bring the necessary pressure to bear to amend it. That has helped to restore the prestige of Parliament.
The nub of the debate is the word "reasonable". We are inclined to depend on the broad interpretation of that, on the high reputation of our Garda and Defence Forces generally. Their interpretation of reasonable is the keynote to the manner in which this legislation will be implemented. We are not prepared to go the whole way in giving them unlimited scope, even taking into account the fact that we have reason to have a certain respect for the forces who will implement the legislation and the courts who will interpret and execute it. Nor should we be prepared to hand over the actual implementation and interpretation of security behaviour to them. This House must hold a grip on what is its function. That is what we seek to do in aiming to improve the wording of this section, one of the most important of the Bill.
A lot has been said and written in different places about the rights of an individual, in custody, before a charge is preferred against him. Those rights, provided for in legislation by this country and others, are something which have been held up as the symbol of our freedom and respect for democratic institutions.
Comment on this
The right of an individual, in custody, not yet charged. In our very eloquent speeches in Strasbourg before the Declaration on Human Rights became a convention to which we could subscribe, we felt very competent and qualified to become signatories. I mention all of this to highlight the importance we attach to the liberty and freedom of the individual, the protection we are prepared to afford people who are innocent until held to be guilty. For that, if for no other reason, we must be most careful in the extent to which we go to produce legislation going beyond those principles for the purpose of apprehending people who use them to carry out subversive activities against the State. That is where the sense of balance enters in. That is what entirely governed our thinking and approach to this package. We were opposed to the declaration of national emergency. We do not think that the security problem obtaining has attained those proportions. We are prepared to accept that there is a security problem in respect of which we did our part to provide legislation and in respect of which we were sternly opposed by the then Opposition. They are competent now to understand better what is the position, because they have been on both sides of the House for the duration of this problem. The Minister appears to be getting worried that I am getting away from the section.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle seems quite happy. I could not have said what I did without making reference to the overall position. The extent to which the Minister is prepared to meet us in respect of this section makes it a more respectable Bill and will allay many people's fears. The reason the Minister gave for those words being inserted in the first instance was that they were to be a reminder to people, would have some psychological effect on what can be done in the matter of incitement. He claimed that such will still be used irrespective of whether or not they are mentioned in the section. I do not quite go along with that. That is a matter with which my lawyer friends will deal. But, to the layman looking at this section it is much more respectable and acceptable to people who had entertained serious fears about it.
If the Minister found it difficult to deal with matters raised in the debate up to now he can blame some of his colleagues who, inside and outside the House, made statements which did not make his position any easier and which did not allay the fears of many people but rather raised serious doubts in their minds. I refer to statements made by the Minister for Defence to American newspapers and here who quite blatantly challenged us and told us there would be not one iota changed in the legislation. In the face of those difficulties created for the Minister I am pleased to note the more reasonable approach he has taken to the Opposition's point of view. This House has gained much by his so doing. This Parliament, in turn, is keeping a grip on matters which could seriously be eroded and feelings towards it have been improved as a result of the action the Minister has taken.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 3, lines 11, 12 and 13, to delete all words after the word "who" in line 11 down to and including the word "means" in line 13.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 2:
In page 3, line 13, after the word "invites" to insert the words "or recruits".
Comment on this
On the question of procedure, I have withdrawn amendment No. a1, in effect, and have accepted amendments Nos. 1 and 2. I would respectfully suggest that there is not much point in debating amendments which have been accepted and agreed. Could we, perhaps, now move on to section 3 because, again I would respectfully suggest, we will, in effect, be debating the section unless Deputies want to consider this the debate on the section as well? Could we agree on that procedure?