We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Criminal Law Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 190–394 of 394. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Criminal Law Bill, 1976
Enacted

No. 33 of 1976 ›

Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That will be dealt with here.

Comment on this

It is not accepted.

Comment on this

Presumably we would have to debate that before the section.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let me clear the matter, Deputies. Amendments Nos. 1 and 2 in the name of Deputy G. Collins have been agreed.

Comment on this

May I say a word——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

There is no disorder in what I am saying.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have not completed my remarks, Deputy, please.

Comment on this

I want to know what is going on in the House. It is about time I did.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I will repeat it for the Deputy. Amendments Nos. 1 and 2 in the name of Deputy G. Collins have been agreed. Amendment No. a1 in the name of the Minister is withdrawn. We then proceed to amendment No. 3 in the name of Deputy G. Collins.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

On a point of order, Deputy.

Comment on this

The Chair says these are agreed. Is the Chair excluding any discussion on them because I do not agree with them?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will be able to discuss the section.

Comment on this

I offered and I want to speak on the matter of the agreement on these amendments. To come along now and say they are agreed and that I can speak on the section is quite a different matter.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

If the Deputy wishes to speak, he may do so but I presumed that once we had agreement we could move on to the next amendment. The Deputy may speak on the section. Amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

I presume I can speak on the amendments.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Of course.

Comment on this

Thank you.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is it on amendment No. 3 that the Deputy is going to speak?

Comment on this

On all the amendments, Sir.

Comment on this

They are disposed of. Amendment No. 3 has to be moved.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We have disposed of amendments a1, 1 and 2.

Comment on this

We did not dispose of them. I have been here since they began and I have not been speaking on them.

Comment on this

They are agreed. The person who moved them and myself agreed.

Comment on this

Who agreed them?

Comment on this

I agreed them.

Comment on this

Of course, the Minister did but he is not everybody. He should have an idea that he is not.

Comment on this

The Deputy should remember that he is no longer in Government.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am proceeding now, Deputy.

Comment on this

In fact, so few has he in the House that he cannot talk to anybody but himself.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. I am now proceeding to amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 3, after line 17, to insert a new subsection as follows:

"(2) Any person who recruits or attempts to recruit persons under the age of 18 years into unlawful organisations shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 years."

Comment on this

I want to speak on the matter on which I have offered on a couple of occasions here.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will have a full opportunity on the section. I am now dealing with amendment No. 3 and it has been moved by Deputy O'Malley.

Comment on this

Am I being denied the right to give my say on any matter——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy had ample opportunity of doing so.

Comment on this

I had no opportunity. I offered and I was not called. Where was the opportunity? If I wait until after those who are proposing and those who are talking about agreeing, is there any fault in that?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I will call the Deputy on the section.

Comment on this

I want to talk on these matters about which there is agreement——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am sorry, we must proceed in logical sequence.

Comment on this

The Chair is proceeding in the logic that there is a group over there and another group over here and nobody else matters a damn. I count for as much as any of them. I have been elected and I am entitled to be here. There are no rules saying I cannot be heard.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are dealing with amendment No. 3.

Comment on this

The Chair should uphold that right. I should not have to come here fighting for it every time a matter is raised——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

There is no need for that.

Comment on this

There is no need so long as I keep quiet.

Comment on this

The purpose of this amendment——

Comment on this

This is a disgraceful performance and I hope the Chair has a good look at it——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows I cannot go back on amendments that have been disposed of. Deputy O'Malley is in possession.

Comment on this

It is not a question of going back on anything. I asked the Chair, I offered when the Chair was brought into this. The Chair is being led by the nose by those two people——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy knows that is untrue. He should not make that kind of statement.

Comment on this

I offered but the Chair did not——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will get ample opportunity to speak on this section.

Comment on this

That is not the point. I have as much right to speak as anyone else and the Chair should ensure that I can speak.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair would be concerned about the rights of minorities in this House.

Comment on this

The Chair should be.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have called Deputy O'Malley.

Comment on this

The amendment seeks to differentiate between the recruitment of persons into illegal organisations——

Comment on this

I have as much right to speak as any other Member——

Comment on this

The amendment seeks to impose a penalty not exceeding 12 years in respect of any person who recruits or attempts to recruit persons under the age of 18 years into unlawful organisations——

Comment on this

There is great talk about agreeing on these matters——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Will the Deputy please allow Deputy O'Malley to proceed on the amendment?

Comment on this

The main reason we put down the amendment was to draw attention——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think we should have a House.

Notice taken that 20 Members were not present; House counted and 20 Members being present,

Comment on this

We felt it desirable to draw a distinction between recruitment generally to these organisations and the recruitment of young people. It seems to us, as it does to virtually all people, immensely more reprehensible that there are in the country, presumably North and South, people who seek to get young people under the age of 18 years to lend their support to or to join unlawful organisations. By drawing attention to the recruitment of young people, we hope it will tend to discourage it to a greater extent and that it will put people on notice generally as to the most undesirable and reprehensible action of those who seek to recruit young people into organisations that kill and maim. It is not a much larger penalty but it would be well if it were seen that the Oireachtas saw fit to fix a longer maximum penalty in respect of this aspect of the crime of recruitment than it did in regard to the matter generally.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment because persons under 18 years are already covered by the section drafted. It does not make any distinction between persons and, therefore, it covers persons of all ages. Consequently, there is no need for the amendment. I sympathise with the desire of the Opposition to highlight the particular evil of recruitment of young persons. It is a matter on which, as legislators, we must educate the people. It is coming across that there is a danger for young persons in the sense that they are at risk when approached by these people and parents are becoming more alert to this.

From the point of view of the section there is no need for the amendment because young persons are already covered in the section as drafted. Furthermore, to have such a distinction as as to the age of the person where an offence is committed would place what could be an extra and a difficult burden of proof on the prosecution. It might also be necessary to prove that the person who did the recruiting had knowledge of the age as we are creating a serious criminal offence with a penalty of 12 years. In such a case the court would have to hold that intention was necessary and part of the intention would be knowledge of the essential kernel of the offence, the age of the person being recruited. On that score the amendment is faulty. Even if that were not an ingredient of the offence, the prosecution would still have to prove the age of the person recruited and that would be another burden. Thirdly, the section as drafted already provides for this offence, albeit with a penalty of ten years. I do not think the extra two years would be sufficient to justify a subsection with all the difficulties in it that I have outlined.

Comment on this

Our intention is to note the distinction between recruiting a young person and someone of mature years and to take note of this in the Bill. The Minister has stated that it could add to the difficulties in discharging onus of proof but I do not think that is so. There are precedents in existing criminal law that relate to the age of the offended person, whether one talks of cases of indecent assault, rape or other crimes. The age is an essential ingredient in the offence in some of these cases and I do not think that it adds considerably to the burden of proof; that can be discharged simply by the normal manner of proving the matter with a birth certificate. In all of these cases knowledge of the offended person's age is not an essential ingredient.

I do not wish to become involved again in the mens rea argument but a person who runs the risk of committing an offence in respect of a young person, whether in relation to this type of legislation or to other legislation—sexual offences are a good example of this—takes on himself that very serious hazard. I make those points to the Minister to indicate that our amendment is not without precedent and that the Government's acceptance of it would not involve a major change in the procedure of the law of evidence. However, if the Minister, having considered all of this takes the view that the offence is adequate, that is a matter for him, but we see the distinction. There is a precedent in existing law in respect of many offences to warrant a distinction to be made and we think that the distinction should be written into this Bill. On that basis we ask the Minister to reconsider his reaction to our amendment and, perhaps, on reflection he might accept it.

Comment on this

In spite of what Deputy O'Kennedy says it appears that the Minister is not prepared to accept the amendment. Like Deputy O'Kennedy I do not accept that it would create all the difficulties which the Minister has enumerated. However, we have made our point in relation to it. In view of the fact that the Minister has seen fit to accept two amendments on this section that are far more important than the one in question and in the light of the commendable change of heart involved although we were told as recently as Tuesday last that no amendment of any kind would be accepted by the Government, I do not intend to press the amendment.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I should like clarification in relation to your decision at the time at which Deputy Blaney was offering. I am not taking sides but wish to have clarification in this regard. I understood the procedure would involve your having to put the section formally to the House before you could announce that there had been agreement in order that Deputy Blaney or any other Member who wished to oppose any or all of the three amendments involved would be given an opportunity of so doing. Therefore, am I right in thinking that it was a departure from precedent that you did not put the amendments formally?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have afforded the Deputy every opportunity of indicating dissent as the record for today will show. There was agreement on both sides that the amendments be accepted and the Deputy offered slightly too late because amendments Nos. 1 and 2 had been disposed of.

Comment on this

I shall not go back into the muddle that has been created already by reason of the two sides of the House having agreed the amendments without their being put. Deputy Flanagan is right in that matter. I am the victim of the muddle but no doubt I shall find a way round it. Unlike those who drift in merely when the bells ring, for instance, I have been here throughout this debate. This is because I am interested in it. I am not opposing it with my feet only.

The section as amended—if one can regard it as having been amended since none of the amendments was put formally and accepted and since agreement was recorded despite the fact that not all present had indicated their agreement or otherwise—means that the Minister has now got by way of amendments from the Opposition, amendments which have been accepted in a manner regarded as gracious and a change of heart from the attitude of last week, more than he had originally. Again it is the old story that if you threaten sufficiently and then give way on your threat you are regarded as having conceded something. Last week the threat was that not one iota of the Bill would be changed. The amendments that have been inserted in place of some of the words of section 3 do not constitute any concession on the part of anyone, least of all the Minister. For the purposes for which he has included section 3 in the measure, the amendments have given him more than he had in the original wording. That is not to say that I agreed with what was in the section originally nor that I agree with what is in it now.

I see no need whatever for the section. As has been indicated already, the offence proposed under this section is covered already in our existing law. The section proposes that any person who incites or invites or recruits other persons to join an unlawful organisation will be guilty of an offence for which there is to be a maximum penalty of ten years' imprisonment. That provision is the same as it appeared in the section before it was amended. The section is aimed at people who recruit—as the Minister said usually impressionable young people—into unlawful organisations. The plural is used here when it suits the wording but as has been shown clearly there is no intention of applying this section, no more than any other, to any but the one organisation. It will be legal, as it is now, for persons to incite others to join all other organisations that are rampant in the Six Counties. Neither is it an offence to belong to any of these organisations despite their notoriety, their reputation and despite the claims they have made for some of the outrages that occurred. All of that is of no consequence because of this one-track minded attitude in so far as unlawful organisations are concerned.

We are labouring under the belief that regardless of whether we use means fair or foul, regardless of whether those means comply with any of the general norms of proper treatment of the individual, regardless of how we might infringe such rights, everything is in order so long as we can be seen to be knocking the one organisation to the exclusion of all others, whereas the essence of the situation is that by being selective to such degree all that is being done is creating an antagonism within the public mind against the authority that is seen to be so heavy-handed in its selectivity in the application, preparation and enactment of laws which deal with only one organisation as against all the others. The happiness and pleasure expressed by Fianna Fáil, and their gratitude to the Minister for having accepted their amendment, are very much misplaced because the section is unnecessary either in its original or amended form. What is proposed in it is already available in the common law but the Minister defends its inclusion on the basis that although what it is proposed to deal with is already covered in the common law— according to his introductory speech he said these offences can now carry unlimited fines and imprisonment, to rely on the common law would be an indirect and technical method of approach.

The fact is it is in the common law and there is no limit to the fines or imprisonment that can be imposed. The Minister does not justify its inclusion. He says that the fact that the matter can be dealt with under the common law does not make this section inappropriate. I say it not only makes it inappropriate but it should be scrapped. On the Minister's admission, this section is here to make it more convenient for the prosecutor or the prosecution who, apparently, are to take precedence over the long suffering public.

There have been sighs of relief here that the news media will now be free from the dangers outlined the other day by the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs. There is nothing in this section as amended to protect the newspapers. They will still be inhibited as they were up to now by the propaganda of the present Government which forces them not to speak the truth, not to give a fair overall spread of what is happening lest what they would publish would be about one organisation, excluding all the others who also should be proscribed. The newspapers and the nationally controlled television and radio station will now be on a totally selective basis as far as the news of the gruesome happenings up North are concerned. Indeed, it will be much more so because this section is mainly aimed at the convenience of the prosecution to do things which they could already do under the common law.

There is more in this than meets the eye. The Minister may smile and nod assent when I say that he can get as much if not more in the section as amended than he intended in the original section. The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs let the cat out of the bag in his usual inimitable way and that cat is still around and his claws are still in this section as amended. Its selective application will continue to be there and this has been clearly indicated by the Minister. In his introductory statement he said:

To rely on the doctrine of incitement could no doubt be adequate and appropriate in respect of many offences; but in the present instance we are concerned with a particular evil the essence of which is recruiting for unlawful organisations and it is clearly right to deal with it by a specific provision referring to the kinds of conduct aimed at and providing the appropriate penalty.

The "particular evil" is, of course, the IRA but not the murders, the burning of houses with people in them and all the other evils committed by organisations such as the UVF, the UDA, the National Front and the others. They are not a particular evil, nor will they be so declared, according to the Minister, because he and his Government are not of the opinion that they are such types of organisations as should be prescribed. They can go their merry way and their evil way. They can recruit publicly and otherwise on both sides of the Border.

They can declare themselves to be members of these organisations. They can and they will continue to make claims about what they have done by way of depredation and damage and murder over the years. They are quite free and untrammelled by any part of this section because of the Government's lack of conviction that they are subversive organisations, that they are dangerous, and that they are doing our people down in the Six Counties and occasionally on this side of the Border. Again, we have the selective application of the section because of the Government's attitude and their blindness to the real problems causing trouble in the country.

The Minister said section 3 seeks to do a number of things. He says it is important to note three points in respect of the section. He said the offence is not to be limited to incitement to join the organisations but will extend to incitement to help the organisation by other activities which might not be easily identifiable as specific offences so that persons could be successfully prosecuted for incitement to commit them. I take it the movers of the amendment are happy with the latter part of that. Does the Minister still see that as being capable of being used in the wider sense than would be the hope of those who by their amendments have attempted to restrict its application to some degree while, at the same time, making the intention of the section more directly effective for the purpose of dealing with only one subversive organisation? Perhaps they have forgotten about that. The Minister said the second point is that the proposed offence will apply to inviting as well as inciting. We have now added "and recruiting". The Minister said:

The third point is that, by providing a higher penalty for bringing other people into an unlawful organisation than for being a member, the Bill will show clearly that the legislature regards recruiting as even more serious than membership.

How does it matter two hoots what the Legislature may indicate? What matters is what we pass here and how it is interpreted by the Judiciary. The Minister implies that if we want persons to get two or three years' imprisonment we provide for 12 years' imprisonment and, when the case goes before the courts, the innocent Judiciary are induced to give a sentence of three years because we provided for 12 years. The Minister has belittled the Judiciary, perhaps unwittingly, in his whole approach to this measure providing extraordinarily increased penalties on the basis that we must show the Judiciary we take an extremely serious view of this matter. These men are trained to be judges. Otherwise they should not be on the bench. We are trying to lead them by the nose. You would think they were little children. You would think they did not know what time of the day or what day of the week it is and that, if we provide stupidly long terms of imprisonment, they will be induced to step up the sentences. We are told that a term of two years was given by the Judiciary in the very worst cases and, therefore, they had little latitude to step back from the worst to the not too bad case. We are providing these outlandish sentences to induce the poor innocent Judiciary to forget their training and judgment as to what punishment should fit what crime.

The Minister's indication that he takes a more serious view of recruitment to an organisation than of membership would seem to be a contradiction. If it is a crime to be a convinced member of an unlawful organisation, surely it is not as big a crime to recruit members. This gets us back to what the Minister said earlier about relativity. Perhaps we can excuse him on that basis, but I do not see the logic in talking about punishing people for inciting, inviting or recruiting, when the people who invite and incite and recruit the most people so far as the IRA are concerned, or any other subversive organisation if ever there is one so described by the opinion of the Government, which I doubt, are the people who are attempting by the application of these laws to wipe out that organisation altogether.

The people who recruit most teenagers are the people who are responsible for putting away their fathers and brothers, that is, the State. Over the years we should have learned that repression and heavy visitations of sentences on people in the IRA are not the way to diminish support for them or recruits for them. In fact, they are counter-productive. That is already evident without getting into the realm of the application of these new and amazingly lengthy sentences, and the new offences which are being created, new in the context of this Bill but already covered by our existing laws.

I cannot reconcile the attitude that we got anything from the Minister by his acceptance of amendments. We have got a change of heart in that he is no longer stone-walling but in so far as getting anything with any real meaning in it that has not changed. He is stone-walling as much now as he was at the outset. He is not codding everybody by saying: "I will take that; it means much the same as I had there." I agree it is a change but it is no change in the real application of the law as proposed in the amended section.

That section still has the same impact, the same objections and, perhaps, to some minute degree it can be argued that in some respects it is not quite as dangerous as it was but nobody will say that it is not still dangerous. While it is reduced to some degree in its verbiage, I do not agree that its actual content has changed. The Minister up to now, with one exception last week, has stood steadfastly to whatever was in his brief and would not change anything. There has been an over-reaction in welcoming the changes and it is unwise to be placating or reassuring the newspapers and the media that the warnings of the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs to them are still not capable of being visited upon them. It would be unwise for the newspapers to take the changes made today as curing all the fears they might have had. They are still suffering from fears and, in fact, without this section at all they had their fears. There were grounds for those fears. They and the Government, and everybody who has been in Government knows they had their fears without this section. They know that those fears are in no way diminished by these amendments. They can still have the worst visited upon them as the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs said last week, prematurely, no doubt; he wanted to be first with the news himself. The dangers are still there and for that reason all these things are unnecessary.

To say that this is for the convenience of our State prosecutors is a poor excuse. It is not necessary; it is superfluous. No matter how this section is amended I will oppose it as strongly as possible and with everything at my command because it should not be there. As the Minister said four years ago, we have too many laws.

Comment on this

One has to avoid some understandable temptations in dealing with this section. I will refrain from quoting from any speeches made from this side of the House on Second Stage although the points the Minister has now almost verbatim repeated in accepting our amendment were made then. It would be ungracious of us to underscore that the arguments we made so consistently have been fully vindicated and accepted. I do not want to be seen to take any joy or satisfaction from the fact that the Minister may seem to have climbed down from his original determined and confident position. I welcome the fact that he has belatedly accepted our amendments. I agree with him that the section as it now stands is much more effective and the need for what he was introducing was not at all clear unless it was to extend the scope of the section to people whom we were told it was not intended to apply, namely, the press.

We must be clear as to the obligation of a Government before they bring in this kind of legislation and this type of section and in this regard I should like to quote what the Minister for Foreign Affairs said on 8th September, 1976, as reported at column 641 of the Official Report:

It has been suggested that the section was brought in in some way to deal with the press. That is simply not true. In relation to this section the question of the press never arose in its preparation, drafting or discussion. It was brought in for the purpose of getting at those who recruit to the IRA. The question of the press did not arise in connection with it at all when it was being drafted, prepared and decided...

If what the Minister for Foreign Affairs said on that occasion is accurate and true, then it is a reflection on the Government because clearly the question of the press should have arisen in its preparation, drafting and discussion. It seems extraordinary that every section of the community, the newspapers and the public, as soon as the Bill was published immediately noticed the implications the section could have for the press.

It is extraordinary that the Government who spent so much time considering this legislation in great detail at no stage considered the implications this would have for the press. On the face of it that is scarcely creditable and if it is creditable it is a reflection on the Government who should give much more serious thought to the effect of legislation before they present it to the House. Is it accurate to say what the Minister for Foreign Affairs said in connection with this section? The Minister for Posts and Telegraphs on the previous day said, as reported at column 479:

...But something I am sure of is that an editor contemplating the publication of such a letter as that I have just quoted would be likely to consult his legal advisers once this law is passed and that the advice received would be likely to result in a significant diminution in the publication of pro-IRA propaganda.

Then he made these telling remarks:

That is what is intended under this legislation. We make no secret of that intention.

There we had a Minister saying that there was a clear intention in the legislation to ensure that certain types of publications that appeared in the press hitherto would not appear subsequently. He was referring to a letter which appeared in one of our newspapers. Nevertheless, on the following day the Minister for Foreign Affairs told us that the Government never considered the press. The Government, if these divided counsels so clearly expressed in those statements are evidence of the way they approach legislation, owe it to the House and to the public to examine that legislation more carefully. They owe it to the public to examine the consequences of legislation more carefully.

I will be supported by every member of the Fianna Fáil Party when I say that we looked at that section as drafted and in within 15 minutes we had formulated the amendments which the Minister has now accepted. Immediately we read the section as the Minister originally introduced it, we saw the ramifications that the Minister for Foreign Affairs said were never considered by the Government, but that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs seems to note were considered. While we appreciate the fact that our arguments have been vindicated and that we are ad idem in getting at the godfathers of the IRA, or any unlawful organisations, we think that more care should be given in future to such sections.

There has been some suggestion about selectivity. I want to make it quite clear that we hold consistently to the position we have stated here throughout this debate. When we are talking about inciting or inviting to join an illegal organisation we are not talking in terms of the one illegal organisation that happens to be the subject of suppression order, we are talking about all unlawful organisations which, by definition, having regard to their activities, are as equally unlawful as the IRA. The fact that they may or may not be the subject of suppression orders is irrelevant at this stage. Deputy Blaney apparently thinks that there is selective application. That may be the case from the Government's point of view but from our point of view every organisation that has unlawful aim, as defined in the 1939 Offences Against the State Act is covered by section 3. We would remind the Minister to bring that to the notice of the Garda Síochána so that we can see a definite move against all unlawful organisations on a common front.

Comment on this

It is natural that we on this side of the House should be pleased that the Minister for Justice has accepted amendments put forward by Fianna Fáil. At the same time it would be wrong if we were to pass from this section without reminding the Minister and his colleagues in Government of the immense amount of damage done to the institutions of this State, the great shaking given to the belief of the people in the motives of the Government, and the immense damage done outside to the reputation of this country by what was attempted by this Government in section 3 of this Bill. No amount of praise that may now be rightly given to the Minister can take away from the fact that that damage is irreparable. The fears internationally expressed about the motives of this Government because individual members of the Government spoke in very different voices about what the Government's intentions were, the fears expressed throughout the editorial chairs of this country and throughout the press rooms of the globe about the intentions of this Government in bringing in this Bill will take an awful lot more to eradicate them than the mere acceptance of a couple of amendments this evening.

The fears that are driven deep into the hearts of the ordinary people because of what this Government attempted to do, but were ultimately forced to abandon, will not be eradicated by the mere acceptance of amendments, which I have no doubt the Minister was obliged by his Government to accept. It could not be otherwise because the Minister had an opportunity last week to circulate his own amendments. Even as late as that time the Minister was not prepared to accept the Fianna Fáil amendments which he has accepted now. Obviously pressure from the Government or from outside brought about this change of mind. I hope the Irish people will not forget what this Government tried to do. I would ask the people to judge the members of this Government by what they attempted to do in regard to section 3 and not by the final result. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Local Government made it perfectly clear what the Government's intentions were last week when in Volume 292 at column 552 of the Official Report for 8th September last he said:

as Members of this House, we know that many people in high places, particularly in editorial chairs, have acted recklessly in the past.

He then went on to preach rubbish about the duties of editors to provide the people with food for good clean thought. He is not worth talking about.

The action of the members of the Government will be remembered and a very great deal of good conduct by this Government and its individual members will be needed to wipe out its actions from the minds and hearts of a disillusioned Irish people, a disillusioned world, a disillusioned Europe of which we are no longer the full part that we were a couple of weeks ago, having derogated from the European Convention on Human Rights. Those who admire the stand that Ireland has taken in so many ways in the name of liberty and for human rights, over the last decade, at the League of Nations, the United Nations, and at various international organisations, those who admired the way in which we have practically applied what we have preached about outside and inside our country to the betterment of our people, were deeply shaken and greatly surprised at what has taken place here, about what they have discovered about the intentions of the Government.

The damage done by the Government will, as I said before, take a very great deal of time to cure, if it is possible for the damage to be cured at all. My own belief is that the reputation of this Government is irretrievably damaged. My own belief is that the Irish people can no longer be persuaded this is a trustworthy Government and they hope to get an opportunity of expressing that view in the near future.

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle, I think we might, by agreement, have a short break until, say, 8.15 p.m.

Business suspended at 7.45 p.m. and resumed at 8.15 p.m.

SECTION 4.

Comment on this

Section 4 amends section 25 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939. It empowers an officer of the Garda, not below the rank of chief superintendent, to make a closing order on a building on the conditions as set out in the 1939 Act.

The amendment extends the period of operation of the order. Under the 1939 Act a building may be closed for a period of three months in the first instance and may be extended for one further period of up to three months. Section 4 of the Bill proposes to allow the building to be closed for an initial period of 12 months and then for a further period or periods of up to 12 months in each case so that the total period of closure shall not exceed three years.

Of course, there is power under the 1939 Act for a person to challenge a closing order in the courts. I might say that this is not a power which has been used frequently, not one which is apt to be used frequently. It was used quite recently in regard to a premises in County Cavan where the manufacture of explosives and weapons was taking place. While it is not a power that is used extensively, it is a very useful one to deal with such cases.

Comment on this

Section 5 replaces section 29 of the Act of 1939. Subsection (1) provides that where a superintendent is satisfied there are reasonable grounds—as set out in the section— he may issue a search warrant. That warrant may be directed to authorise a Garda sergeant to execute it. In the 1939 Act the officer to execute the search warrant had to be of the rank of inspector. As I think I explained on Second Stage, it has happened that a number of places have had to be searched simultaneously. Deputies will understand that if a largish area of the countryside is being combed it would be necessary to enter quite a few premises simultaneously and there might not be just sufficient inspectors on the ground at the time required. Therefore, the execution has been extended to a sergeant. In addition, the warrant may be directed to members of the Garda or the Defence Forces. At the moment it can be directed to the Garda or any other persons named in it. Certain rights arise on foot of the warrant to seize property and to retain it for evidence —that will arise under section 9. Then there is provision as to what is to happen if the forces are obstructed or are given false or misleading information.

The offences would be offences under the 1939 Act, the Criminal Law Act—if it becomes law—and scheduled offences.

Comment on this

The Minister has said that section 5 is a replacement of section 29 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939. Under the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, I understand a search warrant was issued by a chief superintendent. This has been brought down to the rank of superintendent. Would the Minister comment on that?

Comment on this

In that connection I would draw the Deputy's attention to section 3 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, which says:

Any power conferred by this Act on an officer of the Garda Síochána not below the rank of chief superintendent may be exercised by any superintendent of the Garda Síochána...

Therefore, it is not a radical departure to give the power in this case to a superintendent.

Again, there is a limited number of chief superintendents in border areas. There is one in the divisions of Donegal, Sligo/Leitrim, Cavan/Monaghan and Louth. Of course, that covers quite a stretch of country. It may be necessary to search in a hurry and it is operationally more practical that the power to issue the warrant would be in the hands of a superintendent and not confined to a chief superintendent. It is a matter of practical convenience so that the Garda may operate more efficiently.

Comment on this

I understood the Minister to say that the warrant could be directed to a member of the Garda Síochána or to a member of the Defence Forces.

Comment on this

I am glad to have that assurance because it seems to me that the warrant must be specifically directed to a member of the Garda Síochána.

Comment on this

Not below the rank of sergeant.

Comment on this

But a member of the Garda can be accompanied by a member of the Defence Forces?

Comment on this

And can only be issued to a garda not below the rank of sergeant.

Comment on this

I think the Minister did say directed to a member of the Garda Síochána or——

Comment on this

If I did say that, it was in error.

Comment on this

He is to be accompanied by a member of the Garda Síochána if it is a member of the Defence Forces.

Comment on this

It cannot be issued to a member of the Defence Forces at all.

Comment on this

Yes, but the question I posed was this. Can a search warrant be executed by a member of the Defence Forces without a member of the Garda Síochána being present?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Is section 5 agreed?

Comment on this

There is in subsection (2) and some subsequent sections—section 7 particularly—the provision that anything held during a search may be seized. This applies not just to the searching of a vehicle, vessel, aircraft or hovercraft or any other place named in the warrant. It is empowering the searching of any person who happens to be there even though he may have no connection with the location and could not be regarded as coming within the terms of the warrant. Nevertheless, provision is made for the searching of any such person. The last line of the subsection reads: "...and to seize anything found there or on such person". The term "anything" is very wide. There is no obligation regarding when "anything" may be returned or if it may be returned, irrespective of the effect of such loss to the person concerned. The power is there in the Bill; it is not qualified in any way, nor is there any provision made for its return. I should like the Minister to tell the House why he regards this provision as necessary. Is there no way by which the term "anything" may be qualified? Is there no way to ensure the return of any article that is seized?

Comment on this

I would refer the Deputy to section 9 which provides what will happen articles seized. They may be retained for use as evidence in criminal proceedings for such period from the date of seizure as is reasonable or, if proceedings are commenced in which the thing so seized is required for use in evidence, until the conclusion of the proceedings. Thereafter the Police (Property) Act applies. They are returned to the owner or are disposed of as directed by the District Court under that Act. This is stated in section 9 of the Bill.

Comment on this

Therefore, we need to take section 9 and read it with the section we are discussing?

Comment on this

Yes. Section 9 makes provision about what will happen to articles seized on foot of a search under section 5.

Comment on this

What is the situation in cases where the seizure of the article constitutes a grave and irreparable loss to the person concerned? An example could be a large sum of money held by someone, which was seized from him, but which was for a specific purpose and which was required immediately. While it might be regarded as suspicious that he held that money——

Comment on this

There have been instances where, as a result of a search, sums of money have been found on persons detained. The property can be held until proceedings are commenced; otherwise it can only be held for a reasonable time. It would be for the owner of the property if he considers the time unreasonable to make an application to the District Court for the return of the property under the Police (Property) Act and it would be a matter for the District Court to adjudicate on that.

Comment on this

I do not know if that covers the matter. So far as the issue of a warrant is concerned, where a member of the Garda Síochána or the Defence Forces may operate a warrant under this section——

Comment on this

No, that is not right. The warrant can be issued by an officer not below the rank of superintendent and it can be issued only to a garda, not below the rank of sergeant. On its execution he can be accompanied by other gardaí and/or soldiers.

Comment on this

Subsection (3) states:

A member of the Garda Síochána or the Defence Forces acting under the authority of a search warrant under this section——

Does that refer to the authority——

Comment on this

Subsection (2) governs that. It states:

A search warrant under this section shall operate to authorise the member of the Garda Síochána named in the warrant, accompanied by any members of the Garda Síochána or the Defence Forces,...

Comment on this

Is subsection (3) subservient to it in all respects?

Comment on this

Then, we are left to deal with the sergeant. It seems clear that the reason for this stepdown in the rank of garda who may be named in the warrant to a person below the rank of superintendent is due to the fact that there does not appear to be a sufficient number of inspectors or those of higher rank to execute all the warrants expected as a result of this legislation. We have more gardaí in all ranks than ever before but it is only now that we are providing legislation to name a garda of a rank lower than that of superintendent to operate a search warrant. Again, this raises the question as to what sort of situation the Minister envisages for the future in which there will not be sufficient police officers higher than and including the rank of inspector to deal with all the warrants necessary at any time. One wonders how we managed in the past in circumstances much more serious than is the case now.

Comment on this

We managed all right up to now but not as efficiently or as speedily as we would have wished when executing search warrants. This was because the full carrying out of searches was delayed until such time as inspectors were present to issue the warrants. It is of the essence of the relevant provision in the 1939 Act or of the legislation before us that searches be conducted speedily. So far as I am aware no searches have had to be put off because of there not being an inspector present but it has been reported to me that delays have occurred in carrying out these searches. The Deputy will appreciate that if the need for a search arises it is usually very important that it be carried out as speedily as possible and if several houses have to be searched it is important usually that they be searched simultaneously.

Comment on this

I take it that the Government are expecting a substantial escalation in the incidence of search warrants since there are more personnel within the higher ranks of the Garda than ever before but even with this section they are not regarded as sufficient to cope with the situation of warrants in the future.

Comment on this

It does not follow that there will be an increase in the incidence of searches following the passing of this Bill but the point is that the Garda will be enabled to carry out the searches more speedily and on a broader front.

Comment on this

The use of the phrase "broader front" would seem to contradict the case for a greater necessity for search warrants. I suppose we can only wait and see, as may be the case in regard to much of what is contained in this measure. Would the Minister agree that under this section, which is purporting to cater for an emergency situation, the issuing of search warrants would become part and parcel of our criminal law and, if so, is this not an encroachment on the rights of the public generally? It would appear that this sort of provision, which as well as copperfastening the existing situation is widening the net in regard to the searching of persons and their property, is an indication that the State is the all-powerful entity in this matter and that what the State requires must take precedence over everything else. I would not agree with that attitude but if the situation is such it is well to divorce it from the thought that it has any relationship to the declared state of emergency but that it relates to the situation as it will be permanently from now on. Is it possible that we may move further in the same direction at any given time so as to allow for more interference generally in the lives of the public? This is what the section conveys to me.

Not accepting that there exists a national emergency I am viewing the legislation as I would view it at any other time. What I see is a widening to an unbelievable degree of interference with people and their property, an interference that is not necessary in terms of the common good but which, perhaps, for very little reason and with very little gain, interferes with people in the privacy of their homes. In those circumstances we are talking more of those who are innocent than of those who may be of wrong intent.

The provision in regard to penalties for the obstruction or the attempted obstruction of a garda or a member of the Defence Forces in the execution of searches on foot of warrants would seem at first glance to be justified but we know from past experience that obstruction in that sense can be alleged against someone who merely applies the pressure of his little finger in an effort to impede a garda or a member of the Defence Forces. Consequently, if one measures such technical obstruction against the sentences proposed, the provision would appear to be open to abuse because if a garda were obstructed merely by the placing of a silk thread across his path, such act could be construed as obstruction within the terms of this measure. It would depend on the attitude of the garda concerned as to whether the accused would be faced with a severe sentence.

Again, depending on the attitude of individual members of the Garda or Defence Forces, searches could take place at any hour of the night or at the most inconvenient hours during the day. While a garda could not expect a welcome at any time that he made known his intention to search a private house we are setting up a situation whereby many innocent people may rightly resent what will be done and in the course of their objections to the invasion of their homes may be held to be obstructing the security forces. Their obstruction may be no more than a strenuous objection to the invasion of their privacy at any hour of day or night. Is there not a great danger in this type of operation that they will find themselves in court and subject to heavy penalties on the say-so of a Garda officer? Have the Minister and the Government considered this aspect in framing this section? In their enthusiasm have they ignored or completely overlooked that at the point of the invasion of their privacy people will be resentful and will react? Resentfulness on the part of such people could be easily understandable but it clearly could be regarded as obstruction—not necessarily vicious, only a natural reaction to circumstances that can arise under this section.

This is a section that will create more difficulties than it is likely to cure. It is in complete keeping with what has come before it and what would come after it in this legislation. Are we not in this legislation creating by parliamentary devise a national emergency which does not exist? Are we not pretending that something exists which does not exist? Are we guilty of self-deception? Deputy Desmond spoke of self-deception which is afoot which may well condition us, and the public through us, to acceptance of matters that can do more harm than good, perhaps totally unwittingly. I do not support any aspect of this section despite the elucidation the Minister has given of a couple of points. To my mind it is a section we could do without and if it is we should do without it.

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney is worried that the section widens the net in terms of searches. The size of the net is determined by the range of offences in respect of which searches may be made and there is absolutely no change in that regard of the position in the 1939 Act, with the exception, of course, of the inclusion of offences under the new Act. Under the 1939 Act the search could be made in respect of offences under the Act. This proposed section provides for searches in respect of offences under the 1939 Act, this Bill and scheduled offences, which broadly speaking are very serious terrorist type offences. In essence, there is no significant widening of the net.

The fact that the warrant can be executed by a sergeant instead of an inspector does not add to the dimensions of the search, as the searches will be determined by the situation on the ground, not by the fact that there are more sergeants available. The only difference that would make is that searches will be carried out more speedily and, hopefully, more effectively.

Obstruction, I am glad to say, has not been a serious problem and I am not aware of any large number of prosecutions for obstruction of the Garda in the course of carrying out their duties. I do not think it has been a problem. Even people one might not have expected have co-operated in these searches and I am certainly not aware that there has been any difficulty in that regard. Should there be a prosecution for obstruction it would be for a court to decide the appropriate penalty on the offence being proved. In deciding the appropriate penalty, the court would take all mitigating factors into account and would apply the penalty appropriate to the offence before it.

Comment on this

It is not agreed to.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Blaney is taken as dissenting.

SECTION 6.

Comment on this

This section creates certain offences relating to escape from custody. Escape and rescue from custody are already common law offences but aiding a prisoner to escape or to attempt to escape is a statutory offence and it arises under a whole series of very old Acts. Section 6 (1) provides in modern form an offence of aiding escapes from custody. Subsection (1) provides:

Any person who—

(a) aids any person in escaping or attempting to escape from lawful custody or, with intent to facilitate the escape of any person from lawful custody or enable a person after escape to remain unlawfully at large, or with intent to cause injury to persons or property in a place where a person is in lawful custody, conveys any article or thing into or out of such a place or to a person in such a place or places any article or thing inside or outside such a place, or

(b) makes, or takes part in, any arrangement for the purpose of enabling a person to escape from lawful custody, facilitating such an escape, enabling a person after escape to remain unlawfully at large, or causing injury to persons or property in a place where a person is in lawful custody,

shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable on conviction on indictment to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 10 years.

Subsection (2) provides:

Any person who, contrary to any rules or regulations in force in relation to a prison, conveys or attempts to convey any article or thing into or out of the prison or to a person in the prison, or places any article or thing in any place inside or outside the prison with intent that it shall come into the possession of a person in the prison, shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable—

(a) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding £500 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months, or to both, or

(b) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years.

This subsection is to penalise the unauthorised taking of material into or out of a prison. At the moment under the Convict Prisons (Ireland) Act, 1854, there is a prohibition against bringing in and carrying out of unauthorised material, but that is only in respect of convict prisons. The Prisons (Ireland) Act, 1856, prohibits the taking of unauthorised material into a prison but it does not prohibit the taking of such material out of a prison. There is a gap there which subsection (2) seeks to close.

Subsection (3) empowers a prison officer in the interest of security to search a person when he is a prisoner in the custody of a governor of a prison. Those powers are already there by virtue of regulations but it is felt better to give them statutory form.

Comment on this

There are just a couple of questions on this section. I do not think we can have any particular objection to it. Indeed it is to be welcomed in so far as it spells out the law in regard to these matters. First of all, I take it from reading the section that it applies to all prisoners who become part of our general prison regime. To that extent in so far as it clarifies the law it is, perhaps, useful. I find a little difficulty about it because section 32 (2) of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, provides: "Every person who shall aid or abet a person detained under this Act to escape from such detention or to avoid recapture after having so escaped shall be guilty of an offence under this section and shall be liable on summary conviction thereof to imprisonment for a term not exceeding three months."

The question which comes to my mind is: is there duplication there? Section 6 makes no reference to section 32 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, and to that extent it seems to me that there is some looseness involved. Does it replace section 32 (2) or will both of them stand side by side? If they do, they seem to me to be somewhat contradictory. Perhaps the Minister would clear up that matter for us.

Secondly, section 6 (3) reads:

A prison officer may in the interests of security search any person at any time while he is in a prison or while he is in the custody of the governor of a prison.

My question to the Minister in that regard is: does that cover visitors to prisons? Does it cover persons visiting prisoners, or is it specifically confined to prisoners themselves? It seems to me that one way or another the wording is not exact, is not precise. If it is intended to cover only persons in custody in prisons it should say so, or if it is intended to cover both prisoners and persons visiting prisoners it should also say so quite specifically. These are the only questions I have at this stage.

Comment on this

Section 32 of the 1939 Act applies only to a person who is detained under section 30 of the 1939 Act. Section 6 of this Act covers all persons in custody whether they are in prison or in a garda station, which is essentially what section 32 is concerned with. To the extent that detention under section 32, the limited type of detention in a Garda station or other convenient place, is covered by section 6, there is duplication but that is the only area of duplication present.

Comment on this

It is undesirable nevertheless.

Comment on this

It is undesirable I agree, but to draft it out would lead to immense problems and would lead to all sorts of provisos. It would make it extremely difficult to read and it could well become unintelligible. In practice I do not think there will be any difficulty, nor will there be any undesirable features resulting from leaving section 32 because of its extremely narrow application.

The power to the prison officer to search covers power to search any person in prison. I think that is quite clear from the wording of the subsection:

A prison officer may in the interests of security search any person at any time while he is in a prison...

It is clearly intended to cover visitors. It can cover members of the Garda Síochána, members of the Defence Forces and other prison officers themselves, and it is so intended. The reason for the words, "or while he is in the custody of the governor of a prison" is that a prisoner could be attending court for his trial. While he is in the courthouse he is not in the prison, but he is in the custody of the governor of a prison. The power is to enable a prisoner to be searched while he is in the custody of the governor of a prison.

Comment on this

It is the use of those words that throws some doubt on the previous words.

Comment on this

The "or" clearly distinguishes the two situations.

Comment on this

In his reply to what Deputy Haughey raised about section 32 of the 1939 Act, did I understand the Minister to say that Act was confined in its application? Does it apply only to those held under the 1939 Act?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

Until this Bill becomes law, is there no offence existing under any other law for aiding and abetting an escapee who was duly and legally held in prison or in custody?

Comment on this

The law in that regard is not as clear as it should be. Aiding a prisoner to escape or attempt to escape is a statutory offence. Some of the statutory provisions dealing with it are contained in section 4 of the Tumultuous Risings (Ireland) Act, 1831, section 18 of the Convict Prisons (Ireland) Act, 1854, and section 32 of the Prisons (Ireland) Act, 1856. These are all very old statutes and it is confusing to have an offence spread between three very old statutes. It is preferable that it should be reenacted in modern form.

Comment on this

How did the Minister overlook the word "tumultuous" in drafting this package?

Comment on this

Is any attempt being made to substitute a new section for three sections of three different Acts which are extremely old? Is there any question of their being scrubbed? Why are they not taken away to tidy things up if they are not useful? This will supersede them all in its effect. The sections the Minister mentioned should be scrubbed and so should section 32.

Does the provision in regard to prison staff cover any member of the staff no matter how he is employed or for what purpose? People who look after the needs of prisoners and their maintenance are all prison staff. Are they prison staff within this definition? The Minister mentioned members of the Garda. Does this mean the prison staff can search each other at any time? This could become a bit of a lark rather than an operation.

Comment on this

"Prison staff" are not the proper words to use. The section mentions a prison officer. That is a clearly identifiable person who has been recruited into the prison service through the normal channels. They are the only persons with this power to carry out a search. Certain procedures are observed for persons coming into prisons. These procedures apply to everybody coming into a prison from the most senior Army or Garda officer, prison officer or civil servant, down to the newest member of the service. In that sense a prison officer may search prison officers.

The overall security responsibility in any prison rests with the governor and it would be for him to decide on any searches to be carried out other than the routine regular searches. I agree with Deputy Blaney that it would be nice to repeal all these old Acts. There are many very old criminal Acts on our statutes which have fallen into complete disuse and which are never operated. It would be nice to repeal them but it does not make the legal situation more difficult by leaving them there. When they are superseded by a modern version they fall into total disuse. I am not sufficiently familiar with the sections I mentioned to be able to say they could be repealed simpliciter. There may be other clauses or provisos in these sections which would have a life of their own and their repeal might be quite difficult.

Comment on this

The Minister might follow the codification of law reform I initiated.

Comment on this

If the impetus the Deputy started had been kept between him and me it might have been possible to do it.

Comment on this

I was worn out trying to get Bills through this House.

Comment on this

Are the penalties provided in subsections (1) and (2) parallel with the provisions for penalties in any or all of the three sections the Minister mentioned in three older Acts? While I accept that there is a security procedure in regard to visitors attending at prisons, does subsection (3) envisage a situation whereby they will undergo a rigorous check before they go into the prison and that at any time while in the prison they may be further searched? Is this regarded as a likely happening?

Comment on this

It is not envisaged that would happen but it could happen. The standard of scrutiny in a prison depends on the security considerations attaching to such a prison. The Deputy will appreciate that there have to be stricter security measures operating in Portlaoise and Limerick than, for example, Mountjoy or Shelton Abbey which is an open prison. There is a difference in approach depending on the situation in the prison. On the question of penalties, I regret I am not in a position to give the Deputy details of penalties fixed by the old Acts I mentioned but I am certain that they would be considerably less than the penalties provided here. The penalties provided here are serious because the offences in a modern context are serious ones and are likely to cause a lot of public concern when they have taken place.

Comment on this

The money part of it would not worry me but the stepping up in time would. While there is justification for the money increases, there is no justification for the time penalties being increased unless they are totally out of keeping and out of step with the relativity the Minister is so careful to try to carry through this measure. Will the Minister ensure that the provision in subsection (3) is not used in a way that will mean an even further imposition on the innocent visitor who has to run the gauntlet, in the interests of security when entering the prison? Will he ensure that it will not be an added deterrent to such visitors to make the infrequent visits they are allowed to make? So many visits turn into disappointment because the visitors find that having gone through the searches the person they went to see is not allowed visitors. Some of those visitors have to make long journeys and then suffer the disappointment of not being able to see the person they wish to see. I hope this section does not further discourage some of them from travelling. I hope the system is not devised to discourage them seeing their folks in the prison rather than to facilitate them.

Comment on this

I should like to assure the Deputy that the system is not so devised. The system is forced on us by the avowed intention of the prisoners at Portlaoise— I take it the Deputy is referring to that prison—to use every and any possible means of escape. They are also not prepared to conform to prison discipline in many ways. When one has a number of prisoners who have expressed the intention to try to escape then, naturally, a stricter security regime must be applied in that prison. If those prisoners were prepared to give an undertaking to conform to prison rules and not to seek to try to escape, then there could be considerable relaxation on the security at present in operation there. I urge the Deputy, if he has any influence with those people or with their families, to convey that message to them. It is no joy to me or to the prison authorities to have to enforce a strict regime in terms of security. This is forced on us by the avowed intention of these people to at all times try to escape.

In the past visitors have been used for the purpose of conspiring to escape. There was the notorious case of the woman who carried in explosives in her vagina. That case was rather horrifying. We have had instances of explosives being brought in concealed in the heels of shoes. These are some of the activities of visitors. When I mention these the Deputy will understand the need for strict and continuing strict security. It would make life easier for everybody if these people were prepared to give an undertaking not to escape, attempt to escape or seek to escape and to conform to prison discipline. If that undertaking should be given, then the security measures could be relaxed and that, undoubtedly, would be in ease of the prisoners and staff. The measures in operation at Portlaoise or at Limerick are not designed to impede visitors. They are designed with one objective in mind only, to keep prisons secure. The recent changes made in visiting policy were made to try to obviate too many visitors at the one time crowding into the prison visiting room. It would be easier for everybody if the prisoners would instruct their visitors to agree to what was suggested, that visits would be on a pre-arranged basis so that when a visitor arrived there would be no long delay and no undue crowds. If there is co-operation by the prisoners, a regime easier for themselves and the staff could be implemented.

Comment on this

Would statements or undertakings given by prisoners that they would not attempt to escape be of any real significance as to the outlook of any prisoner in any institution? Is it not an unusual situation to be relying on, the barring from something or other people who either give it or do not give it or declare it as their intention that they will try to escape? Is the Minister aware whether any of the escapees of the past were people who declared that they would not attempt to escape? How many prisoners are still in who have never attempted to escape but who have said they would attempt to escape at any opportunity? If it aids their aims and objects of trying to make a successful break, I would be surprised if prisoners would not in furtherance of that aim be declaring themselves as not desirous of escape in order to facilitate their aims of escape.

It seems to be an extraordinary setup that the decision either way should be of any significance in regard to the availability of visits, duration or the manner in which such visits may be conducted. I wonder whether, apart from the visitors, the inmates of prisons may as a result of this have body searches at any time of the day or night even if it is quite obvious that they may have been locked up in a cell since the previous search, or it is totally covered already? Is there not a danger of this sort of thing happening occasionally for reasons that we would not condone but that we might understand? With this more closely knit provision that is here now that would supersede or at least replace although not repeal the old three sections that were mentioned, can we have it from the Minister that visitors from a long distance will not find themselves at the prison having gone through the check to find that, as in one case I know of, the next visit for the particular member of the family is the 15th of next November? That happened last month, and these things do happen from time to time.

The Minister has in the past as a result of private representations to him cleared the way in certain respects. The Minister gave advice that anyone coming from a long distance should not come to the prison without first consulting with the governor's office or somebody in charge by phone to ensure that that sort of thing does not happen. Will the Minister take steps, now that he is getting this much more composite wider power of search of anybody at any time within the confines of the prison, whether they be staff, Defence Forces, Garda, visitors or prisoners, to see that that power will not be used other than in the absolute strict interests of security? Will the Minister make sure that the innocent visitor is not further punished by being intimidated by this sort of thing and if there is a certain amount of unavoidable intimidation because of the provisions and the closing of any gaps that were in previous provisions will the Minister make sure that disappointments, particularly for visitors from a distance do not arise at the prisons if at all possible? Surely there can be some way of having better communication between the prisons and the families of the inmates than perhaps has been obtained up to now.

Comment on this

I assure the Deputy that any searches that take place in our prisons are dictated only by security needs and the implication that unnecessary body searches take place is totally wrong and I reject it. It is a matter for the prisoners and their visitors whether they are prepared to keep the prison rules and not seek to escape. If they are, the entire situation can be looked at again. In relation to visitors coming and being disappointed, it is a matter for the visitor to communicate with the prisoner they wish to visit or with the prison authorities and find out how many visits are allowed, how often and for how long and on what days of the week. People come there seeking visits irrespective of prison rules, and I am afraid visits can be permitted only in accordance with the rules. That has to be the procedure and if people do not take the trouble to acquaint themselves with the rules, some people will be disappointed.

Comment on this

The Minister could tidy up the situation by simply deleting subsection (2) of section 32 of the 1939 Act. It seems to me that section 6 as it is now framed covers all eventualities and in particular as subsection (1) paragraph (a) refers to the position of a person who aids any prisoner in escaping or attempting to escape from lawful custody. Detention under section 32 subsection (1) of the 1939 Act would certainly be lawful custody and it seems to me to be quite clearly covered under section 6 of this Bill.

Comment on this

I will look at it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 5, subsection (1), to delete all the words in line 2 and in line 3 down to and including the word "questioned" and to substitute therefor the words "section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939 or section 2 of the Emergency Powers Act, 1976".

This amendment seeks to delete the words "any enactment for the time being in force under which persons may be arrested, kept in custody and questioned..." These words appear in lines two and three of this section, subsection (1). We propose to include in place of these words the words "section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939 or section 2 of the Emergency Powers Act, 1976." I understand the Minister to have said and, indeed, the explanatory memorandum says, that what is intended by this expression "any enactment for the time being in force under which persons may be arrested, kept in custody and questioned..." is the two sections to which I refer and which are included in our amendment. It is reasonably evident that that was probably the intention but it is by no means certain that a court would so interpret it.

Comment on this

It would have to because the three conditions under the section as drafted "arrested kept in custody and questioned" apply only to those two particular measures— the 1939 Act and the Emergency Powers Bill. I have no doubt that that is what is meant but if the Deputy wants to have it specifically written in, I will accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I am very much obliged to the Minister. We are making wonderful progress these days.

Comment on this

I want to welcome the clear indication given by the Minister. Undoubtedly, the explanatory memorandum as circulated by the Minister is quite explicit but I think quite properly these points were raised by Deputies on this side of the House as well, asking that the Bill should relate to section 30 and to the Emergency Powers Act, 1976. Therefore, I welcome the specific confinement as accepted by the Minister. It is one which certainly removes from our minds the initial misgivings we had, and it shows that the power of observation is not necessarily confined to the Opposition.

Comment on this

Go bhfóire Dia orainn.

Comment on this

Had the Deputy no misgivings about the Emergency Powers Bill?

Comment on this

The acceptance of the amendment by the Minister certainly tidies the whole thing up in no uncertain terms.

Comment on this

The section is, of course, greatly improved by the acceptance of our amendment.

Comment on this

It does not make the slightest difference to it.

Comment on this

It could be used against people arrested for drunken driving, petty theft, or a whole lot of other things.

Comment on this

It could not.

Comment on this

It could, but it cannot be now. I want to draw the Minister's attention to the fact that the maximum penalty under section 30 for failure to give a name, and so on, is six months. Section 30 is not repealed in the total sense. The Minister accepted our amendment on the last Bill to the effect that, while section 2 of the Emergency Powers Bill, 1976, was in force the powers under section 30 would not be exercisable. The effect of subsection (2) is to increase the penalty of six months for refusing to give one's name, be photographed, and so on, to five years and that makes the offence a much more serious one. It is a ten-fold increase in sentence. Section 30 in the past has not been regarded as a section under which a substantial crime is committed but a similar crime under this section will carry a five-year penalty which makes the crime a very serious one indeed with a very, very, serious penalty. This may not have been intended but anyone who is in custody under section 30 and offends against any of the sub-clauses (a) to (f) will be liable to a term of imprisonment for five years. If someone refuses to give his name or gives a wrong name is that such a serious offence that he should get five years for that alone?

Comment on this

I disagree with the Deputy when he says this was never a substantial offence. It always was and the penalties provided for obstruction in the 1939 Act were surprisingly small. Having regard to the powers which can now be exercised, particularly those with regard to the taking of swabs to enable modern technology to be used, obstruction could be extremely serious because modern technology could lead to the prevention or the detection of serious crime and obstruction which might inhibit that very desirable result must, therefore, be a serious matter. It is very important that there would be a large penalty to deter people from obstructing the Garda in the making of tests having regard to the vital importance of such tests. I think it is right the penalty should be increased and increased substantially.

Comment on this

There may be certain instances where a heavy penalty might not be inappropriate but they would be limited. Usually this section would be used where someone is brought in, asked his name and address and searched, or has his fingerprints taken. If he objected to his fingerprints being taken or to one of the other things that could be done to him under this section, unless he had some very nefarious purpose in not co-operating, five years is a very severe penalty.

Comment on this

I think the Deputy is overlooking the fact that there are two methods by which proceedings may be taken against him. He may be proceeded against summarily, when he can be fined or imprisoned, or he may be proceeded against on indictment. It is when the latter course is adopted the five years maximum applies. Again, it will be for the court, on hearing the prosecution and the defence, to decide the penalty appropriate to the crime. It does not follow that, because he refused to have his fingerprints taken, he will be sentenced to five years imprisonment. He may get a substantial sentence, depending on how the court regards the particular offence. It is only right in a matter so important as this that obstruction in the course of investigation should be marked seriously.

Comment on this

The Minister should explain what is involved in the three procedures set out in subsection (1):

make or cause to be made any test designed for the purpose of ascertaining whether he has been in contact with any firearm (within the meaning of the Firearms Acts, 1925 to 1971) or with any explosive substance (within the meaning of the Explosive Substances Act, 1883) and for that purpose take swabs from his skin or samples of his hair:

This sounds potentially pretty gruesome. Would the Minister explain exactly what it involves.

Comment on this

Nothing beyond what is stated can be done.

Comment on this

Could one also ask as an extension of that if, in fact, a medical officer would be present?

Comment on this

Not necessarily. What is involved here is not a medical operation. A swab from the skin does not mean taking actual skin. It means the skin would be rubbed with some sort of chemical substance. There would be no interference with the physical integrity of the person. A sample of hair would not be a very onerous requirement. There may have to be tests on clothing. Clothing might have to be sent for examination or there might be other chemical tests designed to discover if a person has been in contact with explosives. I am not au fait with the scientific details but I certainly know it is not necessary to remove the actual skin. Taking a swab is a common enough procedure and a quite painless one.

Comment on this

This is a very sensitive area. Our Garda have power to interfere with the person of the citizen. It is a very important power we are conferring on them here.

Comment on this

If I might amplify what I said, possibly I did not make it clear, a scientific test of that nature would be carried out by people with scientific training, forensic scientists or perhaps medical people. It would not be the Garda who would be undertaking these scientific tests.

Comment on this

Did the Minister say forensic experts?

Comment on this

I accept that. I accept also that this power has, to a large extent, been there since 1939; we have all lived with it. I want to ask the Minister this question, the answer to which I should know but do not: is there some general stipulation that the Garda, when exercising any of these powers, must only use the degree of force called for by the situation? I have a feeling that there is such an omnibus provision somewhere. If there is, it would be very important that we should advert to it because this is a sensitive area. If members of the Garda are given this power we should all like to be assured that they would use only the degree of physical force necessary on any occasion involved in their procuring the particular result they are seeking. Perhaps the Minister would say whether or not there is such a general provision.

Comment on this

There would be—I would just have to search my mind for a moment—as a matter of law. As a general legal proposition there would have to be such a provision because it would be unlawful to use an amount of force that would be excessive; it would then become an assault. The section gives power to "take, or cause to be taken". Once that power is given it has to be assumed that, in its exercise, no more force would be used than was reasonably necessary to carry out the power. There is a general, overriding legal requirement that force, more than is strictly necessary, becomes unlawful and an offence is thereby committed.

Comment on this

An offence or a right to civil action?

Comment on this

Also an offence because assault is a criminal offence as well as giving rise to civil action. Therefore, the rights to implement these powers carry with them the corresponding duty to exercise them reasonably and with only sufficient force as is necessary to exercise them. Therefore, there is the overriding legal constraint that, in exercising any of our rights, we can only do so lawfully and to use more force than would be necessary would be to act unlawfully.

Comment on this

May I take it from the Minister that subsection (1) will now read:

Where a person is in custody under the provisions of section 30 of the Offences Against the State Act, 1939 or section 2 of the Emergency Powers Act, 1976, a member of the Garda Síochána may do all or any of the following in respect of him.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this

The matters of demanding the name and address, searching or causing to be searched are probably time-worn practices.

(c) photograph him or cause him to be photographed;

Of course, we should remember that it can be him or her in all these cases.

(d) take, or cause to be taken, his fingerprints and palm prints;

(e) make or cause to be made any test designed for the purpose of ascertaining whether he——

or she——

has been in contact with any firearm...

Comment on this

It might help the Deputy if I tell him that, by virtue of the Interpretation Act, the use of the male gender always imports the female gender.

Comment on this

I am merely reading it in because that is what it means.

Comment on this

There is no need to read it in. It cannot mean anything else.

Comment on this

It is just as well to have it quite clear that this does mean male or female. The subsection also says:

...or with any explosive substance (within the meaning of the Explosive Substances Act, 1883) and for that purpose take swabs from his skin or samples of his hair;

(f) seize and retain for testing anything that he has in his possession.

(a) and (b), yes; from (c) right down to (f), No. I say "No" to those for the very good reason that, where a person is in custody, is not guilty, has not been charged or had anything proved against him—therefore working on the assumption that a person is innocent until proved guilty, which, of course, is becoming a rather forgotten aspect of our way of life up to now—I contend that this photographing and causing to be photographed is wrong until such time as the person may have been found to be guilty and detained as a result of some charge or other having been proved. The taking of fingerprints and palm prints should not be insisted upon and should not be provided for unless and until a person in custody has been put there as a result of a charge proven.

With regard to the making and taking of tests designed for the purpose of ascertaining whether a person has been in contact with any firearm or explosives, which covers a very wide range, and for that purpose the taking of swabs from his skin, the Minister amazed me by saying that he was not terribly well up on all of what it means. He should have informed himself in this respect because it is he who is carrying the can in so far as putting this Bill through the House is concerned. With no reflection on the Minister, surely it is the duty of a promoting Minister of any legislation not only to satisfy himself as to what it means but to inform and educate the House and, therefore, the public, what is involved right down to the scientific, medical, or whatever type of jargon used. It should be recorded here whether he understood it fully, or we, as a result of his having related it to us. Small use it would be at a later stage to hear that a Minister and we, in all innocence, had passed something the inner details of which we did not understand.

The actual methods of doing any or all of the testing or swabbing implied in this may or may not be onerous. We do not know but we should know. It is not good enough that the Minister should come in here unarmed, not being in a position to inform the House about what he is asking us to consider, never mind pass. In the terms of the reply I thought I heard him give it would not necessarily mean that some medical person would have to be available. That is rather disturbing considering that the Minister followed that up by saying that he did not quite understand fully what might be involved but that he did not think it was onerous and so on. It may be.

This is coming back to where I interjected "she" as well as "he" even though we are supposed to read and understand it as applying to both. Females in custody who are not charged or proven guilty will be subject to all these tests without a medical doctor in attendance. Neither is there any indication that the tests will be carried out by female prison staff and it still remains a question whether they will be medically qualified. I should like the Minister to give us details of the testing. If he is not in a position to do this at the moment, perhaps he would take the trouble to become fully informed about the matter before the final Stages?

At the outset of this debate the Minister referred to "anyone in custody for any reason" but that is gone now. However, it does not take away from the fact that under these two enactments, in the Act of 1939 and in this proposed legislation, there is an extremely wide area where people may find themselves in custody. Will the Minister state if this involves persons in custody as a result of the operation of the 48-hour period plus the five days' detention covered in the measure we passed last week? If it involves all those who might come under that umbrella, the demands listed here, apart from the name and address, and perhaps the searching for the purpose of immediate security, are a total and complete invasion of the privacy of the individual. It could bring about a situation where there would be the most extraordinary array in a rogues' gallery for posterity. That would be wrong for two reasons. First, it would be wrong to the persons concerned who were innocent and, secondly, it would only add to the confusion.

Will there be copyright attaching to these photographs of people who may be pulled in under section 30 of the 1939 Act or section 2 of this measure? If there will not be any conpyright, will there be an assurance that such photographs and pictures will not be used for any purpose other than that of immediate concern to the prosecution that, presumably, will follow? If there are no charges, will the photographs—which should never have been taken—be returned together with the negatives to the offended person who was taken into custody? This may sound facetious but it is not so. I take the most strong objection to any police force in any country pulling in any person on something that does not stand up, with no charge sustainable, as I take the strongest objection to a situation where a person may be obliged at the dictates of the State, through the agency of the Garda Síochána, to leave behind photographs, finger prints, palm prints, swabs and so on.

Comment on this

Perhaps I should explain to the Deputy that these items of information would be part of Garda records——

Comment on this

I cannot hear the Minister. I have complained about this on other occasions.

Comment on this

Any information got on this on foot of these inquiries would be part of Garda records and, consequently, any documents would be subject to the Official Secrets Act. There is no question of their being disclosed other than in accordance with that Act. Information got under these procedures could be—I would go so far as to say has been—of vital importance in solving crimes, perhaps not at the time but a year afterwards.

Comment on this

This is the objectionable feature. To follow that argument through, why not have the entire population from the cradle to the grave photographed, finger printed, palm printed and swabbed for posterity in case this may be of help in the future in the solving of a crimes I have no doubt that it would be of help but the question is, does the likelihood of the benefit deriving from that kind of operation justify the perpetration on the individual of what is proposed here, even though the people are innocent?

Comment on this

The short answer to the Deputy's question regarding exercising these powers on the entire population is that these powers are only exercised in relation to persons who have been arrested by a garda who suspects that person has committed, is about to commit or has been concerned in the commission of an offence, or whatever is the more modern wording in the Emergency Powers Bill. It is not a question that these are people picked up at random. They are people arrested in very specific circumstances where there is reasonable cause for suspecting that they have been involved in terrorist type offences.

Comment on this

That is fair enough as far as it goes. It is a fair reason why there should be a division between those who have not been brought into custody and those who have. I say there are even more compelling reasons why those who have been brought into custody, who are subsequently found innocent, with not a shred of evidence to be found against them, why that category should also be removed from the obligation of having photographs on record for all time. This has been justified by the Minister on the basis that they were brought in under these enactments, that this is their hard luck. This is what we have been complaining about. No matter how well meant these powers are a large number of people will be brought in but found to be not guilty of any chargeable offence but they will have suffered the hardship, the indignity and the inconvenience of their being detained for two days or for seven days as the case may be. Why should there be visited on those people while in custody the provisions of paragraphs (c), (d) and (e) of subsection (1) of section 7? They will already have suffered the loss of their liberty for a period of up to seven days, that is, within the framework of what is here but not taking into account the possibility of what could happen. Surely if they are innocent of any offence under any of the Acts concerned it is adding insult to injury to say to them that because they were brought in at all they are to be treated differently from the rest of the population and that they must be photographed, palm printed and recorded for all time. As a legal man, the Minister must find it very difficult to attempt to sustain such provision.

In circumstances in which a person is found to be innocent there should be no record kept. This legislation can only have a bad effect because the fact that these innocent people are recorded puts them in the rogues' gallery for all time. Therefore, the legislation can only be counter-productive and detrimental to the observance of law and order in the future not only in respect of these extraordinary powers but in all respects. It can only tend to bring into contempt the whole idea of law to treat innocent people in this way when we know that at large among the general public are people who, if they were brought in, could be found to be guilty in so far as certain offences are concerned. These are the people who, in the interest of State security for the future could usefully be taken in, charged, convicted and then recorded.

There is the Minister's admission that the cradle to the grave regard is some sort of tag. Such tag is tantamount to tying a card to a person's ears or toes and the fact that it will be used only in respect of persons detained under the provisions before us in no way justifies it. How can the State be justified in doing those things to people when by being unable to show any cause to charge them they are lumped with people who had been found guilty, recorded and their case histories filed away for the curiosity seekers of future years? Such records would be of no value since they would show nothing, unlike, for instance, the person who is discharged from a mental institution and of whom it can be said has proved he is entitled to be out. The same applies to the measure before us. Those who will be detained but released without being charged with any offence can say that they are the only members of the population who are not guilty of offences. Despite this their records are to be filed away for all time.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy but he seems to be repeating some of the statements he has made already.

Comment on this

Hear, hear. I have got the Deputy's point several times.

Comment on this

I agree that there is a certain amount of repetition in my contribution but in latter years I have often advised my younger colleagues never to be reluctant to repeat something that is worth saying, regardless of how often it has been said already. Perhaps I am taking my own advice too literally. I apologise for that and shall attempt to refrain from repetition regardless of how worthy it may be. No doubt the Minister who, in the past, has shown himself to be very sensitive to the rights of the individual, particularly during his relatively short time in this House, is not sleeping very well those nights but is lying awake thinking of what these measures involve.

Comment on this

The difficulty is to stay awake here.

Comment on this

I commend it to the Minister during his sleepless hours in the night for his kindest consideration so that I will not be forced at a later stage to repeat what I have said now. Subsection (2) states:

Any person who obstructs or attempts to obstruct any member of the Garda Síochána or any other person acting under the powers conferred by subsection (1) of this section, or who fails or refuses to give his name and address when demanded, or gives a name or address which is false or misleading, shall be guilty of an offence and shall be liable—

(a) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding £500 or to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months, or to both, or

(b) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years.

There we can conceive a situation wherein a person is in custody on the say-so of a garda who suspected "with reasonable cause" that that person may have been involved in the commission of an offence or that he had knowledge of the commission of an offence or that it was intended to commit an offence or any of the rest of the jazz we had in the Emergency Powers Bill. Can anybody justify that sort of treatment being visited on that sort of person who may be totally innocent of any of the suspected matters but who may be held for seven days during which photographs and finger and palm prints and swabs can be taken? Is there anybody here who would not object violently to that intimidatory treatment?

These demands in this section are not only completely unnecessary but they are useless. Yet if such a person objects to any of these procedures he or she will be liable to this intimidatory fine of £500, or 12 months inprisonment or both, or on indictment to a sentence not exceeding five years. The photographs and other records cannot be of any value to the State now or at any time in the future. The Government say this legislation is necessary to safeguard the rights of the community. Is this kind of intimidatory procedure safe-guarding the rights of individuals, this intimidation by the Establishment which will now reach a degree that it can be regarded as Establishment violence? Is it not around the most recent violence in the Six Counties that we have built our reasons for bringing along this repressive paraphernalia? This can only be wrong and the Minister is well aware of it. It far outreaches what the Minister and the Government set out to do. They are overplaying their hand and this will be the cause of defeating anything they had hoped to attain by these extraordinary measures.

The Minister has this week given the so-called concession of accepting amendments which he would not have dreamt of accepting last week. Much more is needed in face of the discontent of a large section of our people if this discontent is not to grow. We have all too much of this "no surrender" in another part of our country. We are doing the Minister a favour when we try to induce him to make changes. We are doing a favour to the Minister and the Government, not for the love of them but for the purpose of trying to alleviate and minimise the impact of this unnecessary, repressive legislation. This is the type of exercise we are engaged on through the Government's operations at the moment. If there has been some success as a result of some underground subversive movements by the supporters of the Government over the past couple of weeks, when supporters of those representatives here in the House began to——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should keep to the section we are on.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

A good idea.

Comment on this

If it were not out of order I would love to go back on some of the other sections for the edification and education of the missing Deputies who have now appeared. They are better than the vast majority of their colleagues who have not appeared at all. I am sorry if I have digressed from the section but it is so far-reaching that one can envisage the most outlandish situations. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle may be driving home next week or the week after when this legislation is in operation, and if a garda suspects with reasonable cause that this personage whom he may or may not know by sight has some knowledge of the commission or the intended commission of an offence he could be taken in legally and detained for a number of hours. His name could be demanded. He could be searched and photographed, finger printed, palm printed and tested. I do not know whether they will carry out TB testing and brucellosis testing.

Comment on this

Will there be lay technicians?

Comment on this

We will have to wait for the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to inform us about that. Then we will have to consult with the IVU and, no doubt, the farming organisations.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy must keep to the Bill.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That can be done under the Marts Act.

Comment on this

The Marts Bill was capable of being challenged successfully in the courts under our Constitution. These provisions cannot be challenged anywhere because we were muzzled before we started. The people who complained about the Marts Bill are now reaping the benefit of it, so much so that if one is for sale anywhere they are trying to buy it to try to make a few bob out of it.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

We are a constitutional party, not a slightly constitutional party.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney on the Bill.

Comment on this

They can take the piece of the Constitution which has been covered up here and keep it in their pockets until this has been declared null and void at some future date.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Is it the 1937 Constitution?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These interruptions are leading the House astray.

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants to go back further, I am in the humour for that.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is asking the Deputy not to do that.

Comment on this

I have been a long time here and Deputies know I can be provoked. To get back to what I was saying, the person who has the honour to be the Leas-Cheann Comhairle of this House could be lifted on his way home next week and taken in and finger-printed, swabbed and photographed. If he refuses to co-operate, as I would expect him to refuse knowing that he was innocent, he will have committed an offence for which he can be nailed. He will be in the rogues' gallery for the rest of his life and long after he has gone.

That is what the Government are doing, and that is what the people who are supporting the Government are doing, although they may not know it because they spent very little time in the House during the course of these proceedings. I would laugh if some of them were picked up in those circumstances and were put in the rogues' gallery even though they were totally innocent. Better still, perhaps, they would refuse to cooperate and they would be nailed for £500 and a year in jail. That would change their minds about supporting the lot in front of them. There are smiles over there now but there will be smiles over here if that happens, and stranger things have happened.

Why should a person who is taken in and ultimately released as innocent be liable to a fine of £500? Despite the depreciation in the value of money that is still a considerable amount. Even in these days of escalating costs and depreciation in the value of money, £500 is still a considerable amount.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is repeating what he has already said.

Comment on this

I did not think I had dealt with the money part of it. When the late Frank Fahy was Ceann Comhairle he said that if the Chair said it was ten minutes to 11 o'clock it was that time. I never forgot that. I commend it to newcomers to the House and the not so newcomers. I suppose it is hard to expect them to accept that if it is only five past ten o'clock and he says it is ten past, it is ten past. This happened to me long years ago. There was a difference of only two minutes between us but it was there and I never forgot it.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

This sounds like Alice in Wonderland.

Comment on this

Alice left Wonderland a long time ago. Is there any parallel for the penalty of five years for refusing to give your name to a garda in our existing law outside the enactments of 1939, 1972 and 1976? Is there anything in the existing laws whereby five years' imprisonment can be visited upon a person who is innocent of what he is being questioned about but refuses to give his name or gives it incorrectly for any reason, maybe for a joke or because he has had a few drinks? Is there anywhere in existing law where such a term of imprisonment can be imposed upon a person for simply remaining silent? We all know that the people in rural areas take it hard when a guard asks them for their name and address particularly when they are well acquainted with that guard. Although he is entitled to ask them for a name and address they, because of their acquaintance with the guard, think he is having them on. Such people may not give their name and address because they know the guard is in possession of that information. I would be amazed if the Minister could quote any law that imposes such a prison term on such a person who refuses to give that information. Is there any provision that has a tag of £500 for failure to give that information, one year in jail or both? I do not believe there is.

I have heard of Deputies who did not know their own address on occasions. I do not mean any disrespect; in fact it is one of the best stories I have heard about the House for a long time. The occasion I am speaking of did not occur yesterday so that it is not news but such a thing can happen. On occasions people do not give their name or address because they feel the guard knows that information already. The name and address requirement is not a very objectionable practice and people are more understanding of it. They know that the guard is required by the dictates of his own boss to seek this information even though he may know the person concerned very well.

While the provision for search or causing to be searched is irksome in certain circumstances it is not all that objectionable if it is done in a reasonable way. While the searching of a person and the demanding of the name and address of that person are acceptable how can one blame anybody who refuses to be photographed? Heavy sentences are handed out to persons who refuse.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy appreciates that he is going back again on what he has already repeated.

Comment on this

I am attempting to relate the exceedingly provocative and irritating circumstances in which under these special powers of 1939 and 1976 innocent persons may be pulled in, deprived of their liberty and, having added the insult to the injury of demanding photographs, fingerprints and tests are, if they refuse, guilty persons though they were innocent when taken in. As a result of the system they are guilty and are liable to severe penalties.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy will agree that he has already repeated that.

Comment on this

Not in that context. By this system we will be making innocent persons guilty and if they do not conform to the system they become convicts in their own right.

Comment on this