Criminal Law Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–152 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 33 of 1976 ›
If somebody completely innocent is pulled in under section 7 and is kept in detention for seven days and perhaps on the fifth or sixth day an effort is made to take fingerprints and so on, he will be very likely to protest violently. If force must be used who is to determine what is a reasonable amount of force? Suppose an innocent man is pulled in on suspicion because of his associations, when that man is released where would he go with a complaint that unreasonable force was used?
Comment on this
The question as to whether adequate and reasonable force was used would be a matter that would be decided subsequently if the person took action complaining that unreasonable force was used. It would be decided by a court.
Comment on this
The police will be the only people who are entitled to or who can give evidence before the court.
Comment on this
Why is this section necessary at all? The principal purpose of the section seems to be to give the Garda power to search vehicles and persons in vehicles. The section gives them that power if they have reasonable cause to suspect that an offence has been or is about to be committed under one of the provisions which are set out in the section. Most of us thought that the Garda already had this power. If that is not so, the insertion of this section in this legislation, and indeed other sections that have been inserted in other legislation recently such as the Drugs Bill, would seem to indicate that we need a comprehensive Police Powers Bill because we seem to be legislating ad hoc in order to confer particular powers from time to time on the Garda Síochána. I could well visualise a member of the Garda being completely confused from time to time as to under which particular section of which particular statute he should decide to take action. The section itself does not present any difficulties to us, but that question does arise and I would like the Minister to let us know why the Garda have not already got this power and why has it to be set out in this very detailed specific way in this section.
Does the Minister agree that at a very early stage he should come before the House with a comprehensive police powers measure? From the point of view of the effectiveness of the Garda as a security force and, secondly, from the point of view of the ordinary citizen and legal practitioners it is becoming increasingly important that there should be some codification so that everyone will know exactly where he stands in regard to the powers of the Garda to search either vehicles or premises.
Comment on this
The powers being given to the Garda now were, oddly enough, not already covered by legislation and I think most Members were surprised to learn that this was so. They have power to stop vehicles under the Road Traffic Act but there was no power to search the vehicles and any searches that took place were carried out with the co-operation of the public. As I indicated in my Second Stage speech, this co-operation was at all times forthcoming and there was, therefore, no difficulty. However, once the gap was there, it was felt desirable that it should be closed and the Garda should have legal powers to enable them to deal with a person who might not be co-operative.
The idea of a comprehensive police powers Bill sounds attractive but I do not think it would improve the position. Every existing statute would have to be searched to see what power the Garda had under it and this would then have to be transferred into a comprehensive Bill. In doing that one tries naturally to devise an omnibus provision and that could lead to great difficulty and, after the Act had been passed, I am quite sure some situation would arise not covered by the Act. As a matter of practical procedure, I cannot see any alternative to giving the police the powers they need to implement whatever legislation comes here from time to time. In addition, a sort of omnibus measure covering past and future events could inhibit debate here. If power were already provided there could be a feeling in the House that the power being granted in the comprehensive Bill was too wide or too narrow. Thinking about it for the first time these difficulties would be very great indeed, but the idea is an interesting one and I shall keep it in mind.
Comment on this
The Minister must acknowledge we are getting into a fairly confused sort of situation. We are dealing with a Drugs Bill and under that the Garda will have power to stop and search vehicles. They will have the same power under this Bill, plus other powers. What will be the situation of the Garda, on the one hand, and the citizen on the other? Will the garda have to make up his mind whether he will search the vehicle under the Drugs Bill for drugs or under this Bill because he thinks someone in the car has committed an offence under the Offences Against the State Act? What is the citizen to think? Is he being stopped and searched because he is suspected of being a subversive or because he is suspected of having drugs? There is a great deal to be said for the Garda having powers spelled out very clearly in a composite measure. The Minister's argument that a comprehensive measure would be found to be inadequate is not very convincing because, if a comprehensive measure were found to be inadequate from time to time, surely the present situation in which we have isolated powers dotted all over different statutes is much more likely to present inadequacies.
Deputy O'Kennedy and Deputy Blaney rose.
Comment on this
This section is very similar to section 5 and the probability is that what is proposed here has really nothing to do with an urgent situation but will become the law to be applied in future. Police powers are being sought and, beyond being justified because of an alleged emergency, these are powers that would not be sought or, if sought, would certainly not be given by this House at a time other than this trumped up emergency we are supposed to have. Only the Minister and the Government know anything about this emergency. If there were an emergency, there would be some point in seeking these powers. Providing these powers is bringing us straight into the realms of a police State and the Minister or anybody else will not convince this House or the public that this will not happen. The Garda will be empowered to stop any person anywhere at any time. This is just not good enough. We have survived without that up to now and I do not see why we cannot survive without it in the future.
Under subsection (3) the Garda may use reasonable force. This provision is very similar to that in the Emergency Powers Bill. If it is thought to be required in this bogus emergency situation, then let us have it in the Bill already passed but do not incorporate it in this measure. The references in the earlier subsections are more objectionable even than those in the Emergency Powers Bill because there is no effort to present what is proposed here in the light of there being a special situation. As far as we are concerned, this will be for all time. In subsection (2) we have the same objectionable wording as that in the Emergency Powers Bill: "Where a member of the Garda Síochána who with reasonable cause suspects...". It is changed around here. Under the earlier Bill it was "suspects with reasonable cause" but I dare say the interpretation would be the same. If the Garda have the slightest suspicion cars will be pulled up and searched and, so long as this Government continues, we will have the amazing situation of the Garda "with reasonable cause" suspecting or "suspecting with reasonable cause" having the power to stop and search vehicles and persons in those vehicles. This may be done at any time, anywhere, to anybody in any circumstances whatsoever.
With the Emergency Powers Bill being through, I take it, by the day of the all-Ireland final, would the Minister ever get them on the roads leading out of Dublin that evening to make what we are talking about here really obvious? Indeed, he should get them in their cars on the roads into Dublin on that day; pick out that day particularly because it will happen on such days, as happened before with even less powers at their disposal. Without doubt, in some of those thousands of cars moving in and out of Dublin on that day there will be one that contains somebody or other on whom the guards would like to get their hands. Therefore, there would be reasonable cause to suspect that a car coming to or going from the all-Ireland final would contain some person who could be apprehended under this or a previous measure. So, stop the lot and search the lot. Compel them to stop and use whatever force is necessary.
I see Deputy Luke Belton smiling. It is no laughing matter. I am merely instancing the crazy situation for which we are providing in the immediate future. Only a fortnight from now it could be done. It has been done on such occasions already without the existence of this power. What will it be like now that we are providing the power, not alone in this Bill but already under section 2 of the Emergency Powers Bill? All that is required is that any single member of the Garda force "who, with reasonable cause suspects", and all the rest of it, which would not let a fly through a screen in so far as there being any way out of it; there just is not. This is a complete and absolute road block in the literal sense.
I totally object to this interference with the rights of the individual. God knows we have had sufficient interference in our short history without adding more by our own say-so and operations in this allegedly democratic institution. It will not be democratic too long if we continue to churn out laws of this nature, not for emergency purposes, as provided for in the Bill we passed the other day, but for permanent operations. Then there are those who blandly stand up and say this is needed, with all sorts of niceties being added as to why we should have it in that way. It is police state control, do not have any doubt about it. If at present it can be said that our police will not do this or that, we are now providing powers under which they can. Therein lies the danger. We should not be providing powers that will make it possible to have that type of police state operation—a "Big Brother" job—we have sufficient of that and certainly we do not want it provided for in this manner, not alone in the other Bill for an emergency situation but in this one for all time. "Big Brother" is the operative thought behind this type of legislation. No number of reasons advanced could justify that sort of thing. The Minister particularly will be responsible for the introduction and furtherance of the opportunity to practise police state operations here. We do not need it, we do not want it and we should not give it.
Comment on this
It would appear that the provisions of this section, which confer the power of search on the Garda, are to be confined to the various offences set out in subsection (1). May I ask the Minister if, in pursuance of these powers, a member of the Garda, having reasonable cause, searches a car or some other vehicle and finds, for example, stolen property, drugs or contraceptives—if that is an offence—is he then entitled to proceed with the search, proceed with the search of other persons, to use reasonable force and all the other powers conferred on him under this section? Is the State then entitled to use that evidence—which I would submit is improperly obtained—to support its prosecution, on indictment, or charge of receiving stolen property, stealing property or for illegal possession of drugs?
Comment on this
The search would be under section 8 and the Garda would be carrying out the search under the powers of section 8. The search would be quite lawful. If, in the course of that search, a guard were to come on stolen property, he would be committing an offence himself if he did not move on foot of what he found because he would then be guilty of felony. Therefore, it is quite clear that any other offence that might come to light as a result of the exercise of the powers under this section would properly have to be investigated by the guard and would be a proper subject for a charge. Likewise, any searching of persons in the car would be done as a result of the original stopping of the car, which would have been done under the powers in this Bill. The fact that other matters were found incidentally, subsequently, would not have any effect on the legal rights of the guard to continue the search under the powers conferred on him by this section.
Comment on this
Of course, that is what I was afraid of, that this whole package is likely to be used and abused by members of the Garda Síochána, indiscriminately and without reasonable cause, to search persons, to use force in searching persons and vehicles to discover information which may have nothing at all to do with the present state of emergency. That is absolutely inevitable; it must happen. The guards are only human beings and they will go on searching, without having reasonable cause, looking for matters to which they are entitled under this section. The whole process of the law will be abused. Information and evidence will be sought to support prosecutions having nothing at all to do with an emergency or security.
Comment on this
I want to reject quite categorically the Deputy's suggestion that the Garda powers under this section will be abused or used indiscriminately. It is an unwarranted suggestion and made without any foundation whatsoever. Nothing whatever in the tradition or activities of the Garda up to now could give any basis for making that suggestion.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister why what he wishes to do in section 8 is not capable of being contained within section 5, or an extension of it, with the control that these things may only be done on the direction or under the authority of a warrant? This is objectionable enough but the idea that we can have all of this in addition to the powers in the Emergency Powers Bill is too much. Why is section 5 not sufficient, in addition to the Emergency Powers Bill, to do what is required?
Comment on this
Section 5 is designed for a completely different purpose and gives completely different powers. Section 5 gives powers to search specific places as named in the warrant and section 8 enables the vehicle checkpoint system to be operated——
Comment on this
Many checkpoints are set up as security measures for the protection of citizens. They are operated on occasions such as all-Ireland finals, rugby internationals and similar occasions. They are set up as a security measure; they are there for the security of all the citizens, not to harass the drivers. There are two completely different powers envisaged in the two sections. It would not be possible to provide for the random type of vehicle checkpoint search under section 5.
Comment on this
It is a matter that it is not practicable, it is not possible. Section 5 requires that a search warrant has to be issued by a superintendent in respect of the place to be searched and issued to a Garda sergeant for execution. The Deputy is asking that that procedure be undergone for every car coming into Dublin, for example, on an all-Ireland final day.
Comment on this
I realise it is much more convenient from the point of view of the Minister and the authorities to say: "Let's knock all of them to get the one person." What I am suggesting could be justified on any day when there is heavy or even normal traffic coming into Dublin. Any garda could conform to the requirements of the section by saying that he had reasonable cause to suspect that one car coming into or leaving the city on a certain day came within the ambit of the provisions of section 8. On that basis every car coming into or leaving the city could be stopped and searched and if the owners were not prepared to allow this they could be compelled by the use of reasonable force to have their cars searched. At that stage there could be an open-ended provision allowing for the searching of the persons in the car.
I am sure the Minister would argue that that would not happen unless in the course of the search of the car there was further cause as to why the person should be searched. There is a very fine line here. It does not prevent the indiscriminate searching of any car and, possibly, the people in the car. There is no point in saying it will not happen because we are making provision for it here. As the Minister has pointed out, the Garda are already stopping and searching cars without authority. Here we are giving them absolute, total, global authority. Irrespective of how they apply the provisions, they are so completely covered there can be no come-back by any person, no matter how aggrieved he may be about the manner in which he was compelled to allow the search to be conducted. One would imagine the public were the servants of the Garda instead of the other way around. In all the legislation we put through this House it seems that all levels of our public service are being provided with instruments in law to ensure that it is the public who are the servants instead of the reverse. In this case there is no doubt that we are providing here the blueprint for a police state in its worst form.
Comment on this
The Deputy is repeating himself. He has made that point on a number of occasions. I would ask him to please desist from repetition.
Comment on this
Probably soon there will be laws that will apply to this House, controlling it in the same way as is happening outside. The powers being provided here are not necessary. They are an imposition on the public and they are a danger to the future well-being and to the rights of our people. The Minister should be ashamed of himself.
Comment on this
I am not satisfied with the Minister's assurance that this section will not be abused. It is inevitable that over-conscientious and over-anxious members of the Garda Síochána will use this section in the investigation of offences and crimes that have nothing to do with this alleged emergency.
Comment on this
Has the Deputy any evidence that the Garda Síochána in carrying out searches up to now have abused their powers?
Comment on this
I am satisfied that innocent people will be harassed by over-conscientious members of the Garda Síochána——
Comment on this
——to justify the powers conferred on them and to justify the case made by the Minister and others in this House.
Comment on this
I do not see how Deputy Blaney or anyone else can object to a situation where the Garda Síochána would have the power to put up road blocks in the case of an important occasion, for instance a rugby match, when there would be a stream of vehicles coming into Dublin from the North and elsewhere and where the Garda were apprehensive about the situation. I cannot see why anyone should object to their searching vehicles in the interests of the security of all of us.
Comment on this
I do not think so. I am as conscientious and as anxious as anyone that the ordinary citizen would not be harassed, as Deputy Brosnan pointed out, or that the Garda would not be excessively zealous in the exercise of any powers we may confer on them under this section. I am prepared to accept the section because I have seen road blocks set up by Garda on these important occasions. It has given me a sense of security to see the gardaí out on the roads endeavouring to the limit of their ability to prevent some of these appalling and horrible occurrences. I wish in every way that is necessary to control and limit the powers being given to the forces of the State but in the situation in which we find ourselves I cannot see any particular objection to the powers proposed here. We are in the threatening and intimidating situation in which on any Friday or during any weekend we could have an incursion of evil-minded persons into our cities or into any part of the country. Surely we will not prevent the Garda having reasonable power to try to circumvent such atrocities. I do not wish to prevent anybody on this side of the House giving expression to legitimate fears. Indeed, as the debate has progressed those of us on the front bench have been firm advocates of the retention of the maximum amount of freedom for the individual and the restriction of harassment to the greatest extent possible but in this regard common sense should prevail. I will support any measure which enables me to walk the streets of this city with some sense of security.
There is one further point I wish to make, that is, that in the sort of situation the Minister has been talking of and to which I am now adverting there is underlined the importance of bringing in suppression orders against some of the organisations who might perpertrate atrocities. The powers we are giving here to the Garda would be supplemented considerably if the Minister took the additional necessary step of identifying certain organisations and suppressing them so that the Garda would be able to have the full panapoly of power available to them to deal with any members of those organisations whom they encountered in these sorts of situations.
Comment on this
I was amazed to note the list of Acts to which this section relates. For example, the Fire-arms Acts 1925 and 1971, the Larceny Act, the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861 and several others. The reason I was amazed was that I understood the Garda always to have had power to search cars under the conditions we are talking of. Indeed, if at any time I had been asked to allow my car to be searched, I would have considered myself obliged to co-operate with the Garda. However what concerns me is the casual type of search that is carried out. If people wish to come here carrying explosives, they will not carry them in the boots of their cars nor will they travel on the main roads. Perhaps this type of detail is something which the police are capable of dealing with but I suspect that the type of casual search carried out by the Garda is a waste of time because in the knowledge that the search is casual, people of evil intent would be tempted to take risks. They would be likely to travel by way of backroads. As I have said here already, a friend of mine and his wife were blown up by an explosive which had been tied to the chassis of their car. The device was intended to blow up the place at which the wife worked. The point is that the explosive was not placed in the boot of the car or on the back seat but was concealed underneath. That is why I say that if there is to be a search, it should be a thorough one.
The same applies to the searching of cars entering the precincts of this House where an usher merely looks into the boot. To me this is a silly exercise and is a waste of time on the part of those whose duty it is to conduct it. If anybody wished to use my car for the purpose of sending an explosive in here, he would not put the device in a place as obvious as the boot.
Now that the Garda are being made aware of the powers which have always been there, I trust that they will not abuse them. In this context I do not entertain the same fears as those expressed by Deputy Brosnan for the reason that I understood these powers to have been available all along. I was of the opinion that after a murder had been committed, for instance, the Garda had power to stop cars and search them and anybody travelling in them. However, I trust that the people will appreciate the real purpose of emphasising those powers and will give to the security forces any co-operation necessary in the conducting of searches.
Comment on this
Listening to Deputy Haughey, one noticed a certain similarity in his approach and that of the Minister. It is an approach which is very dangerous because it indicates that this phony, pseudo emergency has caught on and that we are thinking in terms of protecting Dublin and other areas by the vigilance of the security forces in executing searches of cars approaching our cities and towns. By all means let us have those searches but there is no need for a sledge hammer to permit them to be carried out since there are powers in existence which can be used for this purpose. If this is the only matter which concerns us in the field of the security of our cities and towns, is there any reason for going beyond the first two paragraphs—(a) and (b)—of subsection (i)? These paragraphs give reason for the fears that have been expressed and for what Deputy Haughey said. Does the Minister say that at the moment the gardaí have no right to stop anybody?
Comment on this
The Minister has indicated that the powers of the Garda are defective in so far as carrying out global searches are concerned, searches of persons as well as cars. I have not much confidence in the efficacy of checkpoints as far as protecting a city is concerned. It may be that they give some sort of feeling of security to the people, and perhaps that is good in itself, but I personally would not have much confidence in them. This is evident from the continuance of violence in the Six Counties in the past seven years. There, no cars were allowed into towns and yet there were blow-ups in the middle. On big days in Dublin—of course there are big days outside Dublin too—I would not accept checkpoints at the bounds of the city as being of much security value.
Why not use the powers the Garda have already under other Acts, under the Emergency Powers Bill and elsewhere, without having to impose this subsection as permanent legislation? There have been laws which have fallen into disuse in a generation. Why not develop the situation we have instead of imposing other measures as permanent legislation? This seems to me to be superfluous and dangerous.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 6, to delete lines 14 to 16 and substitute the following:
"9.—Where in the course of exercising any powers under this Act or in the course of a search carried out under any other power, a member of the Garda".
This is intended to put beyond doubt that the provisions of the section apply only to the exercise of lawful powers. The words in brackets in the section "or otherwise" might be construed as including an unlawful search and it is extremely doubtful if the courts would so construe it or would permit any action to be taken on foot of a search that was unlawful. The words "or otherwise" are not specific enough and the amendment is designed to cure that. The section and the amendment refer to "powers" as distinct from searches. It is possible an article might be seized or obtained under, for example, section 7 (1) otherwise than in the course of a search.
Comment on this
During the course of the Second Reading this side expressed as strongly as possible our concern at the provisions of this section. Indeed our views have been strengthened with the publication of the views of the Incorporated Law Society which are similar to ours. They expressed concern at the portions of the Bill which would directly affect the independence of the legal profession. In my opinion, the proposed amendment of the Minister allows the provision still to be too wide. The amendment appears to suggest to the public that the subsection is to safeguard the independence of a solicitor or barrister and so to protect the rights of an accused person in relation to his legal advisers. This matter is of some significance when it is recalled, as reported in the newspapers, that in a recent case in the Special Criminal Court when the presiding judge directed that certain papers be returned to an accused person, that direction was obeyed reluctantly——
Comment on this
The reports I read indicated there was reluctance to return the papers. Even with the Minister's proposed new subsection, the section would appear to me to take away from the Judiciary the right to give such a direction. It is arguable that the subsection leaves it open to a person, not necessarily with any knowledge of the law or even of the facts of the offence with which an accused person was charged, to decide on his own initiative if the document was not made solely for the purpose of giving or communicating legal advice. All this could be precipitated on the basis of "the reasonable suspicion" of the unqualified searcher.
The Minister must be aware of a common situation when a solicitor has an interview with an accused and possibly takes a statement from him. A note of the interview with the client and his statement will often be forwarded to a barrister to get his advice. That having been obtained, the solicitor would then naturally wish to communicate those views to his client in custody awaiting trial. In the first instance, this bona fide confidential advice can be seized on the representation of a third party to the searcher who in turn can say his suspicions were genuine because he believed the representations of the third party were genuine.
It should be fairly clear that the wide wording of the earlier part of section 9 would allow this confidential advice to be used as evidence in any trial, including the forthcoming trial about which the accused and his lawyer have been in correspondence. If this subsection as presented now is passed, it means an accused person is faced with a new danger, and one which could effectively destroy the presumption of innocence every accused has and which we would all like to see him having in this jurisdiction.
The Minister and the Government must be aware of the very frequent cases where an accused will give an account to his legal advisers of his connection with the crime with which he has been charged in order to get legal advice on whether or not he should plead guilty, for example, when his trial comes for hearing. If such a statement is seized under section 9, clearly it can be used in evidence. The only protection against this is the suspicion of the searcher which, under the subsection he may have obtained from a third party, that the document was not solely intended for the purpose of giving or getting legal advice. Once the searcher has claimed such a suspicion, the document is liable to be seized and used in evidence. If the searcher maintains his view that, at the time he seized the document, his suspicion and only his suspicion was genuine, there seems to be no way in which such a document can be ruled out as evidence, even if it is a totally genuine correspondence between a member of the legal profession and his client.
I am fairly satisfied that this amendment will not meet the genuine worries which are shared by many with regard to the contents of this section. I am not at all happy that the distance the Minister has come in his amendment will satisfy his own colleagues in the legal profession who are members of the Incorporated Law Society.
Comment on this
The Minister's amendment goes part of the way but, in the absence of legal knowledge——
Comment on this
If I may interrupt the Deputy, I think we are discussing amendment No. 5a as well as amendment No. 5.
Comment on this
We are discussing amendments Nos. 5 and 5a together. We can have separate decisions if necessary.
Comment on this
The amendment seeks to remedy the principal objection we have to the section, that is, the seizing of legal documents in relation to the defence of the person involved. I do not like the word "retain" which indicates that a document would be in the possession of the prison officers, or the Garda, or the court officers, as the case may be, depending on where it was seized. If it is a question of whether a legal document should or should not be retained, this indicates to me that it has been in the possession of the person who seized it. A legal document could be misused by the people who seized it, even if it were in their possession for a very short time only. They may have time to have a photostat copy made, or they may have had time to get to the kernel of the defence of the person in custody.
How is the officer who seized the document in the first instance to find out whether it is a legal document if he does not read it? If he does read it, he can glean from it all he wants to know about the approach to the defence. The legal profession, of which the Minister is a member, would take great exception to that. The amendment actually concedes that, because it says he has the right to retain a document. That is the only thing which concerns me as to whether the amendment is actually a proper safeguard against the main objection to the section.
Comment on this
Our difficulty here is to give what Deputies opposite and the professional bodies would like, that is, absolute confidentiality in regard to documents during visits to prisons. Unfortunately, if that were to be given, there would be a conflict with security. There have been instances where the high degree of confidentiality, the privileged position afforded to legal advisers, has been abused. For the information of the House I might indicate that, only a matter of some days ago, a solicitor was fined £250 by the President of the High Court for unprofessional conduct which involved a breach of prison security. He was also prohibited from entering Portlaoise and Limerick jails.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say if that person is now liable to be brought before the courts in the ordinary way?
Comment on this
No, because there was doubt in the law at that time. One of the doubts has been cured by an earlier section. In any event, it is no answer to say a person can be brought before a court or a disciplinary body. We have to stop the abuse at the time or before it happens, because that is when the breach of security can take place, and that is when there could be a danger to the security of the institution. We are in the dilemma that absolute confidentiality and security are incompatible. There are no two ways about that. As far as I am concerned, absolute confidentiality has to give way in the interests of security.
Comment on this
Will the Minister take a question? Have his amendments drawn further comment from the Incorporated Law Society? Is the Minister aware of any views they may now hold on the section as it will be if amended?
Comment on this
The Deputy referred to the Incorporated Law Society's memorandum to me, but he did not refer to my reply in which I dealt in some detail with their criticism of section 9. I presume a further reply will be coming to me from them.
Comment on this
Have they studied the proposed amendments and sent the Minister any comments on them?
Comment on this
Not that I am aware of. What I said to the Incorporated Law Society, and I think it is relevant to say it again here, is that there have been abuses. I have indicated a particularly serious one which has now been punished. I am not suggesting there is any widescale number of abuses. The number is extremely small. The vast majority of legal practitioners discharge their professional functions honourably. On the other hand, when serious security issues are in question, I cannot ignore the fact that abuses have taken place and that provision for absolute confidentiality could permit abuses to happen in the future. The general right to search and seize articles from legal advisers unfortunately cannot be waived.
One would gather from the tone of the debate here that prison officers are avidly awaiting a chance to read a document and pass it on to the prosecution. I want to reject that sort of idea. This has not happened. Lawyers who have been in the habit of visiting prisons regularly and have been in contact with prison officers will be aware that they have been received with scrupulous decorum and that the privacy of their documents has not been abused. There is no intention of changing that practice. If there could be a formula which would provide a statutory guarantee with regard to confidentiality and, at the same time, recognise the realities of security, I would be glad to hear of it. Quite frankly, I am certain it is not possible to reconcile the two positions. The amendments I put down, particularly amendment No. 5a, are designed to go as far as I possibly can in that regard, but we have to retain the ultimate power to seize and retain a document in the interests of security.
Comment on this
The Minister is agreeing that the amendment does not prevent the seizure of a document?
Comment on this
That is assuming that a document that is seized and given back will be scrutinised for what I might say will be illicit purposes but the whole history of relationship between prison officers and visiting legal persons suggests that that will not happen. It is not part of the tradition. Confidentiality and respect for the privacy of legal documents has been a feature of prisons officers' relationship with the legal profession.
Comment on this
This is the section which has given rise to much concern by the Incorporated Law Society of Ireland and lawyers in general. The Minister's amendments, or anything he has said, will not allay their fears and suspicions. The section, even with the amendments, makes it impossible to operate properly the Judges' Rules which are there for the protection——
Comment on this
I repeat, makes it impossible to operate rules which are there for a long time for the protection of prisoners, detainees and persons in custody. The Minister says it is impossible to have absolute security and preserve absolutely the confidentiality between a solicitor and his client or a barrister and his client and I agree but the Minister would be well advised to err on the side of absolute confidentiality rather than to insist on this absolute security.
The members of the legal profession can and should be trusted as much as prison officers to preserve and protect the security of the State. I am not satisfied and neither are members of the Incorporated Law Society of Ireland that in the operation of this Bill abuses will not arise, inadvertently perhaps. I ask the Minister what will happen in the case of a prisoner who makes a confession which he proposes to hand to his legal adviser when he visits the prison. In the course of that confession the prisoner might admit to an offence but that confession might inadvertently and innocently, but not maliciously, be found by a prison officer or a guard or a member of the Defence Forces in the course of the detention or search of a person detained or in the course of a search of a visitor to a detained person. Would that not inevitably come improperly into the hands of the authorities? Will that not be admitted as evidence against the accused person? That is one of the many ways in which this is open to having innocent persons and persons in custody having evidence admitted improperly against them. That is why we are all concerned about this.
Comment on this
I understand the Minister's dilemma. The Minister has certainly gone part of the way to try to meet the situation and having heard what was said this morning, would the Minister bear in mind what we have said? Will the Minister try to get the views of the Incorporated Law Society of Ireland on his proposed amendments? I do not think we have had those views so far. Perhaps during the course of the debate in the Seanad the Minister might improve the situation, if he can, bearing in mind the security involved and professional etiquette.
Comment on this
I have invited the views of the society and indicated to them that I will certainly consider them.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5a:
In page 6, between lines 27 and 28 to insert the following subsection:
"(2) If it is represented or appears to a person proposing to seize or retain a document under this section that the document was, or may have been, made for the purpose of obtaining, giving or communicating legal advice from or by a barrister or solicitor, that person shall not seize or retain the document unless he suspects with reasonable cause that the document was not made, or is not intended, solely for any of the purposes aforesaid."
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 6, lines 36 and 37, to delete "in his possession" and substitute "in his possession without that permission".
This is purely a drafting change. It is to complete the sense of the provision and it does not add anything at all to the section.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 6, to delete lines 41 to 51 and substitute the following:
"(2) (a) A person who is in or in the precincts of a prison, Garda station, or courthouse and while there intends to visit or meet, or has visited or met, a person in lawful custody in that prison, station or courthouse shall not have in his possession any representation or note which is referred to in subsection (1) of this section without the permission specified in that subsection, and any person who has any such representation or note in his possession without that permission shall be guilty of an offence if he has been informed orally or by written notice that possession of any such representation or note without that permission is forbidden.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this subsection, if a person applies for the permission specified in subsection (1) of this section at the first available opportunity after arrival at the prison, Garda station or courthouse, he shall not be guilty of an offence under this subsection unless and until the permission is refused and he continues to retain possession of the representation or note."
This is to insert two new subsections. These amendments are all of a drafting nature. This one breaks up the existing subsection (2) into two paragraphs as set out in the amendment and introduces the words "meet" and "met" in the new subsection (2) (a). These appear to be necessary to cover a situation for what occurs and that could not really be categorised as a visit in the sense of a person coming into the prison for the purpose of visiting and meeting somebody. It introduces the words "without that permission" in subsection (2) (a) because they are necessary to complete the sense and it makes clearer the let out for the person who declares that he has the representation or note in his possession on arrival.
Comment on this
Would it apply to persons only visiting persons in custody or to persons in custody?
Comment on this
It would be clear that a person in the precincts of a prison and while there intends to visit or meet a person in custody is covered. That would be the condition before a search could be carried out.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 6, between lines 51 and 52 to insert the following subsection:
"(3) Nothing in this section shall make it unlawful for a person to have in his possession in a courthouse any representation or note which is referred to in subsection (1) of this section and is intended for production, use or reference in any proceedings that are taking place, are about to take place or have taken place in that courthouse."
This is to insert a new subsection. The subsection is to cover the case where the representation or note is bona fide in the possession of a prisoner or his lawyer in a courthouse where it is intended to be used in the course of proceedings before the court. Again, it is to ensure that no injustice will take place and to give a let out to people who are innocent.
Comment on this
This is a technical change to declare the offences of kidnapping and false imprisonment, and section 10 of the Criminal Law Jurisdiction Act offences—which can be broadly termed as hi-jacking offences —to be felonies. I know that there is general feeling in law reform circles that the distinction between felonies and misdemeanours should be abolished, and it may be asked why declare the two offences felonies when it is proposed to abolish that category? In the abolition of the category the incidents that attach to a felony will have to be preserved in law and until such time as the distinction is removed, and felonies and misdemeanours are the same, with all the same powers and general legal consequences, it is important that the serious crimes of kidnapping and false imprisonment should be categorised as felonies, so that they can attract the various consequences that attach to a felony, the principal one being the right of arrest for a citizen. Subsection (2) provides that a person guilty of kidnapping or of false imprisonment shall be liable to imprisonment for life. This is to put into statutory form what is already a matter of common law, but it is to make the penalty life imprisonment because they are such serious offences.
Comment on this
This is a section to provide more severe sanctions for what is commonly called the bomb hoaxer. I am sure Deputies will agree that that is an offence which needs to be dealt with severely because of the amount of economic harm that bomb hoaxers can do. I feel there will be a general welcome for this provision.
Comment on this
We welcome very much the provisions of this section— as we did on Second Stage—which as the Minister said is designed to deal with bomb hoaxers. We said and we still believe that the section is long overdue, and certainly the whole House, and the country, will agree that inconvenience is being caused to the general public, the amount of very valuable Garda Síochána time that can be and is being wasted by a person who wrongly indicates that there is a bomb in any place, is sufficiently serious so that the present punishment of a fine of £10 or a month's imprisonment is insufficient. I suggested during the course of the Second Stage that it might be strengthened up by inserting in clause (a) of section 12 the word "recklessly" so that the offence would be if a person either knowingly or recklessly made such a false report or statement. This might be dealt with perhaps on Report Stage. If the Minister has not considered it by now he might consider it on Report Stage or in the Seanad.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9:
In page 7, between lines 29 and 30 to insert the following subsection:
"(2) Subsection (1) of this section shall not apply in any case where the sentence being served or to be passed is a sentence of penal servitude for life or imprisonment for life."
I will take the section and the amendment together because when I speak on the section I can make the point of the amendment. Subsection (1) provides that any sentence imposed on a person for an offence committed in the course of serving a sentence will be consecutive on the sentence he is serving, subject to the qualification that two sentences imposed by the District Court cannot exceed 12 months. This is to take account of the constitutional position in relation to sentences in that court as provided under the Criminal Justice Act, 1951. It was suggested in a newspaper comment on the section that it did not include life sentences and the amendment which I am now moving is to deal with that anomalous position.
Where a person is already serving a life sentence and is convicted of an offence, or where he is serving an ordinary sentence and during that sentence he is convicted of an offence for which he must be sentenced to life, it would be anomalous if not ridiculous to have a provision that in either of the cases mentioned the new sentence has to be expressed to operate from the termination of the sentence being served, so the new subsection has been introduced to provide that subsection (1) shall not be applied in any case where the sentence being served or to be passed is a sentence of penal servitude for life or imprisonment for life.
Comment on this
I do not follow the Minister too clearly. Am I right in assuming that section 13 is necessary to clear up some doubt in the existing law?
Comment on this
There is no doubt. In practice what often happened was that the court did not specify that a sentence imposed for an offence committed during the course of an existing sentence was to be consecutive and without such specific direction by the court it was concurrent and what often happened was that the sentence did not mean a thing.
Comment on this
The power of the section is restricted to dealing with the case of a person who commits an offence while in prison serving a sentence, therefore it is a very narrow, limited operation. To some extent it restricts the freedom of the court to exercise discretion. The Minister in the section is making it mandatory, if the court finds a person guilty of an offence while serving a term of imprisonment, that the term of imprisonment to be imposed as a result of the conviction must be consecutive to the term that the person is actually serving, or if he is serving one sentence and is due to serve another after that, that it follow the later sentence.
I am not clear on the need for it or the legal desirability of it. I can see that the Minister does not want to have the court, in the case of a person who has been found guilty of committing an offence while in prison, impose a sentence which runs concurrently with the existing sentence and is therefore meaningless. One can see that that is a reasonable proposition in normal circumstances. There is no point in the court imposing a prison sentence for an offence committed, if it will simply run concurrent with the sentence which the convicted person is already serving. However, is it not possible to visualise, even if some technical offence is committed and the offender is found guilty, the judge taking all the circumstances into account and feeling that the case could properly be met by a concurrent sentence? Such a sentence is a common feature of the normal law.
Comment on this
If a judge felt that a concurrent sentence, or a very short extension of the existing sentence would be adequate, there is a device whereby the court can, in fact, achieve that by imposing the appropriate sentence and then suspending it for whatever period is appropriate.
Comment on this
I can see the need for it and I am sure the courts will operate it satisfactorily and find a formula to enable them to meet peculiar circumstances in particular situations. The amendment is just plain common sense. If a man is already serving a life sentence there is no point in adding on another sentence to the end of it. The only way in which such a sentence could be made effective would be by giving the man another life. We accept the amendment.
Comment on this
This is purely a drafting section. The 1972 Act extends the definition of documents contained in the 1939 Act to include such things as photographs, discs, tapes, films. Sections 13 and 14 of the 1939 Act require printers of documents to record the names and addresses of the persons for whom they have printed the documents and their own names and addresses. Unless the old definitions were retained for that section an extended definition would not mean anything. It would be ridiculous. It is purely a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
This section proposes to give certain powers to the Defence Forces to arrest and search in certain circumstances. These new powers have been the subject of criticism and that criticism implies that an armed police force is being constituted. It also implies that there will be soldiers on our streets acting as policemen in a way that has not happened up to now. It is suggested that this is opening the door to further possible powers to the military. I should explain the reason why the Government decided to make this change and the nature of the change because if both are understood the apprehensions expressed will be seen to be misplaced and unjustified. At the moment we are in a state of emergency, a state when there have been many acts of gangsterism and terrorism throughout the country.
Comment on this
Actually and technically. We know that in an adjoining jurisdiction there is an armed conflict taking place which has over-spilled into this jurisdiction. It is important that the State should be in a position to protect itself and, protecting itself, means protecting its citizens because the State is the sum total of its citizens and those citizens want to be protected. Accordingly the Government have a duty as the people temporarily in charge of the State to utilise all the forces available to the State and designed for the protection of the State.
Our Defence Forces are designed for the protection of our State. We have this force of some 14,000 persons uniformed and disciplined. It is important to remember that these are uniformed, disciplined people who have sworn to serve the State. It is not an army of mercenaries recruited for a particular operation. It is a permanent defence force organised on strict military lines, disciplined and highly trained, a highly responsible force which from the day it was set up in difficult times has given loyal service——
Comment on this
Would the Minister take a question for clarification? When he talks about the Army, in the Bill it is described as "Defence Forces". Do those forces include members of An Forsa Cosanta Aitiúil and of the Naval Service?
Comment on this
It does include. The Defence Forces are all the people recruited under the Defence Forces Act. All the members of the Defence Forces have taken an oath of loyalty and traditionally—tradition is important in the personality of any such body—they have served the State loyally. The Government consequently felt that to have such a force available, uniformed and disciplined, and not to utilise it in situations where it could be properly more fully utilised would be negligent on the part of the Government. We have a very long Border and Deputies familiar with the topography of the area understand precisely the difficulties of patrolling the area with its hundreds of crossings, its twisty roads and varying terrain. It is most difficult to patrol from a security point of view. The primary law enforcement agency are the Garda Síochána. They have always been an unarmed police force right from the date they came into being until now and I assure the House there is no question of the policy of maintaining them as an unarmed force not being maintained.
They are our primary law enforcement agency and will continue to be so. On them falls the primary burden of providing security and enforcing the law in this difficult area I have described, an area involving the Border, many hundreds of miles long, with hundreds of crossing points on it, embracing a very difficult, isolated and, in many instances, lonely terrain, lonely in the sense of being situated quite a distance from Garda stations or urban areas. Naturally, in regard to the limitations on the size of our force very often they are stretched, in terms of man-power in performing their duties, in such an area notwithstanding the fact that the force, for some time past, has been at its highest level since the inception of the State—with a further 500 men being recruited—and notwithstanding the fact that there are more men stationed on the Border than have ever been stationed there before. There have been instances in which the absence of a garda at a particular time has inhibited the carrying out of a security operation to the fullest and maximum extent. The Government felt that the military presence in that area—and they are stationed there in considerable numbers—should be utilised to supplement the Garda operation and that they should be given certain powers to act in strictly limited circumstances.
Comment on this
The constraints on the circumstances—and I will answer Deputy Brennan's question now— under which the military can act are set out in section 15. The military can act only to use the powers conferred on them under section 15 whenever they have been required to do so by a superintendent of the Garda Síochána. He makes a request to the members of the Defence Forces for their assistance, for the period specified in the request.
Comment on this
Therefore, it would be a matter for the police on the ground to specify the period of the request. It is not envisaged that it would be for a year, that, if you like, these would be requests made to deal with an ad hoc situation, not a request to deal with a situation on a continuing basis. That is the way in which the powers will be exercised. If it were to be otherwise there would have been no point in mentioning a period at all in the section.
Therefore, the first constraint is that the military powers are not independent military ones, in the sense that the Garda have independent powers under the Acts setting them up. They are subordinate powers, subordinate to the Garda Síochána and, because they are subordinate, will remain, and have to remain, the principal law enforcement agency of the State. They will have the overall control of the enforcement of the laws of the State. They will decide, in their judgment, if a situation is such that they require military assistance, using the powers proposed to be conferred by section 15. Of course, there can be situations where the Garda can call up the Army in aid of the civil power, as heretofore in the normal way, and not by way of a requisition under section 15. In such a situation the Army will come to the assistance of the Garda, as has been happening all along, but their role will be passive in a legal sense, that is, they will not have any powers of search or arrest.
I do not envisage any significant difference in the modus operandi along the Border consequent on the passage of section 15. I have no doubt that, in the vast majority of cases, the military role will continue to be passive in practical terms though, if they are on the scene in pursuance of a requisition, their presence would not be passive legally and they would be entitled, if the need arose, to exercise the powers here. I do not envisage any difference in the scene, so to speak.
The first constraint is that the new powers to the military are under the control of the Garda. The only person who can requisition the military, issue the request which gives these powers, will be a member of the Garda Síochána. By that provision the primacy of the Garda as the law enforcement agency of the State is being specifically and very definitely preserved. Therefore, to suggest that a second police force is being created is, I think, altogether an exaggeration and misrepresentation of what the section contains. There is one police force only, the Garda Síochána. They can call in the Army to assist them in certain instances and, in some of those instances, they can make a specific requisition for Army assistance which will enable the Army, in response to that request, to exercise some of the powers the police possess. To suggest that, in that limited way, a second, armed police force is being created is, I submit, a gross exaggeration.
The second constraint is that the powers which are being conferred are limited ones. They are already limited in the way in which they come into being. They can only come into being —I feel I must keep repeating this—in response to a requisition from the police. That is the only way they can come into being. That simple mechanism preserves the primacy of the police. The second constraint, then, is that when they do come into being in that limited fashion, they are exercisable, not over the whole broad range of our law, but in regard only to matters set out in section 8. That is a further argument against the exaggeration that we are creating a second police force. There can be no question of creating a second police force because it is of the nature of a police force that they have a function within the entire spectrum of the legal system. But the powers given to the Defence Forces to arrest and search, in the circumstances set out in section 15, relate only to the offences described in section 8 which. I think, I have accurately called in broad terms "terrorist offences".
That is the situation. I might say that I envisage the powers not to be used extravagantly; that they will be used only when there is a need for them. We are conscious that they are new powers. We are conscious that new powers such as these—which have given rise to genuine but, I feel, totally misplaced apprehensions —should be used sparingly. It will be alleged that the police do not want this extension. As far as I am concerned, that argument is not valid. But, even assuming it to be valid——
Comment on this
It is not accurate either. Even assuming it to be valid, there will be members of the police, the same as there are members of the general public, who do want to see these powers being given, who do not understand fully what is involved and who do not appreciate their very limited nature. It would be extraordinary if there were not some members of the police with such views. It should be a matter for gratification that it is a view that might be held because it will ensure that the giving of the powers—and it will be for the police to give the powers to the Army—will be done very sparingly and in circumstances in which the security situation requires them; when there is a need on the ground. Therefore, I do not think there is any need for worry on the part of the public.
I do not foresee a situation in which, after the passage of this Bill, we will be held up by soldiers whenever we drive around the country. The situation will continue to be exactly the same. The Army will be called out, in aid of the civil power, as they have been heretofore. There will be police presence at road blocks. If the Garda think that in a situation which they see developing the Army should have the new powers, a requisition to that effect will be made. The Army will then come out and will be in a position at road blocks in the same way as they are at present. Certainly, it would be the intention always to have a garda present. But, as I have indicated, because of the difficult nature of this terrain, the extended nature of the Border and our comparative scarcity of man-power resources, this might not always be possible. We have to decide whether it is better to have a military patrol without a guard and detect a terrorist or have the military patrol standing idly by and the terrorist drive off cocking his nose at them.
I do not think any citizen would want to see that situation but I regret to say that situations akin to that have taken place. At the moment a soldier has only the common law power of arrest when he sees a felony being committed or in similar restricted circumstances. This is to extend and make them effective when the Garda Síochána consider they want them on the scene with these powers.
I am satisfied that this limited power, exercised in this limited way, is a proper response and utilisation by the Government of the resources at their disposal in a time of emergency.
Comment on this
We are opposing section 15 of the Bill. The purpose of this section is to give power to the Defence Forces to arrest and search in certain circumstances. Since the debate on the resolution declaring a state of emergency all members of the Government including the leader of the Government have used the word "Army" rather than "Defence Forces". We now find that this has been a misuse of the Army in that members of the FCA will have the same power under the section as will members of the Naval Forces and the Army. The words "Defence Forces" are used here.
We are very gravely concerned and worried about the implications of section 15. As I said before, we are equally concerned about the motivation of the Government in bringing in the section in this Bill. In his defence of the Bill, the Minister did his best to say that the section is in response to the declaration of the state of emergency. This is not so, it is wrong. Everyone knows that this Bill has been ready since last March. It is not an emergency Bill; it will be with us permanently. The Minister said that this section was necessary because of the so-called state of emergency but if that is so, why was this section not in the Emergency Powers Bill? If it were in that Bill, it would have a limited life span. It would automatically lapse when the emergency legislation lapsed or when the Houses of the Oireachtas declared that the emergency was over. This is permanent legislation and it is intended that this Bill will remain on our Statute Book as part of the substantive criminal law of the State.
That is one of the reasons we are opposing this section. If the Government insist on having this section in the Bill, I want to give the House notice that on Report Stage we will have some amendments. We will strive to ensure that this section will remain in operation for 12 months only unless it is renewed by resolution of the Oireachtas for a further period of 12 months.
The present situation is that the Garda Síochána can call on the Army for assistance. Where this is likely to occur, particularly in Border areas, if an incident occurs the garda on the spot can call on a contingent of the Army to give the assistance the Garda officer considers necessary and which he requires. The basic functions of the Garda Síochána and the Army are totally and absolutely different. Because they are different functions, the Army and the Garda have different traditions and training and different roles to play in the administration of justice and in the keeping of the peace. The Garda Síochána are justifiably proud that they are an unarmed police force. Everyone knows they do not wish to become an armed police force. Indeed, a great degree of the public acceptability of every member of the Garda Síochána has been that during the years the public have come to accept them as an unarmed police force. I have no doubt that this general acceptance by the public of the Garda Síochána as an unarmed police force has much to do with the success of the police in their dealings with the public.
During the course of the debate here this morning the deputy Leader of Fianna Fáil, Deputy Brennan, expressed a view which many share, namely, that the people generally have co-operated with the Garda Síochána at all times even when they knew the police did not have powers. Because the Garda Síochána were so acceptable, when ordinary members of the public were stopped and asked if their cars could be examined and checked they responded magnificently.
By definition the Army was founded under a completely different concept and it is to be, and should be, used for different purposes. I have pointed out before that the Army is the ultimate line of defence which any country must have to protect its geographical and national integrity. Any member of any army is a person who, in the normal course of events, is issued with a gun. Members of our Army are issued with modern high velocity and high calibre weapons. The function and purpose of having a gun is that if the occasion requires it can be used. If it is used the person on whom it is used is liable to be injured, disabled or killed.
The first matter which should give this House and all Members reason for thought, particularly the Minister charged with looking after the laws of the country and the protection of the citizens, is that practically every member of the Garda Síochána is completely and utterly opposed to the powers being given to the Army under this section. These views must be given the most serious consideration by all Members of this House, particularly the Government.
The Minister and the Government have said that a state of emergency exists. They told us that it was necessary for the Houses of the Oireachtas to pass a resolution to that effect, even though a senior member of the Government, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, has described the emergency as just a technicality. Even if the state of emergency did exist and if the Minister genuinely believes it, his first consideration should be to the general public, that they will respond to the declaration of the state of emergency and that they will give the security forces, particularly the Garda Síochána, far more co-operation and help on a voluntary and on a totally free basis. The public will totally accept the Garda Síochána who must perform their own duties but it is not certain that they will give the same degree of acceptance to the Army when they have to perform functions properly the preserve of the Garda Síochána.
It is not enough to say that any law-abiding citizen will give automatically to the Army the same degree of support that he is prepared to give to the Garda. One can envisage situations in which innocent people driving home at night would resent being stopped, questioned and searched at the point of an automatic rifle and possibly by very young members of the Army. These people would not be likely to have any objection to being stopped by a member of the Garda and questioned about themselves, their passengers and their cars. Members of the Army performing these tasks would not be likely to have any training in this type of contact with the public. In saying this I am not complaining in any way about the Army. I do not think that in the circumstances envisaged in this section any member of the Army would go out with an intention of creating ill will among the public. However, I consider the Minister to be imposing an improper and unfair burden on them by asking them to carry out functions which are not really theirs.
The Minister for Justice and the Minister for Defence may well tell us that the Army are prepared to assume these functions, that they are prepared to accept any criticism which their acts may bring about. I accept totally that the Army are prepared to assume any functions imposed on them by the Houses of the Oireachtas but this is not the point. The point is that at a time when the Minister says it is necessary to declare a state of public emergency, he is using the last line of defence within the country—the Army and the FCA—and that as a result of what we fear may happen there may result the denting and blunting of the overall effectiveness of the Army by reason of the general public not accepting armed soldiers operating in an area which rightly is the preserve of the Garda.
We are very strongly of the view that this section, if it is to be brought in at all, should have been included in the Emergency Powers Bill but if the Government insist that it is to remain in this Bill, we shall propose during the Report Stage that a time limit be imposed on the life of the section. We shall propose further at that stage that if the section comes into force only the Minister as the one answerable to this Parliament will have the power to operate the section.
The Minister has taken some trouble to assure us that there will not be an armed police force in the country but this assurance cannot be accepted if we are to have the Army and the FCA working without the supervision of the Garda in carrying out duties which properly are the duties of the Garda.
This party appreciate fully that there are difficulties in relation to security operations along the Border. We appreciate that there is a great strain on the number of personnel available in this regard and we are aware fully of the responsibilities of the security forces in that area. However, we do not think that the way to tackle the problem is to put into permanent legislation a section of this nature. It is a provision which is wrong in principle and which will do far more harm than good.
During the course of the debate in the past couple of weeks we had the odd contribution from members of the Fine Gael and Labour Parties and from these contributions one got the impression that under section 15 the Army can work only in conjunction with the Garda. This is not so because having been called out by the Garda, the Army will be left to do a job of work. A few minutes ago I understood the Minister to say that in the ordinary course of events we will not see members of the Army performing Garda duties. In this regard I might say that as an ordinary citizen driving from my home to this city, a journey of 165 miles, I see more members of the Army than I see members of the Garda.
This section is not here because of the so-called state of emergency. It was mooted by the Government, not between the time of the deaths of the British Ambassador and the civil servant and now but many months ago. It has been included in this Bill, a Bill which could have been taken in June last or left until the House was due to resume in October. Therefore, there is no point in the Government endeavouring to tell us that the section is put forward for the purpose of dealing with the emergency situation which they say exists. If it related to the emergency which the Labour and Fine Gael Parties—sorry, the Fine Gael Party—say exists——
Comment on this
——it should have been in the Emergency Powers Bill. We are opposing the section and will vote against it. In addition, we shall table amendments for Report Stage on the lines I have indicated.
Comment on this
We do not like this section. I agree with Deputy Collins that at least one would have expected it to have been included in the Emergency Powers Bill but we know that it was drafted some time before there was any thought of declaring a state of emergency. This is rather ominous and gives credence to the opinion that it is merely a device to supplant the Garda and to avoid Garda recruitment.
Whether these are the motives that led to the insertion of this section, it is objectionable to the people. Bringing armed members of the Defence Forces on to the roads and giving them police duties creates a war atmosphere which is abhorrent to our people. They are being given police powers which have been given to the Garda under section 8 to hold people up, to search people, cars, boats, aeroplanes and to use "reasonable force" if necessary. They can arrest people and do everything the Garda are permitted to do under section 8.
God forbid there should be a situation when it would be necessary to give these powers to the Defence Forces. In present circumstances the Government should at least consider deferring the operation of this section until it became necessary. Part of the emergency legislation package will expire on a certain date and the greatest distance any reasonable Opposition would be prepared to go is to provide that the Minister would operate this section by order of the Oireachtas. Importing it into perpermanent legislation is wrong. It could be understandable that the Government would want to give these powers to the Garda, however the justification for that is exaggerated.
At the moment we find that at police checks the Garda are supported by members of the Army and although they give the fearful appearance of war, carrying arms, the Garda presence minimises it somewhat. But the appearance of members of the Army on their own carrying firearms at the ready creates an atmosphere of war which we have tried to keep away. In this, we are going a long way too fast to do something that is not necessary.
When the Minister was explaining this provision he revealed that the numerical strength of the Garda on occasions might not be sufficient to deal with a given situation. I suggest that that is the real cause for this section. One garda accompanied by a number of members of the Defence Forces can carry out a number of duties and this would enable the strength of the Garda to meet any imaginable situation. As some of us painfully know, there is a vast difference between being approached by an unarmed policeman and a number of members of the Defence Forces with firearms at the ready. Some of us who visit the North have become accustomed to this climate of war and trouble. It is a horrible atmosphere which we should try to avoid for as long as we can.
As I have said, because this legislation is not part of the emergency package, this part of it should be brought in only by way of order debated by the Oireachtas, and it should be only of a limited duration. The Army can be brought in at the request of a Garda officer not below the rank of chief superintendent but the period of the operation is not specified. It could be open-ended. It could be for a week, a month, a year. The Army during this period can if necessary use what is termed "reasonable force".
What an armed member of the Defence Forces would regard as reasonable force as compared with a garda is open to interpretation. It is left entirely to the persons carrying out these duties. I do not cast aspersions on members of the Defence Forces, but will they be trained for these duties or are we to send out the FCA in the role of B Specials to carry out duties for which they have not been trained? What will the set-up be if the Minister does not accept an amendment and this becomes law?
A situation might arise when it would be necessary to call in the Army but that situation does not exist now and the Minister should be prepared to accept an amendment to the effect that this will not be done until a draft order has been debated by the Oireachtas. That is as far as any reasonable Opposition would be prepared to go in regard to such a dangerous and objectionable section. I do not think either the Defence Forces or the Garda want this. I suggest that this is merely a device to obviate the necessity to recruit more gardaí. This is a device to have police work done cheaply by members of the Defence Forces. It is a dangerous precedent and one which should not be embarked on unless it can be shown to be absolutely necessary.
I should like the Minister to show the same consideration as he did for amendments suggested by the Opposition yesterday for the reasonable amendments we have in mind for Report Stage, and to put the section in abeyance until such time, if it ever arrives and we hope it will not, when such powers might be needed.
Comment on this
First of all I should like to debunk and to take exception to Deputy Brennan's suggestion that this section is intended to obviate the necessity for Garda recruitment. This is a simple matter of statistics and facts. One senior Garda officer might feel the right number of police should be 8,000. Another senior Garda officer might have an opinion that the number should be greater. Whether you pick 8,000, or 12,000, or 13,000, or 14,000, the fact still remains that, on an occasion such as the murders at Glencairn of the British Ambassador and Miss Cooke, the necessary manpower would not be available.
We have 14,700 Army personnel available around the country. States far larger than this State, with far lesser problems, have the tradition that, when there is a problem that cannot be dealt with by the police force, the army are called out. In America they have State troopers. In Germany they have a squad which deals with riots in cities. In various countries much larger than ours this is a fact of life. Whatever is a reasonable assessment of the proper number of Garda spread out all over the country doing ordinary police duties, that number is not sufficient when it comes to the point of having to deal with an act of subversion such as the murders I have just mentioned.
In that sort of situation if it is our ordinary democratic decision to call out the Army to supplement the Garda, we must call them out in a very measured way. Deputy Brennan said it was intimidating when, as he passes through Northern Ireland, army forces come and interrogate him in his car with loaded weapons, perhaps, in close proximity to him. Of course that is so. It is important to say that the powers being given here have no relation at all to the powers given to the British Army in Northern Ireland. They are merely powers of search and arrest. The Army are called out by the Garda, as has been pointed out by the Minister for Justice when, in their wisdom, they decide that is necessary.
On the occasion of the murders at Glencairn it would have been necessary to have checkpoints at a huge number of points on the roads. Because Dublin city is right beside that location, and because the countryside to the west and south is available for escape, a huge number of people would be required. At present for the Army personnel to have any powers at all, they must be accompanied by at least one garda. That means their efficacy is completely restricted. Happily we have brought them up to 14,700 from 8,900 when this Government took office. Happily many of them are now well out of recruit training and are seasoned men just like young gardaí who are three years out of Templemore. We can put these people out, by direction of the Garda, to do checkpoint duties on all these roads.
The question the Opposition must pose to themselves is: are they whole-heartedly against subversives or are they not? Are they prepared to go the whole way with all the agencies of the State and fight subversion with everything we have within the limits of proper democracy, or are we to fight it with one hand tied behind our backs?
Comment on this
Within the bounds of democracy. I have pointed out that much larger nations than ours with a normal police force—about which I could not agree more; the Opposition can argue as to whether it is too small or too large——
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy. Much larger nations find it necessary to call out the army to provide services when there is an extraordinary spate of crime. The emergency which exists at present is there because—and this is the mildest way it could be put—of the extraordinary spate of subversive crimes.
The Government want to ensure that the relevant Garda superintendent can ask for services from the Army when the number of police he needs to do the work he wants done is so restricted that he cannot put one policeman with every four or five Army personnel, as was described by Deputy Brennan. That is where he laid the egg which I am now going to hatch out. We intend that there shall be a plan whereby the Army can go to specified crossroads and specified places and do certain duties, all agreed before through plans and operations of the Army, and all agreed before and organised before with the Garda, so that these villains cannot escape and so that there is a much greater chance of apprehending them and bringing them to justice. Do the Opposition want that to be the situation or do they not? They have to make up their minds about that.
I want to comment on a rather odd statement made by Deputy Collins which he did not attempt to substantiate. He said this was all given birth to many months ago. What does he mean by that? I know of no instance at Government meetings or anywhere else when this proposal was mooted many months ago. I know of no instance when it was mooted publicly many months ago. I know of no instance when it was mooted in this Parliament many months ago.
I want to make something else quite clear. Throughout these debates during the past fortnight, the Opposition have been trying to suggest that the murders at Glencairn were an isolated incident and that, as a result of that isolated incident, the Government suddenly over-reacted. If they go to the Taoiseach's speech introducing this parcel of legislation, they will find he said the murders at Glencairn were the culmination of a spate of terrible crimes which have gone on over the years. They were not even a flash point. They proved the necessity for emergency legislation. I do not know what Deputy Collins means by "many months ago", or whether he is trying to imply some sort of illicit dealing or underhand thinking by the Government. I should like him to tell me what he means in that regard.
I was a bit shocked to hear Deputy Collins saying citizens would not give the same co-operation to our Army as to our Garda. Since I became Minister for Defence, and before that, I have been quite clear in my mind that the great majority of citizens have a great degree of affection and respect for the Irish Army. If there has been any odd, queer thinking in relation to the Irish Army, it has come not from this side of the House but from the Opposition. Perhaps there are historical reasons for that. I do not know. When I meet people all over the country they are absolutely delighted when an Army person does well in some athletic contest. They are pleased to see the Army on manoeuvres, like to meet Army personnel and ask me about the Army. In my view there is a great respect for the Army among 90 per cent of our people.
I have no doubt that on the very special occasion when a crime is committed which needs a much greater degree of manpower and the Army are standing on their own at a checkpoint and ask a decent citizen where he is going and for permission to search the boot of his car they will get the same reaction a garda would get if he asked the same question. They are our Army and they typify our proper patriotism—there are many degrees of patriotism here at present—and I have no doubt they will get full co-operation from our people. In relation to what has been said about training of the Army for this work I should like to state that the Army have gone out with gardaí on thousands of occasions in the past year. They provided bomb disposal services and one NCO and five soldiers acted with one garda at checkpoints on 7,500 occasions last year.
We have a different system from the British. We instruct in detail at least once a month. An officer is instructed by the legislative division and he instructs ordinary NCO's at least once a month but on every occasion that a batch of men leave barracks with the gardaí they get a short two to three minute instruction on their duties, their powers and their responsibilities. I will not go into the details of that system because it would not be correct to do so but we believe it is a better system than the British one. Under the British system a yellow card is put into a fellow's tunic with his instructions and he is meant to know everything on it. Therefore, to some extent one throws away the responsibility of the senior officers and one's political responsibilities in as much as one gives the soldier a yellow card. Our system is more detailed, is better and produces better results. The experience over the last number of years on instances that have occurred proves that.
There is no question of the Army being used as bully boys taking over police duties or anything like that. When the superintendent of the day in the situation as it is needs certain services he can ask for them. They would have been planned before. Would we not be a silly State if we had 14,700 men all fit and well, men who joined the Defence Forces with proper patriotic ideas, all well trained and indoctrinated with proper patriotic ideas, if we did not use them against people who have murdered 1,600 people and injured 18,000 in the last seven years?
Comment on this
One wonders whether one should get back to the provisions of the section or whether one should comment on the statements made by the Minister for Defence. I should like to put a few questions to the Minister for Defence and he can deal with them subsequently. That Minister said that normally what is done when the Army are called out is that they get a two to three minute instruction and that they find this more effective.
Comment on this
They get that instruction on every occasion but they get a much more detailed instruction at least once a month.
Comment on this
That system which the Minister announced relates to the existing power of the Army when they are called out in support of a civil power?
Comment on this
The Minister must accept then that that is a different position entirely to the Army being called out or requested by the chief superintendent and acting on their own. I should like to know from the Ministers for Defence and Justice what regulations will be made, what guarantees and restrictions will be applied not just for the convenience of the Army, not just so that it will be done better than it would be by the British Army but for the protection of the public in the discharge of this new function of the Army. The Minister talked in a bland and general way about other more powerful states doing this. Of course, they do but he will find that many other more powerful states have a role for the army that we do not have. Equally, they have a role for their police that we do not have. The American or German examples were not the best examples for him to quote because the police force in America is an armed one and ours is not. There is a definite difference between calling out an army in support of an armed police force and calling out an army in substitution for an unarmed police force. The Minister should take account of these facts when he throws such casual examples across the trail.
The Minister for Defence should stop talking about the Army. It has been clearly acknowledged this morning that we are talking about the Defence Forces and that includes the FCA but the Minister for Defence made no reference to the voluntary Defence Forces at all. We do not have to make imputations on any body, but we have to note the fact that this legislation will enable a chief superintendent to call any element or section of the Defence Forces, in this case it could be the FCA, to operate the powers given by virtue of sections 8 and 15. There is no point in the Minister saying he is thinking of the Army, that brave body of 15,000 men which he has referred to so consistently. I do not know how many are in the FCA or what training they have. I do not know what instructions they get or how disciplined they may be as a professional body of men, and the public do not know either but the Government are asking us to transfer these powers to them operating independently of any police authority.
I mention those points to show that the Government are not clear in what they want in this regard as was proved in relation to other aspects of this legislation, happily now amended. If they are not clear, it is our obligation to ensure that their minds are clear before this legislation passes through this House. I hope we can persuade them to drop the section or at least to persuade them to see the extent they are extending the role of the Army and Defence Forces generally and how they are introducing them into an area of ordinary police work that was never within the anticipation of those who established the Defence Forces. Certainly, it was not contemplated up to this time. We are not talking about emergency provisions; we are talking about the permanent criminal law.
I should like to take up the Minister for Justice on a number of things he said and ask for his response. He said that the functions now being transferred to the Army would be exercisable only in regard to subversive activities as indicated under section 8. "Subversive activities" is a phrase we hear more and more to justify the Government's stance on many aspects of this legislation. Some of the offences in section 8 cannot be defined as subversive activities exclusively. It is possible that subversives engage in those activities but the Minister will know that there are many aspects of the ordinary criminal law with no relationship to subversive activities. First of all, we have an offence under the Offences Against the State Act, 1939, or an offence which is for the time being a scheduled offence for the purposes of Part V of that Act. That does relate to subversive activities. There is an offence under the Criminal Law Jurisdiction Act, 1976. There is murder, manslaughter, or an offence under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861. There are countless offences under those sections that have nothing whatsoever to do with subversive activities. Does the Minister accept that?
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept that the vast majority of charges brought in our courts in the history of this State, even for murder, manslaughter or offences under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act have nothing to do with subversive activities?
Comment on this
That is a different question but in the present context for which we are legislating many of these offences are terrorist offences. We are not legislating for 30 years ago.
Comment on this
The Minister thinks in terms of the present context. We are talking in terms of what we are doing here permanently to our law. What happens for the next 30 years is related to what we are doing here now. If the pattern of ordinary crime over the next 30 years is to be similar to the pattern of crime over the last 30 years, I say without doubt that ordinary criminal offences that have no relation to subversive activities will entitle the Army to act under the powers being given to them under this measure. The Minister cannot deny that. There are many people serving sentences at the moment for manslaughter in prisons which have nothing to do with subversion. One of the regular charges where a person who has been driving a motor car dangerously and as a result of which somebody has been killed is a charge of manslaughter.
Comment on this
Not numerous cases. The Deputy may have defended some but the general charge is dangerous driving causing death and it is only in exceptional cases that manslaughter is the charge.
Comment on this
I will accept the Minister's qualification that the regular charge is dangerous driving causing death, but the charge of manslaughter is still being brought. People have been charged with murder and have been convicted of manslaughter who have had nothing to do with subversive activities and the Minister tells us that this section is concerned only with subversive activities. Offences under section 18 of the Offences Against The Person Act, 1861 are the offences generally referred to as wounding with intent or malicious wounding. There is no doubt that there are a large number of people serving sentences in Mountjoy or elsewhere on conviction under this Act. That is now being included within the scope of the powers being given to the Defence Forces. The Government will have to clear their minds much more than they have done when they ask us to accept legislation of this sort.
The Minister for Justice this morning referred to the powers which the Garda would be giving the Army under this section. The police do not give any powers to the Army. They have no right to give powers to the Army. They create a position where the Army discharge powers that we give to the Army. The Garda do not confer any powers on the Army and both Ministers here will acknowledge that. We as the people who are giving the powers cannot hide behind what the police, the Army or the Defence Forces may do. We have to look to our responsibility and see how we can control and regulate the use of the powers we are giving to them. Did the Government consider that under this legislation they were extending powers into the area of ordinary criminal law that was never anticipated to the Army? While the Minister for Justice may say that we are not concerned with the last 30 years, I feel that we are, as those years indicate a pattern which will probably give us a fair indication of what the next 30 years will be like apart from subversive activities.
There are areas in our cities for which the Minister for Justice has a very special obligation, where violent crimes are an unfortunate pattern and are on the increase. The Minister will have to recognise that he will need to get at the social causes that are breeding grounds for these crimes of violence. The Minister for Justice may say that hopefully the next 30 years will not be like the last 30 years but to judge from the present pattern my view is that they will be worse unless the Government take some positive steps to eradicate the causes. These crimes of violence, malicious wounding, manslaughter, or anything else are coming within the ambit of powers given to the Army. The Minister asks the rhetorical question: would we not be foolish Government—I think that was the word he used—with these 14,000 fine young men if we did not use them? With that kind of mentality on the part of the Minister for Defence, is there any reason why we could not say we would be a foolish Government not to use them to the fullest extent under these powers in the ordinary area of criminal activity?
Comment on this
We would not want to rely too literally on what the Minister for Defence says because he is the one who told us we would be wasting our time discussing this at all; not one iota would be changed. Has he, I wonder, any comment to make on that now?
Comment on this
If the Deputy reads the section, he will see there is no material change in the wide world.
Comment on this
Did the Minister's colleagues not take him into their confidence? We will have to forgive him. We do not take what the Minister for Defence says too seriously.
Comment on this
The Minister for Defence has fooled everybody. Nothing has changed. The Minister for Defence is right. Maybe Deputy Blaney was right. I think what the Minister for Defence actually said was that to have such a force and not utilise it would be negligent on the part of the Government.
Comment on this
Apparently the suggestion is now that these young men in the Permanent Defence Forces are not being fully availed of and the normal unarmed police force is under pressure and so we should call in the Army simply because the Army are there and do not have enough to do; they are not at full stretch like the Garda.
We come back then to the point we made at the beginning of this package. If you are short of manpower, the way to cure that situation is by recruiting more gardaí and giving them the special training normally given to a civilian police force, with full awareness of the limitations on their powers and of the tradition, which is something you cannot give by way of specific instruction in two or three minutes, to quote the Minister for Defence built up over the years in regard to the way in which that force will exercise its powers. That is why we say a civilian police force is the only force which can properly be given the powers now being transferred to the Army under this section. Remember, these powers were not even possessed by the civilian police force up to this. We have accepted the need for giving these powers in certain circumstances, with qualifications.
The Minister for Justice made an extraordinary statement this morning. He said: "I do not envisage any difference in the scene by virtue of the introduction of the Army". Could anything be further from reality? The position now will be that the Army can appear independently and exercise powers which up to the passing of this Bill the police never had. It is very important to recognise the powers that are being given to the Army under section 8. They will be able to search vehicles and the people in those vehicles if they have reason for believing they have committed an offence or are likely to commit an offence. Up to this moment our unarmed police force did not have these powers. Now we are giving these powers to the Army and the Army will operate independently once they have been requested by the police.
The Minister for Justice is apparently so blind that he can see no difference as between the police operating under existing powers and the Army coming out on our roads with completely new powers. It should not demand any great imagination to see the very considerable difference. Those of us who find ourselves in the vicinity where an offence has been committed will henceforth find ourselves stopped by the Army independently of the Garda Síochána. This is something the Government should consider. I pass by Portlaoise going to and returning from Dublin. Offences, like escaping from prison, have been committed from time to time in the vicinity and henceforth I and other citizens travelling along the road will find ourselves stopped by the Army. This will create very serious hazards. Their training is not such as to qualify them to act as a civilian police force. They are an armed force and the less we see of them on our roads in the course of our daily activities the better we like it and the better it is for the welfare of the State. Under existing laws we have accepted the presence of the Army in support of the civilian police force in certain instances but we do not want to see these young men being called out simply because they are available and because our police force is apparently inadequate in both personnel and equipment.
The Minister for Defence said—I do not see the logic in it—that after the murders of the British Ambassador and Miss Cooke it did not matter how many gardaí you had you still would not have enough to man road blocks and so on. If we have so many men available in our Defence Forces, I can see no reason why we should not increase the number in our civilian police force to enable them to discharge their particular functions.
Comment on this
I had been referring to one phrase of the Minister in the course of his introduction to this section this morning. I see he has gone again and there is no point in repeating it in his absence. This section is a major change of the existing law. It constitutes a major change in the functions of the police and of the Army. One does not have to say anything critical of the Army or of the police to note that these changes have to be introduced with great caution, after considerable thought, and must be regulated very strictly. For the first time we are introducing a situation in which the Army, admittedly after request, and that is the only qualification there is, from a chief superintendent of the Garda Síochána, can operate independently of the Garda not alone in relation to subversive activities— on which the Minister seems to rely— but also in relation to numerous offences which may have nothing whatsoever to do with subversion, whether manslaughter, wounding with intent—unfortunately, the kind of offences with which we have all become too familiar in more recent times than we were, say, ten years ago. We are also all too familiar with them in our courts. I would venture to suggest that before this era of subversion got under way approximately 40 per cent of those serving sentences for any appreciable term in our prisons were people who were detained under the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861, those serving longterm imprisonment for manslaughter or murder.
This Bill proposes to give these powers to the Army, powers which, up to the passage of this Bill, even the Garda did not have. The Garda never had powers to search vehicles or people in vehicles whenever they had reason to suspect, with reasonable cause, an offence had been committed. If the Minister will look at section 8 (2) it says:
(2) Where a member of the Garda Síochána who with reasonable cause suspects that an offence to which this section applies has been, is being or is about to be committed requires a person to stop a vehicle with a view to ascertaining whether——
These are powers being given to the Army under section 15 when this Bill comes into operation. It might well happen that the ordinary motorist going his way along the roads can be stopped by an Army patrol because of an offence that comes within the ambit of section 8. It might well have been an offence of having been in contact with a firearm, but it could also have been an ordinary offence of manslaughter or malicious wounding under the 1861 Act. A person who was in no way associated with that offence, who happened simply to be in a vehicle somewhere adjacent to the scene, can be stopped and put through all of these rigours, not by the Garda but by the armed Defence Forces and that includes, repeat, An Fórsa Cosanta Aitiúil. What training have they to undertake such an exercise?
At the risk of repetition, it is not good enough for the Minister to say: "Oh, it will not happen that way", or: "We will ensure it does not; does everybody not know that is not going to happen anyway"? All we can rely on is what the Bill says, and it refers to the Defence Forces, the Offences against the Person Act, 1861, manslaughter and murder. Therefore, this power can be brought into operation under those sections.
We have justifiable cause for concern particularly in view of the statements made by both Ministers that what one must do is maximise the personnel resources available. That is a fair summary of what they have said. Therefore, if one has these resources available in the Army or police, one must maximise them, use them to the best advantage, utilise them fully, irrespective of whether the surplus happens to be in the Army or vice versa. That is bad law. It is bad practice. It is just too bad that we have to pay the price of the Government's economic problems and mismanagement by introducing the Army into a police role instead of recruiting sufficient people into the police to do the job for which they have been trained and qualified. We are not here concerned with maximising the personnel available to us for the purposes of the Minister for Finance or of anybody else. We are concerned with employing the police in an unarmed police role, the Army in an army role, in support of that role. If one wants to increase recruitment to the Army or police, by all means do so. In doing so the Government certainly would have the support of this side of the House. It has been put on record here by our spokesman. In fact, that is what we called for by way of amendment to the emergency resolution. Therefore, we are committed to supporting such a move.
In relation to the Army role in all of this, everybody knows at present that the main concern of the ordinary citizen, doing his ordinary job, living his normal life is normal security; not in the sense of national security, personal security. That is the main concern of many of our people living in the suburbs, towns and elsewhere.
Going back to the Larceny Act, 1916, section 23 brings the role of the Defence Forces into focus again. Basically that is the section which creates the offence of robbery. We are all aware that there is too much robbery taking place, particularly in our suburbs, about which people living alone are very concerned. They want to see police presence to guard against an increase in crime. There is no better way of doing it, as some neighbours living close to Ministers living in Dublin will testify, than by police presence. Recently when the Minister for Foreign Affairs moved house from, was it, Goatstown to Belgrave Square, the neighbours in Goatstown were very sorry to see him go because it meant the police went with him. Those in Belgrave Square were very happy to welcome him because it meant the police came with him. That in itself proves the case that police presence is what is wanted to guard against such things, not Army presence.
If one is talking against robbery, we do not want to see the Army, armed or otherwise, even having the power under this statute which the Minister sets out in section 8. We do not want to see them play that role. It is not enough for the Minister to say: "Oh, they will not. Deputy O'Kennedy is being unreasonable and taking debating points." When the Minister introduces it in legislation, then I am entitled to criticise it, not merely by way of debating point but by way of pointing out that now we, who relied so much on an unarmed police force and who think we need more of them with better equipment, must register our protest against the right of the Army, an armed force, to be called in in that situation simply—if I might quote the Minister for Defence—so that the Government would not seem to be silly not making use of this magnificent squad of young men. Did he say indoctrinated?
Comment on this
I said: "We would be a silly State." The Deputy keeps using the word "Government". I said: "We would be a silly State not to use the 14,700 young men."
Comment on this
I did not refer to indoctrination in regard to the Army. I referred to the indoctrination of young people to join the IRA.
Comment on this
No, Sir, I think the record will show that it was the Army to which the Minister was referring at the time. We can have a group of indoctrinated young men carrying out tasks which it is not their function to do. One may assume that 97 per cent of the fears I have expressed will not be realised but even if only 1 per cent is realised that is something this party are not prepared to concede. Even if none of the fears is realised, the fact that the Government are so oblivious as to introduce this function for the Army is cause for concern.
If we are to see more of the security forces on the streets protecting the normal civil liberties and the security of our people, we want to see that role as much as possible given to the police force that has been created to deal with such matters. As much as possible we want to see the Army confined to the role they are well equipped to do, namely, securing the safety of the State in a different sense rather than interfering with the functions of the police. The Minister on reflection should give way to our opposition to this section.
Comment on this
Those of us who have some little experience in this House and in the Army do not like to see legislation of this kind being written into a Criminal Justice Bill. As an ex-member of the Defence Forces, I admit there is a case to be made for calling in the Army in certain circumstances. Members will recall the time when Mr. Moran was Minister for Justice when he introduced into this House a Criminal Justice Bill that was kicked out by the then Opposition. They were such liberals at that time they did not want law and order; they kicked out the Bill and the then Minister had to withdraw it. If we had that law it would have been a considerable help in dealing with disorder and with the petty crimes that have taken place in the meantime.
It is regrettable that we must have this legislation but given the circumstances in which it is introduced one can admit that there is room for it. What Fianna Fáil object to most strongly is the manner in which it will be administered. The main point at issue is that at the behest of a superintendent the Army can be called in. Long ago the phrase "he called in the cavalry" was frequently used and perhaps this is what will happen in the future.
It is open to question whether a superintendent should have this power. We believe it should rest with the Minister responsible, the Minister for Defence, in conjunction with the Minister for Justice. He could come to this House with a proposal or if he wanted legislation by order he could make the order and place it before the Dáil. We object to the shortcuts being taken in this matter. We accept that it is the obligation of the Government to preserve law and order but they also have an obligation to preserve human rights. Almost invariably the two obligations are in conflict in the times in which we live. To enshrine in our permanent legislation the calling in of the Army at the behest of a member of the Garda Síochána is going too far even in our circumstances. The power should be left with the Minister for Defence in conjunction with the Minster for Justice. There is nothing wrong in that. It will not weaken the Bill or take from the powers that are there.
I submit that what the Government are proposing may prove to be a dangerous precedent. If the Minister for Justice were in Opposition today he would press strongly that what we are doing is short-circuiting the ordinary administrative justice and this can be a dangerous precedent even in an emergency. This is why we are asking the Minister to look at the matter again, not to put the House in the situation that we pass legislation that is later found to be bad law.
We have been blamed for preserving emergency legislation during the years but those of us who have lived with it and who were active in politics or in the Defence Forces realised that there was need for such legislation. That being so, we have come to accept that extreme laws of this kind are necessary in our circumstances but there must be a point at which we stop. If the Minister looks back he will see that during the years the law was balanced to a degree, that it could be said of the then Governments that they tempered the wind to the shorn lamb. There is no such element of care in this legislation. A superintendent at any place on the Border might call in the Army but he might do so in error. The Army bear arms and arms are dangerous if used in the wrong way. This could get us into serious difficulties later. As administrators it is our duty to do our best to frame laws that can be used in such a way as to bring balance into a situation. At the moment it is completely unbalanced. There is the ordinary criminal legislation in existence. As Deputy O'Kennedy said, the position has become untenable in the last few years. Regrettably house robberies have become an everyday occurrence. These crimes may be regarded as being petty and I am not blaming the Minister entirely for the situation that allows them to be perpetrated. But we must recognise that the situation exists. We must, then, go outside the bounds of ordinary law to appeal to parents to watch carefully the company which their teenage children are keeping thereby endeavouring on their part to bring about an end to the petty larcenies and robberies and to the muggings. We know that the Garda have been so busy dealing with other matters as to have to neglect the petty criminal side. This Bill is not merely to deal with emergencies. It is to become part of our permanent law. In these circumstances section 15 should have been framed within the context of the Emergency Powers Bill.
The Minister should reconsider this section. He should reconsider who should be responsible for calling on the Army for help in the first instance and, secondly, who should be responsible for the administrative side of their functions once they have been called in. I say this because a conflict could arise in this area. As I have said here often in the past in relation to various matters, Departments of State tend to be too isolated from each other, to be too introspective, rather than to be endeavouring to work together. I shall not harp back on that point. Suffice it to say that it would be much better if we had an inter-mixing whereby there would be special units in each Department to deal with general matters such as that which we are talking of here as well as matters associated with trade and commerce and so on.
It is unwise to over-work emergency powers. The function of government is, on the one hand, to protect the State and, on the other, to protect human rights. Although at all times in history the human rights aspect was overlooked to some extent it is something which is as important as the concept of the protection of the State. We should endeavour to accomplish a balance between the two areas and to achieve an acceptable degree of security in both areas.
There are many other elements of this section on which one could elaborate. We have sufficient experience of Northern affairs to be wise enough to frame legislation which would have the effect of advancing our prospects in the areas of peace and security. I am not finding fault with the general aim of the legislation but I am concerned with the methods being suggested to achieve those aims. This is a matter which should concern not only those of us here but also every member of the community. I appeal again to the Minister to reconsider the method suggested in the section for achieving the aims desired.
Comment on this
I wish to add my voice to what has been said by Deputy Collins. In the first instance I would ask whether this whole package has been introduced on foot of what, according to the Minister for Foreign Affairs, is a mere technicality. Have these powers been asked for by the Garda or are they being imposed on the Army by the Government? Perhaps the change in the role of the Defence Forces is one of the most serious steps that can be taken especially when the change is to be on a permanent basis. In this regard the statements from the Minister for Defence and the Minister for Justice are alarming in the extreme. We are told that the FCA are now part of the Defence Forces and, consequently can be called out to undertake the duties in question. The Minister for Defence has told us that only a two-to three-minute briefing will be given to personnel called on in these circumstances. Is this considered an adequate period of briefing for people unaccustomed totally to this type of work?
On Second Reading the Minister for Justice said it was only right and proper that a large uniformed disciplined force should be utilised to a greater extent by extending their powers to enable them actively to assist the Garda. He went on to say that members of the Defence Forces are to be given powers exactly similar to those of the Garda. However, this is not what is proposed. In addition to the powers vested in the Garda, the military will be in possession of firearms and will obey the orders of their superior officers. Therefore, there is a major difference in the powers of the military as set out in this section compared with the powers of the Garda.
Obviously, the Minister for Defence has not much grasp of the situation because he spoke of the problems of the Defence Forces, their activities and the nature of those activities in instances in which they will be called out. He spoke of a yellow card system but said there was no need for the pinning of yellow cards to the coats of the personnel involved. I agree but there is the over-riding factor that once the military are called out and posted their deployment can mean many men operating individually in a variety of places so that they would have to take it on themselves to make decisions since, in effect, they would no longer be under the command of a superior officer who, while they were dispersed on this type of duty, might be at a distance.
The House, and through it the public, must be made aware by the Minister of the type of duties that will be imposed on the military, the conditions to be observed in the firing of ball ammunition and so on. The public should be made aware of the circumstances in which the military can fire and they must be told that nothing but ball ammunition will be fired. The Minister must clearly outline the resulting danger from the additional powers given to the Army. Up to now we had an unarmed police force and there was a balance between security and defence, the Army playing a low profile role.
In the Bill a member of the Defence Forces may use reasonable force, and so on. Is that the sum total of what the Army may do? Does "reasonable force" mean the force of arms? Is there something hidden in the Bill in this respect? Paragraph (b) of subsection (3) states:
A member of the Defence Forces may use reasonable force in order to compel a person to comply with a requirement to stop a vehicle, and such force may include the placing of a barrier or other device in the path of vehicles.
We should be told what that means. If the military can use other force it should be clearly spelled out so that the public would be fully aware of the extent of the force that can be used under this Bill, which brings a new dimension to the role of the Defence Forces.
It was interesting to hear the Minister saying that the FCA would be part of the Defence Forces in this context. Will they be adequately trained for this work? Will there be special courses of training not alone for the FCA but for the regular Army who, according to the Minister, get only a two-to-three minute briefing by superior officers before an operation? Although the FCA are highly efficient, as are the regular Army, are they trained for this special work? We want the Minister to elaborate on this as well as to tell us the duration of the time of their service on such duties. Can we have an assurance that there will be some type of regularisation so that both Garda and Army will be on the same wavelength? We have seen the confusion that exists in other parts of our country and the resultant dangers. Paragraph (b) of subsection (4) states:
For the purpose of arresting a person under this subsection, a member of the Defence Forces shall have the same power to enter and search any building or part of a building or any vehicle, vessel, aircraft or hovercraft or any other place as a member of the Garda Síochána would have in like circumstances.
In regard to the powers conferred here, will there be further regulations governing the actions of the Army? We must be given a global picture of the implications of this, of the extent of Army intervention. We should be told that their role in this will be no more and no less than that of the Garda. Unfortunately, as we know, it will have to be more because the Army will be armed and they can use the force of arms. The public must be made aware of the extent to which they can use force.
The force the Army can use is contained in subsection (3). There is no need for me to read it into the record because it is already in the Bill. It does not include such things as breaking open a prison, or the burning and destruction of buildings, or such other matters as are covered by calling the Army out in aid of the civil power. Troops may be called out under this Bill who cannot enforce law and order in the same way as troops called out in aid of the civil power with a garda. The limitations may deprive the Garda and the State of the type of support this House agrees with, that is, troops being called out in aid of the civil power for the restoration of public peace in the manner duly described which has been in operation here for quite a considerable time.
Perhaps the Minister will give us some clarification on the points I have raised so that we can have a more detailed look at the entire situation. Under section 5 a person may be held in custody for up to six hours.