We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Criminal Law Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 153–309 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Criminal Law Bill, 1976
Enacted

No. 33 of 1976 ›

Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am sorry to interrupt Deputy Dowling but we are dealing with section 15 and I am anxious that he should confine his remarks to that section and please avoid repetition.

Comment on this

A person arrested under subsection (5) of section 15 may be detained for a period of up to six hours. That is too long a period for the military to detain a person. In the North the military have power to detain a person for four hours. If six hours are added to the 48 hours and the additional five days, there is a further extension of the period during which a person can be detained in custody.

The Minister has made most alarming statements on the question of troops being unsuitable, the FCA, quite apart from the permanent Defence Forces who have not got the necessary training. Will they be trained at Templemore? How will they be trained? Will there be a coordination of effort? Will the Minister indicate the conditions which will be written into the Defence Forces Regulations so that Members of the House and the public will know the exact circumstances in which the Defence Forces will operate?

Comment on this

As most Deputies now know, we on this side of the House had two major objections to this Bill as presented in its original form. The first was our objection to section 3 and the sweeping and indiscriminate terms in which it was originally framed. Fortunately, the dangers we saw inherent in section 3 as originally drafted and put before us have now been obviated. We have already expressed our satisfaction at the change which has taken place in that regard, but we are still left with this last objectionable proposal. This was always our second major objection to the Criminal Law Bill.

We now come to what I think is our final confrontation with the Minister and the Government on section 15. If we could persuade the Government at this stage that this section should be dropped, and that they should bring the same change of mind to bear on this proposal as they did on section 3, we on this side of the House would be quite prepared to let the Bill go forward onto the statute book with a reasonably easy mind. As I have already said, there are aspects of the Bill which we do not particularly like, which we find distasteful and which, in normal circumstances, we would not tolerate for a moment. Now that section 3 has been amended and the dangers we saw inherent in it dissipated, we feel the Minister and the Government should come this final step with the Opposition and have a serious fundamental look at exactly what is being proposed here in section 15.

If they would meet us on this section, we could say to the people and to the nation that this Criminal Law Bill has the almost unanimous support of the Dáil. That would be a very considerable weapon for the Minister and the Government to have at their disposal in combating lawlessness and violence. I want to make that suggestion to the Minister now that he has moved a certain distance from his original position on this legislation. There is everything to be said from this point of view for going this final step with us and avoiding this final confrontation which, unfortunately, we see looming up on section 15.

Speakers on this side of the House have argued cogently and, to my mind, very decisively against the provisions of section 15. I have nothing very much to add to what has been said except to reiterate in outline our approach. First of all, there is the inexplicable aspect that the Government and the Minister are making this Bill part of our permanent law. That has not yet been adequately explained. In fact, no real attempt has been made to explain why this unusual and dangerous proposal has not been put on all fours with the emergency powers legislation, and why this power should not be expressed at the very least to be of limited duration, to be for a period of 12 months initially, renewable only with the consent of the Oireachtas expressed in some shape or form.

That is, perhaps, one of the most intimidating aspects of this proposal. It is to become part of our permanent law. There is no suggestion that it will be done away with when the emergency under which the Government say we are suffering at the moment passes. It will enter on our statute book as a permanent and immutable part of our criminal law. I do not think the Government and the Minister have made any attempt to say why this proposal should not be expressed to be of limited duration. I am reinforced in urging that argument by the enormity of what this proposal means to our community. It is a fundamental change in our society and in our way of life. It represents a very deep seated alteration in the type of community we had hoped to establish for ourselves in this part of Ireland. It is a fundamental far-reaching change and as has been pointed out it in effect vitiates the claim we could always make that we had here the sort of society where we could have an unarmed police force. We will no longer be able to claim that and we will no longer be able to say we can claim that in the short term, that when this present emergency passes away we will go back to the normal situation. We are, in effect seeking to legislate for all time without any limitation in time in what is proposed.

This is a very serious far-reaching change in the type of community in which we are going to live. The present situation which prevails in most Western democracies is the right one: there is an historical traditional separation of function and forces in the security area. On the one hand, there are the police who are responsible for the maintenance of law and order, for dealing with the public and combating crime. On the other hand, there is a different type of organisation, a different type of force, a military force, an armed force, which normally in parliamentary democracies is kept in reserve and has a very specific, limited constitutional function. That force is there to protect the State in time of war and protect the community from its foreign enemies and, in the internal situation, to be the line of last resort, to be the force that is only had recourse to when everything else has totally failed.

That separate distinct function has been traditionally reserved in the free democratic societies of western Europe for a long time. It has been built up over centuries and has been found to work satisfactorily. It is something I believe should not be interfered with except in the most dire, difficult and dangerous circumstances. I do not believe that we have those sort of circumstances here at present. On Radio Éireann the Minister said that in his view the Garda Síochána had the situation under control here. If the Minister wants to get away from that statement, we will accept his reversing of it. If it was something he said without having full advertence to what it really meant in the course of an interview that is one situation but he has not at any time during this debate gone back on that statement, that the Garda in this part of the country have the situation under control. If they have the situation under control, why is this fundamentally drastic step being taken?

I want the Minister to deal with that matter because it represents, as things stand, a very real anomaly, a real gap in the logic of this argument. I am not going to dwell for one moment on the idiotic statement of the Minister for Foreign Affairs because if one keeps talking as much and for as long as that man does one is bound to say something idiotic from time to time. I am not going to dwell for a moment on the silly statement that Minister made in Killarney, that this state of emergency was only a technicality. Fortunately, the Minister for Justice, in reply to a question put by Deputy Gerry Collins, swept that nonsense aside and indicated that this emergency in his view is not a technical emergency; it is a real emergency. At least the Minister for Justice has been consistent in that regard. We do not agree with what he says; we do not agree that there is a real war-like type of emergency prevailing here. To follow his own statement up he has said that in his view the Garda have the situation under control.

All that causes me to query specifically why this power is thought to be necessary with all the implications it has for us as a community. I mentioned the impression in some people's minds of a creeping militarism taking over here. Some people react very positively when they see the Minister for Defence posturing in war-like situations, when they see the Taoiseach appearing in armoured cars in other military-like surroundings. People have this sub-conscious feeling that there is in this Government this militaristic tendency, whether the Government are conscious of it or not. I am afraid this measure is going to accentuate and exacerbate that feeling in the public mind. If people get that feeling, it will be very dangerous and as far as the Minister for Justice is concerned the introduction of this measure will be counter-productive. As the Minister has stated, and as we all agree, if he is to succeed in combating lawlessness and illegal activities, then he must have public support in a physical and moral way. If people get the impression that there is some sort of military tendency in this Government and a wish to impose some sort of military regime on us, that would be very detrimental from the Minister's own point of view.

I genuinely believe that the Minister for Defence has not done any good in some of the contributions he has made. He interprets his role as Minister for Defence completely incorrectly and is inclined to do some crude old-fashioned sabre rattling. As Minister for Defence, his job is to be a civilian administrator of our Defence Forces. He should eschew all these military trappings. I make that criticism of the Minister for Defence in all good faith and I trust he will accept it as being made in good faith. I believe that the arguments against the Government proceeding with this proposal in total are overwhelming. As far as we are concerned on this side of the House if these powers were to be introduced on an expiry basis, if they were to be introduced and expressed as being of limited duration just as the other emergency powers are, it would go a long way to meeting our objections to them. We are also very worried about the way in which these police powers are going to be handed over to military personnel. It seems to us that once the chief superintendent requests the assistance of the military after that the military are on their own.

Once that request is made and acceded to they have, in effect, police powers. If there was some limitation on the time that that request remains operative, it would go some way to assuage our fears in that regard. But then there are two very intimidating aspects of the proposal. First of all, the law will be permanent. This provision in regard to the Defence Forces will be there for all time and, secondly, once an officer of the Defence Forces accedes to a request from a Garda superintendent, there is no limit to the exercise by him of all the powers normally given to the police—search, arrest and so on. I suggest that it would be acting in a very sensible and responsible way if the Minister either dropped this section altogether or limited it to a very considerable extent along the lines we have been suggesting.

Deputy Dowling has opened up for us a very terrifying vista. It seems that in this part of the country we would be in the same sort of situation in which, unfortunately, the people in the North have been for so long, with the Army in the streets using their weapons and having the powers of search and arrest. As time goes on we in this House will be involved in this situation. Questions will be asked about the actions of the military under this section. Allegations of all sorts will be made and Deputies will ask questions about the behaviour of our Army in certain circumstances. Can the Minister not see that we will have a very unhappy and undesirable chapter in our relations as a community with our Defence Forces? We will be brought into an entirely new situation in so far as relations with the general public, public representatives, and everybody else is concerned. Can the Minister satisfy himself that it is absolutely necessary and essential at this stage?

Nobody will be satisfied with the Minister saying that he thinks it will be helpful or desirable. This is such a serious fundamental step that the Minister must satisfy us that it is essential in the public interests and for the security of the State. We do not believe this and, therefore, unless the Minister can come forward with some specific proposal we have no option on this side of the House but to reject the section outright as it stands and to suggest that with all the new powers that the Garda have been given they should be well able to cope with the situation. This is the last crunch between us and the Government and if the Minister could be persuaded at this late stage that the sensible and reasonable approach which he took to section 3 should be extended to this section, we could wrap up this Bill and send it off to the Seanad with the almost total approval of the Dáil. That would be something of considerable assistance to the Minister and to the security forces in trying to continue their struggle against crime and lawlessness in this part of the country.

Comment on this

The Opposition has constantly over the last hour said things as if they were true, on the basis that if you say something often and convincingly enough people will believe you. Nothing has changed about the situation. Members of the Opposition have wanted to know why the Garda cannot be increased by 1,000 or 2,000 men. When we have the sort of crime that we have to combat, crimes such as bombings in provincial towns or in Dublin—38 people died in the bombing of Talbot Street, Nassau Street and Monaghan —a cordon must be set up involving thousands of men. If the police force was doubled and taking into account the police duties they would have and were spread across the whole Twenty-six Counties, you could not produce within hours the cordon that would be necessary in order to make these people believe that if they do any bombing again they will be caught. The only reserve of men we have to do this is the Army.

We have had a series of small niggling points as to what terrible things might happen. Deputy Dowling started by criticising the fact that before any group of soldiers goes out in aid of the civil power a few minutes' instruction is given to bring them up to date on the constant instruction they have been having. Last year there were 12,000 Border patrols of the Army, and 7,000 military parties were provided to give assistance at 11,500 checkpoints and in those joint Garda-Army operations a close harmonious situation has developed and a great friendship has been forged between the men and the officers of both forces. The Opposition will do more harm in our fight against subversion if they do anything to upset that harmonious relationship. We have the officers to instruct the NCOs and the men of the Army. Almost four out of five of the senior officers in the Irish Army have had service overseas in Cyprus and the Middle East in an exclusively peace keeping capacity. These men shed the highest of lustre on our reputation as a State and we are regarded by most united nations people as the best force that were there. The best officers that served with the United Nations serve with us and they have the duty in this horrible time since 1969 of instructing the NCOs and men in peace keeping duties. They have done this duty well. The fact that somebody criticises me for saying that they will have a few minutes' instruction before going out on any job is nothing but prevarication. The question of the degree of force and the presumption by Deputy Dowling that Defence Forces Regulations will have to be changed——

Comment on this

Would the Minister be worried if he had a fully qualified surgeon about to operate on him who was only given two minutes' instruction before the operation?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order.

Comment on this

After constant and detailed instruction and after briefings that go on during the training and after the training of recruits, a short briefing is added before a man goes out, even if there is a bomb down the street. The short briefing is the thing that is picked out as being the only thing that happens, whereas it is nothing more than a debating point worthy of a secondary school.

Comment on this

Every operation is different.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order, Deputy Dowling had a good hearing. The Minister without interruption, please.

Comment on this

The full instruction is there and the officers to instruct the men are there and have instructed the men constantly. Deputy Dowling for the second time during this series of debates presumed that Defence Forces Regulations would have to be changed. The first thing I want to say about these regulations is that they are regulations for the instruction of Defence Forces personnel under the Defence Act, 1954. They are founded on law. The Attorney General's Office, the military authorities and the Department have produced these regulations for the guidance of those concerned. Once this Bill is enacted there may be need for a change in phraseology, or there may not, in one or more Defence Forces regulations, particularly in regard to CS 1. The position legally is that, whatever changes are necessary, regulations as far as force and firing are concerned will remain totally unchanged. The position will be exactly as it is now. With regard to a person who meets an armed patrol, the only difference will be power to search and arrest, followed by a handing over to the Garda.

Comment on this

A new Defence Forces regulation will have to be made.

Comment on this

The Deputy presumes a new regulation will have to be made.

Comment on this

I say positively it will have to be made.

Comment on this

I do not accept the Deputy's contention that a new Defence Forces regulation will have to be made.

Comment on this

Under what regulation will they act? It cannot be CS 1.

Comment on this

There may be a change of phraseology in CS 1 or an addition to it but that change or addition will make no difference whatever to the present situation in relation to the use of force or the firing of ammunition.

Comment on this

That is bunkum. CS 1 refers to the restoration of public peace. Troops are called out to aid the civil power and, under this, the troops will not be called out on that basis.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Dowling must cease interrupting.

Comment on this

The Deputy is entitled to express his opinion. I am telling him what the position is and will be. The existing law will pertain. In regard to holding persons for six hours, the implication by the Opposition is that every person held will be detained for six hours. Nothing could be further from the truth. They will be handed over as quickly as possible.

Comment on this

To whom?

Comment on this

To the Garda Síochána. If there is a murder committed and an area is cordoned off, and the Army happen to be part of that cordon and believe in their wisdom they should hold a suspect, the Garda will not be more than a mile or two away, if even that, and the Deputy knows that well. This will not be up on the top of Carrigtuohill. The Garda will be there. Six hours will be the absolute maximum. Every suspect will have to be released after six hours, if not handed over as quickly as possible to the Garda.

Where will the Garda be? They will be intermingling with the Army. The Garda will have their own check-points and they will be close to the Army at all times. That will be the position. It may not suit Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are disorderly and will have to cease.

Comment on this

Deputy Blaney obviously does not like what I am saying.

Comment on this

I do not because the Minister is talking the greatest rubbish.

Comment on this

If I were coming through Dundalk and I was asked by a member of the Army to open the boot of my car I would do so. If he asked me to accompany him to the Army barracks and stay there, I would do so, because I remember that two people were killed and many injured in Dundalk some months ago and that demands from me that I shall not be so "uppity" as to refuse to co-operate with either the Defence Force or the Garda. Perhaps Opposition Deputies do not like what I am saying. I would put it to the Opposition that there is at the moment a great probability that these murderers will perpetrate further crimes and, because of the size of the police force, escape the consequences of those crimes. If we did not utilise the Army, with all the safeguards written in, we would be trying to fight these people with one hand tied behind our backs. We have to use all the resources of the State. This is the last resource. If people can get into Dublin and kill people and go out to Glencairn and kill the British Ambassador, a man under the strictist security with anything up to ten or 12 people on him, and not be brought to justice so far, to use Deputy Haughey's words, is this not the last resource? In my opinion it is and the State must bring in whatever resources are available to ensure such people are brought to justice.

I shall not refer to what Deputy Haughey said about my posturing and the Taoiseach travelling in an armoured personnel carrier. So long as I am Minister and the Army ask me out I shall leave my desk and go out. If a photographer takes a photograph of me talking to an Army officer, that is all right. I do not mind. If he does not take a photograph, I do not mind either. But Deputy Haughey went further and said we would have the same situation here as far as the military were concerned as that which exists in Northern Ireland. That is absolutely untrue. The military in the North have quite extraordinary police powers. They can do most things on their own, things that are not included in this Bill at all. If utilising the Defence Forces acts as a deterrent, and I believe it will, because the chances of being apprehended will be multiplied, then it is the duty of the State to utilise the Army and all the talk by the Opposition about small arms and so on just does not matter. What matters is that if there is another Glencairn not only will there be the maximum number of gardaí around Dublin to try to get these fellows before they get away out there will also be the maximum number of Army personnel.

Comment on this

The basis of this case is that the Opposition are not prepared to support this section because we believe it introduces the Army into a police role. The Minister for Defence says that he does not care what the Opposition say. We do not care what the Minister for Defence says if we believe this section will do what we think it will do. The Minister for Defence said our members keep on saying things as if they were true. Let me say to the Minister for Defence that we simply say things because we have concluded from a reading of the section that what we are saying is true. It may not be but we have got to speak to the belief we have.

We do feel that the role being given to the Defence Forces under this section can lead to their increasingly widespread use as a police force. It may not do so but we feel this can happen. This is one of the reasons we are opposed to it. In the last three quarters of an hour the House has heard quite a few former members of the Defence Forces speak against the use of the Army. On the other hand, earlier on, we heard the Minister for Defence ask the question: are the Opposition whole-hearted in fighting subversives? That is the kind of question that can make mischief in this House. Obviously, the Minister for Defence either would like the Opposition to be on the side of the subversives or he is asking the question so as to imply that, perhaps, Fianna Fáil are on the side of the subversives. It is no harm to remind the Minister for Defence that, at a stage when some of his closest colleagues were opposing security measures in this House a few years ago, the Army were playing a major role assisting the Garda outside this House in protecting it. There should not be any suggestion of a doubt about the attitude of our party on the question of subversion. The Opposition are entitled to disagree with a proposal without having their motives questioned.

We maintain that there can be only one security authority and that is the Garda. We believe that under this section the Army can assume an independent role. If that is so, we are not prepared to support it. We are in total agreement with the two Ministers opposite who said that in serious situation the State should use all the forces available to it. We believe that the use of the Army to aid the Garda in situations of short term emergency is one thing but to make the Army a permanent unit—as is done in this section— as part of a police force is quite another. It is that aspect we are quite firm in opposing.

The Defence Forces cover quite a wide field—the Army and, as members on this side of the House have said, the FCA. Quite obviously, also whatever naval forces and air services we possess are involved. It must be made clear to us that where the Army operate in their role of assisting the Garda there will be a Garda presence, that there will be no doubt that it is the Garda who are in charge. If the Minister is not prepared to approach it from that point of view, I am afraid we will not be able to support this measure.

A lot has been said on this section. As Deputy Haughey has said, it is the crunch section. I suggest there is no point in talking indefinitely on it. It is quite clear that we are not in agreement on the manner in which the Defence Forces may be used in these circumstances. We believe that the role of the Army is primarily in defence of the nation against enemies, foreign and domestic, as they say, but that the role of the Garda is one specifically to deal with criminal and subversive situations, that the Army should be supporting the Garda in that role. That is as far as we are prepared to go at present.

Comment on this

When dealing with section 8 this morning I expressed grave misgivings about the capacity and ability of members of the Garda Síochána to carry out the extra powers conferred on them by that section without inflicting grave injustice and oppression on innocent people. I do not share the complacency of my colleagues, Deputies Haughey and Brennan about that section. Under this section the same powers, which are global, are being given to members of the Defence Forces who, by training, tradition, education or vocation, are not equipped to exercise them. They never asked to be peace-keepers. They never asked to co-operate with members of the Garda Síochána when they joined the force. In every country in which the Army have engaged in this type of activity, the pattern has always been the same as in the North of Ireland. I have no doubt at all that, instead of achieving the results which the Ministers for Defence and Justice promise, this whole package will achieve the opposite and lead to further frustration, violence and terrorism.

Of course, we have received assurances from the Minister and the Government that this legislation will not be used oppressively. The very fact that these assurances are given is a condemnation of this legislation by the Government and Ministers. It is an admission on their part that the legislation is capable of being used oppressively. Otherwise, why the assurance that it will not? Of course, if laws can be used oppresively—I may now be quoting or paraphrasing somebody—then they are bad laws. This is one of the worst parts of the whole of this obnoxious legislation. Ministerial assurance is no use. We had ministerial assurances at the beginning of this debate, now almost three weeks ago, that we would have ample time to debate this matter fully. We had a shameful example here last Friday of the worth of these ministerial and Government assurances. I want to protest now in the strongest possible terms at the treatment which I and some of my colleagues received at the hands of the Ceann Comhairle and the Minister for Justice who is apparently not listening——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy appreciates that he should not refer to the Ceann Comhairle in this way in his absence——

Comment on this

I am sorry the Ceann Comhairle is not here but I must make my protest now. It is part of what I am talking about, this suppression and oppression. Without even the slightest gesture of embarrassment or surprise and with indecent alacrity, the Ceann Comhairle responded to the request of the Minister for Justice to bring an end to the debate.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that criticism of the Ceann Comhairle, particularly in his absence, is not in order.

Comment on this

I cannot keep waiting. I have been here for the last three days and this is the first opportunity I have had to speak on the matter. I have not mentioned it now just because the Ceann Comhairle is absent from the House. I intervened in the debate in the earlier stages and I addressed myself mainly, if not solely, to technical matters which I considered important. I was concerned about the wording and the machinery of the Bill, about the nuts and the bolts of the Bill. I asked the Minister a number of questions which he failed to answer; he treated them with silence, if not contempt. For that reason I was anxious to make some contribution to the debate last Friday but I was not allowed to do so. The Minister accused me of collusion with Deputy Blaney in a filibuster——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy will appreciate that we are moving away from the matter under discussion at the moment.

Comment on this

It was a disgraceful performance. It caused an outcry and I hope that outcry influenced the decision of the Government over the weekend to have some sense and to see the light. I hope they will see the light in relation to this section also.

Subsection (6) puzzles me. It states:

A person effecting an arrest under this section complies with any rule of law requiring him to state the ground of arrest if he states that he is effecting an arrest as a member of the Defence Forces because he suspects the person being arrested of being in the act of committing, of having committed or of being about to commit, as the case may be, an offence to which section 8 of this Act applies.

In all the sections in this and in the other Bill where the question of suspicion and cause comes in it is always prefixed by the word "reasonable". I should like to know why there is not an obligation on the person who effects an arrest under this subsection to have reasonable suspicion. What standard of suspicion is intended here? Is it a greater or a lesser standard than the "reasonable" suspicion referred to in other sections? Is it a defence for a member of the Defence Forces in a possible action taken against him for assault or for false imprisonment? That may be an unnecessary and naive question but it worries me and I should be glad if the Minister would answer it.

Comment on this

I support this section. As I listened to the debate this morning I found the Fianna Fáil position becoming more confused. If they have detailed objections or amendments I should have thought they would have disclosed them by now for Report Stage. It is appropriate that we should debate in depth a measure as serious as this and the House is doing so.

The points made by the Minister for Defence and the general information given to us strengthens the case in favour of the measure. I think all Deputies would not like to see a situation where the separate respective responsibilities of the police force and the Army would not be clearly delineated, observed and separated by the Executive. However, there are circumstances now, as there have been in the recent past, where bringing the Army to the aid of the civilian force is warranted and quite inescapable. Deputies should pay tribute to the several thousand of our troops who carry out Border patrols every day and night and the many hundred Garda Síochána in the Border counties who must undertake this appalling work. They do so at the risk of their lives and indeed some of them have lost their lives; I am referring to members of both the Garda Síochána and the Army.

It is remarkable that despite the large number of patrols undertaken in recent years—a figure of 12,000 was given—both the Army and the Garda Síochána have operated on this side of the Border with the total support of the local population. They are depending on that support in their security operations and, with respect to Deputy Blaney, we should not say anything in this House to put that support at risk. That is what we could easily do.

Comment on this

What support does the Deputy mean?

Comment on this

I am inferring that there are enough cowboys around from Donegal to Dundalk——

Comment on this

The Deputy should be careful about the cowboys.

Comment on this

I think we all know what I mean.

Comment on this

That is not what the Deputy said. He had not mentioned cowboys when I asked him what support he was talking about. How can he be serious in what he has said? Is he just acting the ass? Is it a case of a bob each way?

Comment on this

The Deputy need not worry about that.

Comment on this

The Deputy mentioned my name and I want to know what he meant.

Comment on this

I want to mention one key aspect that is a matter of concern, namely, the possible use of firearms in certain circumstances. Not being a member either of the Garda or of the Army, I am not aware of the precise regulation or of the circumstances in which the Army in such operations may meet force with force. One presumes that the regulations permit a degree of force based on the degree of force with which the Army are faced. However, there might well be circumstances in which special care should be taken if we are to devolve this power on the Army. I refer specifically to the possession of firearms in what one might regard as circumstances in which the use of firearms are not necessary. Can the Minister tell us whether the troops on all occasions will carry firearms and also what will be their orders in relation to dealing with situations in which individuals may not only try to resist arrest and to escape but to fire on the troops? I am aware of many members of the Garda who have narrowly escaped death or serious injury when fired on in such circumstances. There have been instances in which their car wind-screens were pierced by bullets. There are gardaí who consider themselves to have escaped death or injury miraculously on occasions. In relation to effecting arrest there may be some cowboys along the Border whom it would be difficult to hold for a couple of hours, let alone for six hours, especially if their associates are nearby. Some of them, should they come across the Border, are capable of taking on any army. The Minister has been reasonably reassuring but, perhaps, he would outline in more detail the circumstances in which, in particular, the use of firearms could eventuate.

In asking for these details we are conscious of the fact that it would be irresponsible of us as Dáil Deputies to seek information which might prove to be of direct assistance to subversives by enabling them to know when or when not to pull the trigger. Consequently, we appreciate that for security reasons the Minister may have to be circumspect.

Comment on this

Have not the ordinary citizens a right to this information?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Desmond.

Comment on this

I suggest that the ordinary men and women in this country are overwhelmingly in support of these measures. That has been the reaction I have got both by way of correspondence and verbally.

Comment on this

What about the Labour Party members?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

These interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

One must distinguish between political prompts and reality.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy telling us that the members of his party are overwhelmingly in favour of this section of the Bill?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies are allowed make their own speeches. They must allow the Deputy in possession to make his contribution.

Comment on this

As this is Committee Stage, we are merely putting a question to the Deputy.

Comment on this

There is an overwhelming acceptance of the need for measures of this nature. That has been the view of most people I have met. If it is necessary to give these powers to the Army, they must be given to them.

Comment on this

The Deputy must have been very selective in relation to his inquiries.

Comment on this

I wonder whether he has travelled far from Dublin since this legislation was introduced?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

If Deputies would listen, they might find that out.

Comment on this

I support the measures but I am under no illusion as to the dangers inherent in the measures. Indeed, a person would need to be stupid not to see those dangers but our job here is to ensure that the measures are there to be used when necessary. So far I have not heard what one could regard as coherent and logical reasons from Fianna Fáil as to why this measure should be opposed.

Comment on this

If, apart from coming in now to examine his conscience, the Deputy had been present during the speeches from this side, he would be aware of our reasons for opposing the measure.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputy Desmond.

Comment on this

I understand that the embarrassment to Fianna Fáil in relation to voting against the section is growing by the hour because they know that the Army will note very carefully some of the implications of what is being said by the Opposition.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows very well that we support the Army.

Comment on this

Yes, but I am merely saying that they will take a careful note of some of the implications of the views of the Opposition on this section.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Cross-talk in the House always leads to this sort of disorder.

Comment on this

One would have thought that since Fianna Fáil are unhappy with the section they would have attempted to table amendments to it either on this or on Report Stage. It would be interesting to hear from them on, for instance, the type of defence regulations which Deputy Dowling had in mind.

There are ample circumstances in which can arise the implementation of this section. If we are to permit situations to develop where either members of the Garda are shot because of the inhibitions we might have in relation to these measures or citizens are attacked and shot by terrorists, but by the time a joint Army-Garda patrol arrives the individuals have flown back to Northern Ireland, or to some other country, them, as far as I am concerned, the protection of property and of people's lives, even by extreme measures of this nature, is necessary.

I would hope—and I put this to both Ministers—that very shortly we will see the day when this section of the Bill can be deleted. We have to be extremely careful that the separation of both forces, with their different traditions, training and so on, will be maintained. There are undoubtedly circumstances which can be advanced by Deputies on both sides in which it would be necessary to have the Army, under direction, operating on a separate basis in support of the security operation. There has been an area of sensitivity here from the Fianna Fáil point of view with which I would not cavil but we have had instances of ruthlesseness displayed in operations in which those people would disregard whether it was a Garda car or something else that was in front or behind the car driven by the British Ambassador. There have been many cases of attacks, particularly around the Border, where they did not inquire as to the colour of the police or the Army. Whoever came in their way got in front of their pistols or larger weapons.

In terms of the overall situation, I am prepared to accept that there must be flexibility given to the security forces. That is logical. It is unpleasant, abhorrent in many respects in terms of the structure of the State, but I cannot see any option in this. I have spoken to many people in regard to this section and I am of the opinion that the Government's decision is merited. I do not think there is much to be gained by the kind of comments made by Deputy Haughey in regard to the personality of the Minister for Defence. That kind of argument is not in the interests of the House, of the Garda or Army. We in Ireland attack each other sufficiently without attacking the people who are charged with the security portfolios, and I was surprised that Deputy Haughey, a former Minister for Justice, saw fit to do so.

Comment on this

I was amused to hear Deputy Desmond refer to cowboys. It did not clarify matters as to his feelings. If one wants an example of the Rhinestone Cowboy one could not go to a better place than Deputy Desmond's hacienda at Rathdown. The liaison of the Left have done a lot of compromising.

I had the pleasure of listening to the Minister for Lands in the Seanad saying that many of us on this side who should have contributed were silent and that that might be construed as being in favour of the proposals in the Bill. I represent a constitutency with a big Army vote and I am glad of the opportunity to give my views. The Minister for Lands did not say that many of us were denied the opportunity to speak the other night when the guillotine was applied.

I then put my views on record and said I hoped we would put our views in regard to this proposal. I detest the Provisional IRA, the UVF and all their kindred bodies, but I am against this section which changes the whole status of Army life. It has been pointed out that it will be of a permanent rather than a temporary nature. The lot of the Army will be that of a police force. On 1st September the Taoisech said the object was to make the Army act as a police force. He said it was not the object to have an Army of our strength marching up and down being an ornament. In other words, in the eyes of the Taoiseach the Army would be an ornament if they did not engage in police activities.

I am sure those who answered the advertisement "Join the New Army", did not know they were being conned to "join today's Army and be in the police force of tomorrow". I am confident this is not wanted by the Garda. I discussed it with some of them and their attitude is that the force should be strengthened and more men put on the beat. The long-term good of the country would be best served in that way.

What will happen to the Army when the so-called emergency is over? Will they be sent to join the thousands of others who are unemployed, as happened when the last emergency was over? The Minister should realise —he has, judging by his acceptance of some of our amendments—that he must have 100 per cent support from the public for legislation such as this. Public opinion has been coloured by the role of the British Army in the North and we can go back far enough to the frightful memories of their predecessors in this State prior to independence.

The Army do not want this legislation. I know the attitude of those of them in the Curragh who have been forced to take up the duties of prison warders. They were hopeful these provisions would not be of a permanent nature. Men joining the Army would not join a police force if they had a choice. They are poles apart. Another point is that this decision will undermine the good opinion of the public as far as our Army are concerned.

When the type of security the Government could muster at the court-house which was blasted failed and the number of personnel made available to guard the British Ambassador failed, how can they expect to cast an effective nationwide net of security with the aid of the Army and be successful? This is part of a window dressing campaign. The Cabinet decided to call out the cavalry. The long-term use of the Defence Forces will now be brought into play to buttress the poor performance of those who always place themselves on record as being the sole supporters of law and order.

I am sorry the Minister for Defence, who should be very much involved in this debate, could not find the time to stay here and hear what is being said. If we are in an emergency situation and the Government must use all the powers and resources at their disposal, money should be no object. I should like the Minister for Defence to answer one final question. Will the members of our Army who will now find themselves doing police duties side by side with members of the police forces be paid the same rates of overtime as are available to members of the police force. These are the questions being asked by members of the Army in my constituency who are not subversives but ordinary people doing the day's work they enlisted to do. These are the questions I should like to hear answered.

Comment on this

A number of points have been raised in the debate so far and I will endeavour to deal with them. First of all, may I comment on what I consider to be an unfortunate tone in the debate starting off with Deputy Collins's contribution and exemplified in the contribution by the last speaker? This seems to be the total sense of alienation or nearly antipathy which the Opposition apparently feel for the Army and the Army's role in the nation.

Comment on this

That is totally unwarranted.

Comment on this

It is not true.

Comment on this

Let me develop my point.

Comment on this

What the Minister has said is damaging enough and it is totally untrue.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies must learn to listen and then they can answer.

Comment on this

When a Minister of State makes a statement like that we are entitled to protest.

Comment on this

The entire tone of the Opposition's debate, the whole thrust of the Opposition's debate, is somehow that the people have something to fear from our Army because they are being given these new powers, that our Army cannot be trusted. Deputy Power compared them with the Army in Northern Ireland, and he even went so far as to draw attention to the experience in this country, before we won our independence, at the hands of an army. Is it any wonder that I rise with some sense of outrage and shock that this general tone and thrust should be informing the approach of the other side of the House? When the Minister for Defence said the Army are held in affection by the great majority of our people, he spoke accurately. The Opposition would do well to reflect that that is an accurate view of the feelings of the vast majority of the people.

Comment on this

Absolutely. We endorse that 100 per cent.

Comment on this

There is no question about that.

Comment on this

There is a feeling of affection and total trust. Like Deputy Power, I have the honour to represent a constituency where there are three garrison towns. I can assure him that the feeling of the people towards the Army is one of affection and trust.

Comment on this

We agree with that 100 per cent.

Comment on this

Deputy Collins implied that somehow the Army will suddenly lose that feeling of support and trust overnight. He said the public might not support the Army in the same way and that the public will not accept the Army operation in the police area. This has the implication in it that somehow the Army will be oppressive that, as I said earlier, a force something like a collection of foreign mercenaries will be inflicted on the people. The soldiers in our Army are our relations. They are Irishmen like the rest of us and they are as sensitive to their obligations and their rights and duties as citizens as any of us. To suggest that in some way their performance of their duties will be in the mould or way of a foreign army, as Deputy Power seemed to imply is usually unworthy and seriously insulting to the force.

Comment on this

I did not imply that. The Minister is implying something I did not say.

Comment on this

As the Minister for Defence pointed out, there may be historical reasons why the feeling on the far side of the House for the Army may contain an element of alienation——

Comment on this

Here we go again. Flash back 50 years.

Comment on this

——a feeling of what use or abuse may be made of the Army. It is significant that there was so much neglect for so many years of the Army. When this Government took office, the numbers were inadequate and the equipment was inadequate. Those two things, of course, contributed to inadequate morale. The present strength of the Army is the highest peacetime strength ever. The equipment available to the Army has never been better. The morale of the Army is 100 per cent. This reflects the complete identification of this Government with the Army and an acknowledgment of the importance for us of the Army in our State. We trust the Army and we are prepared to build the Army up, to give the Army the equipment and to keep the Army morale high.

It ill-becomes Deputy Haughey to come in here and sneer, as I heard him doing, and suggest we are introducing some idea of creeping militarism because the Minister for Defence identifies with the Army and because the Taoiseach identifies with the Army. To suggest this is some form of creeping militarism is unworthy of the Deputy. Indeed, it carries with it the implication somehow that this could lead to a situation of constitutional instability. I would remind the House that never have our Army endangered the constitutional stability of the State. The last time there was any danger to the constitutional stability of this State was in recent times and it ill-behoves Deputy Haughey of all people to make slighting references to creeping militarism.

Comment on this

For God's sake will you deal with the section?

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has identified publicly with the Garda in a way none of his predecessors in recent times had done. He was the first Taoiseach to take the trouble to go to the Garda depot and present Scott medals to Garda and take a passing out parade. Is he thereby to be accused to some sort of creeping alliance with police and in some way bringing us nearer a police state, the equivalent, in police terms, of this creeping militarism Deputy Haughey sneered about? I am afraid that for historical reasons the Opposition are incapable of identifying fully with the Army. We on this side of the House can do so, and we are satisfied that the vast majority of the Irish people have affection and trust for the Army.

Various points were raised during the debate. We have taken positive steps to indicate our concern for the Army and the needs of the Army, and similarly for the police. Their numbers are at the highest level ever. Their equipment is second to none now and was never of a higher standard in the history of the State. This shows our concern to maintain the State's protecting forces at a high level of efficiency and to keep them in a position where they can help the State in a time of emergency such as now.

Another indication of what I might call the cavalier attitude that could be adopted by the Opposition towards the Army leads me to accept a point made in the course of the debate, but not for the reasons it was made. It was suggested in the debate that giving powers which might be used by the FCA was even worse than having those powers exercised by members of the permanent Defence Forces. I take that point and I will introduce an amendment on Report Stage to limit the powers to the permanent Defence Forces.

Comment on this

So will I.

Comment on this

The reason I am prepared to do that——

Comment on this

The Minister does not trust the FCA.

Comment on this

——is not that I do not trust the FCA. I had the honour of serving in the FCA. I do not trust all future Governments if they should not be of this persuasion over here as to how they might deal with the FCA because only some years ago— the Deputy who was in charge of Defence then is in the House—the FCA were abused because IRA men from Derry were given arms training in a military installation here under the guise of pretending they were members of the FCA.

Comment on this

The Minister does not trust the FCA.

Comment on this

That is so serious that the possibility of it being excluded in the future must be written into this legislation. For that reason I am confining the powers to the permanent Defence Forces. It is not that I distrust the FCA but, on the evidence of past performance, I would distrust future Executives of a different persuasion to this as to how they might treat the FCA, or rather abuse the FCA.

It is not apt or appropriate that the powers contained in this section would be put in the Emergency Powers Bill. The Emergency Powers Bill is presented pursuant to the emergency resolution and because it contains matters which require the immunity given by Article 28 of the Constitution. The operation of that Article excludes constitutional challenge for the matters in the Bill and prevents a citizen challenging the Bill. I am sure nobody here would want to restrict the right of a citizen to challenge the powers under section 15 and that would be the effect if they were to be put into the Emergency Powers Bill. It would be entirely inappropriate that a piece of legislation which does not need the immunity given by Article 28 should be put into a Bill where it would have that immunity and thereby remove from a citizen the right to challenge it if he wishes.

Comment on this

The Minister is now acknowledging that there is immunity under Article 28. He never acknowledged that before.

Comment on this

The suggestion that the powers should be exercised by a Minister for Justice is window dressing on the part of the Opposition. It is impracticable that powers which are of their nature operational should have to await the approval of a single person, the Minister in question. The proper person to exercise these powers is the Garda officer in charge of the situation on the ground. It is his job, his responsibility and his knowledge that will decide when these powers should come into operation. Furthermore, that principle preserves the primacy of the police as the law enforcement agency of the State. That principle is maintained by the provision that the powers are requested by a superintendent. In the same way at the moment if the military are needed in aid of the civil power it is the Garda who called in the military in aid of the civil power and there has never been any suggestion that that power should be reserved to the Minister.

Deputies Collins and Haughey asked why, if we need the military to do these things, do we not have more police. We are recruiting more police but we are recruiting them because there has been an inordinate drain on the manpower resources of the police up to now for Border and terrorist duties. The extra police will be primarily intended to enable more men to be deployed on what might be called more routine police work. Deputy Carter made the valid point that it is important in the security element that citizens should be secure and safe in their homes and the incidents of crime should be curtailed. He said that one way this could be done would be by a greater police presence on our streets. This is where police could be used and not in an anti-terrorist role. They have to be used there and take the lead but it is equally important that they should be used in the other civilian role as much as possible. If their role in the anti-terrorist area can be supplemented by using the military, it is commonsense that the military should be given a greater involvement subject to—I must repeat this and I cannot emphasise it too often because it is constantly being ignored by the Opposition—the primacy of the police and in a subordinate role to them.

Even if we were to double the number of police available to us, we would still be left with almost 15,000 uniformed disciplined men in the service of the State in an entirely passive role. That would be daft government. The Garda, as I said on the radio, are essentially on top of the security situation here. They have scored a number of outstanding successes and their achievements in bringing terrorists to justice is quite remarkable and reflects great credit on them. I have no doubt it gives all sides of the House a great measure of pride but I must remind the House that this present state of emergency is stated to be and is arising out of the armed conflict in Northern Ireland. There were some disturbing trends lately in that the addresses of perpetrators of some more violent crimes here and the general tone of crime down here has been informed by what is taking place up there. The time to move is before it gets any worse and arm ourselves with these extra powers.

Comment on this

Why not make some suppression orders?

Comment on this

While the Garda are on top of the security area here, and I hope they will continue to be on top of the security area here, these powers are brought in to ensure that they will continue to be on top of security in this jurisdiction. That is the answer to Deputy Haughey. I should like to repeat that we are not creating a second police force. We are giving some extra powers to the military to supplement the Garda in their anti-terrorist operations. Those powers can only come into operation when called into operation by the police. The primacy of the police is being maintained and the subordinate role of the Army as an aid to the civil power is being maintained. Deputy Barry Desmond was correct when he said there was a welcome for this provision.

Comment on this

In fairness to the Minister for Justice, I can only liken his most recent outburst to that outburst of the Taoiseach at the close of the debate on the declaration of a state of national emergency. It is a pity that the Minister who normally can keep his cool had to go back to the civil war and try and bring in the causes of the civil war.

Comment on this

I was objecting to the Opposition's statement of creeping militarism.

Comment on this

If the Minister is suffering from the constant pressure he seems to be suffering from as a result of this debate and he finds his case so difficult to defend he can deal with it without blowing his top. It is wrong that we have to throw charges of any nature at any Member of this House. This is not the first time the Minister for Justice has resorted to this tactic when he has been cornered. During the course of the debate I gave in on points when I felt I should and I never resorted to personally attacking any Member on the Government side nor would I do so. This matter is far too serious. We are now, irrespective of what the Minister says, creating a second police force here because the Army are being involved. I have as much time for the Army as the Minister or anybody and I respect the Army as an Army but I am entitled to criticise the Army's new role being thrust on them by the Government. That is what I criticise. I have as much affection as every Member on this side for the Army as the Minister for Justice or the Minister for Defence or any Member of their party. The Minister does not have to try to knock it and say that there are historical reasons why the Fianna Fáil Party would be questioning this. He said that our affection and trust for the Army are questionable. I reject this as utter nonsense and an argument so poor that it ill becomes the Minister for Justice to use it.

I should like to repeat what I said earlier today. In voicing my criticism of the Army's new role, thrust on them by the Government, that is, doing police work, I knew I would be misinterpreted. I am sorry the Minister tried to send the message abroad from this House that the Fianna Fáil Party say the Army cannot be trusted. That is untrue. I accept that the Minister is having second thoughts about the role the FCA should play. So well he might. Surely he or the Minister for Defence did not have to wait until today to know what the Bill, as prepared by them, which purports to give power to the Defence Forces to arrest and search in certain circumstances only meant the Army? If they believed that, that shows the public and the House the amount of preparation that went into putting this Bill together.

I sincerely hope that the attitude seen here today and yesterday where we can agree to differ in a cool and fair fashion, will prevail in future. I cannot see the relevancy of any civil war issue in this debate nor what the rights and wrongs of the Blueshirts of the thirties have to do with this debate. For the reasons we have given we are objecting to the new role being thrust on the Army, namely, to be a second police force.

We on this side have as much faith in and affection for the Army as anybody on the other side. It ill becomes any member of any Government to try to send the impression abroad that Fianna Fáil are criticising the Army and that they cannot be trusted. That is very wrong and is damaging to all, mostly to the Army.

Comment on this

I support what Deputy G. Collins said. I want to draw attention to what the Minister said when he indicated that he was prepared to accept our argument in relation to the FCA. The reason he gave was not that on reflection the FCA would not be suitable for this role—I would have thought that was the proper reason—he said he did not trust any future Administration, other than one from that side of the House, to have a proper association with the local FCA.

Comment on this

And I gave my reasons.

Comment on this

The Minister will have to accept the Government the people elect.

Comment on this

The Minister stated that for the future he is prepared to do less than he thinks is desirable in this legislation. He is prepared to delete the FCA simply because he does not trust any future Government, unless it is a Fine Gael dominated Government.

Comment on this

The last Government abused the FCA.

Comment on this

The Minister is implying that no future Government can be trusted.

Comment on this

I presume the Minister is implying that we would be less than reliable in our dealings with the Army and the Garda Síochána. If what the Minister has been trying to convey in his contribution were to be put across, we would be less than reliable. He has been saying that everything we have been arguing was a reflection on the Army. That is in line with the kind of argument he made about the police functions in the course of this Bill. He has had to acknowledge that on many occasions our arguments were well based and warranted.

We support the Army and the Garda unreservedly. Terms of affection, loyalty or support, for the work they have done, are doing and will do, are as apt to come from this side of the House as from the Government side. It is because we support them that we have to question an extension of the role of either the Garda or the Army to an area in which they have not been accustomed to operate and in which the public have never seen them operate, in this case, an area in which the Army have no special training and which we believe to be hazardous not only to the public but to them also.

If the Minister wants to interpret that as being a criticism against the Army he is free to do so. We cannot stop him. But if he does that he is trying to raise fears and present unworthy arguments which should not come from a Minister who is seeking support and who should be able to justify this section in logic and reason. He has not done that. I listened to him for the last 15 minutes and did not hear any logical answers to any of the precise questions raised. I want to ask him a few questions again and will yield to him immediately if he chooses to reply. Does he not acknowledge that the new powers being given to the Army under this Bill can be applied for offences other than subversive offences, as stated in this Bill?

Comment on this

The powers given to the Army can be used in regard to the offences set out in section 8 what are broadly called terrorist-type offences.

Comment on this

We need more than that from the Minister.

Comment on this

I will use clearer English for Deputy O'Kennedy and say offences which come to be frequently committed by terrorists.

Comment on this

Does the Minister acknowledge that the extension of the powers of the Army can apply to offences other than what are broadly called terrorist-type offences and that there are people serving sentences under section 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act, 1861, and sections 23, 23 (a) and 23 (b) of the Larceny Act, 1916 who are not terrorists?

Comment on this

Yes, and there are people serving sentences who are terrorists.

Comment on this

The Minister is making my case. In spite of that, he is including in the extension of Army powers offences which, in some cases, have nothing to do with subversion. If the Minister acknowledges that, he is meeting us somewhere along the line. I hope he accepts our right to note that fact, to question it and to ask him to correct the position, because someone has to take the decision at some stage. Once we give power that is the end of our role and the Minister's role. It is then for the Garda and the Army to operate the Bill under the powers we have given them. The Minister has acknowledged that we have given them powers to introduce an Army presence into areas hitherto reserved to the Garda for offences or crimes that may have nothing to do with subversives. That is a very serious position.

We said that we welcomed the presence of our police force, and many more gardaí, to maintain normal security and peace and to guarantee the safety and liberty of our citizens in every area of their normal lives. We see the need to regulate and restrict the presence of an armed force doing what has hitherto been restricted to an unarmed police force. It seems that this section will pass without any amendment or reservation, apart from the unworthy acceptance of our suggestion about the FCA. When this Bill is passed the Army will have powers to which they are not accustomed, powers which the police did not have, do not have at the moment and will not have until this Bill is passed, that is the right to stop and search vehicles, the right to search people in vehicles——

Comment on this

They have the right to stop vehicles.

Comment on this

But not to search. I said, to stop and search vehicles. The police at the moment do not have these powers. Members of the public might assume that the police have those powers. There would not be great trouble if the police did have those powers. When this Bill leaves this House not only will the police have that power but the Army will have it as well. The Minister says that we are expressing unreal concern here and that we are making implications against the Army. We are doing no such thing. I would hope that we can discuss this kind of legislation and the serious extension of Army powers in a much more reasoned and objective fashion than heretofore.

I sincerely regret the fact that the Minister tried to imply that for historical reasons anything that we have said about the Army has to be questioned and that we have an historical distrust of the Army. That is a terrible suggestion. I hope that none of us on this side looking at the history of any political party could imply that only we have the understanding and the right to supervise the role of the Army. We are all concerned with upholding the democratic institutions that have been entrusted to us to uphold. We accept the enthusiasm of the Minister for Defence and the Minister for Justice in the roles they have and we accept their wish to discharge their roles with concern and integrity. Nonetheless we are entitled to question the manner in which the Minister for Defence, in particular, more or less indulges in a maximum presence of the Minister for Defence in Army activities. We feel that the Army are capable of discharging their functions without the presence of the Minister for Defence. That is the type of thing Deputy Haughey was referring to. We trust the Chief of Staff and the Commissioner.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

We do not think that the Chief of Staff or the Commissioner needs to be directed regularly by the Minister for Defence or the Minister for Justice. In fact, they should never need to be directed in this area. To imply, as the Minister for Justice has, that because the Taoiseach presented the Scott medals that the previous holders of the office had less respect for the Garda than has the Taoiseach is a very unworthy implication. Perhaps the Minister would now indicate what precautions he proposes to take and what directions he would give to either the Army or the Garda to ensure that these powers which can be operated by the Army in areas other than subversive activities will be strictly regulated and controlled.

Comment on this

I repeat that we are dissatisfied and disappointed by the Minister's attitude in replying to this debate. We had made a case to which we were entitled to have a reply regarding our concern over this complete new departure in giving a police role to the Army. We should try to avoid in this debate the possibility of identifying the Army with a political role. The Minister has nearly brought the debate down to that level. The Minister has explicitly stated that for historical reasons Fianna Fáil cannot identify with the Army. That is an unworthy statement which will not go down well with the Army, because the personnel of the Army have their different views too. If they are to be left a political contention with which to play around and if we are to have this type of argument injected into what was a serious debate, it is an unworthy role for either the Minister for Defence or the Minister for Justice.

The Army has lived through many political vicissitudes and we do not have to go back on the different roles they had to play. There were times when they had to be prepared to suppress a political blueshirt army. At all times they were prepared to take on whatever role was necessary and one characteristic of the Army down through the years was that they showed no political leanings one way or another.

We have been treated to a not too transparent effort to have the Army identified with one political party and I would say that is the last thing the Army would want or that the people would want. We are treading on very thin ice when we are even moving by implication in that direction. The Minister was obviously saying in his speech that Fianna Fáil did not like the Army and that the Army belongs to the Government. The Army belongs to the people of this nation. The Government may change ten times but the loyalty of the Army would be given to whatever Government is in power, so long as they continue with the democratic institutions of the country. We should stop making a political football across this floor of the Army and the Garda. We do not intend doing that. I hope the Government speakers are actuated by the same intentions and desires. It is quite a serious intervention by the Minister.

We raised certain questions regarding the drastic change which has taken place, and I pleaded with the Minister that there might be safeguards in the form of subsections built into this at some stage, which would ensure that it would not be brought into effect until such time as circumstances might justify it. We will be vindicated in that stand. The Minister made no effort to explain how this new role of the Army would work. The Minister sought to tell us that the Army were the grandest people in the world, and that Fianna Fáil did not like them. That is not the type of ending there should be to this debate. If we are going to identify the Army with one political group it is a sorrowful day for us.

Comment on this

Lest it go abroad that there is an attempt to identify the Army with one political group I want to make it clear that the Army is apolitical and above politics. It always has been and it will continue to be and that is the way we on this side of the House want it.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that that is not the way we want it?

Comment on this

I agree that is the way you want it.

Comment on this

I am not suggesting that at all. The Minister should not be so touchy.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Let us hear the Minister out without interruption.

Comment on this

The debate has taken this turn because Deputy Haughey has made serious charges, charges, as I said, of this Government introducing something he called "creeping militarism" and his justification for that was the public identification of the Taoiseach and Minister for Defence with the Army. I was simply pointing out how this is a desirable thing and how it is only proper that the Government of the day should respond to the Army. I also indicated our attitude towards the Army. The level to which we have raised its manpower and the extent to which it has been equipped indicate a different attitude here and I am not going to have that attitude sneered at as "creeping militarism".

Comment on this

The Minister's only argument at any time is personal abuse. He can never argue a case reasonably.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputy Haughey, please.

Comment on this

He is the most discredited man in this country today.

Comment on this

Far from it. I have no shadows to come out from under. The point I am making is that, if there is an allegation of "creeping militarism" against people whose tradition for democracy is impeccable, I will defend them and I am entitled to defend them.

Comment on this

I will go back on allegations too and the Minister will be sorry.

Comment on this

I will never be sorry.

Comment on this

The Minister will.

Comment on this

I will never be sorry and I will not have my colleagues sneered at. It was in that context I raised the matter. I do not claim that the Army should identify with any particular political movement of the day. It should not do so. It belongs to the nation and it is above politics. I want to make that clear.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The Minister is excluding the FCA from the operation of these powers because he does not trust any successive Government to operate this properly. That is what the Minister said.

Comment on this

That is what I said.

Comment on this

Is that the Minister's reason for excluding the FCA?

Comment on this

They were excluded in the past.

Comment on this

The Minister did not know they were excluded in this Bill.

Comment on this

I served in the FCA.

Comment on this

So did I.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

This section deals with the role of the Army and the security situation. If the Army is going to be brought in I suggest it should be brought in properly. We are led to believe there is a certain amount of co-operation between the security forces on both sides of the Border. I suggest that now is the time for the Government to approach the authorities on the other side of the Border and tell them if they cannot make a good enough job of patrolling and manning checkpoints then leave it to our lads and make our Army responsible for protecting us and them. I read in the papers over the weekend that Monaghan County Council had asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs to do what he could about complaints at Aughnacloy because of the harassment and delays on both sides of the Border there. His reply was that he had little success. I would say that "little success" sums up the Government's achievements in a whole lot of areas.

I was delayed for 35 minutes at Aughnacloy yesterday. There was no other vehicle there. I was asked for identification. I showed my driving licence and I was told to wait for two minutes and the car would be cleared. I sat there for 15 minutes and, after 15 minutes, I asked for a wipe—I suppose it was cheeky—and they let me sit there for another ten minutes. On another occasion I was coming up here and I had heard some complaints about delays. A Scots soldier asked me where I was going and I said I was going to Donegal. He asked me where I was coming from and I said I was coming from Dublin. He said: "Why don't you stick to your own State?" I have more right to travel through County Tyrone than any British Tommy. Some move will have to be made by the authorities on this side dealing with security, searches and checkpoints. We hear a good deal about checks and patrols in operation. I can verify what Deputy Blaney said about this. I travel at all hours of the night from here to Donegal. Last weekend I saw one garda at Muff. So much for all the talk about patrols.

I would seriously put it to the Government that now is the time, when there is talk of making changes, to go the whole hog and tell the guys up there they are not doing a good job; "We have complaints day in and day out of delays and other things. Let this side be responsible." Maybe that would be the first step to get us out of the sorry mess the country is in at present.

Comment on this

This would be a very amusing discussion were it not such a serious matter. The contributions of the Minister for Defence and Deputy Desmond were very entertaining. They must think we came down in the last shower judging by the way they talked here. We have the Minister for Defence defending the Army against attacks that were never made about their alleged inexperience in doing what is obviously a police job. He cited the 11,000 Border patrols in the last 12 months and talked rather emotionally about their experience abroad. Surely the Minister is not suggesting that this experience, and some of it was bitter experience, by our Army engaged in UN peace-keeping operations is needed for the type of operation envisaged in this particular section. Surely that is not what is intended. I certainly would not envisage it as parallel to the Congo, Niemba and so on.

This is what the Minister talks about here in an attempt to defend the Army against attacks that were never made against it by anybody. I do not know why he should think he had to take it on himself to defend the Army. Deputy Dowling made the telling point that the Army would get a couple of minutes' briefing under this section before going out. The chances are that in the circumstances envisaged there would not be any minutes in which to brief them at all. The Minister takes it on himself to talk about the experience the Army has had. Nobody has denied the honourable and honoured part they played as part of the UN peace-keeping forces. We are not dealing with a UN operation here. There might have been the chance that such would have been the case when it was sought to have the UN come in and do a job in so far as the whole sad saga of the Border and Partition was concerned but that is not the case any longer. The Minister for Defence rushed in with a defence that is uncalled for and which has no parallel in relation to what we are speaking about here. That does not get away from Deputy Dowling's assertion that members of the Defence Forces will be committed to this type of operation, which involves simply police duties on the basis of a couple of minutes' briefing. I am sure they will be committed at times without there being any time at all to brief them. Since it is on the cards that the briefing will be of a very short duration, if at all, the lack of training in police peace-keeping operations by an unarmed force is very alien to the training they will have received as prospective combat units. Therefore, Deputy Dowling's criticism of the role to which the Army are being exposed and the inherent dangers through lack of briefing, backed up by lack of training, is justified. No blustering by the Minister for Defence can get away from the fact that the Army is an armed force here that has had, and is recognised to have, a distinctly different role to the unarmed Garda force we have had since the foundation of this State.

The Minister for Defence spoke also about the terms of the operations in regard to the six hours. If the Government and their manner of governing could be measured by assurances given by front bench Members inside and outside this House in regard to their operations, then they would be the greatest things ever. But, as is accepted by every Member of the House, both Government and Opposition, assurances are in no way laws in themselves and it is under the laws being enacted here we will operate. It will be what is written down here when this Bill becomes an Act that will count and not assurances. Then we had the contention that nobody will be kept for six hours, that that will be most exceptional, that there will be Garda around the corner to take any persons that the Defence personnel may have arrested in the course of the duties conferred on them under this section.

What will be the position if arrests are made and a delay in excess of six hours occurs for one cause or another? It could even be the breakdown of a vehicle transporting prisoners back from some outpost not just on the perimeter of Dublin, as somebody said, with an inner circle of Garda and an outer circle of Army, a double cordon, when it would be merely a matter of whistling from one to the other. That is so far removed from what is likely to happen it does not wash.

It is quite probable that arrests by Defence personnel, with no garda in the vicinity, will take place in the most out-of-the-way parts of the country, at the most outlandish hours, when there would be no garda or Garda barracks within many miles of such an operation. It might also be that, having made the arrest, there would be no transport immediately available to meet the six hour deadline. It is also possible that even where transport is available it may break down or may not be able to get through before the six hours' period expires. After expiration of the six hours, do such people held then go free? I understand that they should. But the Minister for Defence contended that even the six hours were unnecessary. It would happen right away. If that is the manner in which he thinks the operation will take place, then there is no need for the section at all. If members of the Garda are in the vicinity, in close proximity to the Army personnel, why is there a need for this specific provision? Time and again the Army are to be seen with a member of the Garda Síochána doing his police work in the normal way. Why cannot that continue? Where has the shortfall taken place? Why is it necessary to attempt to treat the Army as a police force, which it is not, has not been and never will be, unless we totally disband the Army and train them as a police force, which I presume there is no intention of doing?

We have had a great deal of bragging by a couple of Ministers here but particularly by the Minister for Justice who spoke about the Army and its inadequate numbers and equipment some years' ago. The comparison now being drawn is that they were never better equipped, their morale never higher and their numbers never greater since the last emergency. The deduction to be drawn is that since we have them in such numbers we must find some use for them, so we whack them in to do the Garda job rather than recruit more gardaí. If that is intended to convey what the Minister's words appeared to convey, then the Government and the Ministers for Justice and Defence are open to very severe criticism for having allowed Army numbers increase to that extent, for having expended moneys we can ill afford equipping them and then contending that they have nothing better to do so they will use them as police, at the same time ignoring the everyday peace-keeping role in which the police have been engaged and which is being totally neglected at present.

This neglect has continued for some years now while those on recruitment waiting lists have been standing by waiting to be called for up to two years. Why have we not been recruiting more gardaí rather than stupidly recruiting more members for the Army which, on the admission of various spokesmen for the Government, are not needed in their present numbers? I think somebody mentioned that the Taoiseach had said that to be marching them up and down in their present numbers, equipped as they are, would merely be using them as ornaments. We cannot afford ornaments of that nature at present, particularly when we are in need of more gardaí. That need did not arise yesterday. It should have been foreseen a number of years ago. We understood in this House that that need had been foreseen, was being attended to, that Garda numbers were being supplemented in order to cater for the new demands being made on them in and around Border areas, enabling normal police work to go ahead in normal times. Instead of that, through some bungling or other, recruitment takes place, money is spent on equipping more Army personnel to act as ornaments while the Garda remain at a point where we have got now to make policemen out of the Army for which they were never intended, were not so recruited and have not been trained.

There is no doubt in anyone's mind that the Army are not the best people for this job. That is not a reflection on the calibre, the standing or the status of the people in the Army. The Army personnel would be the first to admit that this is not their role, that they have not been trained for it and that they should not do it. Subsection (2) states:

Whenever a member of the Garda Síochána not below the rank of superintendent requests an officer of the Defence Forces....

There is no indication given regarding the rank of the officer so requested. It is a serious matter to make the request but providing troops armed to do police work is much more important in the final analysis and the question of the rank of officer must come into the picture. There has been no attempt in the subsection to qualify the rank of the officer of the Defence Forces who may be requested to make available soldiers in aid of the Garda Síochána. The subsection also states:

...to make members of the Defence Forces available for the purpose of the exercise of the powers conferred by subsections (3) and (4) of this section during a period specified in the request....

In what circumstances would a superintendent be in a position to specify the period referred to? If it should happen that the job took much longer than the time specified by him, the members of the Defence Forces, not being accompanied by a superintendent of the Garda, may find themselves operating outside the period stated. How can that difficulty be overcome? The subsection also states, "...the officer may make——". There is no obligation on the officer to make available members of the Defence Forces. In such a situation the pattern of peace-keeping and security arrangements of the Garda Síochána might be thrown out of gear having been given the understanding that they could rely on the availability of the Army to act as armed policemen when, in fact, they might not be available. For instance, a junior officer might not know if personnel were available; alternatively, he might make them available to the Garda Síochána, thus exposing the Army to a greater risk than what they may be called on to cure. There are alarming faults in the subsection and the Minister for Justice should give serious thought to them.

Subsection (2) (a) refers to an officer and one or more members of the Defence Forces under his command and subsection (2) (b) mentions one or more members of the Defence Forces under his command. This means that the ordinary ranks could be made available without an officer and that is another point the Minister should seriously consider. The subsection also states:

...available for the purpose aforesaid, and a member of the Defence Forces made available as aforesaid may, while on duty in uniform during the period specified in the request, exercise the powers conferred by the said subsections (3) and (4).

What provision is being made as to how any member of the Defence Forces in uniform can identify himself by way of identity card or other document that he is a genuine member of the forces? Somebody could be masquerading in a uniform similar to that of the Army. The Garda Síochána must give proof of their identity when they are on duty and not in uniform. We know that uniforms are very easy to come by and they have been used on occasions on both sides of the Border; no doubt they will be used in the future for various purposes. Having put the soldier on the road as an armed policeman, although he is not trained for work of that nature but is trained for combat duty, the public are in the dilemma that the only thing that they must rely on for identification of the person by whom they are accosted is the uniform he happens to be wearing. The Bill should not have been presented with such an omission. Even if this mad section goes through we can only hope that the Minister will rectify this situation. Otherwise there is the very real danger of persons masquerading as members of the Army in the knowledge that the public expect to be stopped and searched on the roads. Therefore there could be instances of persons being taken away by people other than members of the security forces.

Another aspect of this is that doubt on the part of a person accosted as to the identity of the person in uniform may cause him to resist and this would put him in the position of being guilty of a serious offence in the event of the hold-up being genuine but in the event of it being a bogus effort the fate of the one held up may be much worse in the long run than what would be his fate for resisting genuine arrest. This danger has been recognised, though not adequately, in another section in regard to members of the Garda who would not be in uniform. It is a departure from practice that the uniform is to be the only means of identification. With the UDR crossing the Border so frequently and with the many changes in regiments of the British Army in the North residents along the Border are more accustomed to these uniforms than they are to the uniforms of the Irish Army. However, allowing for that and for the similarities in various uniforms and taking into consideration that combat and camouflage jackets are worn in all armies, the Minister must realise that there is a need for means of identification other than the wearing of uniforms. I cannot understand how the Minister and his advisers overlooked this aspect of the measure especially when in relation to other cases identity cards can be required to be produced on demand.

Apart from this very serious omission one must ask whether there will be available to members of the Defence Forces operating under subsection (2) means of proving that they have been called out under the subsection? How are the public to distinguish between those who have been called out and those of evil intent who may pretend to have been called out? There is nothing in this measure to satisfy members of the public in that regard. This is another serious omission which makes the section even worse than it might be. These two omissions alone even at the early stage of the operation of the provision would render it unworkable in that the co-operation of the public could not be expected to be forthcoming.

Talking of co-operation, why is it necessary to have this section? All one can say is that while disagreeing with its inclusion I am very much assisted in my rejection of it by the words used by the Minister in introducing the Second Reading when he said, as reported at column 446 of the Official Report for September 7, 1976:

While I have said that the Garda have no general right to search cars, I would like—in case any situation in which the Garda have to mount road blocks should arise before this Bill is enacted—to make it quite clear that this is not to be taken as meaning that the Garda are powerless against any criminal who might feel like insisting on what he regarded as his legal right to refuse to open a car boot. The fact of the matter is that public acceptance of the need for such action is so near to being unanimous that the person who refuses to cooperate is virtually asking to be treated as a suspect and, of course, when the Garda have reasonable grounds for suspicion, they have a number of powers which they can call on.

Can there be recorded anywhere a combination of words which rebuts more concisely the need that is being expressed for this section? Not only do we not need this section but we do not need the earlier section which confers like powers on the Garda. Consequently, the whole effort of both sections is a hoax to say the least and not a very palatable hoax considering the implications of the section not only for the Garda and the Defence Forces but for the public generally. As Deputy Power has said, the Army have no wish for these powers. They are being given a role for which they were neither recruited not trained. If this was the life they had wanted they would have sought to join the Garda Síochána. Likewise there are many gardaí who would not wish to be in the Army. Should we say to the Garda that they should be available to carry out the duties of the Army at any time? One is just as unusual and awkward as the other. The Minister has answered the question of whether we need this section or the previous one. He has given clear reasons as to why both are superfluous.

The Minister for Defence told us that even if this goes through nothing will be changed, and in this connection he spoke of Army regulations CSI. He said that some phrase might require changing. Surely regulations for purely combat operations could not be taken as applicable to Army units doing police work? Surely there is something wrong in the insistence of the Minister for Defence that everything will be the same?

Some of us have had experience of soldiers doing police work. I am talking about the real thing in the other part of the country. You are stopped day or night, in company or alone, and a sophisticated automatic weapon is shoved into your snout through the car window within inches of your head by a British Army man or a UDR man as the case may be. I do not know how other Deputies would feel with a gun within three or four inches of their heads. Whether travelling alone or in company, you would be just as dead if the thing went off accidentally.

Do we want to introduce such a situation into our operations here? What does a member of the Defence Forces do, armed with a sophisticated automatic weapon, when he seeks your identity at a checkpoint? He comes up to the car and asks for your identity. Does he lay the weapon on the ground or does he hand it to his fellow patrol who has a weapon of his own already and who could not possibly cover the other man at the checkpoint with two weapons in his hand? Are we to have repetitions here of what has been happening at the Border for years, whether by accident or otherwise? Weapons have gone off and we have seen many instances of it reported.

As a young lad being introduced to the use of the shotgun and later to the use of a rifle in the emergency services, I was always reminded of the adage not to point a loaded gun at anybody unless it was intended to do something with it. What is a member of the Defence Forces to do with his gun while he is at the window of your car establishing your identity? Is he to sling the weapon behind him or is he to lay it down? He will put it within inches of your head. Recently the Defence Forces have to wear gloves to keep their hands sufficiently warm to be able to handle their weapons. That gives us the situation at a checkpoint where a soldier with gloved hands and armed tries to establish your identity through the car window by way of the production of driving licence or some such document. At night he has to use a torch, so he has a gun, a torch and the identity document in gloved hands.

Does the Minister realise what in practice we are letting ourselves in for in such circumstances, forgetting all the other grounds for objections from this side? Is this freedom which the Minister is allowing to be the cause of a repetition of what we have been enduring on the northern side of the Border? I have got a bellyful of it on the other side without having to go through it again on the southern side.

There is a difference. We can blame the people above for doing that because they should not be doing it, they should not be there at all, they should get to hell out of it, but we will not have the same feeling in our minds and hearts against the people who will be doing it on this side because they are members of our Army, this is our country and we, representing the people, will have put the Defence Forces in that position although they do not want to be in it. How many people travelling from the east coast go through Sligo to Donegal, not because they have experience of what I am telling the House but because they will not take the risk of experiencing it? They are afraid to go that way because of what they have read and heard. They go the long way around if they go at all. Unfortunately, too often, unless they have some pressing business they do not go at all.

That is all very well for people who come to our county once in a while on holidays, as many do and I hope more will do in the future. Despite the long journey they are on holiday and it is not an imposition on them to travel through Sligo by car. People living in Border areas may have reason to cross the Border time without number on the same day or during the same week. They are heavily frustrated and bowed down by the operations of an Army acting as a police force on the northern side of the Border and many times chasing them into this side of the Border to be probably given some comfort and then escorted back and sent on their way.

The Minister for Defence referred to 11,000 patrols. It would be interesting to know how many would be added to that if the figure took into account British Army patrols on our side of the Border in any given 12 months. What does the Minister intend to do about this matter I have outlined in a purely practical way? I am not drawing the long bow in any way. What is he going to do in regard to the practical operation by an armed member of the Defence Forces acting as a policeman at a road block and checking a driver's licence and identity and the identity of other persons in the car? How will this be arranged? Will we have exactly the same operation on this side of the Border by our Army personnel as we experience on the other side of the Border?

I am not talking about the further objectionable operations by the Army on the northern side. I am talking about an armed person stopping a vehicle and searching it, and using a torch if it is after dark, and wearing mittens from now on during the winter months. Will it operate that way on this side of the Border? Are we who are unfortunate enough to be coming and going because we live adjacent to the Border to have our ordeal doubled overnight because of a measure passed by our own Parliament? I would ask the Minister to give that very serious consideration and see whether he can come up with something—I was about to say something which would make it more acceptable but that is not possible; it is unacceptable—less onerous and objectionable.

I have been talking about cars involving a driver and a few people. Another very objectionable procedure is when laden buses, tour buses, service buses, express buses or otherwise have to go through army checkpoints in the Six Counties. This is a most hellish operation. It is probably due to the regulations. The Army personnel have to observe them and hold on to their weapons. A member of the British Army, armed to the teeth with automatic weapons, walks into a bus crammed with people. That is dangerous because of the possibility in the confined space of the passage, with obstructions on the floor, bags, cases and so on, of the man accidentally stumbling and setting off his automatic weapon. Not just one person's head might be at risk but dozens.

I am not making any case one way or the other as to why this is the practice by the British Army personnel and the UDR. It is frightening to people and particularly the occasional traveller who has no other means of transport and who cannot afford a car. He may not be availing of any service around by Sligo because of the cost and the time factor, and he is compelled to use a service bus or a charter bus. I want to know from the Minister what the situation of our Army will be under section 15 (2). What will the instructions be to our defence personnel acting as policemen, acting as gardaí on checkpoint duty and search duty on buses laden with people?

There is an answer but it is not very practical. You stop the bus and order everyone out. I have seen the British Army adopting this practice while it was lashing cats and dogs. At their leisure they search the bus from which the entire complement of people had been piled out onto the roadside in teeming rain. An hour later they were allowed to get into the bus. I am not suggesting our Garda or our Defence Forces acting as gardaí will do that. It is not the practical answer to the problem I have set the Minister. In considering the first problem I would suggest that the Minister should not create a second one by saying everyone will have to get out while the buses are being checked. That would be very dangerous in inclement weather, particularly for people who may not be too well, young children, old people, and so on. You would not do it to your dog if you had anywhere else to put him.

That takes me from dogs to cowboys. Deputy Barry Desmond spoke about cowboys in Donegal. If we had Deputy Barry Desmond on a horse in Donegal we could say then that we had a cowboy in Donegal. There are other classic ways of describing him. He was not satisfied to talk about cowboys in Donegal. He went on to talk about what he described as political cowboys. At the same time he was coming in with his tongue in his cheek to make interventions trying to take the temperature in the House, politically speaking, so that he could report back to his absent colleagues of the Labour Party either to assure them or make them more unsettled in regard to their support of this measure. I have asked a sufficient number of questions on this measure and for the moment I will leave them with the Minister. I have raised questions in relation to the calling out of the Army, the officer in charge on the Army side who may be requested, the going out of soldiers without any officer in charge, the question of identity or lack of identity cards, the questions of uniform being a sufficient identity and of checking cars while fully armed. I believe I would be fair to the Minister if I gave him the opportunity of replying to those questions at this stage.

Comment on this

The question of the rank of the Army officer has not been specified because it will be for the superintendent making the request to make it the officer of appropriate rank. The superintendent will assess who in the situation that faces him is the appropriate officer. That may be decided on by the extent of the problem. The superintendent may feel he has to go to a senior officer or that a middle rank officer would be adequate to address the request to. It may be decided on the availability of officers. The superintendent can put a time limit but it need not lead to the situation envisaged by the Deputy.

If the time limit expires before the situation for which the Army have been summoned is resolved two things can happen. The Army can continue in position but their role then will become their old role of being there passively in aid of the civil power and their powers under the section lapse. Alternatively, a further request can be made by the superintendent to the officer in question for the use of the Army for the period. It will be a matter for his judgement. Preferably, and more efficiently, that request would be made before the expiry of the time if it looked, coming towards the expiry of the time, that the period for which the Army was requested was going to prove inadequate. Then a further request could be made to extend the time.

Comment on this

This is envisaging a situation where there would be good sophisticated communications or physical communication capable of being transmitted from the Garda to the Army. I am thinking of circumstances which are likely to arise in the usage of Army personnel where communication would not be all that readily transmitted or communication might not be possible.

Comment on this

I can assure the Deputy that communications between the Garda, inter-Army and between the Garda and the Army have never presented any difficulty because they are all possessed of sophisticated radio equipment. There is no difficulty in communications. The Deputy may be envisaging a situation where an Army person might be in a remote area far away from the police officer in question but that can be overcome by the use of the wireless equipment. I would not envisage any difficulty at all in that regard. I was asked how weapons would be handled. This is a matter the Army will have to decide on as an operational matter. It chiefly concerns the person carrying out the searching. Two courses will be open to him. He can stack the weapon at the scene in the custody of one of his colleagues; he can leave it in the vehicle in which they travelled.

Comment on this

The Minister should ask his colleague, the Minister for Defence, about that. I do not think soldiers are allowed do those things. I do not think they can leave the weapon anywhere.

Comment on this

This is a matter which can be arranged as a matter of Army practice. The alternative is that the member detailed to carry out these searches can go on the patrol without the weapon. There is no reason for the Deputy to be apprehensive that an overloaded soldier will be searching his car with a danger to himself or his passengers.

Comment on this

I am not making this up; this is the practicality of the situation.

Comment on this

I am telling the Deputy that there are two ways this situation could be dealt with. The weapon could be stacked in the custody of a colleague in the Land Rover that would be on the scene or the member detailed to carry out the search could travel to the scene without a weapon. It is something that would be kept under review by the Garda and Army authorities to ensure that the consequences which Deputy Blaney has outlined, and which I agree are undesirable, would be avoided. Likewise, I take the Deputy's point if there is any need to search a bus. It would not be a desirable thing in a crowded bus with all the obstacles one might encounter there to have a heavily armed soldier go up and down through the bus. That sort of situation would have to be planned for and provided for. I will draw it to the attention of the authorities.

On the question of identity cards it is not proposed that a member of the military would have to produce an identity card. If he is in uniform this will be sufficient. I take the Deputy's point that the type of jackets worn nowadays are easily copied but nevertheless there are other markings which are not easily copied and which will be adequate to distinguish a member of the Army on this side of the Border. I do not anticipate any difficulty as to that. The Deputy also raised the question of how the general public would know when the Army were acting in exercise of their powers. The only answer I can give to that is that there would have to be an assumption by the general public that the Army were so acting. If there was any dispute about it there could be a query made and if the Army were acting in excess of their powers action would be available to the citizen, depending on the nature of the excess. Certainly, action would be available as an internal disciplinary matter for any action so carried out.

Comment on this

It is not just as simple as the similarity of combat and flak jackets and that other insignia should be sufficient to identify soldiers. This is not so. Different regiments have different flashes and badges. One would need to be very well up—and most of our people are not—to be able to make a positive identification from the insignia on the sleeves of any army to determine if they are Irish, English, Dutch, French or any other army. I am not particularly concerned about the question of the uniforms being easily copied. It is not difficult to acquire uniforms, legally or illegally; one does not have to make them. That is why I say that a uniform alone is not sufficient identification to assure people, especially in Border areas at night time, that they are dealing with a genuine member of the force. The uniform may be genuine but there is no assurance that the man in the uniform is a genuine member of the Army. Flashes or badges would not seem to be the answer.

Comment on this

An identity card is not necessarily the answer either because people are even less familiar with them and it would be the easiest thing in the world to forge one if somebody wanted to masquerade as a soldier at a military checkpoint. Therefore, an identity card would not be the answer. It would possibly put the matter further but I do not think so. This is a risk that cannot be overcome. I will see if there could be a further identity arrangement but it may be difficult operationally to be able to ensure that it would be available to the degree necessary on all occasions.

Comment on this

There is another matter to which I want to draw the Minister's attention. All this legislation is aimed selectively, as far as the security aspect is concerned, at one organisation, namely, the IRA. The Minister said the other day when asked if this included Saor Éire, IRSP, Official IRA and Provisional IRA that they are all the same and they are all embraced in it. On his own admission earlier he indicated and defended to a very great degree the non-inclusion in any suppression orders of any of the other organisations that have been rampant here for many years, long before the troubles began.

As I said, this legislation is directed only to any type of organisation that is republican in outlook or in their alleged aims, whereas anything with a unionist or loyalist tinge cannot and is not being touched and is not being provided for here. I am leaving myself open to all kinds of charges— but I am used to that—when I say that these are the facts. How can the Minister, the Government, the Garda or the Army acting for the Garda, expect to get full co-operation from the people when they are applying laws that are aimed selectively at one element which is allegedly responsible for the declared national emergency by the Government while other organisations who are clearly a great danger to us are not included?

Comment on this

These laws are not aimed selectively at any particular terrorists. They are aimed at all terrorists and all lawbreakers. It is a figment of the Deputy's imagination if he thinks they are aimed at one type of terrorist. They are not. They are intended for all.

Comment on this

Why only one suppression order?

Comment on this

We went into that before.

Comment on this

We went into that before but the Minister convinced nobody, not even himself.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 67
·
Níl 62
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

This section has a short title and a second subsection to ensure that the provisions of sections 2 and 11, that is, the increased punishments, do not apply to offences committed before the passage of the Act. That is not a constitutional requirement but is a requirement under the European Convention.

Comment on this

With no blame to the Minister, I have not heard a word that has been said.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

Section 16 has two subsections in it, the first is the Short Title of the Bill and the second is a provision that the new punishments imposed by the Bill and the provisions of section 13, which provides for consecutive sentences in the case of offences committed during the currency of a sentence, that none of these shall apply to offences committed before the passing of the Act. They can apply only to offences committed after the passing of the Act.

Comment on this