We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Building Societies Bill, 1975 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.

Contributions 1–140 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Building Societies Bill, 1975
Enacted

No. 32 of 1975 ›

James Tully Minister for Local Government (Mr. Tully) Labour Party

I should like to thank Deputy Faulkner for co-operating in this matter. I asked him to have amendments put in fairly quickly so that we could deal with the matter this week if possible. I wish to state how grateful I am to him for making an extra effort to have this done. Yesterday when I was talking to him it appeared we would not get an opportunity of discussing the Bill this week but now we have that opportunity. If it is dealt with in the same expeditious way I am sure we will get it through fairly quickly.

Comment on this

In this section the phrase a "member of the family" means the spouse, son, daughter, stepson, step-daughter, adopted son or adopted daughter. Is a son-in-law or a daughter-in-law included in the definition?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Is the Minister satisfied that this does not leave a loophole?

Comment on this

We could go out to very far degrees of kindred but we decided the section went far enough. In reply to the Deputy's question, it may leave a loophole but I hope it will not.

Comment on this

The Minister appreciates that the person could get around this by having his daughter-in-law apply?

Comment on this

It could happen, but I hope it will not.

Comment on this

I will not press the matter. I just wanted to know if the Minister had that in mind when he decided on definition.

Comment on this

We checked on this matter but we did not want to go too wide. I admit that what the Deputy suggests could happen but I do not think anybody would do a thing like that. I feel it would be too pointed.

Comment on this

In this section the word "society" means a building society established for the purpose of raising funds, by the subscriptions of members and the acceptance of deposits and loans, for making loans to members on security by the mortgage of freehold or leasehold estate or interest. Does the Minister not consider this definition is too narrow? Would he not consider including development in some way as well as the simple function of raising money or making loans available? Does the present definition not confine the building societies too much?

Comment on this

No, it does not. We do not want to make this too wide. We are dealing with building societies and it was thought that if we went any further possibly we might enable societies to expand their operations in areas other than those strictly necessary to enable them to carry on as building societies. I can assure the Deputy a great deal of thought was given to this section and to this definition. We came down in favour of confining it in the way stated and I think that was the right thing to do.

Comment on this

In the event that at a later stage the Minister considered the building societies could involve themselves in something other than what is laid down here, would that mean he would have to amend the definition?

Comment on this

Yes, it would. I would point out that there are quite a few finance houses dealing with various matters. To widen this area and allow building societies to expand into other sectors would give them an opportunity if the occasion arose to make profit on some other front. All of us are interested in ensuring that as much as possible of the money invested is used for the purpose of the building societies. That is as it should be and we are anxious to have it retained there.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

Is the Minister satisfied that the definition of the word "mortgage" is clear enough? It states in the Bill that it includes charge. Does that mean any charge?

Comment on this

This is one of the difficulties one encounters when framing a Bill of this kind. The word "mortgage" has a well-known connotation. If we attempted to give it another connotation it might do more harm than good. When we talk of a mortgage we mean a charge on registered land. I take the point made by the Deputy but he can be assured it was deliberately kept very short because everyone understands what the word "mortgage" means.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

Is it necessary to define the word "mortgage"?

Comment on this

No. Everyone knows what the word means and it would only create confusion if there was an attempt to redefine it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 6, line 13, after "Act" to insert "(other than a regulation under section 76)".

This section provides for the making of regulations by the Ministers for Local Government and Finance. Subsection (4) provides that every regulation made under the Act shall be laid before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as it is made and it may be annulled by resolution of either House. As it stands, subsection (4) does not take account of the fact that a draft of any regulation under section 76 must be approved by each House before it is made. The purpose of the amendment is to eliminate the necessity of laying regulations before each House which have already been approved in draft by each House. In other words, it is the draft that will come before the Oireachtas and it can be annulled by either House. There would be no point in having the regulations back again for a second run. This is simply a drafting measure to ensure that there is no confusion.

Comment on this

I should like the Minister to define what is meant by "prescribing". The section states that he may make regulations prescribing any matter or thing and I should like his comments on this.

Comment on this

It is a general provision regarding the making of regulations. It empowers the Ministers for Local Government and Finance as appropriate to make regulations under the Act. The regulations may apply generally or to specified classes of society. Any regulation must be laid before each House of the Oireachtas and may be annulled by resolution of the Oireachtas except for 1976 which we have just mentioned. "Prescribed" is the word normally used to say—"the Act of".

Comment on this

I am well aware that it is normally used. I wanted to get a basic definition as it applies to the section.

Comment on this

The Deputy will find it in the definitions section. If the Ceann Comhairle has no objection, let us go back to the definitions section. "Prescribed" means prescribed by regulations made under this Act.

Comment on this

"Prescribed" means prescribed. I will not take it any further. If the Minister looks at the definitions he will see that "prescribed" means prescribed.

Comment on this

And we all know what prescribed means. Let us not bring a dictionary in here.

Comment on this

I appreciate that previously a fewer number of persons could establish a building society. Is the Minister satisfied that ten, which is a relatively small number, is sufficient?

Comment on this

I think ten is an appropriate number. Normally it would not be ten individuals but ten people representing perhaps many more. Ten would appear to be a fairly reasonable number. As Deputy Faulkner said, under existing regulations any number of persons may establish a society, under section 13 of the 1874 Act, and the rules to be transmitted to the registrar must be signed by three persons and the intended secretary or other officers, under section 17 of the 1874 Act. All of us agree that the existing requirements are inadequate and a reasonably large number of persons should be involved. Therefore, the ten founder members provided for is in line with the requirements of section 1 (3) of the British Building Societies Act, 1962. It seems to be working well over there. At least we can use experience which has been found to be useful in other countries. Therefore, ten is what we have inserted here.

Comment on this

This section reads:

Any ten or more persons not disqualified under this Act...

Would it not be better if it read: "Any ten or more qualified persons"? The word "disqualified" seems somewhat negative; it gives the impression that one is looking for people disqualified, rather than assuming that most of them are honest.

Comment on this

There is a very good reason for that wording because persons disqualified from establishing societies are undischarged bankrupts or persons convicted on indictment of offences involving fraud or dishonesty. Deputy Moore says it is a negative way of doing it but it has been found to be the safest phraseology.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): In relation to the ten persons mentioned in this section is there any criterion laid down as to what should be their qualifications? I agree that it should not be less than ten persons. It is important when establishing a building society that plays such an important role in handling the money of shareholders and depositors that some criterion be laid down with regard to their qualification in this field, at least some of them. I know that in a later section the Bill states that it requires a deposit of £10,000. In my opinion money should not be the sole criterion here—the £10,000 from each of the directors that would be necessary. In today's society people can come by that amount fairly easily. I should like to see at least some of those ten qualified in the field of handling finance. If an average ten people got together with no proper knowledge of the running of a building society, investment of the funds, or handling of mortgages, it would be a bad day for building societies. Expertise is needed in this field today; people who know their job are essential to the proper running of the societies.

Comment on this

We think it would be rather dangerous to lay down qualifications such as Deputy Fitzpatrick referred to.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I am saying one or two; I am not saying all of the ten.

Comment on this

We believe it would be dangerous to do so. The registrar will have the right to decide whether or not the person is qualified. For example, section 11 (3) says:

The Registrar, if he is satisfied that the rules comply with the relevant requirements of this Act, shall not refuse to register rules delivered to him...or that the name of the proposed society is undesirable or so resembles the name of another society or the name of a person carrying on in the State banking business within the meaning of the Act of 1971 as to be calculated to deceive, or that registration would not be in the interest of the orderly and proper regulation of building society business.

That gives the registrar fairly wide scope, much wider than if we stipulated certain things. We could be at it for a week and still miss out something that would cause a lot of trouble.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

The absence of qualifications is a qualification in itself. If one had anything else one might be setting up something like a star chamber.

Comment on this

That is what I would be afraid of.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I merely mentioned it in passing.

Comment on this

In subsection (1) I recognise the reason for the use of the words "building society" or "cumann foirgníochta". Basically it is to ensure, when we refer to subsection (2), that societies which are not entitled to be building societies cannot use either description. I should like to know in what circumstances it is envisaged that the English or Irish version would be used.

Comment on this

If a building society had an office in the Gaeltacht I am sure they would use the Irish version there and it would be quite in order for them to do so.

Comment on this

I am very much in favour of it being inserted. In fact I would prefer to see "cumann foirgníochta" having precedence over "building society".

Comment on this

The trouble is that a lot of people might have difficulty finding where to put their money.

Comment on this

I do not think they would. It really means that building societies themselves will decide which form they will use.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Paragraph (i) reads:

the manner in which loans are to be made and repaid, any deductions for premiums,...

Paragraph (h) reads:

the purposes to which the funds of the society are to be applied and the manner in which they are to be invested;

How will a society know in what fashion they will invest their funds? How can they tell the Minister for Local Government or the Minister for Finance when they must first consult with the Minister for Finance from time to time as to how their funds are to be invested?

Comment on this

This is dealing with the rules of the society. It would be dealt with before that would arise at all.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I read it that these rules have to be submitted to the Minister before they are accepted.

Comment on this

Yes, but if the rule said: "the society shall invest its money in hotels, farms" and so on, naturally that would not be acceptable.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): In other sectors the Minister will lay down guidelines as to how and where the money is to be invested, in consultation with the Departments of Local Government and Finance. How can any building society tell the Minister exactly where they will invest their moneys when it is at the discretion of the Minister for Finance?

Comment on this

It is a re-enactment of section 1 (a) of the 1894 Act. It is similar to section 4 (1) (b) of the British Act of 1962. The rules must state the manner in which the funds of the society are to be raised. They raise their funds in different ways, by the issue of shares, of one or more denominations to be paid up in full or to be paid by periodic or other subscription. It is a continuance of what obtains already except that we are tightening it in such a way that, before a society are registered they know exactly what are the terms.

Deputy Fitzpatrick asked how they would know what they were going to do with the funds eventually. We must have in it a certain broadness which will allow this to be dealt with. We could not enact in this House in any way a Bill which would allow building societies to take in money supposed to be for building houses and it turned out that it was to be loaned to other people, perhaps members of the society, for the purpose of buying or investments for which the money was never intended. Deputy Fitzpatrick will find that there is nothing new in this. We are trying to ensure that the loopholes that were there are not being continued.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I agree that it is nothing new and I am sure it was in the procedure of building societies but up to now they had not to have the same consultation or the permission of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government. They drew up regulations. I know what the Minister is coming at but there is a different clause in this Bill because there will have to be consultations with the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government in their regulations. They will have to know the Ministers' mind in this matter as regards investing finances.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

There are returns made throughout the year. Outside and inside auditors go through the accounts. They go through the quarterly accounts all the time so constant consultation goes on between the societies and the various watchdog areas of the Government.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I do not doubt what Deputy Dockrell says but there is something in this Bill that was not in former legislation, that is, the consent of the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government. They intervene at certain points in relation to where their money will be invested.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is probably aware that on the 23rd of May, 1973, the Minister for Local Government, in consultation with the Minister for Finance, had to make certain arrangements to save the building societies with regard to tax remissions, that unless they use the money as building society money and not for other reasons or further uses certain steps would have to be taken. We are now ensuring, before the society are registered they will know what is expected of them. It will be in their rules and it will be discussed before the society is registered.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I just wanted to get this clarified.

Comment on this

I appreciate that and I thank Deputy Fitzpatrick for bringing the point out.

Comment on this

Lines 26 to 39 of this section deal with the rights of members to requisition meetings, the formal notice for convening meetings and the manner in which notice will be sent. Is there a change in this Bill as distinct from the previous legislation? Does a mortgage holder have voting rights? Did he under the previous Bill? We want to get this on the record and have it clarified. What protections are there for mortgage holders? Is it just a subscriber, an investor, who has voting rights or has a mortgage holder voting rights?

Comment on this

A mortgage holder has not voting rights unless he is also a subscriber. Many mortgage holders are subscribers. It is as subscribers that they have voting rights not as mortgage holders. This is a normal case. If somebody borrows money from Deputy Burke or from me, it does not give that person the right to tell us how we should run our business in order to lend him more money. This is quite evident.

Comment on this

I just wanted to have this matter clarified. It is something which came up in the past and it is as well to have it on the record.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Are preferential shares only issued to founder members or can they be issued to other members afterwards?

Comment on this

They could be issued to others but it would be a matter for the society themselves to decide.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): What grounds would establish the issuing of preferential shares to an average shareholder or depositor?

Comment on this

The provision has been made fairly wide. The authority for building societies is being made fairly wide. The idea is to encourage a widening of the type of investment and this is why it is included. The society will have the right to do it themselves. Perhaps it is a matter which will have to get further discussion at a later stage. Once the provision is there it is not a matter we would legislate for in the House, whether the provision is or is not there. We are saying that the provision is there and that it can be widened.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): It is one which should not be abused.

Comment on this

The registrar will have the right to control it.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

Is section 10 (1) (b) which says that the rules of every society shall specify the manner in which the funds of the society are to be raised really necessary?

Comment on this

Yes. The rules should be as full as possible. Therefore, that is included in this type of legislation. It is necessary to have this.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

I presume the same thing applies to paragraph (f) "whether the society intends to borrow money and, if so, within what limits". It is obvious that a society must borrow money.

Comment on this

Of course. Many small investors invest money in those societies. If somebody comes along with £100,000 of hot money which he wants to invest, I do not think the rules should be such that he can dump the money in for a couple of weeks until the heat goes off and take it out again. This is a very necessary stipulation.

Comment on this

Does it mean that should the society decide to change part of the manner in which funds are raised they can do so by including it in the rules and referring it to the registrar?

Comment on this

That is exactly the point.

Comment on this

Subsection (1) (c) refers to the terms on which shares are to be issued and repaid. Is there any place in the Bill dealing with the terms on which loans are being paid?

Comment on this

That would be in the mortgage scheme. It would not be included in this.

Comment on this
John O'Leary Mr. J. O'Leary Fianna Fáil

Do I gather from the Minister's reply that it is the intention of the Minister and his Department some day to make rules within which a society should be bound or is it up to each society to make their own rules?

Comment on this

The societies will make the rules and will submit them to the registrar who will approve or disapprove of them. The whole point is that the rules will be made by the societies but they must be approved by the registrar. They must be sanctioned before they can be put into operation. The registrar can prescribe certain rules if he feels the rules are not adequate. He can say that this, this and this must also go in which I consider is right.

Comment on this

How will the existing building societies be affected by this? Will they have to submit a new set of rules to the registrar or will their existing rules, on which they are operating, be automatically accepted or is the whole thing going to be tightened or altered in some way?

Comment on this

They will submit their existing rules and any amendments they feel should be put in. In order to keep them all in line they will have to be submitted to the registrar. In the main, there will be very little difference in the new rules which will be prescribed by the registrar and the existing rules. They are not so bad considering they are so long in existence. However, this will have to be done and the authority to do it will be there.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Any alterations they feel ought to be made as a result of this Bill will be made, if necessary, by the societies concerned. That is laid down in the Bill.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

I am letting the sections run along if there is no query from the Opposition. I have a brief on each of the sections which I could read out but, in my opinion, that would only waste the time of the House. If there is no objection to the procedure I am adopting. I will continue with it because it is, perhaps, the easiest way. If any point is raised, I will deal with it.

Comment on this

I suggest that if the Minister has anything in his brief he feels he should tell the House he should do so but it is not necessary that he should be concerned with every section. Subsection (4) of this section states:

Whenever the Registrar decides to refuse to register rules delivered to him under subsection (1), he shall, within six months of such delivery, notify the signatories of the rules of his decision and of his reasons for it,

Does the Minister not think that six months is a very long period? Even the courts would be quicker than that.

Comment on this

It will not be a question of the registrar receiving a set of rules, looking at them and saying: "Okay, they are not right". I am sure he will ask to see the people who have submitted the rules and there will be a lot of discussion in connection with them. We felt that a period of six months was not an unduly long term for such discussions. In fact, there was a suggestion that 12 months might be more suitable. It will not affect the operation of existing societies while the rules are being considered. This is a reasonable approach to the matter and to make it shorter than six months would not be in the interests of the societies or the proper drawing up of rules.

Comment on this

If a building society decides to register particular rules they must regard it as a matter of importance to them that these rules should be registered. The registrar has the right to refuse to accept the rules and in such cases they can bring the matter to the courts on appeal. It is my view that societies would be more than anxious to have discussions with the registrar to clear new rules as quickly as possible after they submit them.

Comment on this

The Deputy should remember that the existing societies were aware of this provision and raised no objection to it. With regard to new societies, if the rules are approved there is no trouble about the matter and they can be accepted within a short period. If a discussion is necessary, it can take place as soon as the registrar and the societies can arrange a meeting but in no case can it drag on longer than six months because within a period of six months the registrar must give a definite decision. I feel the Deputy is looking at it as if the registrar was going to sit down for six months and do nothing about it. That is not so. Six months is the longest period the registrar can hold up an application for the registration of rules. If the Deputy looks at it in that light, he will find that it is a far more reasonable thing.

Comment on this

I am sure the Minister will agree that where one defines a particular period it is often allowed to run to that. I agree that where the registrar is satisfied that the rules are in order he can sanction them quickly but where he is not satisfied and the society wishes to have the rules registered a problem can arise. I can fully appreciate agreement with the existing societies on this matter because they already have rules laid down and the vast majority of them have been accepted. If the Minister assures me that from the consultations he has had with the societies the period of time is not considered too long, I accept his word.

Comment on this

In my view there will be very few cases where this will drag on. In most cases the rules when submitted will be approved within a short time. However, it would be unfair to the societies if we insisted that the rules are approved within, for instance, two months. They may be forced to go to the courts on appeal then when a longer period of discussion with the registrar might clear the matter. It would be in the interests of the registrar also to ensure that the rules are confirmed as quickly as possible. It is in the interest of us all to ensure that he does not allow through a rule which would be against the interests of our people.

Comment on this

If the registrar did not approve the rules of a new society for the six months' period that society could not commence operation?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

How can a society commence operations if the rules are not approved?

Comment on this

I did not say they could. They are not a building society until the rules are approved.

Comment on this

If the registrar holds up an application for six months the commencement of the operations of such a society is held up for that period.

Comment on this

That is so but that is the best method. Those who are anxious to start a building society do not make up their minds to do so today and commence operations tomorrow. Even if they submit rules with which the registrar does not agree it follows that they are still making the necessary arrangements to proceed as a building society. I imagine that one of the first things they will do is draw up a set of rules. When that is done they apply to the registrar and then go ahead with arrangements to set up a society. Unless there is something terribly wrong with their rules—in which case they should never have started—they will eventually get their rules cleared. "Eventually" in this case means not later than six months after the application is made. If it runs beyond that period, they have a right to go to court. It is preferable to have it this way rather than have a shorter period and have discussions breaking down resulting in expensive court actions over something which could be solved over discussions.

Comment on this

I suggest a compromise similar to that brought in by the Minister on the Bill dealing with planning, an amendment which gives an applicant the right to go to the planning authority and say that the application can be held for two months or four months while negotiations proceed. Could the Minister do that in the case of building societies, that the registrar can hold the application for three months and a further three months, by agreement?

Comment on this

Although I can see the merit in Deputy Burke's point, I would prefer not to do that. I can see arguments against it. We are talking about the extreme case here. The number of societies that will be registered will be very small. Of that number a small proportion may submit a rule or rules which are not acceptable. It would be a mistake in order to try to rush things if we did something which would work against the general body of societies. A society interested in going ahead will wait that period to have the rules approved. I would prefer to leave it as it is.

Comment on this

The only reason I mentioned the point is to endorse what Deputy Faulkner said. If you write six months or any period into a Bill, instead of becoming the maximum it becomes the normal. That is what I was afraid of.

Comment on this

We intend to make it clear to the registrar if it is necessary —and I do not think it should be necessary to do so—that this is only the extreme case where it will drag along. There can be reasons why it may take that time. He will have the right to sanction rules as soon as he is satisfied, whether that is within a week, or a day, or whatever it is. Section 10 lays down what they are expected to meet so it should not be so difficult.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

Deputy Burke has brought out an excellent point. One does not want the registrar's office sitting on every application for at least six months and arriving at a decision in the last week. One would hope there would be consultations throughout the whole period and that, in most cases, it would be a great deal less than six months. The public must be protected by giving the registrar a longer period to enable him, if necessary, to go into the various financial and legal matters that will arise.

Comment on this

I agree fully.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 2 is in the name of Deputy Faulkner. I observe that amendments Nos. 3, 7, 10 and 11 are cognate. I suggest that we debate them together, with separate decisions if necessary.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 9, subsection (6), line 24, after "society" to insert "within two months."

I notice that in the Bill the registrar is required to take various actions and that no time period is specified within which a decision must be taken. In contrast to that, there are a number of occasions where the societies are compelled to take action within a specified time limit. Our whole approach on this side of the House is towards giving more power to the registrar, but we still believe some checks and controls are necessary. In most Local Government Bills, on contentious matters local authorities are required to give their decisions within specified time limits. It seems reasonable, therefore, that the registrar should be similarly constrained. This would have the additional advantage of ensuring he has adequate staff to carry out his legal obligations.

By a special resolution, the building societies can alter their rules. If they decide to do so, we must assume the alteration is being made for the benefit of the society and their members. The registrar may decide to accept the change in the rules or to reject it, and an appeal may then be made to the courts. If the society believe the alteration is beneficial to their members, the longer the decision is held up the greater the disadvantage to the members concerned. As I said earlier, to ensure that a decision of this kind is not put on the long finger, we should leave it open to the registrar to delay a decision for a limited period of time, but we should specify the time within which he must make a decision.

Comment on this

I said on Second Reading of this Bill and on a number of other Bills that this is a matter which is in the interests of everybody in this House. The Bill is the property of the House and the House have the right to make amendments if they consider them necessary. As on previous Bills, I will welcome any reasonable amendment which will improve the Bill. If I think an amendment will not improve the Bill or is not necessary, I will say so. I can easily see the merit of what Deputy Faulkner is proposing in these amendments. I accept the principle that a time limit should be set within which the registrar should be required to give a decision. I visualise that the registrar will be very involved with the societies and the need for the time limit will not arise in practice. In most of the cases mentioned, I agree that two months is an acceptable limit, but I would suggest to Deputy Faulkner that in the case of section 19 regarding an application for permission to advertise for funds, a time limit of six months would be more appropriate. The registrar is statutorily bound to take into account a large number of factors under section 19 and a limit of two months might become impracticable.

As regards the amendment he proposes to section 30, amendment No. 11, this section derives from section 169 of the Companies Act, 1963. There is no time limit in the section in the Companies Act and the practice throughout this Bill has been to follow, rather than anticipate, company law. Furthermore, this is mainly a matter of internal communication and I do not think a time limit is really necessary. I propose, therefore, to accept in principle amendments Nos. 2, 3 and 10, and No. 7 amended to six months. As the precise wording needs to be looked at, with the permission of the House I will introduce an amendment on Report Stage. I thank Deputy Faulkner for bringing the matter to my notice.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): The Minister is right to accept the spirit of Deputy Faulkner's proposal. I would not agree with the Minister's suggestion that we should follow what happened in the past only. We should be looking forward too.

Comment on this

Company law.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Company law has often been changed. Some time limit should be in the Bill. The Minister said he is accepting the principle of Deputy Faulkner's amendments and that he will bring in an amendment covering a period of six months. It is hardly necessary for the registrar to take six months to make his decision. Other sections in the Bill are more complicated. Six months is a bit long. Perhaps three months would be a compromise between Deputy Faulkner and the Minister. Deputy Faulkner is quite right in putting some time limit in this and other sections in the Bill. Otherwise a decision would be left to the discretion of the registrar and it could lie on his desk for 12 months or two years. This is an omission from the Bill which the Minister will rectify on Report Stage.

Comment on this

Six months is the lowest I can go. If the Deputy looks at section 19 (5) (a)——

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I had not looked at that.

Comment on this

There are so many things the registrar must do that six months is a reasonable limit.

Comment on this

I should like to express my appreciation of the Minister's acceptance of my amendments. I recognised that there was a difference between the various sections when I submitted the amendments. I recognise that in the promotion of advertising it is, perhaps, a bit more difficult than it is in relation to some of the other amendments.

I will accept the Minister's proposal and I take it he will bring the amendments in on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I understand, therefore, that amendment No. 2 is agreed to.

Comment on this

No. I do not know whether technically it would have to be withdrawn on condition that it would be reintroduced. Would that be the proper procedure?

Comment on this

Yes, on condition that it would be reintroduced.

Comment on this

Yes. If the wording fits we shall leave it as it is.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Amendment No. 3 has been discussed and I take it is not being moved?

Comment on this

On condition that it is reintroduced on Report Stage.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): The Minister stated earlier that the purpose for which the building societies are established is primarily for the building of houses. Subsection (1) states:

A society shall, so far as is necessary for the purpose for which it was established, have power to hold land with the right of sale.

I did not think building societies could buy land as they are established at the moment, but evidently this subsection gives them this right. Does this mean they can go into commercial development?

Comment on this

No. They can buy land for the purpose of building an office. I can understand why the Deputy has this impression, but they cannot—and this is what was happening—go out and buy land for speculation purposes. This section, which is a re-enactment of existing provisions, allows a society to hold land or buildings for the purpose of conducting its business. The section has been drafted tightly and would not allow a society to become involved in land speculation or land development. A society may hold only such land and buildings as are necessary to enable it to conduct its business as a building society, that is, to raise funds and make loans to members. The purpose for which a society may be established is clearly defined in section 2 as being the raising of funds for making loans to members by the mortgage of freehold or leasehold estate.

There are a number of fields of commercial activity which are incidental to building society operations. These would include, for instance, bridging loans, fire insurance and life assurance. Arguments have also been put forward that societies' close involvement with the property market places them in a good position to become more directly involved in that market. Much consideration has been given to these questions but, on balance, it is felt that the interests of the building society movement as a whole and, in particular, the security and confidence enjoyed by investors, are best served by allowing societies to operate only within their traditional limits of accepting funds and making loans to members on the security of freehold or leasehold estate.

This power to hold land is, accordingly, being limited by subsection (1) to that purpose. Subsections (2) and (3) enable a society to acquire land for the purpose of erecting an office for the conduct of its business, but the section does not permit a society to hold land for development purposes.

Comment on this

While I accept the Minister's good faith in this, I believe the section is broad enough as it is worded here to allow flexibility as far as the society is concerned. Take office development, for example. What is to stop a society buying a site, deciding they are going to build an office; they get a better offer for their site six months later and then sell the site? I am not saying they would do it meaning any harm, but is this type of speculation stopped in section 16? It should be written into the rules of the society that that type of operation will not be allowed.

Comment on this

If Deputy Burke looks at section 76 he will see that is covered.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Why they could not bring the provisions together I do not know. As subsection (3) of this section reads the society may purchase, hold or lease land for the sole purpose of erecting on it a building for conducting a business, and the next subsection says the society “may sell, exchange or let”. Under that section I could erect a building, have part of it for my building society office and let a substantial amount of it as a hotel. I I know that under section 76 that is tied up.

Comment on this

Unfortunately we cannot write it all into one section. We have tried to avoid running a line from an early section to a later one. Also, it is very annoying to have to relate back to previous Acts. Luckily there were only two previous Acts dealing with building societies in the last century, so it is not so bad. Deputies can be assured that the point is well covered.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): Section 16 does not refer us to any other provision in the Bill. It does not say “subject to—”.

Comment on this

It is not necessary to do that, because section 76 itself is quite clear. The Ceann Comhairle would probably prevent us from dealing with section 76 now; it is one of the contentious ones.

Comment on this

Any legislation passed here should be capable of being understood by the layman, the man who would be investing in the building societies. To avoid any misunderstanding, surely the Minister could write something into the section that would clarify it, even by referring it to section 76.

Comment on this

We have already discussed the reasons for which building societies were established. Section 16 (1) says:

A society shall, so far as is necessary for the purpose for which it was established, have power to hold land with the right of sale.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): That is better.

Comment on this

That is as clear as crystal to anybody who has any interest in a building society, even the man going in to invest his "fiver". The reasons are set out why the building societies were established and the purposes for which they can hold land. That is clear enough without going to section 76, but 76 clinches it.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

The Minister has stated clearly that, on the one hand, there is the fact that the building societies do not want and have not been given the right in any way to indulge in land or property speculation. At the same time, it would be unfair to place them in a position in which they were unable to buy a property for the purpose of carrying on the administration necessary to their business. Some of the societies are doing vast business and have vast administrative offices. It would be very unfair to leave them in the position that they dare not buy any property, because they were held up somehow on a right of sale, if such was necessary for their business. The Act recognises that there is a possibility that something might occur which gives them the right of sale.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): What does subsection (4) mean to the Deputy?

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Mr. M.E. Dockrell Fine Gael

They may sell or let any building or land mentioned in subsection (2) or (3) which is for the purpose of conducting their business. It may want to move to bigger premises so it may have to sell its property or part of its property. It is right to ensure that societies cannot indulge in land speculation and property speculation. Certainly they do not want to. They have enough speculation in a sense with each individual loan but, at the same time, the Bill recognises that they must not be placed in an unfair position in relation to all other forms of financial business. In other words, they must be able to sell their own property if it is in their interest to do so.

Comment on this

While nobody would disagree with what Deputy Dockrell says, many people would be worried about section (2). A building society could build an office block, use one room in the office block themselves and let the rest of the block at a profit. That is very good business, but that is not what they were established for. Building societies were established for house building and not for building office blocks. Office block building is a very lucrative business to be in and there is a temptation for building societies to build and let an office block and bring in plenty of money. While I know that this section cannot be omitted we should look at it further and ensure that building societies will recognise that their reason for existence is to make money available for house building. A building society could become very prosperous and move out of its original sphere of activities, and we would have big property developers making plenty of money and even ploughing money back into house loans but they would be missing out on their essential purpose which is to devote all their energies towards providing house loans. Deputy Dockrell made a very good case when he said that we cannot tie them down altogether. We do not want to but we should write in every possible precaution to impress on them that the Oireachtas adopted this legislation to make them better prepared to provide more house loans and we do not want to see them go overboard on office developments.

Comment on this

Possibly we are going a little wide of the mark. I refer Deputy Moore particularly back to section 2, the definition section, page 5, line 10 which says:

"society" means a building society established under this Act for the purpose of raising, in accordance with this Act, funds (by the subscriptions of the members, the acceptance of deposits and loans) for making loans to members on security by the mortgage of freehold or leasehold estate or interest;

At present by arrangement between the Minister for Local Government and the societies 90 per cent of the net inflow must be spent on mortgages for houses. The suggestion that we are putting something in here which will allow building societies to go out and start building office blocks all over the place and completely ignore the object for which they were set up is wrong. The Registrar of Building Societies will not allow that to happen because it would be an infringement of this section. What Deputy Dockrell said was that if a society require an office and they purchase a building in which such an office is, it would be perfectly in order for them to make a transaction which would result in the sale or disposal of the remainder of the offices. They could make money on that which could be re-invested provided they stayed within their 10 per cent. We are talking about building societies whose object is to build houses and we are labouring the point. We are making a lot of something which is not a serious matter. Even under existing legislation it has been possible to confine them to 10 per cent. Under the new legislation we resisted the temptation to widen the scope; they must stay within their own ambit. I think it would be a mistake if we attempted to tighten the Bill any further.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): I would not like to inhibit the expansion of the building societies in any way. I take the point that Deputy Dockrell has made, that if a society expands it requires new offices. Naturally, building societies are in business to make money. When I read the section I thought that it was rather broad in its context in relation to the previous sections which the Minister had defined so closely.

Comment on this

I appreciate that but I am satisfied that we have it as tight as it would be reasonable to have it.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

As amendments numbers 4 and 20 are related they may be taken together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4.

In page 11, subsection (5), line 31, to delete "twenty-one" and substitute "eighteen".

Section 17, subsection (5) reads:

A person under the age of twenty-one years may be admitted as a member of any society the rules of which do not prohibit such admission and can give all necessary receipts, but while he is under that age he shall not be entitled to vote or to hold office.

I believe that this subsection as it stands is very much out of date. Many young people are marrying and becoming houseowners before the age of 21 and, more important still, they can vote in Dáil and local elections and they can become members of this House. Yet in this Bill they are given less than their full rights. I am aware of the argument put forward by the Minister when supporting this anomaly in the Seanad when the Minister said that the Department of Justice was preparing a law for changing the age of majority and that when such legislation was passed all reference in this legislation to 21 years would automatically change to 18 years. I can see no reason why we should wait for that day. This legislation is now before us and the Minister says it will last for a long time. If we are to consider it in the context of the length of time since the previous legislation on building societies was enacted, it certainly will last a long time. If this new legislation has to be amended in a few months when the legislation mentioned by the Minister is passed, then I can see no reason why we should not amend the legislation now and insert 18 instead of 21. The same arguments I put forward in relation to section 17 relate perhaps even more closely to section 53 (2). To suggest that the person who can vote for those who govern the country is not regarded as a fit and proper person to vote in elections on issues relating to building societies is ridiculous. Therefore, I commend the amendments to the Minister.

Comment on this

I wish to support everything said by Deputy Faulkner. It is ludicrous that a person of 18 who is entitled to vote for his representative in the Dáil is treated in this way in this legislation. Many young people between 18 years and 21 years are getting married and they are put into an awkward position in regard to mortgages. I should like the Minister to give serious thought to this and to accept the amendments.

I realise the Minister is anxious to wait for the overall change with regard to majority age which is being drafted in the Department of Justice but we have seen instances where other Bills have been delayed in that Department and in others. Various problems can arise that delay the drafting of Bills. We should not wait for the general Bill but should make the decision as we go along. Here is a classic example of problems being put in the way of young people by legislation. We had a referendum and the people expressed their wishes regarding the role of people of 18 years and we should not go against the general wish of the public. The Minister should accept the amendments.

Comment on this

Nobody in this House is more anxious to give rights to 18-year-olds than I am. I would point out that the first Bill I piloted through the House was the measure that gave 18-year-olds the right to vote. In this case it is not simply a question of putting this into the legislation and thus making it operative. If that were the case I would be prepared to say this was the right thing to do but I am advised that putting in that provision here would not make it operative.

Until the Law Reform Commission have completed their investigations and until the legislation is passed reducing the age of majority to 18 years, a person under 21 years is still a minor. As such he is not entitled to sign a contract and, if a contract is signed, he can repudiate it unless it can be proven that it would be in his own interest not to do so. In those circumstances I do not think anybody, never mind a building society, would be prepared to accept the signature of somebody under the age of majority.

I have every sympathy with Deputy Faulkner's amendments. I know he thinks of this matter in the same way as I do. A young person can carry a gun to defend the State but he is still a minor until he is 21 years. I could never see the merit in that but until legislation is passed it would be unfair and would be a bad joke on those people if we gave the impression that by writing that provision into this legislation we were giving them something when that was not the case. For that reason I am sorry I cannot accept the amendments and it would be better if the Deputy withdrew them. I will give an assurance to the House that I will do my best to have the age of majority reduced to 18 years. I believe it will come in a relatively short time and it must apply to everybody in all walks of life. When the age is reduced to 18 it will apply to existing law. Where the age of 21 years is entered it will be as if it were 18 years. In the circumstances I would ask the Deputy to withdraw the amendments. They will not do what he wishes and will cause complications.

Comment on this

Section 53 (2) provides that a person under the age of 21 years shall not be entitled to vote at a meeting. I accept that the Minister is as anxious as anybody to have the change made. I am trying to prove whether it is possible for us to make changes here before the Bill is introduced by the Minister for Justice because, as Deputy Burke pointed out, that may be held up for a considerable time. It is absolutely ridiculous that at a meeting of a building society where individuals are being elected to certain positions somebody cannot vote for the person of his choice simply because he is under 21 years but, at the same time, the young person can vote in national and local elections. Young people are being deprived of rights that all of us consider are their entitlement. I think the Minister has pointed out that a person under 21 years is still a minor in law.

Comment on this

A point was made by Deputy Burke regarding loans but neither of the amendments referred to loans. They refer to the right to vote at a meeting of a society and that is an entirely different matter. I am as anxious to give 18-year-olds the same rights as anybody else. If Deputy Faulkner will withdraw the amendments I will have a look at the position before Report Stage. If it does not infringe on the law of contracts I will introduce an amendment that will meet the point he is making. Many people of 18 years come to me and tell me that while they can get a loan they are not allowed to sign the relevant documents. That would still be the position even if we put the requested provision into the Bill.

Comment on this

I had not included that. When the change is made in law relating to the age of majority, will a person under 21 years but over 18 years be allowed to sign the documents?

Comment on this

Once the age of majority becomes 18 all those rights will accrue to that young person.

Comment on this

I accept that there are problems in this matter and I will leave it to the Minister to have a look at it. In a comparatively simple matter of electing officers in a building society it seems strange that a person under 21 is not permitted to voice his opinions by way of a vote when he can do so in a national election.

Comment on this
Tom J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fianna Fáil

(Dublin Central): This problem arose with regard to the Finance Bill last year. When will the Law Reform Commission make some effort with regard to this matter? This question has arisen on numerous occasions in the last four years—it applies to many areas.

Comment on this