Building Societies Bill, 1975 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 141–280 of 280. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1975 ›
I could also say I have been listening to this for a very long time. Remember how long it took us to get the Constitution and the voting age changed. The thinking of those preparing this report is that it would be better to take a little longer because it is a very important issue. There are so many different facets. That is why it is being held up. I have yet to meet somebody, except, say, a crank, who will say that they do not believe that the age of majority should be 18 not 21. Therefore, Deputies can be assured that, as early as it can be done, the necessary legislation will be introduced.
Comment on this
I agree to withdraw the amendment on the basis that the Minister will have a look at it.
Comment on this
Is it wise to include subsection (2), which allows a building society to make a loan available to a person who is not a shareholder in the society?
Comment on this
Is it wise to build into this legislation a provision under which a building society can, in law, make a loan available to a person who has not a share or an interest in a building society?
Comment on this
Deputy O'Leary will be the most unpopular man in the country if that is published in the newspapers. I am quite sure the Deputy does not mean it exactly as he has put it. I would ask him if he would consider rephrasing it. There are thousands of people who have got loans from building societies who could not have done so unless they were legally entitled to get such loans, who are not shareholders, who never had any money invested. I think I know what Deputy O'Leary is thinking of—as do all of us—that everybody should be encouraged to save some money and to invest it in societies.
Comment on this
But there are lots of people who have not found it possible to do that, who want to buy or build a house, who have applied to a society and, if there is adequate money available, have got such loans. It would be a tragedy if we did not continue that arrangement. I think Deputy O'Leary does not mean that but that is what it sounds like.
Comment on this
I would have no objection, say, to including this in the rules of a society, or allowing a building society to make loans available to people who have not shares in it. I think it unwise to build into legislation a provision under which people, even without a £5 share or £10 share in a building society, can get a loan while, at the same time, other people can get a loan by reason of the fact that they have a share in a building society.
Comment on this
A society, subject to its rules, may allow a person to whom a loan is being made to become a member without holding a share. This subsection specifies the liability of such a person. In the definitions section "society" is defined as a building society established for making loans to members. In order to comply with this definition a building society is enabled to make a loan to a noninvestor by allowing him to become a member without holding a share, obviating the need for advance shares, which was the practice in many societies and will not disturb the practice of issuing advance shares. The liability of a person to whom this subsection applies, in effect, will be that of the holder of an advance share, that is, the amount of the mortgage deed itself.
As I said to Deputy O'Leary, to stipulate that if somebody had not got money invested they were not entitled to borrow money would simply mean either that building societies would have to go back to a statutory arrangement under which the shares would be referred to as advance shares or, alternatively, applicants for loans would have to put in a nominal sum, go through the motions of becoming a member, and then proceed to draw money out. I do not think either would be desirable and would merely further complicate the matter. In view of what is happening, particularly this year in which an enormous number of people have drawn money without being members, it would be a pity if we interfered with that arrangement. If Deputy O'Leary takes another look at it he will realise it would be a pity to do so.
Comment on this
I raised a point with the Minister on section 10, line 26 onwards, in regard to the rights of members to requisition meetings and the form of meetings. I made the point to the Minister of the person who got a mortgage and asked was he then a member. Here he is automatically being made a member when he gets a loan. Is that not correct?
Comment on this
Just for clarification, is it specified in an earlier section?
Comment on this
Would the Minister say why it is necessary to have subsection (2) in the Bill? Surely the Minister will agree that a person with a £100, £50 or £25 share in a building society should have a prior right to a loan rather than a person who has no share at all in a building society?
Comment on this
Of course, he has. Suppose on the first of any particular month a particular building society have £1 million they want to loan for the purpose of building houses and by the 28th of that month they have loaned only £500,000. Although they may have claims with them from people who are not members of the society for £2 million should they hold on to that and say: "No, although you want the money, we are holding this just in case somebody who has an investment in the society wants to borrow money." The point being missed is that an awful lot of people invest money in societies for the purpose of getting a loan and initially indicate that by saying: "We will be looking for a loan at a later date." However, an awful lot of people invest money in societies because it is an investment; it is a safe income on which tax will not be payable and which they are sure of getting.
To insert a stipulation saying that unless somebody had an investment with a society they were not entitled to borrow money would be the cause of an uproar, particularly as the societies themselves, if they find they have 100 applications on hand and 50 of them are from members, will give priority to those 50 members. That is an established practice and is as it should be. I am trying to go easy on Deputy O'Leary because I am sure he does not mean what he appears to be saying. It might give the impression that Deputy O'Leary is opposed to anybody except those with money invested in building societies being allowed to draw moneys from them. I do not think that is what he means but that is what he is saying.
Comment on this
Possibly the confusion that has arisen here relates to what Deputy Burke raised earlier. Deputy Burke asked if a person who got a loan automatically became a member and he was told that he did not; unless he had shares he did not automatically become a member.
Comment on this
I am sorry, Deputy, that is not what I said. I said he was a member without voting rights.
Comment on this
I said that if somebody borrowed money from Deputy Ray Burke or myself we should not, or would not, give them the right to run our business, or have a say in the running of our business so that it would make money to lend them more but that those who would put money in the business would naturally have their voting rights. That was the very first point I made.
Comment on this
Reverting to the last time I spoke, the Minister referred me to the definition of the word "society". If the Minister looks at it he will see that "society" means:
A building society established under this Act for the purpose of raising in accordance with this Act, funds (by the subscriptions of the members, the acceptance of deposits and loans) for making loans to members on security by the mortgage of freehold or leasehold estate or interest.
It says "by making loans to members".
Comment on this
They automatically become members. I am sorry if I am not getting through. They become members when they borrow money but they do not become members with voting rights.
Comment on this
Subsection (6) (a) (i) states:
the person whose name first appears in the records of the society in relation to shares jointly held shall be the senior joint holder.
Is that necessary? If shares are jointly held by a man and his wife and if he is a chivalrous husband and lets his wife sign first she would become the senior joint holder. This could lead to trouble further on. It should be enough if they are on the register as joint holders.
Comment on this
It is only for the purpose of issuing the notice instead of sending out two notices. The person who is first on the list will receive it.
Comment on this
Suppose there was some difference between the husband and the wife afterwards, could either use the voting rights without the consent of the other person?
Comment on this
This can happen in a lot of things. The husband or wife could get the letter. We could not legislate for matters of difference like this.
Comment on this
Subsection (6) (a) (iii) states:
Where under this Act a member of a society may attend and vote at a meeting by virtue of being a holder of shares in the society, and such person is a joint holder of such shares, the person entitled to exercise the rights conferred by sections 52, 53 and 54 shall, notwithstanding anything in those sections, be the senior joint holder;
What Deputy Moore is attempting to put across—there may be a lot of merit in it but not in this Bill—is that there should be some way of differentiating that if the husband and wife have a dispute, even if it is only a temporary one, the husband or wife, whichever name is down first, should not be entitled to go along and vote for the other person. If we started to do that we could have a lot of fun but we would not solve the problem. I suggest that we leave it as it is. We are following the recognised regulation and I suggest that Deputy Moore agree with me.
Comment on this
The object is to save money for societies, shareholders and mortgagees because post costs a lot if notice has to be sent out to thousands and thousands of people. I feel strongly about the register of electors in this regard also. Politicians do something similar but it does not cost us as much money.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 5:
In page 12, before section 18, to insert the following new section:
"18. —(1) A society shall not raise any funds under section 22 after the commencement of this section unless—
(a) written evidence has been produced to the Registrar satisfying him that not less than ten of the appropriate persons (or where there are less than ten, all such persons) have each been issued with shares in the society to a value not less than such sum as may be prescribed by the Minister after consultation with the Minister for Finance, and that the total value of such shares is not less than such sum as may be prescribed by the Minister after such consultation,
(b) written evidence has been produced to the Registrar satisfying him that the appropriate persons have been paid to the society the prescribed sums in cash for those shares,
(c) written evidence has been produced to the Registrar satisfying him that the society has complied with section 20, and
(d) the Registrar has certified that the evidence referred to in paragraphs (a) to (c) has been produced.
(2) For the purposes of subsection (1) the appropriate persons are—
(a) in the case of a society which is incorporated on or after the 5th day of December, 1975, the persons who established the society, and
(b) in the case of any other society, the directors of the society.
(3) (a) The terms applicable to the shares to which subsection (1) (a) refers shall not, either at the time when the shares are issued or at any time before the expiration of five years from the date on which the Registrar's certificate referred to in subsection (1) (d) is issued, be in any respect more favourable than those applicable to any other shares issued by the society.
(b) Within the five-year period referred to in paragraph (a) a society shall not give effect to or recognise any transfer of shares referred to in subsection (1) (a) other than a transfer by operation of law.
(c) For the purposes of paragraph (a) "terms" shall include rate of interest, dividend or bonus, liability to contribute to losses, rights on a transfer of engagements or winding-up of the society or on the union of the society with another society.
(4) Within the five-year period referred to in subsection (3) a society shall not repay the sum (or any part thereof) subscribed for the shares referred to in subsection (1) (a) unless during the period the society is wound up under section 95 or a transfer of its engagements to another society has been registered by the Registrar under sections 26 or 27 or a person who has subscribed for those shares becomes disqualified under this Act or dies.
(5) Where a person referred to in subsection (4) becomes disqualified or dies, either—
(a) the remaining persons who subscribed for the shares referred to in subsection (1) (a) shall within the period of 30 days after the disqualification or death pay to the society sums in cash equal to the aggregate to the sum subscribed by the person becoming disqualified or dying, and shall be issued with shares in the society to the value so subscribed, or
(b) any other person not disqualified under this Act may subscribe in cash for, and be issued with, shares in the society to a value not less than the sum subscribed by the person disqualified or dying,
and the provisions of subsection (3) shall apply to shares issued under this subsection.
(6) The evidence referred to in subsection (1) shall be produced to the Registrar—
(a) in the case of a society which is incorporated on or after the commencement of this section, within three months from the date of incorporation;
(b) in the case of any other society, within three months from the commencement of this section;
(7) Where a society fails to produce to the Registrar within the appropriate period specified in subsection (6) the evidence referred to in subsection (1)—
(a) in the case of a society which is incorporated on or after the commencement of this section, the Registrar may cancel the registration of the society under section 94;
(b) in the case of any other society, the Registrar may take an application to the Court under section 95 for the winding-up of the society.
(8) If a society to which this section applies raises any funds in contravention of this section, or if at any time within the five-year period referred to in subsection (3) any provision in that subsection or in subsection (4) is not complied with, the Registrar may make an application to the Court under section 95 for the winding-up of the society.
(9) For the purposes of this section, the shares referred to in subsection (1) (a) shall be deemed not to be shares issued under section 22.
(10) This section shall not apply to—
(a) any society which was incorporated on or before the 5th day of December, 1973 and which, during the two-year period ended on the 5th day of December, 1975, raised funds and made loans to members on the security of freehold or leasehold estate,
(b) any society which was incorporated during the two-year period ended on the 5th day of December, 1975 and which, on that date, had assets of not less than £20,000."
Sections 18 and 20 deal with certain matters relating to the commencement and carrying on of business by a society. The situation which exists at present is that where any four persons wishing to establish a society submit rules for registration, the registrar has little or no option but to register the rules and incorporate the society. Once registration has been obtained, the society may immediately advertise and begin accepting funds from the public. Bearing in mind the scale of operations of societies at present, this situation is considered most unsatisfactory. The provisions of section 18 are designed to remedy the matter to some extent by prohibiting societies from accepting any funds until they have complied with certain requirements.
The purpose of the amendment before the House is simply to meet some inadequacies of detail which become apparent in the text of section 18 as it now stands. I will elaborate on these points of detail in a moment. In the main, however, the proposed amended version of the section does not differ from the existing text. The purpose still remains of prohibiting a society from accepting funds until it had met with certain requirements. These requirements are that:
(a) the founder-members must each have been issued with, and paid in cash for, shares in the society to a value not less than that specified by the Minister for Local Government, after consultation with the Minister for Finance, and
(b) the society must have deposited funds with the Central Bank in accordance with section 20.
Certain restrictions are placed on the founder-members' shares—for example, the terms applying to them cannot be more favourable than those applying to other shares in the society and they cannot be repaid or transferred within five years. This is to ensure that persons establishing a society shall have and maintain a minimum interest in the society from the start and will, therefore, see to its proper management. The purpose of the deposit at the Central Bank is to provide a measure of protection for investors' funds.
Societies which do not comply with the requirements of the section may have their registration cancelled, or may be wound up. It transpires, however, that a situation could arise with the section, as it stands, where the founders of an existing society, which may have been established for some years, could now be required to contribute substantial amounts if it is to be allowed to continue in operation. I am not satisfied that this would be either equitable or feasible as, in certain cases, some or all of the founders might have ceased to be associated with the society or might even have died. Accordingly I am now proposing that, in the case of an existing society coming within the terms of the section, the shares should be subscribed by the directors, rather than by the founders.
It is provided in subsection (2) (a) of the Bill that the terms applicable to the founders' shares shall not be more favourable than those applicable to "any other shares of that class" in the society. It could be argued that the founder shares could themselves constitute a "class of shares" and, in that case, subsection (2) (a) would not be effective. I am therefore proposing that the terms shall not be more favourable than those applying to "any other shares" issued by the society and the meaning of "terms" is being spelled out in detail.
It is not proposed that societies which are actively carrying on business, that is, accepting shares and deposits and making loans, should come within the ambit of the section. I am satisfied even that societies fairly recently established and which proceeded to build up a fund for the making of loans should also be excluded.
There are, however, a number of registered societies which have never carried on any business but which were established in an attempt to circumvent the provisions of the Bill and, presumably, to confer some advantage on the founders. It is proposed that the provisions of the section should apply in full to these societies. Similarly, there are a number of very old societies which have long ceased to function but which could be taken over and reactivated by persons seeking to circumvent the provisions of the Bill. It is proposed that the provisions of the section should apply in full to these societies also.
The proposed amendment to the section has, accordingly, been drafted so as to apply the section to three categories of societies. These are:
(i) all new societies established after the Bill was published,
(ii) societies established more than two years before the Bill was published but which in the two years prior to publication did not make any loans to members, that is, old dormant societies, and
(iii) societies established during the two years prior to publication but which at the date of publication did not have total assets of more than £20,000.
I consider that the section, as amended, would be more watertight and more really enforceable than the original section and so I commend amendment No. 5 to the House for its approval.
I also commend amendment No. 8 to the House. This amendment is consequential on amendment No. 5 and serves only to maintain consistency between the terms used in sections 18 and 20.
Comment on this
The Chair should have mentioned that amendment No. 8 is consequential on amendment No. 5 and both may be discussed together.
Comment on this
We accept the amendment. The explanation given by the Minister in relation to section 18 would be very much the same if he had not made the change except, as he pointed out, to make the section more watertight. The Minister's statement, in the main, referred to the situation as it was in the original section.
Comment on this
The acceptance of that amendment means that a new section is inserted and section 18 deleted.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Do I take it that the Chair is telling the House that we have passed that section?
Comment on this
The old section 18 is deleted and this new section inserted. The amendment which we have disposed of relates to the insertion of a new section.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I thought that when we adopted the amendment I could then speak on the section.
Comment on this
The acceptance of the amendment meant the deletion of the old section and the insertion of this new one.
Comment on this
If the Deputy has some comments which he feels might be helpful to me I have no objection to his making them.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): With regard to the provision in relation to the death or disqualification of one of the founder members or directors and of the fact that the subscription be made by the other members within 30 days, is there an obligation placed on the remaining members to take up these shares within 30 days?
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): That is what I thought. In the event of a death or disqualification of a member I can visualise a situation arising where it would not be financially possible for the surviving shareholders to take up the funds which the person who died or was disqualified could not hold. In that event what will the situation be with that society? Is there any provision whereby this can be overcome?
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Assuming that a member cannot be found to subscribe in cash for, and be issued with, shares in the society to a value not less than the sum subscribed by the person becoming disqualified or dying, what is the position?
Comment on this
Does the Deputy feel that because somebody dies or is disqualified there should be a lacuna— a word over used by a former Minister —that there should be a term during which nothing would happen, like Mohammed's coffin that is shared between heaven and earth? Surely it is in the interests of everybody that the remaining members take up these shares. If they are not able to do that, they will find a reputable person who will fill in and take up the shares. I am sure there will be no difficulty about doing that. If there is, I assume the registrar will have to decide what is to be done. If the money cannot be found I can only assume that that society was in a bad way. Steps would have to be taken to deal with that society if that could not be done. The alternative to what is in the Bill is that the society is on its way out.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I do not accept the view that it will be possible too often to get people to rush in with £10,000 to be deposited in the Central Bank at 1 per cent over lending rate. It may be difficult to get an outsider to take up the shares. In the event of the remaining members not being able to take up the shares would the Minister or the registrar force that society out of business?
Comment on this
If the Deputy wishes to put down an amendment for Report Stage he is entitled to do so. As far as I am concerned what is proposed in the new section is a sensible arrangement. We either allow the people who may claim to have a proprietary right as they are the remaining members to take up the shares or if they cannot do it a reputable person prepared to do it is found. Building societies would come to a sorry state if we reached a stage where nobody was prepared to do this. Deputy Fitzpatrick's fears are groundless.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): They are not. Some discretion should be left to the registrar with regard to the remaining members, even if they are not able to come up with the money.
Comment on this
If I accepted Deputy Fitzpatrick's point I would be leaving a wide open trail for somebody to dash through in order to spoil the whole thing.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I do not mean that but the registrar should be given a discretion in a unique situation where a company through its own members was not able to find the capital. I do not wish to see this abused.
Comment on this
Subsection (7) (a) and (b) states:
(a) in the case of a society which is incorporated on or after the commencement of this section, the Registrar may cancel the registration of the society under section 94;
(b) in the case of any other society, the Registrar may make an application to the court under section 95 for the winding up of the society.
There is a discretion there; the word "may" is used in both cases. I would hate to see it being used because a society that would find itself in that position would not be one that would encourage a lot of investment.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I was referring to a genuine society that may find itself in that position.
Comment on this
I do not think we can legislate for the failure of people to produce the necessary money or the necessary numbers we are demanding in the Bill. Deputy Fitzpatrick's ideas confuse me. In my view he is trying to bring about a situation which would contravene the terms of the Bill. The Registrar cannot do anything contrary to what is in the Bill if the people cannot find the money. If they cannot find the money they cannot run a society and that is all that is about it.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am not trying to do anything to undermine the structures of building societies and I am fully aware of the meaning of the section. I am trying to visualise a situation which may arise of genuine founder members of a society who could find themselves faced with this. I should like the Registrar to have strict regulation over this. I am not trying to undermine the structure or weaken it in any way. It struck me that the section could cause complications at some future date for some genuine group who started a building society and lived up to their promises and carried out their functions. They could find themselves in this kind of situation.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 14, to delete lines 20 to 25 and to substitute the following paragraph—
"(b) the society has complied with the requirements of section 18, if that section applies to it, and with the requirements of section 20;".
Section 19 generally prohibits certain societies from advertising for funds until they have complied with the requirements of the section. The purpose of the amendment is to correct a looseness in the drafting. The intention is to ensure that, if a society are required to issue founder member shares under section 18, the society must comply with the requirements of that section before they can obtain permission to advertise for funds under section 19. It is a drafting amendment.
Comment on this
I should like to welcome any section that will control in some way wasteful advertising by the building societies. By the very nature of their business the building societies must advertise to get funds, but I should like to see some control as to the relationship between the amount of money spent on advertising and the total assets of the societies. A guideline should be set down by the Minister. I do not see any such guidelines in this section setting down a particular figure which a building society cannot exceed in an advertising campaign in one year. If there is such control I should like the Minister to clarify it. We have seen over the past few years a ludicrous amount of advertising, particularly by two or three of the bigger societies. Night after night we have seen this advertising on television. Undoubtedly, it brings in a certain amount of money, but I feel that the same amount of money could be raised with much less wasteful advertising.
Comment on this
This is not the section which deals with the control of advertising. It deals with who may advertise for a certain purpose. Deputy Burke's point can be discussed on section 76, which is the regulation section. However, I should like to deal with the two interesting points which Deputy Burke has raised since they might appear in print and people might get the wrong impression. First of all, if all societies stopped adver tising completely, it would mean a drop in the mortgage rate of one-third of 1 per cent. Secondly, the three building societies to which Deputy Burke referred who have carried on a large amount of advertising are, in fact, the societies whose business has increased very substantially, while those who did not advertise at all or who spent less on advertising have grown very slowly. Since all the building societies offer almost the same conditions it has been suggested that they should combine in some way, but, of course, business people often sell the same goods at the same price and they do not offer to combine. They have their own ways of seeking customers. We can discuss this matter further on section 76.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned one-third of 1 per cent as if it were a small amount of money. This is, in fact, quite a substantial sum.
Comment on this
It would be a retrograde step if we were to prevent building societies from advertising over a certain limit. The flow of funds could drop and fewer people would be able to get loans. The cure would be worse than the disease. We must be very careful on this point.
Comment on this
Deputy Burke does not realise two things. Firstly, if the Minister attempted to limit advertising quantitatively he would inevitably substantiate the position of the larger societies. There would be no free competition. Smaller societies would inevitably be condemned to remain in an inferior position. If that had been done some years ago, many people who are now living in houses and paying off their mortgages would be walking about the streets or the country roads or living with their inlaws. The money would not have come in to make it possible for the societies to lend as much as they have done.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister a question. Section 19 (2) provides:
A society which on the 5th day of December, 1975, had total assets of less than £1,000,000 shall not advertise...
Is the reference here to gross assets or net assets?
Comment on this
I do not necessarily agree with the points made by Deputy Dockrell but I will wait until we come to section 76 to deal with those points.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Do I take it that it is not necessary to have assets of £1 million in order to advertise? In section 19 (2) it states that a society must have assets of £1 million in order to advertise. Does that apply to the smaller companies or companies which are starting business?
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): This I am sure will be forthcoming. It is very difficult for a small company starting off to attract funds and I am sure this will be left to the discretion of the registrar.
Comment on this
In most cases it will be a matter of form, but it will be purely at the discretion of the registrar. I would not like to make rules for the registrar. He would probably resent it.
Comment on this
If the assets had increased considerably since 5th December, 1975, surely he would take that into consideration?
Comment on this
I am sure he would. I should hate to do the registrar's job and I am sure he would hate to do mine.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Section 19 (5) (d) provides:
the society complies with such conditions in relation to liquidity, reserves and other matters of a financial nature as may be prescribed by the Minister for Finance under Part IV;
Have the building societies ever considered the setting up of a rescue fund such as applies in the stock exchange? The various companies in the tourist industry also pool a certain amount of money into a reserve fund.
Comment on this
Two societies which went to the wall during the past couple of years were rescued by the association. I give them credit for being very fair in dealing with these matters and I am sure they will continue to be so.
Comment on this
There is no obligation. They acted without obligation to preserve the good name of the societies. It is good business practice.
Comment on this
Section 19 (7) provides for an appeal to be made to the court against the decision of the registrar. Does this refer to the District Court or to the High Court?
Comment on this
It would be great fun having it appealed to the Circuit Court and from the Circuit Court to the High Court. This is a very serious matter and it would have to start at the High Court.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 15, to delete lines 43 to 56 and substitute the following subsection:
"(10) (a) In the case of a society to which section 18 applies, the initial calculation of the amount of the deposit for the purposes of this section shall be made by the Central Bank as soon as may be after the commencement of this section or as soon as may be after notification by the Registrar of incorporation under section 11, whichever is the later.
(b) In the case of any other society this section shall not apply during the period of three months beginning at the commencement of this section.".
Comment on this
I would like to tell the House I am considering the introduction of a small technical amendment on Report Stage. It is to deal with the Central Bank, subsection (6). It will not affect the Bill but the wording is not what it should be, and I will introduce it on Report Stage.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): As regards the deposits with the Central Bank, I presume once this Bill passes, the larger building societies, as we know them, will have to find £500,000 to deposit with the Central Bank and the other, smaller societies will have to find in the region of £20,000. Has the Minister any fear in his mind that the transfer of this capital from the building societies to the Central Bank will slow down the rate of loans which could be made available to house purchasers?
Comment on this
I do not think it will affect that. Present trends appear to show it will have no effect.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): My information is that the flow of money into the building societies has been slowing down.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I presume the liquid reserves they hold at the moment are in short-term investments carrying a very high interest rate, in the form of gilt edge or something like that. When they transfer them to the Central Bank they will certainly not qualify for the same interest rate.
Comment on this
This is a technical matter but I understand this must be done. I think Deputy Fitzpatrick will agree something like this is necessary.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I agree something like this is necessary, but I said on Second Reading that if some type of securities were lodged, of which they hold a considerable amount for their offices and so on, that would be just as useful for the Central Bank. Although I see the reason for this, I would not like to see the building societies deprived of £500,000, particularly if they are short of cash for housing loans.
Comment on this
At the present time they are running towards £100 million loans this year, which is a great deal of money, so I do not think there is any question of a shortage. I think the Deputy will find it will work out all right.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Money is very expensive and I would not like to see too much of it lying in the Central Bank, where maybe the Minister for Finance could put his hands on it. We know how he uses it.
Comment on this
It touches me when I find the faith the Opposition have that they will never be back in office again.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 9.
In page 17, between lines 54 and 55 to insert a new subsection as follows:
"(8) A deposit or loan to a society, which is permitted under section 19 of this Act to advertise for funds, shall be acceptable as a trustee security for the purposes of section 1 of the Trustee (Authorised Investments) Act, 1958."
Section 1 of the Trustee (Authorised Investments) Act, 1958, specified those investments which are trustee securities. Section 2 authorised the Minister for Finance to vary, by addition or deletion, that list. The trustee status can only be conferred on investment bodies which attain certain qualifications. These qualifications were not specified by the Minister when he spoke in the Seanad debate, but he did not imply that the bulk of building societies would not qualify. He said:
A number of the provisions in this Bill will remove the last obstacle in so far as a number of societies are concerned.
While this may be so, it is still up to the Minister for Finance and the Department of Finance to take action and they could be very slow in doing so, because, for example, this action might slow down the flow of funds into national loans. The amendment we propose would make it automatic that any society which was permitted by the registrar to advertise for funds would have trustee status. It would also make the decision to permit advertising a more crucial one and one that would not be taken without considerable thought. I think we would be in agreement that when a building society is permitted to advertise this will only be done after very careful scrutiny by the registrar and that a building society in such circumstances would be a fit society to be included among those who have the qualifications to be entitled to have trustee money invested with them. As I said, while I recognise that it relates mainly to the Trustee Act, nevertheless, being admitted would result in a very considerable flow of funds into the building society and it would help to stabilise this flow of funds. We have knowledge through past experience of the fact that money flows into the building societies at varying rates. Sometimes the building societies are short of money and cannot fulfil their obligations as happened in 1974; then there was a considerable inflow of money, but in more recent times that has again slowed up and since the bank strike a considerable amount of money which was invested in the building societies has gone back to the banks, in fact, more than the inflow. This resulted in some building societies refusing to grant mortgages, or granting them under stricter regulations, in October, 1976. Membership would create a more stable situation. I strongly urge the Minister to agree to its inclusion in this Bill.
Comment on this
The question of trustee status was raised on Second Stage. I indicated then that the granting of trustee status to building society deposits was a matter for the Minister for Finance under the Trustee Acts, 1893 to 1958. As the Minister responsible for housing, I should like trustee status to be given to certain building society deposits as it would open up a new range of investment funds for building societies.
Deputy Faulkner's amendment seeks to confer trustee status on deposits with any building society. This would be an easy way for me to boost the inflow of funds to building societies, but I must resist the temptation to do so. In the first instance the granting of trustee status is a matter for the Minister for Finance. A society would have to satisfy more rigid financial criteria than those set out in section 19, which deals only with permission to advertise. When an Act such as the Trustee (Authorised Investments) Act, 1958, exists, which deals fully with the matter, it would be absurd to begin the proliferation of references to trustee status in a variety of enactments. The provision in the Bill will remove obstacles which have been in the way to granting this status to building societies.
To accept Deputy Faulkner's amendment would amount to bad legislation and I recommend that it be withdrawn. I am anxious to see trustee status granted. I am sure that within a relatively short time of the enactment of this Bill most of the societies will obtain trustee status. It is important that it does not become the right of any society to get it and for that reason I would ask Deputy Faulkner to withdraw his amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister said that my amendment would appear to grant the right to any building society to obtain trustee status. That is not so. My amendment specifically states that only building societies authorised to advertise for funds should achieve this status. Any building society which has to go through the stringent examination which would be necessary before it was permitted to advertise would be a suitable subject for trustee status. The Bill provides that the Minister may consult with his colleague, the Minister for Finance. When we get to the Committee Stage the Minister for Finance will know what is likely to arise under this Bill and he could agree with the Minister for Local Government that trustee status should be granted to the type of society I have referred to. The Minister will agree that, having gone through the process which will be necessary to ensure that a society has the right to advertise, there can be no doubt that such a society will be a suitable subject for trustee status. Apart from an increased flow of funds, it would stabilise the situation and we would not have a continuation of the stopgo situation to which we have become accustomed.
Comment on this
The Deputy is oversimplifying the matter. Trustee status will be granted quickly after the passing of the Bill. The Minister for Finance and I are in agreement on this matter. Deputy Faulkner's amendment reads:
A deposit or loan to a society, which is permitted under section 19 of this Act to advertise for funds, shall be acceptable as a trustee security for the purposes of section 1 of the Trustee (Authorised Investments) Act, 1958.
In other words, Deputy Faulkner says that every building society is entitled to trustee status.
Comment on this
If they cannot advertise they are not an active building society. Deputy Faulkner is saying that as soon as a building society is allowed to operate it is entitled to full trustee status. I could not accept an amendment which would give that authority. Some people have found ways to circumvent the existing legislation. If trustee status had been granted a serious situation could have arisen.
Comment on this
We share the Minister's hope that the passing of this legislation will strengthen the structure of the building societies. If the amendment is not accepted it could be said that it will not give trustee status to building societies. While we want to see money flowing into the housing fund, it may well be that other Government Departments might not.
Comment on this
The registrar would not be able to interfere if, under section 19, they were allowed to advertise. They would be entitled to trustee status under Deputy Faulkner's amendment.
Comment on this
If we can raise the standards of building societies we hope that some day they will all be worthy of trustee status. We must therefore speed the day when this is possible. Deputy Faulkner's amendment would strengthen the Bill, give status to building societies and attract a large amount of money for house building. Our main concern is to ensure that building societies are strong enough to help in the housing drive. The more money we can attract, the more we will have for housing.
Comment on this
The Minister makes the point that he would like to extend trustee status and hopes that building society standards will be so high that every society will be worthy of trustee status. If they get the right to advertise for funds under section 19—and there are strict controls on advertising for funds under the section—surely the small investor is entitled to the same controls. If they are not given trustee status they should not be allowed to advertise to attract the small investor's funds. If they are so weak as building societies, why should we give them the right to advertise for any funds?
Comment on this
Deputy Burke is assuming that the small investor goes to the small society. That is not so. Most of them invest in the larger societies because they have more confidence in them. The small society may be prepared to meet more quickly the criteria required than the larger society. The main point is that they must reach a certain standard. They are allowed to advertise and nothing will bring them to that standard more quickly than the fact that other building societies have been given trustee status. Therefore, within a short time everybody must have trustee status to survive. The right to advertise guarantees the right to trustee status.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): We all appreciate that giving trustee status would be a wonderful advantage as regards the inflow of capital to any organisation but we must always consider that trustee status must carry far more guarantees than any other type of financial institution. We on this side of the House are convinced that if we want to boost inflow of capital to a building society the granting of trustee status at some time with proper regulations laid down is desirable. This is very much a matter for the Minister for Finance and I am very glad to hear that the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Local Government are on the same wavelength in relation to the granting of trustee status. I wonder if that view is shared by all the top financial experts in the Department of Finance.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): The Minister might mention publicly in the House that his heart is in the right place, but we know perfectly well that there are other impediments besides the regulations laid down here, although it is of vital importance that trustee status in building societies is protected. A lot of funds are invested in trustee status that the Government have available to them. I can see an outflow of this capital into the building societies. I am not sure that the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Finance are on the same wavelength. It is a good public thing to say: “Of course we will give trustee status when the proper standards and regulations are established.” I know that the Minister for Finance will say that if a question is put down. The standards that the Minister for Finance will set down will be fairly restrictive, in my opinion. Many building societies will not be in a position to qualify, although the leading building societies are all on a par with each other. A case can be made for the granting of trustee status to building societies. I believe that the Minister for Finance may not be too keen to push trustee status and make it available to the building societies. Certain funds which are available to the Minister at present could be used in the building societies to far better effect for the country if we get it.
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Fitzpatrick might comment whether or not he thinks that simply complying with section 19 should qualify every building society for trustee status?
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I am quite convinced that the structures and the limits that are granted to trustee status must be watertight.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): I believe that the building societies must get trustee status if they are to have the inflow of capital.
Comment on this
Trustee status will come but there is a recognised procedure in relation to conferring trustee status. Everybody here is aware of it and many, I am sure, will have checked up on it. I am satisfied that there is no way to deal with the matter except through the recognised criteria. It cannot be changed, as has been suggested, because somebody feels that this would be a way of preventing it from being given. Section 19 does not require permission to advertise even for all the existing societies. The amendment does not do what Deputy Faulkner suggested it would. We have made a great deal of progress this morning on the Bill and I would ask Deputy Faulkner to withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I accept that the Minister for Local Government is as anxious as I am to have trustee status granted. I am equally as sure of what Deputy Fitzpatrick has said: that the Minister for Finance may not be as anxious to have it granted. It is vitally important that trustee status should be granted to the building societies, and I feel that in relation to these societies which under this Bill will be permitted to advertise the necessary structures will be built in. In these circumstances we should have trustee status incorporated in the Bill, but if the Minister can assure me that he will do his utmost to have trustee status conferred by the Minister for Finance as quickly as possible after this Bill is passed, I will withdraw the amendment.
Comment on this
I have no hesitation in giving that assurance. There is no difference of opinion between the Minister for Finance and myself on this issue. There has been a tremendous increase in the inflow of funds to building societies, and it is quite true that this year they hope to lend £100 million as against £43 million two years ago. The granting of trustee status will bring in a lot of funds which can only be invested with trustee status.
Comment on this
The Minister would agree that while the inflow has been very good recently it can take a down-turn as it did in 1974 and we have to have the situation consolidated.
Comment on this
It was lucky that we had a good Government that were prepared to take steps to remedy the situation in 1974.
Comment on this
The Minister is well aware that the reason that the money went into the building societies was that people who had money which they would normally invest in industry put it into a safe deposit.
Comment on this
The money that came into the building societies has always been that of the small investors, because it is the only way they can avail of income tax reliefs. Anybody who has a big amount of money will invest it elsewhere where it will earn very much more.
Comment on this
Could the Minister say when approximately trustee status will be granted to the building societies?
Comment on this
In a relatively short time, as soon as the Bill has passed through the House. The sooner we get this Bill through the House the quicker we will have trustee status granted.