We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Maritime Jurisdiction (Exclusive Fishery Limits) Order, 1976: Motion.

Contributions 1–230 of 447. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Garrett Fitzgerald Minister for Foreign Affairs (Dr. FitzGerald) Fine Gael

I move:

That Dáil Éireann approves the following Order in draft:

Maritime Jurisdiction (Exclusive Fishery Limits) Order, 1976,

a copy of which Order in draft was laid before Dáil Éireann on the 7th day of December, 1976.

This motion arises out of the need to extend Irish fishery limits beyond the present limit of 12 miles.

The legal status of coastal waters, the extent of the jurisdiction of the coastal state, the rights and duties of the coastal state as well as the rights and duties of other states therein, are among the main topics under discussion at the Third UN Conference on the Law of the Sea. As you would expect in the case of such complex questions, and where so many states with such varied interests are taking part in the negotiations, there is a wide spectrum of positions at the conference. The land-locked and geographically disadvantaged states continue to resist the concept of an exclusive economic zone while the maritime powers feel the coastal states' powers should not be too wide. Fishing rights for other than coastal states, especially the land-locked and geographically disadvantaged states and in particular the developing countries among them, are still among the major unresolved issues. Coastal states are anxious to retain the present draft articles, herewith, in the single negotiating text and there is a view at the conference that the solution lies in general acceptance of an exclusive economic zone.

The slow progress at the conference towards reaching world-wide agreement on the issues before it, including that of economic zones, has resulted in an increasing trend towards unilateral action being taken by a number of states to extend fishing limits to 200 miles for conservation reasons. Already Iceland, Norway, Canada and the United States have stated their intention to claim or have claimed 200 mile exclusive fishing limits. This has led and could continue to lead in the future to extra pressure on the waters adjacent to the State and to overfishing immediately outside our existing limits not only by our Community partners but also by boats from other countries. This is so not only of waters adjacent to us and of the waters near the coasts of other Community countries, but overfishing has been widespread throughout the North Atlantic area. The effect of these activities on catches in our waters and in the waters of other coastal states has been highly damaging.

It is my view that agreement on a world wide scale is the best method of protecting the interests of all, and in particular the interests of small states. I am also convinced as a result of the Law of the Sea Conference that a large majority of governments now consider states should be entitled to 200 mile fishing limits and I expect that whatever convention the conference adopts it will include such a provision.

In the meantime, we cannot face the extinction of our fishing industry and we also must take action to extend our limits if we are to protect the fish stocks and the interests of our coastal areas.

The Community also, in the context of the common fisheries policy, has been considering the question of extension of limits. The Council at its meeting in July 1976, wishing to protect the rights of Community fishermen and stressing the need for the member states to act jointly, adopted the principle of concerted action under which member states would be led to extend the limits of fishing zones to 200 miles, and agreed to consider the matter further in the light of the outcome of the fifth session of the conference. By resolution of 30th October, 1976, which was formally adopted through written procedure on 3rd November, the Council of Ministers agreed that from 1st January, 1977, member states should extend the limits of their fishing zones to 200 miles of the North Sea and North Atlantic coasts and that from that date the exploitation of fishery resources in these zones by fishing vessels of third countries should be governed by agreements between the Community and the third countries concerned.

By extending our limits we will be excluding boats from other countries, other than those countries with which we have undertaken contractual obligations, from fishing within those limits. As members of the European Community we are subject to the common fisheries policy.

The common fisheries policy as you are aware, was devised by the original six member states and was put into effect shortly before the three new members joined the Community. We maintain that it reflects the interests and needs of the Six and was, in effect, imposed on Ireland as part of an otherwise acceptable Accession Treaty. The Accession Treaty, indeed, allowed us certain derogations from the principle of common access, which were to be reviewed before 31st December, 1982, but overfishing on the part of third countries, and some of our partners, in adjacent waters has resulted in decreasing catches for Irish fishermen and a threat to the development and even the maintenance of our fishing industry.

In the light of developments in the Law of the Sea Conference the Commission made proposals in September this year for certain elements of a new Community fishery regime. These proposals were unacceptable to Ireland in as much as they provided for nonexclusive bands of not more than twelve miles width, and relied on quotas to conserve fish stocks. Our partners were persuaded to agree at The Hague on 30th October that Ireland is a special case, and they committed the Community to applying the common fisheries policy so as to secure the continued and progressive achievement of our fisheries development programme for coastal fisheries.

This was secured without our having to concede one iota of our claim to a coastal band of up to 50 miles—indeed, our claim to such a band is in practice greatly strengthened. We do, however, recognise that some of our partners have a very strong political interest in preventing the present coastal bands being retained, never mind enlarged, after the end of 1982 and that very difficult negotiations lie ahead.

At the meeting of the Council of Ministers in Brussels on 15th/16th November, 1976, I reiterated our view that the importance of reaching early agreement on an internal system should not be lost sight of. Work on this question should continue to have a high priority as it is vital for the future of the Community's fishing interests that measures for the conservation of fish resources within the extended zone should be agreed upon and implemented as soon as possible. I also stated that Ireland was particularly concerned about the regime which will operate after 1st January, 1977 within the 200-mile zone. This regime must, in our view, involve the application of the common fisheries policy in such a way as to secure the continued and progressive development of the Irish fishing industry. I repeated again that the Government's view is that this development can be achieved only through the operation of an exclusive coastal band.

At this Council I also stated that if agreement on an internal regime was not achieved before 1st January, 1977, the Irish Government would, as a temporary measure and in consultation with the European Commission and interested member states, have to take interim steps to ensure progress towards the achievement of the objectives for the development of the Irish fishing industry agreed between the member states at The Hague on 30th October last.

The Commission has in the past week come forward with proposals for an interim fisheries regime to operate for 1977. In their present form these proposals, the details of which must, for the present, remain confidential, are unacceptable to us. We consider that any interim system adopted should apply, inter alia, to clearly-defined Irish coastal waters and should be such as to secure the achievement of the objectives of our fisheries development programme to which our partners in the Community have clearly committed themselves. Moreover, any interim system adopted should not prejudice our claim for an exclusive coastal band of up to 50 miles.

As regards third countries, we have, of course, agreed to postpone our right to veto agreements with third countries, something which is vitally important to many of our Community partners, until such time as permanent agreements come to be negotiated to replace the interim agreements which the Community is now seeking with Iceland, Norway and the Faroes, or until the moment comes to open actual negotiations between the Community and other countries for reciprocal access arrangements to the 200-mile zones to be proclaimed by member states on 1st January next. In the case of third countries which are not in a position to offer reciprocal rights to our EEC partners, our contention is that their fishing in European Community waters should be phased out as rapidly as possible, we would envisage within six months.

Apart from the member states of the Community, Spain also has rights, as a party to the London Fisheries Convention, to fish in certain waters round our coasts. The Community will, therefore, now negotiate a new fisheries arrangement with Spain in the light of the action taken by member states to extend their fishing limits.

The Council of Ministers of the European Community, both Foreign Affairs and Agriculture, will meet in Brussels early next week and the question of fisheries will be discussed in depth by them.

The Government is empowered under section 6, paragraph 2, of the Maritime Jurisdiction Act, 1959, to make an order extending the exclusive fishery limits of the State. Any such order may be made only if a resolution approving the terms of the draft shall have been passed by each House of the Oireachtas. It is the intention of the Government to make such order with effect from 1st January, 1977.

The purpose of the order is to extend the fishing limits of the State to 200 miles and in areas where a 200-mile limit would cross with a similar limit taken by Britain and France to indicate a fixed line in those areas being a line equidistant from the nearest point on the coasts of the respective countries and this line is defined in a schedule to the order by reference to co-ordinates. It will mean in effect an overlap of jurisdiction pending agreement on a mutually acceptable line. It has not been possible in the short time available to work out an agreed line and official discussions are continuing at present. Meantime it is hoped that the Governments concerned will co-operate so as to ensure that unilateral conservation regulations would be in harmony and that conflicts in attempted enforcement in the overlapping area will be avoided.

It has been agreed that an Opposition motion calling on the Government to make an order restricting fishing in waters situated within 50 nautical miles should be taken in conjunction with the motion which I have moved so that the two may be debated together. I should like before concluding to refer to this Opposition motion.

This motion is based on the argument that the relevant section of the Accession Treaty dealing with fishing rights, and comprising Articles 100 to 103 of that Treaty, is "rendered inapplicable by the extension of exclusive fishery limits by all member states".

Regrettably this assertion is ill-founded. The section of the Accession Treaty referred to in the Opposition motion is expressed in the form of a temporary derogation from the provisions of Article 2 of Regulation (EEC) No. 2141/70—later consolidated in Regulation 101/76—on the establishment of a common structural policy for the fishing industry. The terms of these articles of the Accession Treaty provide for a temporary derogation permitting member states for a period to restrict fishing in waters under their sovereignty or jurisdiction situated within a limit of six nautical miles, which is, however, extended to 12 nautical miles for certain areas specified in Article 101.

Basically what we are bound by is Council regulation 2141/70 subject only to such derogations as were agreed at the time of membership and as are incorporated in the Accession Treaty. The relevant article of Regulation 2141/70 is Article 2 which says that "rules applied by each member state in respect of fishing in the maritime waters coming under its sovereignty or within its jurisdiction shall not lead to differences in treatment of other member states. Member states shall ensure in particular equal conditions of access to and use of the fishing grounds situated in the waters referred to in the preceding subparagraph for all fishing vessels flying the flag of a member state and registered in Community territory".

Unfortunately for us nothing in the form of the derogation negotiated by the preceding Government with the European Community of that time modified or purported to modify the broad provisions of Article 2, save to the extent that a temporary derogation within limits of six or 12 miles was agreed.

I think it unfortunate that at the time of the negotiation we did not succeed in securing a more fundamental modification of Article 2141/70 which would have covered the case that the Opposition are now belatedly making. As I have said on a previous occasion in this House, I am not conversant with the details of these negotiations, and therefore I am not in a position to say whether any attempt was made to seek a more fundamental modification of this kind. Whether or not this was attempted, the fact is that it was not achieved and we are left with a position which has been succinctly summed up by the legal department of the Council of Ministers in the following terms: "As the arrangements under Regulation No. 101/76 (which consolidates 2141/70) apply to maritime waters over which a member state exercised its sovereignty or jurisdiction, they would therefore apply ipso facto to the 200-mile zone, with the proviso that, within the 12-mile zone, they applied having regard to Articles 100 et seq. of the Act.”

Consequently the making of an order by the Government under section 3 of the Maritime Jurisdiction (Amendment) Act, 1964, restricting fishing in waters situated within 50 nautical miles, calculated from the base-lines of the State, to vessels which operate from ports in the State, would be in conflict with the terms of Regulation 2141/70 and would accordingly have no legal force in Community law or, by virtue of the Constitution as amended in 1972, in the domestic law of this State.

Comment on this

I understand from the fact that we can have only one motion before the House, it will be in order for us to refer to the terms of our motion also.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

They are being discussed together.

Comment on this

We have learned for the first time in the latter part of the Minister's speech his reaction to the motion which we circulated as well and which is now being debated simultaneously with the motion as named. What we are doing here this afternoon on the face of it has no relationship whatsoever to the European Economic Community. The Minister will acknowledge that the order we are being asked to make makes no reference to the European Community. It is an order which we, as a coastal State consistent with the single negotiating text now before the International Law of the Sea Conference, are making and that in effect is the only business before the House, that we as a nation and as a Parliament extend exclusively the 200-mile limit as far as fisheries are concerned consequent on the consensus which has been presented at the International Law of the Sea Conference.

What we have been asked to do this afternoon is not, of course, the full story at all. The Minister's opening speech makes reference to the other story, that is the position of the European Community. It does highlight the fact that only this Parliament will have the power exclusively to order this extension of our limits to 200 miles, as has already been done by other countries such as America, Canada, many countries in South America and Iceland, and arrangements for it are under way in the United Kingdom as well. We are following what many other coastal states have done. The difference in our case is that we are following it at a time when we have already conceded to the European Community the strength of our special position as a coastal State to protect our needs in this and our future potential for the fishing industry and the economy of our country as a whole. This is where the very serious and significant clash arises between Government and Opposition on this motion.

On the face of it we all are, of course, supporting an extension of our exclusive limit to 200 miles, which is what is being asked for here today. Were we not members of the European Community what we would be doing here would be in line with what other countries are doing without any qualification whatever. Two hundred miles is exclusive to this country, Germany, Holland, France — apart from the west coast of France where the fishing grounds are not by any means of comparison rich — cannot through themselves do anything under the proposals before the International Law of the Sea Conference to secure for themselves or the European Community any economic coastal zone up to 200 miles. We as a coastal State can. That is our trump card and we have now been placed in the position that we agreed at the last meeting of the Council not to play this trump card until the game is already concluded and to allow some other player at the table to take the spoils, to win the praise, and afterwards with the trump card in our hands when the game is over to say that we rely on their goodwill to give us a share of what is ours by right under the concept of the 200-miles economic zone at present contained in the text before the International Law of the Sea Conference.

Let me ask the Minister some simple, precise questions. He has this afternoon repeated what he said on a few occasions in this House, that it is unfortunate, as he said at the time of our negotiations, that we did not secure more fundamental modifications in Article 2141/70 which would have covered the case now made. I want to ask the Minister, as one who actively supported our accession to the European Community, once and for all did he ever at that stage utter one syllable, make one whisper of reservation, express any inhibitions, he himself or the Opposition as they then were at that time——

Comment on this
A Deputy

Yes.

Comment on this

——through the Treaty of Accession that we entered into at that stage in relation to these fishery negotiations that we should have reserved to us a position which would take into account the development in international law? I want the Minister in reply to say if he did, or if he did not, why not. I want him to clear the implication that had he been entrusted with the negotiations at that time, with the benefit of foresight, he would have seen what he did not see because it was not relevant at the time.

Comment on this

Why was it not relevant at the time?

Comment on this

The Minister can reply to this——

Comment on this

We were not negotiating. Fianna Fáil were.

Comment on this

I presume the Minister would have felt obliged, having regard to the interest and concern he had for our membership of the Community, at least to inform himself on matters that would have been of such fundamental importance. I grant that he informed himself, but I want to tell him that it is wrong and misleading for him to come here four years later and say "Yes, the Opposition, Government at the time, conceded what they should not have conceded." I am concerned that the Minister at least be consistent. If he can point to even one occasion when he mentioned the slightest caution, I will keep silent. He knows and I know that not once did he enter a reservation. If he did, what he is saying now would be consistent.

The reservation would not have been appropriate because at that time the structural policy of the European Community in the fishing area was within the international law, as it was known then, and the existing waters within our sovereignty or jurisdiction were from six to 12 miles. They took no account of any concept of a 200 mile economic zone for the simple reason that such a concept did not exist and did not come into being as a real proposal until two years after the Treaty of Accession. Not until the first stage of the International Law of the Sea Conference was under way was this proposal first presented.

It is misleading for the Minister to come here and imply that what was not even contemplated at that time was relevant. Not only is he misleading us but he is defeating his own case. Our position is this: in so far as the Treaty of Accession which we entered into at the time was made within the existing international legal framework and the international rights, it was binding. When, as the documents of the Commission acknowledged, a new element entered into it two years later, and when the economic zone concept of the 200 miles for coastal States was widely promoted and accepted, the EEC and every country concerned in this area saw that a new dimension had entered into it, that a new regime was contemplated and in the light of that new regime there would be a qualification, an amendment and even a repeal of agreements which up to then were being regarded as binding. The fact that the Community are now proposing to extend before 1982 the derogations, which were conceded to us in the Treaty of Accession some four years ago, is a recognition of changed circumstances since that agreement was entered into. Either the Minister accepts that as being the strength of his position or he does not.

He cannot come into this House and pretend that this order might have been contemplated in 1972. He cannot pretend that world circumstances are the same as they were then. He cannot justify the failure of his negotiations at the moment— allowing for the magnificent Press to which I may refer later—by reference to what he might call the oversight of the previous Government, an oversight he shared with them. I do not accept that it was an oversight.

I would like now to refer to some statements the Minister made which confirm what I am saying in relation to the previous position. He made a speech at the meeting of the EEC Council of Ministers in Luxembourg on 18th and 19th October, 1976. That was not too long ago and it should be sufficiently recent to be clear in his mind. We see some amazing cartwheel-turns between what he said then and what he is saying here this afternoon. He said:

I should perhaps begin by referring back to the origins of the common fisheries policy adopted by the Council of the original Community of Six separate countries in 1970. As an applicant country, the regulations implementing the policy faced us with a fait accompli which provoked great resentment in Ireland as, I believe, it did in Britain. It was seen by our people, and I may add by the then Government and the Opposition of that time, as involving the attempted imposition on the prospective Community of Nine of a policy that suited the interest of a Community of Six, a policy which indeed gave to the original Six who had largely fished out their own waters a potential right of unlimited access to the waters of Ireland and the United Kingdom.

He then went on to say:

We had no practical alternative as applicant Members but to accept this move, which, however, we viewed as being contrary to the whole spirit of the Community as we had understood it to be at that time. The alternative would have been to have remained excluded from the Community to which our ideals and, be it said, our interests in other respects commit us.

The Minister who said "we had no alternative but to accept the conditions" six weeks ago, implied in this House a week ago and again today that if he had been doing the business of this nation at that time things would have been different.

I would like him to come clean on this once and for all. While we all realise the difficulties he is facing in these negotiations, these difficulties should be presented fairly. But he should not—and I say this advisedly —mislead the House in the interpretation he is trying to put on the constraints which exist at the moment.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should not use the phrase "mislead the House".

Comment on this

The record speaks for itself. I can only put an interpretation on that, regrettable though it may be.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is aware that to "mislead the House" is unparliamentary.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

On a point of order, should the Deputy not be asked to withdraw the allegation that the Minister is misleading the House?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair takes it that the Deputy does not mean the Minister is deliberately misleading the House.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Does the Deputy have to withdraw the remark?

Comment on this

The effect of this is that the House is being misled. Whether the Minister is doing that deliberately or for any other reason is a matter for him to answer.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

"Deliberately misleading" is not parliamentary.

Comment on this

I never heard of that ruling.

Comment on this

It is used every day.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

On a point of order, will the Deputy withdraw the remark?

Comment on this

Deputy Collins will be making his statement later; I am making mine now.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has already mentioned to the Deputy in question that he is not imputing "deliberately misleading the House".

Comment on this

I rely on the records of this House and I have put this statement on the record too. This House and the people can judge the effect of that.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is assuming that the Deputy is not implying that——

Comment on this

I am relying on the records of this House and I will leave it to the House and the country to make their own judgments.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair takes it that the Deputy is not imputing that the Minister is "deliberately misleading"——

Comment on this

I accept that.

Comment on this

The Minister referred to a Council resolution of 30th October, No. 101 of 76, which quite clearly refers to an extension to 200 miles and clearly recommends consideration of that extension. It is from the beginning of 1976 that the new position emerged within the Community which should have enabled us to secure the special interests of our fishing and ancillary industries. The Minister will accept that the purpose of the Commission's proposals to the Council, and adopted by the Council, was to enable the Commission to negotiate with third countries in regard to rights of access for those countries within the 200-mile zone, and equally to give, by way of agreement and exchange, to the fishing states of most of the Community exchange rights of access to the exclusive zones of third countries such as Iceland, Norway and so forth.

The progress of events in this regard derives from the interests of Community member states to guarantee their access to waters to which they have not access. We in Ireland have always fished exclusively within our own jurisdiction and because of the pursuing of the right of access to third country waters we have conceded to the Commission the right to negotiate with these third countries exchange rights in waters which are exclusively, as a result of this order, within our jurisdiction.

By agreeing, as the Minister has done, with the Council decision in The Hague in October, and by accepting the resolution giving to the Commission the right to negotiate with third countries, the Minister has thrown away our strongest trump. The Minister has said that is not so, that it is quite the opposite, that our position has been strengthened as a result of the Council decision. If the Minister can point to me anything to confirm that, I will be glad because I cannot understand how our position has been strengthened. There has been informal agreement on the needs of the Irish fishing and ancillary industries, we have been told, yet we have conceded the legal basis on which our strong position was being maintained.

It is obvious that the negotiations which the Commission are now conducting with third countries will not confer any benefit on us as a nation or on anyone engaged in the fishing and ancillary industries. Indeed, it is obvious from the proposals we read about recently that the reverse is the case, that it will allow the Commission to grant rights of access to fishing fleets from Russia, from Iceland, from Norway, even from America, to waters which are within our exclusive jurisdiction.

What is the return for us as a sovereign nation anxious to develop our fishing industry? The Council are prepared to acknowledge that we should be encouraged and supported in our endeavours to develop our fishing industry, and this is the quid pro quo, called a concession, which gives the fishing fleets of those developed nations access to waters from which they would be excluded otherwise. I am sure the Community would have wished that this question of an economic zone, or any such plan, had never arisen, because I am sure the Community would be happy if that had not happened, if they could have fished in Icelandic or Norwegian waters without this concession.

The coastal states quite often were the undeveloped states of the world although they had natural resources which to some extent compensated them for the disadvantages they had as island countries. We have the natural advantage of being an island and of having the resource of the fishing around our coast. On the other hand, however, as an island we have the natural disadvantage of being distant from the markets for our exports and imports which we need in order to maintain our industrial arm. We have to balance our extra costs in importing and exporting from and to the Community in order to be able to compete with countries in the centre of the Community, like Holland, Germany and France.

The Community have recognised that the countries on the periphery, by virtue of being on the periphery, ipso facto are at a disadvantage. If Germany, Holland, France and Belgium are to be allowed to exploit their location in being near the markets, then we should be allowed to enjoy the natural advantage we have in regard to exclusive fishing waters. It is true that the EEC fishing fleets have been very much responsible for fishing out the resources of the waters we are now concerned with, waters which all of us are concerned to protect. The EEC, the Commission and the Council chose to ignore these facts and now ask us to agree to a system which in future will be related to performances in the past, which performances were the root cause of our present problem—the overfishing of these waters. If quotas are to be based on past performances of the fishing fleets of Community states, they will be neither equitable nor fair and will not take any account of our needs or of our development potential. We would have the strange irony that the countries and the fleets responsible for the problems we face are now to be rewarded for having over-fished, exploited and exhausted the resources of our fishing grounds.

I wish to refer to some other aspects of the Treaty of Accession which must be clarified, in particular Article 103. It is important that we recognise the strength of our position. On this matter, the Minister spoke in this House recently at Question Time. At column 1116 of the Official Report dated 1st December, 1976, with regard to Article 103 he said that he regarded the article as being a condition precedent of a new fishing regime. He stated:

I do so regard it and I have in fact, as the Deputy is aware, made that particular point in my juridical argument before the Council of Ministers. In my view the review, as I have regarded it at this time taking place now, not being based on a separate and adequate report, is a defective review. I argued that before the Council of Ministers.

The Minister went on to say:

The Commission argued on the contrary, that their communication to the Council on which the proposal before the Council was founded contains data which it can legally be sustained, in their view, is such a report. I have not accepted that.

The Minister told us last week that the Commission now say, and have argued before the Council, that to that extent they have complied with the provisions of Article 103. I want to repeat that on a visit by an all-party committee of the House—Deputy Esmonde was on the committee—to the EEC Commission within the last two months when we raised the question of Article 103—I believe for the first time in any substantial way with the Commission; the Minister does not accept that but I know from the response of the Commission that it was not presented in a positive fashion by the Government before that—the Commission acknowledged that no such report or survey had been done. Deputy Esmonde was with me in discussions subsequently when representatives of the Commission acknowledged that this was the case. I have checked with individual members of the deputation, not all of them from this side of the House, and they have told me that at no stage did the Commission even begin to suggest that any such report or survey had been undertaken by them. However, the Minister told us last week that the Commission now say that is the case.

I find it very difficult to accept that the Commission could turn completely in such a short time on what they freely volunteered to the all-party Committee. If that is the case, it is a very belated opinion from the Commission and it is not an argument that is convincing. Whatever has been done, obviously it does not conform with the provisions of Article 103 and I was amazed when the Minister told us that the Commission are relying on that argument at the moment.

I should like the Minister at some stage to present to the House the formal statement of the Commission's position incorporating that argument on their behalf. To me it is absolutely incomprehensible that they should make that argument at this stage.

Comment on this

The Commission's statement was made verbally in Council; there is not a verbatim record of it. I would ask the Deputy to confirm that the contrary statements were made by a member of the Commission, not just by some member of the Commission staff.

Comment on this

They were made by a member of the Commission staff——

Comment on this

Then, it was not made by a member of the Commission. The Deputy is talking only about the staff.

Comment on this

They were senior members of the Commission staff whom I presume would be the ones who would present the proposals to the commissioners concerned.

Comment on this

I am talking of a formal statement made by a commissioner on behalf of the Commission——

Comment on this

It was not a statement made by a commissioner.

Comment on this

In the Minister's interests and in ours, I wish to have for the record a copy of that formal statement. If the Minister is saying that is being used against him, that it is one of the difficulties he is facing, I reject it. Let us have a clear position on this matter. I do not want to have this debate conducted on the basis of unreal arguments which the Commission may be presenting as difficulties when I do not regard them as any such difficulties. If that is being presented as a difficulty in our path, I presume the Minister will accept from the all-party committee that at no stage did the Commission representatives suggest that a survey had been undertaken.

Article 103 states that before 31st December, 1982, the Commission will present a report to the Council on the economic and social development of the coastal areas of member states and on the state of stocks. On the basis of that report and the objectives of the common fishery policy the Council, acting on a proposal from the Commission, will examine the provisions that could follow the derogations in force on 31st December, 1982.

At that time it was not contemplated that there would be any change before 31st December, 1982, for the obvious reason that the economic zone concept had not emerged as a principle. Of course before any new regime could be introduced after 1982 the Commission and the Community bound themselves to do a survey of the social and economic development of the coastal regions. They acknowledged to us as an all-party committee—I am surprised they did not so acknowledge to the Minister—that they had not made a survey. In so far as they are not even aware of the social and economic development needs of the coastal regions, they must acknowledge they are not in a position to restrict or limit our rights to the exploitation by our fishermen of an exclusive coastal band of 50 miles which we consider essential for the well-being of our fishing industry and its future development.

Comment on this

Perhaps it would help the Deputy if I read what was said in Council:

The Commissioner said he could not accept the criticism of the Irish delegation regarding non-compliance with the requirement in Article 103 of the Accession Treaty regarding a report on the economic and social development of the coastal areas of member states, and the state of stocks. He maintained that the proposals submitted by the Commission constituted that report, particularly with regard to conservation. The Commission could not be criticised for submitting its report earlier than envisaged in the Accession Treaty. He could not agree with the legal arguments put forward. They would make a nonsense of Article 7 of the Rome Treaty.

Comment on this

I am glad the Minister has put that on the record of the House. He has confirmation from us as an all-party committee—I presume it will be available from all sides of the House—that this argument was never made by any representative of the Commission with whom we had discussions. We are surprised that now they take a position that is entirely in conflict with the position taken by their representatives as recently as six weeks ago. I hope the Minister will find his negotiating position strengthened on this issue.

Comment on this

I am grateful for the information.

Comment on this

This is obviously a very complex legal area particularly because the whole question of the International Law of the Sea has been in a state of flux, to say the least of it, for some considerable time. There is no fixed criteria which can guide and on which we can say "These are the principles which bind in relation to member states of any international organisation. These are the articles which commit us to a certain course of conduct". This has been under negotiation for some considerable time at the International Law of the Sea Conference. I am not implying that the advice available to the Minister is anything less than the best legal advice that would be available from our public service. I would like to recognise the diligence of our public servants in this area and their capacity. It seems to me that the issues for our country are so vitally important here that it would be worth the Government's while to engage, on a full-time basis, the advice of three, four or five specialists after discussions in New York, the Commission and elsewhere to present to the Minister a clear position of what our legal rights are, having regard to the newly emerging doctrine of the economic zone concept in particular.

The consequences to Ireland of what will happen in the next couple of years on the fishery question will be enormous. Millions, if not billions will be involved. Obviously it is an area on which we should spare no expense whatsoever. Other countries have the benefit of the best advice in international law which they seconded in many cases from chairs of international law universities, who are working on a full time consultancy basis with their governments, whether it be Canada or otherwise. I presume America has the benefit of a similar kind of advice. Our Government should be supplementing the advice they are getting within their own Departments in this area by the most informed and expert advice available to them at whatever cost, in order to ensure that those most vitally important issues for our country will be determined to our advantage without leaving any possibility of overlooking any legal form or right which would strengthen our position.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows we are able to look after ourselves.

Comment on this

So are we. The Deputy will recognise, even on the rather cursory observations which we, as a committee had on this question from a legal point of view, that points emerge which all of us recognise were not presented before. If they had, certainly the reaction from the Commission representatives did not indicate they had been presented before. I feel it was too late at that time to have those very important legal issues discussed when in January, when the first Council regulation was adopted, this matter was very much an issue. We are now at the final minute of the final hour but even now it is vitally important that every avenue of our legal right in the international area is fully explored by people who would devote their full attention to it, working in co-operation and supplementing the advice available to the Minister from his own Department.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that the Minister has not the best advice?

Comment on this

I am not saying that and nothing I have said would imply that. I want to refer to Council Regulation No. 101 of 1976. This is the regulation of January, 1976. It was drafted, obviously like so many others subsequently, in the light of the desirability of the member states extending their exclusive zone to 200 miles. This document was meant to be, and is at the moment, the guiding principle of the Community in relation to the structural policy of the European Community in the fishing area. During some discussions we had in the House recently the Minister said that our representatives at the UN always take account of the preambles to documents when determining if they should support the motion presented in that document.

Council Regulation No. 101 of 19th January, 1976, has some very significant preambles in it. One of them states that "Whereas sea fisheries form the most important part of the fishing industry as a whole; whereas they have their own social structure in fish under special conditions" and it goes on to state "Whereas, subject to certain specific conditions concerning the flag or the registration of their ships, Community fishermen must have equal access to and use of fishing grounds in maritime waters coming under the sovereignty or within the jurisdiction of member states". That was in January, 1976.

Comment on this

It is a consolidating regulation.

Comment on this

Yes, but it is a new regulation of January, 1976, taking account of the new developments that have occurred since the other regulation of 1970, otherwise what is the purpose of this regulation in 1976?

Comment on this

It is a consolidating one.

Comment on this

It is not just consolidating. It is a new statement from the Council having regard to new developments. It is more than a consolidating regulation. It is the statement from the Council in January of this year of what principles are to be applied in the proposals from the Community with regard to the development of the fishing industry of the member states. In January, 1976, when the debate of the economic zone was under way and this whole question was certainly very much in the air and when the International Law of the Sea Conference was in session in New York and this whole question of the right of the coastal state was already very much an issue our Minister adopted, with other Ministers, a preamble which recognised almost 11 months ago that fishermen of member states would have equal access to the use of fishing grounds in maritime waters coming under the sovereignty or within the jurisdiction of member states. If the Minister can blame the Government of four years ago for not taking account of what did not then exist surely we are entitled at least to blame him as our negotiator at that time for ignoring what existed in 1976?

There are some further preambles in this particular Council regulation. It is quite clear that there is no preamble that takes account of the special position of Ireland, the special position of coastal regions, or the special commitment which the Community should have towards the coastal regions.

Comment on this

This is a consolidating regulation comprising the text of what was there in 1970, subject to the dropping of transitional measures which have disappeared just as our Constitution no longer has transitional measures. There is no new matter in it at all. It is simply consolidating the existing regulations of 1970. The Deputy's argument is therefore pointless.

Comment on this

It is stated to be a Council regulation laying down a common structural policy for the fishing industry.

Comment on this

It is consolidating what was there in 1970.

Comment on this

It is not quite the same and the Minister knows that.

Comment on this

It is, except for transitional measures.

Comment on this

This is what has changed. I say to the Minister, because it has changed, that the principles of the 1970 Council regulation should have been capable of being changed in the light of the circumstances that have emerged since 1970.

Comment on this

Consolidating legislation cannot change except in so far as transitional measures are concerned.

Comment on this

The transitional provisions have totally changed as the Minister knows.

Comment on this

Yes, to the extent that the transitional measures had disappeared, are no longer applicable and are dissolved, otherwise the text is the same. It is a consolidating regulation.

Comment on this

If they are to be dropped the Minister should see that it is as relevant to introduce articles and guarantees which will safeguard the new provisions.

Comment on this

We cannot introduce anything into a consolidating regulation. The Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

If the Minister is only relying on the fact that it is a consolidating regulation that is a procedural point. If there is a Council regulation, which lays down the common structural policy for the fishing industry, it was open to our Minister at least to propose that there should have been incorporated in a new regulation if not in this consolidating regulation in some other preambles or articles which would take account of the changing of international law since 1972 and some guarantees which would take account of Ireland's special position. That has not been done. Article 2 of that regulation goes on to say:

Rules applied by each Member State in respect of fishing in the maritime waters coming under its sovereignty or within its jurisdiction shall not lead to differences in treatment of other Member States.

For approximately nine or ten months, while all of this was being prevented by way of consolidating regulations or otherwise, while it was obvious that the Commission wanted to have a negotiating right on behalf of the Community with third countries, while it was obvious that we would reach a deadline by the 1st January, 1977, the Minister waited until October of this year at the Hague Summit to get a position which would strengthen the negotiating position on behalf of the Irish fishermen within the context of the European Community. It is inexplicable that we should have allowed this matter to develop to this point. Some time ago, prior to the Summit at the Hague, we asked the Minister to have a debate in this House on the fishery question, and the Minister stated that it would be harmful and that it would weaken his negotiating position. The result is that after the event, after the Minister has agreed to extend our limit to 200 miles by arrangement with the European Community, we are asked formally to authorise what the Minister has already bound himself to do. We ask the Minister what is the quid pro quo for the authority which only we can give to the European Community? We see no such exchange and we see no legal obligation on this Parliament to take up the position which is obviously meant to strengthen the negotiating hand of the European Community with third countries but which is not directed to ensuring the development of our fishing industry.

The Minister will recognise that the Treaty of Accession in 1972 contained a protocol which took account of the special position of Ireland. As a protocol to a binding international agreement merits some recognition by the European Community, I have asked the Minister on more than one occasion if he has ever called this protocol into question to support the position he is negotiating on our behalf. One must put the terms of this protocol before the House and analyse whether or not what is being asked of us is in accordance with the terms of the protocol negotiated for us in 1972. It says:

The high contracting parties, desiring to settle certain special problems of concern to Ireland, and having agreed the following provisions, recall that the fundamental objectives of the European Economic Community include the steady improvement of the living standards and working conditions of the people of the Member States and the harmonious development of their economies by reducing the difference existing between the various regions and the backwardness of the less-favoured regions;

If they recall all of that as being one of the fundamental objectives of the European Economic Community, now is the time to remind them that, far from reducing the differences between the less favoured regions and the developed regions, they are proposing to prevent the less favoured regions from exploiting their own natural resources in the interests of the highly developed and prosperous regions of the Community. Even if we are not asking them to do something positive, having regard to the provisions of Protocol No. 30 at least we can ask that they refrain from doing something negative which is totally inconsistent with the provisions of Protocol No. 30. It goes on to say:

Take note of the fact that the Irish Government has embarked upon the implementation of a policy of industrialisation and economic development designed to align the standards of living in Ireland with those of the other European nations and to eliminate underemployment while progressively evening out regional differences in levels of development;

Recognise it to be in their common interest that the objectives of this policy be so attained;

Agree to recommend to this end that the Community institutions implement all the means and procedures laid down by the EEC Treaty, particularly by making adequate use of the Community resources intended for the realisation of the Community's above mentioned objectives;

Recognise in particular that, in the application of Articles 92 and 93 of the EEC Treaty, it will be necessary to take into account the objectives of economic expansion and the raising of the standard of living of the population.

Has the Minister or any spokesman on our behalf presented a clear programme of our fishery developments over the next five to ten years to the Community? Has the Community been told what is involved in this in relation to employment around the west coast of Ireland in ancillary industry? Has anything been presented to the Commission which says: "This is what we are proposing to do and this is what we call upon you to acknowledge and support under the provisions of Protocol No. 30, which was a special protocol negotiated on the occasion of our Treaty of Accession"?

In the course of questions to this House over the last few weeks it has appeared that there is no fishery development plan in existence, and if there is no plan it is not surprising that the European Community do not take account of what does not exist. If the blame is our own for not moving in an urgent way to do what we should do, we should not blame the Community for not acknowledging the need to develop what we have not presented to them in clear and unambiguous terms. If we are to be allowed to develop our own fishing industry to the extent that we may in three years have twice the potential catch we have at the moment, what are the present plans to ensure that this will be done? If we have such plans, what programme have the Government set for BIM or for the marine manufacturers of this country to enable extra boats that will be needed for this development programme to be manufactured exclusively in this country? If we are going to undertake urgently a determined fishery development plan we will obviously need extra boats. The Federation of Marine Manufacturers are concerned about this. There is no blueprint, programme or any statement, published or otherwise, of what the Government's boat building programme will be and on which this important section of our industry can act within the next months or years. If we are to move urgently surely there should be such a programme both for the fishery industry and for ancillary industries associated with it.

The Minister said this afternoon: In the light of developments in the Law of the Sea Conference the Commission made proposals in September this year for certain elements of a new Community fishery regime.

That confirms the point I have been making since the start of my contribution here this afternoon.

It is in the light of the development of the Law of the Sea Conference that the Commission are making their new proposals, and I quote, "for certain elements in a new Community fishery regime". On the Minister's own statement everything has changed utterly in the light of those developments and it is in the light of those developments that we say the regulations entered into before these developments were contemplated are no longer applicable. It is in the light of those that we say we are now entitled, because of what we are conferring on the Community, to retain for ourselves at least the minimum guarantees we need, guarantees all of us recognise can only be provided under an exclusive coastal band of 50 miles.

We recognise that in the first years of this new exclusive coastal band it will not be possible for our fishing fleet to supply the existing consumer market in Europe. Our fishermen recognise this. They recognise there is a consumer demand on the European mainland that they could not possibly supply and, on that basis, we now repeat to the Government our proposal that what the Government should do is insist on the exclusive 50-mile limit and, within that limit, to do what they are already doing in exploration and other areas, namely, grant licences as a sovereign Government to certain fishing fleets from certain traditional member states, subject to review each year on the year by our Government after consultation with our fishing industry to ensure these licences granted by us will not be operated to the disadvantage of our fishing industry and ultimately to the disadvantage of our economy as a whole. That surely is a consistent position which will guarantee the protection of the Community consumer to a very considerable extent because the fishing fleets from some of the Community states will be given access under licence and the result will be that our fishermen, our industry and our economy generally will benefit from what is after all ours and no one else's.

The waters that we will now apparently be bringing within our sovereignty and jurisdiction were not within our sovereignty and jurisdiction and were not contemplated as being within them and so did not come within the terms of our Treaty of Accession. To the extent that they did not do so we now find ourselves in a new position. The Minister can present his side of it and I do not think he does it with any great enthusiasm but rather more as an argument presented to him. Contracts are made in the light of conditions that exist and in the light of what the contracting parties agree to and bind each other. If circumstances that did not exist and could not have been contemplated intervene subsequently that changes the whole nature of the agreement and the contract in either civil or international role cannot then be interpreted as if the events and facts subsequently known were known when the contract was originally entered into. It is on that basis our party insist that the minimum quid pro quo of our extending our limits to 200 miles, and we alone can do it, is that we be given the exclusive right for our fishermen to a 50-mile limit and, if we are not given that exclusive right, then our party will have to consider what attitude it will take on the Minister's motion.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

As a member of a coastal constituency which contains the second largest fishing port in Ireland, Dunmore East, I am naturally very interested in the question of fishery limits, the protection of fish stocks and the development of our fishing fleet. I have been so interested since I came in here in 1969. Sitting here today listening to the debate, if one did not know better, one might get the impression that the whole question of fishery limits, rights of access, exclusive bands, conservation and all the other matters vitally affecting our fishing industry suddenly blossomed up overnight and had never existed before and we must now press a little button in order to sort out everything. Of course we cannot do so. All these problems were there before and the current position has been reached because of years of mishandling of the whole matter by what is now the Opposition party in this House.

I take exception to the statement of Deputy O'Kennedy when he accused the Minister for Foreign Affairs of misleading the House. I am sure his lack of generosity in not withdrawing that remark will be noted and I hope the Minister will take the opportunity of replying to it in no uncertain fashion.

I should like now to go back in time to establish the line of thought in this whole matter and I am sure I will be forgiven if I quote from the Official Report. The debate is very enlightening. First of all, in Volume 249, column 588 of the Official Report of 4th November, 1970, there is a somewhat lengthy question and answer session. Two questions were addressed to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy J. Gibbons, by Deputy Begley and myself respectively. The Minister replied:

The question of common access to fishery waters as provided for in the common fisheries policy of the European Communities was raised by the Irish delegation at the Ministerial meetings with the Communities, who agreed to take careful note of our views. The Irish delegation has submitted a comprehensive memorandum on the subject and it was also further discussed at a meeting in Brussels on 20th October with the Communities. It is intended to pursue the matter further in the course of the entry negotiations.

Mr. E. Collins: Is the Minister aware of the grave concern expressed by fishermen on our access to the EEC if our fishery waters are thrown open to European countries?

Mr. J. Gibbons: Yes, I am so aware and this concern is being expressed in the proper quarter in the discussions which are at present going on in Brussels.

Mr. Begley: Can the Minister tell the House what assurances he got from the Common Market countries in view of the fact that they now have adopted a Common Market policy for fisheries and Ireland was not even consulted when this policy was adopted?

Mr. J. Gibbons: This whole subject is still the subject of negotiation with the Community in Brussels at the present time and I do not think it is appropriate, therefore, to go into it further here and now.

Dr. FitzGerald: Is the Minister aware of the helpful, informal suggestions made by Dr. Mansholt at the recent seminar in Dublin in response to a question I put to him on the subject? Will he follow up those suggestions?

Mr. J. Gibbons: Every suggestion which is helpful to the interests of the Irish fishermen the House can rest assured will be followed to its utmost.

Dr. FitzGerald: Is the Minister aware of the suggestion made?

Mr. J. Gibbons: I am not aware of the suggestion that Deputy FitzGerald is referring to.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that the suggestion Deputy FitzGerald was referring to was something which would enable us to make a claim in the economic zone two years later?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I am not making that suggestion.

Comment on this

I thought that was the Deputy's intervention earlier.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

This quotation is independent entirely of either the Minister's speech or the Deputy's speech. I give it because it enables the House to get the attitude of the then Fianna Fáil Government. It was obvious to us, including the Minister, then Deputy Dr. FitzGerald, that the then Government were not capable of making the derogations from the Treaty in their negotiations which would protect our fishery limits, conserve our fishery stocks or, indeed, lead to the expansion of the fishing industry. The whole attitude of the then Government was one of arrogance and indifference. There were practically no consultations with outside bodies interested in the industry. The answers given in the House to the parliamentary questions were such as to give the impression that the then Government were not really interested in the industry. I wish to quote now from column 677, Volume 256 of the Official Report of 10th November, 1971, in relation to questions put down by Deputy Kavanagh, Deputy Ryan, now Minister for Finance, Deputy Creed and myself. The Tánaiste, then Deputy Corish, in the course of supplementary questions to the Minister, asked:

Are the Government giving serious consideration to the idea of protection for a certain part of our coastline to the exclusion of the rest of the coastline? Would the Minister please bear in mind in these negotiations that the fishing grounds which have been deemed to be overfished in recent years due to the incursion of foreign trawlers are the fishing waters of South Wexford and South Waterford particularly as far as herrings are concerned? Would the Minister clarify the position of Mr. Brendan O'Kelly, head of Bord Iascaigh Mhara, who was excluded from the negotiations? Will the Minister not admit that this man has been and is a key figure in the fishing industry?

The then Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Brian Lenihan, replied:

I wish to emphasise that this is a Governmental matter in which we are seeking to preserve the rights which we have at this time and in this particular negotiation, which, as I say, has been adjourned until 29th November, we are all for seeking to preserve the situation along with Norway, Denmark and Britain.

In a further supplementary question I asked:

Is the Minister not aware that unless this Government makes it quite clear to the Council of Ministers in Europe that we reject the principle of free access the Government is putting into jeopardy the livelihood of all inshore fishermen?

The reply the Minister gave me was:

I wish Deputies would not play politics with this important matter.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I understand the position is that our motion may be discussed with the Government motion. Has our motion been circulated to the House? It is not on the Order Paper because there is no Private Members' time.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I believe it has been circulated in a White Paper.

Comment on this

We would like it circulated so that Deputy Collins and Deputy Esmonde would know what we have in mind.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I received a copy this morning.

Comment on this

I am sorry for interrupting the Deputy.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Again I give these quotations, and I am sorry they are so lengthy, to explain to the House the arrogance and indifference of that Government to the whole question of our negotiations, to draw attention to the exclusion of people who were involved in the industry at the time of the negotiations for our entry.

The last quotation I have is from column 865, Volume 258, of the Official Report of the 3rd February, 1972, at which time the negotiations had been completed. This quotation is somewhat lengthy, but I think it is worthwhile, because the moaning and groaning we are now hearing from the Opposition is in stark contrast to the stand they maintained in 1972. The then Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries said:

The most important development affecting our fisheries in recent years is, without doubt, Ireland's application for membership of the EEC. As Deputies are aware, one vital aspect of the EEC fisheries policy which came into operation on 1st February, 1971, had been a cause of concern to all of us. This concern arose from that part of the Community policy which provided for equality of access to and exploitation of fishery waters of each member State by the fishing vessels of the other member States. However, after protracted negotiations we have been successful in securing a satisfactory arrangement which has removed what we regarded as a serious threat to the livelihood of our fishermen and to the continued expansion of our fishing industry. This represented a major breakthrough, having regard to the position adopted by the Community earlier in the negotiations.

That was a complete and total defence of the derogation clauses which Fianna Fáil then negotiated. The House might like to know that in that discussion on Vote 38, Fisheries, it was the first time in which the regulations vitally affecting the fishery industry were discussed in the House. They happened to be raised by me, regulations 2141/70 and 4142. The then Parliamentary Secretary who was introducing the Supplementary Estimate made no reference whatever to those regulations, and they were discussed in my contribution and that of Deputy Keating, now Minister for Industry and Commerce. It was pointed out and I want to make this clear to the House and particularly to Deputy O'Kennedy, who has accused either the Minister, Deputy Dr. FitzGerald, or other Members of the Fine Gael and Labour Parties of not taking any other stance in that period. This is not so and if any Member of the House who may or may not be interested in the fishing industry takes time to go through the volumes of the Dáil Debates from 1969 to 1973 and particularly the Estimate from which I have just quoted, it will be quite plain to him that we in Opposition took violent exception to the negotiations which Fianna Fáil have made in respect of fisheries, and were completely dissatisfied with the derogations made in relation to the Accession Treaty.

Comment on this

May I ask the Deputy to refer us to one precise proposal from any Member of the then Opposition which would have ensured that our position under the extended economic zone would have been protected?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

The whole debate is here.

Comment on this

Just one proposal from any source.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

We made a comprehensive statement under that Estimate. I doubt if the Deputy has read it.

Comment on this

He has picked out one sentence.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I will go back then.

Comment on this

Raise the matter on the Adjournment.

Comment on this

It is obvious that the Deputy is not going to find it and he should not waste the time of the House.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I will find it. I have given so many quotations that it is difficult to find the relevant one. I should like to put on record another quotation by the then Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, as reported in Volume 258, column 1950, of the Official Report, which is:

Concern has been expressed in this debate, I think, by Deputy Collins about the future of the herring industry. I think I am right in saying that he described what was achieved in Brussels, even in the last few moments, as a sell-out. I should like to say that this criticism bears no relation whatsoever to the facts.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That was the attitude of the Government then. It is more obvious that it is the attitude of the Fianna Fáil Party since then. We must bear in mind also that at that time it was accepted that there was over-fishing, but the Government of the day were incapable of comprehending the problems facing the industry and incapable of negotiating sufficient derogation clauses in respect of fisheries to protect the industry. Our fishermen know too well the result of the treaty negotiated by Fianna Fáil on behalf of the country.

That was a damning debate and one which will stand to the discredit of Fianna Fáil for a considerable time. It ill behoves them to start crying here about the present situation when they were responsible for bringing it about. I am pleased that as and from 1st January next we will be establishing a 200-mile exclusive zone in association with our EEC partners. When we joined the EEC we automatically accepted our duties and responsibilities. I agree that it is better that the EEC take joint action in relation to any matters affecting member states at international level. I should also like to point out that the London Convention of 1964 was negotiated by Fianna Fáil and that was to the detriment of our fishermen.

The question of what will happen after 1982 is one which needs to be considered. There is need for an interim policy for the conservation of stocks and the protection of the fishing grounds of western Europe. I am aware that the Minister is involved in negotiations in this regard and it ill behoves the spokesman from Fianna Fáil to denigrate his efforts in this respect. It is obvious that quite an amount of work has been put into the question of the development of our fishing industry. The enthusiasm, work and dedication of the Government in relation to the fishing industry stands in stark contrast to what Fianna Fáil did when in Government.

Our claim is for an exclusive 50-mile limit and we are standing over that. I hope it will be successfully negotiated at EEC level under the terms of the common fisheries policy. It is up to us to revise that policy to our best advantage. Such an extension of the limit is vital to an industry which could prosper greatly in the near future. Our industry could prosper greatly if we could prevent illegal fishing of our waters.

On the question of the protection of our existing fishing limits I should like to state that there is a need for the expansion of our naval services. There is also a need for the permanent basing of a fishery protection vessel at Killybegs and Dunmore East at certain times. The law under which illegal fishing vessels are arrested should also be changed. Apparently, the only avenue open to us is to arrest at sea, but an arrest following air surveillance would be a positive step forward in our protection policy. If we adopted such a system we would be protecting our fishing grounds because an aeroplane can cover a greater area than a fishery protection vessel. I should like to know if any EEC aid will be forthcoming for the protection of our fishing grounds.

I was pleased to read in The Irish Times of 1st November that we would receive EEC aid in respect of our fishery protection policy. I hope we will be given a generous grant and that when the EEC are reviewing the policy in relation to protection they will consider changing the procedure of arrest. Conservation is a matter which has been causing concern for some years. At the meeting of the NEAFC some years ago concern was expressed about this and their fears proved correct because this year was the worst herring fishing season experienced in Dunmore East.

Quotas play an important part in the EEC's fishery policy. The Minister for Foreign Affairs sees quotas playing a minor role in the overall situation. We would prefer an exclusive ban of 50 miles. The irresponsible attitude of the Fianna Fáil EEC delegates at a recent European Parliament vote leaves a lot to be desired. There is no harm in having quotas to supplement exclusive fishery limits and to reject them did not do justice to our case at the European level.

Comment on this

It is only an excuse to kow-tow to the partners.

Comment on this

That is an inane remark.

Comment on this

To abstain on that issue was an inane thing to do. Any system must have quotas, at least for the outer areas.

Comment on this

It was the right thing to do.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

It was not the right thing to do. It was a disservice to our negotiating position and to the Irish fishing industry.

Comment on this

In what way?

Comment on this

The Government are being deluded by their own propaganda.

Comment on this

We are not being deluded by yours.

Comment on this

The Government have nothing to show but a bankrupt Exchequer and a ruined economy.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

The Fianna Fáil vote which defeated the motion before the European Parliament deprived that assembly of discussing fishery limits and that is another disservice of which the Fianna Fáil Party can be proud.

Comment on this

That is a mis-statement.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

The question of quotas is a peculiar one and the Fianna Fáil rejection of them is an about face. At column 1953, Volume 258 of the Official Report, the then Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries said:

The Commission consists of 14 countries and a special study group of the Commission met in Dublin in December, 1970, and reported on the position to the main body. The Commission is now considering adopting powers to introduce measures for regulating the amount of total catch, or the amount of fishing effort, or any other measure we can find to deal with this problem, the problem of the conservation of this very important Dunmore East stock. I find this absolutely necessary.

We are either for or against quotas. It is a matter for the Fianna Fáil Party.

Comment on this

The Deputy will be short of quotas the next time.

Comment on this

Surely Deputy Collins is aware that the herring fishing in Dunmore East is the worst ever. The more quotations he gives the more confused he seems to be.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

The lack of knowledge of the former Parliamentary Secretary, as outlined by my quotations, leaves a lot to be desired.

Comment on this

There is a lack of activity by the present Government.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

There was a lack of activity by Fianna Fáil when the Accession Treaty was being negotiated. The arrogance of the Fianna Fáil Party at that time has led to the present sad state of the fishing industry. We are now trying to remedy the situation and Fianna Fáil are trying to jump on the bandwaggon. Why did Fianna Fáil not introduce a 50-mile zone when they were in Government? Where were ye when the candle was lighting? Fianna Fáil do not know what they want. The records show that they were a negative Government with no respect for the potential livelihood of thousands——

Comment on this

The figure is 130,000.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

The Minister has put the case correctly. There is nothing that Deputy Brennan can do or say to move me from my stand in this respect, which is a complete rejection of Fianna Fáil policy on our accession to the EEC. The manner in which they handled our fishing negotiations at that time was contemptible.

Comment on this

Your stance is one of confusion and contradiction.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

My stance is based on my experience in this House since 1969. The records of this House will highlight my concern and interest in the fishing industry. The question of conservation of stocks affects our coast and the coasts of other European countries. During the past few years Iceland has suffered because of a reduction in her fishing stocks. Iceland must be congratulated on the stand she took in regard to her fishing limits.

To conclude, the position is that we are now facing a situation within the EEC where we will have, as from the 1st January, 1977, an exclusive 200-mile zone. That is progress, a damn sight more progress than anything Fianna Fáil showed. Discussions have been going on in relation to the expansion of the Irish fishery limit. The EEC are prepared to finance the policing of our waters. We are committed to an expansion of an industry which was for many years neglected by the Opposition. I hope that those involved in the industry will have confidence enough in themselves to expand their fleet, to go into deeper waters, to establish the industry on a sound footing and to set up a processing industry in Ireland—something which is needed for a fishing industry. In this respect I ask the Minister what would be the possibility of introducing a law that would force all fishing vessels to land their catches in Ireland irrespective of whether they were Irish or foreign vessels or foreign fleets. It would seem not to be going outside the terms of the treaty, as the law could be equally applicable to Irish and EEC member country fleets. It may be another way of establishing a processing industry in Ireland.

The industry itself has great potential. We need to expand the fishing vessels. We need to have proper finance for those involved in the industry. We need a very extensive and concentrated market for our products. In this respect I hope An Bord Iascaigh Mhara would play their part. The negotiations which the Minister has been, is and will be involved in in the coming years in respect of protection and conservation are vital to the industry and should have the support of the House and not be receiving negative criticism from the Opposition.

I sincerely hope that we will get a 50-mile fishing beat. Indeed, it is needed in the context of conserving stocks, and I would hope that the negotiations when concluded will be to the satisfaction of all those involved.

Comment on this

There have been suggestions recently that Ireland might in some way be acting detrimentally to the best interests of the Community if the position which we in Fianna Fáil seek to establish is maintained. There is a suggestion that we would be acting as bad Europeans, that we would be acting in contravention of the Community spirit. I want to state categorically that exactly the opposite is the case. It is certainly not Ireland but others who are acting in a selfish, nationalistic manner in this area, a manner which is completely in contradiction of the spirit of the European Community. There are certain fundamental principles enshrined in the Community treaties, certain ideals which are basic to the whole concept of European unity. One of those principles is set out clearly and explicitly in the preamble to the Treaty of Rome. It stipulates that member states:

Anxious to strengthen the unity of their economies and to ensure their harmonious development by reducing differences existing between various regions and the backwardness of the less favoured regions...

should do so and so. That is the principle to which everybody should be having regard in the context of this debate.

I ask the Minister, the person responsible to us in this context, as a member of the Council of Ministers, how can that principle set out in the preamble to the Treaty of Rome be reconciled with what is now being attempted in regard to fishery policy by certain member states, by the Commission and by others? Is it not crystal clear to everybody in this country and should it not be immediately crystal clear to everybody in the Community that our fisheries are one of the basic natural resources on which we must rely for our future economic development, one area that we could develop and exploit in order to compensate for the natural disadvantages we suffer by being geographically situated at the extreme of Europe?

The state of the Irish economy is well known in Brussels. The disastrous state of the Irish economy in fact has been described recently by a Commission expert as catastrophic. The state of the Irish economy has been officially accepted in Brussels as being catastrophic. One understands that the experts of the Commission are at the moment seeking ways and examining the mechanics of the Community to see how special aid can be channelled into the Irish economy, because the particularly unhappy state of the economy is fully known and recognised in the Commission. On the other hand, while Community experts are examining how special aid can be made available to the Irish economy, in this connection certain member states with the full connivance of the Commission are endeavouring to sequester one of Ireland's basic assets —her coastal fisheries.

I have already asked the question, I have not received any answer to it and I am going to ask it again. I asked the present Commission experts when I was in Brussels recently why should Irish fisheries, this one natural resource that our underdeveloped economy has at its disposal to develop, be thrown into a Community pool for the benefit of all the member states of the Community, when German steel, British oil, Dutch gas, none of these are thrown into a Community pool? British oil is an asset which has recently come upon the scene. Perhaps in that regard it is more relevant to my argument than some of the other resources. Have the Commission abrogated to themselves the right to lay down a regime whereby British oil will be exploited? Certainly not. Are the Germans prepared to put the exploitation of their natural mineral resources into some common pool in which we can all share through a Commission-designed structure? I ask the Minister to deal with that point. Why are fisheries isolated in this way, particularly in view of the fact that our economy is comparatively underdeveloped in relation to the rest of the Community?

I believe this is a brazen, blatant attempt by certain member states, acting in a nationalistic, selfish way, to exploit their political power in the Community to get access to something which should in all justice be reserved exclusively for the development of the Irish economy. We in Fianna Fáil are not prepared to accept this position. If the Minister were on the Opposition benches he would be boisterous, garrulous and emphatic in refusing to accept this position. I do not believe he has yet made it clear to this House, to the Irish people or to the Irish fishermen why he is adopting this ambivalent stance in regard to the common fisheries policy. We in Fianna Fáil, without any partisan approach, are simply asking this House to protect a basic Irish natural resource, to protect Ireland's national interest in this matter.

Deputy Collins betrayed the weakness of the Government's stance by going back to 1970 or 1972 and making party political debating points about the negotiations which took place at that time. Deputy O'Kennedy dealt with that. We all had responsibility for accepting that package at that time. I was not a Member of the Government who negotiated our entry into the EEC, but I supported our entry and this package, as did this Minister. The people will not believe us if those of us who accepted that package then come along now and say that there was something wrong with it and that it should not have been agreed to.

We are attempting to defend the Irish national position in two ways. The Minister, for reasons best known to himself, agreed at The Hague to extend our fishery limits to 200 miles without getting any cast-iron guarantee in return in regard to the protection and development of the Irish fishing industry. He did something else. He agreed to hand over to the Commission the negotiations in regard to the regime which will come into operation in those extended limits. These are two points we are now confronted with and which we must face. In pursuance of his undertaking to the Council of Ministers—and I cannot understand what the indecent haste is about this—he is asking Dáil Éireann to extend our fishery limits to 200 miles on 1st January, 1977.

We in Fianna Fáil suggest that he should not have given that undertaking. He should not have walked himself into that position but he is now faced with the consequences of that undertaking. We want to try to restore the situation in the national interest. We put down a motion which we asked be taken contemporaneously with the Minister's motion. Deputy Gallagher put forward a Bill which we hope will be taken next week in Private Members' Time.

I want to read the terms of the motion so that they will be on the record of the House, and because the procedure we are following today is a bit complicated. It seems we cannot debate two motions before the House at the same time. If the Minister with his voting majority insists on pushing through his motion and extending our limits to 200 miles at the same time, he should accept our motion which reads:

That, consequent on the extension of the exclusive fishery limits of the State and having regard to the fact that section 2 of chapter 3 of title II, Part Four of the Act annexed to the Treaty relating to the accession of Ireland to the European Economic Community and to the European Atomic Energy Community will be rendered inapplicable by the extension of exclusive fishery limits by all Member States, Dáil Éireann, being of the opinion that it is necessary to protect the livelihood of Irish fishermen, calls on the Government to make an order under section 3 of the Maritime Jurisdiction (Amendment) Act, 1964 restricting fishing in waters situated within fifty nautical miles, calculated from the baselines of the State, to vessels which operate from ports in the State.

In other words, we are asking the Government if they must, as apparently they must, extend our limits to 200 miles, they would at the same time give an undertaking to this House, to the people and to the fishermen, that they will make an order under section 3 of the Maritime Jurisdiction (Amendment) Act, 1964, as they are perfectly entitled to do and, as we submit, they are entitled to do under the existing Community legislation, to establish an exclusive 50 mile band for the development of the Irish fishing industry.

I hope the Minister will accept that motion contemporaneously with his own and thereby protect our national situation. If he is not prepared to do that, we will again come forward with the Bill in Deputy Gallagher's name which will legislate for this situation and which will lay down that within 50 miles of the baseline waters will be reserved to Irish fishing vessels and between that 50 miles and the 200 miles, the regime can be settled by a directive of the Community.

I think that is an entirely logical position for us to adopt. We would expect that the Minister if he is not going to accept our motion, will give us some positive, incontrovertible, concrete reasons why he will not accept it. He has the statutory power to do it and I hope I will prove now that he can do so and be entirely consistent with our legal obligations under the existing legislative regime of the Community.

Perhaps it is necessary to go back into the history of the development of the European common fishery policy. Before the Community was enlarged, the fishing rights of the existing Six were governed by Regulation 2141/7. It is no harm to mention here by way of an aside, again in relation to this suggestion that we in Ireland are being bad Europeans at present, that that regulation was rushed through by the existing Six in anticipation of the enlargement of the Community. Everybody will accept that that is so. The Six wanted to go into the enlarged Community with this structure tucked under their belts and to be able to negotiate from there. But the basic rule of that regulation of 1970, Article 2.1, obliged member states to ensure equal conditions of access to and use of fishing grounds situated in the maritime waters under their sovereignty or within their jurisdiction for all fishing vessels flying the flag of a member state and registered in Community territory —all perfectly simple and straightforward. The Six agreed to pool their fishing resources and to fish in each other's waters.

The important thing is the words "use of the fishing grounds situated in the maritime waters under their sovereignty and within their jurisdiction". I maintain that that applies exclusively to the fishing limits then laid down. Therefore, Regulation 2141 became applicable to the new member states by article 2 of the Act of Accession, but the provisions of article 2 of the Act of Accession were qualified by articles 100 and 101. I think there is common ground on that score. Article 2 adopted the regulation for a new and enlarged Community, but that adoption was subject to reservations contained in articles 100 and 101.

Article 100 of the Act applies not alone to the new member states but also to the original Six. That is of more academic importance than anything else. Article 100 is probably the only instance in the whole procedure of accession which involved a change for the original Six of a regime which was applicable to them before the new member states joined. The only importance of that is that it shows that fisheries at that time were dealt with in a way completely different from anything else. It is the only instance in the whole accession procedures where the regimes appertaining to the existing Six were gone back on. What had been a common patrimony between the Six original member states, by articles 100 and 101 was derogated from. In the enlarged Community fishing rights are governed by regulation 2141 as amended by articles 101 to 103 of the Treaty of Accession. There can be no gainsaying that situation by anybody.

The original regulation establishing a common fishery policy in the Community is in operation today only in so far as it is amended by articles 101 to 103. Article 6 of the Act of Accession states:

That Act may not unless otherwise provided for herein be suspended, amended or repealed other than by means of the procedure laid down in the original Treaties enabling those Treaties to be revised.

I want to draw the attention of the House to the provisions of article 6, which says that the Treaty of Accession "may not unless otherwise provided for herein be suspended, amended or repealed other than by means of the procedure laid down by the original Treaties enabling those Treaties to be revised".

I submit that what is happening now is that the Treaty of Accession is being amended and revised and that therefore article 206 of the Treaty of Rome applies to that act. Articles 100 to 103 of the Act of Accession were obviously intended to apply only to waters which were under the sovereignty or jurisdiction of member states at that time. The articles in question mention specifically six nautical miles and 12 nautical miles. They do not refer vaguely to exclusive limits or areas of coastal waters or anything of that sort. Articles 100 to 103, which modify the regulation, refer specifically to areas which are comprised within six miles and 12 miles of the base lines. The references to the six nautical miles and 12 nautical miles support that view.

Moreover, in paragraph 3 of article 100, it is provided that if a member state extends its fishing limits in certain areas to 12 nautical miles, certain consequences follow. I notice the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries is taking notes and I hope he will take note of the points I am making in that connection. In paragraph 3 there is no reference whatsoever to any further extension, to 50 miles or to 200 miles. It is clearly and categorically envisaging a situation where the limits can be extended to 12 miles and no further, and I do not think any lawyer can argue that that can be interpreted to mean an extension to 200 miles. If it did, some other form of words would have been used. The Act of Accession was clearly intended by the member states to be applicable to maritime waters within the jurisdiction of member states in 1972. Regulation 2141, which the Act purported to modify, must have been intended to have similar scope.

My point is that the Act of Accession referred only to and had knowledge only of and pertained only to areas of six and 12 nautical miles and nothing else, as modified by regulation 2141. That regulation also only applies at this stage of the proceedings to six and 12 nautical miles and to nothing else, and it is a complete fiction to imagine that the original regulation, as modified by the three articles of the Act of Accession, can in any way be considered as applying to a new extended 200-mile area.

It seems to me that the Commission implicitly have accepted that argument, because in the document which they presented to our Joint Committee in Brussels, R2227/76, the following quotation occurs:

At the same time the Commission considers it necessary that the Council should decide now on an extension, in time, of the provisions of Articles 100 and 101 of the Treaty of Accession with some additional provision designed to limit access to coastal waters to vessels which fish traditionally within those waters and out of nearby ports as well as, in certain special cases, provision for coastal fishermen to enjoy a privileged position in the allocation of catch quotas.

The Commission accepted quite clearly that what they are seeking to do now involves a revision of the Act of Accession, and what the Minister is attempting to do in extending our 200-mile limit and creating a new regime in respect of these extended areas is nothing more or less than an amendment and a revision of the Act of Accession, and should be treated as such.

I believe therefore that it is incontrovertible that a revision of the Act of Accession, a renegotiation, is necessary if the Community are to attempt to acquire rights in maritime waters over which individual member states propose now to acquire sovereignty, and I believe that pending such a revision of the Treaty of Accession nothing governs those extended waters except the national law. That is why we will come forward next week with a Bill to lay down the national law to cover those extended areas. Any impartial observer will admit there is substance in that argument.

Why then is the Minister for Foreign Affairs not attempting to make that case in Community councils? Why is he not attempting to make a stand on the argument I have made in Ireland's interest? Why does the Minister say:

The motion is based on the argument that the relevant section of the Accession Treaty dealing with fishing rights and comprising Articles 100 to 103 of that Treaty is rendered inapplicable by the extension of exclusive fishery limits by all the member states. Regrettably this assertion is ill-founded.

Why should our Minister be endeavouring to upset that assertion when it is in Ireland's interests that it should be maintained? I do not see why the Minister has to dig up all these quotations to try to defeat Ireland's claims. He quoted from the legal department of the Council of Ministers which he said succinctly summed up the situation in the following terms:

As the arrangements under Regulation No. 101/76 which consolidates 2141/70 apply to maritime waters over which a member State exercised its sovereignty or jurisdiction, they would therefore apply ipso facto to the 200 miles zone,——

I ask any lawyer in the House if that is a sequitur? To my mind it is a total non sequitur. It is stretching words to try to make them fit some indefensible conclusion. Even then they go on to say:

——with the proviso that, within the 12-mile zone, they applied it having regard to Article 100et seq of the Act.

The brilliant legal department of the Council of Ministers want us to accept this absurd situation, that in six and 12 miles because of the existing Community regime of legislation there are certain restrictions but from 12 to 200 miles there are no restrictions because of the same regime of legislation. To my mind that is a piece of legal nonsense. If the Minister adopts our position in this he can go to the International Court or anywhere else and maintain a case on the basis I have put forward.

Apart from the legal niceties, our case is quite simple. When the Treaty of Accession was being signed adopting the common fishery policy under Regulation 2141 it spoke specifically of waters under the jurisdiction and sovereignty of the countries——

Comment on this

Coming under.

Comment on this

Meaning coming under at that time.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Why is the Minister trying to put an anti-Irish interpretation on these simple words?

Comment on this

Is the Minister implying that "coming" in that sense relates to the future?

Comment on this

The unfortunate thing is that Fianna Fáil did not advert to it at the time. In fairness, none of us did.

Comment on this

We are talking about today.

Comment on this

The difficulty is that it was not adverted to in the Accession Treaty. We did not seek a modification on that point.

Comment on this

I leave it to the House and to the general public. My argument is simple and succinct. The provisions at that time applied only to the waters and the areas that were within the jurisdiction and sovereignty of the nations at that time. At this stage when different countries in the Community extend those areas to 200 miles it is a completely new factual and legal situation.

Comment on this

It was because the then Government made the mistake of putting a false interpretation at the time. They did not renegotiate this in the Treaty of Accession.

Comment on this

The Treaty of Accession is very clear, adopting Regulation No. 2141 to waters under sovereignty at that time——

Comment on this

Coming under.

Comment on this

"Coming" does not mean the future in that sense.

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying that "coming" in any legal sense relates to the future?

Comment on this

It means coming within.

Comment on this

If the then Government had adverted to this matter at the time they could have sought an accession treaty to modify the impact. Instead of which we went for the review process.

Comment on this

There is no legal justification for the Minister's interpretation and I am sure any lawyer would tell him that.

Comment on this

Even if there were some substance in the convoluted point the Minister is trying to make, why is he trying to make it? Why is he doing Ireland down in this way? Should he not be over there with all the great voluble skill he has, for which everyone praises him, making the point I am making on Ireland's behalf? Has he sold out to somebody?

Comment on this

I am negotiating, not making legal points. That is all right for the Opposition but I must negotiate.

Comment on this

Is it because the Minister and his colleagues have had to go cap in hand to the Commission and to the Council of Ministers seeking a loan to bail them out of their economic difficulties? Is it the case that he has no voice left in the Council of Ministers? Is this why he has to accept this humiliating position——

Comment on this

That is nonsense and the Deputy knows it.

Comment on this

That is why he will not fight Ireland's case as he could fight it on the legal basis I am putting forward. That is why he has to seek artificial definitions of what I am saying to try to justify the sell-out position he has adopted.

Comment on this

When the Deputy reaches that position there is no point in interrupting him.

Comment on this

Can the Minister contradict what I am saying?

Comment on this

It is total and absolute nonsense and the Deputy knows it. He is not fooling himself or the House.

Comment on this

The Minister is now so beholden to the Council of Ministers for bailing him out economically that he is incapable of putting any reasonable case to them. The present Commission will be going out of office in a few weeks. Why are they so adamant in rushing through this new regime? There is a new Commission coming in and one would have thought that it would be better to leave this complicated business to them but apparently we have to get everything tied up before the present Commission go out of office. To me it is inexplicable. They no longer have the moral authority to do these things but they are trying to force Ireland into this position.

On one occasion the Minister went over to The Hague and indulged in a certain form of manoeuvring over there. We had two statements, one by the Council of Ministers and another by the Minister alongside it. Of course that meant nothing, it was a piece of sleight-of-hand intended to deceive. As a result of that the Minister succeeded in having one of our Irish newspapers come out the following morning with a blazing banner headline saying that a great new deal had been procured for Irish fishermen. "An Irish Fishery Development Plan" was blazoned across the top of the front page of one of our national newspapers, obviously inspired by the Minister himself or by some of his propagandists. It was to the effect that the Minister had brought back from Brussels in his briefcase a new regime for the Irish fishing industry. Many figures were quoted. We were going to have 15,000 people employed in the industry and we would have 1,700 boats. It was all mapped out for a three-year period. However, when we got down to questioning the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries on the following week he admitted that there was no fishery development plan——

Comment on this

That is a complete lie.

Comment on this

He gave the figures for boats, year by year——

Comment on this

Including rowing boats. The Parliamentary Secretary has not the forked tongue of the Minister for Foreign Affairs. He had to be reasonably honest with this House when we questioned him——

Comment on this

I am always honest with the House.

Comment on this

The newspapers were quite clear that it emerged from the questioning across the floor of the House that there was no Irish fishery development plan.

Comment on this

That is a complete lie.

Comment on this

Is there one?

Comment on this

Of course. What does the Deputy think we were negotiating about?

Comment on this

Did the Minister negotiate a development plan with the Commission? Where is it?

Comment on this

On the basis of the plan which they accepted.

Comment on this

The Minister negotiated the basis of a plan? The Minister negotiated with the Commission on an Irish fishery development plan? Where is it?

Comment on this

On the basis of it.

Comment on this

The Minister negotiated on the basis of a plan.

Comment on this

Could we have a look at it?

Comment on this

It was made available to the Press at the time in regard to boats, people and fish catch. It can be made available to the Deputy if he wants it.

Comment on this

We are talking here about the alleged existence of an Irish fishery development plan. I am stating that the Minister for Foreign Affairs, in a major propaganda exercise in an endeavour to confuse the fishermen and the general public, sought to convey the impression that he brought back from Brussels approval for an Irish fishery development plan. When we asked the man responsible, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, a reasonably honest man in this regard, who is not capable of the Minister's evasions and dubious tactics, he admitted to us across the floor of the House that there is no such fishery development plan in existence.

Comment on this

That is not so. It is quite the opposite.

Comment on this

He gave the figures.

Comment on this

I asked for the document. I took the precaution of checking with An Bord Iascaigh Mhara who know nothing about any such fishery development plan. Where is the document?

Comment on this

It was issued to the Press at the time.

Comment on this

From Brussels?

Comment on this

No. The Press in Dublin. The figures covered catch, boats and personnel for the years ahead.

Comment on this

They were given in the Dáil on no fewer than three occasions.

Comment on this

I suggest that in this vital life and death matter, which involves the entire future of the Irish fishing industry, the behaviour of our Minister for Foreign Affairs has been dubious and evasive. His public pose throughout those last months has been as devious and as deceptive as his handling of the negotiations has been inept. I will also make a statement that he has assiduously leaked misleading reports to the media, that he has misled the Irish fishermen's representatives.

Comment on this

Deliberately?

Comment on this

The Deputy should never say that. He should withdraw it.

Comment on this

I will not withdraw it. I am making a categoric statement that the Minister has deliberately misled everybody, the Irish public, and the fishermen in connection with what is happening with regard to these negotiations.

Comment on this

I always understood the Deputy did not make personal charges.

Comment on this

This is not a personal charge. I am making a political charge in relation to the Minister in his capacity as a Minister.

Comment on this

On a point of order, when the word "misleading" was used previously the Leas-Cheann Comhairle said that he understood what was meant was unintentional as to say "deliberately misled" would, of course, be out of order in the House. The words "deliberately misled" have now been used. I ask, on a point of order, that they be dealt with in accordance with the procedure of the House.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison Acting Chairman (Mr. Pattison) Labour Party

The words "deliberately misled" are out of order. I ask Deputy Haughey to withdraw them.

Comment on this

I understand they may be out of order in regard to deliberately misleading the House, I am saying that the Minister has misled the fishermen and has sought to mislead Irish public opinion on what is happening in regard to the fishery negotiations.

Comment on this

The Deputy virtually called the Minister a liar. He said he deliberately misled.

Comment on this

I am saying that he has carried out a campaign to deliberately mislead the people on what is happening. I am saying that about him in his ministerial capacity. I am not saying anything about the Minister as a person. I am talking about his behaviour as a Minister.

Comment on this

I do not know how the Deputy can separate the man from his office. The Deputy knows as well as I do, as he is an intelligent man, that he cannot make the statement he made. He should withdraw it.

Comment on this

I will not withdraw my statement that to my best belief the Minister sought to create confusion and doubt about what is actually happening as a result of these negotiations in Brussels. I can quote from newspaper article after newspaper article to that effect as a result of official leaks by him as to what is actually happening which totally contradicted the real situation.

Comment on this

That is not what the Deputy said. He used the words "deliberately misled". If that is a withdrawal, I accept it. If it is not a withdrawal, I suggest the Deputy should withdraw it.

Comment on this

I will withdraw any imputation against the Minister personally. I would never make such an imputation. I am talking about the Minister's behaviour in his ministerial capacity.

Comment on this

There is no such distinction.

Comment on this

I will make a distinction. I am talking about the statements which either the Minister or his Department issued, the leaks that were made, the impressions created.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is out of order to accuse a Member of deliberately misleading and should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I do not know what the ruling is? Is the ruling that I must not say that the Minister deliberately misled the House. I can see that being unparliamentary. If that is your ruling, I certainly accept it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deliberately misleading is the same as accusing——

Comment on this

We all accuse each other of deliberately misleading the Irish public. That is part of political accusations.

Comment on this

The Deputy is misleading the Irish public at the present time.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It has been ruled out of order heretofore. Deliberately misleading is the same as calling somebody a liar.

Comment on this

Let us refer the matter to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. I am prepared to withdraw it.

Comment on this

We have a point of order settled here not at the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. The Deputy has been asked to withdraw the remark.

Comment on this

I will not withdraw it. I withdraw any imputation that the Minister deliberately misled the House.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The words used by Deputy Haughey, "deliberately misleading", are out of order.

Comment on this

Misleading the public are not.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

"Deliberately misleading" is out of order.

Comment on this

The Minister misled them in the last election.

Comment on this

I cannot accept that ruling. Political debate would cease if I had to accept that.

Comment on this

If we cannot accept the ruling of the Chair, we cannot continue with the debate.

Comment on this

I will continue with the debate.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

"Misleading" is in order but "deliberately misleading" is out of order and should be withdrawn.

Comment on this

I want to say what I believe the Minister's tactics in this regard were.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy withdrawn the statement? If not, what procedure does the Chair intend to adopt in the matter?

Comment on this

Deputy Collins waxed eloquent attacking every Fianna Fáil Minister there ever was for national treachery. He was not taken to task.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

There have been numerous clear rulings on this question. The statement Deputy Haughey made is definitely out of order. The statement that a Member was deliberately misleading the House or public——

Comment on this

Or public?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Yes, it definitely has been ruled out of order on numerous occasions.

Comment on this

Who gave the Chair that advice?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

It is there by precedent on many occasions.

Comment on this

It should be applied to the two sides of the House.

Comment on this

You are not playing the game.

Comment on this

I am surprised that you permitted Deputy Collins to proceed with the things he said that we took in kind as part of political debate in the House and that you are now being so assiduous in pursuing this matter, which has nothing to do with the rules of the House, nothing to do with an imputation of the Minister about the House.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy withdrawing the statement?

Comment on this

If the Minister had not said that, I might have. I will not be bullied by the Minister. That may be his tactics but it would be much better if he tried bullying his fellow Ministers in the Council of Europe.

Comment on this

I am not prepared to be called a liar by Deputy Haughey.

Comment on this

The Minister will not tell the Wexford fishermen that he deliberately misled them.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair wants to know if Deputy Haughey is withdrawing the statement?

Comment on this

Every fisherman in Wexford will believe it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Could we have some order?

Comment on this

I believe, by the Minister's tactics in this regard, that he sought to create the maximum amount of confusion in the public mind that he could.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is the Deputy withdrawing the statement he made?

Comment on this

I am not arguing any more about it.

Comment on this

He has not to do that.

Comment on this

Surely the Deputy realises that there are certain rules in the House and that when the Chair asks him to observe them he does so.

Comment on this

I am consistently a reasonably well behaved Member of this House. I am making a political charge. The Minister for Foreign Affairs, in regard to this matter, has been less than forthcoming with the Irish fishermen.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Before the Deputy proceeds, is he withdrawing the unparliamentary remark?

Comment on this

I made no unparliamentary statement that I have to withdraw.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I will have to send for the Ceann Comhairle because what the Deputy has said is clearly unparliamentary.

Comment on this

What was unparliamentary.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The charge that the Minister or indeed any Member was deliberately misleading the House or the public.

Comment on this

I did not say that. I certainly said that the Minister was deliberately misleading the public.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is unparliamentary.

Comment on this

Even if he is telling the truth?

Comment on this

I do not think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is being very fair or impartial in this matter. The Leas-Cheann Comhairle's conduct in this debate is not impartial. However, the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is in the Chair and I will accept the ruling.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am applying the rule here as it has been applied consistently down through the years.

Comment on this

It was not applied to Deputy Collins a short time ago.

Comment on this

Deputy Haughey said that the Minister was deliberately deceiving the public. That statement has been made thousands of times before in the House. This is a laughing stock. Deputies have abused every Minister and every ex-Minister in this way over the years.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I have made the ruling on it. The Chair has made the ruling on it and the Chair has been guided by precedent.

Comment on this

The Chair should not be influenced by the Minister.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair is not influenced in any way. Deputy Haughey has now withdrawn the statement.

Comment on this

I did not withdraw anything. I accepted the ruling.

Comment on this

Has the Deputy withdrawn the statement?

Comment on this

I have accepted the Chair's ruling.

Comment on this