We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Maritime Jurisdiction (Exclusive Fishery Limits) Order, 1976: Motion.

Contributions 231–447 of 447. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Acting Chairman

Deputy Haughey has accepted the ruling of the Chair so I am assuming that he has withdrawn the statement.

Comment on this

I have previous experience of the Minister's vindictive capacity for seeking to extract his pound of flesh.

Comment on this

I do not like being called a liar and this is understandable emotion.

Comment on this

I did not call the Minister a liar. I have never in this House deliberately called anybody a liar and I hope I will not. I was making what I thought was a legitimate political charge against the Minister for Foreign Affairs in the circumstances of recent developments. The Chair has ruled that what I said was not in accordance with parliamentary procedure. I am accepting the ruling. The Minister for Foreign Affairs is being tendentious if he says I called him a liar.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Could we get back to the motion before the House?

Comment on this

Could the Minister for Foreign Affairs stop interrupting me?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Could Deputy Haughey proceed with the motion?

Comment on this

Will the Leas-Cheann Comhairle administer the rules of the House impartially and stop the Minister for Foreign Affairs from interrupting me tendentiously and provocatively?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair will certainly do that if Deputy Haughey proceeds with the debate.

Comment on this

Does the Minister accept that the statement which he made here today is totally at variance with and contradicts the statement which he made to the Council of Ministers on 18th and 19th October?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am calling on Deputy Haughey to resume his speech. No one else is entitled to speak except Deputy Haughey, who was in possession and should resume.

Comment on this

Is the Leas-Cheann Comhairle admonishing me now to proceed having interrupted me to the best of his ability? In page 5 of the Minister's statement he said that:

As regards third countries, we have of course agreed to postpone our right to veto agreements with third countries, something which is vitally important to any of our Community partners, until such time as permanent agreements come to be negotiated to replace the interim agreements which the Community is now seeking with Iceland, Norway and the Faroes.

Why have we "of course agreed to postpone our right to veto agreement with third countries"? Here we are talking about Russia, Eastern Europe and other countries which are particularly virile in their ravaging of the seas around our coast. Whatever the Minister's commitment to member states within the Community, I cannot understand his reasons for saying that he agreed "of course" to postpone his right of veto on agreements with third countries. Perhaps when the Minister replies he will overcome his natural animosity to any point I make and deal with this particular statement. We are dealing with something very fundamental and far-reaching here. This is not a situation which will be dealt with by ministerial evasion or by the Minister for Foreign Affairs briefing friendly correspondents, as he is wont to do on occasions like this.

Comment on this

Deputy Haughey has more friendly correspondents than the Minister for Foreign Affairs.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Haughey without interruption, please.

Comment on this

Will the Leas-Cheann Comhairle admonish the Parliamentary Secretary for interrupting me? There are Rules of the House that should be enforced.

I have been endeavouring to say that in this regard we are dealing with a situation which is of fundamental and critical importance to this country. We are dealing with the natural resource which could be used to procure a great deal of worthwhile beneficial economic developments, which could be exploited to build up a valuable labour-intensive industry which would be decentralised by its very nature, and which would bring prosperity and employment to those regions of our country which need every advantage and benefit that we can possibly provide for them. One would imagine that it is the sort of thing that the Commission in Brussels, if they had Ireland's economic welfare and development at heart, would be helping us to develop and exploit to the greatest possible extent we could.

I would ask the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Government to see it in that way. This is a crucial turning point in our membership of the European Economic Community. It is a test of faith for many Irish people of the goodwill of the Community. The future of the Irish fishing industry depends basically on the establishment of an exclusive 50-mile zone for Ireland's fishermen. Nothing else matters. The Minister should already have clear evidence of that fact in what has happened in the recent document which the Commission has brought out, which he is afraid to disclose to the House because of its contents. The Minister knows what the Commission propose for 1977. He says the document is confidential. Why is it confidential? Its contents were leaked in the Agence report last week. The Minister knows from what the Commission are proposing in that document that we cannot rely on anything the Commission will bring forward as a regime for the future of the Irish fishing industry. They will propose some minimum useless quota for Ireland for 1977. That is an indication of the way things are going.

If we hand over, as the Minister would do when we pass this motion, our coastal seas to the Commission we can forget about the development of an Irish fishing industry. That is the naked, brutal truth of the matter.

Comment on this

That is what Fianna Fáil did in 1972. They did just that. They handed over the fisheries to the Community. That is what happened.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Haughey is in possession and he must be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

The fishermen will not thank the Parliamentary Secretary for that kind of thing.

Comment on this

Be factual.

Comment on this

I am being factual. I have put forward what to my mind and to the mind of any impartial observer is conclusive legal argument that we have a legal right now under Community legislation to lay out our own regime for the extended fishery limits and the fishermen will not thank the Parliamentary Secretary for partisan political remarks about what happened or did not happen in 1972. They are concerned with what is happening now and that is what we are concerned with too.

Comment on this

What we are doing now is rectifying the mistakes made in 1972.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I call on the Parliamentary Secretary to allow Deputy Haughey to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has not made one statement in support of the fishermen since this controversy started and it is a bit late in the day now for him to be defending them.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Haughey is in possession and no one else. He is entitled to speak without being interrupted.

Comment on this

I am suggesting that modern Ireland with an undeveloped economy in the European Community of nations is entitled to the exclusive use of a 50-mile zone to develop this, perhaps last, natural unexploited resource in the seas around our coast. I am suggesting a case can be legally maintained and that we are perfectly entitled to legislate here for a 50-mile zone exclusive to Irish fishing. I am suggesting that the extension the Minister is proposing of 200 miles creates an entirely new legal, constitutional, factual situation and the Minister has every moral and legal right to accept our motion to introduce legislation for an exclusive 50-mile limit and I urge him, in the interests of Irish fishermen and in the general interests of Irish economic development, to accept our motion concurrently with his own and ensure that position.

Comment on this

Far be it from me to try to defend the Minister for Foreign Affairs in our fishery negotiations. There is no one better able to do that than the Minister himself. His integrity has been brought into question in the course of this debate and for that reason I will impose on the time of the House to make a few pertinent observations. As one who has always, and not just in 1976, in 1975 or in 1972, believed in the necessity and desirability of an exclusive limit to save our fishing industry, I must now examine the position that obtained when we, in the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, went negotiating with our colleagues in the Department of Foreign Affairs. Since our entry to the Community the task of our Minister for Foreign Affairs has been a burdensome one, probably more burdensome than in any other Ministry, but I assert here and, through the House, to the country that there is nobody—I emphasise nobody—could have given us more help and assistance than did the Minister for Foreign Affairs. He sat in on numerous occasions with the officials of the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries. He met the fishermen's organisations. He studied every aspect of the fisheries question day in and day out and, as I said here on another occasion, he burned a great deal of midnight oil.

Comment on this

Is he for or against the 50-mile limit?

Comment on this

There is no doubt in my mind, as there can be no doubt in anybody's mind, that there is no one inside this House who could excel the present Minister for Foreign Affairs in work, in endurance and in the energy he applies to whatever task he turns his hand. I am not a member of his party but, as I said on another occasion here, we are fortunate in having a man of his calibre and capacity to head our delegation in our negotiations on this fishery question.

Comment on this

This is very relevant to the motion, I must say.

Comment on this

It is completely relevant because an attack was made here on the integrity of the Minister. I am quite positive that all the statements he has made to this House, to the fishermen and to the country were all factual and truthful.

Comment on this

Do not forget the journalists.

Comment on this

What have we been doing during the last number of months? We have been negotiating a new fisheries policy.

Comment on this

Negotiating a new policy, not an agreement.

Comment on this

On what foundation are we building? On a very sandy foundation. I know quite well that this emotiveness on the part of Fianna Fáil is engendered for purely political purposes because in 1970, 1971 and 1972 there was not a single word here about fisheries. That was the time we were negotiating our entry into Europe. I was a member of a party opposed to entry at that time.

Comment on this

On a point of order, is it in order for the Parliamentary Secretary to accuse us of doing things for political purposes?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

Another new ruling?

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is attacking our integrity.

Comment on this

We were then rushing into this European Community without proper preparation in a number of areas, one of the most notable being our fisheries. Deputy O'Kennedy agreed—that is the only implication— that nothing could be done about fisheries at that time. No move of any kind was made. I said here a few weeks ago that, so acute was our desire to rush into the Community, fisheries were swept under the carpet. It has been admitted by Deputy Haughey that the common fisheries policy of the Six was a disaster and he has asserted in the course of his statement here that this policy was rushed through and finalised by the Six before the additional three could get a chance of joining the Community. If this was so, then it was evident to our negotiators, evident to the Government in 1970, 1971 and 1972, and evident to those of us who were told by the Commission's officials dealing with this question that our negotiations were not as they should be.

It could be easily seen at the time —and that was the impression I got in Brussels on a number of occasions —that the EEC were very anxious that Ireland would become a member of the Community. They felt perhaps that our geographical position would be strategically helpful. I do not know, but on a number of counts they were anxious to admit us. However, as far as the discussions with Community officials were concerned, from the commissioners down, they were completely factual. Every statement they made, as far as I can recollect, was a truthful, factual appraisal of the position under every heading, whether it was agriculture, fisheries, regional affairs, social welfare or any other matter. They had booklets and numerous leaflets on all these questions. But the Government here at the time suppressed these booklets and leaflets and all other EEC pamphlets and in place of them issued their own concoction of half truth and half lies.

That is what the people had before them in May, 1972, when they went to the polls and when 83 per cent of them said "We do not want to hold on to our sovereignty as we know it up to the present. We cannot live in an isolated position. We want to become members of the Community." We became members of the Community and, in my opinion, we have to acknowledge the expressed view of the majority of the Irish people, 83 per cent of them, in 1972, and that the negotiations must be carried on within that context.

Subsequent to the announcement of the referendum results, we as a party, acknowledging the people's expression of opinion, acknowledging the uncertainty of their views, stated that we were without question accepting the expressed wish, through the ballot box, of the Irish people, and that we would as a political party, whether in Opposition or in Government or whether participating, as we are at present, in a Coalition Government, do the best we possibly could within the community to bring whatever benefits were available to our people, and that is what we are doing.

I am a firm believer in this coastal band. This, as I said, is my view, as a man living on the sea year in and year out. It was my view in the 1950s. I have expressed it again and again in the course of several fishery debates down through the years that fishing was a great source of revenue which would provide a great deal of economic development. That is what Deputy Haughey said about it a few minutes ago. He added to that numerous other statements all in support of fisheries being a great source of revenue to our economy. That is a factual statement and I do not find fault with it, but in the not too distant past, when Deputy Haughey was a member of the Government and Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, why had he not that view of fisheries? Why did his successor and predecessor in the Fianna Fáil Party who were in charge of fisheries not have that view? Why was it that we were warning at the time that we should be more watchful in our negotiations with the Six and try to get outstanding questions in such matters as fisheries and other fields, as I mentioned already, attended to?

Our negotiations, as we said during the campaign, were a shambles. We were rushing in. We were told that this European Community would act towards us, a small off-shore island, as a fairy godfather. These were all people who would take a broad view, and if poor Ireland wanted any special handouts, here was the godfather with his hands in his pockets ready to give us what we required. Deputy Gallagher has changed his mind. According to the interviews he has given to the Press quite recently, this fairy godfather is becoming a little ruthless with this country and is not behaving as we would like him to behave. People who were saying in 1972 that the EEC was a kind of heaven upon earth are now saying we should be thinking of pulling out.

My remarks on the EEC relate solely to fisheries. This is the question at issue, and this is the question, I want to emphasise again, that did not get the attention it should have got in our negotiations in 1972. What should we do? Deputy Haughey says we should ignore our membership. He brings in this political motion here in the name of Deputy Gallagher and suggests we should declare an exclusive band of 50 miles. I would love to say that. I am in full agreement with that point of view, but are we entitled to do it?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Do our legal commitments entitle us to do that?

Comment on this

The statement here prepared by the legal people attached to the Department of Foreign Affairs does not tell us that. That is what we would like to do. Some may ask why we do not emulate the example of Iceland, Norway, Canada and other South American countries. These are independent countries who do not have to consult other people. We are obliged under our commitment to consult other people.

Comment on this

We are in the pocket of the EEC officials.

Comment on this

We are, if you like. The Deputy helped to put us in the pocket, particularly in the fisheries business. Is there any Fianna Fáil Deputy of the four present here who can say we made any effort to help the Irish fishing industry in 1970, 1971 or 1972, the years when we were negotiating? They cannot. However, I have already stated on a number of occasions that there is no use in crying over spilt milk. The reason I refer to this question again is that, listening to the statements opposite, one would think that all this happened because of the ineptitude of the Minister for Foreign Affairs and that when Fianna Fáil left office on 14th March, 1973, everything in the garden was rosy as far as our fisheries are concerned.

I have not the legal frame of mind of Deputy Haughey or of the Fianna Fáil spokesman in this debate, Deputy O'Kennedy, but this is my interpretation: we have this position facing us, that in May, 1972, we agreed to a common fisheries policy which was then operating within the six original countries of the Community, and so far as our interests were concerned, this policy was deemed to be disastrous. That has been admitted already here tonight because it is factual and there is no counter-argument. For some unknown reason, possibly because it would hinder other activities —when I say "other activities" I mean activities relating to other industries—we did not make any noise about our fisheries. We had signed on the dotted line and we had to retain the status quo for a period of up to ten years. According to all the Community documents I have read—irrespective of the quotation by Deputy Haughey—after 1982 there would be common access. That was the policy of the existing member states and the three new members did not change it. Norway voted against entry mainly because they could not get a change in that policy.

After we had entered the Community the Law of the Sea Conference commenced and the question of making economic zones of up to 200 miles arose. Deputies Haughey and O'Kennedy, both former Ministers, have admitted that in 1972, even with all the information at their disposal in their respective Departments, they could not see two years ahead. They did not anticipate that there would be big changes as far as fisheries were concerned. Now they are introducing their redemption policy, knowing the shambles they made of fisheries, by saying that once the Law of the Sea Conference took place and resolutions such as that before the House were introduced, a new situation arose. The Minister for Foreign Affairs is at present trying to renegotiate a new situation. We are debating a resolution which has been approved by the Community and the parliaments of other member states are engaged in a similar exercise.

Is it the contention of Fianna Fáil that we should pull out of the EEC? I would not like to see that happening because when we are in we should try and make the best of what we find within the Community. During the campaign before our entry into the EEC my main objection to entry was centred around our lack of negotiation. I believed our negotiations were carried out on a low profile. I can recall having a private conversation with an official of the Commission in relation to this matter. That official, a devoted European, pointed out that small countries such as Ireland could not exist in isolation but that in the negotiations our Government were very soft.

Comment on this

Dúirt bean liom gur dúirt bean léi.

Comment on this

I asked that official for a definition of the term "very soft" pointing out that there was little our Government could do, but he pointed out that we could have got these fishery concessions in 1972 without any trouble. I am of that opinion also.

Comment on this

Get them now.

Comment on this

Deputy Haughey sold out.

Comment on this

I was not a member of the Government then.

Comment on this

My apologies. I accept that Deputy Haughey was not a member of the Government then.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is a generous man.

Comment on this

I accept that he was not a member of the Government. I erroneously stated that he was a member of the Government. Because we had a population of less than three million there was a certain amount of sympathy for us. It is possible that other states were over sympathetic because we were better off than they thought we were. However, it amazes me that our negotiators did not work on that sympathetic view to help us.

Comment on this

Get the sympathy now.

Comment on this

The Deputy was not too vocal in 1971.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary was always vocal.

Comment on this

We give as much consideration as possible to the people living on the islands around our coast. We know they labour under disadvantages and have difficulties to contend with. I have fought their case time and time again and I am acknowledging the fact that Deputy Haughey gave these people a generous allowance.

Comment on this

Why does the Parliamentary Secretary not give them salmon licences?

Comment on this

The number of licences issued to islanders has increased six times. The issuing of licences is determined in accordance with the criteria laid down for this purpose.

Comment on this

Who determines it?

Comment on this

The boards of conservators. The Europeans considered us in the same way in which we considered our island people. They saw us as an island race labouring under disadvantages. But our standing was good, which is an important factor.

Deputy O'Kennedy introduced the card game into this debate. He dealt at length with trump cards. He implied that the Minister could negotiate in Brussels and Luxembourg with trump cards up his sleeve, that he pulled some vital cards too fast and laid them on the table. Deputy O'Kennedy did not have a trump card. If he had his sleeve he certainly did not play it at any stage of the game.

Deputy Gallagher was not a Member of the House at the time, but I have no doubt that he was interested in this matter. I am confused by some of his recent statements, particularly the one in relation to being cross with the EEC, threatening to withdraw and so on. If we were to do that I wonder what the other members of the Community would say. The motion meets everybody's approval but it cannot be implemented. This is a legislative assembly and we make laws in accordance with our Constitution. It is all very well to insist on an exclusive 50-mile limit but the Minister must try to achieve it legally. The Minister was outspoken to all concerned in connection with the negotiations and did the best he could in the circumstances. Does Deputy Haughey assert that this motion can be approved and that——

Comment on this

I have argued that point.

Comment on this

This is a matter——

Comment on this

That motion is totally compatible with the existing legal situation in the Community.

Comment on this

It has been said that we were begging for favours from the Commission. The Minister is trying to get a 50-mile band with the approval of our Community partners. He has said that an interim arrangement has been made in regard to fisheries.

Comment on this

What is wrong with the motion?

Comment on this

We are trying to work as fast as we can within the limitations imposed by the Community. I am not a believer, in the circumstances, in unilateral action. If circumstances warrant, it should and could be taken but it is something we should avoid as far as possible. We must try to get the best we can for our fisheries, but we will be debating regional activities of one kind or another during next year. We will be debating agriculture and other industries and we will be saying that we must try to get the best we can for all such industries. This is the position that the Minister for Foreign Affairs has to contend with. He is not confined to fisheries. He has a global responsibility for many of our industrial activities here together with the appropriate Departments. It is a matter for him, by virtue of his appointment as Minister and of the powers and functions vested in him by this House when they approved him as Minister, to do the best, in a definite term, that he possibly can. I think he has done that. He has told us again and again that he wants to live with Community laws as far as it is possible to do so, and surely Deputies opposite crying from the housetops about the advantages of the Community cannot say he is wrong in doing that.

I listened to some of the statements made by Deputy E. Collins from Waterford, and I do not think it necessary to repeat any of them. Unfortunately, I was not present for his entire speech but I can endorse the statements he made. They were factual and set down the position clearly.

I refer now to the Minister's speech, and Deputy Haughey has quoted from it. I would say that I would not be quoting from it now were Deputy Haughey not present. This is open for debate by subsequent speakers. I quote:

Basically what we are bound by is Council Regulation 2141/70 subject only to such derogations as were agreed at the time of membership and as are incorporated in the Accession Treaty.

The Minister today says that is basically what we are bound by. He goes on:

The relevant article of Regulation 2141/70 is article 2 which says that rules applied by each member state in respect of fishing in the maritime waters coming under its sovereignty or within its jurisdiction shall not lead to differences in treatment of other member states.

Is that not a clear-cut statement? This is taken from the laws and regulations governing the fishing industry.

Comment on this

What is the Minister negotiating for?

Comment on this

This is a complete new job of work.

Comment on this

What is he negotiating?

Comment on this

He is negotiating a new fisheries policy for Ireland.

Comment on this

What has that got to do with it?

Comment on this

This is what he found before.

Comment on this

This is a completely new one from what went before.

Comment on this

Yes, but it has made it so much more difficult for the Minister and the Government because the Opposition agreed to this kind of assertion, these kinds of regulations when they agreed to enter the Community in 1972.

Comment on this

That is our point; that is a new situation.

Comment on this

Yes, the Deputy made the point that it is a new situation by virtue of the 200-mile economic zone question and we are building on that. We are in Government for only three years and some months and it is peculiar that at that time the Government could not see any change in the fishing industry. The fishing industry is in Ireland since Adam's time and that is a few years back. Fishing has been here all the time with or without State aids of one kind or another and has always been an important source of income even in the last century.

Comment on this

The Minister's argument is that those regulations bind the new situation. We are saying they do not.

Comment on this

The Minister is trying to get approval to remove these stipulations. Is that not what he is negotiating on?

Comment on this

No. He said they govern the new situation. We say they do not.

Comment on this

He is trying to amend them or to have them retracted or rescinded.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary said he was negotiating a completely new policy.

Comment on this

I would be satisfied with the type of policy we have. If we have the present policy by 1982 which is only five years hence, when we find ourselves with the Belgians, Dutch, German and French boats fishing off our shores, he has to do that. More important, he has to try to keep the Eastern Europeans away from Ireland. I agree with Deputy Gallagher that it does not matter to the fishermen here whether the boat fishing on the 12-mile limit is British, French, German or Dutch; it is all the same to him. They are taking up his fish. What the Minister has said is that he is trying within the framework of the Community to get this benefit from what we are legislating for today, the phasing out of our Eastern European visitors in particular who are not welcome to our shores.

Comment on this

On the contrary, he has withdrawn his veto on them.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Interruptions are not in order.

Comment on this

It is quite clear in the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries that we must try through whatever forces are at our command to achieve this objective. To my mind the only force at our command is the Community. The Minister is as perturbed as anybody about the inflow of Eastern European boats around our coasts.

Comment on this

Why did he withdraw his veto?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Deputies should not interrupt.

Comment on this

My claim must always be that we do not poach on anybody's waters. Iceland got this 200-mile zone. They have flexibility about their coastal band which they fought for and won, and I admire them. I had the privilege of being over there for a time and meeting many of these people and seeing what fishing meant to them. We are like Iceland, an island somewhat similar in size, and we possibly could be doing the same thing and we are entitled to the same benefits. However, we have to go through the Community. The Minister also states:

I think it unfortunate at the time of the negotiation we did not succeed in securing a more fundamental modification of Article 2141/70....

Was any effort made to secure a modification of that article? In the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries the answer is "no". There is no document of any kind that I can find relative to our European negotiations four years ago that would lead us to believe that any such move so far as modification is concerned was made.

I am a believer in the coastal band of 50 miles. I do not accept quotas because one cannot ascertain if they are adhered to. If people over-fish their quotas it is hard to detect them doing so. We had quotas—and they were probably better than nothing— but they are only useful to a limited extent. I do not believe they are suitable for us. Suitability here means exclusivity, and that is very difficult to achieve.

I cannot say what the outcome of the negotiations will be because I do not know for how long they will continue. They may take years. Our stand is outlined in public statements. Whether we get approval for it or not, I cannot say. All we as a Government can say is that we will fight for it and we will give every possible assistance to develop this industry. There is no doubt about that. Every person, whether he is engaged directly in fishing or indirectly in boat building, processing plants, transport and so on, will get the best assistance we can give.

In a number of parliamentary questions Deputy O'Kennedy asked about the availability of plans and documents. Some documentation was deemed to be confidential and the Deputy said that all these documents should be made available to him. I want to tell the House what I learned in the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries. There are no great secrets in that Department. What secrets could there be about harbour development works? I have always given to any Deputy who asked full information on any topic. During Fianna Fáil's time reports on harbours were secret and confidential. I had occasion to look at these files in order to answer questions here and was amazed to read that the report of a survey team was deemed confidential.

It is good to have a debate like this on fisheries even though I know Fianna Fáil are trying to redeem some of their lost prestige with the industry. The good thing about this is that fisheries have at last got publicity in the national and local press. Fisheries are covered on radio and television and people living inland are now talking about the industry. The fact that people all over the country are anxious to develop this industry is bound to be helpful. In my position as Parliamentary Secretary I can assure every Deputy on both sides of the House that I will give any assistance I can.

Each Deputy, on average, is responsible to 7,000 people. It is a Deputy's job to make representations on behalf of his constituents, cumainn and clubs. The occupant of any office should accommodate Deputies in the best way possible. We all know the work Deputies do.

I realise Fianna Fáil have possibly repented and would like to have done better, but it is no harm to see them making amends. I would like to see all public representatives uniting as much as possible. We are bound to have differences—this is political business— ensuring that our fishing industry will grow and prosper. However, let us hope that eventually we will get the exclusive band we seek.

Comment on this

After that very nice lecture by the Parliamentary Secretary I am sure we will all go away very happy and satisfied that the fishing industry is being well looked after. We are aware of the situation. We do not need to listen to lectures because we know that at this moment the whole future of the fishing industry is in serious doubt. The Minister for Foreign Affairs may be a very hard worker and jet from country to country and I do not think anybody will doubt that he is working to his capacity on behalf of our people. Nevertheless it can be said that this Minister is rather naive, that he does not fully understand the situation and likes to get involved in semantic exercises or in any kind of mathematical calculations. The real exercise we want to get him interested in, and to devote all his time to, is to ensuring that we get our 50-mile exclusive limit. Nothing else will do. As the Parliamentary Secretary said, according to all the legal advice available to his Department, we cannot get the 50-mile limit.

Comment on this

I did not make that statement.

Comment on this

I wrote it down as the Parliamentary Secretary was saying it. If we cannot get this 50-mile limit what is the Minister negotiating?

Comment on this

He is trying to rectify what Fianna Fáil negotiated.

Comment on this

Deputy Haughey was castigated for accusing the Minister of misleading the public, yet the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs can call Deputy Haughey a security risk and nobody takes any action. Again, we have the application of double standards. We were given a lecture by the Parliamentary Secretary to the effect that everything in the garden was rosy. What I find most significant about this statement by the Minister for Foreign Affairs is that we have become quite used to the chronic unemployment situation being blamed on the oil crisis; we have become used to the drop in our tourist industry being blamed on the situation in Northern Ireland; and reading this document by the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Fianna Fáil are now being blamed for the policies of the Coalition. Whom does the Parliamentary Secretary think he is codding? They codded the people once at the last general election but they will not do it a second time. To blame Fianna Fáil for the position in which our fishermen find themselves at the moment is ludicrous. If the Government are really serious about protecting the livelihood of our fishermen and ensuring that they can fish in our exclusive waters—I am talking about a 12-mile limit—they should ensure that the Russian ships which are now there in their hundreds should get out.

I cannot understand how we can sit here in this House and have a situation where Irish fishermen are finding their livelihoods in jeopardy because we have the fleet of a large Eastern European country looting our seas inside our 12-mile limit. The Irish naval vessel Banba did an excellent job in arresting the Russian trawler off Dunmore East and yet was tied up in dock and could not patrol while the court case was going on and the Russians were looting and ravaging as they were before. This calls for stronger action than talking about sections of our Accession Treaty to the EEC. The Minister for Foreign Affairs should call in the Russian Ambassador and tell him that unless the Russian ships are withdrawn we will break off diplomatic relations. This is the only kind of talk Russia understands.

How naive we are to fall for the fact that they came here to establish a diplomatic headquarters after they had been thrown out of Britain and to believe that this is to do with mutual trade. If they are serious about trading with us and about ensuring the commercial welfare of our country, then they should stop the theft and robbery of our waters by their fleet. They are not just fishing in the ordinary sense. They are using every modern method to catch every type of fish by suction pumps and they are upsetting the balance of nature on our seabed by this type of process. There are spies on our shores with high-powered radios advising those ships of the position of our naval vessels. The Parliamentary Secretary and the Minister for Foreign Affairs should take a helicopter trip along our coast and see the poaching and looting going on.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is moving very far from the amendment in the name of his own spokesman, Deputy O'Kennedy. He should get back to the motion and the amendment.

Comment on this

I accept the ruling of the Chair, but if we are to have a 50-mile limit we must protect the rights of our fishermen within that zone. In this era, when the heavy hand of the Coalition is falling on our employment situation, the one bright light is the future development of our fishing industry and the tremendous number of jobs which can be generated in the processing of those fish. I should like to ask the Parliamentary Secretary what happened to the processing factory supposed to come to West Cork, about which he made an announcement six months ago. Has that taken another dive?

Comment on this

The answer is no.

Comment on this

According to the Parliamentary Secretary's statement six months ago it was to have happened last week. It is important that our fishermen get every help and protection and assistance to ensure that they can harvest the sea. At the moment they are in a frustrated state and have lost all confidence in the present Government. Some of them have actually gone to Iceland for training in trawler harrassment. That is how serious the situation has become. What are the Government doing to protect the fishing industry? In the eyes of the fishermen they are taking no action at all.

We must consider devoting more and more money to the development of our piers and harbours. In the Parliamentary Secretary's own area, in Dunmanus Bay, three boats were lost worth £50,000 because the pier was inadequate and because there were no lights on the pier. The fishermen were working with a little flashlamp trying to save their equipment and boats. I hope the Parliamentary Secretary will consider paying some compensation to those people who have lost the means of earning a living.

It is time that the Irish Government started throwing their weight around in the EEC. For too long we have been the nice guys of the Community. I know, as the Parliamentary Secretary has said, that we must work within the framework of the system and there are certain restrictions with which we must comply. I feel that we are the only country observing these regulations and this is why I condemn the Minister for Foreign Affairs most of all. In my opinion he has been conned by his partners in the EEC. He has taken everything that they have said as gospel truth and he has negotiated badly on our behalf. Worst of all, he has shown a complete unawareness of the Irish people in relation to matters such as the fishing zone. I wonder how serious he is about negotiating an exclusive 50-mile zone. Is this just an exercise from the political point of view? The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries let the cat out of the bag when he said we had no chance of achieving a 50-mile limit, even though he would like us to do it.

Comment on this

I did not say that.

Comment on this

We will achieve it then?

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary confident that we will achieve it?

Comment on this

I hope we will. I like to be as factual as possible.

Comment on this

If the Parliamentary Secretary reads his speech he will see that he implied that the 50-mile limit was for the birds even though he admitted he was in favour of it.

Comment on this

I said it was the job of the Minister for Foreign Affairs to try to reach that objective within the Community. I understand that is what he is trying to do.

Comment on this

As I understood the Parliamentary Secretary, he said the Minister would not be able to achieve that because of the restrictions imposed on him by negotiations entered into in 1970.

Comment on this

The matter is constitutional within the Community.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary has told us that the Minister is negotiating a completely new policy.

Comment on this

One could say that because a policy did not exist before. It was a question of common access. Fianna Fáil sold out the fishing industry.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is talking in clichés because he has not an answer. He does not know where the Minister stands on this matter and I sympathise with him. Very few people know that and I am glad to see that the Parliamentary Secretary is as confused as the rest of us on where the Minister stands.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

We are throwing away our greatest national potential for the creation of employment if we give in easily or if we do not win this exclusive 50-mile limit. The Parliamentary Secretary has described the motion as political. Of course I bow to his knowledge regarding the meaning of that word but nevertheless I must state categorically that there is nothing political about the motion. It is straightforward and easy to understand. We want for our fishermen an exclusive 50-mile limit. There is nothing complicated about that. According to the Parliamentary Secretary it can be achieved but we must ask why the Government will not accept the motion. The reason the Government will not accept it is because some other concessions have been given by them. Everything has been agreed already and there is no chance of achieving the 50-mile limit. That is why the Government will not accept the motion. Time will show if we are right and I shall be the first to congratulate the Minister if he achieves the 50-mile limit. However, I do not hold out much hope that we will achieve it.

We must ask what kind of position our fishermen will be in as a result of all this. The Minister responsible for their future should view the matter very seriously. What action will he take to ensure that they get full protection, that when they invest heavily in expensive trawlers they will have a continued occupation to pay back their commitments? The Parliamentary Secretary knows that many fishermen are having second thoughts about entering into heavy commitments because the future of the industry is in doubt. On an occasion like this it is no harm for the Opposition to come in here and twist the tail of the Government to make sure they act in the right manner. The only way they can do that in this matter is to ensure that fishermen have an exclusive 50-mile limit.

Comment on this

I shall be brief on this matter because Deputies O'Kennedy and Haughey have dealt adequately with the legal implications of the whole question of the Treaty of Accession and the question of fishery limits which is of such importance to the whole economy. Fianna Fáil wonder why it has taken the Minister for Foreign Affairs so long to bring this order before the House for debate. The matter is important to the fishing industry and its future and to the economy as a whole. At the 11th hour and with a limited time for debate we are trying to discuss the future of this important industry.

We tabled a motion seeking a 50-mile exclusive band. We are being accused by the Government of playing politics and we have been told more or less that the 50-mile exclusive band is not on. I do not understand the reluctance of the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Parliamentary Secretary to accept this motion. All of us realise that the matter of a 200-mile zone has come about as a result of pressures on the EEC in relation to the fishing industry. They realise that the nations who fished the Icelandic waters and other areas will now be devoting their attention to waters in the region of our country which the EEC like to declare and class as their own. This is the sole reason the EEC brought in the 200-mile fishing zone and encouraged member states to seek this limit.

We agree there is a necessity for this. We have seen what has been happening in our own area. On the south-west and south-east coasts at the moment large trawlers from Russia, Bulgaria and Rumania have been taken in by our Naval Service. How many more are plundering our stocks? The answer has come from the fishermen in that particular area who fish for herring and are experiencing the worst year in memory. At this time of the year herring at Dunmore have always been very lucrative as far as the fishing industry is concerned. Many fishermen with large boats depend entirely on the catch of herring at Dunmore to help them meet their repayments on the very expensive boats they have.

There is an urgent need for conservation. In Luxembourg recently Commissioner Lardinois, in reply to a debate in Parliament on 17th November, stated:

Naturally there must be confidence but we cannot give the fishermen of the Community the confidence that there will be enough fish next year or in two years or in three years' time. When we really have a policy that bites then we can say we will have enough fish probably for all of them within five, six or seven years. We cannot give hope to all fishermen that if this becomes a Community matter there will be enough quotas for everybody. No. We have to restrict fishing not only for third countries but also for our own fishermen quite vigorously. We have to do that. If we do not do that in my opinion a lot of species will not exist any more in three or four years' time.

The only way this conservation, which Commissioner Lardinois refers to, can be carried out is by the individual member states. If we are not in a position to control a 50-mile exclusive band we have no hope whatever of preserving stocks if they are left wide open to other member states.

We know quite well what happened in France, Holland and all the other coastal areas of the member states. They have no fish at the moment. We cannot expect, if they have cleaned out their own coasts that, they will help us with out conservation policy. The fishermen realise this and in their policy programme, which they drew up in 1975, they demanded a 50-mile exclusive zone. They know better than anyone else what has been happening because from day to day they see the plunder conducted by other member states.

We are not saying that if we have this 50-mile exclusive band we will keep it for ourselves entirely. We say that we should decide how fishing is controlled in that particular area. There are many ways this can be done. We have seen, as I said here on a previous motion, the example set by Iceland where, by international agreement, they have decided the number of boats that can fish in their waters and the amount of fish they can take out at any given time. We would like to see those lines followed. We should all be honest with ourselves on this and try to ensure that our fishermen get the best possible deal. We can talk about what has happened in the past but I do not believe that will get us anywhere.

Deputy Haughey pointed out that when the Six drew up this common fisheries policy prior to our entry they did so in a rather hurried way and it has militated against the coastal states, particularly ourselves and possibly Scotland and England. It is fair to say that our Minister for Foreign Affairs at the time, Dr. Hillery, negotiated terms which gave us a 12-mile limit up to the end of 1982. The idea was that in that time we would have an opportunity to plan for our fisheries, to develop them in an orderly way, so that by the end of that period we would be in a position to tell the other member states that we were ready to exploit the fisheries of the area.

We have fallen down in not producing a plan, in not approaching the expansion of our fleet in a more businesslike way. If we made better use of the time available to us to convince the other member states that we were planning for an expansion of the fishing industry we would now be in a far stronger position in relation to the various arguments we have to make in connection with this very important industry. If we apply the principle that the EEC have applied this 200-mile zone, which they are now so anxious to see in operation because third countries are plundering stocks, we have the same right to declare a 50-mile exclusive zone for our fisheries. There is a parallel here that they are looking for the 200-mile zone to protect their own interests. We, as a member state, with a lucrative fishing industry on our doorstep, should be allowed to apply this same principle.

The argument is often made that we would not be able to protect a 50-mile fishing limit. Again, without going into detail, without dwelling too long on the example set by Iceland and knowing our fishermen, I feel confident that with one or two patrol boats and by using the helicopters and aeroplanes that we have at our disposal we could provide adequate protection for our fisheries if we were in a situation where we had a 50-mile exclusive limit.

In reply to a question last week the Taoiseach stated that there were no plans for the immediate expansion of the Naval Service and that there were no plans to remove it from the Department of Defence, but that the matter was being examined in the light of the new EEC proposals. I am not suggesting for one moment that we should have the fishery protection service removed from the control of the Department of Defence, but we should have some separate control where fisheries protection would be the sole responsibility of some central authority. Naturally it would come under the Department of Defence, but there should be some central control arrangement where fishery protection would be the responsibility of a section of the Naval Service, the Department of Defence, or the Army, as the case might be, when one would relate it to planes and helicopters.

There are many other methods which should be used to ensure that we will not have undue plundering of our fishery stocks. We could have a situation where boats would be fishing under licence and where we would know at any given time where a fishing vessel was and the amount and type of fish they were catching. The sad part of this is that in the past all along Western Europe fishing communities have developed their own economic and social way of life and in the main they are rather poor communities. As a result of EEC policies they now find themselves being brushed aside. They have no guarantee of survival at all with the present policies being adopted by the EEC, and the same situation will apply here if the EEC do not change their whole outlook and thinking on the question of fishing.

Many of the nations in the EEC are just interested in a good financial return on their investment. Companies are involved that invest in boats and gear and they look at it in the short term and that is why they are in such a sad plight in their own countries. We must try to ensure that we get this 50-mile exclusive band. We must be the people who are in a position to control what happens inside that 50 miles. If we do not succeed in this, I am firmly convinced that we have no business talking about the future of our fishing industry. There is no point in asking fishermen or the State to invest heavily, as they have to do at the moment because of the sophisticated type of boat and gear that is necessary. There is no point in this unless we have this 50-mile exclusive band. It would be a great thing for the House if we could show a united front and have a full measure of agreement on this whole question. We may fight among ourselves occasionally, but we are working in the interests of the whole nation and are trying to get the best deal we can for our fishermen. If we could be unanimous on this question tonight we would be doing a very good job for our negotiators, for the fishermen, for the economy and for the whole country.

Comment on this

I have been a bit surprised at the tone of the debate emanating from the Opposition front bench. I specifically exclude Deputy Gallagher. He has taken the right tone in that it is a national problem. However we may not agree with any particular person's conclusions from the Opposition benches. Having said that I do not want to say that I am damning Deputy Gallagher with faint praise, but I think that he has been wrongly advised in relation to the wording of this motion. I will deal particularly with the last line which states we should allow access to vessels which operate from ports in the State. That, in our opinion, is equivalent to taking the bung out of every Irish fishing boat in the Irish fishing fleet at the moment. It is a very serious blunder of wording in any motion that has at heart, or claims to have at heart, the interest of the Irish fishing fleet now and in the future. It means that any fishing vessel registered here or fishing out of an Irish port would have free and untrammelled access to Irish waters.

Comment on this

It does not mean that.

Comment on this

Legally I am afraid it means that. You may disagree but there are no limitations on that. It says vessels which operate from ports in the State. No distinction is made between an Irish boat or a foreign boat. Somebody blundered. In fairness to Deputy Gallagher, I do not think he was the instigator of every word in that motion. It strikes me that some whizz-kid in a back room drafted that and blundered very seriously. For that reason that motion is completely unacceptable to me as an Irishman. I cannot accept it because it is giving a blank cheque to foreign boats to fish within our exclusive limits.

What are we really discussing in relation to the proposed order? What we are basically dealing with, and this is recognised in the proposals, is the conservation of our fishing stocks. There is a very good precedent for taking the steps we are taking in this instrument in declaring an exclusive 200-mile limit. I am prepared to look a great deal further than the terms of the Treaty of Rome and of the Act of Accession because basically we are dealing with rights which we are claiming over what were originally international waters.

In 1974 there was an important decision come to by the International Court of Justice. It is a reported decision. It is described as the Fisheries Jurisdiction case. This is the case that was fought out between the United Kingdom and Iceland in relation to the proposed extension of the territorial limits of Icelandic waters. There was another case with the same title between some other countries. Now the basis of both decisions was the question of the allocation of preferential rights where there was overfishing. No matter what a person's political colour is in this House it is clear beyond any shadow of doubt that our present predicament, be it a 50-mile zone or a 200-mile zone, is that there has been gross overfishing. This is a point that has not been mentioned so far and I would like now to take my friends in Fianna Fáil off the sharp end of the fishing hook on which they seem to have got hung up. They were responsible for the negotiations of accession.

Deputy Haughey this afternoon turned himself into a lawyer and got a little bit out of order, a little bit emotive, but not one Opposition speaker so far appears to have really read article 100 of the Act of Accession because, if one reads this Act, there are very few references to regulations already enacted by the Commission and the Council of the Six, as it was prior to our accession. It seems to me that a case can be made, but it has not been made by the Opposition, in explanation of their slight shortcomings in regard to their work in the accession negotiations, if I may so describe them.

If one reads the whole of section 2, article 100, of the Act of Accession it seems to me implicit in that article that the original Six, when negotiating with the new countries, acknowledged that the previous regulation, No. 21R1/70 of 1970, which purported to set up a fishing structure for the EEC, was only a transient regulation. It was not intended, and could not have been, as a permanent regulation and, if one carefully reads the different wording of the various paragraphs of article 100, I do not think in all honesty that the then existing members of the EEC really believed under any principle of law or justice, or could have accepted that as a permanent regulation to bind the future conduct of the member states. I mention that to try to ease the uneasy consciences of my Opposition friends. I see Deputy Fahey smiling quite pleasedly over there and I am sure he is delighted I have given him this little help because he must have had something to do with the negotiations. I think he was the Parliamentary Secretary in charge of fisheries. There were a great many changes, of course, about that time and it is very hard to be certain who was who, but I think Deputy Fahey had something to do with the negotiations. I hope now that any future propounders of what should be in the national interest in relation to fisheries might bear in mind the few humble words I have uttered on this aspect of the matter because there has been no reference whatever to it so far by the Opposition. I think Deputy O'Kennedy would have had a far easier passage in propounding the law as Fianna Fáil saw it if he had adverted to this aspect of the Act of Accession. Of course, when one is under pressure one does not always think too clearly.

Deputy Haughey was very critical of the Minister for Foreign Affairs and he made a point in relation to article 100, paragraph 3, that by virtue of the fact that it referred to 12 nautical miles it meant article 100 did not have to be considered in relation to the proposal propounded by the Opposition looking for the 50-mile exclusive limit. I have already condemned the proposal and given my reasons for doing so. If I read Deputy Haughey's remarks correctly, they mean that outsiders can travel through the waters outside the 12 miles and fish in the exterior six. I do not understand his reasoning on that. It does not seem to make a great deal of sense to me.

There was some criticism of the Minister being guilty of indecent haste—I took down the words "indecent haste"—in extending to the 200-mile limit. I do not see why the Minister should be condemned for declaring an exclusive limit of 200 miles. At least when we have done that we have something to bargain with. Deputy O'Kennedy tried to deal with it on the basis that when the negotiations were taking place to get into the EEC nobody knew anything about the economic zone. What Deputy O'Kennedy forgets is that the only justification for the economic zone is that we have a vital interest in that zone. I have sat here for many hours but I did not hear those words mentioned once by the Opposition, although there were many politicians from the Opposition knocking around Brussels at the time I was there and there was great talk about vital interests. We are talking sanely and seriously in this House about the matter. It is no off-the-cuff business with us. We are dealing with what this Parliament has to decide and what it must take into consideration. Nevertheless there has not been one reference I know of to our vital interests.

The one thing that the EEC Commission have to face up to is this: what is international thinking on fisheries and the economic zone? The entire current of international juristic thinking would tend to support by a very large majority, in utterances, in thought and in depth of thought, the actions we are now taking in the interests of the Irish nation, and I gather from what I heard of Deputy Gallagher's speech—I was not here for all of it—that he took a nationalistic approach. However, I am sorry to say that other speakers for the Opposition did not take that line. They got themselves into personal attacks and put party before country. Maybe they were reared that way, maybe that is their political philosophy; but we here as responsible Deputies have to put the interests of the nation before that type of thinking. In other words, one has got to get one's priorities right. I think that declaring the 200-mile exclusive limit as is done in this motion, is the right priority.

Remember this, we are not just dealing with fisheries. We have other interests. It is an economic zone we are dealing with, and we are a maritime nation, maybe somewhat in default over the years and over the decades. There might be some older Deputies in this House who may have elderly parents still alive who will remember and may still have photographs on the walls of their houses showing the size of the old Irish fishing fleets. There are harbours that are regarded as small and defunct nowadays that were packed with boats, herring drifters and such like, in the old days. We were a maritime nation. We are now coming back, I believe, to our heritage, to what our ability was. We were great fishermen and had a very large fleet at one time, a very large fleet in terms of any European fishing fleet.

Comment on this

Relatively large, the Deputy means.

Comment on this

Very large. I am sure the Deputy has seen photographs of our various harbours and the number of fishing vessels in them.

Comment on this

They catch more fish in a day now than they would in a month in those days.

Comment on this

I am saying, relatively speaking, we had a very big fishing fleet when we compare ourselves to other nations.

Comment on this

I said "relatively".

Comment on this

In other words, we had the ability—and I do not think we have lost it—to be a fishing nation. However, I am afraid that much of the talk that goes on in relation to fisheries and many of the articles that are written in that regard seem to come from a bunch of land lubbers. I would say that if they were out in Force 4 wind there would be very little chat out of them.

Comment on this

The Deputy would not hold that against anybody?

Comment on this

No, but at least you should be able to come back after a Force 4 wind.

Comment on this

I wish all the Deputies in this House were out in a sailing craft in a Force 4 and they might realise that Irish fishermen have to put up with a Force 6 and a Force 7.

Comment on this

Force 4 is a sailor's dream.

Comment on this

It is a nice sailing breeze, a nice working breeze, but not Force 7 and upwards.

Comment on this

You can tack. That is what the Deputy is doing now.

Comment on this

If you judge your wind right you do not always have to beat against it, and the days I refer to, you could not beat against the wind because the boats were not rigged fore and aft as they are now.

Comment on this

They are really rigged now.

Comment on this

And I think there are certain people speaking with rigged minds in this debate too. In relation to another matter which seems to have troubled some of the learned land lubbers I have heard speaking here tonight, the Minister for Foreign Affairs was criticised because he reserved the right to veto the internal proposals of the EEC. Was he to be criticised because he reserved this right on behalf of Ireland? How poor are my friends in the Opposition to descend to that.

Comment on this

Who criticised him?

Comment on this

One of the Front Bench spokesmen in the Opposition. The Deputy may not have been in the House at the time, and I think it is very unfair to the Deputy as spokesman on Fisheries that these land lubbers should make such statements here. I would like to help my colleagues who might know something about the subject.

Comment on this
Augustine Healy Acting Chairman (Mr. Healy) Fianna Fáil

I would ask Deputies to let Deputy Esmonde continue his speech without interruptions.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy tell us about the 50-mile limit we want?

Comment on this

Could I go back to what I was dealing with originally before the Deputy came in? I raised the point that somebody had made a "palooka" of the drafting of the motion in the names of Deputies Gallagher and O'Kennedy. Deputy Gallagher is from the west of Ireland in a seaboard constituency; Deputy O'Kennedy could, I suppose be described as a land lubber, being from an inland constituency. I say there was some faulty legal drafting in the motion. Could I refer him to the last line? The motion is so drafted that it is leaving a 50-mile limit on vessels which operate from ports in this State and they could include Japanese, Spanish, Canadian, American and Russian vessels.

Comment on this

They would have to be registered.

Comment on this

I understand Deputy Brennan is in charge of the Fianna Fáil "think tank" and for that reason he might be able to explain to us what went wrong in the wording of their motion.

Comment on this

The Deputy is only filibustering.

Comment on this

If a vessel operates from any of our ports it must be registered.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I would ask Deputies to allow the Member in possession to continue his contribution without interruption.

Comment on this

According to the motion the entire Japanese fleet could be registered in Schull or the entire Russian fleet could be registered at any of our ports. The Fianna Fáil motion would make it easier for them to fish in our waters. Any lawyer could tell them what to do if they wanted to fish in the exclusive Irish zone.

Comment on this

The Deputy should tell us about the 50-mile exclusive limit we are seeking. I have not heard one word from him about that. His contribution is totally irrelevant.

Comment on this

I am pointing out that this is a serious matter. It is a simple thing, equivalent to taking the bung out of every Irish fishing vessel.

Comment on this

Baloney.

Comment on this

It is obvious that somebody is giving wrong advice to Deputy Brennan, the chairman of the Fianna Fáil "think tank". My advice to him is to take a more realistic view of this matter, on the lines of Deputy Gallagher. I exclude Deputy Gallagher from my comments concerning the wording of the Fianna Fáil motion because, as a Deputy representing a seaboard constituency, I do not think he would use such words. It is possible that if a little thought was given to this matter wiser counsels would prevail.

Comment on this

It is vitally important as far as our fishermen are concerned that we consider this issue seriously. There can be no doubt but that our fishermen are confused and disillusioned at present. I do not think they will gain anything from what has gone on here tonight. They have not heard any clarification of the Government's position. The Minister for Foreign Affairs claimed credit for getting this exclusive 200-mile zone but that is of no advantage to our fishermen unless they get an exclusive 50-mile limit within that zone. I doubt if the Government are sincere in their efforts to get a 50-mile limit. I have not heard one word of sincerity from the Government benches in relation to this matter. The Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries admitted it was desirable but doubted if it was obtainable. It was obtainable as far as our negotiators were concerned because as a coastal State we were the only ones who could declare this 200-mile zone.

We should have refused to declare this 200-mile zone until the rights of our fishermen were protected. We have given away our strong bargaining point and now the Government are putting forward excuses for having done so. The Government are trying to create the impression that our fishermen are getting something which they will not. That is why we have had such waffling from the Government benches. It is also the reason why we have heard Government Deputies say that the present situation was created by Fianna Fáil when negotiating our entry into the EEC. The fact is that when Fianna Fáil were negotiating on behalf of our fishermen they gave away nothing and that cannot be disputed.

Comment on this

They got nothing.

Comment on this

We gave away nothing but now we have a sell-out as far as Irish fisheries are concerned and the Government are trying to cloak that fact. Deputy Esmonde waffled on about our motion. I can see nothing wrong with the wording of it because for a fishing vessel to fish out of an Irish port it would have to be registered in Ireland. There is nothing to prevent a boat from anywhere registering in Ireland. When we were negotiating on behalf of our fishermen we were faced with the common fisheries policy adopted by the original Six. By careful and diligent negotiating we succeeded in having that policy changed so that an open ended review could take place prior to 1982. This review was to take into account the social and economic needs of the member states.

Comment on this

It was to take into account free access after 1982.

Comment on this

I wish the Parliamentary Secretary would study what went on at the negotiations and stop blaming Fianna Fáil for the sell-out by this Government. The survey has not been carried out and it appears that the Government have not insisted on it being carried out. If that was done it would strengthen our hand in the present negotiations. We insisted on that survey because our fishing fleet was growing.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil did not make any case. That is fantasy.

Comment on this

The Government have no plan to deal with the fishing industry and that fact emerged clearly during Question Time in recent weeks. It is not the intention of the Government to look after the interests of our fishermen or to exploit our great natural resources. Perhaps this is the reason we have not got the much needed conservation measures to protect our stocks. The Government have neglected the interests of our fishermen and the fishermen are aware of this. They are not confused because they know there is no plan for expansion and that the fish are being taken by foreign vessels. We were speaking of an expansion that should have taken place some years ago, but now it is too late because the fish are not there for the catching. The fishing capacities of the other maritime nations are more than adequate. Therefore, the Government should protect the interests of our fishermen.

The Minister for Foreign Affairs cannot shirk his responsibilities by saying that Fianna Fáil committed themselves during the negotiations for entry to the EEC. In spite of the waffle in the Minister's hand-outs to the press in Brussels and at home, there has been a recent sell-out. The 50-mile band we are seeking is surely not too much.

Comment on this

The Opposition should have asked for that.

Comment on this

I was expecting that remark from the Parliamentary Secretary, but he should study the situation. At the time we were negotiating our entry to the EEC there was no question of a 200-mile zone or of Law of the Sea Conferences. This is a new situation and the Parliamentary Secretary's argument will not wash. It is vital that the fishermen's interests be protected.

Deputy Collins spoke about the herring fishing in Dunmore East. He admitted that this is the worst season in living memory. We are now in danger of losing this valuable stock as a result of the Government's neglect. Once herring stocks go below a certain level they do not recover. There were indications of a deterioration in herring stocks in 1974. The fishermen cannot fill their quotas because the fish are being taken by foreign vessels, particularly the Russians. I hope Deputy Collins will explain this matter to the fishermen in Dunmore East, where the herring season was considered to be the harvest.

Prior to 1964 we had a three-mile limit. Those who negotiated on our behalf succeeded in getting a 12-mile limit, but a concession had to be given to those who fished within that limit. Nevertheless, it was an improvement. The sell-out will be a tremendous loss to the fishermen and the nation. As we are an island, none of the other EEC countries is in a similar position. British interests are divided because they have long-distance and inshore fleets. The conditions being sought by us should be ours by right. If our negotiators fail, the responsibility will rest on their shoulders. It was quite obvious that the Parliamentary Secretary had little hope for the fishermen. The Government could restore the confidence of the fishermen by accepting this motion.

Comment on this

That is a political gimmick.

Comment on this

It is not a gimmick. That is not our style. The fishermen wish the Parliamentary Secretary to show some sincerity on their behalf. It has been said that the Parliamentary Secretary has not spoken on behalf of the fishermen since the negotiations started. Our fishermen will not be able to compete with other fishing interests and no amount of talk will relieve the Parliamentary Secretary of his responsibilities. I make a final plea to the Parliamentary Secretary, to the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Government to accept our motion. It would be some sign of the sincerity of the Government as far as the fishermen are concerned. If not, it will be taken as a sell-out of the fisheries of this country and there is no use in trying to blame Fianna Fáil or somebody else for that. The responsibility for failure in the negotiations will rest on the Minister for Foreign Affairs and his team if they fail in this vital issue.

Comment on this

Very briefly I would like to make a few points. I do not think it fair to say that there is a lack of sincerity on any side of the House. There is quite a lot of sincerity on both sides. I do not altogether agree with the previous speaker when he said the 200-mile zone is an open book for everybody. Surely Russian fleets will not be able to operate in that type of zone. We have in recent times seen that these massive Russian vessels are probably the greatest single culprit ravaging our waters. They are massive vessels using a completely new device like a vacuum cleaner with suction which literally pulls in everything out of the waters.

A step in the right direction would be to get a 200-mile zone exclusive to EEC countries. With regard to the 50-mile zone, this is certainly not lost by any means. There is no doubt in anyone's mind about that. We will have a 50-mile zone and it can and will be got by our Minister for Foreign Affairs and our Parliamentary Secretary, and it will have to be got in the context of the EEC. We can no longer make a unilateral decision. We are a member of the Community and anything fought for, agriculture or anything else, will have to be fought for in the context of the Community.

I agree generally with the tone of the debate which indicates the seriousness of the problem. I do a small bit of fishing and I can see plainly that stocks of fish are certainly decreasing. Watching as we do in the evening, one can see all these massive vessels, quite a number of them Russian and Japanese, coming right into our waters. Certainly, I would be fully behind any efforts to ensure that we protect our fishermen, because we are really now getting down to the job of taking fishing seriously. We have, rather belatedly, gone in for the right type of fishing vessel. We have now vessels that can withstand the elements and we have people with the courage and the initiative to use those vessels. Both Bord Iascaigh Mhara and the Parliamentary Secretary are doing an excellent job to make finance available to our fishermen to purchase and maintain those vessels. Therefore, there is great confidence at the moment regarding fisheries and an awareness of the value of fish. We have, indeed, a very big responsibility as a Government and as a nation to protect what is ours.

We might even adopt new tactics when it comes to the protection of our rights. Other countries instead of using very expensive vessels such as we are accustomed to in the naval services use ordinary fishing-type vessels. These fishing vessels could be manned by naval personnel and would be similar in every way to the other fishing vessels and in that way would be a very useful deterrent against anybody moving in. They would be far less expensive to buy than some of the vessels we now have to purchase. The policing of the 50-mile zone is not by any means impossible. All it means is that we might have to change tactics, to use smaller vessels and vessels that simulate in every way the ordinary fishing vessels.

Our stocks of fish are by no means exhausted. We have had our good and bad years at Dunmore East and all around the coast. The same applies to salmon, and I might briefly mention that the Parliamentary Secretary is very concerned about and is doing quite a lot for the conservation of salmon. That is terribly important, and it may not be generally known that some of the captures by our naval people did disclose quite a lot of salmon in some of these captured boats. Therefore, not merely are some of these very big boats taking in ordinary fish, they are pulling in salmon as well. Certainly with regard to salmon our Parliamentary Secretary is to be complimented. He has recently made an order shortening the depth of the net from 60 down to 30 mesh to ensure proper spawning of our salmon, thereby giving them a chance to go upstream. That is important, too, because many people earn their living from salmon.

I view with anxiety the ravages to our fisheries from outside sources. Not only will we negotiate a 50-mile zone; even outside that 50 miles I would be seriously concerned about the discipline that should apply to the member states. There is very little point in us and our fishermen keeping the rules if the Dutch, French and so on do not obey them. This is vitally important for us as a small fishing nation.

The 200-mile initial zone is very important for the sake of keeping out Japanese, Russian and the very big boats that are traditionally used by other foreign nations. After that it would be the immediate task of the Minister for Foreign Affairs and the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to make sure that we have our 50-mile zone. They have the means at their disposal within the Community to ensure that we get this right. It is only logical, and the EEC will see it that way, that we would get this right because it has been accepted that we are a nation which is recovering and really forging ahead economically, a nation which still requires quite a lot of assistance from the EEC. It does not seem logical that we should be helped on one hand and hindered on the other. If the EEC people are to be logical, they will see that if we can build up our fisheries to help our economic position and to improve revenue for the nation as a whole this must of necessity be of benefit to the Community. The Minister will not have the terrible task on his hands to ensure that we get this right.

The traditional spawning areas are the inshore areas. We have a reputation for genuine concern about conservation. Traditionally, our fishermen are interested in fish stocks. It is important from the point of view of the community that the shelf around our country should not be tampered with by massive suction cleaners, or whatever they are called, which literally pull everything into their meshes, and that properly regulated fishing should take place.

I should like to compliment the Parliamentary Secretary. Since he took office he has put a lot of effort into the fishing industry. He has given confidence to our fishermen. This is reflected around our coast in the size of our boats. It is nothing unusual to hear of boats costing £250,000 being purchased by our fishermen. This confidence is indicative of the future of the fishing industry as our fishermen see it. They are no fools. If they think all is lost, as some people on the other side of the House seem to think, they will not continue to invest in very expensive boats. They believe, as I believe, in the future of the industry if we look after it. We are competent to look after it. We are going the right way about it. It will be soon enough to start moaning and groaning the day we have to come back to this House and say we have lost the 50-mile limit.

Comment on this

I do not propose to keep the House too long. This debate has developed along peculiar lines. It has become rather acrimonious. There has been a good deal of generalisation about fishing. Our motion has been put down for the specific purpose of strengthening the hand of the Government, and the Minister in particular, in negotiating an exclusive 50-mile limit within the 200 miles to give our fishermen and the industry a chance to develop in the future. That is what the debate is all about. Many speakers have not adverted to the purpose of either motion.

I trust the Government have not abandoned the hope of getting this exclusive 50-mile limit. Our fishermen will settle for nothing less. If the tone of the debate, which tends to cast aspersions on the efforts of Fianna Fáil in the past, is indicative of the thinking of the Government, it would appear to me that they have abandoned hope of attaining that exclusive limit and are already seeking some scapegoat to blame for their failure to secure it.

This country has four outstanding industrial sectors. One is agriculture. One is the manufacturing industry which Fianna Fáil have nurtured and brought up to its present stage. The third is tourism, and the fourth, with perhaps the greatest potential of all four, is our fishing industry.

Comment on this

Which Fianna Fáil forgot about.

Comment on this

I will deal with that in a moment. Our fishing industry is indigenous to this country and it is the industry which we would expect to have the greatest potential for the future. At the moment we are in an horrific state in relation to economic development. As Deputy Haughey pointed out one important member of the EEC referred recently to the catastrophic state of the Irish economy. In that context, and against the background of the Treaty of Rome and the spirit of that treaty, is it too much to expect that one industry which has the greatest potential particularly for the development of the western seaboard, should not be given by the EEC the full effect of the spirit of the Treaty of Rome?

The Minister has a very strong negotiating point and that is what the debate is about. We are interested in the 200-mile limit which, in effect, gives the member states a playground and also gives them the right to barter with non-member states on the right to fish. This is of tremendous interest to other countries and particularly to Great Britain. We go all the way with that, so long as we get the exclusive 50-mile limit within the 200-mile zone.

We are attempting to strengthen the hand of the Minister who will negotiate that exclusive limit. I hope we will be seen as doing just that. Following this debate, the Minister can go back to the negotiating table feeling strengthened in his resolve to pursue that purpose. He can point out to his colleagues, the other memberstate's representatives, that the Opposition who will, in the course of months, form the Government——

Comment on this

What a hope you have.

Comment on this

——are determined to ensure we get that limit. That is a strong negotiating point. These are the facts of the situation, look at them as you may. Fishing is an industry which does not develop overnight. Those of us who know a little about it—and there are a great many in this House who know very little about it; I might name a few of them in a moment—have seen the struggle to develop fishing harbours. We can boast of the primary fishing harbour in Ireland on the coast of Donegal in Killybegs, with Burtonport and others coming up well. This did not happen overnight.

When Fianna Fáil took over the Government in 1932 there was not a sail which belonged to an Irishman coming into any of those harbours. It was a long haul literally and metaphorically, but we saw it develop, and we saw it move into the stage where its potential became obvious and evident and assured. If you increase the fishing catch, the catching power, you must also increase the market on which you dispose of your increased catch.

If the market is to be expanded there must be processing ashore also. The employment fishing gives, and it is important, is relatively small in relation to the employment it can give if the necessary processing stations are established, whether it be for marinating, smoking, canning, filleting or anything else, such as was developed under Fianna Fáil around the coast and particularly in Killybegs. These things must be developed simultaneously with an increase in the catching power so that the marketing system is geared to meeting the increased catches one might expect from increasing the catching power which, in turn, means increasing the number of boats that go out to fish and, consequently, the number of men.

We have seen it develop from the smaller boat, from the half-decker, to the larger and better equipped boats capable of staying at sea. We have seen the market develop from what used to be a fresh market only, as it was called, which could be glutted in two days to the stage where we had different types of processing to ensure that dumping did not take place. These things may be new to some Members of the House who know nothing about what the fishing industry means. It was a long, hard struggle to develop that industry around our coast. We have seen it develop in all spheres, in processing, in manpower which was related directly to the catching power, in the provision of boats, in the establishment of boatyards around our coast for the building of our own boats and in the expansion of the markets.

This is the industry about which we are speaking here this evening and which could very well end up in the melting pot if we do not take the right and determined steps to ensure its protection for future generations.

Deputy Haughey was right when he asked if we are to place the waters of our coast at the disposal of the other members of the EEC, are they prepared to place their resources in a common pool available for our development? Is British oil or German steel available to us in the same manner as they wish us to use the waters off our shores for their general benefit?

Comment on this

That is what Fianna Fáil were telling the public in 1972—that they would do all this.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Parliamentary Secretary is talking about.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

That is the strongest argument we can place on the lips of the Minister who will be negotiating, I hope with determination, an exclusive 50-mile band available for our fishermen. If the Opposition take the view that for some reason or other Fianna Fáil did something in the past for the development of fisheries does that mean the Coalition are not in favour of the 50-mile band? Does that mean they will not try determinedly to get it? Does that mean they do not feel strengthened by the action we are taking here to ensure that they can negotiate it? We should all be at one in this. We should all be determined to do the same thing. When this country acceded to membership of the EEC, we accepted common access. In other words, we boarded the bus at the stop where it picked us up, as was expected.

Comment on this

The Deputy is quite honest. He has said that they accepted common access. Now some of them are trying to deny that.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Deputy Brennan without interruption.

Comment on this

At that time there was a common fisheries policy admitted by the Minister in his speech here today. We accepted that common policy in order to gain accession. There were certain derogations from it which leave us ample space. There are no impediments to the Minister fully negotiating the 50-mile limit, or anything he wishes, for our major industry, something that can be the saviour of our whole economic situation.

As has been pointed out repeatedly by different Members this evening, the whole purpose and spirit of the Treaty of Rome, the main knitting factor of the member states of the EEC is that they work for the uplifting, harmonisation and equalisation of the different countries' economies. One industry bearing the greatest hope of future expansion in relation to our economy is fishing. We are merely co-operating with what the other nations must realise in seeking to develop—and, indeed, make exclusive to us—the industry holding the greatest hope of expansion. Given those 50 miles restricted to our exclusive use we could then proceed to develop that industry utilising EEC assistance in the direction we considered best.

We must obtain that security which will encourage our people to engage in the industry, whether it be procesing on shore, or fishing inshore or in deep waters. Our fishermen must have that security. They can have it only in the knowledge that they have exclusive rights over a particular band off our coast. That is what the debate is about here this evening. It is not for the purpose of scoring political points. I do not care what Fianna Fáil did in the past. There is one thing certain. There is nothing to prevent the Minister at present getting what the fishermen want. Blame Fianna Fáil if you wish but that can be used only as a means of covering up any failures on the part of the Government. There is nothing to prevent them negotiating for what the fishermen want and what our economy requires so much at present. Surely this can be brought home to the members of the EEC. Deputy Esmonde, and others, generalised about fishing and the means of fishing. Speaking about the last line of our motion, he took exception to the fact that it allowed access to vessels which operate from ports in the State. He sought to split hairs and say that that could mean the whole Japanese flect. Nonsense like that does not get us very far. This sovereign State will have the right to decide who will register a fishing boat here and who is admitted into the industry when they have got exclusive rights. It is only those who will be permitted by the Government of the day who will have the right to operate from our ports, not the Japanese fishing fleet. A statement like that tends to magnify what I feel is the abandonment of hope on the other side of the House that things will turn out as they should. I hope I am wrong. Why did every Deputy from the other side of the House tend to refer to what Fianna Fáil should have done? Is that an indication that we are failing already in what we are trying to do now?

Comment on this

The Deputy will agree that it was a major blunder. It is on that sandy foundation we are trying to build.

Comment on this

No, I do not agree with any such thing.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

It was not even referred to by the Deputy who was then in this House.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Time is now limited in this debate. Interruptions are most unwelcome.

Comment on this

Not once during his days in Opposition was Deputy Murphy recorded as talking about fisheries, but he was one of those people who asked the people to join the EEC.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

In that case he was opposed to membership.

Comment on this

We accepted membership once the people had expressed their view.

Comment on this

That makes the situation worse so far as the Parliamentary Secretary is concerned.

Comment on this

Now Fianna Fáil are thinking of getting out.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

We have the right to declare a 50-mile limit without reference to anyone. We have that right in international law so let us hear from the other side of the House as to whether it is the intention to declare this exclusive limit. I had assumed that the tone of this debate so far as the Government were concerned would be a welcoming one, that they would welcome the action we were taking to strengthen their hand in what I had hoped would be their determination to get the 200-mile limit that is necessary, provided we can have declared the 50-mile exclusive limit.

However, the attitude of the speakers from the other side and the annoyance that has been obvious in the Parliamentary Secreteary's interruptions indicate that we are not moving in the direction that this party would wish for. The Government are seeking a reason and an excuse for failure before that failure has taken place. This situation augurs badly for the future of our fishing industry. We have the opportunity now, as we had on becoming members of the EEC, of bringing our fisheries up to a standard that would harmonise with the standards of the other member states. That was the spirit of the Treaty of Rome. Have not the other landlocked countries who have vast resources reached a high standard of development and should they not recognise that as members of the Community they must allow to Ireland the right to use the resources that are indigenous to us? One such resource must be fisheries. It is in the light of this situation that we tabled this motion. Not to have done so would have been to fail in our duty to the people.

I appeal to the Government generally to consider what we are advocating as something that will strengthen their hand in negotiations in the future and will enable them to point out to their colleagues in the EEC the views of an Opposition that is likely to unseat the Government one day soon. The attitude of the Government should be that, if they are not prepared to do their utmost to secure the protection of one of our main sources of economic development, they will be failing as a Government. That is the argument we are putting in their mouths. We trust we are making clear to the Minister for Foreign Affairs the exclusive limit that our people are seeking. In the European Parliament our members opposed a motion dealing with the question of quotas because we are opposed to that idea.

I am not sure whether it was relevant to refer to fishing policy and plans but the question was raised and permitted during this debate. Perhaps the Government have a plan and a policy in respect of fishing but so far we have not heard anything in that regard. However, it would be useful if they would let us in on the secret before the Christmas Recess.

There are many thoughts occupying the minds of those who are interested in the future of this country and particularly those who are interested in the fishing industry. The Government tell us that it is their aim to make possible the doubling of our fishing catch by 1982. A remarkable programme would be required to achieve that aim. This would involve the areas of boat building, personnel training, processing and so on. In other words, a tremendous programme would be required within a short time to attain this increase. Are preparations being made in this direction? There is a good boatyard at Killybegs. I know the output that that yard is capable of, but are there efforts in hand to enable a trebling of that output? There are about 160,000 people out of work, so that there are many who would be glad of employment.

Regarding the proposals for conservation, can the Parliamentary Secretary explain how these can be reconciled with the Government's stated intention of doubling the fishing catch? What species are to be preserved? How can we achieve a doubling of the fishing catch while at the same time operating a conservation policy? The people would like the answers to these questions. The Government are charged with the immediate task of developing the fishing industry and, consequently, of protecting the livelihoods of future generations in that industry. There is no point in telling us what we did or did not do. They are showing few signs of being either able or prepared to take the action that is necessary. So far we have had no answers from the other side of the House. Regardless of politics, each of us here must have an interest in the future of our country and I am sure all Members share with me the hope that future generations will be left with a country in which there will be improved standards of living. That is what this House is all about. This evening we are discussing one of our most important industries. It is not one to be kicked across the House as a political football and saying what you did or did not do. Let us know what is going to happen now, the determination with which it will be approached and the will is there to achieve it. One thing is certain, there are no obstacles if there is the right will to attain an objective.

The EEC is not a closed book. It never was and it never will be. Irrespective of what accession or any other treaties hold, we are a group of nations coming together to improve the general lot of the members. We are trying to do our best for this country. That is why we joined the Community. There is not a lot to be gained by posing as the best Europeans in the Community. When they feel like it, the British will kick over the traces to get what they want. They do not always strictly toe the line and obey the letter of the law. They renegotiated when it suited them and got away with it. We toe the line and are good members, fulfilling all the requirements, keeping to the letter of the law, observing all the rules and ensuring that we do nothing that will in any way offend any of our fellow members. We have grown up; we have cut our teeth. The time has come when we must make ourselves felt, irrespective of the fact that we are a country surrounded by water. We have an opportunity of doing that through our membership of the EEC. This applies very much to the present time when we can protect one of our greatest industries, the fishing industry.

Say what you like about what Fianna Fáil did or did not do, we handed this Government a fishing industry that was built on a solid base and capable of being expanded given the necessary injection of extra capital. That industry will respond to any assistance the EEC may give. I forgot that the Parliamentary Secretary was a member of the Labour Party, the party which objected to our membership. When we advocated support for membership of the EEC one of the factors we used—perhaps we should apologise now for using it—was the regional policy, and what it could do for the west coast. We went out of office a year after our accession to the EEC. What did this Government do about the regional policy which we sold the people as one of the most important factors of membership? There is a serious imbalance between the east and west coasts. The Government declared the whole country as an area for consideration under regional development. We had hoped the west coast would be given special treatment and we especially had great hopes for the development of the fishing industry there. I hope the Minister will not miss the many ways that exist to help that industry. The only thing that ever retarded the rate of development of that industry was the amount of capital one could acquire——

Comment on this

There is no indication in departmental records that Fianna Fáil made such assertions about the development of the fishing industry. That industry was completely forgotten.

Comment on this

The only thing that retarded the fishing industry was the lack of capital.

Comment on this

We trebled the capital in the last three years.

Comment on this

Please have manners.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Please, Deputy, there is a time-limit.

Comment on this

We gave capital far beyond what was expected would be available to us. In doing so we did not borrow foreign capital which we would be unable to repay, nor did we respond with an 18 per cent inflation, having the cost of development completely eroded by the inflationary spiral. Anybody who says today that there was more money given this year than in 1973 is talking a lot of nonsense. To do the same amount of development as was done in 1973 one would need double the amount of capital. That is what this Government are boasting about—they are talking about money rather than actual capital development. It is time somebody on that side of the House "copped" themselves on. We left this Government a soundly-based fishing industry capable of rapid development. They could have used the capital they got from the EEC to make it a viable industry.

There will be unlimited expansion for this industry provided our waters are not made the playground of every nation. To prevent that we are asking that one of our greatest natural resources will be protected by a 50-mile band. I am sure Deputies in the Government benches are as anxious about this as we are, although nobody from those benches has said so.

A 200-mile limit, with the right for all member states to use it, is all right. We are not opposing that, provided the Minister ensures that we get a 50-mile exclusive band that will enable us to expand the industry by using money from the Social and Regional Funds of the EEC. If the Government fail to show good reason why they do not get that, it will not be accepted that they were impeded by anything Fianna Fáil did in the past. The logical case is in their favour. There are no impediments. Instead of political slogans, the Parliamentary Secretary should ensure that there is complete co-operation and that the western seaboard gets the necessary assistance to remove the imbalance with the eastern seaboard. I will quote from the Minister's speech:

In the light of developments in the Law of the Sea Conference the Commission made proposals in September this year for certain elements of a new Community fishery regime...

The common fishery policy which the Minister used as propaganda does not obtain any longer. This is a complete new policy and the whole position has been changed radically.

Comment on this

We are entitled to change it. Fianna Fáil sold us out.

Comment on this

It was changed in spite of the Government. We sold nothing but fish. The Parliamentary Secretary would be wise to keep quiet. Is he looking for an exclusive limit or not? The country wants an answer to that. Nobody on the Government's side answered it. We on this side want it and we will not settle for anything else.

Comment on this

Like the last speaker, as a Donegal Deputy I would be failing in my duty if I did not speak on this matter. People are talking about the Fianna Fáil red herring here today. What we are discussing is a proposal to extend Ireland's fishing limit and I have not heard Fianna Fáil say they are not in favour of a 200-mile zone. When they go into the division lobbies later that is what they are voting for or against.

Comment on this

We are looking for 50 miles.

Comment on this

If they vote against this proposal tonight we can take it they will be against the 200-mile limit. Deputy Brennan quoted the Minister's speech but he did not finish the paragraph. The Minister went on to say:

Our partners were persuaded to agree at The Hague on 30th October that Ireland is a special case...

He also said:

This was secured without our having to concede one iota of our claim to a coastal band of up to 50 miles...

As I have said, like Deputy Brennan I come from Donegal and I realise the potential of the fishing industry for the western seaboard. I would not like to settle for 12 miles and we can rest assured the Minister will do his best to get the maximum possible limit.

I am sure Deputy Brennan happened to see last Wednesday the big Dutch trawlers at Killybegs. They would scare you. They were more than 150 feet long. If we are to let the Dutch come to within 12 miles of our coast we are asking for trouble. It is only in the past six years that we have begun to see the tremendous potential of the fishing industry and it would be utter madness on our part to give everybody carte blanche as far as our fish stocks are concerned.

When we speak about better limits we must think about protection for our trawlers. The present outdated methods will have to be changed. A lot of thought will have to be given to more modern methods of spotting foreign trawlers. It is ridiculous that gear can be confiscated and yet the offending skippers can get it back within a few days. We should initiate legislation to ensure that nobody whose gear has been confiscated will get it back within 12 months.

Comment on this

I am glad Deputies White and Hegarty got the message from their constituents because it would appear that no other speaker on the Government side has got the message from the fishermen they represent. Some of their speakers, Deputy Esmonde in particular, appeared to base their case on the mistaken premise that Fianna Fáil are opposed in principle to a 200-mile zone. It should be apparent that they are not. We are particularly interested in securing a coastal band of 50 miles. We know that this aim is also the aim of our fishermen and that they will not deviate from it. We know they are prepared to take action on their own to ensure that they achieve their objective. We are determined to give them all the assistance we can. As Deputy Brennan pointed out, we consider our motion should assist the Minister in his negotiations.

The Minister's speech referred to a fisheries development programme. Will he tell the House what is this programme? Has it been published? Will he tell us where the boats will be built and when will the piers and facilities be made available? How much money will be spent in the coming year? These are questions that must be answered if we are to ensure that we double our catch within the next few years.

How can we ensure that the proposed quotas will be kept? Will we ask the British to police their own boats or the Germans to tell us when they have caught enough fish? Why should we calmly and without murmur hand over to third countries the right to fish inside 200 miles just because some EEC member states will get a quid pro quo for the right of their long-range fleets to fish in other waters? We have no long-range fleet and it is essential that the 50-mile zone be written into any agreement we may make. That is essential for the development of fisheries, particularly along the western coast.

Deputy Esmonde in his speech said that this House had certain decisions to make. In this instance the House has to decide that what we want and what our fishermen want is the same thing. As Deputy Esmonde pointed out, we should have the interests of the nation at heart. Our fishermen have the ability and expertise; what they need is confidence to expand the industry. They need the assurance that the large investment they make will not be in vain. They look to the Minister to ensure that large trawlers will not fish inside the 12-mile limit. They look for the protection that is their right. We consider that this motion will help the Minister in his negotiations and we ask that the House accept it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Minister for Foreign Affairs (Dr. FitzGerald) Fine Gael

There are a number of different aspects to this debate. First, there are the reasons for declaring the 200-mile limit, its effects and consequences. There is the Opposition motion and the reason why it would be legally ineffective and void and there are the political issues that were raised. I do not want in any way to be unfair about what I say about the past. I have tried not to be in what I have said but I am not sure I have always succeeded. In replying to supplementary questions I may have been goaded into saying more than was strictly fair. However, I want to go over the record because I think there were deficiencies in the way the matter was handled. It is perhaps the case that even if there had not been those deficiencies on the part of the Government of the day it might not have made any difference. I do not know; it is hard to judge. Objectively, the handling was less good than it should have been.

There was the wording in the White Paper of April, 1970, which dismissed summarily the problem that could arise. The White Paper said:

Some difficulties could arise from any decision which might be adopted by the Community within the framework of the proposed common policy for fisheries in regard to access to fishing grounds in the exclusive fishery limits of the member states.

I do not think it was sufficient for the country to put them on notice of what was obviously going to follow. The White Paper certainly did not suggest to the EEC that we were seriously concerned about the disastrous effects of a free access policy applied to our fisheries. The first words of Fianna Fáil on this subject were "Some difficulties could arise".

In June when we applied for membership all that was said on the subject was:

It may also be necessary to raise particular points in regard to other agricultural matters, including future arrangements for fisheries before the accession negotiations are complete.

There was no sign of urgency or a realisation that this was a vitally important area, that the key element in the negotiations lay here, and that this was the one matter where we had to seek special treatment and where it was very important that we got it.

Until now I have not attempted to look back on the record of what was done then. I have had too much to do in trying to deal with this problem effectively to waste time on historical research but in view of what was said in the debate today for the first time I inquired when representations were first made in Brussels on this subject. As I understand it, the date was 21st September, 1970, when the common fishery negotiations with the Six were very far advanced; in fact it was within a month of its conclusion by the Council.

During that period the Norwegians in particular and the British also were fighting hard on the subject. The Norwegians secured assurances, applicable only to them, which they found inadequate to justify joining the Community. Fisheries were very important for them and the inadequacy of the assurances, as they saw them, led them in the referendum to decide not to join. It is interesting that in a speech by the Norwegian Foreign Minister on 14th January, 1972, with regard to the negotiations there is reference to the situation. The speech stated:

In the early stages of the negotiations the Norwegian delegation proposed that fishing within the fishery limits should be based on the same principles as those valid in the Treaty of Rome in the sector relating to the right of establishment.

This would mean that foreign fishermen would have to be domiciled to carry out fishing within the Norwegian fishery limit. It was a very sound principle and one that I have argued in Brussels is all that the Treaty requires and that making this regulation in 1970 they went beyond what the Treaty required. The Norwegian document went further. What they said was very significant and I should like it to go out from this House. What I am talking about is another State, not propaganda by this Government or by any party here. The document stated:

During the enlargement negotiations we were not supported in our proposal by the Community or the other applicant States.

That was published on 14th January, 1972. At that time it was quite clear that the first representations had been made on this subject on 21st September, and they did not support even this minimal reasonable claim by the Norwegians, that all that should be done was to apply the right of establishment and that the right of access should not be applied. That is the record, objectively. As we have had a political argument it is better to get that out of the way early on and to get down to the more legal and practical aspects.

On the other side of the House we had people asking when did we raise these matters in Opposition. I spoke for two-and-a-half hours in the Dáil on this question of the EEC fishery's policy in December, 1970. I know I had the reputation when in Opposition of tending to speak for rather long periods on subjects, and two-and-a-half hours, in the context of some of my other speeches, may not seem too long. It was a very full exposé in which I pointed out all these dangers and difficulties. To be fair about it, it was December, 1970, and the policy was through—it was too late because the damage had been done. We did not know that the Government had failed to act until September and we did not know they had not supported the Norwegians at that time. In Opposition we could not know what was going on, but when the thing came out into the open with the publication in October, 1970, of the Council regulation, I took the first opportunity to speak on the subject.

If we move on to the debate on the EEC referendum, this was a matter to which Fine Gael speakers adverted. In Volume 259, column 1991, of the Official Report, the present Taoiseach, Deputy Cosgrave, spoke on this subject and referred at some length to our concern about what had happened and what had been done.

He said there was concern in regard to the fisheries aspect of the agreement and continued:

This is one aspect of the negotiations in which I believe the Norwegians were right. We should have gone along with them in the battle they put up to get an agreement.

He went on to talk generally about the importance of fisheries and to emphasise that we should have taken action in the matter. The same is true of the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, Deputy Clinton. In the same debate he also spoke on the subject of fisheries and expressed his dissatisfaction with what had been secured in the negotiations and his feeling that inadequate emphasis and attention had been paid to it. He said:

Many of the fishermen are dissatisfied or not fully satisfied with the outcome of the negotiations. It could be said that perhaps a better bargain could have been made.

His attempt to contribute on this subject was interrupted very frequently by a Deputy on the other side who is no longer with us. It was not easy for him to make his points clearly because of the constant interruptions. He emphasised that more could have been done and that we were not satisfied with what had been done.

The Opposition were vigilant but concerned but because we could not have known what was going on in the negotiations, and did not know, we were not off the mark as rapidly as would have been desirable because we had not the information. The Government had it and they were not off their mark at all. That is where our difficulties come from. That having happened and our having failed to join with the Norweigens then and to press the issue, whether in the accession negotiations the matter could have been retrieved, I admit there is doubt. I believe it would have been very difficult in the subsequent negotiations to have got back what was lost at that time when that regulation had gone through with the wording in it, which unfortunately refers to the future area of sovereignty and jurisdiction as well as the past. Once that was done I am afraid the chances of retrieving it were probably small. It is probably fair for the Opposition to argue that at that stage, in the final stage of the negotiations, it was not possible to retrieve the damage done earlier.

I simply say, without wanting to pursue the political thing any further, we inherited this situation and whether it is something that could have been prevented or not, the simple fact is that it was not prevented. We have inherited a legal, juridical situation in the Community which leaves us with no legal grounds to stand on. I do not think it is honest for the Opposition to put down a motion pretending that they left us with any legal grounds to stand on when they did not. Perhaps they could not do any better; perhaps they were not to blame, although they could have been quicker off the mark. Perhaps if they had been quicker off the mark they still would not have been able to secure a result. I do not know. It is quite possible that is the case. I do not want to be unfair or harsh. The least they could have done, having been responsible for the negotiations, having left us without a legal leg to stand on, was not to try to mislead fishermen by putting down motions suggesting that we, simply at the wave of a wand, can declare a 50-mile band.

Deputy Fahey used the words "The 50-mile exclusive band is there for the taking". That kind of talk will not convince anybody, particularly anybody who reads back over the record when Deputy Fahey was Parliamentary Secretary in charge of Fisheries. He would have been wiser not to remind people of that by using phrases of that kind. It is not there for the taking. We have a very difficult negotiation on hand, stage after stage. We shall have to fight every inch of the way, think out every move in advance and be careful that we do not trip over many dangerous trip wires that are there around us. Certainly in the three-and-a-half years I have been in Government——

Comment on this

I want clarification before the Minister goes on to discuss the future, which is the important thing. Could he refer us to any one statement from any Opposition spokesman at the time, including himself, which related to anything outside the six- to 12-mile jurisdiction?

Comment on this

No. We had this out at Question Time. I do not want to waste time in this debate.

Comment on this

Just one statement.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister.

Comment on this

I do not think there is any such statement. I am not disagreeing with the Deputy but do not let us waste time because the matter was discussed at Question Time. The fact is there were 200-mile limits in South America at the time. If the Deputy wants to go back over that fair enough. All I am saying is they existed and once they existed it was possible they could be extended to other areas. That possibility was not considered and as far as I am aware, subject to contradiction by the Opposition, I do not think in the representations we made in 1970 that they adverted to the phraseology in the regulation which opened it up to future extensions of sovereignty or jurisdiction. The Deputies opposite may state that because it was there in South America it did not mean it would happen elsewhere. Of course it did not. It meant that it would happen elsewhere and a vigilant Government could have been alert to that and could have raised the matter. Perhaps they did but I am not aware that they did. I do not think going back over that ground is helpful.

Comment on this

The Minister said it was a fait accompli.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputy O'Kennedy allow the Minister to speak?

Comment on this

Once the 1970 regulation was passed then effectively it was a fait accompli and, as I said, the chances of retrieving it in the accession negotiations were negligible. The damage was done in 1970 when the possibility of future extension in jurisdiction was not contemplated, neither by us nor the Government. The Government are the people whose job it is to think these things out.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Will Deputies cease interrupting?

Comment on this

The Opposition did not know what the phraseology of the Council regulation was to be. We did not have advance copies of it in front of us as the Government had. We were not negotiating. We had not got the information about it and, naturally, not knowing that such future wording was used, we were not in a position to raise it at the time. It could have been thought of and was not. Perhaps nobody is to blame but whether or not there is blame, for the people who were responsible, even if not to blame, to pretend at this stage that the limit is there for the taking when as a result of, and consequent on what happened at that time, it is not open to us, is not honest and is not helpful in the negotiation. It probably does not hinder us much either. If the Opposition think they are going to get any political bonus from it they are welcome to it. I do not think this kind of argument does us any harm or any good in Brussels except it just makes us look foolish to have an Opposition claiming something is the law which everybody knows is not but that redounds more to their discredit than to the country's.

The only other political element in this, to which reference has been made, is the situation of the European Parliament. The excuse given for the vote by the Fianna Fáil membere there was that the motion contained a reference to quotas and they were so damaging and dangerous that anything quoted in it must be rejected, even if it was a motion favouring the 50-mile band. Of course, we all know that any system of conservation will need quotas for some purposes. They may be useful, valuable, essential; they may work well or excellently or not very well, but they will be essential because certainly for the area outside the 50-mile coastal band, from there to 200 miles there will have to be some control over the amount of fish taken. Total catch figures will have to be available. Once we have those catch figures the catch has to be divided among countries ourselves included, and that can only be done by way of quotas.

We do not believe that quotas are the answer or that they could provide the answer to the protection of our fisheries, but we know that quotas will be necessary in some way in the scheme of things and that they have a role to play. To make an excuse that the mere mention of quotas was such a dangerous thing and that for that reason a resolution was voted down that would have supported our claim for a 50-mile band, was not honest and was merely to cover up the fact that a mistake was made by entering into an alliance not with another ideological European Parliament but with another nationalist party. That was one alliance which was bound to tie one's hands. The one alliance nobody should be in is with another nationalist party with divergent interests where one could be swallowed up and forced to follow their lines or be influenced by them.

Deputy Haughey or Deputy O'Kennedy wanted to know why we are rushing this whole thing. They should ask the fishermen that. The fishermen are suffering from severe depredations at the present time. They know the urgency of getting by the 1st January some provision that will alleviate the problem even if it will not resolve it overnight. They know how important it is that on the 1st January there will be a 200-mile limit as a result of which non-community countries will no longer be permitted to fish except under terms of an agreement which may be negotiated by the Community to phase them out. They know that to get to that situation, where in some cases these countries are excluded, perhaps in all cases excluded, is vitally important, because of the damage that these non-community countries are doing to our fisheries. They also know that under the terms of what was agreed on the 30th October amongst the Ministers of the EEC and subsequently put in form by written procedures and a council decision on the 3rd November, we have a provision under which the council agrees to secure the increase in our catch in accordance with our development programme, and they know that that gives us a leg to stand on for the first time, in order to take action, or have action taken, in order to phase out, and reduce, the amount of fish catching going on by Community countries also, so that the fish are left there and from the 1st of January onwards there are more fish available for our fishermen so that next year there will be a substantial increase instead of a reduction in the amount of fish caught. They know the urgency of keeping out the non-Community countries and of getting us into a position to negotiate a situation where the catch by other Community countries will be reduced and controlled in a way that will leave more fish for them. That is why this motion is urgent. For Members of the Opposition to ask "what is the rush" is to show a total failure to appreciate the urgent dangers to the Irish fishing industry, and the possibilities given to us of starting from 1st January to reduce these dangers and to help that industry to build up from the position it has been in, of being held down to a low level of activity over the last few years. So that argument does not stand up very well.

We are faced with the terms of the Accession Treaty plus the regulation 2141, (1970) of the Council. The one unimpressive thing in Deputy O'Kennedy's speech was his attempt to confuse the House, the people and the fishermen by talking about the consolidating regulation made this year as if it were a fresh regulation into which we could introduce new matter. The Deputy is sufficiently aware of the general principles of consolidation of legislation to know that no new matter could be introduced into a consolidating regulation. To ask why we did not get things put into it was to ask a silly question. No doubt there is some political point to it, but I want to make it clear that it was a consolidating regulation, there was nothing we could add to it and Deputy O'Kennedy must have known his point was invalid. The regulation, whether you call it 2141, (1970) or whether you give it its number as a consolidation regulation 1976 is one which sets out in article 2:

1. Rules applied by each Member State in respect of fishing in the maritime waters coming under its sovereignty or within its jurisdiction shall not lead to differences in treatment of other Member States.

That is the foundation of the common fishery policy. It goes on to deal with access.

Member States shall ensure in particular equal conditions of access to and use of the fishing grounds situated in the waters referred to in the preceding subparagraph for all fishing vessels flying the flag of a Member State and registered in Community territory.

That is the crucial phrase of article 2 (1) of that regulation. That, as I said in the argument in the Council of Ministers, goes far beyond anything required, or contemplated by the Roman Treaty. As far as the Accession Treaty is concerned upon which the Opposition apparently wish to hang a good deal, including the fishermen, it does no more than derogate temporarily from this provision. In the Community it is an attempt to elevate the Rome Treaty and the Accession Treaty into having a role in regard to the right of access that they do not have. I hope that the argument I put forward in the Council of Ministers on this point, seven weeks ago, has helped to settle this argument and to eliminate some of the confusion that existed in the minds of some of our partners, that there was some foundation in the Rome Treaty or the Accession Treaty for this right of access. There is none, and the attempt of the Opposition, Deputy Haughey in particular, to suggest that the Accession Treaty stands and can only be amended under article 6 of the Rome Treaty, and that unless that is done, nothing can be done that modifies the situation in our favour is a very dangerous argument. It goes along with the argument of these Community countries, to the effect that the Accession Treaty in some way binds us. The Accession Treaty derogates from this regulation. The method of derogation chosen was to put the derogation in our favour into the Treaty so as to secure us with that minimal protection of being able to continue with our restrictions until 1982. A derogation from a regulation does not add to that regulation one iota, and Deputy Haughey's very dangerous argument has no foundation in this respect.

The regulations made by the Council can be changed by the Council, and as far as this Government is concerned the Council will change that regulation and will remove this free access provision in a way that will still provide safeguards for our fishermen. They can do it and are in no way inhibited by the Rome Treaty or the Accession Treaty. It can be done by a political decision of the Council of Ministers and it is our job to extract that from them. The wording that is there is wording which unfortunately ipso facto brings any waters that we extend our jurisdiction to within the framework of the common fisheries policy. That being so we have to change the policy. On that there is no legal doubt. The attempt by the Opposition to suggest to the contrary, that there is some way out of the situation created by the 1970 regulation and the Accession Treaty is not honest, to suggest to the fishermen that the 50-mile limit is there for the taking is not honest. If it was there for the taking we would have taken it long ago. This was something we went into exhaustively, and I looked for any angle, any way out, any possible legal loophole, to be found, but unfortunately there was none. We were left in the position where that is the law and that law applies to the extended zone and we have to face that and negotiate our way out of it, not sue our way out of it as the Opposition seem to think is possible. We are engaged in that negotiation and it is complex and difficult.

Basically there are three stages in the negotiation. We have completed the first stage with considerable success and we are currently engaged in a very tricky middle stage, and we have the first half of next year to get through the final stage. In everything we do in the first and second stages we have to avoid doing or saying anything which would prejudice our claim for a 50-mile coastal band. That must be the first consideration. Whatever we do to get preliminary concessions or interim arrangements from 1st January, 1977, we have to bear that in mind and we cannot risk seeking some advantage now of a temporary character, or some provision in the interim arrangement, which might help us but which might in any way prejudice the 50-mile band. I can think of things we might do with regard to the interim arrangement which would be very helpful and effective in helping our fishing in the early part of next year but which could prejudice our 50-mile band claim and, therefore, these are things we cannot and must not do and that must be the primary consideration.

Having that in mind then we have to go through these three stages. The first stage was to use our possibility of veto on the opening of negotiations which, in the case of certain countries like Iceland, were extremely urgent and badly needed by the other Community member states, to use as the leverage provided by their urgent need to get certain preliminary concessions by conceding nothing under 50-mile coastal band. The most crucial concession to be got politically was the recognition that Ireland is a special case. Members will be aware that in the United Kingdom there are problems similar to ours, especially in Scotland. We bear no ill-will to Scotland or to the United Kingdom, and good luck to them if they can get concessions but, to be frank about it, if in fact concessions are to be sought on the basis of having to be given not just to Ireland, which is a relatively small problem catching less than 2 per cent of fish in the whole Community, but on the basis that anything Ireland gets Britain must get too, Ireland could get damn little. The first most important thing for us to do then is to get the special position of Ireland recognised as different from and superior to that of any other part of the Community.

That was the particular major gain we secured at that meeting on October 30th but we got beyond that something of very great importance from the practical point of view which, perhaps, some might feel was more than we could have expected to have got at that stage. We got Ireland recognised not merely in a general way by some form of phraseology on October 30th which one might use in negotiations afterwards but we got it recognised in a specific way. We got it recognised that there must be a common fishery policy and the words go on to say "as may be amended" and so on. Not just the present fisheries policy or a new common fisheries policy or a revised one, if that emerged, but a common fisheries policy which must be operated and applied in such a way as to secure the continued and progressive development of the Irish fishing industry. This then went on to relate this to our development programme.

I repeat: a continued and progressive development of the Irish fishing industry at a time when for every other country what is proposed and what is now being implemented are cutbacks in fishing for conservation reasons, a continued progressive development linked into a development programme which had been discussed with the Commission immediately before this, which the Commission were aware of and the details of which I notified to my colleagues, and a programme which involved the doubling of our fish catch in three years, of which they are on notice. In accepting that phraseology and in reference to the programme, they knew what was in the programme and the Commission is committed as a political commitment so to apply the common fisheries policy as to yield this result and the other countries are on notice that is what is involved and have accepted that and that is now agreed as the objective of policy.

Let us be clear on this. What is important for us is not any particular means of securing that objective. The most important thing of all is to get it recognised that Ireland is in a special position, that this special position requires that we should have a continued and progressive development in fisheries when every other country is to be cut back and to get this as far as possible quantified in a form which is clear-cut and specific and guaranteed, and quantified it has been on the remarkable basis of the doubling of the catch in three years.

Comment on this

Perhaps, unlike Germany, we have waters off our shores which put us in a rather different position from other countries. Perhaps that is the only advantage we have.

Comment on this

The United Kingdom has three times the waters but is not mentioned in this clause. When I returned and reported on what was achieved I got the most curious reception from Deputy Gallagher who, on radio, expressed great doubt, having been so successful in getting this guarantee, whether we could possibly catch so much fish. Maybe it will be a little difficult to do but I am always prepared to accept in any negotiations more than it is possible for us to take advantage of and it is not a bad accusation then to be levelled at one whether by fishermen or by Opposition spokesmen. We have that guarantee and what we have to do now is to ensure that policy is applied in that way from 1st January so that we can be certain of expansion starting at the beginning of next year. Our job is to ensure sufficient expansion of our fishing fleet in this period. The need to expand is there because the existing fleet could not catch double the quantity of fish.

Comment on this

Where will these boats be built?

Comment on this

I am sorry. My time is limited.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister should be allowed to speak without interruption.

Comment on this

I would like to get my speech finished. I will answer questions at the end. Also, in that first stage we got the provision that, because of the totally disproportionate area of sea to the fish catch, there must be financial assistance provided to help us with protection costs so that, in so far as additional fishery vessels or aircraft are required, finance will come from EEC sources and not from our sources because for us catching less than 2 per cent of the fish, and even with a rapid expansion of the programme to 4 per cent of the fish in the Community, to ask us to patrol unaided 22, 24 or 25 per cent of the waters is unreasonable and we got agreement on that too.

Those concessions were secured without any concession of any kind on our part and, while stating quite clearly that we would require when negotiations got to a later stage the coastal band and that we would use our veto on the second stage of the negotiations to achieve that, that was accepted by the other member states. Now we face the second stage of the negotiations. That is the interim arrangements for next year. At the last Council meeting in mid-November I made it clear that we could not accept that the process of expansion of the Irish fishing industry based on the agreement of 30th October should be postponed until some time later next year when agreement is reached on the final arrangements. I made it clear that in the absence of adequate interim arrangements operating from 1st January to secure an expansion of the catch we maintained the right to take the necessary unilateral action for that purpose. The right would not be to abuse or to go beyond what is reasonable and necessary to secure an expansion of the catch moving towards our target but that we had that right and that right we would use if it were necessary and if the interim proposals by the Commission proved inadequate. The Commission has put forward proposals for this purpose to which I referred this afternoon. They are confidential. I know they appeared in the papers to a degree but there are certain confidences and certain convenances to be observed. The Opposition are entitled to what they see in the papers which, let us face it, are substantially accurate and they would have no difficulty in guessing that the proposals made by the Commission in their present form are quite unacceptable to us.

Comment on this

The first setback in the three-year period in a system based on quotas——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

Any system based on quotas only is unacceptable to us. We have not accepted it and it has to be fought out. Anything based on quotas only is unacceptable. The Opposition are inclined to say quotas are no good without giving the reason. It is important that we state the reason for consumption overseas. The reason is because you can have a quota which entitles you to catch so much fish but if other people come in close to your coast and catch all the fish there the quota is no damn good. The quota does not achieve what we are now entitled to. It does not secure the expansion of the catch. It gives you a legal entitlement to catch the fish if you can find them but, because of the size of the zones used for the purpose of calculating the quotas, which go far out to sea and far north and south of Ireland, quotas in relation to those zones could be useless for us because the whole of other countries' quotas could be caught close inshore to us instead of out in the Atlantic leaving us with nothing. So a quota system is of its nature unsatisfactory and cannot achieve what has to be achieved now under the agreement of October 30th to ensure the expansion of our industry.

That is the reason why quotas are unacceptable. Deputies will have seen a figure in the paper for the proposed increase in the quota, but that kind of percentage would not, to my mind, represent appropriate progress towards the target of doubling the catch in three years either. Even if the quota system worked, which it would not for this purpose, such a figure would be unacceptable.

We are now proceeding with the interim negotiation and either we will have a satisfactory result from it or we will have to take action of our own in order to ensure that the fish are there for our fishermen to catch from 1st January onwards. We are not going to wait till later next year for some final agreement to get to the stage when the fish are available for the fishermen, who are having a very bad season at present because of the gross over-fishing, much of it by Community partners, not all of it from people outside the Community.

Comment on this

Would the Minister like to indicate what the action will be?

Comment on this

No. I have no intention of indicating in advance of negotiation what our intentions are. It is a complex and delicate negotiation. I have told our partners that if the provisions made by the Commission are not adequate we will take the necessary unilateral action. I have told them it will be done in consultation; it will not go beyond what is necessary to secure the objective of an appropriate expansion in the catch off our shores, but we will take the action necessary for that if we have to.

The third and final stage of this negotiation is when the Community comes to negotiate the final agreements with Norway, Faroes and Iceland after whatever interim agreements may now be negotiated, and when the framework agreements with other countries come to the stage where figures have to be agreed for reciprocal catches. We have put them on notice that, at that stage, unless a satisfactory solution has been found to the coastal band problem, we will not be prepared to assent to those agreements being settled. What is not easy to say at this point is precisely when that will happen. There has been talk of agreements with, for example, Iceland, lasting three or four months; both figures have been mentioned, but as nothing has been settled yet, I cannot tell the House when the breakpoint will come, the first point at which there will be the need for a permanent agreement or for the filling in in detail of a framework agreement, at which point our right of veto will arise again. As I say, I cannot be certain of the date, but I think it will be fairly early next year. That will be a very difficult negotiation. The other member countries are unconvinced that they should give up what they won for themselves by that unilateral action on the part of the Six in 1970. I do not suggest for a moment it will be an easy task to secure agreement on a coastal band and the Opposition should not pretend to anybody that it will be easy.

I was asked for details of the programme. The programme, which was drawn up last year—I do not know the exact date—covers the period 1975 to 1979. It has been in existence for some time, so that when Commissioner Gundelach came here to see us and put certain proposals to us which led to the agreement of October 30th, I said to him we would have to be satisfied that any agreement secured the objective we had set out in this programme. The officials then met together and agreed that the programme was appropriate for this purpose. The Commission officials thought it a little optimistic, as Deputy Gallagher has thought; and maybe it is, but it was agreed as the basis for discussion. The figures concerned, which related, as I have said, to the catch of fish, to employment and to the number of boats—which are set out by a size of boat; we are not talking about rowing boats but boats up to 130 or 140 feet—were published and issued to the Press by us here in Dublin on October 30th simultaneously with the announcement of the agreement in Brussels. I did not see any of this in the papers, but it was not our fault, they were issued in detail but I did not see them set out in tabular form anyway. Certainly if they are not easily accessible to the Opposition they are welcome to copies of it. They represent the programme drawn up by Bord Iascaigh Mhara at some earlier point in time and which we have been able to get the Community to adopt as a legitimate target for us to aim at and one which they are obliged to secure for us by making the fish available for us to catch on that scale and expanding at that rate.

Another thing I want to say in this debate—and it will not be any news to Deputies opposite because of some little altercation earlier today—is that I dislike and resent being referred to as devious, deceptive, as deliberately misleading the people. I do not like questions, whether in this House or elsewhere, of a rhetorical character, "who is telling the truth?"; and I do not like it when a colleague in this House is asked, does he think I have misled the fishermen and the Dáil as well? I do not like it being said that I am not entirely honest. I would be less than human if I did not resent these, and if my resentment showed earlier, I hope it did not show in an unparliamentary way.

We are determined to carry this battle through to a successful conclusion. There is too much at stake here for this country and for our fishermen. It might have been that if the 200-mile limit had not come up we would have no chance to do this, that we would have reached in 1982, the review process would be put into effect offering a very weak guarantee of continued and restrictive arrangements for our fishermen. We might have been able to get some continuation of it in a limited form, I do not know; but fortunately for us the 200-mile zone issue has come up and we have used this effectively and are using it to renegotiate our fishery policy. We have got to the point where our fishermen know the Community are now committed to guaranteeing them the doubling of the catch within the next three years and continued development thereafter on a large scale, because I indicated also at that time the level of employment at which we were aiming for the year 1980.

This is the most difficult and complex negotiation I have been engaged in, and one which is extremely demanding, because one is conscious it is so easy to make a mistake and so difficult to win a point. However, we are determined to carry it through to success, and I think the fishermen can have confidence that we will not miss any tricks and that out of it will come prospects for a rapidly developing fishing industry in Ireland of which till a few months ago there seemed to be no prospect as a result of the situation we were left in by the regulation of 1970 and the Accession Treaty.

Comment on this