Ceisteanna — Questions. Oral Answers. - Garda Membership.
- Garda Recruitment Examination and Selection 16 speeches
The Minister said 1,776 of 3,077 applicants held the Leaving Certificate and explained that applicants would sit an examination to establish merit, with an interview also forming part of selection. He offered to send the syllabus and any available interview standards.
James C. Tunney, Patrick Mark Cooney, Gerard Collins
- Age Limit for Earlier Garda Applicants 4 speeches
Deputy Allen questioned whether the age limit unfairly excluded people who had applied in 1974 or 1975. The Minister undertook to check the rules, then said applicants could have entered earlier competitions while eligible.
Lorcan Allen, Patrick Mark Cooney
- Married Men Barred from Garda Recruitment 4 speeches
Deputy Gallagher challenged the exclusion of married men; the Minister defended the longstanding policy on training and postings. Deputy Power noted the same restriction applied to Army recruitment, before the Chair moved to the next question.
Denis Gallagher, Patrick Mark Cooney, Patrick Power, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Justice the total number of applications for membership of the Garda Síochána received between 15th March, 1974, and 15th January, 1977, from applicants who stated that they had the leaving certificate or higher educational standard.
Comment on this
The available records indicate that of the 3,077 persons who applied for membership of the force in the period mentioned, 1,776 were holders of the leaving certificate.
Comment on this
Would the Minister indicate the proposed standard of examination in respect of the 500 garda who will be recruited?
Comment on this
I have not got the particulars here but I will send the Deputy a copy of the syllabus which has been published setting out the details of the subjects and the standards which will be expected.
Comment on this
Is it not possible then to recruit from those applicants that the Minister had on hand prior to the announcement for a sufficiency of gardaí for the much-needed services that are required and have been required over the last couple of years?
Comment on this
It would be, but even among gardaí who had the leaving certificate it would have been necessary to hold the examination in order to establish an order of merit. In addition to that we had to consider those applicants who did not have the leaving certificate and it would be unjust to deprive them without adequate notice of the opportunity of competing for entrance to the Garda Síochána. Many of them have not done the leaving certificate through no fault of their own. Many of them might have very good intermediate certificates. It would have been unfair to have excluded them. That consideration plus the need to establish an order of merit coerced me into the decision that a competitive examination was the only fair way to deal with the problem.
Comment on this
If the standard of education required for this competition, which we are all waiting for, is to be lower than the leaving certificate, surely the Minister would agree that the holders of the leaving certificate would have a head start in sitting for that open competitive examination over the people who have not got that standard of education. Would the Minister say whether or not as a result of what I call the change in the regulations——
Comment on this
It is a change in the system of recruiting. Can the Minister say whether or not there will be oral examinations or interviews?
Comment on this
May I say that I do not accept necessarily that the people with leaving certificates will have a head start over other applicants? I think I made it clear that you can have excellent people with very high IQs who for some good reason were not able to do the leaving certificate. Also, nowadays a person can have the leaving certificate with just one subject whereas four years ago there had to be a certain minimum number of subjects, so possession of the leaving certificate is not necessarily a mark of academic excellence. There is of course an interview procedure as well.
Comment on this
Would the Minister in his offer to Deputy Tunney in circulating a copy of the syllabus send me also not just a copy of the syllabus but a copy of the standards for the interview as well?
Comment on this
There must be some basis if you are going to interview people, there must be a certain standard of applicant and I would like to know how that is going to operate.
Comment on this
This may not arise out of this question, but possibly the Minister could enlighten me. With regard to people who applied in 1974-75 and who now find themselves over 26 years old on 1st April, is that not discrimination against the people who now find that they cannot sit for the examination?
Comment on this
I will inquire into that aspect of the matter and I will communicate with the Deputy. I am not sure whether it is the date of application or the date of entry.
Comment on this
They have to be under 26 on the last of April, 1977. People who applied in 1974 and 1975 and who had the leaving certificate now find that they are not being allowed to sit for the examination.
Comment on this
They cannot blame the entrance conditions for that because it was open to them to apply for earlier competitions when they were the proper age.
Comment on this
Why does the Minister find it necessary to debar married men when the upper age limit is 28?
Comment on this
It has been consistent policy right through the years to restrict recruitment to single men. It is not compatible with the married state in many ways for a person to undergo a period of training in a recruit depot, and there could be difficulties with regard to making assignments to posts. I think the conditions are right in so far as policy is concerned.
Comment on this
Would the Minister care to comment on the fact that married men are not allowed to join the Army because the same condition prevails?