We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Bula Limited (Acquisition of Shares) Bill, 1977: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–145 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Bula Limited (Acquisition of Shares) Bill, 1977
Enacted

No. 2 of 1977 ›

Justin Keating Minister for Industry and Commerce (Mr. Keating) Labour Party

When we debated this section last night the Deputies opposite were asking about the financial plans for the development of the orebody. It was perfectly proper to ask if there were well drawn up and serious plans for that development. On the basis of the scrutiny of the experts available to me I can tell the House that this is the case and that the matter from our side has been properly and thoroughly investigated. I think that it is proper to ask if the question of the financial planning was discussed by the arbitrators and formed a part of the final arbitration and I will answer that question. Yes, it was taken into account in the valuation. It seems entirely improper for the House to ask for the details.

Last week and again this week we have discussed the extent of revelation and the extent of confidentiality and the need for a balance in our society between those two things. This particular instance, the financial plans of a mine, is a perfect illustration—I could not ask for a better one—of the need for confidentiality. This is the most public place in the land. I had affirmed last week that behind the Canadian company, the parent company of the Irish subsidiary, there were some of the most powerful mining houses in the world, though because of nominee shareholdings they were difficult to identify in all cases. It is a fact about which we could agree that there are intimate relationships between the great mining houses and the mining finance companies and I think we could agree that banking is a world-wide club. I think we could also agree that one of the most precious things that the private citizen, especially the businessman, possesses is his power to borrow and I am asked, in fact, to bare the jugular of Bula Limited.

I am asked to reveal details which could very obviously be the basis for the sort of pressure which would make that orebody difficult to finance. I am not saying that this would be the case because I have no way of knowing. Banking is a club and the result of this demand, were I to accede to it, would be to do damage to Irish businessmen of good standing who have contributed to this society and who have broken no law and to do damage to the value of the participation of the State in the development of this orebody. It would damage both in a very obvious way which nobody can contest. I could not pick a better example than this of the need for the preservation of confidentiality. The breaking of this confidentiality would be detrimental to the private individuals in the enterprise, to the enterprise itself and to State participation in it. Anybody who knows about financing will appreciate this. The plans were thoroughly prepared, investigated and examined by the arbitrators and I stand on the quality of those who studied them on my side and I stand on the quality of those who arbitrated on the final orebody of the mine. Here we have a very good example of how a company could be damaged by total revelation of confidential data.

Comment on this

It is reassuring, even to a limited extent, that the Minister now knows something about the plans for the development of this mine because quite clearly in his answers last night he did not know anything about them, and indeed, said so. He was not, of course, asked for detailed plans for the development of this mine. Assuming that the cost of getting the mine into production is £25 million, the figure the Minister gave, I asked him for a general outline of how it was proposed to finance this. The principal question I asked was whether it was intended that the State would have to invest more money in this connection and if so I asked the Minister if he could give an approximate idea of how much was involved. The Minister could not give any idea of that and of course it is ridiculous to suggest that to answer that question would put at risk the future borrowing prospects of Bula Limited. That is so totally removed from reality that it hardly needs further comment.

I was very interested to hear the Minister say that this was a good example of the need for confidentiality. If it is, it bears out precisely the point I made yesterday that there is a major distinction between the day-to-day operations of a company, on the one hand, and the arrangements made for initial investment, on the other. I asked the Minister previously, and without success, if he would indicate in what way the future of this company could be put at risk by disclosing the terms agreed on, not for the development of the mine, not for its future policy, but simply for investment in the share capital. I am assuming, of course, that the agreement referred to in this Act which the Minister is refusing to produce relates only to investment in the initial share capital and does not extend beyond that.

The Minister's reply was that he could not and would not give details in relation to this particular company and that he had to talk about categories of companies. Therefore, I am asking him now, if, in relation to any company of any category in which the State participates, he would indicate one way in which disclosure of the details of the State's investment in that company could be damaging to the company's prospects. I want to repeat that I am not talking about the operations of the company, merely of the initial investment.

Comment on this

It seems to me that that is the substance of the amendment which we debated and decided on last night.

Comment on this

Is that the Minister's answer to that question?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I think I ought to draw the attention of the House and of anybody else who is interested to the fact that one of the major planks in the Minister's argument for non-disclosure of this agreement is now being totally withdrawn. His whole case was that he would not give information about this company. I have asked him to give any example he likes, in respect of any company or all companies in which the State participates, of how disclosure of details of the initial investment could damage that company, and the Minister has refused to reply. I hope the Minister will think better about his reply before we conclude on the section. Let him know that if he sticks to that position, he is selfconfessedly showing to this House that he has not a leg to stand on.

Comment on this

The Deputy may affirm anything he likes, but we discussed the matters of the availability of information, of the publication of the agreement, last night very lengthily. We are still on section 1——

Comment on this

Is the Minister saying it is out of order?

Comment on this

No, I am saying I decline, having had three-and-a-half hours on it yesterday, to go into detail on a section on which we have already voted. It is not for me to rule as to what is out of order or not out of order.

Comment on this

Does the Minister recall that he was asked by me yesterday on the discussion of the amendment how a company could be damaged by disclosure of the arrangements made for the initial investment and he did not reply to that question yesterday? He is asked today and his plea is that we have already discussed that matter.

Comment on this

I am rather perturbed that the Opposition have proceeded to make a meal of an issue which one would have thought at this stage would be crystal clear to them and to the public at large. One can only infer from their sustained campaign to date in relation to this matter that their real purpose is to do everything possible to discredit the concept of State participation in a company of this nature. That has a great deal of foreboding for the prospect of Deputy Colley being Minister for Finance, as he would wish to be, in the event of his being successful in the next general election. As a trade union official of some years past, I can recall Avoca mines making representations to Deputy Colley, then Minister for Finance, for State aid, and many a time when, in Opposition, I looked for details in relation to a company of that nature, I was greeted with horror on the part of Deputy Colley at the very prospect of data being made available to this House in relation to, say, the Canadian directors of that company and the local management in respect of negotiations which took place very frequently at that time with the Department of Industry and Commerce.

I could draw innumerable analogies of that situation, and the only conclusion I can come to is a deliberate ideological decision by the Fianna Fáil Party to denigrate, to destroy, if at all possible, the concept of State participation in the future development of our natural resources. I asked here the last day—and I intervened only once previously in this debate—what was the real purpose of the Fianna Fáil intervention; whom they really represented? I have not the slightest doubt, having read the various statements made, particularly by the other companies directly involved in this, that there was a fronting operation going on.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to dissuade the Deputy and any other Member of the House from engaging in what is tantamount to a Second Reading speech on this occasion. We are dealing with section 1 which concerns definitions. There has been very wide latitude in respect of this matter, but I cannot permit the equivalent of Second Reading speeches all over again.

Comment on this

I could not agree with you more and, therefore, I shall be as brief as possible. However, we have this razzmatazz on the part of the Opposition, the republican party, whose heart is bleeding in this House for multinational mining companies, because the one thing that has stuck in the craw of those companies is the prospect of this State getting even a 2 per cent shareholding in such companies. This is their total opposition, and Fianna Fáil have fallen for it hook, line and sinker. I am not a bit surprised at Deputy O'Malley falling for it. While he is one of the most perceptive Members of this House, he acts like a bull in a china shop, demolishes all in front of him and then has to withdraw as gracefully as he can. Deputy Colley had, I thought, a little more experience and circumspection in that regard. Therefore, if the Opposition wish to prolong this relationship, one must ask them whom they are speaking for. As regards the agreement originally made between the principals of Tara as originally established and the multi-national corporation which eventually took over the total holding, is there the slightest suggestion on the part of the Opposition that that agreement should be disclosed to this House? Not at all, because that is private, and this one happens to concern State money. There is not a peep out of the Opposition that an agreement entered into with a private, multinational company, owning and controlling a wholly Irish subsidiary and totally dominating it here in terms of its attitude towards the State, should be disclosed.

Comment on this

They have been.

Comment on this

Have they? That is very interesting.

Comment on this

A public company must publish all their agreements. They are even registered in the Registry of Deeds.

Comment on this

Even with a 1956 version of a B.Comm. from UCC, I would not fall for that. However, solicitors should stick to their own field of activity and accountants to theirs.

Comment on this
Desmond Governey Acting Chairman (Mr. Governey) Fine Gael

The Deputy must confine himself to section 1.

Comment on this

One might make a similar point in regard to the media's incursions into this observation.

Comment on this

How dare they.

Comment on this

There has been an obsession of late on the part of the media——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I must remind the Deputy that this is not relevant to section 1.

Comment on this

I submit that it is relevant.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Chair says otherwise.

Comment on this

In relation to section 1, I would make the point that the obsession of the media in relation to the affairs of Government vis-à-vis Bula has not extended in any way to the relationship between the Tara Company and some of their multi-national shareholders. Indeed, some of the phone calls that were made recently could be extended usefully in that direction also. What has happened is that some people on coming into the possession of documents that other newspapers have had for weeks have run riot and must find ways and means of leaking some rather faded documents that have been floating around this city for the past six months.

Comment on this

Since the documents were written only three months ago, it is difficult to understand how they can have been floating around for the past six months.

Comment on this

I am sure that Deputy Colley will assume his republican royalty role as we go along.

Comment on this

If we leave aside the type of waffle and the flak that we have had from Deputy Desmond who is performing his normal and useful function for the Labour Party, what emerges is that the Deputy does not understand what has been said in this regard. But the Minister understands it so well that when put up against the wall, so to speak, he refuses to answer. I might very briefly explain the position for the benefit of Deputy Desmond.

This section contains a definition of the agreement. Later in the Bill there are references to acts that may be undertaken by the Minister subject to the agreement and this House is asked to approve of that situation. However, we do not know what is in the agreement. In case Deputy Desmond is not so aware, I would remind him that never before in the history of this State has a Minister brought in a Bill referring to an agreement but not producing that agreement.

Comment on this

I had to wait six months before succeeding in screwing the Marathon agreement from Deputy Colley during his time in office.

Comment on this

No other Bill has ever been brought before the House seeking approval for an agreement that was not made known.

Comment on this

The people opposite merely handed out money. They did not even bring the relevant legislation before the House.

Comment on this

The Minister has told us that one of the reasons for not disclosing the terms of the agreement is the consideration that to do so would be damaging to the affairs of the company concerned. I have no wish to be unfair to the Minister. He has said he cannot reply in respect to this particular company but that he can reply only in respect of companies as a category. He has said that if he were to give a reply in regard to particular categories, he would breach the whole tradition of confidentiality which would mean that business could not deal with the Government in future.

We have pointed out that there is an enormous distinction between, first, disclosing the affairs of a business in relation to its day to day affairs and, secondly, disclosing the arrangements made already for the initial investment by the State in that company. In respect of any category or of any company of any kind in which the State has participated or might participate, I have asked the Minister to give one concrete example to illustrate in what way the disclosure of the arrangements made for the initial investment could damage the affairs of the company. In giving an example the Minister need not mention any company. He may mention a category of companies. That very reasonable question was met with the reply from the Minister that the matter had been dealt with already on the amendment. The Minister did not deal with the question on the amendment although he was asked to do so. The Minister's stance goes to the whole root of the Bill and to the root of parliamentary democracy. If he persists in refusing to give even one example of how disclosure of the information would damage the company, the significance of his refusal cannot be lost on anybody who pays any attention to the whole matter.

Comment on this

Perhaps I shall be permitted to follow the very wide path that Deputy Colley has beaten in relation to the rather narrow confines of section 1.

Comment on this

It is a very narrow path that I have trodden.

Comment on this

Associated with the point made by the Opposition in regard to the disclosure of the terms of the agreement is a share of innuendo as to the reasons for this stance on the part of the Minister. Surely the innuendo cuts both ways. For that reason I do not wish to travel on that particular road, at least not yet, but I would remind the House that in matters of this kind, non-disclosure on the part of the State in relation to its commercial dealings with companies of the type we are talking of, indicates a strength rather than a weakness. It might act to the advantage of the State's development of our natural resources that there would be a very broad area of confidentiality because the State is in the business of being a competitor. It must go out and seek various partners.

Comment on this

Perhaps I might interrupt the Deputy for a moment. As he appears to be serious in relation to this matter, can he distinguish for us between the disclosure of a company in relation to its day-to-day workings and disclosure in relation to the initial investment?

Comment on this

A brilliant observation.

Comment on this

I shall come to that. We are in the business already, in relation to the development of our natural resources, of shopping around between many multi-national companies. Consequently, there is the necessity for getting the best bargain possible. Deputies opposite must know that if we were to disclose our hand fully in regard to every agreement, we would be weakening our bargaining position. The great strength of the State in this sphere is that the companies concerned do not know what their competitors are giving. In dealing with a cartel, for example, where supposedly a product is sold at a fixed price, members of the cartel make secret deals with a company. I should hope that nobody would put a semi-State body here into the position of having to disclose such details.

For that reason the principle of disclosure, as has been raised by Deputy Colley and others, is very important. Since they have attacked the principle I would like to defend it from the point of view of development of our resources. I regard it as being an essential weapon if we are to deal with these companies who are tough and ruthless and will exact from the State the maximum they can. They seek maximum disclosure of information so as to weaken the State. Deputy Colley made an important contribution in relation to the establishment of an Oireachtas committee on semi-State bodies. The legislation dealing with semi-State bodies contains a provision whereby at the request of one of these companies information is made confidential only to the members of that committee.

Comment on this

That is true, on its ordinary working.

Comment on this

On all its agreements as well. It applies to An Bord Gáis as well as to everybody else. Do not try to be clever.

Comment on this

I made the point that we had to seek a balance between confidentiality and the principle of public disclosure. I had the advantage of having worked for a semi-State body and I have been involved at a level of management where I was privy to exchange of information between the company, its board of directors and the Minister. This information was never put before the House. Deputy Colley and Deputy de Valera made the point that it may be that this committee even with its wide powers would not be able to get access to information which flows between the offices of the Minister and the chairman of the board of directors, and the general manager, of the company. We accepted the principle there in the formation of an Oireachtas committee dealing with semi-State bodies. Shall that principle not apply to this deal where the Minister is investing the State's money? A semi-State company which is voted taxpayers' money by this House could make a similar deal and would not have to come before this House with any element of disclosure such as is now being sought. I believe Deputy Colley will be a member of this committee, and if this company was to come before the committee and request that there be no public disclosure of information, that information shall not be published. The committee does not have any discretion.

Comment on this

We sought to give it discretion.

Comment on this

The terms of the resolution were agreed in the end.

Comment on this

We sought to amend it.

Comment on this

Not on that issue.

Comment on this

On that issue specifically.

Comment on this

As far as I am aware we did not divide on the issue.

Comment on this

I cannot say for certain but I know we had an amendment specifically on that point.

Comment on this

I know that and I was very sympathetic towards the point made. In the end I came to the view that, perhaps, the balance of advantage lay in the company having the right to demand that its information remain privileged because otherwise it might be that we would not get the information. I have been in the business of writing reports and presenting information. We all know that there are very many ways of presenting information. It can be cloaked very easily on occasion. I draw the attention of the House to the distinction which is being made in relation to a disclosure in respect of this agreement and disclosure in respect of a similar agreement which could be made between a semi-State body and Bula Limited or anybody else.

Comment on this

No, that is capital investment by the State.

Comment on this

That is the legitimate inference that can be drawn from the Fianna Fáil position here. On section 1 Deputy Colley addressed a question to the House as to whether we could identify any examples whereby disclosure of equity participation would be damaging. From my experience I could give an example but I am not going to divulge that now.

Comment on this

The post office is one example. The ESB is another.

Comment on this

What is the Deputy talking about?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Halligan without interruption, please.

Comment on this

No wonder the files are piled high over in the Department of Finance. No decisions were ever taken.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy with us at all?

Comment on this

Without disclosing confidential information, I will give the Deputy one example. I worked in a project where a semi-State body was attempting to set up a joint venture with an American multi-national company. State money voted by this House was to be invested in the new company. Disclosure of the information relating to the provisions of equity participation by that company in the new joint company would have been damaging to the operation of the venture. It is ludicrous to pretend that there is a distinction between an agreement regarding equity participation and disclosure of information about day to day operations. Perhaps it is the argument put forward by counsel speaking for some other interest who wishes to elicit information which should not be put before this House.

This State has through its various agencies put money by agreement into companies and those agreements have not been brought before this House and have not been sought. I direct the memories of Deputies opposite to the Potez affair in the early 1960s. A fine factory was built for a French company on the Naas Road to produce aeroplanes. The IDA and An Taisce lost £1½ million of public funds on that venture and were we to gross that amount up in today's terms it would be considerable. It is important to note that the agreement in relation to this large project which consumed such amounts of public money was never published and the equity participation was in the region of £1 million to purchase shares. I agree with Deputy O'Malley's Second Reading speech in relation to the risks associated with equity ventures being true. The Minister is not being selective in relation to Bula Limited. The Minister should not be persuaded to disclose more information than he thinks fit.

Deputy Lalor said that we are setting a precedent for the development of our natural resources and the State's participation in that development and I agree with him in that. Let us not be so naive as to underestimate the forces with which we will have to unite on occasion. Let us not be so naive as to throw away the weapon of commercial confidentiality. In the last analysis this House must have sufficient trust in any Minister of State and in any Government so that if information is not forthcoming, it is accepted that it is not for any private reason associated with personal or party advantage, but it is simply in the public interest. I would not refuse to extend that trust to members opposite if they were in Government and I expect them to do the same here. The amount of innuendo that is being passed around here is damaging all of us.

Yesterday it was asked what was being hidden, what was the Minister hiding? My answer to that is "Nothing except that which is in the public interest". There is nothing in the Minister's personal interest that is being hidden and the amount of innuendo which suggests that there might is disgraceful. It should not be allowed to pollute the debate because that is what is happening.

This debate should be about the important question of the development of our resources. There is a clear philosophical distinction about how the two sides view this. Well and good. Let us have the debate on that but let us not drag down the debate to the level of personal innuendo. Mind you, we are all tempted to follow that and I am as open to that temptation as the next person. Perhaps I will succumb to it and doubtless I shall feel sorry afterwards. The issue is too important for us to fall to that level. The issue is whether we want State equity participation or not and, if we do, what are the conditions under which we give assent to it here. The issue is what are the limitations on the amount of information we in this House accept as being realistic in proportion to the commercial risk.

As the Minister said yesterday, there is a fine distinction to be drawn in the balance of advantage but I would say that the development of our resources will take such a period of time that it can be legitimate to expect that that side of the House will be over here during that period. That is the way democracy works. When they are I hope we will extend to them the same trust that we now ask them to extend to us. In the last analysis there is only one motivation in this case which is the public interest. There is no other motivation.

Comment on this

I do not want to prolong this debate unduly but there are one or two points I wish to make. For a fair proportion of Deputy Halligan's contribution the thought was in my mind that I would speak when he finished and that the first thing I would say was congratulations to him. I do say it but with less enthusiasm than I was inclined to say at first. I say congratulations because he attempted to deal with the problem in a way that the Minister has not attempted. The Minister has run away from it. I congratulate Deputy Halligan on the fact that he has at least put forward the argument that here we are dealing with a new situation, the development of our national resources. The Minister has tried to pretend he is doing exactly everything that was done in the past and is sticking to that but he is not. At least Deputy Halligan is putting forward a logical reason when he makes that argument although it does not stand up to examination.

My less than enthusiastic response to Deputy Halligan is because earlier he said he was going to deal with the point I had been making, namely, the distinction on the one hand between the initial investment and, on the other hand, the day-to-day working of the company. When it came to the crunch he dealt with it by saying that there was no distinction. With all due respects to him, that is not dealing with the situation.

I am assuming all the time that the agreement referred to in section 1 relates only to the State's initial investment in the company. If it relates to other things— we have no way of knowing unless the Minister tells us— that raises another issue. We have not been told anything about this except such as would suggest that this agreement relates only to the State's initial investment. Clearly the Minister does not or cannot tell me but perhaps Deputy Halligan can answer my question which is, in what way can the disclosure of the terms, fixed and agreed and already in existence, for the State's initial investment damage the company? In what way could similar disclosures in respect of any other company cause damage?

Comment on this

If the Deputy cannot answer that he will never be a businessman.

Comment on this

I have asked the Minister to answer it and he cannot and neither can Deputy Halligan. Deputy Desmond did not even attempt to do so and it must not be as simple a matter as it seems to him. It is not a matter of its being a difficult question. It is a question of political will. It is a question of what is at stake here. We do not know because the Minister does not tell us what is in the agreement.

On the assumption that it relates solely to the terms of the State's investment, I ask any Deputy, any reasonable person, to give an example of what way the disclosure of the terms of the State's initial investment could be damaging. It is a simple straightforward question and it goes to the root of this section and of the Bill. It goes even further but yet we have not been able to get an answer. It is no good trying to muddy the water by talking about the necessity for confidentiality in regard to the ongoing work of the company and the possibility that its commercial rivals might get advantage by knowing about it. That is common ground and it has always been so. However, it is not what we are talking about here. We are talking about the disclosure of the terms of the State's initial investment. In what way can that damage this or any other company?

Comment on this

If the Deputy cannot answer that he will have to be sent to the IMI. Let Frank Dunlop book him a course in the IMI.

Comment on this

That is very smart but it does not answer the question. Perhaps Deputy Esmonde can answer it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, we are on section 1 which deals with definitions. Yesterday we discussed the question of confidentiality and the question of publication of the agreement at very great length and we voted on it. It seems to me we are having that discussion all over again. This Bill has already received a large amount of time and discussion on Second Stage.

Comment on this

On a point of order in furtherance of the point of order made by the Minister, may I point out to the occupant of the Chair that prior to this the Ceann Comhairle was in the Chair and the Minister made the point he has just made now in a slightly different fashion. I asked him if he was suggesting that it was out of order on the section to have this discussion and he said he was not so suggesting. It seems to me that his suggestion now is reversing what he said.

Comment on this

The official record will bear out what I said. I did not offer a judgment as to whether or not it was out of order. I said it was for the Ceann Comhairle to do so.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister if he is suggesting it was and he said he was not so suggesting. The official record will show what was said.

Comment on this
Augustine Healy Acting Chairman (Mr. Healy) Fianna Fáil

I am informed that the Chair has endeavoured all the time to keep the debate to section 1. The Chair will continue to do that, to contain the debate as much as possible. I would ask the Deputies on both sides to remember that.

Comment on this

It appears that one matter has been lost sight of in the debate, namely, the purchase of shares in a private company. As I read the case made by the Opposition, the hypothetical questions put amount to a request for a prospectus as one would have on an issue of shares in a public company. It may be difficult for certain public representatives, full of bloom of acting for the public, to have to accept the fact that there is a very big distinction between the operation of a private and a public company.

It is also well to bear in mind that when a person buys shares in a private company he does not buy them on the blind, so to speak, as a result of public blurbs or comment in the financial columns of newspapers or stockbrokers' handouts. He does it as a result of his own private investigation on expert advice. That has been done in this case. It may be hard for Members to stomach this and to stomach the fact that, when one is dealing with private companies, one is dealing with a big emphasis on the word "private". If we were to ask for the disclosure of the terms of the agreement a simple corollary to that would be to ask for the terms of the advice and we would be running completely contrary to the legal and commercial principles involved in a private company. It is difficult naturally for people who represent the public to accept that fact. They would like to be able to turn around and say the facts are such and such.

This is a novel venture by the State and we must look at it in the light and from the point of view of the Minister acting on behalf of the State putting himself in the position of a shareholder in a private company. Bearing in mind what I have said that is the position in which he is putting himself. Deputy Colley sought to make a distinction between initial investment details and day-to-day working. I do not know whether Deputy Colley is aware of what the circumstances are like in relation to mining enterprises. Without being too caustic, cynical, critical or sarcastic, I would suggest to him that one is dealing with a completely different set-up when one is dealing with mining companies and secrecy in relation to such companies is an absolute must because eventually one will be dealing on the international market with the produce, the rate at which it is produced, the percentage of deposit, the finance involved at any stage and, above all, the time factor. These are just a few small facets that have to be weighed in consideration of a mining enterprise and the disclosure of even one small facet of these things could be highly damaging to a mining enterprise. It might have the effect of literally putting the mine into liquidation or into cold storage for years.

Those of us who can read know that when we open the mining page of a financial paper we see there surmises in relation to mining shares. There has to be a cloak of secrecy if a mining concern is to be successful. I am not talking about the effect disclosure might have in relation to obtaining further working finance or the terms of that finance. This will be an ongoing commercial enterprise. If public money is invested in it is it not in the interests of the public that we give that company, particularly our shareholding in it, maximum advantage? It is all very well for Deputy O'Malley to give us a litany of ifs and cute, clever questions. They are exactly the questions a client asks his legal adviser or his financial adviser when making an investment. Is it to be assumed that, because these questions were asked and because they are given great mileage by certain scribes, Deputy O'Malley is making a great case for the Opposition and that the Minister is on a beating to nothing? Let us have a little common sense. Let us live in the world in which we are and let us realise we are dealing with a very vital commercial enterprise.

We are not here to pander to the curiosity of commentators. We, on this side, are concerned with ensuring this will be an ongoing, viable enterprise. It is vitally important from the point of view of the State and from the point of view of the citizen that we should have a stake in the resources of the State and not just be a little officer on the tilley going out of the mine taking our pence here and there. It is time we got involved as a State. Questions such as were asked yesterday by Deputy O'Malley are questions Deputy O'Malley or I would ask if we were advising a client. Deputy O'Malley is assuming the Minister has not had advice and has not got experts. If the Minister says he has taken the best advice available to him, are we not right in accepting that?

Comment on this

He did not accept it. He totally disregarded it.

Comment on this

The Deputy is speaking like an Annie Oakley on the basis that, if he were there, he would have done better. That is what the Deputy's case amounts to.

Comment on this

I certainly would never put myself in a minority position in a private company and hand out £9 million tax free to four individuals and have them laughing at me and at the State.

Comment on this

The Deputy is in a minority position in this House at the moment. I referred to facts that would be sought by a lawyer. The Minister has gone into these facts and told the House he has done so. He had a contract that was put to arbitration at which worldwide expert opinions were given and the arbitrators came down with a finding which bound the Minister under the arbitration. I cannot see what question mark there can be over that. There might be question marks had there not been an arbitration. Did that not happen before where there was no arbitration clause where a Government did deals?

Comment on this

The last speaker has asked us to apply common sense to this debate. Certainly, we have been applying common sense. The fact remains the Minister has brought in a Bill here and failed to produce an agreement. We are not here to pander to commentators. We are here to protect the rights of the people who sent us here. That is common sense. This is a private company and this private company will in due course have its annual general meeting and at that meeting any shareholder, if dissatisfied, will have the right to ask for an agreement, if an agreement has been entered into. If the board of directors fail to produce that agreement, the shareholder then has the right to go to the courts and the courts will make an order directing the board to produce the agreement. That situation can arise in this particular case. A shareholder will be able to take action and the agreement we have been debating here for two days or more will find its way before the courts for the benefit of that shareholder. Here we are acting on behalf of 3.1 million shareholders and this House cannot have access to that agreement.

Comment on this

Deputy Esmonde is a man I have a degree of regard for. I look upon him as an honest Deputy and I fully accept that what he said by way of contribution a few moments ago was given to us in all sincerity and that he meant every word. He opened by saying that we have here a totally private company and it was most improper of us on this side of the House to be demanding information with regard to the internal dealings of a private company and that we were linking up with the media in bringing in this ministerial bashing. I presume that is the situation as Deputy Esmonde sees it, but surely it is our responsibility as the representative of, by 1973 figures, little less than 50 per cent of the public. I believe, as the representative of the majority of the public at present, that if the State invest £9.54 million of public money, taxpayers' money, the money which is the property of the people, that it is very wrong for Deputy Esmonde or the Minister or his backup Deputies Desmond and Halligan to castigate the Opposition on our insistence that £9.54 million of public moneys be properly protected at least.

What got me to my feet was this allegation of the media bashing the poor, unfortunate Minister caught with the child in his arms. What was that in comparison with the bashing that I got in 1972 and early 1973 in relation to this? At present the State is proposing to invest £9.54 million in this project but four years ago at this time the State had under Lalor, Minister for Industry and Commerce, sold down the river; it was all gone, there would not be any possibility four years later of getting this sort of money for it, it was all evaporated. The three principal subscribers here today, the Minister backed by Deputies Desmond and Halligan, were standing on the same platform with the Neligans and the Merrigans who were making this claim. They are still standing on the same platform and we have to listen to the allegation that we are crying crocodile tears for £9.54 million of taxpayers' money.

This debate went on yesterday morning. Talking about the agreement, I referred yesterday evening to the fact that it was clear from the interest being taken on the Government side of the House that there was the feeling of sympathy for the Minister and he played up to it with his speech about a beating to nothing. The Deputy who stayed longest in the House was his colleague, the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs, and I became convinced that that colleague was affected by the argument yesterday despite the fact that he made no contribution. At lunchtime today I found that he had arranged with RTE to put the director general of Bula, Mr. Wymes, into the programme to protect the Minister by saying: "We will call foul if the Minister proposes to disclose the terms of the agreement". The Minister directed attention a few minutes ago to the fact that we were over-flogging the definition section of the Bill. I agree that section 1, the definition section, has been discussed far more than normally but it is the first time ever in a definition section we had a description where the description is not amplified. Here we have just three definitions:

"the Company" means Bula Limited;

"the Minister" means the Minister for Industry and Commerce.

"agreement" is defined as meaning:

...the agreement dated the 12th day of December, 1975, and made between Bula Holdings, Patrick Wright, certain other parties named in the Agreement and the Minister;

This is one of the very significant omissions from the Bill. Perhaps it should be included in section 2 but I mention it here because the omission strikes me as being remarkable.

The Minister in his opening remarks in what I presume to be the explanation of the agreement, through not stated, says: "...we have also secured 25 per cent of the equity for nothing and 24 per cent on a valuation, giving us in all a 75 per cent share of the profits". We are conducting our debate here on the assumption, although we have never seen anything positive in writing, that the State—because we get mixed up with Ministers later on—is, arising from this agreement, going to have a 49 per cent share in this company. There is nothing in the Bill which says this. We of necessity have to take what the Minister says in good faith and I do not question that aspect of it. Deputy O'Malley yesterday made reference to the fact that the Minister had of necessity to tell us something about what was in the agreement and I presume that this 49 per cent is built into it.

We heard the Government side media bashing today. I am usually an expert on that. While on the subject of the media, I thought it extremely significant that the Minister's directorgeneral in relation to this business is booked specially on radio today to announce that it would be a breach of confidence for the Minister to disclose this. He was asked if he thought that was fair to the Irish people whose £9½ million was being invested and his reply was that that was a matter for the Dáil. I agree that it is and this is why we are making the battle in relation to this today.

Deputy Halligan seemed to go much further in an effort to justify this. To use the cliché and put it on the record of the House, it was interesting to hear Deputy Halligan say that non-disclosure is a strength rather than a weakness. He is a new recruit, of course, to the open Government party. He had a lot to do with getting them elected four years ago. We heard the former secretary of the Labour Party saying that proudly. I agree with him. I am not saying he was wrong. He said they are shopping around with multi-national companies. I wonder what his two colleagues who are not in the House yet have to say about that.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy agree with him?

Comment on this

Yes. The Minister said yesterday we must change and we must do something else. I have lost the quotation. I think the word was devolved. It is very difficult to have to sit here——

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

It surely is.

Comment on this

——and be refused information on what is actually happening. Yesterday the Minister gave us to understand that no financial arrangements had been made in connection with the development of this business. Today he came in to straighten that out. He said it was improper for the House to ask for details of the financial arrangements for the working of this business. I accept that. As Deputy Colley said, that is not what we want. I would draw the attention of Government backbenchers to the fact that they are subscribing to this without it being written into the Bill that we will get 49 per cent. I take the Minister's word for it, but in Parliament we should not be expected to do so. Deputy Halligan said future legislation may involve this sort of thing when the Labour Party have finished shopping around with the multi-nationals. When the State is participating and taking equity in companies such as this, the Bill should spell out the value of the shares. This Bill does not do that. For a man like Deputy Desmond to have spoken three times already on this Bill——

Comment on this

Twice.

Comment on this

——without bringing in worker participation is a bit of a slip up.

Comment on this

The Deputy is trying to kill State participation.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Listening to Fianna Fáil wailing about this Bill one would think that when in office they had done great work with regard to our mineral rights and mineral resources. The fact is that they did sweet damn all to protect the rights of the people to have their resources properly developed. I was not a Member of the House at the time of the Marathon agreement, which was of great significance, when there was a gentle signing away of the right to search and drill for oil around our coasts.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know the difference between a prospecting licence and other licences. He should get somebody to teach him.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I will leave the finer points to the Minister who is far better informed than I am. I am merely discussing the principle of that agreement where the State took no equity and no measures to ensure that the revenue accruing from that exploration and from subsequent findings of oil, if any, would go to the State for the benefit of the Irish people. The price charged for the right to explore for oil was marvellous. I am not sure whether the magnificent figure involved was £500 or something tremendous like that. I have not seen the agreement.

Comment on this

The Deputy should read that agreement some time. I brought it up from the Library a couple of years ago and read some of it to Deputy Desmond and I quietened him about it. The Deputy should read what the Leaders of the Fine Gael and Labour Parties had to say about it.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I do not recall the debate in the House on it.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Malley tends to forget I had it placed in the Library in the first instance.

Comment on this
Augustine Healy Acting Chairman (Mr. Healy) Fianna Fáil

Order. Deputy Collins without interruption.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I believe this agreement should not be discussed. Supposing other types of minerals are found in other parts of Ireland, as naturally we all hope they will, if the agreement were made public the details would be available to other commercial interests. Apart from the political aspect, commercially it would be most unwise to have an agreement of the type we are discussing today bandied around in public. It could jeopardise any future agreement. This could be extended to any future developments on the oil scene and to any future mineral finds. If this agreement were published, it would be available to very wellinformed international conglomerates and multi-nationals. This could jeopardise a Government decision in the future in dealing with multi-national companies in relation to exploration of our mineral wealth. On that basis it would be very unwise. The general tenets of the agreement have been revealed by the Minister.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Where?

Comment on this

Where have they been revealed?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

He has told the House of the capital commitment of the Government.

Comment on this

He has not. That is what we are asking him about.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

He has told the House of the equity participation of the Government. Far more important, he has established a responsible and serious attitude to the State's participation.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

That is speculation. It has still to be proven.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That is the difference between the attitude of this Government and the attitude of the Opposition who, in Government, had not the confidence in the nation's resources to suggest they should take an equity participation in our wealth. They did not have the confidence; they did not have the brains. They are now crying crocodile tears because this Government are taking an equity in our mineral wealth. We have taken the right decision in relation to this agreement. We have taken a 49 per cent equity and we will get 75 per cent of the profits.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

How does the Deputy know? Has he seen the agreement?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

If the Deputy wishes to challenge the Minister's integrity, I am sure the House would be satisfied to hear him and, if he wishes to go further, I am sure the Committee on Procedure and Privileges will be delighted to give him as good a hearing——

Comment on this

Star chamber treatment.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

——as Deputy Crinion and Deputy Molloy got. Deputies know well the outcome of that little episode.

Comment on this

If we do not stop criticising this Bill we will all be up before the star chamber. We had better be careful.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

When the Deputy mentions the star chamber I suppose he is referring in passing to the Committee of Public Accounts inquiry into the £100,000. I must say they christened that one. If the Opposition wish to refer to that committee, their party will not come out of it too well.

Comment on this

They were referring to section 1.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

I want to refer to the agreement. There are two basic principles involved under this section and one is that the Government are right to retain confidentiality in regard to the commercial agreement they are entering into in relation to mineral wealth development. Such information should not be available to people in this industry or to people who might be developing any future mineral wealth found. Secondly, this agreement is an innovation. It is a sign that the Government are confident in themselves and in our mineral resources and are prepared to put the people's money into a wise investment. I do not think Fianna Fáil have anything to gain out of their present politicking in this whole matter.

Comment on this

This debate began about 6.30 p.m. last evening and we had about a half-hour discussion on the definitions here. We discussed capitalisation and I asked a number of questions. We did not have the advantage then of all the crown princes, the would-be parliamentary secretaries, four or five of whom trotted out this evening.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Some from Finglas and some from Ballyfermot. How could one believe those fellows?

Comment on this

We had to do without the benefit of their wit and their wisdom. The debate was conducted between the Minister on one side and Deputy Colley and myself on the other. In the course of the debate I asked the Minister a number of brief questions which he tried to answer as far as he could. We came to a point when we were discussing capitalisation of the company where the Minister said he did not know in reply to a number of questions I asked, adding: "I have no brief on that". He had four officials with him but one assumes they did not know either or had not the information with them because they did not offer it to the Minister. The debate was adjourned at 7 o'clock and I had expected and hoped that when we resumed on the definition section at 3.30 p.m. this afternoon the Minister would have said that Deputy O'Malley had asked a number of questions last night which the Minister endeavoured to answer but did not have sufficient information but had since looked it up and the following are the answers. The Minister stood up all right and said he had made inquiries in the Department and found there were answers to these questions but he was not going to give them.

The two questions were: what were the arrangements about a rights issue and what was the Minister's position in regard to a rights issue? These are relevant matters which we sought to have clarified last night. It seemed to me that if the Minister had to take up 49 per cent of a rights issue he would have to take up, on figures I worked out last night and to which the Minister did not demur, about £2 million in rights. That is not allowed for in this Bill and a further Bill would therefore have to be introduced to enable rights to be taken up.

I inquired about the guarantee situation where the Minister as principal individual shareholder in the company would certainly be the most attractive guarantor from the point of view of the bank. I was told that he did not know the position in that regard. I presume he knows it now. We have now spent about one hour and 20 minutes in discussion although admittedly 95 per cent of the time went on totally different matters and did not deal with matters relevant to this section. It we could get back, now that we have had the four crown princes displaying their wares——

Comment on this

Sorry for coming in and interrupting.

Comment on this

Not at all; we were very happy. There is a great element of levity, one might say jollity, about today's debate which was quite absent yesterday when it was rather heavy and serious. Then along came the court jester from Dún Laoghaire——

Comment on this

They will apply the Official Secrets Act to you if you are not careful.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

They cannot do that because integrity does not matter where he is concerned.

Comment on this

These are the questions that Deputy Colley and I posed last night. They relate entirely to the capitalisation of the company and it is quite ridiculous for the Minister or anybody behind him to suggest that to disclose the capitalisation of a company will give commercial competitors an advantage or that it will inhibit the borrowing powers or ability of the company which I think was what the Minister said at one stage.

Comment on this

The lenders will certainly have to see the information if we do not.

Comment on this

Does the Minister or those behind him have the faintest idea of what is involved? If you go to a bank or group of banks for longterm finance to open a mine and put it into production is not the first question the banks will ask: "What is your capitalisation? Have you a capitalisation plan? Have you any money subscribed in cash in respect of your equities?" Of course, in this case the answer is: "No, we have no money subscribed in cash. We have 9,998 shares issued for consideration other than cash. We have no cash. We owe large amounts that appear on the registrar of charges in the Companies Office and they appear to be very substantial amounts. Everything we have is mortgaged. But we have a capitalisation plan."

The Minister seemed to suggest last night that there was no plan. That surprised me because as reported in the Official Report of 2nd February, 1977, at column 721, when the Minister was going through the 20 propositions I put to him he came to number nine and said:

...The next point, that no capitalisation plan exists, is untrue.

Comment on this

Where is it?

Comment on this

A capitalisation plan has been submitted to my Department. It exists and we have received it.

Comment on this

When was it submitted?

Then he went on to the next one. We had that kind of not very useful debate. Although on 2nd February he avowed the existence of this capitalisation plan he did not seem to know anything about it last night. He now says there is a plan but that we will not get any details. But the public and the Deputies are entitled to know if the Minister is going to subscribe to rights. Perhaps I should explain for the benefit of some of those opposite what rights are because they probably do not know but that would not inhibit them from pontificating on this matter. If a company wants to raise additional equity capital or, in this case, if it wants to raise any cash at all—it has no cash, only shares issued for consideration other than cash—it has to go back under a rights issue to its existing shareholders and ask them to contribute cash on an agreed basis. Shareholders normally contribute so much per share in accordance with the proportion of shares they have. This means that the Minister in this case would have to contribute 49 per cent. I have suggested that the figure would be about £4 million which would leave the public subscribing a further £2 million.

We have no answer on that yet and we have no answer about the guarantee. The Minister will be expected to guarantee at least half of the bank borrowings which it appears would have to be about £30 million at the least and probably more. That would leave public liability in that respect at £15 million in round figures. Add that to the £9.5 million in this Bill and to the £2 million under the rights issue and you get about £26.5 million approximately of potential public liability in respect of this matter.

It is wise to go back to first principles: this is a private company in which the State is risking all its capital in order to acquire a maximum of 49 per cent of the shares. It has no say in the running of the company and cannot ensure that the company ever goes into production. In order to get itself into that situation, it has not invested one penny in our natural resources but it has handed £9.54 million tax-free to four individuals. This is the great investment in our natural resources that Deputy Collins, Deputy Desmond and the others become so eloquent and proud about. These four individuals are in the happy position that they have £9.54 million in their pockets and they still control the company. This is incredible but it is true. They still decide whether or not the company will ever go into production. They may say: "We are up more than £2 million per head and we see no point in undertaking all the trouble and worry about planning permissions, taking on staff, having strikes and breakdowns of machinery, borrowing money and all the trauma involved in opening a new mine particularly for people who were never before involved in it and we will not bother going ahead." I hope they do not say that but one must accept the possibility of such a decision. If they were to say that there is nothing the Minister can do about it——

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Let us talk about the 40 ministerial orders your Government brought in.

Comment on this

——because the Minister for Industry and Commerce at that time, whoever he may be, will be in the position that £9.54 million will not have been invested in our natural resources but will have been given to four individuals tax-free. If they were able to manoeuvre a Minister into that situation they must have some ability. They must certainly be good businessmen if they could get that money from the Minister and still retain him in a minority situation. They have some negotiating and commercial ability. It may not lie in the mining field. The present Minister or possibly myself, or whoever may be next Minister for Industry and Commerce will have to sit there with a 49 per cent share and say that a lot of money was paid for those bits of paper but the directors of Bula have now decided to postpone production indefinitely until world markets improve, or something like that. In the meantime, the minimum outlay of £9.54 million is useless; it is gone; it is not invested in the mine or in the company. It is not invested in natural resources. It is gone under the worst deal that any Minister in our history has ever done and I think nobody can seriously dispute that because nobody with the faintest commercial sense would pay £9.54 million particularly out of public money and still end up in a minority with no control, no say and no voice.

Arising out of that situation, I asked certain questions about capitalisation of the company which had no bearing on commercial opponents. It does not matter to them how the company is capitalised. It has nothing to do with the operation of selling their product or anything else. The only reason the Minister could give after a great deal of pressure from Deputy Colley—first we discussed this yesterday and it finally came down after three or four efforts by Deputy Colley to asking not in relation to this company but in relation to any company, how any harm could come to the company by a disclosure of capitalisation—was that it would weaken their borrowing position. The banks from whom they would borrow should know their capitalisation. Is that not the first question the banks would ask? "What is your equity? How much is actually paid up in cash? What is your position vis-á-vis a rights issue if we say that before we will lend to you, you will need more capitalisation? Will you refuse to take up your right?”

Comment on this

The Deputy will tell me next that every private company must be fully open for investigation by everybody.

Comment on this

That is what the Labour Party say if Deputy Esmonde is not aware.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Malley, without interruption.

Comment on this

Is the Minister proposing to invest?

Comment on this

These simple questions were asked last night. In fairness to the Minister he tried to answer similar questions last night but when we came to these he said they were very technical and detailed and he just did not know. I got the impression, perhaps falsely, that if he did know we would have been told. That is why I was happy the section was not completed last night because it gave him an opportunity to find out and no doubt he has done that. But perhaps he has not; perhaps there is no decision on these matters. He does know whether the State will have to take up further shares through a rights issue. Perhaps no decision has been made on it. Perhaps he does not know what the situation will be in regard to guarantees. If that is so, he should tell us that no decisions have been made by the Government or the Department in relation to those matters. This has nothing to do with commercial operations. It is simply an attempt to assess what the potential full liability of the taxpayer will be in relation to this ill-fated and unhappy purchase.

Comment on this

Once again one sees Deputy O'Malley playing postman's knock for other commercial interests. It is getting less impressive as the days pass. It started out with the ministerial order which should have been renewed because the first one was defective. Then he went on to the fact that from his investment analysis of the situation the bargain was not a good deal anyway. Such was the comprehensive details of his equity investment analysis. Yesterday it finished up being unconstitutional. Today we are back in the same merrygo-round again. I think this House is being subjected to the spectacle of a lecture from somebody who cannot even select a good stockbroker. We have had a dose of a lecture in that regard. I hope that some day the Deputy will be Minister for Industry and Commerce because it would be with a sense of great irony that Deputies would put to him the disclosure of, say, agreements reached between An Bord Gáis and individual companies in relation, possibly, to offshore gas exploration.

Comment on this

In relation to initial investment. I guarantee to the Deputy that under a Fianna Fáil Government no information concerning the initial investment by the State in any such company will be concealed.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That is the nail in your coffin so far as private enterprise in this country is concerned. I am glad you have said it.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy know that if it is a public company they are obliged to publish the information?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Why then did Fianna Fáil bring in the legislation dealing with minerals exploration and development in 1941?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot have proper debate by question and answer and interrogation of this kind.

Comment on this

Let us pinpoint the touching selectivity of Fianna Fáil on this matter. Deputy Halligan rightly went back to the Potez days and indeed we had enough of that I well remember the late Seán Dunne taunting the Government of the day in relation to their most amazing secrecy at that time. Of course, this was a private French company for a while and details could not be disclosed. We built the wings of jet aircraft in a premises which is now, ironically, owned by a company which we have been discussing here today. History has a peculiar way of repeating itself, particularly in the context of the Fianna Fáil operations.

Comment on this

I do not think the Deputy realises the real irony of what he is talking about, that that particular company had State participation and disclosed full details of it.

Comment on this

We can get on to that. I drew a number of analogies without any great difficulty, whether it is NET in relation to its particular contracts with private companies or the ESB and its contracts with private companies. Deputy Colley often sanctioned under the public capital programme the relationship between the post office and private companies. When I was only 18 years of age and worked for a metal fabrication company in Cork city before I joined——

Comment on this

Is it relevant where or for whom he worked when he was 18?

Comment on this

I think one should go right back to the foundation of the IDA and that exercise will be done. I have not the slightest doubt about it because it will be a very interesting exercise in terms of the dramatic about-turn of the Fianna Fáil Party in relation to a mixed economy in which the State is entitled to have fundamental rights regarding the confidentiality of its affairs. This would be completely wiped out by Fianna Fáil by initiation of a new principle here under the rule of debate. It will be marked not merely by the Confederation of Irish Industry but by many public and private entrepreneurs in relation to any future dealings under a Fianna Fáil regime.

Comment on this

The smokescreen is a bit thin.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce has instructed Deputy Esmonde to speak next.

Comment on this

Therefore, I will conclude my intervention in this matter by suggesting that Deputy Colley should go on one of those longterm IMI refresher courses.

Comment on this

I do not need to. I have the Deputy to tell me everything.

Comment on this

He has the gall to come in here and suggest that all the Minister has to do is to release the initial agreement in relation to capital investment. Deputy Colley must think that the Minister is the greatest sucker in the world and that he will disclose this information to any multinational company or finance house, either here or abroad, which might have an interest in future investment in the mining industry here.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot be serious. Even he could not mean that.

Comment on this

Of course the Minister is comforted by Deputy Colley saying that he does not want any disclosure of the day-to-day operations of such an undertaking. He says that naturally that would remain within the ambit of the agreement.

Comment on this

As it always has.

Comment on this

But he does want total out-pouring in relation to any, for example, State opinions or other view points——

Comment on this