We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Bula Limited (Acquisition of Shares) Bill, 1977: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 146–293 of 293. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Bula Limited (Acquisition of Shares) Bill, 1977
Enacted

No. 2 of 1977 ›

We are asking for the details of the initial investment. We want to know what is in the agreement, what is in this section.

Comment on this

Which means in effect disclosure of the agreement.

Comment on this

And why not? What is in it that will damage the company?

Comment on this

The question I have repeatedly posed is: what do you really want?

Comment on this

The details of the agreement or the reason why it should not be disclosed.

Comment on this

Deputy Colley knows perfectly well from his ministerial involvement in Cabinet affairs and particularly his involvement with the Department of Finance that no sooner would this agreement be disclosed than you would flush down the toilet of this country the prospect of future State investment with private enterprise in a mixed economy on a joint venture basis.

Comment on this

The Deputy is talking nonsense.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I charge the Deputies opposite with a malicious effort to undermine and destroy the prospect of State joint venture agreements within the context of a mixed economy.

Comment on this

By disclosing details of the State's investments?

Comment on this

What is sauce for the private enterprise gander will be sauce for the State enterprise goose so long as a mixed economy situation operates. We are not going to tie our hands behind our backs in terms of State involvement and investment in the manner which Fianna Fáil suggest.

Comment on this

Was it the goose or the gander that laid the golden egg?

Comment on this

I charge you as front benchers of a so-called responsible Opposition to declare your interest.

Comment on this

Let the Minister declare his interest.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order. If Deputy Crowley wishes to intervene he should do so in an orderly way.

Comment on this

The Minister has a public interest and if the Deputy wishes to elaborate on any other interest he is free to do so and we can thrash out the matter at the Committee of Public Accounts.

Comment on this

We will do it here.

Comment on this

Lest anybody may be shy of that issue here, I was one of the Deputies who inside and outside this House stated that Members of this House who have share-holdings in any private or public company in excess of a given amount—the amount I had in mind at the time was in the region of £1,000—should have these investments recorded in a register in this House so that when Members stand up to speak they do not have to declare their past, present or future interests. Let those in Opposition who are so magnificently lily white——

Comment on this

Do the Deputy's colleagues agree?

Comment on this

The Deputy was advised not to proceed with this.

Comment on this

My colleagues on the Committee of Procedure and Privileges agreed with me.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us get back to the section.

Comment on this

I would have the greatest pleasure in tabling a motion for the next meeting of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges and I have no doubt that, as at previous meetings, some of the Fianna Fáil people, including some of the front bench members, will oppose it.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

On a point of order, could I ask Deputy Desmond to state when our side of the House opposed any motion at the Committee on Procedure and Privileges?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

What the Deputy says is not true.

Comment on this

On a point of order, you are the Chairman of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges and I understand that the proceedings of that committee are confidential.

Comment on this

That rule never applied to Deputy Desmond. He was always leaking things to the Press.

Comment on this

I thought this was the age of disclosure.

Comment on this

The Deputy should get back to the section. He will be safer on that even though he knows nothing about it.

Comment on this

The Opposition cannot have it both ways. They want the State to disclose their interest but Members cannot disclose their private interests. This contradiction in the Opposition, a republican party, amuses me.

Comment on this

Bring the motion to the House.

Comment on this

Would you support such a motion?

Comment on this

Bring the motion in with the support of Fine Gael and Labour and then we shall see——

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Ní féidir leis an ngobadán an dá thrá do fhreastail.

Comment on this

This frenzied concern of the Opposition for the total disclosure by the Minister of the capitalisation of the company on a joint basis under the agreement with Bula Limited is, to say the least, suspect. It is suspect because the Fianna Fáil Party cannot get rid of the ideological blockage from which they are still suffering in relation to companies who happen to have, under our Constitution, the private ownership of resources of gas and minerals. The Opposition have had four years of advance warning of the intention of the State to change that situation dramatically, and now, as a last gasp, they want to destroy the prospect of future international investment in this country so that companies who want to join in a venture with the State would have to disclose the whole capital outlay and capitalisation of such a joint venture for every scavenger, public and private, to proceed to make a fast buck on the situation. It is significant that a man who has a wiser financial head than the rest of the party put together, Deputy Haughey, has not expressed approval of the strategy being followed by his party in this matter. I doubt very much that Deputy Haughey would approve——

Comment on this

Wholeheartedly

Comment on this

As on all matters, Deputy Haughey is wholehearted but his real opinion is carefully cloaked, and his silence in the benches over there is quite significant. The Opposition know the change in Government policy. They know the determination of the Government——

Comment on this

To conceal the facts.

Comment on this

——to carry out this policy, which has the full support of the Labour Party, for greater investment in ventures of this nature. The longer this debate goes on the clearer it will become to the public and to business people——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Expressions like "riff raff" should not be used in respect of Members of this House.

Comment on this

A cursory examination of the record of Fianna Fáil in relation to any State-sponsored body or in relation to agreements with private companies will show that they tried to stand the principles, which they supposedly upheld, on their heads. They are now doing a bad day's work for future joint-venture investment in this country.

The level of the debate was reduced to an all-time low by Deputy O'Malley and he made one of the worst speeches in the 20th Dáil, with due respect to the parliamentary correspondent of the Irish Independent, in his introduction to this matter, because it had not a shred of factual evidence to substantiate the global assertions he made with gay abandon, ranging from £7½ million to £290 million. Of course one can disagree with one's colleague either in the House or through the media; it is part of Irish life, and one does not need to be nasty about it. One can have a difference of opinion with the Minister of the day. The attitude of a Minister for Posts and Telegraphs and a Minister for Justice in a previous Administration surprised me. I am sure they had many tenders before them from private companies in relation to the supply of materials for their Department and had to make up their minds on an interdepartmental basis with the Department of Finance which tender should be accepted in the national interest, the details of which would very often not be disclosed to the House. One would have thought that these two former Ministers of the Fianna Fáil Party would have exercised more wit in relation to this fundamental issue. If I had £20 million for investment in this country I would make sure I would not be coming over here to negotiate with a Fianna Fáil Minister for Industry and Commerce, bearing in mind that if the State put in another £10 million, three months later I would be screwed right left and centre by the publication of the details involved. Whether it was with CIE, ESB, Aer Lingus or any other of our companies deeply involved in public capital expenditure, not one industrialist would trust the Fianna Fáil Part in relation to an agreement because the precedent they are trying to breach here would have a scuttling effect on investment. It is a deliberate effort on the part of the Fianna Fáil Party to write down whatever value Bula may have, so that another company, well known, immediately close to it, can move in and buy out at a chickenfeed price. That is the real effort behind the scenario.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

I put it to Deputy O'Malley that the scenario which was favoured by that company not so long ago as to how it would campaign to destroy the State's intent to invest in Bula——

Comment on this

Which company?

Comment on this

Tara. I put it to the Deputy that that scenario is being enacted here with a particular appropriateness, vindictiveness and accuracy which in the national interest——

Comment on this

If there was a majority shareholding on the part of the State, the Deputy would sound more convincing.

Comment on this

If the State were to take a majority investment in Bula, the Deputies opposite would come in here withing and saying that the Labour Party Policy had been yielded to totally by Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Is it a question of Labour, 51 and Fine Gael, 49?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The analogy is very interesting. If we had succeeded in obtaining a majority shareholding, Fianna Fáil would have issued a joint statement, probably with Tara, to the effect that the country had gone into a rampant socialist escapade in terms of State investment. But the situation is unpalatable for Fianna Fáil even with a 49 per cent shareholding just as it would be unpalatable for them if the ratio were 42 or 25. This attitude can be described only as the royalties razzamatazz of the Fianna Fáil front bench. Even that is so discredited now that they are changing feet and are suggesting that the Bill be sent to the President so as to elicit his opinion in regard to State investment on a joint venture basis.

Comment on this

Even for an ass like Deputy Desmond, that is a classic.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Malley knows well that in effect he is presuming to advice the President in relation to matters pertaining to the Constitution.

Comment on this

This should go into the Guinness Book of Records.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Where is the Deputy performing this evening?

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil would be wise at this juncture to stick to one objection. It is not possible for them on the one hand to have a defective order which they wish to have renewed while on the other hand to send legislation to the President on grounds of its compliance with the Constitution in the hope that from his past ministerial experience he may remember an analysis on a question of constitutionality. On the other hand, the legislation cannot be sent back to private enterprise in order to get the information that Fianna Fáil seek. That party would be wise to make up their mind on where exactly they wish to go in relation to this legislation.

Comment on this

We shall go whereever the Deputy would like us to go.

Comment on this

On such a matter I would make up my own mind rather than go to a defunct stockbroker.

Comment on this

What kind of stockbroked is that?

Comment on this

Incidentally, I do not have recourse to a stockbroker but if I needed the sort of advice that these people supply I would not go to a Fianna Fáil source to ascertain it because I know that I would receive sounder advice from this side of the House.

Comment on this

I suppose the Deputy will tell us shortly that we are filibustering.

Comment on this

If Fianna Fáil wish to filibuster in relation to the Bill, the longer the debate will continue and, consequently, the more will they be discredited.

Comment on this

If the Deputy were a trout, he would be dead long ago because he would rise to every fly.

Comment on this

The longer the debate goes on the more discredited will Fianna Fáil become in relation to their real intention in regard to the national interest and the more obvious will be their policy in relation to this country.

Comment on this

That is a remarkable contribution.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Having regard to Fianna Fáil track record in this area, one can place no credence in what they are saying. When they enacted legislation on various occasions to deal with situations similar to the one we are discussing here, they did not allow for or insist on provision for the publication of the agreements concerned. There is no point in Deputy O'Malley speaking when he does not know what he is talking about. There is no provision, for example, in the Minerals Exploration and Development Company Act, 1941 in relation to the publication of any such agreements.

Comment on this

Which agreement is referred to in that Act?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

May we hear the Deputy, without interruption?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Fianna Fáil's track record leaves them very flat.

Comment on this

Tell us about the next Act?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

There was the Industrial Development Act, 1969.

Comment on this

Which agreement is referred to in that Act?

Comment on this

Was there no agreement in respect of that Act?

Comment on this

If there was an agreement, there was no prohibition on its disclosure.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

No Fianna Fáil Minister ever refused to disclose such information.

Comment on this

There is no prohibition in that regard in this Bill, either.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

This new-found open philosophy on the part of Fianna Fáil is interesting. In the Acts I have mentioned there was no insistence regarding the publication of agreements.

Comment on this

To which agreements is the Deputy referring? Perhaps he would read them for us.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Perhaps we could hear the Deputy.

Comment on this

Where, in any of the Acts referred to by the Deputy, is there provision of the kind that is concerning us here?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

If the contribution made by Deputy O'Malley had come from a person not versed in legal and company matters, it might have had some credibility but anyone who has anything to do with a company must know that it is not possible to change the structure of the equity of a company other than by way of special resolution and that is not done by a simple majority. In other words, the Deputy is talking through his hat.

Comment on this

Perhaps Deputy Collins would develop that remark.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Obviously, the Deputy is not familiar with the Companies Act which provides that equity issue cannot be changed by simple majority.

Comment on this

So what?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

In his last contribution the Deputy implied that the situation is otherwise.

Comment on this

In what way did he imply that?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Let the interruptions cease.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

In any event, even if share capital could be changed surely the so-concerned Opposition should be happy that the Minister would revert to the House in relation to the matter. Deputy O'Malley is arguing simply for the sake of argument.

Mr. Esmonde rose.

Comment on this

On a point of order, you will recall that at about 3.40 p.m. the Minister complained of people speaking on matters that were not relevant to the very confined provisions of this definition section. Are we to assume that there has been a change of policy on his part or on the part of the Government and that there is now a concerted effort to keep the Bill going for as long as possible? If that is so, perhaps, we could be told the reason for this change.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is hardly a point of order.

Comment on this
Garrett Fitzgerald Mr. G. Fitzgerald Fine Gael

Are we to take the silence from the other side as an indication of an answer in the affirmative?

Comment on this

Has the change been caused by Whipping problems?

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

There are no problems. We simply disregard ignorant contributions.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair would wish the debate to continue in an orderly fashion.

Comment on this

Any time the Opposition would like a vote we shall be pleased to accommodate them.

Comment on this

Why are the people opposite holding up the Bill?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. I am calling Deputy Esmonde.

Comment on this

I am glad that this debate has gone on for so long on this section because Deputy Colley dropped a political and economic bombshell in the last quarter of an hour when he stated that: "We in Fianna Fáil will disclose agreements between the State and companies who are taking State money."

Comment on this

Will the Deputy stop there for a moment? Since the Deputy is apparently attaching some importance to this, he will appreciate that he should quote me accurately. What I said was that Fianna Fáil will never refuse to disclose the details of State investment as such in companies.

Comment on this

I take it that that is the same. If a question is asked in the House——

Comment on this

It is quite different from agreements.

Comment on this

I am trying to get this clear.

Comment on this

I have been trying to point this out all day to the Deputies. Do they not understand it?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order. Let us hear the Deputy in possession. If other Deputies have a point of view, they will be afforded an opportunity in orderly fashion. Deputy Esmonde without interruption. Deputy Esmonde might avoid interruption if the Deputy would speak through the Chair rather than to any Member of the House.

Comment on this

This is a very important matter. Do I understand that Deputy Colley means that if I am in opposition and he is Minister if I ask a parliamentary question for details of the agreement and the financial transactions that take place between the Government be it through the IDA or otherwise full details will be given in the House?

Comment on this

In so far as the agreement relates to the investment by the State the answer is yes. That is what I have been saying all along and that is what we are assured this agreement is about and that is why it should be disclosed.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order.

Comment on this

This has very serious implications for anybody in business in this country. I hope a great deal of publicity will be given to Deputy Colley's answer in the House this evening.

Comment on this

I hope so. It will show exactly what has happened.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order.

Comment on this

It is a shattering statement for anybody in the private sector of business in this country who receives State investment in their company.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy elaborate?

Comment on this

It means that people will be afraid to take State money if Fianna Fáil happens to be the Government of the day.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, order.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not know it is happening all the time and it is disclosed all the time?

Comment on this

Deputy Colley is saying that he is prepared to disclose the domestic circumstances of a company because the State happens to have an investment in it.

Comment on this

The details of the State's investment not the agreement.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Please let the interruptions cease.

Comment on this

The agreement only in so far as it relates to the State's investment. If the agreement here covers more than the State's investment, we should be told so. I said all along that my remarks were based on the assumption that that is all it relates to.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I beg the Deputies to yield to me on this. I beg them not to pursue this line of debate because whether it is I, or whether it is another Minister for Industry and Commerce from any of the three parties, what the Deputies are doing with this line of debate is severely damaging the work of the IDA and our efforts to promote industrial investment in this country.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I would ask Deputies on both sides not to go on with this line because they are damaging the work of our industrial development in this country.

Comment on this

I did more work for the IDA than the Minister ever did and with more effect.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The Minister is just trying to cover up whatever is in that agreement. The Minister is determined to cover it up.

Comment on this

It is the biggest cover up job since Watergate.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am putting the question.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 61
·
Níl 55
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 2, subsection (1), line 18, after "acquire" to insert ", after full and final planning permission has been obtained for a partly open-cast lead/zinc mine at Nevinstown, Navan, County Meath, by the Company".

The purpose of this amendment is to make the purchase of these shares conditional on full and final planning permission being obtained. The purpose of trying to ensure there is planning permission—in the financial context of this whole operation viable planning permission not subject to conditions which are onerous or expensive—is because, without knowing what the conditions are, and obviously there will be conditions, one cannot know the cost of establishing or the cost of running the mine because there are matters entirely dependent on the conditions of the permission. We have been informed that an application was made last August to the Meath County Council. It is disturbing to find that it was only in August, 1976, that application was made because the Government have apparently owned this property since some time in 1971 and it has taken over five years to make application for planning permission. The Minister came to his agreement regarding the purchase of shares and the obtaining of other shares free in June, 1974, although the agreement was not formally signed until December, 1975.

Planning permission, the most necessary single step in the whole process of trying to put this mine into production and create employment, was only put in train 2 ¼ years after the Minister became involved in the shareholding of the company. We are, of course, fortunate enough to have minerals like this in the country. This is the first time a rich orebody has been found but to my mind there has been a quite extraordinary delay on the part of the company in seeking planning permission. The application was put in in August, 1976, and one learned it was not making much progress and the most important single environmental factor that should have been in the planning application was not in it at all. I refer to the diversion of the River Blackwater which is pretty well essential for economic development. One can assume that Meath County Council would hardly have looked very favourably on a planning application that omitted the most significant aspect of the whole operation. Since then we have learned in more detail what the attitude of the Meath County Council is in relation to this planning application. Unfortunately, from the point of view of the public, if this Bill goes through, as presumably it will by virtue of numbers, if nothing else, we have since discovered that the situation is in fact a great deal more serious than we might have thought. I will quote now from an article in last Sunday's Independent written by Mr. Vincent Browne. I might add that there has been no denial from Meath County Council of anything in this article so I assume it is accurate. The article states:

Serious difficulties have also emerged this weekend about planning permission for the development of the mine. An official of Meath County Council said that on the basis of the present planning application there was "no chance" that planning permission would be given.

Later on, the writer says:

On the issue of the planning application, Bula Ltd. first submitted an application last August, but this was returned to the company in October because information accompanying it was inadequate.

The county council "in returning the application asked 32 question mainly related to noise, dust, environmental and health aspects, but most of these questions were unanswered when the planning application was re-submitted on December 21, last".

The article goes on:

This weekend the planning application has again been returned to Bula, without even formal consideration of it by the Meath County Council. Bula would certainly appeal to the Planning Appeals Tribunal recently established, if Meath County Council ultimately rejects its application. Since the setting up of the tribunal, there is considerably less scope for political interference with planning permissions. It cannot be taken for granted, therefore, that even ultimately Bula will get the planning permission.

It also emerges that Bula has made no application for the diversion of the river Blackwater, under which much of the ore in the area is situated. Lack of information on this, and on other critical aspects of the project, is one of the reasons why there is such disappointment in the Meath County Council with the Bula application.

That appears to me to be a vital statement of the current position in relation to the planning application from the point of view of bringing this orebody to the point where the mine might be able to go into production. Planning permission was not sought for more than five years after the company purchased the property and for more that two years after the Minister became involve through the medium of the agreement he came to in June, 1974. These delays are very distressing and the likelihood of early planning permission seems far from hopeful.

Thirty-two specific queries were apparently raised by the county council and after an interval of some months a lot of those were not even answered when the planning application was re-submitted to the local authority. The position as of last weekend was that there was not even formal consideration given to the latest re-submission because it was apparently so incomplete and the queries not dealt with and it was sent back to the company. So we are in every sense back at square one and no more advanced in regard to the planning application than we were in August, 1976, when it was first submitted or indeed in June, 1974, when the Minister first became involved.

One aspect of this application is that it seeks permission for the mining of the Bula part of the ore in this orebody partly by open-cast mining. Roughly speaking, the percentages or ratios are that they want to get out about 50 per cent by open-cast mining and 50 per cent approximately by ordinary conventional underground mining. It is necessary to consider for a few minutes the nature of open-cast mining because we have not had it in this country on a big scale. We have had it on a limited scale. In recent years the Gortdrum mine was partly, to a limited extent, an opencast mine; but the Gortdrum mine was situate quite some distance from any town. The nearest town to it of any size would have been Tipperary town. I cannot say exactly how far away it was but it was certainly several miles and there was no great accumulation of houses in the vicinity of that mine. Any other opencast or partly open-cast mine that we have had in this country would have been in the fairly distant past or just a sort of quarrying operation where minerals were not really involved, but just stone, and these have tended to be away from centres of population. On the world scene opencast lead and zinc mines are not unknown but they tend because of environmental factors to be confined to more remote parts of the world.

In this instance of this orebody a small part of it at the Bula end comes up to or very close to the surface before it starts to go down at an angle under the river and continue downwards or in a roughly downward direction for quite a distance on the other side of the river. It is unfortunate that that part of it is at or near the surface and that that circumstance is combined with its extreme proximity to the town of Navan. If this mine were situate at a more remote place it would be an enormous advantage to have it in this way with one end of the seam or orebody coming up to or close to the surface. It is unfortunate that an orebody such as this should have turned up in the place that it did, so close to a fairly large town. It appears that in the last five or ten years a lot of new houses have been built in the general vicinity of this orebody and in general the orebody is within half a mile of the town of Navan which is only a short distance in environmental terms when one takes into account the nature of an open-cast mine.

An application to have the Bula ore mined partly by open-cast and partly by underground methods is based on the provisional mining plan prepared by the Canadian subsidiary of Bechtel on behalf of Bula and submitted to the arbitrators and to the local authority. Bechtel apparently take the view that the more open-cast mining that can be done on this orebody the better because it will make the mine or the Bula part of it more profitable. The difference in cost of extraction and concentration of the two methods of mining is estimated at various sums. The best advice I can get in respect of that is that it would appear to be a difference of £4 a ton in production and concentration of the ore; that of course is a significant difference if one accepts the output of the Bula part of the orebody as being approximately a million tons of ore a year. That will mean a difference in running costs of £4 million a year approximately if one were forced into an underground situation rather than an open-cast mine. It is obvious, therefore, that Bula and their advisers would, very properly in the interests of the company, presumably be supported in this by the Minister in seeking to have as much as possible mined by open-cast methods.

An open-cast mine has to be opened by machinery and explosives. The quicker it is opened the more commercially advantageous it is. Therefore, having got your permission, you could open it by working 24 hours a day, seven days a week and so you would cut your costs and bring your mine into production much more rapidly. In doing that you would keep down your capital expenditure.

There will obviously be enormous, perfectly understandable, objections in the locality to work going on there on the opening of an open-cast mine and subsequently on the mining of the ore from it on a 24-hour-day basis or anything even remotely like that. It will presumably be the wish of the local residents, if open-cast mining is to be used there at all, to have it confined to ordinary eight to five or eight to six working hours when people, particularly children, would not be expected to be asleep normally. The county council will be very strongly pressed by objectors and local residents that, if they are going to give permission at all for open-cast mining, they confine the hours of the operation, and presumably also the mode of the operation of opening the pit and mining from it; and that the machinery and explosives appropriate to the opening of an open-cast mine in the middle of the Australian desert or some such place would not be at all appropriate to the edge of the town of Navan and that less efficient but environmentally more acceptable methods would have to be used.

If the local authority listen to these views and accede to them—and one can scarcely envisage how they could refuse to do so—the costings of this proposed mine will be considerably higher than have been envisaged by those who made valuation bets on the Bechtel report. Of course those who made valuations based on the Bechtel report were not confined by any means to Bula's economists or Bula's financial advisers. The Minister did not have any detailed examination of the production plan of the mine carried out on his behalf and he simply used the Bechtel report and the other documents submitted by Bula to the arbitrators, copies of which were sent to him and these documents in turn were submitted by him to his various advisers, such as the Geological Survey, Lazard Brothers and Company Ltd., Mergers Ltd., and the other people who advised the Department from time to time in regard to the valuation, the feasibility and the likely cost of this project.

It would appear from what we now know that Lazard Brothers were very concerned, and very properly so, about the planning and environmental aspects of the proposed operation. Although they had only six weeks to do a job which obviously would need many times that to do it as thoroughly as they would wish, in that period of six weeks they commissioned one of the leading firms of town planning consultants in Ireland, the name of which I understand is Delaney, McVeigh and Pike to advise them on the planning and environmental considerations involved.

One understands that Mr. Delaney of that firm, one of the principal partners, in advising Lazard, who in turn passed on the advice to the Department, expressed grave reservations about the planning aspects generally, and expressed great fear about delays, and set out what he felt was likely to be a timetable. He felt there would be considerable delay. By virtue of the lack of progress of the application to Meath County Council for the reasons I mentioned earlier, it would appear that Mr. Delaney's timetable has been set back perhaps another four, five or six months, and that it could be late in 1978 before one would finally be in a position to know where one stood in regard to planning.

All this presupposes that planning permission in some form will be given eventually. I do not think one is entitled to presuppose that. Many people take the view that it is unrealistic to talk about the possibility of planning permission not being granted because there is a Minister involved. While that may be a popular way of looking at it, I do not think it is fair to the local authority concerned, who will look at the matter objectively whether or not a Minister is involved. Although I do not know anything about them. I hope the new planning board, with some experienced officials and some other members who I understand on the admission of their patron have no experience whatever in this field, will be equally objective, and one trusts they will, in their consideration of this matter.

Obviously this is one of the most involved planning applications made to any local authority since our new form of planning came into operation in 1964 under the 1963 Act. The appeal, if there is one, and there almost certainly will be either by Bula if they are turned down by the local authority or by the objectors if permission is given, will be a very lengthy process. One would expect An Taisce to become involved as well as the local residents. There will probably be an enormous amount of evidence given and technical evidence from various parts of the world will be called and 300 or 400 individual householders or house owners may wish to come along to voice their objections.

Therefore, it is very likely to be up to two years from now before what I describe in this amendment as full and final planning permission is granted. An enormous number of things could well happen in that very long period, whether it is nearly two years, as has been suggested, or whether it is a shorter period of one year, or a year and a quarter. Certainly it will be a very long period by any normal standards. An enormous number of things can happen in the meantime. An enormous number of factors which are imponderables at present may clarify themselves in one way or another.

If some of these imponderables and, in particular, if the planning imponderables clarify themselves in a way which is seriously detrimental to the company, is not the position of the taxpayer, who is ultimately carrying the can for the Minister in regard to this whole affair, seriously jeopardised? Should not the Minister wait until he knows where he stands in relation to planning before he commits himself and the taxpayer to the money mentioned here and to the potential further payments which may have to be made, and probably will have to be made, as a result of the undercapitalisation of the company and the necessity for giving guarantees, and so on?

Would not any prudent businessman make perfectly sure that he would not expend a £5 note on a project of this kind which was obviously going to be the subject of enormous objection at the two levels of the planning process? Would not a man of even the most moderate prudence decline to become involved until the planning situation had clarified itself? It might be—although I think it unlikely— that Bula will get a fairly straightforward planning permission with some slight or what would be from their point of view very reasonable restrictions on their mode of working and the amount of work they could do in opening an open-cast mine and mining from it.

On the other hand, it is very likely that planning permission could be granted subject to conditions which Bula or anyone else who owned an orebody they wanted to mine on the edge of a town by open cast mining would find very onerous in the financial sense to comply with? Is it not perfectly conceivable in this instance that the conditions might be such, because of the nature of open cast lead and zinc mining, that the company in their commercial financial wisdom might decide it was too expensive to go ahead and that to comply with all those conditions would add millions of pounds and perhaps even tens of millions of pounds to the capital and running costs of the company? Therefore they would decide as a matter of prudence not to go ahead with opencast mining and to think again about opening an underground mine to which one would assume there would be no significant or serious objection.

The whole costing situation is then thrown into the melting pot if that happens. I have been talking only about the things which might happen on the positive side. I have been assuming all along that permission will actually be given. Are we entitled blandly to make that assumption? The public are making it because a Minister is involved but, as I said, that is not sufficient reason for making it. We are not entitled to assume that, even subject to onerous conditions, permission will be given. It is quite conceivable that it will be refused.

I understand that in the past few weeks An Taisce have issued a public statement to the effect that this part of the orebody could be mined underground and, if that were done, there would be very little environmental or other harm caused in the locality. There would be no noise, or very little noise. The noise would be quite negligible. There would be no dust because everything would be underground. There would be no muck or dirt because all the work would be going on underground. There would be no danger to health from lead concentrate or zinc concentrate which I think is less dangerous but, nonetheless, contains some danger to health if inhaled in large quantities.

All these problems would be avoided by underground mining but the cost to the company would be significantly more. It might be that the local authority and/or the appeals tribunal to whom the inevitable appeal would be brought in this case by one side or the other would say: "O.K. We accept the company's case that it would cost them a great deal more, millions and millions of pounds more, to operate an underground mine. It appears to be technically feasible, at any rate, and even though it will cost millions and millions of pounds more, the harm to the environment caused by an opencast mine in this place would be so great that we cannot see our way to give permission for it." That is on the cards. I do not say it will happen but it is certainly a possibility to which one would have to give very serious consideration.

The House should look at this question, not from the point of view of the Minister who is committing and has committed himself with his eyes closed —this was long ago in June, 1974— but from the point of view of a prudent and successful businessman, a man like yourself, Mr. Chairman. Would any prudent and successful businessman commit more than £9.5 million into a venture such as this where the planning and environmental difficulties are enormous, probably greater than in the case of any other single planning application since 1964? There is only one possible answer and that is that no prudent businessman would do it. If a prudent businessman would not commit himself to spending this money whether he got planning permission or not—which is what this amounts to— why should a Minister in charge of public moneys commit those moneys to a purpose to which no businessman would commit his own money or his bank's or his shareholders' money? We all know that no businessman would do it but still we are asked here where we represent the Irish people to give carte blanche to the Minister for Industry and Commerce to do this with our money. I think that is wrong and I would be very surprised if the chairman thought it was anything other than wrong.

Comment on this
Maurice E. Dockrell Acting Chairman (Mr. M.E. Dockrell) Fine Gael

My thoughts may not be introduced no matter how lattering they may appear to be.

Comment on this

I know that. In this amendment I seek to defer the payment of the money until permission is obtained if it is obtained, and if it is not, that the money should not be paid. If it is obtained, I seek to give Dáil Éireann and the country at large an opportunity to assess the conditions, to give Bechtel an opportunity to produce a detailed production plan based on the actual conditions that will apply, not on some theoretical possibility that if we were given permission to do (a) we would do it this way and if the permission were (b), we would do it another way and so on. Bechtel should be handed a planning permission if they ever come. They should be told: "These are the conditions for planning permission, now produce a detailed plan." Having done that, they should go to the financial advisers of the Minister and the company and let them work out the capital costings and the day-to-day costings of producing the ore concentrate. Until that is done, one cannot have all these plans the Minister says exists. No doubt they all exist in the sense that they are written on paper that if such and such, then so and so.

Until you know that, first, you have permission and, second, you know what the conditions are, you cannot produce any of the subsequent 19 points I referred to in my Second Reading speech, because you cannot have a production plan that is final or definite. You can have an assumed one subject to contingencies; you can base it on a hypothetical situation that if you did have planning permission, subject to these conditions then this would be a suitable production plan. Until you know the conditions, you cannot know any of the other factors needed to arrive at the final figures in relation to this company. Until you have planning permission and you know the cost of complying with those conditions you cannot make a final valuation of that company and you are foolish to try. Lazard have said that very forcefully and clearly, and I have no doubt that various other advisers on all sides have said much the same.

No prudent businessman would get himself involved in a situation of so many imponderables, and the biggest of them all is the planning imponderable. If no prudent, normal, businessman would do it, why should a Minister using public money do it? Surely the standard for a Minister is not less than that of a prudent, knowledgeable, businessman. I suggest that because public money is involved it should even be higher. That only reinforces my argument.

There is no point in somebody like Deputy B. Desmond coming in here, as he almost certainly will, and say that Tara went ahead before they had planning permission, as did other companies, for an underground mine where there was not the slightest difficulty or doubt about the fact that they were going to get it because there was little or no interference in those cases with the environment or with the locality or the amenities enjoyed by the several thousand people who live close by. They were not seriously interfered with in all the development that has taken place up to now and they would not be interfered with to any significant degree by the non-open cast method of this mine. They will be interfered with by open-cast mining. There is, therefore, grave doubt about the situation generally.

It appears that Mr. Delaney who is very experienced in these matters gave precise and detailed advice to Lazard about the difficulties being encountered here. He said there would be very substantial difficulties and that there was no guarantee that at the end of them the permission would be definitely forthcoming, although he thought it very likely that it would, and there was no guarantee that the conditions would not be extremely onerous and costly to comply with in financial terms. That is the position we are faced with. There is no businessman of even reasonable prudence who would commit himself to a deal like this without planning permission. The Minister is now seeking to do it. Because of that, he is unable to assess accurately the costs of all the various other aspects of trying to open the mine.

That is why I believe this whole operation is foolish. I do not believe, as Deputy Desmond and others sought to suggest, that the State should never get involved in equity participation in companies, even in mining companies which are notoriously the most dangerous of all. I have no objection to the State getting involved, subject to two conditions: first, that they have control of the company. They should not be in the degrading position they are in now, where even if they got 59 per cent of the shares they would still be outvoted by the 41 per cent held in one block. Secondly, if the State is involved, the company should not act in a way a normal, prudent, businessman would not act.

The State should not put in £9.54 million in circumstances in which a normal, prudent, businessman would refuse to put it in. If a normal, prudent, businessman would wait to see the terms or existence of the planning permission, the Minister, too, should wait. I have no objection, to equity participation by the State in mining or any other commercial or industrial venture. I damn well object to the State going in in circumstances that they are making fools of themselves when no businessman would do the same. I also object to them going in with a permanent in-built minority situation, and taking foolish risks such as this in paying a large sum of money for a minority shareholding, when there is no permission given for something one cannot assume permission about. If the State were prepared to act as a normal, prudent, businessman would act, I would be behind them in that respect but they are not doing that here.

Comment on this

I dealt at length with the subject matter of this section during the Second Stage debate. Deputy O'Malley described the situation about the planning application which is between the applicant company and the people who have the statutory responsibility to deal with it. I must be very careful not to express any views that could be interpreted as seeking to influence the decisions that these people may make. Of course, there are certain things I can say without influencing the position or without, I hope, in any way being accused of endeavouring to apply unfair pressure. Orebodies occur not where we would wish them, but they have been there for millions of years and they occur where we found them. We do not choose the location. In having an orebody of that magnitude and of that quality, grading at that level, and coming so near the surface, we have had a great piece of good fortune. In having it so close to Navan, we have had bad fortune, because one wants to keep the environment of our towns and cities not just as good as it is, but continuously making it better.

It is a truism that between the optimum economic exploitation of that orebody, and the proper environmental concerns of the people of Navan, particularly those closest to the mine, that is, between maximum profit and maximum environmental protection, there is, of course, a conflict and there will have to be a trade off. That is a truism which I am sure we all accept.

The optimum economic development of this orebody is very important at a number of levels. Firstly, it is important for prosperity. Let us remember that while Navan have an environmental threat and they must be very aware of this, on the other hand they have good fortune because this means prosperity for the area. The livelihood of the people employed there during the construction and production stages is also a consideration. That is a plus. It is important for the State not only because of their financial interest in it but much more widely because of the added value which can be achieved from processing the ores by an Irish smelter and because of the significant impact that will have on our exports and our balance of payments.

On the other hand, there is the important consideration of the environment and of the entitlement of the people living in the area to arrangements which will not unduly interfere with their lives. I believe the whole task is to find solutions which reasonably provide for both those important objectives. I am prepared, even though apparently others are not, to leave it to the applicants for planning permission and to the competent authorities to work out appropriate solutions.

I want to emphasise this. The question of planning permission was fully considered by the board of arbitrators. They reached their decision after hearing all the facts. It is relevant to say in regard to the seriousness of their work on the planning aspect that members of the board visited the site of the mine and were able to see for themselves its relationship to the town of Navan and its environment.

There was an assault on the competence of the board of arbitrators, and the correctness of the Government in choosing that arbitration mechanism. The board consisted of three people, one a lawyer and an engineer, a rare combination in those important skills, a man who had considerable experience of planning because he had been involved in planning applications and planning permissions; another an accountant with money skills, and the third an engineer with technological skills. In terms of the range of their skills, it would have been hard to find a more balanced board. If one says there should have been mining specialists——

Comment on this

I was interrupted by the Official Reporters sending in for documents but is the Minister talking about the arbitrators?

Comment on this

Yes. I was saying they had visited the site and not alone had they submissions but one was actually a planning specialist and they had gone to have a look at the mine. Such was the seriousness of the concern that arose on this question of planning permission.

Furthermore, detailed submissions were made by the State and their advisers in relation to the environmental indications on different mining methods, both as regards the type of measures which would have to be adopted to reduce the environmental impact of the operations to acceptable levels, and also how the provision of these measures would affect development and production costs. The board were made fully aware of the planning legislation and procedures applicable here and the environmental standards which had been imposed in relation to mining development nearing completion in the area. The report and outline specification which Bula submitted to the planning authorities were made available to the board. Ultimately, the members of the board having seen the position on the ground, and having studied everything submitted by the two sides, had to draw their own conclusion as to what the likely outcome of the planning application would be.

Let me say this about planning. We have had bad experiences in two directions. We have had had experiences because we let things happen which should not have happened. They are numerous and stretch over a long period. Now, at last, and I say it with great pleasure as a long-standing environmentalist, we have become aware of the environment. In politics it is suddenly a matter of public concern and I am very pleased about that. Then we made a few mistakes by not permitting things to happen which should have. I give the example of Schering Plough in the Suir Valley. This industry would have been of great help and benefit to that area but it did not go ahead.

The danger, as Deputies know, is to avoid exaggeration and hysteria and letting the genie out of the bottle because you can drive half-informed, quarter-informed or not completely informed people crazy with apprehension and prevent things from happening that ought to. That is a great danger. I regret Schering Plough. We were doing very well in the pharmaceutical industry but it went astray. I am sure it was a mistake, and as an environmentalist, I am sure that industry posed no threat to the environment.

On the other hand, we succeeded with Asahi, though it was a close run thing. I am glad we did but it was very dodgy and it makes a great deal of difference to a large area of Mayo. This is a delicate area and I want to avoid the possibilities of hysteria and bad decisions. When that is said, it therefore follows that the valuation put by the arbitrators took into consideration all those things which were thoroughly and fairly put before them. Indeed, a report which Deputy O'Malley quoted was in fact prepared for one of my advisers for my side of the argument and at my behest.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that because the report was prepared for him it was geared to give the impression that the prospects of planning permission were worse than they actually were?

Comment on this

No. I am suggesting that we were well aware of the planning difficulty and we were telling it like it was. The real problem deserved a thorough examination and needed to be looked at truthfully without hysteria.

Comment on this

Was it what the Minister has called a negotiating report?

Comment on this

Since about 6 o'clock we have been behaving reasonably and on this very sensitive issue I should like to continue. Suddenly we get the tone of sneer and of irrelevance introduced because the Deputy is talking about the question of valuation procedures. He has an amendment about valuation. We will debate it. I want to do so but if we observe the decencies we will get there all the quicker. I was making the point that the material quoted was produced from our side. The valuation for the whole orebody took those things into consideration and the valuation assumes a normal return on capital. That is one way of defining what a valuation is; it is that which gives an average return on capital.

If we had invested at that rate we might have been doing something good or something bad; we would have been taking the normal risk. But we did not do that. That is where the built-in protection is because we got more than twice as much as the money we spent. We asked the valuation of the orebody and they gave us an answer. That arbitration will stand up and the excellence of the arbitrators will stand up. Of that total valuation we got more than 100 per cent compensation built in because we got 49 per cent for the price of 24 per cent. It is something that a normal and prudent person would do because it is twice as good as that which the arbitrators considered would give a normal return on capital. That is not the end of the story because Deputy O'Malley knows that the Tara orebody is four times as big as the Bula one, give or take a bit; we cannot be exact. Deputy O'Malley knows that I could not have got 25 per cent of Tara without 25 per cent of Bula.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

Because there was an agreement given under duress by the previous Government that they would get a lease and because without the negotiating card in my hand, without having got the 25 per cent without charge from Bula, there was not a hope in hell of getting it from Tara.

Comment on this

Without any agreement as to the terms of it?

Comment on this

I got 49 per cent and I got another 25 per cent of something four times as big. If normal, prudent businessmen could find deals as good as that they would be queuing up for them.

Comment on this

Is there anyone queuing up to buy you a shareholding?

Comment on this

There are various other points but I have tried to deal concisely with what Deputy O'Malley said. There are bits and pieces about open-casting, about small points that I could take up but I will not. How can it be called a bad deal when one form-it be called a bad deal when one formally got twice as much and in fact got four times as much again as the amount an arbitrator considers will give a normal return on capital?

Comment on this

What Deputy O'Malley is asking the Minister to do by way of accepting this amendment is quite reasonable. The Minister has not dealt with the amendment at all in his reply. All Deputy O'Malley is asking the Minister to do is to postpone payment of any moneys until such time as planning permission has been granted. This is a very reasonable approach and is quite a normal practice in business particularly when dealing with property. Most people who buy property for development in any form insert a condition in their contracts of sale making the purchase subject to planning permission. Deputy O'Malley is asking the Minister to do something that is being done everyday. What control has the Minister over the length of time that will elapse with regard to this planning permission? He has spoken about assessments and valuations by experts and so on. He has mentioned Schering-Plough. I mention the planning application for the Dublin Bay oil refinery. How long did that go on from the date of the first submission to the planning authority until it finished up following and oral hearing? As far as I am aware it went on for a number of years. Surely the Minister will appreciate that the promoters of that project also had expert advice available to them such as the Minister says he has had?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not believe me?

Comment on this

The Minister will accept that nobody had any control over the length of time it took. The Minister is proposing to pay out part of £9.5 million. In the interests of the people of Navan and the surrounding area we hope that the decision about planning permission will not take too long but it is quite possible that it will take two years or longer because of emotionalism, oral hearings and all that goes with this. We have experienced this recently in the case of the Dublin Bay oil refinery.

Comment on this