Bula Limited (Acquisition of Shares) Bill, 1977: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–123 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 2 of 1977 ›
I wonder whether, since the discussion on this section last week, the Minister has had an opportunity to consider the point I made in regard to the deletion of the words in subsection (3) "and subject to the Agreement" which were contained in amendment No. 12 in the name of Deputy O'Malley which, as the Minister will recall, he accepted. He will also recall that I raised the point at the time that it would appear from what the Minister had told us that these words may be necessary.
Comment on this
The Chair will recall that a number of questions were asked by me and Deputy Colley in relation to various aspects of this company in which the Minister is buying shares. The Minister did not have the information available to him, nor did the four advisers who were with him in the House. He said he understood the information was available in the Department and that it would be given on the following day, Wednesday of last week. Though the Bill was ordered for Wednesday, at the last minute it was taken out, and for that reason we did not have the opportunity to get the information. In the circumstances, would the Minister give the information now?
Comment on this
The situation was that we had passed on from that section to subsequent sections. I have information here but I think it would be appropriate to follow the normal order of dealing with such matters.
Comment on this
We must first of all dispose of the section we are discussing, section 4, as amended. We cannot do anything else until we have disposed of the section before us.
Comment on this
I wonder if we are at cross purposes. In his reply now, was the Minister referring to information sought on section 2?
Comment on this
The Chair also was under the impression that reference was being made to section 2. Questions on section 4 would be in order.
Comment on this
This arises on both sections. It relates to the question of indemnifying directors of Bula under article 11. I raised the matter again, admittedly not as fully as I had done on section 2 before discussion on that section was postponed. Section 4 refers to shares being transferred by the Minister into the name of a nominee, and when we inquired the reason we were told it might be necessary for the directors appointed by the Minister under the secret agreement of 12th December, 1975, to hold a share. The discussion then went on to consider the position of those and other directors in the company in relation to article 11 of the articles of association which gives directors indemnity for any difficulty they might be in.
At the time, the Minister said they did not give the guarantee in their capacity as directors but as shareholders. I should have adverted on the last day, but unfortunately due to the complications of the matter I did not, to the fact that the four directors who gave the guarantee are not shareholders. They are directors only. The only two registered shareholders of Bula are those of Frolic Investments, now known as Bula Holdings, an unlimited private company who are registered in respect of 80 per cent, and Patrick Wright, since deceased, who was registered in respect of 20 per cent. Therefore, the Minister's contention on the last day that Roche senior and Roche junior and Messrs. Wymes and Wood gave the guarantee under the secret agreement in their capacity of shareholders is not right. It was in their capacity as directors, because they are not in fact shareholders. Bula Holdings, formerly Frolic Investments, are the only shareholders other than the late Mr. Wright.
I referred the House to the company's office file and what I have been saying is what is set out in that file at the latest state in which it is available for inspection by the public. I should like the Minister to deal with that point.
Comment on this
I am a little confused in regard to procedure. I thought that point came up and was discussed on section 2 and that it was dealt with under that section and, in my wish to avoid unnecessary repetition, I do not think we should have this matter discussed twice round. It would not be a reasonable way to proceed.
Comment on this
I would point out to the Minister, as has already been pointed out by Deputy O'Malley, that this matter was, in fact, discussed on section 4 and not unreasonably, having regard to the provisions of section 4 which envisage the transfer of shares by the Minister to a nominee. The only obvious reason why this procedure might be necessary at all would be if the holding of a share or shares were a necessary qualification to be a director and if the Minister wished to appoint certain people as his nominee directors and if in order to do so, to qualify them, they would have to hold a share or shares, then the provisions of section 4 would apply. This clearly raises the issue as to the position of directors in this company.
Deputy O'Malley has pointed out that under article 11 of the articles of association of the company a director of the company who gives a guarantee is indemnified by the company against liability on foot of that guarantee. As a result it would appear that if the Minister sought to enforce a guarantee which he has, apparently, under this secret agreement—in other words, if he were dissatisfied with the actions of the company or the inaction of the company in developing the mine—he would have power under this agreement, on foot of a guarantee apparently contained in it, to enforce that guarantee against the parties to the agreement personally. Deputy O'Malley was pointing out that under article 11 this would mean, in effect, that the Minister was trying to enforce a guarantee in respect of which he was 49 per cent responsible and this was on the face of it a ludicrous position. The Minister replied to that by saying that the people concerned had not given their guarantee as directors which would entitle them to this indemnity but rather as shareholders. Deputy O'Malley pointed out that this argument is not correct because these people are not shareholders but they are directors. It would appear, therefore, in the absence of any other explanation from the Minister that the position is as originally set out by Deputy O'Malley, that is, that such guarantee as the Minister has received in practice cannot be enforced or would be enforced by the Minister against himself, at least to the extent of 49 per cent of whatever liability arises on the guarantee. That is a ludicrous position. It is such that there is an onus on the Minister now to explain to the House why the position is not as we have outlined it, if in fact it is not, or alternatively if the position is as we have outlined it, to acknowledge that it is so and let us consider what can be done about it.
Comment on this
I am not trying to be procedurally obstructive but I must insist that this was in fact a section 2 discussion and I will be happy to come to it when we get to section 2, but I do not wish to have this discussion perpetuated needlessly by discussing things under a number of sections. It was raised on section 2 and presumably it was in order on section 2 and I submit that that is where it should be taken.
Comment on this
It arises equally relevantly on this section and on section 2 and there is no question of its prolonging the discussion because if the discussion is not held on this section then it will be held when we go back to section 2. But if the Minister wishes to withhold the information until such time as we get back to section 2 that is his affair and I will not make an issue of it. I would have thought that it would be better if we clarified the situation in regard to these matters at an early time because I am afraid that the Minister made a number of statements the last day which were wrong, on the face of it. These matters should be clarified. First of all he said he did not know anything about it but he went on afterwards to seek to make some statements which apparently do not stand up in the circumstances. However, I will not raise any objection.
Comment on this
Section 5 states:
All moneys required from time to time for the acquisition under this Act and pursuant to the Agreement of shares of the Company shall be advanced out of the Central Fund or the growing produce thereof.
Having regard to the amendment accepted earlier by the Minister which refers to not less than 49 per cent of the issued share capital, I think it is amendment No. 3, could the Minister say whether in his view section 5 authorises the acquisition by him or by the State of more than 49 per cent of the shares or whether it is his view that the wording of the section in conjunction with the wording of the agreement confines the State share to 49 per cent?
Comment on this
My understanding is that the two sections taken together confine the State's holding to 49 per cent.
Comment on this
I presume we may take it that the fact that the Minister accepted the earlier amendment means that it has been his intention and is his intention to restrict the State's share to 49 per cent and not to envisage the acquisition by the State of more than 49 per cent.
Comment on this
It is a hypothetical situation. I would not offer any binding commitment on myself in the future or on a successor in this Department but what we are now looking for under this Bill is as the Deputy indicates.
Comment on this
Does it follow from that that if at some stage the Minister or his successor wished to acquire a greater share than 49 per cent further legislation would be necessary?
Comment on this
I could not answer that question with certainly because I do not know whether, in fact, a new Bill would be necessary.
Comment on this
But the Minister does take the view that the Bill as it is now authorises only 49 per cent and no more? It does not authorise anything more than 49 per cent?
Comment on this
How does the Minister reconcile that reading of the Bill with the provision in the secret agreement of the 12th December, 1975, whereby if control of the 41 per cent interest that will exist after the Minister's purchase and after the gift to him of that 41 per cent changes significantly out of its present hands, the Minister is then entitled to acquire a further 2 per cent in order that he will retain or obtain for the first time control of the company? If the Minister's understanding of the effect of this Bill is to allow him to acquire not more than 49 per cent, does that mean that, if this situation arises, he does under the secret agreement become entitled to buy another 2 per cent out of the 41 per cent and does that mean we would then need further legislation to enable him to do that or is it his intention not to take up that potential option of the further 2 per cent?
Comment on this
I have made my position about the agreement clear over and over and I have made the position about my understanding of this section clear just now and I do not propose to discuss the assumed or hypothetical contents of the agreement further.
Comment on this
I do not think it is correct for the Minister to say that the contents as outlined by me of some of the provisions, and we have only come to some of them so far, are assumed or hypothetical. We had a pretty long discussion earlier on the fact that the shares in the company are not pari passu in the sense that they do not have equal voting rights. The Minister's block of 24 plus 25 is actually in a weaker position than the Bula holdings block of 41 and the Bula holdings block of 41 can still out-vote the Minister plus the Wright share of 10 per cent in certain circumstances. I think we have established that, even if we have only established it by default, and nobody has so far said it is wrong. The Minister agreed at some stage in the debate that the shares did not carry equal voting rights. In those circumstances, is the Minister aware of the difficulty he is creating for himself or for any successor of his who might have an opportunity of buying a majority control of this company but who will be excluded or prevented from doing so by the interpretation the Minister has given the Bill, namely, that it prevents the acquisition of more than 49 per cent of the shares?
Comment on this
The Deputy is failing to take into account the provisions of section 2. Section 2 provides: "The Minister may acquire shares of the Company in accordance with the Agreement...." Whatever can be done in accordance with the agreement will be authorised by law and the only possible limitation that would be placed on what the Minister can do seems to me to be that the Bill sets out an aggregate figure and, if the aggregate is exceeded, then authority from the Dáil to spend more would be required, if that is what is required by the agreement, but I certainly think the terms of the agreement can be carried out by this Bill when it is enacted.
Comment on this
The Attorney General's intervention is interesting because he does not deny what I have said.
Comment on this
He refers to the agreement and says the Minister can do certain things in accordance with the agreement and he conveniently overlooks the fact that we are still, even at this stage of the debate, essentially debating the provisions of this agreement and we have never seen it, which causes the debate to be prolonged unnecessarily and, indeed, to be carried on in a quite extraordinary atmosphere in that the Attorney General can stand up here and say the Minister can do a, b and c provided the agreement authorises him to do a, b and c. A few minutes ago the Minister told us he could not acquire more than 49 per cent and, by implication at least, the Attorney General now seems to be saying the Minister could acquire more than 49 per cent.
We are being put in an impossible position. There appear to be two points of view. We are referred back by the Attorney General to the phrase in section 2 "in accordance with the Agreement" and that, of course, is our objection to this whole procedure. It is no good the Attorney General referring us to the agreement if he will not show it to us. How can we know what the Minister can or cannot do if we do not see the agreement? Never before, as we have shown repeatedly, has a Bill which refers six times to an agreement not had that agreement published in conjunction with it. It is not enough for the Attorney General to say the Minister can do whatever the agreement allows him to do if he will not publish the agreement. I pointed out one of the provisions in the agreement with which the Minister on his own say this afternoon could not comply. He says he cannot buy buy more than 49 per cent. There is provision that in certain circumstances he can acquire 51 per cent. I think the circumstances are unlikely but nonetheless they could arise. The Minister has told us what he cannot do and the Attorney General says the Minister can do whatever the agreement allows him to do. It is all very frustrating, to say the least of it, and without precedent to try to legislate in these circumstances. How can this House legislate properly when we are told by the Attorney General that the Minister can do whatever the agreement allows him to do and we do not know officially what is in the agreement? I have given one provision in the agreement which would contravene the Minister's statement to the extent that it would prevent him acquiring the 51 per cent he could in certain circumstances acquire under the agreement.
Comment on this
I would like a little clarification. I do not know whether the Attorney General was here when I referred to the terms of this section— in fact, I read out the section—and I adverted to the amendments which had already been made and asked the Minister did he, as the Bill now stood, understand it to mean that the State was restricted to an amount not exceeding 49 per cent as its share and the Minister said that was his understanding of the position. There was a restriction to 49 per cent in the amount of shares which could be acquired by the State. That is quite clear. What is not clear, arising out of what the Attorney General said, is whether the Attorney General agrees with that interpretation or whether he is saying that, in certain circumstances, if the agreement so provides, more than 49 per cent can be acquired. Could we get some clarification of this? Which is the official view of the meaning of this section and of the rest of the Bill?
Comment on this
The question is based on a paraphrase of what the Minister said and I think the record will make clear what, in fact, the Minister said. I was dealing with the query raised by Deputy Colley initially as to whether it is necessary to come back to the Dáil at any time. I pointed out that, whatever the agreement permitted to be done, whatever contractual arrangement was entered into by the Minister was going to be sanctioned by this Bill under which he is given power to do certain things. One would want to be living in a very restricted world not to know that the Opposition have taken objection to the fact that the agreement had not been made public. I am well aware of this. The point I was making was that in relation to coming back to the Dáil whatever is in the agreement can be carried out by the Minister. The Opposition object to the fact that they do not know. All I am saying in relation to coming back to the Dáil is that if there are powers in the agreement which the Minister wants to carry out he can do so as a result of this legislation. The only circumstances at the moment in which I would see any necessity for further intervention by the Dáil would be if the aggregate sum referred to in section 2 is exceeded.
Comment on this
I am afraid the position has not been clarified by the Attorney General's remarks. I put a very specific question to the Minister. I referred to the terms of the Bill as amended and to the fact that this section contains a specific reference to the agreement. The section refers to "... the acquisition under this Act and pursuant to the agreement of shares...". In response to my question the Minister quite unequivocally said that the position as he understood it was that it would not be open to the State to acquire more than 49 per cent of the shares of this company under the Bill as drafted. Of course this includes the agreement.
The Attorney General appeared to be saying something different. He said if the agreement provides for the acquisition of more than 49 per cent then the Bill as drafted allows for that. I am inclined to agree with the Attorney General's view of the situation but I specifically put this question to the Minister. The Minister answered it quite specifically but it was a different answer from that given by the Attorney General. I suggest that if we cannot see the agreement at least we are entitled to get a specific reply to a specific question.
In the light of the discussion that has taken place, I should like once again to put that specific question. It is: Having regard to the terms of the Bill as amended so far, and those terms include the references to the agreement, and having regard to those provisions, is the State restricted to 49 per cent of the shares of this company in so far as it may acquire shares?
Comment on this
The amplification given by the Attorney General is entirely in accord with my understanding of the situation. I could add we are restricted simply because of the money provision. The sum provided for in the Bill is a restriction. The Attorney General and myself are not in disagreement about that.
Comment on this
I presume the Minister appreciates I raised this question specifically on this section which refers to the advancement of money out of the Central Fund for the acquisition of the shares. It is not accidental that I raised the question on this section. The Minister now appears to be saying that because of the restriction on the money being made available there is a restriction to 49 per cent of the shares. If I understand the Minister correctly that is the argument he is making.
I understand that argument in so far as it goes but I suggest it does not square with what the Attorney General has said. Under the terms of this Bill either the State's share is restricted to not more than 49 per cent of the shares or it is not. That is straightforward. The State is so restricted or it is not. Is the Minister saying the State is restricted to 49 per cent or that it is not restricted?
Comment on this
With regard to those alternatives, there can be a position to which neither will apply. The Opposition are asking me to make commitments about hypothetical situations and about the future which it is not possible to do.
Comment on this
My question relates to the Bill as it stands. It has nothing to do with hypothetical situations. The question is: on the Bill as it stands, is the State's share restricted to 49 per cent or is it not?
Comment on this
The Minister says the restriction in the Bill is a restriction related to a sum of money. He will recall that earlier he said quite specifically that the Bill as it stands restricts the State's share to 49 per cent.
Comment on this
The Minister said that quite specifically. I am trying to find out now if the Minister is withdrawing that statement and saying the only restriction relates to the money being provided. It is a basic question arising on the Bill as it stands and we are entitled to an answer.
Comment on this
I have been as helpful as I can. The record of this discussion has been made and I can simply refer people to that record.
Comment on this
Obviously there is no point in pursuing this matter. The Minister was asked a specific question by Deputy Colley and he gave an answer. In fact, my recollection is that he repeated it.
Comment on this
Deputy Colley wanted it made very clear and he put it to the Minister again. The Minister actually repeated what he said. He said: "My understanding of the effect of this Bill is that it does not allow the State to acquire more than 49 per cent of the shares in this company". That is what the record will show.
The Attorney General then came along and Deputy Colley raised further matters arising out of that point. The Attorney General then intervened to reply to Deputy Colley and he gave what was essentially a different answer to what the Minister had given. Then the Minister and the Attorney General found themselves in the position that they had given different answers to the same question. Deputy Colley and I pressed them to reconcile their answers. The Minister's method of reconciling them was to say there was no conflict; he said he was now saying the same as the Attorney General. He may now be saying the same thing as the Attorney General but he did not start off by doing this.
This is a demonstration of how incredible this debate has become. On the last day when we discussed this Bill we had to do something I had never heard of in the House before and I have not met anybody else who had heard of it either. The key section, the kernel of this Bill, had to be put back to another day so that the Minister and his advisers might get some information about various fundamental matters that were raised.
Today we have a very unusual situation in this House where, in order to help him, the Minister has brought along the Attorney General to answer some of the questions. I have never seen or heard of an Attorney General coming to this House to answer questions for a Minister and it is unusual to say the least. I am not objecting to it. It is commendable that the Attorney General would participate in debates in this House even though it has not been his practice to do so during the past four years. It is commendable that he is doing so now but it is also significant that he had to do so on this debate.
The best thing to do with the point at issue is simply to pass from it. Perhaps we will put down an amendment on Report Stage that will enable this matter to be clarified once and for all. It will enable the Minister and the Attorney General to have a conference outside the House at which they could reconcile their views on when the House could be given some information that would enable it to judge whether or not this provision should be passed.
I should like to draw the attention of the House to the words "and pursuant to the Agreement". Having accepted the deletion of the words "and subject to the Agreement" in subsection 3, to be consistent the Minister should agree to delete the words "and pursuant to the Agreement?" in this section. The presence of these words raises the question of the absence of the agreement and the secret nature of it. The House might be willing in its wisdom or otherwise to vote moneys from time to time for the acquisition of shares but the House might be quite unwilling, if it saw the agreement, to allow moneys to be advanced out of the Central Fund for the purchase of shares. It seems logical that if the words "and subject to the Agreement" are deleted the words "and pursuant to the Agreement" might be deleted from this section. I have not put down an amendment to this effect because I was not sure that the Minister was going to accept my earlier amendment which he did. Having done so, it would seem logical to do it now by agreement, or I could put down a further amendment on Report Stage.
Comment on this
The two sections are different. Section 4 (3) deals with what the Minister for Finance can do as a result of this subsection. It was not considered necessary to leave in the words "and subject to the Agreement" because without those words the section would permit the Minister to do what is necessary. Section 5 deals with a separate matter. In order to give the required legal power to the Minister these words are necessary.
Comment on this
Presumably the Attorney General appreciates that the words "and pursuant to the Agreement" would not appear to be necessary unless the agreement provides for the acquisition in certain circumstances of more than 49 per cent of the shares to which we have been referring. If one assumes that the agreement does not provide for that, why should these words be necessary?
Comment on this
I was dealing with the arguments about the apparent illogicality that was suggested, and pointed out that they are two separate functions. This is why it is necessary to keep the words in section 5 and not in section 4.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 3, lines 19 and 20, to delete "a Minister of State" and to insert "the Minister for Finance".
This amendment is down for the same reason as amendments Nos. 7, 8, 9 and 10.
Comment on this
The wording of this section arises from the situation where the shares may be held for a period by the Minister for Industry and Commerce before they are transferred to the Minister for Finance. I consider the present wording to be appropriate. On the other hand, the proposed amendment will not give rise to any difficulty and I accept it.
Comment on this
Unfortunately, the less important half of my amendments has been accepted, but it is promising enough in the circumstances. We might be equally wise on Report Stage and twice as wise when the Bill reaches the Seanad. Section 6 provides for the payment of dividends and other moneys received by the Minister for Finance in respect of ownership of shares. Would the Minister tell us what the words "other moneys" mean?
Comment on this
I am informed that this is a standard form of drafting which it is normal to include in circumstances of this kind.
Comment on this
Could it be a reference to the disposal of shares or does it envisage something wider than that?
Comment on this
Am I not correct in my recollection that one of the terms of the agreement was a small royalty arrangement in relation to the company, such as 1 per cent?
Comment on this
That is not correct. I am reminded that there might be the question of bonus shares in this context.
Comment on this
It raises the possibility that, as a shareholder, the Minister may receive other moneys. He could receive them in various ways other than by means of dividends.
Comment on this
Bonus shares are not moneys. We are told that there are no royalties in this operation.
Comment on this
I am informed that this is the normal wording and that there is no specific mechanism intended.
Comment on this
The Minister is now saying that the words do not mean anything. If that is so, can we agree to delete the words?
Comment on this
This is entering into an extraordinary area. I am informed that this is a normal traditional form of words. I do not know what the traditional reasons are, but I do not think on a Bill of this kind where this form of words has been traditionally and normally used we should enter into the business of deleting by agreement. I do not think it is a major issue. It is a tiny issue and I do not see why the Deputy cannot allow the section to go through as it is.
Comment on this
I will give the Minister one reason why it should be questioned, that is, that we are here dealing with an agreement the contents of which we do not know. This is just another example of what Deputy O'Malley said a few moments ago. If the agreement were before us, whether we approved of it or not, almost certainly this debate would be quicker than it is at the moment. This provision says: "all dividends and other moneys received by the Minister for Finance". An obvious question that arises is whether "other moneys", that is, money other than dividends, are envisaged under the agreement? That is not an unreasonable question, but the Minister, if he reverts to the kind of thing he has said on some occasions, it likely to say: "I am not going to disclose what is in the agreement". Of course, as I have said many times, he should have disclosed what is in the agreement, but I do not intend to go back over that. What I am saying is that in the circumstances where this phrase is used "and other moneys", we are at least entitled to ask the Minister whether that is to have whatever its normal meaning is or whether it is to have a meaning which has to be interpreted in the light of the terms of the agreement we have not seen. Is there anything in the agreement which could be covered by this phrase "other moneys"?
Comment on this
I have indicated earlier that it has its normal meaning, that this is a normal, traditional form of drafting and that it has no other content or intent than that.
Comment on this
We may take it then from what the Minister is saying that the agreement referred to in the earlier section does not provide for the paymnt to the Minister of moneys other than dividends. Is that correct?
Comment on this
It is a little more than a comment. Either that is correct or it is not. If it is correct, then the Minister is entitled to say this phrase "other moneys" simply has the normal, traditional meaning. However, if the agreement provides for the payment of any sums other than dividends, then clearly this phrase "other moneys" can and almost certainly does refer to whatever provision is in the agreement for payments other than dividends. Consequently, we are entitled to ask the Minister to make it quite clear whether this phrase "other moneys" does or can refer to any payments envisaged under the agreement other than dividends.
Comment on this
I have, in fact, answered the Deputy's question. The intention is the normal traditional intention and no other.
Comment on this
And no other? The Minister did not say that before. If the Minister says "and no other" he is, in effect, saying that there is no provision in the agreement for any payment except a dividend on foot of these shares. This is what I asked him the first time, but it took quite some time to get him to say that. However, since there have been a few statements by the Minister which he has subsequently retracted or controverted, I do not want any misunderstanding on this or the Minister to say that it is simply a comment by me. I want to spell it out as clearly as I can so that if there is any misunderstanding about it the Minister will have the opportunity now to correct that misunderstanding.
The position appears to be as follows: The Minister says that the phrase "other moneys" has it normal, traditional meaning and no other. If that is so, it follows that the agreement envisages the payment of dividends only and not payment in any other way. If that position is being correctly represented by me, then the phrase "other moneys" does not present any difficulties. If it is not being correctly represented in what I have said, I suggest that now is the time for the Minister to correct the position, because if there is any other provision in the agreement, then the Minister would be misleading the House if he allowed the impression to go forth that there was no other provision in the agreement when in fact there was and that the words "other moneys" did not refer to anything in the agreement if, in fact, they could so refer.
Comment on this
I am afraid we are gone back to the old habits again, no answer. It is often the loudest answer.
Comment on this
Section 6 refers to shares held "by a nominee under section 4 of this Act". The Minister has said we are dealing only with dividends here and that this phrase "other moneys" is just a pattern followed by the parliamentary draftsman. If there are one or two nominees of the Minister under section 6 and the directors get an annual fee because of the ownership of shares of the company by the Minister, does this mean they must hand over this money for the benefit of the Exchequer? That is the way it reads to me. I shall be delighted if that is the case but I want the Minister to confirm it.
Comment on this
Yes, but the Minister's nominees are there because the Minister has shares in the company. The Minister has referred to dividends, but also built into this section is a reference to "dividends and other moneys received", and I was assuming that the other moneys referred to would be moneys that would be received by the nominees of the Minister in respect of the ownership of shares.
The section says these moneys "shall be paid into or disposed of for the benefit of the Exchequer", and the Minister's answer has not clarified that point for me.
Comment on this
I can only repeat that the dividends or other moneys are in respect of ownership of shares.
Comment on this
Under the terms of this section, would the Minister's nominee directors have to pay their fees as directors into the Exchequer?
Comment on this
This section refers to the expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act. I take those expenses to be in addition to the £9,540,000 of taxpayers' money re-referred to in section 2 and which is to be paid tax free and direct to the four fortunate beneficiaries of the Minister's generosity. Can we have some idea of what sort of expenses are envisaged in section 7? Already we have extracted one figure from the Minister, that was, the sum of £58,500 to two firms—Lazard Brothers and Company Limited and Mergers Limited—for advice on the question of the valuation of 24 per cent of this company. We know that that money has been expended.
The Minister received advice also from the Geological Survey Office. I do not know whether that advice had to be paid for. Presumably it had to be paid for. These then are three headings under which expenses have been incurred but can the Minister tell us the various other headings which are intended to be covered by this section and also what are the approximate amounts of money involved?
Comment on this
The sort of expenses that arise from the administration of the Bill, once enacted, are things like employment of consultants, if that is necessary, the matter of travel and there could be circumstances in which there was a matter of staff but all of that would have to be brought forward and dealt with by the normal mechanism by which moneys are voted by the Oireachtas. This section is simply enabling those expenses to be paid from moneys provided by the Oireachtas but the section is not providing the money.
Comment on this
Therefore is the Minister saying that the £58,500 he paid to Lazards and Mergers is not covered by this section?
Comment on this
I understand the moneys voted to my Department are the source of those payments and that this section is an enabling one in relation to circumstances in which the Act is law.
Comment on this
It was easy for the Minister to read that but would he explain in less official language what it means? Is this money that is being paid to Lazards and Mergers, to the Geological Survey Office, to solicitors and counsel who have been retained, apart from the advice that he is getting from the Chief State Solicitor's office and the normal legal channels, to be paid under section 7 or is it being paid under some subhead in the departmental Estimates. I note there is no subhead for this purpose in this year's Estimate although there was provision in this respect under subhead T of last year's Estimate.
Comment on this
Queries being raised by the Deputy do not, in my opinion, apply to this section because they relate to items carried out and paid for last year.
Comment on this
That was the question the Minister was asked the first time. He has now given an answer in terms that are understandable.
Comment on this
We are used to that. Can the Minister tell us, then, what are the total expenses that are likely to be incurred by him in relation to this legislation, either last year, this year, or next year so that we can add those to the £9.54 million in order to arrive at the exact figure that 24 per cent of these shares is costing?
Comment on this
Perhaps if the Deputy reflects on the formulation of his question in regard to last year, this year and next year he will realise that it is not possible for me to give the sort of information he requires.
Comment on this
We know, for example, that it was possible for the Minister at Question Time to give me the figure in relation to two of his advisers. Would he add the figures for the rest of his advisers, be they financial or legal?
Comment on this
In the light of what has been said I should like guidance as to whether these matters arise under section 7 of the Bill.
Comment on this
It would not be pleasant to have to suggest that it is as difficult to get an answer from the Chair as it is to elicit information from the Minister. Did not the Minister ask whether the questions posed by Deputy O'Malley were proper to this section? I would be interested in hearing the reply. In my opinion the questions are relevant to the section.
Comment on this
Perhaps it would help the Deputies opposite if I indicate that there has been no expenditure whatever under this Bill.
Comment on this
We have a situation whereby under section 7 the Minister is making provision for the payment of expenses incurred in the administration of this legislation and where he is saying that the money will be paid out of the moneys provided by the Oireachtas. We know that there have been sizeable expenses already in relation to this whole matter. Since the Minister has said that all of the expenditure involved up to now has been found without reference to the Bill, is there a need at all for this section? Deputy O'Malley was endeavouring to ascertain the sort of payments the Minister envisages in respect of the administration of the Act.
Comment on this
I indicated the sorts of categories of payments that could be envisaged as being required but the point I made was that no expenditures have been incurred or could have been incurred under this section since the Bill is not yet an Act and that, therefore, discussion of other expenditures in respect of the past and to which Deputies have made reference do not seem to arise under section 7. It was on that matter that I asked the guidance of of the Chair.
Comment on this
The record will show that I have given this information already when I referred to such categories as consultants, travel and staff of certain categories.
Comment on this
What puzzles me is the situation whereby the Minister envisages engaging more consultants having regard to the fact that he did not take the advice of those he had in the past. I am assuming that the Minister intends appointing two directors to Bula. I am assuming that section 7 will enable the Minister to make provision for the payment of these two directors, or are we to assume that Bula themselves will pay the two directors? We are entitled to an answer to that.
Comment on this
In practice if people are directors of companies they are paid from the funds of the company. There is no mechanism suggested here for the payment of directors.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned three headings as possible headings of expenditure under this section. Could the Minister indicate the kind of circumstances in which he envisages the use of consultants for whom payment may have to be made under this section.
Comment on this
That is putting me into a very hypothetical situation. One can only talk about general circumstances in which consultants are retained by Departments and then ask if such a hypothetical situation might arise. Consultants are employed where the expertise does not exist within the Department or within another available Department or State agency and it can be envisaged that such circumstances might arise. But I would be entering into an extremely speculative area to be more precise than that. The Deputy's experience in public life might provide speculative answers to the question, but I do not wish to be speculative.
Comment on this
Perhaps the significance of what the Minister has said does not strike him as it strikes me. When the Minister talks about the use of consultants it is in the context of expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act. One could envisage the use of consultants by the company in respect of further developments and so on, but that on the face of it would be something that would be paid for by the company and not by the Minister as an expense in the administration of the Act. In what circumstances would the Minister envisage the use of consultants for which the Minister would have to pay as an expense incurred in the administration of this Act?
Comment on this
I have no specific set of circumstances in mind. This is a technical provision in the usual form.
Comment on this
I appreciate that and I also appreciate the fact that the Minister may not have some specific thing in mind. Quite clearly some of the Minister's advisers have something specific in mind when they advise the Minister that the cost of a consultant or consultants could be a possible expense under this section. Would the Minister inquire from his advisers what they had in mind when they advised him to refer to the possible expense of a consultant as an expense under this section?
Comment on this
I am informed that this is an enabling provision in the usual drafting layout and that there is no specific intention at this moment to retain consultants.
Comment on this
The Minister is being evasive. We are aware that the section is in the usual form. We can assume that there is no specific intention at this time to engage consultants. That is not an unreasonable assumption. Equally, it is not an unreasonable assumption that if the cost of a consultant is envisaged as a possible expense under this section somebody had something in mind when they said that. Could the Minister elaborate a little on the other heading mentioned, staff and travel? How could they arise as expense in the administration of this Act?
Comment on this
The Deputy says that it is not an unreasonable assumption that somebody had something in mind. I wonder if we are being entirely serious. I have assured the House that this is a technical provision in the usual form. This detailed speculation about what might be envisaged by members of my staff is a very extraordinary sort of speculation which is not germane to the purpose of this Bill.
Comment on this
Clearly it has not occurred to the Minister that that is a very peculiar form of reply, to refer to consultants, staff and travel. On the face of it that answer is so peculiar that it immediately raises the question as to what the Minister had in mind, or if he had nothing in mind, what his advisers have in mind. As the consultants seem to be a problem we will leave that aside for the moment. Does the Minister think it peculiar of us to ask in what circumstances does he envisage possible expenditure under this section under the heading of staff or travel?
Comment on this
It is peculiar. It is simply taking up time and spinning a thing out. This is an enabling section so that if circumstances arose in which it would be desirable to have people travel, or desirable to have someone employed who was not a normal member of the establishment of the Department paid for in the normal way, then it would be possible to do so. That is the extent of the intention. It is not worth the rigmarole which it is now receiving.
Comment on this
The Minister is missing the whole point. The Minister has a Bill coming up shortly which deals with the setting up of an overall authority in regard to science and technology. I have not looked at that Bill, but there is almost certainly such a section in it. In that case the Minister is setting up a form of State authority for which clearly expenses will be incurred in relation to its administration. This is a Bill for the acquisition of shares in a private company. How can one incur expense in the administration of this Act when the purpose of the Act is to acquire shares in a private company? I do not say there is no reasonable answer to that, but at the moment I cannot imagine what it is. I am asking the Minister to give us a reasonable answer. In answer to this the Minister gave us an example of three headings, consultants, staff and travel. We asked the Minister to indicate how under any one of those headings expenses might be incurred in the administration of this Act, which is quite different from the normal one which the Minister has referred to. It is not an answer for the Minister to refer to the normal provision, because this is a normal provision in a different kind of Act. I hope the Minister has got the point I am trying to make. It seems to me that, once one thinks about it, it is self-evident. Maybe the Minister had not thought about it up to now. I hope it is clear why there is a considerable difference in this case and why the questions are not strange or peculiar in the circumstances of this Bill and what it is seeking to do.
Comment on this
The section refers to the expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act. I have always understood, and I believe I have always functioned on the basis, that when I am required to administer any Act that I should be entitled, if I deem it necessary in circumstances that I cannot now envisage in regard to this or any other Act, to these sort of powers. That seems not alone normal but necessary if a Minister is to discharge his functions properly.
Comment on this
If one accepts that proposition it is one thing, but when the Minister was asked what kind of expenses would be involved he did not give the answer he has just given. The answer he gave was consultant staff and travel. Is he now wanting to withdraw that answer or did it mean anything when he said it? If it did not, why did he say it? If it did will he tell us what he meant?
Comment on this
I gave those things as examples of the sort of expenditure. They are not exhaustive.
Comment on this
Taking any one of them would the Minister explain how it could arise as an expense of the Minister in relation to this Act? I will explain what I mean. On the face of it when this Bill is enacted the Minister will acquire the shares referred to. He will appoint, let us say, two directors. The two directors will, as the Minister indicated earlier, if they are paid directors' fees, be paid by the company. The cost will not be an expense under this section. If they incur travel expenses as directors these presumably will be paid by the company also and will therefore not be an expense under this section. The question therefore arises: in what way will the Minister be incurring expense in the administration of this Act? I am inclined to accept the proposition put forward by the Minister with a general insurance clause which the Minister should have. He cannot spell out too precisely all the expense that might arise and there should be exceptions which would absolve him if this should arise. This is not an unreasonable proposition. Surely the Minister can appreciate that that is not the case he made. He mentioned three specific headings.