Bula Limited (Acquisition of Shares) Bill, 1977: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 124–240 of 240. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 2 of 1977 ›
Take these as examples and see how it could arise. How could travel expenses arise in the circumstances we have envisaged? How could staff arise in the circumstances we have envisaged? Would these not be expenses of the company and not the Minister, or am I completely misunderstanding the position arising under this Bill?
Comment on this
And there is no certainty that it would ever be necessary to incur expense. There is simply a usual form, which is enabling should the circumstance arise.
Comment on this
I should like to raise a point before we pass the section. The Minister has told us the names of his financial and geological advisers in this matter. Another very important set of advisers in the circumstances would be his legal advisers. Would the Minister now tell us the names of the counsel and solicitors outside the public service who may have advised him in relation to this matter, the amount paid to them and whether the advice they gave extended to the constitutionality of the 1940 Act and, if so, what the advice in relation to that matter was?
Comment on this
We are on section 7, which says:
The expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act....
This means when enacted. It is not now an Act. I suggest that all of the questions asked by the Deputy are out of order on section 7.
Comment on this
The Minister has told us what his financial and geological advisers told him and how much he paid them, that is £58,500. He did not include the Geological Survey and we do not know what they got. I presume they were paid. I am repeating the same query under what seems to be the most appropriate section, because this section would retrospectively enable the payments to be made. I am inquiring what the position is about the legal consultants. I understand the Minister did not confine his legal advice simply to the full-time officials of the public service. Since we have been given information in regard to financial and geological consultants we should have this in relation to the legal equivalents as well.
Comment on this
The Chair would point out at this stage that the expenses are in relation to this Bill when it becomes an Act.
Comment on this
We have discussed at great length the question of the Minister paying £9.54 million plus X hundred thousand pounds for expenses under section 7. The £9.54 million cannot be paid officially, or lawfully at any rate, until the Act is passed. With the greatest respect to the Chair, the Chair's reasoning in relation to the question of expenses under section 7 would have also included any discussion of the £9.54 million. We spent a long time on that.
Comment on this
The Chair is dealing only with expenses on the administration of this Bill in section 7.
Comment on this
The Chair at the Minister's invitation has ruled as he wished, but it is a pity that these questions are not answered because every question of this nature left unanswered in this debate simply raises more and more queries and deepens the already pretty deep public suspicion about the whole affair and creates a larger question mark over it all. Never has a Minister declined to answer so many question as this Minister on this Bill.
Comment on this
The Chair is dealing with section 7 which deals with expenses in the administration of the Act.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if we can have a categorical assurance that no money will be paid on foot of this section in respect of any expense incurred prior to the enactment of this Bill?
Comment on this
I understand that it is simply not possible that there can be any payments under this until it is an Act, which it is not now.
Comment on this
I am sorry. That is not quite the question I put to the Minister. The question I put was: can we have a categorical assurance that no payment will be made under this section in respect of any expense incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill? That is a slightly different question.
Comment on this
To reiterate, payments are made out of voted moneys against subheads. This is an enabling provision in the Bill. It is not enacted.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Minister feels the question I am putting to him is more complicated than it really is. Let me give him a very simple example. Deputy O'Malley referred to one expense we know of, the fee paid to Lazards. May we take it no payment will be made under section 7 in respect of that expense?
Comment on this
May we take it no payment whatever will be made under section 7 in respect of any expense whatever the liability for which was incurred before the enactment of the Bill? In other words, all expenses incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill will be paid for in a way other than under section 7.
Comment on this
No. The possibility of a continuous fee occurring partly before and partly after the enactment of the Bill is a real one.
Comment on this
A fee, part of which occurs prior to the enactment and part of which occurs afterwards for a continuing service.
Comment on this
Surely if that is so the Minister, quite inadvertently I am sure, was misleading the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in the submission he made in regard to this section. The whole point of his submission was that no expense could be incurred and paid for under this section until after the enactment of the Bill. Therefore, he contended Deputy O'Malley was out of order in referring to any expense incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill. That was my understanding of what was said. On that basis I was merely trying to clarify the position.
The Minister appears now to be saying expenses could be incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill which would be paid under this section. If that is so, I suggest all expenses which have been incurred in connection with this matter prior to the enactment of the Bill are open to discussion on this section because they may become payable under this section.
Comment on this
This is a general enabling section. The funds have to be voted. In the interests of trying to be precise. I was indicating that there could be circumstances in which a service would commence at a certain stage, and continue through the moment in which the Bill became law, and the question of payment for those sort of services under the enabling umbrella of this section, using voted moneys, could not be ruled out. I cannot understand the Deputy's difficulty. He knows such overlap services will arise.
Comment on this
If we take expenses incurred quite clearly prior to the enactment of the Bill which have already been paid for—assuming some have already been paid; I do not know —they will have been paid for on foot of the authority in some subhead of the Estimate for the Minister's Department. I see no reason why expenses incurred of the kind the Minister is talking about would continue from before the enactment of the Bill until afterwards which could not also be disposed of in the same way.
In other words, this section does not appear to me to be necessary to discharge such expenses. Indeed, on the face of it I agree with the contention the Minister was making that it relates only to expenses incurred in the administration of this Act and therefore, on the face of it, can only relate to expenses incurred after the Bill is enacted. I was trying to clarify that and get it on the record, and the Minister took me aback by what he said which indicated that he envisaged the possibility of making a payment under this section in respect of expenses incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill. If it is possible to make a payment of that kind under this section, it seems to me all expenses incurred in connection with this matter might well come for payment under this section and should be open to discussion.
I did not think they were and I was merely trying to clarify them. I intended to follow up with another small point. The Minister has opened up the whole position now in a way I did not envisage and which I do not think the Leas-Cheann Comhairle envisaged when the Minister made his submission to him. Would it be possible for the Minister to clarify the position? I have no desire to open this matter up but, on the other hand, I have no desire to let the section go without a discussion on the expenses involved if, in fact, this section will be deemed to authorise payments in respect of expenses incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill.
Comment on this
The Deputy says "deemed to authorise payments". This is an enabling section, I repeat, of a standard form. It provides that they may be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas. It is the voting of the moneys by the Oireachtas that is the authorisation. Surely the authorisation for all moneys paid in such circumstances is the vote of the Oireachtas.
Comment on this
The Minister has incurred some expenses and I presume he has paid some expenses already. Is that correct? Have some expenses which have been incurred prior to this already been paid?
Comment on this
Yes or no? Will the Minister answer the question and not go running to the Ceann Comhairle for help?
Comment on this
It was intended to be a simple question but it does not appear to be as simple as that.
Comment on this
We are having a discussion on an area which I submitted under section 7 was not admissible for discussion. We are gradually being carefully worked onto that area.
Comment on this
The effort is being made to work us onto an area which does not arise under section 7.
Comment on this
I am trying to clarify this position and I am finding it extremely difficult. In fact, the simpler I make my questions the more difficulty the Minister appears to find in answering them. I will try to break it down so that we can eliminate the areas where we are agreed and see if, in fact, there in any conflict between us. Could I ask the Minister again: have any of the expenses which have been incurred in connection with this transaction been paid? Any of them?
Comment on this
Unfortunately I do not know the answer and that is why I ask it. Have they or have they not been paid, any of them?
Comment on this
The Deputy may not be aware of the reply to a parliamentary question but reference was made to it by his colleague, Deputy O'Malley, in this debate.
Comment on this
If the Minister is referring to the fee due to Lazards I am aware that he gave a reply in which it was stated what the amount was, but I am not aware that he said it was actually paid.
Comment on this
The position was made distinctly unclear by something the Minister said some time ago. We have now established that some expenses which were incurred in connection with this transaction have already been paid. Clearly they have not been paid on foot of this section but on foot of a subhead in the Minister's Estimate which was approved by this House. There is no reason why other expenses incurred in the future, or incurred already and not yet paid, cannot be dealt with similarly. Therefore the question arises as to how can any liability for expenses already incurred or incurred prior to the enactment of this Bill fall to be paid or authorised for payment under this section? Why is this section not relating solely to expenses incurred after the enactment of the Bill and expenses which relate to the cost of administration?
Comment on this
This is my understanding but I stated that there would be certain services that would have started prior to the enactment and would continue after it and that there would be a question of apportionment of payments.
Comment on this
No, I fear the Minister does not pay as much attention to what he says himself as we do. What he said was that there could be a situation in which fees incurred were on a continuing basis dating from before the enactment of the Bill to after the enactment of it. If he did not say, he certainly implied that such fees, covering the whole period, would fall to be paid under section 7. Did he not mean that because that is the impression I got from what he said and that is the reason for the whole difficulty? If the Minister did not mean that, would he say so? Did he mean to convey that such fees would be apportioned, that there would be a separate payment for those incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill and another one under section 7 subsequent to the enactment of the Bill? If that is what he meant, it is not what he said.
Comment on this
I would refer the Deputy to the record in due course. I was trying to be specific in saying that there were services which had been initiated prior to the enactment of the Bill but which would continue after the enactment of it and the payment of those in the latter context would be, as I understand section 7, subject to, or not subject to—because this is simply an enabling Bill—the vote of the Oireachtas but would arise after the Bill has become law and therefore in the context of section 7.
Comment on this
Does the Minister mean that there would be, in respect of that continuing fee, in effect two separate payments, one in respect of that incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill and a second in respect of the one incurred afterwards, the second one being a payment made on foot of section 7? Is that what the Minister means?
Comment on this
Fees are paid from subheads. I think I was not referring to a payment; I was referring to a service. In fact, I was trying to clarify matters for the Deputy when I made it clear that there would be some services that would be continuing beyond the moment when the Bill became law. It was my whole intention to be clear about that fact.
Comment on this
I appreciate that the Minister was trying to make that point clear. What he did not make clear, and I fear has not yet made clear, is whether in such a case the services incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill will be dealt with separately from those incurred after the enactment of the Bill.
Comment on this
I appreciate that. Those already incurred by the Minister before the enactment of the Bill—some of them have been paid, as we have established and some have yet to be paid—will be paid under subheads. You do not need section 7 for that purpose. The difficulty has arisen because the Minister drew into the argument, quite unnecessarily in my view, expenses incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill under section 7. It was the Minister who brought in that. He has still not made it quite clear that in fact there is a separation between the two, even if it is the one firm rendering the one service and that in fact there has to be an apportionment. He hinted at that but he did not say it.
I am not making a mountain of a molehill in case the Minister is tempted to think that I am because if the Minister proposes to make any payment under section 7 in respect of an expense incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill there is a new situation in regard to our discussion of section 7. All of this has arisen because of what the Minister said. Would he now indicate specifically in the case of a service of the kind he has envisaged, which commences prior to the enactment of the Bill and continues after the date of its enactment, when payment falls to be made for that service, is it envisaged that that payment would be apportioned, that one portion would relate to services up to the date of enactment and another portion to be paid on foot of a subhead authorised under section 7 would relate to the services after the enactment date? Is that what is envisaged?
Comment on this
The fees, as I said, are in fact paid under the subhead. I believe that the mechanism that I described and that the Deputy has now described again is the mechanism that would have to be used.
Comment on this
If that is so, then no expense incurred prior to the enactment of the Bill comes under section 7. That is what, apparently, the Minister was trying to establish: in fact what he conveyed was something quite different. He has now switched it around and he is talking about apportionment and I think he is getting me to make the case for him rather than making it himself, the case he should have made the first time.
Comment on this
The record will be very clear unless, as Deputy O'Malley said in another context, it is interfered with, as to what the Minister did say. I think we have now established some degree of clarity, not a great deal. I now ask the Minister what kind of service would involve payment for service rendered prior to and continuing on past the enactment of the Bill?
Comment on this
This is really hypothetical stuff. We have spent more than ten minutes discussing something that I thought, in an effort to clarify, I had introduced at the beginning. I believe the record will show that I introduced it in a clear way. I am not prepared to pursue this particular end.
Comment on this
Are we to take it that the Minister is saying that when he referred to a service continuing on——
Comment on this
That is the question I am putting to the Minister. Would he at least allow me to put the question to him? Was he bringing in something hypothetical? Is that what he is now saying, that it was hypothetical? He did not say that at the time.
Comment on this
Is the Minister now saying that such a service does not exist and that it was purely a hypothetical exercise on his part?
Comment on this
I am not surprised that the Minister is not saying one or the other because he is saying one and the other on almost every question that comes up. It is totally unsatisfactory that a Minister should come into the House, and not know his job, not be properly briefed, not be able to explain things, putting forward a case and then withdrawing it, and changing his feet. This is a totally unsatisfactory performance. He is wasting the time of the House and of the Opposition.
Comment on this
In view of the fact that the Minister cannot envisage in what way expenses can arise under section 7, and that he has already found in existing legislation ways and means of spending quite a sizeable amount of money on research, the business of staff, travelling expenses and the various other things he mentioned tonight, surely he could accept this Bill without providing for the possibility of incurring further expense administering it? In view of the abstractness, as the Minister put it, of being able to visualise further expenses in this regard, could he withdraw section 7, because it does not seem to be necessary?
Comment on this
We cannot agree. The Minister has failed to answer various questions and has changed his answers several times. This is not the normal provision where a State company or its equivalent—the example given by Deputy Colley was the National Board for Science and Technology—is concerned. This is a private company in which the Minister is buying with the taxpayers' money a minority interest. These expenses are matters for the company. Any expenses incurred from now on should be paid by the company and not out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas. We have had no reassurance on this matter from the Minister and in those circumstances we cannot agree to the section because it is not usual in that context.
Comment on this
Question put.
Do you agree with this result?
I want to deal with two matters that came up the last day because during the earlier debate on this section Deputy O'Malley remarked that at the time he obtained copies of the documents of the company's file in the Company's Registration Office the latest annual returns of Bula Limited did not appear to be available. I promised to look into that.
I am informed that the 1974 and 1975 returns were submitted some weeks ago and they are now on the file, but it is possible that one or both of them were being subjected to the registration process at the time of the Deputy's inquiry. As I said, they have since been filed and I understand that the 1976 return is on file also. I think the item from these returns which Deputy O'Malley particularly wished to be informed about was the figure of the indebtedness of the company, which appears at part 4 of the annual return. The figure entered in the 1976 return for this indebtedness was £3,091,409.
The other matter, which to a great extent has been dealt with but which I will just return to, is the matter of Haras el Chorro, SA. That matter again was raised by Deputy O'Malley. The reason he did so was that contracts entered into by Bula Limited with Haras el Chorro, SA were listed in a charge registered in the Companies Office as part of the security for the credit facilities by banking institutions. This matter, I think, has been incorrectly taken up by the press as being a situation where Haras el Chorro, SA hold a mortgage on Bula lands or minerals. This is not so. Haras el Chorro, SA are and have been since 1970 the registered owners of lands known as the Kruger lands. These lands were essential and support lands for the Bula mining projects and contracts for the acquisition of these lands were entered into by Bula Limited. It is the surplus use of the land which is important to Bula for the purpose of constructing tailing dams and other facilities ancillary to the mine development. Those are the specific matters Deputy O'Malley raised—the matter of the returns and also the matter of Haras El Chorro, SA. The latter was misunderstood and I believe it is now recognised that it was a misunderstanding. That has been substantially cleared up but I wanted to add the official record to the explanations already given.
Comment on this
Before I comment on those two—and I will have quite a lot to say on what the Minister has said, or not said, as the case may be— I should like to mention a third matter. The Minister made a statement on the last occasion that the four guarantors, whom he named as Messrs. Roche, senior and junior, Mr. Wymes and Mr. Wood, were not guaranteeing in their capacity as directors although they are directors but that they were guaranteeing in their capacity as shareholders although they are not in fact shareholders, as I demonstrated since. Would the Minister deal with that situation, because the question as I originally posed it remains perfectly valid, that as directors they are entitled, under article 11, to an indemnity. That means that the Minister is suing himself so far as 49 per cent of his action might be concerned.
Comment on this
I can amplify a little what is in the record. I said that the guarantee was given by the four individuals as the beneficial owners of the shares; the individuals control Bula Holdings. The guarantee was drafted to take account of the way in which the shares in Bula Limited are held.
Comment on this
The only connection of these four individuals with Bula Limited is that they are four directors. They are not shareholders in Bula Limited. The shareholding of Bula Limited, as I demonstrated from the Companies Office file on the last occasion, is 80 per cent Frolic Investments, now with its name changed to Bula Holdings, and 20 per cent Patrick Wright, since deceased. None of the four men concerned is the owner of a single share in Bula Limited. Who owns what shares in Bula Holdings I do not know and nobody knows because it is a private unlimited company. These companies are common enough nowadays for taxation purposes. They have no great advantages or value other than for taxation purposes.
One of the provisions of the Companies Act, 1963, is that it is not necessary to disclose the names of the shareholders. Therefore, while we might well guess, and make a very informed guess, perhaps, that these four men are the principal shareholders at least of Bula Holdings, we do not know because there is no information in the file in the Companies Office to that effect. My original proposition stands, that these four guarantors are guaranteeing in their capacity as directors and it can be the only capacity in which they are guaranteeing because they are not shareholders and they cannot therefore guarantee as shareholders. If they guarantee as directors, as indubitably they do, then they have an indemnity under article 11. I regard as seriously wrong that they should have an indemnity under article 11. I regard as seriously wrong that they should have an indemnity under article 11 because the value of their guarantee is diluted straight away by 49 per cent.
In practice that guarantee may be diluted to a greater extent. The Minister might well be advised that it would be futile or unwise for him to seek to enforce a guarantee when he will have to indemnify as to 49 per cent of what he succeeds in enforcing. In practice the dilution of the value of those guarantees given in the secret agreement of 12th December, 1975, may be virtually nothing. The dilution is so great that the value is virtually nothing. I do not wish to say that the Minister misled the House the last day, because I have no doubt he did not consciously try to do that, but the effect of what he said in practice was to mislead the House. Now that we have established the precise facts they bear out precisely what I said on Tuesday, 22nd February, as reported in Volume 297 (1) of the Official Report.
The Minister said now that the 1974 and 1975 annual returns were sent in "some weeks ago and are now on file". On 22nd February the Minister said these returns were made and filed in the Companies Office on 24th January, 1977. I had a search carried out on that file by long established, most competent and experienced law searchers in Dublin. They carried out a search for me on Tuesday, 15th February, 1977, and sent me an invoice with the search dated that date. On that date the file was available to them but the annual returns for 1974, 1975 and 1976 were not on the file. I communicated with the firm concerned by telephone last Tuesday and told them I understood that in the last few days, as a result of what the Minister said here, a number of annual returns which had not previously been on the file were now on it. I asked them to get me copies of those. They said they would. When I had not heard from them I telephoned them at lunchtime today and they told me that the file was not available in the Companies Office. They said they had been there a couple of times but the file was not available. I asked them the reason it was not available and they said they understood that a number of forms had recently been sent in and the file had been withdrawn, presumably, to have the forms put on it. I asked them when they thought the file might be available. They hoped it would be available by Friday and if so they would then copy the additional documents for me.
The position is that, notwithstanding the statement of the Minister on the last day that these annual returns were placed on the file on 24th January, 1977, they clearly were not on it when that file was copied for me on Tuesday, 15th February. The file was not available since Thursday last or today. To say the least of it this is an unsatisfactory position. It is not a position that pertains to the average company. There is secrecy, mystery and doubt about the fulfilment by this company of its legal obligations under the Companies Act, 1963. If the Minister's statement of the last day that these documents were filed on 24th January, 1977, was correct—that statement was not correct—that would disclose on the face of it a breach of the Companies Act, 1963. It was a serious matter for the Minister to make that statement. The position now is that a servant of his, the Registrar of Companies, having had drawn to his attention in Dáil Éireann by the statement of his own Minister the failure of a particular company to file its annual returns in time, presumably will now have to take the appropriate steps open to him under section 125 (4) of the Companies Act, 1963.
On the question of the annual returns, I raised on the last occasion, but the Minister conveniently overlooked it, the position that the 1972 and 1973 annual returns had not been filed until 12th November, 1974. On the face of it that disclosed what seems to me to be a further offence under section 125 of the Companies Act by the company in which the Minister is seeking to buy a small minority share with more than £9½ million of the taxpayers' money.
On that occasion I also drew attention to and asked the Minister to deal with, which he failed to do, the situation that on 16th July, 1974, a resolution was passed at an extraordinary general meeting of the company increasing the authorised capital from £100 to £1 million. That resolution was not filed until more than 18 months after the date of its passing, although there is an obligation in section 143 of the Companies Act to file it within 15 days. Subsection (5) of that Act states that a criminal offence is committed by failure to file within 15 days. It states:
If the company fails to comply with subsection (1) the company and every officer of the company who is in default shall be liable to a fine not exceeding £50.
This matter has not been dealt with by the Minister, though he has given us to believe over a long period that the company in which he will get a 24 per cent interest with more than £9½ million of the taxpayers' money are a company admirable in every way. In view of the statements he has made today about the filing of these documents, which presumably was done after information from some source or other, I ask the Minister how he reconciles this with the non-availability of the documents and the non-availability of the file in the last two or three weeks.
I have often made searches of Companies Offices in regard to ordinary companies, and have never found this sort of cloak and dagger mystery. You go in, you get the file, you put it back and that is it. But it is almost as hard to get the file on Bula Limited as to get the secret agreement of 12th November, 1975. When it was got less than a fortnight ago by a reputable firm of law researchers in this city the documents to which the Minister referred and which he said on the last occasion were filed on 24th January, and which he said today were filed some weeks ago and are now on file, were not on file. That was the position again this morning.
We are now told that in the 1976 return, which we were not told about at all last week and which must have been got together in a great hurry because of what I disclosed to the House last week, discloses indebtedness on foot of mortgages and charges of £3.91 million. That is a very substantial amount of money. If that company file with that information had been available to the various advisers and to the arbitrators we might have ended up with a very different result. It is a serious matter that if the Minister's statement that these documents have been filed in the last few weeks is correct it would prima facie appear to be a breach of the law.
I am aware from practice that small companies in a small way of business, without the assistance of the considerable high grade professional advice available to this company, often default, that they forget to put in an annual return sometimes and that they have to be reminded by the registrar, but it does not happen to companies of which the secretary is a solicitor, in which the capital is £1 million and in which the liabilities, as declared in the annual return exceed £3 million and where, presumably, the assets are fairly considerable. It does not happen normally with such companies, and one is entitled to ask why it has happened in this company and why it is so difficult for a citizen to exercise his right in the Companies Office, given to him under the Companies Act, to inspect the file.
The other matter I raised and that the Minister knew nothing about last week—he did not appear to have heard of the company at all—was the involvement of Haras el Chorro, SA, which in French would mean Societié Anonymie, but I think this is Spanish. I could not follow what the Minister told us about that company—as far as I can remember he did not tell us anything. I think he told us they had sold the surface land to Bula Limited, but apparently not the minerals. I am no linguist but I assume the name of that company to be Spanish. The reason for that assumption is that I understand the company are registered in Panama, which is an unusual place for a company to be registered who own land, or owned land, whichever the position is, in Ireland. Financially speaking, Panama is one of those mysterious little countries used for the most part not by the citizens of Panama but by the rich citizens of many other nations for the purpose of carrying on what are known as offshore operations. The whole point of using a Panamanian registered company is bound up with what we should delicately call taxation affairs.
I have not come across a Panamanian country owning land or minerals in Ireland but possibly there is some other Panamanian country which does. The interests of Haras el Chorro, SA, are widespread; they are not confined to land in Meath in Ireland. My attention was drawn to the edition of Tattersall's catalogue of 29th September, 1976. A yearling was offered as lot 460, a chesnut filly by Ridan out of Narrow Escape described in the catalogue as being the property of our old friends Haras el Chorro, SA. It is a company with widespread interests throughout the world. I want the Minister to tell me its exact connection with Bula.
According to the returns in the Companies Office there is an agreement of 17th February, 1975 between Bula and Haras el Chorro, SA. I want to know—and I feel I am entitled to know—the nature and effect of that agreement. I understood the Minister to say that the surface land appeared to have been sold to Bula and that there was some other arrangement about the minerals but in order to try to clarify that I looked up in the Land Registry folio 26646 County Meath, which is the folio mentioned in relation to Haras el Chorro, SA, to find out had they sold the land to Bula and the position relating to the minerals. It appears that Haras el Chorro, SA are registered on that folio still and there is a reference there to the mineral rights. The registration extends to the mines and minerals other than minerals of gold, silver and petroleum within the meaning of Part II of the Petroleum and Other Minerals Development Act. The entry in relation to minerals was registered on the folio on 1st April, 1976. It would seem, if my reading of this is correct, that the folio is owned by this Panamanian company and that all the minerals other than gold, silver and petroleum are owned by it also.
There is a curious entry in No. 2 relating to the charge of the Northern Bank by a mortgage dated 30th September, 1976. It refers to the lands comprised in the folio but excludes the mines and minerals on or under the said lands. It also refers to the estate, right, title and interest referred to in the agreement dated 17th February, 1975, between Haras el Chorro, SA, and the company therein described as the estate, right and title of the vendors to any minerals. It seems to me that Haras el Chorro, SA on the basis of this have mortgaged their interest in the minerals to the Northern Bank Finance Corporation. I cannot understand otherwise how the reference to the right, title and interest of the vendors in and to any minerals under the lands can be explained.
These are matters about which the Minister has had a full week to find the answers. One would have expected a great deal more information than the very skimpy information which we were, in fact, given. We are not at all clear as to the position in relation to this company which is registered, so far as I know, in Panama. One assumes that it is not owned by Irish citizens; perhaps Irish citizens have some interest in it. Perhaps it is an offshore asset stripping operation. I do not know. One cannot form any definite conclusions about it on the basis of the very inadequate information given by the Minister but I think one should continue to ask that sufficient information be given so that we can ascertain the exact position in relation to the company. The Minister has an obligation to give further and better information than he has done and to explain fully what the dealings were with this company, why they were carried out and why this company is still referred to in this charge on the land of the Northern Bank Finance Corporation. Also, we are entitled to ask in the circumstances for a copy of the agreement of 17th February, 1975, between Bula and Haras el Chorro, SA.
Comment on this
I want to intervene briefly on one point raised by Deputy O'Malley. He made reference to the guarantee. The Deputy has not got the agreement for reasons which have been made clear and which he does not accept; both sides understand exactly the position of the other without accepting it. The Deputy's suggestion that the guarantee is of very little value is based on the assumption that the contract which he has not seen would have been drafted in a very slipshod way. All I can say to the Deputy and to the House is that it would be a very serious error if an agreement was drafted which contained a guarantee which turned out to be of very little value to the Minister and I think it would be wrong for the House to assume that such a basic error was made.
I do not wish to intervene in matters which the Minister has dealt with but I want to raise a general matter which has reference to a point Deputy O'Malley made, that is, the position when the State is buying into a private company, as will be done if and when this Bill becomes law. When the State buys into a private company, that company will have entered into all manner of transactions and I think it would be extremely wrong that the company in which the State is taking a stake should be required to publicise its commercial transactions. I think it would mean that it would be extremely difficult for the State to carry out an operation such as has been carried out under the present legislation. Members may differ as to whether or not this is desirable. Members may differ as to whether or not it is a good idea for the State to buy into private companies in the mineral area or otherwise, but assuming it is a good idea and assuming it is a good idea for the State to take a shareholding, particularly in mineral development, immense difficulties would be raised in future in the operation of such a policy if at any time suggestions were made that such a company was subject to, shall I say, the threat that its private dealings would be made public.
It seems to me, therefore, to be unreasonable that the Opposition should require the Minister to ask the company whose shares he is purchasing to produce its private agreements. What the Minister has done is to indicate to the House the nature of the particular transaction. The nature of that particular transaction is, of course, now known and it is wrong to suggest that the actual agreement itself should be produced. Generally speaking, Members should know—certainly Deputy O'Malley should know—that when a sale is being closed all the transactions in relation to the particular company are examined. Whilst it is true that a private company has a statutory obligation to file its accounts, the purchaser of shares, while concerned about the viability of the company, is not primarily concerned with whether or not the company carries out its statutory obligation. What he is concerned about is whether he is getting a good bargain. These are matters taken into account when the sale is being closed and certainly anything in reference to the accounts of the company are matters which are examined very carefully when the sale is being closed. Deputy O'Malley may, if he wants to, comment on a company which has delayed filing its accounts. I suppose he is entitled to make his comments, but I do not think that affects the decision of the House in relation to this particular section.
Comment on this
There are two matters to which I wish to refer. The first is the filing of the accounts. I note what my colleague, the Attorney General, has just said, but I must say I certainly do not condone the failure of any company to submit its returns on time. That being so, I believe the position is, as the Deputy well knows, that a high proportion of private companies are not as prompt in submitting their accounts as they should be. This failure is due to a number of causes. Deputy Colley made reference to these last week—illness, pressure of work and so on. I am quite sure none of the Members opposite would suggest there is anything exceptional or remotely sinister about delay in having returns submitted. I do not condone delays and the Registrar of Companies quite rightly takes a serious view of such delays.
Deputy O'Malley dealt with some dates and some words of mine. May I now be quite clear about this? What I said was that the returns were lodged on January 24th. I understand that normally returns are processed and filed within ten days but, due to shortage of staff and for a number of apparently valid reasons, there is now a longer delay between the lodge ment and the filing. If Deputies consult the Official Report they will see that the word I used was "lodged".
Comment on this
The reference is column 88 of Volume 297 of 22nd February: "I should like to say something about the return to Bula Limited". That "to" should be "of". "I understand the returns for 1974 and 1975 were lodged on 24th January of this year". That is information I believe to be correct and I repeat it now. I have pointed out that as between lodgment and filing there is an interval.
Comment on this
Before the Minister leaves that, he will appreciate we are now at 1st March and the filing has not apparently taken place yet.
Comment on this
I regret that. I am not in a position to comment on whether what the Deputy says is right or whether it is not, but the situation is as I have said: normally between the lodging and the filing there is ten days for stamping. I said that due to reasons of illness and other difficulties in the Office of the Registrar——
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware these documents are stamped in advance before they are lodged, or filed, as the correct word is?
Comment on this
I am making a distinction between lodging and filing and I say the delay is now longer than the ten days. That is the reason for the difficulty in obtaining these documents. I understand they are now filed.
I want to deal now with Haras el Chorro, SA, if the Deputy wants more of it. He knows that since 1970 Haras el Chorro are the registered owners of the lands known as the Kruger lands and that there has been a stud farm and other sorts of farming carried on there. The point is these lands were essential as support lands. First, we have to have an idea of where tailings can be and secondly, there was the question of the diversion of the river. Both were relevant and it was essential that these support lands for the Bula mining project should be acquired. These lands were there beside the Wright farm and they were necessary for the development of the mine. These lands were secured by Bula under a contract arrangement. That is the essence of it.
I hope that is clarification because this was a contract for the acquisition of the lands which were essential for the mine. It does not relate to the working of the mine in its underground sense; it simply relates to a servicing area for it. I know that Bula could not have had a choice with regard to the adjoining people. They could not have had a choice with regard to the registered owners of the land, the so-called Kruger lands. That was as it happened. They were correct and they were prudent in seeing that the land was secure. That is the story and there is no mystery or drama there. Had the registered owner of what are known as the Kruger lands been an Irish farmer—this might just as well have occurred; it was a matter of chance that it was Haras el Chorro, SA and not a local farmer with a more normal name that would give rise to less surprise—there would not have been any comment at all.
Comment on this
Is it the position that Bula have purchased the surface land of what are called the Kruger lands?
Comment on this
My understanding about the minerals is that it is not a geological interesting area. The people disposing of the land argued as follows: if by any chance there turned out to be a mineral interest—this is not anticipated—there was some other arrangement which could be made with regard to reimbursement about minerals. The particular interest is not a mineral interest; it is an interest in relation to the surface availability of the surface land.
Comment on this
It is Mr. Kruger's interest that is involved. I am not clear as to the status of the minerals. I know that the need, the interest and the reason for the exclusion here is that the requirement is a requirement of service land and, therefore, of the surface of it. This would be seen as a perfectly normal transaction if it were a local farmer who was involved; the comments of the newspapers originated because of the name of the company. That was something that existed long before decisions were taken by this Government or by the Opposition when they were in office with regard to the matter.
Comment on this
The folio concerned would appear to indicate from what I understand that this company became registered not in 1970 but on 1st June, 1972, that is approximately 18 months after the discovery of the existence of the orebody beside it or beneath it. The Minister has said that a contract exists for the purchase of the surface of these lands but not of the minerals under them. From the folio concerned it does not appear that the purchase has been completed because so far as one can see this Panamanian company is already the owner of the land. Under the Registration of Title Act, 1964, any form of trust of this nature is not enforceable as against the registered owner. The Registrar of Titles is entitled to deal with the registered owner who appears to be this Panamanian company.
If I were purchasing into this company it seems to me I would have to insist that they would become registered as owners and they are in a very weak position at the moment without that. I am not clear about the area of land involved. I understand it is sizeable and I presume the price is sizeable also. It is a pity that the whole thing is so vague and so highly unusual.
The Minister is not right in saying that if this were an ordinary Irish farmer with an ordinary Irish name it would not appear unusual. What attracted my attention to the very extraordinary nature of the transaction —and the more I hear of it the more extraordinary it seems to become— is the provision that the lands in this folio are charged to the Northern Bank Finance Corporation but the mines and minerals on and under the lands are excluded and exempted.
It is extraordinary for a mining company, or what hopes to be a mining company, buying land immediately beside what it hoped will be its mine not to buy the minerals if they are there. The Minister is not aware whether they are State minerals. Has he made any attempt to make an acquistion order in relation to these minerals? Without going into the history of the mineral title, on the face of it I would say that the likely ownership of these minerals is different from the ownership of what was originally the Wright minerals. It appears from these documents that Mr. Wright's land was not registered land. It was not registered in the Land Registry and, therefore, it did not go through the Land Commission. Therefore, the opportunity of the Land Act, 1903, and subsequent Acts vesting the minerals in the State did not arise.
In the Haras el Chorro land, the property is registered in the Land Registry. One assumes that some time before 1972 when this Panamanian company came to Ireland the property had been vested in the Land Commission and was revested by them in whoever was the tenant under the Land Acts. If that were done the normal provision would be to retain the minerals for the State. There has been a great deal of discussion here about the fact that Mr. Wright's minerals were privately owned. The Minister failed to make a second acquisition order to acquire them and he did not make an acquisition order for anyone else's minerals in that area. Apparently he did not make one for Haras el Chorro's minerals. For some extraordinary reason they have been allowed to retain their minerals even though they are next door to a mine in which the Irish taxpayer is buying a 24 per cent interest and receiving a further 25 per cent. That seems to be another extraordinary fact of this saga. We have in Panamanian ownership the minerals of an extensive farm that are under the lands owned under contract by the company in which the Irish taxpayer is to get 49 per cent at a high cost. Why did the Minister not make a mineral acquisition order in relation to these minerals? If they are in Panamanian ownership, why should they be left in it? One assumes from what the Minister has said that they must be privately owned. He explained that there was a division between the sale of the surface land and the minerals. The Panamanian owners want to maintain an interest in the minerals in case they become valuable. They have a much better chance of becoming valuable next door to the Navan orebody than if they were elsewhere.
In these circumstances, would the Minister not make an acquisition order under the 1940 Act in relation to this holding and other holdings on that side of the river? The Bula part of the orebody extends beyond what was originally the Wright farm to other lands which they have bought. Because these are registered land folios one assumes that some of them must be State minerals and that the others might be easier to acquire than the Wright minerals. What is the State's position in relation to those non-Wright minerals, including the Panamanian minerals, if the mining operation continues? The State owns some of those other minerals. Why are we not getting royalties? Why are we not getting paid for them? I should like the Minister to answer those questions?
Comment on this
The existence of workable minerals in relation to Haras el Chorro has not been established. There is an assumption about minerals which one would need to know more about before considering any procedure. If they are State minerals, they are State minerals, and that is the end of it.
Comment on this
Why are these companies making charges, mortgages and agreements? It does not indicate that the State has acquired them?
Comment on this
I doubt that an astute body like the Northern Bank Finance Corporation would take mortgages and charges on minerals from someone if they did not have title to give. Banks employ lawyers who spend their time investigating titles to property which is offered as security for loans and on which the banks want to register charges. They do not lend money or register charges unless they are satisfied that the mortgagor has the title to do it. If the mortgagor did not have the title, the bank would not acquire any valid security. In this Bill the company are referred to as mortgagors. No mortgage seems to be registered on the folio and there is no change of ownership in respect of the surplus lands.
Comment on this
There are subdivisions and subletting charges and there is one about gold, silver and petroleum.
Comment on this
Not on the Haras el Chorro folio. I am talking about a charge in the Companies Office on the company, a legal mortgage and debenture. It recites the agreement of 17th February. I must confess that the information given to us by the Minister in regard to it is not helpful. Would the Minister not agree with me that, if there are minerals which could be acquired by the State in the immediate vicinity of this land, the State should exercise its rights and should not allow a private company to use them? If the State owns them—and the State must own some of them—why do we leave them in Panamanian ownership?
Comment on this
How is it relevant to this section whether or not the Minister exercises rights in regard to other land?
Comment on this
How is it relevant to the purchase of shares in a company whether the Minister has State minerals next door or whether he is right or wrong in acquiring them? I do not see how these provisions are relevant to section 2. The point I am making is that I would express the hope, which would be shared by many Deputies, that the activities which are being undertaken by the Minister in this area will be continued in the future; that in the future the State will take a more active role in the development of our minerals and will give effect to that role by different means, one of which would be the purchase of shares in private companies. If that role is to be played, it is important that the State does not see to it by what it does in this instance or in other instances that private companies will fail to deal with the State.
What we are dealing with here is a situation where a private company has entered into a contract with a neighbour for the purchase of land. That is what this is about. The Minister has explained to the Dáil what is the nature of the contract arising from the information sought by the Deputy last week. That having been given, it is then a matter for the Minister's advisers to see that the shares being bought have not in any way been affected by any transaction undertaken either before or since the contract was entered into. The debate in this House has arisen to a great extent because Deputies are objecting to the fact that they cannot see the agreement. However, that matter having been debated at great length and the Minister having explained the position, the situation now is that we are dealing with a section which is making provision for the purchase of shares in a company which, of course, has entered into many transactions. It would be extremely unreasonable for this Dáil to be asked to ask the company whose shares the Minister is buying to produce details of all these transactions.
The Minister has gone, I think, as far as is reasonably necessary to indicate what the nature of this transaction is. Whether the Minister takes further action in relation to his rights under the 1940 Act in this neighbouring farm or another farm is surely a matter that has nothing to do with this Bill.
Comment on this
The matter is not quite as simple as the Attorney General seems to think or, which may be more accurate, as he would like to present it. We are told that there was a simple contract between Bula Limited and Haras el Chorro, SA for the sale of the adjoining surface land needed for the development of the mine, but there is no explanation why that agreement is still an agreement rather than a completed transaction which is registered and gives that ownership to Bula Limited. It is easy to lose sight in all of this of the fact that the purpose of this Bill is to pay nearly £10 million of the taxpayer's money to four individuals for a share in Bula Limited.
It would appear from some entries in the file in the Companies Office that this is not a simple contract for the sale of the surface land; in fact, it is a reference to what appears to be Bula Limited as a mortgagor. If there is some transaction between Bula Limited and Haras el Chorro, SA which involves not just a contract for the purchase by Bula Limited of the surface land owned by Haras el Chorro, SA but a more complicated agreement which involves some form of borrowing by Bula Limited from Haras el Chorro, SA —and that would appear to be the explanation of the reference to a mortgagor in this agreement—then of course this can have a bearing on the value of the shares being purchased.
I think we are entitled to ask, is the transaction such that it should, on the one hand, increase the value of what is being acquired by the Minister or, on the other hand, decrease that value? It is not at all clear what the position is, and I think it is not unreasonable that we should ask for some details as to what is involved here.
The Minister was making the point that it has not been established at all that there are any worthwhile minerals involved under the Kruger lands. That may be so, but I would suggest that there is at least as good a chance of the discovery of worthwhile minerals under the lands as there is of the discovery of oil wells in the waters off the western coast of this country, a factor which recently the Minister was indicating presented a very good opportunity for this country. It may be, and we all hope it is; nevertheless, I would suggest that on the basis of existing information, if you are trying to sell your chances on an oil well in the waters off the western coast, on the one hand, or, on the other hand, the chances of minerals being found in this land adjoining the Navan orebody, I think you would find an easier market for the minerals hopefully adjoining the known Navan orebody.
Therefore the question of what is involved in this transaction in so far as it relates to Bula and in so far as it affects either the potential assets of Bula Limited or the liabilities of Bula Limited, these are matters that ought to be disclosed to the House. Of course, an inquiry of this nature does involve the disclosure of the business of private companies—two private companies in this case. A lot of the information which was being sought was information which statutorily should have been disclosed anyway under the Companies Act, but was not, but in so far as the inquiries seeking information go beyond what is required to be statutorily disclosed, I am afraid that is one of the hazards that face a private individual or a private company that deals with the State, and in particular a private company that deals with the State and proposes to sell a minority of its shareholding for very substantial money to the State. It may be unfortunate but I suggest it is quite unrealistic to put a proposition to the House that any Government can come in here and propose to spend money, as is proposed to be spent here, close to £10 million, on a minority investment in a private company, and expect at the same time that there will be no inquiry on the part of the Members of this House or of the other House into the affairs of that private company. Of course there must be.
If the Minister were investing his own personal money in this, then the proposition being put forward would be a reasonable one, a matter entirely for him, but it is not his personal money; it is the taxpayer's money. It may be unfortunate and it may lead to difficulties; in some cases it may lead to a certain amount of inefficiency. However, when you are dealing with the taxpayer's money, then you must face the fact that there is a degree of accountability required which is not required if you are dealing with your own money. You may not like it but it is a fact, and anybody involved in such a transaction knows that is so. It is not something directed against the private individual or the private companies concerned. It is a natural corollary that follows from dealing with the State, particularly in regard to large amounts of money.
Consequently, the inquiries being made as to the precise nature of the relationship between Bula Limited and Haras el Chorro, SA, are in accordance with the principle I have been trying to enunciate. I do not think we should either seek or be given any information in regard to Haras el Chorro which is not relevant to their relationship with Bula, but we ought to be given all the information that is relevant to their relationship with Bula, information, as I said earlier, in relation to the potential increase in the value of the assets of Bula or, alternatively, to the actual or potential increase in the liabilities of Bula.
Broadly speaking what the Minister has said is that there is a contract for the sale of the surface land owned by Haras el Chorro. On the face of it the information on the file of Bula and referred to by Deputy O'Malley does not bear out what the Minister has said. Therefore I would ask him to clarify the nature of the agreement between the two companies: how does a reference to Bula Limited as a mortgagor arise in the file in the Companies Office in relation to their transactions with Haras el Chorro? What is the nature of that mortgage or debenture, if it is a debenture, which leads to this situation?
The reference in the Companies Office file is to particulars of a charge created by Bula and which is described here as legal mortgage. It is dated 30th September, 1976, and is between Bula Limited as the one part and the Northern Finance Corporation as the other part. It is securing all sums due or to become due by Bula Limited, both principal and interest, to the Northern Finance Corporation on any account whatsoever. But then the property is described as all that comprised in the agreement dated 17th February, 1975, made between Haras el Chorro, SA, and the mortgagor of the other part. That mortgage covers the lands comprised in Folio 26646 County Meath: but excluding and excepting thereout the mines and minerals on and under the said lands. It goes on to describe particulars of the property charged as all the estate, right, title and interest referred to in paragraph 1 of the agreement dated 17th February, 1975, and made between Haras el Chorro and the mortgagor.
One can interpret this in a number of ways. I do not wish to waste the time of the House speculating on it if the Minister will tell us what is involved in the relationship between Bula and Haras el Chorro. The Minister will appreciate this is just an indirect version because it refers apparently to a mortgage or charge by Bula in favour of the Northern Finance Corporation Limited of lands they have acquired or are in the process of acquiring from Haras el Chorro. If the Minister would clarify the nature of the agreement between the two companies it would help to clear up some of the questions that arise and not all of which we have put yet. The Minister's explanation of the situation has been that what is involved is a simple agreement for the acquisition by Bula Limited of surface land. That would not appear to be a sufficient explanation to give any rational meaning to the increase under the heading quoted in the file of Bula Limited in the Companies Office.
Comment on this
I rise briefly to make this point. I sought to suggest to the Deputy that the points he was making were not relevant to the Bill but he says they are relevant. The Deputy seems to be asking the House to do the impossible—to decide on the value of the shares of which the House is authorising purchase. The shares have been valued by an independent arbitrator and the basis on which the Minister has come to the House is that he is purchasing something which has been the subject of independent arbitration. When fixing shares the arbitrator takes into account the underlying assets of the company. One of these is the contract to which reference has been made. To suggest that it is the nature of the contract that is relevant is not to answer the point I made, which was that it seems to me that the Minister had indicated the nature of the contract. This is a contract which was taken into account when the valuation of the shares was being fixed. The Dáil is being asked in this section to authorise payment for these shares. It would appear that the other matters to which the Deputy refers are not relevant. Mainly what he is asking the House to do is to value the shares.
Comment on this
Happily the situation is not as simple as the Attorney General would wish it to be. Perhaps the Minister could reconcile his description of this arrangement with the Panamanian company as being a simple straightforward acquisition deal which would create no notice if the company happened to be Irish—with the statement of the managing director of Bula which was issued either during or immediately after the debate here on Tuesday last and in which he said that the agreement represents the deferred payment mortgage arrangement and that payment was to continue for a period for whatever they were buying. Mr. Wymes did not go on to specify how much the payment should be or to say what exactly was the nature of the transaction.