Local Government (Water Pollution) Bill, 1976 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–141 of 296. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 4 of 1976 ›
Amendments Nos. 2 and 14 are cognate with amendment No. 1. Consequently I suggest that we debate those three amendments together, having separate decisions if necessary.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 2, line 16, to delete "1974" and substitute "1976".
The enactment of the Fisheries (Amendment) Act, 1976, which became law following the passing of this Bill by the Seanad necessitates the amendment of the collective citation of the Fisheries Acts where it occurs in sections 1 and 3 of the Bill. These three amendments provide accordingly.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 4, 5 and 7 are consequential on amendment No. 3 and No. 50 is related also. Therefore I suggest that we take these amendments together with provision for separate decisions if required.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 3:
In page 2, to delete lines 22 to 28, and substitute the following: "‘local authority' (except in section 25 (5) (b)), means—
(a) in the case of the administrative county of Dublin, excluding the borough of Dún Laoghaire, the council of the county of Dublin,
(b) in the case of the borough of Dún Laoghaire, the corporation of the borough,
(c) in the case of a county borough, the corporation of the county borough, and
(d) in the case of any other administrative county, the council of the county,
and, where the context permits, includes a water quality control authority established under section 25, and references to the functional area of a local authority shall be construed accordingly;".
I have put down amendments Nos. 3, 7 and 50 in order to give effect to the intention of Deputy Dockrell's amendments Nos. 4 and 5 which relate to the inclusion of Dún Laoghaire Corporation in the definition of local authority in section 1. I would point out that the Deputy's amendments would not achieve this objective fully. I am sure that in the circumstances Deputy Dockrell will be prepared to withdraw the amendments.
I accept that there are many precedents for grouping the Borough of Dún Laoghaire for various purposes with the four county boroughs and I see no objection to making similar provision in this case. Amendment No. 3 provides accordingly. Amendments Nos. 7 and 50, which deal respectively with the definition of "reserved function" and expences are consequential amendments of a purely technical nature.
Comment on this
I do not understand why there should be specific provision for Dún Laoghaire. Is it not covered by "county borough"?
Comment on this
Is there any other borough in the country which is not a county borough but which has the status of Dún Laoghaire?
Comment on this
It is included in a peculiar way. Dún Laoghaire Borough covers its own area while Drogheda is covered by Louth County Council so that there is no necessity for providing for Drogheda. There is a difference in size as well as everything else.
Comment on this
While I appreciate that there is no problem with Drogheda or with any of the other boroughs in this respect, I understood that Dún Laoghaire was known always to be a county borough and consequently would be included under the specific provision in that area which refers to county boroughs.
Comment on this
Dún Laoghaire is in a very different position from other boroughs and urban districts. Its population—53,171 in 1971—is 65 per cent greater than that of Waterford County Borough and is almost as large as Limerick. Dún Laoghaire Corporation provide practically all the local government services in the borough and in some instances provide a service for a large area of the county—for example, the fire service. Virtually no services are provided by Dublin County Council in the borough. This is borne out by the fact that the amount of county at large charges contributed by Dún Laoghaire Corporation is very small. It amounted to slightly more than 1 per cent of the total revenue expenditure in 1973-74 compared with an average of more than 27 per cent for all other boroughs and urbans. It will be seen, then, that there are special circumstances affecting Dún Laoghaire. It is almost a separate entity and for that reason it was decided to make a separate case for it.
Comment on this
We have no objection to that. I merely wished to be told what was the situation. What is the position in regard to the city of Dublin?
Comment on this
Amendment No. 37 is consequential on amendment No. 6. I suggest that the two amendments be debated together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 6:
In page 2, between lines 31 and 32, to insert the following:
"‘monitoring' includes inspection, measurement, sampling or analysis, whether periodically or continuously;".
The term "monitoring" which is used in sections 4 (5) (b), 16 (4) (b) and 22 (1) (a) of the Bill is open to a number of interpretations and it is considered necessary to define it. The definition proposed by amendment No. 6 includes the various activities, such as inspection, measurement, sampling and analysis, coming within the meaning of the term as used in the Bill in relation to water pollution.
Comment on this
Why since we are defining the word "monitoring" do we not define it in toto? Is there any reason for this? It states here that monitoring includes such activities as inspection, measurement, sampling and analysis, whether periodically or continuously. The word “includes” indicates that there is something else involved. I am wondering whether the Minister is depending on the definition of the word “monitoring” in some other Act.
Comment on this
The word "monitoring" is taken as having the normal meaning but some people might argue that the words we are including in this amendment might not be included in the normal meaning. In order to prevent any misunderstanding it was decided that those words should be included. The draftsman, no more than ourselves, has not been able to think of any other wording which would be considered necessary to include here. We are merely ensuring that there will be no loopholes.
Comment on this
There is nothing unusual in this. In a number of previous Acts interpretations have been added to words in order to ensure their inclusion.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 7:
In page 2, line 43, after "a county" to insert "or the Corporation of Dún Laoghaire".
Comment on this
I note here that the word "person" is used in a number of instances, for example, in section 3, subsection (1).
Comment on this
I am referring to the possibility of the need for a definition of "person". Section 3 says:
Subject to subsection (5), a person shall not cause or permit any polluting matter to enter waters.
(2) A person who contravenes subsection (1) shall be guilty of an offence . . .
The same applies to section 4, section 5 and so on. What does "person" mean here? Does "person" mean more than an individual? Could it mean a corporate body or a statutory body? Is there a need in section 1 for a definition of the word "person"?
Comment on this
I would refer Deputy Faulkner to the legal interpretation in the Interpretation Act, 1937.
The word "person" shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as importing a body corporate (whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole) and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual.
Comment on this
Do I take it that interpretation applies in this Bill irrespective of the fact that that interpretation does not appear in this Bill?
Comment on this
Board of conservators is interpreted as meaning a board of conservators under the Fisheries Act, 1959 to 1974 and includes the Foyle Fisheries Commission. In the event of a board of conservators being dissolved, which is the present position in some areas in this country, do we take it that those who are acting on behalf of the board of conservators are included here?
Comment on this
If it was intended to do that, an Act would have to be passed in this House and provision would have to be made in the Act to provide for that.
Comment on this
Do we take it that whoever would be acting on the part of the board of conservators is included here?
Comment on this
In the definition of "polluting matter" is "recreational uses" broad enough? Would it include swimming?
Comment on this
Yes. "Polluting matter" includes any poisonous or noxious matter and any matter which would render the water harmful or detrimental to public health or to domestic, commercial, industrial, agricultural or recreational uses. Recreational uses would include swimming. The main significance of the term as used in the Bill relates to the prohibition in section 3 on causing or permitting any polluting matter to enter waters. This prohibition will have fairly limited application. It will not apply to trade or sewage effluent. The term is also used in sections 12, 13 and 14.
Comment on this
I was mainly concerned that the word "recreational" should be absolutely clear. I am glad to hear that it covers all forms of recreation including swimming.
Comment on this
I cannot understand how it would not cover swimming. The Deputy can be assured that it includes all forms of recreation.
Comment on this
I note here that
"tidal waters" includes the sea and any estuary up to high water mark medium tide and any enclosed dock adjoining tidal waters.
It is a pity that the responsibility in relation to this whole question of water pollution is divided. I know that is not the Minister's fault. A Bill came before the Seanad recently in relation to pollution at sea. It is a pity that we should have a situation where we are dealing with all inland waters plus the coastal waters, estuaries and so on but that another Minister is dealing with the question of pollution at sea. When this Bill on sea water pollution was issued, there was no explanatory memorandum and everybody immediately assumed that it was a matter for me on this side of the House.
Comment on this
I cannot agree with Deputy Faulkner. The Minister for Transport and Power will only deal with discharges from vessels at sea and the responsibility for discharges from pipes and anything on land will be the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government. "Tidal waters" has been defined and the main significance of the definition is to define a line below which discharges from vessels and marine structures will be excluded from the general prohibition in section 3. It would be a pity if we did not define the responsibility of the two Ministers. The Bill deals with the matter very adequately.
Comment on this
I am not concerned with the definition. I accept that it is all right. I am concerned with the fact that the responsibility should be divided. When the Bill in relation to pollution at sea was introduced in the Seanad, it was immediately assumed on this side of the House that it was also the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government. We had felt that the problems in regard to the purity of water and pollution of water should be the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government. I have no real objection to the definition.
Comment on this
I would not like Deputy Faulkner to get the impression or to give the impression that there was some sort of derogation of duty on the part of either Minister in this case. The matter is very clearly defined and it is my responsibility as laid down in the Act. The other Bill to which the Deputy has referred deals very clearly with an entirely different matter and while there is co-ordination between the two Departments this is not the only thing in which there has to be delineation between the local government authority and the transport and power authority on many matters dealing with the sea. The arrangements made in this and in the other Bill are more than adequate to ensure that nobody will escape.
Comment on this
I was basically concerned with the fact that I felt that this whole question of pollution of water should be the responsibility of the Minister for Local Government or of one Minister. We can agree to differ on that. Were EEC regulations in relation to monitoring taken into consideration when the definition was prepared?
Comment on this
Yes. Dún Laoghaire is included. I put in a special amendment in relation to Dún Laoghaire Borough.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 9 is an alternative to amendment No. 8 and therefore, these two amendments may be discussed together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 8:
In page 4, between lines 7 and 8, to insert the following subsection:
"(8) The Council shall in each year make a report to the Minister of its activities during the preceding year, and the Minister shall cause copies of the report to be laid before each House of the Oireachtas."
I put down this amendment to meet as far as I can amendment No. 9. It proposes that the Water Pollution Advisory Council be required to make a report to the Minister each year of its activities in the preceding year and that the Minister shall cause copies of the report to be laid before each House of the Oireachtas. A procedure on these lines is the more usual one adopted in regard to reports by bodies of this nature. I trust that the amendment is acceptable to Deputies J. O'Leary and Faulkner and will enable them to withdraw amendment No. 9.
Comment on this
The Minister has come more than half way to meet our amendment with his, but he should include in his amendment the word "recommendation". The amendment then would read: "The Council shall in each year make a report to the Minister of its activities during the preceding year and its recommendations . . . ". In any annual report there should be more than statistics and figures and a summary of the workings of the committee of the council for the previous year. It should also include any recommendations which that council or committee make during the previous year. In other words, if there is to be any informed discussion as a result of an annual report that report should include the recommendations made by the council.
Comment on this
We are, perhaps, playing a bit with words. I understand what Deputy O'Leary is trying to do but a report must include recommendations. Apart from its departure from the usual formula in regard to the reports by such bodies, amendment No. 9 is unduly specific in regard to publication of recommendations of the council. It might inhibit the council from making recommendations if they had to be published in full. There is even the possibility that the Minister might find himself in a situation where he might have to consider not referring certain matters to the council; which would be unfortunate.
If an advisory body is to be useful it is best that full and frank exchanges of views should be the rule. Deputies will agree with this. If a specific requirement regarding recommendations is omitted, there will still be every likelihood that the council will give information in their report as to the recommendations since that would form an important part of their activities. I cannot see how they could make the report without including in it recommendations which they felt should be made. I would expect that recommendations of general public interest would be adequately covered. Some discretion should be left to the council, and in view of the composition of the council and the wide range of interests involved, I do not think that we need have any fear that their activities will not be adequately covered if they are required to produce an annual report.
I ask the Deputies not to press the point because I feel that those concerned are all intelligent people; they know what they were set up for and if they are doing their job, and I believe they are doing it well, they will include any recommendations they consider necessary in the report and that will be available. Therefore, I feel it is adequately covered.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy J. O'Leary that the Minister has come a considerable way to meet the point we made. I take it that we can expect that the recommendations, or at least some information in relation to the recommendations, will be made available in any report to the Minister which will be laid before the House.
It is well that the activities of the advisory council will be in the public eye. The fact that they will be in the public eye will be a spur to the council's activities. More important still, it would be very helpful to many of the bodies concerned about water pollution if they had access to the research and, to an extent, to the recommendations made by the council. This would help the activities of such bodies very considerably, firstly, by assisting them to protect the environment through the expert knowledge which would be made available to them. Also, and this is very important, the council's reports would give an opportunity to such bodies to assess in a factual rather than in an emotional way the dangers or otherwise to water supplies related to industrial development. At a time when we have such considerable numbers of people unemployed, it is vital that we should not lose an industry to purely emotional considerations. In those circumstances and in view of what the Minister has said about the likelihood of recommendations being available in the report which would be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas, we will withdraw our amendment and accept the Minister's.
Comment on this
I would regard the advisory council, as I am sure the Minister does, as a very important element in assisting in the control of water pollution. They would be expected to bring what I might term a new dimension to the advice being offered to the Minister. They will not be part of the civil service who normally advise him, nor will they be part of the purely professional individuals or groups who might be involved. That does not mean that we would be satisfied with a body of well-meaning amateurs who would regard it as their function simply to note and accept the suggestions, proposals or actions of the Minister and add a few innocuous pieces of advice. There is nothing wrong with the well-meaning. In fact, it is of considerable advantage to have people involved in this council who are and who have been deeply concerned with the enormous problems presented by water pollution.
Nor, indeed, is there anything wrong with them being amateurs at the outset. If this body are to do the very important work laid down for them and to give advice which will make a mark on water pollution problems, they must have every opportunity to develop their expertise and to have up-to-date knowledge and information on water pollution problems. Therefore, I would urge that every facility should be made available to the council to acquire the requisite knowledge and expertise so that their advice will be well-informed and useful.
I should like to know what the present temporary council are doing in this regard. I should like to know what facilities are available to them. Have they got a headquarters? How many times have they met? What contacts have they got with similar bodies abroad? Are they in contact with the Council of Europe, a body who have taken a particular interest in the whole question of water pollution, as well they might, because the problems facing many of our partners in the EEC in relation to water pollution are much greater than, fortunately, we have had to face to date? There is a lot to be learned from the activities not only of our partners in the EEC but also the activities of the members of the Council of Europe in relation to this matter.
A considerable amount of worth-while documentation is available to anybody who is interested. I have no doubt the advisory council will be in touch with them. I should also like to know whether or not any links have been forged between the advisory council and any similar type of body either in the EEC or in Britain. Some time ago we learned that salmon were being caught again in the Thames which had been so polluted that there was no fish life in it for a considerable number of years. Anything the British have learned in relation to this matter would be helpful to us in our endeavours to ensure that our waters are not polluted.
As I said, we are very fortunate that as yet the problem is relatively small and I emphasise the word "relatively". In this technological age with the development of industry and with the extended use of various fertilisers in the agricultural sphere we are becoming more and more in danger of pollution. We are fortunate in having the opportunity now of being able to forestall the type of problems which almost destroyed some waters in Britain and in Europe.
I should also like to know whether the council will have the right to call on expert knowledge at home, whether they are building a library to facilitate them in their work, and whether publications are available to them from abroad. As I said, the council are exceptionally important. I am pleased to note that their raison d'etre will be to devise means by which our waters can not only be cleaned but that cleanliness can be maintained. In this technological age this is an extremely important matter in relation to the health of our people.
Much will be expected from the advice tendered by this council to the Minister. I wish them well. They have a very important task ahead of them. I have no doubt they will carry out that task. It will be impossible for them to do so unless they are given the full backing, financial and otherwise, they will need. Both through publications and by going abroad themselves, they will have an opportunity of reviewing the methods which have proved successful in some instances.
Comment on this
I am sure Deputy Faulkner is aware that the Water Pollution Advisory Council, on an informal basis in advance of this legislation, were set up by me with the approval of the Government. Their inaugural meeting was held on 7th February, 1975. There is very wide representation on the council. During the preparation of this Bill they were very useful and most helpful in their advice. They have headquarters at the Custom House, Dublin. The necessary staff are provided by the Department of Local Government. Any publications they may require are made available to them. Any research they have required so far—and I should imagine in the future—has been provided, in the main, by the bodies represented on the council.
We have on the council the Confederation of Irish Industry, Bord Fáilte, the IFA, the National Youth Council, the Department of Local Government, the County and City Managers Association, the Trout Anglers Federation, the National Science Council, An Foras Forbartha, the Department of Health, the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards, the Institution of Engineers of Ireland, the Department of Agriculture, the General Council of County Councils, the Inland Fisheries Trust, the Electricity Supply Board, the Office of Public Works, An Foras Talúntais, the Department of Education, the Irish Federation of Sea Anglers, the Institute of Chemistry of Ireland, the Department of Fisheries, the Pharmaceutical Chemical and Allied Industries Association, An Taisce, the Institute of Biology of Ireland, the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association and the Industrial Development Authority.
I do not think there could be wider representation than that. They represent practically all that could be fitted into a reasonable council. They have been doing a good job. In the circumstances I cannot see where the fears Deputy Faulkner seems to have arise. On the question of travelling abroad, I do not think that arises at present. We will meet it if it does. Any information required can be obtained. Any documentation or books or publications they require can be made available. They co-operate with the Northern Ireland Council and attend meetings, as the Northern Ireland people attend meetings of the council in the Republic. That is the proper way to deal with this matter. They are doing a good job and they will continue to do a good job.
On the question of the salmon caught in the Thames, while I believe there has been a vast improvement, that is one salmon which has been caught so many times that it must be a little bit stale now.
Comment on this
I even heard it described as a minnow on one occasion. If there is any fish life in that river it is a good sign. I hope our people will be able to ensure that fish will be caught again in some of the rivers and lakes which have become pretty bad. They are improving and I am hoping that, within the next few years, we will be able to catch fish in any of our rivers and lakes.
Comment on this
I am very far from being critical of them. My purpose, and rightly so, is to ensure that whatever expertise is required by the council is made available to them and that the facilities which I have no doubt they will need are also made available to them. One of the most serious problems facing humanity today is the whole question of water pollution. It is such that we, who are in the fortunate situation that, relatively speaking, our problem is not as bad as it is in other more industrially developed countries, should ensure that nothing is spared to help a council such as this to provide the advice which is vitally essential to ensure that our water would not be polluted. It is not good enough to say that this council will have within themselves the means by which advice can be given; in other words, that they would have within themselves the expertise and basic knowledge which would be essential in a matter like this. There is no doubt that they will be able to provide quite a considerable amount of information that will be helpful to the Minister; nevertheless a certain expertise is essential which is available from areas where very serious water pollution obtained and where the problems in regard to it were overcome. It is essential that all this be made available to the council wherever it is needed. I am not being critical; I wish the council well but I want to ensure that whatever facilities are necessary and whatever financial provisions are needed will be made available to them so that the advice they will tender to the Minister will be of top quality.
Comment on this
I entirely agree with the proposal to set up this Water Pollution Advisory Council and I am glad to hear the Minister say that the committee which already exists is working very well. However, I think the section could be strengthened; there are many aspects of it with which I am not happy. The Water Pollution Advisory Council will have a vital role to play in the years immediately ahead. I presume the Minister has a good team of experts on this committee and that he will have a similar expert team on the water advisory council.
Advisory councils are common nowadays; we have one under the Wildlife Bill. Subsection (4) of this section says that the council will consist of such number of persons appointed for such period as the Minister thinks fit. Would it not be better to spell out the number of persons to be appointed? Does the Minister intend it to remain flexible so that he can add one or two who have a certain expertise in one field or another as he thinks fit? Subsection (6) says that the Minister may remove any member of the council from office. I think it is a bit severe to have this in the Bill. There are many arguments for and against it but I am against such a subsection. Can the Minister remove a member from office just because he does not like him? The conditions under which the Minister may remove a member from office should be stated in the section or else in regulations to be made under the Bill.
How will the Water Pollution Advisory Council stand in relation to An Foras Forbartha and the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards? Will these bodies act in an advisory capacity for the water advisory council? Will they be working for that council? Must the council accept their recommendations, ratify them and submit them to the Minister? Or can the Institute for Research and Standards and An Foras Forbartha submit their own independent reports directly to the Minister over the heads of the advisory council, so to speak? I sincerely hope there will not be a conflict of opinion with different recommendations going from these organisations to the Department against the recommendations submitted by the advisory council.
I presume the council will have available all EEC draft directives from the very first stages and that they will be in a position to make recommendations to the Minister as to any changes they think should be made in the draft directives if they think that the directives if implemented would not suit Irish conditions or could not be implemented at reasonable cost. If the council are to have teeth their recommendations should be made public. No Minister would have anything to fear from the publication of such recommendations. If he does not agree with the recommendations I am sure he will be able to justify his position and will not accept recommendations only for good and sufficient reasons which he can stand over publicly. I think the section could be strengthened considerably.
Comment on this
This Bill was passed through the Seanad and was very fully discussed there and it has passed through this House and has been fully discussed so far. We are now on Committee Stage and a number of amendments have been put down by the Deputy, by Deputy Faulkner and by myself. Deputy O'Leary now raises a matter which he says he thinks should be included in the Bill but which has not been mentioned so far. I do not think he can justify what he says. If he had listened to what I said earlier, I went pretty fully into the matters he has raised. First, as regards publication, the position is the recommendations will be placed before the Houses of the Oireachtas and if anybody here knows of a document placed before the Houses of the Oireachtas that did not appear in the newspapers, I should like him to tell me about it. Of course everybody will know what the recommendations contain.
As regards what An Foras Forbartha or the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards may do, they are represented on the council as I pointed out and their advice will be available to the council at first hand. All the necessary documentation is available to the council and any information or documentation which they may require from anywhere will be provided. That being so, I cannot see where Deputy O'Leary's fears arise because we have done everything to ensure that the council will be well armed. In regard to the removal or appointment of a member, one of the reasons why we have not mentioned a number is that we believe it is better to be flexible. At some time some organisation may arise which could give some very useful information. Some very useful information could be obtained from some organisations. As it stands at present it would be possible to add to the committee for the purpose of using that information.
With regard to the question of removal, the normal thing in all Acts is that the members are appointed "with the right of the Minister to remove". It is suggested that he can go around with a little hatchet and cut off the people he does not like. They would not be there if he did not like them or if he felt they would not be useful. As far as I can see, we have set up this committee in advance of the legislation and picked the people best qualified to serve on it. We have made provision in case some other organisations could be useful. They can get all the information they require. Their report will be made available to the Members of the Oireachtas and will be laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas.
I cannot see any sense in Deputy O'Leary's argument. All his points were adequately covered before we came into the House this morning. I thought I gave full information on all these points made by Deputy Faulkner and Deputy O'Leary. If they require any further information I will be glad to provide it. I do not think any of the fears expressed by Deputy O'Leary are likely to affect this Bill when it becomes law.
This Bill was introduced in the Seanad because we were anxious to get it made law as quickly as possible. The longer we delay it the longer we are preventing the necessary steps being taken. There are a few important amendments which must be fully discussed, and I think we are wasting time on matters which have already been fully discussed.
Comment on this
On and from the 15th of this month the new planning board will be in full operation. Will the recommendations the Water Pollution Advisory Council make to the Minister be binding on the new planning board and any decisions they may make?
Comment on this
Nothing will be binding on the new planning board. They will make their own decisions.
Comment on this
They would have to make that information available. As far as changing the planning board is concerned, you cannot do this because a certain organisation considers it is wrong. If we did that there would be no point in having a planning board. They have a very tough job and I would not like to tie them any tighter by saying they would be bound by decisions of outside bodies.
Comment on this
Despite the fact that the council will take into account the views of everybody concerned with water pollution, any recommendations they make should be binding on both county councils and the new planning board, especially in relation to water pollution. I agree the planning board will have a difficult task but I still feel that if a council such as the one being set up make recommendations to the Minister they should be acted upon both by the county councils and the new planning board.
Comment on this
This is an advisory council, not a statutory council to make laws. They will make recommendations. This is a different thing altogether. The recommendations must of course be taken into consideration by everybody, including the planning board, but they are not statutorily bound to accept them. In my opinion it would be wrong if they were.
Comment on this
As one who is suspicious of boards I admit that this is one of the most important ever set up particularly, as Deputy Faulkner said earlier, since pollution is rare here. We must industrialise the country. I read an article the other day which said that when you industrialise a country it cannot be as pollution-free as before You must make a choice—to create employment which is bound to lead to more pollution or to have a pollution-free countryside and unemployment. I know what my choice would be. The greater the population the more pollution we will have. If we had deserted villages we would be pollution-free. The reason we have very little pollution is that we were under foreign rule for a very long time and this was a holiday ground for an industrialised country.
We must control pollution and keep it to the minimum. This is a wide-ranging committee which should be able to do good work. The members must be experts. They must visit other countries. The Minister said he did not see any reason for this but in my view there is. I have great admiration for State companies but they are not doing enough to avoid pollution. I refer now to Bord na Móna, a company for which I have great respect. They are very good employers and are an asset to the nation and the ESB. This company should have had settling lakes along the Shannon when they started to develop bogs. I do not know if they did enough research at that time.
This is why I want to point out the importance of having experts to do research, to find out the best way to prevent pollution and to keep it to the minimum. State companies should set an example by insisting that pollution be kept to the minimum by industrial development. I assume that the new committee can only advise and the planning board will make final decisions. They will accept or reject the advice of the committee.
We must have expert knowledge on how to control pollution, not stop it. We must be very careful that we do not weigh too much in favour of certain people who might for personal reasons want to prevent industries being established in different areas. This reminds me of the itinerant problem. Some people say "Settle them, but not at my back door". This is happening all over the country.
We must ensure that not too many dirty industries are established here, but we must strike a balance. Anybody who thinks we can industrialise this country quickly and at the same time keep it as free from pollution as it was before is making a fool of himself. Of course we must keep pollution to the minimum and we must insist that we have the best experts available. Anything the committee can do to ensure that should have the support of this House.
This committee should spare nothing, money or anything else. They should go abroad to find out the latest and most modern way to prevent pollution. State companies must ensure that they do not cause pollution unnecessarily.
Comment on this
As usual Deputy Callanan made a number of very good points. The members of the commitee, as members of the organisations they represent, are frequently abroad investigating the facts the Deputy mentioned. When they come back they report on the steps being taken in other countries and there is no necessity for them to go abroad again simply because they are members of the board. Their advice is available. That is why the net was spread so widely. We have got everybody on the board we thought could give advice and at the same time we have tried to keep the committee to manageable proportions.
As Deputy Callanan said, if we industrialise the country we are bound to have a certain amount of increased pollution. It is up to us to ensure it is kept to a minimum. There are people who constantly condemn pollution. If they meant what they said they would never travel in a motor car and would try to prevent everybody else travelling by car too because cars are polluting the air. They would not smoke cigarettes or tobacco under any guise because they are causing a certain amount of pollution also. We can go overboard on this kind of thing.
The planning board must have authority to deal with the Planning Act. They have a statutory requirement to deal with it when matters come before them. I am quite sure that advice given from everybody, such as the advice that is being given at the present time from various bodies, will be taken into consideration. With regard to the question of cost the bodies which have been set up have already been able to provide a lot of expertise. We are already providing them with services. We will provide them with any documentation and any information they may require.
There is one thing I would like to mention which might be overlooked in this debate, or an outsider looking at the debate might miss it. This is one of the least water polluted countries in the world. At the present time, wherever there is any population, pollution occurs, but we should remember that this is one of the least polluted countries. Secondly, we do not have to go abroad to find out a lot of things. There are certain things here which are not in many other countries. Deputy Callanan referred to one of them. Where would we go to find out a way in which we could prevent peat from polluting water? We are almost the only country in the world that is commercially using peat so there would not be any point in sending somebody to a foreign country to find out what they would do about it because they never heard about peat. We have people working on it who are doing a very good job. I give credit to Bord na Móna because, even though again and again they cause a certain amount of water pollution, they are doing their best to try to prevent it happening. I hope this will be the case in relation to all the commercial industries in the country.
I believe we are labouring this. The committee which has been set up are doing a good job and will do a much better job when they come under this Bill because they will then see that we have provided the necessary muscle to allow them to work. They are advising at the moment and they know, as the law is and has been for a considerable time, there is nothing that can be done about it. In this Bill we are providing the teeth Deputy O'Leary referred to to enable them to do their job. I believe the position will be improved considerably. I want to say again that I believe we might be labouring this matter a little too much.
Comment on this
I would like to refer back to the Minister's reply to Deputy O'Leary in which he again referred to the fact that this matter had already been discussed in the Seanad. The Minister has done this on a number of occasions. I can only assume that he feels that, having had it discussed in the Seanad, there is no need to have it discussed to anything like the same extent in the Dáil.
Comment on this
I do not want to be misinterpreted. I said that the matter had been discussed in the Seanad and it had reached Committee Stage in the Dáil and everybody had an opportunity of putting down amendments including the Deputies opposite. I do not believe it is relevant to suggest new ones.
Comment on this
I feel that the Dáil is the place, as well as the Seanad, to have the Bill fully discussed so that everybody will be clear in their minds about what is contained in the Bill when we are finished with the discussion. Deputy O'Leary said that the Minister would decide on the number of people, that he would appoint them and he could summarily remove them. I feel that that is a bit arbitrary. However, the Minister pointed out that in relation to the appointment it might be necessary to appoint somebody from some new body which could contribute towards the work of the council. I accept that but I do not see why the Minister should not allow the council, once they are appointed, to elect their own chairman. As the Minister said, he would not have nominated them if he did not believe they would do a worth-while job.
There is another point I should like to question. Section 2 (2) states:
The Council may, either of its own volition or at the request of the Minister, make recommendations to the Minister in relation to any matter relevant to his functions or responsibilities . .
Why is the word "may" used instead of "shall"? I did not put down an amendment because I expect there is a specific reason why it should be that way. It appears to be rather strange that it is worded that way. It could be interpretated as meaning that should the Minister request information from the council that they would decide they would not give it to him. I accept that is a bit far fetched but the subsection says that "the Council may" make recommendations either of their own volition or at the request of the Minister. I imagine that this particular aspect of the work of the council is the reason for their existence, that is, that they shall make recommendations to the Minister either of their own volition or at the request of the Minister. I should like the Minister to explain why the word "may" is used here.
Comment on this
The only reason "may" is in the subsection is that if they feel there is no necessity to give advice on certain matters they do not have to. If they want to give advice they may do so. It would be rather ridiculous to say that they shall give advice on something when in fact that is what is being done and they are not in a position to give advice on it. Subsection (2) states:
The Council may, either of its own volition or at the request of the Minister, make recommendations to the Minister in relation to any matter relevant to his functions or responsibilities concerning control of water pollution and shall advise him on any matter referred to it by the Minister in discharge of his functions and responsibilities under this Act.
If they feel there is something they want to give advice on they may give it and if they do not feel they want to give advice they do not have to. If they are asked for advice they cannot say "No, we do not have to". They shall give advice on it. I believe the matter is very clear and I do not see any ambiguity about it. I do not see any reason why the wording should be changed.
With regard to the election of a chairman it has been practice for many years, when a board such as this is being set up that the Minister of the day appoints a chairman. The chairman appointed in this case is an excellent man and I believe he is doing a very good job. Possibly if the people on the board were appointing him they would appoint the same man. As Deputy Faulkner knows as well as I do, very often when a group of people come together as in this case the first thing they must do is elect a chairman. They may not know each other and, individually, they may not be able to assess who anybody is or what each person's capabilities are. In that case it is good, sound practice that the Minister, having a fair knowledge of the people on the committee, may appoint the chairman
Comment on this
Will the Minister accept that I am not attempting to reflect on the present chairman.
Comment on this
Surely the Minister is not saying that he would be glad of it? Surely he will accept it.
Comment on this
Amendments Nos. 10, 12, 43, 44 and 45 are related and may be discussed together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 10:
In page 4, line 11, to delete "any polluting matter to enter waters" and substitute "polluting matter exceeding the standards established under section 26, to enter waters".
I believe that this amendment is much simpler than the Minister's amendments but it implies that a standard has been set. As the section stands it is rather vague. It is very important that no polluting matter exceeding the standards should enter any waters. This is an important amendment because there could be very minor polluting matter entering waters which could be covered by the use of the word "any", something which could be polluting matter but shortly after entering the water would no longer be a pollutant; its polluting effect would be completely eroded.
Comment on this
Briefly, we feel that the standard which will be established under section 26 will be sufficiently wide to guard any problems envisaged by the Minister. As Deputy O'Leary has said, any sort of matter which would not necessarily be polluting but which might interfere with or be detrimental to the recreational uses of the water and which would come from natural causes could be regarded as an offence. We do not want to involve people in the commission of an offence in relation to some relatively minor matter. If the Minister would accept this amendment it would safeguard what he intends to safeguard but at the same time would not be an irritant.
Comment on this
I feel that we will have to establish some kind of standard, otherwise there will be vexatious court cases. People will claim that a matter is not serious because the polluting matter does not exceed the standards laid down. Very often where a fishery body prosecutes a firm they will claim that the matter may be undesirable but it is not polluting. There must be definite standards laid down.
Comment on this
I am afraid there must be a complete misunderstanding here. The fundamental point which the Deputies appear to be missing is that section 3 deals with discharges which would not be permitted at all and it is impossible to provide standards for something which is completely banned. We cannot tell a manufacturer or a farmer that he will be prosecuted if he puts matter into waters unless that matter comes up to a certain standard. I am afraid that section 3 has been read and section 4 has not. Section 3 deals with discharges which should not be permitted at all—waste oil, rubbish, slurry and so on—and it would make no sense to provide standards for such discharges. All discharges of a type which can be discharged to waters in a proper manner are covered by the licensing provisions of section 4. As I see it, this amendment to section 3 would make a provision whereby materials would be licensed or permitted when in fact this material had been completely banned. Regarding matter which would affect swimming, either it is banned and would not be allowed at all or we are talking about something entirely different which does not come under this Bill. We are talking about pollutants and there are two types, that which is completely banned under section 3 and that dealt with in section 4, which provides for the licencing of certain types. We must get this clear.
We are taking amendments Nos. 12, 43, 44 and 45 with amendment No. 10. The intention of amendments Nos. 10, 43, 44 and 45 appears to be that section 26 should be amended so that quality standards may be prescribed for any pollutants and to amend section 3 so as to restrict the prohibition to polluting matter exceeding such standards. The first point is that amendment No. 43 would not, in fact, enable quality standards to be prescribed for other pollutants because the addition of this phrase in section 26 (1) would only provide for standards in relation to methods of treatment. It would accordingly be argued that since section 26 enables quality standards to be prescribed only for trade and sewage effluents, a prohibition as proposed in amendment No. 10 could not apply to other pollutants. The prohibition will not apply to trade or sewage effluents because these will be controlled by licence. Therefore the effect of these amendments would be to make section 3 ineffective. The issue here is not simply a question of drafting. In case there is a misconception perhaps I should explain that trade and sewage effluents will be controlled by licence under section 4. The purpose of section 3 is to prohibit the entry to waters of any other form of polluting matter. Indiscriminate dumping in waters is something which we do not want at all. We could not fix a quality standard in that case and it would also be inappropriate to fix a quality standard for waste oil; it is completely prohibited. The same thing applies to pig slurry; it should not be discharged into the nearest watercourse. Silage effluent and industrial waste are other forms of polluting matter which would come within the prohibition.
Perhaps Deputies O'Leary and Faulkner had in mind that since there will be some exemptions under section 4 (10), there should not be an absolute prohibition in section 3. What we have in mind in section 4 (10) is that there may be classes of trade or sewage effluent where in the generality of cases there would not be a danger of pollution. Septic tanks which are properly designed and maintained and which deal with domestic sewage from individual houses are unlikely to cause pollution problems. There may also be other cases where the quality of polluting water or the normal effluent quality would not warrant the inconvenience and administrative cost of licensing. We are therefore providing in section 4 (10) for the possibility of exemption from licensing requirements and provision should be made that any effluent so exempted should be brought within the scope of the prohibition in section 3. Perhaps it was the intention of Deputies O'Leary and Faulkner, and I agree, that it would be clearer if section 3 were amended so as not to apply the prohibition in that section to any effluents exempted under section 4 (10) where they comply with any relevant standards under section 26. In other words, if an effluent is exempted from the licensing requirements of section 4 it would not come within the scope of the prohibition in section 3 if it complied with any relevant standard prescribed under section 26. Amendment No. 12 provides accordingly and I hope it will enable Deputies O'Leary and Faulkner to withdraw amendments Nos. 10, 43, 44 and 45, which, as I have already explained, are unacceptable. Section 3 provides for total prohibition and section 4 provides for the licensing of certain types. We must look at these two sections separately and the amendment which I have suggested does the job that Deputies Faulkner and O'Leary are interested in. That is all that is required.
Comment on this
I can clearly see the point made by the Minister "Polluting matter" includes any poisonous or noxious matter or any substance which enters the water and is liable to render such waters harmful or dangerous to public health or to domestic, commercial, industrial, agricultural or recreational users. Section 3 (1) provides that a person shall not cause or permit any polluting matter to enter waters. Take as an example when a farmer allows 20 head of cattle to stand in a river for the most part of the day during the summertime. Naturally, the waters become polluted. A few hundred yards downstream there is an area used for swimming or recreational purposes and this area could be deemed to be polluted. Farmer No. 2 could then bring a case against farmer No. 1, as the section stands. It is with the intention of preventing such situations arising that Deputy Faulkner and I put down this amendment.
Comment on this
I would be amazed if any effort were made to prevent farmers allowing their cattle to use a stream during a period when those cattle are running because of flies. Such a stream is one of the greatest assets a farmer can have. To suggest, as Deputy O'Leary does, that because there is swimming lower down the river or stream special provision should be made so that farmers would not be allowed to let their cattle use the stream I do not think would work at all. Subsection (3) says:
It shall be a good defence to a prosecution under this section to prove to the satisfaction of the court that the person charged took all reasonable care to prevent the entry prohibited under subsection (1).
I do not know if that means that a farmer should wait around with a little tin for his cattle to pollute a stream and try to collect in the little tin and deposit that pollution elsewhere. I am very anxious to ensure things are properly dealt with and while I have some sympathy with the people who want swimming facilities, I still do not see why farmers should be prevented from using an asset they have been using from time immemorial, namely, the streams running through their lands as drinking water and a refuge for cattle during hot weather. I doubt if any of Deputy O'Leary's party, especially rural Deputies, would give very much support to the suggestion that farmers should be prohibited from using such streams and that is the only interpretation I can take out of what the Deputy has said.
Comment on this
The Minister is misinterpreting. The reverse is the case and the main reason for the amendment is to prevent situations arising which might lead to litigation.
Comment on this
I am sorry if the Deputy did not make it clear. If that is what he means, then subsection (3) provides for that situation and the Department of Agriculture are quite satisfied this is a good defence.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not agree that, under the definition of "polluting matter", if we allow section 3 (1) to stand situations could arise like the one I have cited.
Comment on this
But the good defence would cover it and that is the reason that subsection is there.
Comment on this
How would Deputy O'Leary set standards? Would he let the cattle in but ensure they excreted before they entered the water? We must be reasonable about these things.
Comment on this
No. We want to ensure that standards are laid down and we do not want to leave it open for anybody to pollute waters in which recreation takes place, and that includes swimming, but there is a good defence here. The Department of Agriculture are satisfied it is a good defence. What Deputy O'Leary is saying is that we either take out swimming completely as a recreation or say all recreation except swimming so that the farmer with the swimming pool will not have his portion of the river polluted by his neighbour's cattle or else we prevent the cattle from going into the river or arrange they do not pollute it when they go in. That would be an impossibility, as Deputy O'Leary knows. We are talking about something which is just not possible. We have gone as far as we can. I suggest the Deputy leave the matter as it is.
Comment on this
I still maintain that section 3 (1) could give rise to numerous court cases and to unnecessary litigation unless this amendment is accepted. Subsection (3) would add to the dangers inherent in subsection (1). I shall come to those later.
Comment on this
I have gone as far as I am prepared to go. I do not think the Deputy really studied the matter and, if he does so now, he will realise what he is asking is something this House would not accept.
Comment on this
What Deputy O'Leary intended was to ensure the situation he describes could not arise. He is convinced it could arise under section 3 (1) and he is anxious there should be no misunderstanding. If the Minister tells us amendment No. 12 is going some way to meet us, I will accept that.
Comment on this
I want to be fair to Deputy O'Leary and ensure that there is no misunderstanding about his argument.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 11 in the name of the Minister and amendments Nos. 16, 17, 21, 22, 23, 27, 28, 31, 39, 42, 47, 48 and 49 are cognate and, perhaps, these could all be discussed with No. 11.
Comment on this
They all relate to the change of title from Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to Minister for Fisheries.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 11:
In page 4, lines 32 and 33, to delete "Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries" and substitute "Minister for Fisheries".
Comment on this
Do I take it from this that the Minister for Agriculture now only enters into the matter of water pollution where there is a reference to consulting with other Ministers?
Comment on this
I recognise that the change had to be made because a new Department of Fisheries was established and the decision to change from the Minister for Agriculture to the Minister for Fisheries is welcomed. However the setting up of the new Department is fortuitous in these circumstances. I am not concerned with the personalities presently occupying the positions of Ministers but with the difference of outlook of the Departments themselves. I felt somewhat perturbed at the many references to the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries in the original Bill because the reference to him concerned, in the main, exemptions. As the agricultural sector of his portfolio was the largest in that it related to a wider field and was concerned with more people and their activities on the farm, the main emphasis and thrust of a Minister for Agriculture would relate to exemptions.
It is possible that pressure groups might feel these exemptions were necessary in the circumstances but they could result in grave damage being done to the environment and, particularly, to the purity of our water. This pressure could appear to be justified on economic grounds. I must admit that when I studied the Bill in relation to the part to be played in it by the Minister for Agriculture, and particularly when I noted the emphasis on exemptions, I felt that the fisheries aspect of his portfolio tended to fade out.
I believe that now we are in a different situation when the emphasis is on the Minister for Fisheries. The pressures on the Minister for Fisheries would in my view be quite the reverse of those on the Minister for Agriculture. The pressures will be to exhort the Minister to do everything in his power to safeguard fish life and this in turn will ensure that the water is preserved and kept as free as possible from pollution in this technological age. This emphasis which will now be placed on the matter of water pollution, particularly when one notes from today's news that fish died because of water pollution in a river, is welcomed. For these reasons I am glad of the change even though I know that the change has taken place for technical reasons. I feel the emphasis now will be much more on ensuring that our waters will be kept pure rather than on exemptions.
We learned the profound lesson last summer when during the long hot spell we saw for the first time how badly polluted some of our rivers were and the effect this had on our fish life. We had a bad experience in relation to water for human consumption in Clogherhead in my constituency. I believe the change will alter the emphasis and this is good.
Comment on this
As far as the change in ministries is concerned it is true that the new Minister will have fisheries as his main concern but at the same time it would be unfair if I allowed the comment to pass that if a change had not taken place the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries, and his Parliamentary Secretary, would not have been as interested in protecting that particular aspect. While somebody whose sole interest will be fishing will be referred to in future, and that will be a help, the position would not be as black as Deputy Faulkner believed it would be. Deputy Faulkner told us of fish dying and I should like to tell him that I read in a newspaper, dated 1880, of the death of salmon and trout in a river in the south of Ireland. It was not attributed to "water pollution". The story stated that the fish appeared to have been poisoned and cattle running into the river were blamed for it. I do not think any prosecution was taken against the owners of the cattle by those interested in fish.
It was tragic that the position was so bad in Clogherhead but the Deputy cannot blame the Minister for Agriculture or anybody else for that. This is a case which proves that for years no Government spent enough money on the question of sanitary services. Had that been done Clogherhead and places like it would not find themselves in the position they found themselves in last summer. Deputy Faulkner's comment about realising how polluted our rivers were was not a fair one because, no matter what we do, if the supply of water runs low pollution will appear and it has been appearing for a long time, long before this State got its freedom. That is something even this Bill will not remedy. If we get another long hot summer we will have a lot of rivers running dry and pollution will appear. There is nothing we can do to prevent that. The Bill will prevent pollution in rivers throughout the year and we have a lot of that. We are still a lot better than Britain or continental countries.
Comment on this
When I noted in the original Bill the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries coupled with exemptions my attention was focused on what exemptions he would be looking for. The fact that he was also the Minister responsible for fisheries did not appear to me to enter into the matter because the Minister for Fisheries, rather than looking for exemptions, would be looking in the other direction. In those circumstances —and it is no reflection on anybody— I felt it is a fortuitous improvement that the name is changed from the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries to the Minister for Fisheries.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 12:
In page 4, to delete lines 34 and 35, and substitute the following:
"(5) Subsection (1) does not apply to—
(a) discharges of trade effluents or sewage effluents (other than a discharge the subject of regulations under section 4 (10), unless where a relevant standard is prescribed under section 26 the discharge complies with that standard);".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 13:
In page 4, line 39, to delete "sections" and substitute "section".
This is a minor drafting amendment, to delete the word "sections" and substitute "section".
Comment on this
Will this section be used to control discharges from road vehicles or mobile containers?
Comment on this
It will prohibit completely certain types of discharges into waters, whether from road vehicles or anything else, where possible.
Comment on this
How can we be assured of this? Such discharges could cause serious problems. The Minister will agree that, though discharges through pipes could be supervised and controlled, it would be difficult to control the use of mobile vehicles for this purpose.
Comment on this
I am not happy about subsection (3), which states:
It shall be a good defence to a prosecution under this section to prove to the satisfaction of the court that the person charged took all reasonable care to prevent the entry prohibited under subsection (1).
This subsection will probably be regarded as a dream provision by junior and senior counsel. I can see it being argued for and against ad nauseam in the courts. As soon as any person or body is prosecuted for an offence his first reaction will be to claim the benefit of this subsection and I can see legal advisers taking the initiative and relying on it as a defence. I have been advised that district justices and Circuit Court judges will have to take such a defence into consideration when ruling on cases brought before them. I suggest the subsection is unnecessary because most people served with notice of prosecution will be inclined to rely on it. For that reason I suggest the subsection should be deleted.
Comment on this
There is considerable public disquiet about this. I was not happy about it when I first saw it, but we did not table an amendment to delete it, appreciating that there may be reasons why the Minister inserted the subsection? I would be anxious to hear those reasons. As I have said, undoubtedly there is considerable disquiet about the provision among those concerned with the environment, and with water pollution in particular. The Minister was good enough to furnish me with a copy of the recommendations sent to him by the advisory council and they, too, expressed disquiet in this regard. As Deputy O'Leary said, it would be a pity if this provision provided an escape for somebody from an offence in relation to water pollution. The difficulty is in relation to the word "reasonable". The Minister will probably say that the courts will have to decide, but I should be happier if the phrase were reworded. I agree it would not be fair to tie people absolutely in the sense that they would not be given any opportunity to defend themselves and that is another reason we did not table an amendment in this respect.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputies O'Leary and Faulkner because the words "all reasonable care" leave the thing wide open. We all know different judges will have different views on what is reasonable. Take a farmer who lays down a silage pit adjacent to a stream; he can argue that he took all reasonable care to avoid polluting the stream. However those of us who are farmers realise the havoc that can be caused as a result of the location of silage pits. It has been proved that streams which were not near to silage pits have been polluted. If a person is brought before the court can he not argue that he took all reasonable care to avoid polluting although he located a pit at such a point that it actually caused pollution?
Comment on this
I associate myself with the three previous speakers on this point. As Deputy O'Leary said, this subsection gives a sort of blank cheque to the legal profession. It is an escape device for people being brought before the courts. It reminds me of a provision in the old Planning Act in regard to prosecutions for unauthorised buildings—it was practically impossible to catch offenders under that provision because of the various mechanisms they could rely on. The delaying process was there in the old Planning Acts and it is very similar to the out that is being left here for people polluting waters. There is such an out under subsection (3) and I should like to hear the Minister's comments on it.
Comment on this
I think this House has gone a little screwy. The last two Deputies who spoke did not seem to be au fait with Deputy O'Leary's argument. Earlier he established the fact that swimming was a recreation and I agreed with him. He then mentioned the case of a person who might use part of a river for swimming and where a farmer might allow his cattle to use another portion of the river, thereby causing concern to the first person that the river might be polluted. That is the point at issue here. We are an agricultural country and I would not be prepared to see a Bill going through this House which would say that a farmer should not be allowed to let his cattle into a river during the summer. What is being suggested by the Opposition is quite ridiculous.
Comment on this
I should like to know what Deputies O'Leary, Hussey and Burke want. Deputy Faulkner tried to point out that Deputy O'Leary had said he was not trying to prevent the cattle from going into the river but he did not want the person with the swimming facilities to prosecute the farmer. Can anybody say that that line is being followed now? Deputy Burke suggested it would be wrong to have an out in this case. Is it not the case that the Opposition have been arguing that it would be wrong if there were an out for people who pollute rivers? The word "loophole" was used. Who is the loophole for? It is not for the person who does the swimming. The loophole is for the farmer whose cattle might pollute the stream. That is a very dangerous argument to follow and it would be very foolish if an agricultural country came down on the side of a person who might want to have a swim. Cattle do not stay all day in a river. The whole argument being advanced by the Opposition is ridiculous.
My advice is that it will give a better balance to leave in the subsection. The prosecution must prove that the pollution in the water was done wilfully or negligently. The alternative is to take out the subsection. That means we should not leave what the Opposition call a "loophole"; in other words, that we should ensure that the person who wants to swim in the river can take a prosecution against the farmer whose cattle have been using the river. The Opposition should take a long look at this matter because it is not as simple as it looks.
There are other problems we are attempting to deal with; for instance, there is the large-scale pollution of water supplies and we are making provision for this. This section is an almost exact replica of what is in the Northern Ireland legislation which has been in operation for four years. It has not caused any of the problems suggested by Deputies opposite and there have not been prosecutions as a result of it. I want to make it clear that while I am anxious to ensure that this Bill will be effective at the same time I am not going to agree that as an agricultural country we should take out this subsection and thereby leave the farmer open to prosecution without any defence if his cattle have been using a river or stream. Another point arises and I am not quite clear on it. It is the question of wild animals, into which category cattle fit, and domestic animals. Under law their control is quite different. The subsection is not perfect but it is the best that can be put into the Bill and I should prefer to leave it there.
Comment on this
I am glad the Minister admitted he understood what I was talking about when I spoke in relation to section 3 (1). Had our amendment been accepted on that point it would have covered this situation. I do not accept the Minister's point that subsection (3) is necessary as a consequence of section 3 (1). It appears to me that subsection (3) gives the initiative with regard to defence to a person who is prosecuted. His first reaction will be to fall back on subsection (3). In the case we discussed with regard to farmers, a justice would take into account the fact that reasonable care was exercised by the defendant. This is the normal practice in courts. The escape clause in subsection (3) should be deleted from the Bill because it is unnecessary.
Comment on this
The Deputy seems to be changing feet. He started the discussion and at first he stuck to his line of argument. Earlier he asked me to say if swimming was included and I said it was. His second point related to a person who had a river passing by his property and where he or his family wanted to swim. He mentioned the situation where a farmer next door to that person had an open field leading to the river and who allowed his cattle to use the river. The Deputy's point was that this section would allow the person who wished to swim in the river to prosecute the farmer. He is now talking about an entirely different matter.
Let me give another example. If a farmer spreads pig slurry on his land at the appropriate time and a sudden storm washes that slurry into a river or lake and he is prosecuted, section 3 (1) provides a way out for him. He is entitled to that because he did not intend to pollute the river or lake. Deputy O'Leary is saying that every case should be prosecuted. If the section is deleted, they will have no defence. We tend to forget that we are an agricultural country. Deputy O'Leary's discussion related specifically to the man with the swimming pool and the man with the cattle that are using the river above it. My advice is that it would be a good defence to say that he was not responsible for polluting the river to the detriment of the swimmer. If the section is not left as it stands, there will be many questions to be answered in the coming summer.
Comment on this
There is little point in giving examples. The Minister will agree that we might be in some difficulty had Deputy O'Leary not put the cattle in the river in an earlier section because it seems to be his main defence in relation to this subsection. We have discussed the matter at some length. The main purpose was to bring the attention of the Minister to the disquiet in relation to it. Deputy O'Leary has a point when he says that if a case came before the court, irrespective of the subsection, the judge would have to accept a reasonable defence. The fact that the subsection is in the Bill does not give any more protection than if it were not in the Bill. It leaves loopholes for other individuals in regard to polluting waters. The main purpose of the discussions was to bring to the attention of the Minister that there is disquiet; even the advisory council are perturbed about it. In that sense the debate was worth while.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 15:
In page 5, between lines 36 and 37, to insert the following subsection:
"( ) A local authority shall issue a decision within a period of two months, on an application for a licence received under this section."
We believe that this is a reasonable amendment and that it is in line with the provisions in the Planning Act. If the amendment is not accepted, a local authority could delay the issue of a licence as long as it wished. This could cause serious inconvenience to the applicant and, more important, it could mean that waters would continue to be polluted.
Subsection (1) (a) reads:
Subject to subsection (2), a person shall not, after such date as may be fixed for the purpose of this subsection by order made by the Minister, discharge or cause or permit the discharge of any trade effluent or sewage effluent to any waters except under and in accordance with a licence under this section.
Section 5 (1) reads:
A person shall be deemed not to have contravened section 4 (1) in relation to an existing discharge of trade effluent or sewage effluent made before he is granted or refused a licence under section 4 if, before the relevant date, he applies for such a licence and complies with the requirements of any regulations under section 6 regarding the furnishing of information to a local authority.
This means that where there is an existing discharge a person cannot be prosecuted once he has applied for a licence until such time as the local authority either decide to grant the licence or refuse the licence. If that time were to be lengthy, the pollution would continue. If we can specify a time limit we would be ensuring that the matter would be dealt with quickly by the local authority. This is a reasonable amendment and it should be accepted.
Comment on this
It would be unrealistic to impose a time limit because some applications may require considerable investigation by the local authority, for example, water quality investigations extending over a period of time. It should be possible for local authorities to give decisions in the vast majority of cases within a relatively short period, in many cases less than two months. Therefore, it would be undesirable to fix a longer period generally for consideration of applications. When giving instructions to local authorities, I will tell them that they should make every effort to speed the decision. There are many cases on which a speedy decision should be possible. At present there are a number of pollutants which will require to be dealt with. Some of them will have to be investigated at great length and for that reason to fix a time limit of two months would mean that many of them would probably get a refusal. There would not be adequate time to allow them to prove that they are entitled to a licence. The fixing of an unrealistic time limit would have the undesirable effect that licences would be refused or that stringent conditions would be attached to them. This could lead to appeals and further delays. On the other hand, applicants could delay in furnishing relevant information which would seriously inhibit the proper appraisal of applications within the suggested time limit.
The amendment would also remove the flexibility of approach to the licensing of existing discharges, which is provided for in sections 5 and 18 under which an existing discharge can continue to be made until such time as the local authority decide either to grant or refuse a licence. This could take quite a long time. If they do not apply or if a time limit is there, the natural thing would be so say: "All right, we think that is a pollutant. We will stop immediately" and it could cause a great deal of trouble; in fact, it might close down industries. My advice is that as the Bill stands an applicant for a licence can seek an order of mandamus where a local authority or sanitary authority fail in their duty to deal with an application. However, I think we can rely on local and sanitary authorities to operate the system in a reasonable and expeditious way. It would be better not to prescribe any period within which decisions must be given and for the various reasons I have outlined I would not be prepared to accept the amendments. However, I will try to ensure that a speedy decision is given and I will try to have any complaints that are made dealt with as quickly as possible. We are all on the one side in attempting to stop pollution of the waters but we do not want to tie it up unnecessarily. I believe that to make this order now would be a mistake. I shall keep the whole matter under review because I believe only experience will show whether or not a time limit is necessary. Existing cases are dealt with. New ones could possibly be dealt with in a fairly short time except that water tests have to be carried out. I would ask that the amendments be withdrawn.
Comment on this
I would accept that the Minister is just as anxious to control this situation as I am. There might be something in what he said in relation to requesting the local authorities to speed up matters, but when there is not a statutory control in a matter such as this local authorities can, if they so wish, continue to be rather slow in their operations.
The Minister, I think, appreciates what I am trying to get at, that where there is a discharge which is causing grave pollution, as the Bill stands at the moment this discharge can continue until such time as the licence is either issued or refused. I can accept what the Minister says in relation to an industrial project, that there could be serious consequences if a local authority were to refuse a licence. A local authority which has such an industry in their area would be very slow to refuse such a licence in any case, because I doubt very much if they would be anxious to take responsibility for disemploying quite a number of people.
I agree that in some instances it would be necessary to carry out possibly fairly lengthy investigations, but in relation to the problems which we have at present and to which the Minister referred, I would have thought that the local authorities would already have had a considerable amount of information long before this Bill was even introduced in regard to the difficulties and problems which arise from the discharge from these industries. In fact, they have at present a responsibility in relation to them. It would not take all that long for them to issue a licence, and there would be nothing to prevent them adding to that licence, as is allowed for in the Bill, the particular conditions under which this licence is issued. In issuing to the industry or whatever it might be the licence with the conditions attached, the local authority would have the right to go ahead in relation to the efforts to prevent the continuation of this discharge.
I was wondering while the Minister was speaking whether it might not be possible to amend slightly the amendment we have already submitted: "A local authority shall issue a decision within a period of two months or, with the consent of the Minister, a longer period, on an application for a licence received under this section". I am a little worried about the fact that while this Bill has very worthy objectives and, in my view, will, as I said in my Second Reading speech, do a great deal of good in regard to the question of water pollution, the fact that there is no time limit imposed will allow an out which will, to some extent anyway, frustrate the worthwhile objectives of the Bill. Is there not some way in which we could ensure that the local authority would issue a licence within a reasonable period?
The local authority themselves know a good deal about the problems and difficulties within their own area in regard to industry and many other aspects of life also which are the cause of water pollution. I do not feel it would take all that length of time to investigate those ones. The investigations into the new ones might take longer. While I understand the problems the Minister is facing, at the same time, if we leave it wide open as it is now, there could be instances where a particularly awkward case came before the local authority and the local authority would just put it to one side and not deal with it for a lengthy period. They might feel incapable of making a decision because they knew the decision would create other problems possibly for themselves. In those instances, the very fact that there would be a time limit would force that situation. I appreciate that in certain industries a hasty or a wrong decision could be very harmful, but as the local authority are entitled not only to issue the licence but also to lay down the conditions, that aspect if it could be overcome.
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner will appreciate that, having got rid of one set of appeals, I am not very anxious to have appeals under another heading coming in. Therefore, I would not like to put into this Bill a provision that they would give the right to appeal after two months. There is the right to an order of mandamus. What I would be prepared to do when the regulations are being sent out to the local authorities is to tell them that unless they were in a position to give a decision within a period—we can think about two or three months—we would require them to let us have a report as to why this has not been done, and we could then take the necessary administrative action in order to speed it up. Or if anybody felt he was being held up and reported the matter to the Department, we would take the matter up with the local authority.
I do not want to tie the matter up any further because there can be exceptions. However, I can assure Deputy Faulkner that I am more than anxious that there would not be any unnecessary delay, and I would ask him to accept that assurance.
Comment on this
While I accept the Minister's assurance, I am sure he is aware that planning authorities are not finding it too difficult to issue decisions within two months even in the most difficult of cases. I hope there will be a sense of urgency in dealing with applications on the part of local authorities under this Bill.
I would not like to see any of the provisions of this Bill becoming too flexible. Flexibility is all right in respect of some legislation, but where the improvement and protection of the environment is concerned we must be very cautious about such flexibility.
I am sure the Minister realises the importance of local authorities being adequately staffed to deal with applications under the Bill; otherwise it would be impossible for them to deal with applications within a reasonable period. I am prepared to accept the Minister's assurances, particularly his assurance that the arrangements for the control of pollution will be reviewed after a reasonable period of experience of the operation of the Bill.
Comment on this
In anticipation of this Bill, a discussion document was issued some time ago to all local authorities and was laid also before the House. This relates to practical aspects of implementation, including staffing, which are problems that will have to be dealt with. There will be discussion in the very near future with the managers regarding staffing requirements. I would assume that in respect of new industries decisions in relation to licences would be issued with the planning decision. This will eliminate delays and will enable existing industries, for instance, to continue, provided they had applied for exemption, until the decision was made. It will be necessary to ensure that planning authorities, by reason of lack of action, do not allow existing pollutant industries to continue simply because they have applied.
I thank the Deputies opposite for the way in which they have dealt with this matter. We are all anxious that the situation be tidied up in the best way possible.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 16:
In page 6, lines 33 and 34, to delete "Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries" and substitute "Minister for Fisheries".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 17:
In page 6, lines 35 and 36, to delete "Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries" and substitute "Minister for Fisheries".
Comment on this
Regarding amendment No. 18, Nos. 32 and 40 are cognate so I suggest that we debate those three amendments together.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 6, subsection (10), line 36, after "Agriculture and Fisheries" to insert "and the Water Pollution Advisory Council".
I have spoken already at some length on the function of the Water Pollution Advisory Council. This body will be doing worthwhile work in the field of research and so on.
Comment on this
Perhaps I might interrupt the Deputy to tell him that I am prepared to accept amendments Nos. 18 and 40 but not No. 32.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Minister's accepting amendment No. 18, the purpose of which is partly to upgrade the council.
Comment on this
Again, this is a situation in which we could have tabled an amendment. However, I wish to discuss the matter. Section 4, subsection (2) (b) says that subsection (1) does not apply to discharges from a sewer. It may be said that to have a local authority licensing themselves is not a very sensible procedure. The section gives to local authorities the right either to grant or to refuse licences. Although the local authorities concerned would be the licensing bodies, they should have to go through all the procedures laid down for any other groups or individuals. This is important. It is said often, but I do not know with what degree of accuracy, that local authorities are the worst offenders at times in relation to water pollution. In these circumstances I would consider it desirable that the local authority, as the licensing body, would fulfil all the requirements in regard to planning permission as must be fulfilled by industry, for example.
The Minister should direct the carrying out of a survey by the local authorities in relation to ensuring that modern disposal systems were in use. In many areas there are systems which are not up to standard, some of them being in very poor condition. A local authority which might not have sufficient financial provision could be in a situation where they would be insisting on certain conditions being fulfilled by industry while not taking any steps to provide modern disposal systems for themselves or one could visualise situations in which the Minister, who has power to prescribe standards in relation to effluent, might not press for changes because of financial considerations.
The doubts we have in relation to the local authority being the responsible body in so far as a major part of the Bill is concerned are increased by the fact that local authorities themselves are not included. I decided neither to table an amendment nor to ask to have the subsection deleted but I consider it worth while having the matter discussed here in order to hear the Minister's views in this regard.
The local authorities should be required to fulfil the same stringent conditions as apply to other groups or individuals and the one way in which we can provide for this is by exempting subsection (2) (b) from the conditions laid down in subsection (1) (a).
Comment on this
While I am well aware that many local authorities are polluters, they are the people who allow sewage into waters. I have been criticising this for many years. Every Government since the start of this State fell down in relation to money for our sanitary services. When I took over less than four years ago there was only slightly over £8.3 million spent on sanitary services for the whole country. Last year it cost £25 million and this year it will cost £25 million plus. It is not meeting the requirements but there is a scarcity of money. We are doing the best we can. The local authorities are the appropriate authorities to operate this Bill. It would be ridiculous to say that the local authority should report and prosecute themselves. That does not mean that we do not realise that a lot of things have to be done in regard to ensuring that where pollution is being caused by the local authorities steps should be taken to alleviate it. The local authority could say that they will prepare the schemes which can be operated provided they get the money. In a period of two or three years we would not be able to produce enough money to solve all the problems. Deputy Faulkner must be aware that these problems exist in many towns. We can only meet the requirements in a planned way as we are doing now. The larger amounts of money are certainly improving the situation. There are people who, having got primary and secondary treatment works in at a large cost are now insisting on tertiary treatment before others come into line with what they have already got. We must make sure that when we are notifying local authorities, we will try to ensure that they are aware of the fact that we expect them to do the best they possibly can.
It is up to us and the Government to ensure that money will be available as soon as possible to provide for the type of sanitary services required. The position under the Bill as regards the discharge from public sewers is that while they will not be licenseable under section 4, the Minister will have power to make regulations under section 26 prescribing standards for such discharge or for waters into which such discharges are made generally or in particular cases. Where such regulations are made, there would be a statutory duty on the sanitary authority concerned to take steps as soon as practicable to ensure that the effluent does not contravene the regulations. I know Deputy Faulkner did not put down an amendment but decided to have it discussed in this way. I have no objection to that; it may serve a very useful purpose if it brings to the notice of the general public that every sanitary authority have not got the necessary up-to-date equipment, and that it must be provided as quickly as possible. It would not be a good idea to ask the local authority to report and prosecute themselves if they are not meeting requirements. For that reason the best we can do is leave it as it is.