Local Government (Water Pollution) Bill, 1976 [Seanad]: Committee Stage.
Contributions 142–296 of 296. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 4 of 1976 ›
My main object was to try to ensure that the local authority would have to accept the same stringent conditions that would be placed on an industry. It would not be a good defence on the part of an industry which was creating a serious pollution problem to say that they could not afford a better system. In section 4 subsection (9) we find that:
A prosecution for an offence under this section may be taken by a local authority, a board of conservators, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or any other person.
In circumstances where effluent from a sewer was obviously creating a serious pollution problem there is nothing to prevent another person from prosecuting the local authority. Admittedly, that would cost money and no doubt very many people would not do it. Nevertheless, the fact is that it is possible and it would not simply be necessary for the local authority to take a case against itself. I am uneasy about the situation. It should be incumbent on the licensing authority, which will decide where they will grant refuse licences to any other group in relation to this matter, where possible to have the same standards. It would be ridiculous to have a situation where a licensing body would insist that certain conditions be fulfilled by an applicant when they on the other hand would have lower standards. I agree that there are financial difficulties. I will accept this if the Minister keeps an eye on local authorities and will take action on receipt of a complaint in relation to the activities of the authority. It is vital that the local authority should give the example.
Comment on this
A number of local authorities have not got the equipment to improve sanitary services. Incentives should be provided for people to build houses in isolated parts of the country where they can put in a septic tank and effluent can be disposed of without having to be treated. That would relieve the situation in villages and towns. Local authorities should be asked to build more rural houses. The increasing amount of sewerage is a problem that has to be dealt with and I agree that it cannot be dealt with overnight but my suggestion would be a help. Local authorities are being accused of being the greatest polluters because of the fact that the treatment of sewerage is such a big job.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware of my approach to that problem. Four years ago when I took over dealing with planning appeals, the regulations said that houses should only be allowed in settlements, in other words, towns and villages. I think I have reversed that trend over the last four years. Of course there will be building in towns and cities. This is natural, but I have encouraged everybody who wants to build in a country district where there is the incentive of a much cheaper site——
Comment on this
I have encouraged all local authorities who have suitable applicants for local authority houses to build isolated cottages where sites are available for them. I will do everything I can to encourage them to do this. Again and again local authorities have instructions to do this. Some county managers are opposed to this kind of thing; I do not know why. Public representatives should ensure that they do it.
With regard to the question of who should be responsible for operating the Act, the local authority are the people who must do it. When we talk about local authorities polluting I wish people would understand, including people who complain, that when we talk about the local authorities we talk about ourselves. The local authorities are our representatives. We appoint people to them, we elect people to them, and those are the people who run the areas under this House. There is no reason why anybody should try to create mystery about what is happening. We have not the necessary money to do all the jobs. We are doing everything we can, but it will be ridiculous if we create the situation where not alone are a local authority asked to report and to prosecute themselves, but where an individual should be entitled to prosecute a local authority over the sanitary services or lack of them in the area polluting rivers, streams and lakes and we, the public, would pay whatever fine was imposed and would also pay the court costs. There would be a net loss to everybody and nobody would gain as a result of such a court case.
While we want to ensure that a very tight monitoring system is carried out on discharges into lakes and rivers by local authorities, we must have a reasonable approach and accept where responsibility lies. As far as I am concerned I am as anxious as anyone to see this matter dealt with as quickly as possible but I do not believe the suggestion made would be the best way to deal with it. We can deal with it properly under the Bill as it is going through. I give my word that I will do everything I can to ensure that there will be no breaches by local authorities where this matter is being dealt with.
Comment on this
We should face this problem in a frank, sincere and serious manner. There is great disquiet among the general public, particularly among the environmentalists, those interested in fishing, tourism and in the protection of our amenities, about the fact that this exemption is provided for in this Bill. There is great public concern about the fact that local authorities can keep on polluting rivers, streams and lakes.
This is a financial problem. It is very important that a planned system of priorities should be prepared as soon as possible and a programme drawn up over a period of five years or so which would eliminate pollution completely in the areas of major contention and disquiet. The Minister referred to a number of local authorities having sewerage plants installed adjacent to rivers and lakes at large cost to the ratepayers and taxpayers and they are now looking for a third stage or tertiary treatment unit. I understand that there is another system under consideration at present whereby chemicals would be applied to the existing treatment works. This system is known as chemical precipitation. If it is successful it could mean that the third stage treatment could be carried out at far lesser cost than was possible a few years back.
Another source of pollution which is very serious, as expert advice shows, is the discharge from sheep dipping tanks. The position is so serious that it may be necessary to restrict discharge from sheep dipping tanks into the sea, into tidal waters, despite the fact that it may have to be piped a considerable distance or there may be a soakaway adjacent to tidal waters or to the sea. If this is so, how serious is the position in relation to septic tanks adjacent to sheep dipping tanks which are near rivers and streams? This must surely kill off any form of fish life in these rivers and streams.
The areas of high amenity and tourism value as well as areas which are renowned for fishing should get priority in any such schemes. The Minister should exercise some form of control over the discharge from local authority sewers. Perhaps he could set himself or his Department up as the licensing authority in this regard. I see no reason why he should not insist on local authorities applying for licences to him or to the environmental section of his Department.
The public are very concerned that local authorities can carry on polluting by discharge from a sewer, which by the interpretation of this section includes sewerage treatment or disposal works of a sanitary authority. The Bill is weakened considerably by virtue of the fact that the local authorities can discharge untreated sewage in some cases into lakes, rivers and streams.
I recognise that the Minister has power to prescribe effluent standards which would be binding on local authorities but that is not the answer to the problem. There should be some commitment involving improved and effective management of existing systems, commencing with an early review of the systems. The need for the control of discharges from public sewers should be included in the review of the Bill referred to by the Minister when it becomes law.
We must face the fact that the main problem is a financial one. Some scheme should be established whereby local authorities would fix their priorities within a reasonable period, have the cost of eliminating pollution estimated and submit the overall cost to the Minister. Some years ago an effort was made to have this costed. That would be out of all proportion in relation to present day costs. I urge the Minister to set such a scheme in motion as soon as possible.
Comment on this
I do not know what Deputy O'Leary has against the poor farmers. Having had a go at the man with the cattle, he now has something to say about the man who is dipping sheep and what happens to the effluent when he is finished dipping them. This is covered completely in the Bill. All these matters are adequately covered and there is no way in which somebody who uses toxic material——
Comment on this
On a point of order, I did not say it was not covered in the Bill. I mentioned in passing how serious uncontrolled discharges from sheep dipping tanks could be.
Comment on this
We propose to prevent uncontrolled discharges from sheep dipping tanks. That is not the most serious problem. There is a far more serious problem from industrial effluent which is doing a lot more damage. When Deputy O'Leary did not mention those and did mention sheep I wondered if he had a particular reason.
Comment on this
It is all right to say there must be special controls and there must be a special study of municipal sewage, and so on. One thing we need is more money. We are getting as much money as we can. In my short time here we have expended about £30 million on sanitary services, £30 million on the sewage end of sanitary services. If water schemes had not to be dealt with, we could spend a lot more money on the other side of it, but water schemes have to be dealt with and have to get more than their fair share of the money. We are putting as much money as we can into it. We are putting in a tremendous amount as against one-sixth in the previous four years. It would not be right to say we are not paying the necessary attention to it. The plain facts are that the Bill remedies a great many problems. It will not remedy the problems of sewage from towns and cities. We can only do that if we get effective ways of doing it. That requires money and the money will be provided as quickly as possible.
With regard to the question of the tertiary treatment, there are not only two as Deputy O'Leary said but 100 different ways in which people think the problem can be solved. In his own area at present an experiment is being carried on in Killarney to find out how one type of treatment would work. We have a report coming to the Westmeath County Council on a proposal for another type of treatment. I met a person recently who told me that they had cleared the lakes between Canada and America of sewage very effectively by tying bags of bluestone to motor boats and driving them up and down the lakes. Everybody has his own idea about how these things should be done.
The tertiary treatment has been suggested by certain interested bodies. There are lobbies in this as well as everything else. They usually consist of people who, no matter how well meaning they may be, have very effective water sewerage schemes in their own areas and therefore do not worry very much about those who have not. They forget that not only does the installation of the tertiary system cost a sizeable amount of money but there is also an annual payment which has to be made available. Until we are satisfied about one which will work, it would be wrong to expend some of the scarce finances on those schemes, not because we do not want to do it but for that reason.
I think we have established the fact that we are aware of what should be done. A continuing and increasing amount of money will have to be made available for sewerage schemes. For years local authorities have been preparing these schemes and presenting them to the Department. I believe one of my predecessors got a proposal about all the water and sewerage schemes then required in the country, and the figure of £36 million nearly made him faint even though he was a strong man. That was some years ago. Now £36 million will finance little more than one year's output. Local authorities can bring their proposals up to date. Some of them are a little doubtful as to which comes first and the representatives on the local authorities tend to differ as to which should come first.
I want to make it clear that when the documentation is finalised and cleared in my Department if a scheme is third, fourth or fifth on the list submitted by the county, we cannot be blamed if the allocation of money goes to one higher up on the list. This is a lesson which might be learned by many people when they are sending in their schemes because they tend to clear and finalise one which is much further down than the one they want to deal with principally.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned the £36 million, which nearly made somebody faint, and the small effect it would have today. This underlines the fact that it is useless to compare the amount of money being spent now with the amount of money spent previously unless inflation is taken into account. In replying to what I said on this matter, the Minister said that if the local authorities were brought to court we would all have to pay. That is true but to quite a considerable extent we all have to pay when an industry is brought to court. Usually they will recoup their money in some other way, perhaps by increasing prices if the fines were all that big. While that may be so, it is incumbent on us to ensure that the local authorities who are the licensing people have as rigid and as stringent conditions imposed on themselves as they would impose on other people.
We have discussed this matter for a long time and I do not think it is necessary to discuss it any further. There are one or two questions I should like to ask the Minister. One relates to the matter I raised earlier with regard to discharges from road tankers and mobile containers.
Comment on this
While it is reasonably easy to watch the outflow from fixed positions, rather than having a proper outflow somebody could have a mobile container and carry the effluent to some other place and discharge it into a river.
Comment on this
We are aware of that. It is being watched. Usually these people are traced. If somebody dumps waste oil he is caught and prosecuted.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) (a) provides that subsection (1) does not apply to discharges to tidal waters from vessels or marine structures. Does that mean if the vessels are in tidal waters when they discharge somebody else is responsible?
Comment on this
That does not appear very sensible to me. I could understand it if the discharges were well out to sea. I would prefer the Minister for Local Government to be responsible for the lot. If the discharge took place well out to sea we could say: "OK that is the responsibility of the Minister for Transport and Power", but if the discharge actually takes place in tidal waters and, in many instances, very close to the shore——
Comment on this
I appreciate that, but nevertheless the Minister lives relatively close to tidal waters——
Comment on this
It would cause the trouble to which the Deputy referred earlier with the wrong Minister trying to deal with it because we have no facilities for dealing with a discharge below low water level as far as the law is concerned and there is nothing we can do about it.
Comment on this
I do not think I should repeat what I have already said in regard to subsection (1) where it states that a person shall not be deemed to have contravened section 4 (1) in relation to an existing discharge of trade effluent before he is granted or refused a licence. We already went into that argument.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 19 in the names of Deputies O'Leary and Faulkner. No. 33 is cognate. Nos. 20 and 34 in the name of the Minister are alternatives to Nos. 19 and 33.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 19:
In page 7, subsection (3), line 45, after "£100" to add "and in such circumstances any licence granted by a local authority may be revoked or amended by them".
Comment on this
Might I suggest that if the Deputies opposite are satisfied with the amendments I have put down, we may be able to shorten the business?
Comment on this
We are, to a considerable extent. In regard to amendment No. 19 there is a much greater awareness today of the need to protect the environment. People recognise that unless they are eternally vigilant such damage could be done to our natural surroundings as would have very serious consequences for all of us. I think it is accepted that if a person were to get a licence in these circumstances, on the basis of false or misleading information, it could have very serious consequences. I believe we would have the full support of the public in pushing this amendment were it not for the fact that the Minister has submitted an amendment which more or less covers what we want.
Comment on this
I think it is desirable to cover the situation where a person obtains a licence on the basis of false information and I thank Deputies Faulkner and O'Leary for raising the matter. I have, therefore, put down amendments 20 and 34 which I am sure will be acceptable to the Deputies as meeting the full purposes of amendments 19 and 33 which I suggest should now be withdrawn. I am advised that it is preferable to provide that where a person is convicted under section 6 (3) or 19 (3) of making a statement in writing which is false or to his knowledge misleading in relation to an application or an appeal, any licence issued to that person consequent on the application or appeal should be automatically revoked and amendments 20 and 35 provide accordingly.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 20:
In page 7, between lines 45 and 46, to insert the following paragraph:
"(b) Where a person is convicted of an offence under this subsection, any licence issued to that person consequent on the application or appeal in relation to which the information was furnished shall stand revoked from the date of the conviction.".
Comment on this
I should like to refer to subsection (3) where it states that a person who, in relation to an application for a licence under section 4 or an appeal under section 8, when furnishing information under this section or when verifying any such information makes a statement in writing which is false or to his knowledge misleading in a material respect shall be guilty of an offence and so on. What exactly is meant by "or to his knowledge misleading"? How can you prove——
Comment on this
It is a normal provision in legislation. We just adopted this as it is. Obviously, it has been working and we have had no complaints about it. It is in many other Acts, the Planning Act particularly, and it appears to be operating satisfactorily. It means that if somebody makes a statement and he claims afterwards that he did not understand at the time or did not know something it might be a defence, but if he knew it and cannot prove that he did not know it, then it is false and misleading and to his knowledge.
Comment on this
It appears to be quite easy to prove. It is a question of whether or not a person is prepared to swear something that is false. If he is put on oath he will have to swear it; either he knew it or did not know it.
Comment on this
I think that quite a number of cases through the years have fallen on that particular clause; people have had to admit that they knew certain things when making a statement. It figures very prominently in the Social Welfare Acts. Even without going to court people are punished for making statements which they knew to be false.
Comment on this
In regard to the question of publication of notices, could the Minister say in what form these are likely to be published? It is a somewhat similar provision to what is in the Planning Act?
Comment on this
This is dealt with in another part of the Bill if the Deputy could renew his question when we come to it.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not consider as rather harsh the requirement in subsection (2) (f) requiring an applicant to defray or contribute to the cost of any investigation carried out by a local authority? Could he state the circumstances in which he would envisage such a contribution being required?
Comment on this
Why? The local authority are entitled to put that on the licence and if you are not satisfied with it you have the right to appeal. I would think it is quite reasonable.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) (d) requires local authorities to give specific information in relation to any applications and the manner in which they have been dealt with or publish any specified notices in relation to applications for, and the granting or refusing of licences. Would the Minister state the circumstances envisaged?
Comment on this
It is the same as in the Planning Act. We took it word for word from that Act and again this seems to be the proper way to deal with the matter.
Comment on this
But what are circumstances under which local authorities would issue notices in relation to applications for the granting or refusing of licences under this Bill?
Comment on this
For instance, notices published with the intention of giving information about licences which are to be issued. Again, it is only an enabling provision requiring local authorities to furnish the Minister and any other specified persons with any specified information in relation to applications and the manner in which they have been dealt with or to publish any specified notices in relation to applications for, and the granting or refusing of, licences. There is nothing extraordinary or unusual about it. It is a section that has been found to be very useful in the 1963 Planning Act and it is also in the new Planning Bill. When you find something works well, you put it in and use it.
Comment on this
To revert to the first question put by Deputy O'Leary on subsection (2), I have a note on the side of the Bill asking as the Minister asked, "Why?" The Minister will make regulations in regard to the licences. Investigation may be necessary. For example, an industry is causing pollution and an investigation may be necessary to determine what is the extent of the pollution, and to consider what conditions will be necessary to attach to the licence which will be imposed on the industry and so on. This is all in the cause of improving the situation and the purity of the water.
I wonder why an industry which might have been causing this pollution for many years should now be charged a certain amount of the cost of this investigation. I would have thought the licensing authority would carry out an investigation, pay for it and then issue the licence with conditions attached. It would be a different matter if the industry were told that they were committing an offence and because they continued to commit the offence, an investigation was necessary. Then I agree they would have to pay the expenses. In this case where the whole function is of importance and of benefit to the public generally, I cannot understand why we should have a subsection which would require the applicant to defray or contribute towards the cost of the investigation.
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner is missing the point. These are regulations I may make which may require an applicant to pay whole or part of the cost. We are talking about somebody who is causing what may be major pollution. In such a case it may be necessary to spend a very sizeable sum to find out if he is. I am suggesting in this Bill that I may make regulations which will allow the local authority to recover all or part of this money from the firm concerned.
At present certain firms have paid substantial sums for this purpose. I was not allowed do it in the Planning Bill but I would have considered it reasonable—and I said so in an amendment which I had to take out of the Bill—to make people who cause extensive investigations to be carried out pay a share of the expenses. Deputy Faulkner spoke about somebody doing this for the good of humanity and said that everybody would be helped by it. The whole cause of the investigation is that somebody was harming the amenities of other people by causing pollution.
The EEC have been discussing, approved and I hope will make a regulation which they call polluter pays. I would be in favour of that. I do not believe the general public should be asked to put their hands in their pockets to pay for something someone else is doing. We have too much of this going on at the moment. I can see nothing wrong in asking these firms to make a contribution. I am sure it will be dealt with in a reasonable way.
Deputy Faulkner appears to have in mind that a firm might be put out of business because they would be asked to pay more than they could afford. That is not likely to happen. If a firm are causing pollution and insist that they are not but try to prevent the operation of the Act to such an extent that expensive, or maybe not so expensive, investigations have to be carried out, there is nothing wrong in insisting that they be asked to pay some of the costs. It is not a question of trying to punish people who are in the right but people in the wrong should be prepared to contribute towards the public purse.
Comment on this
I agree with what the Minister says about polluter pays which is generally accepted by the EEC. As I understand it, the polluter who is deliberately causing pollution must pay. That is acceptable in these circumstances if the polluter believes he is not causing pollution and somebody else says he is. This is a new Bill under which an investigation will take place. The investigation will decide whether that person is creating a pollution problem. At that point the local authority are entitled to issue him with a licence with conditions attached to it. If he does not act in a way to reduce or end pollution, then I can understand his having to pay. That is how I interpret the polluter pays.
The Minister possibly misunderstood me because he said that I had said the person in those circumstances was doing a benefit to humanity. What I actually said was that this investigation carried out by the licensing authority would ultimately result in a benefit to humanity in general because it would prove whether pollution was present. If it was present, the authority could insist on action being taken to ensure that the pollution was abated.
I believe that when you talk about the polluter paying you are really saying that where a person in full knowledge, and having been forewarned deliberately continues to pollute the water. I fully accept he should be brought to court, have to pay fines and pay for any investigations that are necessary. But this is a different matter. The licensing authority will carry out this investigation to decide whether what he says or what they say is correct. If they decide ultimately that what they say is correct, then they can issue a licence with conditions and if he does not fulfil them, he is liable to prosecution, to be fined and he should have to pay for any further investigations necessary.
As I said at the beginning, the investigation referred to in this section is in the public interest generally and, therefore, should be paid for out of public funds.
Comment on this
This is a question of dealing with regulations. Industry generally do not take the same view as Deputy Faulkner. We are putting in the provision that an applicant is required to contribute towards the cost in cases where a special or unusual investigation is carried out by a local authority, to enable that to be done. The licensing authority would not do this in every case and this can be put in the regulations. We will also put in the regulations that where there are exceptional circumstances or excessive costs, all or portion of the costs should be borne by the firm. We will have large multi-national industries coming to this country. If we did not include this provision, we would not get one red cent from them. At present most of these firms would be prepared to pay a reasonable amount towards the costs. In my view we are protecting ourselves by giving authority in this case to make regulations which will allow this to be done.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that industry would be willing to contribute to the cost of overcoming the problem or is he saying, as is in this section, that they are willing to pay towards the cost of any investigation?
Comment on this
Where it would be obvious to everybody that pollution was being caused, and somebody else insisted on all sorts of tests which would cost money to be carried out——
Comment on this
If the person who made the application insisted and said they were not causing pollution and we insisted on having certain tests carried out and eventually after spending a lot of the people's money it was proved that it was a pollutant, I see no reason why the firm should not be asked to pay some or all of that cost. Industry should be prepared to accept that. If there was a fairly expensive investigation carried out, where a firm was concerned, I see no reason why they should not be asked to contribute and I do not think industry see any reason why they should not. I am not talking about ordinary simple ones which might cost a small amount of money. There are special circumstances and if we do not put it in this Bill, then we will not be able to make the regulations. If we cannot make them we cannot get any money from those people. This is reasonable.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that in the type of special circumstances he is referring to the possible end product of the investigation would be quite similar to the one we have had recently where we had experts coming down forcefully on both sides?
Comment on this
No. I am a great believer in getting experts. If the State or a local authority employ experts, they employ people who will give an unbiased opinion on the matter as they see it. Unfortunately, it is possible to get people to prove one thing or the other. If you keep travelling around enough you will be able to get somebody to believe the point of view held by everybody else. Deputy Faulkner is as well aware of this as I am. I do not think we are talking about that at all. We are talking about where people will be involved in industry and where there is a question of cost. I do not believe that the public should have to bear all the cost of cases where they are not responsible for the extra cost.
Comment on this
I will accept it as long as the Minister assures me that it will be operated reasonably.
Comment on this
Is it definitely the Minister's intention that applicants for licences must publish notices in the same way as applicants for planning permission have to do?
Comment on this
A decision has not been made but it is the general opinion that something like that must be done because the public must be made aware of the intention.
Comment on this
Subsection (5) states that a prosecution for an offence under this section may be taken by the Minister or a local authority. Why is the Minister brought into the picture here when in other sections it is the local authority?
Comment on this
He is brought in because false information may even be given in the case of appeals and the Minister would then have to have the right. He would only come into the picture in this case. In the normal way it would be the licensing authority but if there was an appeal it would be the Minister.
Comment on this
Will the licence last for three years providing there is not a specific need to have it investigated earlier than that?
Comment on this
Subsection (1) states that any person may, before the expiration of the prescribed period, appeal to the Minister. Is there a specific prescribed period?
Comment on this
The same argument would apply here in relation to an appeal as did in relation to my earlier remarks when I pointed out that the longer a person was refused a licence the longer the pollution of the waters would continue. I suggest to the Minister, in view of the damage that could be done, that the time given for the appeal should be reasonably short.
Comment on this
I will be dealing with them for many years to come. We will have power to refer them to the appeals board.
Comment on this
As the Bill stands, they will be dealt with by me but the intention is to transfer them to the appeals board.
Comment on this
This subsection deals only with the register of abstractions by local authorities from waters in their functional areas. The Bill does not provide for control of water abstractions. Such control would be more appropriate to some future measure dealing with the regulation of water resources. Water abstraction has, however, a considerable bearing on pollution control since major abstractions can reduce the assimilative capacity of a river or lake. That is what Deputy Faulkner was talking about earlier when he spoke about all the pollution last summer. The water was down so low that it looked a lot worse than it was. It is necessary, therefore, that local authorities should keep a register, at least, of significant abstractions. The requirement in this subsection that a register be kept of water abstractions will also facilitate the compilation of comprehensive data on water resources.
Comment on this
All abstractions, no matter by whom they are made, will be recorded. There will be some done by local authorities.
Comment on this
Is there any stipulation about how often those abstractions are made or if they are made in different parts of a river and so on?
Comment on this
There may be areas where it will be necessary to make them but in others there may not. So many of them could be made that it would not be proper to set down a special condition under which they should be made, when they should be made or where they should be made. This would complicate matters far too much.
Comment on this
Subsection (8) provides that regulations can be made to provide that specified classes of abstraction shall be exempt from subsection (2). This means that specified classes of abstractions shall not be maintained on the register of abstractions from waters in the functional areas of the local authorities. What type of abstractions?
Comment on this
Subsection (8) makes it clear that regulations under subsection (7) may exempt certain classes of abstractions, for example, minor abstractions or abstractions for certain purposes such as public water supply, from registration requirements. In the case of local matters it would not be necessary that those shall be registered but in others it would. It is an enabling subsection so that somebody cannot come along and say: "Why is this not recorded?"
Comment on this
Is there any danger that classes of abstractions other than abstractions from public water supplies may be excluded?
Comment on this
No. Deputy O'Leary knows that a person who takes a bottle of water from a river is abstracting water from that river but it will not be recorded. If some industry were to take a few thousand gallons of water out of it, it would have to be recorded. Casual abstractions of small amounts will not have to be recorded. There is no danger in this at all. It is quite a simple matter. It gives some facilities to local authorities.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 9, lines 26 and 27, to delete "Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries" and substitute "Minister for Fisheries".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 22:
In page 9, line 29, to delete "Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries" and substitute "Minister for Fisheries". —An tAire Rialtais Áitiúil.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 10, lines 16 and 17, to delete "Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries" and substitute "Minister for Fisheries".
Comment on this
Subsection (1) states:
Where it appears to a local authority, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or a board of conservators that a contravention of section 3 (1) or 4 (1) has occurred or is occurring, the authority, the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries or the board may apply to the District Court for an order directing such person as may be named in the order to mitigate or remedy any effects of the contravention within such period and in such manner as may be specified in the order.
I should like to know why "or any other person" is not included. There appears to be some restriction here regarding the authorities who may take action in relation to a contravention of these sections.
Comment on this
This is the implementation of the licensing provisions and therefore it is only the bodies concerned who would be responsible. There is power, of course, for anybody to take a prosecution under a different section.
Comment on this
Does this mean that in relation to, say, section 3 (1) or section 4 (1) any individual who so desires can take action in the courts regarding a discharge of effluent which he believes to be a pollution problem?
Comment on this
Yes. An ordinary prosecution can be taken for contravention of either of these sections.
Comment on this
This is follow-up action where a decision has been taken by the licensing authority which has not been implemented. If defects have not been remedied the licensing authority are entitled to take court action.
Comment on this
This is a subsection which empowers a local authority to take any necessary steps to mitigate or remedy the effects of contravention and to recover the costs in the event of non-compliance with a District Court order under subsection (1).
Comment on this
This is a provision which we see in many Acts, particularly those relating to local government and sanitary services. I often wonder how effective it is.
Comment on this
I am referring to section 10 (4), the giving of power to local authorities to recover the costs of any steps they take.
Comment on this
There is no difficulty about this. It is one of the simplest and most effective means of dealing with matters of this kind, involving a simple District Court order rather than a long legal wrangle.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister will agree that it is most unusual for local authorities to take this extreme step.
Comment on this
Naturally they would not take this step unless they had to but it is proper that they should be able to do this in the cheapest and most effective way.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 24:
In page 10, between lines 22 and 23, to insert the following subsection:
"(2) Where a contravention of section 3 (1) or 4 (1) has occurred and damage ensues to a fishery, a local authority may, where the ownership of such fishery can not readily be established, sue the offender for the full cost resulting from such damage.".
Comment on this
Section 10 does, in fact, do exactly what Deputy Daly is suggesting in his amendment. Perhaps Deputy O'Leary might bear this in mind before he proceeds.
Comment on this
In many rivers valuable fisheries exist where no right of ownership is exercised. Thousands of pounds worth of damage can be done and because ownership is not exercised no claim can be made under existing law for damages. A very considerable stretch of river could be involved. In the west this could apply to a complete tributory or catchment. The purpose of this amendment is to give power to the board or to the local authority to sue for damages where damage is done to fisheries and where no claim is being lodged by the private owners or by the person who may have the right to do so but who, for one reason or another, is not exercising that right.
Comment on this
Would Deputy O'Leary like to say what exactly is meant by the amendment? It looks like a case of the invisible man—if one cannot find who is responsible, one sues him.
Comment on this
I explained it. Action should be taken against the person or organisation who causes the pollution.
Comment on this
I quote from the amendment:
"(2) Where a contravention of section 3 (1) or 4 (1) has occurred and damage ensues to a fishery, a local authority may, where the ownership of such fishery cannot readily be established, sue the offender for the full cost resulting from such damage".
If the local authority cannot establish who the owners of the fisheries are, then they should sue that person or body though they do not know their identity. This is something I cannot understand. Can Deputy O'Leary explain exactly what he means?
Comment on this
I assume that what is meant is that if a contravention of section 3 (1) or section 4 (1) takes place the owner of the fisheries concerned would be the person to take action in defence of his property. Possibly what is involved here is covered already. Where the ownership is not known and therefore where the owner will not be in a position to take action, the local authority would then take such action.
Comment on this
That is adequately covered in sections 3 and 4. It is accepted that it is already covered.
Comment on this
I take it that in the event of a contravention of section 3 (1) or section 4 (1) the people responsible can be prosecuted by the local authority.
Comment on this
It is a pity that Deputy Daly did not come and give us the benefit of his wisdom on this.
Comment on this
There is a specific reason why he could not be here. Deputy Dockrell was also late this morning, so we will not argue about that.
Comment on this
Basically, the point is that normally the owner of the fishery would take action but if he is not there to take such action and if the fish in the area are being damaged by pollution, then the local authority should take the necessary action. I believe, as I pointed out, that the local authority can take action in regard to section 3 (1).
Comment on this
I note that the question I asked earlier is answered in this particular section. Where contravention of section 3 (1) or section 4 (1) occurs the High Court may, on the application of a local authority or any other person——
Comment on this
——whether or not that person has an interest in the water prohibit the continuance of the contravention.
Comment on this
What type of person would the Minister visualise? Would it be a person interested in the prevention of pollution?
Comment on this
The most likely person would be someone interested in the prevention of pollution, I assume.
Comment on this
The Deputy assumes correctly. One would not expect any or every fellow to enter a High Court action and run the risk of High Court costs.
Comment on this
People are interested in the cost of such litigation. The man in the street would have little hope of curbing pollution on his own because the cost of securing an injunction is very high and securing the injunction itself is an unwieldly process.
Comment on this
That is so but there are bodies which could afford to take action and such bodies will take action if they consider it necessary. If an individual wants to have a go on his own, then he will have to bear his own costs unless the court decides otherwise. We do not want a situation in which everybody might proceed to the High Court and the ratepayers and taxpayers might have to bear the costs.
Comment on this
No sane person would take action unless he thought he had a reasonable chance of success.
Comment on this
I would not be too sure about that. There are people who take actions because they like going to court.
Comment on this
It depends on one's definition of sanity. They enjoy themselves while the action is going on.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 25:
In page 11, between lines 25 and 26, to insert the following subsection:
"(3) A local authority may recover the cost of steps taken under subsection (1) from another local authority or from a sanitary authority, where its acts or omissions necessitated such steps".
As I said earlier, there is a feeling, whether it be true or false, among the public that local authorities are themselves very often offenders where pollution is concerned and they feel it is like setting a thief to catch a thief to appoint local authorities in charge. I am inclined to agree with the Minister that there is not much option though the Minister said that at a later date it might be possible to introduce some better system. Now we should be seen to be ensuring that local authorities will act within the law in the same way as the industrialist, the agriculturalist or the individual. One way of ensuring that local authorities comply with the law is by making them liable for damages, costs and so on. That would make them more careful. If a local authority can recover from a neighbouring local authority, the latter will be very careful to ensure it does not offend. This amendment would ensure that local authorities would be particularly careful in the matter of containing water pollution.
Comment on this
I am advised this amendment is unnecessary because the power it proposes to confer on a local authority is already contained in section 13. Section 13 (2) enables a local authority to recover the cost of any steps it has taken under subsection 1 from such person as it satisfies the court is the person whose act or omission necessitated such steps. The Interpretation Act, 1937, provides that the word "person" shall, unless the contrary intention appears, be construed as importing a body corporate, whether a corporation aggregate or a corporation sole, and an unincorporated body of persons as well as an individual. Local authorities and sanitary authorities, therefore, come within the definition of "person" and recovery of costs from another local authority or sanitary authority is, therefore, covered in the section.
I suggest that the amendment be withdrawn. It is rather interesting because, when Deputy Faulkner was speaking, I was thinking that one of the cases which might occur when this Bill becomes law would involve Drogheda Corporation. Again and again, Drogheda Corporation have been accused of polluting the beaches at Mornington, Bettystown and Laytown and Deputy Faulkner and I might very well find ourselves on the opposite side of the fence if such a court case cropped up. It would be interesting finding out what evidence might be produced.
Comment on this
While I agree the local authority have the power to prosecute and recover damages and costs, nevertheless I believe it would be salutary for us to direct the attention of local authorities specifically by the insertion of this amendment because it would clearly identify the local authority aspect of the matter. While local authorities will not be slow to take action in dealing with individual cases, I have grave doubts as to whether they will make quite the same effort to recover from other local authorities. Local authorities will be responsible for the implementation of the Bill. They will be the licensing authority and so on. The more emphasis we place on the fact that they must come within the scope of the Bill the same as any other individual, the better. It is because of this line of thought that we tabled this amendment. We recognised that a local authority already had the power to deal with "any person" and, as the Minister has said, "any person" could mean another local authority. It is incumbent on us to impress on the local authorities in every way possible how important it is for them, the authority responsible under this Bill for dealing with pollution, to recognise that they are not there to ensure that others preserve the environment but that they also have a grave responsibility in this matter. If the amendment was accepted, that emphasis, as far as the general public are concerned, would be placed on local authorities. I agree that "person" in the circumstances will include local authorities but nobody else outside the legal profession or those deeply interested in this matter realise this. They are of the opinion that nobody is involved here except private individuals, industries or other groups.
Comment on this
This amendment is important and the vital words in it are "where its acts or omissions necessitated such steps".
Comment on this
The vital word in my opinion is "may". We are just wasting time on this amendment now because this is already included. The local authorities are the people affected and they know the position.
Comment on this
I should like to know if the decision by a local authority to take action against another authority is an executive or reserved function or does it really matter?
Comment on this
For that reason would this section not lead to all sorts of difficulties and problems?
Comment on this
No. If a local authority want to take another authority to court they are entitled to do so. Does the Deputy want this provision in or out? He is suggesting now that it might be a good idea to have it in but it is already included in section 13. At one stage the Deputy wants it in a second time and later he expresses the view that it should not be in at all.
Comment on this
I have asked the Minister to again impress on local authorities the importance of their role in this matter and I accept that he will do that.
Comment on this
I will, but I do not think it is necessary because local authorities are reasonable people and they are concious of their responsibility in this matter.
Comment on this
I cannot see the point in having this section when local authorities are allowed to discharge from sewers into lakes, rivers and streams. The section permits a local authority, which could be a major polluter but which would not come within the ambit of the Bill, to take proceedings against another local authority in respect of what could be a minor matter. Until such time as local authorities are obliged to licence their own sewers this section should not be included.
Comment on this
I find this extraordinary. Deputy O'Leary has put his name to an amendment to the effect that a local authority may recover the cost of steps taken under subsection (1) from another local authority or from a sanitary authority, where its acts or omissions necessitated such steps. Even though this was debated fully and an amendment withdrawn by Deputy Faulkner, Deputy O'Leary wants the same thing, which is included in section 13, withdrawn completely. We will never get legislation through the House if Members change their mind every five minutes. I can see no reason why we should not include in this section the provision to ensure that if a local authority deliberately continue to pollute waters flowing into the area of another local authority—we have enough of this on the continent between Germany, Belgium and Holland—the authority suffering the pollution should be entitled to take the necessary steps. That is included in the Bill, but Deputy O'Leary now says this should not be done. I do not think action will be taken very often because it will not arise very often. But the fact that it may arise only once in 25 years does not mean that it should not be the law of the land.
The omissions referred to by Deputy O'Leary are included. I believe the section is as perfect as such sections can be. We should leave it as it is. Deputy O'Leary talked about a local authority that is a major pollutant of its own waters. There is no way of stopping that authority; one cannot tell them to stop the sewage going into the river or lake until the necessary money is spent to prevent it.