We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–127 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976
Enacted

No. 42 of 1976 ›

I would like to call the attention of the House to the constrictive nature of this section, in particular subsection (1) which says:

The Authority may, on such terms and conditions as the Minister may, with the consent of the Minister for the Public Service, approve...

This seems to me to arrogate to the Minister for the Public Service and the Minister for Agriculture total control over the operations of the proposed new authority and any pretension it may have to the facade of democratic control falls when one examines the wording of this section. I suggest that the Minister consider this and also the possibility of amending this section. If he does not this side of the House will have to consider submitting an amendment on Report Stage. It must be self-evident even to the Minister that part of the subsection I referred to is obviously constrictive and is obviously arrogating to the political heads of the new authority all worthwhile control, including control over matters such as research, where there should not be political control of such an allpervasive kind as is granted in this section. I ask the Minister to consider changing this.

Comment on this
Mark A. Clinton Minister for Agriculture (Mr. Clinton) Fine Gael

There may possibly be some misunderstanding of what is intended in the section. This section is intended to provide for situations where a relatively small proportion of the duties of a Department's office are proper to the authority and it would not be advisable to transfer them to that body. For instance, the teaching functions of certain members of the staff of the Botanic Gardens who give courses in horticulture is an instance of this kind. The Botanic Gardens are not being transferred but the amenity courses are. Therefore, a very small proportion of the time of the people who give those amenity courses is involved. Their main work is in the Botanic Gardens as such. It is to permit of this sort of agency basis transaction, to allow them to do this on behalf of the authority that the subsection is so worded. There may be cases where we would want to do this in reverse. It is only to make legal provision to enable that to happen. It is extremely sensible. I believe the objection raised arises from a misunderstanding of what is intended in the section.

Comment on this

I would be glad if the Minister would enlighten the House on the meaning of this section, where it says that fees will be recovered on behalf of any person, firm, institution or agency and for services, courses, seminars, lectures and demonstrations provided or organised by it. I would like the Minister's assurance that this is not a provision under which, possibly at some later stage, the advisory services will become a fee-charging institution and that farmers availing of them may not under this section at any time in the future be required to pay a fee to the Minister or to the authority.

Comment on this

That assurance is given in subsection (2). Deputy Gibbons will be aware of the existing powers of An Foras Talúntais to charge fees for research done on behalf of outside organisations and for the acceptance of donations. These are preserved under sections 22 and 23. The provision in this section is only to enable them to accept donations or charge fees to outside bodies if they want certain researches done. That has been normal practice up to the present and it is really to preserve this in the authority that this is put in.

Comment on this

I do not want the Minister's assurance about the aspect he has just mentioned. I want an assurance from him that at no time in the future will the ordinary farmer availing of the advisory service or participating in the modernisation scheme be charged for the services of the authority.

Comment on this

Subsection (2) says:

No fee may, however, be charged in respect of—

(a) any advice that may be given by the Authority in response to a request from the Minister under section 21, or

(b) any facilities, assistance or courses of instruction that may be provided by the Authority under section 14 or 16 (b),

Those subsections give that assurance.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 12, between lines 5 and 6, to insert the following paragraphs:

"(b) The Minister may, in the order referred to in paragraph (a), in relation to the Board to be established on the commencement of section 25, provide, as regards the member or members who are to be representative of the staff of the Authority, for the selection for nomination, on or before a specified date, of a representative or representatives of the said staff and, notwithstanding the fact that, in the period between the establishment of that Board and the date of the appointment to that Board of the said representative or representatives, there are not any members who are representative of the said staff, nothing done by or on behalf of the Board or the Authority shall be invalid solely by reason of that fact.

(c) For the purpose of paragraph 1 of the Second Schedule, any member appointed by the Board by virtue of paragraph (b) of this subsection shall be deemed to have been appointed on the date of the establishment of the Board."

I am introducing this amendment because it is possible that the board of the authority may be appointed prior to the transfer of some or all of the existing staff designated for transfer. This amendment proposes to enable the board to carry out their functions in the interim period, prior to the transfer of staff, even though there will be no staff representation on the board. It is really to enable us to set up the staff of the authority, give representation to the board subsequently, and also to empower the board to function until it is possible to have that done.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I am putting the question: "That the amendment be made."

Comment on this

I have an amendment. I do not know whether acceptance of the Minister's amendment prejudices the taking of mine but I have a few observations to make on the section myself.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I must ask, first of all, if amendment No. 3 is agreed?

Comment on this

We oppose this section. The Minister is aware of the fairly widespread disquiet about the proposals in this section for the establishment of the board of the new organisation. From a layman's reading of the section it seems fairly obvious that the ability of the Minister to make up the personnel of the board in a manner that will be acceptable to himself is too widespread. It is also worth mentioning that there have been very strong representations made, I understand, to the Minister himself and certainly to the Fianna Fáil Party from the General Council of Committees of Agriculture who will have a very important part to play in the implementation of this proposal and indeed in the carrying out of any advisory service that might be contemplated under this or any similar Bill. It is proposed in this section that the General Council of Committees of Agriculture would have only one representative of the 24. It is not nearly as clear that this general council should be entitled to as much representation as but no more than the Government Department, namely, the Department of Education. If the Minister is satisfied that the present arrangement and those arrangements envisaged in the Bill for the future constitution of committees of agriculture, and the general council that would be drawn from them, are adequate he cannot very well argue that the representation he proposes to give them thereafter in this section is adequate also because it is not.

I do not propose to alter in any way my opinion, to which the Minister referred in his Second Reading speech, on the general revision of the advisory services, including committees of agriculture. But I am assuming, as one must that the Minister is satisfied with the proposed constitution of the general council. At the same time he will give no more, and possibly less, representation than he would give to the universities or to the farming organisations whose democratic structure would not be able to withstand the same type of examination as would that of the general council. It is manifestly reasonable that on the board of the Authority there should be representations from the farming organisations. It is of vital importance also that people placed on the board derive their presence there from some democratic source. Certainly this can be said of the members of the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. I may have misunderstood my informant when he said that the Minister, when he met a deputation from the General Council of Committees of Agriculture, said that this section was capable of amendment and that he would not object to an amendment if one were put down. If the Minister is of such an opinion I suggest that he make the amendment himself or, at any rate, if this party make such an amendment that he would look favourably on it.

In this attitude of the Minister there is a certain Pontius Pilate element in that while he would not wish to increase the representation of the general council it seems he would not, at the same time, object to somebody else making that type of amendment. Why does the Minister not take a stand one way or the other? I suggest that he do so. There has been vocal and well-expressed anxiety that local representatives of the countries should have a larger say in the composition of the board. For instance, subsection (3) of this section says that a great many of the board members shall be selected for nomination in accordance with the provisions of an order made for that purpose by the Minister and that any such order shall indicate the procedure for filling casual vacancies in the membership of the board. As I understand it, the Minister will make an order which will permit him to nominate people to the board. I presume he can make an order in such a manner as will permit him to nominate the people he wants to place on the board, in other words, people of the Minister's political persuasion.

I do not want to labour the question of patronage but we cannot avoid some reference to it. We cannot avoid a backward glance at the appalling record of Fine Gael, in particular, and the Coalition Government, in general, in this respect. Having a lively recollection of what they are capable of, their cynical blackguardism in the matter of patronage, one shudders at the power the Minister can take under section 26 and the use he can make of it. When one considers the position in regard to every board under the general aegis of the Department of Agriculture since the Minister took office, one cannot expect that this authority will be treated any differently. For that reason I cannot do anything but oppose the section.

Comment on this

I should like to make a few remarks on the statement of Deputy Gibbons. Far be it from me to take up the time of the House, which I rarely do, by going into the general principles of the Bill, but I think the position taken by Deputy Gibbons is basically correct. Speaking as a university teacher, I feel that the bringing in of research institutes into the purview of civil service Departments is a retrograde, regressive step and I do not think we should be doing it in this instance. It has always tended to stultify research.

Deputy Gibbons said that the Coalition parties have had an unhappy record in the matter of appointments of people to boards of this kind. In my view both Fianna Fáil and the Coalition Government have got equally unhappy records and I am concerned to express my view that the staffs concerned in research institutions like this should be people who ultimately will determine the manner in which they conduct their business and earn their livelihood.

I am a member of the Coalition and if Deputy Gibbons presses this to a vote I will have to direct my feet in the general direction of the Government of which I am a junior member, but I want to put on the record of the House that I regard this Bill as an extremely bad one, an extremely stupid one, and I think that in this case Deputy Gibbons is correct.

Comment on this

I am glad that at least one member of the Government parties had the courage to come in and express his opinion on the Bill, even if he goes into the Government lobby to vote. I cannot understand why the Minister has decided to give such a small percentage of the representation on this board to people working on the land. Already the great work the advisory services have been doing has been mentioned and I wish to compliment them once more. I suggest to the Minister that one-third of the representation on this board should be given to members of the General Council of Committees of Agriculture. They are free agents, elected by the people. The ratepayers will be paying a large contribution towards the running of this new body and their representatives should have at least one-third representation.

Theory is all very well but the people who put theory into practice on the land deserve more consideration than the Minister is giving them here.

Therefore, I ask the Minister to bring in an amendment on Report Stage to ensure that one-third of this board will be members of county committees of agriculture. That would be a representation of eight, four from each province. Throughout the years these committees have helped in an unequalled way to promote the interests of agriculture. Among other things they helped in the development of the co-operative movement. Their advisory services have always been available to all local organisations. Deputy Thornley pointed out the irony of putting research under the control of the Department of Agriculture. The Minister could redeem himself a little by giving strong representation to those who do the practical work on the land and I therefore appeal to him to amend the section to that effect.

Comment on this

Since I last spoke on this Bill I have been meeting quite a number of elected representatives, nearly all of whom feel that they should have a stronger representation on the board than 50 per cent. Most of these are young people who are taking an interest in public life and in being elected. They go to the trouble of being elected and they should have at least 75 per cent representation on behalf of the agricultural community on this board.

In the past, agricultural instructors went out into the rural areas during the winter months conducting lectures and night classes until the middle of March or 1st April. I hope the Minister will ensure that those lectures will be continued. They instructed the people on the yield that should come from the land——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

This section deals with the composition of the board.

Comment on this

Again I hope this matter is kept within the control of the Minister and that he will take note of this desire for 75 per cent representation on the board. The health boards were established, having got the approval of the various councils throughout the country, and I think if they were back for approval again hardly a councillor in the country would give approval to them. I hope the same thing will not happen as far as this matter is concerned.

Comment on this

This section, like some of the previous sections we were discussing last night, is a further step on the road to bureaucracy, having regard to the representation of the people who are elected by the public and having regard to the composition of the board under this section. Rightly, we are opposing this section for the reasons which have been outlined. So far as the elected representatives of the people are concerned, the representation outlined in this section is very small. I have no doubt but that the Minister will reconsider this section and that on Report Stage he will bring in an amendment to give adequate representation to the General Council of Committees of Agriculture on this new board. This is necessary, because the public representatives are the people who have to provide 50 per cent of the finances at local level, and they are also aware of the needs of the farming community and of the rural community in regard to the proper implementation of this new authority.

This section provides that agricultural and rural organisations will be selected for nomination in accordance with an order made by the Minister. I feel that at this stage they should be named, and I would like to know if the rural and agricultural organisations who are currently represented on the board of An Foras Talúntais will now have an opportunity of nominating a representative, or a representative from a grouping to the new board, and also if other agricultural and rural organisations will be involved in the nomination of members. The Minister should consider the fact that some of the groupings of the organisations are not proper groupings. I am referring to those groups which have nominations on to the board of An Foras Talúntais and which, I have no doubt, will have power to nominate to this new board under section 26. I would like to see certain organisations having direct representation on the new board.

However, the most important aspect of this Bill is the representation of the elected members and this is something the Minister should consider very carefully. Having come up through the ranks and being an elected member, I am sure he appreciates the role they play.

Comment on this

I would like to add my voice to those of my colleagues and I would hope the Minister would take heed of what Deputy Thornley has said as a person involved in education, that this Bill was bad and stupid. However, I was concerned when I heard him say once again he would let his feet control his head or better judgment.

We on this side of the House must be concerned about the composition of this board which seemingly will be under complete departmental control. Having regard to the contribution that has to be made to the up-keep of this, the Minister should have spelt out clearly what he had in mind and given some indication of the organisations he proposes should have nominations to that board. Reading the Bill I can see it could very well be that there might be only one elected representative out of a total of 24, which would be a serious imbalance. I hope the Minister will use his better judgment and give a fair representation to the elected representatives because they are well equipped to contribute and have contributed a great deal in the past to those organisations. It would be a sad day if he cut off the line of communication of public representatives to such boards. Therefore I hope he will listen to the Deputies on this side of the House as well as his colleague up in the right hand corner.

Comment on this

I wish to add my voice to the opposition to this section. I spoke on this already when the Bill was being introduced. It is a very dangerous practice to get away from the principle of giving elected representatives the majority membership on a board such as this. The board will make a demand on the ratepayers. The county council will have to meet that demand regardless of its size. They will have no say in where the money will be spent, or whether it will be spent in the local authority area in which the demand is made. It is only right and proper that the people making that demand should have to face the general public and answer for their stewardship at election time. Elected representatives have to do that and, therefore, they are quite cautious in making demands of that nature. They make sure that whatever demand is made, whatever money is asked for, will be spent wisely.

Under this section the Minister will appoint one member. The Minister for Education will appoint another, and one will be appointed by the General Council of the County Committees of Agriculture. I assume that is correct, even though I consider one member from the General Council totally inadequate. Other farming organisations will be demanding representation on the board. This will leave the number of public representatives on the board very small indeed. This is a very dangerous departure. I earnestly hope the Minister will have a rethink on this matter. I am sure every member of his own party who is a member of a local authority, or who was a member of a committee of agriculture, will tell him the same thing as we are telling him this afternoon. I hope he will heed our demands in this respect.

Comment on this

I also believe the General Council of the County Committees of Agriculture should have more representation than one member on a board of 24. They represent the committees of agriculture, 27 in all. The Minister says they will have at least one member but I believe a specific number should be written into the Bill.

Another educational sector is not being catered for in this Bill, the schools of domestic rural economy. Those people have been making their views known to the Minister and his Department and they have been turned down. These schools have done dedicated work for young girls in rural Ireland. A large number of the Minister's staff in the poultry section and in the farm home advisory service came through the rural domestic economy schools. Many men who have married these girls are very appreciative of the training they received in those schools. Most of them are in convents run by very dedicated people. Even as members of a group they should have one member on the board. I know we have a large number of rural organisations but these people are giving a very good service. To a large extent this Bill is devoted to farmers but we must look after the girls as well.

Comment on this

I must have been called everything it is possible to call me by now.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

Nevertheless I will be amazed if Deputy Gibbons runs out of new descriptions. The last one was Pontius Pilate. Not all the contributions made were relevant to the section. By no stretch of the imagination was Deputy Thornley relevant to the section and Deputy McLaughlin was talking about section 42 which we will come to later.

This section provides for the appointment of the members of the board by the Minister on the nomination of bodies such as the General Council of the County Committees of Agriculture, such farming and rural organisations as the IFA, the ICMSA, Macra na Feirme, the Irish Countrywomen's Association, the Irish Creamery Managers' Association, the staff of the authority, the universities, the Irish Veterinary Association, the IAOS, the processing and marketing sectors of the industry, and the livestock breeders. These are the rural groups I have in mind who will nominate people to this board. How can Deputies opposite by any stretch of the imagination say it will be rigged and only people I want——

Comment on this

On the basis of performance?

Comment on this

What performance?

Comment on this

The best criterion of all.

Comment on this

What performance is the Deputy specifically describing? He is showing an imagination which is beyond me in some of the statements he is making on this Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister knows perfectly well. He blitzed every board——

Comment on this

The list I have just given is not necessarily a complete list. It is the list of organisations which immediately come to mind as being suitable to serve on the board of this authority. I gave it to indicate to the House that the board will represent the more important interests of the agricultural industry. It will be a board which can be expected to ensure that the staff of the authority will be able to carry out their duties without any undue or unnecessary interference. I assume that all these people, when they are nominated, will be concerned to get the best possible service for agriculture. That is why I propose to put them on the board and for no other reason. I ask the House to confirm the section as it stands.

Comment on this

The Minister did not say anything about the rural domestic schools.

Comment on this

It is specifically stated in the Bill that they can be appointed.

Comment on this

I agree that some of the speeches were irrelevant but no speech from this side of the House was irrelevant to this section. The Minister did not give us any indication of what he intended to do about public representatives on the board. We are dealing with the composition of the board at top level. This board will make a demand on the rates in different counties. I can prove that under this Bill it is possible that there might not be any public representative on this board. The Minister has not spelled out how many public representatives will be on the board. He still says he will give them one but in my opinion we would need more than one.

Directive 161 was mentioned here last night. Is that directive not being well implemented by the advisory services and the county committees at present? We cannot pass this section without at least asking the Minister what he intends to do with these people who have been doing a reasonably good job.

Comment on this

Deputy Callanan is making a very strong fight for the representation of the county committees of agriculture. I intended to say something about this. Deputy Gibbons said I had met a deputation from the general council and that I had said if the Opposition put down an amendment for stronger representation for the general council that that would be considered. I did not say that.

Comment on this

I did not say the Minister said that. He is putting words into my mouth.

Comment on this

Perhaps I misunderstood what the Deputy said, but he said something of the kind. He asked why would I not amend this. He also said that I had said this to the members of the general council, but I said nothing of the sort. I gave no such undertaking in relation to this matter. I met the deputation and they made their case very strongly and of course I listened to their case. I have been misrepresented here on more than one occasion. I never said I will only give one seat. Deputy Callanan used that expression. I said I would give at least one.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I said.

Comment on this

That is what is said in the Bill, indicating that that is a minimum. It is the only organisation that gets a guarantee of one.

Comment on this

What is the point of mentioning an organisation if you are only giving them one?

Comment on this

Can they be given less?

Comment on this

I am mentioning all these organisations to try to clear the minds of the Deputies opposite as to the type of board that will be set up. Those Deputies are hoping I will do something daft in relation to the setting up of this board and that I will pick people who are totally unsuitable so that they can shout about it.

Comment on this

The Minister should clear his mind on this issue. He has not answered our questions. Deputy Callanan was not talking about the General Council of the County Committees of Agriculture but about democracy, that is, representation by public representatives on this national board. If the general public are denied representation by their public representatives, then it is a sad day for democracy.

Comment on this

The Minister went to great pains to protest his innocence and wipe his hands of any fell intentions. Before he sat down the cat hopped out of the bag when he said he had not yet decided how many members he would give to the general council. The slant behind all that is that the Minister will decide the personnel of the board. He wondered whether the people on this side of the House had gone daft but this afternoon only two members of the Government parties spoke and both spoke against the Bill.

I do not think Deputy McLaughlin was up with the play, but I understood him to say he wanted 75 per cent representation from committees of agriculture on the board. Possibly I misunderstood him because he was difficult to hear, but there was no doubt at all about what Deputy Thornley said. He said what we were saying yesterday, that the destruction of An Foras Talúntais and its somethering in this new organisation is a detrimental, retrograde, ill-informed step. He is in a particularly sensitive position because he has an academic background and understands these matters more sensitively than the normal person. As an academic he immediately sees the fatal flaw in this, that is, the destruction of the concept of agricultural research.

The Minister said we expected him to do something daft but he has already done it—he introduced this Bill. When replying to our observations on this section, I was waiting to hear if he would give any indication of the future composition of the board. It would not be unreasonable if we were to ask him to tell us if there will be four IFA representatives, three ICMSA, two representatives from the Irish Countrywomen's Association and how many Macra people will be on the board. I would like the Minister to give some indication of the line-out because we have not got any so far.

Comment on this

The word "democracy" was used a moment ago. There has been a great abuse of this in my county. Galway County Committee of Agriculture are 99 per cent Fianna Fáil but I will give in to one man, Deputy Callanan. He is better than the whole lot of them put together and the Minister will agree with me on that.

Comment on this

Is this relevant to the Bill?

Comment on this

If that is their idea of democracy, they have a lot to learn. Every time they use the word it should stick in their throats. It is only right that anyone who talks about democracy should understand it. There are 99 per cent of the members and a few lickers——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should not use unparliamentary language.

Comment on this

They lick envelopes for them and this is the pay-off.

Comment on this

As the Minister knows, party representation on the General Council of the County Committees of Agriculture is fairly balanced and we are talking here about a committee of the General Council of County Committees of Agriculture. As I said on Second Stage, I sat on a committee where there were seven members from the Government parties and two from Fianna Fáil. The General Council of County Committees of Agriculture should have a majority on this board. Now they have decided that they will accept one-third. That would give two to each province. That is very little. Public representatives should get fair play. County Leitrim is completely Fine Gael but there are good men on the general council. We do not discuss politics on that council. I want to make that quite clear. It is wrong to deprive public representatives of proper representation. It is wrong that this can be arranged in such a way that there need not be one public representative on the board. We could not possibly support that suggestion.

It is a great pity there are not more men like Deputy Thornley and Deputy Coogan prepared to stand up here and give their opinions. They may vote with their party but they will give their honest opinions. I give my honest opinion but I vote with my party. If my party make a decision I stand behind that decision but I am not ashamed to stand up and give my opinion. I know what the opinions are on the Government side. I could name Deputies but I will not do that, but I know they do not agree with the constitution of the board. Why will they not stand up here and say so? That will not prevent them voting with their party.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 60
·
Níl 53
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 4 and 5 are related and, by agreement, may be taken together. If necessary, separate decisions may be made regarding the amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 4:

In page 13, subsection (1) (f), lines 7 to 9, to delete "and allow him to examine such documents and records as he may consider necessary" and substitute "in relation to the finances of the Authority and allow him to examine such documents and records as he may reasonably consider necessary for that purpose."

Amendments Nos. 4 and 5 deal with the same point under subsection (1) (f). As I stated on Second Stage, the subsection is necessary to enable those who have statutory accounting responsibility for the expenditure of state and EEC moneys to carry out this responsibility. I pointed out then that it is not the intention that this subsection would be used to obtain for wrong purposes information in the possession of the authority or to interfere in any way with the conduct of research. I am introducing this amendment to allay fully any fears which any person may still have with regard to the intention of this subsection.

Comment on this

I accept the assurance of the Minister. I accept also that the main anxiety which we expressed in our amendment is being adequately catered for by the Minister's assurance. In speaking on this section there is another matter to which I should like to refer——

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The House can deal with the section later. We will first deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

I accept the Minister's assurance that there will be no invasion of the privacy of any farmer for any reason.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

We can have a full discussion on the section later.

Comment on this

I take it that my amendment meets with the Deputy's requirements? It goes even further than the Deputy's amendment. I am advised that a person's normal right to privacy is a constitutional right and, therefore, it need not be included in the Bill.

Comment on this

The Constitution does not guarantee the ordinary citizen a great deal of privacy from the Revenue Commissioners. That is what our anxiety is about.

Comment on this

I think I have clarified that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 6:

In page 13, lines 10 to 12, to delete subsection (2).

The inclusion of subsection (2) in this section is a restoration of what seems to me to be the confusion of thought in the drafters of the Bill in that they get education, advisory and research functions mixed up together in the way a scrambled egg is. Even accepting the Minister's proposition that there must be an amalgamation the merging of the three functions of the authority and the supremacy of the Minister in all those functions, as indicated in subsection (2), is unacceptable. We cannot but reject that subsection. That is why I put down this amendment.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment as I consider the board of an authority of such importance to the development of the agricultural industry should have the right to consult with and make proposals to the Minister on all matters coming under the Minister's responsibility. I do not know how Deputy Gibbons can see it as something wrong that this right should be there to consult with those organisations and agencies that are coming together now in a single aggregated authority. Where would the Minister get his information; where would he get the material for his policy-making if not through such a group? I do not understand Deputy Gibbons's point in objecting to this because I do not know how a Minister could carry on without having this contact.

Comment on this

It does not require a great deal of imagination to conceive a situation in research where a large measure of confidentiality is essential and the research might be of a kind that would have a commercial implication. The unwarranted intrusion of uninformed people, either from the authority or the servants of the Minister, by being uninformed if for no other reason, could cause a great upset in the carrying out of any worthwhile research. Research in certain cases requires a measure of confidentiality that should be proof against the intrusion of the Minister or any of his servants, who would not have technical competence, to intervene in the normal operation of this. It is not workable. I ask the Minister to recognise this reality.

Comment on this

The purpose of the subsection is to give the authority the right to consult with the Minister if they so desire. They need not consult with the Minister if they do not want to. That is why I think it is a misunderstanding of the situation. It is to give them that right to consult but they do not have to consult with the Minister.

Comment on this

There is no consultation with the board of the Agricultural Institute. Why put it in? If they want to consult with the Minister surely they know they can consult with him.

Comment on this

Deputy Callanan is not quite correct in what he says about An Foras Talúntais. Section 12 of the Agricultural Institute Act states:

For the purpose of assisting the Institute to carry out effectively its functions under this Act, there shall be paid to the Institute in every financial year, out of monies provided by the Oireachtas, a grant towards the expenses of the Institute, the amount of which shall be determined by the Minister for Finance in consultation with the Minister and the Council, after due consideration of any information furnished under subsection (2) of this section.

That is one part. Subsection (2) of that section states:

The Council shall furnish to the Minister such information regarding its income and expenditure as he may from time to time require.

A lot of things were required in the An Foras Talúntais Act that we are losing sight of. I am giving them the right to consult with the Minister if they desire. They need not consult with him if they do not want to.

Comment on this

The passage the Minister read out is not relevant to what we are talking about. We know they have to provide the finance. I am talking about consultation. Why write it into the Bill? We seem to have consultation with the Minister right through this Bill. This is what people are worried about. I want to make it quite clear that we are not casting any aspersions on the present holder of any office. We are referring to the fact that the Minister has too much authority. Personalities do not come into it.

Comment on this

My experience is that I get more and more demands for consultation. This is very desirable.

Comment on this

Why write it into the Bill?

Comment on this

I find it hard to understand, having made provision to give them the right to have consultation, how this in some way is seen as being wrong. They need not use it if they do not want it.

Comment on this

Surely to goodness the board will be in consultation with the Minister without having to write it into the Bill. It looks like an order when it is written into the Bill.

Comment on this

I anticipate that at some time in the future there might be Ministers who would not want to consult with them. I want to make sure if there is ever a change of Government that this thing is taken care of.

Comment on this

The Minister is joking now.

Comment on this

Why not place the obligation on the Minister to meet them? There is no obligation on him in this to meet them.

Comment on this

There is. If they are given the right of consultation they must get consultation.

Comment on this

It says "may".

Comment on this

"May" is "shall".

Comment on this

It might be "shall" for one and "may" for the Minister.

Comment on this

I believe it has been proved that this subsection is unnecessary when they may consult. I suggest that the Minister should agree to withdraw it.

Comment on this

I do not believe the board of the authority would be grateful to the Deputies opposite if I agreed with this. They would be very sorry if it happened.

Comment on this

Is it not unnecessary?

Comment on this

No, because I do not know who will sit in this seat when I leave it.

Comment on this

That is a matter of great speculation.

Comment on this

Great speculation.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

No, Sir.

Comment on this

In the creation of the Minister's new pyramid of power there will have to be a director. This section makes provision for this office, with the remarkable difference in the appointment of the first and all subsequent directors. The first director will be nominated directly by the Minister; he will be a Minister's man. Thereafter the directors will be appointed by the board. Perhaps the Minister would tell us why all subsequent boards will be competent to appoint a director while the first will not. I cannot see any logical reason for this and perhaps the Minister would elaborate on it.

On the construction of the directorate of the new establishment it strikes me that, since the authority will have three main functions—those in respect of education, advice and research—it might be as well, in this or some subsequent section, to arrange for deputy directors with responsibility in each of those three main subfields. I make that suggestion principally bearing in mind the recent death of An Foras Talúntais and the need existing for the maintenance of some separate identity of the research function that might be afforded some kind of survival by the appointment of a separate director. I would regard it merely as a temporary and unsatisfactory expedient but it would be better than nothing. A more radical method will have to be utilised at a later date to repair the damage contemplated in the Bill. But, as a holding measure—to prevent the total extinction of agricultural research—I suggest that the Minister consider the appointment of three deputy directors. I would ask him to explain the differentiation in the appointment of the first director directly by the Minister and of all his successors by the board.

Comment on this

I have followed the same procedure taken in the setting up of every board by various Governments; the Government have always appointed the first such person. It was done in the case of An Foras Talúntais. There is no other really good reason for it.

Comment on this

Is precedent a sufficiently good reason?

Comment on this

In relation to the appointment of deputy directors, as I see it, when the board is set up they can appoint whatever staff they feel necessary for the proper running of the organisation. If they decide to appoint two or three deputy directors that is their business as a board.

Comment on this

This is the Dáil.

Comment on this

Yes, but that is their business.

Comment on this

It is our business, too.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Gibbons was objecting to politicians taking anything on themselves, that it was all to be left to people outside the House. We cannot have it both ways.

Comment on this

If the Minister thinks the appointment of deputy directors is a good idea there is nothing to stop this sovereign assembly, the Dáil, making that provision in the Bill rather than abdicating from the powers given them to a body the Minister will set up under his own rules.

Comment on this

I simply would not know whether it is the right thing to do in the reorganisation of these services. I submit that neither would Deputy Gibbons until he sees what form generally the reorganisation should and would take when people get down to their jobs, when this board is set up and they commence work. That is the time to make decisions as to the correct staffing of the organisation.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not envisage a huge workload being placed on the shoulders of the director who will be responsible for administering the affairs of this board and for promoting agricultural activities in the various fields throughout the country, particularly at a time when schemes are changing so rapidly and when new ones are coming forward as a result of our entry into the EEC and so on? It is very important, even at this stage, that some provision be made for the appointment of a deputy director because piloting the various schemes through will be a tremendous job.

Comment on this

I should like to ask the Minister how the present director of An Foras Talúntais will be affected, with the death of that body as we knew it?

Comment on this

I have given a specific undertaking that the position of any member of the staff of the bodies coming into this integrated service will not be worsened in any way, that at least they will be entitled to what they have at present.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that it would be physically impossible for a director to cover the complete field and that it will be necessary to have deputy directors appointed, as was suggested by Deputy Gibbons? Why not incorporate such provision in the Bill now?

Comment on this

Might I say that the person who knows the strength of his own back and capacity would be the person who would have the responsibility to carry out such a task? That would be the time for him to decide what additional help he would need. He is free to appoint whatever additional help he might feel he needs in order to do the job properly.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that it would take a considerable time for the director to ascertain the capabilities of his staff and that agriculture could suffer in the meantime. The Minister will be completely dependent on one man.

Comment on this

The services will improve. That is why we are doing this.

Comment on this

The sole concern of the director of An Foras Talúntais was research and it bore magnificent fruits for the country. The institute are now being abolished, finished, destroyed and the director of the new body will have responsibility not only for research but for the entire unreformed services which I forecast will not be nearly as good as they have been. I cannot understand the mentality of a Minister who would try to argue that agricultural research will be as well served by a director who will have two other fields to serve. The Minister knows that is not so.

I know all the narks and grievances that gave rise to the abolition of An Foras Talúntais. The Department of Agriculture have a few things to be proud of but they have a few things to be ashamed of, and this is one of them. There is nothing this party can do to stop the passage of the Bill once the bit has been shoved between the Minister's teeth by the interested parties in the Department. I reiterate that the situation in regard to the proper carrying out of research will have to be restored by a future Government who will not be as amenable to being pushed around by interested people in the Department as the Minister seems to think.

Comment on this

I would describe as disgraceful the performance of Deputy Gibbons in blaming the officials of the Department for everything he sees wrong in the Bill that I am taking total responsibility for, that I am happy about and proud of. Otherwise I would not have brought it to the House. On the point in relation to the deputy director, when Fianna Fáil set up An Foras Talúntais they made no provision for such a post but a deputy director was appointed subsequently by the board because they felt it necessary to do so. One of the purposes for which the board are being established is to see that there are adequate staff. If I were to decide what the staff should be I would be told by the Opposition that I would be dictating to the board before they were set up.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not think he is putting too much responsibility on one man?

Comment on this

I am putting the responsibility on the board to appoint the staff they think will be necessary.

Comment on this

Everybody knows that in co-operatives and other such organisations decisions have to be made by the director and if he has too many departments to look after he will not do an efficient total job. There should be some indication in the Bill that a deputy director will be appointed.

Comment on this

Subsection (10) states:

The Board may, with the consent of the Government, at any time remove the Director from office.

Does this refer to the first director or to directors who may be appointed subsequently?

Comment on this

This is normal practice —it was in the Foras Talúntais Act The board will be appointed by the Minister. Even though the majority of them will be nominated people, the Minister has to go through the formal act of appointing them and therefore he has the formal act of dispensing with their services.

Comment on this

Can the board fire the first director if he is found not to be doing his job properly?

Comment on this

They have power to do so with the consent of the Minister.

Comment on this

I do not want to weary the House but I think it is relevant to say that the clearer it becomes that the all-pervading civil service are being allowed, in every section——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy will appreciate that it is wrong to reflect on officials. The Minister is responsible and any blame or praise should be directed at him, not at his officials.

Comment on this

I was referring to the abstract thing, bureaucracy. In its own context, it is beneficial and useful, but when it goes on the rampage it becomes a danger to freedom and to democracy itself. The invasion of the areas of research of the advisory services by bureaucracy is to be deprecated and deplored. Section 32, as many other sections, illustrates the all-pervading intrusion of bureaucracy in this vital field.

Comment on this

The Minister is inclined to contradict himself on subsection (3) of the section. On other sections he said he would leave the running of the functions to the authority that would be appointed. Subsection (3) provides:

The programme as adopted by the Board shall be submitted to the Minister for his approval. The Minister may, in conveying approval, indicate such further amendments of the programme as he considers necessary.

It goes on to say:

The Board may, however, with the approval of the Minister, make such alterations to the programme as it subsequently considers necessary.

It is the approval of the Minister that I am concerned about. Can we presume then that this affects factors outside of financial requirements, and can we presume that if the board consider an item, either educational or one of research, important enough to be included, it can be deleted by the Minister under the subsection? Why not give the authority full power to run their programme of research or education as he has indicated in the previous sections? Why take the control from them here? It is a contradiction by the Minister when one considers the other sections.

Comment on this

A few minutes ago the Minister seemed to be greatly concerned with leaving the control with the director. Subsection (3) would certainly give us cause for concern because, as Deputy Noonan has pointed out, the Minister may, in conveying approval, make such further amendments in the programme as he considers necessary.

Over the last few years the stock phrases from this Government were "financial constraint" and "shortage of money". There is no doubt that if any agricultural development programmes went over the last few years to the Department they would be slashed. In this subsection we are coming back to complete departmental control and that is what we must fear.

Comment on this

This subsection proves conclusively that we are correct in stating that this board has no authority at all. Subsection (3) places the Minister in the position of the board. The board can do nothing here. Everything has to be submitted to the Minister. Questions of finance must be submitted to the Minister. Therefore in regard to any research or development programme the Minister can put down his foot and say it cannot be done.

Comment on this

I dealt with this fairly exhaustively when replying on Second Stage, but it might be no harm to spell out again what is intended here. I stated on Second Stage that the Minister for Agriculture has responsibility for the development of all aspects of the agricultural industry. He has to satisfy himself that the necessary resources are applied to whatever sector needs support at any time. We have given an undertaking in this Bill that the moneys provided for this new authority will be not less in real terms than the moneys at present being provided for the separate authorities that are coming together in an integrated service. That surely is an assurance to those concerned. We have just been told that the Government could decide to starve the services and provide no money for them. Specific provision is being made that in real terms it cannot be less than it is at present. Therefore Deputies should not have fears about something that cannot happen.

The proposed authority will have such an influence on agricultural development that the Minister must satisfy himself that the programme is adequate before he gives it his approval to go ahead. I think that is reasonable. However, when the programme has been agreed, the authority will be completely free in carrying it out and in publishing their own results. The Government will have nothing to do with publishing results and they will not compel them to publish results of the individual experiments on researches they are doing. I think a Minister for Agriculture should not interfere in the day-to-day conduct of research or in the publication of the results of this research. That should be the responsibility of the research authority, and that is the way I want it to remain.

The position, however, is that most of the finance needed by the authority will come from the State. While I have no intention of insisting that he who pays the piper should call the tune, a Minister for Agriculture could be charged by this House with evasion of responsibility if he were not concerned always with the setting up of priorities in regard to what projects ought to be undertaken at any time to promote the development of agriculture. I believe that it is a gross exaggeration to say that it will impinge on the freedom of the staff of the authority if the Minister is interested in and concerned about what this new authority, that is all-embracing in its service to agriculture, should be engaged in. In almost every country around the world the Minister for Agriculture takes a vital interest in the functions which will be the concern of the authority, and I think that is as it should be. This does not prevent such countries being among the leaders in agricultural development, and the countries to which I am referring are the envy of most of us. Therefore, I could not possibly accept that there is anything wrong about this.

Comment on this

Could I ask the Minister what was wrong with An Foras Talúntais that he had to destroy it?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not relevant now.

Comment on this

The Minister has not satisfied me at all. In what the Minister read out he has contradicted himself having regard to section 32 (3). Some time ago he was talking about giving authority to the members of the board that is to be set up.

Comment on this

To appoint staff.

Comment on this

To appoint staff to carry out their jobs. Now he is saying in another voice that the self-same authority are not men of the calibre, as he stated earlier, to carry out the functions set out in this Bill. The Minister cannot have it both ways. He referred to his Second Reading speech. He has contradicted himself. Subsection (3)—

Comment on this

Nonsense.

Comment on this

Why not give the board authority to carry out their functions as they see fit? He said previously he would not do anything daft. I hope he will not. If the board considered that an item of research or an item of education was important, under this section the Minister could withdraw it. On the one hand he is setting up the board and on the other hand he is taking authority away from them because they have to go to him for approval.

Comment on this

Deputy Noonan has said most of what I intended to say. The Minister said that in real terms the same amount of money will be provided. Is he serious? What is the idea of setting up a board such as this if we do not intend to develop agriculture? Does the Minister consider that the amount of money made available to the committees of agriculture——

Comment on this

This is a guaranteed minimum.

Comment on this

It is only chicken-feed having regard to what we would like to do in the development of agriculture. We are told the board are being set up to do more research and to do more in the educational field to develop agriculture. In real terms they will only have the same budget as previously. What is the idea of the change? Under subsection (3) the board will not be allowed to expand agriculture. The Minister is taking complete authority. I am not being personal. Any Minister could do the same. The board are being completely controlled and I object to that.

Comment on this

We are justified in our fears about this subsection. It is obvious the board will not have the power we would like them to have for the development of agriculture. While we know Deputy Clinton, as Minister for Agriculture, would be sympathetic to any proposal which would enhance the livelihood of farmers, it might happen that Deputy Desmond would become Minister for Agriculture and then it would be God help the Irish farmers.

Comment on this