We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 128–258 of 258. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill National Agricultural Advisory, Education and Research Authority Bill, 1976
Enacted

No. 42 of 1976 ›

Mocking is catching.

Comment on this

The Deputy would be surprised.

Comment on this

He might not be as sympathetic——

Comment on this

What way did Fianna Fáil Deputies vote today in Europe?

Comment on this

I am not concerned about Europe at the moment.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us not bring in irrelevancies.

Comment on this

At least I was never a rag-bag Gaullist whatever else I was.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a salmon pink socialist.

Comment on this

I was never that hard up.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Let us not indulge in personalities.

Comment on this

I am trying to highlight the dangers inherent in this subsection. If a Deputy like socialist Barry Desmond were appointed Minister for Agriculture——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I have asked that we should not indulge in personalities.

Comment on this

The Minister started it.

Comment on this

The subsection takes away power from the board which we hoped would be of some benefit to agriculture. The subsection provides:

The Minister may, in conveying approval, indicate such further amendments of the programme as he considers necessary.

That is very strong language. It indicates to me that the Minister will have the final say in any programme submitted by the board. For that reason, they have lost the freedom they require to promote and develop agriculture. That is a very retrograde step.

Comment on this

Unless Deputies opposite want me to abolish the office of Minister for Agriculture entirely, I believe I could not give any more power or authority to the board than they are getting.

Comment on this

They have none.

Comment on this

It is very good times when Deputy Callanan talks about mini-provisions and a mini-budget when he is talking about £18 million. If that is a mini-provision for the services we are talking about, we have gone very high up on the scale.

Comment on this

The Minister knows it is not adequate.

Comment on this

I am endeavouring to get better use of the money being spent on these services by combining them and getting better teamwork and better results from the same amount of money and any additional money I can find for them.

Comment on this

I can assure the Minister he will not.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree he is retaining power to restrict the financing of the programmes of the authority?

Comment on this

That was always there.

Comment on this

The Minister mentioned the availability of money. With the inflationary rate——

Comment on this

I said in real terms.

Comment on this

He is retaining that power and he should admit it.

Comment on this

Every Government have to retain power to decide how the taxpayers' money will be spent.

Comment on this

When the proposals are submitted and the plan is prepared for the succeeding year, if an item of urgency crops up that needs to be examined can it be dealt with?

Comment on this

It can.

Comment on this

Under this Bill?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Is there power under the section to have proposals recommended by the local county committees examined by the authority, or will they have to go to the Minister's office for approval?

Comment on this

Yes, for final approval.

Comment on this

In the overall plan?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

Again we have a restriction on the programme. This section should be deleted.

Comment on this

Invariably money is the restriction.

Comment on this

The Minister plucked a figure of £80 million out of the air——

Comment on this

£18 million.

Comment on this

Right. Is the modernisation scheme from the European Community included in this figure?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

We oppose the section.

Comment on this

I would ask the Minister to tell the House that this section does not mean what I suspect it means, that people on the staff, whether they be specialists of one kind or another engaged in research or advisory or educational work, will all be equated and made into a kind of milk pudding mixture in which men will lose their identity and be stamped with a particular grade, a Department of Agriculture grade, like eggs and the possible reward for specialisation which might go to a more independent authority will be gone under the provisions of this section? I would ask the Minister to enlighten us as to the true meaning of this section.

Comment on this

In this section the method of recruitment and the determination of the staff's conditions of service are set out, and the board of the authority are given the widest possible discretion in regard to staff matters. Why should people lose their identity suddenly when they are run by another board? Why should that board decide that a man with certain qualifications should not be put in an appropriate position and get an appropriate job to do? That will give him his own identity if he has what is necessary to identify himself in his work. I know something about the people Deputy Gibbons is concerned about. These people will always come through as exceptional people if they are entitled to identification. They are part of a bigger organisation and that is a good thing for them as well as for the country.

A number of people have voiced their concern about the position of staff within the new authority. I take this opportunity to dispel these anxieties which are, I am certain, totally unwarranted. First, it has been suggested that the considerable freedom given to the board in section 33, which will take effect immediately following the establishment of the authority, will be nullified through the subsequent application of section 34 which requires the board to submit a staff scheme or schemes for the regulation, control and management of the authority staff to the Minister and to the Minister for the Public Service for their approval. The point is that there is no reason why the autonomy in regard to staff matters which the board will enjoy initally by virtue of section 33 should not be subsequently incorporated in the general scheme or schemes under section 34. A good deal of anxiety has been felt about this matter and I wanted to clear it. What I am saying is that people come into the authority with certain rights. They retain those rights absolutely and no staff scheme can change them unless the staff want voluntarily to accept what is being offered in the new staff scheme that may be subsequently prepared. Therefore, in my view there should be no fears for staff coming into this authority.

Comment on this

I am relieved by the assurances given by the Minister, but which are not necessarily contained in section 33, in relation to the staff transfer situation. It is undoubtedly true that there has been a good deal of concern about the full implications of this section. There is a particular difficulty in relation to this section and that is that the board will be given authority under it to determine from time to time the qualifications, numbers, grades, tenure of office, conditions of service and so on, of the staff of the new authority. This is, of course, subject to sections 34 and 65.

While I am pleased to note the Minister has amended section 65, the full import of section 33 is still a matter of some concern. It is not unfair to draw the Minister's attention to the somewhat similar proposals which are contained in the Bill relating to the National Board of Science and Technology where such stringency as is seen in sections 33 and 34 are not to be found.

It is difficult to discuss section 33 in its entirely because subsections (4) and (5) are subject to sections 34 and 65. Perhaps we should have taken sections 33 and 34 together. In no way should the concern of the staff of the Agricultural Institute be heightened by the complex staff industrial relations situation which inevitably exists in any relatively large organisation.

While I am certain the Minister will honour the undertakings he has given that in no way will staff conditions be worsened on transfer—that is implicit, clearly understood and accepted by the staff—nevertheless, I would have been happier, and the trade unions involved would have been happier, if section 33 had been permitted to stand apart without the caveat being entered into in relation to section 34.

As an ex-trade union official, I do not know of any other legislation, even when we were drafting for organisations like AnCO, the Institute for Industrial Research and Standards and so on, where such implicit control was inserted. I am fearful that there may be industrial relations problems in relation to section 33. Admittedly the board can now proceed, on immediate transition, to determine the qualifications, numbers, grades and so on subject to section 34, that is, subject to their submitting a staff scheme as soon as convenient.

In any organisation where there is a wide variety of grades, research staffs and so on employed, it is almost impossible to define just what is a staff scheme. Knowing how bloody-minded some people can be, it may take an inordinately long time to get a consensus, particularly with a new board, on what precisely constitutes a staff scheme. Under section 33 this would be subject to the Minister, the senior hierarchy of his Department, the Minister for the Public Service and the Houses of the Oireachtas. Perhaps the Minister would have a fresh look at this before Report Stage so that undue fears may be mitigated.

I fully accept the Minister's good faith in this regard. I know his intentions are the very best but I am concerned lest it would unnecessarily give rise to areas of what one might call disaffection and contrariness which would impose undue restrictions on the negotiating staff procedures, particularly of the Agricultural Institute. Perhaps I might remind the Minister that his ministerial colleagues when introducing legislation did not find it necessary to have such rigidity as exists in this Bill. Sections 33 and 34 could be composed in a more flexible manner. I share the Minister's view that we need integration and rationalisation, but unfortunately some people are interpreting this as a dilution of their status, prospects or salary scales.

Inevitably one is suspicious of a new organisation. One always tends to fear the worst. I would be quite happy with subsections (4) and (5) standing as they are without being subject to section 34. Somebody must be the final arbitrator, the Minister for Agriculture in relation to the global provisions and the Minister for the Public Service in relation to staff structuring. Organisations are, of course, very complex. Invariably one has in them a wide variety of expertise and skills. Invariably there are certain precedents. Over the 20-year period of their existence the Agricultural Institute had built up their own structure and their own negotiating procedures. It is important that in this transition undue friction should be avoided. To avoid anything like friction the Minister should have a look at sections 33 and 34 between now and Report Stage to see if there is a necessity to have staff schemes formally approved by the Oireachtas. God knows, we have enough to do without embroiling ourselves in staffing arrangements.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

It does seem to the Chair that we are now discussing section 34.

Comment on this

Sections 33 and 34 are inextricably bound together.

Comment on this

The final sentence of subsection (3) says: "the Board shall consider the recommendation of the panel". Does it follow from that that the board need not necessarily accept the recommendation of the panel? On my next point I will be guided by the Chair. Where promotional facilities are concerned within the existing staff I do not want a situation to arise in which the existing staff might find they would have to transfer to another field in order to gain promotion.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

That would arise on section 65. Sections 33 and 34 are related but what the Deputy is now talking about would arise relevantly on section 65.

Comment on this

I agree with Deputy Desmond that the two sections are more or less inextricably bound up with each other.

Comment on this

Would the Minister answer my question about the recommendation of the panel?

Comment on this

The wording here is exactly the same as that in the Act setting up An Foras Talúntais. There is no change.

Comment on this

I fully appreciate the difficulties we are facing here and I agree with Deputy Desmond there is no precedent. However, there is no time within which a scheme or schemes must be prepared. The section simply requires the board to submit a scheme as soon as it finds it convenient to do so. The reason for specifying the submission of such a scheme is to provide for the closer integration of the existing staff groups which will be combined within the new authority so that the staff will act as a team in a proper environment designed to make the maximum contribution to the development of agriculture. The scheme will have to be agreed voluntary and so it should not hold any fears for the staff. I repeat that the existing staff come in with all the rights they have at the moment unchanged and with all the conditions they enjoy at present. The approach will be one of encouragement, not coercion. That, in my view, would be counter-productive. There is no question of the conditions of the staff transferred being worsened. I emphasise that.

Comment on this

I would like to accept the Minister's assurances but I simply cannot. First of all, I do not see the necessity for the collectivisation of all the people involved in all the different sectors amalgamated in the new authority. It is as if the Minister put all of them into khaki uniforms of the same kind and deprived them of any personality or identity of their own. I do not think this will be readily accepted by people in the service, whether on the advisory services, in what is left of the remnants of An Foras Talúntais or in agricultural education. I do not think it will be popular with any of them. I do not see any need for treating a man whose business is teaching in the same way as a man whose business is research or possibly a third person whose work is advisory. They are three different separate functions. This section will give rise to trouble because it seeks to impose uniformity that does not exist.

Comment on this

There is no doubt in my mind but that it will give rise to trouble. However, the fact that there is nothing binding on the staff and that such a scheme can come into existence only with the agreement of the staff makes it worth-while. I was asked if I would be prepared to look at this matter again before Report Stage and, of course, I am prepared to do this. If anything it puts additional work and responsibility on whoever is in my place and on the people responsible for the effective working of the organisation subsequently but if it could be done it would be desirable to bring the staff together, to let them feel they were all staff of the one authority and as a result, they would work more as a team. That was the reason for including the provision. I am not particularly tied to it and, if it is the wish of the House that I should look at it between now and Report Stage I will do so.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his comments on this matter. Perhaps the inclusion of the words "following consultation with the relevant staff organisation concerned" after the words "the board shall prepare and submit to the Minister" might be considered. This would be a major acceptance that these things are subject to negotiations. I am only suggesting consultations at this stage because inevitably the question of negotiations will arise. In relation to section 4 the Minister may consider it unnecessary. For example, the order for an increase in the salaries of Deputies was placed before the House some weeks ago but it will not go through before the middle of May. We will not get any money before June but people in the country will think we are getting another rise. The Minister might want to have an urgent amendment of the staff scheme following national wage negotiations or some internal negotiations. The board might submit this to the Department and it would have to be before the House for 21 sitting days. We might be in the middle of the summer recess——

Comment on this

That is democracy breaking out.

Comment on this

The Minister has been superb in his accountability. Perhaps section 4 is unnecessary and the whole of section 34 might be looked at. I would be glad if the Minister would do so before Report Stage.

Comment on this

I can give that guarantee.

Comment on this

I am opposed to the section.

Comment on this

It is generally accepted that the functions and duties of committees of agriculture as we have known them are going to be radically changed by the provisions of this section and this will apply to the composition of committees. The last function they had as independent bodies in the appointment of temporary staff is mercifully being taken away. However, there is a considerable opinion that new arrangements for the new committees will convert them into rubber stamp organisations. It is thought they may talk until the cows come home but they will have little effect on policy if what they recommend does not meet with the approval of the Minister and his most immediate servants in the Department of Agriculture.

I made certain suggestions about the advisory services. They are my own ideas and I stand over them and if the Minister wants to regale the House by quoting them again he is at liberty to do so. There is a large body of opinion, in his party as well as in other parties, that would reject the removal from committees of agriculture of the last little vestige of authority which they had. I do not approve of the creation of rubber stamp bodies of any kind. I should prefer to see proper county committees of agriculture elected possibly by a restricted electorate composed of people from the farming and food producing industries, including food processing as well as food producing. An electorate such as that could exercise their franchise just as other people use their local authority franchise. I put that idea before the House as my own idea of a possible way out, of creating a democratically elected worth-while organisation. The individuals concerned would be elected by people from the food industry to carry out similar functions to those envisaged in the Bill.

There is an anomaly in this Bill. This afternoon the Minister accredited some considerable importance to the General Council of County Committees of Agriculture. He indicated that their representation on the board will be at least one member. It could possibly be two, three or four. Under this section the real effectiveness of the committees of agriculture is taken away. A considerable part of their democratic structure is taken away along with it. It is all very fine to say that we will have representatives from the IFA, the ICMSA and other organisations, like Macra na Feirme, that may or may not be represented on the committee of agriculture. It is unsatisfactory that the people we are talking about will not have been elected by the people from the industry as they could fairly easily be elected by people from the farming industry or from the industries that develop from farming.

That is not the kind of committee we will get under section 36. We will get a committee that is neither fish, flesh nor good red herring. There are some realities that stand out no matter what one's general approach to agricultural research and advice may be. One of those is the very strong county allegiance. It does not matter that one might say that the county boundaries were prepared by different English administrations in the country in the 16th and 17th centuries but the county allegiance is very strong. One has to live with it whether or not one likes it. If we take a sample of popular opinion from farmers and people in the industry in general, a very heavy majority I believe favour the continuance of the committee of agriculture. Since this is so, the committee of agriculture should be a worth-while community representative of the industry. I do not think we can get that under section 36 and, therefore, I oppose it.

Comment on this

I am opposed to this section because it suggests that county committees of agriculture will only be in an advisory capacity. The way they will be constituted under this Bill the people who pay the piper will have very little to say. As the Minister knows, the people to whom he will give representation are elected by the county committee of agriculture. The Minister proposes a 50 : 50 basis on the advisory committee. All the powers which the county committees had are taken from them. We are not sorry about some of them particularly the one relating to the appointment of temporary staff. I believe the county committees of agriculture were doing a reasonably good job. I cannot see what the benefit will be. I am chairman of a county committee of agriculture and I know we would like to do a lot more. We could only get so many pence in the pound. Since it was increased, the amount of money is still inadequate. We have still to get a certain amount of money from the ratepayers. It is 50 : 50 in the east and in the west of Ireland it is 75 : 25. That is the ratio of the collection of money from the ratepayers.

It could happen, if some public representatives did not want a particular man to get on to the committee, and they lined up with rural organisations that no member of the local authority or any elected representatives need be on the general council. The general council will get direct representation on to the board. This is completely undemocratic. We all want to see farming organisations on the county committees of agriculture but at least 75 per cent of them should be elected representatives so that we can be sure that the people who pay the piper know a little about how the tune is being called.

This is not a party issue. I do not know what is wrong with this House. Everybody knows political parties and that one must toe the line or get out when a vote is called but I did not think we were compelled to sit down and not express our views. I am always prepared to vote for my party but I will stand up and express my views. I know the views about county committees of agriculture on the Government side of the House but there are empty benches there this evening. I cannot understand why they do not come in here and try to convince the Minister to change the system which he has put into the Bill. The Minister said he wanted us to be the watch dog for the people but this is a watch dog without any teeth whatever. We are going away from democracy here.

I know that good people may get on to this new council but they have no responsibility. They have not to go back to anybody or give an account of their stewardship to the people who pay the piper. If the elected representatives do not do a good job, the people will tell them in four or five years time to get out. We are taking from the people who pay the piper the power to remove people who do not do a good job when 75 per cent of the members of those committees are not public representatives.

I know that the Minister can come back at me and say that this is not the case. My own county can be fired back at me. It does not mean that any county do everything correctly. In the interests of democracy the public representatives should be in the majority so that enough of them get on to the body that the Minister will give representation on. It is important that the county committees are constituted from elected representatives from every county.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am sure the Deputy will appreciate that what may be dealt with under this section is limited. It deals with the functions of the committees.

Comment on this

As far as I can see, the functions are nil. As Deputy Gibbons said, they are a rubber stamp. County committees cannot put up programmes because they will be vetoed along the line. Now there will be a board consisting of 24 members that will examine programmes submitted by every county. If the board do not like a certain programme submitted by a particular committee, they may go back to that committee saying, perhaps: "You will have to modify this in some way". When the money is pooled, what will happen committees at present doing a good job who are, perhaps, spending a little more money than others? The board will have a say in what will it be spent in, say, County Galway, County Kildare and so on. They will vet the programmes submitted by the various county committees. When one has no responsibility there is the tendency to prepare very elaborate programmes and such may be the case with regard to people who did very little before this board was set up. For instance, if I were a member of a committee with no responsibility but charged merely with the job of preparing a programme of agricultural advice in my county, I could prepare one that would be completely unrealistic from a financial point of view. Is there a danger that, when the county committees of agriculture have lost their status, they would be somewhat irresponsible in preparing programmes for their counties?

I believe the Minister, in this Bill, will be doing a bad day's work by taking that responsibility from the present county committees of agriculture. At present they know the amount of money they can get from the ratepayers; they have to keep within that estimate and spend it to the best of their ability.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

Perhaps section 39 is the one under which the question of finance and programming might be dealt with.

Comment on this

I accept the Chair's ruling but I thought it was relevant to the duties of the county committees of agriculture with which we are now dealing. The functions of such committees are to prepare programmes and submit them to the new authority. I contend that a committee, having no responsibility, might prepare very elaborate programmes. I am afraid also that, when all the programmes from all the rubber stamp committees have been submitted to the authority for fine combing, the new board will have an impossible task. I should like the Minister's opinion on that aspect. I am speaking of the advisory committees, having no responsibility, everybody wanting to do the best they can, getting as much money as possible from the authority. I know that the ratepayers of such counties will have to put up the money but the county committees will not care if they do not have to account to their ratepayers.

Comment on this

They have to go back to the ratepayers.

Comment on this

They will not because they will not be public representatives, except, perhaps, very few of them. Therefore, they will be able to prepare any type of elaborate programme and shove it over on the ratepayers of their county. The problem I foresee is that of rubber stamp committees preparing unrealistic programmes with no responsibility whatever for their implementation or financing.

Comment on this

Subsection (1) says that every committee of agriculture shall submit the programme to the authority for consideration by the board, which programme may or may not be accepted. Will the county committees of agriculture themselves have any further function in this regard? Can the relevant programme be returned to the committee in question by the board for further scrutiny with, perhaps, further consideration by the board subsequently?

Subsection (2) (a) says:

Every committee of agriculture shall have, in addition to the powers and functions mentioned in subsection (1), the functions that were exercised or performed, or were capable of being exercised or performed, by it immediately before the commencement of this section....

This brings me to the point raised by Deputy Gibbons about the functions of the county committees of agriculture, the powers being transferred by them to the new board. What will be left to the county committees of agriculture? One might answer that they will submit programmes for their counties that may or may not be accepted by the board. Therefore, the situation will be that we will have county committees of agriculture with no real power. Here-tofore they had the power of selecting and appointing staff—although that was not very satisfactory from the point of view of temporary staff. Nevertheless, they had the power to provide education and advice which, as was rightly pointed out by Deputy Gibbons, is now being taken from them. Henceforth they will be rubber stamp committees.

As Deputy Gibbons further pointed out, it would be far better to have no committees at all than have ones such as are proposed in this Bill which would be more or less talking shops or rubber stamp committees for want of a better description. The Minister should give further thought to these county committees. I am not speaking here of their composition, which will arise later in the Bill, but rather of their functions under this section. Perhaps the Minister would comment on the power the committee may or may not have if a programme, as submitted by them, is rejected by the board.

Comment on this

The question may correctly be raised: have the county committees of agriculture any functions at all left? In future, I fear their programme will tend to be over-ambitious, that they will aim high knowing that such programmes will be diminished, thus leading to a lot of frustration when they would see that they had no real power left.

I foresee great danger in this Bill for the weaker agricultural counties, that they will not receive proper attention. There arises also the question of the pooling of funds. How does the Minister propose that such funds be used because it would be very difficult to have them spread evenly. Certainly, I feel it will be the cause of a lot of frustration within the county committees of agriculture and that they will become ineffective.

Comment on this

I might say that the functions of the county committees of agriculture are spelled out very clearly in the White Paper. If the House wishes me to restate those functions, I shall do so. My opinion is that such committees of agriculture will continue to perform a very important function under the new authority. Any board, and particularly that of the new authority composed of the people I described earlier, would be less than responsible and would not be doing their job properly had they not considerable regard to the programmes put up by the people living on the spot. Deputy Gibbons is quite right when he says that there is and will continue to be a lot of county loyalty, so to speak, and pride in what happens locally. This is a good thing, but they are given a very important role in the first instance. They will have to decide what they believe is the sort of programme that should be provided by the authority for individual areas in the county and individual counties.

Deputy Noonan asked what they can do when they have that done. Can they do nothing more about it? Can they appeal to anybody else if this is rejected? Of course the answer is that they can appeal. Section 36 (1) (a) says they may:

review, and make recommendations to the Minister and the Board, as appropriate, regarding, the operation of such programme and the schemes operated by the Minister in the county;

When they submit a programme they can follow it up and make representations either directly to the Minister or to the board. How effectively county committees will continue to function in future will depend to a very considerable extent on the sort of man the CAO in the county happens to be whether or not he is a dynamic, interested person, concerned with providing the best possible services for the farmers in that area. It will depend too on the quality of the county committees.

Deputy Callanan is concerned about the quality. We will be talking later on about that. He does not agree with the composition, but this is not the section under which to discuss that. However, it is unnecessary for me to go down through (a), (b), (c) and (d) of the responsibilities that are left with the county committees. They are important responsibilities and they will continue to be very important. I would be extremely disappointed if the committees regarded them as anything else and if they did not make the maximum use of organisations in existence at the moment and use them as they should be used.

Comment on this

Can the county committee appeal to the Minister if their programme is rejected by the board?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I thought the Minister in setting up this board was trying to rid himself of his responsibility, and here we are now back to the Minister. In other words, the Minister is a sort of appeals officer if the programme is rejected by the board. I was wondering what function the Minister would then have. Would he say to the board "My decision is that the recommendations of the county committee of agriculture concerned should be accepted by the board"? I am confused with regard to what the Minister has stated.

Comment on this

It is spelt out in section 36 (1) (a).

Comment on this

That the county committee can appeal to the Minister?

Comment on this

The Deputy has it in front of him.

Comment on this

I have, but has the Minister spelt it out himself? What will be his function when the appeal is made to his office?

Comment on this

I want to get out of the heads of Deputies that there is somebody in my position going around with a big stick walloping everybody if he is not doing what I think he should be doing in this. I want to encourage people to talk to one another in a friendly way and to work as a team. That is the only way the thing is going to work. This is giving the committees the right to approach the Minister or the right to approach the board and make further representations about their programme in case of misunderstanding or not seeing the importance of what they were proposing and recommending by way of programme to be followed in their area for the year ahead.

Comment on this

Who makes the overall decision, the board or the Minister?

Comment on this

The board will have the overall decision in consultation with the Minister.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that the board and the Minister will have a lot of applications before them. The Minister did not answer my question. There is a lot of development that could be done in agriculture in every area. If there was a dynamic committee in each area not responsible for paying the piper, the Minister will have a very heavy and expensive programme coming from every county if the committees are worth their salt. The Minister must say whether the board or the Minister will prevail finally. If we in Galway put up a scheme which is not acceptable to the board and we appeal to the Minister will he go to the board and say "The county committee have put up a scheme and why have the board turned it down"? The board may still turn it down. Is it the Minister or the board who then has the final decision as to whether the programme will be allowed or not? That is the most important question on the whole Bill.

Comment on this

"When are you going to stop beating your wife?" Is that what Deputy Callanan is saying?

Comment on this

Would the Minister answer the question?

Comment on this

I am not interested in beating my wife. It is a very important question and I want an answer.

Comment on this

Does it not seem that the next step would be to set up an appeals board? Would the Minister agree, from recent experience in this House regarding applications or pressures from counties to include a greater portion of the counties as handicapped in the underdeveloped areas, that he will have the same type of appeals coming now? He will have committees putting forward a fairly ambitious programme which in all probability will be turned down in many cases and will be going to the Minister for appeal and the matter will be back in the political ring with a tug here and a tug there to see that one county would get more than the other. Does he not see a danger in this that he will have to set up, as the Minister for Local Government had, an appeals board?

Comment on this

All these fears are based on the foolish assumption that this is going to be an unreasonable, ineffective board when set up and that it is going to do everything in one county and nothing in another. Part of the responsibility of the board will be to see that every area in the country gets fair play as far as the money available from the State and from the local authorities will go to providing the best possible services available. Deputy Callanan does not like the job of going back to the county council to look for some of this money. He has that responsibility at the moment. Only half of the members on his committee have to go back at present and he is killed with the idea that the same half will have to do it in future under this Bill.

Comment on this

Let the Minister not forget that there is a limit on the amount of money to be got from the county council and schemes must be kept within that limit. Under the new board as far as I know whatever money is asked for must be given.

Comment on this

Oh no.

Comment on this

It is written into it. The county council cannot refuse.

Comment on this

That is so.

Comment on this

When we are doing a programme at present we must keep within the limited amount we get from the county council. Under this new board there is no limit. If the new authority ask us for money, the county council have to cough it up. I would like the Minister's opinion on this.

Comment on this

This is not on this section at all.

Comment on this

It is the functions.

Comment on this

Provision is made for this in another section.

Comment on this

The function of the county committees of agriculture is referred to in this section. The function of the county committee is to prepare a programme. I am referring to the programme that may be prepared in all the counties in Ireland, because much development in agriculture is needed where there is no restraint whatsoever in relation to the amount of money they can ask from the local authority. I can see such programmes coming up and I would like the Minister's views on this. There is plenty of scope for development in every county in Ireland.

Comment on this

We are dealing with section 39.

Comment on this

It has emerged from discussion of this section that both the Minister and this side of the House share the view that committees of agriculture in counties are necessary. My party holds the view that committees, as the Minister envisages them in this Bill, will be deprived of any real value and of any function. The Minister appears to feel obliged to retain committees of agriculture because it would be politically unacceptable to do anything else but in retaining them he wants to deprive them of any effectiveness that they might have. I put it to the Minister that this is not necessary.

Since we require committees of agriculture we require them to be as effective as possible. In order to be as effective as possible they should be elected by people from the industry. I reject, and have always rejected, the idea that people from casual occupations have a real function on committees of agriculture. Other people in my party and in this House do not share my view. It should be possible to have an electoral list confined to people in the industry, farmers, farm workers and their families, workers in the fruit processing industry and their families, people in industries like Comhlucht Siúicre Éireann whose business is producing and selling food, whose livelihood and future is wrapped up in the food industry. They have a legitimate case for forming a specialised committee in each county to represent the food industry people, a committee with real functions who can say that they are the democratically elected representatives of the people from agriculture. Elections of this kind can be carried out at the same time as local government elections.

I can see no objection to a person who is a Member of the Dáil, a county council or a corporation, being also a member of a committee of agriculture, provided he is from the industry. Until people have a democratic base and have the right to call themselves democratically elected representatives of the people, they cannot insist on a certain status, and the committees of agriculture will not mean much. They will mean less than ever when the Minister's Bill is law. They meant little enough under the two-tier appointment system we have at present. Under the system I am suggesting, people from the farming organisations, from Macra na Feirme and so on, could put themselves forward for election on the same basis as everybody else. People from the processing side of the industry are entitled to representation. It is feasible to make a restricted electoral roll which would carry out the business of electing these committees of agriculture. If we do that we will have committees of agriculture with a real function. I would be grateful for the Minister's views on this suggestion.

Comment on this

I do not feel I am entitled to discuss the composition of committees of agriculture under this section. It comes up under section 42, not under section 36.

Comment on this

Is the Minister setting himself up as an appeals officer in regard to a programme which will be submitted by a county committee and rejected by the board?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

There is no comeback to a county committee whose programme is rejected by the board.

Comment on this

The Deputy is misreading subsection (1) of section 36.

Comment on this

Earlier the Minister said that they could appeal to him.

Comment on this

Yes, that is here in writing. They can appeal to me and to the board. The good sense of the Minister and the board should be sufficient to decide one way or the other as to whether a programme is a proper programme. Programmes will be amended because, as the Deputy said, committees will be too ambitious, especially if they think they have not to pay for them. They will have to pay for them and how they will pay is indicated in section 39 of the Bill.

Comment on this

In the event of a programme being turned down by the authority, the Minister adjudicates.

Comment on this

It is not a question of turning down.

Comment on this

The Minister adjudicates in consultation with the board. Is that correct?

Comment on this

I have not said so.

Comment on this

There is no comeback then. It is a matter for the board completely.

Comment on this

Does the board make the final decision? Who is the adjudicator? Before the Planning Board was set up, the Minister had the final decision on a planning application. Now we are going to have a county committee of agriculture which puts up a programme which is not accepted by the board. They appeal to the Minister and the Minister consults with the board. Who has the authority to say whether that will or will not be accepted?

Comment on this

That is all dealt with in section 32.

Comment on this

Would it be any harm for the Minister to inform us here and now who is to decide? I do not remember it coming up in section 32. Somebody must decide. It is a simple question.

Comment on this

The size of a programme that can be carried out always depends on the amount of money available to carry it out.

Comment on this

Of course, that is so. If a completely unrealistic programme is submitted and it goes on appeal to the Minister and the board, who says yes or no? Somebody must be in a position to say.

Comment on this

Have they the right of appeal at all?

Comment on this

Whether a full programme can be accepted eventually by the Minister entirely depends on the amount of money that can be provided for that programme.

Comment on this

We accept that, but who is the final arbitrator?

Comment on this

The man who provides the money eventually has to decide what will be possible.

Comment on this

So it is the Minister.

Comment on this

Priorities have to be set by somebody on behalf of the taxpayers and the ratepayers.

Comment on this

It is the Minister all the time.

Comment on this

I oppose the section.

Comment on this

Is the purpose of this merely to exclude forestry functions?

Comment on this

There is only a small bit of forestry being done and it is in Donegal.

Comment on this

What about the shelter belt scheme?

Comment on this

That is being done by the Forestry Division.

Comment on this

I am thinking about projects such as the growth of popular trees becoming a sizeable and profitable proposition on bits of waste land—something that could be included in an overall farm scheme.

Comment on this

I have explained that the shelter belt scheme remains. The Forestry Division provide grants for the type of thing Deputy Gibbons is looking for. They have the expertise and they are the right type of people to do it.

Comment on this

When a scheme is submitted, presumably by a local committee, the Minister can either accept or reject it. I am referring specifically to subsection (2). This seems to bear out what we said earlier, that the new committees can talk their heads off for as long as they like but if the Minister decides a scheme is not to his liking he can reject it. I do not believe this is a good system in modern days and it will bear very heavily on counties like Leitrim and Mayo, areas like west Cork, west Limerick, parts of Kerry and the Ulster counties in our jurisdiction. Subsection (4) will bear on county rates and militate against development in poorer counties, possibly to the overall advantage of the better-off counties. This is contrary to what should be national policy. If I am mistaken in what I have been saying I apologise.

Comment on this

There is no change here. Seventy-five per cent of the salaries of staffs was met by the State and that will continue to be the position in those counties. We can therefore say that special consideration was and is being given to poorer counties. If the board have the money and if those counties want more staff there is no reason why they cannot get them.

Comment on this

I do not want to be contentious on this, but as I see it in the modern context, certain areas will perish altogether unless special measures are taken to assist them, and such assistance will have to come from the Central Fund.

Comment on this