Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill, 1980: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–178 of 360. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 9 of 1980 ›
(Cavan-Monaghan): I have pointed out that the system of collecting revenue for the State or local authorities by rates is unjust and inequitable because it does not have regard to the capacity of the ratepayer to pay. It does not have any regard as to whether the ratepayer is well-off or in poor circumstances. The yardstick or method of assessment, the poor law valuation system, is almost 150 years old and the criteria used when it was introduced are no longer valid. The system was regarded as unjust and inequitable by all parties in this House and I would have thought that the method of collecting revenue for local authorities would have been changed away from rates. We were astounded to find that on the return to power of Fianna Fáil they set about extending the system to the agricultural community. In their first year in office they abolished the agricultural grant on valuations down to £75 and saved themselves £7 million. That was later reduced to £60 valuation, saving another £2 million. That £9 million went towards the rates Fianna Fáil removed from private houses although the former Taoiseach gave a solemn undertaking that there would not be any shifting of the rates from private houses to any other hereditaments, agricultural or industrial.
Section 1 is being introduced in pursuance of a budget announcement by the Minister for Finance which was to the effect that one of the principal objectives of the budget was to introduce greater equity into the taxation system. Instead of introducing greater equity this Bill is doing the direct opposite.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I am putting on record the effect that section will have on the farming community.
Comment on this
The Deputy cannot go through the entire field of taxation. The section reduces the valuation to £40.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I will keep within those guidelines and, if I wish, I can keep within them for quite a while. Instead of introducing equity the Government are extending the injustice of the rating system. I should like to give some examples of this inequity. Last year the rate in the £ was £11 and this year it has been increased to £12. The effect of this is to increase the rates payable on a valuation of £40 from £198 to £480, an increase of 142 per cent. The rates payable on a valuation of £41 will be increased from £205.7 last year to £492 this year while the rates payable on a valuation of £59 will increase from £344 to £708, an increase of 106 per cent. It is worth noting that the highest percentage increase is on the lowest valuation in this bracket. The percentage increase on a poor law valuation of £40 is 142 per cent while the percentage increase on a PLV of £59 is 106 per cent. That is not introducing great equity into the taxation system.
The Bill discriminates against the agricultural community compared with the non-agricultural sector.
Comment on this
We must keep to the section before the House. The Deputy is getting into other fields of taxation. We are only dealing with rates and rates on agricultural land.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): We are dealing with more than that because I have no doubt that the Minister will tell the House that we must deduct income tax relief from the rates. They are connected.
Comment on this
The Deputy is well aware that speeches on Committee Stage are not in order; they are relevant to the Second Stage.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): The Chair is overlooking the fact that it is said that it is possible to take credit for the rates as against income tax.
A married couple in the non-agricultural sector with an income of £3,400 are free of income tax and do not pay rates. But a farmer who has a valuation of £34 and is deemed, according to the Agricultural Institute, to earn £3,400—the same as his non-agricultural friends—is liable for heavy rates. If he were a non-agricultural person earning £4,000, married with two children, he would be free from income tax and would not pay rates. But if he is a farmer with a poor law valuation of £40 with an assumed income according to the best information available—of £4,000 he is not liable to income tax but is liable for £480 rates. I want to know whether that is introducing greater equity into the taxation system. In my opinion it is discrimination against the farmer as compared with his non-agricultural counterpart.
We are told by the Minister, and his Minister of State, that of course the farmer will be given credit for those rates against his income tax liability, that is if he is liable to income tax. All of us know that many farmers in the bracket about which we are now speaking, on the accounts system, or indeed on any other system, would not be liable to income tax because of their family commitments, their method of farming or their incomes. Nevertheless these people are being called upon to pay heavy increases in rates this year as a result of the provisions of this Bill, increases ranging from the lowest rung of the group with which we are dealing, of 142 per cent in the case of a farmer with a £40 valuation on down to an increase of 106 per cent in the case of a farmer with a £59 valuation. That is totally unjust. Furthermore, we are told that the farmer can deduct the rates from his income tax. He cannot deduct this year's rates from this year's income tax; he can deduct last year's rates from this year's income tax if he is liable to income tax. Now he is being asked to pay portion of his income tax liability one year in advance, again discriminating against the farming community as compared with the non-farming sector.
I should like the Minister to tell us how much this reduction in the poor law valuation for the agricultural grant will save the Exchequer this year. In my opinion it will save approximately £10 million in round figures. If that sum of £10 million is correct, or anything like correct, it will mean that the Government will have saved approximately £20 million in agricultural grants since they assumed office. If that is so it constitutes a serious transfer of the rates on private dwellings to agricultural land and is in contravention of the solemn assurance given by the former Taoiseach when it was alleged that rates on private dwellings would be transferred by this Government to industrial buildings or to agricultural land.
Comment on this
That does not arise on this section. Would the Deputy please deal with the section before the House?
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I should like the Chair to go down to some constituency, Wexford, for example, and——
Comment on this
The Chair is not to be involved in the debate. The Chair must control the debate and he is telling the Deputy that he is again making a Second Stage speech. There is one section only before the House at present. The principle of this Bill was adopted on Second Stage.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): Far be it from me to involve the Chair in any political discussions or any economic questions——
Comment on this
The Chair can defend his position in Wexford or anywhere else if he wants. The Deputy should not worry about the Chair.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): If somebody, whom we shall call Mr. A, was to go down to Wexford and tell a farmer there that a transfer of rates from private houses to his farm was not of any concern or was not worthy of discussion in the House I know what Mr. A would be told to do with himself.
Comment on this
The Deputy should not allege that the Chair is saying things he did not say. All the Chair is endeavouring to do is to keep the House on Committee Stage, on section 1 of the Bill.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): The only point I was making—and I submit with the greatest respect is a relevant one—was that this section transfers rates from private houses to agricultural land. I want to put on record that I am against that and contend that it is relevant to do so. It is against an assurance given by the former Taoiseach, Deputy Lynch, when he was challenged on this in relation to the Fianna Fáil manifesto. I have made my case as strenuously and, I hope, as clearly as I can.
I have taken a rate of £11 in the £ for last year and £12 for this year, a conservative rate because I understand that the rate in the £ in Mayo is £17.46 and in Kerry £15.11. Of course the effect on farmers there with valuations of £40 and upwards would be much more serious. I readily concede that there would not be the same percentage of such farmers in Mayo or Kerry as there would be perhaps in Counties Kildare and Meath. But so far as my constituency is concerned many farmers will be affected by this unjust operation. Between the two counties there are 1,171 farmers who will be affected in addition to those who were brought into the full rating system last year and the year before. There are 495 such farmers in County Cavan and 676 in County Monaghan. I am sure they will be very concerned about section 1 which transfers rates from the private houses of well-off people to farms.
Comment on this
I wish to add my voice to this protest because I represent a constituency where 1,500 farmers will be affected. We were told two years ago that any section of the community which did not derive benefit from the abolition of domestic rates would not have to pay extra. In this case the Government are more than doubling rates for many people. The Minister may say that farmers derive benefit from the abolition of domestic rates but the people who will be affected by the provisions of this Bill generally live in older houses which have an average valuation of £5. We must compare that with the average valuation of a new bungalow at £23 or £24. People who have a good income may benefit from the abolition of rates and I am not suggesting that I am opposed to this. I was one of those associated with the Government which began the abolition of domestic rates, but it was not then suggested that the difference would be made up by any other section of the community. The original intention was that the expense would be borne by the Exchequer and in this Bill we have a complete turn around. This Government have given the impression that there would be protection against further increases for other sections of the community.
The local authorities will not derive any benefit as a result of this imposition. If some portion were to be given to the local authorities, I would be prepared to accept it because it is badly needed.
The Minister speaks about relief but there is no relief whatsoever for those with a valuation between zero and £40. This year the agricultural sector are badly off. There are counties which will not suffer but there is an obligation on me to protest at this measure because I represent a constituency where the rates of 1,500 people will be doubled. We are being told that they are not making an extra contribution and are not subsidising anybody but it can be clearly seen that the farming community are the victims when one considers the allocation to county councils this year in respect of domestic rates and compares that with the agricultural grant during the past three years. I am not opposed to big farmers making a contribution but this measure will affect people of very limited means. Deputy Bruton has already given the average rural income and every rural Deputy is familiar with these facts.
In speaking of Munster I am speaking of people with more than average good land but there are people in my constituency with valuations of £40 and £50 who are in dire straits to meet their rates at present. I shudder to think that a rural Deputy would vote in favour of this Bill. I would welcome a contribution from the backbenchers on the Government side in regard to this measure. I could not defend it and I doubt if it could be defended by anybody else, particularly by those who made certain statements in 1977. An opportunity has been taken by the Government who are in dire straits for finance and it is obvious that the agricultural sector is the most vulnerable. I hope the Minister will reconsider it in view of the serious consequences for the agricultural community.
Comment on this
The purpose of this Bill is to make available to farmers relief in respect of rates. If this Bill fails to pass through the House we cannot pay to the local authorities relief which would be due for people who still qualify. The amount involved this year is £37.7 million and the Bill is necessary in order to permit us to pay that sum on behalf of farmers who are entitled to relief. Deputy Fitzpatrick asked how big a saving is involved and the sum involved is £6 million, not £10 million.
Comment on this
It will cost an extra £6 million. Regarding the allegation that farmers are being asked to bear the burden of the relief of domestic rates, the grant this year in lieu of rates on domestic dwellings, community halls and farm out-buildings comes to just over £107 million. This is being paid by the Exchequer or, in other words, by the taxpayer. The total amount this year for the relief of agricultural rates is £37.7 million, making a total of more than £144 million from the Exchequer and the taxpayer for the relief of rates. We must have this Bill in order to make this relief available to farmers having a valuation below £40.
There are 497,686 rated agricultural holdings. Of this number, 396,871 are under £20 valuation and no rates are paid. Of the remainder, 58,684 have valuations between £20 and £40 and there is partial relief. There is 80 per cent relief on the rate up to £20 valuation and 30 per cent on the remainder, except for those between £20 and £33 who pay the full rate in the £13 as well as getting relief on the £20. The number of holdings affected by the fact that the ceiling has been lowered from £60 to £40 this year is just over 20,000. In Deputy Fitzpatrick's county there are 19,969 rated holdings under £20 valuation. There are 2,865 between £20 and £40 which are getting partial relief and there are 495 holdings with valuations between £40 and £60.
The section mentions anomalies in our valuation system and the unfairness and inequity involved in them. We debated this question about two years ago. All agreed that the valuation system is not the fairest system possible where land is concerned. This is because of the variations from one area to another, even in small areas inside the same county, caused by the famous Griffith's valuation and the manner in which the valuation of land was assessed at that time. However, that is the valuation system on which we still work. Changes in the valuation system where land is concerned are not a matter for my Department. The Valuation Office comes under the Department of Finance.
There are no plans at the moment to revalue the land of this country. I have heard mention of valuations on an acreage basis or some such system, but I understand that the farming organisations are opposed to this. In other words, they would prefer the existing valuation system. The present system is the only way we have of levying rates on land at present. The question of asking the farming community to bear a major or sizeable part of the burden caused by the derating on the domestic side is not correct. All that is being saved—call it what you like—this year is £6 million.
Comment on this
It would cost £6 million more. In other words, instead of £37.7 million we would be talking about £43.7 million for which this Bill would be responsible.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): Is the Minister aware of the effect of the agricultural relief grant on all holdings over £40 valuation? How many would be involved? There were nine previously, but that would have to be adjusted. I imagine it would be in the neighbourhood of 20.
Comment on this
I do not have that figure available right now. As the Deputy will understand from the figures I have given, there are 58,600-odd holdings between £20 and £40 valuation, almost 400,000 derated under £20. Adding those gives approximately something in excess of 30,000 holdings over £60.
The total figure involved asked for by Deputy Fitzpatrick would be £17 million.
The purpose of section 1 is to permit us to give relief of £37.7 million to farm holdings under £40 valuation. We need this Bill in order to make that money available to the local authorities in lieu of the derating. Deputy Enright asked me to withdraw this section. Withdrawal of this section means withdrawal of £37.7 million from the farming community. The Deputies across the way must decide whether or not they want this sum made available under the relief of rates scheme. Deputy Fitzpatrick mentioned the number of farmers who could set this off against income tax. There is no hard and fast rule. All farmers cannot be treated alike with respect to their liability to income tax. Some types of farming would make farmers more liable to income tax possibly than their neighbours. Last year might not have been a good year for cattle, but it was not a bad year for the milk industry. Since payment is on accounts one cannot say whether it is of benefit to a farmer or not. It would be a benefit to quite a number of people to set this off against income tax. The Deputy mentioned that it would be next year's income tax.
Comment on this
Next year the farmer would be paying income tax on the previous year's earnings. This year he would be paying on last year's accounts. That is the way it works. I cannot see that that makes a great difference.
My colleague, the Minister of State, replied to the Second Reading debate and I wish merely to deal with this section. The section is necessary, as is the Bill, to make relief available to all holders under £40 valuation.
Comment on this
The Minister has said that this is a relief of rates for farmers. Certainly, this is a misnomer. This Bill could not be called a relief of rates for farmers. It is a relief as far as the present Government are concerned; but as far as the farmers between £40 and £60 valuation are concerned it is a savage attack on them. Those small farmers have often been told by Fianna Fáil in the past that they were the backbone of this country. We all know that they stood in the past between the people and hunger and want. They worked long hours. They were not promised this form of taxation when the Fianna Fáil canvassers went around the country in the dead of night saying that the Coalition Government had taxed them out of existence.
Comment on this
They claimed that they would relieve the farmers of taxation. Instead of relief, they get this savage attack by the Fianna Fáil Government. A small farmer with £40 poor law valuation in County Longford pays £266.84 extra in rates. That is the relief that the Government are giving this unfortunate man under this Bill. That is almost £5 per week, after the farmers of Longford have had a very bad year. Very few of them are engaged in the milk industry. Their land is not suitable for tillage and the vast majority are engaged in cattle production. They purchased cattle in many cases at £50 per cwt and sold them during the winter at £39 to £40 per cwt. In Westmeath the small farmer loses £271 and, what is worse, those farmers must engage an accountant because they are in the income tax bracket. They may find that they have no income tax to pay, but will have to pay the accountant anything from £200 to £400 for telling them that they are not liable for income tax. That is putting a further £4 per week on these people. Therefore they have an extra burden of from £9 to £10 per week with an inflation rate of 20 per cent and cost of living increases.
Comment on this
The Deputy will deal with section 1 of the Bill. He is making a Second Stage speech and the Chair will not allow that.
Comment on this
I am dealing with it. I am speaking about the £50 poor law valuation. In Longford the farmer pays £266 extra. Is that a relief for that man, to put an extra £10 per week on him? In Westmeath he pays an extra £238. Where is the relief for these people? The farmer with a £60 poor law valuation in Westmeath pays £266 extra and in Longford almost £400 extra. Will that farmer call that a relief? Will it help the small farmer with a family to increase production? The Minister said that he could set it off against his income tax. For a start off he can only set off last year's against his income tax, that is, if he is liable for income tax. Many farmers under £50 valuation will not be liable for income tax.
The Government in this Bill are imposing an extra burden of anything from £8 to £14 per week on those people. There are 928 people involved in Longford-Westmeath, with poor law valuations between £40 and £60. There are 361 affected in Longford. That makes 1,289. The Minister in replying to me on the last day mentioned the relief that those under £40 valuation will get. The bachelor with £39 poor law valuation will be getting the full relief. Where is the equity there? Will anyone turn around to his neighbour and say "Are you over £40 valuation? We shall pay quarter, or half of your rates"? They will not and there is very little use in pointing that out to anyone in this House.
Instead of a relief, this is a savage attack and, indeed, not for the first time by a Fianna Fáil Government. That is the same Government that jailed the farmers in the past, the dairy farmers who marched peacefully outside Leinster House.
Comment on this
The Deputy is not entitled to bring in matters that do not concern section 1 of the Bill. He will get other opportunities to do that.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows he is not entitled to bring in such matters under section 1 of the Bill.
Comment on this
They jailed them at one time and now they are imposing savage taxation by way of this Bill. The farmers whom they fooled in the past should remember this when a certain man drops the flag.
Comment on this
I listened with interest to the Minister's reply to previous speakers. The day is past when people can be fooled by figures. The Minister gave us a figure of 396,000 for people with a valuation of less than £20. If that is correct then these people are living below subsistence level and they cannot be expected to pay rates. The remainder, somewhere in the region of 90,000 people, will be responsible for a certain percentage of rates and those with a valuation of £40 and more will be responsible for full rates. According to the Minister's figures these people will contribute somewhere in the region of £100 million, taking rates, income tax and levies into consideration. I object to the heading of the Bill. The word "relief" is in the title but the only group getting relief will be the Government. There is no way that people can be fooled from now on. The impression has been given that the farmers are getting relief but it was available before Fianna Fáil came into government. People with a valuation of up to £60 got relief of rates but now the Government have reduced the threshold to £20 valuation.
Comment on this
That is not so. The explanatory memorandum states that rated occupiers of holdings with valuations of £20 or less will receive full relief of rates. Those unfortunates are living on subsistence allowances.
Comment on this
The explanatory memorandum states that rated occupiers of holdings with valuations of more than £20 and less than £33 will receive full relief of rates on the first £20 valuation. Will you tell me what relief will they receive on a valuation of £33?
Comment on this
You did not answer my question. It is not specified in your explanatory memorandum what will be the position so far as a valuation of £33 is concerned.
Comment on this
The Deputy should address the Chair, not the Minister across the floor. The Chair has no responsibility for the Bill and when a Deputy uses the word "you" he is referring to the Chair, not to anybody else.
Comment on this
I asked a specific question. In respect of valuations of £20 or less the occupiers will receive full relief of rates but the situation has not been explained in respect of those people with valuations between £20 and £33. The explanatory memorandum has set out clearly enough the situation with regard to valuations of £33 to £40 but has not explained the situation with regard to valuations between £20 and £33.
Comment on this
They could not afford to do that. They would be much worse off than people with valuations just under £40. The position has not been explained in the explanatory memorandum or by the Minister. Rates on agricultural land are a means of collecting tax in order to provide services for local authorities in particular. Tax collected at this level should be related to income. Rates must be described as taxes and they do not relate to income or family circumstances. The increase of rates, particularly in the category of £40 to £60 valuations, is becoming a burden. This is especially the case in high valuation areas such as Wexford. There are high valuations in the Macamore area which is well known to the Leas-Cheann Comhairle——
Comment on this
That may be but it does not arise on section 1 of the Bill. The principle of the Bill has been adopted by the House. We are now on Committee Stage but we are having Second Stage speeches.
Comment on this
I am speaking of people in areas of high valuations, particularly in the Macamore area. There the valuations range from 75p in the £ up to £1.25. You are talking about relief in the the Bill but people with a valuation of £50 will be responsible for approximately £12 per £ valuation. That will be approximately £600 and they will also be responsible for full taxes because their valuations are in excess of £40. As Deputy L'Estrange pointed out, these people will have to pay an accountant and that may cost them £300. Some of these people may have only 60 acres and their return last year would have been in the region of £3,000. Their rates bill will be £600, they will have to pay £300 to an accountant and this total is approximately 30 per cent of their income and you are responsible for making them pay this amount in 1980.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I do not blame the Chair for disclaiming all responsibility for the Bill.
Comment on this
I am only worried about the records of the House. Each speaker must speak through the Chair and must refer to the Minister.
Comment on this
I am here to try to get Bills through and I get very little co-operation from some people in doing that. Deputy D'Arcy, through the Chair.
Comment on this
In relation to people being entitled to deduct their rates from their income tax, in perhaps 90 per cent of cases of people with valuations up to £60 they pay little income tax so there is absolutely no relief. Last year was one of the worst years in record——
Comment on this
As far as 1980 is concerned things are shaping up reasonably well weather wise, but the general opinion is that with the agricultural costs of production going up by 20 per cent at least, and poor representation overseas, agriculture in 1980 will have a very bad year. The Minister is putting a burden on over-burdened people to the tune of 30 per cent of their gross income for 1980 in some cases. What is the position of people with valuations of between £20 and £40? Will they get the 30 per cent relief mentioned here? The position is certainly not explained and is very misleading.
Comment on this
I endorse what Deputy D'Arcy said. It is a grave misnomer to call the Bill a rates relief Bill when the Minister knows the difference between relief and a burden. This should be called a rates burden Bill.
With some justification in the past politicians have been treated as a joke and it was considered that they spoke from both sides of their mouths. When a Minister of State brings in this sort of Bill we cannot blame the people for thinking like that about us. Let us tell the people clearly that this Bill is an extra burden on a small section of the community. It is a penal taxation on the farming community in a year that has no bright spot in it. From the point of view of marketing we cannot even get agreement on the grains situation.
Comment on this
The Minister is endeavouring to make big play of the fact that the bulk of the people have under £20 valuations and that therefore the Bill is right as only a small section are involved and they do not matter. If we are doing an injustice to only one person the Bill is wrong. Numbers have nothing to do with it. When it comes to fairytales the Minister would leave Hans Christian Andersen in the shade.
Comment on this
The Minister tried to make what could only be described as a semantic point when he claimed that this was a relief measure. Reliefs which existed up to now required to be renewed by statute every so often and were renewed automatically in previous years. This year instead of being renewed reliefs were substantially cut. It is purely an accident that it has been the practice to renew this relief by statute every so often. It is not as if on each occasion the statute was reintroduced and a new set of reliefs introduced. All that happened was that reliefs which existed up to now were renewed. The difference on this occasion is that instead of merely keeping existing reliefs in being the Minister is reducing these reliefs substantially.
What is happening in this Bill, whatever the Minister may argue from a legalistic point of view, is a substantial reduction in reliefs. The Minister may seek to get a few lines in the paper conveying the idea that this is a relief measure and anybody who does not study the thing might be fooled into thinking that it is so, and not read any further, but the Minister will not fool any of the farming community or anybody in this House by using those terms. As a result of this Bill the property tax—-because that is what it is—payable by farmers in the £40 to £60 valuation range will be far higher than the property tax being paid by any farmer in any country in the EEC. I challenge the Minister to controvert that statement. Will the Minister inquire into this matter to assure himself that I am correct, although I am satisfied that I am.
If a farmer in Monaghan goes a few miles down the road into County Armagh he will meet a farmer in the same situation as himself working the same type of land but the Monaghan farmer will be paying substantial rates whereas the farmer in Armagh will pay no rates.
Comment on this
The farmer in Monaghan with valuations of between £40 and £60 pays income tax as well. That is no great case for the Minister to make. The farmer in Armagh will pay no rates but he will pay income tax on accounts. That is fair enough. However, the Monaghan farmer will pay income tax and rates and his rates will be increased to a far greater extent than they were previously as a result of this Bill. That is not equitable because those two farmers must complete on the world markets to sell their produce.
Comment on this
The Minister would do better to keep quiet because he is only getting himself caught——
Comment on this
The position is that the farmer in Armagh and the farmer in Monaghan have to compete on the world markets to sell their products. As far as Ireland is concerned we export four-fifths of our agricultural products so we have to be able to compete.
Comment on this
All this type of speech is relevant to a Second Stage debate but not to section 1 of the Bill.
Comment on this
——increases the input cost of production and reduces the ability of Irish farmers and the Irish food industry which is based on agriculture to compete abroad with France, Germany and other countries. In Germany they have practically no taxation on their farming community.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy deal with section 1 of the Bill before the House. The Deputy is making a second stage speech.
Comment on this
He may be good, but it is not in order and Deputy Begley should not lecture the Chair. Deputy Bruton, please.
Comment on this
The Deputy is dealing with everything except section 1 and he is travelling all over the world. The Deputy is irrelevant.
Comment on this
The Irish farmers have to travel the world to sell their products and if they cannot compete because the Irish Government are putting a penal taxation on them——
Comment on this
Too damned decent. That is the trouble. The Deputy should deal with section 1 of the Bill. The Deputy is making it impossible for the Chair.
Comment on this
The Minister has not answered satisfactory the question about the divergent effects of this section on different sections of the community. It has not been contested by the Minister that the amount of income actually derived by farmers on valuations between £40 and £60 per £ of valuation can vary in a ratio of 3:1, depending on what part of the country they are living in. In some parts of the country a farmer with a valuation of £40 could be earning three times as much as a farmer with a valuation of £40 in another county.
That has been borne out by studies carried out by the Economic and Social Research Institute and by the farm management survey of the Agricultural Institute. There is no doubt about that. Yet, no allowance for that is made in this legislation which will apply straight across the board to all farmers with valuations in excess of £40. In some counties some farmers can earn an income of only one-third of the income of another farmer with exactly the same valuation in another county.
In the normal course of events if this were a tax measure, at this stage we would be able to introduce amendments to remedy the anomalies with which we are confronted, such as the one I have mentioned about the divergence in income relative to valuations in different parts of the country. Because strictly speaking this is not a tax measure, because it is merely a renewal of a relief, any amendment to remove that anomaly, if moved from this side of the House, would be deemed to be imposing a potential charge on the Exchequer and would be ruled out of order. If it were a matter of imposing exactly the same additional charges in the form of a Finance Bill, rather than in the form of an alleged relief Bill, we would have no problems at all about introducing amendments to reduce the burden of tax. Unfortunately, we are forced to raise it in the form of a general discussion. It is not my preference that we have to discuss it in this way. I would prefer to discuss it in the context of specific amendments. When this matter was before the House earlier I sought to introduce amendments and they were all ruled out of order, rightly, by the Chair, given the form of the Bill.
Comment on this
I accept that completely. I am not contesting the Chair's ruling. I am precluded from introducing an amendment to provide this relief. Therefore, I am reduced to asking the Minister to do what he can do. Under Standing Orders he is empowered to introduce amendments to a Bill which seeks to grant a relief which will impose a charge on the Exchequer. He is empowered to do something in this instance which no other Deputy is empowered to do.
I would ask him if he is prepared to introduce an amendment to the section providing that the reliefs which applied prior to the introduction of this Bill will apply in a case where it can be shown that, in a particular county, the income levels per £ of valuation are substantially below the average for income levels per £ of valuation in the country at large. I suggest to the Minister that he should consider an amendment of that nature. I agree this could not be done in all counties. Perhaps the Minister could say that if it could be shown that the income levels were, shall we say, 40 per cent below average in a particular county per £ of valuation vis-à-vis the national average, a system would be introduced whereby the reliefs which existed prior to this year would be allowed to apply. Given the figures I have mentioned, would the Minister be prepared to consider such an amendment which he can do and which I cannot?
Comment on this
The Minister is not disposed to answer at the moment. I am amazed and really worried that the Minister has given in to what I would describe as the anti-farmer lobby within the Government who have deprived numbers of people whose valuations are £40 and in excess of £40 of rates relief. That was unexpected. It is quite obvious that rural Deputies, the people who have a rural outlook within the Cabinet, are dominated and overpowered by the thinking of the city-orientated members of the Government. I believe the Minister has a proper understanding and a proper perception of what an agricultural income is in the west. I do not believe he would introduce a Bill such as this and exclude practically 1,000 people in his own County Clare, if he had a free hand.
That is exactly what this Bill is doing. It is excluding 1,000 people with valuations between £40 and £60. It is depriving them of a total sum of £184,000. That is what the anti-farmer lobby in the Government have done to the farmers in County Clare. I certainly will oppose this section of the Bill which is deceptive in its introduction and its memorandum and attempts to gloss over its real purpose. I will oppose it and I will vote against it. If I did not, I would be accepting something which the farmers themselves resent, particularly after a year in which they had to overcome many hardships.
I do not want to repeat what I said, but we cannot give too much publicity to the losses which the farmers in that income bracket in each county are suffering. I am particularly interested in the groups which have developed in County Clare, particularly, in the dairying areas and adjacent to the seashore, where valuations are excessively high. On their behalf, I protest in the strongest way against the introduction of the Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy D'Arcy asked me to explain the situation of a man with a valuation of between £20 and £33. There is no change whatsoever there. It is exactly as it was. He gets full relief on the £20 and he pays the full rate on the remainder. That is as it has been for some years.
The amendment Deputy Bruton proposes would be impossible to administer. How could one establish an average income per valuation for a particular county or for different farms?
Deputy Taylor is worried because I am not worried about Clare farmers. In Clare there is a total of 23,529 holdings with valuations under £20. I would say a big number of those are in the part of the county where Deputy Taylor lives.
Comment on this
On valuations between £20 and £40, there are 2,858 who still get partial relief. That is a total of 26,387 in County Clare who are either on full or on partial relief. The number of those between the £40 and £60 valuation who are affected is not 1,000.
Comment on this
It is 697. Deputy Taylor has told us that he will vote against this section and against the Bill but I would remind him that by doing so he will be voting to deprive 26,387 holders of relief.
Comment on this
On a point of information, there were 231 holders deprived of rates relief as a result of the Act brought in by the Government to reduce from £70 to £60 valuations qualifying for relief. The Minister can add that figure to the number that will now be deprived of relief and he will find that the total is very nearly 1,000. I am opposing strongly the £40 to £60 valuation group being deprived of the rates relief to which they have been accustomed almost since the founding of the State.
Comment on this
I have raised the question of persons who will have to pay full rates in respect of a holding of between £20 and £33 valuation.
Comment on this
If those with holdings of between £20 and £40 valuation are getting a 30 per cent relief why is the same level of relief not being applied to those with holdings of between £20 and £33 valuation? What is the reason for this discrimination? A person with a valuation of £33 will be earning much less than someone with a valuation of £40.
Comment on this
He will be paying much less in rates than is the case of a man with a valuation of more than £33.
Comment on this
I accept that, but there remains the question of discrimination. Surely the smaller landowner and, consequently the one with the lesser income, should be entitled to the same level of relief as applies to the person with the bigger holding. I accept that in the case of valuations of between £20 and £33 there is full relief on the first £20, relief which does not apply to a £40 valuation, but there is an anomaly here.
Comment on this
There is total relief on the first £20 in respect of valuations of between £20 and £33.
Comment on this
In respect of holdings of between £20 and £33 there is relief of only 80 per cent on the first £20 valuation.
Comment on this
The Minister referred earlier to the inequities which exist in the rating system but what do the Government intend doing to rectify these inequities?
Comment on this
That was because it had been raised by somebody else, but I have ruled that it is out of order.
Comment on this
Have the Government any proposal for rectifying this wrong? There are a number of people within the £40 to £60 valuation range who are literally on the breadline whereas people with valuations of less than £40 are earning a good living by reason of their land having been rated very lowly in the 1850s. This situation should be rectified.
Comment on this
In relation to counties such as Monaghan, and indeed to parts of my county where incomes per £1 are very low, I suggested to the Minister that he introduce an amendment to the effect that where it can be shown that county incomes per £1 of valuation on the farm are more than 40 per cent below the national average a system be introduced whereby the reliefs which existed previously should be allowed. The Minister said that this would be impossible administratively but I do not agree. The relevant figures are available. The ESRI have just completed a study—it was carried out by Mr. Micheál Ross—which dealt precisely with this point of county incomes in agriculture. It is possible to relate this information to valuations. The Agricultural Institute have carried out extensive studies in the course of their farm management survey regarding the relating of what is earned to the amount actually earned per £1 valuation. The national average is about £100 per £1 valuation but there are wide variations around this average. In some cases people would be earning as low as £30 or £40 per £1 valuation while in other cases the figure would be much higher. The Minister should introduce an amendment using the existing published data produced by the ESRI and by the Agricultural Institute for the purpose of producing an index that he could use or, if he is not satisfied to use these sources, he could commission the Central Statistics Office to produce a special study for this purpose. The system I have in mind would rectify the situation in counties in which incomes in agriculture are well below the average. This would be one way of dealing with the problem even if, admittedly, it would be crude and unsatisfactory. It would be one way of mitigating the obvious injustices of this section.
Another amendment that the Minister should introduce to the section is one to provide for some system of personal allowances against rates for those in the £40 to £60 valuation band and whose rates will now be almost doubled. In my earlier contribution I illustrated that the injustices, vis-à-vis the PAYE sector, of the rating system are far greater in the £40 and £60 valuation band than is the case among any other category of farmers. Therefore there would be justification for some special system of relief for those in the £40 to £60 band.
I suggest that the Minister introduce an amendment to allow a farmer with children under 18 to claim in that respect against his rates. This will apply both to farmers with families and to those without families. Large families are common in rural Ireland but particularly so among farmers in the category I am talking of. Demographic data could be adduced to sustain that case. If it is justifiable to have a system of personal allowances in respect of income tax for people who find income tax burdensome, why should there not be a personal allowance in respect of wives and children for the purposes of the rating system for farmers? The Government have always used the case of rates paid by farmers in their arguments with the trade union movement about the amount of taxation being paid by farmers and have always treated rates as a contribution by the farmers to the Exchequer. Business people or PAYE workers are making a contribution out of their incomes to the Exchequer but they are allowed to claim in respect of their families. The same allowances should apply to farmers especially those with large families. The Minister must not complain that the administration of such a system would be difficult. The data relating to the marital status of any farmer and to the number of children concerned is available in the Department of Social Welfare in respect of eligibility for children's allowances. If the data in respect of children's allowances were supplied there would be no difficulty in computing the amount of rates remission that should be allowed to the farmer in respect of the number of children he has. The Minister should consider very seriously an amendment along these lines which would be administratively quite simple to operate and would introduce a measure of justice into the provisions of this section. I hope the Minister will consider this very carefully.
There is another amendment which the Minister should consider in respect of this matter, that is, to allow some relief against rates to farmers in the £40 to £60 valuation range affected by this section for the cyclical nature of agriculture. Under this Bill some farmers in certain years will not have any income, not a single penny, and will not be able to set off their rates against income tax because they will not pay income tax. They will pay full rates in a year in which they did not have any income. Last year there were many farmers who did not have any income and some had negative incomes. The Minister as good as admitted that in the debate when he referred to the position of the cattle trade last year.
I believe there should be an amendment to this section and that a variable relief should be allowed to take account of the cyclical nature of agriculture. I would be happy if this were confined to farmers below £60 valuation because farmers above £60 valuation can look after themselves. They usually have the possibility of having more than one enterprise on their farms. If one enterprise is going badly, the other may be going reasonably well. They can inure themselves against the cyclical nature of agriculture more readily than can the small farmer who, because of the size of his farm, if he wants to be any way intensive, is driven into having a single enterprise system. It is only by having a single enterprise that he can get any economies of scale into his farming operation. The larger farmer can afford to have two or three enterprises and still obtain economies of scale. He is not so much affected by the cyclical nature of the position.
A farmer under £60 valuation, which is the classic case of a full-time small farmer, usually will be single enterprise in either milk or cattle. If the cattle trade goes bad—and this is the example I am particularly concerned with—that man could find himself without any income in a particular year, or if he borrowed money he could find he had a negative income.
There should be some provision built into the legislation so that, when price indices in agriculture for a particular range of commodities to be chosen fall below a certain line relative to the general rate of inflation, automatically a formula could be worked out quite easily by relating the agricultural prices index and the consumer price index——
Comment on this
The Deputy is now dealing with the whole rates code, introducing children's allowances and so on. This is a matter for a different type of legislation. It does not arise under this section.
Comment on this
It comes into the Short Title—an Act to amend and extend the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Acts. What I am talking about is relief, and the Minister insisted that this is a relief Bill. Therefore, I am perfectly in order in talking about——
Comment on this
The Chair is telling the Deputy that he is not perfectly in order. It would require a different type of legislation to deal with the whole rates code. Children's allowances and other matters mentioned by the Deputy cannot be discussed under section 1 of this Bill. The Chair has been very lenient and very fair.
Comment on this
It would require complete amendment of the rates legislation code to deal with the matters the Deputy is mentioning.
Comment on this
As I said earlier, in the normal course of events if this measure was introduced in the Finance Bill I would be perfectly in order in introducing amendments along the lines I have been discussing, bringing in children's allowances against rates, and anti-cyclical measures to help farmers who have a bad year. But because this is not a Finance Bill—it is nominally and artificially described as a relief Bill—I am precluded from introducing these amendments, I am forced, reluctantly, to put the case in this way and to ask the Minister to introduce the amendments. I have no doubt that within the terms of this Bill the appropriate section to do that would be section 1.
Comment on this
That would require complete amendment of the rates legislation code and does not arise under this type of Bill.
Comment on this
All I am suggesting is an amendment to this section to apply a certain type of relief to farmers affected by this section. I specifically said I am not interested in extending relief to farmers with valuations above £60. There is no need for relief for farmers below £40 valuation because their rates will not be substantially increased as a result of this Bill. The people I am interested in are those in the narrow £40 to £60 band. I would argue that my comments and the amendment I am suggesting are perfectly within the section.
Comment on this
The Chair does not agree. The Deputy will have to accept the Chair's ruling, whether he believes the Chair is right or wrong. The Chair believes that that type of amendment is for the rates code as such and not for this Bill.
Comment on this
I should like to feel that the Minister would look at my suggestions nonetheless, because in my view there is a grave injustice in the rating system. I made practical suggestions which are worthy of thought by any responsible Minister. Deputies on all sides recognise that this is an unjust system of taxation, and this section is doing nothing but aggravating it. It behoves all Deputies to apply their best thoughts to some system of rates relief, and that is what I have been trying to do. What disillusions people most about debates in this House is that when Deputies protest that the system is unjust they cannot or will not do anything about it. We on this side of the House cannot do anything about it. The Minister admits it is unjust but he will not do anything about it, and that is more disillusioning——
Comment on this
The Chair maintains that is not relevant on this Bill. It is a question for the amendment of the rates code, and that is another day's work.
Comment on this
I should like to ask the Minister for elaboration of this section. Subsection (1) reads:
Subject to subsection (2) of this section, the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Act, 1946, shall apply to the local financial years ending on the 31st day of December, 1980, the 31st day of December, 1981, and the 31st day of December, 1982....
What are the Minister's intentions after 1982, if he still has influence on matters after that date? It is important that the Government should outline their long-term views on this matter. Will the Minister consider extending the date to 1990? Why stop dead at 1982? The fact that the three dates were put in and no further dates envisaged suggests that there will be a worse and more draconian change in the rating system after 1982. That is why we ought to have the benefit of the Government's long-term views on this because it is impossible for the Commission on Income Taxation to discuss this as far as farmers are concerned. They are not aware of the long-term views of the Government with regard to rates, an essential component of farmer taxation. Is it the intention of the Minister to make any submission to the commission indicating his views on this matter?
I should like the Minister to elaborate on subsection (2) which states:
(2) (a) Subject to paragraph (b) of this subsection, a rating authority (within the meaning of the Local Government Act, 1946) shall not apply the Act aforesaid to a person, as respects a local financial year, if the valuation of all the tenements of agricultural land in respect of which he is rated and which are situated—
(i) in the rating area of a county, or
(ii) in a part of the rating area of a county borough, borough or urban district, being a part which before the 2nd day of March, 1976, formed part of a county health district,
I should like to know what is meant by a rating area of a county borough, borough or urban district which formed part of a county health district before 2 March 1976. What is the significance of that date? I should like an explanation of the reference to Land Commission land. Does this refer to land that is in the hands of the Land Commission prior to division and which is being rented by them on the 11-month system? Does it mean land which has been distributed by the Land Commission to tenants but not yet vested? A large proportion of the land held by the Land Commission has been divided but is nominally in the ownership of the Land Commission in that the tenant is paying an annuity and is not the outright owner. I should be grateful if the Minister would say whether tenements of agricultural land in respect of which the Land Commission is rated includes all those people.
I was disappointed that the Minister flatly refused to have any examination carried out of the Griffith valuation. Why did he dismiss the matter? Has the matter been discussed by his colleagues? I would have thought that there were serious anomalies in this system and there should be some means by which they can be corrected. I do not think it is necessary to go to the extent of revaluing every piece of land.
Comment on this
I should like the Minister to outline his attitude in general to the amendments I suggested.
Comment on this
The basis for levying rates is the valuation system and any changes would have to be in the valuation system. That is not a matter for this Bill or my Department; it is a matter for the Minister for Finance who is responsible for the valuation authority. Deputy Bruton asked if it would be possible to revalue part of the country or some areas. That would not be possible. It would be necessary to carry out a total valuation of the country which would take some years. The Deputy asked me to explain the reason why this Bill covers three years. I should like to point out that previous legislation covered two years. At the end of this three-year period the position will be reviewed. I should like to tell the Deputy that since 1976 where extensions of urban areas or boroughs have taken place into county council areas the rates relief has applied to such areas and that is why they are mentioned in this section. The reference to Land Commission means that lands where the Land Commission are the rated occupiers will be treated as one unit or one holding. There will not be any aggregation of the holdings of the Land Commission. Where the Land Commission are the rated occupiers it will be treated as one holding and it does not have anything to do with land the commission have divided or allocated.
Comment on this
I was talking about counties which are below average income and was not suggesting a revaluation of those counties. I was suggesting that the reliefs which existed prior to the introduction of this Bill should be allowed in those counties. The reliefs should be restored in respect of counties where the income is very low by comparison with the valuation. Therefore, the Minister's objection that the valuation would take a long time does not apply.
Comment on this
Although the Minister stated that he sees the injustice of the valuation system he is not prepared to do anything about it and that is disappointing. There was a great hue and cry against rates on houses and, although they were unjust and capricious, the rates paid on houses represented a smaller share of actual income than the rates paid on land by the categories of farmers we are concerned with in the Bill.
If there is an injustice in the application of the rating system to the people with whom the Bill is concerned it is because it relates to a greater share of their income. It is greater than any injustice that may have existed in respect of the rating or otherwise of houses. If this legislation concerned more people than just a small section of the farming community the Minister would not get away with the attitude he has adopted because the pressure that would be put on him, electorally and otherwise, would be irresistible. It is because this section of the farming community affected by the Bill are not as electorally significant as home owners are that an injustice, which is admitted by all sides, is being left in existence. That is bad. The Minister is aware that he is presiding over and implementing a system of unjust and capricious taxation. The fact that he can do so with a straight face and no apparent expression of concern is a serious reflection on him or on his ability to influence his colleagues.
Comment on this
Can the Minister say if the Department or his colleagues carried out any examination as to the length of time it would take to rationalise the rating system?
Comment on this
The Chair has already ruled that that is not relevant to this Bill or to the Minister in the House. It is a matter for another code and another Minister.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): It has now become clear that this section and the similar section of the 1978 Bill introduced by the Minister is collecting an additional £17 million from farmers. If the position had obtained as it was when Fianna Fáil resumed office, this year farmers would be paying £17 million less in rates than they are now being asked. That is rather disgraceful coming from a Government who wrote a small paragraph into their election manifesto regarding rates and tax to the effect that Fianna Fáil would retain the notional system of farm taxation and allow rates on agricultural land as an instalment of farmers' tax bills. It was added further that taxes due under the national system would be payable at the end of each year and that farmers would be free to opt for assessment by farm accounts. There is there not one hint of any change in the method of assessing rates on farmers, or in the method of collecting rates from them. Yet, as a result of a direct action by this Government since their return to office, they will this year collect £17 million extra from farmers. In fact they will collect more because, in addition to that, they have imposed a resource tax which will bring in another few million pounds.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I could talk about this resource tax for a very long time but I shall not even try.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be afforded an opportunity next week on the Finance Bill, when such matters will arise.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I am bewildered by this section in view of the statement made by the Minister for Finance on budget day. I have already put on record that he said his first budgetary objective was to introduce greater equity into the taxation system.
Comment on this
The Deputy has already made that case. He is repeating himself and he knows that repetition is not in order.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I have shown that this Bill rather than introducing greater equity into the taxation system imposes greater injustice.
The Minister for Finance said his second budgetary objective was to improve the position of those on lower incomes. This section rather than improving their position attacks those on lower incomes. As I have illustrated already, it increases the demand for rates on a poor law valuation of £40 by 142 per cent, whereas the increase for those farmers with a poor law valuation of £59 will be increased by 106 per cent.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): I am making the point in relation to the solemn promise given to improve the position of those on lower incomes.
Comment on this
The Deputy knows the rules of this House as well as the Chair and that repetition on all of these matters is not in order.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): The average increase—I did not give this before—in the valuation band between £40 and £60 is 124 per cent but the lower income group are being asked to pay 142 per cent. Therefore this is an attack on the lower income people rather than an effort to improve their lot.
Amongst other things the Minister for Finance gave as his third and final budgetary objective the protection of sources of economic growth. I cannot see this as anything other than an attack on one source of economic growth, that is, agricultural production, because this is not a tax on wealth from production but rather constitutes an addition to the overhead expenses of the farming sector and, to that extent, is an attack on the source of economic growth. I can only assume that there must be very bad lines of communication between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for the Environment. The Minister for Finance comes into the House saying that he will introduce more equity into the taxation system, that he will improve the position of the lower income groups and sources of economic growth. Then he sends his colleague, the Minister for the Environment, in with section 1 of this Bill which will reverse all of those things. As Deputy D'Arcy rightly pointed out, the Minister, in an earlier contribution, was making a virtue out of necessity. I do not know how many farmers the Minister said there are in this country—I think he spoke in terms of 400,000; that could not be so. I assume he must have been talking about holdings.
Comment on this
Some farmers in the west have three or four holdings, little patches of land which would not amount to more than 20 acres altogether.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): As Deputy D'Arcy rightly pointed out there are tens of thousands of farmers who fall into exempted categories. For example, categorised by area there are 11,778 farmers with less than an acre.
Comment on this
If we had one Deputy at a time we might make some progress. We are not going to make any progress anyway. That is very evident.
Comment on this
Apparently not, but the Chair is interested in making some progress and repetition and irrelevancy are not in order.