We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill, 1980: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 179–360 of 360. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill, 1980
Enacted

No. 9 of 1980 ›

Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): But I got this information only a moment ago.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is time we made some effort to move on.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I want to put on the record the type of farmer about whom the Minister is boasting at not claiming rates. There are 11,778 holdings under one acre of land; 38,398 with less than five acres; 41,027 holding between five and 15 acres; 57,146 holding between 15 and 30 acres, with 56,344 holding between 30 and 50 acres. In my opinion practically all of those would have a valuation of less than £40 and, of course, they are receiving some relief. Most of them would have a valuation of less than £20 and would not be rated at all. But is the Minister serious in saying that they should pay rates. There are some thousands of them deemed——

Comment on this

I never said that.

Comment on this

The Minister gave the impression that he was being very generous in not imposing rates on them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The Minister stuck out his chest and gave the impression that he was a very fine fellow dispensing all this largesse, that he was something like lady bountiful. These are unfortunates who are not able to live and a large number of them are deemed to be on such substandard incomes as to be entitled to social welfare. I mentioned earlier that this is a most inopportune time to change the system of rating in regard to agriculture which has existed for about 50 years. I say that because the Government recently set up a commission to inquire into taxation in general and farmer taxation in particular and to advise the Government.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is the third time during the past two hours the Deputy has repeated that point. The Deputy is long enough here to understand that the Chair must get co-operation.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I made a passing reference to it.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I had heard the point twice already and the Chair has a fairly good memory.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I am suggesting that it would be better to wait until the commission report.

Deputy Bruton has appealed to the Minister to make various amendments which we cannot make or even seek to make because they would impose a potential charge on the Revenue. It is admitted by all that the rating system is unjust and the Griffith valuation is out of date. There are various precedents for treating the western counties in a special way. The old Congested Districts Board recognised certain areas in the west as being in need of special treatment and assistance. The areas involved are referred to nowadays as the 12 western counties and this includes Monaghan, Cavan and Longford. The Minister should bring in an amendment on Report Stage which would allow the present law regarding relief of rates to stand in regard to the 12 western counties.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is making a Second Stage speech. The Chair must put the question if we cannot get anything new or relevant to the section. The Chair has a duty to the House to see that some progress is made and to ensure that everything is relevant and there is no repetition. Despite the fact that it has been disputed, the Chair has a right to put the section if the Chair feels that nothing further relevant to the section is being raised.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The Chair would be establishing a precedent.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It has been done.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I have known debates to be guillotined but I have never known the Chair to put a question to a vote until the debate has ceased. I respectfully submit that the matter of extending relief to the 12 western counties has now been raised for the first time. This is a Committee Stage debate during which it is appropriate to make such a point. If anything is relevant to the section, it is this point. As far back as 1906 special notice was taken of the type of land and the impoverished conditions prevailing in the western counties.

Comment on this

We are not that badly off.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is Second Stage material which does not arise on this section. We are dealing with one small point and there is no amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I am asking the Minister to bring in an amendment. The seaboard counties have their tourist attractions but there is real poverty in the inland counties. The Minister should consider between now and Report Stage the desirability of allowing existing reliefs to continue in the 12 western counties.

Comment on this

I asserted very strongly earlier—and it may be significant that the Minister did not contradict what I said—that as a result of this section the farming community in this range of acreage will be paying a higher level of property taxation than farmers in any other country in Europe against whom Irish farmers must compete. The Minister should be aware of the taxation position of farmers vis-à-vis their competitors in Europe. The introduction of a system such as we are discussing affects the competitive position. If input costs are increased the selling price of one's product must also be increased if one is to make a reasonable income. The Minister has not given an answer on this matter and the information should be available because I understand that the Community are collating information on various systems of farm taxation.

Deputy Fitzpatrick made a case in respect of the western regions, but it is important to bear in mind that the concession he sought should not be confined only to western counties but should be extended to all disadvantaged areas. Some of these areas, such as parts of Laois and Offaly, are outside the western counties. Very sophisticated means have been used to determine whether or not certain districts should be included in the areas deemed to be disadvantaged. The bulk of that work has already been done by the Department of Agriculture and has been cross-checked by the European Commission. There is no question of any being undeservedly included.

There should not be allowed to exist a situation where people in a disadvantaged area have to pay a penal increase in rates. The Irish Government are arguing in Brussels that farmers in the west are in a bad way and need help and assistance.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is all relevant to Second Stage. It does not arise on this section. I have said that 14 times in the last two hours and can get no obedience whatsoever from the Deputies. There is nothing before the House but section 1 of the Bill and the Deputy will deal with section 1 as it stands.

Comment on this

I am sure the Chair will realise how frustrated we are.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair is very frustrated trying to get Deputies to obey him. Deputy Bruton has made about six Second Stage speeches in the last hour-and-a-half. The Chair has told him on each occasion that he is doing that and still he persists. He may be frustrated, but the Chair is becoming frustrated with all this. We must make progress with the Bill. It is up to the Chair to see that the Deputies deal with the section before the House, section 1 of the Bill.

Comment on this

It is a totally bad section.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That may be. That is how it is and the Chair has no say in it. That does not mean that the Deputies can make Second Stage speeches.

Comment on this

We have spoken widely, I admit.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It is nearly time that somebody admitted it.

Comment on this

In regard to the disadvantaged areas, has the Minister available to him the actual average valuation for each county? If so, the disadvantaged area in each county should be available in his office. If one speaks of disadvantaged areas and low incomes as a result of disadvantage, is the Minister prepared to consider any moves to combat this as far as rating is concerned?

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has already ruled that that is not relevant. That is a matter for other legislation.

Comment on this

The average valuation in the country is £1.10, speaking from memory. I do not have the average for the different areas of the country. In the western counties, to which the Deputy is probably referring, the valuations are low except in specific areas such as the Shannon estuary where they are £2.00 to £2.50 per acre—higher than Wexford, I can assure you. That is again as a result of the Griffith valuation. He decided that the land along the estuary was ideal for growing wheat, whereas by modern standards it is not suitable at all. That is another anomaly.

If there is any redeeming feature in the Griffith system of valuation it is that it has not changed over the years despite the improvements which have been made in production and land due to modern methods. The valuation has remained static and cannot change without new legislation for the whole country. On the other hand, a person could have a business and if he improves his business his valuation goes up. That is the only redeeming feature about the system that I can see, anyway.

Deputy Fitzpatrick said that we were responsible now for making the farmers pay £17 million more since we came into power. That is not correct. At least it is not correct when one considers that we have relieved farming ratepayers of £12 million because of the domestic derating and derating of farm buildings which were still rated in 1977. There is £12 million on the credit side there. I do not have available the number of farmers liable for income tax who can set that off against the rates. Seventeen million pounds extra is not a true figure.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): It is £17 million over and above the farmers' estimate.

Comment on this

The Deputy said that we were asking the farmers to pay this extra, but we reduced this commitment by £12 million under the derating of the domestic sector. I do not have any information on the taxation system throughout the EEC. This is not a taxation Bill. This Bill, let me repeat again, is necessary in order to give £37.7 million relief to the farming community. It is necessary to have the Bill to give legislative power to the local authorities to make that deduction in the demand notes when striking the rates.

Comment on this

It is outrageous that a Minister can come in here to introduce a measure which will dramatically increase the rates paid by farmers who are exporting and competing on the international market and admit that he does not know even the system of taxation which applies in the other countries with which Irish farmers are supposed to compete. This is completely wrong. The Minister should have that information about the system of property taxation applicable in other countries. I repeat that as a result of this Bill the small farmers who will be affected by it will be paying substantially more property taxation than in any other country in Europe with which they are supposed to be competing. This is wrong. We are an exporting country and must depend on export markets to sell our products successfully. If our farmers are forced to pay higher levels of property taxation regardless of whether they make a profit or not, they will not be able to compete equitably.

Comment on this

The Minister made a statement that the redeeming feature of the Griffith valuation was that it never changed. I might point out that the use of the land changed. Land which was highly productive when the Griffith valuation system was introduced is the low productive land now. The land with the low valuation is now the high productive land. This is where the inequity comes into the valuation system. This valuation system has completely outlived its usefulness. If lands were suitable for beans and wheat at that time, they are not suitable today as a result of the movement from horse to machinery. This land is unsuitable for high productivity and the Minister's own county has 40,000 acres of Macamore land. This is able to produce only 75 per cent of its potential while the other land can produce up to 100 per cent. Those are facts and are the results of modernisation. The Minister certainly has got it wrong when he said it has a redeeming feature. There is no redeeming feature in the fact that the valuation has not changed.

Comment on this

I said that the one redeeming feature that might be in the Griffith valuation is that it never changed.

Comment on this

I do not consider it a redeeming feature.

Comment on this

It does not change like building valuation.

Comment on this

Fair enough, but the fact is that the average valuation of £1.10 means that people who are liable for rating in most counties will be talking in terms of £18 to £20 per acre. That is a direct tax, taking the average into consideration.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): A brief intervention. I stated when last speaking that the present Government were extracting £17 million more from farmers by way of rates this year than farmers would have been paying if the law were not changed. The Minister corrects me and says that that is not so. Perhaps the Minister is technically correct. Certainly the Government are extracting £17 million more from farmers in rates than they led the farmers to believe that they would have to pay. Before the election they stated that the farmers would not have to pay rates on private houses. Before the election they stated that they would not have to pay rates on farm buildings. The farmers were entitled to assume that. The Government said that loudly and clearly all over the country, but never said a word about the abolition of relief in respect of agricultural rates down to £40. They told the electorate about the goodies. They did not tell them about this particular operation. Perhaps I should correct myself and put on record that, as a result of this section and the same section of section 1 of the 1978 Act, £17 million more is being extracted from the farmers than they were led to believe by Fianna Fáil before the last election they would have to pay. That is a disgrace.

Do I correctly understand the position. Could the Minister explain briefly from his brief section 1 (2) (a) of the Bill? Could he tell me if I am correct in thinking that the effect of this section is to say that holdings in the possession of the Land Commission will not be aggregated in order to bring them over £40 valuation and suffer a loss of the relief grants? Am I correct in thinking that the proviso to section 1 (2) (b) means that if any holding in the hands of the Land Commission exceeds £40 valuation it will lose relief?

Comment on this

The Deputy is correct in both instances.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I should like the Minister to explain section 1 (2) (a).

Comment on this

It means there is no relief if the valuation is more than £40.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): What is the situation with regard to section 1 (2) (a) (ii)?

Comment on this

I explained that earlier to Deputy Bruton. It means that extensions of urban and borough areas into counties qualify for relief of rates whereas old boroughs and urban councils prior to 1976 did not qualify for rates relief. Since that time extensions have been qualifying for relief of rates.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Does land within urban boundaries other than that brought in since 1976 qualify now?

Comment on this

No. Agricultural relief applies to land since 1976.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): There are certain urban areas that encompass quite a lot of land and two examples come to mind. Ballinasloe is a big urban area with quite a lot of land and Naas is another example. Does the Minister think it reasonable that those areas should be excluded from the benefit of agricultural rates relief? I presume the thinking behind not giving the lands the benefit of agricultural rates relief was that it was thought they had all the amenities of a town and had inflated values as a result of being in an urban area. As I understand it, modern thinking now proposes to value these lands at use value.

Comment on this

There is an existing system of reliefs for those areas. For example, urban district councils get 40 per cent; borough councils, except Dún Laoghaire, get 25 per cent; Dún Laoghaire Borough gets 50 per cent, as do the county boroughs of Dublin and Cork; Waterford County Borough gets 30 per cent and Limerick Borough gets 40 per cent. This means that areas taken in by urban councils since 1976 qualify for the agricultural relief we are talking about in this Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I understood the Minister to say that Dún Laoghaire Borough gets 50 per cent while other borough councils get 25 per cent. Why the special position for Dún Laoghaire?

Comment on this

The county boroughs of Dublin and Cork get 50 per cent, Limerick gets 40 per cent and Waterford gets 30 per cent. It is historically based.

Comment on this

As a Deputy from south Tipperary, again I should like to place my views on the record of the House. The spring show is being held at Ballsbridge now and every effort is being made to show the people the value of agriculture to the economy and to build up the confidence of the farming community in their industry. Yet, in this House we are trying to extract an extra £6 million from farmers, money that could be spent on the development of their industry. Farmers today have no confidence in their industry. They do not know what direction agriculture is going and they have no confidence in the Government to protect their interests at home or at EEC level.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This seems to be a Second Stage speech. We must keep to the section.

Comment on this

No. I am just filling in the background.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy said at the beginning of his statement that he would again like to place his views on the record. It is not necessary to repeat them. I ask the Deputy to speak on section 1.

Comment on this

I should like to emphasise the points I made. With regard to eligibility for county council loans to enable the farming community to erect houses or to purchase houses, will the Minister state if he has any intention of lowering the threshold——

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That has nothing to do with the section.

Comment on this

I beg to differ with the Chair.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Loans for housing have nothing to do with the Bill.

Comment on this

They are based on the rateable valuation and this applies also with regard to grants for third-level institutions.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Bill before the House deals with rates on agricultural land.

Comment on this

As eligibility for loans, grants and scholarships are based on the rateable valuation, I want the Minister to say if he has any intention of lowering the threshold.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I will not allow a discussion on this. It is outside the scope of the Bill, let alone the section with which we are dealing.

Comment on this

I am awaiting a reply from the Minister.

Comment on this

It does not arise.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair has said that this has nothing whatever to do with the section.

Comment on this

The Ceann Comhairle is limiting the discussion.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Ceann Comhairle is doing exactly what Standing Orders strictly lay down. We are on Committee Stage and we are dealing with it section by section. The Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

I fully appreciate the position but I would stress that the farmers, particularly the small farmers of south Tipperary, are totally disappointed that here again the Minister has not taken their plight into consideration. They look upon this as a further levy on them, a further means of extracting £6 million that is sorely needed for reinvestment in plant, machinery, farm buildings and in extra livestock. The Minister mentioned a figure of 20,000 extra people with valuations of between £40 and £60 being brought into this. There is a predominantly larger number of farmers involved in south Tipperary and I would ask the Minister for the exact figure of the number of farmers in south Tipperary and indeed in north Tipperary who will be affected if and when this Bill goes through.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question is not even relevant. If every Deputy in the House wanted to know how their constituencies were affected under section 1 we would be here until Christmas. We have to deal with the section.

Comment on this

I am dealing with it. I am waiting for a reply.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The section does not deal with south Tipperary any more than any other part of Ireland. There is no good in making a mockery out of the debate.

Comment on this

It is a serious debate.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

It should be.

Comment on this

No one is trying to make a mockery out of it. Nobody is making a laughing stock out of it, expecially with the further extraction of £6 million from the farming community.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to have said that a few times.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister about land valuations and he surprised me by pointing out that there were valuations as high as £2.50 per acre in the Shannon estuary.

Comment on this

It is lower in north Clare.

Comment on this

The position is capable of being remedied in that the Agricultural Institute have done considerable work based in Johnstown Castle on a soil survey of the country. It should be possible on the basis of their information to arrive at a more equitable valuation of land. The Minister said that where a person feels that a valuation on his house is excessive he can appeal to have it revalued. Am I correct in my understanding that the Minister is saying that one of his constituents in the Shannon estuary area of south Clare is precluded by law from appealing to have his valuation altered in the light of changed circumstances?

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

What has this to do with the section?

Comment on this

It has a great deal because——

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The question of changing valuations of agricultural land is a totally separate matter.

Comment on this

I am concerned about the impact of rates on farmers and rates are related to the valuations. The impact of this section depends on the valuation of land and if the valuation system is, as is a common case on both sides of the House, unjust, the impact of the section will be ipso facto unjust. It is a matter that we should try to remedy. I am asking the Minister how the injustice which is inherent in this section, because it is based on an unjust valuation system, can be remedied.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is an obvious effort to make it relevant but it does not impress the Chair. We are still miles away from the section.

Comment on this

The Chair is very restrictive this evening.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We must have some sort of order.

Comment on this

I take it that it is not possible to appeal an individual valuation of land. Will the Minister consider introducing some mechanism whereby it will become possible on a case by case basis——

Comment on this

Any change in the valuation system is a matter for the Minister for Finance.

Comment on this

In view of the substantial increase in farm rates especially in this category—and we know that other EEC countries do not have this problem—I am surprised that none of the Cabinet seems to be aware of the problem and their ignorance is inexcusable. Will the Minister consider the abolition of rates, because this section of the community are now carrying the entire burden of the State for bin collection and the whole lot? We are coming to a stage where this sectional type of tax is becoming unconstitutional.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 1:

In page 3, line 2, after "municipal rate" to insert "(within the meaning of the Income Tax Act, 1967)".

The reason for this amendment is that the term "municipal rate" is not defined in this legislation. The definition chosen is the one in the Income Tax Act 1967 which covers the municipal rates in boroughs and urban districts and in the four county boroughs.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): What is the purpose of this amendment and the effect it has on this section?

Comment on this

It is not defined in this legislation and we have chosen this definition which is the definition in the Income Tax Act 1967.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Will the Minister give us the definition in the 1967 Act?

Comment on this

In this Part "the municipal rate" means any rate which is—

(a) the rate leviable by the Right Honourable the Lord Mayor, Aldermen and Burgesses of Dublin under section 63 of the Local Government Dublin Act, 1930.

or

(b) the rate leviable by the Corporation of Dún Laoghaire under section 63 of the said Local Government Dublin Act, 1930, or

(c) the rate leviable under section 25 of the Limerick City Management Act, 1934, or

(d) the rate leviable under section 24 of the Waterford City Management Act, 1939, or

(e) the rate leviable under section 16 of the Cork City Management (Amendment) Act, 1941, or

(f) the rate leviable under section 18 of the Local Government Act, 1946.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I thought that the Act did not apply to those areas except in respect of land brought into them from outside since 1976.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Is the definition being put in simply in order to apply the relief to those areas situated within local authority areas listed by the Minister in respect of land brought in to them since 1976?

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this

Would the Minister tell the House what section 2 of the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Act, 1976, is? Will he quote the relevant section?

Comment on this

This is the section that applies agricultural grant relief to areas taken in since 1976.

Comment on this

Would the Minister quote the exact section?

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy speaking to the amendment or the section?

Comment on this

Could we hear the relevant section quoted?

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is nothing in the amendment to justify the question the Deputy is asking.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, you need not come to the defence of the Minister on every occasion.

Comment on this

I am not looking for any defence. It is a question of what the Chair rules.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair will not have snide remarks. The Chair is most lenient. The Bill will be debated and discussed strictly in accordance with Standing Orders. There is nothing in the amendment which relates to the question asked by the Deputy. We will come to the section.

Comment on this

Surely we are entitled to that information.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The section will be discussed after the amendment is dealt with and passed or defeated.

Comment on this

Surely I am entitled to inquire from the Minister what is stated in that section.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not on the section. We are on the amendment.

Comment on this

In section 2 of the Bill that section of the Act is mentioned. Surely a Deputy is entitled to ask the Minister to tell us exactly what is in the section.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Definitely, when we come to the section.

Comment on this

We are on the section.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are not on the section. We are on amendment No. 1 in the Minister's name. Is the amendment agreed to?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): With all respect, I do not want to get involved but I think it could be said fairly that in order to understand the amendment the Deputy is entitled to have read section 2 of the Rates on Agriculture Land (Relief) Act, 1976. In order to understand the amendment it is necessary to know what is in that section. I am just making that point.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The amendment is on the paper and reads:

In page 3, line 2, after "municipal rate" to insert "(within the meaning of the Income Tax Act, 1967)".

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Unless somebody interested in this was familiar with the wording of that Act he would not understand the amendment. That is a reasonable submission.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comairle Fianna Fáil

When we come to the section the Deputy can raise whatever matters he wishes.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Then the amendment will have gone through or will have been rejected.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I do not want to get mixed up in this.

Comment on this

I would request the Minister to quote section 2 of the 1976 Act so that we can discuss it.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comairle Fianna Fáil

It is quite in order now.

Comment on this

Section 2 (1) reads:

Where after the passing of this Act the boundary of a county borough, borough or urban district is extended so as to include hereditaments of agricultural land which before the extension formed part of a county health district, the allowances provided under the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Acts, 1939 to 1976, shall, subject to subsection (2) of this section, be made to occupiers of such hereditaments by the local authority whose boundary has been so extended, and such portion of the agricultural grant as may be necessary to enable that authority to make such allowances without loss to itself shall be paid by the Minister for Finance to the authority.

Subsection (2) reads:

Subsection (1) of this section shall apply to a hereditament only for so long as it continues to be used solely or mainly for agricultural purposes, that is to say, as arable, meadow or pasture ground or as woodlands, market gardens or nursery grounds.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I have been trying to understand this section. Am I correct in thinking the effect of section 3 is merely to bring into section I the areas of land which were brought into urban authorities since 1976?

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): As a matter of interest, could the Minister give me any idea how much land was involved and how many urban areas and corporations and so on have been extended since 1976? How much land are we dealing with?

Comment on this

For example, Drogheda, Waterford city, Youghal, and perhaps one or two others.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Is there much land involved?

Comment on this

The biggest would have been Waterford. That was recently. I have not got the total.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Has the Minister any thoughts about simplifying the method of extending urban boundaries? I am very doubtful as to whether that is in order. If the Minister has, perhaps he would tell us?

Comment on this

The procedure in Waterford did not present any difficulty.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand Deputy Bruton is not moving amendment No. 2.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 3, before section 4, to insert the following new section:

"5.—The Minister for the Environment, in conjunction with the Revenue Commissioners, shall, within three months of the commencement of each calendar year to which this Act has application, prepare and have presented to both Houses of the Oireachtas, a report setting out the following in respect of each of the three previous calendar years—

(a) in respect of each rating authority the number of persons, the valuation of whose tenements of agricultural land in respect of which they are rated equals or exceeds the amount standing specified on the first day of the year in section 15 (3) of the Finance Act, 1974, who were not liable to pay income tax because of insufficient income but who were liable to pay rates, as provided in this Act, in the relevant year,

(b) in respect of each rating authority the number of persons, the valuation of whose tenements of agricultural land exceeds £1 per acre on average and whose total valuation exceeds the amount standing specified on the first day of the year in section 15 (3) of the Finance Act, 1974, and

(c) in respect of each rating authority the extent to which the percentage increase in the county rate in the year exceeds the percentage increase in agricultural incomes in the State in the year in question or the latest year for which figures are available as determined by the Central Statistics Office.".

The purpose of this amendment is to introduce a new section. At the beginning of the year the Minister will be required to make a report on the application of the Act and he will be making that report under three headings: first to indicate the number of people in each rating authority who, although they will suffer an increase in rates under the removal of reliefs, do not have sufficient income to render them liable for income tax.

In other words, we want to know in respect of each area the number of farmers who are being asked to pay substantially increased rates but who do not have to pay income tax because of their not having an income that would be taxable. We want to pinpoint those farmers who are the victims of injustice. As I said earlier, farmers who are paying income tax can set their rates off against that tax so that the injustice to them of an unfair rates demand is greatly mitigated. But for those farmers who do not have sufficient incomes to justify their paying income tax but who will be faced with a dramatic increase in rates there is an injustice because there is nothing against which they can set off their rates. Each year for the next three years we want a report from the Minister on the position in each rating authority in respect of the number of people who do not have sufficient income to justify their paying income tax but who are being asked to pay this dramatic increase in rates.

We want to know also in respect of each rating authority the number of people whose valuations exceed £1 per acre on average and who are being subjected also to reduced rates relief. In such cases the burden of rates will be more substantial on an acreage basis for somebody whose valuation is less than £1 per acre. Thirdly, we want a report in respect of each rating authority on the extent to which the percentage increase in the county rate is more than the rate of increase in agricultural income in the State as a whole. We can foresee a situation occurring quite often where in a given local authority area the rate of increase in the rate will be much faster than the rate of increase in agricultural incomes. Perhaps this year is the best one for this sort of assessment because while rates will increase by about 10 per cent agricultural incomes have fallen by about 3 per cent. Therefore we will have a situation in which the relief for farmers against rates will be reduced, with their rates being increased by 10 per cent on a substantially increased amount of their holdings as a result of the removal of the relief at a time when their incomes will have fallen by 3 per cent.

We are asking that information be laid before the House each year to demonstrate clearly every case in which the increase in rates exceeds substantially the increase in income from which the rates should be paid.

The purpose of this amendment which is seeking information, and that is all we can do under this Bill, is to get information about the inherent injustices in the Bill and about the system which the Bill is aggravating. If the information that we request is laid before the House each year the public will see clearly the injustice of the system. The amendment is very reasonable and its acceptance would be very useful in that it would expose the injustices of the rating system and would bring about a situation in which by force of public opinion and of public information this unjust system would be changed.

Comment on this

The Deputy's amendment seeks to have written into the Bill a provision that each year I would be bound to submit report to both Houses of the Oireachtas. Such report would have a number of sets of detailed figures related in some degree to the agricultural grant and covering the three previous years. I do not conslider the amendment to be reasonable and I must oppose it.

My Department publish three major document on an annual basis and all three are submitted to both Houses. There documents between them contain a large amount of figures and of information of general interest relating to the work of my Department and of local authorities. If at any time any Deputy wishes to have extra figures or information about particular schemes or services it is open to him to table a parliamentary question and I should be willing always to answer any such question to the extent to which I have the information being sought. But it would not be right for me to undertake to submit detailed figures of particular servies as a matter of routine. If this were to be the case we would all be snowed under quickly with facts and figures which might be of very little general interest or value. I must take into account also the likely value of detailed information in relation to the cost of producing it.

Regarding the particular information to which the amendment refers, some of it would not arise directly from the administration of the agricultural grant while some of it would involve the responsibilites of other Ministers. Therfore, even if I thought that the information concerned was important to justify the submitting of a special annual report to both Houses—and I do not think that is the case—I would be unable to accept it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The amendment highlights the inequities of this piece of legislation. If a tax of any kind is being introduced or imposed it should be applied uniformly. Let us take a case of two landholders each wilth a valuation of £40. If one of them is liable to pay income tax—and the amount of the rates liability will be, at £12 in the £1, £480—he can deduct the amount of the rates from the income tax liability with the result that he will not be paying any rates. However if he has a large family or if for one reason or another matters are not good with him—for instance, if his herd is stricken with brucellosis or with TB and he is not liable for any income tax by reason of the Inspector of Taxes being satisfied that his income is such as to absolve him from income tax —he still must pay the £480 rates so that the net result is the same. Surely that is unfair in the extreme. It is a system of taxation that cannot be justified. It is saying that although somebody is not liable for imcome tax he is being told that he will have to pay the £480 anyway. Therefore two farmers with similar valuations could find themselves in two very different situations. One could get a credit note for his £480 rates and would not have to pay while the other farmer would have to pay. How can such a system be justified?

Comment on this

That is under paragraph (a) of the amendment. Whether the Revenue Commissioners will have this sort of information I do not know but I would not have any information on the amount of income tax paid.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I am asking the Minister how he can justify a system under which two farmers with a valuation of £40 will find themselves in the position where one will have to pay £480 rates and the other will not have to pay any rates because he will ger a refund or a credit note.

Comment on this

One man will be liable for income tax; otherwise he could not set his rates off against his tax and the other man is not liable for income tax. We discussed this earlier this afternoon. It all depends on whether he has a liability to pay income tax.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): If a man is liable to pay income tax, it is because he has an income which justifiers the assessment of income tax on him. That man is obviously in a much better position than his neighbour who is not liable for income tax. Yet, each pays the same amount of tax—call it rates, tax or what you like—although it is acknowledged that one man is much worse off than the other. One has an income which attracts income tax and justifies the demand of income tax from him but the other man has an income which excuses him from paying income tax. Each pays the same tax. Is that not an unfair law? Is it not an unjust law? Is it not a discriminatory law?

Comment on this

That has been part of the Finance Acts in recent year.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): It has not. It is collusion between the Minister for the Environment and—

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am not being facetous when I ask the Deputy to relate this to the amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The amendment proposes to give details of that sort of thing. It proposes that the Minister would have to bring before the Oireachtas a list of cases where a person is liable for income tax, yet has lost the benefit of the agricultural relief Acts. The amendment can be justified when I explain what Deputy Bruton wants to bring into the open. He wants to knwon how many people will find themselves in that position. If the people knew and understood this legislation, they would rebel against it. I could see the Supreme Court overruling this sort of legislation as being unfair.

Comment on this

Like Deputy Fitzpatrick I find these amendments reasonable, When giving the reasons for rejecting the amendment the Minister said that the information was available from various sources—he quoted three sources. As he is responsible for introducing this type of legislation, he should have this infomation at hand and it should be incorporated into any legislation for which he is responsible so that the very obvious and glaring anomalies of this Bill can be seen by the people concerned.

Deputy Fitzpatrick quoted the obvious case of two farmers and the injustice being done to one farmer. If this amendment were accepted we would know immediately the number of such cases affected and the injustice perpetrated on our farming ratepayers. The Minister in rejecting this amendment so glibly is doing a disservice to the farming community. If, as he says, the infomation is readily available from three sources, it would not be too difficult to have that information transferred into a Bill.

Comment on this

I do not know what the Minister is afraid of in accepting this amendment. He said most of the information is available already and I cannot see why he does not accept the amendment. The information will be very relevant in deciding whether the legislation is operating justly. The intention of the removal of the rates relief should be seen in its overall context. It was announced in the budget as part of a measure of achieving equity between the farming community and the reat of the prople and figures were provided of revenue that would be derived under various heads, rates being one of them, from the farming community. The whole idea was to achieve a sufficient amount of revenue from the farming community so that it could be said that equity was being achieved between farmers and everyone else.

If we are concerned with equity, this information is very relevant because it shows how equitable or otherwise the mesures introduced in this Bill will be in practice. If the idea is that people should be paying an equivalent amount on an equivalent income, whether they be farmers or somebody else, it is clearly not equitable if farmers who have no liability for income tax have to pay a very substantial increase in their rates. That is not equity. Yer the Government are arguing that the whole idea of their budgetary policy is to achieve equity . If that is happening, the information should be brought to public knowledge and this amendment will ensure that that happens. Equally, if valuations differ widely from one part of the country to another, that is not equitable or in line with the objectives of the budget. If the increase in rates is completely out of line with the increase in agricultural incomes, with which these rates have to be paid, that is not equitable either. This information should be made available so that we can see if these circumstances exist.

I believe an amendment such as this, seeking from amendment Minister that he make avaialble on a regular basis statistical information as to the application and effect of the legislation he is sponsoring, should be included in much more legislation than it is at present. Far too often we pass Bills and forget entirely about their effect for years afterwards and we do not discuss them in any way until for some reason or other, amending legislation is brought in. In the meantime, this legislation could have caused considerable injustice, could have been applied in circunstances which were never the intention when the legislation was passed. There is no system for review on a regular basis of on the Statute Book.

This section is, in that sense, breaking new ground in that it seeks to institute a system whereby the responsible Minister will have to report regularly on the implementation of this legislation. If that system were adopted, It would be a very good day's work. I believe very strongly in this and propose to have it further discussed on Report Stage. This matter is important enough to warrant further discussion. I will withdraw my amendment to give the Minister an opportunity to reconsider his position. I believe that when he reconsiders it he will alow our amendment or something similar. It will not cost anything to give this sort of information.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): What is the effect of the repeal? This section repeals suvsections (2) and (3) of section 1 of the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Act, 1978 but I thought that Act had expired by the effluxion of time.

Comment on this

The section provides for the repeal of subsections (2) and (3) of section 1 of the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Act, 1978 which had been replaced by section 1 of the Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I thought the 1978 Act had expired

Comment on this

Subsection (2) of section 1 of the 1978 Act provided that allowances would not apply to a person the rateable valuation of whose land holdings exceeded the income tax threshold for full-time farmers applicable on 1st January in the relevant local financial year. This threshold was £60 on 1st January 1979 and £50 on 1 January 1980. The Minister for Finance in his budget statement indicated that the imcome threshold was being settled at £40 for 1980,1981 and 1982. Subsection (2) of section (1) of the 1978 Act is being replaced by subsection (2) of section 1 of the Bill which specifies the ceiling of £40. Subsection (3) of section 1 of the 1978 Act empowered the Minister by order to grant a waiver to local authorities generally from the requirement of national aggregation. This was necessary at the time for administrative reason. Order were made in 1978 and 1979 under subsection (3) of section1 of the 1978 Act.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I thought the 1978 Act only applied to 1978 and 1979 and that it expired on 31 December 1970.

Comment on this

That Act specified £50 from 1 January 1980 whereas the Bill changes that to £40.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Subsection (1) of section 1 of the 1978 Act stated that ssubject to subsection (2) of section 1 the Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) ACt, 1946 shall apply to local financial years ending 31 December 1978 and 31 December 1979 and shall so apply subject to the modification that no employment allowance shall be made. In the Bill as initiated in 1978 there was no subsection (3) but, perhaps, an amendment was inserted later.

Comment on this

The allowances given in the 1978 Act expired. The threshold was £60 according to the Act up to 1 January 1979 and £50 from 1 january 1980. The Bill specifies the ceiling at £40 from 1 January.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Apparentlym, the Act did not expire at the end of 1979.

Comment on this

The relief given under the Act expired but the subsections did not.

Comment on this

I move amendment no.4:

In page 3, line 34, before "Relief" to insert "Wilthdrawal of".

The Bill is misleadingly titled Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill and I propose to change that title to Rates on Agricultural Land (Withdrawal of Relief) Bill because the effect of the Bill is to withdraw reliefs which previously existed and had been renewed annually. Although some of the previous reliefs are being renewed automatically this year a substaintial portion of the reliefs which were previously given are withdrawns the Bill. The Bill is one which withdraws reliefs which perviously existed. Legislation should not be misleadingly titled; it should always be titled as to its real effect so that people can see what it is about. There is not doubt that in any reasonable interpretation of political and economic reality the Bill is about the withdrawal of relief from rates. It is not about granting reliefs because the reliefs which it renews and maintains existed for years. The only major change in the Bill from the situation which existed previously is one of withdrawing relief which have existed since the last war. That justifies a more honest title and that is why I am proposing a change.

Comment on this

It is a misnomer to call the Bill Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill because noboday could take it as a relief. I would go so far as to suggest that the word "imposition" instead of "relief" be used. The Minister may look upon this as providing relief but he has told us that a further £6 million will be extracted from the farming acommunity and that could not be termed relief. If that is the Minister's interpretation of the word "relief" he should check a dictionary to find the true meaning of the word. If the Minister is trying to get across to tlhe farmers that he is granting them relief he is deceiving them because he is extraction £6 million from them. I support Deputy Bruton on this.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment. I agree with Deputy Bruton that no Bill should have a Misleading title. If I were to comply with what is in this amendment I would be giving the Bill a misleading title. Without this Bill all farmers throughout the country would be paying full rates. This Bill gives relief to the extent of £37.7 million. We must have the Bill to give that relief; without the Bill no rate-paying farmer would get any relief. Therefore the Bill is properly named and I cannot accept an amendment which would misname it.

Comment on this

It is purely a legislative accident that this relief requires statutory renewal every few years. The fact that the Minister is introducing a Bill to prolong something which had existed before the war—

Comment on this

There have been changes over the years.

Comment on this

Not significant changes. The fact that the Minister is doing that is in no sense creating a situation in which it would be said that he is granting any relief. He is merely renewing or maintaining something that has existed for a number of years. There is nothing new about it. What is new about this Bill is the withdrawal of reliefs which existed previously. That is how this Bill will be seen by the farming communilty when they come to pay their rates later in the year. That is the effect that this bill will be perceived as having had. If people choose to look up the index of statutes for the year 1980 in order to find out the legal authority for the substantial and dramatic increase in their rates this year and they see a Bill entitled Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill they will say that could not be the appropriate Bill, that that would not be a Bill that would increase rates. Yet the reality is that this misleadingly entitled relief Bill will increase the rates on lthe farming community. It is a misleading title.

Comment on this

How about farmers below a £40 valuation? Would the Deputy have them rated?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): As we know, when this relief was first introduced it was an omnibus relief that covered all agricultural holdings. Then the Bill was quite rightly holdings. Then the Bill was quite rightly entitled Rates on Agricultural Land (Relief) Bill, 1939, or whenever it was. That was a proper title for it then. But we are inclined to follow precendent. If we can find a precedent for anything we are inclined to take it out of a pigeon hole or a file and continue to use it. There is no relation between the type of Bill first introduced to grant rates relief on agricultural land and the present one. What is being done here is that relief that existed is being withdrawn. It is being allowed expire and is not beng received.

Of course one can have an argument about anything but, as Deputies Bruton and Griffin have said, anybody looking for a rates relief Bill would not recognise this as such. As the Minister has gone so far as to include in it withdrawal of relief he might consider striking out the word "relief" and calling it the Rates on Agricultural Land Bill, 1980. That would go some way towards correcting the misleading title. In those circumstances a person would stop, look and inquire what the Bill was about. But to leave the Bill as at present entitled, when it takes away relief from a category of agricultural holdings extending from a valuation of £40 to £60, is going a bit far. This Bill abolishes relief in respect of that band of holdings and in so doing increases the rates this year by varying degree from 106 per cent to 1472 per cent.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister that it is not his wish to mislead the House ot the farming community. No legislation passing through this House should be deceitful, attempt to misrepresent the factual position or lead any section of the community astray; it should be clearly stated and specified what is the intention of the legislation.

Is the Minister serious when he tells us that a Bill such as this which will bring an extra 20,000 farmers into a rateable category is granting relief? I doubt very much if the 20,000 farmers adversely affected will accept glibly what the Minister tells them, that he is granting them relief. It is outrangeous that a Bill such as this carrying a deceptive title should pass through this House. I would ask the Minister to consider seriously if not Deputy Bruton's amendment at least the reasonable request of Deputy Fitzpatrick when he urged that the word "relief" be removed from the title. I cannot stand over such a title nor can the Minister, especially in the full knowledge that this year 20,000 extra farmers will be affected by the provisions of a Bill misleadingly termed a relief Bill.

Comment on this

Of course the Bill affects farmers. The Bill is necessary because it offords total relief to holdings numbering approximately 390,000—no rates on holdings under £20 valuation. The Bill affords partial relief on further 58,000 holdings. Therefore it is affording relief of rates on something in the region of 460,000 holdings. I have no intention of misnaming the Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister quoted that figure of 390,000 people who will receive relief.

Comment on this

No. Deputy, holdings.

Comment on this

How many people are involved in those 390,000 holdings? That is important.

Comment on this

I am talking about rateable holdings; I am not talking about numbers of people.

Comment on this

We want the nembers of people involved. Deputy Bruton raised the question of a farmer in, say, County Mayo with fragmented holdings, with perhaps two acres in one holding, four acres in another and six in yet another. Can the Minister tell us how many people are involved in those 390,000 holdings.

Comment on this

We do not have that information. We do not have the nembers of farmers. I would suggest that the Deputy put down a question to the minister for Agriculture.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are getting back into the same repetition. We are dealing here only with the Title of the Bill.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T.J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The Minister should have that information.

Comment on this

The Minister's Department must have that information.

Comment on this

For the simple reason that these people must be put down for relief on rates. Therefore the Minister must have the individual names of these people.

Comment on this

No, we do not have the number of farmers.

Comment on this

The different county councils will have them.

Comment on this

I said we do not have that information in my Department.

Comment on this

Surely the MInister's Department are in contact with the various local councils—

Comment on this

We do not have the number of farmers. We have holdings, valuations

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The amendment deals only with Title of the Bill.

Comment on this

I too object to the title carrying the word "relief". It is only right to leave out the word "relief" There is relief only for those living on subsistence incomes who could not possibly be expected to pay because they are already completely over-burdened.

Comment on this