Housing Finance Agency Bill, 1981: Committee Stage.
Contributions 1–155 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 45 of 1981 ›
This section states:
1.—In this Act—
"the Agency" means the Housing Finance Agency;
"borrower" means a person to whom a loan described in section 5 (3) of this Act is made and includes the successor in title of the person to whom such a loan is made;
"the Companies Acts" means the Companies Acts, 1963 and 1977;
"house" includes any building or part of a building used or suitable for use as a dwelling and any outoffice, yard, garden or other land appurtenant thereto or usually enjoyed therewith;
"housing authority" means a housing authority within the meaning of the Housing Act, 1966;
"the Minister" means the Minister for the Environment.
This section is important when one considers what is defined in it. My first question is: why is there a need for such an agency? Yesterday Members on this side in the course of some very good contributions expressed concern about the area of housing. As a party we decided not to oppose the Second Stage and we did so not because we saw great merit in the new agency but because we viewed the agency as irrelevant. Our view is that an injection of funds to help the construction industry is needed at this stage.
Comment on this
I apologise for interrupting the Deputy but he must confine his remarks to section 1, the definition section.
Comment on this
I am attempting to do that. I am dealing with the definition and why we need the agency.
Comment on this
I am anxious to set the record straight with regard to our decision not to oppose the Second Stage. Last night, when concluding, the Minister seemed to cast reflections on our decision in relation to that. The Bill is not the vehicle that will provide much-needed funds for the construction industry or house loans. If the Government were serious they could provide the extra money rather than setting up this agency. I will make my points about the agency on later sections. I am anxious to point out that our decision to agree to the passing of the Second Stage was to highlight the irrelevancy of the agency rather than an enthusiastic welcome for its establishment.
Comment on this
Do I take it that existing urban councils are considered to be "housing authorities" as defined in the section?
Comment on this
I suppose I should not have last night, and I do not do so now, question the reasons why any party vote for or against any measure in this House. That is entirely a matter for the party concerned. I merely put an interpretation on what I thought were the Opposition's reasons for not opposing the Second Stage. I fully accept the point made by the Deputy and I acknowledged last night — I am not sure if Deputy Burke was present at the time — the value of yesterday's debate. I am not sure that everything was entirely relevant to the Bill but I valued the contributions and I made an offer, which I hope will be taken up by the Opposition, that when the White Paper on housing is published in the spring we could arrange between the Whips a one-day debate on housing problems generally. I learned a lot yesterday and I am sure that many more Members would have liked to contribute to the debate.
In reply to Deputy Calleary I should like to state that the reference to "housing authority" in the section is to the 41 authorities which operate a house purchase loan scheme under section 19 of the Housing Act, 1966 — that is, county councils, county borough corporations, borough corporations and three urban district councils, Athlone, Dundalk and Bray.
Comment on this
Do I take it that under the Bill an urban council such as Ballina Urban District Council which has been operating a loan scheme will not be able to operate a similar scheme under the new agency?
Comment on this
They did operate such a scheme and carried out all the investigations. May I take it that they will still be in a position to do that?
Comment on this
If they operated an SDA loan scheme then the answer is yes. I am not sure if that council operated such a scheme.
Comment on this
In the course of his speech yesterday the Minister said that it was envisaged that at full operation the new scheme would replace the local authority loan scheme. A very important part of housing finance here has been the existence of the SDA loans scheme. Most young people if they had first choice would go for such loans because they borrow at a fixed rate of interest, make fixed repayments and they know from the outset the amount of their repayments until the mortgage is paid off.
Contrast that with the type of loan that it is envisaged this agency will provide. The loan the agency will provide is fixed as a proportion of a person's income, going up year after year. I gave an example yesterday from a table produced by an eminent economic journalist in the Irish Independent, Mr. Rapple, in which he showed that, using the system that is envisaged, on a 25-year loan, taking a man on a salary of £5,700 per annum at this stage and taking inflation in the third year down to 10 per cent which, with the policies of this Government, is unlikely although they will not be in office in the third year, the repayments over the 25-year life of the loan would amount to £140,000 on a £20,000 loan. Contrast that with the loan that is provided at present under the SDA scheme which has been a central feature of housing finance for so many years. That is the scheme that this Minister and this Government now intend to scrap. The Minister in his speech yesterday said:
It is envisaged that, at full operation, this new scheme will replace the local authority loan scheme.
The SDA loan provides the ideal situation for a couple or for a single person starting off. It means that one knows from the very first day exactly what one's repayments and one's interest rate will be for the life of the loan. Twenty two per cent of all house buyers are single people and we can judge this Government's commitment to the provision of funds for housing by their actions last July. On 23 July Deputy Barry, the Minister for the Environment, came into this House. It was the week of the three budgets. We had a budget on the Tuesday which raised the level of inflation to figures that we had not seen for a considerable number of years and which was contrary to everything that had been included in the Fine Gael policy document, the Labour policy document and the infamous Gaiety Theatre document. In the Tuesday budget VAT was increased from 10 to 15 per cent. From midnight on 21 July there was a price increase of 2p on spirits, 2p on beer, 4p on cigarettes. There was an increase in the price of wine. The unfortunate motorist was savaged once again with an increase of 4p per gallon on petrol, 4p on road diesel, 8p on LPG. Excise duty on cars and motor cycles was increased from 40 to 50 per cent. Road tax was reintroduced. There were stamp duty changes, bank levies, price increases consequent on the tax increases, increased Post Office charges. On the Wednesday of that week there were further increases in respect of the ESB and so on. Then on the Thursday the Minister for the Environment came in here with a measure which was the greatest act of discrimination by any administration for many years. It was going back to the Victorian mentality. When every administration had been introducing legislation to remove discrimination against women in the workplace and from as many aspects of Irish society as possible this Minister announced that he was removing the entitlement to mortgage subsidy from single people. The Minister himself said in his speech that 22 per cent of house buyers were single people.
Comment on this
The situation is that the Minister on 23 July removed entitlement to mortgage subsidy and to SDA loans from single people. That is a measure of this Government's commitment to housing. Now we have this Bill being rushed through this House. The first time I saw the Bill was towards the end of the week before last. The normal procedure in the House is that after Second Stage debate the Committee Stage, on foot of agreement being reached between the Whips, is taken a week or two later, thus allowing time to reflect on the measure. In the short period available on this occasion we have a number of amendments tabled for today.
We may well ask what is this Bill? It is merely a flag-waving operation on behalf of the Government in an effort to show concern for the construction industry and for young married couples trying to buy a house. It is a matter of shadow but not of substance. The nub of the legislation is the raising of funds from the private sector but that can be done anyway under the existing Board of Works legislation. So far as the provision of funds for the construction industry is concerned I would question the Government's commitment just as I question their commitment in so many other areas. I am concerned about that part of the Minister's speech in which he says it is envisaged that in full operation the new scheme will replace the local authorities loans scheme. While we are still at the definition stage I would like the Minister to clarify for the House exactly what his intentions are in this respect. Does he really intend to dismantle this centre-piece of housing finance of which we have had the benefit down through the years? Are the Government so blind as not to appreciate the advantages and the benefit that the SDA loans scheme has bestowed? Is he prepared to destroy something so precious by the setting up of this scheme and providing for the repayment of mortgages by way of a percentage of income?
Comment on this
(Limerick East): Deputy Burke tells us that the Bill was accepted by the Opposition last evening on the basis that it is irrelevant anyway. To say that is to miss the whole point of the setting up of this agency. The Bill is a very good measure. It responds to a real need. Any Member of the House or of a local authority will know that a certain section of the community are not in a position to get loans to build houses in the present circumstances. They do not qualify for local authority loans at a certain level of income and their incomes are not sufficient to enable them to negotiate building society loans. I am talking about the people in the £8,000 to £9,000 bracket.
It is in response to that need that the Government have introduced this Bill. The scheme is by no means an irrelevancy. The need for it has existed for a long time. That is why the Bill has the support of everyone here despite the charade of opposition put forward yesterday.
Deputy Burke has challenged the proposed repayments scheme and to support his argument he has quoted figures arrived at by a well-known journalist. However, that journalist was predicting a rate of inflation during a 25-year period and none of us knows what will happen in the future. If one takes the present situation and thinks back to 12 years ago he will find that houses bought then at £3,000 are selling now at £30,000. This is a factor of ten anyway so that if one is working on a factor of ten and talking about a house worth £30,000 one is into very high figures in terms of 12 years hence. Therefore, even taking Mr. Rapple's enormous figures, one is talking about people having an asset worth twice the amount at the end of 25 years. I do not know who will be around to pay £300,000 for a house but that is the sort of figure we are talking of if we base our assumptions on the situation during the past ten years.
There is no point in trying to frighten people by quoting such enormous figures. Inflation will not proceed at that pace because one of the factors in inflation in the past number of years has been that too many people had a built-in vested interested in it. One of those sectors was young couples who had taken on big mortgages. If one took on a mortagage that was very high, one knew that inflation would ease the situation. Young couples had an interest in inflation and the greater the better, provided one could recoup one's losses by way of national pay agreements. That is what has been happening down through the years. People who bought houses ten years ago are paying back very little now. Indeed, many of those people are the ones who are buying second houses and renting them to people in the £8,000 to £9,000 income bracket who are not in a position to buy houses for themselves.
There is no need for me to go into the details of the scheme. We are talking about a very important measure. As the Minister said, this legislation is not a replacement for SDA loans but rather, an alternative.
Mr. Fahey rose.
Comment on this
The Chair would point out that the section before the House is merely the definition section and that there will be opportunity for discussion on the other sections.
Comment on this
We have grave doubts about the definition of the agency. I should like the Minister to explain the functions of this agency.
Comment on this
That is in section 4. This section is merely dealing with the definition of the agency, the company, the borrower and the Minister. What you are saying is relevant to the other sections and if you are patient we will get through this section first.
Comment on this
The definition of the agency is involved here because we have a doubt as to what the function of the agency is going to be. I think the definition is important from that point of view.
Comment on this
Its objects are explained in section 4 so you may raise it then or indeed you may raise it on section 2, because section 1 is merely concerned with definition of those words.
Comment on this
I know it defines what the agency actually is but I think in the definition the function of the agency now seems to be very small other than the raising of money, that is why I was anxious to mention it at this stage.
Comment on this
Could I refer the Minister to the second definition of borrower? It means a person to whom a loan described in section 5 (3) of the Act is made. Am I right in thinking that the use of the term "person" normally implies either an individual, a company or a co-operative? If so, is it envisaged that loans might be given to housing co-operatives or companies, entities other than individuals?
Comment on this
It refers to the person to whom a loan described in section 5 (3) is made. If the Minister looks at that section he will see that it sets out numerous terms and conditions which apply to a loan made to persons other than a housing authority. Is there laid down anywhere in the Bill the terms and conditions on which loans may be made to a housing authority that would parallel those kinds of provisions in regard to a loan to an individual?
Comment on this
Section 5(1) covers that point. It says that the agency may, subject to such conditions as for the time being stand approved of under this section by both the Minister and the Minister for Finance, make a loan to a person to acquire or construct a house and advance moneys to a housing authority to enable loans to be made by the authority for the acquisition and construction of houses.
Comment on this
I think the Minister will agree that those conditions to which he refers apply both to an advance to a housing authority or to a loan made to an individual. Yet, as shown in the definition section, reference was made to section 5(3) where from (a) to (k) conditions are set out applying to a loan to an individual but there seems to be no such reference applying to a lona to a housing authority. From the point of view of the agency, the loans will either be to individuals or to housing authorities—most of them will be to housing authorities —directly from the agency. It is strange that there should be such concern to set out all the conditions which will apply to a loan to an individual and no equal concern in regard to what will be the major function of the agency, loans to housing authorities. There is an imbalance and I wonder if the Minister can tell us why this is so?
Comment on this
The agency will lend to individuals under conditions which will be laid down by the Minister as a matter of policy. The agency will lend to housing authorities and the conditions under which they will lend to authorities will be a subject for consultation between the two, because the authorities already lend to individuals money that is borrowed from the Local Loans Fund, and this money would have to be lent under a different set of conditions. In practice, I feel the conditions laid down for individuals and under which the authority can lend to individuals will be the same.
Comment on this
The conditions which will be laid down for loans to individuals will be the same as those laid down for loans to housing authorities, is that what the Minister is saying?
Comment on this
The housing authority, in most cases, will be acting as the servant of the agency and lending the money. I envisage this agency using existing SDA offices to manage the scheme. The agency would lend money to the housing authorities which would, in turn, lend it to individuals and the terms and conditions under which they would lend to individuals would have to be reflected in the terms on which the housing authority would get the money from the agency.
Comment on this
Apart from drawing attention to the apparent imbalance—I say apparent, it may not be when it is analysed—I am somewhat concerned because I thought the position would be as I think the Minister has now described it that, in substance, the SDA machinery would be used for the purpose of operating this scheme.
Comment on this
The SDA loans are not the same as the agency loans but the personnel and the offices, which have experience of handling loans and of dealing with people applying for loans, will be the same. They will be operating two schemes side by side.
Comment on this
The point I am trying to make is that the existing machinery will be used. The various conditions and terms applying both to loans from the local authority from the local Loans Fund and to individual borrowers from the SDA are well known and established. If that system were to be used there would not be need for all these conditions in this section. On the other hand, these loans will be operated through different machinery with different conditions and I can understand why one would have to set out in considerable detail the terms applying to loans to individuals. That being so, I do not understand why it is necessary to specify the new machinery that will operate for advances to housing authorities. My reason for raising this is that the definition of "borrower" refers to section 5(3), but the definition of "housing authority" does not. If what I am saying is correct, there ought to be a corresponding provision in the definition section of "housing authority".
Comment on this
My officals got the point much more clearly than I. Exactly the same machinery will be operating these loans and the SDA loans. Both will be lent to individuals but the housing authorities are part of the State machinery and therefore the terms and conditions must be laid down in the Bill.
Comment on this
Deputy Colley has made a valid point. Perhaps the confusion arises from the tenor of section 5(3) which indicates that the direction of the scheme to be operated by the agency would be the making of loans directly by the agency itself. The whole of paragraphs (a) to (k) are directed to that end. These paragraphs refer to "conditions of loans made to persons". Those paragraphs apply to a person going to the agency to get loans, whereas it appears that that physical action is unlikely to arise because these loans will be processed through the local authorities. That has not been made clear. I assume that it is intended that the same qualifications, categories and so on will apply to loans being made by the local authorities and under this scheme.
Comment on this
Under section 5 there is an allowance for the possibility that the agency might make loans to individuals. If the agency do so, the terms must be set out and the conditions laid down in which such loans would be made. In all of the cases, however, the finance for the loans will be made to local authorities, en bloc, by the agency, and the local authorities in effect will be the agents of the agency.
Comment on this
I was not clear about that. Is the modus operandi to be that the local authority will be an agent of the agency and that the liability will be on the agency, or is it that the local authority clearly will be the body liable to the person who enters into an agreement for a mortgage?
Comment on this
If the agency lend money to the housing authority they will do so en bloc and the conditions applying to that loan to the housing authority will be the ordinary conditions applying in respect of repayment of the money under the SDA scheme.
Comment on this
Will the borrower enter into the mortgage agreement with the local authority or the agency?
Comment on this
With the local authority, acting as the agent of the agency, acting for and on behalf of the agency.
Comment on this
Will the borrower have his loan from the agency or from the local authority? Will the local authority be acting merely as the agent of the agency? Will the loan be between the borrower and the agency or between the borrower and the local authority?
Comment on this
There are two positions. The local authority will be acting as the managing agent for the agency in respect of funds lent to the local authority by the agency. The local authority will provide the machinery for lending the money to individuals, acting through the SDA housing offices. We had two choices. We could have established a network of offices and got the agency to lend money in the same way as building societies. On the other hand—and we opted for it— we could get the local authorities who have experience in these matters to do the job.
Comment on this
I do not notice in the Bill any provision in regard to major house reconstrucion or improvement work.
Comment on this
It does not arise. The Bill is to acquire or to build new houses, not to improve existing houses. Another form of mortgage or loan is available for that, or a grant in certain cases.
Comment on this
If the SDA loan system is phased out, as the Minister proposes to do, the borrowers for improvements will not have any facility——
Comment on this
The definition of "house" includes any "building or part of a building used or suitable for use as a dwelling and any outoffice, yard, garden or other land appurtenant thereto or usually enjoyed therewith." I think I understand why "yard, garden or other land appurtenant thereto" has to be included. That is to ensure that they can be included in the mortgage documents securing the loan. I want the Minister to confirm that it is envisaged that loans may be given by the agency, or by a housing authority acting for the agency, not only for houses but also for flats, maisonettes and so on, complete dwellings.
Comment on this
(Dublin South-Central): Under the Landlord and Tenant Bill which went through the House recently, many people will be unable to meet their commitments when it comes into effect. Many of these people are in very poor circumstances. The repercussions of that Bill will make it impossible for them to meet their rents. Will there be any provision in this Bill under which the agency could have these dwellings purchased and rented back to these tenants?
Comment on this
The Bill is not confined to new houses. The tenant of one of these houses could borrow money from the agency to buy his own house.
Comment on this
(Dublin South-Central): That would not be sufficient to meet the needs of the people I am talking about. They would not be able to meet their repayments. They are people on very low incomes. I was hoping there would be some provision that the local authority could purchase these houses on their behalf and rent them back to them.
Comment on this
On the financing of this agency, the Minister spelled out very clearly to the House yesterday in his statement moving the Second Stage of the Bill that this agency will be self-financing. I should like to know exactly who will do the financing. Will the local authorities subsidise it? Will it be another drag on the finances of the local authorites? Exactly how will this agency be funded? I should like the Minister to spell that out for the information of the House.
Comment on this
I thought that was made quite clear. The agency will issue bonds which will be backed by the Government. They will be index-linked bonds. That has been pointed out a number of times. The Minister for Finance will underwrite them, if that is the correct expression.
Comment on this
A certain portion of the money raised by the bonds will be held and the remainder will be sent in block allocations to the various housing authorities, as I understand it.
Comment on this
Probably in practice that is the way it will work. The housing authority will accept applications. I am hoping to start at the end of next month, and that the money will be available to the agency six weeks or two months later. Each housing authority will make an application for a certain amount of money to cover the loans, and then it will roll on fairly normally as the demands come in and go through the agency.
Comment on this
We will come to the question of the bonds later and the effect they will have on the whole money market, and the cosseting of the financial institutions at the expense of mortgage holders and home owners. This cosseting is quite unusual. It is the first time we have had it here. We will talk about that later during the day. On the question of the agency, the Minister has given us some timing. Is it envisaged that the agency will be established after Christmas?
Comment on this
Yes, hopefully, depending on getting the Bill through the Dáil and the Seanad, and having it signed by the President. I would not presume on any one of those.
Comment on this
On the question of the administration of this by the local authorities, the local authorities will be handling two different types of loans. They will be handling the existing, very efficient, much admired and very desirable fixed-interest rate-type loan in the SDA loans system. They will also be handling this new loan to be provided under the sets of regulations the Minister will send down from the agency.
Does the Minister accept that the increased paper work, the increase in administrative problems, rather than being beneficial to potential mortgages holders, will be a positive deterrent and a block as regards the availability of loans and the speed in getting loans. For the type of loan envisaged here it will be necessary if I understand it correctly — and I should like the Minister to correct me if I am wrong — for the applicant to produce his tax returns for the previous year.
Comment on this
Local authorities deal with perhaps 100,000 people paying pay-related rents at the moment. They are quite used to this type of situation and they know how to handle it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not accept that two different types of loans will be operated by the same staffs within the local authority? Does he not see the difficulties and the administrative delays which will arise? Rather than speeding up the process of getting loans and speeding up the payment of loans, there will be a further administrative block and not the benefit the Minister envisaged.
Comment on this
I do not. The scheme is different of course. Local authority staffs will have to find out how to operate it. I would consider it a reflection on them to say they would not be able to handle it.
Comment on this
I did not say they would not be able to handle it. Does the Minister not appreciate that administrative delays will be involved?
Comment on this
I am quite sure they can handle it. Can the Minister give an assurance that, as a result of local authorities operating this scheme, there will be no fiscal drag, as it were, imposed on local authorities. What I mean is this: we will have a situation here in which I presume the local authorities will draw the money from the agency, not in a block sum as it were but as they require it and then wait to give it out in future.
I would presume that the terms of the loan, as between the agency and the local authority, would involve fairly strict fixed repayments to be made by the local authority, on the due dates, to the agency because the agency, having to be self-financing, have their obligations to meet to the bond holders from whom their finance came. Therefore the situation could arise, as was envisaged in the Minister's speech yesterday, whereby deferral is provided for under certain circumstances by the mortgage holder. How will that work?
Comment on this
I am sorry to interrupt but perhaps the Deputy would agree that the point he is now pursuing would be more appropriate to section 4 or section 10 which deal specifically with these matters. What we are dealing with here is the setting up of the agency.
Comment on this
I do not mind raising it on section 4 but the Ceann Comhairle, when we were discussing section 1, indicated that this line of country would be appropriate to this section which deals with the formation and implementation of the agency. I do not mind but that is the reason I raised it at this point.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is referring to the actual financial matters, it would seem to me that there is no doubt at all that that would be more appropriate to sections 4, 5 or 10.
Comment on this
I do not mind but the Ceann Comhairle did indicate that we would deal with it under this section.
Comment on this
I will leave it to the undoubted ability of the good Deputy himself to agree perhaps that sections 4, 5 or 10 might be more appropriate.
Comment on this
Very well, I will come back to it then.
Comment on this
This section deals with the setting up of the agency. It is clear to me that it may be fairly cumbersome to administer because the situation could arise in which local authorities would be dealing now with three types of loans — loans under the agency, and possibly for a while, existing loans in regard to the SDA scheme on new housing and SDA loans for the carrying out of repairs to houses. I should like to know if there have been consultations with the staffs and unions involved in this. I think I am in order on this because this is the section dealing with the setting up of the agency.
Comment on this
On the other hand, perhaps the fact that the Deputy presents that question to me is a case of conscience making cowards of us, I do not know. There will be adequate opportunity on other sections.
Comment on this
We may be in a grey area, if you like, but still one relevant to the section. I think we must persue it somewhat more to ascertain exactly what it all amounts to. I think the Chair will agree with me on that.
Comment on this
There cannot be one rule for one and one rule for another.
Comment on this
I was not going into the financial aspects; I was dealing with the administrative aspect which arises on this section.
I am asking the Minister if there have been discussions with the unions in this respect. It is not for me to pre-empt what the situation will be but, in other fields, situations have arisen in which personnel in some Departments have declined to operate — or perhaps the appropriate phrase is "shall not operate"— certain proposed new measures. Therefore it is relevant to the question of personnel.
Under the provisions of this Bill there is entailed the setting up of the necessary machinery and recruitment of personnel. I should like to know therefore if the Minister has been given the "all clear" from the unions involved. I am open to correction on this but, if my memory serves me correctly, there may be three unions involved.
Comment on this
The Deputy will appreciate that section 1 deals with the formation of "the agency", the "borrower", the "housing authority" and so on. So long as the Deputy, and other Deputies, do not have sore heads later on when sections arise which deal more specifically with the matters now being raised, the Chair does not mind. But I think the Deputy accepts that section 2 would not be the appropriate section on which to discuss trade union matters.
Comment on this
I do not wish to enter into any controversy with the Chair on this but it is relevant to the setting up of the agency. These were matters I should like to have clarified and on which I would like to have the Minister's views also.
Comment on this
Unfortunately I did not hear the Minister's summing up last evening. This section deals with the formation and registration of the agency. At this stage I presume the Minister has some idea as to how many members there will be on the board of the agency. Has he any idea as to what staff, technical or administrative, will be recruited by the agency, particularly as it would appear now that the agency will give loans to individuals as well as to local authorities who will act as agents on their behalf? He said earlier that he did not presume to know when the Bill would be passed but I understand it has to be passed this evening and will be passed by the Seanad tomorrow. Because the Bill will be passed by the Dáil and Seanad before the weekend I presume the Minister expects applications for loans to be made within six weeks. At this stage the Minister must have some idea of the size of the agency, the number of board members to be appointed, what staff will be recruited and what premises they will have. Perhaps the Minister could let us know what is the position in relation to that.
Comment on this
To take the point raised by Deputy Connolly first, the managers got a copy of the Bill last night plus my Second Reading speech. I do not think it would have been correct to have given it to them beforehand but, of course, they could have obtained a copy of the Bill from the General Office. Those to whom I have spoken are enthusiastic about being given the opportunity of operating this scheme. I do not know whether that applies to all of them. A conference has been arranged for early January to brief them on it, so that they in turn can brief their staffs, when all the matters raised by Deputy Connolly will be gone into. I have not yet decided but the articles of association will say: between three and nine members. The staff will be as small as possible and the overheads of operating the agency will be equally small.
Comment on this
The debate so far has indicated how rapidly this legislation has been produced. In other circumstances one might say it was induced rather than produced. Since it is the Minister's intention to have this agency in operation very quickly he must know whether they will have technical staff to deal with people who apply directly to the agency rather than to the local authorities. Who will process these applications and adjudicate on the value of the houses? Has the Minister made any arrangements?
Comment on this
The Chair has been endeavouring to remind Members that there are other sections where the matters now being discussed would be directly relevant. There is not a word in section 2 about personnel.
Comment on this
We are talking about the formation of an agency and we must have regard to personnel. I bow to the ruling of the Chair.
Comment on this
The Chair is endeavouring to help Members to discuss with greater relevancy the different sections of this Bill. It seems quite obvious that what we are now discussing could be more appropriately discussed on other sections.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Chair would tell me the section under which I should pursue this matter?
Comment on this
The articles of association state that the number shall be between three and nine and it will be for the Government to decide.
Comment on this
(Limerick East): The Minister has said that local authorities will act as agents for the agency in the allocation of mortgages. Will they also act as agents for the sale of bonds to the general public or will this be done centrally?
Comment on this
They will not. The sale of bonds will be carried out by the agency either by negotiations or by auction between the financial institutions.
Comment on this
The agency is to be a limited company and one wonders whether the limitation of liability is really appropriate and whether it might not be better to have an unlimited company. The idea of limitation of liability is normally applicable to a trading company where the participants fear that they might have to go into liquidation and creditors would not get paid. One wonders whether limitation of liability is appropriate for the agency.
Comment on this
The Deputy is probably right. There is not really a limitation of liability because the Minister for Finance has undertaken to pick up the tab. This is the normal way of doing things.
Comment on this
The section refers to consultation between the Minister for Finance and the Minister for the Public Service. Will the embargo on recruitment to the public service apply to this agency? Where does he envisage that the registered office of this agency will be located? Will it be in the Custom House or O'Connell Bridge House or decentralised to Roscommon or Cork?
Comment on this
Cork is not a bad idea. We might take over the offices occupied by the National Enterprise Agency and get the same telephone number.
Comment on this
What will happen to staff in the Custom House who are at present operating the SDA loan system?
Comment on this
In his speech yesterday the Minister mentioned the possibility of an auction of bonds. Will this be done in the Stock Exchange or will tenders be invited from financial institutions?
Comment on this
The Minister said that he intended to introduce a pilot scheme. Is there any significance in his use of the word "pilot"? Is this agency to be set up for all time or only until the Government get rid of the annoyance which mortgages are causing them?
Comment on this
This is a new agency and it is our intention that it will be there for all time, if there is a public demand for funds. Many speakers said yesterday that they did not envisage the scheme being successful because nobody would borrow the money. They may be right, but that is not my opinion. The agency must start off in an experimental fashion because there are bound to be teething troubles.
Comment on this
This company will be involved in raising millions of pounds and lending very substantial sums to local authorities and borrowers and a capitalisation of £100 is entirely inadequate. The company will have initial expenses because they will have to employ staff and obtain stationery, telephones and all the machinery necessary to get the company off the ground. It may take some time before the bonds are floated and before any moneys start to come from that source. That is the only source of funds the company will have. It seems to me, having regard to the size of what is involved here, that a more substantial capitalisation by the Minister would be appropriate to enable the company to set up and to meet the initial expenditures the company will have.
I would have thought that a capitalisation of perhaps £1 million would not have been entirely inappropriate, having regard to the extent of the money transactions in which this agency will be involved. If the agency had such a capitalisation it would have the big advantage of an initial supply of funds from which the agency could commence straight away to make advances and to get the scheme rolling very quickly without having to wait for all the legal delays and formalities involved in raising the bonds, issuing them, obtaining subscribers and so on. This is, after all, put forward as a commercial transaction which has to be self-financing. It would be laughable to have a company set up to deal with several million pounds with a capitalisation of only £100. I would like the Minister to have some further consideration of the capitalisation of the company.
Comment on this
I have an open mind on what Deputy Taylor has said. I believe the Minister is going on the standard rules laid down for any ordinary company. That is the general criteria under which companies operate. I have some reservations in regard to company law but that cannot be dealt with under this Bill. It could be said that the formation of a limited company today should be looked at again in the overall context.
Comment on this
I will not get involved in that. I have some reservations, as I said, in regard to company law in this respect. The amount of money a person can have to form a company is open to review, but that comes under another Department. The agency will operate under the present company law.
Comment on this
I share Deputy Connolly's concern about the operation of company law. I consider that it is at least odd that a person can go into a solicitor's office or through a box number in a paper and set up a limited company. The articles of association are so wide that one can do anything one likes. One can rear elephants, engage in commerce, distil whiskey and anything one likes. This is the normal standard way for setting up a company by the State. I have no views about whether it is enough. I am advised by the Attorney General's office, the State Solicitor's office and by the Department of Finance that these are the normal provisions and this is the normal type of company. They are happy that this will cover everything we want to do and that it is the correct thing to do. Normally, in a case like this, when a company start up, they operate on an overdraft until cash starts to flow. I have the Telecommunications Investment Bill 1981 before me and this has exactly the same type of company.
Comment on this
(Dublin South-Central): I agree with Deputy Mervyn Taylor with regard to the capitalisation of this company. The figure of £100 seems to be a very small amount in relation to the amount of money the company will be dealing with which will run into millions of pounds. The Department and the Minister should at least have looked at this in a different light. I know they are perfectly right with regard to the formation of this company. I see advertisements in the paper every day in the week with regard to £100 capitalisation. The Minister, in order to instil more confidence into this agency, should look at a figure more in the region of the amount Deputy Taylor mentioned. There are bound to be expenses at the initial stage when the company is formed. Personnel have to be employed and there is the usual setting up of offices and so forth which will require a certain amount of capital. I believe, by and large, more resilience would be given to the company if there was a capitalisation of a larger amount because the company can run into trouble from time to time and may require something to fall back on.
I believe we are starting from a very weak base in relation to a company which we require the people to have great confidence in. I believe the investors would like to see a company with larger capitalisation. I would like the Minister to have a look at this section to see if the capital should be increased for the benefit and resilence of this agency. I am quite convinced if he did this the image of the company would be improved particularly in relation to people the company will be looking to borrow money from and also for setting up the company. The Minister mentioned that the initial expenses will involve the employment of nine technical staff or other employees in this company.
Comment on this
I did not mention technical staff. I said the membership of the board would be between three and nine. That is not the staff.
Comment on this
(Dublin South-Central): I thought the Minister mentioned the staff would comprise something of that nature.
Comment on this
(Dublin South Central): There will be expenses at the initial stage in relation to whatever number of staff will be employed. I agree with Deputy Taylor that the capital allocation should be of a large figure.
Comment on this
Section 10 of the Bill states that the company will be involved in £200 million, which is a fair amount of capital. The status the company will have is the signature of the Minister for Finance under all borrowings.
Comment on this
I would like to point out to Members that there is a printing error in Amendment No. 1 tabled by the Minister. The word "each" should appear after "shall" in the second line of subsection (4) to be inserted by the amendment. If the amendment is agreed this correction will be made by the Bills' Office. Amendment No. 2 in the names of Deputies Raphael Burke and Gerard Connolly is an alternative so we propose taking amendments Nos. 1 and 2 together, if that is agreeable.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 1:
In page 4, between lines 23 and 24, to insert the following subsection:
"(4) The memorandum of association and the articles of association of the Agency shall be laid by the Minister before each House of the Oireachtas as soon as may be after the requirements of section 2 of this Act have been complied with.”
I accept the principle of the amendment tabled by Deputies Raphael Burke and Connolly in relation to the memorandum and articles of association. I wish, however, to substitute the amendment which I have moved on the basis of legal advice which I have obtained. The changes I have made in the text prepared by the Opposition are merely of a drafting nature.
Comment on this
This is a key section of the Bill: Subsection (2) reads:
The objects of the Agency stated in the memorandum of association shall include the following:
(a) to provide, by way of mortgage or charge, loans for the acquisition or construction of houses,
(b) to provide moneys to enable such loans to be made by housing authorities, and
(c) to borrow money for the aforesaid purposes.
I would like to contrast the objects of the agency as set out in this Bill with what was included in the Fine Gael policy document. The Fine Gael policy document said:
3. For House Purchasers Through Existing Agencies who have Deposit Problems: Top-Up Loans.
The pay-related mortgage will operate in conjunction with other sources of funding for house purchase. Fine Gael will arrange with building societies that a new pay-related top-up loan will bear far less heavily in the first few years than any other source of borrowing used to fund deposits shortfall.
This is an enabling Bill. The real meat is the regulations and directions to be given to the agency by the Minister, including this top-up amendment. Nowhere in this section is there provision for providing building societies with funds.
One of the big difficulties facing building societies down the years has been the availability of funds so that loans can be provided on request. In the Fine Gael policy document—and this was also included in the housing finance document issued by Fine Gael in October 1980—the clear impression was given that the housing agency, as well as making available money for loans to individuals, would also provide funds to help building societies with their cash flow problems and to eliminate the restriction of the six month-12 month period deposit regulation. That is not included in the objects of the agency, and it should be.
Perhaps on reflection the Minister will include it as one of the objects of the agency. One of the heartbreaks facing a potential house-purchaser, whether single or married, is the difficulty in getting a mortgage from a building society. A person opens a deposit account in a building society and is assured that if the money is left on deposit for six months he will get a loan. At the end of six months he applies for his loan but is told that because the in-flow situation is bad the rules have been changed and he must leave his deposit for 12 months or 18 months. This is a very undesirable procedure and should be stopped. When a society take a deposit and give a clear indication, if the money is left on deposit for six months a person will then get a loan, that should be the law of the land.
Before I go any further, perhaps the Minister would like to clear up the point whether the agency will provide building societies with a new pay-related top-up mortgage.
Comment on this
This Bill appears to be attacking the SDA loan scheme. Additional staff will be required for the offices operating this scheme. Has this been considered? The Minister has given a commitment that the staffing of the agency will be small—he is carrying on his attack on the public service here. What is the situation——
Comment on this
The Deputy is now drawing the long bow. How could he say that is an attack on the public service when I am saving public money?
Comment on this
What is the situation about the additional local authority staff who will be required to administer this new loan? It will not be possible to administer the loans envisaged in this regulation——
Comment on this
As I said earlier, it was intended that the staff of this agency would be kept as small as possible. To interpret that as an attack on the public service is a flight of imagination which is difficult to follow. It is my duty as Minister——
Comment on this
It is exactly what the Deputy said. The Deputy said it was an attack on the public service. It is my duty as Minister, as it was Deputy Burke's duty when he was Minister, to spend carefully taxpayers' money when it is entrusted to us, and I intend to do that.
With regard to the number of staff necessary throughout the country, that is a matter for negotiation. As I told Deputy Connolly, the county and city managers will be in Dublin in the first week in January to discuss this matter with officials of my Department, but numbers in individual offices have not been identified yet.