Housing Finance Agency Bill, 1981: Committee Stage.
Contributions 156–304 of 304. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 45 of 1981 ›
I welcome the fact that the staff in the agency will be kept to a minimum. There is no difficulty about that, but what is the position with regard to staff in local authorities?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy withdrawing the statement that this was an attack on the public service?
Comment on this
No. What I said was that the Minister's policy as a Minister has been an attack on the public service, in particular with regard to the staffing of local authorities. If the Minister wishes to go back into that matter and the embargo of last July on employment of staff in local authorities, I will do so.
Comment on this
If the Deputy says he did not say it, then of course I will withdraw the allegation that he did. But I venture to suggest that he is the only Member in the House who thinks he did not say it.
Comment on this
I said there was an attack on the public service but not in relation to this. It is irrelevant, as the Minister knows. The real question is how will the Minister get over the embargo that exists with regard to employing additional staff in the housing offices of local authorities. There is no doubt that the staff in those offices will have to be increased substantially because of the complexity of the type of mortgage envisaged by the regulations and directions to be given by the Minister to the agency with regard to P.60s, application forms, annual checks on P.60s, or alterations in repayments that will be necessary annually. Has the Minister thought about this?
Comment on this
I do not think this is beyond the competence of local authorities who are accustomed to dealing with people who borrow money under the SDA loan scheme and to the collection of moneys under pay-related schemes, because about 100,000 tenants are pay-related. The number of staff will, of course, be increased but I do not know by how many or where. If the extra staff are necessary they will be provided and that is not included in the embargo of the Minister for Finance announced in July.
Comment on this
Has the Minister thought out the situation with regard to repayments? The new loans are pay-related at between 16 and 20 per cent of annual income.
Comment on this
It keeps changing. In the various documents that have been produced it has changed from 17 to 20 per cent.
Comment on this
It could be a little more. Of course, a figure as low as 14 per cent was also mentioned. If a man gets a loan his repayments will be based on 18 per cent of this year's income.
Comment on this
His repayments will be based on 18 per cent of his income for the first year but he may have to wait for some time to get his P.60 in the second year. The local authority must wait before they can alter their records and give him the percentage he will be liable for the following year. What happens when there are delays in the production of documents by the tax authorities? Will a demand be made immediately on the borrower for any shortfall in the first few weeks in the event of a delay in the provision of documents? How will this area be tackled?
Comment on this
Local authorities are competent to deal with this situation. They meet such situations frequently. Employers throughout the country meet such situations frequently where PRSI forms are delayed or where for some reason documents do not come through on time. I presume that where there is a delay the borrower will make an approximate payment pending the presentation of the documents and then make the full payment at the end of the period to make up the difference or carry it forward and make it up over a longer period. They are normal administrative practices that are met daily by all lending institutions, including banks, local authorities, hire purchase companies and building societies. Such a problem is settled in a reasonable and practical manner and it will be done in the same way by the agency.
Comment on this
I was delighted last night to hear the Minister say that the scheme envisaged will be run parallel with the SDA loan scheme and not in substitution for it. It seems that a keynote factor in the work of the agency should be the issue which was touched on earlier, the provision of a second mortgage. The Minister was correct when he stated that it is referred to in section 5 (4). I would be happier if the words "second mortgage" were spelled out in the objects of the agency. The most valuable service the agency could fulfil would be to help those who are on local authority waiting lists and are eligible for a loan of £18,000 under the SDA scheme. If such people can get £4,000 or £5,000 from the agency they will be able to buy a house. The objects clause should include the words I have suggested, and I regard that as most important. It will seem strange to many people who approach local authorities, the bodies who will have the unfortunate and difficult task of operating the new scheme as a parallel with the existing SDA scheme, when officials point out that there are two schemes operating, the SDA scheme at 12½ per cent and the new scheme at an interest rate of between 18 and 20 per cent. There will be the added complication if, as I trust will happen, the second mortgage scheme is available. Those schemes will have to operate simultaneously. A borrower may seek a loan of £18,000 under the SDA scheme at 12½ per cent and the remainder he requires for his house from the new agency at an interest rate of between 18 and 20 per cent on a second mortgage. That will give rise to technical problems that the legal people will have to work out. I do not know if one can have a first and second mortgage from the same lender, but I have no doubt that the legal people will be able to get over that complication.
Comment on this
I will take the point made by Deputy Taylor. I think the second mortgage is the point he wants to bring across. A second mortgage house will probably give rise to legal problems but I have great confidence in the legal people to solve the problem. I am sure Deputy Taylor would be extremely good at it. I do not have any lack of faith in the competence of the local authority officers to administer two schemes side by side.
Comment on this
It is amazing that the Minister admits there will be legal problems with this Bill. Deputy Taylor, a practising solicitor——
Comment on this
——has expressed worries about this matter. It is unfortunate that the Bill was not circulated to the Labour Party before it came into this House. If it had been, it might be a more effective Bill. The Minister is admitting that it will give rise to legal problems and there will be a field day for the solicitors who will make exorbitant profits from it.
Comment on this
You are attacking the solicitors and the local authority officers. The Deputy is in bad form this morning.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give a guideline to the local authorities as to how they will assess the income of a famrer who is not in the tax bracket? Will it be 18 per cent of an estimated income or will it contribute to the fall in farm incomes? It will be very difficult for local authorities to work this out. Under this Bill the local authorities will have to assess the income of a small farmer and this will give rise to major difficulties.
Comment on this
I am speaking as a full-time public representative and as a county councillor, which the Minister is not.
Comment on this
(Limerick East): When somebody gets a loan from the agency, repayments will be made on a pay-related basis at approximately 18 per cent. I understand the 18 per cent will not be all interest, that part of it will be capital. How will an individual be assessed for mortgage relief purposes for income tax and how will one distinguish between capital and interest? What is the situation there?
Comment on this
There is a well-established and accepted system in social welfare as well as in local authorities for dealing with farmers whose income changes from year to year. With regard to Deputy Noonan's point, the revenue commissioners are at present examining how that will be done. Of course, it is a problem. One does not bring in anything new without some problems. I see that as one of the problems but that will be solved quite simply by a certificate being issued every year as to the breakdown between the two.
Comment on this
(Dublin South-Central): What I envisage happening is something similar to what has happened in the banking institutions over the past ten years. In the old days one could go into a bank and get an overdraft for a considerable time at a given amount but nowadays one is diverted to the merchant banks and given term loans, the reason being that there is more profit in that section. The will be plenty of money available from this agency and the Minister's problem will be who to borrow from. In four or five years' time money will become scarce for SDA loans and at that stage applicants will be forced into taking loans from the agency. This is an easy way for the Government to withdraw money from local authorities. They can always say here is plenty of money to be got from the agency but the house purchaser will pay much more than he would to the local authority. People will be advised that if they want loans in the near future they should go to the agency rather than wait for an SDA loan.
Comment on this
I am getting confused as time goes on. When the Minister moved the Bill he said:
It is envisaged that, at full operation, this new scheme will replace the local authority loan scheme.
I understand that last night he changed that and said that both schemes would work in tandem. I would agree that you cannot expect the present staff of local authorities to cope with two schemes at different interest rates. I think the philosophy behind the Bill originally was that the finance for SDA loans, which now comes directly from the Exchequer to local authorities, was to be raised instead from private financial institutions. I wonder if the Minister would have a figure for 1980 and up to now in 1981 of the amount which was provided from the Exchequer for all the local authorities for SDA loans.
The Minister should remove the two-tier situation that local authorities are now being asked to operate. At present the most popular loan is the SDA loan because one knows at the beginning what one will pay at the end. Naturally people will opt for the lower interest rate when they are told that there are two schemes in operation. Various Governments in the past have asked the building societies to devote a certain percentage of their loan finance to new houses as opposed to second-hand houses. Does the Minister intend to impose the same condition on this new agency? I think it is a very good thing from the point of view of the construction industry to devote a higher percentage of money to new houses as opposed to second-hand houses. Has the Minister any views on this?
Comment on this
The fact is that local authorities have operated two parallel schemes in the past so that in that sense this is not a new matter. As well as the SDA loans scheme they have operated the low-rise mortgage scheme which operated on considerations different from those on which the SDA loans scheme operated. Therefore, local authority officials have experience of operating two parallel schemes but we have here a different situation because the two may be tied together, one on a first mortgage and the other on a second mortgage. However, there is one aspect of the repayments proposal that causes me concern and I should like the Minister to clarify the situation.
If we take the basic principle, that is, that the scheme must be self-financing, it follows that the agency raising its funds from the life offices will be committed to pay them a certain rate of interest on an index-linked scheme. The agency, not having funds from any other source, will have to nominate their rate of interest on the moneys lent to local authorities for intending mortgagors. At least in year one that will be fixed and obviously it will have to be somewhat in excess of the rate of interest that they will have to pay to the life offices because, in addition to having to cover their charges to the life offices, they will have to bear the cost of the administration of the scheme. That is all very well but it leaves a local authority in a situation in which they are committed to paying back the agency at a certain rate of interest, index-linked. Let us put that figure at 18 per cent. When the local authority lend money to a house buyer they will have to nominate a rate of interest that will enable them to recoup from the borrowers at least sufficient to enable them to pay back the agency. Otherwise there would be a fiscal drag on the local authorities and I do not think anybody is suggesting that that should be the case.
We turn then to the proviso that the mortgagor may repay the loan during a 25-year period on the basis of 18 per cent of his gross income for the previous tax year. This imposes an artificial element into the repayments. It may well be that any person availing of that proviso will be paying back to the local authority appreciably less than the local authority are obliged to pay to the agency. There fore, there is a gap and a shortfall and I should like the Minister to tell us where and when that shortfall will be made up and by whom, always bearing in mind the key basic fact that the agency must be self-financing.
Comment on this
In answer to Deputy Leyden the Minister said, in regard to the assessment of farmers, that there is a criteria for them in respect of social welfare entitlement. That is so but the assessment is made either on the notional or on the factual situation. Which of these two means of assessment will be used in this case? Will every small farmer have to be assessed on the basis of factual income thus involving a social welfare officer visiting the farmer for the purpose of getting details of income?
My second question relates to the same matter as that raised by Deputy Taylor. I, too, would like to know who is to pay the local authority if they are at a loss as a result of an interest rate being fixed for a number of years?
Comment on this
The local authority will not be at a loss because the agency will be lending block funds to the local authorities who will collect the repayments and pass them back to the agency. It is envisaged that the agency will borrow money every year. They will not be repaying the money they borrow until the end of the term for which the money was borrowed. Therefore, they will have a very strong cash flow situation all the time and that will apply, too, to the local authorities who will be merely collecting the money and passing it back to the agency.
Regarding the question about farmers, their income would have to be assessed each year because the scheme is income-related.
Comment on this
Regardless of whether it will be a factual or a notional assessment, it should be left to the agency, in consultation with whoever was interested, to make the dicision.
Comment on this
I am surprised that such an important matter would be left to an agency over which the Minister will have no control.
Comment on this
While I agree that the matter is very important, it is much better to leave the decision to the agency who, we hope, will have on their board people who will be used to dealing with those who lend money to people in rural areas.
Comment on this
If Deputy Callanan can suggest a scheme that would be fair to every farmer it could be examined either by the agency or by the Department. So far as I know, it is not possible for a central Government authority to lay down a rule about a matter in which there are so many variables.
Comment on this
——they are bound to act accordingly. It is much better to give them the flexibility of applying different rules to different people in the various areas.
On the point raised by Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn, the figure she requested is about £101 million but included in that is a figure for home improvements. That is the only gross figure we have, but the figure for 1981 was somewhat less. Only those people earning less than £7,000 per year will have an option because those earning more than that do not qualify for an SDA loan. But they have a choice between borrowing from the agency and borrowing from a building society or an insurance company. I think that what will happen in this case is that a potential borrower will be presented with the details of both schemes and that staffs in SDA offices will become so expert in both schemes that they will be able to advise people as to which system would suit their circumstances best. There will be no question of trying to influence people one way or the other. They will look at each application individually and decide which scheme is suitable for that person. The type of person in the SDA bracket, whom the Housing Finance Agency would be suitable for would be young and in a job which may be poorly paid at present but which has good prospects.
Comment on this
What about the percentage of money to be allocated for new houses as opposed to second-hand houses?
Comment on this
We will be giving no directions at all; we will wait to see how it operates for a few years and whether there are any snags. I was inclined to agree that a greater proportion should be given to new houses but people have said that you cannot seperate one unit of the housing market from another. A person in a secondhand house can buy a new house so they are all interlinked. If there are a large number of unsold new houses on the market and the price of second-hand houses is rising because the money is available to buy them, then I, or the Minister of the day, will step in to balance the situation. The idea at present is to leave the agency as free as possible and that it should have as beneficial an effect as possible on the housing market, while, at the same time, providing a different type of funds to people, which are not now available, whereby the repayments in the initial periods compared to repayments under existing housing finances, are very much easier and the deposit very much smaller. Under the SDA scheme you would have to find a deposit of £9,000 or £10,000 because the maximum loan is fixed at £14,000 for most people. Some people can get a loan of up to £18,000 but it is £14,000 for the majority. If they get a loan from a building society, the payment in the first year of the mortgage is going to be 45 per cent or 50 per cent depending on the type of house, which is an enormous slice out of anyone's income. This is not practical for most couples in the smaller income group. People are tending to marry younger nowadays and they must get a deposit together sooner than was the case some years ago.
Under this agency, we are offering them a chance to purchase a house with a reasonably small deposit. At one stage we were thinking in terms of no deposit but I have accepted the advice given by my Department that anybody buying a house should get together a sum of money first. They will have quite small repayments in the initial years, 18 per cent of their incomes, so somebody earning £8,000 a year would be paying £1,500 a year, £30 per week, as against £80. Of course there is a price to be paid. Nobody is going to be forced to take money under these conditions, the fact that you are repaying much smaller sums of money than if you had borrowed from other agencies means that the shortfall in repayments are brought forward and added to your debt but the amount you pay each year is related to your income and not fixed as it is under building society and SDA loans.
Comment on this
No, because the couple will come to a stage where they will be paying more, the amount of capital will drop very sharply and the debt will be wiped out after 25 years. The repayments are related to your income and as your income goes up you repay more every year.
Comment on this
That depends on a person's income and on the rate of inflation.
Comment on this
(Dublin South-Central): The percentage of his wages will remain the same over the 25 years?
Comment on this
Yes, as his wages go up the repayments go up but the percentage of his income does not vary. If you do not want a big deposit or heavy repayments in the initial years then this is the scheme for you but if you feel you can afford to pay 45 per cent of your income then there are other choices available.
Comment on this
The longer the debate goes on the more complicated it gets. With regard to the farming community, there is nothing in the Bill to say that income will depend on poor law valuation. It states £9,000 or under. In the £40 to £60 valuation or over, most of the farming and business community receive an assessment from the Inspector of Taxes. A return of income has to be made at the end of March every year and this is where I see vast paper work involved with the local authority offices. The Inspector of Taxes can send out a demand for £12,000, it is up to you to take up this with your accountant and it is open then to returns and accounts. There will be controversy because there is a slowing down in income tax offices because of the embargo on staff which was placed on them by the Government. They have not sufficient personnel to deal with the returns promptly. Deputy Callanan hit the nail on the head in regard to people with under £40 valuation. How will this be done? In cases of SDA applications, an assistance officer of the health board went around to ascertain the incomes of applicants. This has been a complicated problem over the years. In this case those who are not on PAYE will present difficulties involving tremendous paperwork. I do not know if I took the Minister up properly but I think he said that those on incomes of less than £7,000 can borrow under the SDA system, but suppose such a person needs bridging of £8,000. Will he be able to go to the agency to get them to top it up?
Comment on this
I am glad to have that cleared up. There is no reference to it in the Bill. Repayments will be easy in the first few years but from then on they will get heavier. When rents of local authority houses are increased to keep pace with inflation there is a great hue and cry. The same will happen in regard to repayments of these loans. It has been said, and there is a difference of opinion about it, that total repayments on a loan of £20,000 over 25 years could amount to between £135,000 and £150,000. That is a possibility, depending on inflation. After the first few years borrowers will have growing families and they will have to provide for their education, and that will be at a time when the repayments will be heaviest.
Of course there is the position that the borrowers will have to pay for the establishment costs of this scheme, technical and legal fees. The agency funds will come from financial institutions and of course they will lend in the knowledge that they will be on a gilt-edged investment at, I understand, something like 18 per cent. Such institutions will be protected all the way and the borrowers will have to carry this. I think the Bill is shifting the emphasis of providing housing finance from the Government to the financial institutions in an indirect way and the borrowers will be paying through the nose.
I referred to the paperwork that will be necessary. At the moment there are delays of between eight weeks and three months in the processing of SDA loans. Now local authorities will be saddled with this new scheme and I suggest that the delays will be increased. I understood the Minister to say that he has had negotiations with local authority managers.
Comment on this
The Minister also said that there is enthusiasm for the scheme among the officials. I hope he is right. We have had a different story about other State organisations. I hope I am wrong on this occasion. I hope any financial arrangement that is made will work well.
As I said before, this Bill is being rushed through with little consultation. The people who will operate it have not been consulted yet. It is all right to consult with managers, but managers have to consult with the personnel in their offices. The staff may say they will operate the scheme if they get additional personnel. The Minister said there would be no embargo in regard to the agency. If I am right there will be no embargo on the personnel needed for the agency at national level, the personnel who will accompany the directors. Will the embargo on the personnel at local authority level remain? That is a valid question which needs clarification. We will have the agency personnel who will back up the chairman and the directors of the finance agency. This will involve extra administrative work for the local authority staffs. I am not suggesting that the local authorities will be looking for extra personnel immediately, but this has happened in other areas over many years even when we were in office. I do not deny that.
Under the Bill the agency will want to know what the income was in each year. After a lot of research work, paper work and correspondence, they may get the income right for the first year. What about the self-employed person? There may be a lot of correspondence to be handled and this could be cumbersome and cause delays. There may be delays and disputes over income. There could be a dispute after 5 April between the Revenue Commissioners and the accountants acting on behalf of their client who may be a farmer. It may eventually have to go to a hearing. Will the repayments be on the income for the previous year until clarification is arrived at, or will the person have to pay the difference? I hope I am making this clear.
I have no doubt that local authorities will be looking for extra personnel. Whoever is at fault, over the years there has been a big upsurge in the level of office personnel, but the figure is a diminishing one for road workers. That is open to interpretation. Perhaps the office staff had more muscle. I do not know. When I was a member of a county council the manager told us that if he had the personnel he would handle any problem we put before him. Whether we like it or not, the staffs of the local authorities will want to talk about extra personnel. The Minister for Finance placed an embargo on further appointments and therefore the local authorities cannot employ more personnel to administer this scheme. I hope they will work this scheme with the loyalty and dedication they have shown over the years.
Comment on this
Before Deputy Connolly spoke, the Minister said these new loans were optional. That is not correct. They are optional only for people earning less than £7,000.
Comment on this
They are optional for anybody over that figure as well, but that person has not got the option of the SDA loans scheme.
Comment on this
A person cannot get a loan from a building society unless he has a deposit. We are talking about loans for people who cannot afford a deposit. This is not optional for them. It is optional for people under £7,000 only. Let us be clear about this. The person in the higher income group has the option that he can get a building loan anywhere.
Comment on this
He has the basic option that he need not take a loan. If his income is under £7,000 a year, he can apply for an SDA loan, he can use this Housing Finance Agency; he may even get a building society loan or bank overdraft. If his income is over £7,000 a year, he can get a loan from this agency or get a bank, insurance company or building society loan. But the SDA option is not open to him at all.
Comment on this
That is precisely the reason this Bill is before the House, because these people needed to be catered for.
Comment on this
I should like clarification on a point raised by Deputy Mervyn Taylor and the reply the Minister gave. Do I take it now that the Minister envisages that local authorities will act only as agents? Let us say a local authority get a lump sum then all that local authority has to do is to repay the interest on the money they have borrowed Is that it?
Comment on this
The Minister gave the impression — and I wrote down his answer — that local authorities would just pass on the repayments they got from their borrowers to the agency and that, because of that, there would be no, to use Deputy Mervyn Taylor's words, fiscal bond on them. I would hope that local authorities would not be in a position of having to go on overdraft to pay this back, that they just pay back the repayments. Perhaps the Minister would clarify the position with regard to the question of choice also.
Comment on this
Might I just explain, to make it quite clear, what is involved here. The local authorities will be paid for their services. At present, as the Deputy knows, they are charged ½ per cent under the Local Loans Fund. They will now be paid by the agency for operating this scheme but the financial liabilities of the scheme will be for the agency, not for local authorities.
Comment on this
Therefore the local authorities will not have any problems as a result of this scheme?
Comment on this
All right. The Minister spoke about choice. I might suggest there is one way people could be given a real choice. Reading the Minister's remarks, seeing that the income limit will be £9,000 and that the maximum loan in the vast majority of cases will be £22,500, if the SDA income limit is raised to £7,500 and if the amount of loan to be obtained on that is raised to three times, the same maximum loan applies as in this case. In essence, even though the income limit is £9,000, it would appear to me that the maximum income a person can have to get the loan is £7,500 for a loan three times the income, £22,500. Is that correct?
Comment on this
Yes, an applicant cannot get more than 90 per cent of the grant. If they did, they would get more than £22,500.
Comment on this
That means then that the maximum income an applicant can have is £7,500. To give people a real choice local authorities should be able to say to any person comming into them: Here are your choices. You can take an SDA loan. You can take a loan under the Housing Finance Agency scheme. Or you can go to a building society. That would give people a real option. That can be done quite easily by raising the income to £7,500 and by raising the amount of the loan from twice the income, as obtains now, to three times.
Part of the thinking behind this Bill appears to be the transfer of the whole question of mortgage from the Government to this new Housing Finance Agency. In other words the Government will not be involved at all, except that the Minister for Finance guarantees the loans borrowed. I feel that is what is entailed, that at the end of the day central government will have money to spare as a result and that that money will be able to be put into local authority housing.
Again I apologise for not having been here last evening to hear the Minister's reply. Do I take it now that the Minister has changed his mind and that the SDA loans will continue for all time? The Minister's Second Reading Speech seemed to envisage the phasing out of the SDA loans at some stage.
Comment on this
I cannot say "indefinitely" but as long as I am here, yes. It is not intended to wind down the SDA loans.
Comment on this
I know the Deputy could take that interpretation out of what I said but that is not what is intended.
Comment on this
May I seek clarification on a few points? What worries me is that some items in the Bill are so dangerously vague. We all know that people who want money rarely scrutinise the small print. When one is in the position of needing a house and must get the money from some agency or other, one is so jolly glad to get it one rarely scrutinises the small print. I would be afraid that borrowers would fall into this pitfall. I so not think prospective borrowers will realise the never-ending burden they are taking on themselves because the period is not set. The period is set only in so far as there is a 25 year period mentioned, but not set.
It appears that prospective loans could continue for ever, at least that is my reading of it. For instance, if a borrower becomes ill and goes on social welfare, what rule of thumb or what income is used then? What repayment must such a person then make? Also why is the loan calculated on gross and not net income? Why does the 18 per cent rate of interest remain over the 25, 30 and 40 year period? Why does that not go down?
Comment on this
In the case of a borrower dying what income is assessed for the widow? Will the Department, the agency or anybody ensure that this person is able to meet the repayments?
Another matter is this. If people surrender their house to a local authority they can now, without any question, get up to £27,000. Heretofore they have lived in a local authority house greatly subsidised by the State. They are now handing that back and do not seem to be getting much except the £27,000. I do not think they will ever be able to see the daylight under 25 years. The Irish mentality is such that when one borrows one likes to know exactly the duration of the loan, the period involved. We are not great borrowers but we like to plan. For instance, people who buy a car like to know whether the repayments period is, say, three years or five years. With regard to the purchase of a house we like to be able to say: "I have only three years left to repay on my loan, which is reassuring as I am getting older". It appears to me that prospective borrowers will never know when their mortgage will be repaid, because all this is so dangerously vague. This is what worries me. I would hate to think of a borrower taking this on in good faith, when in need of a house, and being so glad to get the money. As a member of a local authority I would hate to think I had put a noose around their necks, for which they would never forgive me.
Comment on this
I should like to raise a point with regard to local authorities. I am glad the Minister has assured us that the SDA loans will stand as long as he remains in office. If I might cite the example of the new schemes in Cork at present with which the Minister will be familiar — I am referring to the Model Farm Road and Blackrock schemes — I must assume that if those people are to purchase their houses they will do so through the Housing Finance Agency?
Comment on this
For instance, in the case of prospective purchasers in the new schemes in Cork, if they were to prepare a scheme would they have to meet somewhat the same requirements as apply to the Housing Finance Agency scheme? Could the status quo be maintained?
Comment on this
No, this is for privately-owned houses. There is a tenant purchase scheme available for occupants of local authority houses to enable them to buy the houses in which they reside. That is a separate scheme.
Comment on this
(Limerick East): This scheme is aimed at helping people who find difficulty in saving a deposit or in getting a loan. One of the great difficulties, especially for those constructing a house, is the length of time during which they may be on bridging finance. A house costing £25,000 to build would involve an interest payment of from £4,500 to £5,000 on bridging finance. It always strikes me as peculiar that in the case of an SDA loan a person can go to a bank with a letter signed by the county manager and use this as security for bridging finance. I fail to see why the money could not be given in the first instance by the local authority. I should like to see this new agency getting away from the difficulties of bridging finance. Some local authorities will make phased payments at present but others will not. It should be written into the conditions governing loans that payments will be made at intervals during the construction of a house, thus doing away with the necessity of bridging finance. This is one of the factors inhibiting people from building their own houses.
Comment on this
This Bill is anything but vague and the Minister's speech was very explicit and wide-ranging. One area outside the scope of the Bill about which I am not clear relates to the question of grants and whether grants will be taken into consideration in relation to the amount of funds made available.
The agency should be regularly accountable to the Dáil for their activities and I would ask the Minister to make provision for regular reporting to this House, either directly or through the Joint Committee on State-Sponsored Bodies.
Problems are caused in local authority housing schemes because of unnecessary delays in structural inspections and I hope the Minister will instruct local authorities acting as agents of the agency not to allow these unnecessary delays.
Comment on this
It gives me great pleasure to congratulate Deputy Acheson on her maiden speech, a significant contribution which augurs well for the future of what I know will be a long, honourable and distinguished presence in this Chamber. It is also appropriate that as a member of a local authority she should contribute to a debate on legislation which has significant implications for local authority structures.
The last speaker said the Minister was explicit in his introductory speech. Part of that speech was as follows:
It is envisaged that, at full operation, this new scheme will replace the local authority loan scheme.
The Minister has now done a complete U-turn on that. He has told us that it could be misinterpreted to signify the demise of the SDA loan scheme, but I do not think there is room for misinterpretation. It is a specific and explicit statement that the local authority loan scheme will go. The SDA scheme is sacrosanct. It represents involvement by the State in the encouragement of house purchase and should not be interfered with. Under this scheme a house purchaser would know from the first day that he had a fixed rate of interest and that his repayments would not change during the time of the mortgage. That must be contrasted with the situation which will exist for those borrowing under this new agency where repayments will be assessed as a percentage of income.
The Minister has given an assurance that there will be no question of difficulties regarding the employment of additional staff necessary for the local authorities to operate this scheme. This is another U-turn in relation to the embargo on recruitment to local authorities but in this case I welcome it and wish it were carried through to the fire services and other sections. The Minister said that he has spoken to a number of county managers and that they have welcomed the idea. Has there been any discussion with staff representative bodies regarding the implementation of this scheme? It appears that considerable discussion would be necessary and productivity and other questions would have to be considered. If he had not said earlier that this scheme would be operating by the end of January or early February the Minister could say that this question was somewhat irrelevant. Perhaps he will tell us now whether there have been any approaches or negotiations with staff associations?
Are we to see ourselves in a similar situation to that which we have at the moment in relation to the £9.60 transfer from husband to wife, where a scheme was publicised and introduced but now, except for the small number who are applying, would be inoperable because of staff difficulties within the service? I understand that the staff associations representing the officials who will be dealing with the implementation of the £9.60 have refused to co-operate in the pending additional employment of staff and productivity questions being clarified. Will we find ourselves in a similar situation with regard to this particular scheme and the extra burden it will impose on the local authority SDA loans sections?
We are discussing this Bill in a rushed manner without having the opportunity to reflect at length on it and without providing the Minister with the opportunity to put down amendments. I would like, for the benefit of the House, to remind the Minister that in another Bill he produced, up to 3.30 and 4 o'clock on Tuesday, amendments on the Rent Restrictions Bill which was guillotined through that night at 10.30. At that stage he had the opportunity to reflect on the amendments which would be required and the amendments that would improve the Bill. The problem in relation to this Bill is that it is being guillotined through and we have no time for contemplation of amendments.
Has the Minister had the time to reflect on the staffing implication in relation to the operation of the agency? We were told by the Minister of State at the Department of the Taoiseach on Tuesday that this Bill was needed to inject extra funds into housing immediately to tackle a major social problem. There could be an even further social problem created because of a lack of co-operation by the staff of local authorities. I do not intend to be irresponsible on this. I am merely setting this down as a marker. There could be a situation where the existing loans being provided by the SDA loans staff will also be unavailable because of lack of co-operation on the basis of the additional workload being created for them by the implementation of this particular new scheme which is being put forward. We should hear something from the Minister on this. Will he give us some indication on the staffing?
Comment on this
I would like to get back to the points I made earlier and the Minister's reply when I spoke about the difficulty of working the two schemes, the SDA scheme as it is at the moment and the new scheme, by the local authorities in tandem and the problems that will be created. In my county the SDA loans scheme is virtually non-existent because single people are barred unless they can produce evidence that they are getting married. On production of that evidence the income of the spouse to be is taken into account with the result that when the two incomes are added together they are over the limit so they cannot qualify at the moment for an SDA loan.
Deputy Calleary spoke about giving a real choice to a couple who go into a local authority. One of the ways he mentioned, with which I agree, is that if you increase the income limit for the SDA loan and if you also increase the amount of the loans to make them comparable, this would get over the problem. Young people normally want to budget ahead. If they want to buy X amount of things for their house next year they have to be able to budget ahead and know how much money they can spend. Under this new scheme they cannot do that. Every time a person's income is increased the repayments are also increased so it is virtually impossible to decide this year what one can do next year. First of all, one does not know what income increase one will get and, as a result, one does not know what mortgage repayments one will be making. I understand that under the moneys available from the Housing Finance Agency single people are not barred. Is that correct?
Comment on this
That is an anomaly the Minister will have to do something about if he is going to offer a real choice to somebody who goes into a local authority. In the case of the redemption of a loan is there a penalty, as there is in the other lending agencies at the moment? It is fair to say the greatest difficulty young couples have at the moment is that in the first three or four years of any mortgage the repayments are very high and it is far more difficult to be able to make those repayments. The way to tackle that is the way it was being tackled with the mortgage subsidy which gave the relief in the very important early years of a mortgage. It is also fair to say at that particular time couples have least commitments familywise. Perhaps they have no family at all or the family are very young. It is as the family get older the expenses become greater. The educational expenses, the medical expenses and other expenses get greater. Once the repayments level off, as happens at the moment, people can cope with the increased expenses.
Under the new scheme people will not be able to do that because they cannot know this year what their repayments will be next year. If the Minister is serious about giving a fair option to people, as they go to local authorities, he will have to increase the income limit for the SDA loan and the amount of the loan that is available and he will also have to get rid of the anomaly about single people. This is virtually non-existent in my county at the moment because of the adherence to barring single people from loans.
I believe the Minister will find at the end of the day that he would have been better off if the SDA loans scheme was not tampered with and if we did not have the situation we will now have with the two things running in tandem and people being totally confused.
Comment on this
There is no dispute about what local authority officials think about the SDA loan. It served a great purpose and built many a house. What is the position today? If a person's income is in excess of £7,000 that person is denied an SDA loan. If a person earns less than £7,000 he can get £14,000. People are getting married very young nowadays. Many of them are getting married under 21 years of age. A house costs at least £22,000. What do those people do? They get £14,000 and they have £8,000 to make up. Where do they go? We have heard talk about bridging loans but even at the cost they were not available last year and people had to stop in midstream because the contractors walked out.
It appears to me that the Opposition have withdrawn their opposition to the Bill and are concentrating on the staffing and the services needed in local authorities. Not very long ago local authorities were faced with meeting repayments of reconstruction loans, group scheme loans, supplementary loans and they had to deal with the collection of domestic rates. We have now decided to abolish the agricultural rates so I cannot see any problem about local authorities being able to handle this. There has been a lot of emphasis on staffing and the trouble which might arise. Last year the offices of the Revenue Commissioners throughout the country were closed for eight months. Public representatives could not contact them. As a result the people went on strike. We had to get over that at great inconvenicence to the public.
In my opinion, this is a wonderful Bill. Mention was made of the repayment period being indefinite. The period of repayment is only indefinite where the person cannot meet his commitments because of unemployment or sickness. Over the past few years it has not been unusual to see people who borrowed under the SDA loan scheme being taken to court. That is not casting any aspersions on the managers of the county councils, but the money had to be paid and nothing could be done under these Acts. This Bill will protect the people who might run into this difficulty and for that reason I welcome it.
Comment on this
I am grateful for the last contribution because it reminded me of a point I wanted to raise. What will be the situation where young people under 21 borrow? If the husband is 21 and the wife is younger, what will happen? Will the present difficult situation be changed?
Comment on this
In my view that should be changed because in this day and age to say that somebody under 21 cannot enter into a contract is an anachronism.
Comment on this
If persons are old enough to vote and marry they should be allowed to enter into a contract. Here we are not talking about a contract which is binding all their lives; it is only binding for the period until they reach 21 years.
I did not realise Deputy Acheson was making her maiden speech. I join with Deputy Burke in congratulating and welcoming her to this House. She was right when she said people who borrow money do not look at the small print because they are so anxious to get into their houses. The only cure for that situation is when the supply of houses exceeds demand. When there is competition for houses among prospective customers the result is that house prices increase. Young people, because they are in too much of a hurry or are badly advised, do not always fully appreciate what they are getting into. This is an area we must all keep an eye on and try to correct by having so many houses that the customer has a choice.
When somebody goes to a local authority to borrow money to buy a house I hope the officer dealing with him will tell him the best type of loan for his situation and will not try to shove him into one or other category. He should present fairly to the applicant the benefits and drawbacks of both schemes and then the applicant can made his choice.
Deputy Acheson asked what would happen if somebody died. This situation arises all the time, no matter what method of financing is involved. Usually most responsible people take out a mortgage protection policy. Of course, there are some cases where such a policy is not taken out and a person may be killed in a car accident. In that case the widow would be better off if she had an SDA loan or a building society loan while a person who gets sick would be better off under this scheme. If a person is sick and has an SDA or building society loan his weekly repayments remain the same, but if he has an agency loan his repayments will drop to 18 per cent of his new income. There is a measure of protection there but it is the type of protection nobody would want to use because it would mean the breadwinner was sick or unemployed.
Deputy Noonan asked about stage payments. They can and will be arranged because this will help applicants avoid bridging finance. Deputies asked if they would have an opportunity of discussing the operation of this agency later. The annual reports of the agency will have to be laid before the House and then a Deputy may ask for a debate on the agency. Under section 6 if I give a direction to the agency as to how they should operate, I must lay that before both Houses. On that occasion, either House can have discussion on the operation of the agency.
Deputy Mitchell raised the point about the average price of new houses and asked about the combination of payments under this agency. The average price of new houses bought under the SDA loans scheme in the September quarter was £24,760. Under the agency's scheme a borrower earning £7,500 per annum could buy a house costing £25,750, get the £1,000 grant, pay a deposit of £2,250 and borrow £22,500. Under the SDA loan scheme he would have to pay between £9,000 and £10,000 deposit and under this scheme he would pay £2,250 deposit.
Deputy Burke raised the question of the manning of the agency. This is something which the city and county managers will decide. I will be surprised if it is not part of the discussions that will take place between the officials of my Department and the County Managers' Association when they meet in January. A whole range of questions will be asked and many assurances sought. It is a normal thing for this to happen and it occurs frequently between the various Departments and the agencies they control. In my case it is the local authorities. I am sure that something will be worked out.
I hope Deputy Geoghegan-Quinn is satisfied with the answer I gave about new and second-hand houses. The same Deputy asked if there is a penalty for a person who redeems a loan. There will not be but they will be liable to repay the balance of the capital and the accumulated interest. There will be a shortfall in their repayments in the early years and that shortfall will be carried forward and added to their debt which will have to be cleared but there will be no other penalty.
Comment on this
No. They do not pay in the beginning. The perfect way to buy a house where there will be no penalty is only available to the rich because they can pay cash. The cheapest way to buy a house is to pay cash. The rest of us must pay a penalty when buying a house either through a mortgage interest rate or a local authority interest rate. In this case purchasers are relieved of the burden of a heavy deposit, and of having to meet heavy repayments in the early years. The penalty for that is that the money that is owed is carried forward and becomes part of the amount of money that is owed to the agency. Therefore, if one wants to redeem the loan one must clear off that debt. It depends on the stage in the term of the loan that one clears off the debt.
Comment on this
What about the point about the increase in the income limit for the SDA loans and the increase in the amount of loan?
Comment on this
The increase in the income limit and in the level of the SDA loan is being constantly looked at in another context. It has nothing to do with the agency but I will look at it.
Comment on this
Some local authorities have difficulty operating the existing SDA loan scheme at present because of the ban on single people. In order to give couples and single people a real choice in regard to the loans will the Minister consider getting rid of the ban on single people who seek SDA loans?
Comment on this
A couple have no problem because they are entitled to an SDA loan but single people have a problem.
Comment on this
They are not entitled to a loan if their income limit is above the limit under the SDA loan scheme.
Comment on this
In the last two or three months I issued a circular to the effect that if officials thought that the job of a spouse was a permanent one they should take her income into account but if they thought she would be resigning after a few years of marriage they could ignore it.
Comment on this
That is the biggest bone of contention in local authorities. A young couple intending to get married must continue to work for a set number of years after they get married in order to be able to meet the repayments. It is very vague to say that officials can define the difference between permanent employment and a job that a wife will only hold for a number of years. It is unfair to ask local authority officials to decide that. Who will make the decision as to whether the employment is permanent or not?
Comment on this
It is reasonably obvious in most cases. Of course, there is a grey area here but most local authorities will know that some girls will work until the family arrives and in that case I do not consider it permanent employment.
Comment on this
As I explained earlier, if we had unlimited money we would not have to put restrictions on the type of people who get loans or grants but because the money is limited we must see to it that those who most deserve it get it. That is the thinking behind this.
Comment on this
The Minister should have a serious look at the way the SDA loan scheme is operating at present because in my view it operates against single people.
Comment on this
The Minister should also qualify what is meant by permanent and temporary employment. That would be of tremendous benefit.
Comment on this
It calls for personal interpretation on behalf of a manager. A manager must make an interpretation in each case.
Comment on this
He should not have to; it should be laid down by the Minister. A manager should not be put into the position of having to make his own personal interpretation. The Minister has highlighted one of the most damning areas in regard to the type of loans to be provided by the agency. I am referring to the whole area of redemption. According to Mr. Rapple in the article I referred to in the Sunday Independent of September 27 a man who gets a loan of £20,000 today to buy a house valued at £25,000 and decides to sell ten years later to move up the market or out of the area because of his job, using the system to be operated by the agency, he will owe on that £20,000 mortgage a total of £46,982. He could not afford to sell because he will not be able to redeem the loan. The Minister may assume that there will be an increase in the value of the property in the ten years because of inflation and other reasons but the calculation I referred to was made on the basis of inflation at 10 per cent. Under the SDA loan scheme there is a reduction annually in the amount still outstanding on the loan but how can the Minister justify the situation I have just outlined? The Minister has told us that the new scheme will be the same as the SDA loan scheme and those operated by building societies, in that there will be no penalty but surely the fact that a borrower will have to pay back that type of sum is a major penalty. It will make it almost impossible for people to sell the property they have with this type of loan.
Comment on this
This scheme will not be the same as the SDA loan scheme. It is a different scheme and there is a different way of funding it. The way of repaying the loans is different and there are different penalties attached to it. When I bought my first house over 20 years ago it cost £1,900. I had an SDA loan from Cork County Council and I was repaying £56 twice a year. Precisely the same house in the same park sold within the last three months for £47,000. The repayments now on a similar house in a similar park would be in the region of £60 a week. Those figures would have been incomprehensible to me 20 years ago. The repayments will remain at 18 per cent of the man's income. If his income goes up, his repayments will go up. If his income goes up in the same ratio as my income, my standard of living and the value of my house went up over the past 23 years, then the sums will be precisely the same in 25 years time in relation to his income then as 18 per cent is to his present income.
Comment on this
I accept that his repayments will go up according as his income goes up, which is one of the major defects in the whole scheme. I accept that the value of property increases. But if a man takes a loan of £20,000 today and wants to sell his property in ten years time — Mr. Rapple's figures may be a little high or a little low but let us just use them for example purposes — he ends up in ten years' time owing £46,982. Let us take the case of a man who has to move from Dublin to Cork — a mind-boggling thought.
Comment on this
I am citing the case of a man having to move from one part of the country to the other because of his job. How can he sell his property? There is a major penalty imposed on him for having to sell before the expiration of the loan.
Comment on this
I must be very bad at explaining things. I thought that point had been covered umpteen times. Nobody has to purchase a house this way unless he chooses to do so. The benefit of choosing this system is that the deposit is relatively low, very low in comparison with an SDA loan. In addition, the repayments in the first years are extremely low in comparison with repayments on a building society loan. One is not getting these things for nothing. If one does not pay now the debt is picked up and put forward on to the amount one owes in the future. If one does not sell the house that shortfall, because the amount one is paying each year will increase as one's income increases, will be gradually wiped out and one will come back to a very much lower percentage of one's income later on in the time. If one wants to sell the house in ten years' time, then one owes the amount of money on the books of the local authority or the agency as being the amount due for the house. If one buys a house now at £25,000 and in ten years' time it does not make £46,982 then, yes, one has to make up the difference because that is the debt one owes. You cannot expect somebody to run a line through your debt and say: "That is all right, Mr. Burke. You are a nice man. I will not take it from you at all." One goes into this with one's eyes open.
There are penalties attached to using this system but there are also advantages and it is up to an individual to weigh one against the other and see what suits him. If one goes back ten years and looks at a house that was then worth £25,000, it would now fetch more than £46,000. Of course under this system one would not be getting the same "profit" in inflation terms as the person who used the SDA or building society loans. The applicant makes his choice. We are presenting him with a fourth, fifth or sixth option; but for the vast majority of people it is the SDA loan, the building societies and now this additional method of financing.
Comment on this
What we have heard from the Minister is an admission of major defects in this scheme. We were told that the reason for the guillotine motion was that this was to meet a major social need. We are having a good debate and so far we have elicited a lot of information. However, this legislation needs time to be considered and we should have had an opportunity to consider it over Christmas. The Minister is now admitting major defects in the regulations to be set down.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I did not admit major defects in the operation of this. I pointed out that anybody who wants to buy his house under this scheme will have certain penalties that are different from the penalties one has under the Local Loans Fund scheme.
Comment on this
What we have here is not the Santa Claus we were told about on Second Stage. What we are getting now are the warts in the scheme or, to put it another way, we are at the Saint Stephen's Day rather than the Christmas Day stage. There is a major responsibility on the Government to explain to potential house purchasers exactly what the implications are of choosing the type of loan that will be available under this scheme.
The Minister spoke earlier about inflation and about increases in house prices and he implied that in the event of a sale, inflation would probably pick up the difference between the loan now and what it would be later. Based on the calculations I have been using, the position will be that if a person gets a loan under the system envisaged of, say, 20 years but if after ten years he wishes to sell he will find that instead of having to pay back £20,000 the amount due will be £46,982. This would be the position although a person had been paying on his house loan for ten years. People often find it necessary to sell one house and buy another because of being transferred to another area or for some other reason. The position I have quoted is the same up to the seventeenth year by which time instead of owing £20,000 a person would owe £58,013.
The legislation purports to be the salvation of the construction industry as well as of young people wishing to buy houses. I suggest that instead of talking about a weekly payment of £9.60 or of a 25 per cent tax rate, the Government might engage themselves in advertising this scheme and highlighting not only the position regarding the early years of the mortgage but the penalties that will apply to anyone wishing to sell his house in the first 17 years.
Comment on this
This section has wide implications. One can imagine the shock to a person on finding after ten years that he owes the sort of money Deputy Burke has been talking of. In my constituency I could visualise such a person presenting himself at Portlaoise hospital for psychiatric treatment. There is no point in anyone talking about what the value of a house would be after such a period. The position is that the buyer decides the market value. Let us assume that at the time of going on the market the amount due on a house is £80,000 but that it fetches only £60,000. There is a very serious problem in this regard. I do not know whether it would be open to the seller in such circumstances to declare himself bankrupt but he would be in a serious dilemma. While I was in the Department I explored the possibility of other means of helping to finance housing. I consulted with my colleagues, including the Minister, on the matter. A draft was prepared but I discovered that in what I was proposing I would be taking funds away from other areas in which they were very necessary.
This new financial arrangement may cause a big upheaval in the whole area of finance. However, the big problem I see is in regard to somebody who during the period of the loan may, for whatever reason, wish to sell but cannot get for his house a price sufficient to cover the amount that would have to be paid back to the agency. I shall be expecting either the Minister or the local authorities to explain to the people what are the issues involved in taking out this loan and the effect it will have on them?
Progress report; Committee to sit again.