We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1982: Second Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–118 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1982
Enacted

No. 10 of 1982 ›

I will summarise the points I made before Question Time. I adverted to the possibility of another general election and pointed out that the situation would be that we would be without a Finance Bill in that event for a considerable period. I suggested that might cost the country in the region of £250 million. I concluded my point by pointing to the responsibility of the House to provide the country with a Finance Bill irrespective of whether Members are totally happy with various sections of it. That is a great responsibility on Members.

I went on from there to point to a few headlines in the financial situation. One is that the servicing of the public debt is now eating up virtually 90 per cent of the total take from the PAYE sector which demonstrates that that is a road that we cannot go down for any period of time. I pointed out that over the years we got ourselves into a situation where virtually 50 per cent of total current expenditure by the State was spent in three Departments, Social Welfare, Education and Health. I seriously question whether we are receiving value for money in those areas. I also pointed out the very narrow tax base which applies to this country. I quoted a figure of 700,000 to 800,000 people who could be regarded as the real tax base because the gap between them and the population of 3.3 million is taken up with dependants and those employed in the public service. That is a statistic which is getting worse and one which I pointed out as a headline for the nation which we ignore at our peril. In the past six years the public service grew by 37,000 people while manufacturing grew by 7,500 people. If the public service is to achieve anything close to 20 per cent this year, the cumulative increase in public service pay between 1981 and 1983 will come to 75 per cent. That is at a time when incomes in industry, industrial services and agriculture will probably fall. I pointed to the tension in society and said the greatest tension seems to be between the public sector and the non-public sector. The figure of 75 per cent illustrates the point I am making. The consequent imbalances in income awards, job opportunity and security in different sectors of the economy are factors which make this country harder and harder to govern.

I went on to talk about the situation in Austria. I pointed to the openness of that economy and how they got their inflation rate down to 7 per cent. Unemployment is down to 3 per cent. They did this by putting aside ideological differences which existed in their parliament and among their people. They embarked on a course of putting the economic difficulties before any other consideration. It seems to be meeting with some success.

Those are the points I made before Question Time and I should like to continue by pointing to the situation in Austria where they have appointed a joint commission for prices and wages which consists of 20 people. Labour has abstained from using its full bargaining power in return for a direct influence on price formation and on economic policy generally. Some prices, notably foodstuffs and energy, are controlled by the Government. The others are subject to voluntary control. The joint committee have taken a grip on the economy in that way. Free wage-bargaining is allowed. They do not interfere except to postpone negotiations from time to time. Success on the prices front has moderated wage claims to competitive levels. Bargains have been made with unions which are linked to tax cuts. They have successfully managed a hard currency policy which is difficult to implement. The unions have accepted the need for international competitiveness to be maintained. This has improved the Austrian economy and there is no reason why it could not be done. It has produced a remarkable degree of self-discipline among workers and wages have tended to move with those in the highly-competitive German economy.

The main reason for consensus on income determination has been that all sides, business, Government and unions, are committed to maintaining employment at a high level. They managed to keep inflation under control and because of this have been able to introduce more expansionary policies. There are many similarities between the Austrian economy and ours. Between us all we seem to have failed dismally for many decades to lessen, let alone eliminate, our problems. Perhaps the Austrian experience is one we should look at.

We have had social partnerships, national wage agreements and various gatherings of the brains of the nation to sort out our problems but in the end we seem to retreat into our sectional groups when the chips are down. The interests of the nation seem to come out last. If we are to have a new social partnership now is the time for it. It must be genuine and unselfish. It is obvious to anyone who looks at our situation that our options are limited. Basically in terms of day-to-day finance we have three options. We can put more tax on the people. We can broaden the tax base and pile on taxation. Quite frankly, that is not an option and there is no point in anyone thinking that that is the answer to all our problems or that we can continue to pay for services.

As I said earlier, the level of services is not maintainable. Not only is it not maintainable but, as the years roll on, it will be even more impossible to maintain the present level of services. Seeking to raise extra taxation is therefore not an option. I agree with those who say taxation has reached saturation point. I was speaking to a constituent the other day and I was told the joint income of himself and his wife is of the order of £16,000. With PAYE, car tax, value-added tax and the various direct and indirect taxes, he calculated that he was returning to the State out of that £16,000 something of the order of £13,000. Admittedly some of the taxation involved would be voluntary indirect taxation but, even so, there are not many options these days in personal expenditure.

Taxation in not the answer. Some effort must be made to introduce a broader spread. The tax basis is something of the order of 24 per cent on the entire working population. That is the fresh money coming in. What we must do is spread that, broaden it out and introduce greater equity. I trust the commission will take a major step in that direction because taxation reaches a stage at which incentive dies. It stifles initiative. What then is the other option? I have already pointed out that virtually all the return from PAYE goes in servicing the national debt. It would be quite unsustainable to increase borrowing, thereby adding to the national debt. One need not dwell on that. It is quite obvious. It is now accepted there is no real option in that regard and we can no longer look to it.

That brings us then to the only remaining sensible option. Whether the ideology is left or right, or whether one wants to deal practically with the matter, one thing is quite clear, namely, that the level of public expenditure has reached an all-time high. Someone will have to shout "Stop". I have dismissed the other two options and I know the public at large have also dismissed them. The difficulty in curtailing public expenditure is that somebody who wants to be clever will immediately start arguing about a reduction in gardaí, a reduction in the schools, a reduction in the number of teachers and so on. Over the years we have tried to achieve a successful embargo on employment in the public service. I quoted the figure of 37,000 new people in the public service in seven years and 7,000 in manufacturing industry. This shows that, however much we may try to control public expenditure in the public service, we have not been successful, mainly because of the enormous increasing demands under the headings of social welfare, health and education and more and more State services generally. We may indeed have reached the point at which the effort must be to ensure that the level of expenditure will not continue to rise. Health expenditure in just one decade has doubled proportionately. I emphasise proportionately. We are spending twice as much proportionately on health as we did ten years ago despite the fact that we have not earned the extra money to pay for the service in that period.

We are now spending 8 per cent of GNP on health. That caters for some 45 per cent of our people. Britain spends 7 or 8 per cent of GNP in catering for 90 per cent of the population. That comparison must lead to very close questioning of the cost-benefit of every £ we spend on these services. Public expenditure is growing at an alarming rate.

To digress for the moment, I had a lady to see me the other day. She lives in a corporation house. She waited an hour to tell me that the taps in her bathroom were dripping and she wanted to know if I could get the corporation to fix them. She was living on a corporation estate and she said the repair was not her responsibility. I had a gentleman from a corporation estate who told me his front window had been broken and he wanted me to get the corporation to fix the window. I told both that the State is not there to act as a continual subsidy machine. It is there to protect the vulnerable and encourage people but certainly not there at one's right hand every time something minor goes wrong.

That mentality seems to be growing. It is increasing the cost of the public service and thereby increasing taxation out of all proportion. I say that quite bluntly. Equally bluntly I say that the only real financial option in the foreseeable future is the control of public expenditure. Much as we may hate to do that, much as we may hate to say to schools, or hospitals and so on that they will have to do with less, nevertheless that is now the only approach. But we must not do that on its own because on its own it would depress the economy. Parallel with that we must try to increase that figure of 24 per cent mainly in the private sector so that a surplus can be produced to enable us to pay for increasing services in other areas.

The country needs a double injection. It needs control of public expenditure and at the same time encouragement to the private sector to improve competitiveness. There must be no disincentives to those who wish to create employment. Most of our employers are very small, five, six or ten man operations. They must be protected. I am supported in this by no less a body than the Central Bank in its report, which says:

The primary and immediate objectives of economic policy at present, therefore, should be to

(i) correct the imbalance in the public sector finances — particularly through introducing policies that will lead to the elimination,......of the current budget deficit......

(ii) improve the competitiveness of Irish industry and services.

Therefore, the Central Bank also have diagnosed the remedy we must adopt. To be fair to it I think this Finance Bill has taken a step in that direction. It has tackled the question of the deficit and has budgeted to reduce it in the 12 months to end-December 1982. I look forward to some results in that regard. The Central Bank have advocated that course of action as being the only one now available to us.

I pointed out earlier tensions between the public and private sectors. I want to suggest a road we might take in that respect. For example, in New Zealand the system of awarding wage rounds is as follows. The private sector enter into negotiations in the first place based on what the economy has actually achieved. When the private sector have finished their rounds of negotiations a norm is taken which is automatically and statutorily applied to the public service. The private industrial sector, therefore, set the norm for increases in the public service and the public service have no option but to follow that norm on the instructions of the national parliament. What happens here? We do it the other way round. First of all we sit down — and have done for many years — with the public service and tend to say, "what is the rate of inflation? What do you need? What can we get away with?"Then we set that figure. Then we tend to throw the private sector off the deep end and say, "Well, you can always plead inability to pay". That is putting the cart before the horse. The New Zealand system at least carries the benefit of pinning wage increases to something tangible which is the performance of the economy.

As I pointed out earlier, and must do so again, between the years 1981 and 1982 the cumulative increase in public service pay came to about 75 per cent while the corresponding figures for industry fell. It is quite clear that that road cannot be taken. Without making it a contentious political issue — there are too many of them, they are too divisive and rend the country assunder — we might examine the possibility of getting our order of priorities correct. We might measure the performance of the economy by initiating our negotiations in the private sector, coming up with some figures based on the performance of the economy — that is what the traffic will bear and the country can afford — because the private sector is well able to decide what the country can afford, the unions on the one side and management on the other. Having done that we might then take a similar figure, or some formula based on that figure, to the public service. If we do not do it in this way we shall be off on the old spiral of the public service using its muscle, getting its increase, leaving it to ordinary firms to plead inability to pay, or go out of business thus increasing the employment queues.

I want to come now to the main point I wanted to make in this debate, which is that I look forward eagerly and with some excitement to the production of a national economic plan. I know the Government have committed themselves to this, as indeed had the previous Government. That plan must be the saviour of our economy because if it is not and if it does not come up with solutions to the difficulties at present confronting the country, then we shall have missed a tremendous opportunity to tackle our problems. That economic plan must, first of all, deal with the financial situation about which I spoke. It must take account of the fact that we are using all of our PAYE revenue to pay the national debt, that £2 out of £3 in this country is spent by the State at present. It must take account of the growth in the public service. It must take account also of the fact that we are spending nearly half our current expenditure on three Government Departments, Social Welfare, Health and Education. It must take account of the fact that the options of borrowing and of increased taxation are not real options. Therefore, it must face squarely and honestly the only remaining option as a means of curtaining the growth of public expenditure and must do so honestly and openly. I am confident it will and I urge the Government to tackle it in that way.

Having done that, this economic plan must also undertake something much more fundamental. It must adopt an economic philosophy which defines the economic direction of the nation in the few years ahead. It must define the role of the State. Are we to continue to have the State act as the main generator of employment, to have the State act as the party that picks up all the tabs, to have it act as the great big brother who breathes down the necks of everybody? Or are we to adopt the philosophy which merely says: "Come here a second, the role of the State in this country is to be this — it should guide the people of enterprise who want to provide employment; it should prevent the worst excesses of the private sector; should there be excesses its role should be to prevent abuses of the private sector, to act as a referee, a hand-holder and a general climate setter of the economy." I fear we cannot have it both ways. I fear we cannot produce an economic plan which says on the one hand that we shall have some involvement by the State whenever it suits us and, on the other, some involvement by the private sector whenever it suits us. This country is too small to have opposing ideological approaches to our economic difficulties of the day. I trust and I am confident that this economic plan will seek to address those issues and come up with solutions to them. I am not privy to the information as to when that plan will be produced but I see from parliamentary questions that it will come up in the near future.

I should say also that in writing that plan I trust and hope the Government of the day will take into account not just their own views but those of every Member of this House, of pressure groups and the public at large. If it does not seek to pull together the various philosophies, the various pressures and realities facing the country, if it does not pull together those strands and define a course of action over the next five years — based on the kind of philosophy about which I have been speaking — I personally fear that the country will sink into an even deeper decline. I trust that is something none of us wants to see.

Having dealt with the economic plan at least to that extent I want to move on but, before doing so, I should like to quote an attitude of mind with which I find it difficult to disagree. Here I am quoting the head of the IDA, Mr. Padraig White, as reported in a recent newspaper article:

What was needed was a fundamental change in attitude, and the attitude to hard work, he said. "The basic problem with Ireland is that the public sector attitude and mentality dominates thinking within the country: that attitude is that you rely on the State, you get a job with the State which doesn't involve you in great risk."

Quite bluntly he said:

"That's going to change over the 1980s. It might be turbulent, but it's going to change because the public sector is not going to be able to employ the people."

I think I have demonstrated here today from my earlier comments on the budgetary figures that the public service indeed are not going to be able to take up that slack. There are some 100,000 youngsters at present coming through the educational system at intermediate and leaving certificate levels and there is no way at all, looking at those figures, that the public service can make any real impact on taking up the employment slack there. Certainly I agree with Mr. White when he says that it will be turbulent. Indeed "turbulent" probably is too mild a word to describe it.

Therefore, the only solution is to address the problems honestly and openly in the manner I have advocated within an economic plan. The end of this century is the year 2000 A. D. That probably seems to be a long time away but in fact it is only 18 years. Children born today will be 18 years of age at the turn of the century. We shall see many changes in those years and we shall face many stresses. But from the point of view of the country's infrastructure, for example, we shall need another city virtually the size of Dublin because the average growth of 1 per cent per annum will result in a population in excess of perhaps 4,000,000 people by the turn of the century and a substantial shift in age structure, with the young, the 15 to 29 age group, greatly exceeding the maturer age group, the 30 to 49 or so, group. We will see a very rapid shift towards urbanisation. Half of the population by the turn of the century will be living within a 50-mile radius of Dublin city. By the end of the century also we will have perhaps three-quarters or 80 per cent of the people living in cities and towns if present trends continue.

Our population growth is now among the highest in the EEC and will exceed a figure of four million by the turn of the century. We have not been able to keep pace with the growth in population and we have not been able to keep pace with these developments. It was estimated recently by An Foras Forbartha that between now and the turn of the century we need to spend £30 billion on putting in the kind of environmental infrastructure, roads, schools, telephones and all the various infrastructures we need in the next 18 years. Where in ainm Dé will we get £30 billion between now and the end of the century?

We certainly cannot do that if we continue to milk the system dry to the extent we have been doing for a long time. The State will not be able to meet that bill. We may need more imaginative forms of raising finance, we may need to talk to the private sector more honestly and openly and we may need to involve the public in helping to fund various projects. I have not got all the answers. I am sure the economic plan will include some imaginative answers to the kind of problem. If we have not found the answers by the end of the century we will be faced with traffic jams which will make the traffic jams in Dublin city at the moment look like a freeway, which will make the pollution and all the various environmental difficulties look like kids stuff.

I do not know where the money will come from. On the figures of the economy for the past decade, that kind of money is not here. I am trying to inject the realism which simply says that we need to invest in our infrastructure, that we need to spent that £30 billion which we have not got, so we must give some imaginative thought to the question of where we will get it. Earlier today at Question Time the Minister of State said time and time again that he would love to do this, that and the other scheme if he had the money. Quite clearly he has not got it and no other Minister ever had it. With an expenditure of up to 50 per cent on only three Departments and the figure growing all the time, there is no way the Minister will ever get that money, because that figure will continue to increase as the years go on.

I want to see imaginative answers in the economic plan to the problems of the day. I do not believe the recession has bottomed out. That is disappointing, considering we have a lot of advantages. We have a sterling advantage, we have an oil advantage because oil prices have come down and we now have a dollar advantage. Despite those advantages we do not seem to be able to get ourselves up on our feet. I look to the economic plan to chart the course for Irish business, public institutions and the semi-State companies, to tell them what is on for the next five years and what is not on and to pinpoint the type of objectives and targets they will have to meet in that time. One would not dream of running a business today without a three-or four-year plan for how one would do it. Neither can one attempt to run a state as complex as ours without a similar type of plan. Under such a scheme Irish business will, hopefully, be able to plan its own development and employment needs, what areas it can get into and the areas it can make money on to provide the taxation which the country needs.

The Government are collecting 3 per cent of the total revenue of the State in corporation tax. My friends in the Workers' Party will probably say that that is because they are all dodging tax. I have another view of it. I believe that the vast majority of Irish companies — I will put the figure at 60 per cent — are losing money and are not paying corporation tax because of that. On the national balance sheet, if we continue to allow expenditure to go up and revenue to drop, as has been happening by firms getting into trouble, we will obviously face national bankruptcy and we will not be able to avoid the kind of measures needed to develop the economy in the years ahead. The young people of today expect us to develop the economy.

I do not believe the old simple answer thrown out from time to time — devaluation — is the solution. It gives an artificial boost in the short term. There is a feeling in the country that all of a sudden everything is a bit lighter and easier. But, unless it is accompanied by very stringent financial economic measures it is worse than useless because it gives a short-term reprieve before we go into the same type of cycle again. I am not happy with devaluation because I believe the public would see it as a solution to the problems and not what in fact it is, the start to a series of very difficult measures.

I want to reiterate what I said earlier, that we have become a subsidy-saturated society. There is nothing we wish to do now for which we cannot look for a subsidy. Much as it pains me to disagree with Members of the Opposition, I must recall something said by Richie Ryan on radio one day during the time of the great snow, which everybody remembers. He said: "Go out and clean the snow from your own front garden". That is the type of philosophy I would like to see incorporated in a new national economic plan. I mentioned earlier the people who came to see me in my clinic and who asked me to get their windows fixed and to get other things done for them.

Comment on this

The Deputy said it pained him to disagree with members of the Opposition. The Deputy has actually agreed with the Opposition. That is what is paining him and that does him credit.

Comment on this

The amount of pain the Opposition give me is not measurable. We have all paid lip service to reform of parliamentary procedure. I am only 12 months in the Dáil and this is probably the sixth or seventh time I have mentioned this. We all seem to run away from it when the chips are down. We must do something about the reform of the House and about getting the financial procedures and the debating procedures right. I saw in the Fine Gael manifesto before the 1981 General Election a commitment to tackle that, but after seven months in office it was not tackled. We, on our part, mentioned it from time to time but never actually got around to it. It is something which we must honestly face. I am not convinced that we are dealing efficiently with financial legislation and legislation in general. The Chair may feel that this does not come under the Finance Bill but I raise it in the specific context of the manner in which we analyse financial expenditure.

There is a need for some financial committee of this House to go through the various figures in the public glare, comment on them and bring them to the attention of the public. I would like to see some improvement in that regard in the years ahead, but hopefully in the months ahead.

Another item to be mentioned is our balance of payments. That is a nice, economic cliché for most of us but the harsh reality is otherwise. The balance of payments deficit has reached an unprecedented level of £1,300 million, which is now equivalent to 13 per cent of the national output. We simply must get our exports up and our imports down. Various reports from professional accountancy bodies time and time again have stated that Irish industry is working at something like 50 or 60 per cent of its output. It could take another 40 or 50 per cent, if it could sell it. It could sell it if we could get our marketing and exporting philosophy organised. Córas Tráchtála do a fair job, considering their resources. We reach a very tiny proportion of all the markets of the world. As a trading nation, if we do not export we do not survive. I have said to a number of young people recently "Look at the world markets and see what you can sell to them. Do not fall back on the State. By selling to the world at large, you are seeking to take up the slack in Irish industry". Irish industry, believe me, is now gasping and is slack, indeed.

I said earlier that I regarded the Finance Bill, in its attempt to close the budgetary deficit, as being an honest first step. In that regard, I support the Finance Bill. I summarise by saying — and we must make no mistake about it — that a country will not remain unchanged if tens of thousands of young unemployed march every year on our streets. It will not remain unchanged when we must find this extra £30 billion for infrastructure. It will not remain unchanged if we find that all our PAYE money is going on borrowing and that our public services are costing increasingly more money. It is the duty and role of political parties and Governments to seek to make the changes which will live up to the responsibility placed on their shoulders in the years ahead.

I have put forward what I believe to be the solution, which is twofold. It is to contain public expenditure, to encourage the private sector by a series of initiatives, by seeking more concensus in our economic policies, more agreement. Let us have the battle on the streets, but, having had it, let us get down to running our economy and finding a consensus as to how we are to do that. We should package all this into a national economic plan, which above all has as its core and central root a national economic philosophy which charts the course of the country for the years ahead and which says "The State has a central guiding role. It can do so much, but to look to it to do all that has been asked of it is just not on". We politicians must continue to spell out that message in the years ahead.

In supporting the Finance Bill, I look forward to that economic plan and trust that it will incorporate these issues, get some consensus as to the solutions and chart our way forward, so that we can have a document we can all support whether on the Government, Opposition or minority side or as members of the public generally. We want an economic philosophy in a document which we can support. The public are willing to support such a document. I know that the Government will produce that document.

Comment on this

No document presented to this House is of as much interest and importance to the community as a whole as the Finance Bill and its budgetary policy. Each year, this legislation is looked forward to with interest and, by some, with apprehension. No segment of our people view the annual budgetary policy with the same interest as do that sector confined within the PAYE system. Over a number of years they have experienced, which is generally admitted, that their contribution to the Exchequer has been far in excess of what is justifiable.

It would take much longer than the time available this afternoon to go into the merits and justifications of their protests, marches, frustrations and discontentment. The frustration and discontentment have reached such proportions as at last to bring a realisation to the Government and all other sectors of our community that the necessary adjustment in that taxation system, to bring about a degree of equality, cannot be much further delayed.

As Deputy Brennan has already said, we all hope that the Commission on Taxation will be both courageous and just in its interpretation of what the total taxation system should be and that, at long last, the PAYE sector will receive justice, so that that element of discontent, so high among that very important sector of our community, is finally removed.

I will deal now with a number of problems regarding the economy. I start with the tourist industry which is of vital importance to the economy and which is in a state of absolute disarray at the moment. Because of its importance, it merits immediate consideration from the Government, Bord Fáilte and all tourism interests. Let me say at the outset that the principal factors in the decline of this most important industry are inflation and taxation. Our current inflation has raised our prices to such an extent that they are now completely out of line with some of our competitors in the tourist industry. Taxation on petrol, drink and VAT on restaurant and hotel meals has been the last straw which has about broken the camel's back.

Last year, the tourist injection into our economy was £650 million. To date there has been a substantial drop. This decline is caused by our inflation rate, our policy of taxation and, to some extent, the political climate. As we all know, since 1969 the northern troubles have had an effect on tourism. Current British events have also created an unfavourable situation. We have a long-standing relationship with the ordinary British citizen and our brothers in Northern Ireland. At this point of crisis in the industry Bord Fáilte and the Government should intensify their efforts to win back that element of the British and Northern Ireland tourist market that was so welcome here and made such a major contribution to the economy. It is important that immediate steps be taken because there is absolute depression among the major elements of this industry at the moment. Hotels, guesthouses, bars, cafes and so on in tourist areas are suffering a drastic drop in their earnings. Unless the situation improves this will have serious repercussions for the rating authorities because those are among the most highly valued premises and make a very large contribution to the finances of the local authorities. The serious decline in incomes will have a serious effect on their ability to pay the rates which will affect local authority finances by the end of the year.

There are a number of Government Departments involved to some extent in tourism, including the Department of Industry, Commerce and Tourism, who have direct responsibility. The Department of Transport have among their vital concerns air, sea and rail travel and these are concerned with the development and growth of tourism. The Department of Education is involved in training hotel management staffs and all grades of hotel staffs. The Department of the Environment are involved with roads, car parks, monuments and so on. The tourist industry is such that it should have a specific ministry and that ministry should cross into some of the areas in the Departments that I mentioned with a view to getting a completely consolidated structure that would take into account all the aspects that are so important in this vital industry. We are now approaching the peak of the tourist season and because of the prevailing depression positive steps should immediately be taken to initiate a very intensive sales programme in Britain and Northern Ireland as the best basis for a hope of resumption of the normal tourism programme for the remainder of the year. Also the programme for the development of home holidays should be intensified with a view to retaining as much holiday money as possible within the country.

I will now deal briefly with agriculture. This industry has been in deep recession since 1978. There has been a very substantial fall in incomes and milk production. In my own area milk production has dropped very substantially. This year there is some indication of a slight increase. But the drop in milk production for that area represented a loss of about £15 million to members of the co-operative. That is bad. But any drop in milk production and processing means very substantial job losses. Our co-operatives have been operating rationalisation and redundancy policies which are a disaster so far as local employment is concerned. The creamery and co-operative industries were one of the biggest centralised employment agencies in rural Ireland. I asked the Taoiseach last week what tonnage of potatoes was imported in 1981. The astonishing figure of more than 60,000 tons is not only a disaster for our economy but a disgrace to our society. We are one of the principal agricultural communities in Europe and yet in 1981, in addition to the potatoes, we imported about 700 million tons of agricultural goods.

The previous speaker mentioned the serious position in regard to the balance of payments. Here is an area in which both courage and planning are required to ensure that colossal bill is at least reduced if not finally eliminated. I am convinced that the traditional farmers have not lost the technique of producing potatoes and vegetables. What is required is a marketing and processing and presentation system which cannot be developed by the individual farmer but can only be undertaken through a major expansion of the co-operative movement into this field. The Department of Agriculture, the co-operatives and the various farmers' organisations have a major responsibility to ensure that the situation as we now see it, this colossal importation at great cost to our economy of goods which are capable of being produced here and which could create so much employment that is so badly needed, is remedied before things get much worse. With the goodwill that must be there much can be achieved. Then we can look forward to an expansion of employment from the country's natural resources.

In the budget, provision was made for exemption from stamp duty in respect of the transfer of land from father to son. There are specific requirements in order to qualify for the exemption. I accept that today scientific as well as practical training is of the utmost importance. There are a number of people under 35 years of age who would not only have 17 or 18 years' practical experience in agricultural development but in many cases have been managers of their parents' farms. As the regulations stand, such practically qualified farmers would not benefit from the proposed relief. The Minister for Finance should have another look at this regulation which encourages the transfer from older to younger farmers because this could result in the dynamic agricultural development required.

There is a dire need for the development of a realistic land policy. The Land Commission, who do useful work and who have an excellent staff, are starved of the necessary finance to allow them to make any contribution to the realignment of land, particularly in the west, where it is required to enlarge uneconomic holdings. Far too frequently we find that foreigners with adequate bank accounts will outbid a local farmer, thereby denying him and his successors the opportunity to develop his agricultural holding to make it an economic unit. This whole area of land realignment and the number of foreigners allowed to purchase land under EEC regulations should be looked at again.

The Land Commission policy seems to be that after a residency of seven years any EEC citizen is entitled to purchase land here. I know of cases where foreigners bought land but it was not registered in their names until 16 years later. There is a loophole in the law which enables some foreigners to purchase land and these transactions are not made known to the Land Commission until residency has been proved. There are a number of people who are not EEC residents and who have not resided here for the requisite period who are registered land owners. Taking into account the scarcity of land to enable small farmers to have economic holdings and the number of young people who would like to have their own farm but who cannot get land, we should be very concerned that land does not pass out of the ownership of Irish citizens. This is of fundamental importance. The development of a land policy is urgently needed, especially a land policy which will aim at allocating land to the people with small uneconomic holdings rather than allowing people with 300, 400 or 500 acres to buy that land.

A major portion of this Finance Bill is taken up by social welfare. The social welfare recipient has become the hobby horse of many concerns who want to level criticism at the system. It has been said that the level of social welfare benefits is responsible for our unemployment level. Every Deputy knows the problems experienced by those on social welfare. The first thing we must realise is that poverty is confined to those dependent on social welfare. It has been said that people on the higher levels of social welfare will not take employment. If this claim had any substance we would never see protest marches or hear of disputes when a factory is threatened with closure. I can assure Deputies that when announcements of closure are made there is a great deal of concern among workers and their families and the overwhelming majority of these people would rather work than face unemployment.

Some people claim social welfare recipients are a drag on the nation's resources, but I never hear criticism from those boardrooms of the many millions of pounds given to industrialists to create jobs; yet within 12 months those factories, built and equipped at the expense of Irish taxpayers, were closed and the equipment shipped overseas. I have not heard any criticism of the volume of State aid for hotel development which was to benefit our tourist industry. We all know that within a short period of major renovations being carried out with State grants, those hotels were sold and their further use as tourist assets lost. I realise that in any system of grant aid there will be abuse, but what I want to say is that the criticism about the magnitude of social welfare abuse is not justified. There is hardship and poverty experienced by social welfare recipients and they would much prefer if we could offer them employment rather than social welfare.

Many hardships are caused by the delay in social welfare payments — unemployment benefit, unemployment assistance, disability benefits and maternity benefits. This problem is not of recent origin. It has existed over a very protracted period. We were advised that with the introduction of the new system there would be no further delays. Every Deputy knows these delays are still happening and I urge the Minister to leave no stone unturned to ensure that where benefits are due there should be no unreasonable delay in making those payments.

On previous occasions I mentioned the anomalies in the social welfare legislation. Let us take an old age pensioner, living with his wife, who enjoys free electricity, free travel and a free TV licence. When the husband dies the widow has her income reduced by half and her entitlement to free travel, free electricity and a free TV licence withdrawn. Taking all the circumstances into account, the forced reduction of her income and the fact that she will not be capable of earning any sort of income in her remaining years, the Minister for Social Welfare should look benevolently into such cases to try to relieve the new pressures on such widows.

Another important omission from our social welfare services is the introduction of an income-related pension scheme, despite all the work that has been done on its preparation. So far, this has come to nothing and I urge the appropriate Minister to draw up a scheme as soon as possible. At the age of 66 people leave employment in which they earned anything between £100 and £200 a week. At that age their incomes drop to flat amounts, as little as half of what they had been earning.

In the context of the current high unemployment rate, we must all accept the challenge which Deputy Brennan, before me, posed. It is an immense task. The Youth Employment Agency was a step in the right direction because at least it provided a pool of finance to be spread around on various projects. The employment opportunities legislation provided immense scope to local authorities in particular, if only they had the finance. Therefore, there should be the closest possible co-operation between the State agencies—the Youth Employment Agency and the Manpower Service— and the local authorities to ensure that some valuable work will be done to relieve unemployment among our young people. Such co-operation would serve to reduce substantially the drain on the Exchequer of having people on the dole. As well, by way of taxation, it would benefit the Exchequer.

Deputy Brennan dealt with the colossal cost of the health services. On a previous occasion here, and many times in the Seanad, I asked the responsible Minister, having had 12 years experience of the operations of the regional health boards, to try to provide a national health service which would not be so top heavy at the administrative end. We should concentrate on the provision of hospital medical staff, doctors, nurses, ambulance and ancillary staff, and try to cut down on the superabundance of administrative staff.

The 1970 Health Act provided for the establishment of eight regional boards with very expensive administrative centres. I suggest that is over-generous for a nation of our size. We should concentrate more, after 12 years experience, on relating our expenditure directly to the benefit of people who need the health services. Therefore, we should take a hard look at the possibility of restructuring the national health services and the eight regional boards. The hospital service is a vital need and we should concentrate on improving it.

In County Kerry we completed a new hospital complex but we are in the invidious position that we cannot have the hospital opened, because of lack of finance, until 1984, and people who have been waiting so long for it have given up hope. I am asking the Minister for Health to solve any financial problems and have that hospital opened.

We need to give more attention to the mentally handicapped whose problem has been neglected by the State. Apart from the great help of voluntary organisations, we cannot be very proud as a nation in this respect. There should be far more generous Exchequer provision for services for the mentally handicapped. I include our psychiatric services. Until recently we had colossal institutions but they were used for custody rather than treatment. In the past few years excellent improvement work has been done but more needs to be accomplished.

The Department of Health should make every effort to improve treatment for kidney patients by bringing dialysis machines within reasonable distance of sufferers. We have a number of patients in Kerry who have to travel from remote areas over bad roads three times a week to receive treatment in Cork and return home each evening. Therefore, I appeal to the Minister for Health to install one of these dialysis machines in the new central hospital in Tralee. If that is not done kidney patients in Kerry will lose confidence that they can get treatment nearer home within their lifetime.

The innovation in 1979 of issuing medical cards on an annual basis has involved an immense amount of administrative work. I suggest that such cards operate for a period of three years. This would eliminate a tremendous amount of work for the administrative staffs in hospitals and would be more economical.

The Department of the Environment have responsibility for housing, water supplies, sewerage schemes and road works but the local authorities have major problems also in these sectors. When derating was started in 1978 promises were given that there would not be a diminution in the level of services provided by the local authorities but it is now realised that we are coming to a crisis point. There has been a substantial loss of employment in the local authorities and road development work has not been carried out.

With regard to housing, all Ministers do their utmost within the constraints upon them to keep local authority housing schemes up to reasonable level. One of the major problems of a housing authority is the securing of adequate land at a reasonable price so that the impact of the purchase price will not fall too heavily on the tenants. The Minister should recommend to housing authorities that they build up a large bank of land which could be used not only for their own housing needs but also as sites for people who might wish to build their own houses. If people were offered serviced sites many of them would prefer to build their own houses rather than depend on the local authority. The current cost of local authority house is in the region of £17,000.

In addition to the provision of sites the Department should look favourably on the expansion of the subsidy scheme for site development in respect of local housing. At the moment to qualify for that subsidy the density of housing must be not less than ten houses to the acre. In view of the developments in housing since that was originally decided, I suggest that where there are eight or more houses per acre the Department should look favourably on the provision of a subsidy. This would encourage people to take their names off the housing list and the subsidy would be an incentive to them to purchase a site.

The recent schemes for house improvement grants have laid down that approval must be obtained for the grant before the commencement of work. In many instances when people had completed their forms and sent them to the Department they thought they qualified for a grant. I suggest that a proportion of the grant, perhaps 50 per cent, be paid to people who had started work before the inspector visited the site. Many people added an additional bedroom or a bathroom to their premises but unfortunately as they had commenced work before the inspector's visit they did not get a grant. I ask the Minister of State who is present in the House to review the situation with a view to making a contribution to such people.

The Office of Public Works have responsibility for school building and reconstruction work. I accept that there has been a considerable investment in that programme but the number of condemned schools and those in need of major repairs is appalling. In my area one school has been condemned for more than 30 years and only now is work proceeding on the purchase of a site. This is a demoralising situation for teachers and students. It should be a priority to eliminate as soon as possible buildings that have been condemned because of their insanitary condition, overcrowding or because of structural defects. Such buildings are a hazard for students and teachers and they give a very bad image to the public generally.

The Office of Public Works have responsibility also for drainage work. Many rivers throughout the country have been scheduled for such work. Flooding has caused enormous damage to houses and land and it has endangered life. There is no hope that some of the rivers can be dealt with in the next 30 years and people in the areas concerned are becoming restless and are forming action groups in order to deal with the matter. I am suggesting to the Minister responsible that the Government should re-introduce legislation to enable local authorities to undertake interim drainage schemes in order to feed the rivers into the main catchment areas. By doing that they would be making a major contribution to agricultural development and to the safety and security of householders through the elimination of flooding. This is of paramount importance and I hope that in this Dáil session the suggestions I have made will be acted on. There are difficult times ahead and the most useful basis on which we can survive is by the development of our national resources, agriculture, tourism and so on. In regard to agriculture, I hope that the colossal import of goods that could be produced at home will occupy the immediate attention of the responsible bodies with a view to ensuring that not only will our economy develop but that our balance of payments, a vital matter, will benefit accordingly.

Comment on this
Brendan Griffin Acting Chairman (Mr. Griffin) Fine Gael

I am now calling on Deputy Naughten and I wish him well in his maiden speech.

Comment on this

I am grateful to the Chair for his good wishes and I am privileged to be making my maiden speech on the Finance Bill, a most important piece of legislation. The most important business dealt with in the House is the budget because it seeks to stimulate and consolidate the economy. The Finance Bill gives effect to the provisions of the budget. I am worried about what the Finance Bill holds for my constituency, Roscommon, and the country. It is my belief that the three men closest to the Taoiseach, the Ministers for Finance, Agriculture and Industry and Energy, are being influenced by him. That worries me and many other people who have a stake in our economy.

I should now like to deal with the economic policy being pursued by the Government. We have heard a lot about social policies but if we do not have good economic policies we cannot get the money to finance good social policies. Nobody denies that the Coalition Government while in office for seven months alerted our people about the depth of the recession and the debt we had been plunged into by the previous administration. The Coalition Government presented their case so well that in the general election the people showed that they were willing to accept the reality of the situation as outlined by them. Our people were prepared to accept the tough economic policies of the Coalition but in spite of that, in spite of the general acceptance of those difficulties and the understanding of the financial requirements needed to continue to support overseas investment the Government have failed to take any positive action. They continued to postpone for a considerable time positive action to deal with the economy.

In the 1981 general election we heard many promises and there were more promises before the general election of 1982 from the Taoiseach. He promised many stop-gap patching up operations. Wherever problems were clearly identified by Fianna Fáil the Taoiseach made promises. Deputy Haughey during the campaign promised favours in different areas. For example, in one area the Taoiseach promised a general hospital and in another area an airport but he did not recognise the disastrous financial situation of the country. Fianna Fáil are back in office on the strength of those gimmicks and mortgaging millions for the future. That is being done to obtain a few votes here and there and not least to please an Independent Member from a Dublin constituency. We are all aware of how freely that money was handed out particularly in relation to the Talbot workers and the workers at Clondalkin Mills. I wonder what the final bill will be for that at the end of 1982. I am not prepared to accept the accounts presented because they seem to change daily and depend on the type of case presented by pressure groups. As the pressure groups take to the streets one finds that money is made available for this and that but aspects of important investment are neglected. That was the policy prior to 1981. Irrespective of who cried "wolf" the Government stepped in and paid the bill with borrowed money.

It is pointless to hope that the realities of the situation here will be ignored by foreign banks. They will not be ignored simply because we are Irish or because Fianna Fáil are in office. When it comes to advancing loans the nationality of the borrower does not matter. We must pay the going rate of interest for the money we borrow or if not we will not be given it. I deplore the policy of the Government to borrow money for current expenditure. That was Fianna Fáil policy from 1977-81 and we are all aware of the financial mess they left us in. The Bill proposes to introduce a system of collecting VAT at the source of entry and the Minister for Finance told us he would make provision through the ICC for those who must borrow money to pay this VAT. He did not tell us that that money would cost those firms 22 per cent. That is the harsh reality of borrowing money and that will eventually close many of our major industries. What we are doing is collecting next year's tax this year.

Our ability to service and repay debts depends on our ability to negotiate fresh productive lending for the country. In the course of a speech to an economic club in New York some months ago the Taoiseach suggested that the efforts of the Coalition to bring public finances under control had damaged our image abroad. However, in a recent survey it was found that approximately a quarter of the overseas firms who have invested here would go elsewhere if they were investing today. That disenchantment springs from problems which result from decisions taken since 1977, many internal.

I have the height of praise for the IDA and the county development teams. We all admit that great economic strides have been made here trying to develop industries in our cities and throughout Ireland. The present economic policies being pursued are seriously damaging that success. We talk about attracting new industries but we must create an environment in which those industries can produce and export abroad. We must create the infrastructure. For example, in the west very often an industrialist who moves there finds there is no telephone, very poor roads and, if his gateway to the west is through Athlone he is faced with trying to get through a town which is choking to death.

These are areas in which the Government could usefully spend money on building new roads and opening up depressed parts of the country, in which industrialists find it hard to set up businesses which will give major long-term benefits to the area. We need low interest rates, low inflation rates and good labour relations to stabilise those industries. We must have easy communications and facilitate our industrialists to communicate with the Continent or wherever they are selling their products.

That brings us to the question of competitiveness. At present, many industries are not competitive, even on the home market. It was mentioned during the debate that at the present rates for borrowing it is not practical for industrialists to borrow on a large scale. I am not against borrowing if it is for productive purposes but I regret the trend that has developed here for borrowing for current expenditure. The handouts over the last three years were paid out of borrowed money, taxpayers' money given out for cheap political gain. Every member state of the EEC has its own problems and concessions gained by the Irish Government are very small. That does not affect the other member states and they are satisfied as long as benefits flow in their direction. Our Government should be much tougher in negotiating a fair deal for this country. In the past I do not believe that those negotiations were handled as effectively as they should have been and the unwarranted delay in introducing the increases for agricultural produce which was granted recently cost this country vast sums of money and came at a time when farmers are producing the maximum amount of milk.

The Government should pursue more vigorously the schemes that are at present in operation. The provisions of the present Bill are totally inadequate to stimulate growth in the economy and to encourage foreign or home investment. While we have interest rates of 22 per cent, we cannot expect investments from the home market or from abroad. There has been a great deal of criticism about the budget introduced by the Coalition in January which resulted in a general election. However, the provisions of the budget were necessary and people do not deny it. This was borne out at the Dublin by-election. During that election I had my first chance to meet Dublin people in the doorstep, the very poor, middle class and the very well off. Over those three weeks, I learned just how those people are thinking. If they can see light at the end of the tunnel they are prepared to put up with the harsh measures and to support the Government of the day. Unfortunately, the people are not getting that leadership at present. It has been widely stated that the Government are causing confusion and uncertainty by changing their minds from one week to the next and even, at times from day to day.

There are serious changes in the Bill which were proposed in the budget. Our economy will not improve until the inflation rate is reduced. Let us look at our nearest neighbour, Great Britain, who is one of our partners in the EEC. Her interest rates are about 12 per cent while ours are over 20 per cent. Her inflation rate is substantially lower that ours. How can we compete for new industry? If an industrialist has a choice between establishing an industry in Great Britain or here, he will opt to set up an industry in Great Britain.

I object to the payment of VAT at the point of entry. I accept that there is a great deal of tax evasion and that it is the function of the Department of Finance to tighten up in that area. But to have to pay VAT at the point of entry is damaging industry. It is increasing the price of raw materials, machinery which we need for agricultural production and all the other equipment that is necessary for industry and for agriculture. It puts a major strain on the cash flow of firms importing essential materials. Irrespective of whether the people concerned have to borrow from the ICI they will still have to pay exorbitant interest rates of 22 per cent on this money that they now have to turn over to the Government because of the principle of collecting next year's tax this year. There is no doubt that the cash flow of those industries is going to be severely damaged by this decision. Even in the last few days we have seen industries closing down. We are still not at the end of this slide. The Government have imposed this measure to collect £140 million but I believe that, at the end of the year, they will not have collected this amount because the recession will not allow them to collect this kind of money. We will have more redundancies, and the unemployment figures will rise. I sincerely hope I am wrong but I am afraid that is the reality of the situation.

I feel very strongly about the question of subcontractors' certificates. This first came to my notice two years ago when I made representations to the Minister about the problem. The system of subcontractors' certificates was originally intended to counter tax evaders and to counter fly-by-night boys. However, the regulations and the manner in which they are applied are so severe that they are financially damaging to the economy because, in many cases, contractors who should have certificates are not able to get them. If they cannot get them they must pay 35 per cent of what they earn there and then in tax and may have to wait up to two or three months to get this money back from the Revenue Commissioners. This is grossly unfair. If small contractors, young fellows who set up a small business and are prepared to employ two or three people, are faced with this situation, this barrier against equal opportunity to earn a living, it is very unfair and I respectfully ask the Minister to examine the matter carefully and see what can be done to eliminate the hardship caused to these young people.

At present we have a frightening figure of national debt and repayments. The interest on the national debt in 1976 amounted to £268 million. In 1977 it was £399 million. Capital repayments at that time amounted to £315 million. Interest paid outside the State was £99 million. I understand that the figures expected this year are: interest payable on national debt, £1,300 million; capital repayments of national debt, £1,160 million. The interest paid outside the State is a tremendous burden on the economy. With these vast payments it is little wonder that the economy is not able to generate sufficient wealth to invest in worthwhile employment projects or able to create the employment young people so badly need. Another 100,000 students are coming on the labour market this year and there is no employment for them. It is a frightening situation where we have this escalation of unemployment. Many young people now on the unemployment list will never have the opportunity of working or knowing what it is to do a satisfactory day's work and draw a day's pay. This is morally and legally wrong.

Many at the other end of the scale have become redundant through no fault of their own, men of 45 or 50. I doubt if they will ever have an opportunity of working again simply because far too much money has been spent on the past four or five years on domestic expenditure, on day-to-day expenses and not sufficient has been put into worthwhile job creation programmes. I regret that this has happened. The Government have a moral obligation to provide job opportunities for young people. It is hard to understand why the Government will not invest in projects with major employment potential. I am speaking particularly of projects in which we can utilise our national resources.

I want to refer to the building of a briquette factory in the Ballyforan area which the Government now appear to have shelved. It is hard to understand the economics of this decision when we are importing briquettes from abroad. We have the raw material, the manpower and everything necessary to make the same commodity here, but it seems that the Government cannot finance the project. I regret this because the employment potential there directly is 600 jobs. I appeal to the Minister to see that this project is started immediately.

In agriculture the Government have failed miserably to provide money necessary to stimulate output and create jobs in the agri-sector. More than half our total workforce are employed directly or indirectly in agriculture. A thriving agriculture means a thriving economy. If agriculture prospers every other sector of the community shares that prosperity. Progress in agriculture and increased exports mean we can pay for badly-needed imports for industry and thus create jobs and give everybody a chance to earn a living in his own country. In the past four years agricultural production has dropped and farm income has fallen disproportionately. Regretfully, I say that the present Government in the last four years when they were in office took no positive steps to prevent the fall in farmers' income and are not now doing so. Farmers no longer have confidence to invest in the economy, to buy a new machine, to reclaim or drain land. They have neither the confidence nor the money to buy an additional holding becoming vacant near them if it goes up for sale. Young boys and girls who up to three or four years ago were taking a course in agriculture, coming back and settling down to work on the family farm, are now on the labour market seeking industrial jobs. The income from the farm cannot maintain two families. That is the situation that has developed.

The Government should realise that the cost of creating an industrial job is £15,000. It makes good economic sense to try to retain on the land and employed in agriculture as many young people as possible and to try to ensure that the income from agriculture is sufficient to maintain two families. Very often we find on a farm where a father and son are working that when the son marries he must look for an industrial job because the farm income is no longer sufficient for two families.

In regard to the disease eradication programme, I should like the Minister to examine the position fully and to increase substantially compensation paid to farmers with reactor cattle. Many farmers when they sell their cows or yearlings to the factory find tht the price from the factory plus the departmental subsidy is only 50 per cent of the animal's real value. No other section of the community would tolerate this situation. Many farmers in my county face financial ruin because of a major outbreak of disease in the area. The compensation for reactors is ludicrous with no relation to the value of the animals. The hardship fund is totally unrealistic and is not workable. I appeal to the Minister to have that fund restructured so that it will be meaningful and can be operated so as to help the people it was intended to help and I ask him to increase the compensation payable.

I come to a point that costs no money but one about which I feel strongly. In terms of the economy it is very important. Where a farmer is unfortunate enough to have his stock locked up with one beast that reacts — he may have 20, 30 or 40 cattle to sell — these animals are frozen on the farm and he can do nothing with them. They may not be suitable for a factory and the farmer may not be able to afford to take grass or to keep the cattle on his farm. I appeal to the Minister to ensure that the Department of Agriculture would allow these farmers to have those cattle exported, cattle which are disease free but which are from a locked-up herd. I urge that such cattle be exported to Third World countries in which not as much emphasis is placed on disease eradication as is the case here and in the rest of Europe. This would alleviate much of the hardship farmers are experiencing in the context of the disease eradication programme. It was the situation that was in operation up to April 1980, but for some mysterious reason it was discontinued at that time.

I appeal to the Government also to take the necessary steps to stimulate agricultural production and incomes at this time of a crisis situation. Agricultural incomes have fallen from 52 per cent of the industrial wage in 1977 to 22 per cent today. How can we expect farmers to exist on the sort of incomes they are deriving from agriculture? There is an obligation on the Government to ensure that this section of the community are protected just as all other sections are protected and that farmers be given the opportunity of earning decent livelihoods for themselves and their families. This makes good economic sense too because it may prevent members of farming families from seeking industrial employment, from taking up industrial jobs that are needed by others. Production in the dairy and beef industries, too, must be encouraged.

One of the omissions in the budget that astonished me was in the area of the taxation of short-term social welfare benefits. It was a retrograde step on the part of the Government not to include in the budget the proposal in this regard that was contained in the January budget. Such a measure is badly needed in order to deal with abuses of the social welfare system. I refer to situations in which people stay away from work on the pretext of being ill and proceed to draw sick benefit when their aim is to keep down the amounts on their P60's so that they may qualify for other benefits. Short-term social welfare benefits are not included as part of their income for taxation purposes. It is wrong that someone who works for only nine months in the year ends up at the end of the year with the same amount of money as the man who has worked in a similar capacity for 12 months. Morally and legally that must be wrong.

Regarding borrowings in agriculture, I appeal to the Government to do everything possible to alleviate the problem presented to farmers in this regard. In 1977 and 1978 the experts in agriculture — technical economic and financial — advocated increased investment in agriculture. The financial institutions vied with one another in soliciting for the provision of loans to farmers. There was a situation that was tantamount to loans being forced on farmers. Since then rapid inflation, input cost increases and exorbitant interest rates, none of which was envisaged at the time no more than the effects of EMS were envisaged, meant that many of those farmers who borrowed money in 1977 and 1978 found that they were no longer able to meet their repayments and they are now in serious financial difficulty.

When the Coalition were in office they took certain measures to alleviate that problem. These measures were widely welcomed. They should be continued by the Government. The situation should be monitored regularly to ensure that none of those farmers is forced to sell land or even to leave his home as a result of the mishandling of the Irish economy in the past four years. Inflation was one problem that we should have controlled ourselves. Many other factors that have affected farmers' incomes related to domestic problems also and, consequently, could have been dealt with at home.

In the January budget there was a proposal to provide moneys to begin work on a survey of the Rivers Shannon and Suck. The Minister should ensure that this task is commenced in this financial year. More than 500,000 acres of land in the midlands are flooded by the Shannon and the Suck. The Minister should examine the possibility of having local authorities deemed to be drainage authorities within the terms of the EEC western drainage scheme. This would be a major asset in so far as that scheme is concerned. Many local authorities have the machinery but because of lack of sufficient finance for roadworks they are unable to keep that machinery in operation. But if they were recognised by the EEC as drainage authorities for the purpose of carrying out major drainage works there would be a double advantage for the economy, because on the one hand they would be undertaking valuable drainage work while at the same time utilising the machines that are lying idle.

In the years 1970 to 1980, 62,000 farmers left the land and if there is not an improvement in agricultural incomes as many more will leave in the next two to three years. While speaking in the Seanad in January 1 requested that there be provision in the budget for those people who were practically robbed by the Tuohy affair. Some of those people had all of their earnings, the fruits of all their life's work, swept away overnight. Many of them supplied cattle to the firms concerned but found that all they got in return were useless pieces of paper. I would appeal to the Minister to ensure that funds are made available. Interest free loans should be made available until such time as we know what percentage refund they will get. At the moment many farmers are facing financial ruin. They cannot meet interest rates. Many of them have to borrow in order to live. Some have been left without any stock. Some have not been able to replace stock. I appeal to the Minister to examine the possibility of making interest free loans available to these people.

I come now to the plight of our county councils and their inability financially to provide essential infrastructural developments such as roads, water, sewerage and housing. Local authorities play a very important role in our economy. Unfortunately the existing deterioration in their financial situation is having serious repercussions on local communities. The rot set in in 1979 following the Fianna Fáil decision to restrict county councils to a 10 per cent increase in rates at a time when local authorities were faced with increases ranging from 35 to 70 per cent in statutory demands, such as wages, demands from health boards, demands for supplementary welfare, statutory obligations such as those in relation to the Board of Works and so on.

The position now is that the majority of our councils are on the verge of bankrupcy. The number of houses being built has decreased. There is a patent deterioration in our roads and a decline in the installation of water and sewerage schemes. There is no money for county roads. As I said on an earlier occasion, it appears to be the policy of the Government to allow our roads to disintegrate into nature trails. In the long run it will cost the economy far more to repair our roads than it would if money were provided now to maintain them. It is bad economic policy not to provide sufficient money for maintenance. Our county manager recently reported to the council that he would require £1.5 million of an overdraft. Four years ago the council were in a credit situation. The banks will no longer advance money on current account overdraft. It must be a loan with a rate of interest of 20 to 25 per cent. This is an indication of how the change in the rating system in 1977 has affected local authorities. The placing of a ceiling on local authorities in 1979 has had an appalling effect.

With regard to the provision of health services, I would ask the Minister to ensure that money is made available to the Western Health Board to provide for the back-up staff for consultants in Roscommon County Hospital. One will take up duty on 1 July. A second has cancelled the arrangement to come to Roscommon. There was a clear commitment given by the Taoiseach that he would ensure money was made available for the necessary back-up staff. Unfortunately it has not been made available. I would ask the Minister to take this up immediately with his colleague, the Minister for Health, and ensure that the necessary funds are made available for the necessary staff in that hospital.

On returning to office the Government put local authorities generally in further financial difficulty by ensuring that one particular part of the country gets a very large share of the money available to local authorities. I refer to the Gregory deal. I do not object to money being spent in Dublin. We are all proud of our capital city but it is most unfair that a vast amount of money should be chanelled into one particular area to the detriment of other areas. It has resulted in counties like my own not having the finances necessary to build houses for our people. This is a most unsatisfactory situation and will have a detrimental effect in the long-term on our housing programme. Before the House is Deputy Bruton's amendment to the Finance Bill. In that amendment he points out that the better off will get benefits while the less well off will be mulcted. I support Deputy Bruton's amendment. It is our object to persuade the Minister to change his mind on certain provisions in the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

The most important section in our community is the farming section. Yet this is the section which has had to accept a 75 per cent drop in income between 1978 and 1981. This is the section which provides genuine long-term employment because it is their products that are processed in the meat factories, in the creameries and so on. Fianna Fáil are about to produce a four-year development plan for aid to agriculture. I am very happy that this plan is on the way but I would appeal to the Minister to make it a ten-year programme. A farmer cannot do very much in four years. It has been Fianna Fáil policy down through the years to expand agriculture. That is their policy today. Because of the magnitude of the problems facing agriculture there is urgent need to restore viability by overcoming the many problems facing the industry. Fianna Fáil believe it is necessary to bring forward a co-ordinated investment plan for the industry as a whole agreed on by the Government and major farming organisations and State agencies. Fianna Fáil have always stood steadfast in support of the farm family and expanding agricultural output in the interest of national economic growth. Fianna Fáil will take positive steps to restore farm incomes, increase output and bring hope to that sector. The main thrust of Fianna Fáil policy will be reducing inflation, the four-year plan which I appeal to the Minister to increase to a ten year plan, pressing for more EEC measures to relieve the problems in farming, and national aid measures.

Not so long ago the farm modernisation grants were 30 per cent and they were reduced last September by the previous Government to 25 per cent. Fianna Fáil have restored them to 30 per cent. The 30 per cent grant is based on the standard of costs drawn up in 1978 and as a result is completely out of date today compared with building costs. The 30 per cent grant today is equivalent to 20 per cent in contractors' costs. It is important that these standard costs be updated in the light of present costs. I appeal to the Minister to do what he can in that area.

Another change that occured last September was that grants for concrete yards were eliminated unless the applicant was putting up a new building. This is unfair to farmers with existing buildings because they will not be entitled to any grants for concrete yards around such buildings. When we are encouraging farmers to increase stock production it is important that the animals be fed quality winter feed. About 45 per cent of our farmers are making 70 per cent of their winter feed in the form of silage and it is important that other farmers be encouraged to make silage to increase their milk yield. Much higher grants should be given to small farmers to enable them to put up a silage base. The £3 per ton silage grant was a good help to small farmers making up to 50 tons of silage but real benefit from this is not obtained unless the proper facilities are there for making the silage.

To sum up, I appeal to the Minister to bring up the standard costs in line with present grants, that grants for concrete yards be restored and to allow a grant for silage bases for small farmers.

Another area of farming which has come into deep trouble in recent years is the agricultural contractor who is part and parcel of the whole scene of progressive farming. Such people have come under real pressure recently. They have provided an excellent service for farmers, but the inflationary trend has affected them seriously in the areas of machinery costs, oil, interest rates etc. One of the biggest problems facing the agricultural contractor is that he has not the security to borrow money at competitive rates and, therefore, is forced to borrow from hire purchase companies at prohibitive rates. A detailed examination of contractors' problems should be undertaken by the Government and the Department of Agriculture to help to identify the problems of these contractors. I appeal to the Minister to do what he can in that regard because many farmers even at this time — I have met some of them — could not cut their silage in time because contractors had gone out of business. In other words, those farmers will have a lower quality feed. Many contractors are forced out of business by cost and this has created a problem because therefore farmers must purchase their own machinery and equipment. This is not a welcome development because farmers are putting their money into machinery when they should be putting it into stock. Farmers should not be compelled to invest in machinery because contractors are forced out of business. Help in this area will be beneficial not only to contractors but also to farmers.

The proposed interest subsidy is to be welcomed, but it is no help towards getting people involved in systems of farming. It is difficult to justify a calf-beef system of cattle production at present high interest rates. At present costs it would cost £400 to bring an animal from birth to two years of age, including the cost of the calf. Interest on this would amount to approximately £80. It is of the utmost importance to have an interest subsidy for stock production in order to get people involved again in systems of cattle production and give confidence to the farmers. The interest subsidy already in operation is based on capital investments such as buildings and machinery. It is important that the interest subsidy be based on livestock production. Many co-operatives have introduced interest subsidies and they subsidise interest down to 10 per cent in order to enable farmers to increase their herd size. This initiative by the co-operatives would be welcomed in the cattle production sector of farming whether it be through a Government agency or the cattle industry itself.

I appeal to the Minister also to do what he can to increase compensation to farmers for brucellosis and TB reactors which is completely out of date and many farmers are experiencing serious hardship in freeing their herds from those diseases.

Farmers are aware of the high cost and the problems of out-wintering without sufficient winter feed. This can be provided only by use of additional fertiliser and if that is not available at a fair and reasonable price to farmers, then all the plans and programmes for the increase of farm output will come to nothing and will be a waste of time and money. The present high cost of fertilisers is a great stumbling-block in that it inhibits greater output from our cattle and dairy herds. This is true particularly in areas of low quality land which by nature demands a high input of fertiliser. In the light of the necessity of a higher through-put of milk for our processing factories and the new beef and cattle deal negotiated by the Minister for Agriculture, Deputy Lenihan, farmers must be given the opportunity to produce these products. I appeal to the Minister that, if at all possible, some scheme be implemented whereby our fertilisers will be subsidised to increase production and thereby create employment not alone in the farming areas but throughout the country.

We have proved that investment in agriculture has been falling for a number of years. Results show that few farmers now earn more than £10,000 a year. This figure does not represent the farmer's income but is the return for all the family working on the farm for long hours under very difficult weather conditions. Were it not for the help of their families many of our farmers would have been bankrupt years ago. They are entitled to a just reward for their hard work. They cannot say at 6 o'clock in the evening that they are finished until 8 o'clock in the morning. They have to work through the night at harvest time, harvesting beet and wheat, and they cannot look at the clock. They should get a just reward. They proved their worth during the war years in saving the people from unemployment and starvation and they are the only section of the community who can pull this country out of the trouble it is in today.

Fianna Fáil were always behind the small farmer, as they have proved down through the years. Every £1 million that our Government will invest will be returned a hundredfold with increased income for the farmers and thousands of new jobs with resulting spin-off employment. Despite their small income, the farmers are supposed to invest for the future, but borrowing at 20 per cent is out of the question. What will it take to convince our people that a healthy, thriving agricultural industry is of benefit not alone to the farmers but to everyone in the country? Prosperous agriculture will provide extra jobs at farm level and many more in processing. People will be kept on the land and in the rural areas. Instead people are moving to towns where employment does not exist. We have many problems in the bigger cities and I hope that planning for the future will provide more industry in small rural towns and avoid the problems of overcrowding and law breaking of every description which occur in the cities. Rural Ireland was allowed to die slowly because too many industries were established in the cities. That trend must be reversed.

I welcome the encouragement given to parents to hand over farm property to members of their family, but I am not happy with the condition regarding university qualifications. Most young people who have stayed at home on the land have not had the opportunity of going to a university and I hope the Minister will be liberal in this respect and that there will not be discrimination against these people. They may spend 20 or 25 of their best years working on a farm and they should not be penalised.

During the past few years many different types of penal taxes have been imposed on people who are the salt of this country, those who work long hours without looking at the clock and who produce genuine exports. They are being penalised by slick taxes devised by the brains in the Revenue Commissioners. The life of the farming industry is being squeezed out. Fifty per cent of the finest land in Europe is being badly managed because of our stupid system of taxing people because they own a bit of property. The land is not transferred and the young people cannot get hold of it and qualify for grants. I know it is the Minister's intention to encourage people to transfer land, but he must spell things out more clearly in order to remove fears. I appeal to the Minister to do as much as possible for the farming community and they will produce the goods. What other section would accept a drop of 75 per cent in their income while continuing to work hard?

I hope that the report of the Commission on Taxation will lead to the introduction of a fairer system of taxation for every section of society. The present system is outdated and unfair and I am confident that the Taoiseach and the Government will take the necessary steps to relieve the hardship which exists under this system.

I appeal to the Minister for the Environment to be as liberal as possible with people who are trying to improve their houses by extending them or adding on a bathroom and toilet. It is a shame that some people have been refused grants because the work was started before their houses were inspected by the Department. People who find themselves in this position should be enabled to receive these grants. The Minister for the Environment should also do something for people living in NBA houses which were built without chimneys. The costs of heating by electricity are extremely heavy. These people are also being asked to pay unfair amounts of money in order to purchase their houses. We have NBA houses in Tipperary town, Cahir and Killenaule. The Minister should provide the local authorities with grants to enable fire places and back boilers to be installed and to reduce the purchase prices of these houses.

We have the youngest population in Europe and they are as fine a generation as this country has ever produced. With goodwill and commonsense we can be as good as Germany or any other EEC country. We must give hope to young people, whether they are in industry or in farming. There has been too much preaching of doom and gloom and we must have faith in ourselves and in our country. People talk about the tough times today but our fathers went through tough times during the war. We must believe in ourselves.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Chair would like to congratulate Deputy Seán Bryne and Deputy Liam Naughten on two impressive maiden speeches. The Chair must now call on the Member nominated by The Workers' Party. Deputy Gallagher.

Comment on this

(Waterford): The Workers' Party in Dáil Eireann see as their task the provision of representation for a forgotten sector of Irish society, the working class and the economically weak and giving voice to the battered people, the tenants of our rundown local authority schemes, the young, the unemployed, the insecure, the old. We have three seats and are part of a balance of power situation which has afforded us the opportunity of maximising the interests of the people we seek to represent. We make no apologies for seeking to use this position to try to shift economic strategy towards a restructuring of the economy. We will make no apologies for finding ourselves in a position, thrust between the competing rivalries of the two civil war parties, where we must use this rivalry to obtain benefits in the interests of the vast majority of ordinary working people.

In following this course we see the opportunity that exists to help make an historic break in the mould of Irish politics by restoring sovereignty to the Dáil and by making Parliament more relevant in the formulation of legislation. It is in this spirit that we approach the debate on the Finance Bill. We aim to use this debate, and the Committee Stage which will follow, as a means of trying to amend the 1982 budget. Such parliamentary involvement, let me add, is more the norm than the exception in developed democratic countries. By refusing to rubber stamp the Finance Bill we aim to move Ireland in the direction of this democratic mainstream.

However, we know that this motivation is not shared by other parties in this House — by Fine Gael in particular, who view this debate and the forthcoming Committee Stage quite cynically as an attempt to force another election for their own narrow party interests. We are about to be treated to an intriguing spectacle in which Fine Gael will pursue a strategy of tabling ingeniously worked out amendments, designed specifically to put The Workers' Party and other left wing Deputies on the spot so as to force a general election. We shall shortly be able to gain a further insight into their desperation and indeed into the depth of their cynicism when we see the precise nature of their amendments. Will they go so far as disowning measures which they themselves brought in in the January budget, as they did during the Dublin West by-election campaign?

Fine Gael, to judge by the contribution of Deputy Bruton to this debate last week, are already working themselves up into a new found frenzy of concern for the poor and the lower paid. Deputy Bruton argued last week that the budget needed to be amended in favour of the lower paid because the Fianna Fáil budget had already eliminated some of the equity features in the original Coalition budget. This had been necessitated by the inclusion of some savage anti-working class features in Deputy Bruton's budget, such as the proposal to tax pay-related benefits——

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

On a point of order——

Comment on this

(Waterford):—— of recently unemployed workers.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Bruton on a point of order.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

As the Deputy is reading from a prepared script ——

Comment on this

Os ard má's é do thoil é.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

—— which has been circulated to the press, I should be grateful if he would afford other Members of the House an equal courtesy with the members of the press and circulate his remarks to us also.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This is a matter over which the Chair has no control nor is there any precedent for a Deputy being asked for a script.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

On a point of order, is it not the case that Members are precluded from reading prepared scripts in this House and may only do so with the permission of the Chair if copies are circulated but not otherwise?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not in accordance with what has been happening. If the Deputy had been in the House over the last hour-and-a-half even, he would have seen the contradiction of that which he would deem to establish as a precedent. The Chair, as in all cases of contributions made by Deputies, assumes that the Deputy is reading from notes, which is his entitlement.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Is the Deputy reading from notes or is he reading every word?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a matter which the Chair would have a facility to interpret from this distance. I assume the Deputy is reading from notes and I ask Deputy Bruton to allow the Deputy to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Would the Chair not consider it unfair that the press have sight of something before Members of the House have had any sight of it?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a matter on which the Chair should be obliged to adjudicate. Deputy Gallagher to proceed without interruption.

Comment on this

(Waterford): I was making reference in relation to the frenzied concern by Fine Gael for the poor and lower paid. There were features contained in the Coalition budget, which were necessitated by the inclusion of some savage anti-working class measures in Deputy Bruton's budget, such as the proposal to tax pay-related benefits of recently unemployed workers, to raise the price of milk and butter savagely and to put an 18 per cent tax on clothing and footwear.

This is the falseness of their present stance. What they really are looking for is a general election that will return them to power so as to enable them to bring in immediately a pure and uncontaminated Fine Gael budget in 1982. It is our judgment, supported by our Ard Comhairle, that this is not an attractive prospect for the working class and the economically weak in the country. We have good reason to fear a Fine Gael budget now. Their recent record in this area gives us no grounds for confidence that they would not revert to the tough monetarist policies contained in Deputy Bruton's January budget. Their new found concern for the less well-off can certainly give no grounds for encouragement, especially since they are mesmerised by the hope of a return to Government.

Last July Fine Gael, supported by the Labour Party and indeed by ourselves, were given their first chance. The July 1981 budget was an emergency measure to reduce an unsustainable budget deficit. We did not oppose the budgetary measures then implemented, which almost entirely consisted of increases in indirect taxation, a form of tax to which we are opposed in principle, because Deputy Bruton was able to argue that the time was not available to bring in the capital taxation and self-employed profit taxes that we, as a party, favour.

The Coalition had their opportunity in the subsequent six months to get the Department of Finance and the Revenue Commissioners working on proposals which would have ensured that the burden of paying for the economic crisis would be fairly shared and not again by working class shoulders. To help that Government along, we submitted a 27-page document setting out in great detail the realisable taxation changes that could be incorporated in the 1982 budget. They were totally ignored in the January budget. I recall Deputy Bruton's comments last week when he said that he had no patience with Finance Ministers who plead administrative difficulties and that "any difficulties can be overcome if there is a will to do so". Indeed, we can confirm these opinions of the former Minister following our own consultations with the Department of Finance when they costed the alternative taxation measures we proposed in our alternative budget submitted during the February general election.

Thus we conclude that the Coalition's desire to ignore our proposals for capital taxation and for a fairer share to be paid by the self-employed derived not from any administrative inconvenience that arose but from a political will to cushion the wealthy and the gombeen elements from having to suffer unduly as a result of the crisis in the Exchequer finances. Instead, it transpired that in the six months available to them Fine Gael and their Coalition partners had set their energies to formulating a particularly nasty budget which, unbelievably, given their parliamentary weakness, blatantly placed the burden of paying for the economic crisis on the backs of the working class and the less well-off. That budget was run through with the monetarist theories of the economic adviser of the Chilean Junta, Milton Friedman, as instanced by their conscious and declared aim of shifting the tax base away from direct taxation to indirect taxation.

Comment on this

A script has been supplied to the stenographer. If this is the case, could we please have a copy now?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If we are to stay within Standing Orders——

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): On a point of order ——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please Deputy, I am replying to Deputy FitzGerald. Strictly speaking, Deputy Gallagher is not supposed to read.

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We can indulge in the niceties of whether he is reading or referring to a script but, strictly, the tradition is that a Deputy is not entitled to read a script.

Comment on this

What is that?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If the Deputy will bear with me, I have been supplied in the last few seconds with a copy of a script.

Comment on this

Good. Now let us have it.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies, please do not bay at the Chair. It is not necessary. I have been supplied with the script and having been supplied——

Comment on this

On a point of order ——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

—— I am now advising Deputy Gallagher that it is not in accordance with Standing Orders that a Deputy should read a script.

Comment on this

Is Deputy MacSharry's name on it after the discussions today and yesterday?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order, please.

Comment on this

I wish to inform the House——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I take the view ——

Comment on this

A Deputy making his maiden speech is always given way to.

Comment on this

I wish to inform the House that two previous speakers used scripts and read from them.

Comment on this

They did not circulate it to the press.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

If I may, on a point of order, I should say that the matter to which we object most strongly is that people who are not Members of this House have a written text of what Deputy Gallagher (Waterford) is going to say in full and therefore have advance information of the contents of that speech that his colleagues here in this House have not been afforded. I believe that is a breach of not only Standing Orders but of common courtesy.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Whatever about the courtesy — and again one would hope that courtesy was not unrelated to Standing Orders — I am advising Deputy Gallagher that, in accordance with Standing Orders, he is not entitled to read in toto a script. He may use the script and refer to it. I leave it to his imagination as to how he will comply with Standing Orders.

Comment on this

Might I ask you, Sir, as a matter of courtesy — you having been furnished with a copy of the script — to lend it to me? Thank you very much indeed.

Comment on this

On a point of order, could the Ceann Comhairle use his good offices to inform the godfathers of the Ard Comhairle of the courtesies of this House so that in future such scripts will not be used?

Comment on this

May I say, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that the Members referred to——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Sherlock, you do not have to reply. In fact I would prefer that you did not.

Comment on this

I should say, on a point of order, that the point raised is frivolous because others I heard speak in this House had scripts in front of them just as Deputy Gallagher has at present.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Some people can invent their own speeches without having other people to write them for them.

Comment on this

The fact is that what he is saying, from what he has in front of him is making such impact — that is the important thing about it——

Comment on this

They just cannot take it.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): In view of the turn that this has taken I think that the procedure and Standing Orders of the House have been brought to the notice of the Chair and precedents may be established. As you have said, Sir, Standing Orders say that a Deputy other than a Minister may not read a script verbatim. It has now been brought to your notice and to the notice of the House that a script is being used. Indeed, a script has been formaly circulated through the staff of the House to the stenographers and to certain Members of the House. I think you have to decide whether you are going to establish a precedent and whether scripts will be allowed in future. With the greatest respect, Sir, I do not think it is good enough that you draw the attention of the Deputy to the rules and then say to him: I leave it to you to put your interpretation on the rules and to skate around them as you think fit. On your shoulders now, Sir, is the heavy responsibility to decide whether Deputies in this House may read scripts, prepared by themselves or by others, or whether Standing Orders will be enforced. I think it is my duty to say that.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Gallagher has 25 minutes remaining. I appeal to the House to pay to him the respect which is expected in this House for anybody who has the responsibility of replying for his party. I might add that we have a long road to travel before 10 o'clock this evening. I hope we would not make it an acrimonious one and that we would allow Deputy Gallagher to proceed.

Comment on this

On a point of order — without holding up Deputy Gallagher whom I have no wish to interrupt even though he regards my party and the nearly half million people who voted for them as gombeens — may I say, Sir, I would invite you to set a ruling on this — not so much on the fact that Deputy Gallagher is reading a script but on what he said about us and the Chilean Junta some five minutes ago. He may have forgotten it because he never wrote it.

Comment on this

In spite of the fact that he so regards my party and the half million people who supported us, together with the 600,000 very similar people who support the large party opposite, may I invite you, Sir, to rule on this: whether it is in order for any Deputy in this House, I do not give a damn to what party he belongs — to hand out a script which at this time, 6.35 p.m., for all we know is now being broadcast on the 6.30 p.m. Radio Éireann news before the Members of this House know what is the pay-off in this script.

Comment on this

That is what The Workers' Party have to say on this issue and, if Deputy Kelly is afraid to hear that, I suggest he is afraid of hearing the truth.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would ask Deputy Sherlock to resist the temptation to reply. You are not obliged to nor are you permitted to. I am now asking the House to allow Deputy Gallagher to proceed with his contribution. Deputy Gallagher, without interruption.

Comment on this

(Waterford): As I was saying, a concern for the effects of taxation on the low-paid comes very strangely from Fine Gael when they were some of the most enthusiastic advocates of the shift from direct to indirect taxation. Indirect taxation, as even the dogs in the streets may know, is an inherently regressive form of tax because, by taxing expenditure, the poor pay proportionately more of their income than do the rich. Of course, this is the philosophy of Fine Gael.

Comment on this

Theirs and Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

(Waterford): The lower a person's income, the more of it they have to spend to live. That is clear. Indeed, in this country the great majority of people find themselves in the position of having to spend all they have to live. Thus, under an expenditure tax régime, they pay tax on all of their income. The capitalist, on the other hand, spends only a portion of what he gets, the rest he saves, invests or speculates. Indeed, as an economist once said; the capitalist gets what he spends while the worker spends what he gets. By trying to shift the tax base towards indirect taxation Fine Gael were trying to bring about a situation in which workers were taxed on all of their income and capitalists were taxed on a portion only of theirs. It was the frills of that budget — designed to offset the central regressive drift that it represented — for which Deputy Bruton is now shedding crocodile tears. It is only when he can convince us that he has given up his former reactionary commitments to basic right wing monetarism that we might begin to accept that there is some sincerity behind those tears.

As if the attempt to shift the tax base towards expenditure taxes was not enough the Coalition Government added insult to injury by such proposals as the measure to repay to farmers interest on bank loans they had raised to speculate — I might add unsuccessfully — in land for no other reason than it was farmers who got their fingers burned. Industrialists, and even oil speculators were not to be accorded this extraordinary privilege. The audacious attempt to remove the resource tax from the Statute Book retrospectively so that the Exchequer could pay back payments of a tax passed by the Dáil was not alone an insult to the longsuffering PAYE taxpayers but to the democratic system itself. Indeed, listening to some of the comments of the Fine Gael Party, so vehemently——

Comment on this
Michael Moynihan Acting Chairman (Mr. Moynihan) Labour Party

Would Deputy Gallagher please be allowed to continue without interruption?

Comment on this

Listen to the voice of the Irish working class for the first time in the history of this House.

Comment on this

(Waterford):—— the pseudo Liberals within the Fine Gael Party and their commitment to the democratic process. We have seen an example of their commitment to that. They are trying now, as I have said, to add insult to injury by handing back retrospectively taxation which they themselves were going to implement.

With such a record on economic matters there can be few enough grounds for working class representatives and socialists in this House, in effect, to pass a vote of confidence in Fine Gael's alternative budget by bringing down the present Government on the Finance Bill at this stage. And we warn those who might be tempted into this course of action that a return of a Fine Gael Government could well result in a renewed and concentrated onslaught on the living standards of the working class. Fine Gael, to earn our confidence that their alternative approach to the budget will bring significant benefits to the mass of people and to the economically weak will have to do better than they have done in their budgets to date.

Fine Gael were offered a third chance to show an earnest of their good faith after the February election in the discussions we held with the leaders of the Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael Parties to form a new Government. We entered those discussions with an open mind, and indeed if one cares to consult the press cuttings of the time, it was the perception of the media that we would lean towards Deputy FitzGerald in those discussions. However, by the time they were over it was very clear to Deputy Sherlock, Deputy De Rossa and me that Deputy FitzGerald had no policy other than the one which had been rejected by the electorate.

It was made evident to us in our meetings with Deputy FitzGerald that he had no stomach to even consider any of our alternative suggestions. The Fine Gael side were not even willing to pay us the courtesy of even attempting to acquaint themselves with the proposals we were putting forward to shift the burden off working class shoulders and to ensure a fair share throughout society through our proposals for tax equity.

Fine Gael, let me add, seemed to adopt the attitude that they were the rightful majority, even though they did not get a mandate from the people, and in an arrogant way refused any suggestion of engaging in serious discussions with us. They apparently expected from us the meek acquiescence that they had seemingly become used to from their association with the Labour Party.

It was clear to us, too, that in the aftermath of the election it was the right wing of the party that was holding sway, people like Deputies Kelly and Bruton, as was evidenced by the clear message from them of having no truck with serious socialists. This was a signal to us that the more progressive wing of the Fine Gael Party, although having maintained a high profile during the recent general election campaign were decidedly in the minority when it came to the real exercise of power and of showing a willingness to consider the proposals we were putting forward.

We came to this conclusion, despite our reservations about the Fianna Fáil attitude to Northern Ireland, and to the aim of reforming the Constitution and achieving a secular republic. At that time, as a result of the highly-published constitutional crusade of Deputy FitzGerald, the general perception was that Deputy FitzGerald was a true reformer. In the interim Deputy FitzGerald has had the chance to show his commitment in this regard. Yet he has done nothing to date. On the key issue of civil liberties and constitutional reform at present, for example, the proposed pro-life referendum, Deputy FitzGerald has shown himself to be in the same camp as the Taoiseach. Fine Gael's stance on this developing campaign will be a true test of just how deep is their commitment to a constitutional crusade. Thus far, they are in favour of a deeply reactionary amendment to make the Constitution more rather than less sectarian. Thus far, both in the budgetary sphere or in the broader political sphere, Fine Gael have given us no reason to substitute them for Fianna Fáil in Government. Of course, The Workers' Party are under no illusions about Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

(Waterford): Just as every circus must have its clown, I suppose every Parliament must have its fools. You can take your choice from the left.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I appeal to those Deputies who are interrupting to desist from doing so and to allow Deputy Gallagher to conclude.

Comment on this

The simple answer is they have no alternative.

Comment on this

(Waterford): I am now coming to our agreement with Deputy Kelly on one aspect. We are under no illusions about Fianna Fáil, but we accept completely Deputy Kelly's perception of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael as ideological twins as accurate. Why do they not get together? As we said on many occasions, let the two reactionary conservative parties in this Assembly get together, give the stable Government they are consistently preaching about and let those of us on the left in this Dáil Chamber form a socialist left in the country. We are prepared for that.

We will continue to maintain an open mind on the issue of whether a Fine Gael or Fianna Fáil Government will best serve the country's interests of the working class at any particular point in time. If the time comes when a change of the present Government will best serve the interests of the people and the workers in a clear and demonstrable way, then we will willingly participate in bringing this about. My colleagues in this Chamber are on the same line as this. Let nobody in the conservative parties make any mistake about it. If and when we decide, it will be we who decide, not intimidation or pressure from either Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael or, God help us, the Labour Party.

We thus offer neither of the conservative civil war parties in this House an unconditional mandate to govern. They can of course at their own choosing take up Deputy Kelly's suggestion to coalesce. But as long as they refuse to take up that option we will continue to use their division to fight for the workers and for the country, and in relation to the economy, to try and make sure that they will not be able to make the working class pay for this crisis, a crisis created by the economic policies of successive Fianna Fáil and Coalition Governments.

Our resolve to continue to follow this course has been confirmed by the democratic expression of the electorate in Dublin West. Contrary to what Fine Gael have made of the Dublin West result, the real picture was that Fine Gael suffered a drop in their first preference votes compared with the February election. This is hardly a strong vote of confidence in a working class constituency for a Fine Gael alternative budget.

Indeed, the Fianna Fáil vote fell as well. The 100 per cent increase of The Workers' Party share of the vote, on the other hand, is a message to us to continue to use our resources in the Dáil to press for working-class interests. Rather than being a vote of confidence in Fine Gael we take the view that the doubling of the vote secured by The Workers' Party candidate, and the subsequent transfer of our votes to Fine Gael, was an indication of the electorates desire to ensure that a continuing restraint be placed on the Fianna Fáil minority Government.

The debate on the Finance Bill is overshadowed by the continuing difficulties of the Exchequer, as indicated by the continued high current budget deficit. The Minister for Finance's admission that the deficit will amount to 100 per cent of the full year total by the end of this month is a serious matter and one that we must take cogniscance of.

These budgetary developments have raised once more the possibility that the working class people will be asked to pick up the tab for the capitalist crisis which exists precisely because of the failure of the capitalist policies espoused by the two conservative parties in this Chamber.

To the Minister for Finance we give notice that, in considering corrective measures to deal with the budgetary situation, we will oppose any attempts to do so at the expense of the working class taxpayer, the unemployed, and the economically weak, either in measures this year to recoup lost revenues or in the 1983 budget. We note the Minister's statement that the PRSI £45 million will be met through expenditure reductions. If these reductions are to be found through the elimination of waste, or through the raising of productivity in the civil service through better management, then we will support them.

The Workers' Party accept the need to cut the budget deficit. We reject the attempts by Deputy FitzGerald, which are quite unfair given our clearly enunciated policy regarding the budget deficit, to portray the left in this House as irresponsible, as looking for more spending all the time, with blithe disregard for the national interest.

On the contrary, we are advocating economic policies which are of a far more constructive nature with regard to the horrific unemployment problem in cutting the Government's deficit than those of Fine Gael, which are negative and which cannot see any further than cuts, irrespective of the economic consequences. We believe that the deficit must be reduced through the expansion of profitable — and I emphasise "profitable"—activities of the semi-State bodies as well as through the elimination of waste in our public sector generally.

In this connection I mention one example: the opportunity for the development of mariculture in the 1980s. The massive potentials in commercial fish farming were recently set out in the report on the sector by the National Board for Science and Technology. The recent report that the Electricity Supply Board have got "permission" from the Department of Fisheries for the export of 100 tons of cage-reared salmon is welcomed. We urge that the ESB should be made responsible for expanding their activities in mariculture to the fullest and most profitable extent possible, instead of hiving it off, as is the inclination of the conservative parties, to yet more gombeen interests. Such an industry could be contributing £80 million to the balance of payments by the second half of this decade. Such sums are a positive example of what can be done by our public sector to curb the deficits. However, I suspect that this call will meet with little enthusiasm from the private enterprise fanatics of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael.

I cite the ESB's potential involvement in mariculture as one example of what can be done. Who can imagine what could happen to our economy if the whole public sector were unshackled from its gombeen capitalist manacles? It is a disgrace that a great, progressive and productive enterprise such as the ESB should have to go cap in hand to the Department of Fisheries for permission to export a paltry 100 tons of fish.

But in the absence of these more attractive, but unfortunately longer-term possibilities for economic development, we must still come to terms with the grim realities of our present economic crisis, brought about by the capitalist policies of the two conservative parties, whose failures now dominate the discussion on the Finance Bill.

Comment on this

Brought about by Deputy Haughey in Government and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

(Waterford): Notwithstanding the crisis that exists in the public finances we must continue to push for the reform of the tax system which is still an entirely realistic and realisable objective.

We do not need a Commission on Taxation report to tell us what needs to be done. The PAYE taxpayers have been telling successive Governments since 1979 to widen the tax base, to increase the tax take on Schedule D of the self-employed income, both earned and unearned. Interest payments, rent and dividend income must be brought fully into the tax net, like the wage and salaries of PAYE taxpayers. Rent is a major area where tax evasion exists. This must be properly tapped. Other self-employed income must also be brought in, and the problem of tax evasion by professionals must be tackled. The farmers must pay their fair share, a proposal which clearly does not meet with the support of Fine Gael to judge by their January budget, which unbelievably reduced the liability of farmers to pay for the massive amount of services they get from the State, through the outrageous proposal to cut by half the rates payments of larger farmers.

Comment on this

Absolute rubbish. Our party were the first to impose income tax on farmers.

Comment on this

(Waterford): These proposals to offer more State handouts to the farmers, along with the bank loans package were, in addition, quite unnecessary. Farm incomes are to rise by 25 per cent this year, far in excess of any other group, and hard-pressed PAYE taxpayers are expected to pay just to add icing to the farmers' cake this year.

Comment on this

The Fine Gael Party does and will tax farmers.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Would Deputy Kelly please let Deputy Gallagher continue?

Comment on this

(Waterford): In addition, the obscene wealth and anti-social activities of the property speculation sector must also be tapped, and we will not be dissuaded by claims that such attempts are economically disruptive. The existence of substantial untapped tax revenues in this economy is evident to all with eyes to see. The wealth of the black economy is clearly in view.

To achieve these ends we assert yet again that sweeping changes must be effected in our tax system — changes of a progressive nature that will widen the tax base through a reliance on direct taxation of the self-employed and the wealthy and the implementation of capital taxation proposals that will see this form of tax rise as much as is possible.

Our amendments to the Finance Bill on Committee Stage are aimed to provide this House with the opportunity of taking the first serious steps towards a balanced tax system, and finally show the PAYE taxpayers that their campaign for tax reform was not in vain. The kid glove approach of Minister for Finance towards the wealthy in the past must now be ended.

While economic issues are central to this debate, given the drastic level of unemployment, high inflation, a critical balance of payments situation, inequitable taxation, gross under-utilisation of our natural resources, particularly in agriculture, mariculture and allied industries. The Workers' Party insist that the crisis in the economy is but an element, though a key element, of a much wider and more deeply rooted malaise within the social system.

As a socialist party, we are not concerned only to win the ultimate total transformation of society, we are equally committed to the present strengthening of the democratic process, the immediate improvement of the quality of our political, economic and social life and the mobilisation of our people's skills, energies and enthusiasm for the creation of a more just and equitable society within the foreseeable future.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Gallagher has five minutes to conclude.

Comment on this

(Waterford): The Workers' Party also recognise that many of our people within all walks of life and of all ages, men and women, have become disenchanted with the present political system and, in my experience over the last couple of months, I would wish that every working man in the country——

Comment on this
Myra Barry Miss M. Barry Fine Gael

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Deputies

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

What is the point of order? One minute, Deputy Gallagher, please.

Comment on this
Myra Barry Miss M. Barry Fine Gael

On a point of order, has it been agreed that every Deputy can read from a script?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

No, Deputy. The ruling of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle is that he cannot read.

Comment on this

(Waterford): I wish that every working man in the country ——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Gallagher, one moment, please, on a point of order.

Comment on this
A Deputy

I would like a ruling on what is going to happen if Deputy Gallagher does not manage to finish his script?

Comment on this

On a point of order, will the Chair allow Deputy Gallagher time off for all the interruptions he has had?

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Does the Deputy hear all his friends?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Can we have order, please?

Comment on this

The Deputy is not giving time to his friends in Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

By order of the House, I must conclude this contribution at 7 o'clock. There must be no further interruptions. Let Deputy Gallagher be allowed to continue.

Comment on this

On a point of order, our party are quite willing to give further time to the Deputy to finish his script.

Comment on this

He deserves it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

In keeping with the courtesy of the Labour Party, we will allow the Deputy an extra five minutes.

Comment on this

(Waterford): I spoke about the disenchantment of the ordinary working people which arises——

Comment on this

On a point of order, there have been interruptions and in fairness to the Deputy he should be given sufficient time to allow him to conclude and we are conceding time to him.

Comment on this

That is a change.

Comment on this

A reversal ——

Comment on this

(Waterford): Before the constant interruptions, I spoke about the disenchantment of the ordinary working people which arises not simply from the gross inefficiency of these Governments but is related to the actual style of politics which has become the keynote of political life under both Fianna Fáil and the Coalition.

Is it small wonder that there is little trust in the programme and promises of Fianna Fáil and the Coalition, that there is widespread cynicism as to the nature of politics, personalities and parties? Broken promises, inner-party strife, and the blatant pursuit of personal power are not the basis upon which the trust and credibility which certain Deputies are so fond of preaching about in a political institution can be built.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy find it over there, too?

Comment on this

(Waterford): In the course of the recent general election, we set out alternative budget proposals which are simply a short-term response to the present crisis in Ireland. Admittedly, they involve no more than a tinkering with the superficial details of the present capatalist economy. But, as I have already indicated, taxation cannot solve the problem. The problems of 20 per cent inflation and over 148,000 unemployed — and the figure is still growing — and the acute balance of payments problem are just the surface manifestations of the extent to which the private enterprise economy is in trouble. They cannot be solved without a radical change in attitudes and an overhaul of the economic system. The Workers' Party maintain that two basic changes are required for a solution to the long-term economic crisis that faces this country in the eighties.

(1) There must be a renewed commitment among the work force to the task of economic development, and

(2) There must be a planned approach to development so that the resources of the economy are harnessed fully and efficiently to achieve the increase in national output necessary to cut inflation, reduce the taxation burden, raise real wages and provide the material basis for social progress.

Neither of these two changes can be brought about in a private enterprise dominated economy. Why should the work force contribute the increased productivity and efficiency required for such a plan to a system in which it has no stake? The working class in this country know intuitively that if they respond to the endless calls for wage moderation from conservative politicians and industrialists, or indeed to the demands for an acceptance of an unbalanced tax system, that they will get nothing in return. The very fact that capitalism offers no guarantee of economic justice is proof that belt tightening among the workers will only lead to fatter dividends for employers.

It is thus understandable that workers must resist attempts to raise efficiency or productivity at their expense, not just in the public sector, but in the private sector. For the same reasons, the endless calls for wage moderation repeatedly fall on deaf ears even though economic circumstances dictate the need for such austerity.

For this country's long-term economic problems to be solved it is essential that the working class co-operate fully to improve efficiency, increase competitiveness, raise exports and cut imports — the measures necessary to solve the balance of payments crisis. Without the consent of the working class it is inevitable that this country will lurch from balance of payments crisis to deflation for years to come.

Thus the key principle of any long-term economic development plan is a guarantee to workers that the profits to be reaped from belt tightening, from efficiency and from the raising of productivity will accrue to the ordinary people in a just way.

By ensuring, through legislation, democracy in the workplace so that each and every worker will fully participate in the running of his or her enterprise, and by ensuring a key role for socially owned State enterprises such as CIE, the ESB and Bord na Móna, the creative energies of the working class can ultimately solve all economic problems.

The second essential feature of the long-term development plan we propose is planning. Our economy under private enterprise domination is chaotic at present. For example, there can be no effective national drive to solve the major problem of massive energy imports because there is no co-ordination between ESB, CIE and our transport planning authorities, all of which would have to be the pillars of a national plan to reduce the deficit arising from energy imports. By introducing planning on a national scale, the decisions of productive units in the private and socialised sectors of the economy can be meshed together in the national drive for development that is needed. The state sector must be at the centre of any planned expansion. The Workers' Party has consistently backed the expansion of the role of State enterprise in the economy. Because the State enterprises are the most amenable to a planned drive for economic development their expansion goes hand in hand with the introduction of planning.

The long term efficiency and development plan that we propose would concentrate on the raising of exports and the cutting of imports in the following key sectors, in agriculture by the expansion and involvement of State enterprise in large scale farming, and food processing, as outlined in our recently published policy document, "Land for the People", in energy through a plan to raise the production of cheap energy, and by a planned conservation plan, organised and executed by the ESB; in manufacturing by the involvement of the State in manufacturing initiatives to replace the failed small industries programme of the IDA, and through renewed and sustained efforts to obtain foreign industries which are of real benefit to the economy.

The response of the conservative parties to the economic crisis is predictable. The Coalition showed clearly who they wanted to pay the cost. It was to be placed yet again on those who could least afford to pay, the working class. Fianna Fáil in Government have done little different. Deputies Haughey and FitzGerald represent the same interest — they both have shown consistently over time that they will refuse to tax both wealth and capital. The Labour Party by their support for Fine Gael policies have shown that they have lost the will to defend the interests of the workers. But the voting record of my colleague, Deputy Sherlock, Workers' Party TD, made sure that the voice of 900,000 marching PAYE taxpayers had to be listened to at last. That voice was heard on 27 January, budget day.

In voting against the Coalition budget, we did not deny that there is an economic crisis. What we disagreed with fundamentally was how the Government proposed to pay for it.

Comment on this

On a point of order, as I am the concluding speaker for the Labour Party, I would like to ask how long more Deputy Gallagher will be.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Deputy Gallagher has five minutes to conclude.

Comment on this

(Waterford): The Workers' Party fully accept that there is an acute economic crisis. As an economy we are spending more than we are earning abroad and the difference has been made up by Government borrowing. Over the past few years successive Governments have attempted to maintain the illusion of prosperity under capitalism by more and more borrowing to pay for day to day spending. Both Fianna Fáil and the Coalition refuse to follow the policies necessary to lay the foundations for real prosperity through a significant restructuring of the economy to raise production to the levels necessary to maintain our standard of living, and to create sufficient employment for the growing labour force. The unshakeable faith of these conservative parties in private enterprise as the engine of growth is misplaced. Despite an investment rate the same as that of Japan, the inefficient ramshackle private enterprise economy has proved that it cannot meet the challenge. The engine has seized. By 1982 all we are left with is an unemployment level of 148,000 an inflation rate of over 20 per cent, economic stagnation and of course, a huge foreign debt.

With the economy now on its knees, and little prospect of ever being able to pay the interest on that debt through self-sustained growth, the economy by international definition, is on its knees. Like any company in trouble which first turns to its workforce to cut wages, the Fine Gael and labour Party Coalition Government in their 1982 budget tried to do exactly this: they tried to take money out of the pockets of workers by huge increases in direct and indirect taxation. In the past the conservative parties, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, with the collusion of the Labour Party were able to get away with this approach. There is now a workers' voice in Dáil Éireann prepared to call a halt.

Comment on this

On a point of order, has there been any change in the nature of the business of the House arising from any agreement between The Workers' Party and the Taoiseach?

Comment on this

There has been no such change.

Comment on this

Has there been no bargaining yesterday or today?

Comment on this

The Finance Bill was introduced yesterday week and it has been suggested that the Government have agreed to amendments to the Finance Bill. These suggestions may be quite untrue but it is important that we should know what we are talking about. If there has been no agreement and the Government do not propose to introduce any amendments other than those that we have discussed already, then the House will be glad to know that. If, on the other hand, there have been agreements behind the backs of the Members of this House to modify this Bill in some significant way, then before we proceed further we are entitled to know and we ask the Minister for Finance to give a clear statement on it.

Comment on this

Do I understand the Minister to say there has been no change?

Comment on this

There has been no change. Nor have I seen any amendments from any source.

Comment on this

Deputy De Rossa said that the Taoiseach met him yesterday and was to meet him again today.

Comment on this

I would just draw the attention of the House to some of the courtesies. We have extended the courtesy to The Workers' Party, to conclude their speech. We should look at some of the old style traditions. If the Deputy feels a prepared speech is preferable, I do not think it is wise for us to get hung up on it. By all means let us change tradition. We are all aware that many people read speeches, therefore why do we tie ourselves up in such traditions of our own making? I would prefer to see The Workers' Party, formerly the Official Sinn Féin, represented in this House rather than outside and I would prefer to see the Provisional Sinn Féin represented inside rather than outside this House. If certain traditions are broken, they were made by Irish people and we should not get too hung up on them.

I want to address my remarks to the comments made by The Workers' Party and then deal with the economics of the Finance Bill. I want to address my remarks in a manner in which I hope all my comments have been to date, and that is as constructive criticism and not in a personal way. The Workers' Party's attitude to parliamentary democracy is consistent and comes from a long political parliamentary tradition, which does not necessarily exist in this country but which has existed in every European country where there has been a Euro-Communist or Communist Party. The opportunistic behaviour of The Workers' Party in this House since last June is exactly the same as that of the French Communist Party, the Italian Communist Party, the Portugese Communist Party and the Spanish Party.

Comment on this

That is an outrageous implication. The only reason the Deputy is making it is because The Workers' Party are effectively the representative voice of the working class people which he and his Labour Party have forgotten.

Comment on this
Michael Moynihan Acting Chairman (Mr. Moynihan) Labour Party

Would Deputy Sherlock allow Deputy Quinn to speak without interruption please?

Comment on this

If any Member walked in with his little land Bill under his arm and his——

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Will Deputy Sherlock allow Deputy Quinn to continue?

Comment on this

——party purports to represent the working class people ——

Comment on this

They all say one thing and vote the other way.

Comment on this