Finance Bill, 1982: Second Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 119–247 of 247. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 10 of 1982 ›
As I was saying, the opportunistic voting pattern of that party is something our sister parties in the Socialist International forum have experienced. I was not surprised by any of the criticisms made by The Workers' Party nor was I surprised at their decision to vote against an amendment calling for the establishment of a rents tribunal, against which all three Deputies voted in return for some kind of vague changes. They had 27 amendments accepted in that legislation, all of which purported to change the word "shall" to "will" or "may", or some such substantial radical Marxist tranformation of the housing market.
Since The Workers' Party representative in his concluding speech saw fit to attack the Labour Party I feel I should reply in the context of a left wing analysis of what their proposed policies are. There are inconsistencies in, on the one hand, voting in this House for the PRSI increases, which they did, and then going out on the streets to march in opposition to them, which is also what they did. That is something which is not necessarily correctly paraded on the front page of The Irish People, but journalists not representing party newspapers have an obligation and an opportunity to record accurately.
They have also tried to misrepresent some of the progressive measures a small party like the Labour Party are trying to have implemented. Tragically, they cannot recognise the kind of changes that have been made and, because of the economic framework within which their own policy makers conceive politics, they cannot understand the reasons why the belt-tightening exercises have to be undergone in the first place.
When The Workers' Party was originally known as Sinn Féil they were committed to economic independence for the Republic of Ireland. It is my understanding that they are still committed to that policy. So are the Labour Party. The restrictions imposed by the International Monetary Fund on the working class, for whom The Workers' Party are so concerned, would be savage beyond belief when compared with any kind of constraints which any combination of domestic political parties would impose. It is precisely the kind of reckless spending by the Fianna Fáil Party to buy votes which would bring this country and its economic dependence to a stage of disintegration where the IMF would be obliged to come in, as they did in Britain when the Labour Party were in office and as they did in Italy. That is exactly what the Labour Party were seeking to avoid and will continue to do, and we make no apology for that. If that was not understood by the people, then that is a criticism of our ability to communicate our policies, but it is not necessarily a criticism of the policies themselves.
I can understand The Workers' Party's lack of understanding of the role played by the IMF, because the IMF do not operate in the eastern European socialist economies and therefore does not necessarily come into the economic frame of thinking of people who have a certain support. There is nothing wrong about that support. I want everyone to be quite clear about what I am saying, because that is a perfectly valid point of view to have. All I am saying is that every Deputy or party who puts forward a view should try to argue it honestly, rationally, reasonably and recognise all the facts. That is the basis on which scientific Marxism and scientific socialism is constructed.
In the Irish economy and in the western world in which we operate, the IMF are a very strong force, particularly for leftwing governments, or left of centre governments, who want to protect workers from the revages of the collapse of the international system by borrowing and maintaining levels of income at a time when economic growth is declining. I draw the attention of the international affairs committee of The Workers' Party to the fate that befell the Manley Government in Jamaica which attempted to ride out the strictures of the International Monetary Fund by implementing a socialist programme in an extraordinarily difficult economic system.
If we are to have left wing criticism of the role of the minority party in this House, let it be consistent with the facts and take cognisance of all the facts, not the selective facts which are made for opportunistic debate. The tone, text and colour of The Workers' Party speech were extraordinary. I had to pinch myself most of the time because I felt it had been written for the previous budget, not this budget. It seemed to suggest that Fine Gael were in government. The only motivation there can be for that is — and it is quite clear to me, to the House and from the relieved smiles of the Fianna Fáil Deputies — that The Workers' Party again decided to go into coalition with Fianna Fáil to abstain or to vote for the Finance Bill tonight. A journalist recently described an objective assessment of the role of The Workers' Party in this House as "benevolent neutrality".
Comment on this
I welcome the support of every Deputy, but I was surprised and disappointed Deputy Fitzsimons did not vote with us on that issue.
The point at issue is that we are debating the Finance Bill. The impression has been created that there was an underhand deal, a secret arrangement, under which, in return for The Workers' Party's abstention on the Second Stage, concessions would be made by the Minister for Finance on Committee Stage. We must wait and see what the outcome will be. The Labour Party will be pressing their amendment to relieve the kind of distortion that was in the budget, which this Finance Bill compounds and which The Workers' Party appear to wish to support, either by benevolent neutrality or by positive support in tonight's vote. We will do that because the bias in favour of the people who own wealth goes right through the section. That provision has not been modified relative to the needs of the people. It has not been modified one iota by any of the representations made by The Workers' Party in private or in public.
Any progressive provisions in the Bill, and there are some—I welcome their survival and I thank the Minister for retaining them despite lobbying from some sections of the Fianna Fáil supporting groups —in fact are legacies from the Coalition Government. However, the more progressive elements in that budget, which was an extremely difficult budget, have been removed. It was rather sad to hear somebody as sincere as Deputy Gallagher——
Comment on this
I say that sincerely. On the one hand he was able to argue passionately against what he called the "obscene accumulation of wealth" but tonight he will vote, or not vote, in favour of legislation which is the legal vehicle to enable people to hide wealth, which, in the phraseology of The Workers' Party was robbed from the working classes by the capitalists. I understand Deputy Gallagher's dilemma, and Deputy De Rossa's, and Deputy Sherlock's: it is the dilemma of being elected to a parliament that has two large centre parties, populist parties, who have to be pushed and shoved to make any kind of progressive concessions. It is a dilemma that will continue until we get some kind of radical re-alignment.
I suggest respectfully to The Workers' Party that that kind of sloganeering and the sort of insulting analysis they presented here tonight do not fit in with their party's policies. We are in a real economic crisis. On the one hand we are playing in the popular scrum of more money for everybody in demonstrations throughout the country, and at the same time we are saying that jobs can be produced overnight in a whole range of industries. It is simply against economic reality. If we were to apply the model of economic development that has been applied in Eastern Europe, and which is inherent in the industrial revolution proposals of The Workers' Party, we would be forced to have wage constraints on a planned basis and an incomes policy without any of the increases being talked about for a long period. The very first people to baulk at that would be the trade union movement. Indeed, I gathered from what Deputy Gallagher said that all of the benefits of increased productivity should go to the workers, the people who produce the wealth.
If that is to be the case, there would not be any benefit in increasing productivity, whose purpose is to find capital for re-investment. It is clear that our capacity to borrow more money abroad for productive investment is extremely limited because of the declining value of the Irish punt and the parlous position of the Irish economy vis-á-vis the other European economies, particularly the British and the pound sterling. Therefore, we are in a very vulnerable position.
I make these comments on The Workers' Party contribution because we must try to strike a balance. My socialist colleagues in all the other European parliaments have had to respond to the same narrow pre-1973 Marxist analysis of economic realities in the world today. That party's analysis extends to the North-South dialogue on the Brandt Report in regard to Third World development: it is a rigid, hard, narrow interpretation of world economics, conceived in a framework that does not any longer fit the economic realities of the world since the oil crisis of 1973. It certainly does not fit into a programme to try to establish an economy within the EEC. I understand that The Workers' Party now support the EEC, though they did not support it during the 1971 referendum.
It is only through a mixture of socialist planning with co-operation from the private sector in a mixed economy that we can attain any measure of fixed security and stability in Ireland. Unfortunately, the ability to get the kind of consensus that helped to achieve the industrialisation of Ireland from the early sixties to 1972-1973, when there was consensus, when we had wage agreement after wage agreement, when real productivity was gained in nearly all sectors, was shattered by the refusal of certain sections in the economy to recognise the need for change, for people to participate in the spoils, the benefits, of redevelopment.
The most culpable section are undoubtedly the farming community. If any section created a sense of total alienation among workers and brought into the streets hundreds of thousands of PAYE people — they were right to go into the streets, and I joined them there — it was the farming community who, having campaigned vigorously to get us into the EEC in 1971-72 and who then benefited from the undoubted short-term bonanza in terms of farm prices, categorically refused to share their new-found wealth with the urban workforce, many of whom were finding that the old tariff protected industrial jobs with which they had grown up were disappearing.
I remind The Workers' Party that it was not the so-called radical republicanism of Fianna Fáil that took on the farming community: it was on Labour Party insistence, with Fine Gael support, that for the first time those who were making real money, the farming community, were taxed. That was in 1974-75. The effect was that many of them transferred their support to Fianna Fáil. Any analysis made in the House should be based on what happened in history rather than what one would like to have happened in history. The history of that time is that the farmers refused to pay the money: they refused adamantly to pay their taxes and they are still refusing to do so. I suggest they are still being treated too lightly. All the professional lobbyists for farmers, mainly for the large farmers, are conceding that there is growth in the incomes of the farming community. Therefore, it is only right and proper that they should be paying their full and fair share of the taxes required.
This Bill does not ask them to do it. It will not get at the ranchers, will not oblige them to make a contribution. I will be looking for support from The Workers Party and other socialist Deputies for amendments to try to redress that situation. I will give one example. The last Coalition Government implemented the Labour Party proposal for the establishment of the Youth Employment Agency, which is financed by those who are at work, but not by farmers or some of the self-employed. That is unacceptable. Why should one section of the workforce, mainly the PAYE people, be obliged exclusively to carry responsibility for the financing of the Youth Employment Agency when the farmers or the self-employed do not contribute? We have calculated that a Youth Employment Agency levy on farmers and the self-employed would yield £20 million. We draw that to the notice of the Minister for Finance and we will be moving an amendment on those lines on Committee Stage. It is now likely the Committee Stage will be passed because of the "benevolent neutrality" of The Workers' Party.
The budget attempted to provide a cosmetic exercise on the continuing inequality in our country. This inequality has been severely aggravated by the response of the country to the crisis of 1973 and has caused divisions not just between town and country, between farmer and worker, but within the work force itself. On the one hand there is the problem of young people trying to get a job for the first time and, on the other hand, of workers seeking redundancy payments rather than attempting to keep a factory in operation in order to maintain employment. They are real problems that demand real solutions but the solutions are not contained in the provisions of this Finance Bill.
This Government, like the previous Fianna Fáil Government when stability was not a problem, have failed to deal with the central issue of the utilisation of the public finances they control. The convention of the theological dogma of so-called left wing parties is that one should nationalise financial institutions and take them into public ownership. For example, when the Labour Party in Britain were in office the British Government nationalised their loss-marking steel industry, to the great delight and joy of every capitalist shareholder in the industry because they got a bonanza they would not have got otherwise.
This country already owns the largest life assurance company in the nation. It is in public ownership. The Minister for Finance owns 97 per cent of the shares.
Comment on this
Yet, with that kind of leverage the Government have not used their power in a planned way. The Minister could exercise enormous fiscal power through the organ of the Central Bank, which is publicly owned, and control the direction of State finances, the investment policy and the way in which it would develop exactly on the lines mentioned by Deputy Gallagher in relation to the long-term development of sectors of our industry. However, there is an extraordinary reluctance on the part of Fianna Fail to do that, and there has always been that reluctance. It was not there in the forties and fifties when the private enterprise sector simply could not aspire to that kind of thing. I challenge the Minister to refute the claim that Fianna Fáil now are strongly in the hands of a small clique of wealthy people who control their economic policy. The refusal of Fianna Fail when they had a 20-seat majority in this House to take effective action in directing the policy of companies such as Irish Life and the Central Bank into responsible economic planning and development was because it was more profitable for private enterprise to do the job.
When I spoke on the Bill dealing with urban development I pointed out that it was another cosmetic exercise by Fianna Fail that would do nothing to regenerate the north side of Dublin city because it was not making financial resources available for the job. As Deputy Sherlock correctly pointed out, if anything it was attacking still further local government autonomy in the name of the revitalisation of the inner city.
Now the Government have the power, the instruments and the levers to effect major economic policy changes if they have the political will to do so. During the four years when we were in socialist opposition on this side of the House and when the Government had a 20-seat majority there was no point in arguing or even talking to Fianna Fáil. Now that they are a minority Government I appeal to the left wing Deputies and parties to exercise their influence in a constructive manner to get some of the changes and reforms implemented by a minority Government, changes on which all of us are agreed. I can assure the members of The Workers' Party in this House that it Fianna Fail return to a majority situation the courtesies and the secret meetings and all the rest will be something of the past.
Comment on this
The Labour Party are disappointed that the Government, with all their experience, did not see fit to respond to changing the overall composition of the taxation package in order to introduce a greater degree of equity in a manner acceptable to a wider range of people. I am talking in particular of working people who represent 80 or 90 per cent of the population, people who earn their living by head or by hand and who are PAYE workers. For some reason, perhaps related to the enormous cost of Fianna Fáil's election programmes and their election campaigning, as the magazine Aspect indicates in this month's issue, there is an extraordinary reluctance on the part of Fianna Fail to tax wealth. We are suggesting that a comprehensive capital taxation series of measures could be introduced to produce the following: a tax on wealth to produce £25 million; a capital gains and acquisitions tax to produce £25 million; a land zoning development levy to produce £15 million and an income-related selective property tax to produce £20 million. This gives a total of £85 million. I will refer in detail to two of those measures for the purpose of clarification.
Dublin County Council have witnessed the spectacle during the past year of acres of land being rezoned by a combination of Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael councillors. In the opinion of the technical advisers this land was incapable of being developed or serviced for the foreseeable future; yet, in relation to such a parcel of land on the north side of Dublin city, in the vicinity of Swords, it was estimated that its agricultural pre zoning value was in the region of a maximum £3,000 to £4,000 per acre. Even with the restriction that there would be no services available in the foreseeable future and, therefore, no planning permission its value had increased to at least £25,000 per acre. There has been an extraordinary queue of landowners, farmers and land assemblers knocking on the door of the houses of councillors and local authorities and Dublin County Council in particular will testify to the continuous representations made in relation to getting land rezoned. Apparently the market is extraordinarily buoyant and, I suggest, extraordinarily flush and generous with its money.
We propose that the land zoning development levy would be made at the point of the decision to zone. If a person petitions to have his land zoned and if the value is increased — the problem now in local authorities is that far too much land is zoned — the decision at the time of zoning would be the point when the value changes from agricultural use to development use. This would have the advantage of raising capital legitimately in those areas where there was to be redevelopment in a constructive manner and the additional benefit of discouraging in a very effective way speculative rezoning that has effectively destroyed the planning of Dublin county and, as a consequence, made nonsense of any attempt to plan the city of Dublin and for its growing population with any sense of coherence. Members who campaigned in the Dublin West by-election will recognise the type of nightmare legacy we have constructed and will bequeath to our children.
The Minister could adopt that suggestion which would produce £15 million approximately. It would hurt a lot of Fianna Fáil supporters but it would bring in money that could be taken off the load the PAYE sector have to bear. It would be hard for Fianna Fáil to accept another tax which we are proposing since they abolished rates on all dwellings, narrowed the property tax base and total tax base in such a way that it was the workers who carried the tax burden because nobody else was carrying it by the time the extraordinary O'Donoghue — Colley package was introduced. Deputy Colley is the man who discovered honesty in the back benches of Fianna Fáil. We are proposing that the income-related selective property tax apply to the second home and some family homes. It is an extraordinary testament to the division of wealth here that one can propose such a tax in these days when there are approximately 30,000 homeless on local authority housing lists. On the basis of our estimate an income-related selective property tax would produce a yield of up to £20 million.
We will be looking for support from all sides of the House for that change. I presume that the overall budget and deficit strategy is being maintained. We are talking about a package of approximately £85 million and that could be transferred from the PAYE sector to this section. If a Fianna Fáil Deputy wishes to say why he does not want a land zoning tax or why he does not want holiday homes taxed he should say so; that is what democracy is all about. That Deputy should then try to explain at a clinic why it is that housing lists are so long on one side of the fence and why some people can have two houses. He should explain at those clinics why Fianna Fáil are not prepared to tax those people. I am not talking about taking the second house from such people, I am not totally naive, but I am asking Fianna Fáil to be a little just. I challenge Fianna Fáil Deputies, since honesty is something that has now been discovered in the back benches where the Colley faction sit, and since Deputy McCreevy outside the House can make such points like Deputy Colley, to tell us why they are not prepared to support the measure I have suggested.
If democracy is on the wane and if people are becoming cynical about the machinations of politics — it is my view that that is happening — this is the place where we should be discussing this openly and honestly. Indeed, this is the place where not just the press should be but where the TV cameras and the radio should be so that ordinary people can hear what is being said, or more to the point, what is not said. That is one area where the shift in the taxation burden should be. The Bill is designed to give effect to the budget which was designed to give an indication of the Government's response to the economic problems that confront us. Regrettably for all of us that is not the case. It is regrettable for our working people, and the number of people who do not work in some shape or form is small. It is my understanding that at least 80 per cent of the population depend on their economic activity on a daily basis in order to survive. If we do not do something the situation will get worse.
I am saddened, though not surprised, that the Bill does not contain anything that could be presented as going down the road of introducing equity and justice in the system in a substantial manner. I am referring to anything Fianna Fáil put into the Bill because the progressive parts are the legacy of the last administration, an administration that some Members saw fit to attack and vote against. Tonight we will have an interesting transformation by people who voted against progressive legislation now voting for it. That is the democratic choice of The Workers' Party but it should be seen by the public that that is what they have decided to do.
The decision to abandon totally the idea of discretionary trust is undoubtedly in deference to the growing wealthy section. The proposal to introduce the legislation was brought in by a majority Fine Gael-Labour Coalition. If The Workers Party want to be honest about their criticism they should tell the public how they can make a criticism against that Coalition which intended dispelling and removing that capacity for people to retain wealth and evade any type of taxation measure and how its abolition or removal by Fianna Fáil will get their support. In my view that is opportunistic voting and it is right to describe it as such. There may be a reason for it and it is up to The Workers Party Members to respond and tell the House and the country what the reason is. Certainly, the speech by Deputy Gallagher did not attempt to give that reason because it was not referred to.
The country's difficulties can only be resolved by a system of economic planning supported by the majority of our people. With our type of democracy, our type of constituencies where the constituency work of a local Member is as much a contributory factor in their election success as are the policies of political parties at head office, any type of economic policy presented for the support of the people must have a significant degree of consensus. Ideologies in all parties — we all have them, people who always know best but never have to be elected, the theorists, the think-tank boys, the specialists who know precisely what should be done and then have the honour and privilege of being able to tell somebody else go out and do it — must realise that there has to be public support on a broad basis for economic policies.
The divisions that the Fianna Fáil Government introduced into the economy in 1977 between the farmer and the worker on the one hand and the self-employed and the PAYE worker on the other and between different kinds of industries have broken down and damaged that potential consensus in such a way that the trade union movement have found it increasingly difficult to get support among their workers for national wage agreements. The Labour Party have always supported the concept of national wage agreements, as has the official leadership of the trade union movement. It is an essential and integral part of economic planning to have some form of understanding of what wage costs are likely to be in any industry over a period of time so that the law of the jungle between weak and strong sectors does not prevail. If you do not have national wage agreements it would be impossible to undertake long-term planning projects. It is only through long-term projects that we will get the kind of increase in productive wealth that is essential for the provision of jobs. Every budget and every Finance Bill have a direct relation to the ability of the trade union movement to obtain a national wage agreement; that is the workers' most constructive contribution to economic growth, in addition to their own productivity.
The workforce over the last five to six years, led by the trade union movement, have made an extraordinary contribution in terms of productivity and ceding a substiantial portion of the wealth that they create to the Government and to employers. That is done in the form of deferred payments and reduced increases relative to the rate of inflation or, in some cases, relative to the profits of the firm. Yet, Fianna Fáil in particular have consistently refused to radically change or transform the legislation relating to companies or provisions in financial legislation that will enable the workforce to have access to the accounts of companies so that the workforce can participate positively and constructively in the long-term future of the firm. It has been compounded in a whole range of ways by creating divisions so that the co-operation of the workforce is now far less available than it was two, three or four years ago. Anyone involved in the trade union movement knows that there is growing resentment to the concept of national wage agreements. The trade unions believe — and I support the view — that if we break down that consensus, not only will the working people in general be damaged because the economy will be further undermined, but, within the workforce, the most vulnerable sections will suffer most.
I am concerned that this Bill does not provide for making available the information that workers will need in order to assess the financial position of their company. Perhaps we will discuss it in greater detail on Committee Stage but I am concerned that the options for profit sharing and for taking up shares as part of the financial take that a workforce would have in lieu of cash, in order to facilitate the cash flow and the general economic performance or survival of the company, in contrast to the impression in the budget speech, will only be confined to those companies that are publicly quoted on the Irish stock exchange or companies that are owned in whole or in part by publicly quoted stock exchange companies. I think the House will realise that the list of companies in the Irish stock exchange is not exhaustive and would only cover a tiny part of the workforce. Therefore, this Bill fails in what should be the task of every financial resolution and Bill introduced in the House, the objective of introducing equity and fairness into our taxation system and also creating a climate within which the workforce can willingly operate and see that their future is being secured in a reasonable way. There is no evidence, regrettably, to the satisfaction of the Labour Party that this legislation is moving in that direction.
There is continued opposition among many employers to the EEC Fourth Division which would establish the rights of workers to have access to the financial information of their companies albeit in a very mild form because, like many EEC measures, it is the product of compromise and consensus and does not go far enough. Significantly, however, it goes further than any of the legislation on our Statute Books. That will not produce the kind of support which the trade union movement needs within its own ranks to get co-operation among its own workers to give the kind of productivity that is needed in the large public sector. If we confine ourselves to the public sector, where there has been much industrial trouble on the question of wages because of the impostion of PAYE, it is essential that this or any Government can clearly be seen by that sector to be introducing equity and balance in their financial measures generally and particularly in the financial Bills introduced in this House.
Because that is not there, the capability of using the public sector as the engine for economic growth — which in the official view of the Labour Party and of The Workers' Party, is the only substantial productive element in the economy under Irish control with the capital reserves capable of that development, with the full co-operation of the workforce — is being damaged because of the refusal by the Government to introduce the kind of balance and equity that is needed in the financial provisions. I made that point at some length because I want to give notice to the Minister that it is our intention to introduce amendments to try to make changes in that area. I hope the Minister will be open to reason on this because, without it, we are not going to get the kind of economic response in the short term that we desperately need.
The Labour Party opposed the auctioneering politics that emerged in 1976-77. Immediately after the 1977 election, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Colley came into the House and said that the economic policies of that time, of the bonanza days of throwing money around, would not work and that at the end of the day we would, in real terms, be worse off than when we started. I used the analogy that it was like borrowing money to bet on a horse in the belief that you had a sure winner but that at the end of the day not only did the horse lose but you were left with having to pay back the money you had borrowed in the first place. The only problem was that it was not Fianna Fáil money which was on the horse, it was money that the Irish people were legally responsible for. It is because of that extraordinary taxation debt that now hangs around the neck of the country in the form of foreign borrowing and debts that we are in our present situation. Therefore, the realistic room for manoeuvre that Fianna Fáil have in this present economic climate is very constrained and tight.
We are learning all the time, as we did in yesterday's Adjournment Debate, of secret deals and arrangements which make that situation worse. Therefore, on behalf of the Labour Party, I call on the Minister to do a serious rethink on Committee Stage — it is quite obvious that some rethinking will have to be done — and to increase in a general way the level of capital taxation so as to be able to reduce the burden on the PAYE taxpayers; to look seriously at the question of bringing farmers more into the taxation net than they are at present. It is really scandalous to see the low level of money the farmers continue to refuse to pay. Finally, I want him to amend the legislation in relation to access to companies so that workers and their trade unions can clearly see the financial situation of the place in which they work and in which they have a stake so that they can take responsible decisions as the vast majority of them wish to do in order to secure their jobs, expand their plants and create new jobs for their sons and daughters and indeed for their grandchildren.
Comment on this
We are now debating the final stages of the Finance Bill to give effect to the budget introduced by the present Minister for Finance on 27 March. This is the third economic debate on the budget this year. What this country needs now is not another economic debate but a general election. This House and the public have completely lost faith in the present Government who will turn, twist, bend and go back on their word; they will give way to any pressure group. This was quite clearly demonstrated for the past month when they did anything to avoid walking through the lobbies of the House. They are completely in the hands of Sinn Féin the Workers' Party.
Comment on this
I am sorry; I forgot that they changed the name. They may change the name but I do not think the leopard changes his spots. "A rose by any other name..." For the past 24 hours we have had speculation in the House, rumours and counter rumours, and a report in The Irish Times this morning headed, “Minister Talks To T.D. 's On Demands”— not requests or representations but “demands”. I understand that on the news bulletin tonight it was stated that The Workers' Party said they had met Deputy MacSharry again today and issued some kind of a statement whether they were satisfied with his point of view or not — I did not hear it myself so that I cannot quote accurately. If a deal had been hammered out I was sure it would be announced before the conclusion of this debate today. Deputy FitzGerald——
Comment on this
I should like to point out that The Workers' Party Deputies are not responsible for speculation in the media.
Comment on this
I categorically deny that any agreement of any kind has been made between Fianna Fáil and The Workers' Party. That is to put the record straight.
Comment on this
That is fine. I am satisfied with what Deputy De Rossa has said. I was about to say that when Deputy FitzGerald questioned the Minister about it tonight the Minister denied that any deal had been hammered out. If that is so I think the Minister is quite right. It would be wasting his time and further diminishing the credibility of his Government if he came to a deal or accepted amendments from The Workers' Party next week because the Government are in no danger from them. They will trot into the lobby with the Government any time they are wanted because they are as much afraid of the voice of the people as the Fianna Fáil Party. I think the Minister should not further dismantle the budget and the Finance Bill by giving away or accepting amendments that may come from that source in the next fortnight because they are no threat. If the Government want them to vote with them or to abstain, they will do so. We shall have an example of that later tonight. This group of people who profess themselves to be so concerned for the working class will vote tonight for a Finance Bill that dismantles many of the good points alluded to by the Minister in his budget speech because this Finance Bill is certainly a dilution of the budget as delivered by the Minister on 27 March. I think it is true that probably never anywhere in the world has there been such a change between the budget as introduced and the Bill as presented to the House.
We cannot continue under this Government unless they get a bit of backbone. It is for that reason I said at the outset that we should have a general election now to clear the air. Unfortunately, I think there is no danger of that happening because the Government will not be defeated on anything that would warrant a general election because my friends on my right who profess to be on the left will not vote against them.
Comment on this
I tried to emphasise it but perhaps Deputy Barry did not hear me say it: there is clearly no alternative. Deputy Barry and Fine Gael are not going to offer one.
Comment on this
If the Taoiseach had won Dublin West he would not be talking to The Workers' Party at all; he would not want to see them.
Comment on this
I am a bit surprised, I must admit, that The Workers' Party will not have the courage to vote against the Government. I should have thought that if they were so confident in their policies and the support they were getting — we had the boasting by Deputy Gallagher tonight about a 100 per cent increase in their vote in Dublin West — they would be anxious to gather a similar increase in their vote in all other parts of the country. They should be the ones bursting for a general election after Dublin West if they were so confident that they would have this large measure of support from the people. But, as I say, there is no danger. I do not think we should be surprised that the Government, lacking the political courage to face the people——
Comment on this
I am anxiously waiting to hear the Deputy's alternative budget proposals. They do not seem to be coming.
Comment on this
Our alternative budget proposals were put to this House and the people in the last general election, and our vote increased. We have more of a mandate from the people for our budget proposals than the kind of waffle and airy fairy ideological nonsense being spouted here. Deputy Gallagher when speaking — I cannot find it in his script; perhaps because I did not study it carefully enough — referred to the fact that the Ard Comhairle of his party were deciding what to do. That is very interesting.
Comment on this
We should not be surprised at the reluctance of Fianna Fáil to face the electorate because I think the leader of that party has demonstrated in his period of leadership that he is far stronger with words than with deeds. Here it is necessary to go back because we are talking about the same time bracket, from the time Deputy Haughey assumed office until today because it has all had an effect. We all remember and I think many of us breathed a sigh of relief secretly when we heard the then Taoiseach and the present Taoiseach on television in February 1980 listing out coherently and authoritatively what was wrong with the economy, and telling us what it was necessary to do to put it right. That was the promise of February 1980, and that withered away into the reality of the disgraceful Talbot deal in May 1981, prior to the general election. Anybody with that sort of record was rightly thrown out of office despite the fact of having a 20-seat majority at the time. The Taoiseach had clearly and correctly listed the faults in the economy but had taken no action to rectify them. He had let the situation drift, having brought in a disgraceful budget and Finance Bill in 1981. If Fianna Fáil did not have the courage to tackle the problems at a time when they had a 20-seat majority, how can we expect them to tackle them now when they are in a minority position? These problems have been compounded since the recent change of Government. This Finance Bill is simply the last chapter of what has been going on since the 1981 General Election. It was obvious to us on our election last year that problems had to be tackled urgently and courageously. Within three weeks of being returned to office we produced a budget which, as Deputy Gallagher admitted this evening, was justified having regard to the extent to which Fianna Fáil in office had damaged the economy. In our seven or eight months in office we attempted to set about righting that damage by cutting public expenditure in every Department. Our budget of January last was the result of eight months of exhaustive and heartbreaking tackling of the Estimates for every Department. We are told that that budget was too harsh. It was certainly too harsh for Deputies Kemmy, Loftus and Sherlock, who voted against it. In the event we lost the vote and went to the country on the basis of that budget. We used the slogan "Garret is Right".
Comment on this
We did not modify the budget. We said that we would not impose the tax on children's shoes and clothes but we pointed to where we would raise the alternative revenue. This was spelled out clearly, unlike the situation in respect of the £45 million concession in respect of PRSI. Our budget was put intact to the people. We increased our vote but we had even a more significant impact on that election campaign. We forced Fianna Fáil — against, I suspect, the wishes of their leader — to admit that our approach was correct and that they would abide by the thrust of our proposals in relation to borrowing deficit and so on. I suspect that that line was forced on the Taoiseach by the Minister for Education and the Minister for Trade, Commerce and Tourism. At various press conferences held prior to the election it was obvious that a prominent part was being played by the Minister for Education.
Comment on this
A deal, which according to Deputy Colley was not discussed by the Fianna Fáil Front Bench, was drawn up between the Taoiseach and Deputy Gregory on the basis of Deputy Gregory voting for Deputy Haughey on his nomination as Taoiseach. My friends of The Workers' Party then got themselves into a lather of sweat when they found they had been outmanouevred, despite all their backroom boys, their Ard Comhairle and their 200 per cent increase in membership, by an Independent. They had to join the happy throng through the lobby in the hope that they might pick some of the crumbs from the rich man's table.
Comment on this
I appreciate that all this is very hurtful to Deputy Sherlock but he should remain quiet. He has had his opportunity to speak.
Comment on this
The leader of this party does not need any advice from me in dealing with The Workers' Party. He knew exactly what they were at.
Comment on this
What surprised me was how little knowledge Deputy Barry had of the Department for which he was responsible.
Comment on this
The Workers' Party trotted in like tame dogs hoping for a few crumbs from the rich man's table and so Deputy Haughey became Taoiseach. We come now to the intriguing part in all this, to the man who had played such a prominent part in Fianna Fáil's economic strategy for the previous six to eight months and who had taken such a prominent part in drawing that party's economic programme for the election. I refer to one who appeared so often in front of the television cameras as the financial guru of the party and who, having been restored to the Front Bench is now Minister for Education. Apparently the Taoiseach considered that there had been enough of that kind of nonsense.
Comment on this
He was made not the Minister for Finance but Minister for Education and so we are back once more at the old unhappy phrase of "spend all" and it does not matter where the money comes from. The tragedy about this is that both Ministers, Deputy O'Malley and Deputy O'Donoghue, were correct when they saw that the public did appreciate what we have been trying to do. More importantly they saw that unless the strategy we had evolved was followed through, the result for the country would be larger deficits, more borrowing, increased inflation, fewer jobs with the inevitable consequence of having to finance that policy not just this year or next year but for decades to come.
The present Government then introduced a budget and, reasonably enough, the Minister for Finance, Deputy MacSharry, said he had to introduce that budget in a hurry. That budget was introduced on 25 March. Now the civil servants in the Department of Finance naturally thought that the Minister, Deputy O'Donoghue, and the Taoiseach actually meant what they said during the election and they could go ahead on the basis of what was said and prepare a budget on that basis. Of course, once the pressure mounted on the Cabinet from their own back benches, from Deputy Gregory, from Sinn Féin The Workers Party, and God knows who else outside this House, they bent once more and brought in this Finance Bill which bears very little relation to the budget they introduced in March. The variation is something which has never been experienced so far in this country and I would think it is something which has never obtained in any other country either.
The Second Stage of this Finance Bill will be passed tonight. Deputy Gallagher has said they have a long list of amendments drafted and I think it is reasonable to assume that these amendments probably formed the basis of whatever discussions took place yesterday and today. I want the Minister to say tonight when he rises to reply to this debate precisely what amendments he proposes to introduce on Committee Stage and precisely what further changes he envisages on Committee Stage. What sections does he intend to change? What amendments does he intend making? I also want to know whether he proposes to accept any of those amendments which The Workers' Party showed him yesterday and today. Such an important measure as this should be debated and agreed on in this House and not elsewhere. I shall leave it at that. The Minister has assured me he has not dealt with The Workers' Party and, as I said earlier on, if he has not made a deal he is wise because they will vote for him anyway. They are afraid of the people and they will trot dutifully into the division lobby to make sure they do not have to face the public again.
Comment on this
This scenario I have been painting has been quite clearly interpreted by the former Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Deputy Colley. He gave an interview to a newspaper and to Radio Éireann the Sunday after the by-election. He did not want to rock the Fianna Fáil boat and so he kept his mouth shut until after the by-election.
Comment on this
Indeed that was the content of his interview with both the newspaper and on radio. Now Deputy Colley cannot have it both ways. He and whatever friends he has in the Fianna Fáil Party should make up their minds. Either they show that they do not approve of low standards in high places or they shut up. They should not curry favour with sections of the Fianna Fáil Party who disapprove of their present leader or seek publicity for themselves and, at the same time, continue to support that of which they disapprove. The only result of this is to give a hollow ring to their protestations.
Furthermore, if the Ministers, Deputy O'Donoghue and Deputy O'Malley had any courage, if they believed what they were saying during the general election, then they should now resign from the Government. That would be the correct position for them to adopt. Deputy Colley has portrayed himself vehemently and articulately on two occasions recently and on one occasion earlier on as the defender of purity in Irish public life. He should now put his feet where his mouth is but I have no faith in that happening at all. If he is as pure as he likes to portray himself he has an obligation to those friends of his on the backbenches of Fianna Fáil and to those many supporters in the party outside this House — it is a dwindling body of supporters, very obviously dwindling because the more changes that are made and the more variations that occur demonstrate clearly how the Government are being pushed around by every small group, every faction, every Independent, and by The Workers' Party — to demonstrate clearly his purity. The patently dwindling support to which I have referred will be clearly shown in any general election this Government care to call.
Protestations of virtue from Deputy Colley ring a little hollow. Deputy Colley was the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance who oversaw the implementation of the famous 1977 manifesto from which many of our present problems flow. More significantly, he was Tánaiste of a Government who in November 1980 fought a by-election in Donegal where more strokes were pulled and more promises made than even in Dublin West last month. To pretend that he was not party to them or did not approve of them or has a post-disapproval now is less than honest.
Comment on this
If there are people in Fianna Fáil who believe, as Deputy Colley does, that strokes and promised and low standards in high places should not be part of public life now is the time to walk or else shut up. They can walk through those lobbies and vote down this Bill on Second Stage, and the amendment in Deputy Bruton's name quite clearly points out the reason why they should do it.
Comment on this
It boomeranged, as Deputy L'Estrange says. After doubling with The Workers' Party — I cannot get the name Sinn Féin out of my mind — of course it is a fact that Deputy Liam Skelly is in this House and you can double your votes as often as you like as long as we win the seats. That is the reality of politics. As I say, Deputy Colley is equally responsible with all those members of Fianna Fáil who were members of Fianna Fáil Governments from 1977 until last June and again for the last three months but he is more responsible than some of the others because he was a member of the Government whose leader sorted out what was wrong with the economy and then refused to do anything about it between January 1980 and the 1981 General Election. The result of their doing nothing about it was the losing of a 20-seat majority in this House, unheard of in politics in this country. That shows what the people thought about what they were doing and I know the people are thinking precisely the same at this moment. Deputy Colley did not open his mouth either about Knock Airport — and he was a Minister of the Government — nor about the famous Talbot deal about which we heard this morning nor about the Gregory deal — at least he did but after the by-election when he was out of office — nor about the Clondalkin Paper Mills or all the other strokes which took place when he was a member of the Government. Deputy George Colley is a nice man. In many of the portfolios he occupied he was a good Minister. There is no questioning his patriotism, but he cannot, nor should he attempt to, criticise others for what he was part of himself.
This Finance Bill continues on the same spendthrift, low standards that Deputy Colley was objecting to. They were giving in to any pressures, and the changes that were made between the budget and the Finance Bill are obviously a result of pressures by those various groups. The Minister denies, and I repeat his denial to put it on the record of the House again, that there is any deal between The Workers' Party and the Government about amendments that may be accepted in the next fortnight on this Finance Bill.
Comment on this
I want to repeat the denial that any deal was done because we want that in the next fortnight and we want to see the Minister's attitude to that too. The reality will then be proved that Fianna Fáil are not the Government. For the first month Deputy Gregory was the Government and from now on until the by-election no doubt we will have The Workers' Party in government. They will tell the Government what to do, they will call the shots. The extraordinary thing about this Bill — again I cannot understand the attitude of The Workers' Party to it — is that any changes that have been made in it since the budget have been to help the well off——
Comment on this
——and not the less well off about whom The Workers Party are weeping tears here tonight. Regarding the changes in company cars, that perhaps was too severe and I think they were right, but the less well off do not have company cars. I do not know if The Workers' Party provide them but most people on the dole do not have company cars. The change in capital gains tax I will be interested to hear when we come to that in the Bill. Deputy Gallagher was eloquent about that change as he was in defending the rights of the workers here tonight and the restoration of the tax relief on money borrowed. I cannot see how that would help those who are less well off. They do not normally have overdrafts and perhaps they do not have mortgages either and are in rented accommodation. Deputy Gallagher says that the changes in the Finance Bill are to their benefit. Even the changes since the budget in the PRSI hardly help the lower level of taxpayers because it is given as an allowance. That means it is worth 60p to anybody in the 60 per cent bracket and only 25p to anyone in the 25 per cent bracket. Yet The Workers' Party these defenders of the underprivileged, will troop into the Fianna Fáil lobbies and vote for this.
Leaving aside the absolutely inadequate explanation of the Minister as to where he is to get the money for the £45 million — forget about it, we will get it from savings or from increased taxation — they will vote for the concession that helps the better off PAYE payers against the worse off PAYE payers and they will come along in a month's time and vote for the taxation necessary to pay for it. If that is consistency and what their Ard Comhairle are telling them, they should seek other advice. I do not think that is very consistent policy. The Minister says that he will get this £45 million that he referred to either by cuts, public expenditure or increased taxation. I must express grave doubts about the willingness of any Fianna Fáil Minister for Finance to cut public expenditure because during their four years in office from 1977 to 1981 their policy was the absolute reverse and they increased public expenditure. I do not think that leopard will change his spots now. They boasted about the policy of Deputy Martin O'Donoghue to increase the numbers employed in the public sector and to increase the level of public sector spending, now at 60 per cent, one of the highest in the world. I do not have any faith in the nerve of Fianna Fáil to cut that.
I should like to say something about public sector pay. We have all had a go in recent years at the increase in public sector pay but it is only fair to say that individual civil servants have not received pay increases which are out of line with what has been paid in the private sector. What has happened is that the number of people employed in the public sector has grown because of Fianna Fáil policies to an extent which is absolutely unwarranted for a country of this size. Every person employed in the public sector must to a large extent be carried by taxation gathered from those outside the public sector.
If policies are adopted which interfere with industry, the creation of jobs and the willingness of people to invest and if at the same time the public sector is expanded, then the country is on the road to disaster. I do not see any change in Fianna Fáil policy in this regard or any willingness on their part to cut back on the cost of running the country. Neither do I see any willingness on their part to do anything to help the creation or the preservation of the jobs which are so necessary outside the public sector. The reverse is the case. The policies in this Finance Bill, enunciated by the Minister in his budget speech and originally part of the Fianna Fáil programme in the general election, will discourage investment and close businesses.
It is unreal in a time of recession to expect firms not only to pay this year whatever corporation profits tax they will owe for next year but also to impose VAT on imports at the point of entry. This will have the effect of putting into the hands of the liquidator many firms who are at present finding trading extremely difficult. The Minister's solution for this bite into their cash flow is to tell them to borrow, saying that he will arrange for the ICC, through the European Investment Bank, to assist them to raise the money. What help is that to a firm who are breaking even or making losses? What encouragement is to to them to stay in business when all the Minister is doing is increasing their losses by asking them to pay interest on the money they borrow or wiping out their profits? What person in the private sector, to which we continually pay lip service, will invest in those circumstances? The cash needed to run businesses is being drained away.
Money is to be borrowed from banks who are at the same time facing an increased levy, thus diminishing the pool of resources they have to lend to anybody considering investing. Perhaps it is too strong to say that this is a receipe for disaster but it is certainly not the action of a Government or a Minister genuinely concerned with creating jobs and encouraging investment. This is the action of somebody who wants to blunder through as best he can for this year only and let tomorrow look after itself. As a result of the attitude of this Government and this Minister, we are building up problems for 1983 and 1984 which would test even the loyalty of The Workers' Party to vote for Fianna Fáil. They want Fianna Fáil to stay in office for another five years so that they can keep twisting their tails and making them jump through their hoops. They certainly do not want us returned to office.
Comment on this
The state of the economy was best summed up by the Minister when he said that 58 per cent of the projected budget for 1982 has been used up in the first quarter and 100 per cent of it will be used up by June. He said it would be substantially exceeded in the third quarter but he went on to say that of course the final quarter would take care of everything because the receipts would flow into the Exchequer.
Comment on this
I do not know if the Minister believes that. I am certain that those who are advising him do not believe it and I presume some of the amounts he has included in his calculations are to accrue from the down payments of VAT at the point of entry and the bringing forward of corporation profits tax from next year. The Minister should have a chat with the Revenue Commissioners and they will tell him from how many firms it will be possible to obtain this year corporation profits tax due in 1983. They will tell him how much his cash flow will be improved for the last quarter of this year from that source. Does the Minister not listen? Does he not talk to industrialists? Does he not hear the views of the Confederation of Irish Industry or the Federated Union of Employers? Does he not understand that practically every employer in the private sector is short of funds at present, is overdrawn to the hilt, is terrified of the inflationary effects of what is happening and, more than that is terrified of this Government staying in office? Nobody whether an employee, a public sector worker or employer has any faith in this Government as presently constituted to take hard decisions and tackle the problems of the economy so that we can all have a share of the cake which the Workers' Party dish out without any thought as to how it should be made.
If the Government continue on the road they are going, they will damage their own party and that does not worry me. What worries me is that they will damage people's faith in democratic Government and that they will damage the economy to such an extent that their children may be unemployed. The majority of us in the House went to secondary school and left knowing we would get a job. The way the Government are managing our affairs, our children have no such guarantee. They are wrecking the economy and the future for young people. For God's sake let them get out and go to the country before they do any more damage.
Comment on this
I should like to thank all Deputies who contributed to the debate. As I said at the outset of the debate, the measures continued in the Bill were complex and incorporated a number of changes in the taxation code. The comments made by Members were wide and varied and I cannot hope in the time available to me to answer all of them. I have taken careful note of all that has been said during the course of the debate and shall reply to the major issues raised.
I should like to deal with a few points made by Deputies Quinn and Barry. One of the points made by Deputy Barry was that he wanted me to say now what amendments I will be introducing to the Bill. The simple answer to that at this stage, as anyone involved or closely associated with finance will know, is that it is not possible to say what amendments will be made. Deputy Bruton knows that well. I have been consulted by officials in the Department to the effect that there are various recommendations they will be making to me regarding possible amendments, mainly for technical reasons. That is normal in any Finance Bill. It was referred to on a few ocassions and Deputy De Rossa has already replied to it. I confirm that. The only real contact that one has had in relation to possible amendment on this Bill has been by Deputy Bruton who has been in correspondence with me and has had some contact with officials in the Department. I want to make that position quite clear.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): The Minister must be going to introduce an early suplementary budget.
Comment on this
That is the position. If the Deputy does not like the facts I am sorry. I should like to refer to a point made by Deputy Quinn which was the extension of the youth employment levy to farmers and the self-employed. Farmers and the self-employed are already provided for under existing legislation in regard to the collection of the levy which was passed by this House under the Coalition Government last December. Farmers pay their contribution through the health contribution scheme and the self-employed through the income tax system.
At the beginning of the debate, Deputy Bruton put forward a motion opposing the Second Stage on a number of grounds. These were, first, that the Bill departs significantly from the terms of the budget; secondly, PRSI concessions were unfairly distributed; thirdly, some tax measures will add to our economic difficulties and, fourthly, no provision is made for long-term reform of the income tax system. During the course of the discussion, I intend to refute, point by point, the arguments put forward by him.
The Finance Bill does not depart significantly from the terms of the budget. The only major difference relates to the special PRSI allowance which has already been approved by Dáil Éireann and is simply confirmed in the Bill. The other changes vis-á-vis the budget have a total cost of only £2½ million.
Comment on this
This small cost underlines that they are relatively insignificant in the overall context.
Comment on this
If the Deputy is so concerned about additional costs, it is hardly logical that he should seek a higher exemption from development land tax than the £15,000 which is proposed.
It is nonsense for Deputy Bruton and others to talk about changes in budgets. We know that the budget introduced on 27 January was significantly changed as we went into the general election. Following the election, it was again changed substantially in discussions with various groups in the House. The extent of those changes was much more significant than what is suggested in these measures which amount to £2½ million. The Deputy demanded that I should let the House know, when replying to the debate, what the net cost for 1983 would be of the changes now being made vis-á-vis the budget proposals. The full year cost will probably be in the region of £10 million to £15 million. I cannot be more precise than that. I must make it clear that the bulk of this cost arises in relation to two major changes and these are the benefit in kind provisions relating to the private use of company cars and the proposals for mortgage interest relief. Even with the changes I have made, the revised provision for the benefit in kind will still give a higher yield than the scheme put forward by the previous Government.
Changes in the mortgage interest relief provisions have been necessary, as I pointed out, for technical administrative reasons. The Revenue Commissioners advised me that they were not in a position to implement the proposals as originally announced. These proposals would have involved three separate and unrelated restrictions. There would have been a limit of £4,800 on the old interest qualifying for relief, a limit of £35,000 on the capital sum in respect of which new interest was to be relieved and a maximum rate of 35 per cent on which relief was to be given on the new interest.
It was not found possible to devise a satisfactory method of incorporating these unrelated restrictions in certificates of tax-free allowances for PAYE purposes. The only alternative would have been to apply the restrictions by way of review at the end of the year. Apart from the huge increases in staff required to review up to 230,000 PAYE cases where interest relief is claimed, this would have caused inconvenience and, in some instances, hardship to the taxpayers concerned in collecting under-deductions of income-tax. However, I shall be looking further at this relief at a later stage.
Deputies Desmond and Taylor suggested that the relief might be phased out over a period of years. I believe this suggestion has some merit. I was accused by Deputy Bruton of showing a lamentable lack of imagination because I did not exempt low-paid workers entirely from the PRSI increases. These increases were proposed originally by the previous Government; that should not be forgotten by Deputies opposite. They include a 1 per cent levy on income to promote youth employment. When this concept was originally floated there was mention of an exemption for those on low incomes — I may say "mention" at that time — but no such exemption was incorporated in the legislation brought forward last December by the Coalition Government for the implementation of this levy. I wonder where was Deputy Bruton's imagination then? While it is quite true that those with higher incomes will generally receive higher benefit from the PRSI tax allowances it must be borne in mind that these people are making a higher PRSI contribution and are paying more taxes. I should say that the entire PRSI changes were introduced exactly as proposed by the Coalition Government. Now, when a major concession is given by our Government to ease the burden, I suggest the last people to complain are those in the Fine Gael Party.
Comment on this
We did not produce a phantom £45 million out of nowhere, unexplained, to give concessions. If they are going to give concessions they should give them in a fair way, not the way they are doing it.
Comment on this
Well, there is a lot more being done than what the Deputy proposed doing, which is the nub of the question; that is the point.
Comment on this
The motion opposing the Second Reading rejects the Finance Bill because it does not provide for the reform of the income tax system. The income tax changes which were announced in the budget, and were incorporated in this Bill, are carefully designed to achieve virtually the same effects for individual taxpayers generally as the tax credit proposals of January. This can be clearly illustrated if we take a range of individual taxpayers. In the time available to me my ambition was to give the individual taxpayer the same treatment as was proposed by the Fine Gael and Labour budget. This I have done. It is wrong to suggest that the tax arrangements in the Bill offend against social justice while, at the same time, pressing the case for the tax credit proposals of 27 January last. There is one difference and this relates to the family income supplement. This supplement was seen as a support to families where the breadwinner was in low income employment. It was estimated to cost £4 million this year. It must be remembered that although this scheme was advertised widely, the response was very poor; approximately one-eighth only of those eligible applied for the £9.60 payment. It created serious anomalies. Because of the minimum income eligibility limit of £2,000, it would have led to a situation where a family with taxable earnings of £2,000 would have qualified for a subsidy of £500 but a family with taxable earnings of £1,900 would have been entitled to nothing. Also large sections of the community would have been ineligible for benefit — single persons, widows and widowers, one-parent families, the elderly, social welfare recipients, farmers under £40 valuation and all those whose taxable income for one reason or another fell below £2,000. Furthermore, the £500 would have been available to a very wealthy taxpayer who, because of accelerated capital allowances and other business reliefs was able to show a taxable income of £2,000 only for a particular year. In the event, the £4 million was set aside in the March budget for the child dependants of social welfare recipients so that the money is finding its way to the low income families.
There will be no anomalies and I must suggest that this is a more equitable and effective way of distributing income than was the proposed family income supplement.
Comment on this
The impression is now developing that the tax credits are good per se and that the tax allowance system is totally inadequate. Tax credits are equated with tax reform. This is a dangerous assumption. I must advise caution when discussing the merits of one system vis-à-vis the other. There is no reason that tax credits should be inherently better than allowances. There is one criterion only that really matters when measuring the effects of different systems, that is the impact on the individual taxpayer. The particular structure of the tax system is secondary to the overriding consideration that all taxpayers must be treated in an equitable fashion. Equity means that those who have more should pay more. Superficially the tax credit emerges as a more equitable system because it shows an equal distribution of reliefs irrespective of an individual's marginal rate of tax but its weakness is that it makes no adjustment for the fact that the taxpayer on a higher rate is paying more tax in the first instance and, consequently, has a claim to relatively high reliefs in certain circumstances. This is a reality we cannot set aside in measuring the impact of tax changes. If we ignore it we shall create new anomalies which will further annoy taxpayers.
There is no evidence to suggest, as implied in the amending motion, that the new arrangements for value-added tax on imports and for the earlier payments of corporation profits tax will aggravate national economic difficulties. The liquidity cost of these changes on business will not be severe. The overall annual cost to business, in terms of liquidity cost, is not expected to exceed £10 million to £15 million, so that the adverse effects of the new system are being grossly exaggerated.
Comment on this
If it transpires that difficulties are experienced in individual cases as regards value-added tax then, as I said in my budget statement, I will examine the possibility of Industrial Credit Company assistance. It should be remembered also that value-added tax on imports will have a strong, positive effect and will give Irish products a boost vis-à-vis imports by removing the advantage which imports are seen to have over home-produced goods under the present system. It will also eliminate considerable tax evasion.
Surely these effects will do much good for the national economy? The new arrangements for value-added-tax on imports and the bringing forward of the payments date of corporation profits tax will not worsen the budget situation in 1983 by using up revenue that otherwise would be available in that year, as alleged by Deputy J. Bruton. This is a misconception, as any revenue brought forward from 1983 to 1982 will be matched by a similar advancement of revenue from 1984 to 1983. This leads me to the assertion by Deputy J. Bruton, that, because of these two measures, we are facing an opening deficit for 1983 somewhere in the region of £1,100 million rather than the £800 million which would have resulted from their January budget proposals. This projected £300 million increase in the deficit is based on the Deputy's misconception of the effect in 1983 of value-added-tax on imports and the corporation profit tax measures and, is, therefore, incorrect. Apart from this, as a former Minister for Finance, the Deputy is aware that any projections made at this time of the year for 1983 inevitably must be based on a wide range of assumptions which can very considerably. I might point out also that the March budget proposals will have a less severe effect on the economy than those of the January budget, so that the underlying state of the economy and, therefore, of the public finances will be better going into 1983.
Deputy Dukes also referred to the collection of VAT at the point of import and, particularly, the cost which he alleges this will involve for exporters. The Deputy is apparently unaware of the special arrangements which are available under the VAT system for traders who are in a permanent net repayment position, that is traders who are continuously claiming back more VAT on their inputs from the Revenue Commissioners than they are due to pay to revenue on their output.
Companies exporting a large proportion of their output would generally be in this position. They are allowed to account for VAT on a monthly rather than a two monthly basis and this facility will continue. Since provision is being made in the VAT on imports scheme for deferment of the payment of VAT to the fifteenth day of the month following the import these companies will effectively be able to repay the VAT around the same time as they are paying it so any liquidity cost involved for them will be minimised.
I am sure it is clear from what I have said that the amendment in the name of Deputy John Bruton is totally negative. I would have expected a more realistic approach, especially from a former Minister for Finance.
Deputy Barry Desmond underlined, with some vivid examples, the problems of cutting public expenditure. He instanced the abolition of food subsidies, reductions in CIE services, the imposition of fees for education and cuts in overtime in the public sector as the kind of actions that would be required to achieve effective results. He is quite right in emphasising that the cutting of expenditure, no matter on how marginal a scale, is a painful exercise. It inevitably requires the curtailment or the ending of services which we take for granted, as our entitlement. If we are not prepared to accept more taxation then reductions in services and much higher fees for services in the only alternative. I agree with the Deputy that our dilemma is that, while people genuinely want reductions in income tax and PRSI, they will not accept the logical consequences of such reductions.
The Deputy suggested alternative taxes which he estimated would yield £200 million or more. I agree with him that we must widen the tax base and find new sources of taxation. I must at the same time dispute his estimate of £200 million from the sources which he has listed. Quite frankly, this is a highly inflated figure. We are only misleading ourselves in assuming that there are large untapped sources of revenue which can allow us to reduce income tax and sustain the high level of public expenditure to which we have become accustomed.
Deputy Dukes took up reference, as well as other speakers tonight, in my opening statement to the quarterly pattern of the current budget deficit this year and implied that I was preparing the ground for revealing significant excesses on the targets set in the budget. This is not so. The purpose of my reference was simply to point out that the quarterly pattern this year will be rather different from previous years because of the high concentration of new revenues in the later months. This pattern would be obvious to anybody who took the time to analyse the budget proposals in detail.
The Deputy also asserted that the March budget targets were never attainable and that they will not be met in view of subsequent decisions on expenditure and revenue. I reject this totally. The targets set in the March budget are realistic and the Government are firmly committed to achieving them. As I have already emphasised, the only significant change which has been made since then is the £45 million income tax concession for PRSI contributions. The cost of this concession will be recouped by expenditure cuts and, if necessary, additional tax measures.
Comment on this
The other changes in the budget provisions are relatively minor in terms of their impact on the current budget deficit. Deputy G. Mitchell this morning castigated the Government because no specific deadline was being set for the elimination of the current budget deficit. He also, by some feat of mathematical juggling, arrived at the fanciful conclusion that we might have been heading for a deficit of £2,000 million this year but for the intervention of the Coalition Government. The Government's commitment to the gradual reduction and elimination of the deficit has been clearly and unequivocally emphasised on a number of occasions. The action taken in the budget is totally consistent with this commitment. We are bringing the deficit down from £802 million in 1981 to a target of £679 million this year. In terms of GNP the deficit is being reduced from 7.9 per cent to 5.6 per cent.
Deputy Mitchell and his colleagues, who are anxious to bring down the budget deficit, should follow through the logic of their conviction and propose specific measures which will achieve this result. While, on the one hand, they are advocating financial prudence they see no inconsistency, apparently, in proposing at the same time specific increases in expenditure and reductions in taxation. We cannot have it both ways.
Comment on this
On a point of order, I did not quite catch the Minister. Did I understand him to say that the current budget deficit would be eliminated over a set period? Did he say that?
Comment on this
I said that the gradual reduction and elimination of the budget deficit has been clearly and unequivocally emphasised on a number of occasions by myself and other members of the Government. Deputy Bruton raised some questions in relation to tax reliefs for approved profit sharing schemes. He was concerned that the relief might be used as a vehicle for tax avoidance by limiting a particular scheme to directors and higher paid executives. There is always the risk that reliefs of this type will be used in schemes of tax avoidance. I have tried to guard against the more obvious abuses. Indeed, this is one of the reasons why the provisions are so long and complex. A balance has to be struck between attempting to eliminate all possibility of abuse and not restricting the relief in such a manner that would be of no benefit at all. I shall be monitoring the relief very closely and, if there is any avoidance with evidence of abuse, I will act quickly to defeat it.
With regard to the specific points raised by Deputy Bruton, the Third Schedule provides that one of the conditions for approval of the scheme is that it must be open to every full-time employee who has completed the qualifying period of service and that all directors and employees must be eligible to participate on similar terms. Another requirement is that shares may not be allowed to any individual who has an interest of more than 15 per cent in the company, where it is a close company. The relief is not confined to companies whose shares are quoted on a recognised stock exchange, which is a point made by Deputy Quinn tonight and others. It is also available in respect of companies whose shares are not quoted, providing certain conditions are filled.
Comment on this
Deputy Bruton has also referred to the income tax relief for the elderly in respect of private tenancy rents. He was concerned that some persons might be denied relief because they would not be able to furnish receipts for rent paid in the first half of this year. On 27 January, the Deputy himself drew attention to this proposal and specifically advised those concerned to retain receipts for rent paid from that date. The Revenue Commissioners will also be taking steps to ensure that those eligible are made aware of this relief and of the conditions attaching to it. In administering the relief, full account will be taken of the possibility that, in some instances, a claimant may not be able to furnish receipts for all rent paid in the early months of 1982. The rules for proving the payment of the rent by the production of receipts or otherwise will be set out in the regulations to be made under the section. These regulations will give the inspector of taxes sufficient discretion in the matter to enable him to take a flexible view, especially in the first year of the scheme, in cases where receipts are not forthcoming for all rent that was paid.
Deputy Dukes alleged that the provision of £1.5 million in the budget would not be sufficient to meet the cost of the rescue package for farmers in severe financial difficulties, which will arise for payment this year. The budget proposals of 27 January contained the provision of £4 million to meet the direct costs of the scheme which, at that time, were estimated would arise this year. It was necessary to revise this figure by the time I came to present my budget proposals on 25 March, in the light of such matters as a later operative date of 1 April rather than 1 January.
Comment on this
This had a significant effect on the 1982 cost in the case of the ACC, because it was then necessary to provide for one rather than two gale days. In addition, the mechanics for payment of the direct grants had not been worked out at the time of the January budget and consequently the provisions made then were somewhat tentative. In fact, it was some time after the March budget before the mechanics for payment were finally settled.
Deputies will be aware, from press reports, that the response to the scheme has so far been slow and that, as a result, applications will be accepted, exceptionally, up to the end of June. Only when all applications have been received and examined will a clear and reliable estimate of costs emerge. I should emphasise that the revision of the 1982 cost estimate which took place between the January and March budgets has in no way affected the basic conditions of the scheme or lessened its atractiveness for farmers. The later starting date of 1 April will still leave farmers with a full three year benefit period under the scheme.
Deputy Cooney stated that hardship is being created for farmers by the refusal of roll-over relief for sales of development land and he claimed that it was not the intention to treat farmers in this way. If he reads the January budget speech he will, in fact, see that this exact proposal was contained in the Coalition budget. The reason for the provision is that if roll-over relief were allowed to continue for sales of development land, it would undermine the new tax arrangements which are designed to ensure that large windfall gains on the sale of development lands are properly taxed. In no way will hardship arise because if a farmer disposes of development land, the availability of indexation relief for the agricultural value of the land will, of itself, be sufficient to enable him to purchase a farm of equal agricultural value in the vast majority of cases. In addition, where the farm sold has been held for more than one year, he will still retain, after tax, at least 50 per cent of the gain on the development land property. I should like to mention that if a farmer sells sites for development purposes for a total price not exceeding £15,000 in any one tax year, roll-over relief will be available to him.
Deputy Bruton suggested that the size of the tax deduction to be given in respect of increases in employment be increased from £10 to £20 per week. I might remind the Deputy that in the scheme as originally proposed by himself the deduction was to have been £500 a year. For ease of administration, this has been converted to a weekly deduction of £10 so that the maximum annual deduction available per job will be £520. The Deputy will appreciate, therefore, that the provisions are in line with the scheme as originally outlined by him as Minister.
The Deputy also expressed the view that provisions for eligibility under the scheme might be regarded as restrictive. I can assure him that the provisions are designed as simply as possible so as to benefit the generality of companies which provide increased employment. I would like to clarify, in particular, the position of firms which do not have profits. The situation is that a deduction will be treated, for the purposes of corporation tax, as a trading expense and so will be available not only as a deduction against profits, but will create or augment losses. This treatment ensures that it will be of maximum benefit to firms and that if the particular operation is not immediately profitable but is creating employment, then the deduction will be available and will, in effect, be carried forward and set off against future taxable profits. In addition, it will be available for purposes of group relief.
Deputy Bruton asked that VAT on lampshades be reduced from 30 per cent to 18 per cent as part of the reduction for furniture and furnishings. The dilemma facing any Minister for Finance, as Deputy Bruton knows well, in making changes of this kind is where to draw the line between the items to be reduced and those to be left unchanged. No matter where the line is drawn, there will inevitably be some items on the wrong side of the line which are in many ways comparable with those which have been reduced. The definition of furniture and furnishings which has been made for the purpose of this reduction has been quite generous, but it was never the intention to reduce the rate of VAT on all items used in the home. While I sympathise with the case made by Deputy Bruton, I am not prepared to widen the scope of the concession further.
The opinion has been expressed by Deputy Cooney that the 20 per cent excise duty on bets placed off course is too high and that a reduction would, in fact, increase revenue from this tax. While I agree that a 20 per cent tax on bets is quite high, I would not accept that a reduction would lead to an overall increase in revenue. Since the duty was set at this rate in 1975, there has been a constant increase in the yield and the revenue is still buoyant from this source. A reduction in the tax would reduce the incentive to evade, but it would certainly not eliminate evasion. In this regard, I would say that the Revenue Commissioners are active in tackling evasion. This is a difficult area to control. I have made provision in this Bill for an increased level of penalties, along with a reduction in the power of the courts to mitigate the penalty. These changes will be of considerable assistance in discouraging evasion. I should also say that combating evasion in this area, as in other areas, is made easier by co-operation from the public.
Deputy Barry Desmond suggested that higher rates of VAT should be applied to luxury goods bought dominantly by the higher income groups and to goods with a high import content. While I would agree with the objectives of this proposal, we must remember that VAT is a general sales tax on a wide range of goods and services. If it is to be administered successfully by the thousands of traders throughout the country it must be kept as simple as possible. The present system is already difficult enough to implement and it would not be desirable to add to the number of rates of VAT or to charge different rates of VAT on goods in the same general category. However, I will certainly keep the Deputy's suggestion in mind in future review of the VAT system.
Tax evasion was mentioned by Deputy Mitchell this morning and the need to take more effective counter measures. I totally agree with him that we must do more. But having said this I want to point out that in the Bill now before the House we are making some significant steps forward. Penalties are being increased and more exacting requirements in relation to back duty settlements are being imposed. Also I want to give due recognition to the Revenue Commissioners who have made a big breakthrough in the past few years in countering evasion. They would be the first to admit that much more needs to be done. The Commission on Taxation will be giving special consideration to the issue of tax evasion and tax avoidance and I will look forward to their recommendations. The imposition of VAT on imports would certainly help to curtail VAT evasion. Apart from the loss of revenue to the Exchequer, both evasion and avoidance do harm in that they increase the burden of tax for other taxpayers. In this context I treat evasion and avoidance as one problem. While tax avoidance is within the law it is far too often a cynical manipulation of the law and some practices which are patently artificial involve a huge cost to the Exchequer in terms of tax foregone. These practices are designed by experts who deliberately set out to break the spirit while observing the letter of the law.
A number of Deputies referred to the Commission on Taxation and have expressed the hope that the Government will implement their recommendations. I am looking forward to receiving the first report of the commission in the immediate future and I expect that it will be published without delay. In advance of seeing and considering the recommendations I cannot give a commitment that these recommendations will be implemented and I know that Deputies would not look for such a commitment. I can assure the House that the report will be carefully studied and I expect that it will have a major influence on future taxation policy. The report is, I understand, a very detailed and complex document and it would be unwise to give an overnight verdict on its recommendations. It will require very careful examination. Incidentally, I understand that the first report will be concerned with direct taxation. The commission are continuing their work and they will be reporting in due course on other aspects of taxation including indirect taxation. I would like to take this opportunity to thank the members of the commission for the effort they have made and the time they have devoted to this very important task.
Deputy Cooney alleges that the Finance Bill does not provide or even start to provide for any reform of the taxation system. I categorically reject this. In the field of capital taxation, for example, the Bill contains provision for taxing short-term gains at a much higher rate than gains which accrue over a longer period, and thereby focuses the impact of the tax directly on speculative transactions. There is a totally new package of arrangements imposing a special capital gains tax on disposals of development land while the new aggregation basis for capital acquisitions tax both limits tax avoidance and contributes significantly towards tax equity. There are various income tax changes such as the benefits in kind in respect of cars which also are obvious reforms and have been generally seen as such. In fact for the most part the Finance Bill contains changes which were proposed last January by a Government of which Deputy Cooney was a member. These changes were at that time heralded as major reforms of the tax system. I wonder what has happened them since?
I would now like to return again to the amendment tabled in the name of Deputy Bruton. If this amendment, which incidentally is a most unusual procedure, were carried it is well that Deputies should be fully aware of the consequences. It would mean that the Finance Bill would lapse. The various proposals in the budget would cease to have effect, some immediately and some at an early date and there would be a consequent loss of tax this year of more than £300 million.
Comment on this
It is extraordinary that an amendment involving a tax loss of more than £300 million should receive any support from any side of the House at this time. There has been sustained advice from all sides of the House in recent months about the necessity to keep the budget deficit within acceptable limits. Yet this amendment goes against all such advice and it attempts to open the way for a huge addition to the deficit.
Comment on this
It runs directly contrary to the philosophy which Opposition Deputies have been preaching constantly for the past 12 months. I want Deputies to be in no doubt at all about the consequences if the Finance Bill were rejected.
Comment on this
Our problems would not be confined solely to a massive increase in the deficit which in turn would lead to a totally unacceptable increase in borrowing. There would be chaotic administrative problems for the Revenue Commissioners. They would be required to revert to the income tax allowances and bands that applied for the tax year 1981-82 and Deputies well realise what impossible problems this would generate. The special PRSI tax allowance would lapse after a period of four months. No doubt the Opposition will assert that all this confusion is avoidable and that we can easily change course by taking on board the proposals which were put forward by them last January. Apart from the fact that the mathematics of such a change would not work out in our favour there would simply be no sense now in trying to substitute VAT on clothing and footwear and reducing the subsidies on basic foods to compensate for VAT on imports. These alternatives have already been rejected and the community at large would react against any attempts to reinstate them and we would find that out quickly if the people had such an opportunity.
Comment on this
We are embarking on our course as agreed by the people at the last election. When we came into office on 9 March we proceeded on that course; we are still on that course and will stay on that course.
Comment on this
The reality is that if the House were to defeat now the budget proposals incorporated in this Bill there would be an irreplaceable loss of revenue and a huge increase in the budget deficit this year. Confidence in the economy both at home and abroad would be gravely weakened, and half way through 1982 we would be left with no budget policy and no clear indication as to what we propose to do in future. This surely is a recipe for chaos.
Comment on this
It would destroy our plans for creating much-needed employment. This amendment is not a rational alternative to the policy being implemented in the Finance Bill. It is only a negative statement which has nothing to do with the promotion of social justice and economic responsibility. If it were adopted it is an understatement to say that it would aggravate national economic difficulties.
I have no doubt the House will reject this amendment. Again I want to emphasise the positive programme which is legislated for in this Bill. Of its very nature a Finance Bill has some unwelcome provisions because it is concerned with changes in taxation and it is inevitable, especially in the present economic and financial climate, that it must impose new taxes. The changes in the present Bill pave the way for a fair distribution of taxation and it is the Government's stated intention to build on this and to achieve a much more equitable system of taxation than we have at present.
Traditionally several amendments to the Finance Bill are put down and I will consider each amendment on its merits. If I see any proposed amendment as an improvement on the Bill ——
Comment on this
——as drafted, then I will recommend its acceptance to the House. Might I remind all Deputies, particularly the Members of Fine Gael and Labour, of the major changes in this Bill and in our budget as against the budget defeated by the Dáil on 27 January and by the people in the general election. In our budget, they are VAT at the point of entry and bringing forward payments of corporation tax. Surely they will have an impact and will cause some problems? But all those matters can be resolved. The alternative as proposed on 27 January was that we would have VAT on footwear and clothing, a reduction in food subsidies, and tax on social welfare benefits.
Comment on this
To sum it up, they are the alternatives. The Dáil and the people have decided on the Opposition's alternative and the people have decided on our alternative. I have no doubt that the Dáil, in giving a Second Reading, and subsequently the Committee Stage of this Bill, will confirm our budget proposals.
Comment on this
As is customary on these occasions I should like to ask the Minister a short and simple question. When will he make the announcement of his decision in regard to raising the £45 million necessary to pay for the concessions on PRSI and still keep to the budget deficit as set out for this year, bearing in mind that this money must be raised before the end of the year if the targets he set are to be adhered to?
Comment on this
I have already referred to that in my concluding remarks and I will repeat what I said on a number of occasions. The Government made it quite clear that the £45 million PRSI concessions to the PAYE sector would be made good either by expenditure savings or additional taxation. I said at that time that the Government had undertaken, in addition to what was in operation by our predecessors, a complete expenditure review in every Department and to report to Finance and the Government by the end of May. Those reports are due about now, and most of them are in. When the Government have an opportunity to examine them it will be clear what expenditure savings can be made and then the situation regarding the additional taxation required will be known. Then the Deputy and the House will be made aware of the situation.
Comment on this
Does the Minister intend to make these decisions and announcements before the Dáil goes into recess?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that it is very unusual for a fiscal policy change of such magnitude to take place in a given year to be known at least in the first six months of the year? Will he indicate if he can confidently predict that he will be announcing these decisions within a month?
Comment on this
Does the Minister expect to put proposals to the Government within the next three weeks?
Comment on this
Does he expect them to be decided upon within a week or so of being put to the Government?
Comment on this
In what respect does the Minister's proposal to save £45 million differ in kind from the proposal of his predecessor but two, Deputy Gene Fitzgerald, in the 1980 budget, to save £25 million on rationalisation? Will the House be given an opportunity to examine it and will it be presented with the material in transparent gold fish bowl form so that it can decide for itself how genuine are the techniques and methods by which this saving is going to be achieved? We are still waiting to hear about the rationalisation which enabled Deputy Gene Fitzgerald to ——
Comment on this
The Deputy may not make a statement. He had an opportunity to speak on the Bill. He may ask a question.
Comment on this
Will the Minister tell the House how and when it will be able to decide for itself, because the Dáil is being brushed very much to one side these days, whether £45 million or 45 million halfpennys have been saved by dint of the operations of the interdepartmental committee which even now is wasting money away from its ordinary tasks pursuing the hare the Minister raised? How will that be visible to the members of this Party, the Labour Party and the gentlemen over there who think everybody else in the House is a gombeen?
Comment on this
How will it be visible to the gombeens and the non-gombeens and to the sea-green incorruptibles?
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly, at this crucial moment I am sure you do not want to be put out of the House. I am putting the question.
Comment on this
I want to ask one question. The Minister said he will be looking at each and every amendment tabled. Can he assure the House that at this stage he has not agreed with any Deputy or group of Deputies that the substance of their amendments will be found acceptable?
Comment on this
Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."
Do you agree with this result?