We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1982: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 1–176 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1982
Enacted

No. 10 of 1982 ›

Gerard C. Connolly Minister of State at the Department of the Environment (Mr. Connolly) Fianna Fáil

Before Question Time I was referring to the strategy of the Coalition's budget. The Coalition proposed to tax poor people on food, a very essential item. Deputy Bruton and other Fine Gael Members seem to be worried about the underprivileged now, but there was not too much concern in January when they were asking our people to pay a whopping £47 million as a result of the removal of food subsidies. They also proposed to impose VAT on footwear and clothing amounting to £58 million. Deputy Desmond, in the course of the Second Stage debate, told us that if we imposed certain taxes we would be robbing Peter to pay Paul. I would not agree with some of the figures the Deputy produced when he was asked where the additional revenue would be raised. To be fair to the Deputy, I accept that he does not have the up-to-date information on the costings. We must ask ourselves, whether we opt for the £4 million or the £6½ million relief, where the money will come from.

With regard to the family income supplement proposed by the Coalition, the £9.60 per week that was to be taken off a husband's income and transferred to a wife, I should like to state that such a procedure would make little of the husband and seem to indicate that he was not supporting his family. Of course, we all know that the people pegged that out on top of its head. We changed that system and passed over the supplement directly.

Comment on this

Our proposal.

Comment on this

The Coalition were swapping the pockets. It should be remembered that only one-eighth of those eligible for that supplement applied for it even though the Minister for Finance carried out an extensive advertising campaign. Even with the assistance of high powered PRO people the Government failed to rescue that situation and get the people to apply for the supplement. The Coalition failed.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Not at all.

Comment on this

Of course the Coalition did but the Deputy does not have the guts to admit that now.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

We have plenty of guts.

Comment on this

The proof of the matter is that seven-eights of those eligible did not apply. Why did they not apply? They did not do so because they copped on. Before the Coalition left office everything was on the table for alteration but up to then it was not possible to alter anything.

Comment on this

Fianna Fáil have altered a lot since.

Comment on this

Financial commentators and political correspondents have said a lot about the budget deficit, revenue income and borrowing requirements. It is easy for them to talk, but the Government must find the money.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

If the Government resign they will not have to find the money.

Comment on this

The Coalition ran away.

Comment on this

Fianna Faíl took the wrong turn.

Comment on this

In regard to the last statement, I should like to remind the Deputy that the leaders of Fine Gael and Labour, who were members of the Coalition Government, did a U-turn after the defeat in the Dáil in January. They did a U-turn in regard to VAT on clothing and footwear and were going around measuring the sizes of shoes.

Comment on this

We did not do any U-turn on the tax on discretionary trusts.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Leary did a U-turn and the night before he left office everything was on the table for a U-turn or any other turn. The Opposition do not like to hear the truth but they should accept facts.

Comment on this

We should have a vote.

Comment on this

We are having a filibuster by the Government.

Comment on this

The position on the issues before us is clear. We all know of the famous plan of the Coalition to take £9.60 from my pocket and put it into the pocket of someone else.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I should like to point out to the Chair that this morning the speakers who were dealing with the general taxation situation were brought to heel by the Leas-Cheann Comhairle on the basis that speakers would confine their remarks to amendments Nos. 1 and 2. The Minister of State is more than straying a little at this stage and I expect that the same restrictions apply to him as applied to all other Members.

Comment on this

I was referring to the fact that Deputy Bruton dealt with the family income supplement and I was anxious to put the matter right. I never heard so much hypocrisy from the Opposition side of the House. Of course, I am aware of the situation that exists. The Labour Party were members of a Government who allowed food subsidies to be withdrawn and they are supposed to be the ones who look after the under-privileged. They were not very concerned in January.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): Fianna Fáil put VAT on food but we took it off.

Comment on this

The question is: where will the Government get the money to implement the suggestions made by the Opposition? Introducing changes is a slow process but when we were elected to Government we had to produce a budget within two weeks. We had to make all the necessary arrangements to get in revenue. That is the situation.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): I can appreciate the amendments and concern which the Labour Party and The Workers' Party have for the lower paid. This can be shared by everyone. However, we have been taking the wrong approach over the last few years towards improving the standard of living for the lower paid workers. Our primary aim should be to get inflation down. This is the most positive way we can make a contribution to the weakest section of the community.

Comment on this

The 1977 manifesto was the cause of that.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): The higher the inflation rate goes, the richer the rich become and the poorer the poor become. We must take a positive stand and see what road we are following. Budget deficits must be controlled. The current deficit is the figure at which we hope to arrive this year.

Sections 1 and 2 of the Finance Bill deal with personal allowances and changes in the tax bands. In the amendments dealing with the sections — there are about 24 of them — there has been no voice from Fine Gael to adjust any of the bands nor has there been any concern for the lower paid sections of the community. Where is Fine Gael's voice? Why do they not discuss this at their Front Bench meetings?

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

We will invite the Deputy to the next meeting.

Comment on this

The Front Bench cannot hold them all.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): There is no congestion in Fine Gael in Wicklow. What about Fianna Fáil?

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): There is no amendment from Deputy Bruton dealing with tax bands or personal allowance. They are using the amendments put forward by Labour and The Workers' Party to cause a general election. If they had the courage of their convictions and concern for the working people, they would have put down amendments. It is hypocritical to use those parties.

Comment on this

The same way as you are using other parties.

Comment on this

Watch yourself in Meath.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): The sooner The Workers' Party and the Labour Party take this into consideration when voting in the division the better. I have no doubt that the main Opposition party are not concerned that the bands should be changed. Deputy Bruton brought in a budget and had an opportunity then to insert in the income tax code what he is asking the Labour Party and The Workers' Party to do now. If Fine Gael had tabled an amendment of their own, I would give them credit for it but it is hard to believe that they did not bring forward one amendment of their own that they could stand over and speak on. That reflects the true voice and merit of Fine Gael. They do not believe in these amendments.

If we do not continue to hold the line in the budget, inflation will rise to 25 per cent. That will be reflected on the weaker sections of the community. It is only by expanding the economy, bringing down inflation, bringing confidence back into the export market——

Comment on this

On a point of order, the House is debating a very long Finance Bill with many sections. It seems to me, with great respect, that the Government are afraid to face the vote we have been expecting for some time. There appears to be some conference going on elsewhere in the House while other people are being sent in to waste the time of the House. I suggest we have a vote on this amendment now and get an election over with.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): I am not trying to prolong the debate. I am putting the facts as I see them.

Comment on this

The Opposition do not want to hear the truth.

Comment on this

We never heard the truth.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzpatrick on the amendment.

Comment on this

He never was on the amendment.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): If the Deputy is that concerned about income tax bands, why did she not make representations to Deputy Bruton?

Comment on this

I am concerned with getting the Deputy out.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): There is the concern for the weaker sections of the community.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Speak for yourself and your party.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): As I have said, we are not afraid of votes and divisions.

Comment on this

Let us have one now.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): Do not be so impatient about it. We will have time enough for it.

Comment on this

The Deputy may not.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): I appeal to Deputies to consider the serious consequences for the economy. There is no doubt that we are facing difficult times. Everyone knows this. We know what the inflation rate is at present. This must be our primary objective. If the concern of Deputies is for the common good, a positive approach must be taken to keep the budget deficit at what it is. I fully appreciate the Minister's concern that this is done because, if it is not, it will mean more taxation and the standard of living will fall still further for the weaker sections of the community.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): I have always held the view, particularly since the introduction of PAYE, that it is essential to have a fair and equitable system of taxation. Under the PAYE system of taxation, the wage-earner, worker and lower paid have no option whatever but to pay up to the last penny. It is taken directly out of their pocket and they cannot make any private arrangements for themselves. There is an onus on every Government to ensure that the system of taxation is fair and equitable so long as they operate this system.

I was glad to be a member of a Government which, for the first time since the State was founded, did something to introduce equity in taxation. We did this by introducing the capital gains tax. Prior to that the dealer in lands, the speculator in shares, the dealer in house property and so on could make £50,000 a year, which was a phenomenal amount of money at the time, without attracting one brass farthing of taxation because that was not regarded as income but as a capital gain.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): What has this to do with the amendment?

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): It has every bit as much to do with it as the Deputy's contribution had. It was my namesake who prompted me to say what I am saying.

Comment on this

On a point of information, does Deputy Hussey's request not extend to Deputy Fitzpatrick so that we can go ahead with the division?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzpatrick must be allowed make his contribution on the amendment.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): I will be brief and concise. I was proud to be a member of the Government who introduced the capital gains tax and who, by way of that tax, got at the speculator, the dealer and anyone who was in receipt of a big income but who was not paying tax. We left behind a good and workable money-earning tax system but Fianna Fáil on coming into office altered that capital gains tax legislation. They pulled out its teeth, rendered it harmless and left it in such a way that while it remained in name it was not bringing in any worthwhile revenue. In the budget that we introduced in January we proposed to restore the teeth to the capital gains tax, to give it back its power.

A fair system of taxation is necessary. That is why I am happy to support this amendment in the names of my friends in the Labour Party. The amendment is framed so as to help the lower income group. As the Bill is drafted it is proposed to ask a married couple earning £4,400 jointly to pay income tax. In other words, a couple with a combined income of less than £100 per week, that is, less than £50 per spouse, are to be asked to pay tax. That is unjust, regardless of who may be responsible for it. The amendment proposes to increase the figure to £4,800.

Comment on this

But who will pay for it?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzpatrick must be allowed to make his contribution.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): When the Deputy tells me how the £45 million concession is to be raised, I will tell him how the change involved here will be paid for.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Fitzpatrick without interruption, please.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): I believe, as Deputy Fitzpatrick believes, that we need to cut down inflation, that we need to bring about more production and that we should be more competitive. But we will not become more competitive and neither will we increase production or cut down inflation by discouraging people from working. The present taxation system is turning people away from work. A man who is a lorry driver tells me that in the changed tax bands, he will be in the 60p bracket. Is there any encouragement for that man to continue in his job? This is a good amendment and one that should be supported. If accepted, it will encourage people to go back to work. Fianna Fáil cannot offer any good reason for not being able to get the few million pounds extra that would be necessary to implement the change proposed. They have no problem in finding between £40 million and £50 million for a little bit of this city. They are able to give £500,000 to this or that local authority as a stop gap measure. That will not encourage work. Therefore, in the interest of equity in taxation and of encouraging people to work, I am supporting the amendment.

Comment on this

We have tabled this amendment and put in a number of speakers to support it because we believe it is a reasonable amendment, an amendment designed to help those who have been buffeted by the increasing cost of living and who are in need of tax relief. We have costed the amendment to the best of our ability and it is a reasonable cost. Our party have borne the heat of the day in attempting to bring our economy back towards a direction of growth. We have taken the risks and the unpopular decisions inherent in that responsibility. It is important from the point of view of the country that we know where we are going vis-á-vis this Government and in terms of what remains in this Finance Bill. There is an air of uncertainty about the intention of the Government in relation to the various amendments that have been tabled to the Bill. It is time to end this uncertainty. We are very serious about the content of the amendment. We have wrung the elements that are in the amendment and we are now calling for a vote on it. The result of that vote will be a test of the Government's approach to the other elements in the Bill.

Comment on this

In order that we might clear the air, there is a very distinct difference between the rulings of yourself and of the Leas-Cheann Comhairle in respect of amendments Nos. 1 and 2. Certain reasons have been put forward by both Fine Gael and Labour for taking amendment No. 1 separately. The point being made was that amendment No. 2 differed marginally in that it sought to increase the allowances. I think that I am entitled at this time to formally move amendment No. 2.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy cannot do that. Deputy Barry Desmond asked that his amendment be taken separately.

Comment on this

It has been stated that if amendment No. 1 is not accepted, amendment No. 2 cannot be moved.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 1 will be dealt with separately and the Deputy may then discuss his amendment.

Comment on this

Lest the air be clouded up in that direction, we should make it absolutely clear for everyone concerned that the position is that if amendment No. 1 is successful an opportunity will then arise for The Workers' Party to debate amendment No. 2 but that if amendment No. 1 falls that party will not have the opportunity of voting on their amendment. Therefore, if they wish to discuss or vote on amendment No. 2, they must support amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

We should be crystal clear as to the procedure we are adopting. The first motion which you will have to put before the House is that £4,400, the existing limit, should stand. In the event of the House deciding that these words should not stand, you will have to put the question immediately that the figure of £4,800 should stand, that being the content of my amendment. Presumably, Deputies would then vote on that. I understand also that in the event of the £4,800 figure being accepted, that becomes the substantive decision of the House and amendment No. 2 is thereby negatived, because the House has decided that the new rate should be £4,800 and other amendments relating thereto are irrelevant at that stage. Deputy Sherlock and his colleagues should be under no illusion that this is a serious matter, that they have to decide in the first instance if they wish to see £4,400 remaining as it is and, secondly, if not, they must decide whether they wish to support the Labour Party amendment for £4,800. That is their prerogative.

I am not and the Labour Party are not playing games, either of the upstaging variety with amendments put down last night or of any other variety. We are not playing games just to defeat the Minister on the Finance Bill. That is not the purpose of the exercise. Neither are we playing games simply to defeat the Government and possibly have a general election or perhaps force the Government into having a motion of no confidence with the prospect of witnessing further gyrations in the lobbies as Deputies make up their minds where to go. We are in the process of discussing on Committee Stage a very simple amendment from the Labour Party the cost of which we have quite deliberately reduced to £4 million for this year or £6 million in a full year. Lest there be any illusion on the part of The Workers' Party I would not support an amendment that it should become £4,000 or £5,000. We stand or fall on our amendment. We are not here as cannon fodder for any other party who put down amendments. Let that be absolutely clear. I must say this with great deference to The Workers' Party so-called Deputies behind; they will have some difficulty on this whole question.

Comment on this

On a point or order, that man just called us "so-called Deputies". I wish him to withdraw that.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

I am speaking on a point of order.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There is a point of order from Deputy De Rossa. Is Deputy Desmond speaking on a point of order?

Comment on this

I am currently speaking on a point of order.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Even on a point of order that sort of reference is not permitted and I would ask the Deputy to withdraw it.

Comment on this

Yes, I withdraw it. But I want to put it on record that it is about time——

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is this a point of order?

Comment on this

I am speaking on the amendment.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy cannot have it both ways. He can either have a point of order or speak on the amendment. He refused to yield to Deputy De Rossa because he said he was speaking on a point of order. The Deputy should not try to confuse the House.

Comment on this

If Deputy De Rossa wants to make a point of order——

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I wanted him to make it but you said you were speaking on a point of order, which was deliberately misleading the House.

Comment on this

My regrets. I speak on the amendment at this stage.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I ask that the Deputy withdraw the remark "so-called Deputies".

Comment on this

I did that, no offence whatsoever meant in that regard. This is not a personal matter at all. However, I say to the five Deputies behind me: I find it somewhat incredible that when we had a Financial Resolution in relation to the budget a short time ago, Financial Resolution No. 3, which contained for the year ahead the personal allowances, including the £4,400, Deputy Bruton put down an amendment seeking to transform it into a tax credit system and behold, The Workers' Party Deputies fully supported the Financial Resolution. The Labour Party voted against it and in my opinion reacted honourably. Now, because the Labour Party puts down an amendment to increase the £4,400 limit to £4,800 The Workers' Party have apparently undergone a traumatic change of mind. That must be put on record, because if we are going to have a general election we will not have it on the terms of supporting Government Financial Resolutions right through the lobby of the House and careering into selected constituencies and then saying: "We stand for further PAYE relief, further taxation relief right down the line".

I welcome the decision of Deputies to stand for Dáil Éireann and participate in the democratic process, but they cannot have it both ways in the parliamentary proportional representation democratic process. I in no way ask for support — it is up to the Deputies to decide how they wish to vote on this amendment. I will leave it at that. Further, to copperfasten the point, if the Deputies have put down amendments as they have done — any Deputy can put down amendments; they shoved in a shoal of them last night about 6.30 or 7 p.m. to the General Office — one wonders at the tremendous change of mind that has occurred in this regard since the Second Stage of the Finance Bill only seven days ago. The Finance Bill contains, as the Minister outlined in detail, the personal tax changes. They fully supported the Government on that. Therefore, let it be clearly on the record that we are asking the Minister to accept our modest amendment, our necessary amendment, and we are not going to support the £5,000 lark in that regard. I want to make that absolutely clear.

Finally, may I say to the Minister — and he may want to respond — that the Labour Party have other amendments down in relation to the Finance Bill. I am not in the business in moving amendment No. 1, of indulging in a Dutch auction, of upping the ante — if one amendment is accepted, you are screwed in the next amendment and the one thereafter and so on. That is the way the Finance Bill is structured. If you wish to discuss a matter, you must table an amendment.

I am not going to behave in a wholly irresponsible way in regard to any amendment. In relation to some of the amendments I put down I do not know the precise costings because the Labour Party do not have all the data available to the Department of Finance. I do know that some of our amendments — and additional amendments follow on — in section 3, for example, will cost a substantial amount of money. I am acutely aware of that and I am quite prepared to say to the Minister that I propose to act in a wholly responsible, constructive way in this matter. I ask the Minister would he be prepared in that context to accept our amendment. Inevitably I think the choice must rest with the Minister in that regard. I make that point not in any sense of merely endeavouring to defeat a Government for the sake of defeating them; I make it to make progress with the Finance Bill. The Minister has indicated that he currently has a departmental expenditure review going on which apparently is to yield £20 million. No doubt that review can be extended; no doubt the £4 million and £6 million in a full year can be accommodated without destroying the integrity of the current budget deficit which we want to maintain in consideration of the financial solvency of the country. I have no doubt that also can be maintained and I just want to ask the Minister if he has any response to make.

Comment on this

First, I should like to thank Deputy Desmond for his explanation regarding his approach to the amendments. It is very easy for any Deputy to make the case in relation to £4 million in the case of the Labour Party amendment and £6.5 million this year in the case of The Workers' Party amendment. The Minister and the Government are being asked to accept these. I do not intend to delay the proceedings and I have desisted from contributing to the debate and answering some of the points made in the last couple of hours. If we look at this, the first series of amendments, which cost £4 million to £6.5 million, and then go on right through the series of amendments up to No. 90, or whatever it is, the same point can be made. We have amendments down in the names of other Deputies. We have an amendment from Deputy Bruton in relation to VAT on imports which would cost £140 million. Step by step, amendment by amendment, the same case is made to the Minister and to the Government: it is only £2 million, only £4 million. I said at the outset in relation to this amendment that it is £4 million and that it goes on to the budget deficit, on to the level of borrowing. Multiply that by 90 other amendments and you run into hundreds of millions. I made the position clear in my first intervention on the amendments and I have no alternative but to oppose it.

Comment on this

The whole thrust of the Fine Gael approach to this amendment seems to be that they have something better to offer. Possibly they made a mistake this morning in seeking to have amendments Nos. 1 and 2 separated from the rest of the amendments because they have spent the rest of the time talking about everything else in the Bill. The point was made that they did not ignore the less well-off, and they did not. They proceeded in their budgetary efforts to place tax on clothes and shoes, to remove the subsidies on butter, etc., and unfortunately at that time they were supported in that move by the Labour Party.

In speaking this morning to amendments Nos. 1 and 2 Deputy Bruton stated that they had tried to put tax on social welfare benefits because they considered that would be of benefit to the lower paid. Really I cannot see the logic of that when you consider that the social welfare benefits which people receive have been paid for by themselves, that these recipients have paid tax on the contributions they made in relation to the social welfare element. The whole thrust of the Fine Gael approach on this amendment has been to try to pre-empt a debate on the rest of the Bill. We are in this House to try to debate a Bill for the organising of the finances of the State. Either we are serious about trying to improve this Bill or we are not, and it would seem that Fine Gael are not serious about that.

I am pleased that the Labour Party are making a serious attempt. They have stated that they want a debate on this section and on all the other sections. I regret that they have indicated that they will not support our amendment on the tax exemption limits, because our amendment will benefit 32,000 of the lower paid, whereas the Labour Party amendment will benefit 19,000. Therefore, there is a significant difference between what the Labour Party are proposing in relation to benefits for the lower paid and what we are proposing in this regard. As to the cost, it has been stated that the Labour Party proposal will cost £4 million and ours approximately £6.5 million. But we have indicated that the rest of our amendments on this Bill show clearly how this money can be raised in terms of wealth tax etc., trying to close the various loopholes in our tax system, and taking wealth from those, who continually avoid paying income tax of any kind. When you consider that the PAYE sector — who, as has been said already in this House, pay their tax every Friday night — are contributing 80 to 90 per cent of the income tax, whereas another large sector of the community such as the farming sector are contributing something like 1 per cent, you can recognise a serious anomaly there. If this House is serious about rectifying that anomaly, the House should support our amendment, which is looking for an increase in exemption rates to £5,000.

Comment on this

The case has been well made from these benches for the necessity of getting Government approval for this amendment on behalf of the lower paid and those who are overtaxed. We know that throughout the country in recent years there has been a great deal of discontent about the taxation position of this group. In that spirit we put forward this amendment. It is also important for the country to discover the nature of the scaffolding upholding this Government, their conditions and so forth. It is important that we know how the rest of this Finance Bill is to be taken. This amendment is the litmus test of the Government's approach towards amendments. My party in Government have borne the heat of the day in dealing with the problems of our economy in the spirit of normal exchange of debate in this House. We can take lectures from the Minister on difficulties facing the economy, but it comes ill from those benches when you think of their behaviour in recent months and years and their profiligate mismanagement of the economy which has brought the country and the economy to this threatened sorry pass. At any rate, after many speakers and many hours of a debate, while we welcome the spirit of loquaciousness which has descended on the Government benches, dissidents and supporters alike we now think that it is time for a vote. We have heard enough.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I am sorry for having to rise again, but on the result of this vote will depend whether there is a vote on amendment No. 2.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

This vote is being taken separately on amendment No. 1.

Comment on this

If amendment No 1 is defeated I will have the right to call for a vote on amendment No. 2?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this
Deputies

No.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): On a point of order, am I right in thinking that when an amendment or a number of amendments propose to delete words and substitute other words, particularly when there are more than one such amendment, the invariable practice here has been to put the question on the basis that the words proposed to be deleted stand?

Comment on this

That is true.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

For the benefit of the House, Deputy Bruton insisted that they be taken separately.

Comment on this

On a point of order, with all due respect, Deputy Bruton may request what he likes, but precedent is precedent and there is an unbroken precedent that that is the way the vote is put.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

For the benefit of the House, a number of Deputies asked that they be taken separately.

Comment on this

A number of Deputies have requested a number of things. You have a particular responsibility on this occasion to observe precedent and undoubtedly precedent demands that the first vote should be on the proposal that the words stand.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

On a point of order, this morning the Leas-Cheann Comhairle ruled that, in the event of the motion "that the words proposed to be deleted stand part" being successful on amendment No. 1, amendment No. 2 would be out of order. That was the ruling the Leas-Cheann Comhairle gave this morning and which was accepted by the Deputies in the House.

Comment on this

On a point of order—

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

That ruling was given in the House this morning, a Cheann Comhairle. Are you changing that ruling or does it still stand?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that Deputies then demanded that they be taken separately and discussed separately.

Comment on this

Different Deputies may demand different things. The House must be governed by the practice established over many years. I submit that the correct procedure is that the first vote should be on the question that the £4,400 in the Bill stands and the House would vote on that. That is the request I make, because that is in accordance with the rules of order of the House.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that they are taken separately unless the House agrees that they be taken together.

Comment on this

They will be taken separately. That will be the first vote. If that is carried obviously that is the end of the matter. If it is defeated the next vote will be on the question that £4,800 would stand in place of £4,400 and that will be voted on. If that is carried that is the end of the matter. If it is defeated there will be a separate vote on the question that £5,000 stand part of the Bill instead of £4,400. Those votes would be taken separately. That is the long-established procedure. I am requesting that we proceed in accordance with practice.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understand that Deputy Sherlock's amendment has not been discussed yet.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

Are you changing the decision which the Leas-Cheann Comhairle handed down to the House this morning? It is on record.

Comment on this

On a point of order, he moved his amendment.

Comment on this

I support Deputy Collins. I asked the Leas-Cheann Comhairle for his advice this morning. I am not sure whether it was before or after his ruling. He informed me that if the vote on the first one was defeated, if the amendment stood, there would be no vote on the second one.

Comment on this

This is a reasonably serious vote. It would heap obloquy on the proceedings of this assembly if we were not able to proceed according to precedent. We should abide by precedent and approach the votes with absolute decorum.

Comment on this

This is what must be on the record. At an earlier stage it was proposed to take amendments Nos. 1 to 24 together and this was rejected out of hand. Two reasons were put forward. Deputy Desmond said that because his amendment was submitted earlier — how much earlier does not make any difference — he wanted it taken separately. Three or four Fine Gael Deputies, starting with Deputy Bruton, said strongly that by reason of the fact that amendment No. 2 proposed to increase the tax allowances it was separate and should be taken separately. That was the decision accepted by us at that time.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, may I ask you what do you intend to put to the House?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I understood that they were to be taken separately. That was my information.

Comment on this

On a point of order, you need have no concern they will not be taken separately. The point at issue which you seem to be evading, with great respect, is that in accordance with Standing Orders to amend a technical section of the Finance Bill the first vote to be taken is on the motion that the words stand. The words in the Bill relate to £4,400. We vote on that and, as you well know, in the event of those words being voted down, you are obliged to continue with my amendment which is taken separately and proposes that £4,800 be inserted instead. Then we vote on that. Any other interpretation is wholly unacceptable.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I was not here but I was informed there was disagreement and it was decided that they would be taken separately.

Comment on this

There is confusion. They are taken separately. If on the first motion it is decided that the words stand, the second does not come up. If the first motion is defeated then the Labour Party amendment is put. If that is defeated the Sinn Féin amendment is put. If the motion that the words stand is approved the Sinn Féin motion cannot be taken. That is the order to the House and that is the procedure which was agreed this morning. We cannot go back now.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am putting the question that the figure proposed to be deleted stand.

Comment on this

The procedure is now agreed?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is Deputy Desmond's amendment.

Comment on this
Deputies

No.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Sorry. I am wrong. "That the figure proposed to be deleted stand."

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): That means, in effect, that you are putting the section as drafted by the Government. If that is carried, the section as drafted by the Government stands. If it is defeated, you then put the Labour Party amendment. If that is defeated, you then put the Workers' Party amendment.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am putting the question "That the figure proposed to be deleted stand. "Na Teachtaí atá ar thaobh na ceiste abraidís tá——

Comment on this

On a point of order, I did not become involved in the discussions this morning. Precedent has been mentioned very often in the past few moments. Generally speaking, as was suggested by the Chair in the first instance, the series of amendments to the section, 24 of them, would be taken together and discussed together. Some Opposition Deputies said they wanted each amendment taken separately. That is a change from precedent.

Comment on this
Deputies

No.

Comment on this

Of course it is, because in the past 24 amendments related to the one point have been taken together.

Comment on this
Edward Collins Mr. E. Collins Fine Gael

By agreement.

Comment on this

That is the only comment I have to make about precedent.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the figure proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 84
·
Níl 82
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As there is an equality of votes I am obliged to exercise my casting vote and I feel my casting vote should not be used to defeat the Government and furthermore I am maintaining the status quo by my vote.

Comment on this

What did Gregory get in the last hour?

Comment on this
Mr. Bruton

I take it we will be following the same procedure in relation to this amendment as was followed in the other.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am sorry about the misunderstanding.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I appreciate the Chair's ruling in the matter.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am calling on Deputy Desmond to move his amendment.

Comment on this

When will the House be informed of the latest Gregory deal?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That does not arise now.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 3:

In page 9, line 20, to delete "£2,200", and substitute "£2,400".

The purpose of the amendment is to increase the basic tax exemption for a single person from £2,200 to £2,400. As the Minister is aware, as a result of the exemption which he gave in the March budget a single person earning £2,200 had an existing tax liability of £120 and that was reduced to nil by the Minister in extending the allowance for single and widowed persons from £2,000 to £2,200. We propose to extend the limit to £2,400

At the moment a single person with a total income of £3,000 will have a current tax liability of £237.50 less the marginal PRSI relief given subsequently. We are suggesting that the relief be extended upwards. It means that a person earning around £45 to £47 per week would not be liable to tax. I do not know how many single or widowed persons would be given the exemption. However, we consider it an equitable measure and we ask the Minister to consider sympathetically this request from the Labour Party.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

In view of the fact that we have had a very long debate, and in some ways a very exciting and wearing one, perhaps the House would agree to break for one hour at 5.30 p.m.?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the House agreeable?

Comment on this

I have no objection to the House adjourning for one hour from 5.30 p.m.

Comment on this

Will the Chair please clarify what amendment we are discussing?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 3.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Ths amendment is extending to single people the same increase in their allowance as was to be extended by the amendment that has just been defeated. It is logical that they should run together. The Minister was not able to give a separate costing but I can understand that. We will support this amendment as we consider it reasonable in the circumstances. It is within the confines of the tax allowance system. As the House is aware, when we were in Government we did something to change the tax allowance system to a more fair credits system. It is the best that can be done to help the lower paid; in this case we are dealing with the single lower paid as distinct from married people about whom we were concerned in the previous amendment.

Comment on this

On a point of order, did I understand from the Chair in reply to Deputy De Rossa that we were dealing with amendment No. 3?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Yes.

Comment on this

As the House has decided that the words proposed to be deleted stand, where is the sense in continuing to debate any subsequent amendment in that section? If the words proposed to be deleted stand, and that has been so decided, I am somewhat confused as to how we can now be discussing either or a combination of these figures.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

They are not the same figures.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

There is a difference between line 19 and line 20.

Comment on this

I wonder could I have the matter clarified. If the House has decided to leave the figure of £2,200 stand how can we then talk about changing it to another figure?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

£4,400.

Comment on this

How can we propose to change it since a decision has already been taken?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The amendment is to change £2,200. The first one is line 19, £4,400. Now in line 20 it is £2,200.

Comment on this

I understand that but perhaps someone could unravel, for my enlightenment, how if we have allowed by a decision of the House the figure £4,400 to stand we can then talk about changing in another line a figure which is half of the figure, namely, £2,200? It seems to be wrong. I merely seek clarification.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Deputy Blaney found difficulty seemingly in supporting Deputy Desmond's amendment which proposed giving an increased allowance to married people. Perhaps he might in this instance find he has undergone a crisis of conscience and will therefore support an increase in the allowance to single people. We hope he will be able to reach that conclusion and we want to give him the opportunity of doing so.

Comment on this

The same principle runs through all these 24 amendments and I have nothing to add to what I have already said in regard to amendment No. 1. I gave a global reply on the 24 amendments to section 1. I repeat that the increases in general, coupled with increases in personal and secondary allowances, are the most that can be offered to lower paid and aged taxpayers in our present difficult budgetary circumstances. The same principle underlies all 24 amendments and my reply in each case would therefore be similar. That would mean a great deal of repetition and it is not my wish to delay the House. My position on this amendment is the same as it was on amendment No. 1.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 84
·
Níl 82
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As there is an equality of votes, I am obliged to exercise my casting vote in favour of the status quo.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 5.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 5:

In page 9, line 21, to delete "£5,000", and substitute "£5,400".

I do not propose to delay the House. Again this is a consequential amendment — but has to be treated on a separate basis — increasing the figure from £5,000 to £5,400 on the age general exemption limit. The Minister and Deputies generally are aware of this benefit to a small group of persons in the community on very low income. All the arguments have already been made in relation to the section.

Comment on this

On a point of clarification, since the rest of these amendments, numbered 5-24, relate to the same section, the section of the Bill which imposes different limits for people aged 65, over 75 and so on, would it be possible for us to take them all together, having one composite vote or agreement on them? If we are to continue like this my opinion is that it is ludicrous and somewhat of a joke.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): Is the Deputy's blood pressure rising?

Comment on this

Is it possible to reach agreement that we take the rest of them together and have one vote on them or are we to go through the long tedious process of having votes all the evening? I do not think it is in the best interests of the House that we should continue that kind of charade.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I take the point Deputy McCreevy has made. There would have been a great case for the line he is adopting in respect of the last two votes because of the constitutional decision in regard to the treatment of married couples; there is a constitutional necessity that a married couple be treated the same as two single people in terms of their allowances. Had Deputy McCreevy made the point he has now made at that stage there would have been something in it but that does not apply in this instance. This is concerned with older members of the community who get an additional tax allowance. It is an entirely open policy matter on which we can, as a House, have a view, that there should be discrimination of a greater degree, relatively speaking, than exists at present given that the previous amendments have not been passed in favour of older people.

We have made the decisions about the basic allowances and what is at stake now is whether we should give a further additional allowance to older people, which is a new issue from the one we have been discussing up to now. Whereas the Minister made the case that for him £4 million was too much, and that he could not afford the generality of the amendments proposed by the Labour Party, I am quite sure that the cost of this amendment — which is merely extending an allowance to older taxpayers — would be very small indeed.

We are now afforded perhaps a fortuitous opportunity, nonetheless very real, to give something helpful to the older members of our community in terms of an increased tax allowance. I believe we should definitely support this amendment. Having succeeded in the other two votes, albeit by a very narrow and insecure margin, perhaps the Minister could see his way to accepting this amendment. The cost will be minimal and it will be constructively helping the older members of our community in regard to taxation. As the House is aware, there has been a considerable amount of controversy about the fact that old age pensions are liable to income tax. I do not want to get involved in that argument. I can see that if one excludes certain categories of income from——

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Might I interrupt the Deputy? We have agreed that the House will adjourn until 6.30 p.m.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

As I was saying just before we had our well-earned break, there is a lot of agitation because old age pensioners are taxed at all. People feel if they are receiving pensions which have been funded by contributions they made during their lifetime which was out of taxed income, even though they got tax allowances in respect of the contributions, they should not be taxed a second time on the pensions. I am not advocating that case because I believe one has to bear in mind that the more categories of income you exempt altogether from tax the more opportunities you are giving for tax avoidance. Obviously, if you exempted pensions you would have a situation contrived whereby people would be taking huge incomes in the form of pensions once they passed a certain age and not paying any tax at all on those pensions simply on the basis that the pensions per se had been exempted.

I am not advocating that case but I believe we have to recognise that this case has a fair degree of support and that there is a considerable amount of anger among older people because they pay so much tax on their pensions. Deputy Desmond's amendment affords us an opportunity of doing something to help the older people who are paying tax by increasing the exemption for them. I believe it is a very valid amendment. I do not believe it will cause any constitutional difficulties because it does not discriminate between married and single people. The Minister should consider accepting it. I would be interested if the Minister could let us have a costing for this amendment separate from the other amendments because obviously it will not cost £4 million. I imagine it would cost significantly less and it would be useful to have that information.

Comment on this

I would be interested if the Minister could indicate the cost of the particular amendment.

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy B. Desmond and Deputy Bruton in relation to the cost element, as I said at the outset this morning, the computer in the Revenue Commissioners costed all of the two series of amendments proposed and I gave those figures already. I do not have individual breakdowns of the cost. I do not want to repeat myself, I know there has been a distinction made between the first four amendments and amendment No. 5, but already that distinction is recognised when we see the £4,400 coming up to £5,000 for those over 65.

As I said, in reply to the first amendment, which was a general and global reply in relation to the 24 amendments to section 1, these particular areas cannot be looked at in isolation. The purpose of the exercise I undertook on 9 March was to devise, within the existing systems of taxation, the same benefits for the individual taxpayer as were proposed in the 27 January proposals. That included exemption limits, personal allowances, child allowances and tax band charges. Any one part of that overall package cannot be divorced from my main interest in providing, within the existing structures generally, the same benefits for all taxpayers, and that we succeeded in doing. I am sorry that I do not have the cost for which the Deputies have asked. Perhaps on Committee Stage it may be possible for the Revenue Commissioners to get that information for me out of the computer. So far, that has not been the position. If I can get this information at a later stage, I will very gladly give it to the Deputies. For the reasons which I have already mentioned in relation to the other amendments, including the aged taxpayers, the most favourable treatment which can be offered, bearing in mind the difficult budgetary circumstances, have been implemented in the terms of the Bill outlined in section 1 at the moment.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

For the sake of illustration, the figure to which we are referring in this instance is the substitution of £5,400 for £5,000, which in itself is a substitution for the figure £4,600 in section 2 (6) (a) of the 1980 Act. This Act, in turn, is referred back to the principal Act, that of 1967, which states: "In a case where the individual would, apart from this section, be entitled to a deduction specified in paragraph (a) of the said section 138 ..................." I would like to determine exactly what figure we are talking about here by reference to section 138 of the original Act. Could the Minister help us in this matter? I understand that this refers to a case of a husband whose tax is assessed for the year of assessment in accordance with the provisions of section 194, or who proves that his wife is not living with him but is fully maintained by him for the year of assessment and that he is not entitled in computing his income for tax purposes of that year to make any deduction in respect of the sums paid by him for the maintenance of his wife. He would get a deduction of £2,230.

Could we establish, by reference to the section concerned, what exactly we are talking about? It is rather unfortunate that the legislation is so framed that to determine what exactly one is referring to, not only must one refer to the Finance Act of 1980 but back from that to the Finance Act of 1967. When we get there, we find that the relevant section of the Finance Act of 1967 does not give us the answer, but refers us back to another section of the 1967 Act, section 194. This concerns an assessment in respect of the income of both spouses.

Are we, in fact, talking about what we think we are talking about? This looks like a reference to people who are separated, rather than a reference to the aged. Perhaps the Minister could clarify the position?

Comment on this

I can understand perfectly why the Deputy asks why we refer at all to this Act. We are referring back to it because it is in section 138 of the Act of 1967 that we referred to married allowances. That is the reason for the reference to this Act at the present time.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

So what, in fact, we are talking about here is the married allowance in respect of people over the age of 75?

Comment on this

No, 65, not 75.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

So the next reference is to people aged 75 and over?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I was afraid that I had made my case on the wrong basis in the first instance. May I say, without repeating myself unduly, it is a pity that the Minister has not been able to provide the costing of this amendment. This is an amendment which stands on its own feet, independently of the other amendments upon which we have already made a decision. Would the Minister, or those advising him, know approximately how many people are at the moment claiming reduction of their tax on the basis of this section? I would have thought that that figure would be reasonably readily available. The Minister might be able to tell us how many people claimed last year, if the information for this year is not available. That would give us some idea of the order of magnitude of the costing.

The whole thing costs £4 million and it may transpire that somewhere in the region of 10 per cent of all taxpayers come within this section. Assuming that the average income of people over 65 is likely to be less than for those under 65 and, for the sake of argument, that 10 per cent of taxpayers will be involved, one could assume, I would have thought, that the cost of this concession would be in the region of 7 per cent to 8 per cent of the total figure for all the amendments. We are talking now of 7 per cent of £4 million — a very small amount, really. If the Minister has had qualms or trouble about the formula, he should not have much trouble about giving a concession costing such a small amount of money to people over 65. I am surprised that he has not been able to give us this information, but I am not making any unfair criticism either of him or of those advising him. One does not need a computer to give this sort of information. Ministers have been able to do so in the House long before computers were invented.

Comment on this

That is why.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

We probably have more public servants in the Department of Finance even though it is not a particularly overstaffed Department, I must say — than we had in the years when they were able to give the information without the aid of computers. We should not be pleading the excuse of the Revenue computer as a basis for not giving reasonable information like this, which would be useful to us in looking at this amendment. In my view, for what it is worth, this amendment would cost somethere in the region of £200,000 to £300,000, that is all — a very small amount of money. Given that it is helping people over 65 and also that there is a concensus in the House that people over 65 need special help as far as tax is concerned — we all agree that they should get a rent allowance which others are not getting — it is not inconsistent, philosophically or fiscally, to grant some special extra tax allowance to the over 65s. Deputies who might have felt constrained to vote for the Government, if the Government decided to oppose this amendment — which I hope they will not — on the grounds of £4 million being too much, I am sure that they could swallow £200,000 to help the old with their tax. That is not too difficult to accept, from either a financial or ethical point of view.

I would ask the Deputies concerned who are, in a sense, determining the affairs of the House at the moment to consider supporting this amendment. Clearly, if the Government accept this, there is no great issue of principle involved or, if the Government are defeated on this amendment, they would not necessarily feel in the same compromised position as if they had failed to carry the earlier amendments. This would cost only a minimal sum of money in respect of people of an age who deserve help. I suggest that the Minister accept the amendment and I ask Deputies who supported the Minister in previous division to support this amendment. It would cost only about £200,000.

Comment on this

I apologise for not having the breakdown or the information I have been asked for. If I were to agree to these exemption limits I would be making allowances for more rich people than poor. The marriage allowance must be double that of the single allowance. That is a reality. It is not entirely a matter of cost. What is being done here involves a combination of income limitation, tax band allowances and to give the same advantage to individual taxpayers vis-à-vis credits versus allowances. As I said in relation to amendment No. 1, the Bill provides for increases of the size expected in respect of single and married and aged people. We cannot do better in existing difficult budgetary circumstances. Therefore, I cannot accept the amendment.

If I can get the additional information requested later in the Committee Stage I will give it to Deputies. As Deputy Bruton said, before the computer age it was possible to get such information. If I can get it I will gladly give it.

Comment on this

I share Deputy Bruton's view on the amendment. Effectively what we are saying to the Minister relates more to the 75 years-plus group than the 65 to 75 group. There are not many of them, but in terms of actual income it has been clearly established that the over 75 years group tend dramatically to have declining incomes, or at best fixed incomes. I do not have precise information of the numbers claiming the age allowance. It would be interesting to know how many people claim the age allowance at ages 65 to 75 years and those of 75 plus. I do not think it would be exaggerating to say that one could reasonably estimate the cost at not more than £400,000. Therefore, the relief we are looking for in the amendment would cost very little. The Minister can say what he likes about his objection to accepting any of these amendments, but when framing the amendments I deliberately kept the cost of accepting them to a very small amount of money. However, it could have a considerable impact on the people concerned, especially those of more than 65 years of age.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I have found information which will indicate the order of magnitude involved. Widows and widowers caught in the tax net are more likely to be older than 65 years. In the 1977-78 tax year there were 183,000 single males and 166,000 females paying tax. There were 72,000 married couples with the wives earning and 247,000 married couples with wives not working. That adds up to a substantial number of taxpayers. There were only 9,000 widowers and 23,000 widows in the tax net out of 702,000 paying tax. That is a very tiny proportion. I am not saying there are many widowers and widows of under 65 years of age. The people concerned in the amendment are a tiny proportion of those paying tax and I think Deputy Desmond's estimate of £400,000 is far too generous.

Comment on this