We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1982: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 177–340 of 340. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill, 1982
Enacted

No. 10 of 1982 ›

One can make this case in respect of each of the 24 amendments and the overall picture would be as I have already stated. We have provided an income limit in these cases equal to £100 a week for the over 65s. We cannot look at each amendment in isolation. Deputy Bruton would have to accept that we cannot pick out one of the categories involved and say, "We will do it for that section because it would cost only £X millions". We must always watch the trigger mechanism that operates throughout exemption limits. I do not think anybody can pick out a suggestion like this, or the one contained in the next amendment, and suggest that it should be implemented. However, because of the points that have been raised in the course of the debate and in the absence of the information in regard to cost and numbers — the point was made by both speakers about the age structure of such people — I undertake to examine the matter in the context of any review of exemption limits during the course of the preparation of next years' budget. That is as far as I am prepared to go. I will see if it will be possible to do anything in the preparation of next year's budget.

Comment on this

I am reluctant to press for a division in the absence of precise information. I have been searching through the various Financial Statements presented since 1978 and I still maintain that one is talking about a figure in the region of £300,000 or £400,000. That is tenable and because of that I will press the amendment, to a division if necessary.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the figure proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 84
·
Níl 82
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As there is an equality of votes I am obliged to exercise my casting vote and, for the reason I have already stated earlier, I am casting it in favour of the question. The overall result is Tá, 81; Níl, 80.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 7:

In page 9, line 22, to delete "£6,000", and substitute "£6,400".

The Minister will be familiar with the argument in relation to the basic exemption relief for a person aged between 65 years and 75 years. This amendment is to give relief to those over 75 years of age of £6,400. We have already debated the cost and I imagine that in this regard it will be low.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

For the reasons I gave in respect of the last amendment I support this one also.

Comment on this

For the reasons I have already given on numerous occasions I will not delay the House. However, I have some information regarding this amendment and the previous one which I will give the House. To take amendment No. 7 first, the number of people over 75 availing of age exemptions is 7,000 of whom 2,500 are married and 4,500 are either single or widowed. The figure in the 65 to 75 age group is 27,500 of whom 14,500 are married and 13,000 are in the single and widowed category. Again, I must apologise for not having the actual cost but if it comes to hand during the course of the debate, I shall give it to the House.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

This confirms that my estimates were almost accurate. Having regard to the number of people in the tax net the proportion involved is tiny. For the two amendments the total is 35,000 while the total number of people in the tax net in the year 1977-78 was 702,000. That number is probably similar now, though it may be slightly more. Therefore, in relation to these two amendments we are talking of about 5 per cent of the total number in the tax net. If the cost of all the concessions amounted to £4 million, the cost in the case in question would be in the region of £200,000. That would be in respect of both concessions and given that of the 35,000 who are over 65, only 7,000 are over 75, I would expect the cost of the concession we are talking about here to be in the region of £40,000. That is a very small sum of money. Considering that the Government have decided to buy a castle in Galway for £400,000, what we are talking about here is only one-tenth of the cost of that castle.

Comment on this

But there is something happening in Galway.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

That is what the Government are hoping for. This, then, puts in proportion the cost of the concession we are seeking for the over-75 age group. We have heard a lot from the people opposite about responsibility but they can hardly consider this amendment to be irresponsible. Consequently, I look to the Government to accept the amendment.

Comment on this

I have replied already to this question in relation to the previous amendment in so far as those in the 65 to 75 age group and now the over-75 group are concerned. I do not know whether I was understood but I said that in view of the case that has been made by Deputies I would take into account the points raised in respect of these age groups when the January budget is being prepared. That is as far as I am in a position to go at this stage.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

We must take that assurance for what it is worth given the double condition that the Minister is only prepared to consider the question and that he may not be introducing a budget in January.

Comment on this

One would not get very much from a bank manager on such conditions.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The assurance is so hedged with conditions as not to be sufficient to satisfy us on this occasion.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

No, but in the light of the unfortunate happening to those in the 65 to 75 age group, I shall not challenge it to a vote.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 9:

In page 9, line 22, to delete "£2,500", and substitute "£2,700".

This amendment does not require any elaboration and I am simply now moving it formally so as not to delay the House.

Comment on this

It is the same situation in this case as that outlined in respect of the other eight amendments.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 11:

In page 9, line 23, to delete "£3,000", and substitute "£3,200".

Comment on this

Again, the situation is the same.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I must indicate that amendments Nos. 13 to 24, inclusive, are related to the Table and since it has been decided already that the figures in the section stand, the figures in the Table which embody those in the section cannot be changed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 25:

In page 10, in column (3) of the Table, opposite the reference to section 141 (child) in column (1), to delete "100" and substitute "150".

Can the Minister say what is the number of taxpayers involved and also what is the cost involved here? As Deputies will be aware, this is a proposal to raise the child tax allowance from £100 to £150 and I am particularly interested in the cost involved.

Comment on this

The cost of this change would be £10 million in 1982 and £16 million in a full year. The reduction in the child tax allowance in respect of income tax from £195 to £100 as announced in the budget is associated with the increases in the social welfare children's allowances and cannot be taken in isolation. For those reasons and bearing in mind what I have said already in relation to section 1, that is, that all of these changes were part of a package designed to give generally the same benefits to the individual taxpayer as was proposed in the January budget, I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy Desmond agree that amendment No. 26 is related and therefore might be taken with No. 25?

Comment on this

I would agree. What is the cost in respect of amendment No. 26?

Comment on this

In this case the cost is £1.2 million in 1982 and £1.8 million in a full year.

Comment on this

What was the overall expenditure in increased children's allowances in 1982?

Comment on this

It is a social welfare problem. All I have is the amount £11.75. I do not have the total cost of the social welfare changes but I shall get it for the Deputy.

Comment on this

I think the Minister should very seriously examine what I regard as the relative social inadequacy of children's allowances in the tax situation. We have failed to pay sufficient attention to this matter. There is a body of authoritative social research which gives the cost of maintenance of a child within the family unit and one is talking about 40 per cent of the adult rate for certain age groups. It is quite exceptionally high. I have no doubt that in the context of our tax structure the tax allowances for children are quite disproportionate as against allowances for single persons and for married persons. The amounts given in tax allowances for children have become regressive over the past two or three years. I say that notwithstanding that children's allowances, which are across the board, by and large have also areas of regression in them because farmers as we well know—there are 150,000 farmers very many of whom are married but the vast bulk of whom pay no income tax — get ordinary children's allowances and do not make a tax contribution. Definitely in my opinion there is a very serious social discrimination against PAYE payers and those generally liable for income tax but who only get at this stage an actual £100 per child. Admittedly, the cost is quite high.

I do not propose to press this amendment to a division but I ask the Minister in the context of next year's budget and of the report of the Commission on Income Taxation — I am rather dubious about what that commission would suggest in regard to children's allowances and this whole area — to have a social study done on this aspect within the Department of Finance. The Department, with their pervasive influence over budget content, with respect to the staff concerned, exert tremendous influence over the Minister. That is not inappropriate, but the Minister should also be a man in his own right prepared to write his own budget speech. Invariably there tends to be reluctance to give relief on the childrens' allowance side. I strongly urge the Minister to examine particularly the social cost of child maintenance within the family, within the single parent family where it is also very high, and within the family with one parent, a widow or widower. I have no doubt that there is an imbalance in our tax structure discriminating against children, a unique imbalance that has come about in the past seven or eight years.

Deputy Bruton when Minister made a brave effort in the context of the family supplement scheme and general turning about of the tax structure to achieve equity, but I think time was too short and the amount of work to be done too great. The end result is that we have now lapsed back into the old personal allowances and tax bands. I am not putting my amendment to a division because amendments Nos. 25 and 26 together involve something in the region of £20 million. I should like to see that money go to large families and families in greatest social need. I am not so sure that my amendment achieves social equity but there is a serious anomaly in connection with children's allowances.

Deputy Richie Ryan when Minister for Finance also made a tremendous effort in this connection when he suggested the clawback in relation to elements of children's allowances which were given indiscriminately to everybody in the community, as is still the situation. We all recall the vilification which Deputy Ryan incurred at that time when he suggested a change in regard to the money given out to the population irrespective of income. That does not happen in any other European country; there is a tax relationship in the money given out. Taking these points into consideration I urge the Minister to examine the situation which is now discriminatory and unjust and lacks basic equity.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I think it can be shown by reference to the records in regard to tax and benefits for families with children that families with children have lost very substantially in benefits and allowances against tax in the last five or six years. Probably a crucial point in the whole matter was the decision which granted a married couple the right to the same allowance as a single person. The Government financed that change at the time largely by failing to increase the benefits for families with children. In our tax structure a married couple with six children proportionately speaking were much better off five or six years ago relative to a married couple with no children than they are now. This is a socially regressive trend, and to a large extent an unconscious trend in our tax policy. I do not think any Minister at any time said: "We are being too generous to large families". They just slipped into the situation because of other decisions that had to be taken at different times. We have ended up with a tax system which in my view is fundamentally unjust to large families.

Speaking from memory, which I think is reasonably accurate, the child benefit in Britain is about three times as generous as it is here even though our old age pension and social benefits are the same or even less than equivalent benefits in Britain. This shows that we are concentrating all the benefits on people who are voters, adults. If you are an adult you get the benefit but no benefits are being given in terms of families with large numbers of children because the additional children have no vote. I think that is what has happened in a sense, that in voting strength large families are a small minority — even though in terms of population they are not a small minority. Progressively, for a number of years past we have been making the situation worse and worse for large families. We have failed to increase child allowances — in fact we have cut them — although my budget and the budget of the present Minister did increase child benefits, and the present Minister's budget increased child benefits fairly substantially, but they are still about one-third the equivalent rate in the UK even though our other social benefits are roughly line ball with those in the UK. I urge that this is very unjust. I do not believe that child tax allowances — which is what this amendment is about — are the best way of giving benefits to large families because they are of most benefit to large families in the 60 per cent tax band and they are of no benefit to large families who are not paying tax. We should aim to have a generous, means-tested child benefit which would go direct to all families on low incomes, regardless of whether their income comes from social welfare or work. At present persons on social welfare get child benefits, which are reasonably generous and which are built into their social welfare allowances, but if the head of such a household goes out to work he ceases to get the child benefit element in his social welfare payment and all he has is a very ungenerous child tax allowance to set against the income he derives from work. Also if he goes out to work he pays tax, whereas if he stays at home on the same income from social benefits he pays no tax at all on it.

We should aim to do away with the child benefit element in social welfare payments and use that money to give it to everyone on a low income whether at work or on social benefit. Probably we should aim to abolish child tax allowances altogether and give the money thereby saved in the form of a means-tested child benefit to the low income families whether they are at work or not, and we should aim to have that benefit at least as generous as the one that obtains in Britain at the moment. This is a reasonable opportunity to put my views forward on this. I do not expect the Minister to comment on them at this stage but I hope we will have another opportunity to discuss these matters.

I would like to ask the Minister to comment on the point in relation to the dependent relative allowance. That allowance was introduced in the 1949 budget by the late Deputy Paddy McGilligan as Minister for Finance. It has remained almost exactly the same since it was introduced. It had hardly been increased at all until I proposed to increase it in my budget of January and now the Minister is increasing it again. Deputy Desmond seeks to increase it further. If this dependent relative allowance had been index-linked since it was introduced in 1949 it would be around £500 or £600 now. Probably when it was introduced it was equal to or not much less than the personal allowance given to the taxpayer himself but it has remained at £95 until very recently, whereas the personal allowance has gone up to about £1,000. We should discuss the reason why this has happened. On the face of it it seems unjust that the allowance to a taxpayer who is keeping an aged relative, his mother, mother-in-law or father-in-law or any other relative who is not able to earn a living, should be treated so ungenerously that the allowance has remained static since 1949, while we have increased enormously all the other allowances.

I am drawing now on advice that I got in the Department of Finance, so I more than suspect that the reason that we have not increased the dependent relative allowance is that it is impossible to police it and to find out whether the dependent relative is really dependent on the taxpayer. A person can put in a claim for his Uncle Mick who might have been dead for ten years and the Revenue Commissioners have no way of finding out whether he is dead or alive. Certainly they have no way of finding out if he is dependent on the taxpayer or has an income of his own. Uncle Mick could be Nephew Mick who succeeded his uncle and the taxpayer could still be claiming for him so long as he is not in the tax net. It seems that we have not increased this provision because we are not sure that we can enforce it adequately, but that is illogical. If we believe that the thing is so wide open to abuse, why should we not do away with it altogether and not waste money on it? Alternatively, we should increase it but police it properly. We should give a reasonable dependent relative allowance but make sure that it is available only to people who are dependent on the taxpayer.

Now that we have a combined PRSI system where everyone has a number whether he is in the tax situation or welfare situation, it should not be too difficult to devise a dependent relative allowance system that would be enforceable, that would ensure that only people really dependent on the taxpayer would get it. I would like to ask the Minister if he has considered this point and if he can suggest if it would be possible — not at this time, not until he is satisfied that he has a method of ensuring that the dependent relative allowance will not be abused and to go any further at this stage would not be a great idea — before next year's budget to re-examine the whole operation of the dependent relative allowance to ensure that we have an allowance that is capable of being policed accurately and given to genuine cases. I would like the Minister to give me his comments on this and to state if he agrees that what I have said is correct about the dependent relative allowance in his experience and, if so, what he would propose to do about it.

Comment on this

I ask the Minister to reflect that if the dependent relative allowance was increased he would save money in other areas where relatives are put into Eastern Health Board and other homes when, if the allowance was more generous more families would be more willing to keep their dependent relatives. On the one hand he might increase the allowance but he might find that he would have a saving in the other area.

Comment on this

Starting at the end of those two comments, largely I cannot disagree with any of the points that have been made with regard to the dependent relative allowance. For the information of the House, 126,000 people are affected by that allowance. What Deputy Bruton said in relation to the administrative and controlling problems and so on is largely true. I cannot disagree too much with what he has said and I will undertake to have examined very carefully the points he has made in the context of seeing how best we can streamline this whole area in relation to dependent relatives.

The last point made is arguable. If you increase the allowances too much people might, just for the benefit of the allowance, take out of institutions people who are not fit to come out. The Deputy rightly made the other point that if the allowance was reasonable many people who are put into institutions would not have been put in in the first case. We have a two-sided argument there. I have taken careful note of the points made and in the context of future reviews in this regard I will see if there is any way that we could streamline this approach.

On the main point, the child allowance, taking the points that Deputy Desmond has raised, it is quite true that we have now reached the situation where we are writing out the child from the tax system and compensating in other ways under the social welfare code. The point he and Deputy Bruton made is that we should have a very close examination of this matter. There is a difference between what Deputy Desmond and what Deputy Bruton said about what should be done. I gathered from Deputy Desmond's approach that, as he proposes in his amendment, there should be an increased child allowance. On the other hand, Deputy Bruton put forward the suggestion he already put forward in his Programme for Government and in his budget statement of 27 January, which was to take away the tax allowance completely and combined it and the children's allowance for some sort of child benefit. There is a bit of a contradiction in what was said by Deputy Bruton and Deputy Desmond.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

There is no harm in that.

Comment on this

I am not saying there is or there is not. It shows there are different views and different approaches to this question vis-à-vis the social welfare code, children's allowances, child benefits and the taxation code or a combination of them. I will see if we can make any progress regarding the situation vis-à-vis social welfare and tax allowances. I will look into it very carefully to see if there is any way in which we can streamline that consession.

In the circumstances of the overall package of measures to which I referred on previous amendments, I have to oppose this. Deputy Desmond said he will not press it. We are talking about £18 million and £20 million in a full year which is a sizeable amount of money. I have taken careful note of the points made about dependent relative and child allowances. I undertake to have them carefully examined. I am much more confident than Deputy Bruton may be that I will be introducing the January budget and I hope that in some way I may be able to include some of the points made by both Deputies.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

In this instance it does not seem to be relevant which of us will be introducing the budget. We seem to be pretty much in agreement on what should be done. Might I make a further suggestion to the Minister in elaboration of what I have already said? In respect of the dependent relative, probably the best thing we could do would be to introduce, if possible, a dependent relative tax credit. If you have a dependent relative allowance it has the effect that it tends to give a disproportionately large benefit to somebody who has most of his income on the 60p rate. If in the course of changing it into something which could be capable of being properly policed we could introduce it as a credit, it would be of equal benefit to all taxpayers. That might be the best course of action to adopt.

I will be interested to see what the Commission on Taxation will have to say about it. I hope they will not suggest that the dependent relative allowance should be abolished because it is too inconvenient to find a system which works. That might be the temptation they would have. It was introduced for a legitimate reason in 1949 and it has been our successive failure to make it capable of working properly. The fact that it has not worked properly in the past derives from the fact that we did not make an effort to make it work properly. We should try now, and a tax credit would probably be the best outcome to have in the January budget.

Comment on this

We will have a look at that point as well. We are all anxious to secure a system which has greater equity. That is why the Commission on Taxation were set up two years ago. I understand that on 5 July or 7 July the commission will present me with a report. I will deal with it immediately and present it to the Government, and the Government will express their view on it.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Will it be published?

Comment on this

That will be a matter for the Government. The commission were set up to enable us to have more equity within the system. When we consider all the various exemption limits, and allowances, and dependent relative allowances and child allowances, and so on, we realise that we have sought to assist those areas under the taxation code or the social welfare code. Whether the allowances will go up at a given time or come down depends on the finances among other things. Perhaps there is a different approach towards helping these sections of the community. I hope the commission have directed their attention to it and will give us some guidance on what decisions might be taken in the future.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendment No. 28 is related to amendment No. 27 and we are taking both together for debate.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 27:

In page 11, Part I of the Table, to delete "£3,000" and substitute "£4,500".

If carried, this amendment would have the effect of restoring the tax bands to what they were in the last tax year. This is not a proposal to restructure the entire tax system. I am not under the illusion that I am introducing a budget. The Fianna Fáil budget proposal set out in the Finance Bill aims to reduce the 35 per cent tax band by one-third, from £4,500 to £3,000 for single people and from £9,000 to £6,000 for married couples. Even without inflation this would mean an increase in tax for many workers. Combined with inflation it represents a plan for a massive increase in the PAYE yield both as a proportion of workers' pay and as a proportion of total taxation. As a result huge numbers of workers will find themselves pushed into higher tax bands with many paying 60 per cent by the end of the tax year.

I pointed this out in my statement on budget day when, sadly, some of the other socialist Deputies, in The Workers' Party notably, were welcoming this budget as reasonable, well-balanced and a tremendous improvement and benefit. Indeed, they could find no fault whatsoever with it. I have been glad to notice that recently The Workers' Party have had second thoughts on the matter and I hope they will now reverse their vote of 25 March last and vote for this amendment to oppose this massive imposition on PAYE workers.

With this single but significant exception, I must say Deputy Desmond's new financial proposals represent a considerable improvement on those he supported in January. I would give my support to most of them. I reject Deputy Desmond's suggestion that only the very well-off would benefit from my proposal. A single man or woman on £6,362 in 1982-83 will pay 45 per cent tax, that is on £122 or so per week which is more than £20 below the average industrial wage. If a person earns £8,362 over the year to next April, that is, about £160 a week, he or she will pay 55 per cent tax plus 7.5 per cent PRSI. In other words, on any extra pound some of these people could be paying more than 60 per cent tax all told, more than the richest people in the country.

A single person earning £10,362, or under £200 a week, will pay 60 per cent tax at the top rate. By the end of this year, with inflation and the cost of living rising rapidly, these kind of earnings could hardly be described as princely. Similarly a married couple with only one earner bringing in about £12,000 over the course of the tax year may be better off than many but could not be said to be rich in a country with no wealth tax, a small tax on big farmers, and very low capital and profits tax. Should they be asked to bear the penal burden of hitting the very highest tax rates? Young workers who are paid well below the average industrial wage will now find themselves paying £52.5 per cent of every extra £1 between PAYE and PRSI, making it difficult for them to marry and set up home. I can hardly believe the Labour Party and The Workers' Party want this kind of situation.

In view of the fact that Fine Gael and Labour opposed the Fianna Fáil proposal on budget day, 25 March, and then proposed an amendment to increase the lower tax bands again I must express my disappointment at their attitude since that date. Deputy Michael Noonan of my own constituency, Limerick East, made a strong statement on that day protesting that the budget produced a situation whereby people on extraordinarily low levels of income would be moving into very high tax bands. Today, however, he apparently finds this acceptable. Deputy Bruton described the amendment on 25 March, quite similar to the one I am proposing today, as designed to help the lower paid. I hope to hear something from Deputy Bruton today on that score. While I would prefer a system of tax credits as a more flexible and fairer system of taxation, my amendment nevertheless does benefit the lower paid and should be supported by all Members of this House who believe in genuine tax reform.

Comment on this

As Deputy Kemmy quoted my statement after the Minister's statement on the budget I feel it is desirable for me to comment at this time. When I made that statement I meant what I said. I did say that it was reasonable because we have now seen the contentious issues removed from the budget that was supported by Deputy Kemmy on January 27.

Comment on this

I did not support it. I voted against it.

Comment on this

That was the issue and the fact is that we saw that these very contentious issues were removed from that budget and then I said it was reasonable.

But let us come to the issue now before us. I want to refer to the increases in the personal allowance to the various categories. From 1981-82 a single person's allowance was £1,115 and that goes up to £1,450; for a married couple it was £2,230 and goes to £2,290. I would not take that line because broadening the tax bands took away whatever was granted in those increased allowances. Suffice it to say that in any consideration one gives one must have regard to the category of people at this time who would benefit from the amendment as proposed. I do not think that Deputy Kemmy is entirely right when he refers to the people in the lower tax bands benefiting from the amendment if it were implemented. First and foremost it is estimated that the proposal would cost about £50 million. This is a very substantial amount of money and there has been no indication of how that money would be got. Deputy Kemmy mentioned the resource tax amendment which would raise about £7 million. In any case, it is not money that would be well spent in so far as it hands out substantial benefits to taxpayers in the higher income groups. For example, a married couple earning about £19,000 a year would benefit by £20 a week from this measure but it would not mean anything to a married taxpayer with less than £11,500 a year, especially if he is not claiming interest relief on a mortgage. For those earning interest relief it will mean nothing for those with incomes up to £16,000. Like the PRSI allowance the biggest benefit goes to those on the highest income; the more income the more the State foregoes tax revenue. This is not the correct approach to the matter. Of course we have nothing against increasing the exemption limit or retaining the tax bands but if that revenue is to be recouped there has to be reference to the people in the higher tax brackets and those people are the people who will benefit if the amendment as proposed were implemented.

Comment on this

I will only be a moment. I just wanted to say that it is quite obvious, when one studies the figures, that the order of the reliefs is such that the people on the smaller incomes achieve a proportionately higher reduction in the amount of tax which they pay. Surely this is the direction in which we have to try to move if we are to achieve a certain amount of tax equity which we are all trying to achieve. For example, on income tax payable under PAYE on earnings of a married couple with three children a person on £7,000 would save about £120 a year in income tax. Let us move up the scale to people on £15,000 who would pay an extra £125 a year in income tax. Between £7,000 and £15,000 the scale tips the other way. The people on £7,000 have a saving and the people on £15,000 pay more. So the bands as they stand in the Bill are quite sensible. If they were the other way around it would be quite a serious situation.

Again, if one takes mortgages into account which most people here have to pay one finds the same thing. A single person paying mortgage interest of about £2,000 per annum and earning £8,000 would pay an extra £90 or so in taxation under the present schedule which is not that great. A person on £20,000 pays the best part of an extra £600, taking the mortgage relief into account. While we could all write our own budget and put in our own figures and argue those figures the main thing that we have to be satisfied on as legislators is that the direction is the correct direction. We can argue about the detail of that direction, but I am satisfied from these rates that the less well off gain more proportionately than the better off. After that the only argument left is whether or not one has to raise any income tax. As I said on Second Stage, the options are very limited. If one raises taxation one increases the borrowing or one contains public expenditure. There is very little scope left for increasing taxation. There is virtually no scope left for increased borrowing. We will have to do what we can in the area of controlling and getting better value for State expenditure. I am satisfied that under this schedule the drift is quite correct. If we were to adopt the amendment it could tip the scale not to the less well off which I know is the aim of the amendment but it would certainly tip the scale towards the better off because one would be widening the band to give them extra relief. I do not think that is the direction we should go if we are to achieve tax equity.

Comment on this

I know this has been a rather long and strenuous day for Deputy Sherlock but he must be in a desperate state of mental confusion when he accuses me of voting in favour of the January budget. He is very wrong and I hope he will withdraw that allegation because the world and Garrett Reilly know my vote on that occasion.

I have heard the figures quoted against my amendment by Deputy Brennan and Deputy Sherlock and perhaps there is some truth in the statement made by Deputy Brennan about widening the tax bands. I pointed out that the PAYE system is not flexible and I would prefer the tax credits which would give us the opportunity to do what I would like. Nevertheless I will not have my figures disputed because they were carefully researched and analysed and will bear scrutiny by anybody. I have no intention of amending them.

Comment on this

I have the greatest regard for a fellow socialist in the finest tradition, Deputy Kemmy, because his intentions are invariably not just well-intended but are the product of long years of experience in public life. He should be in the Labour Party because we share so many views.

I have not the slightest doubt that when he tabled his amendment he intended providing substantial tax reliefs across the board to those in greatest need. He said those earning above £6,362 would benefit. I share his view but there is a problem. The average weekly earning of an industrial worker in transportable goods industries is £148 gross. Under Deputy Kemmy's amendment, he does not gain one penny. It was argued that he might get something on £120, but it would not be of any great consequence. I estimate that this would cost about £52 million and all that would go to the top 22 per cent of taxpayers. Even examining the Revenue Commissioners' Report of December 1979, and looking at the total range of incomes, in terms of distribution of incomes, there is not much doubt that the relief proposed by Deputy Kemmy would not be substantial.

I have been subjected to a great deal of almost personal abuse because of my attitude to taxation. I believe we should pay our taxes, and that we cannot abolish income taxation or PRSI. It is important to point out that under the existing Finance Bill a married couple earning £7,000 a year, which is below the average earnings of a PAYE worker, pays £1,000 taxes or 14.64 per cent of total income. We want an equitable tax system and I believe we can bring about such a system, but I do not believe there can be massive general reductions in overall income taxation. I believe that a very equitable PRSI system can be introduced. The current system is chaotic, unfair and unjust, particularly for workers earning less than £9,500. I do not believe one should pick figures out of the air and apply them across the board.

There is a great deal of propaganda going around about taxation. One would swear the whole country was paying 45 per cent to 55 per cent income tax. It is important to point out that under this Bill a married PAYE worker with PRSI allowance does not become liable to income tax at the rate of 45 per cent until his income is £11,800 a year. It must be remembered that the media people sometimes pick this up because they earn above the average worker's earnings, as do politicians. There are very few people in this country actually earning——

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The Deputy is tempting interventions from the Press Gallery.

Comment on this

I am not.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. Raphael Burke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is going against his usual angle——

Comment on this

Some people say that a person earning £10,000 or £12,000 is crucified on the 45 per cent rate. The short answer is that there are not that many people earning that amount of money. The average factory worker earns £148 a week gross, including overtime, shift allowances and week-end working, and the average take home pay is about £7,500. Dublin Corporation workers got an increase of £7.50 a week sanctioned by the Labour Court, which brought the basic rate up to £132 a week. If the average local authority worker gets another £10 or £15 a week, his wage will be only £148 a week. It is very important that all the people in the middle income group, those working in the media and politicians, who talk about people paying 55 per cent tax should appreciate that a married worker with a PRSI allowance does not become liable for income tax at the rate of 45 per cent until his income reaches £11,812. If he has additional allowances for mortgage interest, medical expenses, life assurance, he would not reach the 45 per cent rate until his income is well in excess of that figure — he might have another £1,000 to claim and that means he might have to earn about £12,700 before he pays the 45 per cent rate.

There is a great deal of propaganda going around about income tax and PRSI. About £1,600 million is collected in income taxation, of which the PAYE workers pay about £1,400 million. The system is wrong, in terms of inequity and discrimination, to the tune of about £300 million or £400 million. The system should be broadened. I tend to part company with other Opposition Deputies here because I think the farming community should be paying an extra £60 million or £70 million in income taxation, the capital gains side should be increased by another £60 million or £70 million, and there should be a property tax. What has happened is that a very large number of people have salted away substantial amounts of money in commercial banks under the £70 interest exemption and they used that money to buy property in the £70,000 and £80,000 bracket.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy seems to be taking pleasure from the fact that he knows he is out of order.

Comment on this

I am not that much out of order because as Deputy Kemmy correctly pointed out he is chasing tax equity, but we must chase it in the right direction. If I had £52 million to hand out today to support Deputy Kemmy's amendment, I could not do it because this will benefit the top 25 per cent of taxpayers. If I had that £52 million, there are many areas in which I would spend it —on large families, the elderly and those in greatest need. I would say to Deputy Kemmy not to force a division on this. Report Stage has yet to come. He has raised the general question of bands and he is quite free to table other amendments. He would not necessarily get our support at that stage but my view is that we should consider the whole matter. In the 14 years I have been in Dáil Éireann this is the first time the Dáil has discussed a Finance Bill in depth. The tragedy is that we have not had a committee of the Dáil to deal with taxation. As a result, an enormous amount of political mythology and waffle about taxation——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The mythology and the waffle are not pertinent to the amendment.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I agree with Deputy Kemmy where he pointed out that it would be far better if we could discuss this type of proposal in the context of tax credits. As long as Deputy Kemmy is forced, by the abandonment of the Government of tax credits, into a situation of trying to seek relief in the tax code on the basis of extending bands that are on top of allowances it is inevitable that disproportionate benefit will be given to the better off. This is an inevitable consequence of the fact that our system remains an allowance system. I am glad the Deputy has expressed so clearly his support for the idea of tax credits. If we could move towards tax credits we would be able to consider this kind of system.

The problem for taxpayers this year is to some extent a problem of perception. The Government were trying to imitate our tax credit proposals while still retaining allowances. That meant that artificially and in a very misunderstood way, so far as the taxpayers were concerned, they had to reduce the 35p band dramatically. If that had been done in the context of tax credits, even though many people would not be any better off in the end, there would not have been any rebellion because it would have been in the context of a reformed tax system based on credits and people at the bottom of the scale would come out better off with family income supplements. However, as long as the Government try to imitate tax credits while still using allowances there will be many strange results such as the dramatically reduced 35p tax band.

Because implementation of Deputy Kemmy's amendment would cost a substantial sum I do not think it can be contemplated at this time. However, I sympathise with him in trying to achieve greater equity in the tax code. While I find difficulty with his amendment I see myself in agreement with him on the need to move towards a system of tax credits. I hope that between us we will be able to create an opportunity in not too distant future to introduce tax credits.

Comment on this

On the last point made by Deputy Bruton, extending the tax bands gives greater benefits to the higher paid under any system, whether tax credits or allowances. There has been a discussion on tax equity in relation to the amendments. If the amendment was carried it would cost £53 million in 1982 and £82 million in a full year. People in the 35 per cent band would not receive any benefit; those in the 45 per cent band would have a benefit of up to £200 per annum; those in the 55 per cent band a benefit of up to £500 per annum and those in the 60 per cent band would have a benefit up to £700 per annum. I do not know how anyone can see equity in that.

Here is an example — we have had many such examples during the day, although they were relatively minor in comparison — of political opportunism and of misreading deliberately what was done. It has been described by Deputy Bruton as being artificial. There was nothing artificial about it. It was open, above-board and was explained quite clearly.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I did not say it was a secret.

Comment on this

The Deputy said it was artificial but there was nothing artificial about it. Here is an example of political opportunism. As Deputy Bruton pointed out, there would not have been the same reaction if what is being proposed was done by tax credits rather than by narrowing the bands. The fact is that at the end of the day what matters for taxpayers — and I include myself — is the amount they have to pay and they are not too concerned about the mechanism used.

The proposals introduced by me were presented as a package of measures, the rate bands, exemption limits, personal allowances and child allowances. As I said on many occasions, the package was introduced to give the same benefit to the individual taxpayer as was done under the proposals of January. Amendments Nos. 27 and 28 in the name of Deputy Kemmy cannot be regarded as serious in their attempt to help the taxpayers or to give any equity in the tax system. Neither do the amendments take any account of Exchequer finances. If anyone studies my proposals they will see that the individual taxpayer will get the same benefits as were proposed under the tax credit system in January.

I oppose both amendments.

Comment on this

Deputy Desmond made the point that very few people have £200 a week. That could well be so and, if it is so, it is an indictment of our economic structure and a reflection on our society. On £200 a week today one would not live like a Farouk. Even if some few people are earning £200 a week there is an element of contradiction because you cannot complain on the other hand about 100 people gaining by my amendment. The picture painted by the media of a great number of workers groaning under the yoke of PAYE is not wrong because the tax marches and the reaction of people generally have shown that this is no illusion. We have a number of lower paid workers and that is all the more reason for some genuine and drastic tax relief. My amendment is designed to spread the tax load more equitably.

Deputy Bruton's point that the PAYE system is a crude system is correct. PAYE is designed to take money from the workers every week but it does not respond in the same way in giving rebates and refunds. There is no flexibility in it. I fully support what Deputy Bruton said. On the occasion of the March budget Deputy Bruton moved along the same line as I do and I regret that he cannot support my amendment tonight. The Minister says he is objecting and he gives some examples but he did not advert to how my amendment would work. He took the worst possible examples and I hope to check his figures later on to see if they are accurate. He took aspects of the amendment which are not favourable. He ignored the favourable aspects. My amendment is designed primarily to redress some of the imbalances in our taxation system and I make no apology to anyone for doing that.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Minister for the Environment (Mr. Raphael Burke) Fianna Fáil

We are being treated here to gross hypocrisy. It almost borders on the obscene. The proposal is to add £53 million to the budget this year and £82 million in a full year. The Deputy is totally irresponsible in tabling this amendment. Not only that but he has the gall to query the veracity of the figures given by the Minister with regard to the effect his amendment would have. The figures given by the Minister show that of those in the 35 per cent tax band the figure is nil and in the 45 per cent tax band it would be up to £200. In the 55 per cent tax band it would be £200 to £500 and in the 60 per cent £500 to £750. Does this really come from a Deputy who purports to represent the less well-off sections, who purports to support a party whose claim is at all times, though they voted consistently today in a different direction, that their ambition is to keep down Government expenditure and support cutbacks in the public sector? Today they have voted consistently for the addition of extra taxation by their demands here.

Deputy Kemmy spoke of political parameters and the political philosophy of Deputy Bruton. They seemed to share the same philosophy and political parameters on a surprising number of occasions today. I am surprised the Deputy has done so little homework in the preparation of his amendment. We have discussed several amendments today and the one thing that can be said about them all is that their proposers did their homework. That can at least be said for them. On this amendment, however, the Deputy comes in here in an utterly irresponsible manner and proposes the addition of an extra £53 million this year.

Comment on this

What about the £100 million Fianna Fáil promised to Dublin West?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister without interruption.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. Raphael Burke Fianna Fáil

The Deputy won the seat because of the PR system and he should be very grateful to those who transferred their votes to him. Fine Gael's voting last night on the Estimate for the Gaeltacht, an Estimate which they introduced, and their voting today, despite all their protestations about trying to reduce the budget deficit, can only be described as a mealy-mouthed approach by Deputy Bruton to Deputy Kemmy's amendment: "Well, Deputy Jim, we want to be with you but we cannot be with you because even our neck would not stretch as far as £53 million despite the fact that we have been stretching our neck all day". Remembering the support Deputy Kemmy has given Fine Gael he should get the support of Fine Gael now. He has gone with Fine Gael all along the line. He has voted with them and he is entitled to expect Fine Gael to vote with him this evening. They have ridden roughshod over every other principle. They rode roughshod last night in voting against an Estimate they themselves introduced here last January. The Deputy is entitled to their support. His amendment is, as I said, totally irresponsible but Fine Gael have been irresponsible all day and the Deputy is entitled now to their support in his irresponsibility.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

This is the most convoluted language I have ever heard.

Comment on this

The Minister uses emotive language. A charge of irresponsibility is a serious charge. I have been in politics just as long as the Minister and he should remember that people living in glasshouses should be careful about throwing stones, especially if they are in their bare feet.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Order.

Comment on this

The Minister shows the spleen there is against me in a way which is both immature and childish. I would expect better from the Minister. He says my amendment would cost £53 million. It equates very well with the concession given by his Government in recent weeks. I refer to the £45 million. It was given by the stroke of a pen. I can tell the House where it did not go. It did not go to the lower paid worker. The £45 million went almost entirely to higher paid workers. There have been other schemes also which were totally irresponsible — Knock Airport, for example.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I get the impression that Deputy Burke is annoyed with Deputy Kemmy.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. Raphael Burke Fianna Fáil

Deputy Bruton is not supporting Deputy Kemmy as he ought to be.

Comment on this
Gerard C. Connolly Minister of State at the Department of the Environment (Mr. Connolly) Fianna Fáil

We seem to have wandered from the subject we were dealing with. I do not think Deputy Kemmy is aware of the financial implications as far as the Exchequer is concerned. Deputy Desmond is fully aware of the situation and he knows that to make that concession for this year would cost £53 million approximately. It would be nice for me and also for Deputy Bruton — it would give him more into his pocket — and possibly is would be very good for some members of the Press Gallery——

Comment on this

It is true what Deputy Desmond said. A married couple earning up to £11,800 can claim benefits such as VHI, tax relief on mortgages and many other concessions. If a farmer has a valuation between £20 and £40 his allowances are halved. If he has other employment that is also taken into consideration and he will have to produce approved, audited accounts. If farmers over £40 valuation make extra money they will be liable for income tax under the Act. There is a feeling in certain quarters that farmers are paying very little or no tax, but over the years there has been a substantial increase in what they pay. In 1975 £1.1 million was collected and the following year it increased to £3 million. In 1981 they paid £20 million and this year it is estimated they will pay £22.2 million. Deputy Desmond may not be aware of this as he represents an urban constituency. Some of the media have been saying of late that the farmers are getting off more lightly than others in regard to payment of taxation. Farmers have the usual allowances and this was the case when the previous Government were in office. I am not making a case for the farming community but the number of farmers involved in paying tax is about 43,000, which is an increase on last year of approximately 1,800.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

What Deputy Connolly is saying is not relevant.

Comment on this

Deputy Desmond mentioned the farming community and, as a rural Deputy, I could not let the point go in case it went out from this House that the farmers were not paying anything at all and did not want to pay anything. I am fed up with that and it is not fair. Nobody wants to pay income tax. Even Members of the House want to pay as little as they possibly can. Deputy Kemmy mentioned the £45 million which was given in tax relief recently. Is the Deputy opposed to that relief? He seems to have some reservations about it.

Comment on this

I asked a question about where the money went.

Comment on this

Yes, he asked a question but he also expressed reservations about it. The Minister explained in great detail earlier that there was now an inquiry into expenditure and where savings could be made. He stated also that, if additional taxation had to be raised, that would be done. It is all very fine for Deputy Kemmy to say he has reservations in regard to the £45 million but he must take into account that it benefited a great many taxpayers throughout the country. If we were to insert a means clause into the taxation system it would create difficulties from an administrative point of view. The media said that the concession of £45 million was too generous and that we should not have made it.

Deputy Bruton had great sympathy for Deputy Kemmy and I know why. I could not agree with the case Deputy Bruton put forward. I would go as far as to say he is treble faced. Deputy Bruton has not been honest and he has been trying to play it both ways.

Comment on this

Surely that does not surprise the Minister?

Comment on this

No, it does not surprise me and I wanted to get that across because he is a man who had done a lot of twisting and turning over the last few months and speaking ex cathedra as usual. He thinks he is infallible.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Minister please get back to amendment No. 27?

Comment on this
Mr. Bruton

I seem to have got under everybody's skin. I do not mind annoying Deputy Burke but I hate to annoy Deputy Connolly.

Comment on this

The Deputy did not annoy me and I know he liked the little bit about the farmers because his heart lies there.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. O'Keeffe Fine Gael

It is like the Yorick scene in Hamlet.

Comment on this

If the concessions here were agreed to, people in the upper income bracket would benefit. We cannot have it both ways. Deputy FitzGerald, the Fine Gael leader, is always asking where we got the millions to do this, that and the other. Then his colleague, Deputy J. Bruton comes in and says, "Oh, we should give a concession here". I was asked at Question Time why I had not given a concession in respect of various other items. I was honest, I said I had not the money. That is the situation.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The Deputy is awarding himself a medal now.

Comment on this

How does one give £53 million while one talks about deficits, borrowing and so on? If we are to keep our finances in line then certainly we would not be able to do it within the conditions of the amendment put down by Deputy Kemmy. I cannot see its justification. I do not think the Deputy was briefed too well on this. I say that with all due respect to Deputy Kemmy. He was not well briefed. Possibly the briefing he received was from persons who were in that high bracket of money, people who may have said, "Well, it will suit us fine as well and put a gloss on it". I want to bring the Deputy down to the fine issue involved here, which is that this money has to be found, £53 million up to the end of the year and £82 million next year. That is the situation in regard to this. I must agree with my Minister here that there is no way we could agree to that.

Comment on this

This rumpus on the part of the Minister of State, Deputy Connolly, is very entertaining but his logic is far from being impeccable.

Comment on this

The same as the Deputy's.

Comment on this

I merely responded to the question posed by his boss, Deputy Raphael Burke, in relation to the £45 million which equated with my sum in this amendment, of £50 million. I said that his £45 million had gone largely to the higher paid. Neither of the two Ministers has refuted that charge. When they do, I will have some respect for them. In addition, I pointed out that my amendment is designed primarily to reform the imbalance in the tax code. Some of the areas mentioned constitute the worst aspects of it. I accept that because it is a crude method by which to redistribute taxation. By and large it will not have the effect alleged by the two Ministers.

About my being briefed, well, Deputy Connolly is obviously the most briefed man here judging by all the reading he does at Question Time. Indeed, the less said about that the better. Sometimes some of the reading engaged in, such as that in relation to a question I asked him yesterday about a road, let him off the hook. He did not know what he was reading; he was like a parrot. I would say that perhaps his own briefing could be examined somewhat more intently.

Comment on this

The Deputy got bogged down as well.

Comment on this

As far as I am concerned we should deal with facts in this House, not with this sound and fury signifying nothing.

Comment on this

It has been said that perhaps Deputy Kemmy is not too well briefed. I think that charge is quite correct in regard to this amendment, that he is indeed not too well briefed when he asks a question as to where the PRSI concessions went. It has been pointed out to him many times already in the course of the discussion on this amendment that the effects would be greatest for those in the £11,000 to £14,000 gross earnings bracket. If the Deputy took even a cursory glance at the PRSI regulations he would discover that the additional allowance applied to people on incomes up to the £9,500 bracket. If he wants clarification as to where the bulk of the concession on PRSI went, if he looks up the regulations he will discover it. As has been said, he should brief himself a little better.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

It is indeed true.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The maximum benefit goes to those with maximum incomes.

Comment on this

The facts of the system — and Deputy Bruton should know better——

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I do.

Comment on this

In view of his antics when his budget failed to get through the House I am not surprised that he does not, because it would not be the first thing he did not know.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. O'Keeffe Fine Gael

The Deputy is back on that again.

Comment on this

The Deputy has been playing an old tune over there all day, we can play a tune here and put a few unpalatable facts——

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. O'Keeffe Fine Gael

If they were facts——

Comment on this

They are facts. The PRSI benefits apply to those up to £9,500 who pay the full PRSI rate. We should have a little bit of honesty in the House in relation to amendments. Deputies over there can sigh all they like but we should have a little bit of honesty in the House in relation to amendments.

Comment on this

We should have a great deal of honesty, not a little but of honesty.

Comment on this

Holier than thou.

Comment on this

The interruptions put me off my track somewhat so I must wait until we have a little bit of silence when I will direct my attentions to Deputy Kemmy's amendment and his remarks on it. I know that Deputies opposite do not want to accept the truth of the arguments being put forward here but they do represent the truth. Deputy Kemmy's amendment is aimed at benefiting those in the best positions, those with the highest incomes. The PRSI benefit at least was directed at those within a certain defined category which did not come within an ass's roar of the categories Deputy Kemmy wants to benefit.

Comment on this

I should like to say a few words on this amendment. I spoke earlier today regarding section 1 and the various amendments. What I said then holds equally with regard to these amendments. Regarding the increase in the taxation bands or tax free allowances I should say that while the present income tax code and tax free allowances obtain they are always going to benefit people with the greater incomes. The scheme announced by Deputy John Bruton in regard to income tax credits has a lot to recommend it. I have no hang-ups about the present system of tax-free allowances. I see everything to recommend the idea of tax credits. They are not included in this Finance Bill. Personally I have no hang-ups about it. It is a system that might well be looked at and I would have no objection to its inclusion in a subsequent Finance Bill because I found a lot I could agree with in regard to the tax credit system.

In regard to the amendment put forward by Deputy Kemmy, from an ideological viewpoint I can well understand why the Deputy put forward his point of view as to why this tax band should be increased or at least remain at its existing level. Also, viewing the current budget deficit, the present state of the economy and the problems confronting us I am sure Deputy Kemmy will appreciate my viewpoint. I know Deputy Kemmy sincerely holds the view that the lower income classes should benefit from the taxation system most. But from my viewpoint at least a different view must be taken of that. As I said earlier today it is easy to put forward the idea of taxation relief. I do not blame Deputy Kemmy, The Workers' Party, Fine Gael or Labour for putting forward those viewpoints because the history of our system has been that if one gives concessions then one benefits at the polls.

I think it was Deputy B. Desmond who raised the question of the pay-related social scheme in respect of which we had given a concession of some £45 million. Lest anybody have any doubts I should say I am not in agreement with that viewpoint, that one should give in, under electoral pressure whether it be in respect of a general election or a by-election, irrespective of the merits of that case. I would not like anyone to be under any illusion that Deputy Charlie McCreevy changed his viewpoint on that. I do not believe it is in the interests of democracy to have the view that when an election is to take place, whether it is a general election or a bye-election, it is the easiest thing in the world to agree to that type of pressure.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Could the Deputy come back to the amendment?

Comment on this

I am coming back to it now. I agree with Deputy Kemmy when he wants to increase the taxation band to give more relief to people so that they will have to pay less tax. If we encourage that viewpoint we should go ahead and explain this. Deputy Kemmy or any other Deputy in the House is free to put forward his viewpoint to give more relief. The same argument that I used in regard to the relief in section I of the Bill applies to this. If we are to agree to the increases in the bands it will cost the State money and I do not think that is the right thing to do at the present time. I believe the amendment put forward by Deputy Kemmy will have that effect. I understand from his viewpoint why he is putting it forward but from the overall point of view I hold I believe we should reject it.

Comment on this

Is there the same requirement for this as there was last week in relation to those who support my viewpoint?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the Deputy calling for a vote?

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will the Deputies who are in favour of the amendment and who are calling a division, please rise in their places?

Deputy Kemmy rose.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As there are fewer than ten Members standing, I declare the amendment lost, but the name of that Member will be entered in the Journal of the Proceedings of Dáil Éireann.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 29:

In page 11, between lines 12 and 13, to insert a new subsection as follows:

"(2) Notwithstanding anything in the Tax Acts, Part II of the Table to section 8 of the Finance Act, 1980 (inserted by this section) shall apply to persons with dependants who are widows, widowers or single parents.".

The purpose of this amendment is to provide the same tax relief for single parent families including widows and widowers with dependants as for married persons, particularly those who are struggling on low pay. It is just as difficult, possibly more difficult, for those families to survive on their incomes as for married persons. This is particularly true of single parents, especially in the case of a deserted husband or male single parent who is not in receipt of the deserted spouse allowance.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I just cannot hear what the Deputy is saying.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Could we have a little quiet, please? Could we have the sound checked, please?

Comment on this

The sound is all right. It is the voice of the Deputy which we cannot hear.

Comment on this
John F. O'Connell An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Could we have a little quiet for Deputy De Rossa, please?

Comment on this

The difficulty is possibly greater for those families who do not have a second parent to deal with the financial problems, particularly in relation to families not entitled to claim the deserted spouse's allowance. This is an important social reform which would not cost a great deal of money. The amount involved would probably be less than £5 million and we have already indicated here today where that kind of money can be raised.

One Deputy speaking in relation to another point said that there was no scope for increased taxation. I wonder did he mean that there was no scope for increased PAYE taxation. It is probably true that the PAYE sector are paying as much as they can afford to pay. However, that is not to say that there is no scope for increased taxation. Again and again, it has been pointed out here that there is ample scope in sectors which pay little or no taxation. Deputy Connolly referred to the farming class which according to statistics pay something in the region of 1 per cent of all income tax collected. What is required and what this amendment is attempting is to introduce some form of equity within the taxation system. It is obviously not sufficient simply to try to juggle around with figures and the amount of taxation collected at present under PAYE. The ultimate aim must be to broaden the whole base of taxation. Given the present situation and the possibility for Deputies on this side of the House to introduce measures for the raising of taxation, we must try to bring in measures which will result in some kind of equity.

The point should be made again that there is a small number of people involved. This would not apply to all persons who are made widows or widowers, or to all single parents, only to those who have dependants. Most Deputies would have some experience of the situation about which we are talking, where there is a constant struggle by either the mother or father who is left alone, to try to cope, more often than not, with a young family, trying to hold down a job and ensure that the children are cared for, have clothing, schoolbooks and so forth. This amendment would go some way towards alleviating this situation. I appeal to the Minister to see his way to adopting this amendment.

Comment on this

In reply to what Deputy De Rossa says, I would like to reply that if the married rate bands were applied to single parents — and when I say single parents I mean widows and widowers with dependants, as well as single parents as described in the amendment — it would be open to a married couple who have children to elect for assessment as single persons under section 193 of the Income Tax Act of 1967, inserted by the Finance Act of 1980. By each accepting responsibility for one or more of the children, they would then become entitled as single parents would, to be assessed to tax at the married rates of tax.

For example, a married couple with a total income of £17,000, who pay at the moment £4,442, would reduce their liability to £3,826 by this device. It would appear that it would be unconstitutional, following the decision in the Murphy versus the Attorney General case, to legislate against the married couple being taxed at, in effect, quadruple the rate bands if the single parent were granted the double rate band. In the Murphy versus the Attorney General case, the Supreme Court decided that it was unconstitutional for a married couple to be charged more tax than if they were unmarried. The extension of the double rate band to single parents would cost about £4.6 million in a full year. It has been argued that it is a comparatively small amount but we have been dealings with smaller amounts in earlier amendments. The cost in 1982 would be £3 million and in a full year it would be £4.6 million, if married couples were not included. If we were to include married couples the cost would be £23 million in 1982 and £35 million in a full year. I regret I have to oppose the amendment for those reasons, as well as the constitutional reason.

Comment on this

What we are proposing is that married allowances be applied to dependants of single parents and widows. How would the problem of quadrupling that for married couples come about?

Comment on this

In relation to the special marriage allowance, the rate band does not apply, and that is where the constitutional problem arises.

Comment on this

I am not an accountant or a tax expert and I should like the Minister to explain the position about the anomaly.

Comment on this

Neither am I an accountant or a tax expert. At the moment there is a single person's allowance and a single parent's allowance of £2,900. They are covered in the constitutional case of Murphy v. the Attorney General.

Comment on this

I am not clear about the point. The intention of the amendment is to provide for the single parent and the widow. Does the Minister intend to bring in an amendment to cover that category of taxpayer?

Comment on this

The constitutional issue does not arise until a married person pays more than the single person: a married couple shall not pay more than two single persons. The difficulty would arise only when they go on to the band.

Comment on this

Will the Minister indicate if he accepts the principle of the amendment and say whether he would be prepared to look at the amendment with a view, possibly, to introducing a similar type amendment on Report Stage which would overcome the anomaly?

Comment on this

At the moment it appears that the amendment would create a constitutional difficulty. These amendments came only last night and we had not time to study them in depth. I can have them examined fully and give the Deputy more information. I am sure every Deputy sympathises with the amendment but, as I have said, there are constitutional problems and it would be pointless to accept an amendment which would lead to a situation in which married couples could take cases which would result in our paying £35 million in a full year. I can do an in-depth study and deal with the matter on Report Stage.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 30:

In page 11, before section 4, to insert a new section as follows:—

"4.—(1) Notwithstanding anything in the Tax Acts, income derived by way of interest on savings to a bona fide group water scheme shall be exempt from tax for the year 1982-83 and subsequent years of assessment.

(2) For the purpose of this section a bona fide group water scheme shall mean only a scheme registered as a group water scheme within the meaning of the Industrial and Provident Societies Acts, 1893 to 1978.".

I am glad Deputy Connolly is in the House because he has shown great interest in this — it is something he has advocated. About two months ago I was surprised at what I learned in regard to a group water scheme in my constituency. It was brought to my attention that those responsible for a group water scheme had collected contributions from their members in anticipation of work being done. If they lodged that money in the bank while waiting for the work to be commenced, and there is no question of making a profit because the money will be spent in a relatively short time, they would be charged income tax on the interest it would accrue in the bank, even though the money will be used for a co-operative project which would otherwise fall on the State, and the entire expense would have to be borne by the taxpayers.

I am talking about money collected voluntarily by a co-operative to provide a group water scheme for themselves. It is a matter of people coming together to take on a responsibility of the State, to do work which the State would otherwise have to do. They have to pay income tax on the interest the collected money would accrue. I have raised this matter with the Revenue Commissioners because I could not believe such a situation could come about. I received a letter from the Chairman of the Commissioners which was the opposite to what I had hoped to be the case and confirmed the fact that interest on money on deposit in the name of a group water scheme organiser was liable to tax. One must bear in mind that the people involved are voluntary workers who had probably made themselves unpopular with their neighbours when collecting the money. It is ludicrous if they are liable to tax on the interest that may be paid on their deposit. We should try to rectify this. I am sure that the acceptance of the amendment would not mean any additional cost. I am prepared to defer to the Minister if my definition of the situation is not as perfect as it should be. However, I took some time to prepare the amendment which is fairly accurate in its wording. I hope the Minister will accept it without demur.

Comment on this

As the Deputy has stated, the cost in terms of revenue foregone from the bodies in question would be insignificant. The granting of any such exemption creates possibilities for tax avoidance and the Deputy must appreciate that. It would not be an easy matter to confine the scope of any exemption to group water schemes alone. If exemptions were to be granted to any particular category of taxpayer this inevitably would give rise to requests for similar exemptions for other groups also engaged in what may be described as worthwhile projects like group water schemes. The Deputy has rightly pointed out that the only income arising to group water schemes appears to be investment income, that is interest on balance held on deposit prior to the completion of such water schemes and after such completion in respect of moneys required for maintenance.

There is an alternative to a legislative provision for the exemption of deposit interest arising to group water schemes the amounts of which, as the Deputy appreciates, are very small. Such groups might consider the possibility of investing temporary surplus funds as far as would be practicable to do so in tax-free securities, for example, savings certificates. That would meet the aim of the proposed amendment and at the same time avoid the need to introduce legislation which might be used as a vehicle for tax avoidance.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

Is the Minister going to create tax-free securities?

Comment on this

No. I am telling the Deputy that it will be possible for the groups to consider investing these temporary surplus funds in tax-free securities, for example, savings certificates. They would not have to pay tax on interest gained in that way and that would avoid the need to introduce legislation which might be used as a vehicle for tax avoidance, a grave possibility in regard to any concessions that may be given to group water schemes. As a former Minister for Finance the Deputy will appreciate that once one gives in on such an issue one hundred other examples giving the same justification as group water schemes — I am referring to projects like community halls, sports complexes and so on — will be mentioned. For that reason I cannot accept the amendment.

Comment on this

Coming from a former Minister for Finance this amendment seems to be impracticable and difficult to consider. Every Deputy could make a claim for social reasons that interest relief should be granted for savings accumulated. If we agreed to that we would be pulling down tremendous trouble on our heads. For example, I could claim that I have money on deposit to send by children to secondary school or university, that I am saving for a pension, that I am saving for health expenses, or that I am saving to buy a house. People could claim that they were saving money to create employment and we all know that it is the aim of most companies nowadays to have some liquidity so that they can survive the ups and downs that occur. Why not make the interest earned on that exempt? I do not dispute that group water schemes are in need of assistance but for a person who is trying to run the finances of the State the acceptance of this amendment is impracticable. It would open up a new argument. All Deputies could make strong social cases as to why interest should be exempt. It is a mine field and we should not enter it.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

There are a number of problems about the suggestion put forward by the Minister so that group water schemes could avoid having to pay tax on interest earned. They would require a degree of flexibility in regard to the lodgment of moneys particularly if they are paying it out on a current basis from a bank account. If the organisers want flexibility they would not be in a position to avail of the savings certificates scheme because it does not have a cheque-writing facility or the flexibility an ordinary bank account has. The suggestion the Minister has made is helpful and it is something that should be made known to the organisers of those schemes. It is my view that very few of them are investing their money in this way. Practically all group water schemes have money on deposit and technically they are liable to income tax on it. I would be surprised if any of them have the bright idea that the Minister has mentioned and I am sure he would not have come up with that if I had not put down my amendment. To that degree, even if we do not succeed in having the amendment passed, we are making progress. Deputy Connolly, the Minister of State, is in a position to give this advice to the organisers of these schemes.

I do not accept Deputy Brennan's somewhat unnecessary analogies, suggesting that a person saving money to buy a bigger house is in an analogous position to the organisers of a group water scheme.

Comment on this

I did not mention that.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The Deputy mentioned saving for a house and that could mean a bigger one than the person owns. Hospital expenses and so on are personal matters while group water schemes relate to industrial and provident societies which set up specifically for co-operative purposes, non-profit making purposes defined by law that goes back to 1893. An industrial and provident society cannot make profit and because of its co-operative non-profit making character, as defined by law, is in a very different situation from a person who might invest money. I should like to remind Deputy Brennan that his party opposed the proposal that another form of industrial and co-operative society, agricultural co-operatives, be liable to income tax. It is because they are co-operatives that they are not liable to income tax. Why should group schemes be liable to income tax on their deposits if agricultural co-operatives are exempt? That is worth bearing in mind before anybody makes analogies about this matter.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy suggesting that we should extend the tax to the co-operatives?

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

No, but I am suggesting that Deputy Brennan should read a little more deeply into the question of the tax status of industrial and co-operative societies. The Minister has made a suggestion which I will have to consider and I propose to withdraw my amendment with the possibility of introducing a variation of it on Report Stage. I do not accept that this would be the basis for other exemptions. Group water schemes are unique. They are carrying out something which is basically a State function. Individuals are taking it over voluntarily.

Comment on this

What about sports?

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

That is not a State responsibility whereas water supplies are and have been traditionally.

Comment on this

The State is helping them as well.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): What about housing co-ops?

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

That is an area we should look at. I propose to withdraw my amendment and examine the position further with a view to re-submitting it on Report Stage.

Comment on this

As Deputy Bruton referred to me and my Department, I should be glad to bring it to the notice of group water schemes that they could invest their money in savings certificates. I was a trustee of a very large group water scheme for a number of years. We never had any surplus money. Many of the representations I receive inform me that contractors are waiting for their money and if the trustees do not pay up in time they have to pay interest to the bank. I was surprised to hear Deputy Bruton say that some of these have surplus money. Most of those I have spoken to are very anxious for my Department to pay the grant.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

They collected the money but they were held up by the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

They might be held up when the outline of the scheme goes to design. However, I do not want to become involved in that. There might be a spill-over with some of the group water schemes into other areas and it could be used under that disguise.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan):“Spill-over” is very appropriate.

Comment on this

The Deputy understands what I mean. They could take on another line of business. We hear a lot about tax evasion and it would be hard to keep this on the rails. If there are any group water schemes with surplus money which they put on deposit, I shall be only too glad to recommend another avenue for the money.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): Is the first £70 interest earned by a group water scheme free of tax as it is for an individual?

Comment on this

No. Savings certificates are allowable up to £150.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): That is not fair. The first £70 of interest an individual investor earns is free of tax but I understand that the first £70 in the hands of a building society is not.

Comment on this

All the interest is free.

Comment on this

(Cavan-Monaghan): Was the Minister wrong?

Comment on this

Yes, but I admit it.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Amendments Nos. 31 and 32 have been ruled out of order in so far as they would involve a potential charge on the people. Amendment No. 33.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

I move amendment No. 33:

In page 12, subsection (3) (a), between lines 40 and 41, to insert a new subparagraph as follows:—

"(v) by 10 per cent. per annum of the original market value of the car for each year of ownership.".

This amendment is in respect of benefit in kind in regard to cars. As we said on the Financial Resolution in relation to this section, the position is that people will be taxed on a proportion of the value of the car they have from their company when it was new. They may be taxed in the third or fourth year in which they are using the car when its value would be far less than when it was new. Under the Minister's proposal they will still be taxed on a proportion of its new value. What I am proposing is that the new value of the car, for the purposes of the section, be reduced by 10 per cent per year which is not a generous reduction considering the depreciation in value of the car. The Minister's proposal will encourage people who have company cars to hold them for a year and then get rid of them. This will be bad for the balance of payments and a wasteful use of equipment. Such people will be at an artificial disadvantage if they retain a car for more than a year. This amendment is a reasonable improvement on the proposal made by the Minister and I hope he will accept it.

Comment on this

I cannot accept this amendment because it would render the section ineffective. What was originally proposed in the budget was much more severe than what is now in the Bill. As I said earlier in reply to questions and amendments, I and the Government were severely criticised by Deputies in Fine Gael and by many people throughout the country for altering the budget provisions when we introduced the Finance Bill on 2 June. In one case there was a difference of £½ million between what was intended in the budget and what was in the Finance Bill.

The people who criticised us for the supposedly enormous changes which were made between budget day and publication of the Finance Bill now want me to accept a further reduction in revenue in the case of benefit in kind and company cars. It does not make sense. I cannot accept this amendment.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The Minister is deliberately failing to understand the purpose of my amendment. The purpose is not to render the new tax measures ineffective in regard to benefits in kind. It is simply to improve them so that there will be no artificial incentive for people to keep buying new cars when they could retain their existing ones.

I am not seeking to undermine the Minister's proposal. The revenue implications will be minimal. Perhaps the Minister might tell me if there are substantial revenue implications, which I do not intend, because of the way the amendment is drafted. If the Minister can supply me with that information I will be happy to withdraw my amendment with a view to redrafting it in such a way that it will not have any unintended effect of significantly reducing revenue but only the intended effects of removing any artificial incentive to people to keep buying new cars rather than retaining old ones.

Comment on this

The proposal in the Bill is that 20 per cent will be operative for three years. What the Deputy is asking me is that 20 per cent be for the first year, 10 per cent for the second year and nothing for the third year.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

It would be 10 per cent of the 20 per cent.

Comment on this

The amendment clearly states 10 per cent per annum of the original market value of the car for each year of ownership.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

That is not the intention.

Comment on this

I can only go by the way it reads.

Comment on this
John Bruton Mr. J. Bruton Fine Gael

The intention is not to use the full market value as the basis for making the calculation but to reduce the market value somewhat on a sliding scale so as to remove any artificial disincentive. The Minister seems convinced that this would cause major problems and revenue losses and I am sure that with the advice available to him he has some reason for taking this line. In these circumstances I am happy to withdraw the amendment. I do not wish to destroy the proposal but merely to improve it. Therefore, I will submit an amendment for Report Stage designed to remove all the disincentives involved but I trust that the Minister will arrange to have made available to me details of the basis on which he is rejecting the amendment now. In this way I will be in a position to examine carefully the evidence with a view to submitting an improved amendment. Would the Minister be prepared to make that facility available to me?

Comment on this

The interpretation that the Deputy has put on his amendment now shows straight away that he changed the 20 per cent in the first year to 10 per cent. I did not get fully the point regarding the making available of facilities to him prior to the preparation of an amendment for Report Stage but I have no hesitation in giving to any Deputy any information required in respect of any suggestion or amendment he puts forward. I am prepared to be as liberal as possible in respect of any information requested but obviously there is a misinterpretation in this case.

Comment on this

(Dublin South-Central): There has always been a problem with Finance Bills in so far as the question of this benefit in kind is concerned. It has always been difficult to decide on where we should draw the line in these cases. I have always been convinced that business people, commercial travellers and so on should be given full allowances in respect of business expenses incurred. These are the people who motivate business, who sell our products. On this occasion the Minister has been fair. We hear a good deal here about tax evasion and tax avoidance. In this context it is the duty of any Minister for Finance to try to ensure that the loopholes are closed in any taxation measure. The Revenue Commissioners advise the Minister on such matters and they are in the best position to assess a situation.

There are many people who have the benefit of company cars and other perks and we must ensure that in legislating here we do not create a situation in which people entitled to such benefits are not put in the position in which there are disincentives so far as their work is concerned. We are talking about people who contribute in a substantial way to our economic expansion. Frequently, they make efforts in this area that are beyond the call of duty. What we are giving here by way of concession is not generous by any standard but having regard to our economic situation it is as far as any Minister could reasonably be expected to go.

There are many amendments being proposed to this Finance Bill but we must realise that the concession sought in each of those amendments would represent an additional charge on the Exchequer. It is easy for any Opposition Deputy to put forward an amendment but so far none of those concerned has told us where the money for the concessions involved can be found. Surely this question is fundamental to the Finance Bill and to our entire economic structure. I have been here for the introduction of the past 18 budgets and I have known similar problems to arise on each occasion. No matter what figure the Minister might write in to any part of the Bill, there is bound to be some Opposition Deputy who will propose an increase in that figure. That has always been the case but the Minister is the one who must take responsibility, who must answer to the public as to what is in the Bill. The Opposition do not have that responsibility. Naturally, any Minister for Finance would be only too happy to be in a position to concede these various amendments but we all know that that is not possible and that any Minister who would do so would be reneging on the trust placed in him.

I consider the Minister's proposals to be fair. We all appreciate the benefit of a car being placed at someone's disposal. The majority of us here use private cars. We realise the cost of running a car so we must be fair and acknowledge that anyone who is supplied with a company car is deriving substantial benefit in kind. But we must devise a fair system. We must try to ensure that there is a fair apportionment of that benefit and this is what the Minister is doing in this measure.

Successive Ministers for Finance have used a fair rule of thumb in determining what concession should be made in respect of this benefit but none has ever succeeded in satisfying everyone concerned. They have always been criticised by commercial travellers, company directors and so on in respect of the measures taken but we have to be realistic. This sort of benefit in kind represents a certain amount of loss of revenue to the Exchequer and at this time of scarce finances, at a time when £1 million or even £500,000 is a major contribution to the Exchequer, we must try to reach a balance as between what is fair on both sides of the camp.

Any concession granted must be paid for by the public. We do not want additional taxation at this time when we are trying to keep our inflation under control.

Comment on this