Finance Bill, 1983: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 1–244 of 480. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 8 of 1983 ›
I move amendment No. 91:
In page 67, subsection (1), between lines 7 and 8, to insert the following paragraph:—
"(c) Chapter I of Part IX of the Income Tax Act, 1967,".
The purpose of this amendment is to secure that a spouse's income will not be taken into account as such for calculating that person's income for the purposes of—
Comment on this
Would the Members not wishing to remain please leave the House quietly and would those who wish to have a chat please also leave the House?
Comment on this
I do not think it adds either to the dignity of the House or does any good to democracy to have these sniping remarks at the Chair. It ill becomes the Leader of the Opposition.
Comment on this
I notice during the last couple of days that Deputy Haughey does not seem to be very good-humoured. That is meant as a joke, too.
Comment on this
The purpose of amendment No. 91 is to secure that a spouse's income will not be taken into account as such for calculating that person's income for the purposes of the residential property tax. The spouse's income will, however, usually be included as the income of a relevant person under section 91. The amendment therefore proposes the insertion of an additional exclusion in the definition of income. Chapter 1 of Part IX of the Income Tax Act of 1967 contains the provisions relating to the taxation of married persons. It provides that a husband shall in certain circumstances be assessed and charged for tax, not only in respect of his own total income but also in respect of the total income of his wife.
Part 6 of this Bill, as amended, will not aggregate the spouse's income as such with the assessable person's income. However, a spouse's income is likely to be aggregated under section 91 of the Bill for the purpose of the income exemption limits because the spouse would usually be a relevant person for the purposes of section 91.
Comment on this
The Minister has read the brief diligently. Could the Minister tell us now, in plain man's words, what exactly are the consequences of this? There will be a lot more like it. Does it mean that the wife's, the spouse's income will or will not be included for the purposes of reaching the aggregate figure of £20,000?
Comment on this
The spouse is one of the people who will be included as a relevant person. It is on account of the spouse being relevant that his or her income is included in the aggregate of the income. It is not on the head of the fact that that person is a spouse as such.
Comment on this
It is only the normal income tax of husband and wife. It is a special inclusion under the relevant person's provisions in this Bill.
Comment on this
Those few words explain it a lot more clearly. We will have a lot of these — if you like — amendments. It would help if in addition to referring to sections and subsections of previous sections of Bills, the Minister would tell us precisely in normal language what exactly is involved in most of these 84 amendments. We do not have the facility on this side of the House, nor has the press or anyone else, of going back to read these subsections. In addition to reading the actual formal brief, could the Minister tell us exactly what the impact is? If he wishes to take a number of these amendments together and tell us the total impact, that would also be helpful.
Comment on this
It is good to know that the Minister is not moving some of his amendments but this is one that was brought in during the week while we were here debating the legislation and now it is not being moved. Can the Minister give us the reason for this so that we might have some notion of what we are at on this Bill. Why was the amendment put down in the first instance and then withdrawn? There should be some degree of consistency in this regard.
Comment on this
The purpose of amendment No. 92 was to substitute a reference to section 11 of the Finance Act, 1967 for a reference to section 12. We find the reference to section 11 is correct and consequently, should not be changed.
Comment on this
This demonstrates more than anything else that this part of the Bill has not been properly examined and that the consequences of it cannot be ascertained. No matter how much time we give to this part of the Bill we cannot discharge properly our responsibilities in these circumstances of amendments being withdrawn or amended. There is no possibility that the people who are meant to be liable as a consequence of this tax will have any idea what their liability is. The matter is very serious and by the time we have got through this day we will realise even more just how serious it is.
Comment on this
I strongly support Deputy O'Kennedy's viewpoint. In discussing this residential tax it is important early on that apart from opinion that has been given to me the measure could be proved to be unconstitutional. For a variety of reasons it is totally unworkable. I regard it as an out-of-the blue, smash-and-grab taxation. What next may we expect?
Comment on this
I would remind the Deputy that we have disposed of amendment No. 92 and must now move on to the next amendment.
Comment on this
Would the Minister accept that this is the first time in the history of this parliamentary assembly that a Minister for Finance has put an amendment on the Order Paper but was then not in a position to move it because it was erroneous in the first place? What a mess this is.
Comment on this
It is interesting to see Deputies Haughey and O'Kennedy working up a head of steam about drafting amendments. This is completely out of keeping with the remarks made earlier by Deputy O'Kennedy about the amount of time we have to debate the substance of the provisions.
Comment on this
On a point of order, we were given to understand that we would be allowed speak from amendment to amendment within the framework of the residential property tax. The debate last evening was conducted on those lines by both sides. I am not going to be steamrolled on this.
Comment on this
If the Deputy would bear with the Chair for a moment, he might understand the position. Amendment No. 91 was moved this morning and disposed of. Amendment No. 92 was called and not moved. We now go to amendment No. 93 and get on with the business in an orderly way.
Comment on this
Will I be afforded any opportunity of expressing my views on the residential property tax?
Comment on this
On a point of order, the situation may be clear to yourself but I must appeal to you for guidance rather than wait for you to wave your hand and I may speak. When we have disposed of the amendments and come to the section, will I be afforded the opportunity of putting my views?
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 93:
In page 67, subsection (1), to delete lines 19 and 20.
The Revenue Commissioners have decided that the residential property tax should be administered by the capital taxes branch of their office rather than by the inspector of taxes. Therefore, it is proposed to substitute references to the Commissioners in Part VI of the Bill for references to inspector of taxes. A definition of "inspector" is also no longer required.
Comment on this
There is a myriad of amendments to this effect. Perhaps we could dispose of them all now? The Minister made the point this morning that many of these amendments are consequential on each other.
Comment on this
I understand that it would not be convenient to discuss together all the remaining amendments to the section.
Comment on this
There is a series of amendments here which substitute commissioners for inspectors so perhaps we could deal with those now.
Comment on this
Sometimes instead of simplifying matters, that approach confuses them. Perhaps if, when I call out an amendment, the Minister were to explain it very briefly, that would help the situation.
Comment on this
To take the point raised by Deputy Haughey, it might be of assistance for me to indicate those amendments that we could take in groups.
Comment on this
That is the point. It is standard practice in this House that if there are amendments that are considered to be cognate, a list of those would appear first thing in the morning on the Chair's desk. In this instance it seems that even the Chair has not been facilitated.
Comment on this
The Chair has no objection to amendments being taken together if the Minister so wishes.
Comment on this
If I do not get co-operation I will proceed in my way, in accordance with procedure.
Comment on this
I am more interested in the Chair's way than in your personal way. May we have some idea of what the procedure is to be?
Comment on this
The cognate amendments will be indicated together in relation to each section. The one we have just dealt with is the only one relating to this section where that particular wording arises. If it is convenient for Deputies, I can indicate now those amendments I propose to take in groups right through this part of the Bill.
Comment on this
I have a note of those here. When we come to No. 97, for instance, it will be proposed that about ten others will be taken with it. If Deputies would leave the matter to the Chair business could proceed in an orderly way.
Comment on this
If we are to leave everything to the Chair what is the point of us being here at all?
Comment on this
The Chair tells us he has a list of amendments that will be taken together but then tells us to leave matters to him. Will we not know what amendments are being taken together? You might have circulated the list to us this morning.
Comment on this
On this amendment the Minister has indicated that he simply proposes to delete the definition of "inspector". That is all it proposes to do. On the face of it that is all it does.
Comment on this
Conditions can change and the definition becomes surplus. The definition is no longer required.
Comment on this
It is nice to have the view of Deputy Taylor, which I appreciate. I am not questioning what Deputy Taylor said.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 94:
In page 67, subsection (1), to delete lines 25 and 26, and substitute the following definition:—
" `market value exemption limit' has the meaning assigned to it by section 90;".
This amendment arises from the requirement for a change in the definition of "market value exemption limit" which is necessitated as a consequence of the substitution of a new section for section 90. Amendment No. 126 proposes a new section for section 90. That new section will employ a different method of calculating the market value exemption limit and it will be necessary accordingly to amend the definition of the term included in section 84 (1).
Comment on this
We are now coming to something very substantial. This arises because of the proposed deletion of section 90 which deals with the market value exemption limit. This is an essential section of this tax. After whatever consideration the Minister and his advisers gave to it — and I do not know how much consideration that was — they introduced during the course of this week what we were told is a technical amendment to get rid of section 90.
Comment on this
I know. A substitution for market value exemption limit is not technical by any means. We now have a consequential amendment. This demonstrates more clearly than anything else could that the whole purpose of this Bill was confused before it came into the House. It is getting more confused all the time. We are now getting rid of a full section and we are substituting some other section or subsection. We will be doing that a few more times and, unless the Minister tells us right now — and he should tell us now because we cannot begin to discuss this amendment until he tells us — we will have no idea what the purpose is of the new provision which is to be substituted for section 90. If he tells us this is consequential on the deletion of section 90, he should at least tell us now what will be put in the place of section 90 so that we can begin to understand what the consequence will be. He should tell us in straight terms what we will have instead of section 90.
Comment on this
What we will have in place of section 90 is a new section 90 which is proposed in amendment No. 126. The market value exemption limit which is to be deducted in ascertaining the net market value of the property on which the tax will be calculated would normally be £65,000 adjusted in subsequent years by the application of the new house price index number. This figure will be reduced where some or all of the assessible person's property is owned jointly or in common with another person or persons. Amendment No. 126 sets out the new text of section 90 and sets out that the tax is to be charged on net market value, which is to be arrived at by deducting from the gross market value an amount known as the market value exemption limit. This section defines the market value exemption limit. Normally it would be £65,000 this year, adjusted in future years by reference to the new house price index number.
Comment on this
——to take account of the fact that the value of the property would be attributed to a number of persons.
Comment on this
The intention is to ensure that the same amount of tax will be paid on the property whether it is owned solely by one person or jointly or in common by two or more persons. That is the intention of the new section 90.
Comment on this
That has been clear from the start and the Minister's explanatory memorandum says that. Will the Minister please tell us what is the difference?
Comment on this
It is all right for the Minister to read the words in the brief supplied by the Department. Could we know what exactly this is about and why the change is necessary?
Comment on this
The market value exemption limit is crucial to this whole section. It will decide how much tax people will pay. The Minister is changing one definition of it for another. We want him to tell us what is the difference between the two definitions, if anybody knows over there. Perhaps Deputy Doyle knows.
Comment on this
The new section 90 provides for a somewhat different method of calculating the market value exemption limit and it is for that reason that we have to make the change covered in amendment No. 94.
Comment on this
We can discuss the new section 90 when we come to amendment No. 126. It provides for a different method of calculating the market value exemption limit.
Comment on this
That is going too far. The Minister tells us it provides for a different way of evaluating the market value exemption limit. That is as far as he is prepared to go and when we get to the amendment he will tell us. We insist that he tells us now, if he knows. If he does not he should admit that.
Comment on this
That is what I said this morning. The thing is crazy. The Minister can read from a brief which gives all the gobbledygook about sections and sub-sections, but he does not know what this is about, and if he does not know how can we?
Comment on this
I want to add to that by suggesting that this whole absurdity should now be withdrawn. The man in the street who owns a house does not know whether he will be liable for this tax. On the one hand the Taoiseach said it would be the income of the principal owner of the house, and this was subsequently contradicted by the Tánaiste who said it would be the income of everybody in the house. We know now that the second explanation is the fact.
The public are confused. They do not know what the exact implications of this tax will be. We do not know either. We are trying to tease them out. It is now becoming crystal clear that the Minister does not know what the implications are, or what the meaning of "market value exemption limit" is. In the interests of sanity and commonsense, apart from justice to the taxpayer, the Minister should take this rubbishy absurdity away and bring back something else.
Comment on this
I am not so sure what is the direct relevance of those remarks on this section. We have here a provision which introduces a new tax. In the definition of the provisions governing that new tax we want to achieve certain objectives, including the objective of clarity. Deputies on the other side of the House are aware that, as we work out the application of these measures, certain nuances will become clearer, certain nuances will be required to be clarified, and that is the purpose of this amendment.
Comment on this
The Minister just said something very interesting — as this starts to operate certain nuances will become clear. Have we ever heard a statement like that from a Minister introducing a new tax? On Second Stage I said that this new tax would be dealt with appropriately in a separate and distinct piece of legislation. It is becoming quite clear that that is what we should do. Last night Deputy Mitchell and others spoke of the need to look at these matters properly. Obviously they are complex and the Minister has not mastered their complexities. We do not claim to have mastered them either because the amendments have been changed as they have been introduced. The only co-operation the Chair will get through this will be silence from all of us. As Horace used to say, favete linguis, favour us with your silence. That is the only co-operation we can give the Chair to get this nonsense through. In the absence of that, surely it is reasonable to resubmit this thing to a committee under a different Bill. The Minister said, in reply to some of his colleagues last night as well as to Deputies on our side, that he does not know exactly how much it will bring in this year.
Comment on this
We cannot have Second Reading speeches on every amendment, which is what we are having.
Comment on this
The Minister does not know exactly how much it will bring in this year and he did not know how much the cost of our amendment would be.
Comment on this
I plead with the Minister, his colleagues and the whole House — we will give him all the co-operation we can — to put this thing out to a special committee. Let us look at it calmly over the next three or four weeks, let us go through it in that detail and not have amendments on amendments being withdrawn and resubmitted. Unfortunately, some of the people outside the House are bored by what we are doing here. When you are on committee it is not really a circus and we are not entertainers. I apologise to those who think we should entertain. It is very important that we discharge our responsibilities, boring though it may be and unentertaining though it may be. We cannot do it the way the Minister is now introducing amendments. It may not be pleasurable for anybody. Members of the House, the press or anybody else.
Comment on this
It may not be entertaining but it is deadly serious. We cannot make any sense of this nonsense and neither can the Minister. If he wants us to help him in any way will he introduce a separate Bill or give us a committee where we can look at this over a period of three weeks because we cannot do it today?
Comment on this
A bit much has been made of this particular point by Deputy O'Kennedy. The substitute section 90 is set out, as the Minister pointed out, in amendment No. 126. There has been ample opportunity to study the replacement section. Of course, it is complex but will the Deputy show me a section in any Finance Bill which is not, even the one Deputy O'Kennedy brought in when he was Minister. Any section of any Finance Act to any layman is a matter of intense complexity. This one is precisely as complex as any other, no more and no less. It has been set out for some time. I fail to see exactly the point the Deputy is making.
Comment on this
It is set out in amendment No. 126. If there is some particular point in the amended section that requires clarification I am quite certain the Minister will be able to clarify it. The section is set out in detail with its definitions.
Comment on this
We have asked the Minister that very specific question. We have asked him what is the difference between the old section 90 and the new section 126, which he proposes to put in its place. We have asked him to tell us what is the difference between the two and he is not in a position to do so. That is our simple and very reasonable complaint. We know the sections are complex but it is the function of the Minister and his advisers, when they bring an amendment like this before us, to say why they are making the amendment, what was wrong with the first section 90 that it has to be discarded and this new section 90 put in its place, what difference does the new section make. Is that unreasonable?
Comment on this
I do not know if Deputies on the other side are interested in looking at the provisions or making points about the number of amendments that are here. We have set out very clearly in the Bill, as circulated, a particular approach to the matters dealt with in section 90. We have set out in amendment No. 126 the new revised approach to dealing with that. Let me give an example. The essential difference between the two sections is this. Let us take a person who is the sole owner of a property worth £100,000 and jointly owns another property worth £50,000; the original text of section 90 would spread the £65,000 figure over the total figure of £150,000. As the market value of all the relevant properties now is only £125,000, the £100,000 owned solely and £50,000 owned jointly with another person, the £65,000 exemption limit is reduced proportionately.
Comment on this
While what the Minister has just said is reasonably welcome news it demonstrates precisely that he does not know what the amendments are about. He can tell us after all this, that it reduces the liability in respect of property jointly held to ensure that instead of having a total assessment on property jointly held with another property you now reduce the property that is jointly held. The Minister could have told us that in very simple terms, instead of giving us the gobbledygook and we might know something. We have to take the Minister on trust at this stage.
Comment on this
The Minister was not able to tell us earlier if it is like that. I do not know if we should be simply asked to take him on trust. Deputy Taylor said it was not really complicated and we have had the amendment.
Comment on this
The Deputy said we have had the amendment and we have had time to study it. I have responsibility as spokesman for Finance for my party, as Deputy Taylor knows, and this amendment came in on Wednesday. I invite the Deputy or anybody, if we could get a photostat to the press and the public outside, to see how complex it is. I have been on my feet from morning to night every day this week and I take it that Deputy Taylor will acknowledge that neither I nor anybody else here who has been involved in this, could have had any time to study that. Therefore, it is quite unreasonable for the Minister to bring in such a number of amendments this morning without him even fully understanding what he is asking us to do.
Comment on this
Could the Minister give us an indication of how many people have houses valued £100,000?
Comment on this
That figure is not readily ascertainable because that kind of information is not now collected in any central way. There is no register of that kind of property values.
Comment on this
When the Minister refers to properties jointly held does it mean that the home owner, who jointly holds his property with a mortgage company, who would have a mortgage on 50 per cent of the property, gets the credit for that in the assessment?
Comment on this
If the Minister does not know the number of houses involved how did he work out the yield of £3 million this year?
Comment on this
I answered the question put by Deputy Burke in relation to the mortgage. It is no. With regard to the point made by Deputy Brennan I made the point last evening that the expected yield from this tax would be in the region of £6 million. That has been calculated by deduction from the original form of the tax, as we had envisaged it, and the revenue that that would have produced, judging it on various indicators that are not directly relevant now and working back from there. It is an estimate.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not need to know the number of houses over £65,000 to work out that figure?
Comment on this
We would need to know the exact number of houses over £65,000 and the way in which they are held in order to make a precise forecast of the yield of the tax——
Comment on this
But since we do not have that kind of information, we are not in a position to make a precise forecast.
Comment on this
Amendment number 95 in the name of the Minister. I should say that amendment No. 101 is related. Therefore, amendments Nos. 95 and 101 may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I think it would be helpful if we resorted to the normal convention here, that if they are strictly technical, drafting amendments, if the Minister would say so, we can let them go at that.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 95:
In page 67, subsection (1), to delete lines 27 to 29.
Amendments Nos. 95 and 101 are consequently on the deletion of section 87 of the Bill.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 96:
In page 67, subsection (1), in the definition of "net market value", line 31, after "excess", to insert ",if any,".
This amendment is necessitated by the fact that in some cases there will be no excess of net market value, that is there will be no excess of net market value over the £65,000 exemption limit. Section 85 of the Bill charges residential property tax on the net market value of the relevant residential property on the valuation date. In the case where the relevant residential property is a house, for example, currently valued at £100,000, the net market value is ascertained by deducting £65,000 from the £100,000, leaving £35,000 net market value on which the tax is assessed. In the case where the market value of the residential property is less than the market value exemption limit, of course, a nil liability arises. This amendment is designed simply to make that clear.
Comment on this
Amendment No. 97 in the name of the Minister. Amendments Nos. 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 109, 111 and 112 are related and may be taken together by agreement.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 97:
In page 68, subsection (1), line 11, to delete "the occupation of".
The two circumstances which render a person taxable in respect of a property under the definition of "relevant residential property" are, first, that he is the owner and, secondly, that he occupies the property as a dwelling. As the two conditions are distinct it is considered undesirable to use the word "occupy" in the definition of "owner" and the word "holds" is proposed to be used instead.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 98:
In page 68, subsection (1), lines 12 and 13, to delete "that subsection" and substitute "subsection (2) (c) (iv)".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 99:
In page 68, subsection (1), line 14, to delete "that subsection" and substitute "subsection (2) (c) (iv)".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 100:
In page 68, subsection (1), line 18 after "dwelling" to insert "or dwellings".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 101:
In page 68, subsection (2), lines 34 to 37 to delete paragraph (a).
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 102:
In page 68, subsection (2) (c), line 46, after "person", to insert "beneficially, whether solely, jointly or in common".
The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that, first of all, trustees and others who are the legal but not the beneficial owners of residential property would not be liable to the tax and, secondly, that a person would be treated as the owner of a residential property even if he has a share only in the ownership of that property. The proposed addition of the word "beneficialy", is consequential on amendments Nos. 103, 104, 105 and 108 which will have the effect of defining the owner of a residential property — in section 84 (2) (c) — as a person who holds property instead of a person who owns or occupies it. It is not intended that a trustee of property should be an assessable person but, since a trustee may also hold property in the sense that he is the legal owner but not the beneficial owner, the word "beneficially" has been added to the definition of "owner" to make it clear that an assessable person must be a beneficial owner of property, as distinct from an owner, such as a trustee, who is not a beneficial owner.
The proposed addition of the words "whether solely, jointly or in common" is to make it clear that a person will be treated as the owner of a residential property even if he does not hold it solely but holds an undivided share of it as a joint tenant or as a tenant in common. If he holds a share only in the residential property and also occupies the property as a dwelling then the property forms part of his relevant residential property and is subject to tax.
Under section 89 of the Bill where a residential property is comprised in the relevant residential property of two or more persons the amount to be taken into account in ascertaining the net market value of the relevant residential property of each person is the market value of the property divided by the number of persons.
Comment on this
I might just ask the Minister — this is not a point which occurred to me but rather to somebody who drew it to my attention — it would appear to be something that in practice would fairly rarely happen but it is not beyond the bounds of possibility. Suppose two persons — or more than two persons, but the simplest case would be two — own a property in common but in unequal shares, suppose they also have uneven incomes but incomes such that the accumulation of the income brings them over the limit at which this tax plugs in, so to speak, is it not the case — or, if not, I should be glad if the Minister would deny it — that they would be chargeable to the tax in equal amounts notwithstanding that the degree of their interest in the property is perhaps very different?
Comment on this
In those circumstances the persons concerned would be chargeable to the tax in equal amounts, as the Deputy says.
Comment on this
They would be liable to the tax in equal amounts being, if you like, joint occupiers, I would presume, in those circumstances, where it was felt by the persons concerned that the distribution of the tax between them was unequal, having regard to their interest in the property, it would be up to those persons to apportion between themselves the liability to the tax.
Comment on this
I do not want to labour the Minister about this — I know perfectly well that his heart is not in this job — but surely that is a hopeless situation? The State says: "We wash our hands of any obligation to an equitable application of this tax; it is up to yourselves to fix it up between yourselves; all we want, like the Roman Republic used to say to tax farmers, is to extract X£s; how equity requires you to sort it out between yourselves is a matter for yourselves." If the Minister had been in legal practice he would not have been there very long before knowing that, very often, tenancies in common arise, in fact almost always arise, in family circumstances. There is no more common matter over which brothers and sisters fall out than property. The Minister's optimism that a brother and sister who find themselves being charged equal sums of residential property tax, in a case where perhaps one of them owns 10 per cent, or has an interest of 10 per cent and the other an interest of 90 per cent, his optimism that they are necessarily going to adjust that between themselves, I think, does the Labour Party credit. It is as nonsensicial as a lot of the rest of it.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 103:
In page 68, subsection (2) (c) (i), line 47, to delete "owns" and substitute "holds".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 104:
In page 68, subsection (2) (c) (ii), line 48, to delete "occupies" and substitute "holds".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 105:
In page 69, subsection (2) (c) (iv), line 4, to delete "occupies" and to substitute "holds".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 106:
In page 69, subsection (2) (c) (iv) (I), line 15, to delete "occupation" and insert "lease, agreement or licence".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 107:
In page 69, subsection (2) (c) (iv) (I), lines 24 and 25, to delete "occupation of the premises" and substitute "lease, agreement or licence".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 108:
In page 69, subsection (2) (c) (v), lines 32 and 33, to delete "occupies the property at the will or sufference of any other person and in respect of such occupation—" and substitute "holds the property at the will or sufference of any other person, or under any trust, and in respect thereof—".
The purpose of this amendment is to use the word "holds" instead of the word "occupies" to describe a tenancy at the will or sufference of any other person and to ensure that the definition of the owner of a residential property will include a person holding property under a trust. Amendment No. 110 is consequential thereon. In section 84 (2) (c) (v) an owner is defined as including a person who
occupies the property at the will or sufference of any other person and in respect of such occupation—
(I) pays no rent, or
(II) pays a rent of such amount that, if it were paid under a lease of a kind mentioned in subparagraph (iv) granted at the time the person commenced to occupy the property at the will or sufference of that other person, the first-mentioned person would, under subparagraph (iv), be the owner in relation to the property;
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 109:
In page 69, subsection (2) (c) (v) (II), line 38, to delete "occupy" and substitute "hold".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 110:
In page 69, subsection (2) (c) (v) (II), line 39, after "person," to insert "or under the trust,".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 111:
In page 70, subsection (2) (d) (iii), line 3, to delete "occupied" and substitute "held".
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 112:
In page 70, subsection (2) (d) (iv), line 5, to delete "occupies" and substitute "holds".
Comment on this
The definition "occupied", in relation to residential property, means having the use thereof, whether actually used or not, and cognate words shall be construed accordingly. If I understand the mechanics of this part of the Bill there will have to be an operable date and it is difficult to imagine a Bill of this kind working otherwise. What about the case of property which normally is let and which may have been let to tenants for 20 to 25 years but which happens on that date through a quirk of the market or through neglect not to be occupied? The owner may have the key and the property may be on the books of a house agent but suddenly the owner becomes chargeable for this tax because in theory, even though he has no such intention, he could march in and occupy it as a second dwelling if he wished.
Comment on this
I wish to lodge a strong protest against this section. The effect of fluctuating market trends and inflation make a mockery of this measure. It is unworkable and will be impossible to operate. Deputy Kelly traced the history of this taxation last night and I will not go over it now but if the Minister allows his Department to become involved in trying to operate this tax the Revenue Commissioners, already hard pressed, will become further bogged down. This is something we should try to avoid. There are so many permutations and so many cases that can be argued against this taxation that it would be better to do as Deputy O'Kennedy suggests and let a committee discuss whether it can work. The Revenue Commissioners produced a property tax, a job they were given to do, but it is obvious that the hearts of the Minister and his party are not in it. We are to be saddled with a tax which will probably be thrown out by the courts in any case. Why not have a tax on fresh air or on staying alive?
Comment on this
The Chair is of the opinion that Deputy Brady has been making a Second Stage speech.
Comment on this
My point is that the fluctuation in market trends make it impossible on a yearly basis for an individual to give an estimate of the value of his property.
Comment on this
This is very complicated. We must be given some opportunity to talk on it. I should like to refer to the question of income and how this is to be defined. It is divisive to try to calculate the income within households and I am not happy about the information the Minister has given. It will force children to live apart from their parents to keep down the aggregate income. It is very anti-social. The Chair will agree that this is strictly within the terms of the definition.
Comment on this
This section will tamper with the family unit within a household. There may be two houses side by side and the owner of one may always have been prudent and houseproud, putting every penny into that home which is valued at £100,000. The person next door may not have bothered, even though enjoying the same income, but the first person will be penalised for having had a prudent attitude. This is wrong. This property tax is moving against the essence of home ownership.
We all know that because of the escalation of market values this tax will involve a much greater percentage of people within two or three years. Despite what Deputy Taylor said, it is a heavy tax. How is the person to pay this tax to be picked from within a household if the father or the mother is not earning any money? There will be absolute confusion.
Comment on this
There are people struggling to earn less than that but it will be aggregated and Deputy Taylor, as a lawyer, will see the inequity of it. We are directly hitting at the elderly. Deputies may laugh but there are a great many people, and I have had many representations about this, who are well into their seventies and eighties who now be saddled with this tax because they happen to be living in the home in which they have spent practically all their lives and their children are living with them. The only thing they can do is to tell the children to leave so that they will not be subject to this tax. This is socially wrong and Fine Gael know that. This is a sop to the Labour Party. It should not be passed by this House.
I cannot compliment the Department on producing a highly complicated form of residential property taxation and I doubt very much if anybody could possibly subscribe to the view that taxing the home in which he or she is living is right or equitable.
Comment on this
I am someone who is a dealer in capital taxation, someone who believes we do not have the type of capital taxation we should have. I have reservations about this section in the context in particular of the definitions in a number of areas. Reference has been made to this being capital taxation of people who live in houses worth in excess of £65,000 who should pay tax. Possibly that may be the case but the problem is that on the basis of the concept of net market value—the Minister could well explain the meaning of this—an illusion is created because the amount referred to on the basis of valuation indicating a house is worth a particular sum does not necessarily mean that the individual occupying that house has capital worth that particular sum in the context of a residential property tax. That is an anomaly.
Deputy Taylor referred to this tax yesterday evening but he avoided dealing with this anomaly in the context of this tax. I represent the same constituency as Deputy Kelly and in that constituency there are many people who own houses in a particular part of Dublin which, on present day values, would be worth in the region of £70,000 because of the area in which they are situated but they are relatively modest houses, semi-detached, three or four bedroomed houses, and these people will now have to pay tax on foot of this provision regardless of whether or not they have a mortgage. The anomaly is that, if we are going to tax people on the basis of their capital, let it not be an illusory capital or a notional capital. It should be real capital. The person who has a house worth today £70,000 with a capital mortgage of £30,000 whose real capital in terms of residential property would be £40,000, will be paying the same amount of tax as the person who owns the house worth £70,000 and does not owe one halfpenny by way of mortgage or loan to anybody. I appreciate the necessity to some extent to provide a tax which is simplistic, designed not to make life any more difficult than it is, I do not think anyone could describe this tax as simplistic. In ideological terms it might appear to some Deputies that that is an anomaly and this is something that should be borne in mind. We are here to legislate whether it is produced on this side of the House or suggested on the far side of the House and, if there are anomalies, then we have a duty to comment on them.
Comment on this
This is an anomaly to which Deputy Taylor certainly did not advert. The problem is that the definition does not take that anomaly into account. Again the definition of the relevant residential property which brings someone within the context of this tax leaves many who could well afford to pay capital taxation, and should be doing it, outside the net. I refer to the person who is paying £20,000 a year to live in a luxurious penthouse in the centre of the city and owns a yacht worth £100,000 in Dun Laoghaire harbour. Possibly he has an income of £50,000 a year. He can laugh all the way to the seaside in regard to this tax. It is not effective. I would like to see the yacht in Dun Laoghaire harbour, worth £100,000, coming within the tax net and not have this distinction here.
I am not criticising the Minister for this because this tax has been designed in this way to catch in effect one type of wealth or capital and ignore other types. In the context of the definition again—the Minister might correct me on this one—the person who lives in a house that is worth only £40,000 or £50,000 but has £200,000 worth of jewellery stashed in a bank or somewhere else is also unaffected by this tax. In the context in which Deputy Taylor put this tax last night I really must protest. This tax does not and will not do what it was intended to do. It is based on an illusory definition of the capital available or the capital value of someone's house and takes no account of the capital mortgage outstanding. Equally if one looks at the definition of income there is an illusory notion of income of members of the family household. Everybody knows that the income available to the family is the net income after deductions. Deputy Taylor kept on referring to people with incomes in excess of £20,000 who own mansions worth in excess of £65,000 and we should not be weeping crocodile tears for people in that situation who could make large capital contributions to the State. If one takes into account a husband and wife and two or three children whose education has been completed they might have gross incomes at that level and they might live in a house they purchased ten years ago for £11,000 or £12,000 but, due to inflation now and the scarcity of houses, the house now has an inflated value but not all of them are rich, not all of them have capital and not all would be regarded as wealthy. Speaking for a Dublin constituency I can say that many of them are a good deal poorer than the farmer living outside Dublin whose house on a valuation basis would come within this, who owns 200 or 300 acres of land, which land is irrelevant in the context of this type of taxation.
This tax should be put in a proper context. It is an attempt to introduce capital taxation which in a sense ignores many who could be regarded as truly very wealthy and could make a contribution. I hope there is still some possibility of dealing with this in a more rational way and I would be abrogating my function as a Deputy if I did not at least point out the anomaly and discourage Deputies from suggesting that people with houses which are valued at £65,000 are living in enormous mansions and dripping with wealth because many of my constituents with that type of house carrying a mortgage of £30,000 in the present economic climate are finding it very difficult to make ends meet. I am delighted Deputy Taylor claimed the honour for this type of tax. It was a welcome admission from my point of view.
Comment on this
I am in agreement with a number of the points made by Deputy Shatter in regard to the manifest anomaly involved here. I want, however, to confine myself to a particular small point at this stage. I am going on the assumption that we will have this tax anyway even though it is misconceived and wrongheaded, as pointed out by Deputy Shatter. I want to concern myself with the implementation of it. In practical terms, it has been pointed out, it will present many problems. In the definitions section under "market value" we find that the market value means:
the market value thereof ascertained in accordance with section 88.
Section 88 refers to:
the market value of any property shall be estimated to be the price which the unencumbered fee simple of such property would fetch if sold in the open market.
Would the Minister explain to us the thinking behind this. I hope he will not say it is simply a convenient way of getting a figure. If he wanted that he could take the PLV. It would be no better but no worse than the method employed here. The implication in all this is that you are taxing people on wealth which they possess if they have an income above a certain level. The fact is when you talk about an unencumbered property you are talking about a property on which somebody has no mortgage or there is no other interest except his own. Of course, many of the properties which will be coming under the requirements of this tax will be encumbered properties. Nevertheless this definition proposes to introduce this totally artificial concept of an unencumbered property to arrive at the value which the Minister presumably would have us believe and certainly some of the people who support this tax would have us believe represents a method of arriving at a person's wealth. Of course, if he owns a property which is encumbered then the wealth which he owns in relation to that property is the market value less the amount of the encumbrance.
Therefore we have this built-in pretence when we say "encumbered" and then we say "fee simple". Of course most of the properties will not be held in fee simple so we will have a second leg of this pretence which is being added to define the market value of the property. It would be equally logical and reasonable for the Minister to provide here that it would apply to all properties the front doors of which are painted green. It would be equally logical to provide that in a section. I think the Minister would fancy himself as a person who would prefer to adopt a logical rather than an illogical course. If so would he explain to the House the logic behind producing a definition to arrive at the market value of property for the purpose of assessing the tax, a definition which is demonstrably false, which is going to produce a figure bearing no relation to reality. It is the theory behind that on which I would like to know the Minister's thinking.
Given that the tax is to be applied one can certainly see the logic — I am leaving aside the income and dealing only with the question of the value of the property for the purpose of assessing tax — of saying take the market value, what it would achieve in the market if it were sold and what the man who owns it would get into his hand when he sold it, in other words when he paid off a mortgage which would be the case in many instances, if the Minister were to say the net value of the property in such a case will be the basis for arriving at an assessment of tax, but that is not done. I want to remind the Minister again that he has built into the definition two totally false assumptions — that all the properties concerned will be unencumbered and all the properties will be held in fee simple. I do not want to labour this point but I would be very interested to know the Minister's logical, theoretical reasoning behind this definition.
Comment on this
I agree with every word Deputy Colley has just said and I would like to add a few words to what he has said because he stopped a little bit short of getting to the core of the objection which every rational person must feel to this part of the Bill. It is this: on what principle, acceptable to people in this country, is this form of tax being applied? There is not an unlimited number of principles on which a tax can be invented and applied. Deputy Colley in an attempt to demonstrate the theme by the use of the absurdity mechanism spoke about taxing people with hall doors of a particular colour. That is a clearly unacceptable form of tax. If asked to say why, admittedly it is quite difficult to marshal and deploy objective criteria which will be always unchangeable which will show the green door tax to be on the far side of what is permissible. It is difficult to draw a theoretical line but reason tells me that in a country like this a tax like that is unacceptable. Equally a tax related to the way somebody looks, the colour of their skin, are outside the line of what is permissible. There is only a certain range of things which have been traditionally understood here to be legitimate attracters of taxation. Income is one of these, rationally and reasonably so because the State has to live and breathe and function the same as individuals who compose it and who shelter under its wing and who have to contribute year by year. That is an intelligible form of tax.
Wealth, I also think, though I seem to be in a tiny minority here, is an intelligible target for tax also not, I want to make it absolutely clear, in a spirit of vindictiveness, not in a spirit of supposing that the amassing of prosperity or substance is a crime for which one owes a social debt, not that, but simply as a contribution, a social contribution, if you like, to people who are less well-off. There are things like the use of forms of national wealth, the use of the roads, which can attract a rationally defensible tax.
Comment on this
I am trying to complete the thought which Deputy Colley embarked on. There are some forms of taxes which can be related to intelligible criteria——
Comment on this
Deputy Colley introduced his remarks by acknowledging that this was the Committee Stage debate and he kept reasonably within that. You are following a hare raised by Deputy Colley and you have followed it into the realms of a Second Reading.
Comment on this
Deputy Colley fastened on the market value thing and what he said about it is absolutely true. We are piling hypothesis on hypothesis here in order to get at the way this thing works and we are then striking out by the use of the word "encumbered" the element of equity which might lead somebody to see a bit of sense in this legislation.
I agree that in an extremely crude, primitive, erratic way which has not been taken seriously by serious people for 200 years one can regard somebody's residence as a rough index to his wealth or the visible parts of his wealth. It is a crude erratic way and I would not support it in any shape or form if it were proposed on that basis. What can be put up by the taxpayer and established by the Revenue is to what extent that pile of bricks and mortar really represents wealth because in every commercial and fiscal context of every other kind the net value is what is regarded as the wealth. I could sell everything I have and buy a castle and live on orange boxes in it. I could beggar my wife and children in order to do it. My wealth of course is not simply the notional unencumbered fee simple of Adare Manor or wherever it is. It is an extreme degree of poverty caused by my own recklessness and prodigality. In every other commercial and fiscal context what I owe on this heap will be taken into account before anyone comes to a conclusion on what I am worth, what I can leave behind, what I have succeeded in amassing in life.
This item has no regard to that. All forms of taxation are potentially discriminatory and we live in a State in which year by year more and more standards are being set up in regard to equality before the law and outlawing discrimination. The law on that subject has hardly moved into the field of tax but it will move quickly and far into that area. I would like to know on what basis the kind of person Deputy Shatter was talking about, about whom neither he nor I feel any vindictiveness, the penthouse dweller who runs a yacht, can be exempt from this form of taxation while somebody else who does not own a yacht and does not have any other assets or substance can be charged this tax. These two citizens are entitled to the benefit of equality before the law but they are not being treated equally. You can discriminate against citizens, and every State does so, but to be within its own law the State must do so on a principle which is intelligible, rational and bears an intelligible relation to the object which the Act seeks to achieve. There is no such relation here.
The people who thought up this tax do not give a damn whether it is workable. There was only one thing in their minds and that was to apply a crude punishment to the middle classes, to the residents of this road or that road in Deputy Shatter's constituency and mine and many others throughout the country. They would like to hear them squeal. There is somebody to whom the standards of the middle class appear pathetic, pitiful, who would not know where Deputy Shatter's constituency was or mine, and he is laughing but it would take a bit of thought, principle and intelligible reflection to get at him and that is beyond the capacity of the gentleman who thought up this measure.
Comment on this
It seems to fall on me always to follow the best act in the House. I say that with respect to Deputy Kelly who made a very cogent argument against some of the inequities, injustices and anomalies in this Bill. The points made by Deputy Colley and Deputy Shatter, both of whom have considerable legal experience, are right on the button and go to the root of the inequities and anomalies.
I have put down amendments to this market value definition in so far as it relates to section 88. They deal with almost all the points raised by Deputy Colley, Deputy Shatter and Deputy Kelly. My amendments try to get rid of these anomalies, inequities and injustices which exist in this Bill — the deletion of the unencumbered fee simple in section 88 and the guarantee that the valuation of the property will be limited to valuations for residential use. This will always be affected by developments and the sales of properties nearby which might not have been used for residential use. My third amendment will ensure that mortgages will be taken into account. Those are three key amendments dealing with market value. Each reflects the objections expressed this morning on all sides of the House. These anomalies and inequities were so obvious that we had to submit these amendments.
Let me discuss the unencumbered fee simple of the property. Most lawyers, particularly solicitors, will recognise that an unencumbered fee simple is a rare animal in property title, and Deputy Taylor acknowledges that. Nonetheless, every property covered by this is to be valued as if it were that rarest of rare animals in the property title — an unencumbered fee simple. That is asking us to engage in an outrageous fiction and in respect of all householders to ignore those realities whether there are charges in respect of the family mortgages or other encumbrances, because every title in all our towns is now an unencumbered fee simple.
It is crazy to ask us to pass this section as if it were the norm. I put down my amendment to section 88 to delete that nonsense and I hope I will have the support of all the Deputies who expressed their reservations on it. That is the first fiction we are being asked to enact and it is asking too much of this Legislature, to discuss in a couple of hours a new tax which should take a couple of months. In the limited time available to us since publication, we decided that that fiction was nonsense and this section must be amended and I hope I can rely on the support of the House to have that done.
We put down an amendment to cover the second fiction: after line 21, page 71, section 88, to ensure that the market value is the best price for the property for residential use. We are talking about a residence which people have built, looked after and developed. It is their home. It may be that because of potential development in the area, or houses near the area, the actual value of the property as a residence is less than it would be if they decided to vacate the property and sold it to a property developer in the area with planning permission. Unless the Minister adopts our second amendment, these people are likely to be penalised as their homes might fetch more on the open market because of property or office block development in or near that area.
The valuation commissioners could compare the valuation given with double the price got for a neighbour's house and say that the valuation for property tax reasons was under-estimated. They could claim that that property owner owed them the difference between those two house prices plus the interest over the intervening period. We on this side have an amendment to deal with that matter. We must have finality in this area. Hopefully, we may not get to the point where people have to submit valuations but we want those submitting the valuation to know that on that valuation submitted on the best possible advice — and incidentally they are not selling — they will not be penalised because some neighbour sold his property for twice as much to some developer two or three years later.
I am very pleased that Deputies Shatter, Kelly and Colley, people with experience of dealing in this area, apart from their representative capacity in this House, and Deputy Mitchell before me, have also said that this is no way to discuss this new tax. The least the people out there are entitled to have from us is that we have the time and opportunity to use our professional, practical and business experience and our role as legislators to examine this section in detail in a special committee. New taxes normally come in in the form of separate legislation which we can examine properly.
Comment on this
Deputy Kelly is quite right. Preceded by a white paper explaining to us and the public what it is about. It is quite clear this morning — and quite frankly I do not blame him — that the Minister himself does not fully understand this section. How can we expect the public between now and October to understand what their liability and responsibility are? If they do not understand, some may be accused, under section 83, of being guilty of Revenue offences which may make them liable to fines of up to £10,000 or five years' imprisonment. That is the other fiction we are being asked to enact.
I could put down 20 amendments, but one must concentrate on four or five, picking the obvious ones. We are being asked to assume that every house is free of mortgage. There is a very considerable difference between the exceptional house which is unencumbered and in fee simple, perhaps valued at £85,000 or £90,000 and the house valued at that price on which the couple have a mortgage of up to £70,000. Deputy Taylor and Deputy Shatter know that because they are solicitors, and also Deputy Kelly. We are also being asked to enact the fiction that they are not in any way different. The person buying that house will tell you fairly smartly that they are not the same. We are being told, however, to value them as if they were and as if the person living in that mortgaged house wants to sell it, which he has no intention of doing.
Comment on this
It would have been better if it had been put on a much broader basis like the wealth tax which the Deputy's party abolished.
Comment on this
I can speak for myself on this subject. I do not require Deputy Kelly to speak on my behalf. He does not speak for me, judging by his comments here.
Comment on this
Deputy Taylor apparently now sees all the anomalies, inequities and injustices and recognises that what they insisted on as the price for their being together, in a manner of speaking, because they are not together on this issue clearly, was too much to pay, that the wealth tax would have been better. That is a matter for Deputy Taylor. That is not our fault.
Comment on this
Let us keep out of the political hassle and keep to the relevant issues. We are also told that it would be the price which the unencumbered fee simple property would fetch if sold on the open market on the valuation date. Even though the owner has no intention of selling on that day and intends with his children and his grandchildren after him, to live in that house we are to engage in the fiction that he is selling on that date. The only definition of market value in the law—and it is a fairly good guide—is what a willing purchaser will give to a willing vendor for a property which they both have agreed that one wants to sell and the other to buy. That is a precise factual situation which enables one to say on this day that A wants to sell to B his property C and they both know what they are doing. Then one gets the market value. Here we are talking about a market value which would be notional, as if the owner wanted to sell on that date subject to such conditions as might reasonably be calculated to obtain for the vendor the best price for the property — whatever that might mean in the circumstances. The man does not want to sell it, anyway.
I have put down all my amendments to get rid of all the anomalies, inequities and injustices which are so obvious in this section. I particularly support what Deputies Kelly, Shatter, Colley and Brady have so forcefully said. The amendments which I put down a few days ago cover most of the points but I acknowledge to each of these Deputies that they cannot cover all the inequities. That would not be possible. If we were to make any attempt to discharge our responsibility to the taxpayers, and even to the Revenue Commissioners, we should do as I and so many have suggested: take this section quietly away. The Finance Bill without it will not suffer any great loss. We should examine the section for three or four weeks calmly, in detail, and give the benefit of our objective views on it. We might then begin to ensure that not only do we discharge our responsibilities but that nobody outside this House will be liable for a tax about which he or she knows nothing because we know nothing about it.
Comment on this
There are two elements in the definition of a person who is liable for residential property tax — the capital side when one must own property above a certain value, and the income side on which one's income must exceed a certain amount. Deputy Colley, in particular, but also Deputies Kelly and Shatter, have ruthlessly exposed the artificiality and anomalies which exist on the capital side. I want to point out the artificialities which exist on the income side.
Many forms of income which are exempt from tax for many good reasons are treated as income for the purposes of determining whether somebody has income in excess of £20,000 and is therefore liable for residential property tax. Many forms of allowances and exemptions which are given against income for tax purposes are not given in calculating a person's income for liability to residential property tax. I want the Minister to clarify whether the following is the position. Take the case of a sole trader who carries on two businesses. In the current financial year he makes a profit of £25,000 in one business and in the second business a loss of £20,000. His net income is £5,000. Is it a fact that his income is treated as £25,000 and that therefore he is liable for residential property tax? Could the Minister please clarify that point.
Comment on this
Deputy Brady make some remarks about fluctuating market trends and inflation. It is because of the difficulties and of the particular circumstances which have to be taken into account in view of those two factors that we have provided in the Bill that the property values to be taken into account would be adjusted by reference to the new house price index and fluctuations therein and that the income limits would be adjusted by reference to changes in the consumer price index. Therefore, the concern that led Deputy Brady to make those remarks is covered in the Bill. Deputy Kelly asked a question in relation to the definition of "occupied" in the context of residential property. The Deputy should read that definition together with the definition of "relevant residential property" which, as defined in the section, means, in relation to any person, any residential property in relation to which he is the owner and which is occupied by him as a dwelling. In the case raised by Deputy Kelly, the property would not be occupied by the person as a dwelling.
Deputy Shatter referred to incomes which would not be covered by this tax. There is a good deal in what he says so far as the scope of our taxation system as a whole is concerned. On the other hand it is unreasonable of Deputy Shatter to suggest that we should resolve all the problems and the lack of coverage in our tax system by way of one new tax measure. I would point out to him also that even those who have purchased yachts would normally have paid VAT on them here, but if the Deputy thinks that is not enough perhaps he would suggest ways in which further contributions might be got from those people.
Comment on this
It is not reasonable to make the point that because there are deficiencies in the coverage of our system we should hold that against any new tax measure to come before us.
There has been much discussion about the question of unencumbered fee simple and market value. Rather emotional terms have been used during that discussion which has been all on the basis as if a tax were to be charged on the unencumbered fee simple or on the market value and therefore would be subject to the criticism that has been adduced in relation to those concepts. But the tax is not being charged on either of those figures. It is being charged on the difference between them and the 1½ per cent — in other words, the tax is not relating to the total of the figures being talked about.
Comment on this
It is being charged on the difference between the market value exemption limit and the market value of the property.
Comment on this
I suggest that there is no inequality so far as this property tax is concerned between a person in an unencumbered-fee-simple situation and one whose interest in a property is under lease for a term of years or for a short term letting. Basically, the tax attaches to the right of enjoyment or use of the property and not to the extent of the person's interest in the property.
Deputy O'Kennedy talked about the estimation of the market value. I would remind him that there is a section in the Capital Acquisition Tax Act which deals with the market value of property. This is section 15 (1) which provides that, subject to the provisions of the Act, the market value of any property for the purposes of the Act shall be estimated to be the price which, in the opinion of the Revenue Commissioners, such property would fetch on the open market on the day on which the property is to be valued in such manner and subject to such conditions as might reasonably be calculated to obtain for the vendor the best price for the property.
Comment on this
The notion that we are bringing into this Bill is not without precedent and is one which has shown a certain value and effectiveness in the operation of that particular tax.
Comment on this
There are other provisions in that Act that relate to provisions we do not have here.
Comment on this
That is a different question. I am addressing the point raised by Deputy O'Kennedy on the question of deciding on the market value of a property. For those reasons, while recognising the concern of Members of the House regarding the introduction of a new tax, I would make the case that this new tax is not open to all of the criticisms that Members here have put forward. In many ways those criticisms are exaggerated having regard to the way the tax will operate and given the definition we have.
Comment on this
Many people have pushed themselves to the limit of mortgage finance in order to provide for themselves the best houses possible. In my constituency there are many young people who are living in what can be described only as very modest homes but because of where the houses are located they have a market value in excess of the £65,000 limit we are talking of. This is a far cry from what the Minister described last evening as the purpose of this tax — to extricate a contribution from the owners of better-than-average type residences. Indeed, local authority houses in the area I represent are costing £50,000 per unit. However, the people I am talking of will now have to meet this additional burden of the residential property tax after paying their mortgage repayments and also the increases in PRSI and so on.
People have made it clear to me that they are not against paying a tax provided the tax is fair, but the tax we are talking of is anything but fair. The move today is towards introducing equity in to the tax system so that people with similar incomes pay the same amount of taxation. The effect of the residential property tax will be to introduce significant and in some cases violent inequities into the system. It will mean that people with similar incomes but living in different parts of the country or perhaps even living next door to each other will be faced with different taxation bills.
Yesterday when dealing with the section relating to VAT we spent a good deal of time debating the reduction from £15,000 to £12,000 and from £30,000 to £25,000. This was by way of attempting to remove the anomaly that existed. We are doing the reverse here. The inequity of the tax can be demonstrated further by taking the case of a person who has a whole portfolio of property and who may live in a luxury penthouse. He would not have to pay the tax.
Comment on this
I have to comment on the Minister's replies to the points made. The Minister has not dealt with those points satisfactorily. He is not prepared to allow any distinction to be made between types of property. Once you have the bricks and mortar you apply the same norm to all, irrespective of mortgages and so on. The Minister must know there are considerable distinctions. If that is the basis on which he is asking us to pass this Bill, let that be known. This is a basic principle of the tax. There is no distinction. We are to adopt the fiction that properties are all unencumbered, fee simple, and that is the end of it.
Comment on this
For the purpose of calculating the tax liability. We are being told we must adopt the fiction that they are all unencumbered, fee simple, and there is no distinction between them. That is too much to ask of us, irrespective of party whips or anything else. This is the craziest nonsense we have ever been asked to adopt. I do not think any one of us personally wants to be a party to that.
It is just as well that the Minister's position has been exposed for what it is. I am not saying it is a personal position. I do not know where this nonsense derived from, but it is sad that the Minister should ask us to pass legislation on the basis of that fiction. We will not, and we will not make a great political point out of it if others feel they cannot pass this kind of nonsense either. I am glad Deputy Colley is still here. He has much more experience of this in practical terms than I have. The Minister referred to capital acquisitions tax. Understandably his officials drew his attention to the appropriate section.
Comment on this
The words the Minister drew on are in the existing capital acquisition tax legislation. Agreed. That is where the analogy has to end. There you are talking of capital acquisitions. You are talking about a change of ownership, a realisation of wealth on which a liability occurs under that legislation if a person acquires from somebody else something one did not own before. There is an identifiable date on which a change occurred in ownership, user, or whatever else.
Comment on this
The Minister has not listened. There is a change of ownership. There is an identifiable date. It is an acquisition. We are not arguing the rights or wrongs of that here this morning. There is an identifiable date on which there is an acquisition and you can say: "That is the date from which it has to be valued". There are different views here about property and capital taxation but, if you are in favour of it, it is feasible and sensible to work it on that basis.
Here it is not that way at all. There is no point in the Minister drawing terms from the capital acquisition legislation and saying: "We had it before and it is the same here". Here we are being asked to assume the fiction that people who intend to live in their house, and whose children will stay in the house, will be selling the house on some date, when they have no such intention. That is very distinct from what the Minister is drawing from the capital acquisition legislation. The difference is so obvious that, if the Minister suggests there is no difference, that further underlines how untenable his case is. I do not think I should proceed any further. I am beginning to wonder whether we should go ahead and vote on the sections and the amendments. It is quite clear that a number of Deputies have reservations. Deputy Taylor is now developing reservations.
Comment on this
He wishes we had a wealth tax at this stage instead of this nonsense. We will see if the Deputy can make something of this nonsense. We are trying to get rid of the inequities and the injustices and anomalies. I do not think we can do that in another two hours.
Comment on this
I hope the Minister will deal precisely with my arguments and not try to draw a veil over the matter by saying: "We have these words somewhere else. There are no distinctions". Clearly there are distinctions. I have given the reasons for our amendments but, even if we put down five more amendments, we could not get rid of all the inequities and anomalies. We have done our best. This should be taken out of the House for a month or five or six weeks. There is a measure of agreement on this which I have seldom seen in this House. Perhaps we can help the Minister and help ourselves too and the public will see that we are not a circus all the time, or entertainers at any time, and we can be serious and do something useful. This might be the day on which we could start to give that example to the public.
Comment on this
Listening to what I can only describe as the howls of anguish arising from this very modest measure in this tax Bill one would assume that outside this House an immense protest was going on about the suggested imposition of this tax. Such is not the case at all. People who will be affected by this tax fall into a rarified category. I have spoken to many of them about this. Nobody has protested about this tax to me. The comments I got from people who recognise that they have a liability to the tax are that this cannot be faulted, that it is reasonable and modest enough.
People said to me: "I live in a very substantial house. I have a good income." What is the amount involved here? About £100 or £200 in the overwhelming bulk of the limited number of cases involved. People outside say it is reasonable enough and cannot be faulted. In this House we hear howls of anguish which are very different from the response outside. In my constituency people live in houses worth £70,000 or £80,000. That is modest and not excessive. Perhaps the income into the house is £25,000 or £30,000. In this day and age that is modest. That argument has been put forward on my right and on my left.
Comment on this
"These are hard-working people and this is modest enough, nothing exceptional, not unusual". When you describe something as modest — and that word was used — you must realise that "modest" is relative. The overwhelming bulk of people — perhaps 95 per cent — do not fall into the category that the value of their house is £70,000 and the income coming into the house is upwards of £20,000. Some might qualify on one count and some might qualify on the other count. The numbers that qualify on both counts are very rare. I know a lot of them are concentrated in the constituency of Dublin South with perhaps a few in Dublin South East but there are not too many of them in Dublin South West.
Comment on this
We come now to the rarified category who are affected. What is the effect? One would think, to hear the howls of anguish here, that the amount of tax involved was draconian, that this was — I cannot remember the words used by Deputy Kelly — an intensive attack on the major standards, either capital or income, of the people involved. This is not the case. The amounts involved are modest in the extreme. One could reasonably bring forward a criticism that capital taxation should produce an appropriate amount that would at least make some visible easement of the tax paid by the PAYE sector in relation to the income side. I believe Deputy Kelly, to some extent, is making that valid criticism. I agree with him in relation to that. Of course, the £100,000 yacht in Dún Laoghaire should be taxed in some way. It would have been until Deputy O'Kennedy's party laid their hands on the wealth tax. It was at that time, but they got rid of it quickly enough when they got their hands on the reins of power. The fact that this measure, limited though it is, modest though it is, does not tax the £100,000 yacht in Dún Laoghaire should not be a reason for saying even the little bit that is there should go too. Are they saying that the £100,000 yacht is not included and therefore we will have nothing on this category whatsoever?
Deputy Kelly raised a question concerning on what principle the tax is brought in. The principle is understood very clearly by the man in the street, and I believe it is understood very well in here but it is hedged with amendments to cut out even the modest amount that it is envisaged to bring in. There are two basic principles. A person lives in a house which is way above the national average and the income coming into the house is around £20,000 a year, approximately £400 a week. There are many thousands of people who have an income of £60 or £70 a week coming in on social welfare. Will somebody tell them that we should not have a residential property tax of £100 or £150 a year where somebody is living in a house worth £70,000 or £80,000 and £400 a week comes into that house? If you go round to those people at election time and you tell them that this tax is unreasonable, or that there is something wild about it that warrants the anguish expressed here by some Members on both sides of the House, what will those constituents say to you? This is a very reasonable tax. There is no outcry about it outside the House. I have had letters protesting about the Nova radio station but I have not had one letter protesting about this tax. I have spoken to people involved in this, many of whom are constituents of Deputy Kelly and Deputy Shatter, and their universal response has been that they accept the tax, that they feel it is reasonable in all the circumstances and that they regard it as modest. That is the response which has been put to me.
Comment on this
I support this measure in the Bill not because I feel it is in any way adequate in providing revenue from the capital taxation source but because it is the only form of capital taxation element introduced in the Bill. The overwhelming bulk of the people would demand from their public representatives that there be a more equal balance brought about in relation to taxation on capital and income. That does not apply at the present time. This is the best that can be brought forward in the present composition of the House. One would think, having regard to the very limited number of people affected by it, who raise no objection about it and who can well afford it, that the Members who have spoken so long and hard about it would stay quiet on the subject. With regard to what is involved in it, the number of people affected by it and their position, one would think that silence would be appropriate — make a point on a section but just accept the principle. There has been very strong argument on the broad principle and one would think that a more political approach would be to remain silent on the subject and accept the principle as reasonable and modest instead of putting down amendments to try to chip away the little amount proposed to be raised in revenue in this measure. There are a couple of queries I want to raise on the Committee Stage, which indeed has been turned into a Second Stage debate. I have a couple of points on some points in the section.
Comment on this
It has not been turned into a Second Stage debate. It is a very comprehensive section of the Bill and covers a very wide field.
Comment on this
I was indicating that some of the speeches were tending in that direction, no doubt my own included. I want to ask the Minister the reason for the distinction drawn and the need to bring in a separate subsection on the definition dealing with the question of a lease that exceeds 50 years as against the question of a lease that would be less than 50 years. The first point I want to make is in relation to line 49 on page 68 which describes the lease as "the duration of which exceeds 50 years". That seems to me to be a bit ambiguous. Is that intended to mean a lease which originally had a term of upwards of 50 years, or could it mean a lease with a term of 50 years unexpired as from this particular time? If the intent is that it should mean a lease with a term originally of 50 years I think the wording is perhaps a bit ambiguous. I believe the wording used in the Income Tax Act, 1967, in the definition of section 80 would have been a better wording for that. It states: "A lease granted for a term exceeding 50 years". Perhaps the Minister would clarify that.
Comment on this
May I ask the Deputy for clarification? Is he suggesting that, if it was originally for a period exceeding 50 years but has only four years to run, it should be included here?
Comment on this
Which would the Deputy propose? I thought the Deputy was suggesting that the definition should be of a lease exceeding 50 years from the date the lease was drawn up. There might only be four years to run on that lease. Surely the Deputy would not suggest that that should be included as an unencumbered fee simple?
Comment on this
No. I am presuming that what the section is intended to cater for is a lease which when originally granted was upwards of 50 years. I am querying whether there is an ambiguous element in the definition as it stands at present.
Comment on this
Irrespective of how long the lease remains, does the Deputy think it should cover the original date and term of the lease?
Comment on this
Yes, of course, because these leases, as I am quite sure Deputy O'Kennedy knows, are renewable leases under the Landlord and Tenant Act and the Ground Rents Act. One can go into the thing in greater detail but a lot of talk has been made about unencumbered fee simple. People who have not bought out their ground rents in these cases are entitled to buy out the fee simple. Frankly, from a valuation point of view, does it make much difference whether you are entitled to buy it out or whether you have bought it out? The practicality of it is — and Deputy O'Kennedy knows this — that it makes little difference, if you have a lease of, say £5 a year or whatever, when you have the right to buy it out, as a residential occupier does under the landlord and tenant legislation, whether you have actually got around to doing it or not.
Comment on this
Let us have it for the floor of the House, then. If one has a 50-year lease which is about to run out, say in three years time, and be renewed, surely the Deputy knows from his practical experience as a solicitor, which I have not had in that way, that the terms of the new lease can be very different from those of the existing one. It seems extraordinary for the Deputy to suggest that you have a right of renewal but that that does not make any great difference because you could pay a lot more for your new lease after renewal.
Comment on this
What I do know is that the landlord and tenant legislation provides that the terms of the new lease are the same as the terms of the old lease. What I also know is that under the terms of the landlord and tenant legislation one of the categories of people entitled to buy out the fee simple are people who are owner/occupiers. They are precisely the people who are referred to here.