We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Finance Bill, 1983: Committee Stage (Resumed).

Contributions 245–480 of 480. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Finance Bill 1983
Enacted

No. 8 of 1983 ›

Yes, but the landlord and tenant legislation, as the Deputy must know, provides that the fee simple in an owner/occupier situation can be bought out at a very modest price. There are certain overall provisions for the acquisition of the freehold interest by an owner/occupier.

I want to go on then to ask the Minister, dealing with the case of a lease which originally had been for the duration of a period of less than 50 years, at the time it was granted such a lease could have been a renewed lease itself; and in view of the fact that a rent reserved under a short-term lease as originally granted was at a modest ground rent, could it be that, having regard to the circumstances which existed at the time that lease was granted, that was an arm's length situation? The section dealing with this is on page 69, lines 10 to 25. That subsection does take cognisance of the circumstances which existed at the time that lease was granted and other circumstances. Therefore, if you had a situation in which a lease originally had been granted for, let us say 40 years, and at that time perhaps granted in consideration of the premises having being put into repair or something of that nature, when consequently the rent reserved might have been £10 or even £20, nonetheless that would have been an arm's length situation. Is it the position that a person holding a house in those circumstances would be exempt from the tax by virtue of that section?

My final point is that the distinction appears to be drawn here — and I do not know that it is a valid distinction — at page 69, line 32, between a person holding a property at the will or sufferance of another person — in other words a tenancy at will — and, on page 70, at lines five and six, where a person holds the property as a caretaker. There seems to be a distinction drawn there between a tenancy at will and a person who holds under a caretaker's agreement. I should have thought that broadly they would be the one category. There is a provision in that part of section 84 that, if a caretaker's agreement is made at arm's length, the tax would not apply. Could the Minister clarify how one could determine whether a caretaker's agreement was made at arm's length or not? The normal procedure on a caretaker's agreement would be that one person owns a house, he puts another person in, no rent is paid and the basis of the agreement is that he looks after the house as caretaker. That is the standard arrangement under a caretaker's agreement. I find some difficulty in following there how the question of arm's length in the context of a caretaker's agreement could arise. Would this leave a possible opening to avoid this tax by the owner putting in another person under a caretaker's agreement with the sole responsibility of looking after the house? Would that be a possible method of avoidance of this tax?

I might revert to the first point I made — and I think it is a valid one to make in the context of this section as a capital taxation measure. It refers, of course, and is confined to the question of residential property that a person occupies. There is great play about that — the home, the residence, so on — and that tax should not apply to that. Ironically, that is the one item that was excluded from the wealth tax, the person's own residential property. Yet, excluded though it was, that was the tax that the Fianna Fáil Party when they came into power were at pains to get rid of as quickly as ever they could.

Comment on this

I heard here this morning a number of excellent speeches on both sides of the House. I am glad to say I heard the Minister reply to them.

The Minister for Finance is an able man but he found himself today in the unenviable situation that, able and all as he is, neither he nor anyone else could defend the indefensible. The points that have been made simply have not been answered.

This tax is ill-conceived, it is idiotic and inequitable and has been proved to be all of those things. If by any chance it is passed through this and the other House, there is no question but that it will be challenged in the High Court and the Supreme Court at a very early stage. While one hesitates to make any definitive forecasts about the outcome of cases, I would be very surprised if this tax is not found to be unconstitutional on more than one ground. If one applies the principles that the Supreme Court, for examciple, applied in the Murphy case, clearly it breaches the principles that the Supreme Court laid down in Murphy. You have the same old thing again that we were supposed to have got rid of, that it pays a couple financially to live together but not to get married. Of course they benefit clearly from this and the Supreme Court presumably will set that aside because it will be found to be discriminatory against couples who are married. If you like, that is only one of the minor side issues; it is not one of the fundamental effects of this whole provision. There are so many glaring inequities which will be found to be discriminatory as between citizens that the prospects of this tax surviving any length of time are fairly negligible.

The more obvious anomalies and inequities have been referred to in a succession of speeches here today. I am sure, if we had the time to go through it all and analyse it line by line, we would find there is a ludicrously long definition of "owner" and references to rents over and above a certain level. One could spend hours speaking on the sorts of anomalies that could arise.

Deputy O'Dea asked a short, straightforward question to which he did not receive a reply. The Minister waffled on about other things. The reason Deputy O'Dea did not receive an answer is that he is right. The definition of "income" is gross income, except with the most limited number of deductions. Deputy O'Dea gave the example of a sole trader who carries on to two separate businesses, making £25,000 on one and losing £20,000 on the other. His income is £5,000 a year but for the purpose of this tax his income is £25,000 a year because that is the gross figure and therefore he is liable, although presumably it is not the intention that someone earning only £5,000 a year would be liable.

Most of the debate concentrated on the anomalies which exist on the capital side but there are enormous anomalies on the income side also. The Chinese concept of the extended family has been introduced, to the detriment of the family. If someone, as is quite common in this country, were to make provision for his mother or mother-in-law and bring her to live with his family, the family could be caught for this tax if she had an income of about £5,000 as a result, say, of the death of her husband. The obvious remedy is to ask the mother or mother-in-law to depart to the county home or somewhere else where she will be a burden on the State because by kicking her out the family will save the tax on the dwelling.

The gross income of minor children is also aggregated and one might have a child who had been left some property by a grandparent or an uncle and who derived some income from that property. What should one do with that child? Is the child to be kicked out of the house? On a strict reading, even if that were done the income would still be aggregated for the purpose of this tax.

What view will the High Court or the Supreme Court take of this ridiculous tax which has been cobbled together for the worst of reasons, not, as Deputy Kelly rightly says, because it will work or because anyone thinks it will work but because it is politically and ideologically necessary as a sop to the Labour Party. Members of that party will make the kind of speech we heard from Deputy Taylor when he talked in a grandiose way about how great it is to have a tax on big houses. People who have not studied the Bill or studied some of the commentaries on it think there is something basically equitable about this tax. I have read some of the commentaries by tax experts. They tend to express themselves in rather cold and rational terms but even such men are carried away in wonder at the nonsense that pervades this part of the Bill.

The Minister does not fully understand the significance of the argument he tries to make when he equates the unencumbered fee simple with any other kind of title. The definition of "ownership" refers to a lease, the duration of which is 50 years or more. Forty-nine of those years may be expired. How can one compare the value of a house held under a lease with one year to go and a similar house with an unencumbered fee simple, which means that it is owned forever? How can it be said that both houses have the same value? Does the Minister or any Member of this House seriously think that the Supreme Court will approve of this tax when under this fictional notional system two houses of the kind I have mentioned will have the same value for the purposes of this tax? The Supreme Court will laugh that out in two hours; it will not get even to lunch time on the first day. Still we have to go through this procedure and enact this nonsense.

It is easy to challenge people on the other side and ask them to put their feet where their mouths are. They should seriously think about this point. It will be politically embarrassing for them, whichever way it goes. They can either enact it, against their clearly and eloquently expressed better judgment, and wait for the Supreme Court to tear it to shreds, or they can put a stop to the nonsense now and tell the Minister to produce some workable equitable tax that bears some relation to reality. They may not want to vote against this measure but I would ask those who have spoken and others who know this tax is farcical to consider abstaining.

Deputy O'Kennedy made the point that when a totally new system of taxation is introduced it is brought in by way of a special Bill preceded by a White Paper and the principles of it are argued at length. The famous turnover tax in 1963 was argued at tremendous length until Members of this House were blue in the face and value-added tax, although not a fundamentally new tax because it was really a European adaptation of our old turnover tax, was introduced by way of a White Paper and a special Bill in 1972 and debated in great detail. The whole principle of it was discussed throughout the country for a year or two before it was brought in, but here we have a totally new tax dreamed up under pressure — and not in the Gaiety this time. I think this emanates from the Savoy in Limerick.

Comment on this

It was a house out in Ballsbridge. That is where they met.

Comment on this

Yes, but I think it got the imprimatur in Ballsbridge after the Savoy in Limerick, if I am not mistaken. Whether it was Ballsbridge or Limerick, it certainly did not get much technical examination whatever rapid political expediency had to be met by it when it was cooked up. I do not envy the Revenue Commissioners or the people who drafted it because it is totally unworkable, and it will be unworkable, and it will probably be set aside in any event by the Supreme Court at a very early date.

We heard all these cries for equity today. Apart from the inequity of treating a one-year lease the same as an unencumbered lease where is the equity in taking a £80,000 house, which is quite common nowadays in this and every other city — not a very elaborate establishment by any means — subject to a mortgage of £60,000 so that the value of the owner's interest is £20,000 but making him pay tax on £80,000?

Take another example. One could go on all day long giving examples. Take the example of a situation which is unhappily becoming increasingly common. Take the case of someone who was working in Cork. His firm transfers to Dublin. He has to buy a house in Dublin. He puts up his house in Cork for sale and he cannot sell it. He is on bridging finance, tremendously expensive on a house in Dublin carrying 22 per cent to 23 per cent interest. He still has the house in Cork unsaleable. For the purpose of this tax both houses are aggregated. If they are both worth £70,000 he is regarded as the occupier of £140,000 worth of residential property. He may be paying about £1,000 per month in interest alone on bridging finance. That man in that situation — I know a great many of them now — is crucified financially. He is now assessed under this bit of nonsense for another £2,000 or £3,000 because he has what Deputy Taylor calls the equivalent of a yacht owner in Dún Laoghaire.

The whole thing is farcical and those who are in a position to stop it should stop it and do the country a service and do themselves and their parties a service by bringing this to an end. This House has often enacted laws which subsequently proved unworkable or unconstitutional but it can be fairly said that this House never deliberately or consciously did that until today. If the House enacts this law this day, it will have deliberately and consciously enacted something that 90 per cent of us who sit here know cannot work and cannot survive challenge in the High Court.

Comment on this

This debate highlights more than ever before the need for Dáil reform. I agree with Deputy Taylor that the debate has drifted into a Second Stage debate. I think the Minister would be the first to admit it would be a pity if we did not have this kind of discussion on the Second Stage because this section is undoubtedly filled with loopholes. One would almost think that those who drafted it felt themselves it was a tax over which they could not stand. It is so riddled with difficulty I cannot see it working. Deputies get carried away with a great deal with bonhomie and cameraderie with their partners here but just let me put into context the climate in which this Bill has been introduced, a climate created by our friend over there on the Fianna Fáil benches. We should not forget the task the Minister has. He has to raise money.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I think we had an agreement that this type of speech dealing with general budget principles would not be made on the Committee Stage.

Comment on this
John J. Ryan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I suggest the Deputy should deal with the amendment.

Comment on this

We have a duty to find the money to pay our debts. It would have been more honest if, instead of having nine amendments, Deputy O'Kennedy proposed that the whole section should be opposed. If there are so many loopholes that would have been the more correct way of doing things.

Comment on this

Is that the Deputy's opinion?

Comment on this

I am saying Fianna Fáil would perhaps have been more honest had they opposed the whole section. They seem to be looking for the best of both worlds.

Comment on this

That is the Deputy's opinion.

Comment on this

I am entitled to say that. Many speakers have wandered in the debate but I agree with a great deal of what has been said. Coming to the tax, the only value of residential property is the value the residents get out of it, namely, the living value. It is only when they go to sell the house that it become a financial asset or financially valuable. A house, whether it has five bedrooms or three bedrooms, has the same value from the point of view of the people living in it because they are using it only for living in. The imposition of a tax on residential property is something we must argue against. On that basis this tax is built around an illusion. The Minister should seriously consider the arguments advanced and bring in appropriate amendments on Report Stage designed to make the tax workable so that it will bring in this £6 million. There is no use introducing a Bill which will only gather dust. Deputy Taylor described this as a limited and modest tax which will bring in very little. As it is it will probably create problems which will outweigh the benefits the tax might bring. The Minister has been taking careful note of the difficulties that may arise and I am sure he will bring in appropriate amendments on Report Stage.

Comment on this

I have been intrigued listening to some of the points made. I could not help observing that among the vast majority of the speakers on both sides from the legal profession there is a kind of disconcerting unanimity on this part of the Bill. Sean O Faoláin said in his book The Irish that the lowing of cattle is the leitmotif of Irish history and you can equate cattle with property in that context. Anyone studying the Brehon Laws and looking at Binchy's lecture in 1943, the John Reith lecture on the Brehon Laws, will be convinced about the battles fought by the predecessors of the majority of the contributors here this morning on the question of property. The only concession that was made to the Church, the only inroad that the Church, which was all powerful at the time, could make on the question of property — I come back to a point Deputy O'Malley made about the extended family — was that all the family under Brehon Laws had to agree that Church land would be ceded to the Church.

As someone interested in social history, I could not help being interested in the tone of the debate here. It would be a contradiction to hope for enlightenment but there have been some very welcome technical observations. I have no objection as a member of the Labour Party responsible for this and I make no apology for it wherever it was drafted. We are speaking about equity. I have no objection personally to somebody sitting down and looking at the objective merit of the technical objections provided we are agreed on the broad principle that the Bill is based in equity. It was Fianna Fáil who abolished the wealth tax. I know at least one member of the legal profession who under the wealth tax returned his capital acquisitions at £98,000 deliberately year after year to stay below the threshold. He told me that himself. I believe that what is proposed is fundamentally equitable because it will be progressive, vertically and horizontally. The late Limerick city manager used to tell us that this country had the highest proportion of owner occupied houses in Europe — 70 per cent. So it is only a matter of time before most people come into the realms of this proposal. Listening to some of the lawyers speaking I am reminded of Macbeth: "Methink the lady doth protest too much". I bought my house in 1958 for £1,250. That was then the price of an ordinary, urban semi-detached house. That house today would fetch about £25,000, roughly 20 times its value. Some of us used to scream about the banks and insurance companies benefiting from inflation. We all benefited from inflation and will continue to do so in that context, so it is only a matter of time until we all come into that. The advantage of what the Minister proposed, and I support him unequivocally in his search for equity in this situation, is that we are all going to move into it at some stage and it will go up vertically and out horizontally.

Comment on this

This is very optimistic. Lift up your hearts.

Comment on this

Let us take the example of somebody in a house valued at present at £85,000 with a salary of £20,000.

Comment on this

Be careful. You are making the opposite argument to the Minister.

Comment on this

Ni chuir mise isteach ort.

Comment on this

I am trying to save the Deputy from a horrible fate.

Comment on this

Vertical or horizontal?

Comment on this

Worse than death. I am prepared to go through that. Take the example of somebody with a house valued at £85,000. He is paying only 1.5 per cent over the threshold of £65,000. He is paying £300 a year and with an income of £20,000, that is £400 a week, he would only be paying £6. I do not think that is unfair or savage.

Somebody mentioned the disparity in the leases and things like that. I would imagine that somebody could apply a differential to that type of thing in a value context. We in the Labour Party are saying that we believe this is a fair tax and we support it fully and unashamedly. We believe it is progressive and that it is the fairest way of trying to achieve what the Government are trying to achieve. Who can say that 1.5 per cent over £65,000 is penal? If anything it is unrealistic in what it proposes to do in terms of yielding revenue for the State. I support the Minister fully and unequivocally on that.

Comment on this

The Minister's reply on a couple of things did not satisfy me, to put it mildly. To get back to Deputy Prendergast's point, I have not heard anyone allege that this tax is likely to be penal in the sense of being objectively oppressive and excessive. I live in a very good house away above the average, in the sense the Minister intended — only by accident it is true but the House will not want to know about that. I calculate that my liability will be substantially less than I would now be paying in domestic rates if the rates system still existed. I do not object to paying that relatively small imposition. However, I want to know on what rational basis this tax is being imposed. Deputy Prendergast spoke with creamy sarcasm about the disconcerting unanimity among the lawyers on this Bill. What we are doing here is passing a piece of paper into law. If this is not a moment when the lawyers can get in, when can they get in? When might they be given a relatively clear run if not when criticising something which this House proposes to make law?

Property as such is not an issue here. There is a linguistic confusion here deriving from the fact that people talk about house property. We are dealing only with the dimension of one aspect of property, namely house property, and house property that a taxpayer himself happens to live in. If Deputy Prendergast or Deputy Taylor or anyone high or low in their party from Deputy Spring down to the man in the back room who bashed out this document seven or eight months ago——

Comment on this

We are all equal.

Comment on this

If somebody can explain to me an intelligible basis which will be immune from constitutional challenge on which this dimension of that aspect of property, generally speaking, has been singled out for taxation, then I will eat a lot of what I have been saying. I have not heard that from Deputy Prendergast or Deputy Taylor. Somebody happens to live in a house somewhat above the average — and it is not that far above the average because Deputy Doyle said here a while ago that in Dublin city a local authority dwelling is £50,000 a unit. People who are not able to afford any kind of a roof over their heads on ordinary commercial terms and look to their neighbours to supply it on ordinary social grounds or solidarity are living in houses which cost something only a spit away from the threshold which this Bill lays down.

The properties are somewhat above the average but what about people with cars better than the average or with two or three cars where others like myself, for example, run one and it is seven years old with 100,000 miles on the clock? What about that form of property? Where is the intelligible basis for distinguishing one from the other?

Comment on this

A car will diminish in value. A house is an appreciating asset.

Comment on this

House property increases in value. What about the man or woman, and the country is stiff with them, who owns not one but two, three or a string of houses?

Comment on this

I do not know many of them in my party.

Comment on this

I know very little about the people in the Deputy's party or my own for that matter. I could not tell you the personal business of my colleagues here or of most other people; but I do know because all I have to do is to go around and look at the bells on the doors in the enormous areas of the inner suburbs and the outer suburbs on which I have knocked at election time for the last 14 years. I know that colossal tracts of Dublin city are not owner occupied but are flatland. Even in the new suburbs people are buying houses as an investment and letting them out to a transient population. During the Cork by-election in 1979 I canvassed an entire privately built estate. There was scarcely an owner occupier in the place. It was very hard to find names on the register which corresponded with the people on the doorsteps. What about that form of poverty? I thought there was a whole wardrobe full of rhetoric that could be deployed against Rachmans and people profiteering on the necessity which others experience to have a roof over their heads. They are let off here.

This is like standing the wealth tax on its head. In the 1975 wealth tax which the party opposite, much to their discredit, opposed at the time and subsequently scrapped, the principal private dwelling of every person in the State was exempted. It was only when it got to the wealth a person had in addition to that that the tax began to bite. However, the crazy coons who thought this thing up want to do it the other way around. Every form of property is to be exempt, whether it be yachts, shares, horses——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair has some difficulty in recognising this as a Committee Stage speech.

Comment on this

I yield to no one in my admiration of the Ceann Comhairle and Deputy Ryan as tenants of the Chair but one minute we are running free on a fairly loose rein and the next minute we are drawn up with a rather painful start, depending on the alternating of yourself and your colleague.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair does not believe in a tight rein but neither does it believe in taking the bridle off.

Comment on this

I accept that. The whole thing has no rational basis that I have heard in the House. With regard to the section dealing with definitions, I asked the Minister if he could assist me with regard to the problem of somebody who lived in one house and owned another which he habitually let but which happened to be untenanted on 5 April. In theory, it was accessible to him to change the use, to put in a member of his family or even to live in two houses, but at the same time he might be liable for the tax. The Minister answered my worries about the definition of "occupied" by pointing to the expression "relevant residential property", meaning property in relation to which the person concerned was the owner and which was occupied by him as a dwelling. However, in order to understand what that means I have to go back to the word "occupied" in an earlier stage of the definitions section. That tells me that "occupied" means having the use of property whether actually used or not. Even within the frontiers of this fatuous legislation there must be some common ground for reason between the Minister and the rest of us. I hope he will clear up the doubt I raised, and not just by giving us an assurance that is not part of the law of the land.

With regard to the appeals by Deputy O'Kennedy and, I think, Deputy O'Malley that we should not rush through this matter and that it should be sent to a committee, I sympathise with that idea. I have a double sympathy with it when I hear Deputy O'Malley appearing to agree with me that conceivably this is constitutionally defective. In my judgment — although I may be wrong — it contains flagrant discrimination. Deputy O'Malley appealed to the House not to do something with its eyes open which it is specifically forbidden to do by Article 15. Deputy O'Kennedy pleaded for the referral of the matter to a committee. I sympathise with both points of view. It is difficult to be certain about a legal opinion. I do not think that one's view of the constitutional dimensions of the Bill, even if unfavourable, would necessarily lead one not to vote for it. The reality is that in a party, like ours, or the party across the floor of the House or, I suppose any party, one's conscience is respected but on matters on a somewhat lower plane, one has to be bound by the majority wisdom. Under that rule I consider myself bound by the majority wisdom of this party even though I profoundly disagree with it.

What will happen at the end of the day or next week, unless there is a miracle, is that the people will get a law that at least 95 per cent of the Members of the House do not want, do not see any sense in and which they think is rubbish, in the very same way that we will have a referendum about which the same could be said. I do not think there are five Deputies in the House who could genuinely explain the need for the referendum, who believe it is necessary or who could say why it is necessary. Nevertheless we will get it just the same because of the crazy way politics are organised here. We close off the most obvious option, in the way the previous Government did, doing business with Deputy Gregory and The Workers' Party and Canon Horan rather than doing business——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy is departing from the measure before the House.

Comment on this

I should like some information about the procedure from now on. At what time it is envisaged that this part of the Bill will conclude?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I am obliged to put a composite resolution at 3. p.m.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Chair would have some sympathy with this side of the House in this regard. We have some amendments down which are of substantive significance. One is to permit the deduction of the capital value of a mortgage from the value of the house for the purpose of this tax. The second is to confine the income in so far as the income limit is concerned to the income of the husband and wife and the third set of amendments is to try to have some rationale as to the value of the house from the point of view of residence. These are three broad principles we are trying to implement with a view to making the tax somewhat rational, if that is possible. From the way we are debating the amendments it appears we will not get to vote on them. Can the chair offer us any help? Will it be the position that at 3 p.m. there will be a composite vote without regard to the quality of any of the proposals?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair is anxious to facilitate Deputies in any way it can. Unfortunately the Chair's hands are tied by an order made on 24 May and confirmed yesterday by this House. The Chair has no discretion in the matter. At 3 p.m. I will put the resolution that will bring this part of the Bill to a conclusion.

Comment on this

Is there any way in which we could, for instance, isolate in advance of that composite motion amendment No. 118?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We have been debating this section since 11 p.m. yesterday. It is up to Members of the House to decide how long the House will spend on any amendment or any section. For example, the House could nod through ten or 20 amendments in a few minutes and spend the rest of the time dealing with one amendment. The Chair has no control over the matter.

Comment on this

I endeavoured earlier to nod through these technical drafting amendments.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It appears to me that when the amendments to section 84 were disposed of and when the question was put that the section, as amended, stand part of the Bill both sides were keen to have a Second Stage debate.

Comment on this

Deputy Kelly succeeded in bringing in the Constitution.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Well, he did not succeed for very long. He had a swipe at it.

Comment on this

He had a swipe at other things too.

Comment on this

I do not think this section goes far enough. I have no doubt that if various property holders want to have this declared unconstitutional it may well be possible to do so. As we have seen over the years, the Constitution very much favours property holders and the bigger they are the more it favours them. I am not an accountant or a lawyer, but I have listened to the points which were raised and most of them are related to inequities that already exist in the housing market in relation, for instance, to bridging loans. There is no doubt that that is an inequity in the system of transferring houses from one person to another. Any person, wealthy or otherwise, should not have to pay 23 per cent on bridging finance. Clearly, it affects most those who are buying houses costing about £25,000 because they cannot afford a more expensive one.

I do not think this property tax can be faulted because there are inequities in other parts of the housing market. If I am following the debate correctly, the Minister is proposing to reduce the take from what he originally proposed. The original section is now being amended by the Minister and the net effect will be to reduce the amount of tax which it is possible to take. I cannot see that anyone in all seriousness can claim that a tax of £150 per year on a family with an income in excess of £20,000 and living in a house worth more than £65,000 is a gross imposition. I do not think it is unfair.

One of the points raised in relation to it was that the income of a number of members of the family would be taken into account. The question was also asked that, if the income of a son or daughter was taken into account: who was going to pay? Presumably, the person in whose name the house is will have to pay. Again, I cannot see that that is a logical objection. There are hundreds of thousands of local authority tenants whose family income is taken into account in assessing the rent which is paid. The principal income is the largest income, whether it is that of the person who is a tenant or not. The person who is obliged to pay the rent is the tenant although it is not necessarily his income that is taken into account as the principal income in that house. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander in relation to that aspect of the Bill.

Deputy Kelly indicated that those who supported this were in some way vindictive towards people who live in large houses. I am certainly not vindictive towards anybody. It is simply a question of trying to introduce equity into our taxation code. We have spent hours upon hours debating this section and I have to draw the contrast between the time spent of this section, which is attempting to extract taxation from people who are relatively well-off, and the time that was spent on debating the 1 per cent levy which applies to everyone across the board, even those who do not earn enough to be in the tax net. It was passed with hardly a whimper.

Comment on this

We voted against it.

Comment on this

I did not see many Deputies in Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael making as strong a case as they have done against this property tax.

Comment on this

We tried to. There was not time.

Comment on this

Your party, your Chief Whip and the Chief Whips of Fine Gael and Labour set the time for the debate, so I do not accept that time was not allowed. Time could have been allowed if this House was agreeable.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy should address the Chair.

Comment on this

Deputy De Rossa is not fair in that regard. We sought to oppose it.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party sought to oppose it but there was no willingness to do so judging by the amount of time and the number of people who came in here to debate the issue.

Comment on this

That is not true.

Comment on this

There was a very strong debate in relation to farmer taxation which had ranks of Fianna Fáil people in here protesting about the inclusion of 90,000 farmers in the tax net. There was also a much less comprehensive debate with regard to widowed persons when we sought to bring in equity for them in relation to tax allowances and mortgage interest relief. The debate was over in a matter of five minutes. I could accept the concern of Deputies in regard to the inequities in the section we are discussing if they had shown at least as much concern for other elements of society who are being virtually ground into the dust under the weight of taxation. I simply want to make the point that I am among the 5 per cent or 10 per cent of the Members of this House who favour property tax.

Comment on this

I raised a number of questions.

Comment on this

I appreciate Deputy Haughey's concern in relation to proceeding with the rest of it. The questions raised by Deputy Taylor and Deputy Kelly are covered by the terms of the section as it is. If the Deputies wish to have a further discussion we can do so now, otherwise we will proceed to the next section.

Comment on this

Is it the case that a dwelling owned by a taxpayer, not inhabited by him but which happens accidentally to be vacant on 5 April, is not going to be caught by this residential property tax?

Comment on this

That is the case, yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 113:

In page 70, line 25, to delete "assessable".

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 114 in the name of Deputy De Rossa and Deputy Mac Giolla has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

Would the effect of this be that the residential property tax would be a charge on the person or on the property? If the tax is levied would the tax run with the property if the property was to change hands from one person to another?

Comment on this

No. The tax would be assessable on the assessable person. I am anxious to make it clear to the Deputy that that is the case if he is thinking of what would happen in the case of a property changing hands. If a property changes hands from one person to another then, obviously there would be a totally new situation depending on what other property the new owner would have.

Comment on this

The new owner would not carry the old liability with him?

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 115 in the names of Deputies Mac Giolla and De Rossa has been ruled out of order.

Comment on this

I should like to give notice that following, some further reflection I have had about this section, I intend to bring forward an amendment on Report Stage to clarify the position of persons resident but not domiciled here in relation to their liability to this tax.

Comment on this

We were aware of the point but we decided not to pursue it.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 116:

In page 71, subsection (1), line 20, to delete "the unencumbered fee simple of".

This is a very clear cut proposal by us to try to improve the equity of the tax. I believe that Deputy De Rossa, and Deputy Prendergast who has left the Chamber, will agree that if we are going to have the tax it should be as equitable as possible. The point has been ably expounded by Deputy O'Malley. There may be two houses with different types of title and the proposal in the Bill is that it does not matter what the title is they should both be taxed on the basis that they have perfect fee simple titles. That is grossly inequitable. I will not delay the House on this but I recommend it to the Minister, and the House, as something that is simple, plain common sense, fair play and equitable.

Comment on this

I oppose the amendment for the reasons we have already discussed. I stress that the tax in question is not one that is being charged on the total value of the property, it is not one that is being charged on the income of the person. The tax is one that is being assessed by reference to the net market value of the property. It is a tax, one might say, on the enjoyment and use of property and the level of income and the value of the property are the two parameters of assessment of the tax. For that reason I oppose the amendment.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R. Burke Fianna Fáil

The Minister mentioned the net market value of the property but surely he used a very technical way to describe the net market value if he is not taking into account any encumbrances involved.

Comment on this

It is the net market value as defined in the Bill. The point of the amendment is to take account of encumbrances of the title of the House in assessing the starting point for the calculation of the tax. Since the tax is not directly concerned with the property itself but rather with the enjoyment or the use of the property the question of whether or not there are encumbrances on it is not directly relevant.

Comment on this

What the Minister is doing is taking the phrase, pardon me for living — he intends taxing a person for living in a house. That is going a bit far.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 117:

In page 71, subsection (1), line 21, after "sold" to insert "for residential use".

I do not think we are going to get anywhere today because I do not think logic, reason or argument are of any importance today. I believe the whole process of parliamentary debate is being rendered totally nugatory by the way the Minister is treating the legislation. For those reasons I will not delay the House. In the amendment we are trying to have some semblance of rationality in this business. The Minister has just told the House that people are going to be taxed not because they have or own property but because they live in it, they enjoy the property. We are trying to confine the tax to the residential use. If we are taxing people because they live on a piece of property then they should only be taxed on it on the basis of its use as a residence, as we are trying to do in the amendment. We want to make sure that the market value of the house is looked on as a residence and from the point of view of its residential use. That is exactly in line with what the Minister said a few moments ago.

Comment on this

I am afraid I am going to discommode and surprise the Deputy by saying that I accept the amendment.

Comment on this

We have won the argument.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R. Burke Fianna Fáil

And Deputy Kelly is not present to hear that.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 118:

In page 71, subsection (1), line 23, after "property" to add "less the amount outstanding on a mortgage or home loan in respect of a principal private residence of the assessable person on the valuation date".

I should like to warn the House that we intend putting this amendment to a vote because it is crucial to the whole concept of equity.

Comment on this

It may be accepted.

Comment on this

It is crucial to the whole concept of equity in regard to this absurd tax. Deputy O'Malley, and others, have put this argument so clearly that it is irrefutable. If Deputy De Rossa must have this tax I know he will agree with us that it should be equitable. His argument is that the bringing in of this tax is equitable but once it has been brought in as a tax it should be equitable as such. That is what we are trying to do in the amendment. We are trying to equate the different taxpayers. If one person has a house worth £100,000 with a mortgage of £80,000 that person is only worth £20,000 and if another person has a house worth £100,000 and does not have a mortgage that person is worth £100,000. I do not think any system of taxation anywhere in the world would tax those two people on the same basis. In this case we are trying to say that the property shall be valued by taking into account the capital value of any mortgage outstanding on it. I should like to make the point that we are confining it to a mortgage outstanding on the principal residence. None of us has any great sympathy for those people who can afford a second residence and we are talking about the principal residence and the mortgage outstanding on it. These days it is a heavy enough burden on a householder to pay the cost of a mortgage. We suggest that that is a sufficient imposition on the householder without at the same time having that mortgage totally ignored from the point of view of this new tax.

Comment on this

I do not accept this amendment. The procedure being set out in this Bill is not, as Deputy Haughey suggested, without precedent. Up to a few years ago we had a tax which took no account of the fact that one owner of a house worth £X on a different basis had a mortgage and another person with the same kind of house worth the same amount did not have a mortgage. We did not have any adjustment for that in the rates but that is not the point.

Comment on this

The Minister is talking about rates.

Comment on this

Yes. I am making the point that it is not true to say that the kind of procedure proposed in this Bill is without precedent. I am opposing this amendment because since the tax is being imposed on the occupancy of the house, the question of the net real interest in the house is not directly relevant.

Comment on this

Surely it must be relevant because it is the value of the house which determines how much tax a person is going to pay. It might not be relevant from the point of view of the concept of the tax as a tax, but it is terribly relevant for the amount the unfortunate taxpayer will have to pay. I cannot see how the Minister can even attempt to make that case to the House because one man will pay a certain level of tax and the other will pay ten or 20 times that amount. This is relevant and should be taken into account.

Comment on this

We are talking about a tax and the use and enjoyment of a house. That is not directly affected by the question of whether a person who owns a house has a mortgage and his neighbour who owns the same kind of house does not have a mortgage.

Comment on this

The person who has the mortgage is already getting tax relief on the interest element of his mortgage repayments.

Comment on this

That did not apply to a resident of this kind.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R. Burke Fianna Fáil

This amendment highlights the ludicrous situation in which we find ourselves. Every system of taxation should be equitable, and unless this amendment is accepted, it will highlight the total hypocrisy behind the Bill. The Minister is hiding behind technical relevance, use and enjoyment.

In many parts of my constituency there are young couples, both of whom are working to pay for their mortgage on their homes valued over £65,000, and because they have a joint income above £20,000 they have to pay this residential property tax. These couples have large mortgages on their £65,000 or £70,000 houses. They are not mansions. In many cases they are four-bedroomed, semi-detached houses valued over £65,000 because of the values of the property in that area. These people are working to pay off their mortgages but there is no incentive for them to work in what the Minister is proposing. There is no equity if credit is not given when a mortgage is involved. How can the Minister tax a couple in a £70,000 house if they have a mortgage of at least £40,000? I abhor the principle behind this proposal and this amendment highlights just how inequitable this proposal is. This Bill discourages incentive and this is a classic example. In all justice the Minister should give credit for a mortgage because these couples are working day and night to buy a home of which they can be proud and to provide a proper home for their families.

I will deal later with the fact that the Minister is not confining the income to the husband and wife but is including the income of the children, because there are many anti-social aspects involved here. We have listened all morning to Deputy Kelly and Deputy Shatter ease their consciences, but when we call a vote those Deputies, together with their Fine Gael colleagues, will vote the Minister's measure through. So will The Workers Party and the Labour Party. What we are voting on today is not a measure which deals with equity; it is a cobbled version of a cobbled deal to bring the Coalition into existence. It was one of the terms of this Coalition's formation.

Comment on this

Do not forget it is on the floor of the House, not residing in the Library.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are dealing with amendment No. 118. There is an anxiety to get through as many amendments as we can, and I ask Deputies to co-operate.

Comment on this
Ray Burke Mr. R. Burke Fianna Fáil

The reality of the situation is that we will be voting on the ideological sop to the Labour Party, and despite expressions of disgust by Deputy Kelly, Deputy Shatter and others, they will vote through a totally unfair and unjust taxation system against the best interests of initiative and incentive at a time when we should be encouraging people to buy their homes and try to improve their lot. All we are doing is bringing in a totally unjust and inequitable taxation system. Deputy De Rossa would be in favour of an equitable taxation system, but even he and his party could not under any circumstances say that this measure, which will not give credit for a mortgage, is equitable.

Comment on this

I want to recall all the arguments made on this side of the House this morning. I have had the advantage of having my lunch but the Minister did not and I am pleased to note that we seem to have had one amendment accepted, but that was not the main issue on which we argued this morning. Our discussion was to treat all properties as if they were unencumbered fee simple. If there is one thing that stands out from the others which should be taken into account, it is the situation where a person has a mortgage of up to 80 per cent or 90 per cent of the value of the property. The Minister said this was not relevant. He seemed to say that whether a person had a mortgage or owned it in fee simple made no difference. Of course it makes a great difference. A person becomes liable to the income related property tax because of the value of the house, and the amount he pays is determined by the excess over £65,000. The difference between a person who owns his house and a person who has a 90 per cent mortgage must be clear to the Minister because there is a vast difference between them. He does not have the same right or the same clear title to the property, or the same basic ownership to the property, as the other.

Comment on this

He has the same enjoyment and use of the property.

Comment on this

That is a different matter altogether.

Comment on this

Do you really enjoy your property if you have to pay an enormous amount of money every month in mortgages?

Comment on this

I want to remind the Minister of the title of the proposed tax, but perhaps it was Deputy Taylor and his colleagues who thought it up. It is an income-related property tax. It is an income tax related to property. There is no question about that. It is a hybrid, of course. The Minister must recognise that the person who has to make mortgage repayments will not have the same income capacity to pay this tax, if his house exceeds £65,000 in value, as the person who has no deduction in respect of mortgage on the property. Whether in terms of equity or otherwise, he is not on a par, in terms of an income-related property tax as the other person is. Clearly the two are very different from each other. One could give many examples but the Minister does not require us to do that at this stage. We could quote figures of one person whose income was £30,000 with a property valued at £70,000 unencumbered. He is much better off than the person with £21,000 income and a £90,000 property encumbered with a mortgage. The Minister knows that.

If one is going to introduce a tax of this nature and is concerned about equity, this flies totally in the face of equity, as also does the Minister's refusal to accept our previous amendment on the unencumbered fee simple. The Minister does not require us to prove to him by any of a variety of examples that a person who escapes a liability or has a very low liability could be much better off than a person with a heavy mortgage on a house which might be notionally more valuable and with an income just above £20,000. That is one reality.

The second reality is that when one is talking about mortgaged as distinct from unmortgaged houses, one is talking by and large of married couples. We have spent a long time arguing all the principles and reasons and nothing that I heard before the lunch adjournment answered in any way the cogent arguments made from all around this House. I do not suppose that I will hear any reasonable reply now. If the Minister says in relation to this crazy tax and the manner in which he has developed it that we cannot correct it, let it be known as the Dukes' equity. The public will see it as being a better example of a Dukes' inequity.

Comment on this

I speak in support of this amendment, which is asking a minimum. It is obvious that the Minister should accede to it. I have taken some time to try to understand the resistance to this amendment. It is quite obvious that the resistance is due to the huge number of people involved. Of the 150,000 mortgage-holders operating on an average figure of about £25,000, one-third of that figure are young couples who have married and are both earning, perhaps for the first few years of marriage. Real revenue will accrue from that hard-hit sector and hence the resistance. If that is not the reason for it — it is not? I am very pleased to hear that from the Minister. Having heard that it is not——

Comment on this

I am saying they are not necessarily the people who will be paying the tax.

Comment on this

I have pointed out to the Minister a very valid argument for supporting Deputy O'Kennedy's reason for accepting the amendment.

How can the Minister's Department equip itself with an army of valuers to value homes for which private individuals cannot possibly be expected to strike market values? That is ridiculous. If a home is possessed by poltergeists, who will determine its value? The section says that striking the market value cannot be done by self-assessment, that one must engage professional valuers and that will cost the private individual more — that is, unless the Minister has in his Department a sea of valuers readily available to do this work. How many valuers are available at the moment in the Department?

Comment on this

I find myself in agreement with Deputy O'Kennedy when he described this section as a minor ideological irritant, although it could turn out to be a somewhat major ideological irritant. I want to raise a few brief queries with the Minister on section 88.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

We are now on the amendment.

Comment on this

This relates to the amendment with regard to the allowances for the mortgage. Subsection (3) states that any charge to tax shall be made by reference to the market value estimated by the inspector and not by reference to the market value estimated by the person. Would the Minister please tell me the exact appeal procedure against that? I am sure that it is spelt out in the Bill, but cannot find it. It is specific and appears to suggest that there are very little grounds for challenging or overturning that valuation. Perhaps the Minister might deal with that query in reply.

Another part of section 88 touches on our amendment:

if sold in the open market on the valuation date in such manner and subject to such conditions as might reasonably be calculated to obtain for the vendor the best price for the property.

Why should the Revenue Commissioners be entitled to take the best view of a sale of a property? Why would they not, as everybody in this time of recession, take the worst view? Why write into our legislation that the Revenue Commissioners shall take the best price for the property? That is a luxury which nobody else has in this economy. If the Revenue Commissioners were the sellers, perhaps they might not take the brighter view of things. If the person sells the property a couple of months later and does not get that best price, will the sales prices be deemed to have been the value a month earlier and will the money be refunded?

Comment on this

No, it will not.

Comment on this

It is nonsense to put such a phrase into legislation in the present recession. Does the best price imply that the House is painted, the grass cut, the photographs which the auctioneer has look good? That section should be taken out of this Bill pretty quickly.

In regard to our own amendment, the whole principle of our taxation must be based on what people have as disposable income, what they have left after they have paid their bills. Any Minister for Finance with any human touch would not look at gross incomes these days. He would be looking at the take-home pay. One cannot look at disposable income without looking at the greatest single expense. Let him look at his household budget and at his surveys. The biggest single item of expense for anybody is his or her house mortgage. Yet he has chosen to ignore in this legislation that that is the situation. After paying a substantial mortgage there might be no disposable income left and in that case the Minister would be talking about taxing a mythical figure. Section 88 is designed as are other sections to give the Revenue Commissioners the inside track in everything. It is a provision that should be removed now from the Bill.

Has the Minister any view as to the rights of building societies in this matter? Let us suppose that a solicitor is trying to sell a house for a client. If the debt has not been cleared on the house in terms of property tax, can the solicitor sell the property openly and honestly without regard to whatever tax has built up on it? The Minister will probably give the answer that this is an individual tax but I want that put clearly. My main objection relates to the question of the best value of the property on the open market. If the Minister is not prepared to accept the amendment in the name of Deputy O'Kennedy, he is saying that he is not taking any account of the biggest single item in household budgets. In bringing legislation before the House the Minister should think in terms of a person's disposable income. It is irrelevant to talk about gross incomes. If the Minister has regard to his own disposable income compared with his gross income he will find that there is a big difference. Disposable income is what people have to spend and not some mythical figure referred to as gross. The next generation will not even know what gross means because there will be such a difference between that and disposable income.

Comment on this

This appears to be a reasonable amendment in relation to mortgages but it would probably create a few problems and perhaps a further outlet. What we have here is a very complicated piece of legislation for what should be a simple tax. About 12 months ago we endeavoured to cost the suggested tax on second houses which are becoming a common feature in our society but the Department of Finance said it was not possible to do so because they had no information or no method of collecting the information in regard to second, third or subsequent houses and that the only type of property tax they could suggest would be a tax on houses valued at £50,000 or £60,000. We were not talking then about the type of tax proposed here. We were talking about a property tax on houses other than on main residences. Apparently that is not feasible because there is no way of collecting information in that connection. Here we have the position of a tax on the main residence, that is, where a person both owns and occupies the property.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

There is a net point in this amendment and I should like the Deputy to keep to that point. If we reach the section before 3 o'clock, the Deputy may speak to it then.

Comment on this

The point is that if mortgages are exempted from the tax or are related to it this leaves an escape clause for a person to take out a mortgage and purchase another property and let it without having to pay the tax on it. The new house would be free of tax because of there being a mortgage involved. This opens up a new escape clause. There appears to be justification for the tax but at the same time there is the question of income limits and also the offsetting of interest against tax. To pass the amendment would leave a further escape clause for those people who should be taxed more. We could deal with the situation by imposing a tax on second or subsequent houses.

Comment on this

There is a tax on those.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan asked some specific questions. First, he asked in relation to subsection (1), whether it was reasonable to assess the value of the property on the basis of the best price that might be obtained for it. There are two points in that connection. We already have an amendment down to that subsection in which we are using a definition of the market value of property that is enshrined in other legislation in relation to capital taxes.

Regarding subsection (3) this operates if the inspector is not satisfied with the estimated market value of any property as returned by an individual. Therefore, this would not apply to all of the cases. We will be asking people to provide a self-assessed value of the property and subsection (3) will apply only in the event of an inspector taking the view that the value supplied is not correct. I would refer Deputy Brennan to amendment No. 164 which introduces an appeals system so far as the valuation of property is concerned.

Comment on this

I asked the Minister how many valuers there are in the Valuation Office?

Comment on this

There are approximately 40 but it would not be the case that every property in respect of which tax would fall to be paid would have to be valued. That is why we are providing for self-assessment.

Comment on this

These valuers estimate the values from their desks mostly.

Comment on this

A Cheann Comhairle, may I remind Deputies that they are now voting on an issue as to whether——

Comment on this
Division

The Committee divided: Tá,

Tá 64
·
Níl 74
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Nuala Fennell Minister of State at the Department of the Taoiseach (Mr. Barrett Fine Gael

, Dún Laoghaire): It has been agreed to extend the time for dealing with those sections to 4 o'clock.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Does that mean it is proposed to introduce an omnibus motion at 4 o'clock to conclude the Committee Stage?

Comment on this

(Dún Laoghaire): Yes.

Comment on this

We appreciate that.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 119 in the name of the Minister, amendment No. 121 and amendment No. 123 are related. The three amendments will be discussed together by agreement.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 119:

In page 71, lines 31 to 38, to delete subsection (3) and substitute the following subsection:—

"(3) If the Commissioners are not satisfied with the market value of any property estimated by any person, or if they consider it necessary to do so, they may, subject to the same conditions and requirements as apply in the case of that person, estimate the market value of that property and, where the market value as so estimated by the Commissioners exceeds the market value estimated by the person, any charge to tax shall be made by reference to the market value estimated by the Commissioners and not by reference to the market value estimated by the person."

Those three amendments have to do with the fact that we are amending the text of the Bill to provide that the Revenue Commissioners will administer this tax through their capital tax branch. These amendments are consequential on that particular change.

Comment on this

The Minister might tell us a little more. It is nice to know that the Revenue Commissioners are dealing with it through one branch or another. We have been reading through those amendments, Nos. 119, 121 and 123 at great length without seeing precisely the impact of what the Minister is saying. If it is purely administrative that the Revenue Commissioners will deal with it through their capital taxation branch as distinct from some other branch, if that is the case I cannot see any reason for these amendments. Perhaps the Minister would explain it a little further in layman's terms because the amendments are very detailed.

Comment on this

We referred to this earlier in connection with amendment No. 93. In each case we are taking out the reference to inspector and all the pronouns associated therewith and making the reference in each case to the commissioners rather than to an inspector.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 120:

In page 71, subsection (3), to delete lines 35 to 38.

This amendment deletes lines 35 to 38 of subsection (3) in page 71.

Comment on this

Our amendment must have got mistyped.

Comment on this

Perhaps I could help the Deputy. My understanding of the amendment is that we would delete from subsection (3) of section 88 the words "and, where the market value as so estimated by the inspector exceeds the market value estimated by the person, any charge to tax shall be made by reference to the market value estimated by the inspector and not by reference to the market value estimated by the person". Those are lines 35 to 38 of that subsection. The intention of the provisions of this Bill is that as far as possible the tax should be paid by self-assessment based on the valuation of the property carried out by the assessable person. Nevertheless, we have to recognise that there will be cases where the assessable person under-estimates the value of the property. Section 88 (3) empowers the Revenue Commissioners to substitute their own estimate of the market value. Those are the words proposed to be deleted.

I want to make the point, for the reassurance of the Deputies opposite, that the assessable person will have a right of appeal if he is dissatisfied with the assessment made on the basis of the Revenue Commissioner's valuation. That is provided for by amendment No. 164.

Comment on this

Since our amendment was put down the Minister has, in fact, amended the section we were proposing to amend and, on that basis, we will withdraw our amendment.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendment No. 121 has been taken with amendment No. 119.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 121:

In page 71, lines 39 to 45, to delete subsection (4), and substitute the following subsection:

"(4) The market value of any property for the purposes of subsection (3) or section 94 (2) shall be ascertained by the Commissioners in such manner and by such means as they think fit and they may authorise a person to inspect any property and report to them the value thereof for the purposes of this Part and the person having the custody or possession of that property shall permit the person so authorised to inspect it at such reasonable times as the Commissioners consider necessary.".

Comment on this

On amendment No. 121——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It has been discussed already with amendment No. 119.

Comment on this

So it is now out of order to query anything on it?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

It is not in order to discuss it now.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 122:

In page 71, subsection (4), lines 40 and 41, to delete "in such manner and by such means as he thinks fit and he may authorise" and substitute "by authorising".

The purpose of this amendment is to ensure that you do have a properly authorised and qualified valuer to deal with the property, as distinct from what can happen under the existing provisions of subsection (4) of section 88 which says:

The market value of any property for the purposes of subsection (3) or section 94 (2) shall be ascertained by the inspector in such manner and by such means as he thinks fit and he may authorise a person to inspect any property and report to him the value thereof for the purposes of this Part and the person having the custody or possession of that property shall permit the person so authorised to inspect it at such reasonable times as the inspector considers necessary.

The important words being "in such manner and by such means as he thinks fit and he may authorise a person to inspect any property...." We propose to delete those words by simply saying "by authorising", which would leave the appropriate part of the subsection reading: "... shall be ascertained by the inspector by authorising a person to inspect any property and report to him the value thereof for the purposes of this Part...." As the subsection stands at present it is much too vague, loose; there is no way of knowing how the valuation process will be undertaken by the use of the words "in such manner and by such means as he thinks fit". If, on the other hand, he has to authorise, as would be the consequence of our amendment being adopted, a valuer from the branch that the Minister has said will be involved in this, then what the Minister is hoping to achieve, and as far as our amendment is concerned, would be quite the same. I cannot see why anyone should insert anything as vague or loose as the terminology that is there. The Minister has said that the intention is that this will be dealt with by the Valuation Office.

Comment on this

That is not so.

Comment on this

The valuation of the property — well, it is self-assessment in the first instance. But, in terms of the application of this, which section of the Revenue Commissioners will be dealing with it?

Comment on this

Capital taxes.

Comment on this

Who will be advising them in terms of valuation?

Comment on this

It is up to the Revenue Commissioners to decide.

Comment on this

It could be any person who has any experience, or no experience——

Comment on this

——or any means.

Comment on this

For any purpose, for any means——

Comment on this

Think of a number.

Comment on this

Surely the Minister does not want that to happen. There is a specific section in the Revenue Commissioners who have the qualifications, though not always the time. I might say in passing that one of the great risks is that what has become a practice, even up to now because of a lack of adequate staff and facilities in the Valuation Office, will become an even more widespread practice, that is the practice of desk valuations. Anybody who has known anything about that section of the Revenue Commissioners, who has served as Minister for Finance, will know that that is a widespread practice even at present. I should say quite clearly I am not making any criticism of the staff there, quite the opposite, but, even the most highly competent professional staff cannot be expected to make valuations from their desks. I would prefer at least that those people who are the qualified people would be those who would be concerned. If the Minister does not accept our amendment it can be any officer, anywhere in the Revenue Commissioners, who puts a valuation on property here. Heavens above, that is going too far. Surely, if the person making the self-assessment presents a valuation which is reported by a duly qualified, authorised valuer, he is entitled to balance on the other side and not have anybody, in any manner, in such way as the inspector thinks fit putting a figure on it which could make him liable to a significant overpayment for the time being? And remember if he does overpay he will not get his interest back. That is unreasonable and I hope the Minister sees that it is.

Comment on this

I appreciate the point made by Deputy O'Kennedy, but with respect, I would say that his amendment does not appear to cover the case he is making. The text, as amended, says that the inspector shall, "in such manner and by such means as he thinks fit and he may authorise a person...". What the Deputy's amendment would require me to put in is that the market value shall be ascertained by the Revenue Commissioners by authorising a person to inspect.

Comment on this

Well, we could say "a duly authorised person", if you like.

Comment on this

The difference is that you are leaving out the words "in such manner and by such means" which I would consider would be appropriate in order to allow of the proper flexibility and proper response to each problem. The person in question, in either the Deputy's text, as he proposes it, or in mine, can be a qualified person who does not necessarily have to be from the Valuation Office. I am also anxious to make allowance for cases in which the matter can be dealt with otherwise than by sending a person, whoever that person might be, to value the property.

I might reiterate that we have provided, in amendment 164, for a procedure of appeal against the valuation, so that there is an appeal against the valuation and an appeal against the assessment.

Comment on this

Might I make two brief points — we have matters of more significance to deal with — first of all, it is not surprising, as I said this morning at the very beginning, that because the Minister has introduced amendments to the very Bill he introduced a while ago, while we were arguing all during the week, amendments that we have not had an opportunity of looking at until this morning, the amendments we put down before his amendments came in obviously, are in a sense, not now quite to the point, as much as they were when the original Bill was introduced. That is a further illustration of the ridiculous position in which we all find ourselves here, having to deal with a new tax of this nature without even having the time to consider amendments that came in here while we were speaking into the late hours of last evening and the previous evening, with no opportunity whatsoever to examine the impact of the Minister's new amendments. I want to protest about that again. We are being forced to do it and we must live under that constraint. I hope the public will forgive us for not doing the job as well as we should.

That said, the Minister, in view of the changes he has made, if he finds that my words do not quite fit the case, I will be quite ready to say: all right, I am not wed to these words. We are agreed, I think, that it will be a properly qualified person. If the Minister was prepared to tell me now that he is willing to look at a form of words — after all he has more facilities available to him and perhaps more time over the weekend than we will have acting on our own individually — then I would be quite prepared to say: right, I will not press this. The Minister has available to him all the services of the Revenue Commissioners and the legal draftsmen who perhaps have not been working until midnight every night over the last week, and who might have an opportunity of looking at this to ensure that it will be a properly qualified person who values a property.

Comment on this

I might make a point for the comfort of Deputy O'Kennedy. The text I have here is similar to the corresponding text in the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act. Obviously it would be a concern of the Revenue Commissioners to have the valuations carried out in a proper manner. What I am concerned to do is to allow them some flexibility, so that the operation can be carried out in the most convenient manner possible. We have added in, with amendment 164, a further safeguard that there is provision for an appeal in this connection.

Comment on this

Apart from the absurdity of attempting to patch together any kind of repairs on this Part, I must say, that apart from that, I am very much on the Minister's side in this regard. I do not think the expression "by such means as he thinks fit" could be construed, these days, as conferring an unlimited discretion on the Revenue Commissioners to behave unreasonably or arbitrarily. On the contrary, the whole thrust of the way the courts have interpreted an expression of this kind in recent years has been to the effect that the Revenue Commissioners, in making use of these powers, must behave reasonably and within the frontiers of what is objectively related to the purpose of the Act. In this case, that is visible from subsection (1), where they have got to try to reach this valuation by a route which will bring them to the market value of the property — admittedly calculated in a particular way. Any route which is not calculated to bring them to that result, which arbitrarily envisages, as Deputy O'Kennedy said, a desk valuation or something like that, I believe would be quite out of court even though not specifically ruled out here. I think his apprehensions in this regard are somewhat unfounded.

Comment on this

This section is unsatisfactory and the amendment has not quite grasped the problem. The phrase "in such manner and by such means as he thinks fit" is too vague. I might be accused of paranoia about the tax people if I were to suggest that the Revenue Commissioners could appoint an inspector of taxes instead of a valuer who would call to the house in order to value it or adopt any other means such as talking to the neighbours or interviewing people. He might decide when calling to the house to make some other notes as to various items of wealth in the establishment. The section leaves open the possibility of a direct visit by an inspector in order to assess the value of the house and he might do a little survey as well. Perhaps I am being unduly sensitive but both the amendment and the section are far too woolly.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that amendments have already been made by the Minister, this is one case where we will just have to hope for the bona fides of both the Minister and his officers. I will not press this amendment.

Comment on this

There is a similar provision already in force in the capital acquisitions tax which has the same wording.

Comment on this

We have argued that point on other issues and I do not think the analogy holds.

Comment on this

Certainly the analogy holds. They are assessing the market value of a property. The commissioners will also have other means of ascertaining the market value of a property in that they will have information on sales in the open market of similar properties. The appeals provision is built in.

Comment on this
Joseph Doyle Mr. J. Doyle Fine Gael

I and some of my constituents share the opinion expressed by Deputy Brennan of the view an income tax inspector might take if he visited a property. However, it can be assessed in a different way without visiting the property. The emphasis should be put on that kind of assessment.

Comment on this

I am concerned to leave open that possibility.

Comment on this
Joseph Doyle Mr. J. Doyle Fine Gael

It is very important.

Comment on this

Could the person visiting the house be a tax inspector?

Comment on this

It could.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 123:

In page 71, lines 46 to 48, to delete subsection (5) and substitute the following subsection:

"(5) Where the Commissioners require a valuation to be made by a person named by them, the costs of such valuation shall be defrayed by them.".

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 124:

In page 71, subsection (5), line 48, after "Commissioners" to insert "and if agreed by the assessable person this valuation shall be final and conclusive, provided however if the valuation of the person authorised by the inspector is less than the valuation of the assessable person, the excess tax paid shall be repaid forthwith to the assessable person with interest at 1.25 per cent. per month or part of a month from the date of payment to the date of repayment.".

This amendment is designed to make provision for the repayment of interest in certain circumstances. Some people will be so anxious to ensure between now and October that there is no risk of being penalised that they will over-estimate their valuations. We feel that if there is a difference, in such exceptional cases, between the valuation made by the authorised officer of the Commissioners and that given by the assessable person, then that person should be entitled to the repayment of interest when it transpires that his liability should be less. This is to balance the fact that the Commissioners become entitled to interest payments on amounts in excess of the owner's assessment.

Comment on this

On a point of order, at what time is the question to be put?

Comment on this
John J. Ryan An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

At 4 o'clock.

Comment on this

There appear to be two effects which are desired in this amendment. The first point is that if the commissioners value a property and the assessable person agrees, this should be regarded as final and conclusive. Secondly, if the commissioners have a property valued and conclude that the value is lower than that set by the assessed person, an appropriate refund of tax and interest should be made. As far as the first proposal is concerned, one does not know how many properties will fall to be valued annually and it might not be possible for the Revenue Commissioners to have every case fully investigated every year. There will also be cases where people will under-value their properties. It would be desirable that the Revenue Commissioners would have a certain latitude or discretion in this matter of agreeing valuations. For that reason I would be inclined to resist the first objective of the amendment but I would also draw attention to the fact that we have provided for an appeals procedure so there is a protection against what might be considered unreasonable behaviour on the part of the Revenue Commissioners. The second point covering a refund of tax and interest in the case where the valuation would be found to be lower than that stated by the assessable person is provided for in section 97.

Comment on this

Will such refunds be made?

Comment on this

It is provided for in section 97.

Comment on this

Let us deal with the first part. Surely it is reasonable to suggest that if the inspector requires a valuation to be made by a person named by him and if that valuation is agreed by the assessable person, the valuation should be final and conclusive. There must be some degree of finality and the next amendment deals with this matter of finality in regard to a different issue. If one person agrees with another on the basis of an offer, proposal or value, then there is an agreement and it is final and conclusive. If the officer of the Revenue Commissioners sets a certain valuation and the citizens accepts that value, it is essential that it should be final and complete. We are moving into new territory here so there really must be a principle involved when a person does what he is asked to do, meets the bill as presented to him and does all required of him. In those circumstances he should not run the risk of being open to a further charge in respect of something he has agreed on. It is as simple as that and it is a retrograde step on the part of the Minister to reject that principle. I do not know on what basis he does it. He says he does not want to have his hands tied. Remember, it is the Revenue Commissioners who will put the value on this and the citizens will be required to agree and pay up. I do not see why it should not be final and conclusive. I do not know what other reserved powers they would want after that. Otherwise there is no advantage at all in coming to an agreement with anybody. That is why I was anxious it should be a properly qualified person. I presume it will not be somebody on the sixth floor in Government Buildings who will send someone out to examine the situation. I presume there will be higher standards than that. Assuming they apply proper standards and come to a value and the citizens accept that, surely then that should be final and conclusive. There should be no qualification about it. The citizen too has his rights.

Comment on this

Here we are right into the question of arbitration on the acceptance of a particular valuation. Very definitely a slur is being cast on the association of surveyors and valuers. I am just wondering is this a safeguard because the Minister will not have confidence in his own valuation. If the value is agreed it should be axiomatic. Why not just accept it? Why involve the person in more expense? This underlines the fact that again this section is unworkable from a practical point of view.

Comment on this

I understand the concern of the Deputies on the other side but I would like to make the point that this cuts both ways. We have a similar provision to this in the Capital Acquisition Tax Act.

Comment on this

I am hearing that argument all the time. I want the Minister to read the similar provision.

Comment on this

I shall do that although it is not at all relevant to the substance of my point. Subsection (3) of section 15 of the Capital Acquisition Tax Act, 1975, reads:

The market value of any property shall be ascertained by the Commissioners in such manner and by such means as they think fit and they may also authorise a person to inspect any property and report to them the value thereof for the purposes of this Act and the person having the custody or possession of that property shall permit the person so authorised to inspect it at such reasonable times as the Commissioners consider necessary.

The valuation of the property is carried out.

Comment on this

It is the next subsection I am talking about, not that one. I want the words added to the next subsection. The Minister will not get away with this. He is misleading the House.

Comment on this

If anyone is misleading the House it is Deputy O'Kennedy because he has not the patience to wait and listen to my point.

Comment on this

The amendment is not made to that subsection.

Comment on this

The valuations are made for the purposes of the Capital Acquisition Tax Act. Where it happens that the valuation turns out to be lower than the one suggested after the application of this procedure the Revenue Commissioners accept the lower valuation. I want to allow flexibility here to do that. Again, should it happen in any year that a large number of valuations have to be carried out and it would not be possible to have all the applications properly examined the Revenue Commissioners would not be tied down, kicking for touch and going for the higher valuation if on a full examination they could accept a lower valuation.

Comment on this

Quietly and calmly I want to deal with this point. The Minister said the words were identical. He read this subsection but it was not the subsection that is involved here. Our amendment is to subsection (5).

Comment on this

The Deputy wants to split words. I was making the point about the system of valuation.

Comment on this

I am talking about the precise words. We are dealing with a provision giving power to the Revenue Commissioners and protecting the rights at the same time of the individual citizen. We have no control at all over the system. What we do here may not affect the way things are done. The system is an entirely different matter. Our role is to make the law and let those who apply the system know the law. Subsection (5) of this section does not exist in the Capital Acquisition Tax Act. That is what we are proposing to amend for the good and sufficient reasons I have already given here so that where the inspector requires a valuation to be made by a person named by him——

Comment on this

For the information of the Deputy, what he has just said about subsection (5) is not true. Subsection (4) reads:

Where the Commissioners require a valuation to be made by a person named by them the cost of such valuation shall be defrayed by the Commissioners.

When you look at subsection (5) of this section and take account of the amendment we have already made, where we have substituted "Commissioners" for "inspector", it is exactly the same thing. I am going along the same line as the Deputy here. The result that that produces in the operation of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Act is as I described and is a result which I would wish to be produced in relation to the operation of this Bill.

Comment on this

What will happen in the event of it not being possible to sell a house, of there being no market for it? What value would be struck in that event? We all know that at present there are a number of houses coming into that category. How will they be valued? Will it be a notional assessment done by the inspector? If a value has been determined and then the value falls will it be possible to get a new valuation?

Comment on this

The elements that would be taken into account in making the valuation should, since it is my intention that we should keep the text of the Bill in a way that would allow us to do it, take account of factors such as the factor that at a given price a particular kind of house proves to be unsaleable. That is clearly something that will have to be taken into account in assessing valuation, preferably by the assessable person making his own return, but then by the person nominated by the commissioners in the event that that situation arose.

Comment on this

So it has to be notional?

Comment on this

Of course it has to be notional because we are not going to require everybody to sell his house in order to collect this tax.

Comment on this

There are houses at present the value of which has fallen very substantially and they cannot be sold even at the lower value.

Comment on this

It would be a question of assessing what the market value of the property is. If it happens that a given size of house in a given area has proved for a couple of months to be unsaleable at the price of £72,000 obviously that figure does not represent the market value of the house.

With regard to the second question as to what would be the situation if house values are falling, it is for that that we have an appeals system which provides that, for example, if in the first year of the operation of the tax an assessable person were to declare the value of his house to be, say, £70,000 and in the second year of operation of the tax he found that taking all the factors into consideration that kind of house would not fetch £70,000 but might go for £62,000, he would return £62,000 as the value of the house. It would be up to the commissioners then to decide whether or not they accepted that. If they decided to contest it obviously what was happening in the market would be a factor to be taken into account and in any case at that point the appeal procedure would be open to the assessable person.

Comment on this

I am most unhappy about this appeals procedure. The Bill reads:

...reference to the market value estimated by the inspector and not by reference to the market value estimated by the person.

I know there is an appeal procedure but I assume it is similar to the procedure in the ordinary taxation cases. If it is, it means going before appeal commissioners. If it means that, who will pay the cost of taking that case to the appeal commissioners? Will the State bear the cost or will the person bear the cost? I know the ordinary procedure is that the person pays the cost, but there is one difference. At present most of the people who appeal are in business and it is in the nature of their business to have to deal with tax queries and to an extent they have funds available to do that. The average householder will not have a budget to take on the appeals commissioners and to pay for professional advice because one would not dream these days of taking on the Revenue Commissioners without professional advice. I see an additional cost to the householder in appealing this tax. Could the Minister tell me how much it will cost? I heard people last night throwing around figures like £150 or £500 but if one has to go to appeal on top of that because the Revenue Commissioners are not satisfied one is into fees which might be more than the tax.

Is the Minister conscious of what he is starting here? I can see a new market opening up. In a few months time the advertisements in the property page will say: "House for sale, valued by the Revenue Commissioners at £85,000." They may even put in a phone number so that you can ring your friendly Revenue Commissioner to check if it is worth £85,000. The Minister is starting a field day for auctioneers and valuers.

Comment on this

I wish Deputies on that side of the House would look at what is happening in terms of the operation of similar legislation. Deputy O'Kennedy knows this very well, perhaps better than Deputy Brennan would. Deputy O'Kennedy and I represent rural constituencies and we frequently come across cases where estates, farms and properties are being valued by the Revenue Commissioners for capital acquisitions tax purposes. I have never seen in any newspaper — the Nenagh Guardian, the Leinster Leader or The Nationalist, a property advertised for sale with a byline underneath saying: “Valued at £X by the Revenue Commissioners”.

Comment on this

I will bring it back to the Minister in six months.

Comment on this

If the Deputy makes his case on that basis he cannot expect to be taken seriously. As to the cost of appeals, amendment 164 sets out the appeal procedure. Normally each party pays his own costs. It is in order to avoid a situation where we would get a substantial number going to appeal that I want the procedure before that to be as flexible as possible so that we do not have to get into appeals.

Comment on this

The taxpayer pays his own costs?

Comment on this

In the event that it comes to an appeal.

Comment on this

It is not our role here to get involved in administration matters. What we are dealing with is the legislation. We could spend weeks on end discussing how the Revenue Commissioners do their business. We are pressing our amendment for two reasons. First, it is important to maintain the balance between the citizen and the Revenue Commissioners. If the Revenue Commissioners put a value on the property and the citizen agrees, he should not run the risk that it might not be final. The Minister keeps giving the analogy of the capital acquisitions tax and this tax. As I have indicated on many occasions today, there is no such analogy. In one case there is a change of ownership but in this case it remains in the same ownership. The person is not selling or disposing and there is no effective date.

Comment on this

I was talking about a valuation date. For the operation of the capital acquisitions tax a valuation date is fixed and for the operation of this income-related property tax a valuation date will be fixed. In both cases it is a matter of putting a value on a specified piece of property. They are both similar in that respect. Of course a transfer will not take place in this case. In relation to capital acquisitions tax, frequently we are in the business of valuing a property where no commercial transaction was taking place from one person to another or from one generation to another. I make the point that the experience of previous similar legislation is a reasonable guide.

Comment on this

The Minister has not satisfied the House regarding the criteria for any proposed valuations from his Department. Anyone trying to sell a house on the open market will be told by the auctioneer that the market is so volatile that the property has to be put to auction. It cannot be done in any other way at the moment. I see this as totally unworkable. The market varies from month to month and there is no way to determine a valuation.

Comment on this

All the circumstances referred to by Deputy Brady are met year in and year out in one county after another in the operation of the capital acquisitions tax. In the period it has been in operation, since 1975, some 15 cases have been referred to the property arbitrator. In most cases we would be talking about property valuations considerably in excess of the valuations we are talking about here and about tax liabilities very much in excess of what we are talking about here.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 125:

In page 71, between lines 48 and 49 to insert the following subsections:

"(6) If, however the inspector does not express dissatisfaction with the valuation of the assessable person within one year of its submission and does not disprove it within a period of two years from its submission it shall be final and conclusive and shall only be increased on subsequent valuation dates by reference to Trends in Private New House Prices Index Number.

(7) On any future disposal of taxable residential property no account, in respect of any valuation date, shall be taken for the purposes of this Part in respect of disposal proceeds unless the property is being disposed of for residential use by the purchaser.".

This amendment is introduced to ensure that after two years a person can be satisfied that the Revenue Commissioners will not come back to him after the valuation has been determined. The Minister has already accepted the principle of the new subsection (7) in the only amendment he has accepted in the whole Bill. Subsection (6) is important. The inspector has a year to accept or otherwise the assessment put forward. We ask that if he does not disprove the assessment within two years it should be final and conclusive. Two years will give the Revenue Commissioners quite a long time. Surely the citizen is entitled to assume that they will not come back to him after three or four years after somebody else has sold a similar property and say that he underestimated the value of his property. Account should be taken of the principles of justice and equity. The Minister has accepted our proposal in respect of residential use and he should be in a position to accept this amendment.

Comment on this

The arguments with regard to subsection (6) are similar to those we have been through earlier. So far as subsection (7) is concerned, I have accepted the wording in relation to disposal for residential use in a different connection but that is not really the point at issue here. Based on the arguments we have had with regard to the previous amendment, I have to say I cannot support this amendment.

Comment on this

Because of the impossible position in which we find ourselves due to the ridiculous time constraint, I will have to leave it at that. The Minister has rejected two fundamental principles. We have raised the case of an honest taxpayer who wants to discharge his responsibility and who wants to be sure that if objections have not been raised after two years that the matter is finalised but the Minister has rejected that. He is also rejecting the principle that would eliminate an excessive value being placed because of a change of use after the date.

If that is the Minister's attitude, so be it. I insist that our amendment be pressed.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 126:

In page 72, before section 90, to insert the following new section.

90.—(1) In this section—

`general exemption limit' means the general market value exemption limit applying on a valuation date, that is to say, the amount obtained by multiplying £65,000 by the new house price index number relevant to that valuation date and dividing the product by the new house price index number relevant to the valuation date falling on the 5th day of April, 1983;

`market value exemption limit', in relation to an assessable person as respects a valuation date, means the amount of the aggregate of the unit exemption limits attributed to the units of residential property comprised in the relevant residential property of the assessable person on that valuation date;

`the new house price index number' means the Trends in Private New House Prices Index Number compiled by the Department of the Environment and the new house price index number relevant to any valuation date means the new house price index number for the three months ended on the 31st day of March next before that valuation date expressed on the basis that the new house price index number for the three months ended on the 31st day of March, 1973, is 100.

`unit exemption limit', in relation to a valuation date, means the proportion of the general exemption limit in relation to that valuation date which is attributed to a unit of residential property, and shall be the amount determined by the formula—

A x G

———

B

where—

A is the market value (ascertained without regard to section 89) on the valuation date of the unit of residential property.

B is the aggregate of the market values (ascertained without regard to section 89) on the valuation date of all the units comprised in the relevant residential property of the assessable person.

G is the general exemption limit:

Provided that, in relation to a valuation date, where a unit of residential property is comprised in the relevant residential property of two or more persons, the unit exemption limit in relation to that unit of residential property in the case of the assessable person shall be reduced to the amount which bears to the unit exemption limit calculated without regard to this proviso the same proportion as one bears to the number of those persons.

(2) The amount of the market value exemption limit applying on a valuation date in the case of any person shall not exceed the general exemption limit applying on that date.".

This new section is concerned with setting the market value exemption limit. The tax that we are providing for here is charged on the net market value of the property which is arrived at by deducting from the gross market value an amount known as the market value exemption limit, which is what this section defines. Normally this would be £65,000 with provision for adjustment in future years by reference to the new house price index number. However, where a property is owned and occupied jointly or in common by two or more persons the market value exemption limit will be shared between them. This is to secure as far as possible that the property will pay the same tax whether held solely by one person or jointly or in common by two or more persons. Indexation of the limit is desirable because we have a directly relevant index, which is the new house price index. Secondly, the objective is to secure that better than average properties will be subjected to the tax as the tax is one that one would not wish to put on the average house owner. For that reason providing for indexation of the exemption limit is a proper procedure in a case like this.

The market value exemption limit is defined as a function of the unit exemption limit, that is the proportion of the general exemption limit—£65,000 in the first year 1983 — which is attributed to each unit of residential property and is set out by the formula as shown in the amendment. In that formula A is the market value of the whole of that unit of residential property, B is the market value of the total of the units of residential property and not merely the shares of such property which may be owned by the person, and G is the general exemption limit which, as I said, is £65,000 in 1983. The proviso inserted here secures that where a property is owned jointly or in common the unit exemption limit attributed to the property would be the figure obtained by the application of the formula divided by the number of persons sharing the house.

Comment on this

This is one of the very detailed and complex sections that have been introduced by way of amendment while this debate has been proceeding. I must repeat with very deep conviction that this is no way to deal with this Bill. Unfortunately, we must deal with an amendment as complex as this in two or three minutes and that is quite ridiculous.

I want to make a point in relation to market value exemption which also will point up one of the major anomalies which we will not now have time to discuss. Nevertheless, the point must be made. The effect of this Bill will be that properties which are affected will be valued as if this legislation did not reduce the value. The market value, exemption limits and so on will be determined as if this legislation did not exist. That is the effect of this Bill. Unfortunately, this legislation will exist and the reality that follows from that is that it will affect the market value of houses, the exemption limits we are talking about and so on. Such notions will apply to houses and their market value will be reduced. Ask any valuer in this city whether this legislation will affect the market value of houses and any of them will tell you immediately that it certainly will. The Minister should be made aware of this if someone has not already told him. Scores of people have queued up to tell me so. Each potential purchaser will say, "Yes and what is the liability for income-related property tax and what will it be over ten, 15 or 20 years? If I want to sell it in five years time I must take account of the fact that the purchaser will take account of all this." This is one of the matters of which this new section, lately introduced, takes no account, nor did the section originally introduced take any account of it.

Subject to that, we have not an amendment down for it at this point and we are not resisting it in that formal sense. Had we more time we would resist it not just in a formal way but we would also put down appropriate amendments to it. The Minister must be conscious that the provision of this new tax is inequitable and any valuer in this city will tell him so.

Comment on this

I do not want to get into a deep discussion since Deputy O'Kennedy is not inviting it. I want to take one point that he made. He says that we are creating difficulty in that the application of this tax will be in some way on the basis that the tax is not in operation and fixing of the exemption limits will be done on the basis that the tax is in operation. I am not sure that the Deputy has followed that thought through. If the application of this tax would have an effect on property values generally and the effect of reducing property values generally, that would be reflected in the marketplace. Since the values of properties that will be used to determine the amount of tax will inevitably be related to what is going on in the market, other things being equal——

Comment on this

If you are going to sell——

Comment on this

——that would reduce the values that would be used for the computation of the tax. The Deputy is really arguing in a circle in that respect.

Comment on this

I am not. If you are going to sell the market value will be reduced by the existence of this tax, but the people liable for this tax have no contemplation of selling. They are going to stay on living in their homes.

Comment on this

I would like a chance to ask a question because we are coming near the deadline. I want to avail of this opportunity to ask the Minister one very simple and direct question. Does he really believe in this legislation himself?

Comment on this

That is, as the Deputy says, a very simple, direct question and he will get a very simple and direct answer, which is illustrated by the fact that I have been here sitting from whatever time it was, 3.30 p.m. on Tuesday last to 4 o'clock this afternoon. If I did not believe that what I am doing is worthwhile I would not be here.

Comment on this

That is not an answer.

Comment on this

Will the Minister give some clear indication to the House as to how it is intended that the market value of a new house is to be determined when this legislation has been implemented, if it ever is, bearing in mind that the Department of the Environment issue certificates of reasonable value where the house is a new house? In the first year is it to the CRV value of the house that the tax will apply?

Comment on this

That seems to be the least complex of all matters. If somebody comes along who is assessable and has to return the value of the house, if he can say that he paid £52,000 for that house on 1 April or 1 June this year, it seems beyond question that that valuation will be acceptable. I add for the information of the Deputy that I bought my present house last year at the end of May and when I am making my return for the purposes of this tax I propose, in line with the provisions of the Bill, to take the new house price index at the nearest date to when I bought the house, the nearest date to the date on which the tax is payable, multiply the price of my house by the change in the index and that is the value I will declare for the purpose of this tax. If the Revenue Commissioners wish to argue with me and establish a lower value, I will be perfectly happy to go along with that.

Comment on this

The Minister is in a special position because he is an exemplary citizen and he is in a unique position if he wants to argue with the Revenue Commissioners. If he wants to introduce his own position as an example, I should remind him that by comparison with the vast majority of people whom we have been concerned about during this debate and who have been living in their homes for a considerable time, the Minister, for good political reasons, moved only last year to where he now lives. I do not think he should quote himself as an example to reassure the public. The circumstances are very different.

Comment on this

(Clare): The true value of any house is its market value. I am not saying that everyone should put up their property for sale to find out what the bidding would be; but, nevertheless, it is valued according to the current market value.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware of the anomalies which exist at present in departmental attempts to determine the value of houses? I am again referring to the Department of the Environment certificates of reasonable value which are being issued by the Department, yet the houses are being sold at figures way below the certificate of reasonable value issued by the Department. The house price index need not necessarily reflect the accurate price of the house on the open market.

Comment on this

That is a different point. If Deputy Molloy has a proposal to make, the effect of which would be to improve the accuracy of the new house price index, we would be glad to hear it.

Comment on this

That is a very facile answer.

Comment on this

It is not facile. I sincerely mean it.

Comment on this

The Minister is ignoring market forces and the real value of houses in the artificial devices which have been drawn up by the civil service seeking to impose what they consider to be the value of houses and which, in effect, is not the value on the open market. When this legislation is in operation the bureaucracy will be seeking to impose the value instead of trying to determine the accurate market value. That will cause concern to many people.

Comment on this

Deputy Molloy is dealing with a completely different question. If he has a problem on the discrepancy between CRVs and prices being realised for houses on the market, that is a completely different question. The point I made in reply to a question was that in the event of somebody buying a new house this year it is perfectly in order for that person to write down the price he paid as the value of the house.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The new section is inserted and section 90 is deleted.

Section deleted.

SECTION 91.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

Amendments Nos. 127 and 128 may be discussed together.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 127:

In page 72, subsection (1), line 47, after "income" to insert "and that of his spouse".

The purpose of these two amendments is to confine the income to that of the man and wife in the home. If we must live with this extraordinary legislation we must ensure that the income liability will be only the aggregate income of man and wife. We want to exclude all the other categories which were mentioned last night — grandmothers, grandfathers, stepsons, stepdaughters and illegitimate children, whose incomes will all be aggregated to bring in over £20,000. If we are talking about people in reasonably comfortable circumstances, perhaps a couple with an income of £20,000 could be so described in certain circumstances, but you would not so describe a couple with two children who are earning or include grandma's pension, which all add up to over £20,000. That is nonsense and it should only refer to the income of the man and perhaps his wife. Acceptance of our amendment will give effect to that intention.

Comment on this

For the purpose of the income exemption limit in section 91 the criterion would be the aggregate of the incomes of the taxpayer and his or her spouse, rather than the aggregate income of the members of the household. I oppose this proposal because it would being about an unconstitutional position which would go directly against the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in the Murphy case. Any law which seeks to impose a higher tax charge on a couple by reason of their being married than they would be required to bear if they were not married would be unconstitutional. Under section 91 of the Bill, as initiated, the income of the spouse will be aggregated with that of the taxpayer in most cases but it will be aggregated because the spouse will usually be a relevant person as defined in section 84.

Comment on this

This section and this Bill should end on that extraordinary note. The Minister is telling us that the reason he cannot accept this is because of its unconstitutionality. It is quite clear from all the arguments that as soon as it gets through it will not be very long before it is tested for its constitutionality.

Comment on this
Division

Amendment put.

Tá 64
·
Níl 73
Result Lost The question put was not agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

As it is now past 4 p.m. I must, in accordance with the Order made by the Dáil on the 24th May, as amended, put the following question:

That the amendments set down by the Minister for Finance to Parts VI and VII of the Bill, and not disposed of, are hereby made to the Bill; and, in respect of the sections undisposed in those Parts, that the sections or, as appropriate, the sections as amended, are hereby agreed to, and that the Schedules to the Bill and the Title of the Bill are hereby agreed to.

Comment on this
Division

Question put.

Tá 72
·
Níl 66
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?

Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

When is it proposed to take Report Stage?

Comment on this

It is proposed to take Report Stage on Tuesday, 31 May 1983, subject to agreement between the Whips.

Comment on this

When may we expect to have the amendments which the Minister intends to put down on Report Stage? I was hoping that he would give us the precise time or day. We need time to look at these amendments.

Comment on this

I would like to be in a position to give the Deputy a precise time, but since the Deputy and I have been in the House since early this morning, he will realise that I have not had time to ascertain the state of progress in the preparation of those amendments. I can assure the Deputy that they will be made available at the very earliest possible moment.

Comment on this

Would the Minister guarantee that if we do not have these amendments tomorrow there will be people available to take copies of the amendments if they are available—or the Bill, as amended, so that we can study it?

Comment on this

I thought that the Deputy was asking a different question.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Bill will be sent immediately to the printers with a direction that it be given top priority.

Comment on this

Would it be possible to collect it tomorrow in the House?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I do not imagine that the Bill is sent out from here.

Comment on this

In other words, we will not have it until Monday morning.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Clerk of the Dáil will see if there are some copies available. Otherwise, it would be sent out by the printers. I cannot personally give any undertaking, but I imagine that it will be in the post on Monday morning.

Comment on this

If it is available here tomorrow morning, perhaps we could collect it.

Comment on this

The amendments should be available on Monday at the latest.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick An Ceann Comhairle Fine Gael

I have no role with regard to the amendments.

Comment on this

We will be ready to work all over the week-end.

Comment on this

Join the club, Michael.

The Dail adjourned at 4.35 p.m. until 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday, 31 May 1983.

Comment on this