I put down a Private Notice Question asking if the Minister for Finance is aware of the serious unrest and concern amongst the tourist interests in south west Kerry as a result of a decision to close the Skellig Rock to the public during the 1986 tourist season; if he would make a statement on the matter, having regard to the loss of employment and income for the area as a result of his proposal. I was informed by the Chair's Office that this question was ruled out of order.

I have already indicated to the Deputy the reasons for disallowance of the question. Neither the reasons nor the question can be further discussed in the House. However, if the Deputy wishes to discuss it with me in my office he will be only too welcome to come to the office.

It is very hard to understand——

You cannot question my ruling.

This is a most urgent matter.

You are longer in the House than I am and must be only too well aware that when a Private Notice Question has been disallowed and the reasons given, the Chair cannot be questioned on the reasons for the disallowance.

About 20 people are employed here and about 6,000 tourists a year visit the rock.

Deputy O'Leary, you are out of order. You know that better than I do. I have indicated in my letter the reason for the disallowance and you should accept the ruling of the Chair and not enter into an argument.

I am being very reasonable.

You are not being reasonable because you continue to criticise the Chair.

I am being reasonable.

You continue to criticise the Chair for disallowing the question. If you wish to discuss the matter with me or raise it on the Adjournment, I shall communicate with you. You cannot discuss it any further.

I intend to raise this matter on the Adjournment.

I shall communicate with the Deputy.