We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Meat Processing Company's Financial Crisis: Statements.

Contributions 1–150 of 299. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In accordance with the Order of the Dáil this day, the House will now hear statements in relation to the situation at United Meat Packers Limited. Before embarking on this business I appeal to the House that we address ourselves to this problem in a fashion which is characteristic of the high standards which normally prevail here and not in a way which only reflects our occasional lapses.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Why do you presume it will be otherwise today?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

One would not need to be a very discerning person not to have noted from the earlier discussion of this matter——

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

If you had to live with the tragedy you would know all about the gravity of it. The debate will be very much in accordance with the rules of the House.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If it is not, the Chair can employ certain sanctions. I will say no more.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

We are aware of that.

Comment on this
Joe Walsh Minister for Agriculture and Food (Mr. Walsh) Fianna Fáil

United Meat Packers began their operations in Ireland in 1974 when the chairman of the group Mr. Sher Mohammed Rafique purchased a slaughterhouse in Ballyhaunis, County Mayo. Since then, the company have expanded to their present size which comprises some five export approved plants slaughtering cattle and sheep. The factories are located at Ballyhaunis, Charleville, Ballaghaderreen, Sligo and Camolin, County Wexford. All of the factories slaughter cattle except that at Camolin which slaughters sheep only. The plant at Ballyhaunis, which is the largest of the group, processes both cattle and sheep. The company also operate a cold store at Banagher, County Offaly.

In 1991 the UMP group accounted for 14.5 per cent of total cattle and some 24.5 per cent of total sheep slaughtered at Irish meat export plants. It is the second largest meat processor in the country after the Anglo-Irish Beef Processors group and have an annual turnover approaching £250 million. The group also have holdings in both Britain and the Netherlands and total turnover, including the UK and European companies amounts to approximately £450 million.

Comment on this

May we have copies of the script?

Comment on this

They are being provided. The Irish operations are understood to be structured separately for both the UK and continental holdings while an examiner was appointed to the Irish subsidiaries only. I understand that the group employ about 700 people full-time. This figure would increase during the peak killing season.

The group have been rumoured to have been in financial difficulty for some time. It appears that this necessitated a re-organisation of the group's debt structure following discussions with their main bankers, a syndicate of seven banks led by Banque Nationale de Paris.

The fire at the Ballaghaderreen plant in January 1992, which is estimated to have cost the group some £15 million, led to the immediate crisis. Short-term credit facilities of some £15 million were arranged to help the group survive in the aftermath of the fire. When repayments on these loans became overdue, Mr. Des Guilfoyle was appointed examiner to the group by the High Court on 17 February last, with permission to borrow £3 million. On 2 March 1992 he was given permission for further borrowings of up to £4 million, having previously successfully borrowed the £3 million figure.

Last Monday, 9 March, his period of examinership was extended for a further week. This was to facilitate him in endeavouring to overcome substantial difficulties he had encountered in arranging a financial package to enable him to continue to operate the group while he prepared a report for the High Court on their viability. Intensive negotiations have taken place since Monday between Mr. Guilfoyle and the three banks involved, BNP, Bank of Ireland and Allied Irish Banks, which ended late yesterday afternoon having failed to find a solution whereby the funding could be provided.

The Irish banks refused to put forward moneys because they have the strongest reservations about the prospects of a positive outcome for the examinership. They believe if moneys were put forward now they would simply delay an inevitable complete overhaul of the UMP operation. Under intense pressure from Government members the two main banks — Bank of Ireland and AIB — came together with the examiner. They agreed, under certain conditions, to provide £4 million but it was on the strict condition that this money would have to be repaid at the end of the examinership. They made it abundantly clear that they did not wish to be involved in the UMP operation on a long term basis. The examiner could not satisfy this condition as he could not guarantee that the money would be available at the end of his examinership.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

That is where the Minister came in.

Comment on this

Alternative proposals for super preferential status were rejected by the banks. The Minister for Finance contacted the president of BNP in Paris to ask the bank to reconsider their decision not to advance further moneys but the Minister's request was turned down. As late as this morning my colleague, the Minister for Finance, had a further meeting with top executives of the two main Irish banks. The Minister impressed upon them the concern of the Government that they should act in the national interest in protecting jobs and in assisting an industry of vital national importance which has excellent prospects in the longer term. The banks have responded in a very positive manner and they have indicated unequivocally their wish to act immediately and constructively in finding the best possible solution to the present crisis.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

Why not now?

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Why did they not do it yesterday?

Comment on this

When UMP are put into receivership the banks are ready to work with the receiver in providing working capital to secure an immediate resumption of activity. They are particularly conscious of the need to keep the plants in the west of Ireland in full operation in the months ahead.

Comment on this
A Deputy

What about Camolin?

Comment on this

This means that the plants in the west, about which there has been so much concern, should continue in operation. The banks are also ready to provide the necessary financial suppport for potential purchasers of the individual plants. The Irish banks believe that the only constructive way forward is to remove the very large burden of debt on this company. They confirm that there would be no problem about providing £4 million but they felt this would serve no useful purpose because of the large overhang debt which is of the order of £50 million.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

And the £550 million for Goodman International.

Comment on this

They acknowledge that this company encompass a viable meat industry and they want to be part of the future development of this industry.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

It was one-twelfth of what Goodman got.

Comment on this

I very much welcome the positive response that has come from the Irish banks this morning. I welcome, in particular, their support for continuing operations in the west. I am confident that BNP, the main creditor, will also respond positively so that jobs can be protected and a strong and viable industry will emerge from the receivership.

There have been some inaccurate and mischievous comments in relation to the Goodman Group. There have been claims that the Government treated UMP differently and less generously than the Goodman Group when they got into financial difficulties in August 1990. According to a report in the Cork Examiner this morning the Government provided £550 million to the Goodman Group. I wish to put the record straight on this once and for all. The Government gave no money, not one penny, to rescue the Goodman Group. What the Government did was recall the Dáil to speed up the enactment of legislation, which had been close to finality in any event, to allow an Examiner to be appointed to the group. It was this same legislation that was used to appoint an Examiner to UMP.

Once the Examiner was appointed to the Goodman Group no further action was taken by the Government, unlike the UMP case continuing discussions during the past week involving Ministers, officials and the banks. If some Members put as much effort into this matter as they put into trying to stir up hysteria, perhaps we could proceed a little further.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

We are trying to save 900 jobs for the many families involved.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

That is an insult to those people.

Comment on this

Thousands of families.

Comment on this

One thousand five hundred jobs.

Comment on this

Given the size of the company's liabilities a constructive receivership is the best method of ensuring that the plants will continue in operation and the jobs will be protected. There is every reason to believe that the plants will be bought from the Receiver. On the basis, they would commence operations free of the large debt which has encumbered UMP. That is the key to this issue; we have to free the company from this large over hanging debt. Given the inherent profitability in slaughtering cattle and sheep I have no doubt that the plants will be sold and will operate profitably. As I mentioned, the banks have given undertakings that they will be willing to fund the purchase and ongoing operations of the plants concerned.

Comment on this

To whom?

Comment on this

What about the cheques?

Comment on this

Finally, I should inform the House of my intention to meet the Receiver as soon as possible after his appointment and to impress upon him the need, first, to maintain the plants in operation as going concerns to protect the jobs involved and, second, in so far as possible, to protect the small creditors, in particular the farmers concerned. To this end I will offer the Receiver my full assistance, the assistance of the Government and the co-operation of the various Departments concerned.

Comment on this

What about the cheques that are out?

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputies, we appealed earlier to treat this in a fashion which would be representative of the standards. I am appealing to the other side to do the same.

Comment on this

People are holding cheques.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am calling Deputy Deasy.

Comment on this

If you were left holding a cheque, you would not be worried about standards.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Belton, I will not take that from you. Deputy Belton will behave himself or else he has an alternative, he can remove himself from the House.

Comment on this

I would like to apologise, if what you have asserted is correct, but two people recently telephoned me to say they were holding cheques.

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Your personal involvement with people outside is not representative of what the House is doing. I have called Deputy Deasy to address the House.

Comment on this

The Minister talked about protection and I want——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

You are taking this out of Deputy Deasy's time.

Comment on this

First, I want to dispel any notion that we, on this side of the House, are trying to make political capital out of this potentially tragic situation. As you asked initially, I hope the debate will be conducted in a constructive manner. That is what I intend to do. We are dealing with the livelihoods of at least 900 families, and probably 1,500, who are directly involved in these four processing plants together with the two depots.

The impact further afield on those two communities, and ancillary industries, will probably affect not just 1,500 people and families but thousands, if not tens of thousands of families. If the company are allowed to collapse many other businesses in those localities, Ballaghaderreen, Ballyhaunis, Camolin or Charleville, will find themselves in serious financial difficulties.

Deputy Belton was quite correct to ask the question of what will happen to those farmers who have cheques from this company which will not be cashed. I believe there are cheques out to the extent of £4.5 million. This means that many farmers will find themselves in serious financial difficulties. Likewise, I understand that creditors, that is small businesses and perhaps larger businesses, in the localities concerned are owed in the region of between £6 million and £7 million. Again, it will be a tragedy for those communities if this group close. These points should be borne in mind.

We are speaking here about the second largest processor in the largest indigenous industry here. It is ironic at this time, when we are spending so much of our time in the Dáil debating a jobs forum that we are now overseeing the collapse of the second largest company in the largest industry in the country. Let us cast our minds back and remind ourselves that the largest company in the beef industry, the Goodman Group, which was supported to the extent of £550 million, albeit through the financial institutions, are living on sufferance. What we are seeking is the continuation of this company, United Meat Packers, be they known as Halal-United Meat Packers or whatever; we want to see the company continue in their entirety and the jobs in question retained.

In his statement the Minister referred to debts of £50 million. I dare say there are many companies with debts of £50 million if they were to go into liquidation in the morning. There are very few companies with assets on hand to offset their liabilities. From my recollection, companies such as this when they go into receivership are asset-stripped.

Comment on this

It would be of help if the Taoiseach and others listened.

Comment on this

This means that jobs will be lost hand over fist. The plants at Camolin and Charleville are modern and stand a good chance of continuing, even when a Receiver is appointed, but the bulk of the jobs are in the west, in Ballyhaunis and Ballaghaderreen and they are not so well structured. The concern of Deputies from the west hinges on that fact. Will those factories at Ballaghaderreen and Ballyhaunis continue in existence if the company go into receivership?

That is the question confronting us today and my objective view is that they will not unless action is taken by State agencies in conjunction with the financial institutions here. We do not expect the banks to take unilateral action in coming together to formulate a financial package to save this group. However, we expect a Government initiative in conjunction with the Industrial Development Authority and the financial institutions to ensure that the plants continue to operate at maximum capacity because once they close, and I am referring in particular to the two plants in the west, they may never re-open. We cannot afford to lose that number of jobs in deprived areas.

I put it to the Taoiseach who is in the Chamber, and to the Ministers for Agriculture and Food and Finance that they must oversee the financial restructuring of this group, be it under different ownership or management, because they must continue. Not alone have this group provided valuable employment but their activities are highly praiseworthy because the bulk of the beef and lamb they kill does not go into intervention. They are not a drain on the European or Irish taxpayer, they sell on the open market in Ireland, more often in Britain and the Continent. They are a decided asset to the agricultural community, the Exchequer and the nation. They cannot be let go down the drain; those plants will be locked and the chances are that those in the west may never reopen. It will be a case of asset stripping, which is all that financial institutions are interested in when a receiver has been put in, and we are aware that this was the case this morning. I am also aware that the company have appealed that decision to the Supreme Court. Why did the examiner, in conjunction with State agencies, not continue his examination until the time schedule had elapsed? The time schedule should not have elapsed until next Monday morning.

I should like to remind Members on the Government benches of similar rescue operations. I will not refer to the Taoiseach's company——

Comment on this

Go ahead. The Deputy referred to Deputy Barry's company.

Comment on this

I wish to refer to the Insurance Corporation of Ireland owned by Allied Irish Banks. When we were in Government in the mid-eighties that company collapsed with huge liabilities potentially running into billions of pounds. We as the Government of the day underwrote those AIB liabilities to the extent of £300 million to £400 million. Fortunately, the company were able to trade themselves out of their financial difficulties. I believe that United Meat Packers can do likewise if they are given the opportunity by the Government. However, it must be a Government initiative. The Associated Banks, including the AIB, who have a huge debt to repay to the State, have reneged on taking a positive stance on this issue. They are allowing many farmers to suffer financial ruin and allowing numerous industries to go to the wall in conjunction with the Halal United Meat Packers Company.

We are prepared to be helpful and constructive but we expect Government action. The people, especially those in the west, also expect action from the Government.

Comment on this

It is quite clear that a deep crisis surrounds the immediate future of the UMP group of companies. That crisis will affect 1,500 families in the most direct possible way. It will affect every single farmer who is owed money by the company, or who relies on the company as an outlet for product. It will affect the banks, the downstream suppliers, and the local economies of the towns and hinterlands in which these plants are located.

Above all, it will have a devastating effect on local communities. Many of the communities involved, especially in the west, have struggled against the odds for years, often in the face of Government neglect. The blow to hope and to morale which would be caused by the total collapse of these companies would take years to recover from. Already, there must be families in the west who are yet again contemplating the prospect of emigration.

It gives me no pleasure to say this situation was largely predicted when the Dáil was recalled in August 1990. In the speech he made on that occasion, the Leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Dick Spring, called for a "detailed, root and branch, analysis of the medium-term and long term situation facing the industry." He went on to say: "The Government must accept the bounden obligation of drawing up a plan for the industry, based on the principle that no more monopolies will be allowed to be developed, and taking into account the need to develop new markets based on the excellence of the product and the quality of production." He concluded that speech by saying: "what is crucial here is that we recognise now that the beef industry cannot be allowed to struggle from crisis to crisis. I call on the Taoiseach now to ensure that once this short term situation has been resolved, the necessary steps will be taken to place our beef industry on a sound footing."

It was plain to see even then that the crisis which had overtaken the Goodman Company — whatever its causes, and this is not the place to go into them — was certain to have repercussions throughout the industry. It was clear that the failure of the State to address the need for a co-ordinated approach to the development of the food industry would have repercussions. It was clear that the failure to recognise the over-dependence of the industry generally on intervention and its failure to develop and diversify into value-added areas would have repercussions.

In this sense, the Government must take a large measure of responsibility for what has happened in relation to UMP. The Government have turned a blind eye to the ramshackle way in which too much of the food industry is run. They have concentrated on crisis management rather than on development. They have preferred to sell off powerful productive assets like the Sugar Company rather than to use those assets as the focus of a properly planned and co-ordinated approach.

Of course, it is not particularly productive for us to say that the Government are the only body responsible for the crisis facing UMP. It is my understanding that a figure of £40 million, which has been quoted by many sources as being the amount needed to put this company back on a sound footing, is in fact only part of the problem. I am told that £40 million may in fact be a more accurate reflection of the gap between the assets and the liabilities of this company.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

That is not true.

Comment on this

I am quoting what I understand——

Comment on this
James C. Tunney An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Jim Higgins will have to restrain himself. He will get an opportunity later to speak.

Comment on this

We do not know — and we have not been told by the Minister —what the financial situation of the company is. I was referring to what I understand it to be.

Serious question marks must, therefore, be raised about the management of this company. It is impossible to arrive at a situation where a company is effectively trading insolvently, to the extent that this company seems to be, without at least the suspicion that cavalier mismanagement is involved. I have been told, for example, that in recent days substantial amounts of cash have been transferred out of this jurisdiction by senior people in this company. I sincerely hope that my information in this matter is incorrect, and I will be very grateful if the Minister is in a position to confirm that nothing like this has happened.

The bottom line has to be that we cannot turn our backs on the communities dependent on the jobs and cash flow generated by this branch of the industry.

Over the last ten years, this country has faced a number of crises similar to this one, and in every single case that I can think of, it has fallen to the Government, as it must in this case, to spearhead a response. We do not need to concentrate simply on the Goodman affair to find a precedent for action. Although it is clear that the Government reacted in enormous haste when a crisis developed in the Goodman Company, it is doubtful, to say the least, if the action taken then was enough, in terms of its character, to protect the long term future of the food industry. However, in the past, Governments effectively rescued the banks from the consequences of the ICI affair, through a combination of actions which were ultimately successful although they entailed certain risks at the time. When Dublin Gas was faced with a similar crisis, Government action ultimately proved effective as well. Perhaps the outstanding precedent to which we should point was the rescue of the PMPA through action co-ordinated by the late Frank Cluskey. That rescue was effected in the first instance by the appointment of an administrator, under legislation which is still on the Statute Books, and through the investment in the company of resources raised through a relatively modest levy on insurance premia. The company when returned to a sound financial basis were returned to the private sector and they continue to operate on an effective basis today.

The Labour Party will support any action now proposed by the Government to adopt a similar procedure in this case, but we will not support any attempt by the Government to wash their hands of responsibility or claim that this is a matter which must be left to market forces to resolve. The Government have a bounden obligation to act to preserve the crucial nucleus of this enterprise and to protect as many of the jobs as possible. It is often said in agri-business circles that whenever a vacuum is allowed to be created, somebody moves in. I have not the slightest doubt that attempts will be made by people whose monopolistic ambitions are well known to move in on UMP. The Government should resist all such efforts in the interests of the ultimate protection of the jobs involved.

Finally, I want to make a point about the banks. The Minister has referred to the conditionality attached to offers made so far by the banks. The banks should be called in now by the Government and told categorically that such conditionality is simply not acceptable. Whether they like it or not the banks have a social and national responsibility in this matter. Despite what the Minister has just told the House, we know from our experience that the banks will see no responsibility other than to their profits and their shareholders. Whatever pressure it takes now, the banks must be forced to take a measure of responsibility for the rescue which is essential.

Comment on this

The appointment of a receiver or liquidator to United Meat Packers Ltd. following the failure of the examiner's rescue attempts is an appalling prospect for the 900 full-time workers, 600 seasonal workers and thousands of suppliers. It will also be a tragedy for all the towns where the plants are located — Ballyhaunis, Ballaghaderreen, Sligo, Banagher, Camolin and Charleville — and the surrounding areas. There was a steady build-up of employment in the plant in Charleville, which is in the heart of the Golden Vale, and a number of young people were recently employed there. It is difficult to understand why this industry cannot be made viable. The Minister needs to look seriously at the entire industry at a time when jobs are so badly needed.

If the closure of United Meat Packers Limited goes ahead it will be a crippling blow particularly to Ballyhaunis and Ballaghaderreen where most of the jobs are located. It will take these towns years to recover from this blow, if indeed they ever recover. The closure of this company will mean that the amount of money coming into these areas will be greatly cut and every business and service will suffer, with the almost certain consequent loss of yet more jobs. Not one family will be unaffected by the closure. Many of the jobs will be lost in areas where there is no alternative employment. Even the traditional outlet of emigration has been greatly restricted by the recession in the UK. The only option for many people will be to emigrate when the opportunities again become available.

The loss of these jobs will be very considerable to the Exchequer. It has been estimated that the cost of every job lost is approximately £13,000 in terms of tax and PRSI foregone and extra social welfare payments. This would represent approximately £11.7 million for the 900 UMP workers. When the losses from the seasonal workers are taken into account the total would be approximately £15 million. Added to this will be indirect losses to the State in terms of lower VAT returns arising from the reduced purchasing power of people who will lose their jobs, extra health costs, supplementary payments and so on.

Last year the companies supported by the Industrial Development Authority created 12,439 jobs on a budget of approximately £140 million. On this basis the cost to the IDA of replacing the 900 full-time jobs alone would be over £10 million. The more one looks at the figures, the more inexplicable is the Government's failure to take any action on this matter. Given the scale of the potential job losses and social devastation, the reluctance is impossible to understand. The contrast between the way the Government are sitting on their hands in regard to the affair and their "no efforts spared" response to the Goodman crisis is startling. In August 1990 at the height of the summer recess the Dáil was recalled to deal with the Goodman crisis and emergency legislation was rushed through in two days. All UMP and their workers merit in Fianna Fail's order of priorities is a two and a half hour debate.

The Minister's indifference to this issue is astonishing. He played a major role in the Goodman development plan in 1987. On that occasion the Government were apparently prepared to commit more than £60 million in IDA and FEOGA supports, not to mention the organisation of section 84 loans of approximately £70 million, on a plan which, at its most optimistic, was supposed to create approximately 660 jobs. Yet on this occasion the same Minister seems unwilling to commit even a fraction of this money to save these 900 full-time and 600 seasonal jobs.

The banks must not be allowed to evade their responsibilities for this debacle. Once again they have shown a total absence of any sense of social responsibility. They are quick to dish out money and take their generous profits when times are good but when faced with the social devastation which the closure of UMP would cause they simply put down the shutters and locked the tills. This is not the first time the banks will have taken their pound of flesh at the expense of workers. The banks probably cannot be compelled to provide money if they are unwilling to do so but the Government can ensure that they pay a heavy price for their anti-social attitude through the imposition of extra taxes or levies.

Clearly, UMP's only hope of survival now rests on Government intervention of some sort. The scale of the potential job losses is so great that the Government must act. There is little point concentrating on meeting limited job creation targets if the Government sit back and allow actual jobs in an indigenous industry to disappear because of short term financial problems. There is also little point in establishing an elaborate jobs forum if jobs on this scale are allowed to go to the wall. The saving of these jobs must now be the absolute priority. When this is done the other questions can be addressed.

United Meat Packers have many questions to answer. They are one of the most secretive companies in the country and little reliable information is available about the extent of their indebtedness or the manner in which these debts were allowed to arise. Have the debts arisen through their Irish operations or through plants abroad? To what extent did the fire at Ballaghaderreen contribute to the disaster? The UMP disaster emphasises the urgent need for the more effective disclosure of company information. I appeal to the Minister to intervene in this important issue so that these jobs can be saved.

Comment on this

I wish to add my voice of concern in regard to the crisis that has occurred in United Meat Packers. The loss of employment will be a major blow to the whole country, particularly to the west. I visited the plant in Ballaghaderreen in mid-December 1991 and met Mr. Sean Clarke. I was very impressed with the factory, where there is a staff of over 250 people. That factory supply directly to the main supermarkets in Britain and to the major markets in Europe. I briefed the company on the potential of the opening of the Iranian market, in which I was directly involved as Minister with responsibility for trade and marketing at that time. I visited Tehran and had negotiations with the Government in relation to the opening of the beef market there. I felt confident that United Meat Packers, with their contacts throughout the Middle East, would be in a position to supply that market.

Comment on this

I opened that market in 1983.

Comment on this

I had to re-open this market.

Comment on this
Gerry Reynolds Mr. G. Reynolds Fine Gael

The Deputy should not have been sacked.

Comment on this
Pearse Wyse Acting Chairman (Mr. Wyse) Progressive Democrats

Order, please. Every Deputy in the House has exactly ten minutes and should be afforded courtesy during that time. There should be no further interruptions.

Comment on this

I was very impressed by the standard of operation of the company in Ballaghaderreen. UMP invested in a major plant there, taking it over after the unfortunate failure of the Towey organisation which resulted in many farmers being deprived of payment for their stock.

Unfortunately, on 7 January 1992, a major fire engulfed the intervention stores at the United Meat Packers plant in Ballaghaderreen, a fire that most of us would consider impossible in an intervention store. In that fire, 35,000 tonnes of beef were lost. It seems from the Minister's statement that this fire sparked off the crisis in the company, or at least it brought it to a head. The company had to borrow £50 million to compensate for the loss, compensation which I presume will be forthcoming from the major insurance companies. Some of that money should be made available in advance of the full discussions and negotiations which are taking place.

The crisis in Ballaghaderreen, Ballyhaunis, Sligo, Camolin in Wexford, Banagher and Charleville is devastating to the economy, bearing in mind that United Meat Packers are responsible for 24.5 per cent of all sheep exports and approximately 15 per cent of beef exports and that in the next few weeks there will be a major increase in business in the lamb industry.

On 17 February last an examiner was appointed to this company in accordance with the Companies Act, 1990. As Minister of State at the Department of Industry and Commerce I was involved in that Act which provided for the rescue of the Goodman organisation who experienced problems far in excess of those being experienced by United Meat Packers. In the Goodman case, the examiner, Mr. Fitzpatrick, had to put together a package of £500 million. I regard the examiner's activities in this case as lacking. He has not operated the Act as it was passed by the Dáil. I accuse him of total negligence as far as his responsibilities are concerned.

Comment on this

He has not been given the go-ahead.

Comment on this

I fail to understand why he went to the court this morning to appoint a receiver——

Comment on this

The Deputy has to blame somebody.

Comment on this

——which will allow the Banque Nationale de Paris to move in and claim their assets if they so wish. By calling in a receiver this company and their potential suppliers are not being given much credibility. Why did the examiner not read the Act passed by this House and implement it as he is entitled to do? Why did he not bring together all the creditors involved?

Comment on this
Gerry Reynolds Mr. G. Reynolds Fine Gael

To what section of the Act is the Minister referring?

Comment on this

I would be able to inform the Deputy of every section in this Act because I brought it through the House.

Comment on this

The Deputy should inform the Minister.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order.

Comment on this

I would like to see the Minister for Industry and Commerce becoming involved in this issue which is of the gravest concern because it seriously affects the whole country. Under section 3 of the Companies Act a receiver can be appointed by the courts as an examiner. I fail to understand why the High Court judge would allow Mr. Guilfoyle to walk away from his responsibilities under this Act to rescue the company.

Comment on this

The Government do not think so.

Comment on this

The section dealing with the appointment of the examiner outlines the position. Was a meeting called of the creditors of this company, including Banque Nationale de Paris, as provided for under section 21 of this Act? The suppliers are at a loss of £1.5 million and are unsure about the undertakings given by Mr. Guilfoyle. Mr. Guilfoyle has walked away from his responsibilities to the suppliers. The company should appeal again to the courts for the appointment of an examiner, otherwise the Banque Nationale de Paris will move in quickly. I am confident about the company's viability.

In 1990, when the Commissioner rang a Dutch bank, the Opposition criticised him and when we assisted in the appointment of an examiner to the Goodman Group we were criticised. I compliment the work of the Minister for Agriculture and Food, the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach, who have been deeply involved in the efforts made over the last seven days in regard to United Meat Packers. These people have been let down by the examiner who has walked away from the problem. The IDA and the Minister for Industry and Commerce should take whatever action is necessary and the State should make whatever investment is required to rescue this company. This is a national crisis and I appeal to all concerned to act in a responsible way to ensure that the company are rescued.

Comment on this

The Deputy should go in haste and petition the court.

Comment on this

He will have no chance of a nomination after that speech.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I call Deputy Jim Higgins. I want no further interruptions in the House.

Comment on this
Gerry Reynolds Mr. G. Reynolds Fine Gael

We have had five somersaults in three minutes.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

This is a very important debate and I would appreciate if Deputies would approach it in a responsible way.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

The House has just been treated to a most pitiful and pathetic attempt to move the goal posts. To blame the Examiner is most unfair. All that the Examiner wanted was the money to discharge the remit vested in him by the high court three weeks ago. The remit was renewed last Monday and the termination date was not until next Monday. All that the Examiner wanted was one phone call from the Minister for Finance, Deputy Bertie Ahern, the Minister for Agriculture and Food, Deputy Walsh, or the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

The Deputy is wrong.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

In that situation a promise of £4 million would have secured the jobs. That is all the Examiner needed. All that the Examiner needed was a fraction of the £33 million paid for the 15 per cent of the Government's shares in Greencore which we sold last week. What a patriotic gesture that would have been. One eighth of that £33 million would have saved United Meat Packers Ltd. and 900 jobs.

I come from a part of the country that the Taoiseach knows well——

Comment on this

I do.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——and he will get to know it better. That part of the country is wracked by unemployment, is ravaged by emigration and has suffered a massive downward spiral of population since the foundation of the State. I come from an area known as the "black triangle" in terms of unemployment and emigration. We have never got our fair share of national resources. In my county, it is said that one buys three suits in one's life — three suits for the three "ations", confirmation, graduation and emigration.

The House can imagine the jubiliation in my part of the country when, 18 years ago, Mr. Sher Rafique, came from his native Pakistan to Ballyhaunis, purchased a small meat plant and built up a £300 million export industry by hard graft, by the sweat of his brow, and with minimum State assistance. The company developed to the stage that it now employs 900 full time and 600 part time employees and generates sufficient business for numerous small subsidiary industries, each one of which will go to the wall with this enterprise. Mr. Rafique's enterprise gave growth, jobs and hope where before there was nothing but despair. Mr. Rafique carved out markets in the Middle East with the Muslim communities, markets that no one else could have got. He went out on his own — not courtesy of any State agency nor assisted, aided or abetted by a State agency — and negotiated his own markets. He negotiated markets for every possible grade of animal and built up a reputation that has resulted in his now being the second largest meat operator here. Mr. Rafique built up the markets to such an extent that when he negotiated a major market in Iraq back in 1988 and looked for what was his share — the export credit refund — to protect his investment he received a telephone call from the former Minister for Finance, now the Taoiseach, telling him that it was all a mistake——

Comment on this

He did not.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——because somebody's share of the cake had been taken——

Comment on this

The Deputy should tell the truth while he is at it.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

One of the Taoiseach's colleagues——

Comment on this

Tell the truth, please.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

It was because someone went to the Taoiseach's office, banged the table and said export credit refunds were being given to a competitor.

Comment on this

We will be dealing with that in the next few weeks.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

The decision by the Government to go through the motions of trying to save the enterprise and the jobs involved is nothing more than a pathetic, cruel farce.

I listened to the Minister, Deputy Walsh, in the House earlier this week when he gave grounds for optimism. He was very optimistic that the plants could be salvaged and the jobs saved. I listened to him today, after the Receiver had gone in, and he was equally optimistic that the jobs can be saved. The jobs will be saved in a skeleton fashion in one or two of the plants, possibly in the south, but God help the west of Ireland. The Minister is still optimistic, smiling as the ship goes down. The receivership is now on, the vultures will move in, the company will be dismantled and the jobs will go to the wall. I hope, as Deputy Deasy said, that the appeal to the Supreme Court will be successful.

On 28 August 1990 this House, and its sister House, the Seanad, were recalled. Emergency sittings were held; a section of the Companies Bill which was going through the House, was plucked out; an Examiner was appointed, and a £500 million rescue package was put in place to save the Goodman empire. I wish to make it perfectly clear that I have nothing against Larry Goodman or his empire. In the putting together of that salvage operation the Government played a key, instrumental role by helping to assist the process along the way. What a marked contrast there is between that operation and what happened in the past few days.

Last night I listened to the Minister for Agriculture and Food say on the 9 o'clock television news that the Receiver would go in this morning. There was no need for the Receiver to go in this morning, tomorrow morning, the next morning or the next morning. The Examiner had until next Monday to put together a rescue package. The will was not there and where there is a will there is a way. I make the point that United Meat Packers Ltd. have less than one-twelfth of the debts of the Goodman group — I know what their debts are — and they employ half as many people, but neither the Government nor the banks would lift a finger to enable the Examiner to discharge his functions in completing the examination. That makes a farce of the Companies Act. Never again can an Examiner be called in, because one does not know when or at what stage the plug will be pulled by one or other of the banks. As a result, and I am convinced of this, of a combined conspiracy——

Comment on this

That is scandalous.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——not only of indifference but also of scarcely veiled hostility, which I recognise when talking to the Taoiseach's Members and some of his Ministers——

Comment on this

What would the Taoiseach call it?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——a perfectly viable industry, which is making a profit in its plants, which has run into a minor cash-flow problem, has a normal overdraft for a multimillion pound international company——

Comment on this

If the Deputy knows the debt he could tell us, because they will not tell us what it is.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——which employs 900 people——

Comment on this

Nonsense, this is scandalous.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——is now going to go to the wall. Furthermore, I ask the Taoiseach why the Government did not call in the IDA, the ICC——

Comment on this

What about equity shares?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

——the ACC or ICOS. There is a sum of £4 million at stake. The Government got rid of Fóir Teoranta, a company who helped to salvage the Taoiseach's industries as well as other industries.

Comment on this

And Peter Barry's, remember. Put that on the record now.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

The pitch has been well and truly cleared.

Comment on this

And Peter Barry's.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach is getting rattled.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

There is another hidden agenda and the Taoiseach knows what it is. The banks know it.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order.

Comment on this

Tell the truth; we want the facts.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Order.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

Taoiseach, we listened to your contribution but, as I said, you have been nothing other than childish, churlish and malevolent.

Comment on this

His predecessor was never like that.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I ask the Deputy to address the Chair.

Comment on this

I shall stand for the truth, not half truths.

Comment on this
A Deputy

Is that a criticism of the Taoiseach's predecessor?

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

Through the Chair, I wish to say that there is another hidden agenda. The banks have proved to be their most ruthless, selfish selves once again. They will use any instrument at their disposal to get their way. In this instance they have used the people and people's livelihoods. They are the classic institutionalised asset strippers, and that is part of the hidden agenda. The agenda of the domestic banks, Allied Irish Banks and the Bank of Ireland, was to saddle Banque Nationale de Paris (Ireland) with such a debt that they would be gone from St. Stephen's Green and would pull out of Ireland so that they would have their own little cartel to exploit customers.

What economic lunacy, that as and from today the Government must provide £80,000 per week in unemployment assistance — ironically enough, £4 million per annum, exactly what the Examiner needed — to pay the dole for those 900 people. How transparent is the Government action, that the very week they propose to establish a jobs committee they should knowingly, deliberately, sell the livelihoods of 1,500 people. I see the Taoiseach laughing——

Comment on this

I am not laughing at the Deputy, he is a pitiful sight.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

We are talking about 1,500 people and their livelihoods. What is the Taoiseach laughing at?

Comment on this

The Deputy is a pitiful sight.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

I am saying to the Taoiseach never to talk about jobs or a jobs forum if he allows this closure to go ahead.

Comment on this

The Deputy is a pitiful sight.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

The Deputy must conclude.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

I say to the Taoiseach, as a western representative, his performance in relation to defending the west, his country and western alliance, his so-called allegiance, his grassroots loyalty have been found wanting, after only two or three weeks in office.

Comment on this

Give us the financial facts.

Comment on this

The people opposite are those who are supposed to have them.

Comment on this
John Browne Minister of State at the Department of Agriculture and Food (Mr. Browne, Fianna Fáil

Wexford): May I have permission to share my time with the good western Deputy, Deputy O'Toole?

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

(Wexford): The United Meat Packers group were the second largest meat processing operation in the country, having some five export-approved plants, slaughtering cattle and sheep at Ballyhaunis, Charleville, Ballaghaderreen, Sligo and Camolin, County Wexford. It is widely accepted that over the years this group played a major role in the lamb and beef processing sectors. What we should be talking about today is protecting people's jobs. Certainly I hope we will not have to pay social welfare to those workers. I hope that when the receiver takes over he will be in a position to save all those jobs and acquire new companies to take over.

I might compliment Deputy Deasy in having made a very good, well thought-out contribution, without engaging in any hysterics. Deputy Jim Higgins spoke about not calling in the different organisations and financial institutions. To date the Government and the Minister for Agriculture and Food have met the ICC, ACC, and IDA and the ICOS. I understand also that the Taoiseach himself had discussions today with the chiefs of the ICOS who offered the full support of their members in playing their part in restructuring the beef and sheep industry, whether under a joint venture or some other arrangement. Therefore, it is totally untrue to say that this Government have not been in direct contact with the different financial institutions and cooperatives and or their unbrella organisations.

What the Opposition should bear in mind is that while the banks felt that the Goodman group were viable, the present operation of United Meat Packers group is not viable. That is the difference. The banks felt they could not become involved. Therefore, we should base our remarks on that premise.

The Camolin meat plant in County Wexford is in my constituency. I want to put on the record of the House that over the past week I have been in close contact with the Camolin plant, with the IDA and different financial institutions to ensure that that modern plant, with tremendous facilities, supplying lamb to the French market, is maintained. Under any restructuring or possible take over of that plant I would foresee tremendous potential for its expansion, leading to increased numbers of jobs. It is important that there be competition within the industry. I am concerned particularly about the Camolin plant and the important role it plays in servicing Wexford sheep producers. I am also concerned that the market built up by United Meat Packers group should not be lost. I will be making every effort to ensure continuity of processing at Camolin so that these markets will be maintained. Competition within the meat industry, as in all other sectors, is vital. Therefore, I will be anxious to ensure continued active competition for livestock in County Wexford.

It is important to place on the record of this House that the Ministers for Agriculture and Food and Finance and the Taoiseach made every possible effort to ensure that the United Meat Packers group would survive. When the receiver takes over I have no doubt he will make every effort to ensure this. I am aware also that the Minister for Agriculture and Food has immediate plans to meet the receiver, with the food division of the IDA, to ensure that no stone is left unturned in ensuring that these plants continue as viable operations. As junior Minister in the Department of Agriculture and Food I will be making every effort to ensure that the Camolin plant survives.

Comment on this

I join with previous speakers in pleading that everything possible be done to ensure the continuance of this plant. United Meat Packers Limited have enjoyed maximum investment on the part of the State and banks to date, their location in a disadvantaged area constituting one reason for their receiving the maximum grant. The plant was the best and most modern nationwide. Their standard enabled them to compete abroad by way of FEOGA grants. The group are in the unique position of having the best markets in the United Kingdom, Spain and the Eastern bloc, placing them in a very healthy position. I very much regret — as Deputy Jim Higgins said — that they are now embarrassed by having a minimum cash flow. I am not so naive as to make a statement here without knowing the relevant facts. The overall position is much more serious than that and warrants a positive approach on the part of the relevant Ministers. Indeed, I have been engaged in negotiations over the past few days with the Minister for Agriculture and Food and the Minister for Finance and I compliment them both on the way they gave of their time so unselfishly to arrive at a solution to this problem.

At present in the west the maximum number of sheep and cattle are coming on stream. It is too serious for Deputy Jim Higgins, or indeed anybody else, to blow a fuse here——

Comment on this

Or Terry——

Comment on this

Deputy Jim Higgins did not blow any fuse at the closure of the factory in Castlebar in west Mayo; he did not blow any fuse on that occasion.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

You people closed Claremorris and Castlebar.

Comment on this

He is jumping about the House now as though there was no other plant in the country.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

Deputy O'Toole is like a political paralytic.

Comment on this

It would be more productive for Deputy Jim Higgins to sit down with the Ministers for Finance and Agriculture and Food and myself this evening——

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

I spoke with the Minister while Deputy O'Toole was revelling at the Ard-Fheis.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I suggest that Deputy O'Toole address the Chair. I would ask other Deputies to refrain from interrupting.

Comment on this

Many speakers have referred to the 900 workers involved but I would remind Members that there are many farmers and their livelihoods involved.

Comment on this
Jim Higgins Mr. J. Higgins Fine Gael

What is the Deputy doing about them?

Comment on this

It would be preferable if Deputy Jim Higgins and other western Deputies — I know some are willing to do so — would sit down with us this evening in an endeavour to adopt a positive approach to this problem, rather than have the British press talk about us again — another Goodman affair, another meat factory gone to the wall. That is not the type of propaganda western farmers want. They want us to do something positive on their behalf immediately. That is why I am asking Deputies opposite to join with Deputies from west Mayo on this side of the House in an endeavour to bring about a positive solution to this serious problem.

There are many farmers gravely worried today. The plant in question is located in close proximity to my home, a place to which many farmers in Sligo, Mayo and Galway bring their stock. An alternative proposition must be advanced immediately. Whether or not the receiver will have been appointed, that constitutes the bottom line. I call on the Minister for Agriculture and Food to convene a meeting with western Deputies this evening. I have no doubt that he will do so and that it will be more productive than our discussion here this morning.

Comment on this

I should like to begin by quoting some remarks reported in the press of the former Minister for Agriculture and Food, Deputy Woods, following the disastrous fire at the UMP plant as follows:

I will give every support I can in that and in saying it I want to assure people that this is not just idle talk. I mean response on the hour, by the hour.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

I am sorry to interrupt the Deputy, but is he sharing time?

Comment on this

I am. I am sharing my time with Deputy Creed.

Comment on this
Acting Chairman

Agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I was quoting from what Deputy Michael Woods said after the fire in the UMP plant:

"It's the spirit of the people that matters at the end of the day", he said "If you can get the support of the state agencies, you can come back and look on it as a tragedy overcome. We do everything to assist".

Deputy Woods said that, as Minister for Agriculture and Food, on the site at Ballaghaderreen on 9 February after the disastrous fire in United Meat Packers. Is there not a wide gap between that statement and the action of the Government and Government Ministers when they were really called upon to assist? They did not assist. Deputies should note the laden hyprocrisy of that statement when judged against the action when the time came to really assist.

I am delighted that the Taoiseach is here to see me paint some of the picture in the area most affected by this tragedy. The Taoiseach may know a little about it as he is a Deputy for the constituency. The Ballaghaderreen-Ballyhaunis hinterland in the five-year period from 1986 to 1991 lost about 8 per cent of its total population, when the population of the State remained stable. That was way above the national averge and way above both the county averages. Most of the people who left were aged between 18 and 25. They left because there was no work. The profile of the workforce in that area shows that 52 per cent of all people employed work on the land. That is three times or almost four times above the national average of the workforce on the land. Oddly enough, in that area, up to 20 per cent of the people who work in manufacturing industry work in the food industry, and the mainstay of the food industry was UMP. Now we see this whole operation put in jeopardy, faced with liquidation. Is the Taoiseach, as a representative of the area, willing to allow that to happen to 52 per cent of the workforce on the farms and then up to 20 per cent of the workforce in the food industry? Does the Taoiseach support that? I hope the Taoiseach intends to respond to this debate and will make some points about it.

There is no doubt that this company can be saved and that it should be saved. Even at this late stage the Government State agencies could be brought into play to help the company — the kind of thing that the Minister, Deputy Woods, talked about after the fire. Why are those statements not being made today? I appeal to the Taoiseach to see this as something on his own doorstep, to be guided by the principle — and it is not narrow or parochial — that charity begins at home. Charity and help is surely deserved and needed at this critical hour for that area. The Taoiseach should contact the State agencies and use the influence of his office to ensure that those companies do not die.

Comment on this

And then be accused by you tomorrow for it. Such hyprocrisy.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has some experience of this industry.

Comment on this

Such hyprocrisy.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach has some experience, it has been stated, of financial difficulty in his company. There is nothing wrong with that.

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with it.

Comment on this

We also hope, because in the past the Taoiseach has been no lover of United Meat Packers——

Comment on this

That is wrong.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach was not fair to them.

Comment on this

That is incorrect and untrue.

Comment on this

You were unfair to them.

Comment on this

That is pure Fine Gael propaganda.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

It is.

Comment on this