Meat Processing Company's Financial Crisis: Statements.
Contributions 151–299 of 299. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
——in the giving out of export insurance. Mr. Sher Rafique put it on the record that the Taoiseach was unfair to them and the Taoiseach never responded adequately.
Comment on this
I hope that the prejudice the Taoiseach showed against that company is gone today and that the Taoiseach's response to this tragedy or to this looming tragedy will be fair and straight and that the Taoiseach will ensure that the State agencies and the influence of his office will be brought to bear to save it. There is so much more I would like to say but I wish to yield to my colleague, Deputy Creed.
Comment on this
I thank my colleague for sharing his time with me. This crisis is the first real test for the new administration and unfortunately they have failed miserably in it. It gives me no great joy to say this especially as the Minister for Agriculture and Food, Deputy Joe Walsh is part and parcel of that failure. Today 900 people are facing the bleak prospect of life on the dole and a further 600 part-time seasonal employees face the same future. It is ironic at a time when this House is contemplating the establishment of a jobs forum that 1,500 jobs are being thrown away for the sake of £4 million. A simple mathematical exercise for the Government would show that the cost to the State of maintaining these jobs vis-á-vis the cost of paying dole to these people for a twelve month period is exactly the same.
It is surely ridiculous to have a State agency like the IDA working to create new industrial jobs while the Government sits idly by and allows 1,500 jobs to disappear for the want of £4 million. At the Beef Tribunal recently it emerged that the cost of one job in the beef industry is approximately £35,000. Therefore, in the context of UMP it will cost the State between £32 million and £53 million to restore those workers to full employment in the beef industry. All of this could now be saved for a mere £4 million investment to enable this company to trade out if its difficulties.
Over the past number of months I have been concerned by the excessive control which the financial institutions have over the beef industry here. They effectively control 70 per cent of the trade. This is bad for the industry, bad for the farmers and now bad for the employees of UMP. Indeed, I have been seeking to raise this matter in the Dáil in Adjournment Debates on a number of occasions. It is ironic that the control of the beef industry was deemed by the Minister for Agriculture and Food not to come within the ambit of his Department, and adjournment debates on it were also refused by the Minister for Industry and Commerce. The reality is that inter-bank wrangling and a desire to squeeze out the Banque Nationale de Paris has given rise to this debacle. The Government's failure to resolve this bank war is in stark contrast to the application of their ability and energies to coerce 33 different banks into providing £550 million to the Goodman Group. This clearly suggests political and commercial intrigue at the highest levels, the net result being a Goodman monopoly and the loss of 900 jobs. I do not believe the protestations from the opposite benches that those two matters are not related.
I will turn now to the local issue, the Charleville plant. The Minister in his address said that he hoped that the western plants would remain open. I would remind the Minister of what he said when elevated to high office. The Minister said that he felt that he had a particular responsibility to the Cork region. Are the jobs in the Charleville plant, the 120 full-time and 80 part-time jobs secure? I regret that the Minister in his address personalised his attack. That is not what we have come to expect from the Minister. If the Minister wants to fight fire with fire I will fight back. The reality is that the Minister was so closely associated with the Goodman food package in his time as a junior Minister in the Department that he fell out with his senior Minister at the time. The Minister was so adamant that that programme should proceed regardless of cost to the taxpayer that there is now a serious question mark hanging over the Minister's commitment to the UMP group.
Comment on this
That is the truth and the Minister knows it. He fell out with his own Minister over it.
Comment on this
You have no commitment to the UMP. You are so closely aligned with the Goodman group that you cannot get away fom it.
Comment on this
That should be withdrawn by the Minister. It is unacceptable behaviour in this House.
Comment on this
That remark will have to be withdrawn. How dare the Minister; he is the first Minister I have ever heard say that.
Comment on this
I ask the Chair to address the Minister and give him the opportunity to withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
The Minister should be asked to withdraw that remark. It was most unfair. I ask you, Sir, to address the Minister.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy permit me to reply? Minister, I think the word "liar" should be withdrawn and some more parliamentary language used in its place.
Comment on this
I did not mention one Deputy but I did say that Deputy Creed came in here telling untruths, I stand over that and I have no notion of withdrawing that.
Comment on this
That is not my understanding. I am not as familiar with procedure as some other Deputies but it is my understanding that such unparliamentary behaviour is not acceptable and its not the norm and I am insisting the Minister withdraw that remark.
Comment on this
There has been much misbehaviour here this morning and I have no intention of permitting it in future. I call Deputy Morley.
Comment on this
I am insisting that the Minister withdraw that remark. This debate should not proceed until that remark is withdrawn
Comment on this
The Minister withdrew the word and used the word "untruths".
Comment on this
The Chair must interpret what is said in this House.
Comment on this
I will when the Chair begins to protect the Members of this House. I will not have myself labelled a liar by the Minister, Deputy Walsh.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy please show respect for the Chair.
Comment on this
I understood from the Minister that he was using the word "untruth".
Comment on this
On a point of order, if the Minister referred to Deputy Creed as a liar and has not withdrawn that remark it is your responsibility in the Chair to see that he does so.
Comment on this
First, may I have order? I asked the Minister to withdraw that very word. I understood — and I must interpret what the Minister said — that he withdrew that word and used the word "untruth".
Comment on this
May the Chair give a ruling on it? I accept that the Minister has withdrawn it and used the word "untruth".
Comment on this
The Minister agrees that my interpretation is correct.
Comment on this
Sir, I have no difficulty in putting on the record that Deputy Creed came in here and told untruths. If the word "liar" gives some offence to him I have no difficulty in withdrawing it.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity of voicing my concern about the crux into which the company have fallen. When I was first elected to the Dáil this company were in their infancy. Mr. Sher Rafique had been in Ballyhaunis for only a couple of years. He had taken over a slaughter house and commenced operations in it. The company grew under his leadership and expanded. The enterprise and initiative of the owner were fully vindicated in the following years. HalAl, as the company were then called, were responsible for creating a market for a type of lamb for which there had not been a market previously. He cultivated that market and this, of course, was to the advantage of the hill sheep farmers in Mayo and neighbouring counties. I regret that after enjoying wonderful success the company have now fallen into overwhelming difficulties.
The demise of this company will have very serious implications for the communities in Mayo and other parts of the country. It is not easy to attract industry to the west and it is very sad that an industry which was viable up to now and provided very valuable employment is faced with the prospect of going to the wall. This appalling prospect will have very serious implications not just for the people who are directly employed by the company but their families and the community in which they live. Everybody appreciates the ramifications which the loss of employment for such a large number will have on the whole community.
Approximately 600 people from east Mayo and Roscommon and 300-400 people in other parts of the country are affected. It will have implications for the farmers who have delivered their produce to the factory over the past 17 to 18 years. We all realise this but shedding tears will not help the company.
I have been listening to the debate so far and to what was said on national and local radio. I have read the print media since the crisis began. It appears that the Opposition are doing their best to make a political football out of this crisis. I accept what Deputy Deasy said, that he had no intention of making this issue a political football. I have always found Deputy Deasy to be fair and objective and, indeed, he was that this morning. I regret I cannot say the same about my constituency colleague, Deputy Jim Higgins. I have been listening to his statements on local radio since the crisis began and it is clear he is more interested in scoring political points than in finding a solution to the difficulties that threaten to overwhelm this company, and threaten the employment prospects of those who work there. It is clear from his statements that this is the case. For instance, he compared this to the Goodman crisis. There is no comparison between the Goodman crisis and this one except that the legislation which was put in place during the Goodman crisis is being used to assist the company in the appointment of an Examiner. The Government made no grants directly to Goodman, just as they have not done so in this case. I was delighted to hear the Minister refute the suggestion that favouritism was shown to Goodman which was not available to UMP.
Comment on this
The Dáil was recalled to put legislation in place that would help the company. It was successful because the company and their bankers successfully concluded their negotiations. The same machinery is in place in this case but, unfortunately, the bankers and the company could not bring the negotiations to a successful conclusion.
Deputy Higgins is claiming that only £4 million is at stake. That is an insult to the people concerned, to anybody who is listening to him and, especially, to the people of east Mayo because everybody knows — even the dogs on the street — that much more than £4 million is involved. I do not think the final figure has yet been determined. On "Morning Ireland" the Deputy endeavoured to bring the Carysfort issue into the discussion, although it obviously has nothing to do with the present problem. Clearly he is attempting to make a political football of this issue at every opportunity. In this House he descended to a personal low and I have no intention of following him. The jobs and the people concerned are far more important than scoring political points. The Deputy mentioned the closure of Claremorris. It was closed because it was owned by a private company and subsequently sold to another private company. It was not in difficulties when it closed and the Government were not responsible.
I am not interested in playing politics with the livelihoods of the employees of this company. I am not interested in a short term solution which the provision of £4 million would bring about. I am interested in a long term solution to safeguard jobs within the company in its various plants. I am not letting the Government off the hook in this matter. I was heartened to hear the Minister say yesterday that he had been in consultation with the IDA on the issue and that he would be in immediate consultation with any receiver appointed. The first phase of the battle was not successful but if the company go into receivership we will be entering the second phase of the battle. There will be ample opportunity for Government intervention at that time. I expect, Government intervention or not, that the company and their plants will be kept in business and that the employees will be retained. It is difficult to provide new employment in the west. What we have we must hold. The people expect and deserve that.
Comment on this
I will be as brief as I can because I understand that other Deputies want to contribute. I will not utilise the full time allowed to me because it is important that Deputies who are concerned with the food industry in general, and those who have a constituency concern with regard to United Meat Packers, should be able to put a few brief remarks on the record. It is interesting that this debate takes place in the shadow of an unemployment crisis, when detailed discussions are ongoing in relation to establishing a consensus on the creation of jobs. It is our national priority.
It is not without a great deal of sadness that we are faced with the huge threat to 900 jobs. Each of these plants is in an isolated rural area which is extremely deprived. In truth, many of them have no possible source of employment other than in the plants which are so desperately threatened. In my constituency, north Wexford has been particularly badly hit in recent years. The UMP plant at Camolin is in a vast rural area without any alternative industrial employment. A staggering 24 per cent of the north Wexford workforce are unemployed. It is with desperation that the workers at that plant face the dawn of tomorrow and the expectation that the company they have worked for since 1987 will no longer be in existence.
It is a matter of great concern not only for the workers and their families but also for the farmers who supply that plant. The Camolin plant is exclusively concerned with the killing of sheep and since 1987 it has developed a most successful and lucrative export market in sheep-meat, particularly in France, gaining a premium price for producers in the north Wexford area and the whole south-east. The use of the plant has increased sixfold since 1987. The blow is not confined to the workers and their immediate families but will be extended throughout the farming community. It is a problem which must be addressed with great urgency.
The meat processing industry has caused concern for a number of years. Over two years ago the Leader of the Labour Party voiced his concern and called for a fundamental review of the whole meat producing industry. That review must be carried out. We have a new Minister for Agriculture and Food who is not long in that post. He commands respect on all sides of this House and he would not have wished to start his career with this difficulty on his plate. However, it might spur him into taking action which he might not otherwise have taken in looking at the operations of the meat processing industry, the monopolies we have allowed to exist and how they operate in relation to pricing the product and the operating of their plants. I call for a fundamental look not only at this company but at all the meat processing companies to ensure that they can provide sustainable employment for those who want to work there. The Minister and the Government must act now to address that problem.
We have long said in our county that Wexford produces the finest raw materials. We produce milk, meat and soft fruit and most of it goes beyond our county for re-processing and value-added. Although we produce the raw material, other places get the dividend in terms of jobs. We have one or two successful processing operations in the county and we are determined to hold on to them. The sheep processing at Camolin must be safeguarded. I understand that the decision of the High Court is to be appealed to the Supreme Court by the company. I request the Minister as a matter of absolute urgency to ensure, if it is not possible for UMP to continue in operation on the existing scale — and I remain to be convinced of that — that an alternative is immediately put in place so that there is no disruption in employment for the workers who are producing a premium product for which there is a ready market.
Comment on this
I understand the liabilities of this company are in the region of £54 million and that assets total £62 million. The total workforce is in the region of 1,500, one-third of whom are employed on a part-time basis and two-thirds on a full time basis. The company has a turnover of £250 million which takes care of 20 per cent of the total beef and lamb trade of this country. The major difference between United Meat Packers Limited and other factories is that most of the produce is sold on the open market in England and in Europe, unlike other factories who put most of their produce into intervention.
I understand a receiver will be put in place and that a percentage of the moneys owed to creditors will be paid. Does that mean that the farming creditors will merely receive a percentage of what is owed to them on a pro rata basis or will a special case be made for the farmers who are owed in the region of £1.5 million to £1.75 million.
I should like to ask the Minister why so many of our meat processing plants get into financial difficulties? Is it because of poor profitability levels in the meat business, or poor management or a combination of various factors? Whatever it is, we appear to be hit by very poor performances in the meat trade over the last number of years.
On a national basis 15.5 per cent of our workforce is engaged in farming plus another 16.5 per cent in agri-related industries, totalling 32 per cent. In the west, because of the lack of industry, 42 to 43 per cent of the total workforce will be directly concerned with the possible closure of any factories, but farmers from the neighbouring counties of Roscommon, Sligo, Leitrim, Mayo and Galway would be most concerned at the possibility of any threatened closure.
I should say I was dismayed at the comments of the usually very solid Minister of State, Deputy John Browne, when he expressed the wish that Camolin factory would survive. He referred to that on a few occasions without mentioning any of the others, perhaps it was an oversight on his part.
Comment on this
When I became aware last week that the examiner to United Meat Packers was having difficulty in raising necessary finance, I took an immediate interest in the situation. It was presented to me that the problem had arisen because the major creditor, Banque Nationale de Paris, was unwilling to provide any more support unless there was a contribution forthcoming from the Irish banks.
I was in contact with the President of Banque Nationale de Paris and I suggested to him that the Bank might see its way to facilitate the Examiner in view of the potential loss of employment and loss of a business that has strong long term prospects. At the same time my Department was in constant contact with the main Irish banks in an effort to persuade them to come to the assistance of the Examiner.
As a consequence of these efforts, the two main Irish banks, Bank of Ireland and AIB, and Banque Nationale de Paris did come together with the Examiner with a view to finding a solution acceptable to all parties. It appeared for some time that a solution was well within reach and there was really no problem about finding £4 million as such. The essential point was that the Irish banks were not prepared to become involved, beyond assisting the Examiner on a purely temporary basis, because they saw no long term future for the company due to the large burden of debt. I want to emphasise this point because the general impression conveyed to the public was that 900 jobs were at stake due to a failure to advance the small sum of £4 million. This is a misrepresentation of the situation. The issue was about the main banker refusing to go further, without involvement from the Irish banks, while they refused to become involved until the question of a large burden of debt could be dealt with to their satisfaction.
I should add, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, that the exact amount of the very large burden of debt is in some dispute: figures range from £25 million. In a letter which transpired yesterday Banque Nationale de Paris were calling in their various debts of £41 million, other figures suggest that the burden of debt is £56 million, and other figures suggest it could be much more because of the very severe financial difficulties. The precise figure is not known by any of the parties I have met. During the past week I have had discussions with the insurers, the Irish banks, and Banque Nationale de Paris through the senior officials in the Department of Finance. Also, I have had numerous conversations with senior members of management. The burden of debt ranges from £25 million to £50 million.
Thus an impasse was created and it gradually emerged that neither party would concede. There is no merit now in dwelling on the rights and wrongs of the arguments advanced by each side. The Examiner went as far as he possibly could to find a middle ground and I would like to take this opportunity to acknowledge his efforts over the last week. He succeeded in obtaining a time extension from the courts when it appeared that a successful outcome was in sight but, in the event, this did not materialise.
There has been considerable criticism of the Government on the argument that it was not active enough in finding a solution. First of all, let me make it quite clear that it would have served no useful purpose at all, if the Government had somehow produced £4 million. The essential problem — lack of co-operation between the banks and a continuing overhang of debt — would remain. While the Government could and did everything reasonably possible to persuade the banks to resolve the matter, it could not order or direct the banks to take any particular line of action. This would be in blatant contravention of the normal rules and the Government would no doubt be severely criticised. While it may have appeared to the public that the banks were taking a very negative line, I want to put it on record, from my knowledge of events, that at all times the banks were genuinely conscious of their community obligations and were anxious to find a workable solution.
The criticism has been levelled at Government that, while it showed great energy in the Goodman situation, they could not find a paltry £4 million to keep UMP afloat. This criticism is, at best, a misunderstanding of the two cases and, at worst, it is mischievous to say the least. There is no comparison. In the Goodman case all the banks were already committed heavily to the company and they asked the Government to provide a legislative vehicle through which an ordered arrangement could be put in place. This was done promptly but there was no Government finance involved. In the UMP situation, however, the fundamental problem is that those banks not already committed do not want to be committed until the problem of existing debt can be resolved.
Comment on this
By yesterday afternoon it had become finally clear that there was no further prospect of continuing the examinership. There was no possibility at all that the banks could reach agreement. The Government were monitoring the situation very closely and the Government's principal concern was to ensure that a disagreement between banks, however justified, would not lead to large scale loss of employment. It would be a totally unacceptable outcome if the consequence of failure of the examinership was immediate and substantial loss of employment.
On the instructions of Government I had a meeting this morning with top executives from AIB and Bank of Ireland. I did not have to impress upon them the urgency of the situation and the obligation on them to act in the national interest in protecting a vital industry and protecting major employment. I am glad to be able to say that both banks responded in a very positive way. They made it clear to me that, in their opinion, receivership is the best option if the future of the industry is to be assured. Of greater significance, however, is their willingness to act immediately and constructively with the Receiver in providing working capital for an immediate resumption of activity and in providing, where appropriate, necessary financial support for potential purchasers of individual plants. They consider that there is a viable industry which has sound future prospects and they want to be part of this. In particular, I got an assurance from them that they are ready to support, with the co-operation of the Receiver, the immediate continuation of operations in the west of Ireland. This is very good news.
Comment on this
I am confident that the company itself and BNP, the main creditor, will also respond in a positive manner so that jobs can be protected and that the industry can be restructured effectively. UMP have made a big contribution to the development of the Irish meat industry during the past ten years. Of particular significance is the contribution which they have made in the west. It would be a great tragedy if this had to be undone because of financial failures and if a potentially viable business was allowed to fold up.
The examinership has been terminated this morning and a Receiver has been appointed. I understand that he is on the way already and is due to land at Knock airport about now. While the first duty of the Receiver must be the interests of the creditor I am sure that both he and BNP will be anxious to minimise disruption of production. In any event, the best prospect for sale of assets, if this approach is being followed, is to keep the operation as a going concern. I am sure the Irish banks will follow through the assurances which they gave to me this morning and that adequate working capital will be available to the Receiver. The Government will follow developments closely and will be positive in every way they can in assisting the continuation of employment given the major number of jobs involved.
It is unfortunate that a situation should have evolved where disagreement between banks on overall strategy should threaten immediate closure of one of our vital industries. I believe, however, that in the event we have found a satisfactory outcome and I am confident that the plants will continue in operation.
Comment on this
It appears since the debate began today that the only thing that Fianna Fáil Ministers want to do is try to show that Goodman International and United Meat Packers were treated in the same way. That appears to be the only underlying message today. I should say to the Minister, Deputy Walsh, that he is not new to this given that he was Minister for Food for five years. I want to put three questions to him and I hope he will answer them when he comes to address the Assembly in a few minutes.
On the occasion of the famous launch with Larry Goodman — the famous day of the musical chairs — when half the Cabinet sat with Larry Goodman and his associates, the Minister and the then Taoiseach committed the taxpayer to the payment of £25 million provided Goodman International did X, Y and Z. I wish to ask the Minister a straight question. He has said that no favouritism was shown to Goodman International as against any other company, in this case United Meat Packers, but may I ask him if United Meat Packers were afforded the opportunity to avail of money under section 84? Was a similar amount of money made available to UMP as was made available to Goodman International since the launch? Second, is it true that at that launch a clause was inserted which stated that 600 new jobs would be created. It is my understanding that the Government asked that this clause be removed. Does this not amount to favouritism? Third, is the Minister aware that when Mr. Rafique, the owner and chief executive of UMP, arrived in Tuam in late 1987-88 to buy a site on which to build a factory — the Minister can check this with the chamber of commerce — he was told specifically by the Industrial Development Authority that he had no business opening a factory in Tuam because of the deal with Goodman International? I defy the Minister to contradict me. All I am saying is that favouritism was shown to the Goodman Group. Unfortunately, the Goodman Group got into difficulties and we were all left with egg on our faces.
Comment on this
Let me deal with the Tuam sugar factory. It is obvious that what you want to do is to hang a gate on the bridge at Athlone and turn the west into an Indian reservation for the amusement of tourists. You will not be given the chance to do so.
Comment on this
Deputy Connaughton, would you address the Chair? You will get a more sympathetic audience from the Chair than you will from addressing people on my left.
Comment on this
We are being told that the jobs are going to be saved and that the Government are doing all they can to ensure that this happens, but I suggest that the Government have no say in the matter. If the banks say "push off" that is exactly what they will have to do. As long as Fóir Teoranta or some other State agency are not there to oversee the short term strategy of the banks we are undoubtedly going to pay the price. One way or the other once the Receiver is appointed we will know on whose side he will be.
Even at this late stage the Government have an opportunity to show some real will. Unlike most of the Members here, I dealt with Mr. Rafique and Halal the very first week he came to Ballyhaunis. I believed then that he was an independent minded man and, as Deputy Deasy said earlier, he ran a good company and sold meat where other Irish companies never sold it in years gone by. What I am saying is that if we take him and his company out of the equation there will be a lack of competition in the cattle and sheep meat sector all over the country, not just in the west.
What is going to happen to the farmer with a £14,000 cheque in his pocket who telephoned me this morning? That cheque bounced in the bank last Friday. Would the Minister tell me and the House what the receivership will mean for him and many hundreds like him who are small creditors around the country? My time must be up at this stage, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy may have taken a minute of Deputy Kenny's time. He has approximately five minutes.
Comment on this
The only valid test of leadership is to lead and to lead vigorously. The Taoiseach and the Cabinet will be judged on their performance in response to this calamity. On this very day five years ago Fianna Fáil took office following the 1987 general election. Connacht is now being turned into a wasteland by the continued drift from the land, emigration and industrial decline. As I said, the Government will be judged by the people on their performance in response to this calamity.
As Deputy Deasy pointed out, once the doors close and the gates are locked in any factory it will not re-open. The factories in Castlebar, Claremorris and Tuam did not re-open and the Government did not deliver on their promise that a replacement would be found. Despite meetings, discussions, protests and deputations once the padlocks are on that will be it. A few years ago a plant in Belmullet was allowed to close on Christmas Eve but because of the power of the spirit and the will of the workforce, together with the agency involved, they were able to find a replacement. The Culliton report indicates that there has never been as many opportunities available for this country as the number available to us at present. I wonder, therefore, why all the Government speakers have failed to come up with any semblance of a solution to this problem.
The question I want to ask the Minister, Deputy Walsh, is whether all these plants will be saved and allowed to continue in operation. Will it be possible for the courts under the section of the Act referred to by Deputy Leyden to appoint the Receiver as an Examiner to continue the examination in this regard? Do we have at our disposal all the figures involved? Is the figure £4 million, £50 million, £60 million or more? Is there a black hole which we do not know about or are we witnessing a ritual killing by the Fianna Fáil Party with the butcher's knife pointed towards the west? As we are aware, there are people who would like to see this group go into receivership so that they would be able to buy the plants at Camolin or Charleville in the morning. If this happens the vultures will gather and the asset strippers will be in like a flash.
The Industrial Development Authority now tell us that it costs £40,000 to create a full time job. If we multiply £40,000 by 900 we get a figure of £36 million. Six hundred part time jobs multiplied by £20,000 is another £12 million, that is £48 million. Taking an average of £150 per week for social welfare or unemployment benefits it would cost £1.17 million to pay 1,500 workers in a year; an average payment of £200 per week in unemployment benefits to the workforce would cost £1.56 million per year.
The Government will be judged by their response to this calamity. We do not want the province of Connacht and other areas turned into a wasteland. I listened with interest to the Taoiseach's inaugural address at the Árd-Fheis last Saturday when he said that each and every opportunity would be made to retain, maintain or to put jobs on the market and would be examined in detail by the Government. They now have the opportunity to do this. Regardless of the jobs forum it is now up to Fianna Fáil in particular to ensure that all the plants remain open and continue in operation. We shall judge them by their performance.
Comment on this
This is a matter of great concern to the west, particularly to the farmers and industrialists in that area because of the number of herd owners. In County Mayo there are 5,200 sheep owners and 17,000 cattle owners; in County Galway there are 7,500 sheep owners and 16,800 cattle owners; in County Sligo there are 1,900 sheep herd owners and 5,900 cattle owners; in County Leitrim there are 980 sheep owners and 4,800 cattle owners; in County Roscommon there are 2,950 sheep herd owners and 840 cattle owners.
Halal have created employment over the last number of years in the west and I am deeply concerned about people losing their jobs. However, I have the greatest confidence in the Minister for Agriculture, the Minister for Finance and the Taoiseach to ensure that these jobs will be restored. I know what it feels like to be made redundant, I was made redundant from the GWI factory in Collooney many years ago, I know the pain of families who suffer as a result of a bread winner being made redundant. That was a scaled down operation but, unfortunately, some years later the factory closed. I approached the Leader of the Opposition, Deputy John Bruton, who was then Minister for Industry and Commerce, to try to keep GWI open. A sum of less than £500,000 would have saved 150 jobs in the west but the money was not forthcoming from the then Minister and the Government of which he was a member.
Comment on this
I was very disappointed at the time that the money was not forthcoming and the same applies now in relation to the number of people who will lose their jobs in the west. I am very concerned about them but I hope they will not be made redundant. Western Fianna Fáil Deputies had meetings with the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Agriculture and Food yesterday to see what could be done.
Comment on this
I must express my deep sadness at the closure of such a huge business as UMP and their subsidiary factories throughout the country. Our first concern in the face of the crisis at the UMP plant must be for the livelihood of the 900 permanent workers and the 600 casual workers and their families in the various plants in the west and at Charleville and Wexford.
Given the scale of the jobs crisis, nobody wants to see the closure of any of these plants or the loss of jobs. That is foremost in the minds of every member of the Government and indeed every Member of the House. I regret the ritualistic Government and bank bashing which has constituted so much of the debate on this major crisis facing the west arising from the problems of the UMP group. I am aware that there have been intensive efforts behind the scenes over the past week involving various Government Ministers, including my Progressive Democrats colleagues, Deputy O'Malley and Deputy Molloy, in a bid to secure the future of the plants and the success of the examiner.
The problems of UMP clearly go much deeper than the attitudes of the banks or any response which the Government could engineer. We must also look at the very serious management problems which clearly exist in the company. We should also examine how their debts of £45 million arose.
Over half the Irish beef processing industry has collapsed into examinership or receivership over the past two years and it is obvious that one of the country's primary food processing sectors is in an alarming state. Urgent strategic remedial plans must be put in place on an industry wide basis. The knee-jerk, political bashing which has dominated the debate, especially from the Opposition benches, has been inadequate and unhelpful and will certainly not safeguard jobs. We need a rational informed debate on the reasons for the beef processing industry reaching such a sorry state, in particular their reliance on a couple of big players. My colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, Deputy O'Malley, has taken action to prevent further ownership concentration in the beef sector. Many lessons must now be learned from the market dominance which meant that any financial trouble in a single group inevitably affected many workers and farmers and undermines the well being of the entire community.
The Progressive Democrats will do everything possible at Government level to ensure that the various UMP plants are sold as a going concern. We will also do everything possible to ensure that buyers are secured for all the plants so that beef processing can continue uninterrupted, that the interests of the workers, beef and sheep farmers will be secured and that the overall wellbeing of this vital food processing sector is put on a sound footing.
Comment on this
It is impossible in a short time to say what can and should be said in relation to this matter. I heard most of the contributions today and I wish to pay tribute to Deputy Deasy for the manner in which he approached this debate. I also wish to pay tribute to the Labour Party for meeting after the disruption of the Dáil this morning and the way they enabled the two and a half hour debate to go ahead.
Halal and United Meat Packers had an enormous impact on the west. Those of us who were in the Dáil when Halal were established and who have been in contact with them since — and who have been able to help the company — know how much they have done and what they mean to the west. Deputy Kenny used the word "calamity". It is a calamity but questions must be asked in relation to how it overtook us. The Minister for Agriculture quoted a figure of £270 million in turnover. If that is the case, how can the company now have liabilities of one fifth of that amount?
Comment on this
I did not interrupt the Deputy, please do not interrupt me. There have been flights of fantasy in the House this morning in relation to conspiracy. The word "conspiracy" was used by at least three different Members on the other side of the House.
Comment on this
How could a Government who depend on a fair amount of support in the west conspire against those on whom they rely? The suggestion is ridiculous and not credible. Reference has been made to what happened in the case of the Goodman group. Without the legislation which enabled the Goodman package to be formulated this company would have gone into receivership two years ago. However, the Opposition do not seem to understand that.
It is ludicrous to say that United Meat Packers Ltd. could be saved by the provision of £4 million. As everyone knows, it is not just £4 million that is involved. The provision of £4 million would have been easy if the Examiner could have given a guarantee to the banks that he would have been able to repay them after the examination period. The Goodman package was agreed between the banks, the Goodman group and the Examiner. However the Examiner in this case found it difficult to get agreement.
The scenario painted this morning by the Minister for Agriculture and Food is the best option for replacing and retaining these jobs. I do not care who owns the company: my only concern is that these jobs should be retained. I have suggested to the Taoiseach that, if possible, the State should purchase the company. I am sorry if what I have said is somewhat disjointed but it is difficult to say all I want to say in four minutes. Some of my colleagues and I have met the Taoiseach, the Minister for Agriculture and Food and the Minister for Finance on numerous occasions during the past week to ensure that the maximum number of these jobs is retained in areas which badly need them.
Comment on this
I call Deputy McCormack. I should point out that the Minister must be brought in at 2.20 p.m.
Comment on this
I was devastated at the announcement that the Examiner has thrown in the towel and a Receiver has been appointed to United Meat Packers Ltd., formerly the Halal company, and that they will now be put into liquidation. This will be a shattering blow to farmers in the west and particularly to those in County Galway. I am very familiar with the sheep trade in Connemara. Eighty per cent of hill lambs owned by farmers in Connemara are killed in Ballyhaunis or Ballaghaderreen. These factories have built up a special trade for these sheep over the past number of years by going out and seeking openings in Middle Eastern and European markets. No other factory in the country is geared to handling those sheep. What prospects will those farmers have of selling their sheep in the future?
I am also very concerned about the hundreds of farmers, many of them in my constituency, including Connemara, who have uncashed cheques. I am not talking about thousands of pounds worth of cheques. I am talking about cheques for £200, £600, £800 and, in one case, £1,200. I should like the Minister to say when farmers who have cheques in their pockets at present will be able to cash them. When will the east Galway farmers who have received larger cheques for cattle get their cash?
Regardless of what Members from the Government side say, I cannot help contrasting the Government's lack of action in this case with what happened in August 1990 when the Dáil was recalled for a 13 hour debate on legislation which made it possible for the banks to give £550 million to the Goodman group. Yet, it is not possible to make the banks give a guarantee for £4 million in this case. It has not been possible to do this because of the Government's attitude to the west: they seem to believe that the west should be closed down and they do not seem to have any regard for the people who live there.
Despite the fact that three Government Ministers come from the west — two from Galway and one from County Mayo — nothing is being done for the west. In fact, they are not even in the House today for his debate. The Taoiseach and Minister for the western alliance——
Comment on this
The Deputy might wear out his friendship with Deputy Belton and Deputy Ahearn if he continues much longer. There are only five minutes left.
Comment on this
I hope I am not wearing out my friendship with the Minister from the west. I appeal to him today to come to the rescue of the west. I ask him not to close the gates at Athlone and Lanesboro or to say "to hell with the west". We will not allow the Government to live this down. If these factories are closed they will never be re-opened because the vultures will come in and strip the assets for the benefit of the banks and not for the benefit of the farmers and suppliers in the west.
Comment on this
If Deputy Belton wants to be chivalrous he can take two and a half minutes and leave two minutes for Deputy Ahearn.
Comment on this
Earlier I made a remark which the Leas-Cheann Comhairle resented — I suppose I made it at the wrong time. However, I have been contacted by people who have received cheques from this company. These people will not be able to cope with this disaster which has befallen them. In recent weeks we have heard promises from the Government that they will tackle the jobs crisis, that there will be a new beginning on the jobs front. If this is an example of this new beginning, all I can say is God help the country.
As a Deputy from County Longford, I am very familiar with the markets which have been supplied by UMP. I wish to raise a point which has not been faced up to today. I should like to know if, after the Receiver is appointed, the existing markets will still be there after a period of time. I am sure they will not be there. This is an unique case. I hope the Minister in his reply will give a guarantee that those unique markets will be retained. I want to emphasise again the importance of these jobs and markets to the people of the areas affected. As I said, people who have cheques do not know if they will get their money.
Comment on this
I cannot say all I want to say in two minutes. I am appalled at the extraordinary complacency shown by the Taoiseach and the Government to this debate in the face of 1.500 job losses. If this appalling prospect of job losses cannot move the Taoiseach and the Government to act, I question what will? How could the Leader of any Government refuse adequate time for a debate in this House on the impending closure of an industry which has a national dimension and which will affect not only the workforce but the entire country? Yet at the twelfth hour in the life of United Meat Packers Ltd., the Taoiseach sought to stave off a debate in the House and laughed. I could not detect in his attitude any real concern or deep appreciation of the crisis or any need for urgent action on the closure of this company which will be a devastating blow to the entire country and the beef industry.
I ask where this country is going under such leadership. As Fine Gael spokesperson on Labour I refuse, as a result of the Taoiseach's attitude here this morning to accept as genuine any public expression by the Government of their deep concern for the unemployed or job creation. They seem to be prepared to allow 1,500 job losses overnight. Is it any wonder the Taoiseach is refusing to accede to the establishment of a jobs forum? As a result of his attitude to the establishment of a jobs forum and the crisis in United Meat Packers Ltd., I can only conclude that the Taoiseach and the Government are neither interested in job creation nor in retaining jobs. The Government must intervene in this case quickly to cover the short term difficulties in UMP. As Deputy Higgins pointed out, the Government must understand that the phenomenal cost to the State of an additional 1,500 people on the dole queue would far exceed the cost of saving the jobs on the spot.
I cannot accept that the Taoiseach could not consider this crisis worthy of an immediate debate in the House this morning. In view of this, how could we expect the Taoiseach to make the responsible decision to provide £4 million to secure these jobs? It must be remembered that the Government have the power to save these jobs but the question is, do they really want to? The six mark question is: why are the Government reluctant to provide the financial resources to aid this viable industry in the food sector, a sector about which we hear so much and on which the viability of our agricultural industry depends? We are now faced with the loss of 1,500 jobs and no action is being taken. The Taoiseach laughed this morning in the face of the concern expressed by members of this party. If this delights him, how loud will be his laughter when the final sod is laid on the grave of UMP? This is supposed to be an open Government——
Comment on this
——but they are empty and hollow, naked of any concern for the human misery facing the 1,500 workers. The Government are incapable of taking the responsible step of ensuring the survival of UMP.
Comment on this
Before calling the Minister, the Chair wishes to acknowledge the co-operation of all the contributors.
Comment on this
I thank Deputies from all sides who contributed in a very constructive way to this debate. It is with no degree of delight that we in this House, particularly the Government and myself, learned that a large part of the food industry, and indeed the economy, found itself in financial difficulty. The company applied for the appointment of an Examiner to help resolve the difficulty. The Examiner raised some money to try to keep the company in operation but found he had to seek additional money during the week. The main banking group, BNP, which was exposed more than any other bank, refused any further involvement in the company without the involvement of the Irish commercial banks. These banks took the view that, as BNP were the main bankers to this group and had allowed themselves to be exposed to a considerable extent, they would not be prepared to become involved.
The management in this case had a responsibility to the workers and to the industry to run a good operation and not to allow the company get into difficulties. What we are talking about is a company with major liabilities, much more than the £4 million mentioned.
Comment on this
If the problem could have been solved by providing £4 million, that would have been done. During the past week slaughtering was discontinued at these plants and cheques to farmers have bounced. As Deputy Belton said, markets are being lost. The Examiner came to the conclusion that the situation would have become even worse if he continued for another week. At that point it was the view of most people involved that a receivership was the best available option to keep the plants in operation, to retain the markets and to pay the farmers and small creditors who are owed money. A constructive receivership, which is what is expected in this case, will re-open the plants and will in the long term — I am talking about weeks — sell them to people who will be able to operate them free of the heavy burden of debt which has been crippling UMP. When a Receiver is called in, the debt is put to one side and it is the responsibility of the Receiver to re-open the plants and ensure that they operate as a going concern. That is what I expect will happen.
Comparisons have been drawn with various historical cases, particularly the Goodman case. There is a crucial difference between the Goodman case and the UMP case.
Comment on this
In the Goodman case the banks involved considered they could recover a substantial amount of the money owed to them through the sale of other assets outside the companies. In addition, there was a possibility of the recovery of Iraqi debts after the hostilities there had ended. However, no such possibilities existed in the case of UMP. Before I leave this issue I will repeat what I said at the outset, that no Government money was provided to rescue the Goodman group.
Comment on this
Under the Companies Act an Examiner was appointed. I am sure it is the hope of everybody that these plants will re-open. I refer particularly to the west of Ireland because the people there shouted a little louder than everybody else.
Comment on this
In regard to the plants in other parts of the country, including Cork, it would be considered reasonable that other companies will buy these plants. From my discussions with the banks, I understand that ready buyers in the co-operative and plc area will be found for those plants. There is a greater difficulty in the west and that is why we are putting so much effort into ensuring the plants there remain in operation.
Comment on this
I am concerned about the farmers and small creditors who are owed money. The major creditors are the banks and they can be put to one side. I understand that payments owed to farmers and small creditors will be a prime charge on the assets and consequently those people should be paid in full.
Comment on this
If Deputies continue with this corncrakish type of interruption, the Minister will not be able to conclude.
Comment on this
When the Minister concludes Deputy Deasy will be allowed put one question if he so wishes.
Comment on this
I am giving an undertaking to the House that I will make immediate contact with the Receiver who is at present in Mayo endeavouring to re-open the plants. The priority will be to retain the jobs and ensure that farmers and small creditors are paid.
Comment on this
I have been in contact with the State agencies, particularly the Industrial Development Authority, who have communicated with the Receiver to see to what extent they can become involved in the restructuring of this company. We hope there will be a future for the company and for the industry. Deputy Howlin in his very constructive contribution asked when will we stop having crises in the meat industry. What has been happening in the meat industry, particularly in the beef industry, over the past few years has been no joy to anybody. I, more than anybody else, would like to see an end to the crises. I would like to see the meat industry, particularly this organisation, put on a sound financial footing, with quality of management and of product so that we will not end up back in the Dáil insulting, accusing and criticising one another. In many other parts of the industry, particularly the dairy sector, these problems do not arise because that sector is well structured and well managed. I want to see the principles that apply in the dairy sector of the food industry applied in the meat industry. I have no doubt that with my consultations and those of my colleagues in Government with the Receiver and with the State agencies involved, we will ensure a recovery in full in this case.
Comment on this
As a result of what has been said by Minister Walsh and what was stated earlier by the Minister for Finance, Deputy Ahern, can I take it that the jobs in the four plants are guaranteed? I also wish to ask whether the farmers who are owed money and whose cheques have been bounced and the suppliers whose cheques have been bounced are to be paid. Will they be regarded as preferential creditors? Can the Minister guarantee that?
Comment on this
Yes, I understand that in respect of payments owed by the Examiner to farmers, farmers will have a prime charge on the assets and, consequently, should be paid in full. I shall meet the Receiver, who is now in charge, to ensure that farmers and small creditors will be paid in full. That is a matter for the Receiver, but I shall make immediate contact with him to ensure that. As I said, the priority for me and the Government, with the Receiver, is to ensure that the jobs are protected and that those people are paid.
Comment on this
I cannot guarantee it. However, as I said, I shall make immediate contact with the Receiver to try to ensure that that will be the case.