We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Private Members' Business. - Medical Cards: Motion.

Contributions 1–129 of 251. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

I move:

That Dáil Éireann:

–concerned at the fact that many people on low incomes are denied access to adequate primary care for financial reasons;

–further concerned that a failure to increase the eligibility limits will result in people who receive a small increase in their incomes losing their medical cards;

–conscious that the value for money audit commissioned by the Government described medical cards as "real value for money";

–deplores the decision of the Government and the Minister for Health and Children not to proceed with the planned extension of eligibility limits to bring in an additional 200,000 people;

calls on the Government to immediately reverse its decision.

I wish to share my time with Deputies Quinn, Gilmore, Moynihan-Cronin and Wall.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

On a point of order, the House might want to know that there is speculation that Deputy Healy-Rae has got some sort of medical card—

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The House might want to know that.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy is taking time out of the 40 minutes allotted to the Labour Party.

Comment on this

If there is any change, it will clearly be the result of the pressure being put on the Government by the Labour Party and others in the House. We are united in highlighting this essential matter.

In the last four years Ireland has become an increasingly wealthy and, at the same time, increasingly unequal society. We have one of the highest levels of income inequality in the European Union. The gap has widened dramatically in the last four years. The top 10% of the population now have disposable income 13 times greater than the poorest 10%. This has not happened by accident, rather it is the legacy of an ideologically-driven Government which continues, even to this day, to deepen the divide. Nowhere is this divide more evident than in our health service.

We have great health professionals working to deliver care to their patients, but they work in a uniquely dysfunctional system which discriminates against the poor in favour of the rich. We have a two tier health system based on a kind of Irish apartheid which would not be tolerated in any other EU state and which is rapidly becoming unacceptable to the broad majority here. The public is ahead of the Government in its desire for change. People are genuinely appalled at the discrimination which ensures, at hospital level, private patients can access the quality care they need when they need it while public patients often end up on long waiting lists. Even a visit to the family doctor is not exempt from injustice. Those on very low incomes who do not have medical cards are forced to pay the full price to see their family doctor or do without the care they need and suffer the consequences. Such people include the single person living alone whose income exceeds £100 per week or the married couple with two children living on an income of just over £9,000 per year. These are people who are already struggling to pay their household bills and for whom a medical bill constitutes a crippling burden. If other European citizens do not tolerate such inequality, why should we?

Last week the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, launched his health strategy. It was the occasion of lavish PR, clever media management and a benign, if bewildered, public response. It was also four years overdue. Starting out in government with a strategic policy makes good sense. Waiting until the dying months of an Administration leaves the Minister vulnerable to the criticism that this was a political stunt. Be that as it may, there are some good elements in the health strategy, though it is still a failure. It fails to address the central challenge of health care reform. It does not deliver equality. Despite its title, Quality and Fairness, it is a ten year plan designed to perpetuate unfairness in health care. That was a disappointment in itself, but worse was to come.

Two days later the Government's primary care strategy was launched and the result can only be described as a disaster. An overly ambitious billion pound plan was reduced to tatters when the Minister admitted that, far from delivering equality at primary care level, the Government had decided to freeze any increase in income limits to qualify for a medical card for the duration of its lifetime. It is a decision that has been described as deeply disappointing, callous and cruel and even as obscene. It is also a decision that can be reversed, which is the reason the Labour Party has tabled this motion and it is seeking majority support across the House.

The first line of the Government document states, "Primary care is the first point of contact that people have with the health and personal social services." The harsh reality is that for thousands this is simply untrue. They cannot access primary care because it costs too much. They end up in accident and emergency departments because their health has deteriorated or it is their only route to treatment. The Government is on record as stating that an additional 200,000 or so people should have medical cards. We, in the Labour Party, go further by asserting that primary care should be free at the point of delivery. Even if the Government was simply to live up to its own commitment, it would make a significant difference to the lives and health of up to 250,000 people on low incomes. The Minister justified his decision to exclude them on the grounds that their unmet needs would put pressure on the service. This is a terrible admission. Is he really saying the unmet need is so great that he cannot set about meeting it now?

It is clear that general practitioners – they should know since they deliver primary care – do not agree with the Minister and they are so keen for this improvement to be made now that the Irish Medical Organisation has issued a strong warning to him by stating that failure in the forthcoming budget to commit to the extension of the medical card would be a failure to meet the health care needs of the 250,000 who need it most. This, the IMO stated, would only lend currency to those who say the health strategy is no more than an expensive election ploy. A leading GP, Professor Tom O'Dowd, revealed that a recent survey in his practice showed that a quarter of his patients were put off going to the doctor because of the cost. I hope the Minister does not try to convince us that we cannot afford to extend medical cards to the people concerned. The recently leaked value-for-money audit carried out in the health service found that the current medical card scheme is excellent value for money. Nevertheless, the Minister is ignoring that expert opinion as well as the opinion of medical practitioners.

When the Minister extended medical cards to the highest income group among the over 70s he got it wrong. He introduced inequity into the GMS system for the first time. General practitioners are rewarded three or four times as much to care for this group of medical card holders as they are for caring for the poorest in our society. The Minister has thereby introduced, for the first time, incentives to attract GPs out of areas of deprivation and to set up practices in high income areas instead. Already we know that in areas of deprivation there are up to three times fewer GPs per capita, yet the only significant legacy of a Minister who has talked about fairness in the health service has been to make that service more iniquitous. When the Government took the decision to extend medical cards to the over 70s, it did not get its sums right. It estimated 30,000 would apply according to a reply to a parliamentary question I tabled some time ago. Already, 52,500 have applied.

The Minister says his decision results from setting priorities, but does not explain the reason he ignored the advice of doctors, value for money experts and even his own officials. The chief medical officer in the Department of Health and Children in his annual report on the health of children stated:

Specific policy measures, which redistribute resources and provide opportunities and services for families with children, especially poor children, will do most to create better health provision. For this reason basic universal health provision, such as free access to primary care for all children, should be considered.

Despite the good advice and promises made by the Government, the Minister has turned a deaf ear. On Monday he launched a health strategy which promised that "significant improvements will be made in the income guidelines in order to increase the number of persons on low incomes who are eligible for a medical card." By Wednesday the truth emerged that this commitment was not worth the paper on which it was written. It seems the Minister was so bedazzled by his ten year primary care plan that he could not see the real needs to be met.

The Labour Party recognises the central role of primary care in good health care delivery, but we warn the Minister against trying to import into our system the clapped-out British ideas from the 1970s upon which his strategy relies so heavily. He ignores the strengths of the Irish system at his peril. It is vital to maintain and enhance the personal relationship between patients and their doctors. We oppose any proposal which puts barriers between patient and doctor. The proposed triage system could end up with a patient having to get approval from another health professional before he or she can access his or her doctor. No member of the public seeks such a change. It is not good practice and unnecessary. It is also not within the Irish tradition of personal health care. In Ireland people who can afford it or are on medical cards have direct access to the general practitioner of their choice. What is being sought is that such access be guaranteed to 200,000 people on low incomes in order that they can have the security and access for themselves and their children which is denied to them.

If the Minister is serious about primary care reform, he should also commit himself to a free GP service at the point of delivery as the Labour Party has done. He should be less grandiose in his plans to reform primary care and concentrate on the needs of patients. There is nothing to stop him from extending the medical card scheme as the first step towards a free GP service, encouraging the growth of group practices, integrating community nursing with practice nursing, providing incentives for GPs working in areas of high deprivation, guaranteeing patient registration by way of a comprehensive GP scheme, ensuring the regulation and standard-setting concerning out-of-hours emergency services, whether by co-op, rota or commercial deputising, or building the capacity of primary care to deal with prevention, rehabilitation and the management of chronic long-term illnesses. These measures would significantly improve Irish primary care while retaining its strengths and making it more accessible. We, in the Labour Party, propose real reform of primary care rather than the overblown proposals from abroad upon which the Minister sets such store.

The motion is of great importance to people throughout the country. I have no doubt as the debate continues that clear evidence will be given about the suffering and hardship caused as a result of people being unable to access their family doctor. I urge the Minister to accept the motion. He has a chance to put right a terrible wrong being done to families and children who are denied a basic right to medical care. Surely the time has come when the Government and the House can make a simple guarantee of quality and fairness to those who need it most.

Comment on this

An Irish singer named Johnny Logan won the Eurovision Song Contest with a memorable song called "What's Another Year." The Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, is giving his swansong to a whole category of people by saying to them "what's another year" and that they can simply wait. By deciding not to increase the income eligibility limits for access to the medical card system, the Minister has inexplicably penalised upwards of 200,000 people. Will he, if he can, justify the reason he has made this ideological choice? He said last week in the House that he had decided to give people over the age of 70 years the medical card without reference to income. As Deputy McManus said, in making that decision he interfered fundamentally with the basis on which the general medical service system works and introduced structured inequality into the application of the GMS in its current form.

The Minister will not have seen earlier this evening on the "Six-One" news the report from the Society of St. Vincent de Paul condemning outrightly the failure of the Government to do what could be done and what the country could afford to do, which is to give, for the sum of approximately £80 million a year, the medical card to upwards of 200,000 people. That is more than the entire population of the city of Cork.

This Administration has been in government for four and a half years and is the most favoured in the history of the State. It inherited an economic framework unrivalled by that of any previous incoming Administration, a framework which was further underpinned by the stability introduced by Ireland's membership of the euro zone, which meant lower interest rates and exchange rate stability, and ensured the economy grew at an unprecedented rate creating levels of wealth and growth undreamed of by any forecaster or economist. Looking back on that four and a half years, on what was achieved and where the key choices were made by the Government, we begin to see a pattern which reveals an ideological choice which is undeniably right of centre. The choice of the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, between rich and poor in terms of reducing taxes, whether it be capital gains tax, the top rate of income tax, changes in the thresholds, capital acquisitions tax or a range of other areas, has always been to opt for the smaller group who least need the type of support given to them. This is reflected in the decision of the Minister for Health and Children to give people over 70 the medical card and enhance the operation of the terms and conditions of the GMS to ensure doctors complied with its operation. Many over 70 do not need the support of the medical card system, which is the argument made by general practitioners.

I do not like the GMS system. It is a Third World type of operation for a country which developed it and the concept of the medical card, or the blue card as it was originally called, at a time when this was a very poor country. While we are no longer a poor economy, we are still an impoverished society. As Deputy McDowell said outside the House, now that we have achieved the average per capita income of the rest of the European Union, we need to achieve a similar level of public service. One of the key areas where the quality of that service can be measured is in access to health services in general and primary care, in particular.

The reason the Labour Party has proposed and will implement, if we are in a position to do so, a system of free access to primary care is because two out of three people must pay to go and see a doctor. That is the reality. Our measure, small as it is, would at least extend that facility to another 200,000 people. If the child of a young parent on the average industrial income and without a medical card becomes sick for the third time in a month – they tend to become sick at night and other inconvenient times as anyone who is a parent knows – the one thing that parent should be able to do, especially where he or she is detached from family supports because of where he or she lives and where he or she is trying to discern whether the cough is a bad cold or possibly symptoms of meningitis, is access primary care without fear, certainly without the fear of wondering if he or she can afford to pay. Going to see or asking a doctor to make a house call will cost £30 of a person's wages after tax. In effect, it represents a sum closer to £40 of somebody's gross wages. That barrier of fear and denial should no longer be in place.

Access to a properly resourced and established primary care system should have been provided by this Administration. It cannot plead what previous Administrations could legitimately claim, that the resources were not available. Neither are we saying that it can be done overnight. Some of us in opposition have experience of working in a Government that, over 15 months, published the most comprehensive health policy document ever produced by a political party. We know just how complex the task is. We do not claim to have all the detail of such a policy 100% correct, or that the policy cannot be improved, or that aspects of it will not require the input of medical health providers. That is one of the reasons we have proposed that a medical forum should be an integral part of health policy.

At the start of the 21st century the frightening reality is that we know more about the health profile of animals on this island than we do about our fellow citizens. The failure to establish a proper comprehensive primary care system with the necessary support for GPs has left us in a state of chaos and anarchy that prevents the system from delivering the sort of health care to which our citizens are entitled.

We are not asking the Minister to do much. For the past four and a half years he has been a member of the Government whose budget allocation tomorrow will run to £19.5 billion. The Minister has undoubted political skills and influence in the Cabinet. All we are asking him to do is to obtain the extra money needed to increase eligibility income limits, thus enabling 200,000 more people to have medical cards. They have been left behind as a result of the failure to increase the limits in recent years. It was not an arbitrary decision, an accident or an imposed criterion over which the Minister had no control. That deliberate choice was made in recent years at a time when average income was increasing, through the PPF and other social partnership programmes, by the order of at least 8% per annum and in some cases by far more. The Government clearly recognised that a group of people would be consistently left behind as their incomes grew.

In reply to a query from me the Secretary General of the Department of Health and Children informed the Secretary General of the Department of Finance, Mr. John Hurley, that to restore the GMS system to the 40% of the population which, under the current agreement, should be entitled to access it would cost £116 million, based on March 2001 figures. These choices have been made, they have not happened by chance. We are asking the Minister to reverse these choices, and to change the direction of social policy in a manner that will have an immediate and direct impact on 200,000 people. He is in a position to do this. He can make changes elsewhere in his overall budget allocation and negotiate with the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance. We are asking him to do so by accepting our motion.

Comment on this

Tomorrow, mercifully, we will hear the last of the five budgets from the Government. It is a useful point at which to look back at its period in office. No Government has ever had it so good. No Government has ever had so much of the people's money to redistribute and invest. At the end of that four and a half year period it is shameful that the Government has decided that a couple with two children, earning £180 per week, cannot be given a medical card. Such people are effectively being told that if they need to see a doctor, they must pay for it.

The decision not to extend medical card eligibility limits is one that affects all low-income families who must make daily decisions about their health, based on income rather than medical necessity. A parent with a sick child must decide whether to visit the doctor, a decision with which every parent can identify. For the 30% of parents who have medical cards, or those fortunate enough to be able to afford to visit a doctor, that decision is made solely on the basis of whether an ailment is sufficiently serious. For someone on low income, however, the decision on whether to visit the doctor is a financial one. Going to the doctor is not just about the £20 or £25 fee, it also concerns the cost of any prescription the doctor may write. A visit to the doctor with a sick child may end up costing £40 or £50. Many parents on low incomes will have to weigh up that cost against the price of school books, an electricity bill or other household costs. It is a major decision.

People caught in this situation are on low incomes, saddled with big mortgages or paying high rents. The decision not to extend medical card eligibility levels is one of the cruellest that any Government has made. In its recent annual report, the Society of St. Vincent de Paul estimated that for the sum of £80 million the medical card scheme could be extended to another 200,000 people. The Minister, however, says, "Sorry, we can't afford it." The Government takes that stand in the very week when £80 million was found by his colleague, the Minister for the Environment and Local Government, to provide additional compensation for farmers and landowners who have spent the last year obstructing the building of new national roads, but, of course, the IFA is a powerful lobby, unlike a mother with a sick child. That is the reason the Government has turned its back on the sick and the poor. It has done so, however, against the advise of the Minister's own chief medical officer who stated in a report earlier this year that no child should be prevented from having access to a doctor simply on the basis that its parents cannot afford the doctor's fee or the prescription costs involved.

The Minister took office on the strength of the slogan, "Health cuts hurt the old, the sick and the handicapped." I agree with that slogan because the hurt caused by health cuts is never justified. Given the resources the Government has had available to it for the past four and a half years, there is no justification now for it to turn its back on those who cannot afford to go to the doctor.

Comment on this
Breeda Moynihan-Cronin Mrs. B. Moynihan-Cronin Labour Party

I support my party's motion. The issue of medical cards has been one on which I have campaigned passionately all my political life. I know intimately the hardship thousands of families experience in my constituency by being denied a medical card which should be available as an entitlement rather than constituents having to go cap in hand to politicians when in difficulty. Every Member constantly makes representations to health boards on behalf of persons in dire need. My constituency of Kerry South is no different. I was interested to read in this morning's edition of The Kingdom that my constituency colleague, Deputy Healy-Rae, said:

We don't have to be shouting in the Dáil. We make our own representations about medical problems to the Health and Finance Ministers in the Chief Whip's office.

If this is the way the Government dishes out medical cards to Independent Deputies, it is an absolute disgrace.

Comment on this

It is shameful.

Comment on this
Breeda Moynihan-Cronin Mrs. B. Moynihan-Cronin Labour Party

I ask the Minister if this is the health policy over which he presides.

Comment on this

It is shameful.

Comment on this
Breeda Moynihan-Cronin Mrs. B. Moynihan-Cronin Labour Party

It should not be the case that an application for a medical card brought to the Chief Whip by one of the Government's Independents should receive more preferential treatment than any other. Will the Government Chief Whip treat those who have made representations to me or any other Deputy in the same way as those who have made representations to the Independents who support the Government?

During the past four and a half years the Government's Independents have had ample opportunity to assert their so-called independence in which task they have failed miserably. They have proven that they are just so-called "Independents." The vote at the end of this debate offers them another chance to carry out the mandate their constituents gave them at the last election which was to act, legislate and vote as Independents. I earnestly appeal to the Independents, particularly those who support the Government, to vote in favour of the Labour Party motion and exercise real independence for the sake of the 200,000 people up and down the country in dire need of medial cards. I had a woman in my office yesterday who has two children. Last week she took them to the doctor at a cost of £60. One night during the same week she had to call the doctor to the house at a cost of £45. This means she had to pay out £105 in one week. Is the Minister telling me she is not in dire need? She is self-employed and is a few bob over the limit.

Comment on this

That is right.

Comment on this
Breeda Moynihan-Cronin Mrs. B. Moynihan-Cronin Labour Party

Perhaps I should go to the Chief Whip who would be able to help her. I will be making many trips to the Chief Whip between now and next June because there are many in my constituency who ask me to do so given that they cannot get them from the health board. I presume the Chief Whip has a bag of them upstairs. I might go up to him after I conclude my speech and ask for some of them.

Comment on this
A Deputy

They are only for Jackie.

Comment on this
Breeda Moynihan-Cronin Mrs. B. Moynihan-Cronin Labour Party

I agree with the National Association of the Mentally Handicapped in Ireland that children with intellectual disabilities should be entitled to a medical card in their own right. Thousands of children up and down the country continue to live in poverty because they do not have access to primary medical care. Will the Minister see the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, tonight and ask him to see sense, to think about the woman who spent £105 in one week and ask him to ask the Chief Whip what his medical card costs?

This is the time when the four Independents should either shut up or put up. It is a real opportunity for them and their colleagues on the Fianna Fáil back benches to prove to their constituents that they are committed to quality and fairness in the health service. I sincerely hope they rise to the challenge.

Comment on this

The ink is hardly dry on the Government's much hyped health strategy and at the first hurdle it has failed. It has failed to tackle inequality. It has failed to rebalance our health resources in favour of those who need them most. The conscious deliberate decision to freeze eligibility limits for medical cards in 2002 is cruel and heartless. It will cause anger and hardship among low paid workers and families across the country. The decision clearly demonstrates how much out of touch the Government has become. It is a clear signal that the sooner an election is called the better.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The people being penalised are among the most hard pressed workers. Manual workers earn little more than the minimum wage and struggle to make ends meet on a tight budget. The Minister for Health and Children and his colleagues in Cabinet have decided these are the people who must pay the price for the health strategy. They will get in the way of its delivery and, therefore, will be written out of the equation. It is as simple and as straightforward as that. It is a disgrace. Clearly, the Minister does not understand the enormity of what he is proposing. In answer to a Private Notice Question in the House on Thursday last he singularly failed to address the core issue – why, with the advent of the Government health strategy, are the most needy families about to lose out. It is a simple question and the Minister did not even try to answer it.

Let us face the facts. A citizen with an income of over £5,200 must pay every time they visit their general practitioner. A working parent earning £324 gross per week would need to have ten children to qualify for a medical card. Low paid workers are denied free access to a GP. Under the Government this will continue to be the case. The Minister talks continually of ten year plans and establishing priorities. Much of this is arrogant waffle. The Minister has no power, jurisdiction or mandate to speak of Government health plans for the next ten years. At most the Government has six months to run. There is no Government health strategy for the next ten years. That matter will be decided by the people at the next general election. It is they, through their choice at the ballot box, who will determine health strategy for the duration of the next Government. This point appears to have escaped the Minister. However, it will be brought home to him time and again in the next few months.

Having made such an appalling mess of health strategy since 1997 I can understand the reason the Government wants to sweep that failure under the carpet and fast forward to 2011. It will not wash. The Government has a disastrous record in the health service. At a time of unprecedented wealth it has failed to give the people the health service they deserve by right. It has stood over a two tier health system and watched hospital waiting lists grow. Popular frustration with the health service has never been worse. Is this the outfit people want to chart health care reform in the next ten years? One must be joking.

The final act in the health area by the Government is the decision to freeze medical card income limits. The Minister may deny it, but his backbench colleagues, who have retained some degree of reality in the past five years, know this only too well. The Government has targeted some of the poorest families in the State. Some families will lose their entitlement to a medical card while others will be denied free access to primary health care. I know the effect of this on the ground: parents will go without to get their children to the doctor, single parents will put off visiting a doctor because they cannot afford it while accident and emergency units in acute hospitals will be busier than ever. It is a disastrous mean-minded stupid decision, but then what can we expect from a Government which forced the nurses onto the picket line?

Comment on this
Micheál Martin Minister for Health and Children (Mr. Martin) Fianna Fáil

I move amendment No. 1:

To delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and substitute the following:

"commends this Government on its achievements in developing the health service, and:

–acknowledges that, during the life of this Government:

–funding for public health services has more than doubled;

–hospital activity is now increasing faster than ever before;

–the resources available to deal with hospital waiting lists have quadrupled for all the benefit of public patients, resulting in a 16% reduction in waiting lists in the year to the end of June 2001;

–the funding for capital development has virtually tripled over that of the previous Government;

–funding for disability services has increased massively; and

–child care services have seen unprecedented and strategically targeted growth;

–commends the Government on the publication of the new health strategy which is firmly grounded in the principles of equity, accountability, fairness and people-centredness;

–notes the Government's commitment in the strategy to:

–extending medical card coverage to cover more people on low income, including targeted increases to ensure more children, in particular, are covered in order that over 200,000 more people are covered by way of these measures;

–increasing hospital bed numbers by 3,000 by 2011, the largest bed capacity expansion in the history of the health service, with 650 of these beds coming on stream in 2002;

and

–commends, in particular, the new primary care model, which is an innovative response to the needs of a modern health service."

Comment on this

Is that the Healy-Rae version?

Comment on this

I wish to share time with the Minister of State, Deputy Moffatt.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

Last week saw the launch of the mot comprehensive and ambitious strategy in the history of the health service. The strategy addresses every element of the service and points the way forward to a permanent end to many long-entrenched problems. The public and professional response has been extremely positive with patients' representatives calling it "welcome, and well thought out." One of the big departures in the strategy is the fact that specific commitments are given and direct responsibility is allocated for implementation. In this context it might have been expected that the Opposition would be interested in a serious debate about the strategy. Most reasonable people would have assumed that our time could be best used by talking about the programme of development and reform set out. Of course, when one is dealing with the Opposition the expectations of reasonable people will always be disappointed and once again we are confronted with the desperate attempt of an Opposition overwhelmed by the indifference of the public to claw its way into contention. It has decided that the health strategy will provide it with the electoral magic bullet that will achieve what two new leaders and a merger have not achieved.

The basic premise of the posturing of the Opposition parties on this issue is that everything can be done at once. As far as it is concerned, every element of the health strategy that is not implemented within the next few months will represent a betrayal. Under the Opposition we would have a perfect world where everything would move at once. It did not mention this evening that the policy it is condemning was one it pursued throughout its term of office during the rainbow coalition Government.

Comment on this

On a point of order, will we get a copy of the Minister's speech?

Comment on this

I will arrange for a copy to be sent to the Deputy. I have been here since 4.15 p.m.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Deputy Healy-Rae has not completed the last page.

Comment on this

I have been here since 4.15 p.m., but I take it arrangements are being made for copies to be made available.

Comment on this

Does that mean we will get a copy of the speech before the Minister finishes reading it?

Comment on this

I hope so.

Comment on this

Is there a doubt about it?

Comment on this

I have been here since 4.15 p.m. The Deputies probably will get a copy of it.

Comment on this

I presume somebody other than the Minister is working in the Department.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Deputy Healy-Rae is putting the finishing touches to it.

Comment on this

The Opposition parties sat down together to decide income guidelines for medical cards and decided against implementing any real term increase during its term of office. There were no increases at any stage during Deputy Quinn's term as Minister for Finance or Deputy Noonan's term as Minister for Health. They agreed that indexation was an appropriate response. It seems once again the Opposition believes we are to be condemned while it is to be allowed to ignore its record. In contrast we have now proposed to move beyond indexation and to do so as part of the stepped implementation of actions, but the Opposition roars as if we have reversed a policy, as if we are cutting back. It is the same sort of approach it has had to many Government policies.

What I find most curious about the Opposition's position is that it continues to make it up as it goes along. Last week Labour tabled this motion and Fine Gael agreed to support it. It would entail significant additional expenditure next year. Yet on Sunday Labour launched its pre-budget statement, but failed to mention medical cards or health. It recommended major borrowing and spending relating to a range of projects, but no provision whatsoever for medical cards.

In this fact is laid bare the motivation and tactics of the Labour Party. It is to refuse to engage with the detail of the strategy because one cannot beat the best researched and best received strategy of its type ever launched, concentrate on one point and hype it up. Some members of the Labour Party have enjoyed talking about the need for joined-up policies. Where is the join between its budgetary policy and this new decision where medical cards are the number one issue? Welfare, tax, roads, carers, child benefit and housing are mentioned, but there is not one word about health, not one word on the issue about which it is seeking to condemn the Government tonight.

The high rhetoric of empathy is once again revealed to be without substance or credibility. One year after it began an orgy of self-praise, the Labour Party has honoured us with a redraft of its quick fix answer to everything. After one year it contained less substance than the first draft. Last year it admitted that a whole new layer of administration would lead to more administrative costs. This year apparently there will be none, even though every similar system across the globe has significantly higher administrative costs than ours.

Fine Gael, however, has had even more difficulty keeping its line together. In February last year its spokesperson said:

Our health service requires radical reform. Whether the necessary reform can be brought about by the introduction of a universal health insurance system is questionable. What is needed is less, not more, bureaucracy.

Its new leader said on 28 May this year, "If you go in first and announce a universal insurance system, the whole service would just end up like the present accident and emergency chaos." Yet Deputy Mitchell told us on 11 November that they were committed to prioritising an insurance-based system.

One can talk all one wants about equity, but the bottom line is that this is the first Government ever to set out a comprehensive programme for delivering high class and accessible health care for all.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

What happened in 1993? Fianna Fáil did the same then.

Comment on this

Equity in health care is not only about the income guidelines for medical cards. It is about a full range of services and supports. Equity is a core principle on which the strategy is based and one which the Government is committed to addressing in the implementation of the strategy and through service development across the board. The overriding necessity in relation to equity, as was well recognised in the submissions to the national anti-poverty strategy review, is the need for access to services.

Services have to be built up, waiting lists reduced, activity increased and specific groups such as children and those with disabilities require targeted service developments if equity is to be served in a meaningful way. A broad strategic focus is essential to deal with these sorts of problems and no single narrow approach will address the real need for better and more equitable health care services for all.

Before we let the Opposition away with its repeated accusation that the strategy is a last ditch attempt to gain support or that we have been doing nothing for four and a half years, once again the truth is its enemy. More and better paid professionals are delivering significantly more care and services to significantly more people. Waiting lists are down. There have been unprecedented increases in hospital activity. There have been very significant increases in places for the intellectually disabled whose service needs had been all but ignored previously. There is a much enhanced framework for mental health services coupled with much increased targeted investment. Some £41 million has been committed to the implementation of the cardiovascular strategy with the first progress report of the health heart task force completed and launched, and there have been many more advances in cancer treatment services and other services.

Real advances in health and personal social services over the past few years have come as a result of our new and strategic approach to the health services coupled with the most significant programme of investment in health care ever undertaken. Spending has more than doubled since 1997. The overall budget for 2002 is 7.75 billion, or £6.1 billion, representing an increase of 135% since 1997. That is not an illustration of some ideological right wing orientation, as alleged by the Labour Party and its leader. This shows a much greater commitment to health than any previous administration. A year ago the Opposition's big attack was that we were refusing to allocate extra funds to health, today it has abandoned that argument in face of the weight of increases we have put in place. Its only consistent approach is attack.

If one is interested in equity, one must be concerned with the often prohibitive cost of prescription drugs. That is why we introduced the drug payment scheme to replace the schemes where patients reclaimed drug expenditure from health boards. Under the DPS no individual or family need pay more than £42 per month for approved prescribed drugs and non-medicine items from their community pharmacist.

The scheme has been extremely successful. It provides an effective and streamlined point of contact service for more than 950,000 people. Patients no longer need to seek reimbursement from their local health board for prescription expenditure above the threshold, with obvious financial benefits for thousands of families. The total of 950,000 DPS cardholders represents a 36% increase, or 342,000 people, in only one year. The total possible registration is 2.4 million people. All these people can benefit from this scheme which is so much easier to access than previous schemes and which removes the fear of excessive large drug bills. It is not surprising the Opposition has chosen tonight to ignore this major advance.

If one is interested in equity, one must be concerned with the fact that poorer people have to wait longer for necessary treatment. That is why we have been working hard to reduce, and have shown how we will permanently eliminate, waiting lists.

Comment on this

No, the Government will not do that.

Comment on this

The Opposition is aware of the figures but chooses to ignore them. The number of people on public hospital waiting lists in June 2001, the latest date for which figures are available, was down 13% on the comparable figure for the day we took office. During last year there were significant reductions in the waiting lists for target specialties, with the number waiting for cardiac surgery down by 52%, the number waiting for gynaecology procedures down by 35% and the number waiting for ENT procedures down by 30%.

Considerable progress has also been made in reducing waiting times. During the period June 2000 to June 2001 the number of adults waiting more than 12 months for cardiac surgery had decreased by 68%, the number waiting for ophthalmology services had decreased by 38% and the number waiting for orthopaedic services had decreased by 16%. During the same period the number of children waiting for more than six months for cardiac surgery had decreased by 85%, the number waiting for ophthalmology services had decreased by 31% and the number waiting for ENT services had decreased by 25%.

These figures are continuing evidence that the level of targeted funding provided by the Government is achieving results. In spite of this, we saw Fine Gael last week publish a directly misleading leaflet in which it stated that "waiting lists are still rising dramatically". The facts show a decline, but the Opposition does not like the facts so it makes up its own. Perhaps Fine Gael has adopted Labour's most creative attack, where the baseline figure used is January 1997 rather than June 1997. By doing this we become responsible for the unprecedented increase of 4,500 that took place as a direct result of a Labour Minister for Finance and a Fine Gael Minister for Health getting together and deciding to cut back dedicated waiting list funding.

We have no problem justifying our record, but we have no intention of trying to justify the legacies of Deputies Quinn and Noonan.

Comment on this

Shame on the Opposition.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We now have the arrival of the great Minister for Defence.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please allow the Minister to continue.

Comment on this

If the Deputy goes back in time to the beginning of the rainbow coalition, he will see that waiting lists increased by a huge 28% during the Quinn-Noonan golden era of the health service.

The key to reducing and ending waiting lists is capacity and effective management of treatment lists. The strategy on the way forward is clear. Next year will see the largest ever concentrated expansion in acute hospital capacity. That will end over 12 months of waiting for adults and over six month waiting for children. This target will be delivered because of the major foundation already in place in recent years. This year alone will see a 6% – 52,000 in-patient numbers – increase over last year in the number of patients treated in our acute hospital system.

If one is really interested in equity, one must also be concerned with the significant differences in health status that occur between groups. This is the first time any health strategy has comprehensively addressed the issue of health inequalities. It sets out a range of actions specifically directed at disadvantaged groups and which are concerned with ensuring these groups do not continue to suffer most ill-health. The most important action we can take for disadvantaged groups is to ensure they do not get sick in the first instance or that they do not suffer the current disparities in health. Actions to reduce inequalities include implementing a programme of actions to achieve new national anti-poverty strategy and health targets for the reduction of health inequalities. In addition, there are provisions to eliminate the barriers for disadvantaged groups, in terms of making healthier choices easier for these groups, supporting them at community level to understand and access services, as well as specific programmes of action for groups such as Travellers, the homeless, drug misusers, prisoners and asylum seekers and refugees, all of whom have a real risk of poor health status.

If one is really interested in equity, one must be concerned with fair access for all. The strategy sets out a comprehensive plan to ensure equal access for equal need is a core value for the delivery of publicly funded health services. There are different strands to this goal. The first involves clarifying eligibility through legislation and communication with hard to reach groups.

The actions set out in the strategy will ensure all those eligible understand their entitlement, can easily access the services they need and can be sure that regardless of where they live there is a standard approach to their eligibility for services. It will also see a major extension in eligibility. The basic policy of indexation is one followed under Deputies Quinn and Noonan. The idea that we are taking services from people or that next year will see a major reduction in entitlement is a travesty of the truth. If indexation is to be condemned, then every member of the Opposition who voted for indexation is also subject to condemnation.

The strategy recognises that the issue of health services for disadvantaged groups is a complex one which needs to be tackled in a number of ways, both in terms of ensuring, first, that people are healthier and are less likely to need health and personal social services and, second, that when they do, barriers such as transport or opening times do not prevent them from accessing the services they require.

In addition to these measures, on which work will either begin straightaway or has already begun, the Government has set out a range of measures to make more people eligible for services. The commitment to their introduction is clearly stated in the strategy and we will deliver.

It is clear there are other barriers to equity in the system, and these have been prioritised to ensure that in the future the eligibility framework can readily support equal access for equal need. The Government is fully committed to extending medical card coverage to more people on low incomes, including targeted increases, to ensure more children are covered by way of these measures in the course of the strategy. Such actions always have to be considered in the light of the full range of priorities which arise in relation to health services.

The Opposition's only priority is whatever might grab a headline at a particular time. It steadfastly refuses to state which of its promises will have to wait.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We did not spend £10 million doing it.

Comment on this

In the real world one has to have priorities, and ours will deliver real improvements for people and help towards achieving sustainable progress.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister's priorities are for the rich.

Comment on this

Panic stricken.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please allow the Minister to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

Apologise.

Comment on this

We expect more from Ministers.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We expect all Members of the House to allow the Minister to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

I will put a ring of steel around Deputy Ring.

Comment on this

If one is really interested in equity, one has to be concerned with the historic under-provision of care services for people with disabilities and older people. As a society, we have accepted that they are vulnerable groups and that the services, particularly those for older people, need to be expanded hugely to meet current need and to anticipate the needs of the population as it ages.

People with disabilities will gain from the addition of a significant number of extra day places, respite care places and residential capacity. The Government's record in investing in this area is second to none. These people deserve to be and will continue to be a priority.

We have implemented a huge increase in funding. This has delivered over 4,000 new day, residential and respite care places for people with disabilities in the past few years. The Opposition Members should acknowledge once and for all—

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister should get off the stage.

Comment on this

—that this is the first Government which moved to end a major inequality in Irish life, namely, the lack of services for people with disabilities.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister would make Goebbels ashamed. Shame on him.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please, Deputy Mitchell.

Comment on this

Shame on Deputy Mitchell and all others who presided over that history of discrimination. We will go further, however, by ending waiting lists for services and making sure that people with disabilities are not inappropriately placed in psychiatric hospitals. Next year will see further major investments which will help deliver greater equity for some of our most vulnerable citizens.

Older people will also benefit substantially under the strategy. Our commitment is for a total of 1,370 extra assessment and rehabilitation places, 600 extra day places and 800 extra residential-community nursing places per annum each year in the next seven years. These improve ments will bring tangible benefits for older people.

The Government's record on improving services for older people is well recorded. Last July the medical card was extended to everybody over the age of 70 years. The extension of medical cards to the over 70s is wholly consistent with Government policy towards improving the position of the elderly and was a logical consequence of the three year phased doubling of income limits initiated in March 1999. Before the last election the one commitment we gave on medical cards was that we would double eligibility over three years for people aged over 70 years. We have delivered on that promise—

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will deal with that in a minute.

Comment on this

—despite the twisting and turning of the Opposition.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister paid five times over the limit for that on the eve of a by-election.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please, Deputy Mitchell.

Comment on this

When the Opposition was in government it presided over no increase for any group in society in medical card thresholds.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will deal with that in a moment.

Comment on this

That is Deputy Mitchell's record.

Comment on this

Wait for the facts.

Comment on this

His party presided over a nil increase. In three budgets the Opposition, in government, presided over a freeze on medical card eligibility.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.

Comment on this

Scrooge.

Comment on this

The Government has doubled eligibility for the over 70s, and in the last budget—

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I will deal with that in the next few minutes.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please allow the Minister to continue.

Comment on this

—we provided free medical cards for everybody over 70 years who need to see their doctor more than any other age cohort of society.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Bank managers need to see them more.

Comment on this

The Opposition continues to twist and turn on this issue, wanting to oppose, but ultimately satisfied with sniping. Despite all we have heard tonight, even from Deputy Quinn and Deputy McManus—

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Look at the ground now.

Comment on this

—the bottom line is that they voted for this to cover their electoral backs.

Comment on this

The PR people will be annoyed.

Comment on this
Rory O'Hanlon An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Mitchell and Deputy Ring will have their opportunity shortly.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We are being provoked.

Comment on this

Throughout last year, one week we were being condemned for not concluding a deal with the Irish Medical Organisation for the over 70s, but when we concluded a deal the following week we were condemned for concluding it.

If one is really interested in equity, one has to be concerned also with our underdeveloped primary care system. Our new departure on primary care gives it a central role in the future development of our health services. It provides the policy framework to advance equity and recognises the need to address inequalities in accessing the services people need most.

Access to primary care services is of crucial concern to the Government as is shown in the new primary care model that was so well received last week. Many services are not as available as we would like throughout the country. This model seeks to address this problem by putting in place co-ordinated, integrated one-stop-shops for service that will be of particular benefit to older people and medical card holders.

The primary care strategy is a radical, long-term programme which needs to build up momentum as quickly as possible to achieve the targets we have set. The consultation process has demonstrated to us the great value the public places on community based services. The public has recognised what international research tells us, that we can do much more to keep people well and independent as well as to improve the quality of life of those who are ill or have a disability by working at a community level in broad based terms. A properly integrated primary care service can lead to better outcomes, better health status and better cost effectiveness.

We have prioritised as a first step the national development of 24 hour, seven day GP co-operatives. These will be supported by the immediate establishment of a primary care task force to help drive the roll-out of the new model. The emphasis will be on putting together primary care teams which can meet the needs of patients and clients effectively. Patients will have the option of enrolling with these teams and with an individual general practitioner. If they so wish, they will be able to self- refer to any member of the team. This model offers the way forward. It will change utterly the way in which we deliver primary care services and will be hugely important in helping to streamline the delivery of patients and clients to other more specialist services, both within and beyond the community setting.

Anyone really interested in equity and delivering quality care for all must support a move to end the days of the quick fix sloganeering which has so often dominated debates on health in this country.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Tell us about the Irish Blood Transfusion Board.

Comment on this

Unfortunately tonight's debate is part of the old way of doing business. It is an attempt by a desperate Opposition to get some attention and damage a more substantive and credible health strategy than they could ever produce. It will not work. Nobody believes that everything can be done at once. Deputy McDowell's statement does not even mention medical cards as a priority for tomorrow's budget. People will see that the Opposition is unwilling to say what it will do and when it will do it. Over the coming months they will see an Opposition becoming ever more negative and shrill, trying to pick short-term holes in a solid long-term strategy.

The Opposition keeps on arguing for quick fixes, refusing to prioritise, attacking us for implementing policies which it followed and producing leaflets based on misleading figures. We will get on with the substance of delivery and will face into the future. The public will recognise credible and sustainable policies over those with shelf lives as long as a sound bite.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Health cuts damage the old and the young. Does the Minister remember that?

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

We have produced a strategy built on equity which will deliver high quality care for all.

Comment on this

Produced by programme managers and consultants.

Comment on this

I am fully confident that the public will recognise and support our record of achievement and strategy for the future.

Comment on this
Tom Moffatt Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children (Dr. Moffatt) Fianna Fáil

I am thankful to the Labour Party for providing this opportunity to address the issue of health service reform. The health strategy is now synonymous with health reform. It is plainly the way forward. Anyone familiar with my area of responsibility – food safety and older people – will understand how truly exciting the strategy is.

The partnership approach which, much to the ire of the people opposite, is the hallmark of this Government, is at the very core of the strategy. It incorporates the largest public consultation ever carried out in the health service. Members of the public were invited to describe their experiences of the health services and give their opinion on future policy. We received more than 1,500 submissions. We also commissioned market research involving a nationally representative group of over 2,000 adults. Added to this was partnership with the medical organisations and the medical personnel. When we talk about the health strategy we should not think of it as a Government document handed down from Hawkins House to be implemented below. It is a far more egalitarian strategy than has ever before been attempted in this area.

This poses serious questions for the Opposition which it has yet to answer. Should it find itself in Government, would it scrap the partnership and thus ignore the commission on nursing, the strategic assessment of hospital capacity, the national consultative forum and the medical manpower report or reports from the National Council on Ageing and Older People? Would it disregard the 121 specific targets contained in the strategy? What of the specific deadlines along the road to reform?

Labour has already asserted it would not water down its policies to enter Government. Having attacked the Government for taking too long in launching the strategy, would it return to the lengthy negotiations and research? Were it to adopt the sensible path and adopt the strategy, could we trust it to implement it?

Comment on this

There is no fear of that.

Comment on this

There is Devil a one. The record of the parties opposite in Government suggests we could not trust it. After all, in the last few months of the Rainbow Government Fine Gael and the Labour Party decided to cut funding to reduce waiting lists by 20% when these same waiting lists had actually risen by 27%.

Comment on this

How long are they now?

Comment on this

They have been reduced by 25% since we took office.

Comment on this

Does the Minister of State remember the biscuit factory—

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

In both Houses of the Oireachtas they have been challenged to explain this decision. Time and again they have failed to do so. It was the same rainbow coalition which refused to seriously increase the health spend and did not fund the necessary additional nurse training places.

Fortunately for the health service, the present partnership Government will return to office to build upon the reforms to date and complete the health strategy.

Comment on this

The Minister is wishing.

Comment on this

Considerable work has been done. We have not been sitting on our hands. As a direct result of our policies to date, there were 90,000 more treatments carried out in 2000 than in 1997 and 52,000 more treatments were carried out this year than in 2000. This is the largest ever increase in hospital activity. We have more than doubled the health spend to over £5 billion and it is plainly delivering. Staffing in the public health service is up from 68,000 in 1997 to about 86,000 today, which is 18,000 additional people working in the health system. One needs workers in the health system if one is to bring down waiting lists.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Now the Minister of State is talking.

Comment on this

Time has not stood still. While we prepared the health strategy, the job of reform was very much on hand and reform delivered. In the area of equity we have delivered medical cards to the over 70 age group and developed health targets as part of the national anti-poverty strategy. We have introduced the most significant improvements to services for people with a disability in the history of the State. All of this occurred prior to the introduction of the health strategy.

Contrast this with the legacy of inaction left by the rainbow Administration. Other speakers, I am sure, will examine the Opposition's health policies. They are shallow and ultimately unworkable in the context of a large and complex health system in need of reform.

Comment on this

Did the Minister of State write that or did Deputy Gildea do it for him?

Comment on this

Without the policies of future reform and a record of past reform, the Opposition parties come before the House once more to talk about equity in the health system. No one will buy it. Equity is a far broader issue than medical cards. Nevertheless we will increase income guidelines for the medical card – it is in the strategy. The provision of real and lasting equity in our health service involves a broader, more strategic approach which will ensure that services are built up and can be accessed by all those who need them.

It is cynical for those opposite, who failed to increase medical card eligibility in any significant manner while in Government and whose policies would not increase equity in the health system, to feign concern tonight.

Comment on this

Some 39% of the population has a medical card.

Comment on this

For the Opposition this debate is not about health reform or equity, but using the issue of health for purely political ends. The new health strategy represents the way forward in terms of health reform. In my area of responsibility, the health and well-being of older people, it will greatly improve the quality and degree of care provided. In terms of community services it involves the provision of 7,000 additional day centre places, increased funding for appliances and aids in the homes of older people and recruitment of additional staff to support a wide range of primary care services, such as domiciliary care and day and respite services. In terms of hospital services it involves 1,370 additional assessment and rehabilitation beds and 600 additional day places.

Contrast the new health strategy with the uncosted ambiguity of the Opposition. The strategy is specific, with concrete targets and concrete means of achieving them. It outlines what has to be done, how and when it will be done and who is responsible for getting it done. Reforming the health service and providing equity of access and treatment is a serious, complex business. Those parties which have little or no Government record of health reform and did not increase equity in terms of health or social welfare in Government now stand before us as would be champions of equity. The people whose policies would shut local hospitals and increase administration costs now tell us they have a better way. Nobody will buy that agenda.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I call Deputy Gay Mitchell.

Comment on this

Fetch the men in white coats.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I wish to share my time with Deputies Ring, Farrelly, Gerry Reynolds and Boylan.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I am grateful to the Labour Party for giving us an opportunity to again discuss this important matter. The Minister and the Minister of State talked about what they call a specific health strategy. However, it is about as specific as the one they put forward in 1993. Action 38 on page 166 of that specific document refers to the scope of eligibility framework being broadened. It states that income guidelines for the medical card will be increased and it refers to this being deliverable. There is an asterisk after "target date" for the revised income guidelines which relates to the statement that the timing of the introduction of action 38 will be decided by the Government in the context of the prevailing budgetary situation.

Comment on this

When was that?

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

This is the health strategy.

Comment on this

We always took the matter seriously.

Comment on this

The Deputy's party was in office then. It was in Government between 1994 and 1997.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

Deputy Healy-Rae was on a radio station earlier, announcing an increase of 200,000—

Comment on this

That was Deputy Howlin's strategy.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister should take his medicine. Deputy Healy-Rae was on the radio earlier, announcing an extra 200,000 medical cards from tomorrow. The Ministers do not know about this yet because they were not told. The Minister said the Opposition wants everything at once, but that is not the case. We want the poor and not the rich put first. I will return to this point later.

A well meaning journalist, who is a decent person, wrote a column last weekend in which she appeared to suggest that Deputies would have a better time writing to their constituents, enclosing medical cards. We do not do that but some of my constituents sit at home alone in cold houses. They have an income of £101 a week, but they cannot get medical cards. I would not mind writing to tell them that an exception had been made and they will be granted medical cards. If anybody in this House had to pay 30% of their income every time he or she visited a doctor, how many of us would go? The Minister claims to be concerned about reform, fairness and quality but he kicked in the backside, those people with incomes of £101 a week. He gave medical cards to wealthy, retired businessmen who voted for him and he left out the very poor. Such people do not go to doctors and I will return to this point later.

Comment on this

The Deputy does not know the statistics in regard to the elderly.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

In times of plenty, the Minister gave medical cards to retired chief executives and he left out the poor.

Neither of the marvellous Ministers referred to the Deloitte & Touche report during their contributions. The report stated that medical cards at £50 a head would be value for money. However, it did not refer to the activities of the devious Minister who, in the week of a by-election, caved in and gave £250 a head to the IMO to get it to abandon its argument with him about giving priority to the poor. The Minister gave the IMO five times the norm and he also gave it a deal on secretaries. It thought all its birthdays had come at once. The Minister squandered £17 million of taxpayers money to buy that deal in the week of a by-election and he ignored the poor. I can understand the Minister pulling that stroke, but I do not understand him leaving out the poor.

Comment on this

That is an outrageous statement.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

I do not understand how the Minister could leave out the very poor.

Comment on this

The Minister did it.

Comment on this

That is outrageous.

Comment on this

A stroke Minister.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

The Minister quoted his great policy document. The waiting list for orthodontic treatment in the Eastern Regional Heath Authority area increased by 1,300 last year. Some 11,500 people are now on the list, of whom 10,300 have been waiting up to six years for assessment before they go on to the list for treatment. They will not be covered by the Minister's 12 month guarantee because he has no interest in them.

The Minister packed the Blood Transfusion Board with his cronies from his bailiwick for his own advantage. This service needs to have confidence in it restored and it was an outrageous action by the Minister, as I told the House previously. It was outrageous that the Minister undermined the board and this ultimately led to the resignation of its chairman. The Minister leaked information about 1,000 extra consultants months ago, but the report still has not been published. He is at loggerheads with the Department of Finance—

Comment on this

On a point of order—

Comment on this
Gay Mitchell Mr. G. Mitchell Fine Gael

We listened to the Minister's blarney. He should take his medicine.

Comment on this