Private Members' Business. - Medical Cards: Motion.
Contributions 130–251 of 251. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Deputy referred to people outside the House in a tone and using a term that is disrespectful and damaging to their reputation.
Comment on this
I stand over it. I named them in the past. The Minister packed the board of the Blood Transfusion Service—
Comment on this
—with his cronies and people from his bailiwick. These people inflated the Minister's ego in Cork but they did nothing for the national reputation of the service. When the chairman resigned, her letters were published and we saw the references to the Minister's political hacks. Those were her words, not mine.
At the Ballymascanlon discussions, the Minister wanted 5,000 extra beds. His plan now states that 3,000 extra beds will be provided over the next ten years. The Minister hid the Deloitte & Touche value for money report, which he did not commission. The Government commissioned it because it is fed up with him pouring money into a black hole and because he does not have the ability to take a decision and deal with the issues.
During a time of plenty, the Minister made a mess of public services. The country had unprecedented wealth and first class services could have been created. The Minister wants to appoint a board, in addition to Comhairle na nOspidéal, called the hospital authority or hospital board because he cannot take a decision on the role of Comhairle na nOspidéal. He cannot decide where cancer services should be located. He does not want to upset a few people so he proposes to establish another board. No other country the size of Ireland has two boards dealing with hospitals. The Minister makes this proposal in what he considers his marvellous document.
The Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, told the Minister, Deputy Martin, to get lost. He also told the Minister, Deputy Martin, that he could not pour any more money into a black hole. The Minister will not be allowed to repeat the mess he made of the Department of Education and Science in the Department of Health and Children. He rode on the back of decisions made by other Ministers and he came out smelling of roses. However, when Mr. Seán Cromien was sent into the Department to examine the management systems after the Minister left, he said they were in chaos. The Minister wants to preside over the health services in the same way and he hopes nobody will find out about it until after the election. The Minister has established more than 70 reviews, committees, standing groups and quangos. Everything is sent to a review group and none of them ever wind up. He has more quangos and review groups than Heinz has products.
The Minister referred to the document I published last year. It is true that I made proposals in it and I said it was outrageous that the death rate of males over the age of 55 years is three times higher among lower income groups compared to higher income groups. I asked why the Minister for Health and Children recently extended the medical card entitlement at enormous expense to retired businessmen while leav ing persons on incomes of £100 a week without medical cards. Why did the Minister not quote that statement from my document published in November 2000?
Comment on this
The Minister has presided over a system of apartheid in the secondary care area and he has deliberately and wilfully extended apartheid to the primary care area. In the document published 13 months ago, I proposed the doubling of income limits for medical cards to bring them up to a decent level and to fill the State's 40% agreement with the IMO, as the organisation has sought. I proposed a doubling of the limit from £5,200 to £10,400 for a single person. Would that be too much given that £10,400 in this day and age is nothing? Doubling the income limits should not be out of the question. The limit for a married couple with two children should increase from £8,760. As it stands, they are disqualified from having a medical card if their income is above that sum. Even keeping it within the 40% level, doubling the amount would increase it to £19,720. That is still nothing to write home about for a family of four, but the Minister, Deputy Martin, did not do that. He did not look at giving the free GP service to children, as the chief medical officer in his own Department recommended and as I recommend before the CMO did in my document last November which contains these proposals to which the Minister referred, or at giving it to those over 65 only, as I suggested, after doubling the income limits. The Minister did not quote those things in his contribution.
The Minister has missed a golden opportunity to do something decent. I do not mind him playing politics. I am used to his smiling face but when I grew up I was told, "Handsome is as handsome does". The Minister is not handsome. He has let down the poor and he has done it deliberately while smiling into the camera. That is unpardonable.
Comment on this
I look across the floor of the House and I see a wary, tired Government. They are tired Ministers in every sense. They have lost their ideas and certainly they have lost the run of themselves.
I have never had the pleasure of being a Minister. If one continually listens to the spin doctors, the Civil Service and the cameramen telling you "how great thou art", I suppose you get carried away. That is what happened with this Minister.
Tonight I listened carefully. I am told that £80 million will bring 200,000 into the medical card arena. In Opposition, we are accused of not providing answers. I can tell the Minister in two minutes where to find that £80 million. Since the Government came into office, it has spent £130 million on consultants and it has 75 spin doctors. If it gets rid of the consultants and the spin doctors on 1 January, there will be 2,000 more who can have medical cards next year.
What should I tell the woman who was at my constituency office on Saturday? She has four children and her husband brings home £321 a week. He pays £70 on the mortgage and he pays for his car which brings him to work. He, his wife and four children applied to the Western Health Board for the medical card and they did not qualify because his income is greater than that laid down in the guidelines. She said she did not ask the State for a house, for a car or for anything else and all she wants for her four children is a medical card.
A medical card is worth £1,000 per year to a family. It is fine if one can afford to go to the doctor. In some parts of Mayo doctors charge £20 per visit in other parts of Mayo they charge £25 or £30. On average, therefore, doctors in Mayo charge £25. The other day I went to the doctor with a sore throat and he charged £25 straightaway. I went down to the chemist and spent another £30. I can afford it, but what about the poor woman on £321 a week.
Comment on this
That "man's wife" said her child was sick last week. He had a sore throat – this complaint is prevalent at the moment, as the Minister of State, who is a doctor, will confirm. She said: "I could not send him to school but I certainly could not send him to the doctor because I could not afford it." Is it not shameful in this day and age that there are such young families in this situation?
Since this Government came into office there has been one attack after another on the family. It has no respect for the family. One needs a medical card most when one has young children. Fine Gael proposes to give every family the medical card to cover every child from the day of birth until he or she reaches the age of 18. Does that not make sense? Why is the Government always looking after the rich? Since they took office, the rich have got richer, the poor have got poorer and the middle class is being squeezed.
I listened to a colleague refer to Deputy Healy-Rae. I do not know whether he qualifies for the medical card. If he is over 70, he does but I do not know his age. If he got one from the Minister of State, Deputy Séamus Brennan, in the bag, it would not be the first bag which was brought into Fianna Fáil offices. In future, instead of writing to the health board and to the Minister, I will write to the Minister of State, Deputy Séamus Brennan. If Deputy Healy-Rae is right and if the Minister of State is handing out medical cards on a day-to-day basis, then the Minister of State can apply for the vacancy in the Western Health Board. The appeals officer is taking up a job in the legal profession, which is another lucrative profession. If the Minister of State wants to apply for that job, there is a vacancy and he has enough friends within the health board.
I am sick and tired of listening to the Minister of State, Deputy Moffatt, and the Minister, Deputy Martin, telling us about all the money which is going into the health service. What they do not tell us is—
Comment on this
—what has happened over the past number of years. Let us look at the Western Health Board, the Minister of State's, Deputy Moffatt, health board area. When I became a Member of this House in 1997 it had one press officer now there are three press officers. I would not mind if they were spinning out good news, but this morning the first ten letters I got from the health board revealed, for example, that a woman in need of a cataract operation must wait 18 months, a man waiting for hip operation must wait 18 months and another man must wait for a prostate operation. In the case of the man waiting for a prostate operation, who has gone to Galway Hospital twice, I hope on the third occasion I will be able to get him that operation. If I do not, I will raise it on the Order of Business every morning until he gets it.
The Minister has applied spin on the issue of money, but that is what is happening with the health boards and that is what is happening with the money. If he provided less money to consultants for reports and more money to medical consultants, there would not be half the problems.
What is happening in the health boards at present is that, again, they are introducing new structures and new programme managers. There are more managers in the health board than at Manchester United. Up to a couple of weeks ago Manchester United was delivering, but the health service is not delivering. Something must be done.
I put this challenge to the Government and to the Minister this evening. Let us put this health strategy before the people and let them decide whether they think it is a political gimmick. If the Minister thinks that he will send out the political masters from the health boards to sell this message, I have a message for the officials and for the health board. I will be there to meet them at every public meeting. I will bring people waiting for orthodontic services and I will bring people in wheelchairs who are waiting for hip operations to the meetings. When they have been through a meeting or two, they will tell the Minister that they will not go to any more public meetings. The Minister and the health boards should let the health board officials stay in their offices to administer the services. We are paying them to do that, not to go out to public halls telling the people how great is the service. The service provided is not a proper service.
I am sick and tired of people coming to me in tears because they must go to England to get their son to pay for their heart operation or hip operation. That is how the waiting lists are being reduced. The waiting lists are being reduced because people are getting the operations done privately and people are dying because they have not been provided with a service. The Government should be ashamed. As we approach Christmas, this is a disgrace.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to say a few words about the total failure of the Government to deal with the problems of the ordinary people of Ireland. The IMO and the Government had an agreement in place for quite a long number of years that 39% of the people of Ireland would be covered by medical cards. Up until recently, the percentage covered was 29%, a reduction of 10%. That reduction took place because quite a substantial number of spouses or partners, who took up jobs which perhaps did not pay too well, ended up in a position where the income they received put them over the limit for the medical card.
Over the past four years the IMO should have told the Government about this. I am wondering was it discussed during the negotiations when they were getting the IMO to agree to the provision of services for those over 70 years of age. The majority of the people who lost their cards tell us they cannot afford to bring their children to the doctor. As a result many children are going without proper medical care. We waited for four and a half years for this Government to produce a health strategy. We read in the weekend newspapers that it took 36 to 48 hours for that strategy to unravel. I am not surprised there is such a large number of civil servants in the House helping to keep the rest of the strategy together until the Minister for Finance arrives here tomorrow to agree to the demands of some of the independents who know a little more than the Ministers of the problems out there.
The first phone call I had yesterday morning was from a man whose wife became very ill on Saturday and had to go into hospital in Dublin on Sunday. Up to yesterday morning at 10.30 a.m. she was still being treated on a trolley. That is the health service the Government says is working. There has not ever been so much money in the Department of Finance as there has been over the past four and a half years. The Department of Health and Children has not ever had so much money and yet people are still on trolleys in the same way they have been for years.
This Government has ignored the realities of what is happening in our hospitals. The Minister said he would provide 650 new beds next year. How nice to do so in the year of an election. All he will do is re-open the beds that have been closed for the past four and a half years. Where are the consultants and nurses in the strategy who will look after the patients when the beds are opened? They are not there at the moment.
Comment on this
He knows the wait of a year or two years about which my colleagues have spoken, is the reality in every constituency. It would befit the Minister and the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Dr. McDaid who has joined us, if reality struck the Government before 2 May, which I believe is the date for the general election. They might put money into services to look after people who are afraid to bring their children to the doctor, because of the costs involved. This Government has left 200,000 people short of care, 10% of the accepted figure of the IMO and the agreement with the Department of Health and Children.
Comment on this
I compliment the Labour Party for putting down this motion. I read the amendment tabled by the Government and one line in it almost jumped out at me: "that the Government commends itself for the resources available to deal with hospital waiting lists". I find that an extraordinary statement. To put it down on paper is even more extraordinary. The reality is that all the Members of this House have people coming to them every day of the week seeking to try and jump queues and the waiting list to get into public hospitals.
A young man of 34 years who has a tumour on his brain has to wait eight weeks to get into St. Luke's Hospital. In that period he had to go to the general hospital in Sligo three times. He had severe difficulties and went into a coma on one occasion. Despite that, he still had to wait for service and had to come to a politician like me to get into hospital.
No politician should be put in that position but more particularly, no citizen should be. The Minister of State, Deputy Moffatt sat smugly and told Deputy Ring that Fine Gael did not do it when we were in Government. We did not, but we tried and we did not have the funding that has been available to this Government for the past four and a half years.
Comment on this
Where has the money gone? Where has the value for money been and why is the Minister for Finance asking the Minister and the Minister of State where the value for money is? They have put money into the health service but it has deteriorated. That is a fact.
Comment on this
The Minister of State is unable to answer the tough questions. The health strategy he introduced has taken four and a half years to produce and has been launched just six months before a general election. If he thinks the electorate will buy that, he is mistaken. It is sin and spin. It is a sin that this Government has allowed people to remain on waiting lists for health services that are not available. If people are on public health waiting lists they do not get the services to which they are entitled. That is an indictment of the Government. It has failed miserably in trying to provide a health service.
Each Deputy in this House is approached by many people trying to get into hospital for operations. The Minister did not have the courage of his convictions to put in place what is needed. Some 67% of all jobs last year in the health service were in administration. That is horrendous. What are they doing? Is it not more important to have hospital wards open and more nurses, doctors and consultants? That is where the money needs to be spent – at the coalface.
People are leaving the medical profession because they do not have development opportunity due to being over-worked, over-stretched and starved of resources. What this Government has done in the past four and a half years is a disgrace in the management of the health services. Even with this health strategy, the issue in the next general election will be the mis-handling of the health services by this incompetent Government. I am glad we have the opportunity every so often to raise these issues in the House because we, as an Opposition, have come up with policies that we are willing to put in place that will give proper health services to all the citizens which is what they are justly entitled to.
Comment on this
The motion we put down stated that we want to ensure that poor people would get medical cards. The Government has turned it into a motion praising itself for its action on waiting lists. There are two eminent doctors on the Government bench and it is a shame this Government has not dealt with the waiting lists. We have a health strategy policy because the Government has suddenly realised, in its fifth year in office and in the run up to a general election, that there is a health crisis.
A woman in my constituency had a relative who was called off a waiting list for a procedure. She had died seven years previously. This is documented fact in Galway. The longest period of time a person has been on a waiting list in Galway, acknowledged to me in a letter from the chief executive, is ten years. Is that any kind of health service? According to the strategy of the Government and the Department of Health and Children, adults must be on a waiting list no longer than 12 months and children no longer than six months. The figures for University College Hospital, Galway show that for ENT, there are 386 people on the list, that 262 of them, or 67%, have been waiting more than 12 months. Some 122 people, or 44%, have been waiting more than 12 months for ophthalmology, 103 or 80% have been waiting more than 12 months for plastic surgery and I could go on and on.
The Minister of State at the Department of Health and Children, Deputy Moffatt, spoke about appointing consultants. The Minister for Health, Deputy Martin, told me in reply to a Dáil question that a consultant neurologist was sanctioned for University College Hospital, Galway in January 2000. Because of the red tape involved that consultant has not yet been appointed and will not be appointed until well into next year, two years after sanctioning. Will the Government cop itself on about its health strategy, consultants and waiting lists?
Comment on this
I will share time with the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid.
The crucial feature of the new health strategy is that it proposes to extend medical card coverage to cover more people on low incomes. It will also have an increased target to ensure more children are covered and that over 200,000 additional persons will be covered by medical cards during the period of the strategy. That is a stated commitment. We can say to the people that we will do this if returned to Government next year.
Comment on this
It is not very clear what will happen if the Opposition is returned. Deputy Mitchell addressed the House this evening as the health spokesperson of the principal Opposition party and suggested that the decision of the Government to extend free medical card access to elderly persons was wrong. He instanced cases of persons who should not have obtained medical cards. Let us be realistic. There was a substantial increase in medical card provision last year which has to be accommodated by the medical profession and must be implemented through the health board system. That is being done. It is a cheap political gimmick for the Opposition parties, in an election year, to come out and promise the people medical cards they know they cannot give out. The people think all we are doing is engaging in cheap political games.
Comment on this
They think we are engaging in cheap political games instead of addressing the real problems of the health service. The key problems of the health service are ones of priorities. This year the Government has committed additional funding to provide 650 extra acute hospital beds and is addressing the waiting list problem through a new treatment purchase fund. I agree with Deputies Reynolds and McCormack that the waiting list problem is the greatest scan dal of our health service. That is the reason it is top of the list as far as Government priority is concerned in the coming year.
The treatment purchase team will be established in 2002. It can buy services from both public and private hospitals to meet the defined laid out targets in the health strategy, but what has the Labour Party said to this? It suggests a further increase in free hospital coverage for the entire population. That will not be implemented by the end of 2002. It is an ambitious strategy which may have some intellectual merit, but it has a considerable problem. It would result in a vast increase in public expenditure on health services when we have already seen a substantial increase since the last general election in 1997.
All Members of the House must recognise that management of the health service in an efficient cost effective way that provides a decent service for the patient should be our priority. There is no point coming in here week after week cherrypicking the health service and picking out one isolated issue and pretending that issue can be addressed through cheap abuse and point scoring off the Government. Let the Opposition face up to the fact that the Minister has produced a health strategy which has commanded and secured substantial public support.
Comment on this
The increase in expenditure on the health service has been substantial under the present Administration. In fact, the historic under-provision in the health service was not addressed the last time the Labour Party had the health portfolio in the years from 1995 to 1997. I do not want to have to refer to those years, but if provoked on the issue, I will because the Government has a sound, well thought out, common sense strategy. What is most interesting about it is the confidence expressed in it by those who work to provide the health and medical service in this country.
Comment on this
I thank the Opposition for providing the House with the opportunity to discuss the reform of the health system and, in particular, the medical card system. As Deputy Lenihan stated, this issue is being used as an exercise in political opportunism. I remind the House that the previous Minister for Health and Children is now the leader of the Fine Gael Party and the previous Minister for Finance is now the leader of the Labour Party.
We all know people who have been let down by a system that has been underfunded for decades and the frustration, hurt and anger which these failures have caused. For decades the system went underfunded, and crying out for reform, but in the two years prior to 1997, when Deputy Noonan was Minister for Health and Children and Deputy Quinn was Minister for Finance, when money was available—
Comment on this
—there was a notable absence of any Government commitment from those speaking on the issue tonight. I listened to Deputies Quinn, McManus, Gilmore and others tonight, but it is a fact that in the three budgets for which the Opposition was responsible during its period in government it never touched on the medical card issue. The Government, in the past four budgets, has consistently improved the medical card scheme, most notably last year when it extended it to include those over 70 years of age. The rhetoric of the Opposition is not matched by any workable policy now or any credible record of the past.
Again, I remind Members that when Deputy Noonan was Minister for Health and Children and Deputy Quinn was Minister for Finance they cut the waiting list budget in the winter of 1996 and 1997 from £12 million to £8 million. Are we now supposed to believe that they have had some form of Pauline conversion and that at last they are concerned about the health service? Their record does not stand up on this. Not once in three budgets did they touch on the medical card issue.
Comment on this
Reforming the health system is a complex and long-term project which requires a thorough and workable strategy and sustained investment. It also requires specific targets and specific means of achieving them. It takes a hard neck for the Opposition, particularly Deputies Quinn and Noonan, to table a motion on health care and, above all, on medical card eligibility. While I welcome the Opposition's late interest, the people will not be fooled by this latest Pauline conversion.
Comment on this
I must ask the Opposition, taking its past record into consideration, if we can really trust it on the health issue. Instead of having the courage to stand up and support the Government's health strategy we have instead political opportunism at its worst.
The extension of the medical card to those over the age of 70 years has made a huge difference to many who in their later years tend to suffer more from poorer and deteriorating health. It is a fact of life that old people generally have more cause to visit their doctor than others. Medical cards are only one aspect of health reform. By extending eligibility at this time, a substantial amount of funding would be used in paying capitation fees to the general practitioners of cardholders. Figures of 200,000 to 250,000 people, to whom the scheme should be extended, were quoted tonight, but extension of eligibility will include many—
Comment on this
—who never – I will address the Deputy's point – or rarely need to avail of the benefits of a medical card, yet they will be taken into account because the capitation fee will be paid regardless of whether the cardholder seeks assistance.
Comment on this
I estimate that up to 80% of the people that the Labour Party wants to include will not need a medical card. A small percentage of young married couples with children should be included, but 80% of the 250,000 people whom the Labour Party wants to include will never need a medical card. They will be in pubs, sports clubs and discos while £80 million is paid in capitation fees to GPs.
I am refusing a £20,000 annual income into my practice, just as Deputy McManus's husband would, because it is the GPs who will benefit from the scheme. All available funding for health services should be channelled into areas where it will directly affect those in need of treatment. The health strategy—
Comment on this
I ask the Minister to withdraw remarks made about someone outside the House. He should not impugn someone else's professionalism.
Comment on this
I said it is GPs who will benefit from the scheme and I would prefer that 80% of the £80 million be channelled to health boards for services or as capital.
Comment on this
I did not know that the Minister was still in practice. Is he still practising as a GP?
Comment on this
The health strategy contains major reforms of our health system. Everything cannot be done at once and change will not happen overnight, but we have started something that has the potential for change. No one disputes that there is a need to bring low income young couples with children into the medical card system, but I dispute the figure of 250,000 and know the people who would benefit.
Comment on this
The Government is committed to extending the scheme to those families and, unlike the previous Government, we have a strategy that will deliver on the commitment.
Comment on this
I am glad of the opportunity to make a short contribution. I welcome the publication of the excellent health strategy which provides a comprehensive programme to deal with our society's future health needs. It is the result of proper and full studies of the entire health service. We have the reports on medical manpower and junior hospital doctors' working practices, the commission on nursing, the strategic assessment of hospital capacity and the national consultative forum which facilitates the input of health stakeholders into the national health strategy. Through a progressive programme of research and negotiation, a quality, well founded strategy was developed, which will stand the test of time.
We should bear in mind that Government spending on the health service has more than doubled since 1997. The biggest ever increase in hospital activity will occur this year. The total staffing figure for the public health service has increased from about 68,000 in 1997 to 86,000 today. There are 1,700 extra nurses in the health service. A record number of nursing students are training this year while the number of nurse training places is at an all time high of 1,640. I welcome the fact that the report of the commission on nursing is being implemented fully with major improvements in conditions and support for nursing staff.
There is a major capital investment programme in my county, County Cavan. I am sure there are similar programmes in other counties. I thank the Ministers, Deputies Cowen and Martin, and the Minister of State, Deputy Moffatt, for their decision to allocate major funding to the North-Eastern Health Board to enable it to provide an operational 30 bed nursing unit and community health facility in Ballyconnell, a 50 bed nursing unit and health centre under construction in Virginia, a major health care unit under construction at Cootehill and major developments planned for Cavan General Hospital. These are the results of decisions made by the Ministers to provide a proper health infrastructure in rural Ireland. I am glad that these investment programmes are taking place because of the Government's good management of the economy and the provision of facilities for our health service.
Beneath the Labour Party's rhetoric is the infamous insurance company health plan which would shut local hospitals. It would place an insurance company between the patient and the hospital bed. It is a system which has been repeatedly shown to increase funding for administration at patients' expense. Its policy document clearly states that "public and voluntary hospitals will be required to cover their operating costs through income from health insurers and patient co-payments where applicable." This would mean, in effect, that smaller hospitals which could not win service contracts from private health insurers may have to close or, at least, cut their level of service. A year on the Labour Party relaunched the document and again conceded that smaller local hospitals, which could not provide cheap services could "find themselves excluded from insurers lists of approved facilities." The vociferous call for reform from the Labour Party benches does not rest easy with the policy of hospital closure.
Fine Gael initially dismissed entirely the Labour Party policy, but then changed its mind. In February 2000 its spokesperson, Deputy Shatter, stated, "Whether the necessary reform can be brought about by the introduction of a universal health insurance system is questionable. What is needed is less, not more bureaucracy." All of us agree that we do not need more bureaucracy in the health service, yet in November 2000 Fine Gael, in its health plan for the nation, announced a consultative process in which the insurance company policy would be discussed.
Beneath the Labour Party's rhetoric is a policy that would increase administration costs and shut local hospitals. Despite its opposition to the health strategy, in its pre-budget statement last Sunday, it makes no mention of health. Plainly, its focus is elsewhere.
I am glad that the Government, the Minister and Minister of State in particular, have devised a health strategy which is sound and will deliver the level of health service to which the people are entitled. It will deliver an additional 3,000 hospital beds – 650 next year. Rightly, by the end of 2002 no adult will wait more than 12 months for treatment and no child more than six. By the end of 2003 no adult will wait more than six months for treatment and no child more than three. By the end of 2004 no public patient will wait more than three months for treatment. These are achievable targets and a level of service to which people are entitled.
During the years my health board, the North-Eastern Health Board, has bought in services from the North, which was beneficial for those awaiting hip and cataract procedures. I endorse the establishment of the treatment purchase fund. Wherever services are available, in the North, Britain or elsewhere, every effort should be made to buy them to ensure our patients are treated as quickly as possible.
Comment on this
I congratulate the Minister and the Government on the publication of the health strategy, which is a new direction and states that medical cards will be extended to more families with children and people with disabilities being the priority. I welcome the emphasis on increasing bed numbers because we lost out on beds in the 1980s. In particular, I welcome progress in County Galway where, in recent weeks, the Mini ster announced an allocation of £3 million for the Western Health Board to purchase the Bons Secours hospital, which will ensure Tuam has a community hospital. He also announced an allocation of £11 million to purchase Portiuncula Hospital, Ballinasloe from the Sisters of the Franciscan Missionaries of the Divine Motherhood. Portiuncula Hospital has played a very important role in the provision of public hospital services in the region in the past 50 years under the stewardship of the order and it is important that it be retained as a provider of public hospital services, now that the order has decided to withdraw. The purchase of the hospital by the Western Health Board will ensure the acute hospital services will continue to be provided to the public at Portiuncula Hospital and it will facilitate the expansion and development of services in the future.
I pay tribute to the sisters at Portiuncula and the Bon Secours sisters in Tuam for their dedication to caring for people and all their work over the years to provide hospital services for the people of the area.
The Minister has said waiting lists are down substantially for the first half of 2001. There are also regional issues that the Minister should look at. There are a large number of people in the Western Health Board area who must travel outside the area to get medical treatment. The Government is committed to improvements in the west and I welcome the developments in University College Hospital in Galway concerning cancer and heart treatment. I have mentioned the new developments proposed for Tuam and Ballinasloe. I look forward to the day when patients from the west do not have to travel to the Mater Hospital, Beaumont or St. James's Hospital and can have treatment in their own region. I have often been told that patients from Galway cannot get treatment in Dublin because there is a shortage of beds and this must be addressed.
An additional neurological centre is needed in the west. People with head injuries need treatment as quickly as possible and at present, they must go to Dublin or Cork. I urge the Government to support the effort to put this unit in place.
I welcomed the statement by the Minister that a treatment purchase scheme will buy services from both public and private hospitals to meet targets for the years 2002, 2003 and 2004. I welcome the announcement that 800 adult community nursing beds per annum will be available over the next seven years. I urge the Government to support the many projects that involve the retirement villages planned throughout the country. In particular, I commend Dr. Cowley in County Mayo for his initiative. He has given a lead to other communities in rural areas and I thank him for his advice and help.
One of the achievements of this Government is the extra funding for persons with an intellectual disability and those with autism. There are now extra residential respite and day places available. The number of people with a disability in psychiatric hospitals has been reduced from 970 in 1996 to 571 now. I hope these new residential places will be as near to the people's homes as possible.
I hope the Western Health Board will continue to support the Brothers of Charity and the Galway County Association for Children with a Disability so that they can continue their good work. The Minister, Deputy Martin, and his predecessor, Deputy Cowen, have been very pro-active in giving priority to people with disability.
Death rates from coronary heart disease in Ireland are considerably higher than the EU average. I welcome the planned recruitment of 800 professionals throughout the community in the first two years of implementation. I congratulate the Minister on the measures he has introduced, both in prevention and rehabilitation. I wish the Government well with the new national health strategy.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputy O'Flynn. I welcome the opportunity to speak on the debate on health tonight. I welcome the publication of the national health strategy by the Government. This motion was tabled by members of the Labour Party, despite the fact that during their time in the rainbow coalition the medical card eligibility was not increased significantly. Now they present themselves as the great advocates of the health service. They left it to us to give medical cards to all people over 70, to develop the health targets as part of the national anti-poverty strategy, to start the job of reform in the area of disability and they now speak about equality, access and reform as if they had ever done anything about these important areas.
Under the national development plan, annual capital health spending is almost three times that of the previous Government. Our hospitals are treating more people than ever before. The past year alone has seen an extra 52,000 people treated in our hospitals, the largest ever increase in hospital activity. In the area of disability, we have turned the tide on the shameful trend of neglect. By the end of this year, we will have invested additional revenue and capital funding amounting to £205 million in services for people with either an intellectual disability or autism. Since 1997, more than £107 million in additional funding has been allocated for services to people with physical and sensory disability.
I am not saying all is rosy in the health service it is plainly not. However, the investment is being put into the service for the first time and this will deliver results. The new health strategy is a continuation of that process. Built on years of research and negotiation, it represents the path forward in health reform. There will be 3,000 new beds in the system, 650 of these in the first year. By the end of the second year, no adult will wait more than 12 months for treatment. By the end of 2003, no adult will wait longer than six months and by the end of year four, no public patient will be on a waiting list for more than three months. Some people might say these are loose targets. However, when we went into Government we had four key tasks including restoring peace, and reducing tax and unemployment. We have delivered on these and we will deliver on the health strategy.
Enormous effort has been put in by the Minister, Deputy Martin, his predecessor, Deputy Cowen and the Cabinet. In a number of years time, those of us who will be privileged enough to still be Members of these Houses will be able to say that the national health strategy put in place in 2001 was the beginning of the great new health service that we have.
Comment on this
The rainbow Government in the mid 1990s was harsh on the poor and harshest on the health system.
Comment on this
Thankfully, the then Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, continued the policies of the previous Government, which was one of our Governments, and for the first time in the history of the State, a considerable amount of money was available to him. The Minister for Health in that Government, Deputy Noonan, had for the first time in seven years the funds to effect real reform and improvement in the health service, but the wealth was not spread among the poor and needy. The opportunity to reform the health service was not availed of. The total health spend over the life of that Government was a meagre £400 million. It failed to put money into cutting waiting lists. It failed to provide new nurse training places. It simply failed to fund the health service. Deputy Quinn has admitted that concerns about the future of the medical profession, particularly about the nursing profession, were communicated to him and that he was disappointed he had not put systems in place and had not dwelt more on the health system when he was Minister for Finance.
Cork has done very well.
Comment on this
I commend the Minister, Deputy Martin and his predecessor, Deputy Cowen for what they have done for Cork. We were neglected from 1995 to 1997. A new maternity hospital costing £80 million has come on stream. There are new accident and emergency facilities and a new cardiac unit in Cork University Hospital. The South Infirmary and the Mercy Hospital have done well. I was there deputising for the lord mayor yesterday when the Minister for Health and Children opened a new oncology unit. This is the kind of investment which I and the constituents I represent want. This is the kind of investment Fianna Fáil in Government has delivered and will continue to deliver under the new health strategy. Through this strategy we offer our constituents definite reductions in waiting lists. We offer them a system whereby hospital appointments made for 9 a.m. will mean that and not 11 a.m. or noon as at present.
Comment on this
We will improve the system. In one year we will have 650 additional acute hospital beds. We will tackle waiting lists through a new treatment purchase fund. We are very fortunate to have a Cork man, Deputy Micheál Martin, as our Minister for Health and Children doing a fantastic job. I hope the Opposition joins with us and votes for the amendment the Government has tabled.
Comment on this
I wish to share my time with Deputies Bell, Rabbitte, O'Sullivan, Kenny, Deenihan and Ó Caoláin.
Comment on this
I am glad to have the opportunity to contribute to this debate tonight. I am beginning to wonder if some people are living in cloud cuckooland. While the health strategy announced by the Minister for Health and Children last week promised some improvements in the funding and delivery of health care, it did little to address the fundamental inequalities that characterise our health service. The two-tier system which condemns public patients to months and sometimes years of suffering, while private patients are given priority, remains firmly in place. Even if the increased spending which has been promised by the Minister takes place, we will still have a system which is one of the most inequitable in the developed world. We have a system with a nominally free hospital service, but the fear of public hospital waiting lists has driven almost 45% of the population into private health care.
We still have a system which charges 70% of the population for GP visits and where people on low incomes pay a significant contribution to health spending in their payments to GPs and for medicines, while private health insurance contributes approximately 9% of all health spending. We still have a system whereby private care in public hospitals is heavily subsidised by the taxpayers, many of whom cannot afford to avail of such care.
The Minister for Health and Children must be aware that one in four voters puts health care at the top of the list of issues on which the next election should be fought. People throughout the country are asking why, at a time of extraordinary economic growth, many people are on waiting lists. These people are often in pain and many of them will suffer permanent impairment as a result of delayed treatment. They are also asking why, at a time of rapidly increasing incomes and medical costs, the income limit for eligibility for medical cards is below the average industrial wage. At a time when our economic growth is said to create two new millionaires a week, why must some parents reduce their spending on food to pay for essential medical care for their children? Is the Minister aware that free and equitable health care is taken for granted in many developed countries?
Despite being a long time in gestation, the health strategy is largely a series of ad hoc measures and quick fix solutions which the Government hopes will deflect the wrath of the electorate. There is no radical reappraisal of how our health care system can best be funded and organised to meet the needs of our increasing population. The strategy does not show any commitment to tackle the vested interests particularly of hospital consultants whose contacts give them an opportunity to use private beds in public hospitals. In Denmark, which has one of the best medical care systems in the EU, hospital consultants are paid less for their work in the public sector. Consultants in Denmark are remarkable because they oppose the extension of private medical care. It is hardly surprising that 90% of Danes are satisfied with their medical care system, which is the highest satisfaction rate in the EU.
My family depended on a medical card which gave them access to medical services. Without it my family, like many others, would have had to make choices. Parents who need to go to a doctor might stay at home to provide the necessary finance to allow their children to go to the doctor. I am perplexed that someone who is diagnosed with cancer is put through the ringer to get a medical card. As soon as someone gets that news, a medical card should be provided immediately. Some of my family were in that situation. As someone who has lost aunts and uncles from asthma and bronchitis, I cannot understand why a humane society cannot provide medical cards to people with such illnesses. The Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, knows more about this than I do. People can die from such diseases. This area should be examined.
An aspect of the health strategy which has not received much attention is health promotion. It appears from the Estimates that expenditure on health promotion might be reduced this year. The Minister is aware of the frightening level of consumption of alcohol, tobacco and narcotics by young people which will eventually lead to health problems. I am sure he is also aware that the fitness levels of school children are low compared to other EU countries. Many of us, including myself, eat unhealthy diets. More resources need to be devoted to health promotion to avoid huge increases in health care costs in the future. Finland, which once had a level of heart disease simi lar to Ireland, has reduced it dramatically through effective health promotion.
I remember reading about Aneurin Bevan and the opposition he encountered while setting up the NHS. In his memoirs he recalled getting a letter from an old woman in Lancashire who had worked in a cotton mill from the age of 12. She wrote to thank him for the spectacles she had received under the NHS which enabled her to write letters. She ended her letter with a prayer: "Dear God, reform thy world beginning with me." I doubt if the Minister for Health and Children will get many such letters, but he should ponder the old woman's wish.
Comment on this
I listened with great interest to the debate and it is interesting to hear some of the speakers on the Government side. I do not know what is happening in other health board areas, such as Donegal and Cork, but the contributions do not reflect what is happening in the north-east region. I was surprised at Deputy Brendan Smith's contribution. The situation is completely and utterly different from what Government speakers stated here tonight. There are empty wards and beds in every hospital in the north-east region. There is a lack of nurses and medical staff at every level. As a qualified GP, the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, should know that better than anyone.
Comment on this
It is not only happening in Drogheda and Dundalk, but in every town throughout the country. Beds are lying idle, while people are lying on trolleys in the corridors and in emergency beds in waiting areas for hours. If one was to take the non-EU staff out of the hospitals in my area, they would fold up overnight. Most of the staff are non-EU citizens and Asians who had to be brought in because people will not work in the health services as they have lost confidence in the Government and its health policy. One has only to look at the national newspapers every day, particularly at weekends, to see the hundreds and thousands of pounds being spent trying to get consultants and nursing staff. Various incentives are being thought up to entice them into the health service. It is not possible to get nurses to accept jobs in Dublin. I know nurses from my own town who gave up nursing and are now working in Dublin in other professions because they were not paid enough for the hours they worked.
Orthodontic treatment in the north-east region is non-existent. Perhaps the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, will tell me how many are on the waiting list for orthodontic treatment in Donegal. I am sure the position is as bad there as it is in County Louth – if it is not, there is something wrong. I cannot get any positive response from the North-Eastern Health Board about orthodontic treatment. People must go from Drogheda, Dundalk and elsewhere in County Louth to Newry and other parts of Northern Ireland where they must pay more than £3,000 in some cases.
Comment on this
Why would someone work in the public service if he or she can get £3,000 for each case?
Comment on this
The Minister knows that because he lives in the Border area, like I do. People cannot get treatment because they cannot afford to pay for it. It is cheaper in Northern Ireland. People are borrowing money from the credit union on a never-never basis to have their children's teeth treated. The waiting list is miles long – it would stretch from Drogheda to Dundalk. I cannot understand people saying there is not a problem with waiting lists. Another area of concern is hip replacements. How long does it take for someone to get a hip replacement operation? There is one unit in Navan which does a good job, but it cannot cope with the waiting lists.
The man who made the biggest contribution to the health services in my area was Deputy Howlin. He saved the North-Eastern Health Board and other health boards from bankruptcy by giving them a substantial cash injection to wipe out the deficits. He put proper health policies in place in each of the health board areas. Instead of that position improving when we had the cash, it has got much worse. The biggest problem we had to deal with in our clinics used to be people having to wait two years to get a telephone. Thankfully that is no longer the case. Subsequently it was unemployment, but any Member of this House will tell the Government, quite openly, that the biggest issues we face in our clinics now are health related. They are in the North-Eastern Health Board area. The main issue relates to medical cards. The system is an absolute disgrace. People are coming into my clinics crying. There are women who cannot go to the doctor because they cannot afford to pay the fee or for the prescriptions. Some of these women are paying £5 a week on the "never never" so that they can get a prescription when one of the family gets sick. In my town people are paying £5 per week to the doctor and getting a receipt for it every week because they cannot afford to pay the bills. If we could only admit that there is a serious problem, we could do something about it. This is the most outrageous decision of all, because it hurts the most vulnerable in our community.
Comment on this
I have heard the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, Deputy Brian Lenihan and other Members on the Fianna Fáil benches, throw at us on the other side of the House what happened when other Governments were in office. That is extraordinary, coming from Fianna Fáil, a party that has been in Government for 12 of the past 14 years. Its members seem to have forgotten that the man they lionised, former Deputy Ray MacSharry, is directly responsible for the gap that has to be made up in the health services. I do not know why they want to look to this side of the House for explanations when the fact is that we now have wealth which we did not have when Ray MacSharry was Minister. Is this the way to use that wealth?
I listened to Deputy O'Flynn talking about the bad years and he looks like a man who weathered them reasonably well. The health services in Cork are in fine fettle according to him, but that is unknown to us in the rest of the House. It is remarkable how quickly this Government has grown remote from the people as evidenced by the Minister for Health and Children slipping on a banana skin of this size. Even the Minister's most ardent and well-placed supporters – we have seen some in recent days – are taken aback by his blunder on medical card eligibility limits. This was the immediate acid test of his eleventh hour health strategy. Fine rhetoric for reform and promises of what will happen when the Minister is no longer in office are all very well, but what about the here and now? There is, after all, a general election around the corner and we all remember the surprise expressed by the Taoiseach's mentor, Mr. Haughey, when he went to meet the people in 1989.
The present health strategy is an attempt by this Government to retaliate first. The media – and thus the public – was generally well disposed, even if the end of a term of office is an unusual time to promulgate a health strategy. The test must be what actual reforms this Government implements in the time left to it. Enhanced eligibility for medical cards would have been a practical reform on the way to a free GP service. Given the extent to which our health services are characterised by inequality, extending the medical card scheme would at least acknowledge the core problem. The Minister purports to acknowledge that reform of the primary care system will help contain the pressure on acute hospitals, but he has blown it. He managed to persuade the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, to ignore the publication of a glossy document underpinned by notional billions for the future, but he could not manage to persuade Deputy McCreevy to approve a small step to tackle an inequality that causes so much hardship. This calculated rejection of poor people is perfectly consistent coming from this Government.
Everything this Government has touched in four and a half years has widened the gap between the very well off and those struggling to make ends meet. The IMO has said that the Minister's decision will "undermine the Minister's own health strategy's guiding principles". The Society of St. Vincent de Paul has pointed out that more families on the minimum wage are "turning to the Society for money for doctor's bills and for medication". Professor Tom O'Dowd, who has carried out studies in my constituency and is based in the Mary Mercer Health Centre in Jobstown, has noted that 25% of male patients in their fifties were "putting off going to see the doctor because of the cost". In his professional view this is a very vulnerable group with a high risk of cardiac failure. I do not say this Minister's failure with regard to medical cards sets his health strategy at nought. I, along with his party's backbenchers and many groups outside this House, say that the credibility to be attached to the health strategy is greatly diminished. For thousands of poor people it is more serious than that. People on low wages in indifferent health must continue to pay to visit their GPs or else go without and it is an intolerable disgrace if that is to be the legacy of this Government at the end of the boom. I note that if this motion is to be carried tonight it will depend on the votes of the likes of Deputy Healy-Rae, whom I notice is quoted in a south Kerry local newspaper to the effect that he does not need to come in here and vote and make loud speeches. All he has to do is go to the office of the Chief Whip where he will meet the Minister for Health and Children and get bags of medical cards. It would be much better if Deputy Healy-Rae came in here tonight and voted to support this motion and to share the bag of medical cards with the rest of the country.
Comment on this
We are spending three hours talking about something which is very simple. It is about the right of access to basic primary health care. It is extraordinary that this issue has not been prioritised by a Government that has so much money and that we are only getting its health strategy on the eve of a general election. The Government is totally out of step with the people. It does not recognise that the right to access primary care should be an absolute priority. If one does not have access to basic primary care, what rights does one have in health care? What would we say if somebody did not have a right to basic primary education?
The issue of health has been left to be dealt with later. What is being said is that a couple with two children and who are earning less than £200 per week do not have the right to go to their GP. They have to make a choice. When their child is sick they have to think about whether they can afford to go to a GP based on how sick the child is. They have to decide if they can wait to see if the child gets better or grows worse or if that is too great a risk to take.
Comment on this
We are living in a wealthy economy and have the money to spend on this most basic of problems. This is something that will come back to haunt this Government. Given that billions of pounds have been discussed in regard to this health strategy and its complications over the past week, this is the simplest of issues. It is the one that should have been concentrated on. It is extraordinary to hear Deputy McDaid implying that the strenuous opposition of the IMO to the Government's proposal might be motivated by self interest. That seemed to be what he implied when he said the money would go into the pockets of the GPs. The IMO strenuously objected to the decision that was made. Is the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation suggesting that the Society of St. Vincent de Paul might be motivated by self interest in its opposition to the Government's decision? I have sat and listened for approximately an hour to the bombast that has come from the Government side of the House. No attention has been paid to the issue that we have put on the table which is one of access and civil rights for every citizen. What is at issue is the right to have health care needs addressed when a person is sick. The Government will have to go back and look at the decision it has made.
I will make an economic argument which might reach the ears of the Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy. If I were a working person on such an income, I would ask the reason I was working and if I would not be much better off if I had my medical card and did not have my job. That is a genuine economic argument which might be of interest to the Minister because he does not appear to respond to the human stories behind the widespread opposition to this decision.
I will give one human story which I heard this morning. I spoke with an elderly person over 70 years who qualified for a medical card this year. She said she would have much preferred to see her grandchild receive the card because they did not have access to one. She had seen the mother of the child having to decide whether to balance the household budget or take the child to the doctor. That is how basic this issue is.
Comment on this
I believe the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Martin, has the best interests of patients and the people at heart and that he would like to be the Minister who set down a landmark strategy which ensured a health culture was brought about where health bills were reduced and those in need of medical attention received it. This ten year strategy with a price tag of £10 billion was presented with a veneer of competence. The reality of its implementation is far removed from the slick public relations we witnessed.
In every one of past ten general elections in which I have participated there has been a major blunder by the Government in office before the election. I recall the former Taoiseach, Charles Haughey, admitting he did not know the position of haemophiliacs was as serious as it was, the late former Minister Boland saying prescriptions would not be issued from rural pharmacies, and the former Minister for Education and Science, Gemma Hussey, proposing to remove school transport from medical card holders. In each of these campaigns, despite overall figures being shown to be for the good of the country, the issue people understood became the one close to their hearts.
After presenting what is a worthwhile document in many respects and following with a worthwhile document in the context of a community network of care, to follow with a major blunder of excluding 200,000 people from the general medical service scheme who would be eligible next year, while not the Minister's fault, is an indication of how the Government feels about the people. The slogan in the previous election was "People before politics." It appears to be reversed now.
I have a letter from a woman in my town who must wait two years for a tonsillectomy. Her neighbour has a daughter who has blackouts and been assessed as not having epilepsy but who must wait six months for a brain scan in Beaumont Hospital. These are the issues with which these people must deal every day.
In respect of the Government's amendment, which states that funding for disability services increased massively, how does this relate to the young woman—
Comment on this
There are five minutes remaining and two further Members are sharing the time allotted.
Comment on this
There has been misinformation on the guidelines for medical card holders. If one is a single person under 66 years, living alone and earning more than £100, one cannot get a medical card. If one is a single person living with one's family, the threshold is £89. It is £144.50 for married couples under 66 years of age. This rules out anyone who is working or on a low income. As a result, the people concerned cannot avail of the services of a doctor. Minor ailments can become serious and lead to death because people cannot go to a doctor because they do not have the money in their pockets. Doctors are not charitable organisations. The people concerned might go once or twice because the doctor might be kind to them, but they cannot afford to go generally. The health service is not coping with the needs of the underprivileged. Our health status is not what it would be if a proper health service was available and there was proper access to primary care services which the current system does not allow.
I heard a number of Members on the Government side defending the Minister's record on waiting lists. The chief executive of the Southern Health Board announced today that the out-patient waiting list in Tralee General Hospital had been reduced from 5,173 to 3,790. He said that was as a result of verification of the waiting list. Many of those on the waiting list for five years or more were dead. I know this because they were called for procedures and were found to be dead. Others on the list had made other arrangements for treatment. There was an attempt to deceive the people by saying this was a decrease in the numbers on the out-patient waiting list. It is misleading the public and the Minister should correct it.
Comment on this
It is patently obvious that the long delay in producing the Government health strategy had nothing to do with the extent of the work involved, rather it had everything to do with the fact that there was no clear leadership and no direction at Cabinet as to how to put right our grossly inequitable health system. The Taoiseach let the Ministers for Health and Children and Finance fight it out. We are on the side of the Minister for Health and Children.
The health strategy was unveiled with great fanfare and the Government then told us it would not take the one vital short-term action needed, namely, to extend medical card eligibility. Nothing is to be done on medical cards in the remaining term of the Government. We are told the planned extension will not begin until 2003, budgetary considerations permitting.
The Minister for Finance, Deputy McCreevy, won the argument. That is the reality, plain and simple. He has once again had his way. More significantly, the Taoiseach did not take the lead and ensure action was taken in tomorrow's budget to help those most in need in our health system. We have heard the initial extension of medical cards to 200,000 people would have cost £80 million. In 2001, the Minister for Finance reduced corporation tax at a cost of £214 million. That shows the priorities of the Government. The profit margins of big business come before the needs of families who cannot afford to bring their children to the doctor or buy essential medication because they are denied a medical card.
I call for the immediate extension of medical card eligibility to all under 18 years, to all on or below the minimum wage, and to all with disabilities or conditions such as asthma which necessitate expensive ongoing medication. My brother has Down's syndrome and long held a medical card, but I was shocked to learn recently at a meeting of the North-Eastern Health Board that there are many others with the same or similar intellectual disabilities who do not qualify. This is a disgrace and—
Comment on this
—after four and a half years of huge budget surpluses, the Government should hang its head in shame.
I support the Labour Party motion and indicate that we in Sinn Féin will face the battle in the upcoming general election on our policy of ending the gross inequalities in the two tier system of health care delivery in this State and the introduction of free and comprehensive health care for all.
Comment on this
The Minister, Deputy Martin, has set out the health strategy, building on the investment and services that are already in place. The strategy was developed because the Government thought it appropriate to implement the strategy developed by Deputy Howlin when he was Minister for Health. The time is now opportune to spell out where we see the health service going for the next ten years.
Comment on this
It did not come out of the blue because the strategy builds upon four and a half years of investment and development. The strategy is based on that.
Comment on this
I would ask Deputy Stagg to allow the Minister to continue as she has only five minutes.
Comment on this
It was interesting to hear Government speakers dealing with real issues and acknowledging the progress that has been made in tackling disability, cardiovascular disease and cancer, as well as managing the drug payments and medical card schemes. How quickly we have forgotten that people on the lowest incomes, the most vulnerable, and those who deserve them most such as the elderly were given medical cards. There is a commitment in the strategy to extend medical card eligibility to people on low incomes and those with more children.
Comment on this
That will happen in the lifetime of this strategy. We have no problem on this side of the House in addressing the real issues relating to health.
Comment on this
On the other hand, it took Deputy Gay Mitchell to launch a personal attack on the Minister, Deputy Martin. All he could focus on was an attack on the Minister's ability and achievements. I remind Deputy Mitchell that the Fine Gael Party spent all last week objecting to personalised comments, yet its Members did the very same in the House tonight. If Fine Gael Deputies have to resort to personalised attacks and cannot talk about the real issues, it shows that they do not realise what is happening as regards policy, planning and progress.
Comment on this
Much has been achieved during this Government's term of office and it is clear where we intend to go.
Comment on this
Nowhere is that clearer than in my area of responsibility, which has not been mentioned in the debate, involving the welfare of the most vulnerable children. The Government has not only set out the philosophy and policy which guides its thinking, but has also backed it up through legislation, supported it with investment and is delivering it through new structures. Major policies and guidelines have been set down for the protection of our children, which were not there before. These include the national children's strategy, the homeless strategy, which aims to reduce and eliminate homelessness, and the children first guidelines for the identification and reporting of abuse.
No one, either inside or outside the House, can say that real progress has not been made in this area. Policies and philosophies which are backed up by legislation are changing the focus of how we deal with children in these circumstances. This is particularly the case with the Children Act, which we have started to implement. The focus has changed from locking up children to ensuring that detention is used only as a last resort. More importantly, this has been backed by investment in recent years, with over £90 million extra being spent on these children.
Comment on this
One thousand children are homeless on the streets of Dublin. Why did the Minister not reach them?
Comment on this
This ensures that family support is there for them, that springboard projects are developed and that foster care is developed to the extent that the carer of every fostered child in the country now receives £210 per week.
Comment on this
It also provides residential care for the most vulnerable children because where formerly there were 17 special care places there are now 88. They can be staffed by child care workers who have received adequate salary increases backed up by a new career structure. The centres established by the Government have a social services inspectorate to ensure the highest standards.
Comment on this
All these services can, thus, be delivered by the national children's office and the residential social services board. The philosophy, legislation, investment and structures are there, more particularly for children than for anybody else. That is what the Government has achieved, not only for children but for the entire health service which is properly funded and well focused. It will continue that way through the development of our health strategy.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputies Michael D. Higgins and McManus.
Comment on this
The promise that 200,000 extra people were to receive medical cards in 2002 was welcome news indeed. It was a great Christmas present for many low income families, or so it seemed. After last Wednesday's shocking announcement, however, Christmas now appears much bleaker for 200,000 people. The announcement has hit the most vulnerable in society at the most difficult time of year. How can the Minister defend his position to a single mother who wakes up to hear her child crying in pain at 3 o'clock in the morning, but who cannot afford to call out a doctor because it would cost £40 or £50 to do so? How will the Minister explain his decision to an old age pensioner couple who, with an income from the State of £185 per week, do not qualify for a medical card? The guidelines dictate that such a couple can only earn £162 per week to qualify for the medical card scheme. Medical costs for such an elderly couple can be considerable, yet they are a miserable £23 over the limit for medical card eligibility.
Another example of the people who will be penalised by this appalling decision is a married couple with one child and an income equivalent to the minimum wage. All that couple can earn to qualify for a medical card is £162 per week. If their income exceeds that amount by a mere £10 or £12 they will not qualify for a medical card. They can appeal the decision but will be forced to jump through a series of hoops to get what is a basic requirement.
I could cite numerous examples of those who will fall victim to the harsh decisions of the Government in the year ahead. Last week, the Minister's paltry excuse was that he had to prioritise his health policy for the coming year. The Minister has a strange sense of priorities if he is telling us that old age pensioners or a married couple on low income represent a lower priority than a national stadium.
The Independent TDs who support the Government have much explaining to do to their constituents. They have been trying to limit the damage caused by this decision on the plinth all day, sending out conflicting signals about the extension of the medical card scheme. The Government's amendment to our motion, however, only says that it is committed to extending the medical card scheme to 200,000. Crucially, though, it does not say when it will do this. For that reason, the Government amendment must be defeated.
Comment on this
This important topic affects some of the poorest people in my constituency who often attend my advice centres in conditions of great stress. The view of the Minister, Deputy McDaid that 80% of those who might qualify if the medical card scheme was extended would never use it illustrates the fundamental distinction between our viewpoints on health. The issue is not whether one would use the scheme, but having the social protection it affords. There is an enormous difference between two things that divide us in the House. One is the restructuring of the sickness industry, which will welcome private money into what might be regarded as highly profitable activities that are now tax assisted and subsidised by the public purse for private gain – the sickness industry is yielding profit. The other is the health service with a set of guarantees.
When the history of the past five years comes to be written, the question will be asked what people said, or failed to say, about the health service. Claiming credit, often where it was not due, mention was made of the fact that we have the highest growth in the European Union. Many Ministers mentioned that, but few said that over this period of extraordinary wealth we were in the bottom two or three countries concerning social protection.
We have a miserable record in providing social protection for women, for example, who may be under great stress due to high rent, low income and many other problems. The rising cost of housing has had a major influence in the past five years. Rents have escalated while people have had to live in poor social housing conditions. The last straw for such people is when somebody becomes ill. There is nowhere for them to go because they cannot afford to be ill. The guaranteed social protection of the medial card, of its nature, addresses rights to health care. There are many good proposals in the health strategy with which I agree and some proposals for reform but I wonder how they came to gestation just six months before the election. Leaving that aside the fundamental question is what quality of social protection is available to citizens? That is what a health system is about. The stress is not even at the time of illness. At advice centres, one case after another – all Deputies on the other side know this – the question is what happens if one of us gets sick. It is the last straw that pushes people in poverty below the floor of poverty altogether. That is what this motion is about. It would cost £80 million to remove 200,000 of the most vulnerable citizens from such a situation. When the history comes to be written people will know that £80 million was not available in the best of times with the greatest surpluses. There is no need to go back over history about who did what. The question will be put this way: when the economy turned who had to wait? I can say who had to wait. In relation to the housing crisis, which I mentioned earlier, the landlords did not have to wait but the tenants had to wait. The tenants were told they would get their protection in 2002 but the landlords were looked after. In this case the 200,000 people have to wait until 2003 and even then there is no guarantee, it is conditional on what Government revenues will allow.
What always struck me at advice centres was that there are parents who would sacrifice anything for their children. The greatest stress that faced them was the possibility of not being able to bring their child to a doctor. There is another side to this as well. All the evidence of a socio-medical kind indicates that a visit deferred is putting the person at risk, that it would be more costly for the person in terms of their life and more costly for the State in relation to later care. Who has to wait and why? Those who have to wait have to do so because they have not been accorded the priority that an egalitarian approach would accord them. They are entitled by right to a health service. I have listened to all the speeches this evening. The fundamental difference is that on one side of the House, the Government says they will get it when the Government can afford to give it while people on this side talk about an extension of rights, the right to social protection, good health care and the right in a citizenship count.
I will say a word about what I believe to be the kind of degradation of politics that unfortunately is not sufficiently commented upon in this House. That is the suggestion that the medical card has a pre-history which goes back to the old blue card and the time when a person would get the notable in the parish who represented him on the board of guardians of the grand jury to put in a word for him for a blue card. That is what Deputy Jackie Healy-Rae reminds me of. He will not come into the House to speak of the right of every citizen to have a medical card but he will go to the Chief Whip's office where he can meet the Minister for Finance and the Minister for Health and Children and get whatever he likes. That is the kind of statement about behaviour that has degraded politics. I hope the public will have an opportunity soon to express their opinion on it.
I knew people who put the health system before the sickness industry. I knew people such as the late Dr. Paddy Leahy and others who looked at people and saw what they needed and were willing to fight publicly for it. I feel like that about what is happening this evening. Deputy Lenihan argued that a person can get his rights when everything else is in place. Speaking about medical cards for 200,000 people is playing a cheap political game. It is about when the economy turns and those who are asked to wait. It is not speculators in housing who will have to wait but tenants, not those who will invest and make money out of the sickness industry but the 200,000 who might have got medical cards that would have given them some social protection. That is why the motion is important.
Comment on this
I thank the Labour Party Deputies who contributed to this debate and the Members of the Opposition who supported the motion. I listened with interest to Government Deputies who contributed and I was reminded of Alice in Wonderland because it appeared that the one message to the people in need was that they could have had the medical card yesterday, maybe they will get it tomorrow but they should not expect it today. It is worth reminding the Government that a promise was made and commitments were indicated in the run up to the health strategy that were dashed when the Minister for Health and Children announced that far from the expectation being realised there would be no granting of medical cards for 200,000 people in 2002. Is it any wonder that organisations such as the Society of St. Vincent de Paul were appalled and shocked when that news became known and expressed their views so forcefully.
It is dispiriting that a once great party like Fianna Fáil should be so out of touch with the needs of ordinary working people. That was not always the case. Ordinary working people, many of whom voted for Fianna Fáil at the last election, believed in the slogan "people before politics". When Fianna Fáil was elected to Government the same people believed the Government when it said it would tackle the hospital waiting lists. Fianna Fáil and the Progressive Democrats poured money into hospital waiting lists but the numbers have not reduced significantly. There are 26,000 approximately on hospital waiting lists after millions of pounds have been squandered in trying to tackle a problem that requires structural reform, if it is ever to be tackled. Some 200,000 people thought matters would get better for them in the same way that they have got so much better in the country generally, particularly for the better off.
We have seen a growing disparity between rich and poor. If one is very poor and on social welfare one has a medical card. For those whose income just exceeds the limit, life is still a struggle. Parents are worried that maybe a child will get sick and that they may have to call out the doctor. Even if they can afford to pay for the doctor how in God's name will they pay for the medication? That the Minister for Tourism, Sport and Recreation, Deputy McDaid, should say 80% of these people would not need or use a medical card is extraordinary coming from a man who is surely better able to understand what happens in society. When one is living on a low income one runs a far greater risk of experiencing sickness. You, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, would understand that the better off in society live longer and generally have healthier lives and that those on low incomes suffer to a greater degree from ill health and stress. One can imagine how much greater the stress levels when one is worried about whether one can afford to pay the doctor. This is a simple measure and one that would have transformed the lives of thousands of people in terms of providing security and freedom from worry for themselves and their children.
I urge the Fianna Fáil Deputies, quite apart from the Independent Deputies, who know what I am saying is right, to ensure this is done. This is the legacy that should be left by the Minister for Health and Children who so far in his career has only increased the divide in the health service and introduced a new inequality where it did not exist previously. He has provided medical cards for people who are relatively well off and who happen to be over 70 and is denying medical cards to people on low incomes who simply cannot get a doctor and medication when needed. I urge the Independent Deputies to come in here tonight and defend the interests of poor people who cannot have that entitlement unless they make a decision now to support these thousands of people.