We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2006: Second Stage.

Contributions 1–207 of 625. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 3 parts.

Bill Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Bill 2006
Enacted

No. 27 of 2006 ›

Michael McDowell Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform (Mr. McDowell) Progressive Democrats

I move: "That the Bill be now read a Second Time."

When, last Tuesday, the Supreme Court ruled that section 1(1) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1935 was inconsistent with the Constitution and was not brought forward into law in 1937, an unprecedented and extremely complex set of issues was thrown up for the three arms of constitutional government, the Executive, Legislature and Judiciary, but a far graver set of issues was thrown up for Irish society, in particular for Irish children and their parents and those whose role and duty it is to protect them. It is to address some of those issues that this Bill is being introduced in this House today.

Protecting the vulnerable children of Ireland from cruel and predatory sexual abuse and exploitation has been and will be my first and overriding priority. I will have plenty of time and opportunity to protect and vindicate my own reputation and integrity over the coming days and weeks and I will do so but today my primary focus is on children.

Fashionable though it may be to look back condescendingly at the attitudes and values of the generation of politicians who enacted the 1935 Act, it must also be recognised that they decided by the terms of that Act to cast unambiguously and absolutely on persons accused of sexual abuse, which they correctly termed in their Act "defilement", an absolute liability in respect of the issues of age and consent. Put simply, they made no defence for those who defiled children that they were mistaken as to the age of the child. On these issues, the perpetrator carried all the risk.

In a prosecution once the fact of sexual intercourse with the accused by a child was established, guilt was established. No child was to be exposed to cross-examination in court in support of an argument that the accused had been mislead or had led on or consented to the act of sexual intercourse. For 70 years that was a cornerstone of our law on child protection. While that law was stern — the Law Reform Commission referred to it as harsh — it was effective. When the facts of abuse were established or admitted the child was spared the ordeal of reliving and explaining her behaviour, demeanour and motives in an adversarial court setting.

Now the Supreme Court has told us that we must allow for the issue of honest mistake to be a defence in any child protection law where children are protected by reference to their age. The inevitable consequence is that the issues of appearance, maturity, dress, behaviour, sobriety, truthfulness and credibility are now opened up for challenge in these cases. Young girls who are victims of sexual predators will be challenged on——

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

May I raise an issue? It is customary to circulate a copy of the Minister's speech.

Comment on this

I will get it for the Deputy as soon as possible.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

They are on their way.

Comment on this

Young girls who are victims of sexual predators will be challenged on their clothes, make-up and sobriety, on their presence at pubs, discos and other venues for adults, on what they said, how they appeared and acted, on what they pretended or boasted about their past and about their experience. On all these issues their truthfulness and credibility will be rigorously tested by skilled lawyers acting for perpetrators and alleged perpetrators with a view to creating a reasonable doubt about the private state of knowledge or belief of the accused. That is the consequence of the Supreme Court decision. The court has told us in the House that if we want to protect children by reference to their age, we must allow the issue of honest belief to be opened up and to become a live issue in every court case, and to have cross-examination on that issue.

Let us be under no illusion as to what the consequences are. The change will make cases, which are already difficult, far more difficult. The change will make victims of sexual predation, who are already fearful and reluctant, far more fearful and reluctant. This will tend to create a further chill factor in the criminal law on child protection and will add a new layer of difficulty for those whose job it is to protect children from sexual abuse and to bring abusers to justice.

The public has been repeatedly told that the recommendation of the Law Reform Commission in 1990 that there should be a defence of honest mistake was an obvious, worthwhile reform that was left lying for 16 years by an indifferent and incompetent Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform and by successive indifferent and negligent Ministers, including myself. That is a black lie.

Comment on this

That is why we need the Bill.

Comment on this

In those 16 years there has been a succession of legislative measures dealing with reform of the criminal law on sexual matters, of the law relating to children and of the law relating to sexual abuse. No Member of either House of the Oireachtas has ever tabled an amendment to any of those pieces of legislation along the lines recommended by the Law Reform Commission, and for good reason.

Successive Ministers for Justice and successive Governments have chosen not to make such a change, including Máire Geoghegan-Quinn who piloted through one of the most courageous Acts in this House to reform the law on sexual matters.

Comment on this

Look what happened to her.

Comment on this

They also include Nora Owen, who sat in this seat for a number of years, and the Minister, Deputy O'Donoghue, who occupied the same position and published——

Comment on this

I would not go there either.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

The Minister, Deputy O'Donoghue, published a discussion paper——

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

The Minister should talk about the children instead of trying to defend himself. He is a disgrace.

Comment on this

I appeal to you, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, to maintain order.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please. The Minister should be allowed to make his statement.

Comment on this

The Minister should apologise and accept responsibility.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

The Minister, Deputy O'Donoghue, published a discussion paper on this matter and elicited the views of the public, only a small fraction of whom supported change in this matter.

Comment on this

On a point of order, why is the Minister's speech not being circulated? It should have been circulated before he started.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

He cannot get anything right.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please allow the Minister to continue.

Comment on this

The reason for all this is the policy of the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform has consistently been not to make such a change for the very reasons I have outlined.

Some Deputies who have spoken with passion in this House on these matters in recent times have sat at the Cabinet table while that policy position of the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform was maintained and operated.

Comment on this

The Minister should defend himself.

Comment on this

It was not under constitutional scrutiny.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

It has been suggested that warning signs that the law was unconstitutional were ignored. The Law Reform Commission never gave that warning. The law in question has been considered in its operation by every court in the land, right up to the Supreme Court, regularly and exhaustively. The X case is one of many examples of this. In the past ten years, there have been at least 25 cases where the law in question has been considered by the superior courts. It operated for 70 years. Many people have been jailed for many years on foot of this law. In 2004, as we now know, the High Court ruled that it was constitutional and, despite an appeal from that decision, the Director of Public Prosecutions continued to lay charges under it as late as 12 May of this year.

It is a black lie to suggest that the State should have realised that this law was dangerous or defective. It was effective and fair, and until this month it served the people well and stood the test of time and the test of extensive scrutiny.

It has also been suggested that legislation should have been introduced to amend it in the face of the challenge that was launched in 2002 and, if that had been done, we would not be in the position we are in today. In other words, a pessimistic assessment about the law's chance of survival should have caused the Government of the day to introduce a law to make it possible for perpetrators to cross-examine witnesses on the basis I have mentioned and with the adverse consequences I have mentioned, and that this should have been enacted just in case we lost the case in the Supreme Court. That is another example of the people being served up with a black lie.

Comment on this

No, it is not.

Comment on this

The Minister is oblivious to what has happened.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

It has been suggested that if the Government had acted differently, the risk of perpetrators being released on foot of the CC judgment could have been avoided. That is another black lie.

Comment on this

The Minister should stop digging.

Comment on this

He has the emperor's suit.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

The Government and I are doing all we can to ensure that the CC judgment does not unlock the gates for convicted perpetrators of heinous crimes. We are mounting a case in the Supreme Court in which we are making the case that justice and common sense and the constitutional values that protect the victim, society and the criminal justice system, and maintain certainty in the criminal law, must take precedence over abstract theory and the opportunistic right of very dangerous men to escape justice on foot of a judgment that had no relevance to the facts of their cases or convictions, or their pleas of guilty in some cases. That matter now lies in the hands of the courts. It is for the courts to determine the consequences of their own orders.

The Supreme Court decision of 23 May struck down the core and most heavily used statutory provision in our criminal code in regard to unlawful carnal knowledge of under age children. The court found that the absence for an accused person of the right to claim that one was mistaken as to the age of the victim was so great an infirmity from the constitutional point of view that the entire section 1(1) of the 1935 Act had to be declared null and void, both retrospectively and going forward.

As a lawyer who worked in the criminal courts for a great many years, both prosecuting and defending persons in trials for this very offence, I was considerably surprised. Indeed, I was shaken by the scope of this Supreme Court decision.

Comment on this
A Deputy

The Minister is still shaking.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

He will shake more.

Comment on this

As the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, I knew immediately that this decision could have extreme consequences involving possible premature release from prison——

Comment on this

The Taoiseach said it was grand.

Comment on this

——of those who had committed vile crimes against defenceless children, many of them of very tender years. I am as well placed as most Members to say that the crimes against these victims cry to heaven for justice.

While the absence of the "honest mistake" defence in cases of this nature has always been recognised as a rigorous application of law, it went unchallenged in our superior courts for many generations, not without due cause. Many cases of recent years have been heard in the Supreme Court in regard to convictions under this statute and on no occasion was this argument seriously advanced or entertained. Therefore, I share with Members of this House and the parents of young people throughout the country a sense of dismay and outrage at the prospect that six or seven people who have offended grievously against children in this country could seriously be considered for early release on foot of last week's Supreme Court decision. That is why I recoiled when it was put to me last week in certain legal opinion that I should agree to the immediate release from prison — "forthwith", to use a legal expression — of the six or seven men in question who are in custody. I was not prepared to defer to that line of legal reasoning.

Comment on this

The Minister was brilliant.

Comment on this

Therefore, I explored the legal option with the Attorney General very carefully.

Comment on this

What is that supposed to mean?

Comment on this

Who put that suggestion to the Minister?

Comment on this

As my colleague, Deputy Brian Lenihan, pointed out yesterday on "Today with Pat Kenny", such a comprehensive declaration of the unconstitutionality of a criminal statute by the Supreme Court is extremely rare, if not unprecedented, in this country's history as an independent State. The first criminal case that was affected involved one of the appellants to the Supreme Court itself. That person's case had not even gone to trial before he invoked the appeal process. Public attention and my concern focused on the likely habeas corpus applications by people in custody serving sentences in this regard. I instructed my officials that we would not be unilaterally releasing any prisoners who thought they might benefit from the decision. I agreed with the Attorney General that any order for the release of such prisoners must be brought to the courts and opposed vigorously by every argument at the disposal of the State. Moreover, we agreed that we would appeal any High Court order in this regard made in favour of a prisoner who had been found guilty of defiling a young person under relevant legislation.

As I speak, the Supreme Court is preparing to hear the appeal by the State in the case of one such prisoner as to the validity of his release in relation to the decision made by Ms Justice Laffoy in the High Court last week. I do not want to cut across the case being made on our behalf before the Supreme Court but I believe it is a strong one. It is firmly based on the principles of justice and the concept that proven ill deeds must have real and proper consequences for the perpetrators involved.

Comment on this

On a point of order——

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I will allow the point of order.

Comment on this

It would be a minimal courtesy for the Opposition spokespersons who will respond to the Minister during this debate to be given a copy of the Minister's speech. Almost 20 minutes have passed since the Minister started to speak.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

This is not the first time that we have seen such arrogance from the Minister in depriving Opposition spokespersons of scripts.

Comment on this

Does he have any explanation?

Comment on this

I have conferred——

Comment on this

The Minster will never learn.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

Is this another device to try to deflect criticism?

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

I should point out that the Chair has no function in that matter.

Comment on this

I understand that copies of my script are on their way.

Comment on this

The Minister is on his way as well.

Comment on this

He is on the way out.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

The Minister will never change.

Comment on this

Do the media have the script?

Comment on this

I have conferred with the Garda Commissioner about the issue of released prisoners in this category. I will say more in that regard when and if the Supreme Court reaches a verdict on foot of today's judicial review hearing, which may also settle the legal issues relating to the validity of the continued detention of the six people I have mentioned. I will turn shortly to the substance of the Bill that the Government is bringing before the House today to correct the flaw in the law identified by the Supreme Court.

Comment on this

At long last.

Comment on this

The Minister is 15 minutes late in doing so.

Comment on this

Before I do so, however, I will refer briefly to some of the criticisms of the Attorney General, the Government and me arising from this situation.

Comment on this

The Minister will deal with that all right.

Comment on this

When will the Minister speak about the children?

Comment on this

As I have said, the primary accusations are that, somehow, we have been dilatory in our response to this legal judgment and that through incompetence we were unaware of the impending decision, the effects of which could somehow have been averted if some pre-emptive legal measures were taken by the Government.

Comment on this

The whole country is saying that.

Comment on this

Highly political charges are being made. I regret I have to use the time of the House to refute them——

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

When does the Minister intend to apologise?

Comment on this

——especially on a day when we are co-operating to bring a necessary law into effect.

Comment on this

The Minister can skip this part of his speech.

Comment on this

The legal situation that has emerged from the Supreme Court decision requires not only an appropriate legislative response from the Oireachtas but also a response from the Executive. To cope with the new situation I have described to the House, I propose to augment to a considerable degree the resources deployed by the State and its agencies in the investigation and prosecution of sexual crimes and crimes against children in particular. The agencies to which I refer are the Garda Síochána, the Forensic Science Laboratory and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, which is looking for increased victim liaison funding. I propose to ask an eminent legal figure to undertake a quick but comprehensive independent review of the two issues of resources and court procedures to enable me to bring practical proposals before the Government in both respects in advance of the settling of next year's Estimates and the framing of the budget in December.

Comment on this

Can that not be done in the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform?

Comment on this

The Minister has a review on his desk.

Comment on this

I want to say a few things about the Bill.

Comment on this

That is a better idea.

Comment on this

At last — 20 minutes late.

Comment on this

The Bill is designed to restore in updated form the offence of unlawful carnal knowledge against a girl of 15 years or under, which was struck down by the Supreme Court. The new offences contained in the Bill protecting children against sexual abuse contain a defence of honest belief that the child had obtained 15 or 17 years as appropriate in accordance with the Supreme Court judgment. Section 1 defines expressions used in the Bill. "Persons in authority" is defined so that where a person commits such a sexual act or attempts to sexually abuse a child under 17 years of age, that person will be subject to a higher penalty on conviction than other persons. Defilement of a child under the age of 15 years will carry a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. The offences created in sections 2 and 3 criminalise engaging in or attempting to engage in a sexual act with a child. Section 1 defines a sexual act for that purpose. It includes sexual intercourse and buggery between persons who are not married to each other and any act described in sections 3(1) or 4(1) of the Criminal Law Rape (Amendment) Act 1990. Any such act would be a sexual assault with particularly aggravating circumstances. The law relating to ordinary sexual assault remains unaffected by the Supreme Court decision last week. The definition of "sexual intercourse" is taken from section 1(2) of the Criminal Law (Rape) Act 1981.

Section 2 creates a new offence of engaging or attempting to engage in a sexual act with a child who is under 15 years of age. It replaces section 1 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1935 which criminalises carnal knowledge of a girl under 15 years of age and sections 3(a) and (b) of the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1993 which criminalises buggery of persons under 15 years of age. The new offence is gender neutral. The defence introduced for this offence, in accordance with the Supreme Court judgment, is for the defendant to prove that he or she honestly believed the child against whom the offence was committed had attained 15 years of age. It is for the court to decide whether the defendant honestly believed that the child had attained 15 years of age and it will have regard to the presence or absence of reasonable grounds for the defendant’s so believing and all other relevant circumstances.

This section also confirms that it is not a defence to prove that the child consented to the sexual act. The maximum penalty on conviction on indictment for this offence is life imprisonment, the same as for the offence of carnal knowledge of a girl under 15 years of age, which the Supreme Court struck down.

Comment on this

On a point of order, we are 22 minutes into the Minister's speech. It is absolutely scandalous that the Opposition has not received a copy of the Minister's script.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a matter for the Chair.

Comment on this

It shows complete arrogance on the part of the Government and incompetence on the Minister's part. It has never happened before that the Opposition has not had a copy of a Minister's speech.

Comment on this

The media has received copies.

Comment on this

Not even the party spokespersons have received a copy.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

This has never happened before in the House.

Comment on this

I regret that but the order of the House is that I must keep speaking.

Comment on this
Deputies

Why?

Comment on this

He has a copy for himself.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Minister should continue without interruption.

Comment on this

Are there any photocopiers in the Department?

Comment on this

The Government cannot pay the photocopying bill.

Comment on this

Section 3 replaces section 2 of the 1935 Act and sections 3(c) and (d) of the 1993 Act. It criminalises engaging or attempting to engage in a sexual act, as defined, with a child under 17 years of age. The penalty structure is analogous with the provisions in the repealed sections of the 1935 and 1993 Acts but if the offences are committed by a person in authority, the maximum penalties are higher. The defence provisions in section 2 are also incorporated into section 3. No proceedings for an offence under this section against a child under 17 years of age can be brought except by, or with the consent of, the Director of Public Prosecutions. This will ensure consistency in prosecution policy and that the Director of Public Prosecutions’ common law discretion not to prosecute in cases where it would be unjust or inappropriate to do so will be preserved in its entirety.

Section 4 allows for summary disposal of minor offences under the Act. Section 5 ensures a female under 17 years of age cannot be guilty of an offence under section 1 or 2 by reason only of her engaging in an act of sexual intercourse. This is being introduced after several representations including those of the Law Reform Commission going back to 1990 and the strongly held views of the Director of Public Prosecutions this week. These are also the views of many involved in child protection. They believe it would be wrong to stigmatise mothers and pregnant girls of 15 or 16 years of age as if they were either the victims of violent rape or they had committed a crime.

Comment on this

What about their partners?

Comment on this

Section 6 makes necessary consequential amendments to various enactments. For example, it will be possible to convict a person indicted under this Bill with another serious sexual offence where the evidence for the offence under this Bill does not warrant a conviction. Other amendments will ensure, for example, that a person convicted of an offence under this Bill will be obliged to notify the Garda of his or her name and address and any changes to those details, in other words, to register on the sex offenders register.

Section 16 of the Criminal Justice Bill 1992 provides that a video recording of evidence given by a person under 17 years of age in respect of sexual or violent offences shall be admissible at a trial as evidence. A committee established by my predecessor, Deputy O'Donoghue——

Comment on this

He is not in office.

Comment on this

——to draw up guidelines for persons involved in video recording interviews with a complainant regarding a sexual or violent offence during an interview with a garda or other person competent for the purpose subsequently forwarded good practice guidelines to my office with related recommendations.

It was my view that we needed the professional opinion and guidance of the experts in this field. It is crucially important that the video recording of any evidence given by a child who has suffered the horrors of a sexual crime does not subject that child to further avoidable stress. The Health Service Executive was, therefore, asked and agreed to come up with a protocol for the oversight of video interviewing by the Garda and social workers for the development of a joint national training programme for the staff who would be involved in interviewing and for the identification of suitable places and settings where interviews of this type might be conducted.

The HSE confirmed to the Department of Health and Children and my Department earlier that it will finalise its work on this matter before the end of the month. There will be no delay whatsoever on the part of my Department or the Department of Health and Children or any of their associated agencies in rolling out the video evidence approach to support future victims or suspected victims of child sexual abuse.

Comment on this
Paul McGrath Mr. P. McGrath Fine Gael

The Minister has had four years.

Comment on this

He has done nothing over the past six months.

Comment on this

I refer to developments since the process of consultation with Opposition Deputies yesterday. Two omissions from the legislation, which did not occur to any of us in conversation, occurred to me last night.

Comment on this

Typical.

Comment on this

I had a dream.

Comment on this

One is we had not replicated the anonymity guarantees for children who are the subject of prosecutions under the legislation, which the House will obviously want to do. In the rush to get the legislation through, nobody noted that omission.

Comment on this

The Minister should speak for himself.

Comment on this

It is his Bill.

Comment on this

I do not know why Opposition Deputies are baying. They wanted the legislation introduced on an emergency basis.

Similarly, I noticed last night that the provisions relating to victims of more serious sexual offences under the law of rape whereby they cannot be cross-examined about their sexual past, except by permission of the court and with the assistance of their own counsel, have not been replicated for the children who will be subjected to cross-examination as well under the legislation.

Comment on this

What about 16 year old boys?

Comment on this

Amendments dealing with those two matters are being prepared and they will be tabled on Committee Stage.

Comment on this

We only have 30 minutes for Committee and Report Stages.

Comment on this

If Deputies see anything else in this legislation that needs to be addressed, I will accept any reasonably based amendment.

Comment on this

Between now and 2 p.m. We are only after getting them.

Comment on this

I gave that guarantee in private and I am giving it in public today. I want to finish on this point because my time is up.

Comment on this

The Minister should keep his head down.

Comment on this

He should move on.

Comment on this

This is a swansong.

Comment on this

There are times we engage in adversarial debate in the House and I have been as good at that as many other Members.

Comment on this

The Minister is worse.

Comment on this

I do not blame people for taking the opportunity on this issue to be critical of the Government and to demand accountability. I do not resent that activity.

Comment on this
Paul Connaughton Mr. Connaughton Fine Gael

Why should the Minister?

Comment on this

When the dust settles and the frenzy is over——

Comment on this

When the election is over.

Comment on this

——it will be seen that my colleagues in Government, myself and the Attorney General have acted competently, honestly, truthfully and with the best interests of children in mind.

Comment on this

Rubbish.

Comment on this

When the dust settles, issues not raised until this morning in the media as to why the Law Reform Commission proposal was not adopted, the downside, the additional suffering for young children going through the courts process, the additional stress on people coming up to court cases and the fact that many people will be dissuaded from making a complaint will be live issues in the courtroom drama which will unfold.

Comment on this

The Minister is right all the time.

Comment on this

When that truth is widely understood, it will be accepted that successive Ministers for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform and successive Governments, including Members who are on the other side of the House, made the right decision in regard to this issue.

Comment on this

The Minister is right all the time.

Comment on this

It was only when the Supreme Court laid down that we could not continue to protect children by reference to their age——

Comment on this

Blame someone else.

Comment on this

——unless we also made them subject to cross-examination on these issues, it was only when we were pushed to that point that we agreed to change the law to allow for what will be a measure which has negative consequences for the protection of children in society.

Comment on this

The Minister is right all the time.

Comment on this

Let no one in the House think that the measures we are taking today are an unalloyed improvement in the lot of children. Let no one in this House believe that this will make the protection of children easier or the lot of abused children in the criminal justice process or in the courtroom context, any less agonising. On the contrary, it will make it significantly more unpleasant for those children.

Comment on this

This is just a stop-gap measure.

Comment on this

If, at the end, the price of protecting children by reference to their age is that we have to introduce after 16 years of resisting such a proposal, a measure of this kind to allow perpetrators to cross-examine children through their lawyers in court on the issues I have mentioned, we will do it.

Comment on this

That is not the reason, it is to protect children.

Comment on this

The public has been asked to believe the falsehood that there was no good reason why this reform was not made, that it was an obvious reform, that it is in the interests of victims of crime, that it is something which was self-evidently a change that should be brought about, those people will learn over the next few days——

Comment on this

That is the spin.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil backbenchers are trying to get rid of the Minister.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

——and, unfortunately, our children will learn in the coming years, that what we are doing today has been forced upon us reluctantly by the Supreme Court against our better judgment. It is with that very serious warning that I commend this Bill to the House.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

I wish to share time with Deputy Jim O'Keeffe.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I have never witnessed such a display of arrogance from any Minister in this House over the past 30 years.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Give us a break.

Comment on this

He spoke for 30 minutes and did not have his script delivered to Members of the House. To have Members applaud him for his performance speaks volumes.

Comment on this

Did Deputy Kenny listen to what he said?

Comment on this

Two issues bring us to the House today, the first is this emergency legislation, the second is the clear crisis in Government and the clearer crisis of public confidence in the Government. All this week the Government's bungling was a degrading political floor show. In the time ahead, more information will come to light which will discredit this complacent and incompetent coalition. At this stage, for most people, the term "Government" is a stretch too far. The country has been convulsed by the events of the past week. Alarmingly, though, the coalition is oblivious. It has absolutely no insight into the scale of the crisis in the public mind or the scale of the incompetence within its ranks.

This is a Government dangerously and damagingly out of touch with the people it is supposed to serve. Even in the past 24 hours, Cabinet Ministers have been slapping themselves on the back for their performance. In the rarefied atmosphere of the Cabinet, it may well be a triumph, but to the rest of the country, in the real Ireland, it is an unmitigated, unparalleled disaster.

The Taoiseach put it best this morning from the safe haven of the UN in New York. He told the country: "Nobody is to blame. There is no reaction to anything". Despite his comments, the rapists of children walk free.

Comment on this

One.

Comment on this

The prison door is swinging off the hinge for sex abusers.

Comment on this

A Leas-Cheann Comhairle——

Comment on this

The country is horrified and it knows it is leaderless.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

On a point of order.

Comment on this

Sit down, Deputy O'Flynn.

Comment on this

On a point of order, could we get a copy of the script?

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is out of order and should resume his seat.

Comment on this

Everyone is talking about this issue in homes, offices and taxis around the country.

Comment on this

Can Deputy Kenny give us a copy of his script?

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy O'Flynn is out of order.

Comment on this

If Deputy O'Flynn was in this House long enough, he would know that it is not necessary for scripts to be delivered by Members of the Opposition.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Order, please.

Comment on this

The Deputy might not be in the House for much longer.

Comment on this

The country is holding its breath to see what happens next, some evidence of which will be provided today in the courts. All but the Government are holding their breath. It is different for the Government. As far as the Government is concerned, it is just one of those matters which we should get over. As far as it is concerned, these things happen and it is nobody's fault.

The Minister then decides to up the cynical ante. He raises the red herring of the interrogation of children by his colleagues down in the Four Courts. However, the answer, namely, video evidence, is in his hands. He knows that a report on video evidence is probably covered in mildew on the shelves in his Department. His job is to solve problems, not invent them, and if he is not up to this job, he knows what he should do.

I welcome this debate and the Bill before the House. Last Wednesday in the House, I stated:

Yesterday's Supreme Court decision has serious consequences for the protection of young girls. Today, it is not illegal for a man to have consensual sex with a girl under 15 years of age. This is a grave situation and requires action by the House. As a result of the ruling that section 1(1) of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1935 is unconstitutional, it is possible that people in prison for having sex with girls under 15 may be able to have their convictions struck down. Protection of our young people must be a priority for legislators.

The Government's reaction was quite incredible and, in retrospect, risible. The Minister wormed his way around the problem in the House and trashed it outside. The Taoiseach was quite categorical about it and stated that nobody would walk free from prison as a result of the Supreme Court decision. How wrong he was. Not to be outdone, the Minister was ad idem with the Taoiseach. His attitude was that there was no crisis, no gaping hole in the law and no need to rush legislation. He believed the Government could carry on regardless and it did, but Fine Gael did not.

Fine Gael put children's safety before political pride. On that same day, we drafted a Bill to close the gap created by the Supreme Court decision. Our Bill was broadly along the lines of the report by the Law Reform Commission. The next day, the Tánaiste issued numerous assurances in House. Fine Gael acted in good faith in respect of these assurances. We put the country's interest before the party's interest and delayed publishing the Bill so the Government could bring forward urgent legislation. I regret the Government's damning breach of trust in this regard.

Within minutes, the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform went on the national airwaves, bantering about the sexual predilections of, in his own words, "randy 23 year olds". He coolly asserted that there was no black hole and that urgent legislation was not required. Fresh from that success, he was ready for more publicity by the weekend. He engineered yet another leak to a journalist. He supplied the journalist in question with a copy of our Bill and misled that individual about its contents. Our Bill was never published.

At the same time, for good measure, he airily floated his personal preferences, which were to lower the age of consent for girls and to legalise sex between young teenagers. It is vital that this House and the country have a robust debate on the age of consent but it is reprehensible for the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform to breach the protocols of the House on draft legislation simply so that he can hit the headlines and divert attention from the problem.

The Minister should heed the saying "be careful what you wish for" since he has since received it with a vengeance. When the Tánaiste preached in this House about the speck in our eye and the need to keep party politics out of the debate, she should have looked, not at the log, but the entire rainforest stuck firmly in the eye of the Progressive Democrats.

The terms of the Bill are broadly in line with the terms of the draft Fine Gael Bill, from which perspective I welcome them. I especially welcome the provisions restoring the protection of young people from sexual predators. I also welcome the tougher provisions in respect of those in authority, which was a central feature of our draft Bill.

Today's Bill effectively raises the age of consent for boys to 17 years. The Minister's proposal to reduce the age of consent would effectively legalise sex between young teenagers who, in my view, are children. The mark of a civilised society is how we cherish our children and their childhoods. Not for one minute are we cherishing our children or the shrinking space of their childhoods by legalising sex between young teenagers.

Comment on this

That is the reality.

Comment on this

At that age, they are physically able to have sex, which they do, just as they are physically able to drink a bottle of vodka, but they do not have the emotional or psychological maturity necessary to deal with the consequences of sex.

Comment on this

Is this about human rights?

Comment on this

I do not mean the obvious consequences of teenage pregnancies or the risk of sexually transmitted infections, which have reached epidemic proportions in the past five years. Gonorrhoea, syphilis and chlamydia have increased by 900%, 1,100% and 1,500% respectively. Rather, I mean the more subtle and sinister damage caused where sex is callous and commodified, relationships are transitory and our children are deprived of any sense of intimacy, tenderness, responsibility or innocence.

As a society, this is a conversation we must have. We could do with a radical reconsideration of what is acceptable and desirable behaviour by parents, children and the Government. Ultimately, it takes not just parents but society itself to rear a child. In a well-functioning society, there is no such thing as other people's children. All of them are ours, but we have lost touch with this view in the past ten years. We must reconnect with it again.

Comment on this

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

Of course, the reality is that our teenagers have sex. However, that it is a fact does not make it right or inevitable, which is the message I want to send to the people. Legalising sex for that age group is wrong. Moreover, it is out of touch with the values and aspirations of the vast majority of parents, who want to live up to their responsibilities to their children and to nurture, value, mind and protect them while they remain children.

In matters of the age of consent, we must remember that the law is not just a decider of guilt or innocence. It is a code for living that defines what we deem as acceptable in the standards and aspirations of our society. As a father, I speak for hundreds of thousands of parents who want to set higher goals for their children. They refuse to accept early teenage sex as inevitable, acceptable or, in some ways, prescribed. In a mediatised world where promiscuity is increasingly promoted and sometimes celebrated, the vast majority of parents want to do what they can to bring their children up and give them the sanctuary of boundaries and the safety net of appropriate controls. The State should do likewise.

Section 5 of the Bill is a concern, as it exempts all females from prosecution. The section is problematic. Last Tuesday, the Taoiseach told the House that we must try to deal with two main issues, namely:

to ensure the laws are not discriminatory on grounds of gender — the 1930s Act was about boys — and to ensure that they provide the defences required by the Supreme Court decision if they are to sustain their constitutional validity. These are the two crucial issues with which we must deal in a way that satisfies the judgment.

The Bill patently fails the Taoiseach's first test, as section 5 is obviously discriminatory. It may be unconstitutional and throws up serious anomalies. It was drafted on the back of a box of Panadol in the Fianna Fáil Cabinet room. Let us be absolutely clear, this is a Fianna Fáil Bill. I said here on Wednesday that when the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform wanted the ultimate, expert legal opinion, he simply looked in the mirror, but I was wrong. Obviously, when he wants that opinion now, he simply looks to a Fianna Fáil committee. He has become a new type of PD, the prostrate democrat, who lets himself be walked all over by his political lessers to stay in office.

The last two weeks have exposed the shallowness at the core of the Minister's politics. Get the retaliation in first, respond off the cuff, trash anyone who disagrees and sneer at anyone who challenges such a political and legal colossus. We are all but knee high to the great man himself. I remind the Minister of the words of a real leader, Ghandi, who said, "It is unwise to be too sure of one's own wisdom; it is healthy to be reminded that the strongest might weaken and the wisest might err."

In the past few days, people have been looking to the Government to protect their children. In recent years, however, they have been looking for something just as important, and every bit as absent — leadership, leadership that acts from courage and conscience, leadership that makes the tough, often unpopular decisions, leadership that is most notable by its absence in this Government.

The Taoiseach says there is no "reaction" in this case. I want the country to be under no illusions. It is not conscience and duty that bring the Government to its senses and to this House today, what brings it here today is public fury. In its own blind panic, it has been found out yet again, only this time the stakes are immeasurably higher. This time the guilty walk free, and hope and innocence are crushed in their wake.

As a legislator, but more importantly as a father, my heart goes out to the children who have been betrayed by the depraved adults in these cases. My heart goes out too to the parents and the families who are trying to put their broken children, their shattered lives, back together again. Betrayed once by adults, they have been betrayed all over again by this State. They have seen plenty of law but no actual justice.

This is, perhaps, the most dangerous time we will witness in this House. I have never seen such a gap between a Government on one side and the people on the other. Perhaps if any good has come out of this, it has given people a sense that in the end, they are the ones who are in power. A year from now they will decide how they want to be governed.

The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform said in the newspapers and here again today: "When the dust settles and the frenzy stops, I will be seen to have acted with competence, honesty and courage." He did not have his script for delivery this morning — that is competence — and I could go into what he has done in the past couple of years. He makes his defence that he did not know and could not be ready and that when this came to a constitutional test, the carriage was between the Attorney General's office and the DPP's office. There could only have been one of two results, either it would be deemed constitutional or not. The Minister should have been ready for the possibility that the Supreme Court would deem that section to be unconstitutional.

The Taoiseach this morning said the Attorney General should have known. Perhaps he has taken out his crossbow because if the Attorney General should have known, so should the Minister. In terms of competence, honesty and courage, the Minister fails on all three counts.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform's contribution on this Bill was the most disgraceful, self-serving speech I have heard in this House. The only issue for the Minister appears to be to defend his own reputation or what is left of it. It follows his comments last night about his competence, honesty and courage. Is the Minister living in the real world? Does he realise that he is the only one talking of his competence, honesty and courage? The approach to this Bill is in line with the approach of the Minister and this Government from the time the crisis transpired. It was a matter of sharing the blame and pointing the finger. They brought in the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Attorney General and referred to the then Secretary General of the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform from 2002. They referred to previous Ministers in previous Governments, as the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform has done in his speech today. The only people they have not touched on yet are the ushers in the Dáil, and I presume they will be next to be asked to share the blame for the incompetence of this Government and this Minister.

I will touch on one aspect which really concerns me. What I have mentioned so far is what I would expect anyway. I refer to the Cowen logic which was rolled out by the Minister for Finance, Deputy Cowen, yesterday when the Government decided to focus its ire on the Supreme Court. That is dangerous talk. The Supreme Court and the other courts of this country have a job to do under the Constitution. When the finger is pointed at those courts to share the blame for the Government's incompetence, one is in very dangerous territory. I warn the Government off it.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

I am entitled to my view.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

I say to the Government that when it failed to prepare for this kind of contingency, even to see the problem approaching despite clear warnings and signposts, or to implement the recommendations of an important advisory agency in law reform, it is then incompetent.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy have implemented those recommendations?

Comment on this

The Minister of State is not on Matt Cooper's show now.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

When the Government failed to put in place basic safeguards in the Office of the Attorney General which were recommended in the wake of similar crises, then it was incompetent. I remind the Government of the case of Brendan Smyth and the review which took place after that particular controversy.

Comment on this

That is correct.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

I remind the Government that the review recommended an early warning system relating to sex cases involving children. What became of that recommendation?

Comment on this

What became of it?

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

In passing, I remind the Government of the consequences of the Brendan Smyth case.

The incompetence of the Government with regard to this issue was further highlighted by the attempt to play politics with this serious matter. A more serious issue could not come before this House. When the Minister represented his own role to the Oireachtas in a bid to save his own skin, blaming everyone and everything instead of dealing with the problem, it was total evidence of incompetence.

As far as Fine Gael is concerned, the major issue from the beginning was that this legal loophole be closed. We wanted a clear message from the Oireachtas to the paedophiles and sexual predators of the country that this legal loophole would be closed. The message would be that from now on, if a person interfered with or abused children, a law was in place to put that person behind bars, for life if necessary in some instances.

I welcome this Bill despite the incompetence of the Government and the rejections of our offers of co-operation, especially at the early stage. I welcome it despite the contemptible approach of the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform to the first Bill we drafted last week. I want the gap, the legal loophole, to be closed. The Fine Gael Party, our leader and I have never deviated from that fundamental concept.

We should touch on another aspect of the issue. The Bill at long last before the House proves that democratic politics work. Despite the fact that we initially had a Government in denial, a Taoiseach who stated that nobody would walk free and a Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform who argued there was no gaping hole in the law, we have a Bill before the House which I hope will be law before the night is out. This shows that the strength of democratic politics rose to the test, that the attitude of the Opposition ultimately had to be taken on board by Government and that we will end up with that law tonight.

This law will not be retrospective. The issue has arisen because the law was not reformed in the past. It arises because various signals, including a communication to the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform in 2002, were not picked up. It arises despite the fact that the newspapers made the information public last year, and despite an article in the Law Society Gazette in October 2005. I agree with the Tánaiste’s statement that it would not have been easy to tackle the 1935 Act, nor would it have been very popular to do so. Does the Government not realise that the strength of democratic politics to which I referred earlier was based on an all-party approach, the same all-party approach that attempted to grapple with the difficulties under Article 35 of the Constitution? The committee dealing with that issue, on which there is an Opposition majority, was prepared to take an approach on the question of costs that could not be deemed populist. That route has not been followed.

Another aspect has been largely overlooked in this debate about legalities, namely the victims and their parents. At the very minimum I would have expected from the Minister, in introducing this Bill to the House, an expression of regret and an apology to victims, their parents and all the parents of this country, most of whom are thinking: "There but for the grace of God go I". Some, perhaps, will have a more practical appreciation of what it means. An expression of regret from the Government would be appropriate before this day ends.

I am prepared to accept the Bill on Second Stage, because I feel a stakeholder in it. Some 90% of the Bill is based on the Fine Gael Bill.

Comment on this

I thought the Deputy said it was a Fianna Fáil Bill.

Comment on this

The Minister should seesection 5.

Comment on this
Jim O'Keeffe Mr. J. O’Keeffe Fine Gael

I want to see the law enacted and the restoration of the criminal charge of defilement of children under the age of 15. I want to see the introduction of additional penalties for persons in authority. I want to see the maintenance of the age of consent.

I will raise two issues. First, the Minister spoke at length about children being cross-examined as a consequence of certain proposed changes in the law. If the Supreme Court states a law is unconstitutional we must enact a law that is constitutional. However, the consequences to which the Minister referred can be minimised. Why has that not been done? The Minister raised the issue of young children being cross-examined and subjected to ordeals but it will not arise for very young children, who are clearly under the relevant age. I do not want any child to suffer additional trauma. Why have the recommendations of the video evidence committee not been adopted? Why has the report of the expert group gathered dust over the past three years? Why have recommendations that would minimise the trauma to which the Minister referred not been adopted? The Minister must respond to that because it is a further indication of neglect on his part.

Deputy Kenny and I have mentioned our reservations on section 5, out of which serious issues arise. It does not represent the best way of dealing with sex between young people or teenagers, though there must be a provision to deal with it. Following discussions with colleagues in the Labour Party, I was prepared to put forward a proposal to do so.

I am concerned about the constitutionality of the Minister's proposal. There is a considerable danger that its constitutionality or lack thereof may be challenged on the basis that it is not gender neutral. I am also concerned that it could lead to an outrageous position in which girls will be exempt from prosecution for engaging in an act of sexual intercourse but not so exempt for engaging in other sexual acts. It also raises the possibility that boys, particularly younger boys, may be criminalised following involvement with a girl who may be a couple of years older than them. These issues have not been fully appreciated or teased out. For this reason, I have major reservations about section 5 and will propose an amendment on the basis that while my proposal may not be perfect, it offers a more appropriate solution to the problem with which we are dealing than the current provisions of the section.

The amendment proposes to maintain the age of consent, address the issue of teen sex, provide minor penalties for minor offences, hold the line as far as the law and parents are concerned, ensure the word does not go out that the House is sanctioning, approving of or legalising teen sex, deal with the issue in the same manner as the House has tried to deal with other issues such as soft drugs or under age drinking, and try to find a practical solution in legal terms while providing a defence to parents who will be able to tell children that certain activity is not legal, approved of or proper. At the same time, it will provide defences to young girls and, possibly, young boys who should not be faced with the argument that the Dáil has indicated certain activity is acceptable. The approach adopted by the Government in section 5 is not the right one and, on behalf of the Fine Gael Party, I will shortly table an amendment to the proposal therein.

The Minister has many questions to answer and major questions need to be followed up after the Bill is passed. Leaving the political dimension aside, other aspects of the Law Reform Commission report and other issues need to be addressed. Let us, on an all-party basis, put in place a procedure for completing this task in order that the House will no longer be required to deal with serious, complex issues of this nature through emergency legislation.

Comment on this

I ask the permission of the House to share time with Deputy Howlin.

Comment on this
Séamus Pattison An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Labour Party

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I agree with the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform on one issue, namely, his view that the adversarial system in this Chamber is an important dimension of our democratic system, allowing Deputies to probe matters of public interest, scrutinise legislation and hold the Government to account. There are rare occasions when behind the robust adversarial exchanges there is a wish on all sides of the House, perhaps unexpressed, to see the Government do well, take control, give wise leadership and exert good authority. The past ten days have been such a period because the parent took over from the parliamentarian on all sides of this Chamber, and all sides, except those elected to Cabinet to serve as Government, appreciated this. That is what was different. Instead of a Government that could grasp what was happening, provide leadership and appreciate public concerns, this Government was seen to be in disarray, at sixes and sevens, unable to understand the import of the unfolding events, and unable to make any coherent response. Members of the House and those outside could not appreciate the response of a Government that told us there was no gaping hole, nobody would walk free, and that we ought to make haste slowly in replacing the struck down section. Meanwhile, the concern on everybody's mind was the protection of our children. This Government showed itself to be more concerned about protecting itself as the crisis evolved than it was about protecting children.

One of the things that makes politics different from other endeavours is that one cannot tell at the beginning of a week how it will unfold and what events will arise. On this occasion, however, it was different. It was not just people on this side of the House who could see what was happening; the backbenchers behind the Minister could see what was happening also. For Government backbenchers, the Minister's response to this crisis was like watching a car crash in slow motion. People could not understand why he could not grasp the import of what was occurring before his eyes. The Minister engaged in laid-back interviews and relaxed exchanges about what could or could not be done. He promised to bring forward a Bill in two weeks' time — not just after the holiday weekend but after the House was going into recess for a week. Then it was proposed that we would meet and if the Bill was ready we would enact it. The public were in disbelief.

Ministers then went into denial. They denied knowledge and said they could not have anticipated the outcome of the Supreme Court decision. The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform told us that neither he nor his Department had any knowledge of this. The Tánaiste told us that the Department had been advised of the proceedings in 2002. The Minister told us that the DPP had carriage of this case. The Tánaiste told us that it was the joint responsibility of the DPP and the Attorney General. The Attorney General had no knowledge, according to the Minister and the Tánaiste. That is despite the fact that his office was concerned with the processing of the case.

In the opening paragraph of his speech, the Minister made a remark about the protection of our children. He then went on for the next 22 minutes to talk about the protection of his own position, self-justification for what happened, and what we might or might not have foreseen.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The public wants to know if we can reassure it about the protection of their children from the vile degradations of sexual predators. That was the only issue. There is an important subsidiary issue, which is the position of victims. Victims and their families have received little attention in this debate. There have been vague promises of counselling but one hears mothers of such victims saying on the airwaves that the social services approached them two years later. We saw the two young women on television last night detail with unbelievable courage their unimaginable experience. Little attention has been given to that.

The Government has been scurrying, under pressure from the public, the Opposition and some of its own backbenchers, to find a political response to this situation. What we now have is not what was envisaged when the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform told us, invoking the name of the Chief Justice, to make haste slowly and that this was a complex matter. He has ended up doing a 180° turn on that.

The Labour Party consistently and from the beginning advocated the closing of this legal loophole and the inclusion of the defence of honest mistake to make the legislation compliant with the Constitution as an interim measure that would then enable this House and those outside it to discuss the more complicated and difficult questions associated with the age of consent. The Minister did not do that. He said our Bill was constitutionally infirm because it was not gender neutral. What has he now done? He has come up with legislation that is precisely that — not gender neutral.

He has, quite properly, exempted the young girl who becomes pregnant and becomes a teenage mother from prosecution, which is only right. However, the young boy can serve five years in Mountjoy Prison. No thought has been given to that. It is not gender neutral and if the Minister's original argument is right, for that reason it is suspect constitutionally.

I do not think many backbenchers, who are happy to go home this weekend at least feeling there has been some kind of response to the runaway horse we have seen in the past ten days, appreciate that in this Bill the Minister proposes that we treat with equal seriousness the situation of sexual activity between two young teenagers and sexual activity between a much older and a much younger person. They are not to be treated equally. I do not want to have anything in this House that encourages or approves the sexual activity of teenagers today. However, for us not to recognise it is to fool ourselves and to rush headlong into making a decision that is merely to try to pull back some credibility for the Government.

We ought to have proceeded with a two-stage approach. We ought to have enacted something similar to the Labour Party Bill if not the Bill itself to shut off that loophole and make it constitutionally safe. We could then have had the wider debate. I suspect that, for all his self-image, the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform will not in the years ahead like to have the paternity of this legislation traced for public scrutiny. If he enacts it as he proposes to enact it today, it will be shown to have many anomalies and to have been a political response to a situation that requires a finessed legal response.

The Minister found out this week what it is to be the meat in the sandwich. When he found himself between Clara and Cahirciveen, he soon found out who drives the Government. He soon found out what it is like to be the meat in the sandwich.

Comment on this

That is fantasy.

Comment on this

He brought in legislation that was made up on the hoof. As Deputy Kenny said, the section 5 anomaly was drafted on the back of a piece of paper in the Cabinet ante-room by Fianna Fáil. It was quite unbelievable to see——

Comment on this

That is an invention.

Comment on this

The Minister would know all about inventions.

Comment on this

It is false.

Comment on this

It is nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

It was done at the instigation of the Director of Public Prosecutions.

Comment on this

It is what the Minister told us yesterday.

Comment on this

The Minister invited Deputies Howlin and Jim O'Keeffe to discussions and arranged to meet them again. He went into the Seanad in the interim to tell that House that a broad agreement had been reached. He changed his mind three or four times yesterday. He criticised the House for not noting the two omissions that occurred to him last night, even though we did not see the Bill until today.

Comment on this

I did not criticise anybody.

Comment on this

You are the man who comes into this House——

Comment on this

Is the Minister dreaming again?

Comment on this

——with the lawyers' tactic of building up a straw man and then proceeding to knock it down.

Comment on this

You are inventing a myth that the Fianna Fáil Party initiated this exercise.

Comment on this

Who made the suggestion——

Comment on this

It is complete rubbish.

Comment on this
Michael Woods Acting Chairman (Dr. Woods) Fianna Fáil

I ask the Minister to allow Deputy Rabbitte to speak without interruption. I ask Deputy Rabbitte to address his comments through the Chair.

Comment on this

Who made the suggestion to the Minister, which he claims to have so firmly resisted, that he should release the seven prisoners who are properly in jail? Nobody in this House suggested it to him. His tactic is to build up a case before proceeding to knock down a case that never existed.

Comment on this