Order of Business.
Contributions 1–152 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
It is proposed to take No. 27, Arbitration Bill 2008 — Order for Report, Report and Final Stages; No. 28, Planning and Development (Amendment) Bill 2009[Seanad] — Second Stage (resumed); and No. 4, Employment Agency Regulation Bill 2009 — Order for Second Stage and Second Stage.
Private Members' business shall be No. 82, motion re gangland crime (resumed), to conclude at 8.30 p.m. if not previously concluded.
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach share the view of the ESRI in its judgment that there is no underlying rationale for the policy of the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government on waste? A spokesman for the Minister was derogatory of the findings of the State body, the ESRI, and made the comment that it erred in fact. This is an important matter and the Taoiseach should make his views clear on it.
I am concerned by an emerging trend, where companies are proceeding to the commercial High Court looking for examinerships. The Government appointed public interest watchdogs to the boards of the banks. As the Taoiseach is aware, if an examinership is granted creditors may get five cents in the euro. This is a gamble with jobs. The problem with the trend is that small companies are being brought before the commercial High Court but trailing elements of much larger companies are coming in behind them. In many cases receiverships are being appointed to what are solvent entities, within those companies, that could trade their way out of difficulty in time. This appears to be an exercise to get examinerships appointed where jobs will be lost, creditors will not be paid and where holding companies will benefit. I do not know if the Taoiseach is aware of this or has a view on it. From an examination of a list of companies with liabilities well over €200 million, some entities can trade out of this, but if the whole lot goes into examinership, jobs could be lost. It is the right of a petitioner to take a case before the commercial High Court——
Comment on this
I am raising this in the context of NAMA legislation. Public interest watchdogs have been appointed to the boards of banks. I raise this matter as a point of concern. The Taoiseach's people can examine this.
I heard the taxi drivers in Dublin complaining about the new 30 km/h speed limit in Dublin city. Are State cars subject to the speed limit?
Comment on this
Regarding the question on the ESRI report, the first part of the report constitutes a response to the environmental report on the strategic environmentalist process in respect of the proposed section 60 policy direction on the incineration cap and ancillary matters. The second part constitutes a response to the international review of waste management policy undertaken by Eunomia consortium. The SEA is part of a consultative process with inputs from various stakeholders and people with a view on these matters. They have an input on debates on waste and represent different and often partisan point of view that may be contradictory. The Minister and the Government will give consideration to them and must ultimately determine public policy having regard to overarching national and EU objectives and considerations. This is a consultative process where the Minister must consider these issues and inputs before a final decision is taken.
I am not aware of the situation to which Deputy Kenny refers in the commercial court. I will have it checked.
Regarding the third question, Garda cars have the usual requirements under the road traffic Acts.
Comment on this
I wish to ask the Taoiseach about two matters. First, I thank the Taoiseach for writing to me arising from a question I asked him on 20 January 2010, regarding the application of the pay cuts. The Ceann Comhairle will recall I asked the Taoiseach about a circular which was issued by the HSE to the various agencies under its remit and in which the HSE was effectively directing the various agencies to cut the pay of the staff of those agencies. The Taoiseach has replied saying that the circular was issued incorrectly and I accept this. However, he goes on to make it clear that although the circular was issued incorrectly, in effect, the HSE expects these agencies to cut the pay. This is what the reply translates as, even though it is expressed in roundabout language in which he states that providers take appropriate measures to ensure they continue to provide the same level of service in 2010 as previously, notwithstanding the reductions in their funding and that it is the responsibility of each individual employer to decide exactly what mix of actions should be taken, to inform its employees and trade unions as necessary and to manage the human resources and industrial relations implications of its decisions.
All this comes down to, as I understand it, is that while there is no circular, the staff pay of the various agencies will still need to be cut. Is this the Government policy because my point at the time was that the cut in pay in the public sector was now being used by Government to drive down pay in the voluntary sector?
Comment on this
It is a promise of a different kind for the unfortunate staff of all these agencies; it is a promise from the Government that their pay will be cut. I want the Taoiseach to admit this is what it amounts to.
On my second question, yesterday, I asked the Taoiseach and he finally admitted that the number of senior public servants who were being treated more favourably than every other public servant with regard to pay cuts, was closer to 600 than it was to 160. I also asked the Taoiseach about the cost of that decision. He said he would get back to me. I ask him if he has that information today.
Comment on this
No, I do not have that information as yet. I am seeking it for the Deputy but I did not have an opportunity yesterday from the time I was in the House and attending parliamentary party and other meetings. I am having the matter investigated and I will obtain the information for the Deputy as speedily as possible. From memory the numbers are in the order of 655.
Comment on this
Does the Taoiseach get a bonus for writing that letter?
Comment on this
No. What is involved is that the allocations are being given to the funded bodies and it is a matter for the funded bodies to decide how they will maintain a service with the reduced allocations they are receiving because of the economic and financial realities we have to contend with, no matter what Government is in power. In each case they must decide how best they will deploy those resources. If it involves taking actions that require a change to existing arrangements, then they should, as has been said here, consult with and inform their employees or trade unions as necessary and, as managers of those institutions, manage those implications.
Comment on this
I appreciate the Taoiseach was busy with the parliamentary party meeting yesterday——
Comment on this
I am puzzled about this issue of the costs——
Comment on this
When I asked this question before, the Taoiseach told the House that the Minister for Finance had drawn his attention to this. I cannot understand why the Taoiseach would not have asked the Minister for Finance what this decision was going to cost. Second, it would appear now from his answer that none of the reluctant seconders to the motion asked about the cost of it at yesterday's parliamentary party meeting.
Comment on this
I understand the figure is less than €5 million but I will obtain that information for the Deputy. It is a total spend of——
Comment on this
That would replace all the special needs classes——
Comment on this
I refer to the fact there is no inspection of services for people with intellectual disability and that a HSE report is expected to reveal that some 4,200 people with intellectual disability are currently housed within long-outdated, inappropriate conditions——
Comment on this
Yes, it is leading exactly to that. There are still some 300 people with intellectual disability inappropriately placed in psychiatric facilities across this State. What action is the Taoiseach considering against all of these very serious matters? Will he expedite the taking of the licensing of health facilities Bill, which is promised to address the issue of a mandatory system of licensing for all public and private health facilities? Against the information that I have again reflected here this morning and shared with the House, will the Taoiseach take the necessary steps to intervene with the Department of Health and Children, to address this outrageous neglect and expedite the legislation I have called for?
Comment on this
I have every confidence in the commitment and competence of my colleague, the Minister of State, Deputy John Moloney, who has responsibility in this area. He has displayed a very clear commitment and has engaged very intensively with all stakeholders in the area of mental health. I support him and have been supporting him in every way I can to deal with the question of the historical problem of inappropriate placement. A number of initiatives have taken place which have resulted in modern facilities being provided to assist those who have been inappropriately placed historically and this should continue. The Minister of State has obtained the agreement of the Minister for Finance and the Government in the Estimates rounds for a capital programme that will enable this to happen, by way of the selling-off of existing assets in the health service area. He is very committed in this area and I have every confidence in him to deal with these matters.
Comment on this
When will the Taoiseach being forward the licensing of health facilities Bill?
Comment on this
Regarding that matter, the Minister of State has indicated that the HSE and HIQA have agreed that progressive non-statutory implementation of the HIQA standards will now commence and will become the benchmark against which the HSE assess both its own directly operated facilities and other facilities funded by the HSE. Challenges exist to moving immediately to full statutory implementation of these standards, including the availability of resources and including regulation and inspection. We will continue to work progressively to bring these standards into play on a non-statutory basis.
Comment on this
Yesterday, the Minister for Finance issued a press release indicating that he intended to delegate functions to the NTMA which have a very intimate bearing on banking policy for the State. The NTMA is not subject to freedom of information requests and it does not have the same Dáil scrutiny so taxpayers do not have the opportunity to oversee its activities. These included the conduct of discussions with the banks on their capital needs, on the restructuring of the banking sector and on the guarantee. These are at the core of central policy issues as to how we are going to deal with the banks who have brought this country to its knees.
I am very concerned about this proposed delegation of functions. I can see that the NTMA can offer a role but delegating the responsibility to it is something that is a bridge too far. I ask the Taoiseach if this delegation of functions will be brought before the House so it can be properly debated before we sign off on these powers and see them disappear into an area where, at best, we will see only darkly what is happening?
Comment on this
On the same issue, we were given a very innocuous one-page press release last night from the Department of Finance and the Minister on this subject. I do not know but it seems to me as though the ducks are being put in a row to provide for the full or almost full nationalisation of the banks by this structure. It is being done with almost no discussion provided for in this House. Everybody in the House knows that not only have we the debts of the banks in terms of toxic loans but we have four or five other sorts of areas where the banks are taking heavy losses. If fact, it would seem that the holes in the banks' balance sheets are so large — when mortgage debt, credit card debt, car finance debt and the rising failures of ordinary companies in what people often describe as the real economy and not in the construction and finance area — are included.
We are being told in this notice that responsibility for this——
Comment on this
——is being passed to the National Treasury Management Agency. According to the press release, a "draft delegation order is currently being discussed with the Attorney General's office". Under law — as the Taoiseach well knows, because it was his predecessor, Charlie McCreevy, who set it up — the NTMA is at quite a distance from this House and is largely exempt from freedom of information provisions. It does not respond directly to the House, meeting only occasionally with the Oireachtas Committee on Finance and the Public Service. Effectively, the Minister for Finance is delegating——
Comment on this
This is one of the most important financial decisions that will come before the House this year. The Minister for Finance is delegating substantial responsibility for banking to the NTMA. Will the Taoiseach indicate whether the Government will provide for a full debate in the House on the implications of this statement, or are we now sidestepping the Department of Finance and the Minister for Finance and handing the key responsibility——
Comment on this
This is not Question Time. The Deputy's queries are more appropriate for the Minister for Finance.
Comment on this
This country would not be bankrupt and ruined if a debate had taken place in this House on how these guys were handling our banks.
Comment on this
I am not arguing about the merits of points being made. The Deputy must respect that this is the Order of Business.
Comment on this
With due respect to the Chair's great office, I am perfectly in order.
Comment on this
Deputy Burton is entirely in order.
Comment on this
Several Members are waiting to contribute and I have allowed the Deputy great latitude.
Comment on this
I am told there is a daft delegation order with the Attorney General. I am asking the Taoiseach — who holds that office for the time being — whether this issue, which is central to all our economic futures, is coming, as it should, before the House for a full debate. There are businesses, families and individuals ruined and unemployed because of the Taoiseach's actions as leader of Fianna Fáil.
Comment on this
Now the Department of Finance, which the Taoiseach ran in his previous Ministry, is to delegate the functions of looking after the banking system to the NTMA, which is not responsible to this House. I am in order in asking the Taoiseach to be accountable for this.
Comment on this
A draft delegation order is being prepared. Questions are to the Minister for Finance this afternoon which will allow Members to ask detailed questions on this issue. We are designating the NTMA to deal with the banks in regard to areas which are currently a matter for either the Central Bank, the regulator, the Department of Finance or the NTMA. Our objective is to have the story told in one place and to ensure that there is proper liaison with the banks in respect of these matters. There will be a continuing role for the Central Bank and the Minister for Finance which will be in no way different in terms of their responsibilities, and the Government will continue to make decisions in this area. We are talking about an operational matter that will enable one institution to deal with the banks in respect of many of these matters which can then be referred back to the Minister and the Government in due course.
Comment on this
There is no accountability to the House.
Comment on this
Is the order coming before the House?
Comment on this
I asked the Taoiseach whether the order is coming before the House.
Comment on this
It is relevant to the Order of Business to ask whether this order will be presented to the House for debate. The Taoiseach should either respond now or provide Deputies with a response so that we can continue to discuss this issue tomorrow.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is the Head of Government. In answering questions later today, the Minister is only the Minister for Finance. Will the Taoiseach, as leader of the Government, say whether this order will come before the House for debate?
Comment on this
If it is a requirement for it to do so, that will happen. The Minister for Finance will provide the details this afternoon.
Comment on this
In regard to the health information Bill, when will the Minister for Health and Children publish the non-statutory report into the death of Mr. Peter McKenna in Leas Cross nursing home, which was received by the Department last October but remains unpublished. The lessons we must learn from the Leas Cross case——
Comment on this
Yes, it relates to the health information Bill. When will this report be laid before the House so that its lessons can be taken on board? This is particularly important in view of another report referred to in The Irish Times today indicating unacceptably low standards at the TLC nursing home in Maynooth whose chief executive officer is a highly placed officer in a medical organisation. It is unacceptable in this day and age that nursing homes continue to be run in this manner. When will that report be published?
Second, in regard to the local government services Bill, the Taoiseach referred earlier to the large amounts of money being invested in roads. Is it not the case that since December 2008, the Government spent almost €500 million less on national, regional and local roads than previously? The message the proud Minister for Transport is putting out is an absolute con given that more than €1 billion is needed to put our roads into proper repair.
Comment on this
It is not. It adds up, €325 million plus €169 million, which are the figures provided by the consultant, Mr. Power.
Comment on this
It is a gross exaggeration.
The report of the inspection of the private TLC care centre in Maynooth was published by the Health Information and Quality Authority and identifies a litany of problems with the facility. HIQA carried out a follow-up inspection in the last week of January which showed an improvement in the level of care provided and identified some issues which are being addressed on an ongoing basis. The report is being compiled and will be published when completed. TLC Maynooth is being re-registered by HIQA and that process includes a full inspection of the centre. The Deputy should put down a question to the Minister for Health and Children regarding the report to which he referred.
We expect the health information Bill to be published in the course of this year.
Comment on this
Will the report I referred to be published shortly? It has been with the Department of Health and Children since October. I have spoken to the Minister for Health and Children twice but nothing has happened.
Comment on this
I have no information on that report. The Deputy will have to put down a question to the Minister.
Comment on this
In regard to the Bill to which the Deputy referred, for which I am responsible to the House, it will be published during the course of the year. I am not here to answer specific questions on health.
Comment on this
This is not a matter solely for the Department of Health and Children. It is a public health issue. The self-serving response in the case of the institution in question, with serious staff deficits and a serious lack of care in a nursing home run by a medical doctor——
Comment on this
Yes. We currently have a situation, as reported in The Irish Times yesterday, where there is no inspection regime for facilities caring for children and adults with disabilities. Under the health information Bill, will the Taoiseach afford us the opportunity to put that in place before the end of the year in order to show that we look after the truly vulnerable?
Second, I note the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food is in the House. The board of Teagasc is meeting today.
Comment on this
Yes, it relates to the forestry Bill. Teagasc's proposal to close down Kinsealy will have damaging consequences for horticulture in the State. That is a national issue.
Comment on this
There is scope under the forestry Bill.
Comment on this
Third, has the Government any plans to introduce legislation to control the blight of head shops whose numbers are growing throughout the State?
Comment on this
It is a very serious matter. Will legislation be introduced in this regard?
Comment on this
The Deputy is turning the Order of Business into Question Time. If I allow that, we will be on the Order of Business all day.
Comment on this
I hate to correct the Ceann Comhairle but he is wrong. I am asking a legitimate question. Is there planned legislation in regard to the control of head shops?
Comment on this
It is a legitimate question. Is legislation being put in place to protect children from the harm being done by these outlets?
Comment on this
When this issue was raised yesterday by Deputy Naughten, I indicated that the Department of Health and Children is preparing regulations to introduce controls relating to a range of substances on sale in head shops. These regulations are similar to those recently introduced in the United Kingdom, although I understand the latter have run into some legal trouble.
Comment on this
Would the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food like to tell us whether he has instructed the board of Teagasc in any way in regard to the closure of Kinsealy?
Comment on this
That is an operational matter for Teagasc and the latter has nothing to do with forestry.
Comment on this
Kinsealy is under the control of Teagasc.
Comment on this
I thought Deputy Reilly's party was anxious to get rid of quangos.
Comment on this
In view of the obvious and clear evidence to the effect that a considerable amount of reckless lending took place throughout the banking——
Comment on this
We are on promised legislation. If the Ceann Comhairle lets me finish, my question will emerge.
Comment on this
We were working with him, a Cheann Comhairle.
Comment on this
In view of the obvious, clear and emerging evidence to the effect——
Comment on this
——that a considerable amount of irresponsible lending took place in the banking system, can I ask——
Comment on this
Is the Deputy asking about promised business in this area? Would it be more appropriate for the Deputy to ask the Minister for Finance about the matter during this afternoon's Question Time?
Comment on this
With all due respect, a Cheann Comhairle, I am entitled to ask a question on promised legislation, but you keep interrupting.
Comment on this
You are interfering with the right of a Member of the House to ask about promised legislation. Can I attempt to ask my question again, this time without interruption?
Comment on this
In view of the clear evidence that irresponsible lending has taken place in this country's banking system over the past five or seven years, is it intended to approve the heads of the Bills that will deal with that issue? I refer to the Central Bank (consolidation) Bill, publication of which is expected; the Central Bank (No. 2) Bill, publication of which is expected; the financial services (miscellaneous provisions) Bill, publication of which is expected; and the financial services (regulation) Bill, publication of which is expected although it is not possible to indicate at this stage when that will happen. Has the Government done anything to approve the heads of those crucial Bills, having regard to the important issues with which they will deal?
Comment on this
A two-Bill approach is being proposed to make legislative progress in this area during 2010. The first Bill will be relatively short and will concentrate on the reform of the regulatory structures in the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland. The second Bill will facilitate the other legislative changes that are needed to reform and enhance the functions and powers of the restructured banks. Some important regulatory-enhancing elements may be included in the first Bill, as long as they do not lead to a delay in completing that legislation. The Minister for Finance will shortly seek Government approval for the heads of the first Bill and for his officials to proceed with drafting. It is intended to have that Bill enacted by Easter, or shortly thereafter. It is hoped to have the second Bill enacted in the current year and, if possible, to consolidate all the Central Bank legislation into a single statute in 2010. Work on this project will proceed, as far as possible, simultaneously with work on the other two Bills.
Comment on this
Can I ask the Taoiseach about promised legislation? For more than three years, Deputies on these benches have been hammering away at the need for legislation governing the operation of management companies. We cannot get answers to our questions about when the legislation will come into the House. What do I need to do to get that information? Do I have to contact Deputy Mattie McGrath to find out when the Bill will be introduced in the House? The Taoiseach has previously told the House that the Bill got lost in the Seanad and is being considered, etc. When will the Bill come into the House? Developers are going bust and management companies are disappearing at a time when people are suffering from flooding. Nobody can find anyone on the telephone who is responsible.
Comment on this
I thought they had no business to do, even though they are sitting on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays.
Comment on this
The Minister has withdrawn this Bill from the Seanad, in effect, even though it was agreed by the Government on Second Stage.
Comment on this
When a group of builders approached the Minister to say the legislation did not suit them, he withdrew it from the Seanad, in effect.
Comment on this
In such circumstances, is there any way for us to raise the matter in this House? It is not really before the Seanad at all at this stage.
Comment on this
They are sitting up there having statements three days a week. Why are they not passing legislation?
Comment on this
Is there any means by which we can legitimately raise the matter?
Comment on this
No, I am asking you this question, a Cheann Comhairle. It is a question of the manner in which we can highlight the ordering of the business of the House.
Comment on this
The Government should get Senator Donie Cassidy to sit on Fridays, or perhaps get rid of the other House altogether.
Comment on this
Is there any method we can use to legitimately raise the long delay in this regard? It took the Government eight years to put a Bill together. It was agreed after long consultation with all bodies. It went to the Seanad and was passed on Second Stage, but it is now stuck because the Minister has withdrawn it, in effect.
Comment on this
The option of a Private Members' Bill might just provide a solution to the Deputy's query.
Comment on this
It would not be worth the paper it would be written on.
Comment on this
We introduced such a Bill, but it was voted down.
Comment on this
The people cannot wait for action to be taken in respect of this urgent issue, which I raised yesterday. The Bill has been abandoned.
Comment on this
What are you talking about? It is the Government's job to legislate. The Government introduced this Bill, before withdrawing it again.
Comment on this
No motion has been tabled to withdraw the Bill. It has not been withdrawn. A great deal of work has been done. The stakeholders are being consulted on an ongoing basis.
Comment on this
Was that not done before the Bill was published?
Comment on this
The Government has had eight years to bring a Bill to the House.
Comment on this
Deputy Stagg would want to read his post.
Comment on this
There are stakeholders in every town.
Comment on this
They are the builders, in effect, on the ground.
Comment on this
In fairness, "stakeholders" is a nice new name for developers. That is a good one.
Comment on this
They drove a stake into the heart of the Irish economy.
Comment on this
The Government has had eight years in which to put the Bill together.
Comment on this
The builders came back and said the Bill did not suit them.
Comment on this
A Cheann Comhairle, I apologise for the interruptions. Can we hear from the Taoiseach about the current status of the Bill?
Comment on this
The Deputy can blame the people behind him.