Order of Business.
Contributions 153–309 of 309. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
The Bill has not been in the Seanad for a year and a half.
Comment on this
It should have been passed by now.
Comment on this
Deputy Rabbitte's memory is letting him down again.
Comment on this
The Ceann Comhairle is getting agitated.
Comment on this
That was a great deduction by Deputy Burton, given that today is 3 February.
Comment on this
What did he say when he wrote to the Whips yesterday?
Comment on this
I am not going to stand up here ten times and be interrupted ten times. What is the point? Do the Deputies think I am an eejit?
Comment on this
Perhaps Deputy Stagg will restrain himself. The Taoiseach is about to answer.
Comment on this
What did yesterday's letter say? Is the Government bringing the Bill into the House?
Comment on this
If I am allowed to say what I want to say without being interrupted, I will say it. If there are any more interruptions, we will forget about it. The Deputies can find out from the Minister what is in the letter, because there is no point in me talking about it.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach should not be petulant. It does not suit him.
Comment on this
The Deputies opposite might not have anything else to do for the rest of the day, but I have a few things to do.
Comment on this
Deputy Stagg does that deliberately to rile the Taoiseach.
Comment on this
Is the Deputy suggesting that he deliberately fails to read his post?
Comment on this
The Taoiseach needs to remember what happened with Deputy Gogarty — we do not want that to happen again.
Comment on this
The Deputy is the deputy leader of her party for the time being — that is all I will say.
Comment on this
The Minister wrote to the Whips on 2 February last to explain the various issues that are being considered, including the scope of the Bill, the voting rights and the annual service charges. He gave the Whips that information because this issue has been arising regularly. He assured everyone that work on the development of the necessary amendments is proceeding with the Office of the Attorney General and the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel. We are anxious to bring this matter to finality as quickly as we can. There are complex issues involved. If it were a simple and easy matter, it would have been done by now. I acknowledge and accept that this matter has been ongoing for some time. We are trying to resolve the issues in a sensible way that will work for everybody and get the job done. The Minister wrote to the Whips yesterday to update them on the points I have made. The Whips have the detail of the letter.
Comment on this
Was the letter sent to the Dáil Whips or the Seanad Whips?
Comment on this
It was sent to the Dáil Whips, including Deputy Stagg, as they have been raising the matter regularly.
Comment on this
I thank the Taoiseach for that information. I understand he is meeting representatives of the Irish House Builders Association on the matter in the Department of Justice, Equality and Law Reform today. Will a similar meeting be organised with representatives of tenants and owner occupiers who are in trouble?
Comment on this
Does the Government have any plans to help the 6,500 householders who have mortgage arrears of more than a year?
Comment on this
They are facing the real threat of repossession of the family home as the moratorium comes to an end.
Comment on this
Has the Government put a plan in place to help these people?
Comment on this
The Green Party has announced that it is looking into the matter and intends to appoint a task force. Can we get a solution?
Comment on this
When I dealt with this matter yesterday, I made the point that the mortgage interest subsidy initiative is helping 14,000 families at the moment.
Comment on this
The initiative will not help the 6,500 families that have mortgage arrears.
Comment on this
I heard the Taoiseach's earlier response to Deputies Gilmore and Kenny regarding the horrendous unemployment figures. Is it intended that the Tánaiste should meet the chief executive of Kraft Foods, Irene Rosenfeld, regarding the current threat to almost 1,200 jobs?
Comment on this
Allow me to finish the question as the Taoiseach is listening. I refer to the threats to almost 1,200 jobs in Coolock and north Kerry.
Comment on this
The Deputy should consider other ways to raise this matter such as the Adjournment or a parliamentary question, rather than on the Order of Business. There are so many other ways. We are turning meetings with business interests——
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is aware that the Tánaiste has a track record of meeting companies after the jobs have been lost.
Comment on this
Perhaps this time she might do her job and meet them proactively or whatever must be done. I note that Lord Mandelson has met Ms Rosenfeld.
Comment on this
I thank the Ceann Comhairle but I already have dealt with the matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy must have read the letter.
Comment on this
On promised legislation, I wish to ask the Taoiseach a question regarding the road traffic Bill. Last weekend's newspaper reports included a story about a particular individual who has 400 convictions for burglary in the North of Ireland and who has set up a private car park management company down here. He has been highly controversial.
Comment on this
This matter pertains to the road traffic Bill.
Comment on this
This individual's dealings with people have been highly controversial and the controversies that have been raised have been all over the national airwaves. This highlights the need for regulation of the area of private car park operations and clamping. In the United Kingdom, during last November's——
Comment on this
——Queen's speech, it was announced that regulation would be introduced in respect of clamping operations there.
Comment on this
It would be more appropriate to raise this matter at Question Time to the appropriate line Minister.
Comment on this
In Scotland, it has been outlawed as extortion. Does the Taoiseach not agree that, as the road traffic Bill is on the legislative list, perhaps it is time to include therein some movement towards the regulation of private clamping operations? At present, such operators are charging 50% more to release the clamp than is the case on Merrion Square or St. Stephen's Green.
Comment on this
They are highly aggressive in the manner in which they are dealing with it and the public in Ireland needs as much protection as in Scotland or elsewhere in the United Kingdom. Is it not time to regulate for this matter and does this not constitute an opportunity to do it?
Comment on this
I understand the road traffic Bill awaits its Second Stage debate, which will give the Deputy and others an opportunity to raise such points with the Minister to ascertain whether this proposal could be accommodated.
Comment on this
It sounds like a highly desirable investment in this environment.
Comment on this
I refer to No. 67 on the list, namely, the mental health (amendment) Bill, the stated objective of which is to provide a number of amendments to the Mental Health Act 2001. Can the Taoiseach confirm whether this Bill intends to take on board the recommendations of Amnesty International? They include updating the Act in line with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and to spread the responsibility to other Departments, other than the Department of Health and Children. Will the new legislation include the delivery of proper community-based services?
Comment on this
In fairness, I do not make too many speeches in the House——
Comment on this
——and No. 67 is vague in respect of what it promises.
Comment on this
This is the Cinderella area of health——
Comment on this
——and figures for the first quarter of 2009 show a 43% increase in suicides. This is the first time in years that an increase in suicides has been recorded.
Comment on this
The Deputy will be able to articulate these points when the legislation is introduced.
Comment on this
My question is whether the recommendations of Amnesty International will be incorporated into this Bill.
Comment on this
Perhaps the Taoiseach will help it along in respect of what it should contain.
Comment on this
Certainly, and were the Deputy to write to the Minister directly, I am sure he would receive a direct response.
Comment on this
I wish to raise two issues with the Taoiseach. First, this morning he rejected accusations of complacency within the Government.
Comment on this
I refer to two parliamentary questions I had tabled and which were due for reply yesterday, namely, Nos. 470 and 526. Although they were only one-line questions, the response I received was: "In the time available it is not possible to provide the information requested." The Taoiseach should provide the reason for this. Is the Minister on a go-slow, is the Government on a go-slow or is it simply the public servants? Why were these questions not answered? They were simple one-line questions.
Comment on this
Second, I refer to the issue of the regulation of debt management. The Taoiseach should inform the House which proposed finance-related Bill on the legislative list will deal with regulation of debt management. Will No. 57, No. 59 or No. 60 do so?
Comment on this
This pertains to promised legislation.
Comment on this
But I have asked questions and the Ministers have not had time to answer them.
Comment on this
This is promised legislation regarding the regulation of debt management. As this matter does not appear to be catered for in Nos. 57, 59 or 60, the Taoiseach should identify under which Bill the issue of debt management and the regulation thereof will be dealt with and when.
Comment on this
The Deputy seeks specific information that is more appropriate to the line Minister.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is the man who knows and who has all the answers.
Comment on this
When I ask questions of Ministers, they do not have time to reply. What am I going to do?
Comment on this
The Government has been on a go-slow for two years.
Comment on this
The response referred to the time available. The Government is running out of time.
Comment on this
It must be the 30 km/h speed limit.
Comment on this
The Deputy is on a diet and is going through hell at present.
Comment on this
Deputy Mattie McGrath will have to be called on.
Comment on this
Deputy Mattie McGrath has made so many false starts that were he a horse, he would have to be put down.
Comment on this
He said he was very disappointed and deflated.
Comment on this
Following the resignation of the chairman and chief executive of the Red Cross, as well as concerns being raised about various aspects of the operation of that organisation in Ireland, will the Minister——
Comment on this
Yes, that is what I am coming to. Will the Taoiseach give a commitment that, as promised by the Minister for Defence during a recent Question Time, legislation will be introduced regarding the governance and operation of the Red Cross in Ireland? Is legislation pending or is it being considered by the Government at present?
Comment on this
I am informed there is no legislation pending. If the Deputy has been speaking directly to the Minister for Defence on such matters, I am sure he is in a position to outline what is his position.
Comment on this
Have proposals come before the Government to establish a boundary commission for Limerick city?
Comment on this
Willie wants to spread his wings.
Comment on this
Members have been promised one. Even the Minister for Defence, Deputy O'Dea, agrees with the proposal.
Comment on this
Willie wants to spread his wings as he has run out of houses.
Comment on this
He signed a letter to that effect, as did all five Deputies for Limerick East. Consequently, the Taoiseach may be assured the Government will get full support in this regard.
Comment on this
Deputy O'Sullivan should consider submitting a parliamentary question on the matter. A parliamentary question——
Comment on this
The agreement of all five Deputies on a matter from Limerick East is a unique event that should be commemorated.
Comment on this
I seek the protection of the Chair as I did not hear the Taoiseach's reply to that question.
Comment on this
Has there been agreement from would-be Deputies?
Comment on this
They are keeping it among themselves.
Comment on this
I ask the Taoiseach for his views in respect of the forthcoming finance Bill. It has been reported that the Minister for Finance appears to be getting ready for another attack upon rural Ireland through the removal of the tax exemptions for a site to be transferred from a parent to child in the finance Bill. The word has gone out from the Department of Finance and the Revenue Commissioners.
Comment on this
Deputy, when Members get around to discussing the Bill, there will be an ideal opportunity to articulate these points.
Comment on this
I refer to the finance Bill and I am asking the Taoiseach's opinion prior to that debate. When it is done it is a fait accompli ——
Comment on this
——and everyone will march up through the middle of the Chamber to pass the finance Bill.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach is from a rural constituency and I seek his view as to whether it is correct and appropriate to remove the tax relief in respect of the transfer of a site from a parent to a child.