We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Banking System: Motion.

Contributions 1–136 of 303. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Brian Lenihan Minister for Finance Fianna Fáil

I move:

That Dáil Éireann:

notes that the Government has taken bold and successful action to address funding problems in the Irish financial system through the introduction of the bank guarantee schemes and to remove the riskiest loans from the balance sheets of the participating institutions through the NAMA process, which has the support of the IMF, the OECD, the ECB and the European Commission;

affirms that the Irish economy needs a functioning banking system that enjoys the trust of depositors, international markets and the community at large in order to benefit from the global economic recovery;

supports the Government in the measures it is announcing today for the final phase of the stabilisation process of the banking system;

supports the Government in the actions it is taking to ensure that each participating institution in the NAMA process will meet the Financial Regulator's new capital standards by the end of 2010; and

supports the Government's structured and measured approach to the issues facing the financial sector in general, which represents the best way to secure its interests and those of the recovering economy while keeping in mind the requirements of the EU."

The country has come a long way since we introduced the State bank guarantee 18 months ago.

Comment on this

That is what the Minister thinks.

Comment on this

Back then, our banks were on the brink of financial collapse and our economy had gone into reverse. Revenue had fallen steeply and unemployment had risen sharply. For the first time in a quarter of a century, we were experiencing negative growth.

Economic activity remains weak and we face further difficult decisions. The crucial difference, however, is that we now have a credible fiscal position. That is because in the past two years, we have introduced budgetary adjustments of more than €15 billion. As a result, we are now in a position to stabilise the deficit and we are on a firm path to economic recovery.

This adjustment has imposed a heavy burden on our citizens. Taxes have increased, public sector workers have suffered significant reductions in their pay and social welfare payments have been reduced. It is regularly suggested in the House, and outside, that these painful measures have been necessitated by our banking crisis and the cuts in pay are funding a bailout of the banks. That is wrong. The reason we had to make substantial savings is because of the huge gap that opened up between the revenue we take in and the cost of running the State. We are borrowing for day-to-day expenses which all Members know is not sustainable.

Our determination to deal with this imbalance in our public finances through firm and decisive action has engendered real confidence in our economy on the international stage. The outside world believes in us and in our ability to work our way through our difficulties and return to growth.

Jean-Claude Trichet, president of the European Central Bank, recently said, "In the case of Ireland very, very tough decisions have been taken by the Government and rightly so". More recently, Mr. Trichet's colleague, José Manuel González-Páramo of the European Central Bank's executive board, said, "The Irish measures are very courageous. They are going in the right direction". The French Minister of Finance, Christine Lagarde said, "Ireland has set the high standard the rest of us must follow". On a recent visit to Ireland, the German Minister for European Affairs, Dr. Werner Hoyer, said, "I think there is a deeply rooted trust and confidence in this country's ability to sort out its problems. . . . There is a fundamental belief that the Irish are going to solve it".

Already, we have reaped the benefits of this growing confidence. Since last April's supplementary budget and the announcement of the decision to establish NAMA, borrowing costs have fallen and our bond spreads have halved. This trend was reinforced by last December's budget which outlined the next stage of our plans to return to a sustainable fiscal position. That is why we must retain our fiscal discipline.

Having stabilised our public finances, we must move to the final phase in stabilising our banking system. There has been much criticism of the length of time it has taken us to get to this point. I reject such criticism. Crucial pieces of the jigsaw had to fall into place before we could embark on this ultimate phase of our bank rescue.

First, we are in a position to do what we are doing today because as a sovereign State we are now fiscally stable and credible. Second, we now know the extent of the losses in our banks and the scale of the damage that has been done by the excessive lending and bad practices of recent years. Through its bottom-up valuation exercise, the National Asset Management Agency, NAMA, is progressively valuing and removing the most impaired loans from the system. Third, we now have in place a Financial Regulator of international standing who has independently and rigorously reviewed the capital requirements of the Irish banking system in accordance with best international practice.

Comment on this

Is he better than the last one?

Comment on this

The capital requirements that I will outline presently to the House have been set by the Financial Regulator and announced separately by him in the past hour. That is as it should be.

We now have in place a more stringent regulatory system overseen by the Central Bank Governor, Professor Patrick Honohan, and the Financial Regulator, Matthew Elderfield. The new fully integrated structures replacing the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland will be established in law by the Central Bank Reform Bill which I published earlier today. The new Central Bank will be responsible for maintaining the stability of the financial system, the effective regulation of financial institutions and markets and safeguarding the interests of consumers and investors.

The Bill enhances the accountability of the Central Bank and oversight by the Oireachtas of its regulatory performance. I have included in the Bill a provision that gives the bank new powers to ensure the fitness and probity of nominees to key positions within financial institutions. This key provision will, from the outset, reinforce the tone of the new regulatory regime. It will help to restore confidence in the management of the banks at home and in the international markets.

A further Bill to be published in the autumn will contain additional new and enhanced regulatory powers and functions of the restructured Central Bank. A third bill will consolidate all existing statutory arrangements. Further details of today's Bill are included in the information booklet that will be circulated to Members. There will be consultation with stakeholders and the legislation will be enacted as soon as possible after Easter.

The detailed information that has emerged from the banks in the course of the NAMA process is truly shocking. At every hand's turn our worst fears have been surpassed. Some institutions were worse than others but our banking system, to a greater or lesser extent, engaged in reckless property development lending. In far too many cases there were also shoddy banking practices. The banks played fast and loose with the economic interests of this country.

Our previous regulatory system failed abysmally and it is right that the role of the regulator, the Central Bank and the Government is now the subject of independent inquiry——

Comment on this

A partial inquiry.

Comment on this

——but the fact remains that senior figures in Irish banking made appalling lending decisions that will cost the taxpayer dearly for years to come. As I said in this House last September during the debate on the NAMA legislation, the banks should be extremely grateful for the continued support and forbearance extended by the citizens. They must now repay that debt——

Comment on this

By increasing interest rates.

Comment on this

——by facilitating the economic recovery widely forecast to get under way in the second half of this year. The Government will insist that they do so by supplying credit to viable businesses and households in this State.

Today, we are entering the ultimate phase in the resolution of our financial crisis. NAMA has determined the price to be paid for the first tranche of loans to be transferred to the agency, after detailed and painstaking loan by loan analysis. The Financial Regulator and the Central Bank have carried out their analysis of the appropriate capital requirements for financial institutions so as to ensure not just the bare regulatory minimum, but a prudent and adequate deployment of capital. I will outline in detail to the House the Government's response to these developments and explain the strategy for addressing the needs of the banking sector and individual banks.

The process of transferring the eligible loans from the designated financial institutions to NAMA has begun. The first tranche of loans has an original book value of approximately €16 billion. This tranche consists of just over 1,200 individual loans owed by the ten largest borrowers. This first tranche represents 20% of the anticipated total assets to transfer. The transfer of these loans should be completed for four institutions in the coming days, with Anglo Irish Bank following next week. NAMA has advised me the whole transfer process remains on target for completion by the final quarter of the year.

NAMA's work has enabled us to estimate with greater accuracy the overall discount to be applied to each institution and the likely total amount of loans to be transferred. The original value of the loans transferred in the first tranche is €3.29 billion for AIB from a total of €23 billion in eligible loans; for Bank of Ireland, €1.93 billion from a total of €12 billion; for Anglo Irish Bank, €10 billion from a total of €36 billion; for INBS, €670 million from a total of €9 billion; and for EBS, approximately €140 million from a total of €1 billion.

The difference between what NAMA has paid for these loans and the original value attributed to them by the institutions, or the so-called haircut, is as follows: AIB, 43%; Bank of Ireland, 35%; Anglo Irish Bank, about 50%; INBS, 58%;——

Comment on this

Who was involved in that?

Comment on this

——and EBS, 37%. The weighted average haircut across these institutions is 47%. These discounts have been calculated following loan-by-loan assessments, including legal due diligence, detailed valuation processes and internal and external checking processes, including external audit. The doubters have been proved wrong. NAMA has carried out its valuations in a hard-headed commercial manner. The interests of the taxpayer are paramount in this exercise.

The fall in value of the transferred loans means the banks will now have to recognise these losses up front. Decisions on the appropriate capital requirements are a matter for the Financial Regulator in conjunction with the Central Bank. A robust recapitalisation exercise will ensure that the banks are not just adequately but properly and prudently capitalised so they can absorb these losses and foreseeable future losses that may arise on remaining loans. The banks will then be in a better position to attract funding. The regulator has advised me that he will institute an 8% core tier 1 capital requirement, of which 7% must be equity. This is a prudent capital provision consistent with emerging best practice internationally. The regulator has performed a detailed assessment of the capital requirements, current and under a stress scenario, over a three-year time horizon and has determined the additional capital requirement of each institution participating in NAMA. The capital to meet these new requirements must be in place in each of the institutions by the end of 2010. I fully agree with the regulator's view that we do not want institutions to get by on a bare minimum of capital. This only prolongs their difficulties. The capital requirements are set by the new regulator and are being imposed on the banks.

I will now outline the implications for each institution of the regulator's decisions and give details of their capital needs, the proposed solutions and the anticipated Government ownership of each institution.

Bank of Ireland will transfer €1.93 billion of assets to NAMA in the first tranche, which represents 16% of its €12 billion NAMA assets. NAMA has confirmed it will buy the loans transferred in the first tranche at an average discount of 35%. Taking account of this and his broader assessment of the bank, the regulator has determined that Bank of Ireland must raise additional equity capital of €2.7 billion by the end of the year to meet the new capital standards. I have been advised that Bank of Ireland expects to be able to raise private capital and is well advanced in its actions to address its capital needs, which I believe underlines the strength of the institution. I fully support the bank's objective to meet a substantial amount of its capital requirement from private sources. I believe Bank of Ireland has a strong future. In conjunction with this private capital raising and to support it, the State will commit to converting part of its preference shares in Bank of Ireland into ordinary equity. This process requires no new investment of State funds. This conversion will be executed on market terms and the State will achieve full value for its investment in the bank.

Based on the current envisaged structure, the State expects to remain a minority shareholder in the bank. In recapitalising Bank of Ireland, we will secure an institution that will maintain a presence in the international capital markets, provide loan finance to individuals and businesses and support our economic recovery. These proposals are dependent upon the agreement to the bank's restructuring plan by the European Commission. I have discussed the main elements with Commissioner Almunia and I am satisfied there is the basis for agreement between us on the overall framework of the bank's plan but further discussions are required on all the details.

Allied Irish Banks will transfer €3.29 billion of assets to NAMA in the first tranche, which represents 14% of its €23 billion NAMA assets. NAMA has confirmed that it will buy the loans transferred in the first tranche at an average discount of 43%. Taking account of this and his broader assessment of the bank, the regulator has determined that Allied Irish Banks must raise additional equity capital of at least €7.4 billion by the end of the year to meet the new base case capital standards. In view of the extent of capital to be raised, Allied Irish Banks will be required by the regulator to produce a detailed capital plan by the end of April this year.

The basic elements of this plan are already clear. Allied Irish Banks is in a position to raise capital through the sale of overseas assets. As the first step in meeting its capital needs, the bank will immediately commence the process of sale of assets in the US, Poland and in Great Britain. The sale of these assets will be completed this year, subject to regulatory clearances. The disposal proceeds will provide significant capital but it will not be sufficient to address the full requirement. To the extent that the gap is not filled by the private sector, the State is willing to convert some or all of its preference shares as required on terms to be agreed that will provide full value for the State. Depending on the structure of the capital raising and the extent of private participation, it may be that no new Exchequer funding is required but if additional money is required it will be provided by way of ordinary equity. Any additional capital requirement will be met from the National Pensions Reserve Fund.

The private sector will have an opportunity to participate in Allied Irish Banks's capital raising. If sufficient private capital is not available, it is probable that the State will have a majority shareholding in Allied Irish Banks as a listed entity but this is far preferable to an undercapitalised or only adequately capitalised entity. These proposals are dependent on agreement with the European Commission in the context of the assessment of the bank's restructuring plan.

Finding a long-term solution for Anglo Irish Bank is by far the biggest challenge in resolving the banking crisis. The sheer size of the bank means there are no easy or low cost options, as often suggested. Winding up the bank is not and has never been a viable option. As the bank's new management and board have estimated, an immediate wind-up would lead to a fire sale of assets resulting in a permanent additional and unnecessary loss of upwards of €30 billion. In addition, the State would have to provide, immediately and up-front, the large sum of €70 billion to meet the deposit, and bondholders' requirements and liabilities due to the Eurosystem.

Similarly, a longer term wind-down is not in the taxpayer's interest. The new management has provided me with figures, assessed by independent financial advisers, indicating that in addition to the capital losses that would be sustained, a long-term wind-down of the bank over ten years could expose the State to funding obligations approaching €30 billion. I understand why many want us to close this bank. I understand also the impulse to obliterate it from the system. However, I cannot, as Minister for Finance, countenance such a course. The realisation of the costs involved and the wider disruption to the financial system would generate enormous instability for the State, with unforeseeable but potentially long-lasting damage to the overall economy. The unavoidable reality is that the bank has incurred losses from its large-scale property lending and needs substantial further capital. Unpalatable as it is, only the taxpayer can provide that capital. It is the least worst option. For this reason, I am this week providing €8.3 billion to support the capital position of the bank to take account of the bank's losses to date. Additional capital support is likely to be required depending on the NAMA discount on the first tranche of Anglo Irish Bank loans transferred to it. The bank will provide comprehensive information on its financial position in its annual report for the 15-month period to end 2009 which will be published later this week.

The bank will need further capital to cover future losses and accomplish the restructuring of the bank and its balance sheet. The current estimate is that this could be of the order of a further €10 billion over time.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Good Lord.

Comment on this

There is no end to this.

Comment on this

However, notwithstanding very substantial work under way on the bank's restructuring plan, there are still significant uncertainties about this figure, including the size of the discount on all of its loans transferring to NAMA, the scale of future losses on its loans that are not transferred to NAMA and the exact nature and scope of any split of the bank under its plans and the EU Commission decision on the plan.

It is because of the heavy loan losses already incurred on a loan book of €72 billion and those in prospect that the injection of resources into this bank is so large. There is simply no alternative that meets the bank's unavoidable obligations at a lower cost consistent with the maintenance of the hard-won stability of the banking system in Ireland. The bank is expected to transfer approximately €10 billion of loans to NAMA in the first tranche. This tranche will not transfer until early April as the valuations have not been finalised. The latest available unaudited estimate of the discount is in the order of 50%.

The bank's capital support is being provided by the State in a way which spreads the cash requirements over an extended period. I am this week injecting the capital in the form of a promissory note payable over a number of years into the future. In essence, this means the amount will be paid over a period of ten to 15 years, thereby reducing the impact on the Exchequer this year and stretching the payments into the future.

Since nationalisation of the bank on 21 January 2009 there has been a wholesale replacement of key top executives and the board. The new chief executive and new senior management team have implemented rigorous and robust risk management processes and controls. There have been cost base reductions following a detailed cost review and a voluntary redundancy scheme. As part of this recapitalisation, the bank will reduce costs further. The bank's new senior management team is working closely with my Department to update and strengthen its restructuring plan as submitted to the EU Commission last November. Following a comprehensive evaluation of strategic restructuring options, the bank has identified as its preferred option, in terms of minimising the future cost to the taxpayer, to carve out a smaller and stronger bank, leaving the remainder in the form of an asset management and recovery company.

Comment on this

What about a bad bank?

Comment on this

The new going concern entity would be prepared for sale in due course. This option is being evaluated and holds out the prospect of reducing the impact on the taxpayer and yielding some value in the future when the bank is sold out of State hands. The bank has estimated that the new bank could become profitable over the medium term and a target exit from State hands could take place in five to seven years' time.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Wishful thinking.

Comment on this

This is a complex process but I am confident that by the end of the summer we will have a clear plan for the future of the bank approved by the Commission. The bank will give more details on the likely costs of various options for its future when it publishes its results. The sums required to rescue the bank are enormous but the costs of winding it down are even greater. The current bank strategy of seeking to devise a way to realise value for the taxpayer from the remains of the old bank means the State could at least get some return in time, recouping some of its assistance. I assure the House that the bank shares my overriding objective to maximise the potential return for the taxpayer in recognition of the State support.

Traditionally, building societies have played a vital role in providing residential mortgages in Ireland. In recent years the Educational Building Society, EBS and, in particular, Irish Nationwide Building Society, INBS, became involved in non-residential lending. In the case of INBS such lending became its primary focus, comprising approximately 80% of its lending business. As a result it has incurred significant losses on speculative lending for land and development and commercial investment loans. In the case of INBS, approximately €9 billion will have to transfer to NAMA while in the case of EBS approximately €1 billion will transfer.

Both societies have passed resolutions allowing them to issue new special investment shares to the State in return for its support. Both institutions have recently been subject to the Regulator's capital assessment process to determine their capital needs. Irish Nationwide Building Society, INBS, will transfer €670 million of assets to NAMA in the first tranche, which represents 7% of its €9 billion NAMA assets. NAMA has confirmed that it will buy the loans transferred in the first tranche at an average discount of 58%. Taking account of this and his broader assessment of the building society, the regulator has determined that INBS will need an injection of €2.6 billion to remain compliant with its current regulatory capital requirements. This is a very large bill for the taxpayer but as in the case of Anglo Irish Bank, it is the least costly solution.

It is important to highlight that this level of capital support is required to maintain the institution's financial position in light of the large losses incurred on its loan portfolio. Without this capital injection, the taxpayer would have to shoulder the significant and immediate costs in meeting the deposits, bondholders and liabilities due to the European Central Bank. I intend to inject the necessary capital through a combination of €100 million in special investment shares in the society and a promissory note for €2.6 billion issued to the society, giving the society a small buffer.

Comment on this

It is considerably large.

Comment on this

This note will be payable over ten to 15 years, which will reduce the impact on the Exchequer this year. Following the investment by means of the special investment shares, the State will have extensive powers as well as economic ownership of Irish Nationwide Building Society. As a result, the State will control the society.

Following the transfer of €9 billion of its loan book to NAMA, Irish Nationwide Building Society, INBS, will have a small mainly residential loan book of approximately €2 billion. In such circumstances, the institution does not have a future as an independent stand-alone entity. The Government's priority will be to secure a swift sale of the society or its integration with another entity. All options will be fully examined in the institution's EU restructuring plan which must be completed within three months. Deposits in the society are secure and it will continue to have adequate regulatory capital. As in the case of Anglo Irish Bank, a new management team is now in charge of Irish Nationwide Building Society, INBS. I will insist on board changes in the changed ownership circumstances.

The EBS will transfer approximately €140 million of assets to NAMA in the first tranche, which represents 14% of its €1 billion NAMA assets. The Agency has confirmed that it will buy the loans transferred in the first tranche at an average discount of 37%. Taking account of this and his broader assessment of the building society, the Regulator has determined that the society will need an injection of €875 million to meet the target sufficient to ensure 8% core tier 1 capital. To secure the Educational Building Society's immediate capital position, the State will provide it with €100 million of capital through the issuance of special investment shares in a manner consistent with the EU State aid rules. The issuance of these shares by EBS was approved by the society at its Extraordinary General Meeting in December 2009 and will give the State extensive powers and full economic ownership of EBS. The State will, therefore, have control over the future strategic direction of the society.

The EBS is currently exploring the availability of private market capital and has had an expression of interest from a private party. Any private capital transaction will need to comply with the relevant European Commission guidelines for an institution in receipt of State aid. To the extent that private capital is not forthcoming, the remaining capital requirement will be met partly or fully through the issuance of a promissory note from the State to the institution which will enhance the society's core capital by the same amount. If the promissory note is used, it would again reduce the impact on the Exchequer this year as the cost of the note would be paid over a period of ten to 15 years. The EBS will be required to submit a restructuring plan to the European Commission that will examine all options for the direction of the society by the end of June.

Whatever outcomes emerge, there is no doubt that, notwithstanding the differences between them, each society must recognise the position they have gotten themselves into. They must focus on making themselves more efficient. Their future value will be enhanced by a committed drive to improving efficiencies in the coming months. I am strongly of the view, and I am committed to ensuring, that the residential mortgage sector in Ireland is competitive. We want to see an appropriate number of participants in the market in order to meet future demand. Irish Life & Permanent is not taking part in the NAMA process. The regulator is satisfied that Irish Life & Permanent has sufficient capital to meet its needs. The regulator will continue to monitor the capital needs of Irish Life & Permanent and is in discussion with it.

The burden on taxpayers stemming from the losses incurred in our banking system is horrifying. Unless we face up to these losses now, we will not have a functioning banking system and the economy will not recover. My overriding concern throughout this financial crisis has been to get credit to viable businesses, especially small and medium-sized enterprises, which will lead our way out of this recession. The actions I have announced today will put the banks in a much stronger position than before.

I am imposing specific lending targets on AIB and Bank of Ireland. They will make available for targeted lending not less than €3 billion each for new or increased credit facilities to SMEs in 2010 and 2011. This, in particular, must include funds for working capital for businesses. This will be a significant increase on the figures reported by the banks for 2009 and will help to sustain the economy and foster growth. They will be reviewed as the needs of the economy change. Bank of Ireland and AIB must also make available €20 million each for seed capital to be provided to Enterprise Ireland supported ventures, building on the very successful programme launched in 2009. They will each set up a fund of up to €100 million for environmental, clean energy and innovation projects, in addition to the €100 million provided under the recapitalisation last year.

Historically, Irish banking has focused too much on property-related lending. It is fair to say that our banks have not been very well acquainted with our modern economic sectors. This will have to change. For that reason, I am requiring the banks to commit resources to work with Enterprise Ireland and the IBF to develop sectoral expertise in the modern growth sectors of the Irish economy; to explore with Enterprise Ireland and the IBF how best to develop the range of banking services that Irish enterprises trading internationally will need; and to develop expertise and bring forward new credit products in areas where cashflow, rather than property or assets, is the basis for business lending.

In line with the renewed programme for Government, the two banks will be required to submit SME lending plans by geography and sector for 2010 and 2011 in light of the €3 billion target. These plans are to be submitted to my Department within six weeks. They will be reviewed by Mr. John Trethowan, an experienced banker with a demonstrated commitment to public and social service who will be examining bank lending policies as part of his remit as credit reviewer. It is important to stress that credit can only go to viable businesses. The last thing we need is for the banks to incur high losses on risky loans. That sort of imprudent lending must be a thing of the past. The Government will decide, following Mr. Trethowan's review, whether further action on lending targets is needed, and what action should be taken.

AIB and Bank of Ireland will also be subject to a credit review process, headed by Mr. Trethowan, which will allow individual enterprises, sole traders and farmers who have had credit refused or withdrawn to apply for an independent review of the bank's decision. Where the reviewer recommends that credit should be granted, the bank is required to comply with the recommendation or explain why it will not do so. This process will also provide me with an accurate assessment of banks' lending policies and procedures. The administrative arrangements are in place and the statutory instrument is being laid before the House today. Accordingly, applications for a review will be accepted from today. The credit review process will give viable businesses in all sectors an opportunity for an independent second opinion, where credit is refused or withdrawn. The review will ensure that the banks, which have been supported by the State and the taxpayer, comply with their responsibilities to our economy. Mr. Trethowan will outline his work in this area later this week.

The prospect of a family losing its home is one the most appalling vistas in any recession. Those who find themselves in this position are likely to have lost their jobs as well. I do not need to tell anyone in this House the havoc and trauma such events can visit on the lives of those affected. The Government has taken a number of initiatives to support those having difficulty with their mortgages. It has introduced the statutory code of conduct on mortgage arrears for all lenders; extended the six-month moratorium on legal proceedings to 12 months; refocused mortgage interest relief on those who bought their homes at the peak of the market with extensions up to the end of 2017; provided financial help to over 15,000 families through the mortgage interest subsidy scheme; and increased the advisory services provided through the Money Advice and Budgeting Service.

In addition, the Irish Banking Federation has said where a satisfactory arrangement is reached and adhered to, its members will not take legal action against borrowers. The number of mortgage holders in arrears is still increasing, although more slowly than before. In general, repossession rates in Ireland remain extremely low. The guaranteed institutions told us that last year they sought and obtained orders for repossession through the courts in just 28 cases.

The question that has been asked in this House and outside is how banks that have been rescued by the State can be allowed to pursue homeowners experiencing difficulty with their mortgages. I acknowledge the anger and frustration of those who ask this question, but the Government's measures have been successful in minimising the number of repossessions and the institutions which have had most recourse to the courts are not covered by the guarantee. We must be careful that our efforts to help home owners do not store up more problems in the banking sector that will require further calls on the taxpayer. The revamped mortgage and debt group, which I announced recently, has started its examination of the extent of the problem of mortgage default and will report to me on a rolling basis on the most sensible and effective way to deal with this problem.

Comment on this

We have reviewed arrangements for the State's management of its investments in the banking system in anticipation of the potential changes in the State's interests in the banks. At present, the State's preference share investments in AIB and Bank of Ireland are funded and held on my behalf, as Minister, by the National Pensions Reserve Fund Commission. I have decided that it will be given the ongoing role of managing the State's financial investment in AIB and Bank of Ireland, as two banks listed on a stock exchange and operating at arm's length.

As Anglo Irish Bank is no longer listed, it is in a different position. Its shares are held directly and the NTMA will manage the State's ownership through a relationship framework. As they are not listed, I propose to hold directly any special investment shares in EBS and Irish Nationwide, and the NTMA will manage those interests on the basis of relationship frameworks which will ensure that each institution's board and management team will continue to run its business on an arm's length basis.

In September 2008, in response to the international financial crisis, Ireland introduced a two year blanket guarantee scheme for certain liabilities of covered institutions. A new, more targeted, scheme was introduced in December 2009 in order to facilitate the ability of credit institutions to issue debt securities and take deposits with a maturity post-September 2010 on either a guaranteed or unguaranteed basis. A key feature of the new scheme is access to longer-term funding, which is in line with the approach adopted elsewhere in the European Union and is expected to contribute significantly to supporting the funding needs of the banks and to securing their continued stability. In addition, banks can access unguaranteed funding under the new scheme.

Although the capital injections I am announcing today will greatly strengthen the position of the banks and serve to reassure their depositors, I am satisfied that it would be prudent to seek an extension of the guarantee in a more limited form until this confidence has been reliably restored. I will be seeking the Commission's agreement for a modified extension of the guarantee, consistent with a phasing out over a realistic period of time. As with the extended guarantee scheme, any new scheme will not cover subordinated debt. The existing subordinated debt guarantee will lapse at the end of September. This scheme is due to be reviewed by the Commission before 1 June and I intend to make an announcement about the future of the guarantee in advance of that date. I want to stress that the ordinary deposit guarantee scheme which covers €100,000 per depositor per institution is in place and will continue on a permanent basis. Nothing in today's announcement changes that position.

This evening, I have necessarily concentrated on the costs of resolving the banking crisis. There are upsides for the taxpayer who is funding these measures. First, we now have a clear path to fix the banking system and because of that we have safeguarded our economic future. Second, the aggressive valuations conducted by the National Asset Management Agency increase its prospects of securing a reasonable financial return for the taxpayer. Third, the NPRF will hold valuable shares in our two main banks which can realise gains for the citizens of this country. Fourth, there is the proven gain of €1 billion which will accrue to the taxpayer in six month's time from the bank guarantee scheme, and, finally, if a smaller and good bank can be carved out of Anglo Irish Bank's current loan book, we will recoup some of the taxpayers' assistance to that bank.

I began my statement by pointing out the widespread international confidence engendered by last December's budget. The citizens of this country have shown grit and determination in facing up to our severe budgetary difficulties and it has paid off.

Comment on this

They had no choice.

Comment on this

We are facing up to our banking difficulties. We have acknowledged the scale of our problems and we have taken the necessary actions to solve them. The banks have been forced to recognise their losses and this Government, on behalf of the taxpayer, has committed the capital that will ensure we have a banking system to serve this economy as it recovers.

The steps we are taking today will provide certainty to the people from whom we must borrow; certainty among our trading partners; and certainty to investors, both at home and overseas, who look to this country for opportunities. This certainty will further boost international confidence in our ability to recover. Others believe in us. We must now begin to believe in ourselves.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

No clap today.

Comment on this

We must believe it ourselves.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

To delete all words after "Dáil Éireann" and substitute the following:

"noting the complete failure of Government banking policy to support the provision of credit to personal and business banking customers;

suspends the transfer of toxic loans from all banks to NAMA and subsequent recapitalisations until:

a costing of Fine Gael's alternative ‘good bank/bad bank' plan for Anglo Irish Bank is commissioned from independent economic experts at the OECD;

the detailed costings of other options that have been considered by Anglo Irish Bank and the Government are published;

the merits of using the same resources for a new investment plan for the Irish economy in the areas of broadband, energy, water infrastructure and re-training are also assessed;

all these options are assessed by independent experts and their findings are presented to the Oireachtas for debate;

any further recapitalisation commitments to AIB, Bank of Ireland and EBS includes a watertight agreement on additional lending for small businesses and mortgage applicants; and

greater tangible financial support is provided to existing mortgage holders from different providers experiencing financial difficulty."

The decisions we are taking today will at one stroke double the national debt. What the Government is asking us to decide today is of truly horrendous proportions. The evidence has not been offered by the Government to sustain the decisions we are being asked to make, which will convert the loans that were recklessly run up by the bankers into sovereign debt. This debt will now be on our generation and future generations. Today's decisions will bring to €40 billion the amount the taxpayer will be asked to put into Anglo Irish Bank, which was run in a truly buccaneering way by Seán FitzPatrick and his colleagues. This is real money; this is mortgaging our futures. This is the final bill for the reckless economic management we have had to put up with for ten years.

Today is not the day for allocating blame among those who caused this. I do not disagree with the Minister's statement that bankers must take enormous responsibility for what was done there, but I also believe he should have the grace to recognise that regulators and the Government parties failed dismally and that they pursued a strategy in which there was an interlocking embrace between the regulator, the banks and the Government which saw no evil, spoke no evil and heard no evil. That was how those who warned of this impending crisis were treated. They were treated with contempt by Ministers. The Minister and his colleagues in government must look to their own stewardship as well as pointing their guns at the banks on this momentous day.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

We are today crossing the Rubicon. There can be no turning back from this decision. It is a final step in the journey the Government has taken and it is of truly huge proportions. We have to reflect on the advice we have regarding the earlier steps along the road. When the guarantee was introduced, we were told this would be the cheapest bailout of a banking system of any country. How hollow those words look now. When the first €11 billion in recapitalisation funding was introduced in the House, we were told this would result in credit flowing. How hollow those words have been. When NAMA came along, we were told there would be a wall of money in the banks available for lending and within weeks we heard the chief executive officers of the banks explaining the reality to us.

The Government, therefore, does not have a record of success as it asks us to accept on trust that these decisions today should be taken without evidence being presented that stands up to independent scrutiny. This is a huge gamble. We are being asked to accept that this is the least worst of the options available, but where is the analysis to show that? As Colm McCarthy, a Government adviser, said regarding prudent spending of public money, the onus is on the Minister to demonstrate to the House that this is the least worst option and, to be brutally honest, while his script mentioned many numbers, it did not confront the root issue and it has not demonstrated that.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

The doubling of the national debt today is significant. A total of €11 billion has been put in to recapitalise the banks and later we will vote on NAMA spending €43 billion to acquire toxic loans. The Minister stated €11 billion will be used for recapitalisation, most of which will go to Anglo Irish Bank, and a further €10 billion will be paid to that bank later. We are, therefore, being presented with a debt of €75 billion. People outside the House are flabbergasted by the scale of what is happening and they have worry heaped upon worry. Today, bad practices in the Quinn Group have resulted in the new Financial Regulator going to court to put two of its companies into administration. This is another worry for taxpayers and another potential bill that will come home to them to pay.

These are troubling times and the onus is on us in the House to take great care about the decisions we take. That is what we must do in undertaking scrutiny of what is before us. Our economy is in deep crisis and recovery depends on the choices we make today. I believe the Government is choosing to nurse along the bad decisions of the past to protect professional investors whose risk capital helped to protect them from any loss and that choice will put a huge squeeze on the capacity of the Government, or any future Government, to carve out a recovery strategy. A sum of €75 billion, of which €40 billion will go to Anglo Irish Bank alone, will dramatically constrain our freedom of manoeuvre to invest in our future and that has to be acknowledged.

It is important that the debate be conducted on the basis of hard evidence and not on myths. I am appalled that I still hear myths from the Government, which I would like to nail now. I have heard it argued time and again by Government spokesmen that failure to protect bondholders in the banks would amount to a default by the Irish people on its obligations. That is simply not true and even the Taoiseach repeats that myth time and again in the House. The debts run up by Seán FitzPatrick in creating his buccaneering bank are not taxpayer commitments. They were not borrowed by the taxpayer.

Comment on this
Deputies

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

They are commitments made by a dysfunctional bank, which was not properly regulated and which was encouraged in its folly. The guarantee we offered in 2008 will expire next September and, therefore, we offered bondholders a temporary guarantee while the banks got their affairs in order. It is simply wrong for Ministers to come into the House and pretend the taxpayer has an obligation to pay off all that money.

I want to nail another myth peddled by Government spokesmen, which is that this is a paper transaction that does not involve real money — it is ECB money or Monopoly money or soft money — and it is not part of our debt. It is no such thing. It is hard cash that our grandchildren will be obliged to pay. It is not cheap money. It is being borrowed at a short-term rate, which is the same as, if not greater than, the rate at which the Government is able to borrow. We hear this time and again, as if the additional €64 billion we are putting in today is soft money. This is real hard cash and we have to get that into our heads. The decisions we take later will reduce our capacity to do many things to which our people rightly aspire. Now is the time to be clear about what it is we the taxpayers want from the banking system and what we are willing to pay for. We want a good banking system capable of lending. We want banks of systemic importance to the economy to emerge from the crisis cleansed of their toxic loans. The Minister did not answer the question of why Anglo Irish Bank is regarded as being of systemic importance to this country.

Comment on this

Where is the evidence that it is of systemic importance that would now justify injecting an additional €36 billion to add to the €4 billion we have already contributed? The appalling unwinding of Anglo Irish Bank has been revealed again today by the new figures. We now hear there is €36 billion of toxic developer loans, which is 25% more than we were led to believe just a few months ago. The quality of those loans is now being written down by 50%, which is 66% worse than we were led to believe a few months ago. The State's injection, which up to a week ago we were told would total €10 billion, will now be €22 billion for the required recapitalisation. That is 120% more than we were led to believe. Anglo Irish Bank will absorb 70% of the recapitalised money the Minister is investing to try to get our banks going. What will that produce? Will it deliver any lending? Will that 70% of the recapitalisation get credit flowing? Will it put someone back to work or help with a person's mortgage? It will not. That is the reality. The money has gone into a black hole.

Rapid deterioration is evident. The Minister has admitted that the details on Anglo Irish Bank get worse every day. Despite that rapid deterioration the policy remains the same. There is no budging in the Government's policy, which is that the taxpayer should be the first over the hill to rescue the bank, not those who invested in it. That is the essence of the policy. I cannot understand why the policy is not changing as the evidence emerges on what an abnormal bank Anglo Irish Bank was, to the extent that it is jeopardising our future as a nation. I heard spokespersons on behalf of the Government say this morning that Anglo Irish Bank is systemically important to the country. It is no more systemically important to this country——

Comment on this

Seventy billion euro.

Comment on this

The Minister is investing €40 billion in cash into the bank.

Comment on this

Find it by the end of the week.

Comment on this

The Minister has not considered the options.

Comment on this

It is treachery.

Comment on this

Bad decisions in Anglo Irish Bank have been responsible for bringing this country to its knees. Its banking model is utterly broken and will not be revived. It is undertaking no lending to the sectors that can drive our economic recovery. Not one new loan or new job will be created by Anglo Irish Bank. The only purpose of putting money into the bank will be to repay the professional investors. I cannot see a sound economic or moral argument for turning to taxpayers and asking them to do that.

We have heard from Anglo Irish Bank that it believes closing the bank down in an orderly way over a decade or more would be more expensive. Let us be honest. It has not costed that approach. The only strategy that has been costed is one in which all the bondholders would be rescued and have to contribute nothing. There is another strategy with respect to Anglo Irish Bank, namely, what normally happens when a company of no systemic importance to the taxpayer gets into trouble, that its creditors take over and try to recover as much as they can from the debts, loans and assets of the company. That is what happens in capitalism. When people make investments that go sour, they take the consequences. That is not an option that was considered by Anglo Irish Bank, or if it was neither the Minister nor the bank presented the analysis to us. We need to see such an analysis and it has not been presented by the Minister to the House today. That is the nub of the decision we are being asked to make — whether, as the Minister indicated in his speech, this is the only way. I do not believe it is. I can understand how the management of Anglo Irish Bank would not cost that option, because at the end of the day it wants to see the bank as a going concern and to look after the bondholders. The question is whether taxpayers want to see that and if it is in their interests.

Comment on this

We cannot afford it.

Comment on this

While I understand why Anglo Irish Bank did not cost that option it is inexplicable why the Government did not do so and explain to us in clear terms why it has chosen to bail out all those people rather than allow the normal principles of capitalism to apply in a bank that no one other than a few people in the Government parties believes is of systemic importance to this country. I repeat what Mr. Colm McCarthy said, the onus is on the Minister and the Government to explain why this is the right decision.

As far as I can see the calculation is that the bond markets looking at Ireland Incorporated would take a view that it would be far worse to invest in a country that decided a busted flush bank such as Anglo Irish Bank was not important. The implication is that investors would worry about a country that faces reality and says a bank run in a buccaneering way is of no importance. I believe the bond markets would not look on matters in that way. They would recognise that the country had accepted it had commitments to the people and to the future of the nation, not a busted flush bank, and that it wanted to put its scarce €40 billion, if it could pull it together, into building strong arteries for economic recovery. This is not a normal bank and these are not normal times. This is a bank that has behaved recklessly and does not deserve the commitment of the taxpayer for which, as the Minister indicated, the banks should be grateful.

We should not offer Anglo Irish Bank that cover. A different case could be made for the other banks, namely Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland. I recognise that they are systemically important. They run our ATMs, pay our mortgages, keep bank accounts going and business flowing. I recognise that we have to do special things to face up to the difficulties experienced by those banks. There is an assumption that the Government should not apply the rules of capitalism and that we should bail out this bank. The Minister will cite learned bankers who would say that is correct but it is worth saying that the people who recognised the oncoming juggernaut of the property collapse are not on-side. Those who saw and issued the warnings do not believe this is the way to deal with Anglo Irish Bank. It is important that we take on board that view, which was not listened to at the time it was made. The fear of the contagion from not supporting Anglo Irish Bank and all its bondholders should be put under severe scrutiny.

Comment on this

It has not been put under severe scrutiny in the Minister's speech. There was not even a reference to the possibility that the €2 billion of subordinated bondholders in Anglo Irish Bank might lose in this event. Why would we pay back that €2 billion? I do not understand why that has not been addressed in the Minister's speech.

I welcome the tough regulatory capital requirements that the new regulator has set in respect of the other banks. It is crucial that we are not continually coming back to the banking crisis and that we half cure it. The regulator is right to apply rigorous stress tests and to expect the banks to be able to fulfil them. The stress tests look convincing, although I am surprised there has been no reference to the impact of rising interest rates on the potential stress on the loans. Perhaps that is for us to take up another day.

I was surprised to read in the newspapers at the weekend that the attitude the Minister was taking to the banks was take it or quit, that he was going to confront them and firm decisions would be taken, that this was the moment of truth and that they would have to make their decisions at the same time as the taxpayer was facing up to the matter. That is not what has happened today. No decision has come forward from the banks that they are definitely disposing of non-core assets, that they intend to turn to other investors in their banks and expect them to bear some of the losses or that they will offer new shares for subscription.

I believed these were the subject of hard talking by the Minister and that he would bring across the line a package involving everyone making an effort together, even within Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland. Instead, the issue is being kicked down the road like a can being kicked a bit farther. We will have to wait some more months before we see exactly what the banks will do. It will be the end of the year before we find out how the banks will meet their capital requirements. What will happen the banks and the banks' credit while we are waiting for decisions to be made? The banks will try to hoard every bit of capital and ration every loan they can to protect their independence from the Government.

I took heart when the Minister faced up to the take-it-or-quit approach. However, there is now a slow bicycle race that could extend right until the end of the year, at which time the banks will be freezing out people who depend on a flow of credit. Those individuals behind bankable business projects that perhaps could revive this economy will be refused credit by the banks, which will claim they are concentrating on meeting their capital requirements. The banks will say it is too bad they cannot talk to them. This is a real worry. I was misled by the headlines claiming we were finally facing up to this issue.

Let nobody be under any illusion that what we are doing today does not have implications for our capacity to get out of this economic difficulty. Deliberately overpaying for toxic assets is still at the core of the strategy. We have not heard today what the long-term economic value will be or the extent of the uplift over and above the market value. We will deliberately overpay for bank shares considering their value in the marketplace to avoid the majority shareholding. We are to set up a massive State monopoly, the biggest property company in the world, to manage a property portfolio. These decisions will undermine our capacity to do so many things this country needs. The Government's approach is not some inspired stride away from the brink but a step closer to it. The taxpayer will carry all the load for these bad decisions.

I welcome what the Minister has to say about lending but we must question whether we can believe what is now being said about it. When the Minister announced the recapitalisation plan in February last year, he told us the Government had decided on a new recapitalisation plan that would "reinforce stability" and "facilitate banks involved in lending to the economy" and get credit flowing again. He also stated, "The recapitalised banks have agreed to work closely with the IDA, Enterprise Ireland and with State agencies to ensure the supply of appropriate finance". The very same elements that were presented today as part of the credit agreement were presented in February of last year as if they were to be delivered between then and now. No one would agree with the Minister that the commitment of last year has been honoured. Can we believe the commitment of today will be honoured?

While I admit there is a statutory power and that the Minister has the power to issue directives if there is a failure, there is also the reality that the banks will hoard capital to try to defend their position over the coming months and avoid the State taking over. I am grievously worried about what is occurring.

NAMA was mentioned least of all in the Minister's speech today. We are creating the largest property management company in the world. The IMF has warned that State-run asset management companies are fraught with difficulties and that there is a real problem associated with their recovering money, because they become politicised.

We did not hear today about the Oireachtas oversight committee we were supposed to have to oversee the operations of NAMA. We are well past the deadline on which NAMA was to have produced protocols on risk management, its credit management function and its disposals policy. It was committed to providing all those by the end of March, yet none of them has been provided although we are almost at the end of that month. We expected to see them so we could have confidence that NAMA, which was moving to take over all the loans, would be managed in a way that would protect the taxpayer. This has not occurred.

There is a genuine worry that NAMA, having paid too much for the assets, will freeze the property market. It will be scared out of its wits to dispose of any property that would show a loss. It is probably worried that the European Union will look over its shoulder stating that if it incurs a loss, it constitutes State aid. Is this a formula for getting the property market back into shape? This issue still has not been addressed.

We do not have the NAMA business plan. Most people who looked at the last version of the NAMA business plan would regard it as a work of fiction. It purported that 80% of the loans transferred to NAMA would perform fully and that everything would be paid back. Who believes that? The belief that the loans would perform fully underpinned the last business plan. We need to see the revised business plan because we are now crossing the Rubicon. There is no coming back or means of repairing our model or finding a new way of proceeding. We will have this on our balance sheet.

This is a time to be hard-headed in this House, a time to demand evidence from those who thrust this course of action upon us. Thus far, evidence has been in short supply. We need to see the revised business plan and the assessment of all the options, not just those preferred by Anglo Irish Bank. We need to see the independent audits of the various assessments being carried out and to see the risk governance in NAMA. We need to see the Oireachtas committee being established, with clear terms of reference, and a role for the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General that would protect us.

I agree there is no risk-free approach. This is a difficult time. It is superficially attractive for any Government to throw its arms around everyone and tell them it will look after them and that they need not take a loss. However, we are not in a position now to take that approach. The decisions being taken are mortgaging the future of Irish taxpayers. The decisions are pretending the dream can continue such that we can in some way sort out the dreams of the past. Today's decision on where we go as a nation is very important.

The sum total of the Government's strategy seems to involve retrenchment in fiscal policy and writing whatever cheques are necessary to get the banks back in order. This is not a sufficiently good choice. It involves looking back at the mistakes we made, nursing solutions along and battening down the hatches to see whether we will get by. This is the time when we need to have the vision to strike out for a very different future and invent a different future for the country.

Today is a momentous day because the commitments we make, including today's doubling of the national debt and the investment of €4 billion in Anglo Irish Bank, restrict our capacity to reinvent ourselves as a nation. We must be very careful in scrutinising the evidence before we give the pass to them. I do not see the evidence and am gravely worried about what is proposed. We must rethink our approach.

Comment on this

I propose amendment No. 2. Today will be regarded as an infamous day in Irish history. It is the day on which the costs and consequences of crony capitalism, Irish-style, have come home and on which the burden is to be laid on the shoulders of every man, woman and child here, in addition to future generations not yet born. Today is a day about socialism for bankers and developers. It is not for ordinary people because they will be the ones who will carry the €22,000 per head of taxpayer debt for the Anglo Irish Bank arrangement. Today is the day our national debt is likely to be doubled, thanks to the phrase first used by Dr. Peter Bacon, which the Minister for Finance employed last St. Patrick's Day in his Financial Times interview when he confessed that crony capitalism was inherent in Irish society. The Financial Times carried the headline on its billboards around the world, “Irish Minister confirms crony capitalism as part of the cause” of our banking collapse.

On Sunday, the Sunday Independent published an Irish rich list of several hundred, perhaps 1,000 rich. One person looking out from the bottom end of the rich list was “Mr. Fingers”, Michael Fingleton, who was said to have about €30 million. Around the country a farmer, a doctor, a housewife, secretary or a low-paid civil servant will be conscious tomorrow that he or she is taking on a massive burden of debt gifted by Fianna Fáil while people such as “Mr. Fingers” can be on the published rich list. I do not know where now stands Mr. Seanie FitzPatrick. We know, however, that Mr. Derek Quinlan, who was a partner in the ill-fated Irish Glass Bottle site venture, is in Switzerland. We understand that Mr. David Drumm, the recent and former managing director is in somewhere such as Cape Cod in the north-eastern part of the United States. Mr. Johnny Ronan, after the rumble in Ranelagh, went for a pricey weekend to Marrakesh — €60,000 or €80,000 — and he announced afterwards that he was going to disappear out of view for a while.

Does the Taoiseach understand why people feel angry? Unlike other jurisdictions we have seen no justice in terms of the taxpayers taking the burden. Everybody in Ireland understands that our legal processes are slow. They have to be slow and thorough. However, how can the Taoiseach stand over what is being announced for these people today, in terms of a confirmed bail-out and at the same time we are giving up our schools and hospitals of the future? There is so much opportunity lost in terms of the fraction of the money we should like to have seen available, on this side of the House. That, in a way, is the tragedy of today's announcement. Like a Shakespearean tragedy it began in hubris and this has carried on — only in this case it has not destroyed the main characters, the bankers and developers. It is, however, helping to destroy so many ordinary people, and this is a peculiar Irish tragedy.

The Taoiseach may suggest that this is a tragedy for every country in the world and is due to failures of international capital, new financial instruments, derivatives and so on. However, it is not, rather it is due to an old-fashioned bust stoked by a series of Fianna Fáil Ministers. I understand and accept that he inherited a train that he could not stop when he was Minister for Finance, and indeed, when he became Taoiseach, but it is painful for ordinary people.

In a previous Budget Statement on an emergency budget, I recall the phrase which was popular among British and Irish soldiers during the First World War, namely, "lions led by donkeys". This is the sixth time today that the donkeys in Fianna Fáil have asked the lions of Irish taxpayers to leave the trenches to go over the top, face the withering fire — as Irish soldiers did in the First World War — and take on the chin the mess that Government has made of the banks and the economy.

This is not a formal Budget Statement, but let us be in no doubt that Deputy Brian Lenihan has today set the parameters for every budget for years to come, perhaps for as much as a decade. Every autumn from now on, whenever a Minister for Finance has to frame a budget, that will incorporate the true year by year cost of today's and previous announcements. Here is an example of one small thing that will pop up on the agenda of every Minister for Finance. Some €8.3 billion is going into Anglo Irish Bank today, as provided for by a ten-year promissory note. That means that every year for ten years a Minister for Finance will have €830 million as a given item being taken out of current spending and reserved for Anglo Irish Bank. If the later €10 billion the Minister talked about has also to be provided, that will mean an extra €1 billion a year. This means that within a few years a Minister for Finance will face an annual current transfer for Anglo of €1.8 billion a year for ten years, or €18 billion.

We will also have taken out €36 billion of its bad loans, at an average discount, yet to be confirmed of 15%. All this for one small bank which specialised in lending to developers and builders. It is not a systemic bank, and has very few branches around the country. It is now a fantasy bank, with a fantasy plan that will be re-resurrected for small and medium enterprises.

It would be better if we could move into levels of honesty as regards what the future is likely to hold. There is no future for the brand, Anglo Irish Bank. It is a destructive brand, which destroyed itself through greed, weak regulation and lack of compliance. Forget the fairy stories, there is no bright future and the people there are intelligent enough to know that.

What about Irish Nationwide Building Society? That is going to get €2.7 billion, again by promissory notes, in tranches of €270 million a year for ten years. Therefore, if I am an incoming Minister for Finance I shall see €830 million a year for Anglo Irish Bank and €270 million for Irish Nationwide for ten years. That is more than €1 billion a year and if the extra €10 billion the Minister has jotted in for Anglo Irish Bank is true, that will mean another €1 billion a year. This will be €2 billion a year. In addition to all the other costs, we are also facing annual costs of €5 billion from this year for payments because of increased interest costs along with the other elements of the packages that have to be financed.

Bear in mind that as a country this year Ireland hopes to take in something like €30 billion in revenue. This means that the Minister for Finance will find that some €7 billion has gone out of that €30 billion before the Government can even think of building a hospital or school or providing for old age pensions. That is the level of the financial depredation we are in.

The figures are awesome. We heard about "shock and awe" as regards the Iraq war, but these figures are on the same level, and I am shocked and awed. I did a table of the figures earlier as we were being briefed — €16.83 billion is being transferred in the first tranche involving ten developers. That is an average of €1.6 billion for each of them. Between the ten they have 1,200 loans, an average of 120 loans per developer.

The total transfer to NAMA will be €81 billion. It was originally estimated to be €77 billion but because of the rise in the Anglo Irish Bank figure and some small falls in the AIB and Bank of Ireland figures, it is now €81 billion. At an average transfer of 47%, that is a write-down, loss in value or black hole of roughly €40 billion.

Then there are the capital requirements listed by the Minister. I totted them up at €23 billion. It is €7.4 billion for AIB, €2.7 billion for Bank of Ireland, €8.3 billion for Anglo Irish Bank, €2.7 billion for Irish Nationwide Building Society and €875 million for EBS. Then there is the footnote that the Minister expects another €10 billion to be required later for Anglo Irish Bank. That is a total of €33 billion in addition to the losses of €40 billion on the NAMA transfers. The figures resemble monopoly money, and not just for Irish people. The Taoiseach spoke about levels of bank debt throughout the European Union and mentioned a figure of €300 billion. This is a small country among 27 and the Taoiseach should be aware that the figures we are discussing today are actually colossal in European terms for a small country. The Taoiseach suggests that Ireland is hardly a blip in the grand scheme of things. He should think again; he is simply not correct. I beg to differ with him.

This will be the top item in every budget for the next ten years. I expect that with future budgets there will be an inspector from the European Central Bank sitting in the Minister's office saying with a grim smile what can and cannot be done. If the ECB and the European Commission have acceded to this, it is only because they know that realism has finally begun to strike about the values. The Germans want their money back. They might have been foolish in lending to Irish banks but Frau Merkel wants her money back. That is what today is about. Frau Merkel wants her money back and this is Brian's arrangement to give it back. There will be a historical loss of national financial sovereignty that will infuriate all who value with pride the independence of our nation. One thing everybody in this House shares is a love of our country.

Greed has brought us to the point where recovering from this is possible but it will mean that every man, woman and child in the country will have to put their shoulders to the wheel. We will have to devise a political social framework that offers the little people something, as well as the bankers and the developers. It is all gain, care and consideration for the latter, with the little people left to shoulder the burdens. Recall the €4 billion adjustment last December. The Minister said he did not want a reference to that, but the adjustments today are multiples of that figure, regardless of whether they are in current spending, in banking, on balance sheet or off balance sheet.

The State is now the hapless and reluctant owner of dominant shareholdings in all the main financial institutions in the economy. "I own the banks" is a hollow boast. Every extra percentage of ownership is an admission of policy failure and, in their hearts, the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance know this is the truth. It will be acknowledged internationally as a bitter truth. They do not own the banks, however. The truth of today is that the banks own them. They dictate every element of policy, their interests take precedence over everything else and financial resources that ought to be challenged into economic recovery are directed instead in particular at protecting two rogue institutions, the Irish Nationwide Building Society and Anglo Irish Bank. Consider that a tuppence ha'penny little building society has €9 billion in bad loan transfers and requires a €2.7 billion capital injection to be paid for each year from our annual budget.

Since late 2008 the Minister has thrown billions of precious public savings into bailing out these institutions from the consequences of their reckless casino operations. He did not spend much money rescuing indebted homeowners or indebted manufacturers or offering a lifeline of credit to small businesses. The announcements made by the Minister have been made in every budgetary statement. Of course, they are welcome but this is about the fifth time we have heard most of them. We heard in the last two Budget Statements about arrangements for people from Enterprise Ireland and so forth to meet with the bankers and tell them how to get credit flowing again. We have heard several times about the €100 million for innovation and the €100 million for green projects and so forth. This is recycling; we have heard it before.

The Minister has devoted the entire stock of family silver, even the curtains and carpets, to these banks because they told him they were too big to fail. He was panicked into believing them by their sinister threat to unleash Armageddon should he refuse to give in to them, particularly Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide Building Society. Today is end game day. The end game in chess occurs when there are only a few pieces left on the board and the remaining pawns take on a special importance. We are certainly close to the end game in this protracted chess game, which has gone on for two full years since the fateful St. Patrick's Day massacre of Anglo Irish Bank share values in March 2008. That event triggered the unwinding of that bank's business model, with all the consequences we now experience to our cost.

On St. Patrick's Day 2008, the Taoiseach was in Vietnam, on one of the annual St. Patrick's Day trips. Afterwards, he travelled to Malaysia. At that time, the country, and presumably Fianna Fáil, was intensely embroiled in considering the future of the then Taoiseach, Deputy Bertie Ahern, and whether he could continue in politics. Was that the reason the current Taoiseach took his eye off the ball on that St. Patrick's Day and afterwards? The share price of Anglo Irish Bank had collapsed. That was the time for the regulators to go in and sort out the bank. Had the Taoiseach done that, the collapse of the other banks might still have happened but not to the same degree. The Taoiseach lost a valuable six months. He will recall that he became Taoiseach-designate and then Taoiseach, after which people went off to celebrate. We then segued into the night of the guarantee.

In many ways the downfall of Anglo Irish Bank lay in a complex series of transactions. The Quinn family group took a 28% position in Anglo Irish Bank shares through contracts for difference. Two years earlier the Taoiseach and I had a rather bad tempered exchange about contracts for difference when I warned him about turning the Irish Stock Exchange into a casino for casino capitalism. However, it seemed like good business and the Taoiseach would not even put a 1% stamp duty on it. He withdrew the notice about the stamp duty which the Revenue Commissioners had drawn up.

I remind the Taoiseach that, according to the public record, on 24 April that year he went to a dinner at Heritage House on St. Stephen's Green, the then, and perhaps current, headquarters of Anglo Irish Bank. He cannot have been unaware that the shares in Anglo Irish Bank had collapsed in value. People in the Department of Finance, the Financial Regulator and the Central Bank had to know. They are not incompetent. They might not have great knowledge about banking in some cases but they had to know that the share price of the third largest Irish bank, bidding perhaps to be the first or second largest, had collapsed. We have no explanation yet as to who knew what when and to what extent the Minister was briefed and knew about it. However, the Minister is a clever person and a diligent politician; he had to know and the organisations that reported to him as Minister for Finance had to know.

We had the guarantee on 29 September and then the nationalisation of Anglo Irish Bank. The third event was the €7 billion recapitalisation for AIB and Bank of Ireland and another €4 billion then went into Anglo Irish Bank and was lost. We then had NAMA and everything to do with that. Following that, we had the recent announcement concerning the preference shares, which I remember those like Deputy Fahey sold on television and radio stations as being a wonderful investment because the preference shares carried a dividend or coupon rate of 8%. Those of us who suggested this was a bit of a chimera were laughed out of court. What has come to pass today? All of the preference shares are being held in reserve for use in the tier 1 capital of AIB and Bank of Ireland, which shows the truth of that suggestion. While the Minister tells us the promissory notes might carry a rate of interest of 4%, I suggest we will wait and see whether we will ever achieve that 4%.

Today, we have Fianna Fáil's final solution. One question stands out: is there the slightest shred of credibility left in this Government's banking policy? Today's massive bailout announcement is the natural consequence of decisions made that fateful night of 29 September 2008. We are exactly 18 months and one day on from that fateful night. That night, the Minister was surrounded by bankers and he took advice only from bankers. He meekly promised to jump through whatever hoops they put in front of him, and the Taoiseach even went on radio to say no cheque would be big enough for him to sign if it was necessary to meet the insatiable demands of the banks.

The "too big to fail" doctrine, applied with no economic justification even to Irish Nationwide Building Society and Anglo Irish Bank, has taken a savage toll on the economy according to the raw evidence highlighted in the Central Statistics Office information last week. This was supposed to be the cheapest bank rescue in the world. The Taoiseach said that no cheque was too big to write to save our banks. Today, we are beginning to get a more rounded picture of the cheque he is proposing to write today and over the next ten years — a €36 billion bank bailout package on top of NAMA, which is €50 billion plus or perhaps a little less because the discounts are higher, although we do not yet know.

Mr. Jim Kemmy, the late Labour Party Deputy, once joked that while politics might seem easy to some, others had to come by the scenic route. Fianna Fáil is certainly taking the scenic route to nationalisation, via a mega-NAMA bailout, as taxpayers look set to be full or majority shareholders in the four institutions listed today. All nationalisation projects are not created equal, of course. We had the panic nationalisation of Anglo, and now we have the belated nationalisation or part nationalisation of the rest.

The Labour Party proposed a different approach. Following the model of the successful Swedish bank rescue, and as articulated by Bo Lundgren when he spoke in Dublin, the Labour Party proposed taking our key banks — I repeat, our key banks — into temporary public ownership before cleansing their balance sheets for return to the private sector. The key attraction of this approach was that it would have eliminated the valuation risk and the bailout element of NAMA. That still stands. It is not too late to rethink NAMA. There would not have been any need for the fantasy of long-term economic value. There would have been a much higher prospect of an uplift and gain for the taxpayer at the end of the process, which is what happened in Sweden, as the Minister for Finance has confirmed on many occasions.

Having taken the scenic route, we will now be left with the worst of both worlds — a nationalised banking sector alongside the risky NAMA bailout. Not only was the scenic route the longest route, wasting 18 valuable months, it was also the most costly.

The failures of our financial system demonstrate the more general failures of our entire economic system. It is inevitable that changes will come from the events of recent years and the decisions of the new regulator are the first examples of a tighter regime that will move us into line with the more general regime that will now follow the new Basel approach. Nevertheless, there remains one fundamental issue that is only partially treated today. The Government has worked on the assumption that the banks are favoured institutions that must be secured at any cost, even when they become insolvent by their own decisions. This House will have to set out new rules in law for future bank collapses, and these laws will need to be among the toughest ever brought to this country. We have endured enough from bad banking behaviour in the 1980s and 1990s. I would not now take on trust anything the banks promise.

Ireland has paid and, from today's announcements, will go on paying an horrific price for the banking policy disasters of the Government. Youth unemployment in Ireland has risen 170% in the past two years. There are more than 85,000 people under the age of 25 on the dole. When he visited Dublin some time ago, Professor David Blanchflower, who was on the Bank of England monetary policy committee but who is also an expert on youth unemployment, spoke very feelingly in public, to me privately and possibly to the Government about youth unemployment. He suggested that all the research shows that for young men in particular — young women are not affected to the same degree — who become unemployed for more than six months and remain so for one or two years, the effects are not temporary but last for the rest of their lives. Young men lose intrinsic confidence, belief in themselves and the ability to get up and go if they face a prolonged period of unemployment. In many ways, the young men of Ireland are the principal victims of the banking disaster, not just now but into the future.

The Labour Party has offered a series of suggestions from different Labour spokespersons on, for example, internship schemes, training schemes and graduate employment schemes — anything to give the young people who are in this country, particularly young men facing long-term unemployment, an opportunity to get up and not have to give in to a kind of despair and loss of confidence that will affect them for two or three decades. The offer is still there. The Labour Party is willing to work with the Government to see that happen but it is getting very late. We are now two years into the building bust. So many young men who lost their jobs in the building industry, unless they had a chance to go abroad, which some had, are reaching a crisis because they have nothing to do other than collect unemployment assistance. Our country has had to experience an horrific recession involving lost jobs, lost pay, lost taxes, lost investments in infrastructure, lost prosperity and lost personal happiness for tens of thousands of our citizens.

The Minister began his contribution on the bank bailout today by referring to complimentary and encouraging remarks made by various international figures in regard to Ireland. In the eyes of market analysts, however, the announcements today exacerbate the fiscal problems faced by the Irish State. One question I have for the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan is: what is the impact of today's statements on the entire strategy agreed with the European Commission to reduce the deficit to 3% by 2014? For all practical purposes, the Government is about to issue bonds amounting to one third of our entire GDP for distressed bank assets of dubious or no intrinsic value. The Taoiseach may have negotiated an arrangement to keep this off the formal balance sheet but markets and rating agencies are not that easily misled. While the Minister, understandably, wanted to refer to people who were encouraging to Ireland in their public statements, key articles have been written in the past month, particularly by Simon Johnson, the former deputy head of the IMF, advising America not to become like Ireland. The Taoiseach must have seen this article because it was doing the rounds when he was in the United States. Paul Krugman wrote an article which was very understanding in a certain sense. He wanted to be favourable towards Ireland but he pointed out the serious difficulties we have inherited through the bank bust. He warned other countries to avoid being like us if possible. People in the ECB and in the European Commission want to encourage Ireland but we must be realistic about the impact of today. Ireland's sovereign debt to GDP will be over 100% during 2011. The Minister did not say but it is a fundamental indicator.

We have been very smug about Greece's problems and many commentators have been smug about the fact that we are not Greece. The interest rate we pay on our national debt is the second highest in the eurozone, higher than Spain, Portugal and Italy. The Taoiseach will know that Greece is one of the few good things to happen to Ireland. Because of the difficulties in Greece, the euro has been under pressure and has fallen somewhat against the dollar and sterling. One of the best things that can happen to Ireland would be a fall in the euro so that our exports and export of services would gain.

There is evidence of anxiety in the markets about Ireland's debt exposure, therefore, new borrowing and any debt that has to be re-financed may face higher interest rates. This will add to our day-to-day spending. I do not know if the Government has been open and up front about this aspect of today's decision.

What will be the long term impact of today's decision on the international rating of Irish sovereign debt? It begs the question as to who calls the shots in Irish public policy. All the banks, but in particular, Anglo and Nationwide, looked after the developers. In turn, the developers looked after Fianna Fáil, in the classic manner of crony politics. A powerful lobby of these same developers, the investors who bought the bank bonds and Government politicians with links to the failed developers, have conspired to have our taxpayers rather than the bank creditors, carry the cost.

I understand from the briefings we received today that the tier two subordinated debt is about €10 billion; €2 billion in the case of Anglo Irish Bank and possibly €4 billion each in the case of Allied Irish Bank and Bank of Ireland. Tier two subordinated debt is risk. These are investors looking for high rates of return with a very high level of risk. Yet, the Government guaranteed them all and €10 billion is outstanding. Why do we hear nothing about a negotiation with them?

Mr. Alan Dukes said to me the other night on television that a negotiation with the Anglo Irish Bank tier two subordinated debt of €2.4 billion would only save €1 billion. What is the crazy economics whereby €1 billion no longer counts as a saving? What is the rationale? Is this discussed between the members of the Government? As for the other €8 billion, the Taoiseach has not explained why it is not possible to sort out that tier two subordinated debt at a very heavily discounted rate. He has not told us whether the senior tier one bonds are €30 billion or €40 billion. Has he even attempted to suggest a negotiation with the senior bondholders?

If there is improved international sentiment towards Ireland, today's measures could put it all at severe risk as people wonder how a country facing so deep an economic crisis can casually add a vast sum to its national debt.

No details of the administration are as yet known, other than the legal announcements about the Quinn group. The Quinn group owes a possible €2.5 billion to Anglo Irish Bank. What happened in the case of the Quinn group was central to the fall of Anglo Irish Bank which in turn was central to the fall of the other banks. What are the consequences of the announcement today of the administrative process with regard to that €2.5 billion? Anglo Irish Bank will transfer €36 billion to NAMA. The €2.5 billion of the Quinn debt may be as much as 10% of Anglo's loan portfolio remaining. The Quinn group was trying to suggest it would pay Anglo over an eight to ten-year period. This was reported in the media and it was not denied so presumably there is some veracity to it. What is the Taoiseach's analysis of this situation? Is this another Pandora's box? The Financial Regulator indicated that half a billion was at issue with regard to the fall in the value of investments in the Quinn health and insurance group and has looked for administration. It is ironic that just as the Quinn group was involved at the start of the story its administration comes today as we hear the Government's final solution yet there has been no comment from Government. Perhaps this will happen tomorrow or on Thursday. The Taoiseach should make a detailed statement to the House about the Quinn group. It is an important employer with 5,000 or 6,000 employees. Several thousand of those jobs are in the insurance-related companies which are primarily affected by today's announcements.

The Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Eamon Ryan, spoke on radio last Saturday. He suggested that Ireland could be asked to leave the euro. Deputy Ryan is the link person for the Greens in the Cabinet group dealing with banking. Is this what the Cabinet group is suggesting to Fianna Fáil backbenchers? I do not think the average Fianna Fáil backbencher would believe that because it is not provided for anywhere in the treaties. That is economic illiteracy from the Green member on a Cabinet sub-committee dealing with the banks. I think we are entitled to know what the various Government parties believe to be the Irish situation.

We heard about hair cuts today. In the material given to us today we saw a new concept called CoCo — special instruments which may or may not be part of this rescue deal. I wondered if it was not so much a visit to a barber for a hair cut as a visit to a head shop that inspired some of the people judging by some of the fantasy economics we heard today and continue to hear. However, it is ordinary people of this generation and the next who will bear the brunt.

Comment on this

I wish to share my time with Deputy Ó Snodaigh, by agreement.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for Finance and his officials for the useful and practical briefing they gave to Opposition parties this morning. It is unfortunate that the Government does not demonstrate this type of constructive and practical approach more often because it would be more conducive to the work we do in this House. Had the Government brought forward a reasonable and practical plan to deal with the banking crisis and the broader economic problems we face, Sinn Féin would have been happy to support it. Unfortunately, that is not what we have this evening. We can demonstrate a record of supporting Government initiatives such as the guarantee scheme. We set terms and conditions for our support of that measure but because the Government did not meet them we were left with no option but to withdraw our support. I am glad we did so. The Government always has the opportunity to approach the House in a democratic manner and make it work more effectively in the interest of our public.

This afternoon the Minister for Finance told us once again that he is presenting us with the least worst option. That is patently untrue, however, because the measures he proposes represent the worst option possible. My party has proposed a substantial plan of action around nationalisation of the two major banks which would have been substantially less costly to the taxpayer than the option chosen by the Government. The Labour Party's plans contained broadly similar proposals to ours and should at least have been considered. Perhaps I should implore the grace of God when I say that even the Fine Gael option would have been substantially better than the Government's proposals for curing the banks. Again, however, we face a steamroller which the Government calls democracy. Democracy my backside. We certainly are not holding the proper parliamentary deliberations which would allow us to tease out these matters or holding a rational debate on how we can do what is best for the public and the taxpayers whose money is being shovelled into these dysfunctional banks.

The Minister does not have the authority to implement a bank bailout of this scale. Technically, he could argue in the same way as one could for a half legal moneylender who is squeezing his or her victims, that a narrow technical point allows him to proceed but there is no moral basis for his course of action. If the Government has any confidence in the proposal, it should put it before the people as its election platform in a general election. These proposals would impose a huge financial burden on Irish people for generations to come and that is grossly unfair even if it is technically legal in a parliamentary sense.

The Minister is introducing the harshest cuts in decades in an attempt to reduce a €20 billion deficit while simultaneously adding hugely to Government borrowing for this bank bailout. The financial ramifications of what is happening today will be felt by generations to come. Why is the Government spending all its energy on the banking crisis when so little effort is being put into getting the rest of the economy back on track? Why is so little being done to tackle unemployment? We are spending hours on a discussion of the Government's mishandling of the banking crisis instead of debating solutions to unemployment. For the economy to get back on track we need a functioning banking system but 18 months after the bank guarantee scheme we are no nearer to achieving this objective. The Minister admitted that we face many more years of pouring billions of euros of taxpayers' money into these banks. The Government opposed nationalisation and, as many predicted, is now being forced to nationalise by stealth.

During the past 18 months it has completely taken its eye off the ball when it comes to job creation and stemming the rise of unemployment. During that period Sinn Féin put forward a range of proposals to retain and create jobs. In recent weeks we put forward a specific set of proposals to deal with unemployment among the under 25s on the live register. This fully costed and constructive plan would offer hope to members of our population who are essential to future economic growth and stability. Instead, however, the Government is set on a disastrous course for employed and unemployed citizens.

Think of the productive use that could be made of the money the Government is throwing into the black hole that is our banks. The €22 billion being spent on the banks could purchase a youth jobs fund to create 20,000 or more jobs; the delivery of key infrastructure such as universal broadband, the western rail corridor, cancer centres north of the Dublin-Galway line and class sizes of 20 or fewer; a reversal in the pay cut for public sector workers on low and average incomes and cuts to social welfare, including the Christmas bonus; some 10,000 new community employment places; investment in key sectors of the economy such as information technology, tourism, agri-food and green technologies; a free preschool education system; an end to social housing waiting lists; conversion courses for graduates; a future in their own country for the young unemployed; and a functioning health system with adequate numbers of doctors, nurses and other front line staff to meet patients' needs.

The scale of the mess that Fianna Fail must take responsibility for is astounding. It should not be forgotten how vociferously Ministers rejected criticisms from those of us who warned that the economy was not built on solid foundations, that a property bubble was developing and that the Exchequer was overly dependent on taxes from construction and consumption. There was time to act and to turn things around but there was no will to do so. If we could see these issues, how can those who were in Cabinet during that period claim not to have known? Why did they turn a blind eye to the actions of bankers and developers? Does a party that has such close ties to many of those at the top of Anglo Irish Bank really expect us to believe it knew nothing of what was going on?

It is time to overthrow a culture that has existed in this State for far too long. A wealthy elite have been pandered to by successive Governments and has for decades enjoyed a position of privilege and undue influence over Government policies. People want answers to how and why the Government policies which fuelled the property bubble were allowed to continue when the damage they were doing was obvious. This is not about a rogue group of bankers and developers; it is about a parasitical section of our society wedded to the two largest political parties in this State and Fianna Fáil in particular. We will not get rid of this culture of exploiting ordinary people, like those who were injured or killed on the unsafe building sites owned by Liam Carroll as he lined his own pockets, until we get beyond Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael led Governments. Let us be absolutely clear: the elite, those who made up the golden circles and stuffed their pockets at the expense of ordinary workers, are now in self preservation mode and have the Government doing their dirty work. This is what NAMA and the bank bailouts are all about. Nothing has changed. The people this Government pandered to when it implemented policies that created the current crisis are still being pandered to. This is the true reason the Government would rather cut dole payments than introduce a wealth tax. Will Liam Carroll experience life on the dole or live in one of the sub-standard, shoe-box flats he sold to desperate first time buyers? Those at the top of the Civil Service are part of this elite group as well, such as Rody Molloy who, despite wasting vast amounts of public money, will never pay any price for his actions. In fact, he has been further rewarded for his actions.

The Dublin Docklands Development Authority is an example of the rot that existed in the State during the Celtic tiger years. Fianna Fáil cannot distance itself from this debacle and it must be held to account. Among those involved in the debacle relating to the Irish Glass Bottle Company site was Joe Burke, one of the closest associates of the then Taoiseach, Deputy Bertie Ahern. The authority is a microcosm of all that went wrong in this economy, comprising a toxic mix of Fianna Fáil and cronies around the then Taoiseach such as Mr. Burke and Bernard McNamara and Anglo Irish bankers such as Seán FitzPatrick and Lar Bradshaw, who were co-opted on to the board of the authority.

We have yet to get the full information regarding the murky goings on in these affairs but in all of this one thing should not be forgotten: a productive business, the Irish Glass Bottle Company factory, could have been saved with Government intervention. Jobs could have been saved. Now, having paid a much higher price than it would otherwise have had to pay to save those jobs, the State has a plot of derelict land which is worth a fraction of what was paid for it. The former Taoiseach should be forced to make a statement to the House outlining exactly what he knew about all of this. I challenge the Taoiseach to instruct Deputy Ahern to make such a statement without further delay. What took place at the Dublin Docklands Authority is the reason we are where we are and in the mess in which we find ourselves today. Almost half a million people are out of work and billions of euros in taxpayers' money is being put into the banks while public services and welfare are being cut. This is crazy.

It has taken the Minister too long to resolve the banking crisis, which first came to the fore in the summer of 2008. Since then, the real economy has plummeted and the banks have played no small part in this as a result of their refusal or inability to extend credit. Businesses have closed their doors and householders face repossession. The only action banks have managed to take is to hike up charges and interest rates and to fight off calls for cost-cutting among their higher paid staff members. The 0.5% mortgage interest increase from AIB yesterday, at a time when the ECB's rates remain stable, is testament to that. The bank may be borrowing at a higher rate on the wholesale market but what has it done to ensure security for its customers? When people referred to the State taking a higher stake after recapitalisation, all of a sudden the bank suggested it could sell its foreign assets. Should it not have done so before push came to shove? The failure of the Government to put a stop to the rate increase is shameful.

The banks may be borrowing at a higher rate on the wholesale market but if they squeeze already under-pressure mortgage holders, we will be looking at another tranche of bad loans in the residential property market further down the line. This domino effect will grip the Irish financial sector and taxpayers will be hit doubly for the failures of the Irish banking system. This will take place not only through the cost of recapitalisation, but through the increase in mortgage interest rates and personal loan and overdraft rates. What fruits will be borne on the other side? Will there be a nationalised State bank capable of offering individuals and businesses credit at a fair rate? Only partially. The people will be offered more or less the same. Slowly the system, if left to commercial devices, will slip back to its old unregulated ways. The banks will continue to refuse to accept responsibility for what they have done. The only stakeholder that should be given due consideration is the taxpayer. Whatever the banks wish for is completely irrelevant at this point. In any other sphere of business these banks would be in receivership or liquidated at this stage. The attitude of self-importance is the same as that which prevailed in the lead up to the crisis and there is no basis for it to be allowed to continue.

Let us consider what the banks did to bring us to this point. They were not alone; the Government and the regulators, which effectively looked the other way, were cheerleading them. The details emerging now reveal a banking system where lenders had casual and personal relationships with borrowers, where documentation was frequently incomplete or ignored and where basic financial calculations were overridden by bank strategies based on winning market share. For example, during a court action last year Bernard McNamara claimed he was actively pursued by banks to borrow money from them on exceptionally generous terms. The financier Niall McFadden, who is facing judgments running to tens of millions of euro, claimed in court that National Irish Bank accepted a personal guarantee for a €6.3 million loan without ever meeting him. Personal guarantees were the currency of Irish borrowing during that time.

These incidents highlight the lackadaisical approach the banks took in respect of security for loans. Most of the big property deals were funded by groups of banks and now total confusion is emerging over which bank controls which assets. This emerged today in discussions with the Department. This is clear from NAMA and one of the reasons the agency has not functioned up to this point. It simply has not been able to get down to the root and branch details of where responsibility for these loans rests. During the boom AIB lent €550 million to Liam Carroll with only a solicitor's letter and the deposit of title deeds as security. Let us imagine what business people who approach the banks these days must be thinking when they hear that. Court actions have also exposed flaws in the valuation of property assets by basing transactions on a loan-to-value ratio that was too high. The banks did not allow themselves any wriggle room in case property values fell.

The Government has bent over backwards to prevent the nationalisation of the two larger banks. Given the guarantee, the initial recapitalisation, the establishment of NAMA and further recapitalisation now, we have almost spent the past two years witnessing the Department of Finance create policy the sole intent of which is to prevent the banks being nationalised. The only bank the State leapt to nationalise is the only bank that nobody wanted nationalised. There can be no doubt that the speed with which Anglo Irish Bank was dealt with was a reflection of the Government's desire to hide the machinations at the bank, which would have come to light a good deal quicker and in greater detail had the bank been allowed to fold. Instead, we are getting a drip-feed of information from a bank no longer functioning as such but which is costing the State billions of euro. The bank could require a further €9 billion in recapitalisation in the coming months, twice what the Government attempted to cut from the deficit last December. It was disgraceful when the Government chopped social welfare payments and mercilessly took away the Christmas bonus from pensioners but this is what it gives to its bailout friends.

The Minister for Finance stated that the country is in a better financial position now to deal with the funding needs of the banks, which is astonishing. The State is carrying a €20 billion plus deficit, which the EU has ordered us to reduce dramatically. According to the Government, we do not have a red cent for investment purposes, but we can use the National Pension Reserve Fund, NPRF, to recapitalise the banks after NAMA takes the bad loans off their books at an even sharper deal. At the last count, the NPRF had a value of approximately €13 billion and a further €7 billion has already been taken from the fund by the Government to recapitalise AIB and Bank of Ireland. If the Government has its way, the entire National Pension Reserve Fund will be made up of bank shares. It would be ironic if the State, after all its procrastinating, is forced to fully nationalise the banks but the largest shareholder to get burned at that point would be the Irish taxpayer.

These banks are not being hard-balled by the State. They would be defunct had the State not stepped in. They have a Government content to do everything to help them while allowing them to remain in private ownership, a Government willing to socialise their debts while allowing them to continue to privatise their profits. This is the Government that lifted the bank levy, that allowed regulation to become lax. It is the political system that bailed out AIB in the 1980s and turned a blind eye again in the 1990s. Some 70% of AIB is a majority stake in that bank, but it is not full nationalisation. How much influence the State will use while holding that stake is unclear. Certainly, we got no more clarity from the Minister this afternoon. To date, the Government has shown nothing but reluctance to interfere, as they call it, in banking conduct.

Over the past three weeks we have seen revelations that the Government's convoluted and complicated approach to the banks is also mired in secrets and unfairness. The revelation that 78 employees of Anglo Irish Bank had been awarded pay increases is the second of its kind in the past few weeks. This news comes against the backdrop of a 70% pay increase for the chairperson of the board of NAMA. When the public servants all across this land, front-line workers, are having their salaries slashed, there is this 70% increase and significant increases for other board members. Simultaneously, the Government is pushing through pay cuts and attacks on public services. It is clear that the Government values the work of the banking sector over the work of other front-line public sector workers such as gardaí, nurses, teachers.

We must look now at what reform we will get. For example, the Financial Regulator has waived capital rules for EBS, allowing the building society to fall below the threshold dictating the minimum amount of capital that a financial institution must hold in reserve. The so-called new, improved and harder-headed regulation has granted the building society a temporary derogation until 31 May, allowing it to hold less than the minimum core tier 1 capital ratio of 1%.

Any literature on the financial crisis points to the absence of these thresholds as central to the magnitude of the collapse of the banking system. This seems to be the first step in a clawback to the old system. Some might say it is only a temporary measure, propagated by the need to discount the loans. However, when the Government and the Minister for Finance signed Ireland and each and every person of this State to NAMA and bank recapitalisation, reform was promised. Now it seems reform has been short-lived.

The worst of it is that we do not have the full facts of what this will all end up costing us. The loans being taken by NAMA have received an even further discount since the legislation was announced, in recognition of the falling property values. They are falling, which means there is no guarantee that this is the best deal for the State. The Minister is pushing the State down a path of debt and we do not know where it will end. The Minister is opening Pandora's box. Today will go down in history, and the Minister and the Government will not come out of this well.

I do not know what it will take to completely overhaul the culture that persists here. It is not fair, reasonable or rational that at the biggest crisis of generations the Government simply comes in here with a proposal on a banking crisis largely ignoring all of the other fault lines in the economy to bail out these banks in this fashion. It is time the Government at least listened to some of the debate, took on board some of the points that were being made by the Opposition and we all tried to ensure that there is a proper system put in place which will not cost future generations billions of euro through the disgraceful bailout of these bankers and their friends, the developers.

Comment on this

Gabhaim buíochas leis an Teachta Morgan as a chuid ama a roinnt liom chun déileáil leis an cheist ríthábhachtach seo. Ceist í nach bhfuil tacaíocht ag an Rialtas: níor sheas sé i dtoghchán, agus níl sé sásta seasamh i dtoghchán chun tacaíocht a fháil don chinneadh atá sé tar éis glacadh agus atá sé ag glacadh inniu. Is scannal é sin, agus tá sé ag tógáil céime mídhaonlathach inniu, go háirithe toisc go bhfuil an Rialtas ag ceangal an oiread sin de thodhchaí an Stáit seo le dul chun cinn na mbanc agus leis an sealúchas atá tar éis dul isteach i NAMA go dtí seo.

It is rare that I speak on finance motions. In a way, like many other citizens, I found it difficult to get to grips with the full scale of the horror that emerged when the banking crisis began to unfold.

Like many others on the left, I raised the fact that the State and its economy was dependent upon the property bubble continuing and that such was not a position that could be sustained. Two years on from the initial emergence of the crisis, I want to give the two Brians, Deputies Brian Cowen and Brian Lenihan, a lesson in the real world to put into context the giveaway or present that they are giving to bankers and property speculators. The sum of what is intended here is that they are bailing out the banks, through a nice present of taxpayers' money, to help them recover from speculation.

I remember when people invested in eircom shares and many of them got burnt and there were cries for bailouts and help at the time. I was not one of those who believed that a bailout was realistic in that case because I, and the thousands and others who bought eircom shares, had gambled. We took a punt on shares on a market and as one is always told, there is a possibility of losing money or of gaining money. The same can be said about everyone who gambled in the property market and on bank shares and who is now looking to be bailed out. The Government is bailing them out and giving them guarantees. I will deal with one such group, for instance, the subordinated bondholders in Anglo Irish Bank.

The debts of Anglo Irish Bank include the investments of subordinated bondholders. Anglo Irish Bank, and hence the taxpayer, owes that group €2 billion at a conservative estimate. Those bondholders took a risk when they invested, of which they were fully aware and which they had taken day in and day out in other institutions for many years, and they earned high rates of interest during the so-called good times. They gambled, they lost and they should have dealt with it, but the Government stepped in and gave them a guarantee. When that guarantee is up in September, I believe that is the end of it. They should suffer the consequences of their loss. They should have suffered it when the loss occurred, but rather than that, we gave them a guarantee. That is an ongoing scandal, but there are many others.

The Chair of Anglo Irish Bank, Alan Dukes, thinks that it is alright to hand out taxpayers' hard-earned money to those risk takers who, themselves, helped create the financial mess we are in. He also suggests that it is alright for the Government to pay increases to selected employees in that bizarre dysfunctional bank. It is bizarre considering that this is the bank that should have been closed, lock, stock and barrel, two years ago, and it should still be closed today. There is no reason for us to bail out a dysfunctional bank.

Nobody in the Government called a halt at any stage, or even attempted to rein in the obscene property speculation that went on for many years. The Government facilitated it by giving tax breaks and reliefs to those gambling with the economy's future. It facilitated the banks gambling on a three-legged horse. When that horse fell at the first hurdle, the Government expected us, the taxpayer, to suffer the consequences. Those in banking circles and the Government, meanwhile, were too busy congratulating themselves on the so-called success of the Celtic tiger to care about the ordinary people and their future.

Their future now is repossession. I have heard Members on the Government benches claim home repossession is not occurring when Dublin City Council recently made repossession orders against people in its affordable housing scheme who cannot meet their repayments. Banks are calling in clients telling them they will repossess their property unless they start to pay off their arrears. Those are arrears they have been landed in because the Government has no job creation policy. Up to 500,000 people are unemployed and cannot afford their mortgage repayments. Where is the bailout for those who are paying over the odds on interest rates for fixed-rate mortgages on what were overpriced houses? Where is the protection and bailout for those in arrears? Their future and that of the many young people who will leave university later this year and the unemployed will be poverty and emigration.

It is a pity the Minister for Finance is not in the Chamber to tell us what his representatives in AIB were doing yesterday when they gave the two fingers to mortgage holders and small businesses with loans with an interest rate hike. Now with its majority shareholding in the bank, does it actually suit the Government to get more money out of the taxpayer this way? Does the Government intend to oppose any future interest rate increases by AIB and the other banks it controls? Or will the taxpayer get the dividends he is due in worthless bank shares?

The Government is seeking another blank cheque for the banks. Earlier, the Minister for Finance gave this and that vast figure, figures more like those used in Monopoly and difficult to comprehend. He finished his speech with a promise that even more taxpayers' money, not just that announced today, billions of euro, will be used to bail out the banks.

We must also look back at the some of those property transactions in question. The Irish Glass Bottle Company site in Ringsend, before the Dublin Docklands Development Authority became involved, contained a viable and functioning company which made an annual profit of €40 million. The workers at Ardagh Glass created the profit for the company, who earn a wage on which they pay taxes and spend in the local economy. Yet all those workers were sent to the dole queue, a signal of what was to come.

The Minister of State with responsibility for housing, Deputy Finneran, is in the Chamber. He will know Bernard McNamara was mentioned earlier. Many people in Dublin city had much hope in Bernard McNamara because he bid for many of the local authority housing scheme regeneration projects. He was also one of the speculators who has had to step aside with the crash. The Government has not stepped into his place to recreate the hope many inner city communities in wasteland estates such as St. Michael's, Inchicore, Dominick Street, St. Teresa's Gardens and Dolphin House, had of a return to what they once were — thriving communities with businesses and homes. The Minister should visit the wasteland with no hope that is South Hill in Limerick because he and his Government have dashed the hopes of regeneration for thousands of families.

The Government refused to step in to nationalise SR Technics, a viable company making millions of euro which had previously been a State company thereby guaranteeing 500 jobs. It would have been saved at a fraction of the cost of some of the bailout paid for the minor banks.

Since this crisis began two years ago, we have been presented with an opportunity to create a State bank to support small and medium-sized enterprises. To date this opportunity has been ignored. Every day small businesses across the country go to the wall with their employees becoming dependent on the State. A simple economic lesson from this is that if people get back to work, they earn money, pay taxes — even at the penal rate the Government has in place for the low paid. They also spend money which boosts employment in the retail sector and means the Exchequer wins with increased VAT and employee tax returns. This, in turn, allows more money to be invested in public services which means everyone wins in the long term.

Instead, the Government's model is to have fewer people in work with less income to the Exchequer while giving more money to the banks. This creates a cycle whereby more unemployment is created. Unless this cycle is broken, we will go further down the hole the Minister and his cronies have dug.

The economy needs to be refocused on policies of equality, job creation and investment in education. If we want to come out of this recession, we must create a sustainable and viable knowledge-based economy. We never properly invested in education. Doing so now will give a return of a knowledge-based economy. Such investment also needs to be coupled with investment in broadband infrastructure, our public services and in repairing the roads and water services networks. Investment must also be made in energy security. We can no longer depend on imported energy, particularly when our natural resources in the Corrib gas field are sold to a foreign company, making us bid for them against England and the rest of Europe. We need a solid base and proposals have been made in regard to the Spirit of Ireland. If invested to the hilt, this proposal would cost less than what the Minister proposed today to bail out Anglo Irish Bank.

We talk about the property crisis in Ireland. Apartment blocks and estates are in receivership up and down the country. These are now in the State's possession yet people are homeless and thousands of people are on local authority housing lists. There is no logic to having apartment blocks sitting empty for two or three years when people are in overcrowded, cramped and unsuitable accommodation. The economic model is wrong and the Minister needs to change it. This needs to happen now; otherwise, the Minister will send us further and further into the black hole he has dug.

Comment on this

Today we take a tough but necessary step to recovery as a nation. The work done in the past year and a half on Ireland's public finances has greatly improved the world's view of Ireland. The cost of borrowing to fund our day-to-day enterprises has reduced markedly and we are now in a position to recover and grow the economy on a more sustainable basis. Many prominent commentators on the world stage see our efforts as being the model for others to follow. For example, the influential www.bloomberg.com notes today that Ireland’s bonds are poised to outperform those of every other eurozone member except Austria this quarter, as investors have confidence that Ireland will be more successful than other European countries in cutting its budget deficit. Furthermore, Ireland’s bonds are the second-best performing of all EU countries this quarter, returning 3.5%. External confidence in Ireland is returning. It is the same confidence shown by those who invest in our capacity as a country by buying Government bonds. We need this confidence to attract investment and to raise money on the international market. The international community has positively noted the measures we took to restructure our economy. This point was strongly made to me in recent visits to the United States, when the Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, praised the difficult but essential decisions Government is making.

The measures we have outlined will set our banking system on the road to recovery. While the cost of facing up to our problems is very significant, the alternative is a recipe for stagnation and decay. In addition, the lending targets outlined today will provide a welcome boost to the productive sectors of the economy. Allied to that is the proposal that banks will be required to realign their business practices with the needs of the modern Irish economy. We are restructuring our economy so that in future Ireland will grow through the hard work and innovation that will come. The improvements we are making to our banking system will facilitate growth and bolster the advances made to date.

Just as a stable banking system is crucial to our economic renewal, so too is industrial peace. I warmly welcome the outcome of discussions between the Government and public sector unions. It is good news for the Irish economy and for our country. It can send a very strong signal at home and abroad that we will work together to come through these difficulties. I thank those involved for their positive and proactive contribution and I especially thank the two facilitators, Mr. Kieran Mulvey and Mr. Kevin Foley. They all put in long hours of negotiation to achieve a consensus that will help underpin economic recovery. This agreement is good news because it will help restore stability to the public service after a period of uncertainty. I look forward to and hope for its ratification by the constituent unions concerned. This agreement will mean no further reductions in pay rates for public servants, flexible redeployment within the public service and changes in work practices that will deliver savings and help to make the public sector more efficient. It will give us a public sector fit for purpose in the 21st century and will provide better and more effective public services to the public we serve. I urge all public servants on the basis of this good agreement — all our doctors, teachers, nurses, gardaí, those who do much day in and day out to provide people with essential services — to give this agreement their careful consideration. Everyone must judge the proposals on the benefits they will bring to themselves and to the public in the long term. I have made the point previously that in order for Ireland to prosper we must transform our public services. This agreement has the potential to do that.

I have also made it clear that for Ireland to prosper again, we must get our public finances back on a sustainable basis. Those foundations are being put in place by the resolute action of the Government. Revenue and expenditure measures amounting to 5% of GDP were taken to improve the 2009 deficit. The recent budget for 2010 contained spending adjustments amounting to 2.5% of GDP. As a result we have stabilised the deficit at 11.25% of GDP this year, a fact no amount of distortion or spin can undermine. We have a credible multiannual framework to restore order to public finances, which has met with strong international approval. The European Commission, the European Central Bank, the International Monetary Fund, the OECD and respected international commentators are among those who welcomed Ireland's fiscal consolidation framework. The ECB president, Jean-Claude Trichet, described the measures as bold and courageous decisions taken to put the economy back on its feet in difficult and demanding circumstances. Our strategy has attracted praise because it is working and will meet our target of restoring our deficit to a sustainable level by 2013-14. The Minister for Finance has outlined the Government's detailed course of action in this debate. The crisis in banking has taken up much of our time as a Government and we have had to take momentous decisions. We are one of the first Governments to introduce a state guarantee of the banking system, one of the first to set up an asset management agency in the current banking crisis and we know that without a healthy and functioning banking system, our businesses and service providers will not be able to grow and develop products for our main markets and sustain employment, which is what it is all about.

We need credit to flow for business and jobs and that is why today we are imposing specific lending targets on AIB and Bank of Ireland. They will make available to SMEs not less than €3 billion each for targeted lending through new or increased credit facilities in 2010 and 2011. Those working capital arrangements, provided for in the legal framework announced by the Minister of Finance, are in addition to the EIB situation, which speaks about new projects. We are ensuring existing credit facilities to businesses are catered for in this situation. From the outset, I have said our motivation in establishing NAMA was to provide credit to small businesses in order that they can grow and thrive. We are taking a further step on that road. The simplistic argument will be made that today is about bailing out banks. It is about bailing out the economy and creating the right environment for enterprise and employment, facing up to problems and dealing with them decisively and firmly. While no one would wish that these steps would be needed, I am proud the Government I am leading has shown the resolve to do what is necessary in leading the battle for public solvency and prosperity for families in Ireland.

As has been made clear, the Government is committed to recapitalising each of the institutions involved in the NAMA process so the system as a whole can return to its rightful role as provider of credit to the real economy. This course of action will necessarily involve a substantial investment by the State and the taxpayer in the institutions. We will structure our payments in a way that eases the burden on taxpayers. We are forcing the banks to recognise their losses upfront and once and for all rid the system of the scourge of speculative loans and mismanagement in the banking system. It is right we should approach the issue in this way, as all other courses of action would not result in a swift return by the banking sector to its function as a provider of finance to productive enterprises. While the State is committed to making up any shortfall in the capital needs of the institutions, it will not be called upon until other avenues of private capital raising have been explored.

Our new Central Bank legislation, which was outlined today, offers greater protection to the economy from the reckless practices of banks in recent times. The combined regulator and Central Bank will scrutinise more closely the work of banks in our economy. It will have stronger powers and will be set up to use them more often than in the past. In turn, the Central Bank will be subject to enhanced Oireachtas scrutiny. The newly appointed Governor, Professor Patrick Honohan, and the new head of the Financial Regulator, Matthew Elderfield, have shown their independence and commitment to putting the financial system here on a sounder footing. While it cannot be denied there are large costs to resolving our banking crisis, there are significant benefits to the State and its taxpayers from these moves.

As the Minister has already explained, our economy is likely to grow faster as we have now set the banking system to rights again. It is likely that NAMA will in the end deliver a net gain for the taxpayer owing to the robust valuation process it has pursued. The National Pensions Reserve Fund, NPRF, will have in the two main banks valuable investments that have the potential to realise gains. There is a proven gain of €1 billion which will accrue to taxpayers in six months time from the guarantee schemes put in place. Reforming Anglo Irish Bank into a reduced but sound credit institution which can be sold to private investors at a later date and carving out a good bank from what currently exists will go some way towards recouping the taxpayers' assistance to that bank at this time.

The steps we are taking today will provide certainty to the people from whom we must borrow, certainty among our trading partners and, as the Minister stated, certainty to those who will invest in the country. This certainty will further boost international confidence in the country, our people and the economy and will inevitably smooth our path to recovery. Our actions here today mean that we can now begin to live up to a renewed promise for growth and success in the Irish economy, which is the key objective of Government and one that we are resolved to achieve.

Comment on this

I had thought the Taoiseach would come in here this evening to spell out in clear and understandable English the reason the Government has chosen to put a further approximately €20 billion into Anglo Irish Bank. The announcement made today measures approximately 8.5 on the financial Richter scale. The epicentre of this financial earthquake is Anglo Irish Bank on St. Stephen's Green under an incompetent Fianna Fáil Government in Merrion Street for the past number of years. I have no doubt but that the officials advising the Taoiseach today are the same officials who were advising him when Minister for Finance that our economy was heading in the wrong direction and into a bubble, a bubble which burst under his stewardship. These people who are advising the Taoiseach today are in charge while the public servants of whom he spoke — I welcome the conclusion of the public sector talks — are having their salaries cut and will be forced to pay for the actions of the Government for many years.

The financial after shock of today's announcement, with particular reference to Anglo Irish Bank, will be felt not for one or two years but for a full generation. This is the result of an incompetent, careless, mismanaging Government of which the Taoiseach was formerly Minister for Finance and is now Leader. This doubling of the national debt with the stroke of a pen has pauperised a rising generation. The figures bandied about today are so large they pass over the heads of the vast majority of people in this country and are couched in financial language which will ensure they will not come home to roost until the lack of infrastructural facilities, cuts in pay and increases in taxes for which they will have to fork out, becomes evident.

The banks continue to stand, systemic or otherwise. The Government has put €40 billion into a dead bank. For this House to do its job properly the Government would have had to have come into this House to explain to the nation the justification for this plan. If one asks a person to invest €1,000 in a project and then returns six months later seeking a further €1,000 investment and a third time seeking another €1,000 such person would want to see the plan which would ensure a return on his or her investment.

Comment on this

There is no plan from the Government. The banks have sent their plans, with Government input, to Europe. What is the justification for this €40 billion investment in Anglo Irish Bank, including €8 billion today, a further €10 billion in the future and €18 billion that will go into NAMA? I would have thought the choices here are pretty stark. I do not understand why in respect of the subordinated loans, of risk-takers who invested because they knew the risk existed, the Government has given a cast iron guarantee that it will write whatever cheque is necessary. That cheque whether or not we like it will come out of the pockets and salaries of Irish workers. That is what will happen. This is not mythical money, it is real. Anglo Irish Bank is not a systemically important bank; it does not have a network around the country, it has no ATM machines and it does not lend money.

What is happening now in terms of the allocation made today with a further €10 billion to come is money over the cliff. This money is to cover the losses in Anglo Irish Bank with no return to the Irish taxpayer. The Taoiseach in his current capacity or previously as Minister for Finance had to decide on the equation of using €18 billion to buy out or pay for the bad, reckless management systems of Anglo Irish Bank or to put it to some other use such as the NewERA programme costed and put forward by the Fine Gael Party which would result in the creation of 100,000 jobs in the areas of renewables, broadband, water services and delivery of telecommunications, an opportunity to ensure the provision of real jobs with real money and real careers, but it blithely swept it off the end of the table into the black hole of Anglo Irish Bank which will never result in the return of one single job, salary or career opportunity. That is the choice the Government made.

I accept we need a strong working banking system. When the Minister for Finance telephoned me early on the morning of the announcement of the bank guarantee scheme to ask if I would support it, I agreed I would support it under certain conditions. Obviously, business needs a banking system that works. We have been told on three or four occasions by Government that every decision it took from the guarantee scheme to recapitalisation and NAMA would provide a wall of cash and credit moving through the system. The Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Eamon Ryan, publicly stated last Saturday that if Ireland did not pay its bond holders it would be forced out of the euro. I have never before heard such nonsense. Perhaps the Minister got carried away when down around Reginald's Tower in Waterford.

Comment on this

It was the horses that did it.

Comment on this

No bank manager in the country is in a position to authorise the lending of money. Bank managers at Allied Irish Bank or Bank of Ireland cannot and do not have the authority to lend money. A constituent of mine seeking to top up by €5,000 an €18,000 loan already in place was refused that loan despite his business having had a €500,000 turnover less than 18 months ago. The Government has come in here and boasted about the extra money being loaned to the banks. Allied Irish Bank and Bank of Ireland were last year lending €2.5 billion each. The Government says they will lend an extra €1 billion this year, which is fair enough. We will wait and see what happens on a regional basis in terms of what is actually approved.

In respect of loans below €5 million which are not going into NAMA, the banks are now beginning to liquidate many of these using the same criteria as applies when an entity fails and is wound up. The banks, in particular Anglo Irish Bank with its massive black hole, are not being wound up but are getting a bail out from the taxpayer despite the fact that the same principle applies, namely, a commercial entity that does not measure up must close.

The position in respect of distressed mortgages will worsen. Allied Irish Bank recently announced it is to raise its mortgage interest rates. The European Central Bank may raise its rates by the end of this year. The Bank of Ireland will probably follow this practice fairly soon. This will put more pressure on thousands of people around the country yet there is but a fleeting reference to distressed mortgages in the Minister's speech. The Government is putting €40 billion into Anglo Irish Bank, a vote in respect of which will take place in the House tonight. Tomorrow those Deputies who vote in support of this motion will walk up the steps of this House and vote to take special needs assistants from children with special needs. The public are seeing nothing but destruction. In cases where families have been focused since their children were born on attempting to deal with their special needs, they now see the Government being able to raise without difficulty €20 billion for Anglo Irish Bank and a further €20 billion for NAMA, with no plan to have a job stimulus in order to provide opportunities and careers for their sons and daughters in this country, if that is what they want to do.

Tomorrow evening the Government will, by vote, will take away special needs assistants from schools all over the country and children who need them. The Taoiseach knows this. As the former Minister for Finance, the Taoiseach failed to act on the advice which was undoubtedly given to him, namely, that our economy was heading down a one-way street, that we were losing our sense of competitiveness, our focus on exports and our capacity to keep our costs down and that we were heading into the bubble room of development which burst and now has serious consequences for hundreds of thousands of people.

The end result is that, whether we like it, the Government has the numbers pro tem and will force this through. I understand the Financial Regulator has to do its job and Mr. Matthew Elderfield can be very good. He set down his standards and principles. It is about time there was some regulation of the banking system which became reckless and crazy, and which led to the destruction of so many lives in Ireland.

There was and is a better way. I do not accept that, with $80 trillion to lend internationally by bond investors, we should get hung up on a situation whereby the Taoiseach is now allowing subordinated bond holders to be given a guarantee, as happened in the case of Anglo Irish Bank. Last year $80 trillion was available for investment worldwide. Yet, we now have a situation whereby the Government will screw Irish taxpayers, workers and people by imposing a serious levy on every one of the 1.6 million families in the country.

Anglo Irish Bank has proven to be a cancer in the financial world. It has links to the disruption of Quinn Direct and persons on the board of Anglo Irish Bank were also on the board of the Dublin Docklands Development Authority, which had consequences for the Irish Glass Bottle site. The Taoiseach approved the measures for borrowing——

Comment on this

I did not approve anything. That is a scurrilous statement.

Comment on this

——in a very short period of time, right up to the limit. There are consequences for the Irish Glass Bottle site and what it means for the taxpayer.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy, we are heavily into borrowed time.

Comment on this

It is indicative of the way the Taoiseach has allowed Anglo Irish Bank to be saved, without explaining to the House or the nation, how he can justify it in the interests of the taxpayer and the Irish people. He will rue the day this decision was made in respect of Anglo Irish Bank, in which the taxpayer is made to take all the pain and those who invested in the knowledge that they were taking a risk have been given a cast-iron guarantee.

Comment on this
Eamon Ryan Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources Green Party

This is the worst market failure in the history of the State. It is not the first in the banking area. We had ICI, the DIRT scandal and the Rusnak scandal, and perhaps there was a moral hazard in the failure of the banks to learn that such scandals would not be tolerated or accepted and led them and us into this crisis. We now have to face up to the problem, take control of it and deal with it. We do not serve the Irish people if we try to ignore it. If one examines the international experience, in terms of how one handles property crises and bubbles which lead to banking crashes — there have been many — it is clear there is a standard procedure which is followed in most cases.

One puts in place a guarantee to try to stabilise the banks, one has to have some vehicle to manage the assets which are the problem and one has to solve the capital problem of the banks. It is a fairly standard set of procedures which we saw in the United States recently and in any other similar banking scandal. It is what we have been doing. It is not popular or easy, but it has to be done for the sake of the future of this country.

Deputy Kenny used the word "cancer" and he is correct. Anglo Irish Bank has done that level of damage to this country. Shame on the people involved. The sense of regret and anger is palpable and correct, in particular because Anglo Irish Bank is such a small bank and the crisis happened in a short period of time and grew quickly in recent times when the real damage was done.

Deputy Bruton asked about the term "systemic importance". The first time I heard the term used was when the Treasury Secretary in the United States of America, Mr. Henry Paulson used it October last year in reference to, I understand, Wachovia bank. There was a possibility it would go bust and a realisation by the United States authorities that they could not allow that to happen. Obviously they had learned a lesson from Lehman Brothers, which accounted for some 4% of American GDP. Anglo Irish Bank comprised approximately 50% of Irish GDP. They had learned the lesson that a bank the size of Lehman Brothers was of systemic importance for the overall economy. The size of Anglo Irish Bank is unfortunate and deeply regretted. It should never have been allowed to grow that big and was a false, fraudulent banking model.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Regulation.

Comment on this

When one examines it, it clearly is systemic within the definition given by Mr. Paulson, and that is why something had to be done about it. How mutual building societies such as Irish Nationwide could have engaged in such fraudulent banking practice is beyond belief. Deputy Kenny can point, but there are people on all sides who bear responsibility. I remember in 2006——

Comment on this

Only some contributed.

Comment on this

——at the height of the property bubble politicians on all sides said we had to do something, the market fundamentals were right, we had to keep the property bubble going and cut stamp duty and so on. There were political failings.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

That was to give people a break from their mortgages.

Comment on this

The political system let us down but we need to move on now and examine how we can solve the problem.

The figures today are shocking because they show a very sharp discount and show up the nature of the fraudulent banking which went on. They also give us a certain comfort. Deputy Bruton said the Irish people will recover from this. It will require us to make sure we change society for the better as we do it——

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

It takes money. You have spent it.

Comment on this

——in order that we learn the lessons from history.

We took a very harsh approach and examined the banks, and said we said we do not accept their figures any more, that we are giving the figures, in terms of what we see as the potential losses, and are using a much sharper discount than anyone expected. The figures show that our two main banks, namely, AIB and Bank of Ireland, are truly of systemic importance. While they may have made terrible mistakes, in particular AIB, they can survive this. By putting in capital we can get them working again. It is of fundamental economic importance to this country that the two banks which are the bedrock of our economic system can be turned around and get out of their current situation.

While the figures for Anglo Irish Bank are, understandably, shocking, the international perception will be that its assumption of the figures for AIB and Bank of Ireland were far worse. When they hear the regulator, who has real authority and independence, or the Governor of the Central Bank, who has real expertise in this area, say it is worst case scenario in our two main banks it will restore a certain amount of confidence in this country.

We could have, should have and did examine other options. The first thing I did when I went to the Minister for Finance a year and a half ago was tell him we had to nationalise all the banks. I am now glad we did not, because we were not in a fit shape to do anything at that time as we were grappling with such a difficult situation regarding the funding of finance for the State. We did not know what the situation was. It was far better to go through the process we have gone through, whereby we got loan valuations in order to know what was going on.

There are differences between the situations in Bank of Ireland and AIB. Had we gone in and nationalised everything, as some people at the time argued we should, we would not have had a true sense of the reality. Under European regulations, we would have had to go in and do the valuations which we have done over a recent period of time and for which we have legislated. I do not believe a blanket nationalisation would have served this country well. It would have cost us more in higher interest rates, among other problems I have mentioned.

In terms of the default option, I will explain to Deputy Kenny what I said at the weekend because I have examined the issue in detail. I have no love of bond holders or the capitalist system which it underpins. However, it exists and it is the reality within which we as a country must operate and trade. I am concerned about that and I want to be careful to get it right.

Last weekend I referred to going to the bond markets and saying we will not pay our debt on the senior bonds. The subordinated debts are different. Those who hold them have taken a hit and they will take a further hit. However, if we default on senior debt, which is effectively money on deposit in our banks, as seems to have been suggested by some Members——

Comment on this

The Government should negotiate. There is a difference.

Comment on this

I refer to David McWilliams's argument about doing that and giving up on our reputation in that sense but we might as well go the whole hog, leave the euro and use the opportunity to devalue to get out of the economic difficulties.

Comment on this

The Minister is mixing up Anglo Irish Bank and Ireland.

Comment on this

He cannot even understand this himself, which is scary.

Comment on this

The certainty of that as an approach is driven by an analysis which does not consider the fact that the European Central Bank is one of the main depositors or bondholders in Anglo Irish Bank. If we take the option of defaulting on those who have money on deposit in Anglo Irish Bank, we would have to say to the ECB that we will not pay it back.

Comment on this

That is absolute nonsense.

Comment on this

One cannot differentiate between bondholders and the ECB in that section of the balance sheet.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The senior bondholders are hedge funds.

Comment on this

It would be difficult legally to differentiate between them and say we will not touch the ECB but we will touch Deutsche Bank or whichever bank is involved.

Having examined this inside out and having tried to determine what is the easiest way for us to get out of this, the default option is the more expensive and risky. It would require us to take the hugely risky step for which David McWilliams argues. While I respect his opinion and I understand his analysis — he has a certain credibility having called some of the problems in the first place — I do not agree with him that this is the right approach for the country because our problem is on a scale we can manage. It is a lower cost solution, as shocking as it is and as difficult as the figures are, to managing this in the way we are.

Comment on this

A total of €80 billion.

Comment on this

No other country has taken the default option and the ECB has set itself against banks of this scale defaulting in any member state.

Comment on this

At what cost? No more schools and so on.

Comment on this

That is what I tried to say at the weekend and it may have been misunderstood in certain quarters.

I am proud of the Green Party's role in trying to do the right thing in the past year and that we introduced a risk sharing component in order that the banks would take the hit on subordinated debt.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

It equates to only 5% and the Governor of the Central Bank said it should have been higher.

Comment on this

I am also proud that we insisted on and pushed for the highest haircut possible to makes sure we reflected——

Comment on this

The EU ensured that happened.

Comment on this

It was not just the EU. If people had cared to listen, all along we said we would insist on a loan by loan valuation, we would not do favours to the banks, we would force them to recognise their losses and that is what has happened today.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The Anglo Irish Bank losses are only an estimate.

Comment on this

I am proud we have consistently recognised that the culture and people within our banking system are culpable and we called for them to be cleared out from the very start, particularly at board level, where they had responsibility for the strategic errors make.

Comment on this

And gave them wage increases.

Comment on this

I am also proud we pushed for further support for the taxpayer through the introduction of a levy on the banks to cover any losses incurred. In addition, we pushed for the Government to give support to those who have been caught in this downturn with debt problems. It is important that we look after particular groups within our country who have been left in serious debt difficulties.

Comment on this

What is the result of that? There is nothing there.

Comment on this

The Green Party has engaged in several difficult actions. First, we faced up to this problem and we have tried to take control of it in a way we think is the least costly for the taxpayer. However, it is more important that we learn lessons to change the culture in the banking system and in our markets in order that such failures do not happen again and that the State is not left with the task of holding the country together when the market fails and we can move on to recovery.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

I wish to share time with Deputy Noonan.

The Minister is living on a parallel universe. He is trying to see what he wants to see rather than the reality. Anglo Irish Bank will cost the taxpayer more than €40 billion. The bank will receive €22 billion in recapitalisation and it will account for 70% of the €32 billion set aside for recapitalisation of the banks.

Senior bondholders are professional investors and they took the risk. Senior debt is not like deposits and it can be traded. How can the Minister justify voting for something that will cost the taxpayer €40 billion?

Comment on this

How has the Deputy arrived at that figure?

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

By adding €22 billion through recapitalisation and €18 billion in loans transferred to NAMA.

Comment on this

Those loans now have the value they should have.

Comment on this

Following a 65% discount.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The figures relating to Anglo Irish Banks are estimates. The loans have yet to be audited and discounted.

Comment on this

There has been a 50% discount.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What has been proposed is an estimate.

Comment on this

This was done by the regulator, who is an independent international expert.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Can the Minister justify putting €22 billion into Anglo Irish Bank? It is equivalent of the health and education budgets rolled into one. Deputy Kenny asked whether the Minister would go through the lobbies tomorrow evening to vote against a motion regarding SNAs who will no longer be provided for children with special needs.

Comment on this

Every Member deeply regrets it but we should not confuse the people by saying the cost of this is €40 billion when it is closer to €20 billion.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

We have no idea how much NAMA will make. We all want a banking system that works. Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland have been given time. Their losses to date have not been crystallised. If the Government wants private investors to put money into these banks, it should have outlined earlier their losses to date and how they will come up with funding. However, we will not know that for another six months. That would have encouraged private investors. We have had no justification for putting €8 billion into Anglo Irish Bank today or for putting in a further €10 billion down the line, which is extremely regrettable.

The Minister referred to sovereign debt. International capital markets will see the Government parties dealing specifically with a non-systemic bank such as Anglo Irish Bank when they should be encouraging lending into the economy going forward. Instead, for the next ten years, almost 25% of our annual tax take will be used to fund banks with €2 billion going into Anglo Irish Bank and INBS annually and the taxpayer will never secure a return. A sum of €4 billion will be paid in interest on the money borrowed to fund NAMA and the recapitalisation of the banks. Every year €6 billion of the more than €30 billion taken in in taxes will go into a black hole. How can the Minister vote in favour of that?

The Taoiseach said what the Government proposes will not result in stagnancy and decay. The Government parties have sat on this for the past year. No credit has been extended and all they have secured from AIB and Bank of Ireland is a statement that they will examine targets. They have made no firm commitments on lending. The banks have provided €500 million in additional lending, which is grossly inadequate. We need a proper, revised and updated plan for NAMA and we need to see the Government's advice on putting money into Anglo Irish Bank. The draft plan for NAMA states that more than 80% of the loans involved are performing, which is impossible. We need a proper debate and value for the taxpayer. Recapitalising Anglo Irish Bank to the tune of €22 billion does not represent value.

Comment on this

It is an appalling debate in which to be involved. The situation is far worse than any of us thought even a week ago. It is difficult to find anything optimistic to say or to support the Government in its difficulty. It is good that Bank of Ireland is not in deep trouble. It looks as if it can be helped out of its difficulty fairly easily without much cost to the taxpayer. Bank of Ireland has always been a bulwark of the economy. Allied Irish Banks, through mismanagement, followed the lead of Anglo Irish Bank. It came to property speculation late but when it did get involved it did so with a vengeance. It has found itself in a difficult situation and it is a costly rescue. We should congratulate Irish Life & Permanent for not being involved at all and not making any call on taxpayers' money tonight. Beyond that, the situation of Anglo Irish Bank is an absolute disaster.

In the various banking debates in the past two years, we in the Opposition have been generally supportive of the Government's difficulties. We supported the guarantee in the first instance. However, I have lost faith in the Government's ability to provide us with the facts. Ministers no longer have credibility. The reason is that when the guarantee was made on 30 September 2008 we had a new Minister for Finance who had no background in finance or economics. He has learned fast and has proven to be effective since but at that time he was new to the area. We should consider who were his advisers — the then Governor of the Central Bank, the then regulator, and the then senior officials in the Department of Finance, all of whom were incompetent. They did not protect the public interest and on the night when they were advising the Minister, they were hiding their mistakes.

Then the Minister invited in the key bankers who gave him financial advice. Who were they? Mr. Seán FitzPatrick, and the then chief executive and chairman of Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland and Mr. Fingleton were on the telephone. Their advice was to give the banks a guarantee to rescue them and they said that everything was fine. It was only three weeks previously that both the regulators and the senior bankers assured committees of the House that they had tested the loan portfolios in their banks and that they were the soundest banks in Europe. They said there was no problem. There was no question of insolvency. The Minister was caught in a situation where everyone advising him had a vested interest, to say the least of it. If lying was an Olympic sport we would win gold every year if we togged out four bankers. There would be no problem in that regard. On that night the truth was not being told in Merrion Street by the senior bankers. The Minister, Deputy Martin, knows that well.

Comment on this

We would have to hand back the medals in due course after the doping tests.

Comment on this

The Minister is agreeing with me. That was the situation. At every step of the way we have got false information. Reference was made to the valuation and the fact that the haircut was originally to be 25% and then 30%. That was in the business plan for NAMA. The Oireachtas Library & Research Service produced a paper in the same week as the NAMA business plan was published. It had four different ways of valuing assets and each of them pointed to a haircut of at least 40%. If the resources of the Oireachtas Library & Research Service in Leinster House was able to come up with a figure, what were the regulators, the Central Bank and officials in the Department of Finance doing when they came up with those extravagant figures? Even as late as last week the suggested liability that was being leaked to the newspapers was a great deal less than we are faced with tonight. This is an appalling situation.

On that night on 30 September the guarantee to the bond holders should not have been given. It was sufficient to guarantee the depositors. That was the mistake and since then the Government has been chasing itself. It has been tardy in acting as well. The guarantee was made approximately 18 months ago. A similar crisis was evident in the United States. The US Government moved to sort it out and the banks are trading profitably now and supporting a growing economy. A similar problem occurred in the United Kingdom. The result was absolute trauma. It looked for a time as if the UK Government of Mr. Gordon Brown would collapse but it moved quickly to recapitalise the banks in the first couple of months and got them trading again. Now they are underpinning a growing economy.

We have been horsing around with matters for too long. The Government is still doing it. Deputy Bruton made a key point today. In the Opposition we often vote because we have to vote but I will vote with conviction tonight because no one on the Government side has answered the question. No one has made the case for why we have to rescue Anglo Irish Bank when all we are doing is putting money into a black hole. It will never operate as a bank again or lend to anyone again. It will never put up an ATM machine again, not that it had them anyway. It will not open further branches. It is not a bank that is necessary. Why mortgage our children and our grandchildren for the next 15 to 20 years by pouring money into that black hole? It all runs from the original decision. The Minister was misled on the night and action should be taken. Dawn raids by the Garda before a serious Dáil debate is not an answer to an intensive inquiry by the fraud squad into the activities of Anglo Irish Bank.

Comment on this
Micheál Martin Minister for Foreign Affairs Fianna Fáil

I wish to make a number of comments. Much has been said in the debate. I concur with the comments of the Minister for Finance who described the figures involved as horrifying. The steps the Government has taken and those proposed by the Minister today represent policy of substance in leading our way out of the banking crisis. I have been disappointed by the quality and substance of the response from the Opposition today.

Comment on this

The Minister does not like the message. Deputy Bruton's contribution was excellent.

Comment on this

The overall NAMA solution has received significant national and international endorsement. Commissioner Almunia, in his previous role as Commissioner for Economic and Monetary Affairs, stated that NAMA should be approved as quickly as possible. That was in October last. In his current role as Competition Commissioner he approved NAMA last Friday. Of the investment community 80% of respondents to a Bloxham survey agreed that NAMA has and will continue to improve sentiment towards the Irish economy. The European Central Bank has approved NAMA and will be an integral stakeholder in its operation. The Secretary General of the OECD indicated that we must stabilise the financial system and take out the toxic assets that are eating the good credit and put those aside, then we can recapitalise the banks so they can continue to lend to businesses. The recent comments of the Governor of the Central Bank, Professor Patrick Honohan, not the previous Governor but the current one, were that he had said all along that NAMA is an essential part of the strategy, that it does a number of things; provides the banks with capital as a buffer against future risks and provides them with liquidity so that if they want to make loans they can do so.

Comment on this

In his first speech he said NAMA needed to have the right haircut. He said it was very important how much it paid for the loans.

Comment on this

The list goes on. The International Monetary Fund, for example, was supportive of the efforts to restructure the financial sector, including the decision to establish the National Asset Management Agency. Other leading commentators who have stated their support include Mr. Kevin Gardiner of Barclay's Wealth who said, contrary to what Deputy Noonan indicated, that the Government has acted speedily in comparison to other governments. The economist, Professor Philip Lane, said on "The Last Word" yesterday that the Government's approach to resolving the financial crisis is an internally coherent approach. He said there was much concern a year and a half ago about the Government's financial stability but that the Government has more capability in terms of dealing with the banks. He said that the fact that we have stabilised our fiscal situation allows the Government to be more confident that the separation between banks and the Government can be kept.

There is a range of solid opinion from policy makers, economists and institutions who have endorsed and supported the NAMA approach.

Comment on this

With respect, there are as many on the other side as well.

Comment on this

I did not interrupt anyone from across the floor.

Comment on this

There are as many commentators on the other side as well. Let us not kid ourselves.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

Deputy English. Fine Gael has its own time. It is the Minister's time now. The Deputy should explain his point to the next contributor and he can respond in that way.

Comment on this

The Minister can handle it. He is a big boy.

Comment on this

I pose the question to the Opposition spokespersons. Have all of those people got it wrong in terms of the correct solution to the banking crisis? What has been absent from the Opposition has been any substantial policy alternative to the NAMA vehicle.

Comment on this

That is untrue.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

That is not true.

Comment on this

I listened extensively, without interruption, to Deputy Bruton's contribution.

Comment on this

It was guillotined.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

Deputy English should mention his point in Deputy Naughten's ear.

Comment on this

The Minister is rising us. He wants to be interrupted.

Comment on this

I hope I get extra time. This tactic is going on and on and it is ridiculous.

Comment on this

The Minister is asking for it.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

I always give injury time.

Comment on this

If the Minister does not like the heat he should get out of the kitchen.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

We could all do with injury time.

Comment on this

The only comfort in the interruptions is the knowledge that what I say rings true and is hurting. I listened to both Deputy Bruton and Deputy Burton. Deputy Bruton focused on the situation in Anglo Irish Bank. Fine Gael needs to recall it supported the State guarantee at that point and did so as it saw a need for safeguarding. Considering that it supported the guarantee and voted for it, it should realise, as the Minister for Finance pointed out today,——

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

We did not support the recapitalisation of Anglo Irish Bank.

Comment on this

——that any immediate wind-up would lead to a fire sale of assets resulting in a permanent additional and unnecessary loss of upwards of €30 billion. In addition, the State would have to provide a large sum of cash in the order of €70 billion up-front "to meet the deposits, bondholders and liabilities due to the Eurosystem". That is a fact.

Comment on this

That is not a fact.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The guarantee is in place until September.

Comment on this

That is the one fact Deputy Bruton avoided in his contribution. In his entire contribution, he ignored the reality——

Comment on this