We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Banking System: Motion.

Contributions 137–303 of 303. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The guarantee is in place until September.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

The Deputy should not try to shout the Minister down.

Comment on this

——of what would happen if today——

Comment on this

He has not got a clue what he is talking about.

Comment on this

The critique is about today's proposals——

Comment on this

One negotiates one's debt with the bondholders.

Comment on this

He studiously avoided the core point, namely, the cost of winding up Anglo Irish Bank, forgetting it and endeavouring to pretend one can go on——

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

No.

Comment on this

——apart entirely from the default situation.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

I ask the Minister to address the Chair rather than the Opposition.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

He is being disorderly.

Comment on this

I am addressing the Chair and am looking at the Acting Chairman intently.

Economists have known since the Great Depression of the 1930s that the meltdown of any bank, a large bank in particular, can have catastrophic effects on the economy and citizens' welfare.

Comment on this

They did not tell us that when it was going wrong.

Comment on this

Anglo Irish Bank was much larger relative to the Irish economy than Lehman Brothers was relative to the US economy. The disorderly failure of Lehman Brothers brought the global financial system to its knees——

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Anglo Irish Bank is a property company.

Comment on this

——and the disorderly failure of Anglo Irish Bank two weeks later would have had the same effect on the entire Irish banking system. The President of the European Central Bank, Mr. Jean-Claude Trichet, stated on numerous occasions that allowing Lehman Brothers to collapse was a critical mistake in the global financial crisis. The president of the Bundesbank, Mr. Axel Weber, said on a recent visit to this country that in the aftermath of the collapse of Lehman Brothers, allowing a large bank to fail in Europe would have been catastrophic for the entire economy. The French Finance Minister, Ms Christine Lagarde, who has praised Ireland's fiscal policy, called the decision to let Lehman Brothers fail horrendous and a genuine mistake as it triggered panic in its markets and brought banks to the brink of a 1929-style financial meltdown.

I endorse what the Minister said today. While we all understand the impulse to obliterate Anglo Irish Bank from the system, the Minister said he could not countenance such an action. He was telling the truth and stating the honest position.

Unfortunately, Deputy Burton's contribution was 90% critique and she said very little about solutions. The advices we have received show temporary nationalisation would have been the wrong option at the time in question. The Deputy's speech was about political sloganeering and political felon-setting, which is no substitute for a substantial policy option.

Comment on this

Felon-setting.

Comment on this

Felon-setting, get off.

Comment on this

Deputy Stagg knows all about it.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What will Anglo Irish Bank do?

Comment on this

Felon-setting.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

This is not Question Time.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What will we get for the €22 billion?

Comment on this

Felon-setting.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

I am sorry, the Minister wants to respond to Deputy Stagg.

Comment on this

We are all sorry.

Comment on this

Perhaps the Minister will withdraw his stupidity about felon-setting.

Comment on this

Through the Chair, I would like to continue my speech without interruption. I listened for a good hour to Deputies Bruton and Burton and did not interrupt.

Comment on this

The Minister is lucky she is not here.

Comment on this

We are all lucky in that respect.

The point I am making in terms of felon-setting and political sloganeering is that there is a lovely political line coming from the Labour Party that is popular, about electoral appeal and winning votes but not grounded on an honest assessment of the situation——

Comment on this

We learned a lot of lessons from Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

——or on viable solutions to the banking crisis.

Comment on this

The Minister would not do anything like that.

Comment on this
Seán Ardagh Acting Chairman Fianna Fáil

Order, please.

Comment on this

That is the charge I would make. The guarantee was the beginning of the rot for the Labour Party in terms of policy of substance.

Comment on this

The Minister was criticising Fine Gael for agreeing with it.

Comment on this

Perhaps it was fine from the perspective of electoral politics but, from the perspective of creating solutions, it was the beginning of the rot. The Labour Party bottled it on the guarantee and did the easy thing in the days and weeks after it was given, namely lump everything together on popular grounds, including property speculation and tax reliefs.

Comment on this
Jan O'Sullivan Deputy Jan O’Sullivan Labour Party

The Minister cannot have it both ways. He criticised Fine Gael for supporting it.

Comment on this

If one wants to talk about tax reliefs, one must remember it was its Government that introduced the seaside resort relief. The argument that the property market was stoked by a Fianna Fáil Government is erroneous.

Comment on this

The Minister's time is up.

Comment on this

Nobody gave Mr. Sean Dunne a tax relief to buy certain hotels on the south side of Dublin to try to make a profit. We had a free market and the fundamental flaw was with regulation.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The Government had control over it. It was its responsibility. Does the Minister accept that?

Comment on this

I will deal with that.

Comment on this

The Minister's time is up.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy O'Donnell allow the Minister to continue without interruption?

Comment on this

The problem with regulation in any crisis concerns who guards the guards.

Comment on this

The Government does. The regulator would be the Government.

Comment on this

The point is that the conventional wisdom for decades was that politicians should be kept——

Comment on this

Yes, from Deputy Bertie Ahern.

Comment on this

Irrespective of who was in Government, the conventional wisdom was that politicians should be kept out of regulation and that there should be independent regulation that could not be compromised by the political system.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The Government introduced the legislation.

Comment on this

That is what went wrong. Deputy Bertie Ahern in Government——

Comment on this

The bottom line was that the independent regulatory system collapsed and failed abysmally, as I have acknowledged.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The current Taoiseach is using the term "build on".

Comment on this

I do not accept the simplistic propositions of the Opposition in regard to this entire crisis.

Comment on this

They are very well thought out. The Minister knows that.

Comment on this

There are many underlying factors. As the Taoiseach said today, we have witnessed the worst global recession since 1929. The challenge is to chart the right pathways out of that recession.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Ours was created primarily by a collapse in the building industry.

Comment on this

As Minister for Foreign Affairs, I know international opinion suggests Ireland has demonstrated the capacity to take itself out of the fiscal crisis.

Comment on this

The Minister has exceeded 15 minutes.

Comment on this

In terms of NAMA and the special purpose vehicle, the international opinion is that Ireland has created a pathway to enable the country to come out of the banking crisis and help economic recovery.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

The Government is doubling the national debt.

Comment on this

The third pillar relates to the enterprise economy, the indigenous sector, which is still quite resilient in terms of export orientation and inward investment. There is still investment coming into the country. We need some positive thinking. The Government is at least focused on a pathway out of the crisis.

Comment on this

Out of office.

Comment on this

The Opposition is focused on electoral gain to the detriment of sound policy.

Comment on this

Are the slots now 13 minutes?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

No.

Comment on this

That one was.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

There has been a slippage on both sides of the House.

Comment on this

If one had an orderly Opposition, there could be ten-minute slots.

Comment on this

I will be very glad to achieve an equivalence of slippage for the Ceann Comhairle.

I want to make some points of public economy. The Minister for Foreign Affairs referred specifically to the Labour Party. Last Thursday, we launched a policy document about a strategic investment bank that would be funded with €2 billion from the National Pensions Reserve Fund. The document specified a number of ways in which we could create employment. This is relevant to the speeches I have heard because the real issue is the question of what we could have been doing with money the State could have guaranteed and provided.

Last Sunday week, in another capacity, I was presenting medals at a soccer final attended by a couple of hundred children. Their community had built an all-weather pitch for €900,000. The cost of running it is approximately €20,000 and the income is approximately €97,000. Instead of charging, those who run the facility make sure it is available to all the local schools for free. Effectively, the cost was less than €1 million. This creates a capital provision for a facility. Since the annual cost of running the facility is €20,000, there is a surplus of €70,000 or €80,000, which can be used for other purposes. A free facility is provided for schoolchildren that addresses the national problem of obesity.

There are dozens of such projects that could benefit from immediate investment. Lest people believe we are not real in the Labour Party, they should note that every €1 million spent in construction creates 9.1 jobs of full-time equivalence. This is relevant because the Government is transferring what it accepts are astronomically large sums to keep in existence Anglo Irish Bank, the case for whose systemic status has never been made. Consider the Labour Party's position last September when we argued against a blanket guarantee that regarded Anglo Irish Bank as systemic. One did not need to be a genius to see the difference between the gamblers' club that was Anglo Irish Bank and Bank of Ireland and AIB. I challenge the Ministers to say in their replies whether it was not the case that the documents prepared by the Department of Finance to brief the Minister acknowledged that difference and the Department had prepared alternative strategies for the future of Anglo Irish Bank.

I have listened to the Minister for Finance talk, in effect, about the great things they supposedly are saying about us around the world. This type of Ireland’s Own approach to the Irish economy is very interesting because they were not saying great things about us when the Government was flying. A friend of mine describes the reputation that Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide had in London as the building societies on crack cocaine. The Government is rightly concerned about reputation management, but can it answer this question. If it were to calculate the consequences of the different decisions available to it on that September night, did it not take into account the difference of allowing Anglo Irish Bank to be phased down and the calculated reputational responses?

If one believes one must not frighten anybody, even those investors taking a high yield from subordinated debt, one has to justify it by saying, in effect, that such investors are so nervous and highly tuned on their high yield that the slightest action from the Irish Government would upset them. If that is what the Government believes, it is a genuine position. It may be compared with other positions, however, for example, the fact that such investors have regularly taken discounts.

I am glad the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Ryan, has returned because I want to address something else to him. I regret that he was not in the Chamber for my previous example of what investment will not take place because we have had to give such a high proportion of our income towards keeping the ratio right in the banks. That is the choice. The flexibility we had in terms of the proportion of borrowing relative to gross national product is, in fact, the flexibility one has, and that is where the politics plays a part in how to do something different. That is the argument in Greece as well, and it is a political one.

Let us discuss it in a sane manner in that regard. One of the documents floating around today from the National Asset Management Agency suggests that the agency has secured a combined investment of €51 million from three institutions, €17 million each for a 51% shareholding in National Asset Management Agency Investment Limited, the NAMA special purpose vehicle. I was in the House during the long night when we debated all this and one of the points the Minister for Finance seemed to accept was the social dividend. In the loans being transferred and the heavy discount being applied to those, where precisely is the social dividend? Going back to the example I gave about the all-weather pitches, this could be achieved with lighting, security and management for about €900,000. If these were to be on public lands, where is the transfer of assets to build all those facilities — the community halls, libraries and schools — and the social dividend that was at the heart of the argument we made when we were debating this issue in the House during that night?

How can this be squared with the three bodies I have just mentioned and can it be put on the record of the House that there is not the slightest suggestion of a conflict of interest between these bodies and, for example, Allied Irish Banks investment managers and the banks that are being released by taxpayers' money? These are basic issues that are very important, rather than getting the lecture we have just had to the effect that we are going to bring Ireland back to 1929. I am glad the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Martin, mentioned 1929. Had he remained in the Chamber, I would have reminded him that in May 1929 the concept of rational markets was introduced by an economist in Chicago. Two weeks later the crash happened and he died many years later in poverty, getting food vouchers through his relatives. The debate about rational markets went on and on through many different distinguished economists. Towards the time just before the most recent crash, it was suggested that there was no such thing and if sufficient resources were fired into the system — a continual expansion in a cosmic-type manner — a type of order might emerge. That is what has gone down.

If the Ministers, Deputy Martin or Deputy Ryan, want to do something, they can promote the Tobin tax which the Green Party favoured along with me a long time ago. They can deal with the international side of things, but at the moment the Minister for Foreign Affairs is just travelling the world picking up opinions to the effect that they said in France we are great. In this manner, when it comes to explaining the cuts where special needs assistants posts should be created, more carers employed, etc., the Government will be able to say they think we are great in Germany too. Such mantras may be kept up, but they are nonsense. The fact is that there are political choices to be made.

It is necessary to be real in a way that anyone can understand. I believe I am being fair to every ministerial speech I have heard in saying that the only construction to be taken from what they said is, in effect, that when the banking system is stable, we shall then get on with the other matters, that the demands of the real economy are somehow residual to all this. Meanwhile, small retailers throughout the country are having their arrangements with local banks changed. Why should the banks do otherwise, since they can take Government bonds, exchange them for real money with the European Central Bank and get about 2% above anything that may be had in the national economy? There is neither compulsion nor attraction for the banks to put any money into the Irish economy, so let us get real.

We are always being told this about Labour's practical proposals. These entail recognising the liquidity needs of the real economy, having a strategic investment bank and using some of the National Pensions Reserve Fund before it is eroded in the mad caper that was Anglo Irish Bank. At the same time the real economy should be restored to the banking sector, as should a version of political economy that recognises real political choices.

Every speech today on the Government side had the same message, to the effect that they are all impressed abroad at the grief we have been able to visit, fairly silently, on the people at home. That is a miserable argument. It is Dickensian and is illiterate in its economics. What we are listening to is, in fact, the justification of the consequences of a bad night at the casino.

Comment on this

I wish to share my time with Deputy Paul Gogarty, with the permission of the House. As the famous saying goes, those who do not learn from their mistakes are condemned to repeat them. This is, without doubt, the most serious financial crisis in the history of the State, brought about by a combination of factors which all occurred in a relatively short period of time: an international financial crisis, an international recession, a property bubble in Ireland, the failure of financial regulation in Ireland, and a completely reckless spending spree carried out by some of our banks. That is why I welcome the banking inquiry which has been set in train by this Government and which is now in its first phase. I understand that first phase, which is doing the preparatory work, will report some time during the summer. The second phase of that inquiry will be a fully sworn commission of inquiry under the commission of inquiry legislation. I believe such an inquiry is extremely important. The people deserve to know exactly how this crisis came about. That is the least we owe them.

The figures given today by the Minister for Finance were truly horrendous. There is up to €18.3 billion for Anglo Irish Bank, which does not include the €4 billion already given, €2.6 billion for the INBS, the money already invested in Bank of Ireland and AIB and the further moneys that might have to be invested in those companies. These are extraordinarily large amounts of money. The public is correctly concerned about this and has every right to be concerned. The Minister echoed that concern in his speech. However, as the Minister for Foreign Affairs said, there must be a proper pathway out of this crisis and, in fairness to the Government, it has produced that pathway.

If one examines in detail the legislation passed by the Government since September 2008 when the crisis first started, one will notice that the preamble to each measure sets out clearly that the background to each Act is the severity of the economic crisis. In rough chronological order the measures taken were the bank guarantee announced on 30 September 2008, various budgetary cuts, the pension levy, the NAMA legislation, the recapitalisation of the banks and the banking inquiry which I have mentioned. Earlier, I heard Deputy Michael Noonan chastising the Minister for Finance for being tardy. I reject that.

Comment on this

He was right.

Comment on this

Given the amount of legislation, the complex nature of the problems the State is grappling with and the depth of the recession, the Minister for Finance and the Government have done exceptionally well in this area. I sat through the Second and Committee Stage debates on the NAMA legislation, as Deputy Higgins can testify, and although some good and genuine points were made by the Opposition, there was a great deal of time wasting by the Opposition throughout that process as well.

Comment on this

We do not agree with it. Get that into your head.

Comment on this

The Opposition cannot have it both ways. It cannot expect the State and the Government to act quickly yet delay and hobble it at every opportunity and in every procedure in the Dáil. That is inconsistent. What has the Opposition proposed? Fine Gael at least supported the bank guarantee but inconsistently does not support the NAMA process. The Labour Party is consistent. It does not support NAMA, nor did it support the bank guarantee. In fact, Deputy Joan Burton, when responding to the budget in 2004 said all the money in the National Pensions Reserve Fund should be used on existing projects.

I strongly commend the Government's actions. I welcome the Minister's speech today. This is a very difficult day but, to echo the famous quote, this is perhaps the end of the beginning.

Comment on this

In September 2008, the Irish banking system was about to be rolled over as a result of bad business decisions, lax banking practices particularly with regard to lending, a related political system unduly influenced by vested interests at both national and local level, to which I have alluded in previous contributions, as well as poor regulation. It was brought to the brink by its incapacity to deal with what was, admittedly, a global recession. Opinion still differs as to whether Anglo Irish Bank could be described as a systemic bank. The risk was that if Anglo Irish Bank fell, the rest of the Irish banking system would collapse. The Minister for Finance made a judgment call that Anglo Irish Bank needed to be protected, first by inclusion in the bank guarantee scheme and, later, through its nationalisation. It was an educated decision because the risk in letting Anglo Irish Bank fail was far greater than the risk in trying to manage its debt portfolio in an incremental manner through a national asset management agency.

Others both inside and outside these Houses may seek solace from the comforting security of inconsequential responsibility. The suggestions put forward have ranged from pulling out of the euro through letting the banks collapse to nationalising them. That would all be at a much higher cost to the taxpayer than a partial and temporary equity stake. The Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, as the line Minister could not afford to take those risks and just put forward ideas. He had to find something that balanced innovation and conservatism simultaneously. That is what NAMA is, and the Green Party agreed with this and fed into the process.

Much has happened since September 2008. There is a new Governor of the Central Bank and a new Financial Regulator. We now own Anglo Irish Bank and this process has begun, for better or for worse. It should be allowed to continue to minimise the cost to the taxpayer and maximise the returns from the good bank element in the future. There is a new chief executive in Anglo Irish Bank whose responsibility is to the Irish people, not to cronies and vested interests. I am disappointed that some say it is still more cost effective to let Anglo Irish Bank fail and leave its debts uncovered. The argument has moved on. We cannot realistically default on those debts without increasing the cost of borrowing and risking a Greek style financial tragedy. Moving forward is the only game in town.

There also appears to be confusion about where the money is coming from and whether there is an alternative way to spend the huge sums going into NAMA and bank recapitalisation. This is not our wish list. We had to put our banking and economic system on a sound footing and put the money into the banks. This money is coming from different sources, not a wish fund which one can spend on health, education and wages. It comes from a preferential ECB rate which is designed only to cover our bank rescue and NAMA. It would not be available otherwise. If one believes that getting our banking system up and running again is crucial to our economy, there is no other option and this is the cheapest method available. Other criticisms regarding lack of spending on capital projects or covering current annual State bills are spurious.

Today, we have been given the figures relating to the loans transferred to NAMA, comprising 20% of the entire portfolio. The average discount of 47% is far higher than the original guesstimate of 30% and puts paid to the suggestion that this would amount to favours for cronies. This is a decision made on commercial grounds and putting the public interest first. We now own significant shareholdings in the larger banks. This will balance the risks associated with NAMA to ensure a return in future for the Exchequer.

I welcome the measures to protect those at risk of losing their homes, which were announced previously. I also welcome the statement of intent by the Minister to provide additional support to SMEs in particular, with regard to providing cashflow and the credit review process. One sector that could do with help from the State is the printing sector. It is experiencing huge cashflow problems at present. There is scope for the State to act. It could cut up its contracts into contracts of under €50,000 and ensure that Irish printers are provided with good business, rather than the current practice of giving it to contract operations to divvy out the printing to companies in other EU countries that are not covered by the same stringent regulations. Think Irish first where that is possible and help speed up the economic recovery.

Comment on this

I wish to share time with Deputy Deenihan.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

That is agreed.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to speak on the motion before us. The bank bailout that has been presented to the Dáil today is a gambler's nirvana. Sean Fitzpatrick and the big developers of this country gambled on the Irish property market, and that was funded by the banks. The gamble dramatically inflated property values. The banks then supported these untenable prices by providing mortgages of 100% and more to young couples, whom they knew would find it impossible to make their repayments if there was a downturn in the economy. The developers and the bankers gambled, they lost and now the taxpayer is being asked to repay these losses — some €16,500 for every man, woman and child in this country. This is what we are debating today. This is the bailout for which every single individual living in this country will have to put their hand in their pocket. Some 70% of that money will go directly to bail out Anglo Irish Bank, which will not create one job or support one small business.

Legitimate questions that have been put forward in the House and elsewhere by Deputy Richard Bruton have been ignored by the Government, which cannot provide answers to them. The Government attitude is that we must spend another €36.3 billion to protect the €4 billion we have already wasted on Anglo Irish Bank. This is nothing but roulette economics. It is €36 billion that could take half the unemployed off the live register and save the €4 billion in cuts which were announced last December.

As speaker after speaker on this side of the House has said, there is €2 billion in subordinated debt that is held by hedge funds, whose job is to run high risk funds with potential high risk of gains and losses. There is no reason the Irish taxpayer should have to bankroll those hedge funds yet the Government is guaranteeing everything. This goes back to the Taoiseach's commitment in the House that whatever cheques are necessary will be written to bail out the banks. It is threatening the country with national bankruptcy, the doubling of our national debt and the jeopardising of the future of our children and their children purely on a hunch that cannot and will not be backed up by the Government.

And all for what? To protect against reputational damage, we are told, because if we do not bail out the septic bank which is Anglo Irish Bank, it will damage the reputation of this country. While it may damage the reputation of the Minister for Finance when he meets his colleagues at ECOFIN meetings, Seánie Fitzpatrick was not too worried about reputational damage when he had secret loans of up to €129 million from Anglo Irish Bank. The Government needs to decide whether it wants to protect against reputational damage or against the long-term economic damage that can be caused to this country.

Deputy Richard Bruton pointed out that today's decision will freeze credit in this country for at least another eight months. Not one red cent will come out of the banks in the next eight months as they try to protect their shareholders. If we have a basket economy with more than 500,000 people unemployed, what reputation will we have at that stage? We must use the money that is being used to bail out Anglo Irish Bank to restructure our economy, to support business, to create jobs and to make Ireland an attractive investment. Will anyone remember Anglo Irish Bank in the future? If we can get our act together and build up our economy, no one will. Our reputation has to be based on getting people back to work and getting this economy off its knees.

Comment on this

This is the fourth time we have come back to the House to discuss this crisis. First, there was the guarantee, next came the capitalisation, next was NAMA and now we have this chapter. I ask whether this is the last chapter, but I doubt it is.

The Minister and the Government give the spin that Ireland has been recognised internationally for taking corrective action. The Minister of State, Deputy Barry Andrews, and I were in America recently and that is the line being taken there. While the Opposition does not deny this is the case, those in America making that commentary are not living in Ireland, do not realise there are nearly 500,000 unemployed and that we have major difficulties across the spectrum, be it in education, health or otherwise. The spin that is given abroad is not the reality on the ground in this country.

There are no guarantees whatsoever in today's process. I know the Government has asked the banks to lend €3 billion to small business but there is no guarantee this will happen. The regulator has put pressure on the banks in regard to core tier 1 capital requirements. From where will that money come? The only possibility is that it will come from the Government because it will not come from anywhere else. The banks will be saving money, not giving it out — that will be the pressure on them, and it will not change. Small businesses will close every day. It is only since January that this pressure has really come on. I know of viable businesses that were depending on overdrafts but these have been withdrawn and they are simply closing their front doors. There is nothing in today's statement that convinces me there will be any change after today.

While I note ISME has welcomed the proposals by the Minister, it too has expressed concern that this may not mean there will be an increase in lending to small businesses throughout the country. A number of tourism enterprises are currently gearing up for the summer but they need cash flow and overdraft facilities because it is normally at the end of the year they come into profit. If they do not get these guarantees from the banks, they will not be able to start up business.

Following today's announcement, the taxpayer is facing a bill of €40 billion and counting, mainly for bailing out Anglo Irish Bank. It is difficult to explain to people how those who were involved in Anglo Irish Bank can have property all over the world and enjoy their summer in the Mediterranean, South Africa and elsewhere when the people here must suffer in paying that debt. The people are not fools. They know how they are being penalised and public servants know they have had their salaries reduced. Much of the public service dispute was an expression of anger at what has happened, as much as anything else. People cannot understand why 70% of the taxpayers' money which is being allocated to recapitalise the banks is going to one bank which is a dead end, will not lend money to anybody and will do nothing for this economy. It is difficult to explain how this is so and why the Government must prop up Anglo Irish Bank.

As Deputy Richard Bruton said earlier, the Government is throwing good money after bad with Anglo Irish Bank. Fine Gael's policy to wind up Anglo in an orderly fashion and allow the creditors to recover whatever value they can is now becoming more and more relevant. The Government's argument against such a course of action is based on trying to scare people into believing that any option but its own is too costly, which simply is not true. The Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, should publish the evidence on which he is basing his decision regarding Anglo so the public and relevant experts can make an informed judgment on the Government's strategy.

This is what we have been asking for but information from the Government is not forthcoming. It is frightening when one considers that, through this action, we are doubling the national debt to €115 billion. How will we and the next generation cope with this into the future? Today will go down as a watershed in the economic history of this country. This decision will be there to fester and to affect our economy, taxpayers and services for the future and will reflect very poorly on this Government.

Comment on this
Noel O'Flynn Deputy Noel O’Flynn Fianna Fáil

I wish to share time with Deputy Edward O'Keeffe.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Noel O'Flynn Deputy Noel O’Flynn Fianna Fáil

I speak tonight as one of the thousands of small and medium-size enterprises who need a voice in this Chamber. I also speak for the people who have mortgages and personal loans but who, because of this downturn in the economy and because they may have lost their jobs, need our help in dealing with the financial institutions. I speak tonight not only as a Deputy but as a businessman with a small business who started business on 1 April 1985, 25 years ago. The date is April fool's day and people said I was mad to begin on that date but I was not mad because it worked out well. It was in the middle of a recession and over the years my business has managed to do as well as possible.

We are still in business but the past two years have been difficult for any business in the SME sector. The motor industry business is down between 30% and 60% in many places with many closures and loss of jobs. Small and medium-sized enterprises need finance and working capital. We need confidence in business to trade, to purchase, to support credit and to trade in a safe environment. The difference in 1985 was that the banks were not broke and had money to lend but there was a world-wide recession. This confidence has not been evident in the country in the past two years, due to the lack of capital from the financial and banking systems.

I welcome the Government's decision today that AIB and Bank of Ireland will make €3 billion each available to the SME sector to kick-start economic activity. This will be monitored by an independent body with an appeals process to allow those unable to obtain finance to appeal that decision. No one is asking the banks to fund or lend to businesses which are not sustainable or profitable but we ask for fair play. Banks lend money, it is their business, their trade. They make money from this activity. Businesses make goods and supply goods and services, that is their business. They make money to reinvest and that is the nature of their business. The banks were recklessly lending money. Now they need our help but they have not been lending money. They are reducing overdrafts for business and personal accounts and putting pressure on people to pay their outstanding balances, driving some people to depression and even worse. They are putting sound, profitable businesses at risk by starving them of working capital. These businesses did not contribute to the banking crisis and to breaking the banks.

Those in the banks who loaned recklessly for land and buildings must now be removed from our banking systems. The Minister has started the job and he should finish it. Loans, charges and account costs must not be prohibitive by means of indirect charges and increases. Stealth charges have been introduced and charges imposed on direct debits. I could go on all night about this issue. If we do not monitor and challenge the banks and ensure the capital they are receiving and the bonds they will cash for the loans going to NAMA are used for productive lending to the business and personal borrowers, they will go back to their old ways of banking. They must be forced to concentrate on lending to get this economy back on its feet.

The bank guarantee is worth €1 billion to the Exchequer this year. The taxpayer must know that this money will be available this year. We must ensure that when AIB and Bank of Ireland shares are sold in years to come, the State will make a profit. Unfortunately, I agree with the Opposition. The fate of Anglo Irish Bank, EBS and Irish Nationwide, will cost the State money. The alternative is liquidation which would cost the State more. The investigations in the banking sector must be concluded and the Oireachtas investigation must start. Those responsible for wrong-doing must be brought to justice and punished.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I am pleased to speak in this important debate. I speak as a Deputy for Cork East and I speak on behalf of my party which has been to the forefront in Irish politics. I cannot understand people who attack the banks. This is one of the great world recessions but it will not be fixed by bashing the banks and criticising them. The SMEs are getting money from the banks. The economy has shrunk by 20% and SMEs are distressed but there is only a 2% shortage in credit, according to the business newspapers I read every day. There is no point in putting pressure and stress on our Irish banks to fund SMEs when the foreign banks who came here and caused aggressive lending which led to the current problem, will not be asked to do the same. There will be cherry-picking of the best SMEs by the foreign banks and the Irish banks will try to manage and look after distressed SMEs.

I wish to address the issue of Anglo Irish Bank. I am a farming businessman. I would not hold Anglo Irish Bank in my portfolio but I would have it liquidated tomorrow morning and sold off. It is going to be a sore and a boil on the Irish Government and the financial system of this country so long as it is left in existence. It has been a disgrace to Irish banking, to the Government and to the Fianna Fáil Party. Along with other colleagues, I was one of the first to say that this bank would cause great trouble in the days and years ahead. I also said that the construction industry would bring tears to the people and the families involved and how right I was. My then Taoiseach, Deputy Bertie Ahern, said that people saying those things should commit suicide. I did not commit suicide and I probably never will but it was an outrageous statement when our whole economy was falling apart.

I want an answer to a question. Mr. Matthew Elderfield has been appointed as head of financial supervision. Mr. Elderfield worked in the financial services in the United Kingdom. In 2006 he went to Bermuda which was a British colony at one time. He has been in Ireland since last November. What was he doing in London when Northern Rock was on the eve of going bust? He is adopting a Draconian approach to the banking system.

Bank of Ireland and Allied Irish Banks have stood the test of time in this country and have served us well and honourably. They are in distress and difficulty now. Bank of Ireland seemed to have been given a bit more support from the Government and from Mr. Elderfield than has AIB. AIB has been more successful in serving our community on this island for many decades and will continue to do so. It has a number of assets abroad which are worth a lot. Fair play to the bank because it had the foresight to invest. It has banks in America, Poland and London. These are all worth €5 billion or €6 billion. Why make them sell in the next 30 days if there is going to be buoyancy——

Comment on this

What is the Deputy talking about? We had to bail them out.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Deputy Ring does not know the first thing about banking and he can shut up. He should shut up, coming from——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please, Deputy O'Keeffe.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I am being interrupted by an ignoramus from the west of Ireland.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We are endeavouring to get some control back to the House.

Comment on this

I could not listen to that nonsense.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Why should AIB be told to sell its assets in the next 30 days? It should be given space to sell its assets and they will get more on the market. If the world economy is on the up — which it is — the bank will make substantial money on those assets. AIB may then become the free bank in our society and may not be dependent on the State and Mr. Elderfield telling us what to do. We do not want foreigners in here. Michael Collins, Liam Lynch, Patrick Pearse, James Connolly, would not have those foreigners running our business. It is about time we looked after our Irish people who are well educated.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy's five minutes have expired.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I am sorry I was interrupted by that man from Mayo, who knows nothing about banking but a bit about leaving cakes in a van.

Comment on this

I know more about banking than Deputy Edward O'Keeffe. All he cares about are his bloody shares. He says one thing on RTE and another in here.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Ring, please.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Go home and bake some buns.

Comment on this

I wish to share my time with Deputies Ring and Durkan.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is that agreed? Agreed.

Comment on this
Ned O'Keeffe Deputy Edward O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I want my questions answered.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy O'Keeffe, please.

Comment on this

Today is a dramatic and traumatic day for the Irish people and especially the taxpayers. Quinn Group, which is much admired in my constituency, has been put into administration by the regulator and at the same time Anglo Irish Bank has been given a handout of €8.3 billion with a promise that it will get a further €10 billion when necessary. The Anglo Irish Bank loans being transferred to NAMA will be discounted by at least 50% and the transfers from the Irish Nationwide Building Society loans will on average be discounted by 58%.

It is unforgivable that the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance have asked the taxpayer to bail out these two institutions after their management caused havoc in this country through their irrational and unbelievable lending structures. While other banks were also careless it is clear that Anglo Irish Bank and the Irish Nationwide Building Society will cripple the Irish taxpayer for the next several decades.

Unfortunately, the Minister has put off a final decision on AIB and Bank of Ireland. This means there is no guarantee for businesses on when normal banking structures will once again be in place. Clearly these banks will use the time provided to them to strengthen their own structures rather than provide normal lending to viable projects.

I was disappointed that the Presbyterian Mutual Society was not even mentioned. This is an all-Ireland institution which was forced into administration when Governments North and South provided guarantees to other banks. The issue was discussed at the time of the Hillsborough Agreement and although the €100 million required for it, including a 2% involvement by the Irish Government, is chicken feed compared to Anglo Irish Bank or the other institutions, it would have been enormously important to the investors concerned. I urge that recognition be given to the issue even at this late stage.

The fact that Quinn Group has been put into administration has caused shockwaves across the Cavan-Monaghan region and further afield. Seán Quinn created thousands of jobs in an area the Government and the IDA ignored. Without him, I do not know what would have happened to the region. Regulation is important but we must not over regulate. I hope for everybody's sake that Seán Quinn and his companies can weather this storm and that the job they have done for the Irish people will be recognised.

Comment on this

My blood boiled when I heard a previous speaker congratulate the banks on the wonderful job they have done. The legislation we should be debating this evening would allow us to detain these fellows in the Curragh Camp for what they have done to this country. This is not the first time we have had to save banks. The taxpayer had to pick up the tab when our banks invested in America and elsewhere and bail out the messers in PMPA, most of whom were associated with Fianna Fáil.

The people of this country do not understand what €40 billion means. People who are sitting at home unemployed are paying for Seanie FitzPatrick and the other guys in Anglo Irish Bank. They were every bit as bad in AIB. Tonight, however, a Deputy claimed we have a wonderful banking system. They destroyed the economy and the country and have put us back 100 years. I do not hear any outrage from the Taoiseach or the Green Party at the destruction of our economy or at bailing them out again even though we cannot afford to do so.

I am sick and tired of the rich being protected by Fianna Fáil and, now, the Green Party. If Green Party Deputies had any backbone, they would say "No, we will not vote on this. We will give the people of the country an opportunity to decide." If the people decide to give money to AIB, Bank of Ireland and Anglo Irish Bank, fine, but they will not want to do so. Small businessmen all over the country are coming into our clinics because they cannot get credit. These are the people who will create jobs.

Deputy Edward O'Keeffe wants to know what we are doing for the bankers. I want to know when we are going to see some of them put behind bars, where they belong, for destroying the country and the economy. They are friends of Fianna Fáil and that is how we have paid for the Galway tent. Most of the people of this country will finish up living in tents because of Fianna Fáil. The sooner we get that party out, the bloody better for the sake of living in an honest and decent country.

Comment on this

In his opening statement, the Minister stated:

The country has come a long way since we introduced the State bank guarantee 18 months ago . . . Back then, our banks were on the brink of financial collapse and our economy had gone into reverse. Revenue had fallen steeply and unemployment had risen sharply. For the first time in a quarter of a century, we were experiencing negative growth.

I know he has a sense of humour and I think he grinned to himself when he penned those lines. Everybody in this House is aware that we are contemplating a truly appalling vista.

As Deputy Ring pointed out, the uncontrolled operation of the banking and property systems has burdened the public, including those with new or old mortgages and business owners who cannot get sufficient credit, with the bill. The people behind these problems claimed to know better than anyone else and that they were worth every penny they cost us. They were wrong about everything. The economy has not been run well since 2002 because, as anybody could have attested, the fundamentals were wrong.

We have encouraged competition in the banking sector. Anybody who moves a deposit from one bank to another can increase significantly the interest earned, whereas he or she would earn nothing by leaving the money in one place. In theory, it would be better for people to move their deposits to a different institution but given the instability of the banks over the past couple of years, they are understandably slow to do so.

Reference is regularly made to people who borrowed unwisely to purchase houses. However, they were told that they had to get onto the bottom rung of the property ladder. Many sincere people who are now caught by negative equity have to pay for the banks' codology on the property market.

Deputy Edward O'Keeffe claimed the world economy is on the up but the problems that affect our economy are deeper than anywhere else in the world because nothing was done to address the issues on time. Let us remember that those paying for it are the citizens of Ireland. The citizens, who are already shouldering their own burden of debt incurred as a result of banking and economic policy, must now carry the burden for the banking system as well, which is a sad day for this Republic.

Comment on this
Dr Martin Mansergh Minister of State at the Department of Finance (Deputy Martin Mansergh) Fianna Fáil

I refer to the statement made by Deputy Ring and I wonder whether his decibel levels sometimes breach health and safety standards, especially for those sitting next to him. I am long enough in the building to remember the support the Fine Gael and Labour Party Government had to give AIB in 1985 in respect of the ICI operation. That was supported by the then Opposition.

I welcome the setting out by the Minister for Finance of a comprehensive statement of strategy and decisions in regard to the opening phase of NAMA operations and the recapitalisation of the banks. While it is often a natural, human, not to say political instinct to put off facing up to difficult problems, the Minister and the Government have taken the bull by the horns and set out the full extent of the problem, however unpalatable — it is extremely so — and how it must be tackled. Concealing problems is not the road to recovery either for banks or this society.

NAMA has continued to be hotly debated ever since the legislation was passed. It has been claimed or otherwise implied that what the Government is doing now will put future generations in hock. However, it is the irresponsibility of property developers and lending institutions that has done this. The Government and other authorities have been criticised for not having done enough to stop the madness and sometimes for adding to it. From time to time, we all had political or partial insights into the dangers but none of us consistently so. Prominent Labour Party Deputies frequently boasted that we were the second richest country in Europe, which was true on paper, but only on paper, and that the country was awash with money. Those who wished to restrain over-lending or development were cast aside.

We have many lessons to learn about the recent past, not least about not putting all our eggs in one or two baskets, the need to opt for a more cautious or sustainable approach to development, which will inevitably mean less exciting policies in some cases, and learning to say "No" to schemes that appear to promise large jobs and profits. Problems were greatly exacerbated by the international crisis in banking confidence. Deputy Burton was correct to state the problem built up slowly but then crystalised with the collapse of the Lehman Brothers. It is risk-free to make suggestions with regard to alternative acts or courses of action that should have been taken, whether such suggestions come from the Opposition or the media. However, the Government of the day alone carries responsibility for the consequences of its decisions in an emergency. Perhaps this is why the changes made last week were cautious. Only the Government has any recent experience of the pressures of crisis management, although there are still some on benches opposite who have experience of the crisis of the 1980s.

Repeated allegations are made about the proximity of the main Government party to bankers and developers. Perhaps someone would like to explain what in today's statement or in NAMA's decisions represents favours to either group.

Creating confidence at home and abroad is vital to our recovery. Today's statement represents strong Government decisions, not those of a Government short of either strategy or ideas. The decisions create a greater degree of certainty. They free up the banks' ability to lend, which will be as important in the time of recovery as it is in today's depressed circumstances.

Like others, I welcome the direction to the two main banks to lend €3 billion as part of a seed capital fund and for environmental, clean energy and other projects. The credit review or appeals process to address firms denied necessary credit is very valuable. The Minister has explained why Anglo Irish Bank was systemic and why it would not be a good option to close it down either in the shorter or longer term because that would greatly increase the liabilities faced by the taxpayer. The Government is pragmatic about the ownership of banks. It is not an ideological principle.

Deputy Crawford called on me to meet the Irish Presbyterian Mutual Society and I have done so. However, 98% of its assets and holdings are in the UK and it is the responsibility of that country. In this matter there is a dimension of defending the economic independence and viability of the State, whether in budgetary or banking decisions. I welcome the realistic draft agreement reached last night.

Comment on this

I am pleased but somewhat saddened to speak on this issue. It is a disgraceful situation in which we find ourselves. My message to the bankers and the small cabal of developers who caused this problem is, to misquote Shakespeare and a former Taoiseach, that they have done the State some mis-service and we know it. Unfortunately, the taxpayer knows it and the taxpayer must get on with things.

Comment on this

We will let that go.

Comment on this

The taxpayer must get the best possible deal for this country from now on. I refer to the chart of bond spreads. The actions taken by the Government since this time last year have saved approximately €1.5 billion in interest payments. This is equivalent to another pay cut for the entire public service saved by this Government having the most effective policies to reduce the interest rate we pay on the national debt, which is at a serious level.

Comment on this

That is fantastic.

Comment on this

We have been above Greece in terms of the fees on our interest for some time because of the actions the Government has taken, unpalatable though they have been. It is disgraceful that we are in this situation. These actions have stabilised the situation and have saved the country significant sums of money.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What about the €4 billion?

Comment on this

We must continue to do this. No one likes what we must do with Anglo Irish Bank.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

Tell us about Anglo Irish Bank.

Comment on this

I am disgusted and angry that we must do it but there is no point sitting on the sidelines and making up arguments for the sake of it. Why does the Opposition not come with us and agree that we are right and that they would do the same if they were in Government?

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

We do not agree with the Deputy.

Comment on this

This morning on the radio the Fine Gael finance spokesman stated the bank has brought the country to its knees, an indication of how systemically important this disastrous bank was. It was systemically important.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

I was never of systemic importance.

Comment on this

Why did the Fine Gael spokesman say it brought the country to its knees? If one wished to describe systemic importance in plain man's language that was a very good example and the Deputy's finance spokesman did a good job of it. Unfortunately, we are in this situation and we must do this, but it is the least worst option. If we do what the Opposition suggested we would pay many tens of billions of euro more.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

What are we suggesting?

Comment on this

Much as I hate to be here supporting this, I believe the Government must do it and I compliment the Government for its resolution and determination to get this through.

Comment on this

I welcome the opportunity to comment briefly on the motion. The reckless management of our banks in recent years is a national scandal and a bitter pill for taxpayers and Irish citizens generally. It was difficult to hear today the level of bailout required by the Government and the State in respect of our financial institutions. The reality is that we may not like banks or senior bankers but we need them to meet the needs of the economy and if we are to have any prospect of coming out of this recession and, in line with forecasts, begin to grow the economy again later this year.

When families get into financial difficulty one of the first pieces of advice MABS gives is the need to face up to their problems, to confront their loans and to deal with the reality of their situation. The bottom line is that in recent months the Irish banks have not been facing up to the extent of the losses they face. Today, we witnessed a comprehensive package of measures which forced the banks, once and for all, to face up to the extent of losses with which they must deal. The Minister and the Financial Regulator showed clearly today who is in charge. The Financial Regulator set a very high level of capital requirement for the banks, in line with best international practice, and did the State some service by requiring the banks to impose a level of capital far beyond the level of anticipated losses and NAMA loans. He has factored in losses on non-NAMA loans, both commercial and personal.

One of the criticisms of NAMA when it was introduced was that it would somehow go soft on the banks and let them off the hook. Today, we have seen evidence that this is not the case. NAMA has imposed a high level of discount, at an average of 47% across the loan book, which, in fact, improves its capacity to at least break even and, one hopes, make some money for the taxpayer over the ten-year period.

What we saw also today is a clear commitment on behalf of the Minister and the Government to compel the banks to provide an adequate level of lending to the economy, in particular to SMEs. We will see €12 billion worth of lending to SMEs by AIB and Bank of Ireland between now and the end of 2011, and that is a particularly welcome development. The regulator and the Government must be rigorous in ensuring such level of credit is extended because the banks will endeavour not to provide the level of required lending to the economy. It will be rigorously monitored.

The success of NAMA and recapitalisation will be judged ultimately on the basis of whether the banks meet the credit needs of the economy. The measures which have been taken today are necessary and unpalatable, as the Minister stated and as they undoubtedly are. They will put the economy in a position where it is served by a banking system which, once and for all, has faced up in an honest way to the extent of its losses and to the recent reckless and irresponsible management of its banks which now must be bailed out by the taxpayer but which will meet the needs of the economy in the future. I note that both ISME and Chambers Ireland have welcomed today's package of measures as an essential step by the Government in dealing with the banking crisis.

Comment on this

I am glad to have the opportunity to speak in this debate. I trust those Members who hold bank shares and who have come out strongly against some of the banks or in favour of some of the other banks have declared their interests before speaking in this debate.

Comment on this

Do not look at us.

Comment on this

I thought Deputy Edward O'Keeffe made many interesting points and I certainly would completely agree with a number of those. I trust he will have the sincerity to follow through with voting with the Opposition tonight. It is easy to come into this Chamber and shout one's mouth off. It is another matter to have the courage of one's convictions and to vote accordingly. I look forward to seeing what he does in a half an hour's time.

Today, 30 March 2010, is a day that will be etched on the minds of every citizen of this country because it is the day on which Fianna Fáil and the Green Party saddled each taxpayer with a massive debt in order that rogue developers, rogue builders and rogue bankers can be bailed out. Today, we are all paying the price for bad Government policies and for a situation where weak and often compromised Fianna Fáil Ministers remained in power for far too long.

This is the legacy of that trio, Deputy Bertie Ahern, former Deputy, Charlie McCreevy, and, to a large extent, Deputy Cowen, all of whom were Ministers who were happy to facilitate the golden circle in enriching themselves at the expense of ordinary people. Rather than having housing policies that viewed decent housing as an essential social good and, therefore, something that needed to be regulated by Government, these Ministers were happy to allow their developer and builder friends to control the market to maintain land at grossly inflated prices, leading to a frenzy in house buying. Prices soared, ever more people were forced and, indeed, encouraged to get in over their heads, and ever more foreign workers were drafted in to keep the building boom going. This inflated demand and, finally and inevitably, the pyramid collapsed. All of this madness was stoked by the financial institutions which threw out the rule book on lending. As the Minister, Deputy Brian Lenihan, stated earlier today, the banks played fast and loose with the economy. They were allowed to do so by the weak and compromised Fianna Fáil Ministers, Ahern, McCreevy and Cowen, the three disciples of light-touch regulation who presided over the destruction of the economy.

It is important that people know who is responsible for the financial disaster in which we find ourselves today. There were significant international factors but there is no doubt the recession is far deeper and will be much longer lasting in Ireland than almost anywhere else in the world, and that is as a result of Fianna Fáil's mismanagement of the economy.

It is also important that people realise that had they voted differently in 2007, we would not be in this devastating position today. Not only did Fianna Fáil facilitate the conditions that led to the property bubble's creation and its subsequent destruction, when the collapse happened, they failed utterly to deal with it properly. Rather than taking action when serious problems began to emerge, the Government exacerbated the difficulties. As Deputy Edward O'Keeffe stated, we all remember Deputy Bertie Ahern's message to those who urged caution. Shamefully and pathetically, Deputy Ahern advised them to commit suicide. I do not know how Deputy Ahern has the neck to be in this House today. He has a great deal to answer for.

While problems were mounting in the banks, it was not until that other faithful date, 29 September 2008, that the Government took action. It took that action, it would seem, solely on the basis of advice from those bankers and those so-called public servants who themselves had contributed so much to the perilous state of the banks and our economy. It seemed, for ideological reasons, the Government was not prepared to countenance nationalisation and, instead, provided a blanket guarantee. Today's appalling vista can be traced back directly to that decision.

Having given this extraordinary blanket guarantee, the Government was in a position to dictate absolute terms to the banks but, yet again, it showed its complete weakness. There should have been a complete clear-out of senior executives and the entire boards in all of the covered institutions. There would have been no difficulty in doing this in light of the scope of the guarantee. Instead of that, however, the Ministers continued to kowtow to these people. The continuing bloated salaries, with increases as recently as last week, are an affront to decent people. Nobody has been sacked, nobody has been penalised and I doubt very much if anyone will end up behind bars. What else would one expect Fianna Fáil to do but to protect its golden circle friends?

Equally, the Government has failed miserably to do what it promised it would on getting credit flowing to small business. This, after all, was one of the main arguments it used for the guarantee. How many tens of thousands of jobs have been lost since then owing to SMEs being squeezed dry by the banks while all the time Ministers stood idly by? It is quite clear a separate national investment bank is needed and far too much precious time has been lost by the Government. Those who have lost their jobs in the meantime have paid a heavy price for that delay. It is hardly surprising, given the Government's central role, that it has refused to investigate adequately the circumstances leading up to the banking crisis. The paying public must await a change in Government to discover what actually happened over recent years.

The details of the proposals as unveiled today show an unprecedented crisis of far greater scale than had been indicated by Government or, indeed, than had been expected.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Shortall's time is rapidly running out.

Comment on this

I will take my last minute, if that is all right with the Ceann Comhairle.

Comment on this

It is not. Her time started at two minutes past half-past nine. She had ten minutes and, therefore, she has three more minutes left.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I do not think she has three.

Comment on this

I have at least two.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I will allow the Deputy to conclude.

Comment on this

She has three more minutes left.

Comment on this

I have at least two. It is not running out, though. As I stated, the details of the proposals are far greater in scale than had been indicated by Government. The harsh unpalatable reality for the taxpayers, their children and grandchildren is that they have been lumbered with a huge debt for the foreseeable future as a direct result of the failure of Government policy. The Government's incompetence in handling the banks means the crisis is much deeper than it needs to be.

At no stage has the Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, taken charge. Given that he had provided a State bank guarantee scheme with such a wide scope, he was in a position to deal with the bondholders. There was a need to share the risk with the subordinated tier-two bondholders. He could have easily indicated he was considering nationalisation or letting Anglo Irish Bank go altogether. In that context, he was in a strong position to negotiate with the tier-two bondholders. The Government should have also negotiated with the tier-one bondholders; the ones who took the highest risks must realise there is a price to be paid. If the Minister had dealt with the crisis adequately, he could have told them he would not have bailed them out and sought a sharing of risk.

We are told there is a guarantee of a 4% return on the promissory notes for Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide. There is absolutely no guarantee of such a return, like we saw with last year's recapitalisation.

The Minister for Finance denied cuts in public sector pay are funding a bailout for the banks. This is simply untrue as for the next 15 years the State will face an annual bill for €1 billion to bail out Anglo Irish Bank and Irish Nationwide.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Shortall, we are into borrowed time now.

Comment on this

The Fianna Fáil Party completely buckled to the pressure from its developer and banker friends. Meanwhile, the Greens remain silent preferring to do nothing while Fianna Fáil commits one of the gravest policy mistakes in Irish economic history. What is the point in a party having five Members as Ministers when they make no difference whatsoever to the most crucial decision facing the country?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Shortall has seriously exceeded her time and should finish in fairness to other Members who wish to speak.

Comment on this

The electorate will have an opportunity, sooner rather than later I hope, to pass judgment on this.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Deputy Batt O’Keeffe) Fianna Fáil

The Government's actions today are the culmination of painstaking analysis and detailed consideration of the measures necessary to restore our banks to fit-for-purpose institutions that can support economic development and the growth of enterprise.

Our actions today are necessary for the longer term economic stability of our nation which has been recklessly undermined by irresponsible property lending practices and corporate sector greed. I commend the efforts and hard work of my colleague, the Minister for Finance, and his officials, in bringing these banking solutions before the House.

The parallel announcements earlier today by the National Asset Management Agency, NAMA, and the Financial Regulator set the full context in which the Government is making extra resources available to some banks. No Irish person wants to carry the burden placed upon us by reckless bankers. However, without a functioning banking system, our full economic recovery would not be possible. We need adequately resourced and financially sound banks to support the financial needs of businesses and householders.

Similar to the earlier recapitalisation scheme, the Government has again included in this recapitalisation plan explicit provisions targeted directly at supporting our enterprise sector, especially small to medium-sized enterprises.

Under the terms of today's recapitalisation plan, Bank of Ireland and AIB will be required to make available more than €3 billion in lending to new small and medium-sized enterprises, SME, to include working capital this year and next year. This figure will be reviewed as the needs of the economy change. The two banks must each produce a plan that includes a sectorial and geographic breakdown of how they intend to divide up this new lending.

As part of his remit, the credit reviewer, Mr. John Trethowan, will assess these plans following which the Government will decide whether further action on sectorial targets is required.

The two banks will also need to make available €20 million each for seed capital to be provided to Enterprise Ireland-supported ventures and to make up to €100 million each available for environmental, clean energy and innovation funds. That is in addition to the €100 million each made available in accordance with the previous recapitalisation scheme.

The two banks will be required to commit resources to work with Enterprise Ireland and the Irish Banking Federation to develop sectorial expertise in the modern growth sectors of the economy, how best to develop the range of banking services that Irish SMEs trading internationally will need to develop and bring forward new credit products in areas where expected cash flow, rather than property or assets, will be the basis for business lending.

I welcome the formal appointment of Mr. Trethowan as credit reviewer to provide for an independent review of decisions by participating institutions to refuse or withhold credit to SMEs, farm enterprises and sole traders. This facility should afford individual businesses an opportunity for third-party review of bank refusals to grant credit. Participating institutions are required to comply with the recommendation of the reviewer or explain why this would not be appropriate. Statistical outcomes for each bank will be made public.

These measures and more reinforce the Government's commitment to supporting businesses, especially SMEs, a key priority for me as Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment. Last year and this, my Department has made approximately €1 billion available in the capital budgets of the enterprise development agencies to fund financial supports to enterprises, including SMEs.

Enterprise development agencies such as Enterprise Ireland, IDA and the county and city enterprise boards have continued to help businesses through their grant and advisory schemes.

Last year, the enterprise stabilisation fund was introduced which aims to support viable but vulnerable companies in financial difficulty as a result of these unprecedented economic times.

Companies receive funding to support a range of activities, including market development, productivity improvements and development. Last year, €58 million was spent on 181 projects supporting approximately 7,500 jobs. The fund continues to attract a high volume of applications this year.

The employment subsidy scheme was launched last August to keep in jobs workers who might otherwise have been made redundant. Other initiatives included developing intellectual property assets; mandating comprehensive strategy reviews in IDA Ireland, Enterprise Ireland and Shannon Development; establishing a code of conduct for business lending to SMEs; and setting up a credit supply clearing group.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister should begin to wrap up as we need to conclude by 10 o'clock.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

I was supposed to have ten minutes in my slot.

Comment on this

I will give way for a minute or two.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Work is ongoing on a targeted loan guarantee scheme and we have secured a commitment by central government to pay its debts to businesses in 15 rather than 30 days.

Comment on this

That was introduced two years ago.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

We have secured the introduction of a pay-related social insurance exemption for employers creating new jobs this year.

Fine Gael wants a national recovery bank which would have no way of generating funds because the good loans it is supposed to buy from the banks are already being used as collateral for funding from the European Central Bank and international markets.

Comment on this
Kieran O'Donnell Deputy Kieran O’Donnell Fine Gael

It is about new loans.

Comment on this

Please start again. The Minister should go back and read his brief.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

No country in the world has established a bank such as that proposed by Fine Gael because it would be folly, even for Deputy Enda Kenny, to set up a bank that cannot fund itself.

Comment on this

No country did what Ireland did. Fianna Fáil supported it.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

The question Deputies opposite must answer is how they propose to get credit flowing to businesses and householders. We all know that banks have curtailed lending, mainly because banks are finding it hard to access funds.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Keeffe should return to his former position as Minister for Education and Science. He might learn something.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Our banks should be extremely grateful for the resolve of the Irish people to intervene to save the economy and ensure a return to growth.

Comment on this

The Government would not listen to Deputy Richard Bruton in 2005, nor would it listen to him today.

Comment on this
Batt O'Keeffe Deputy Batt O’Keeffe Fianna Fáil

Their forbearance and the courageous actions of this Government is putting this country on the road to recovery. When this period of Irish history comes to be written, it will be recorded in favour of those courageous enough to do the right thing in the national interest.

Comment on this

All of our kids will be outside the country. They will be in the US and Australia.

Comment on this

I genuinely hope this works out. There are some flaws in it. Anglo Irish Bank should not have been protected. I refer to bond holders. Those who buy shares may win and pay their taxes but if they lose they take the loss. They should not be protected.

The banks under the banking guarantee should be protected. We should pay tribute to them. Unfortunately, there are many outside banks here, such as National Irish Bank, Ulster Bank and other UK banks. They are going after Irish deposit holders. We must wear the green jersey. We must put our money into the banks under the Government guarantee scheme because that money is going back to the economy. I ask the Minister to raise this matter. He should let unions and schools put their money into the banks under the Irish guarantee scheme.

Comment on this
Brian Lenihan Minister for Finance Fianna Fáil

I commend the new Governor of the Central Bank, Professor Patrick Honohan and the new Financial Regulator, Matthew Elderfield on their work in this process. They are independent of the Government in the exercise of their functions and that is as it should be. When Deputy Bruton criticised the Government for giving the banks too much time for capitalisation, he missed the crucial point. The requirements on capitalisation are now laid down by the regulator. As a result of the decision made by the regulator today, Allied Irish Banks have until the end of April to draw a definitive capital plan. The time available is quite limited. I commend the NAMA management team who have proven the critics wrong by operating in a hard-headed and commercial manner in the best interests of the taxpayer.

Comment on this

The EU made NAMA do that.

Comment on this

I thank my officials as well.

Comment on this

The Minister should thank the Commission.

Comment on this

They operated under a statutory mandate laid down by this House. I thank the Members for the work they put into that legislation. These agencies worked with my Department and the NTMA to resolve our banking crisis. We now know the problems we have, we have faced up to them and we have put in place a pathway out of them. Today provides for once and for all a solid basis for confidence in the future of our financial system.

The Government is recapitalising the financial institutions so that the system as a whole may return to its rightful role as provider of credit to the real economy. Inevitably, there is an upfront investment by the State because we have forced the banks to recognise their losses upfront and to rid the system of the scourge of these speculative loans and the mismanagement of the banking system.

Deputy Bruton questioned why, as an alternative to recapitalisation, the Government does not just let Anglo Irish Bank fail. Many other Deputies questioned the systemic importance of Anglo Irish Bank and why it was guaranteed at all. Anglo Irish Bank was much larger relative to the Irish economy than Lehman Brothers was relative to the US economy. The disorderly failure of Lehman Brothers brought the global financial system to its knees. The disorderly failure of Anglo Irish Bank two weeks later would have had the same effect on the entire Irish banking system. I understand Deputy Bruton referred to Washington Mutual. The resolution mechanism in that bank cannot be applied to a bank in this country because the bank's senior bonds were issued not by the bank itself but by a separate holding company. That corporate structure allowed the US authorities to treat senior bondholders and depositors differently.

Deputies raised points concerning the treatment of bondholders. When talking about this jurisdiction, it is important to bear in mind that those who provide funds to Irish banks are not exclusively from other countries.

Comment on this

What about Quinn?

Comment on this

Approximately half of the funds advanced to the Irish banks to support the Irish economy are derived from domestic sources. When people talk about defaulting on bondholders, they are talking about defaulting on themselves, Irish credit unions, Irish enterprises and Irish pension funds.

Comment on this

Has the Minister tried negotiating?

Comment on this

If Deputy Shortall wants to negotiate with her local credit union about a reduction in the amount of deposits and wishes to advise her constituents in Dublin North West of her banking policy, I encourage her to do so immediately. She should see what their reaction will be. This is a fundamental issue for the country. If there is any suggestion the Government would lose the vote tonight and there would be a change of Government in a few days time, it would be extremely serious for this country in light of some of the comments made about bondholders in this country and in current opinion polls. Happily, that will not happen tonight and I hope that by the next election we will realise the realities of this issue.

Deputy Bruton noted that Anglo Irish Bank retains approximately €2 billion in subordinated debt. The vast bulk of these bonds are dated bonds, meaning they are covered by the guarantee scheme until September 2010. The treatment of that remaining subordinated debt in the future will be considered as part of the process for agreeing a restructuring plan for Anglo Irish Bank with the EU Commission over the coming months. In assessing the options to deal with bondholders it is important to note the lending base of the Irish economy. It is 50% funded from international sources and 50% funded from domestic sources. Interestingly, Irish sovereign borrowing is 80% funded from international sources. The Labour Party has not advocated this policy but the suggestion made by Deputy Bruton is that there would be no read through from a default on bank debt to a default on sovereign debt; it is erroneous when 80% of our funding derives from foreign sources. The maintenance of international confidence in the Irish financial system is of critical importance to our economy. Despite the many figures bandied about this afternoon our bond spreads have not moved an inch. This is signal testimony to the international confidence in the common sense of the announcement made today and the capacity we demonstrate to tackle our problems.

Deputy Burton suggested that if we nationalised Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland, it would have eliminated the valuation risk around NAMA, and as a result there would have been no need for the concept of long-term economic value. She suggested the approach the Government followed is more costly. I stress that if we had done this the losses crystallised at Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland would still have to be fully recognised and real capital would been required. It is appropriate that we have an asset management agency going through the banks on a bottom-up basis and establishing where were the vulnerabilites in each institution and the degree of culpability for excessive lending in each institution.

Deputies Bruton and Burton questioned when we would see a revised NAMA business plan and NAMA codes of practice. There are substantial provisions in the Act dealing with transparent reporting by NAMA. The board proposes to review the draft business plan published in October 2009 and will publish a revised business plan by 30 June 2010. NAMA has met its obligation to submit such codes of practice and my Department is working with NAMA to ensure these codes fully meet the standard expected.

Deputies have queried the uplift factor on the assets transferred to NAMA today. The uplift factor reflects the difference between the current market value of the asset and what NAMA believes it can achieve for the asset over time, or the long-term economic value. NAMA reports this was 11.3% in the first tranche. Previous estimates had been that this figure would be approximately 15%, which was based on aggregate data provided by the institutions. There are a number of reasons the initial estimate was reduced massively in subsequent discounts. One was the overoptimistic assumptions by the institutions about the loan to value ratios. A further factor was the bottom-up valuation process and another factor was the securitisation and a degree of securitisation for particular loans. The revised uplift is the result of individual loan valuations following extensive due diligence and individual property valuations.

There has been little comment in the debate on the most important steps I have taken to secure further provision of credit to the business community. The specific lending targets are backed up by legal sanctions. If further legal sanctions are required, they will be insisted upon. I acknowledge the work of all parties on this subject in the course of the debate on NAMA. This represents a considerable increase on lending last year and in particular must include funds for working capital for businesses. The two banks will be required to submit SME lending plans both by geography and sector for each year. Mr. John Trethowan as the new credit reviewer will review bank lending policies as part of his remit.

I again emphasise that there is now a renewed international confidence in Ireland because of our determined moves to place our public finances on a more sustainable footing. Today's actions will place the banking system on a robust footing too. My colleague, the Minister for Foreign Affairs, Deputy Martin, today described to the House the positive international reaction to our fiscal and banking correction matters. Contrary to what the Opposition allege there is no doubt that relative to other countries we have moved speedily to deal with our banking problems. The banks have been forced to recognise their losses and the Government has committed the capital that will ensure we have a banking system to serve our economy as it recovers.

We have many other steps to take. We must work on public sector reform. In this context, I welcome the decision of the public service unions to conclude a public service pay agreement with Government to put those conclusions to their membership. We must continue to address our competitiveness, which has improved in the past year. We must examine every sector of the economy to identify wherein there is scope for growth and stimulus. All of these steps must be taken.

The essential precondition to economic recovery is that we have viable public finances and a viable banking system. We have taken those decisions in the heat of intense battle. The Government will ensure it takes the necessary decisions required to put this country on the road to recovery and to ensure all of the jobs we want to see created again in this economy are created so that every Irish man and woman can have a stake in this country.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

In accordance with the Order of the Dáil I am must now put the question on amendment No. 2.

Comment on this
Division

The Dáil divided: Tá,

Tá 83
·
Níl 69
Result _

Do you agree with this result?

Division

The Dáil divided: Tá,

Tá 83
·
Níl 68
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?