We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Macroeconomic and Fiscal Outlook: Statements

Contributions 1–93 of 183. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

As the people of Ireland look to this House today they do so with understandable concern. Our people are concerned about their future, about the prospects for their children, about the well-being of their neighbours and of the country as a whole. They are looking to this House with hope and with expectation. They hope the political leaders of this country have the capacity to steer us through this period of unprecedented economic challenge. As they expect, there will be a clear plan, a pathway which charts our course to economic recovery and secures confidence in our country's future. The people need to hear from the Members of this House what we are going to do to fix these problems.

As the House is aware, I invited the Leaders of the Opposition to meet with me and my colleague, Deputy Gormley, last week, to discuss the budgetary crisis. I proposed that the Opposition should have full access to briefings by the Department of Finance, so that they could appreciate fully the scale of that challenge. I believe it is important to afford other parties in the House the opportunity to formulate their proposals for putting the public finances on a sustainable footing. I am also seeking to build external confidence in the determination of Ireland to achieve fiscal and economic stability through a broadly expressed commitment on the part of Irish political leaders.

It is, therefore, particularly important and beneficial that the leaders of the main political parties in this House have expressed their commitment to the target of reducing the deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014. That commitment will underpin confidence on the part of investors and workers and the community generally. I acknowledge that commitment and the spirit in which it was reiterated at our discussions last week. It is a sure sign of the strength of our democracy, and of the widely-shared recognition in the House of where the national interest lies at this critical moment in our economic history.

We should reflect on how far we have come in our efforts to overcome this unprecedented economic crisis — a crisis that has affected all the developed economies of the world. Since 2008, we have achieved budgetary savings of €14.5 billion in full year terms, in just two years. The economy is emerging from recession, with growth returning and the prospect of stronger growth next year and thereafter. There have been significant improvements in our competitiveness as Ireland prices itself back into the markets we sell to and a remarkably strong export performance is being recorded this year over last year.

The budgetary figures for this year are broadly on target. Despite all that has happened, our debt to GDP ratio in 2014, forecast to be about 110%, will not be significantly out of line with many other developed countries. Taking account of the National Pensions Reserve Fund, and cash reserves in the NTMA, our net debt position is forecast to be about 83% of GDP, lower than many other developed countries. However, our borrowing costs have increased significantly and our public finance position still requires a major additional correction to put it on a sustainable path.

The State, therefore, continues to be faced with an enormous budgetary crisis. Against that background, the Government has decided that an overall budgetary adjustment of €15 billion over the next four years is warranted in order to achieve the target deficit of 3% of GDP by 2014. This is based on a projected average annual real GDP growth rate of 2.75% over the period 2011 to 2014. It is also based on a working assumption that the budgetary adjustment will be somewhat front-loaded in 2011 and that it will be weighted more towards reductions in spending rather than tax increases.

It is the Government's judgment that while a degree of front-loading may dampen economic growth in 2011, it will give the necessary confidence to the international markets and secure our funding position which is, of course, fundamental to sustaining public services for our citizens and achieving sustainable economic growth in future years. The key reasons for the significant increase in the required consolidation are lower growth prospects both at home and abroad and higher debt interest costs. The size of the adjustment for 2011 and the distribution over the remaining years will be announced in the four-year plan, which the Government is currently discussing and preparing for publication in mid-November. However, more work needs to be done and more up-to-date information will be assessed, before a final decision on the precise figure for 2011 is made.

The projected adjustment for each of the four years is not arrived at lightly. It is based on a rigorous assessment of the balance between what is credible to the markets and to international institutions and the inevitable impact on potential economic growth in the economy. It is severe, but it is a necessary next step to economic recovery.

No one can forecast with complete accuracy how the Irish economy will perform next year, never mind over a four-year period. There is also considerable uncertainty about the international economic outlook, which has a powerful influence on the performance of our economy. For instance, last year we ourselves predicted a contraction of minus 1.3% in our budget and if one considers what others were saying about a medium position of about minus 1.1%, it looks like we will have perhaps zero or small growth rather than that. This is just with respect to the one-year forecast. However, there is also considerable room for continued action here at home. We are not passive spectators, watching helplessly as events unfold. On the contrary, I believe the four-year plan we will publish will be a call to action for our entire economy and society. The plan is not only about bringing order to the public finances by 2014, which is vital. It is also about bringing together our growth strategy, as set out in the smart economy plan, our jobs strategy and our proposals for structural economic reform. It will demonstrate how growth in the economy and in employment will be fast-tracked by building on the key competitive strengths I mentioned earlier. If we can do that, we can reduce the scale of the €15 billion adjustment that is necessary if we are to achieve the 3% target by 2014.

I emphasise that the best way to reduce the deficit is to accelerate a major programme of structural reform in our economy, aimed at increasing employment and national income. If vested interests wish to oppose reform, all they will do is help to deepen our problems. If they proceed with such an approach, they will help to condemn our society to persistent unemployment, deteriorating public services and reduced support for the most vulnerable in our society. Our problems are so serious that no vested interest and no section of society can escape from their consequences by trying to protect narrow sectional interests. We all have a part to play. Everyone is in this together. The public service has a critical role to play in achieving the goals of the plan we are preparing.

Comment on this

Does the Taoiseach intend to circulate his script?

Comment on this

Yes. It should be here. It is on the way.

I fully acknowledge the contribution that has been already made by individual public servants across the system as a whole. There has been a significant reduction of 11,000 in the number of staff in the public service. Staff have seen significant income reductions. Staff numbers will fall further over the coming years, as the cost of the public service is reduced and service delivery is radically reformed. Crucially, we have agreed with the public service unions a framework, in the form of the Croke Park agreement, which acknowledges the need for greater flexibility and faster change in underpinning jobs and living standards in the public service. The agreement is an instrument not only to enable the public service to live within its means, but to transform it to meet the needs of our citizens in the future.

The Government is looking not only for a slimmed down and less costly public service, but for a total transformation. We need a transformation in what the public service achieves for our citizens. We need a transformation in the targets that are set and outcomes that are achieved for our people across every stage of the life cycle. I refer to children, people of working age, people with disabilities and older people. We need a transformation in how such targets and outcomes are delivered so the overall cost of the public service is sustainable for the economy. We will need extraordinary leadership, creativity and flexibility from management and staff if the commitment to avoid further pay reductions and compulsory redundancies is to be honoured. The Government has no desire to back away from the commitment into which it has entered. However, it can meet that commitment only on the basis of full and comprehensive delivery by all of the parties.

We need to give our people hope. It is important that the country is taking credible, thoughtful and resolute action. This debate can and should be about finding the right solutions to our problems. We need to implement solutions that are right for our country at this time. My absolute and firm conviction is that the challenges we face can be met and overcome. They will be overcome through the resilience and capacities of our people, through the inherent strengths of our economy, through the intrinsic values of our society, through a commitment to courageous, innovative and responsible policies, and through the formulation and energetic implementation of a plan which demonstrates to our people and to the world how we will survive our present difficulties. The scale of the challenge is clear. It is reflected in the significant drop in economic activity and the output of the economy in recent years. That is why we must continue to plan for growth. It is reflected in the increase in unemployment and the reduced prospects for young people who are leaving our schools and colleges.

Comment on this

They are leaving our shores.

Comment on this

That is why policies and actions to create and sustain jobs are of paramount importance. It is reflected in the loss of national competitiveness in recent years. That is why we will introduce proposals for further reducing costs and improving competitiveness across the economy. It is reflected in the extent of the repairs that are required to our badly damaged financial institutions. That is why we must conclude the process of banking reform and recapitalisation. The scale of the challenge is reflected in the size of the gap between our income and expenditure as a State. That is why we need to continue the process of reducing the deficit, with measures to increase growth, jobs and revenue and to reduce public spending. We will not be overwhelmed by the realities we must face. We take great encouragement from the significant progress that has been already made in tackling this unprecedented crisis. Our objective now must be to build on the decisions we have taken and the stabilisation we have achieved. Now we must push ahead to grow our economy, create jobs and bring down the deficit.

A crucial element in building confidence in our capacity to overcome these problems is to realise the strengths we have and the strong performance which continues in many parts of the Irish economy. We still have 1.86 million people at work today, which is approximately 480,000 more people than were at work in 1997. This is a highly qualified and productive workforce, working in an economy where a high proportion of our output comes from the innovation-intensive, high value-added and growing high-technology sector as well as in an indigenous sector that is now more efficient and competitive than it was when the economic and financial crisis hit us in 2008.

That is reflected in our export performance, which has recovered rapidly this year, despite the very difficult international trading conditions. Today's figures from the Irish Exporters Association show a 12.8% growth in merchandise exports in the third quarter and a 9% increase in total exports on the same period last year. It is expected that the balance of payments of the Irish economy will move into surplus next year. The level of exports and capital inflows is set to exceed imports and capital outflows from next year on. That fact tells us our economic relations with the rest of the world are firmly pointing towards our capacity to pay our way, to service our debts and to achieve economic and fiscal stability.

Ireland's real competitive strength is further reflected in the continuing flow of investment announcements and the expansion of employment by world leading international companies which still see Ireland as the location of choice for many of their activities. Last week an IBM survey stated that Ireland was the best location for direct investment. Many of the best and largest companies in the world have decided to locate their higher value-added activities in Ireland and we are seeing a high and growing proportion of firms engaged in research and innovation. That inherent competitive strength also reflects the realism and flexibility of our people at work across the entire economy.

Comment on this

On a point of order, can we suspend until the Taoiseach's script arrives in the Chamber?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot suspend the House. That is not in order. I call the Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Never mind organising an economy, he cannot even organise his script.

Comment on this

On a second point of order, and I will be very brief——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot set out to disrupt the proceedings of the House in this manner.

Comment on this

I wonder if we will be joined by the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Gormley, who was so interested in consensus.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy Shatter resume his seat?

Comment on this

I apologise. The script is on the way.

The Irish workforce has adapted to the international economic crisis and the very changed circumstances at home. In many cases, work practices have changed, working hours have been altered, pay rates have been reduced, especially premium earnings of various kinds. Employers and workers have got together at local level to agree how to adapt and to preserve jobs.

As a result, the unit labour cost of production in Ireland has reduced while it has continued to rise elsewhere. That improvement in cost competitiveness is already being reflected in the more positive way in which operations in Ireland are being viewed by international companies.

The Government has been also taking a range of actions to help return the economy to the path of sustainable growth. In December 2008, we published our economic plan, Building Ireland's Smart Economy. It identified five action areas as the basis for the Government's response to the crisis. Since then, we have been assiduously implementing that framework.

We have acted aggressively in all these areas to tackle short-term difficulties while laying the basis for future recovery. We have introduced supports for business, for example, the enterprise stabilisation fund and the employment subsidy scheme, while seeing large gains in international competitiveness.

We have acted decisively to stabilise the banking system in very difficult circumstances and ensured a continued flow of credit to business, albeit not yet back to its optimum, and work continues in this critical area. We have begun to re-position Ireland as a global innovation hub, based on the work of the innovation task force, notably through the establishment of Innovation Fund Ireland and improvements to our research and development and intellectual property tax regime. We have invested heavily in renewable energy infrastructure, while developing new market opportunities in areas like electric vehicles and the SmartGrid. We have sustained high levels of capital investment to support economic activity during the past two years, completing the inter-urban motorways and delivering new projects at reduced cost.

The decisions we have already taken, and the reforms we have already introduced, will greatly benefit this country in the years ahead, and there are many reasons to be hopeful and optimistic about the future of our country and her people. Our mission now is to translate our economic strengths into economic recovery. We must be hopeful, optimistic and energetic, and yet we must be clear-eyed, realistic and thoughtful. Hope and optimism are the essential ingredients of our future, but they do no blind us to the realities of the present.

We must recognise that the rapidity of the recent economic decline and the scale of our budgetary deficit have created real doubts about the State's capacity to pay its way. These financial problems have overshadowed our real economic and competitive strengths. The reality is that we must convince those who lend to the State, who fund our banks and who do business with Ireland that we have a credible plan to close the gap between Government income and expenditure, and to meet the cost of servicing our increased debt. There is no other choice, it must be done and the Government is determined that it will be done.

We are entering a crucial period. Together, we will have to make some of the most significant decisions in our recent economic history. Those decisions will shape the future for all of our people for many years. If we shirk the necessary decisions, or if we make the wrong judgments, the consequences are very difficult to contemplate. That must not happen, and I do not believe it will happen.

When the Government presents its budget, it will set out the specific adjustments, in terms of income and expenditure, which will demonstrate progress towards our 2014 target. Achieving budgetary balance will require difficult decisions, based on a clear view of economic and social priorities and, crucially, on the principle that the burden must be shared.

As I have outlined, we all have a part to play in contributing to recovery. The gap between what we are spending and what we are collecting in revenue is too big for anyone to escape sharing the burden of adjustment but the society that we have built has at its core a commitment to help the less fortunate. The Government is determined that the major gains in social protection and support for the vulnerable in recent years will be maintained as far as is possible in present circumstances.

For example, between 2005 and 2010, the contributory State pension rose by 37.7%, the lowest rate of welfare payment rose by 45.4%, the qualified child benefit increase rose by 77.4% and the national fuel scheme payment rose by 122.2%. Inflation in the same period was just 10.3%. Those gains are real and substantial. There have also been major improvements in public services such as health and education, in care for our elderly and in support for people with disabilities.

Given the budgetary crisis we are now in, I do not believe that we can protect every aspect of health, education and social welfare spending. Unfortunately, that is impossible given the scale of spending in those areas relative to the reduced Exchequer resources that will be available. However, many, if not all, of the gains of recent years can and will be preserved, and once financial stability is restored and sustainable economic growth achieved, we can improve our living standards again also. Every measure we consider over the coming weeks will be assessed with this in mind.

We must aspire to the goal that all of our citizens have an opportunity to work and to be valued in our society, to be well-educated and to be properly cared for when needs be. To do this, we must get more from less, and not to be afraid to change things around to get the best possible outcomes for the resources we now have available.

The four year plan is about demonstrating how we will achieve a return to growth and jobs in line with the capacities and ambitions of our people so that we can meet our social objectives on a sustainable basis. While this is a national plan, to be presented by the Government and containing a range of measures requiring the approval of the Oireachtas, we will also seek support for it from the EU institutions. That is prudent and it recognises the reality of the international situation, as well as the support we have already received from those institutions.

A viable plan, with the approval of this House and the support of the EU institutions, is the surest way forward to economic recovery. Responsibility lies with the Members of this House and ultimately, the Irish people. We all need to understand and believe that we can have a powerful influence — as we have had before — on our own economic fortunes.

As a small open economy we have to pay our way in the world through trade and exports. This means we must ensure our costs are not out of line with our competitors, focus our investments and energies on sectors and activities with scope to secure more jobs and organise our business and industrial relations practices in a way that unleashes the full potential of the economy.

We will continue the process of reducing the costs of doing business. While we have seen significant improvements in many areas, some significant costs are out of line with our competitors. This is true of parts of our sheltered domestic economy which are not exposed to international competition. We will look, in particular, at the costs of professional services and charges levied by public bodies of all kinds. We will adopt a focused and determined approach to drive down costs which are unreasonably out of line with those of important competitors.

Many employers, including the public service, have had to take steps and sometimes unpalatable decisions to reduce payroll costs. Labour costs in the economy, like other costs, cannot be sustained at a level which is out of line with our international competitors when account is taken of productivity and other relevant factors.

I welcome the fact that a framework for engagement between employers and trade unions in the private sector was agreed between IBEC and ICTU. Negotiations have also produced adjustments in a small number of sectoral agreements which are underpinned by the institutional machinery of the State. It is time to look closely at the terms of some of these agreements to ensure they are fair by reference to what has happened in the rest of the economy and appropriate to the task of sustaining and growing employment.

As part of an overall competitive economy, there are sectors where specific opportunities arise at this time if we focus particular effort on taking advantage of them. These have been identified in a series of strategic initiatives on the part of the Government over recent months. For example, we are determined to ensure the environment for innovation in existing and new businesses is as positive and productive as possible. This is as important for Irish SMEs as it is for the high-tech sector.

Our economic policy framework is not only about new industries and high-tech capabilities. It applies just as much to what we might regard as our traditional businesses of agrifood, tourism and construction. These industries have the benefit of involving people right across the community and all around the country. They are sustaining communities and families and have the potential to do so for many years ahead as they evolve in line with market realities. They face challenges but their potential for further growth and development is significant. We must ensure those capabilities are fully realised in order that these traditional sectors can also play their part in growing jobs.

The four year plan will, therefore, set out concrete and tangible ways in which key sectors of the economy are being supported and mobilised to grow our economic base in the period ahead. Their vitality will build the credibility of our overall economic and fiscal commitments. Achieving our budgetary targets will, in turn, build a better business environment for investment in these sectors. This can result in many thousands of new jobs which, in turn, can facilitate a much less severe budgetary adjustment. This virtuous circle of budgetary performance, competitiveness and economic development is the dynamic which will drive a successful economic future for our country.

Comment on this

It is a pity the Government did not discover virtue five years earlier.

Comment on this

Democratic government is, in essence, about choices.

Comment on this

This is like a lady of the night preaching virtue on the streets of Dublin.

Comment on this

With hindsight, we can see that the sustained boom period of the Celtic tiger misled us all into believing we could avoid difficult choices. We now know differently. As a consequence, the choices we now face are, unfortunately, very stark. It is essential at this time of severe economic difficulty that our people understand the choices facing the country, the decisions being taken by the Government and the reasons for them.

Comment on this

Will the Taoiseach apologise?

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Allow the Taoiseach to continue without interruption, please.

Comment on this

It is also important and appropriate that the Government can show to this House and Irish people that it is listening to all points of view and considering all policy options.

Some have expressed the view that we can reduce the severity of the fiscal consolidation by extending the 2014 deadline. While the Government understands this view, it is simply not grounded in the reality of the political and economic situation in which we find ourselves. It also disregards the implications of the consequent rise in debt service costs for the economy.

There is a lively debate about the scale and pace of changes to public spending amid fears that austerity could create a deflationary spiral. Reducing public spending on the scale envisaged will temporarily dampen economic growth but we must recognise that even with the proposed adjustment of €15 billion, we still intend to borrow tens of billions of euro between now and 2014. We simply cannot afford to increase borrowing further. If we tried to do so, we would run a very real risk of not being able to borrow.

There are, however, many good ideas to which the Government has been carefully listening and about which it has been actively thinking. While respecting the absolute need to meet the deficit target, we are considering new initiatives to promote employment in various sectors of the economy. We are looking at how we can reduce the abnormally high savings ratio and release some of those resources into the economy. We are examining the entire asset base of the State to make sure it is being used to maximum effect to drive investment and to help our competitiveness. Moreover, the Government is acutely aware of the role of small business in providing employment and the need to make sure we support our indigenous companies by helping to reduce their costs and administrative burden. We are evaluating our capital investment plans to make sure we make the right investments for the future as well as helping employment in the short term. Consequently, all our decisions on taxation, spending and growth will be made with an open mind. There are many choices still to be made.

In bringing forward the four-year plan, the Government will set out its ambitions for the future of the country and our society. In doing this, we will be part of the broader Europe 2020 strategy for jobs and growth to ensure that our economy and society develop to meet the ambitions and aspirations of our people. We will outline an approach to budgetary policy which is not just about balancing the books in line with our commitments but about trying to transform and restructure our economy and ultimately to improve our society. In addition, the Government will set out a new vision for social partnership as a process that can mobilise commitment and energy to support economic recovery and a fair and decent society. Our social dialogue will thereby return to its roots as an important part of the process of building up the real economic and social strengths of our economy and society.

This is a moment with very few parallels in recent economic history. It is a moment when the Government will act clearly and resolutely in the national interest.

Comment on this

There is no parallel for a Government to singlehandedly destroy the economy——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Shatter.

Comment on this

——of the country and ruin the reputation of this State.

Comment on this

I truly believe that the present difficulties, daunting as they appear——

Comment on this

One would think the Taoiseach——

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Shatter, please. The Taoiseach is in possession.

Comment on this

—— was a passive observer of the disaster.

Comment on this

I truly believe that the present difficulties, daunting as they appear, represent an opportunity to rejuvenate our institutions, to refocus our energy and to inspire the people.

Comment on this

One would not know he had been the Minister for Finance or is Taoiseach.

Comment on this

Deputy Shatter sounds like an unhinged observer.

Comment on this

The Taoiseach should apologise.

Comment on this

There is a realistic prospect of achieving, within a reasonable time, not merely budgetary balance and economic security but an Ireland worthy of the sacrifices our people are currently being called upon to make.

Comment on this

Where is the apology?

Comment on this

We can build such an Ireland, that is capable of meeting our ambitions for our children and their future in this country.

I remain open to the possibility of a broad measure of agreement on the details of a pathway to recovery and am very open to hearing and acting on sound proposals that may be aired in this debate.

However, I stand before the House in the full knowledge of my own responsibilities as Taoiseach and I will do my duty. I will discharge my responsibilities to the best of my ability. I will do so with my Government colleagues in the best interests of the country at this important time. I trust this debate will be a constructive and solid contribution to meeting the challenges our country faces at present.

Comment on this

Not a single identifiable or specific proposal.

Comment on this
Seamus Kirk An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I call Deputy Kenny, without interruption please.

Comment on this

Not a single identifiable or specific proposal to be discussed in this House.

Comment on this

I listened carefully to the Taoiseach's contribution, which did not contain a single proposal the Government intends to carry out despite having held two days of meetings at Farmleigh House and Government Buildings. At present, depression, anxiety, concern and fear stalk the land. This is because of the Government's catastrophic failure to deal with reality in the clear-eyed fashion to which the Taoiseach referred. Hundreds of thousands of people have genuine fears and concerns about their future and security. They have concerns about their resolve to keep a roof above their heads and about jobs, employment and an economic future for themselves and their families. The reason for all this is the Government cannot be believed and has no credibility or truth left. On the day Deputy Cowen was appointed Taoiseach, I stated that he should put his new mandate to the people for their approval. The real difference now is that the present Government, which practically is at the end of its life, has run out of time and credibility. Neither the international markets nor the people believe it.

The version from Ministers, who arrived at Farmleigh House in sleek transportation in a manner reminiscent of the Anglo-Irish coming back to the big house, is to state repeatedly that they want to do what is fair and to make decisions that are in the interests of the people and the country. They state that each Minister is looking at all other Departments — so we will all hang together instead of hanging separately — which is a complete change from the manner in which Ministers used to approach budgets in the past. Moreover, this morning I heard the Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport stating that the Opposition parties should now accept the €15 billion.

The leaders of the Fine Gael Party and the Labour Party, who attended the meeting last week with the Taoiseach and the absent Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government, Deputy Gormley, have accepted the target to reduce the deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014. However the Government will not be successful in any attempt to browbeat Opposition parties into accepting all the elements of the budget or the cuts on which it now must make decisions. It is about time for the Government to face this crisis rather than running from it, as it has done repeatedly. Every single projection put forward by the Taoiseach, the Government and the Minister for Finance, who now has lost considerable political momentum, has been wrong. One was told that NAMA would make a profit and that the deficit would be €3 billion, €5 billion or €10 billion but on each occasion, this figure has risen far beyond Government projections.

We now have reached a point at which emigration is back on the agenda. Irrespective of what has happened, the really sad fact about this political situation, arising from the billions that have been wasted by an incompetent Government and by Ministers who neglected to oversee public expenditure, pertains to the hundreds of thousands who are leaving this country with the consequential transfer of the investment in education and training of graduates across all walks of Irish life who now will give of their talent and their futures to other jurisdictions. Added to that is the depression, anxiety and concern of the many people who put their belief in the present Government on the last occasion by a majority. However, it has failed utterly to live up to the trust placed in it through the ballot box. As far as the present Government is concerned, the moral of the story is that everyone should leave, be they bankers, regulators, governors of central banks or bank boards, except for the Government itself. Its time is coming and when the people get their chance they will exercise their mandate appropriately.

There is much talk on the part of the Taoiseach and other Ministers on the need to restore Ireland's credibility in international markets and Members on this side of the House share that concern. However, yesterday's announcement of the need to commit a further €15 billion from the public finances in the coming years constitutes an indictment of the disastrous failure of the Government to restore Ireland's credibility both at home and abroad. The credibility of our country is on the floor and the reason the Government is unable to enter the bond auction markets is because there is no belief in its strategy for growth in the Irish economy over coming years. This is not because of anything that the people have done. It is because of the continuance in office of a Government the policies of which not only led us into this crisis but which at every turn have made that crisis much worse. Our credibility is on the floor because each projection made by the Government has been proved to be wrong and each announcement of recovery has been premature. The Government stated that the corner has been turned, that there was a light at the end of the tunnel and that the only way was up but each time, this has been proven to be wrong.

The colossal failure of the Government's banking strategy also has damaged our credibility. After two years, most other countries have cleaned up their banking problems and people have been put in prison. However, the Government has failed to restore credit availability and now has lumbered Irish taxpayers with a €40 billion mortgage, the cost of which at approximately €1.5 billion must be met each year in perpetuity. Many Ministers could do a great deal of work with that kind of money, were it available to be spent on Irish infrastructure and jobs. Ireland's credibility has been hammered by the paralysis of the Government in the face of the huge reforms required in the public and private sectors to make the economy competitive enough to export our way back to full employment and sound health in the public finances. Six months after finalising the Croke Park agreement, not a single euro has been saved by its provisions as the entire public sector waits for some political leadership and a credible reform plan. After two years of blundering, paralysis and catastrophic misjudgments in almost every area, Ireland now stands at the edge of an economic abyss, threatened with the loss of our economic sovereignty, led there by an incompetent Government incapable of managing the affairs of the people.

The Taoiseach says Irish people must restore Ireland's damaged credibility through massive cuts in services and entitlements and tax increases. He outlined three of them in general terms today — social welfare, health and education. I note the Minister for Health and Children made the announcement of a cut of between €600 million and €1 billion in the health area outside the House. We were promised a world class health system. We know we have world class doctors and nurses but we do not have a world class system to back them up. The Minister calmly announced a cut of between €600 million and €1 billion in the health area, and let them eat cake after that.

The Government has imposed these cuts in services, tax increases and losses of entitlements on people. We must recognise that there are no painless solutions to the crisis in which we now find ourselves. It has become depressingly clear that everyone in our society will be affected by the measures required to undo the damage the Government has inflicted on the Irish people. There is a way to restore at least some of the country's lost credibility. That is by showing that the Irish people will hold failure to account and that there will be political consequences for disastrous economic management. A new Government with new ideas and a new mandate would, at least, have the impact of reducing Ireland's borrowing rate by 0.5%, as happened in Britain a few months ago.

The Fine Gael Party remains committed to reducing the deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014, as agreed with the European Commission. Reopening negotiations at this point with the EU to extend the period of fiscal adjustment beyond 2014 could lead to a further loss of international confidence in the Irish economy in 2011, with disastrous consequences. We know that Ireland is now likely to borrow more than €60 billion over the coming four years, pushing our debt to GDP ratio to well over 105%. Irrespective of the views of the European Union, there is no guarantee that markets will be willing to lend Ireland the additional resources required to extend any period of adjustment. The credibility of any four year fiscal plan is dependent on the likely growth path over the coming years. Largely reflecting the colossal cost of its banking policy and its failure to restore credit availability, the Government now projects higher debt-servicing costs and lower growth — an average of 2.7% — than hoped for last year. As a result, it has doubled the estimate of the spending cuts and tax increases required in order to hit the 3% borrowing target in 2014 from €7.5 billion to €15 billion. There are better possible outcomes. For instance, if the ESRI's updated high-growth scenario of an average growth of 4.5% were to materialise, a smaller package of fiscal measures would be needed to hit the 3% target by 2014.

That is why Fine Gael believes it is necessary, over the coming weeks, to put a relentless focus on the ways to support growth and jobs as the country attempts to repair its public finances. That is why Fine Gael believes that any fiscal plan has to operate in parallel with a credible growth and jobs plan to turn the present downward vicious cycle into an upward virtuous cycle. We have a different approach from the Government. Fine Gael offers real hope that we can rebuild our economy and restore trust in politics and in Government.

I recognise the need for a new start. The language and circumstances of the past cannot deal with the crisis we now face. This crisis has to be dealt with but we have to have a new start based on politicians telling the public the truth about where we stand as a country. The Fine Gael Party will open the books to the public when we get the opportunity, tell them the truth and point out how their country was run for the past decade or so. We are not a prisoner of any big business or powerful union. Our only interest is the public's interest. More than that, we can offer hope for the future because unlike any other party we have done a detailed analysis and made detailed plans to restore our country's fortunes. The central pillar of our plan is the commitment to making the protection and creation of jobs the first and last priority of a new Government.

There is a simple truth that appears to have escaped those in Government Buildings and the Department of Finance. If we do not grow our economy and fix our jobs crisis we will never fix our financial crisis. This is not just about fiscal consolidation, as they call it, or cuts, in the Taoiseach's language. This is about our own society, our people, our country and what the endgame is. The endgame has to be a country that works, a people who have career opportunities and where there is a sense of security, confidence and the hope to which the Taoiseach referred. The endgame will not be easy to achieve. We have been led to this point by the bluffs, untruths, negligence and incompetence of the Government over the last number of years. That is why we are committed to an enterprise society, where small businesses and entrepreneurs are supported by ensuring that banks are the servants of enterprise.

When we look at what creates jobs in our country we recognise the need for a number of key factors. There must be a favourable macroeconomic environment that comprises a competitiveness profile, an advantageous tax position, a sharp industrial policy, a superior education system, support for entrepreneurship and a first rate public sector, particularly where it touches on jobs issues. There must be a targeted policy where it is possible directly to create jobs, or boost or support job creation, in specific areas.

We used to have a number of advantages over all other countries. Some are still in place, others are in areas where we have clearly slipped, some are outside our complete control and others are not. We need to be brutally honest with ourselves in evaluating our position and deciding what measures we have to take if we are to look at a credible growth pattern with a concentrated focus on jobs and on getting people back to work. The low corporation tax has been a fundamental lever for foreign direct investment into Ireland. I was honoured to be a member of the Government that introduced that low corporation tax rate. Many other countries now have a similar position. We must defend our position here. This party, in government, will defend that position. From speaking to business interests abroad, it is perfectly obvious they value the low corporation tax rate. It is still a matter of fundamental importance to our jobs policy.

We have, clearly, slipped in the area of cost competitiveness. The Government lost sight of the impact of cost control and cost competitiveness in business, whether of local authority rates and charges, red tape or bureaucracy. Many of our 80,000 small businesses are nearing bankruptcy. Many are struggling to remain in business. They have never been written to by Government saying: "These are the supports or encouragement we can offer you. This is what we want to do for you if you can take on one extra employee". They have never been contacted and assured that Government recognises the importance of small business and of what small and medium enterprises can do for our country.

I recently spoke to business people in the United States, where there is still huge interest in investing here and ensuring that Irish small and medium enterprises can export to that country. The IDA has always done a fine job in attracting foreign direct investment but we have slipped in some respects in recent years. We have to examine the trends to find out why we were No. 1 and what we have to do to make this the best small country in the world to do business.

Last week in Citywest, I attended the Ernst and Young entrepreneur of the year awards. Somebody who flew in solely to attend that function would be blown away by the potential, initiative and creative ingenuity shown by many small and medium enterprises around the country. In Government, Fine Gael will remove the shackles from people who want to work and create jobs but who are being impeded by a lack of encouragement and obstacles put up by Government bureaucracy.

There has been much discussion of our diaspora. Last year, people from all over the world gathered in Farmleigh House. It is a pity that event was hijacked by the Department of Foreign Affairs, which never had the competence a Department of trade and industry might have in dealing with these matters. Unless we bring from that meeting specific initiatives and results, people will not attend another one. Diasporas have had an impact on Taiwan, India and Israel in terms of serious investment and job creation. The Irish diaspora, whether in the United States or elsewhere in the world, is willing to contribute and wants to help our country. That has not been harnessed to the extent it should.

Fine Gael has pointed out on numerous occasions that our education system has both strengths and weakness. Major employers in the technology sector have voiced concerns about the position of science and mathematics. The rote learning of many aspects of the leaving certificate has led many potential employers to state that our students display less capacity for imaginative and independent thinking than those of other countries. That issue needs to be addressed for the sake of the fine qualities of our thousands of young people who can and will measure up to the competitive pressures of their peers around the world if they are given the opportunity.

The entrepreneurial culture of which Fine Gael speaks must be maintained. In the 1980s, Ireland had one of the lowest percentages in Europe of people who wanted to run their own businesses but by the late 1990s and the early part of this decade, we had one of the highest percentages. That transformation, and the development of a broad entrepreneurial culture over the same period, was one of the most important developments in Ireland's economic history. Many of the elements of this culture are still in place but others have run into difficulties. The entrepreneurial culture survived the boom and bust of the dotcom bubble. Even now, in the face of domestic and international crises, I regularly come across small and medium enterprises which want to expand, change direction or get into exports and new lines of business, yet the Government voted down the loan guarantee scheme which Fine Gael introduced last week.

We have investigated the job creation potential in semi-State bodies through our NewERA economic recovery strategy published two years ago by Deputy Coveney. I note the British Prime Minister, Mr. Cameron, has launched a £200 billion investment programme in major infrastructure, with a £50 billion contribution from his Government. Fine Gael's programme for water, broadband and renewable energy, which involves commercial semi-State bodies providing infrastructure facilities and charging commercial rates at the end of their provision, will mean increased attractiveness for investment and job creation, both locally and internationally. Up to 100,000 jobs can be created through that additional infrastructural investment.

I have previously referred to the impact that international education can have on Ireland. The demand for education beyond boundaries has increased hugely in the past several years and is forecast to reach more than 6 million students by 2020. The number of US students attending college overseas increased from 90,000 in 1995 to 250,000 in 2007. Approximately 300,000 international students attended British universities in 2008, paying almost €4 billion in fees. International education contributed €11 billion to the Australian economy in 2009. We are bogged down with visa bureaucracy and restrictions on students entering this country. It is past time that was addressed. These are areas in which we can change the way we do business.

Deputy Bruton will shortly publish a serious document on public service provision and cost. In dealing with the provision and cost of Government, it is essential that we start at the centre and the top. This is why Fine Gael has published our own document on changing the way we do our business, reducing the size of the Dáil and putting the abolition of the Seanad to the people in a referendum. By changing the way this Chamber does its business, we will make it the centre of Irish politics rather than a place where the Government does not want to be.

We want to bring the Dutch health system, which is the best in Europe, to Ireland. We are now told that between €600 million and €1 billion will be cut from our public health service without reference to protecting the front line services that save lives. Fine Gael's health plan, which we call FairCare, will eliminate hospital waiting lists, as was done in Northern Ireland, and will put the patient front and centre by paying hospitals for what they do rather than what they did last year. We will eliminate the unfair two-tier health system by making health insurance affordable for everyone. People will be able to access care on the basis of need rather than wealth. Our new approach is based on a system that is not fantasy and which works in the Netherlands.

We will change politics and the public service. Fine Gael's programme for political reform will start at the centre and the top to ensure the political system never again lets us down so catastrophically as it did in the past few years.

The Government has on many occasions claimed that the recession is at an end. This claim is no longer credible. However, there is a world of difference between the Ireland that will be ground out by the relentless forces of credit starvation, long-term unemployment and emigration and the country that could emerge if we adopt a more decisive, creative and innovative set of solutions which harnesses our entire community to the task. In every city, town and parish in this country, people want to contribute and assist. It is that contribution which gives people a sense of satisfaction. The days of the Celtic tiger are long dead and its values are not the values of the future. People who want to give their time and experience to their communities will pull this country through. This Government has failed absolutely to recognise the intrinsic values that are held deep down by the Irish people and the old meitheal spirit that is part of a tradition based on emigrant trends over two centuries.

The last recession officially ended in 1983 but it took six years before investment in job creation significantly reduced the dole queues. The Government strategy appears to have only two planks: the first is writing whatever cheques are necessary to bail out banks and the second is cutting the budget deficit each year through savage and insensitive cuts. I did not hear a significant proposal of any proportion from the Taoiseach today in his contribution to this macroeconomic debate. These two planks of the Government add up to a strategy of national retrenchment. There is nothing positive, nothing ambitious, nothing creative to restore confidence in Ireland's economic future and nothing that will add any sense of hope or confidence to people out there, who do not see any security up front despite the fact savings continue to accumulate in Irish banks.

We have a very different philosophy, which is that the people's potential can and will flourish here in this country. The Fine Gael plan states that the crisis must be viewed as an opportunity for the political and economic transformation of our country. To do that, we need to focus not just on, as the Taoiseach calls it, fiscal consolidation and on cuts in the cost of Government and the way we deliver public services, but also in the value of those services and by creating an enterprise society.

In the early part of the last century, the Government, led by the forerunner of the party I now lead, created and built the institutions of this State, such as with the establishment of the ESB in 1927, the Shannon scheme at Ardnacrusha in 1929, the dramatic acceleration of rural electrification in 1955 and the air transport liberalisation in the 1980s that launched Ryanair as Europe's largest airline. Now is also a time for re-imagining our economic future. For me, the end game is not the red line or where it is drawn. The end game is a country where pride can be restored, where people have hope and confidence that they can have a future in this country, if that is what they wish, where we can restore sound public finances, where there is a banking system that works and lends credit to business in circumstances where it should, where there is a health system that measures up and is not a black hole opening up and sucking in relentlessly all of the taxes from all areas of Irish society, and where there is an education system that is competitive and able to stand up to measure against the competitive forces of the world.

We pointed out in our plans how we can fund that enterprise society through the sale of assets that are no longer necessary for the future, through a leaner, more skilled banking situation where credit is lent to business, where necessary, and through a re-balancing of the tax system to offer greater support to enterprise, innovation and employment. As I said, a 51% marginal tax rate is much too high.

Fianna Fáil and the Greens, supported by a number of Independents, have led our country to the edge of an economic abyss. It is ironic that within six years of the centenary of the 1916 Rising, which was the beginning of the opportunity for Ireland to have economic independence, the so-called great republicans have led us to a point where there is no credibility, faith or belief in the strategy of this Government to rectify our problems. As I have said before and say again now, it is time to consult the people, time to give them their opportunity and time to have a new mandate. The Government should go. It has failed in its duty, it has broken the trust given to it by the people and it has failed to implement the policy situations which would keep Ireland proud, strong and clear. We should not be the focus of this international recession; we should be but a backwater of it. We are here because of neglect, incompetence, lack of management skills and a failure to recognise that politics is not just about keeping a party in power, it is about people, about a society and about our country. Fine Gael will measure up to that responsibility when the people give us the opportunity.

Comment on this

Yesterday, the Minister for Finance told the Irish people that the Government has decided to make a €15 billion adjustment in the budget over the next four years, double the amount that was previously expected. Where does this €15 billion come from? When I asked the Taoiseach earlier today for the detail of the information and projections on which that figure must be based, he either would not or could not give me the information. How, therefore, are we to rely on the figure of €15 billion? How credible is it when it comes from the same source that has already told us we had the cheapest bank bailout in the world, that we had seen the last of the really difficult budgets, that the worst was over, that we needed only one more push and that we had turned the corner? Some corner.

What we still do not know is what is the basis for this €15 billion figure. According to the Government, the Opposition has been shown the books. Two meetings lasting a total of three hours and now the Opposition is supposed to know everything. After three hours in the Department of Finance, the Opposition parties are expected to have the same level of knowledge and information about the public finances as the Government has after 13 years in office.

Let me put on the record what we were actually given. The kernel of the briefing last week was three sheets of paper, with a table on each, containing nine rows of figures. The first table shows what would happen if one went ahead with the €7.5 billion plan, and what would happen to the deficit and GDP with a €15 billion plan, assuming a €4.5 billion adjustment in 2011. That is it and no more — GDP figures in ranges. On another page, we were given the same table, this time assuming a €7 billion adjustment in 2011. The GDP figure for 2011 in this table is lower, as one might expect, but the figure for 2012 is higher. What explains this particular form of "bounce back economics"? We do not know because the table contains no data on consumption, investment, exports, imports, inflation, wage growth, interest rates, exchange rates or growth in the US, European or world economies.

When one asks how it could be the case that a massive hit on the economy in 2011 — we are told the reductions in spending are to be front-loaded — is going to produce higher growth in 2012, the answer is one word, "confidence". Not a worked out spreadsheet showing how different levels of interest rates will affect investment or consumer spending, just "confidence", or what Professor Krugman calls "the confidence fairy". While five-year olds in Ireland are understandably prepared to believe in the tooth fairy, it is unwise for a country or an economy to put its faith in the confidence fairy.

Despite all the damage done to the economy, Fianna Fáil still insists on playing political games. The Fianna Fáil spin machine is putting it about that it has opened up the books to the Opposition and now it is up to the Opposition to produce the answer, based on a few so-called scenarios about how the deficit might possibly be reduced, depending on two possible sets of adjustments and two possible sets of growth forecasts — possible, not probable or definitive. We have not yet been given the official growth forecast for next year because, we are told, the Government is still negotiating it with the European Commission. We have not yet been given the official forecast for the three years after that, and we have not yet been given the figure for cuts in next year's budget. Nor have we been given what the Department's estimate is of the additional impact of extra budget measures on jobs and growth. We have simply been told to believe in the confidence fairy.

We do not have a template for the four-year plan. We do not have a figure from Government on what Croke Park will save next year. We do not have an answer on how the bank bailout will be treated in the national accounts and how that will affect the deficit target. If one asks for projections for 2011, one will be told that they do not have the October or November Exchequer returns.

The horrifying thought is that this might actually be the kind of information that has been used to inform Cabinet decision-making over the past few years. Either Fianna Fáil is genuinely uncertain about these key figures, which would be extraordinary after more than 13 years in office, or it knows them and is simply not willing to tell the Opposition or the public because it does not suit its carefully worked out political choreography.

After everything that has happened up to now, one would have to be naïve not to be sceptical about any figures that come from this Government. What we do know is that after Black Thursday, there has been an enormous bill to pay for the banks, of at least €45 billion. We know there has been a catastrophic loss of confidence in Ireland abroad and that the cost of Government borrowing has shot up to the point where the Government feels unable to continue borrowing money. We know there is to be a four-year plan and a budget that are supposed to restore order to the public finances and confidence in the country. However, beyond that the Government has provided very few specifics. There were no specifics at all in the Taoiseach's speech today. The Opposition parties are, justifiably, often challenged over specifics. It is astonishing that, in the opening of today's debate, the Taoiseach did not set out a single specific measure under consideration by the Government. Today's debate should be about solutions. The economic crisis we now face is the worst in the history of the State. Disastrous mismanagement of the economy and the catastrophic error of the blanket bank guarantee have brought the country to the edge of bankruptcy. The reality is that we face a fight to hold on to our economic freedom and the right to make decisions about our own future if the Government cannot convince investors to lend money to Ireland at reasonable rates again.

This crisis is not about economic jargon, or graphs or numbers; it is a human crisis. It is a crisis for the hundreds of thousands who have no work, for families at risk of losing their homes, for people who have lost their businesses. If we are going to solve this problem, we need clarity on numbers. However, we also need clarity on objectives and a serious, sustained approach to achieving solutions.

What I and the Labour Party have been saying throughout this crisis is that there must be more than one objective. We need to lower the deficit to 3% by 2014, but not just for the sake of it. It is a means to several ends. Our objectives must be to get people back to work, re-start economic growth, increase exports and restore our reputation abroad and confidence at home so people will invest and spend in Ireland.

We need to come up with a plan not so much to satisfy our partners in Europe, but to convince international bond markets to invest in Ireland while we go about the difficult work of restoring our public finances. We must combine deficit reduction with a strategy to re-start economic growth. We must do all of this in a way that is fair.

Ever since the Government made its agreement with our partners in Europe to reach the 3% target by 2014, the Labour Party has supported it in that objective. We have done so because we believe it is extremely important that Ireland send a united signal to the wider world that we are serious about dealing with our deficit. People who invest in this country do not necessarily follow our politics or have any understanding of what a change in Government might mean. The Labour Party wants to make it clear that a change in Government in Ireland will not result in the goal of deficit reduction being abandoned. I regret that Fianna Fáil has taken so long to grudgingly accept that this is the case. Had it done so earlier, it could have made more of it, to the advantage of the country.

It is important to be clear, however, about what Ireland has actually signed on for. We have agreed to try to lower our deficit to 3% by 2014. That means having a credible multi-annual plan that addresses the problem over a period. It does not mean we are tied to any particular deficit figure for next year. We will not solve this problem by resorting to ever-greater and ever-more-crude adjustments. We will solve it by having a strategy that combines reduction in the budget deficit with a programme of action on jobs and growth, and which puts in place reforms that signal to the wider world that Ireland is a serious country that will not allow this disaster to happen again.

Bond investors are just like any other investors. They want to see the whole story. If they invest in a country, they want to know how much debt it has and how big its deficit is, but they also want to know whether the country will be able to pay the money back. They will look at headline numbers, but they will look also at the medium-term story. They will want to know whether this country has a growth model that is going to ensure it can service its debts. It is the presentation of that story — of a credible plan to reduce the deficit while re-starting economic growth — that should be the focus of debate and of the four-year plan.

The figures produced by the ESRI and what we have been given by the Department of Finance make it clear that the position is extremely challenging. A fundamental rethink of every aspect of the budget is required. The problem also calls for purposeful and sustained action. What must happen now, and what should have happened long since, is the adoption of a multi-annual approach to budget policy, not just a set of announcements every December and a set of projected multi-annual figures, but continual and determined action on a multi-annual basis. We know we are not going to fix this overnight. We know also that 2014 is a long time away. Relying on the forecasts of a Government that cannot forecast one week ahead for four years from now is a bit uncertain, to put it mildly.

What we need now is a credible multi-annual plan for stability, growth and jobs that gets the economy moving again. That means looking at each aspect of the budget and how savings can be made while limiting the damage to the economy, and promoting jobs and growth. It means cutting expenditure but it also means raising additional revenue. Unfortunately, taxation must be part of the mix. This is a point that Labour has been making for the past two years while others were trying to pretend that the whole adjustment could be achieved by cutting spending. We are finally seeing some rational thinking on this issue. It is regrettable that extra taxes are necessary, but they are nevertheless. While everyone will have to contribute in some way, I do not subscribe to the notion that the only people who should pay more are those on modest incomes.

We should aim for an even split between additional revenue raising and lower spending, roughly at a ratio of 50:50. Given the scale of the deficit, we need to spread the burden of adjustment for it to be economically or socially credible.

We need completely new approaches to both capital and current expenditure. In respect of capital spending, it is clear that the Government will have to go back to the drawing board once again. Our current level of capital spending is still high by European standards and, unfortunately, that will now have to be reviewed. A reduction of approximately €2.5 billion over three years would leave us with capital expenditure of just under 3% of GNP, or approximately the same as the eurozone average. However, if capital spending by the Exchequer is to be reduced, as it must be, until we stabilise the public finances, we should be looking for ways to replace it from elsewhere.

There have been numerous proposals put forward in this area to find alternative funding for capital projects. Labour has proposed taking €2 billion from the pensions reserve fund to provide the capital for a strategic investment bank that could give the lead in this area. Similar banks exist in other countries, and the UK Government is establishing a green investment bank on a similar model.

It no longer makes sense to make payments into the pensions reserve fund. We are now borrowing money on the international markets at an interest rate of 6% to invest back into the international marketplace through the purchase of shares by our own National Pensions Reserve Fund. Borrowing at this rate for this purpose is the wrong way to use our depleted resources and should be suspended until we return to some form of normality.

In the area of current spending, we must stop lurching from budget to budget with crude cut after crude cut. What we now require is a proper comprehensive expenditure review with a three-year time horizon, such as has been carried out by the new Government in the United Kingdom, but using the Canadian model. The truth is that the Government-commissioned bord snip report has been a failure because it has not produced either the savings it promised or the reform we need. It was never likely to do so because it never sought or received buy-in from Ministers and Departments. The problem with the bord snip approach is that it started by looking at the level of expenditure and asked what can be cut. What we actually need is a process, such as was developed in Canada, that is led by Ministers themselves and by the managers of Departments and agencies. They started with the opposite question: what service do we want to provide? We must have a root-and-branch examination of spending that identifies what we believe is really important, such as keeping the schools open and maintaining a decent health service.

A proper comprehensive spending review would lead to a reduction in both pay and non-pay costs. It would very likely result in a reduction in the number of agencies and to a merger of back-office functions in several of those remaining. The results of a comprehensive spending review would then provide the basis for sustained and ongoing reform of the public service, which should include negotiation with staff to bring about change. That was supposed to be the idea behind the Croke Park agreement, but it is not happening. It is now abundantly clear that having spent months attacking the Labour Party for not telling people how to vote on the it, once the agreement was accepted, the Government has done little or nothing to work it. We cannot keep lurching from one budget to the next, inflicting crude cut after crude cut. If we want to reduce costs in the public service, including head counts and payroll costs — but also input costs — while minimising damage to front-line services, then it must be done in a determined and sustained way.

The Revised Estimates for 2010 show that total current spending, excluding social welfare and public sector pensions, was budgeted to be some €31.6 billion. A programme to reduce both pay and non-pay costs by only 3% per annum would yield savings of €2.8 billion over three years, including payroll reductions of €1.4 billion. That is readily possible and the process relating to it should have begun long ago. Public sector workers have already endured big adjustments in their pay and the Croke Park agreement contains a commitment to the effect that there will be no further pay cuts prior to 2014. At this stage, however, it is unlikely that the necessary payroll reductions will be achieved through natural wastage and redeployment. A voluntary redundancy scheme in the public service will, therefore, be necessary. Such a scheme should be strictly confined to areas of identifiable over-staffing and should be tailored to ensure that critical front-line public services do not have their essential staffing levels eroded.

Non-pay costs will also have to be addressed as part of the review. There are a number of areas that have long cried out for reform, particularly the cost of drugs in the health service, which the Irish Medical Organisation, IMO, estimates could be cut by €300 million through use of generics. It could be further reduced by a more robust approach to negotiations with drug companies that uses the State's bargaining power more effectively. Professional fees are also a serious issue. The bord snip report estimated that GMS fees could be reduced by €370 million over time.

The social welfare budget must also be curtailed. It is possible to achieve considerable savings in social welfare by reforming the way in which the system works. Labour's spokesperson on social protection, Deputy Shortall, recently produced a report for the relevant Oireachtas committee which shows that major savings can be saved by more robust and modern enforcement of anti-fraud measures. Savings of at least €100 million can be made in this area. A second area for potential savings is rent supplement. The State is now spending €500 million per year to supplement the cost of private rented accommodation at a time when there is an overhang of residential property. A saving of at least 10%, or €50 million, could be achieved in this area. The most effective way to reduce the social welfare budget is to get more people back to work. Every job lost costs the State €20,000 a year in tax foregone and direct payments. The number of jobs lost since 2007 stands at 288,000, which costs the Exchequer an additional €5.8 billion per annum.

We now face a difficult challenge to gradually raise the total level of tax revenue as a share of GNP without hurting employment. This will be difficult but not impossible. As the Governor of the Central Bank has pointed out, our ratio of tax to GNP has been higher in the quite recent past when the economy was still performing extremely well. For example, if Exchequer revenues as a share of GNP this year were to be the same as they were in 2001, then an additional €5 billion would be coming in. That does not mean that we should just return to the tax rates that were in force at that time. Instead, the place to start is with broadening the tax base. It is time for a major programme of reform to finally curtail the network of tax breaks and tax expenditures. A recent paper by Micheál Collins and Mary Walsh again highlighted this issue which my colleague, Deputy Burton, has been addressing for many years.

Some €3 billion is being spent in the area of pension reliefs. This amount should be curtailed by at least €500 million, particularly by limiting the total amount of relief that can be claimed by any individual in order to make the system fairer. The reliefs for property-based investment, which cost €380 million, should simply be scrapped and interest relief on rental income from investment property must be significantly curtailed by at least €430 million. An entire series of minor reliefs, mentioned in the report of the Commission on Taxation and including relief on trade union subscriptions, should be scrapped. The relief on patent royalties, which is an avenue for avoidance that costs €50 million, should be abolished.

Labour has been arguing for some time that, in the area of taxation, those who have the most must contribute the most. We have proposed a 48% tax rate for the highest earners. There is also a need for a system whereby a minimum effective tax rate is applied to high earners to limit the total relief that any one person can obtain from all tax breaks combined. The Government claims to have done this but the system is full of holes and deliberately so. There must be more equality of treatment of earned and unearned income in order that income from capital gains is subject to PRSI and levies in the same way as earned income.

There is room to increase the tax on second homes. It should also be possible to phase in water charges on a metered basis as part of a broader reform of how we manage and deliver this vital environmental resource. In addition, we should plan to introduce a new bank levy when the capital levels in the banks are adequate. These will be extremely profitable businesses again and they are not just going to be allowed to ride off into the sunset and leave the rest of us to sort out the mess.

We must make hard decisions but they must be the right ones. They must include the decisions that are required to bolster economic growth. This is the hard work of economic management that really matters. Such work was recently described by Will Hutton as involving "the policies that sit between the glories of headline-catching changes in tax, spending and interest rates, and the habitual invocations of labour market flexibility and deregulation".

One of the reasons for the gloom in economic forecasts is the level of price increases in the economy that is depressing nominal GNP. However, we should not assume that there is no work to do in dealing with the cost base and competitiveness. Wages may fall on average next year but underneath that average we are likely to see wage pressures re-emerging in more sheltered sectors. As of now, the Government effectively has no pay policy outside the public service. I favour a return to social dialogue, in a new format with a far more limited agenda than before. Arising from that, I would like to see a negotiated pay freeze for three years.

We must also tackle the level of fees and prices in the protected professions. While some in the legal profession have taken a major hit, I am concerned with regard to what seems to be happening in respect of NAMA, which has an enormous budget for professional fees. In this economic crisis, emergency measures are needed. Such measures must include the State exercising its right to control fees, in areas such as law and medicine, through a temporary fees commission. If we are to deal with the crisis fairly, then everyone must play his or her part. The medical consultant who charges €150 for a ten-minute appointment must be reined in.

Comment on this
Sean Sherlock Deputy Seán Sherlock Labour Party

Hear, hear.

Comment on this

These cost controls must also be applied in the public sector, where there must be stronger efforts to control input costs, including professional fees, but also costs such as those relating to drugs and other elements of supply chain management.

For all the doom and gloom of this emergency, the Irish economy actually has a great future. The real Celtic tiger was an export-led boom before Fianna Fáil turned it into a property bubble. Last week, I had the opportunity to meet with officials from the Irish development agencies based in New York. They are doing excellent work and it is clear that there are enormous opportunities for Ireland in sectors such as food, tourism and alternative energy.

Ireland is, and will continue to be to be, an attractive location for foreign investment. Our relationship with the US is vital but we must also recognise that the centre of gravity in global trade is shifting to the east. The new world economic powers — Brazil, Russia, India and China — present a great opportunity for Ireland to develop new export markets. However, building up our business with these countries will require greater resources and strong political commitment, including trade missions led by Government Ministers. This is an area where the Government must lead.

Labour has been strongly supportive of the knowledge economy, if not of the increasingly discredited buzz phrase "the smart economy". A knowledge economy is one where innovation is pursued in every sector and region not just in a small number of specialist areas. We must maintain our investment in science but we must do far more to promote applied and downstream research, which is focused on commercialisation of new ideas.

We must get away from the notion that innovation only happens in laboratories. Innovation can happen in any business and in any region, and tourism is a key example of this. There are tourism businesses in every county in Ireland offering career opportunities across a range of skill levels. Whereas core values such as good service are essential, the industry has been profoundly affected by the information technology revolution, and that change will continue. Having a coherent tourism strategy and delivering on it is essential, as has been proposed in Deputy Upton's excellent document on the subject.

Equally, Ireland has natural advantages in areas such as clean technology and food. Our food sector is still too reliant on exporting goods with limited value added to the UK. We must see agriculture as Ireland's great raw material and develop our food industries accordingly. We need a whole of enterprise approach but we must also look in detail at specific sectors and how they perform.

The role of the industrial development agencies will be critical and we must encourage the agencies to take more risks, be prepared to fail and to take a longer view on where they put their resources, particularly in building up our presence in India and China. We need a network of enterprise support that covers firms of all sizes, including start-ups but also focusing on scale-ups. Ireland needs to do more to keep the companies that we develop and grow rather than getting a start-up to a certain size and then selling the company to a multinational. We need to look at providing more support to firms that are over the size limit to avail of support from country enterprise boards but which are not now getting support from Enterprise Ireland.

To create jobs, we must have investment in infrastructure, firms and people. Given the limits on resources, that investment will have to come in new ways and must be strategic. Labour's strategic investment bank will act as a source of investment finance for major projects and for companies. Even with the constraints on resources we must also prioritise investment in people, and we cannot stand by as 442,000 people are looking for work. We must make a national effort, including both public and private sectors, to offer educational, training and work experience opportunities to our people. Many are already highly educated but need experience. Some have been working but need to address educational needs. There is no "one size fits all" scheme that will deal with this need. What we need, as outlined in Labour's policy document Just the Job, is a range of schemes meeting a range of needs. This costs money but relatively small amounts. Our proposals would cost approximately €230 million in the short term but would save money because people will get off the dole queues more quickly.

Labour has been responsible in Opposition and we will be responsible in government. We opposed the banking guarantee because it handed the banks a blank cheque and we have been proven correct in doing so.

Comment on this

The Labour Party has not been proven correct. It has been proven completely wrong.

Comment on this

We opposed NAMA and we have been proven correct in doing so, just as we watch the developers continuing to enrich themselves through more tax breaks on interest they have not even paid. We supported the Government on the Lisbon treaty and we have supported the plan to bring down the deficit to 3% by 2014 because it is right that we send the signal to the world that a new Government will tackle the deficit.

Unfortunately, it has taken too long for Fianna Fáil to grudgingly acknowledge that commitment. We should be clear, as the Government is still less than forthcoming about the kind of basic information that should have been available weeks before this debate, regarding growth forecasts for next year and the years beyond, as well as figures on the adjustment to be made in 2011. We should also know details of how the Croke Park deal will reduce costs or of how the bank bailout is going to be reflected in the deficit target. This is all information that in other countries would be provided to parliament and to the public as a matter of course.

What I have outlined is an approach to budgetary policy that will allow us in a balanced and consistent way to start getting the deficit down. It will be an approximate 50-50 balance between taxation and spending and new approaches to current spending, capital spending and taxation. These are reforming measures that would allow us to make steady and consistent progress on the budget deficit while getting the country back on the road to recovery. It is on this basis that we can devise a credible plan for stability, growth and jobs.

Fianna Fáil has been in office for 13 years and it has left an enormous mess for the next Government to sort out. It has done so before but the scale of this disaster is unprecedented even for Fianna Fáil. Ireland is not the only country where an outgoing government has left a mess for an incoming government but it is surely the only country where the Opposition is asked to fix the problem while the Government that created it remains in office. This is a great country and we can sort out this problem. We can create jobs and growth but it is clear that will not happen until we have a strong and stable Government with a mandate from the people measured in years rather than months.

Comment on this
John Gormley Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government Green Party

I firmly believe it will be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for the Irish people to come through the coming few years of economic crisis without some form of common approach. We need some kind of consensus about how we are going to fix our economy. The Irish people have wearied of the blame game and are tired of bickering politicians who appear more interested in scoring points than addressing the significant problems faced by the Irish nation.

For more than a generation the Irish people have not been served by politics as usual. For a long time we have needed a new way of ordering our affairs. Now, as we face the biggest economic challenges in the State's history, we very urgently need to go beyond the short-term political party interests. We must identify common goals and frame a strategy to work towards them. As the leader of a smaller party which has fought an uphill struggle for three decades working in politics in this country, I know I am asking much when I say it but I am genuinely prepared to make common cause here.

Let us for a moment honestly identify a few simple facts. We have got into this position through fundamental errors which were made as far back as 1977 with the infamous give-away budget and election setting us on a course of auction politics, where politicians sought to outbid one another for voter support. It led us to accept bad planning as a fact of everyday life and in time we fell into a very poor system of financial regulation. It gave us endemic crony capitalism and the blurring of boundaries, which meant those in important jobs did not uphold the people's interest.

It is very sad to reflect now that we did not learn the lessons of the economic slump in the 1980s. That grim experience forced me, like tens of thousands of others, to leave this country to find work and should have taught us enough to put in place systems to ensure it would never happen again. We failed to learn one lesson from economic recession in the 1980s; the imperative to ensure it did not happen again. Are we now about to fail to learn an even more important lesson from that era? Are we about to repeat our failure to take tough, appropriate and timely action to deal with our problems? Are we about to relive the 1980s worst-of-all-worlds approach where we take half-hearted and belated measures which gave us lingering pain but no long-term remedy?

It is abundantly clear that we as politicians have also failed to take on board another more useful element from the 1980s experience. The noble stance adopted by the then Fine Gael leader, Alan Dukes, in 1987 was a once-off stab at consensus. He put aside short-term party interests so that the necessary tough policies could be implemented, although it was all too short-lived. In the macho world of Irish party politics, Alan Dukes's Tallaght strategy has all too often been derided as political weakness, and Fine Gael very recently acknowledged that the Tallaght strategy was good for the country but bad for Fine Gael. It must also be said that the other parties did not reciprocate Mr. Dukes's generosity of vision and short-term political goals remained central to Irish politics for the following two decades. They must take their share of blame here.

Most of the political parties — I say this without a hint of rancour — were part of this system and part of this malaise which has brought us to where we are today. Most parties joined in the auction bidding that characterised and were central to the 2002 and 2007 general elections, as parties sought to buy the voters' support with various incentives and blandishments. I do not remember anyone warning of an impending economic crash in the property price spiral. I do not recall anyone raising a flag about poor and inadequate financial regulation. I do not have any memory of anyone calling for root and branch reform of our planning system. Like the Green Party, many Members were not part of a Government which made errors in handling this country's affairs. However, most parties joined in propagating and institutionalising politics as usual. Politics as usual played a significant role in getting us to where we are. Just this week, the main political parties in Portugal engaged in negotiations on a common budgetary approach. These talks are proving very difficult, but they are taking place and we could learn a lot from a country and people first approach.

After weeks of deliberation and many long meetings, the Government has decided we need to bring in measures totalling €15 billion over the next four years. We must do that to meet the 2014 target to cut the budget deficit to 3% as agreed with the European Union. We have considered the arguments for extending this timescale. If we in the Green Party thought there was a benefit for the Irish people in that idea, we would have backed it, but we honestly and sincerely do not believe it is the correct thing to do. We believe it would replicate the 1980s experience, making the recession last much longer than it needs to.

I acknowledge the honesty that led Fine Gael and the Labour Party to agree the target and timescale to reduce the deficit. I further acknowledge their courage in maintaining that commitment despite recent calls for a change. However, I am determined that this is not enough. It is not enough to say that we must achieve that target without agreeing a basic roadmap to take us there. The figure of €15 billion is double the one set out in last year's budget but it will maintain the confidence of our EU partners and lenders on international money markets. This confidence is vital to our short-term and longer-term prosperity and it is crucial to our efforts to protect and reassert our independence.

The main reasons for this significant increase are the reality of lower economic growth prospects at home and abroad and the higher costs of paying interest on our debt. The Government must bring the deficit down to 3% of economic output by 2014 to come back in line with EU rules. I welcome the fact that the EU Monetary Affairs Commissioner, Olli Rehn, will be in Dublin early next month to discuss the four-year budgetary framework plan with the Opposition and the social partners. The Government intends to publish formally the four-year plan shortly after that.

The spending cuts and revenue raising measures needed will impact on peoples' living standards, but it is a matter of conviction for me that it is neither credible nor realistic to delay these measures. We must restore and maintain confidence in our ability to meet our obligations and responsibilities. We cannot repeat the experience of the 1980s and delay a return to sustainable growth and full employment in our economy. It is true that a significant front-loading of the €15 billion correction will be needed next year. We will continue to work with our Government partners in producing detailed plans which will be published in the middle of next month. We in the Green Party are working with two main imperatives in mind. First, there must be a balance in the measures to ensure that the economy is not unduly impaired in the medium to longer term. Second, spending cuts and revenue raising must be fair and impact most on those best able to bear the strain.

There is no denying that difficult choices have to be made, but the job of everybody in the House now is to get a budget that works and that gets Ireland out of the economic difficulties that it is in. The Green Party in government has managed to protect a number of key areas from the deepest spending cuts. We have reversed the education cuts, a key feature in the programme for Government and the reason that so many in my party endorsed it.

We protected actions taken to combat homelessness. In fact, we ensured extra spending in this area. Protecting the most vulnerable at home and abroad has to be priority and that is why the Green Party, as part of this Government, has protected overseas development aid. We have also recognised that the creativity of the Irish people is undoubtedly our greatest asset and that is why we have protected the arts. This is an investment that leads to sustainable growth, particularly when linked to tourism opportunities.

Our job is to get us out of this crisis and plan for the recovery which will be green. That is why we are protecting investments in modern public transport and environmental infrastructure. This is what we have done thus far and we intend to stick to this path. As I have said, I realise only too well that the adjustment required is painful and indeed may seem right now to be overwhelming. I am also aware of the difficulties of persuading people of its necessity when trust in the political system has broken down. That trust has to be restored. It can only be done through fundamental change to the business of politics.

We cannot and we will not tolerate the status quo. We need to see changes to ministerial transport, the salaries and expenses of Deputies and Senators and the working times and productivity of the Oireachtas. Members of the public are also justifiably angry about what they perceive as the inequality of treatment for white collar criminals in this country. My party has always said that this is intolerable and the Government needs to show purpose in this regard.

No Government Department will be immune from cutbacks and other changes, but in the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government over the past two years of major challenge, we have maintained a strategic focus on supporting economic recovery and assisting those in need of support. Focus has been kept on sustainable economic development. As a party which has a fair proportion of people who run their own businesses, we understand the need to keep the rates base low for those in business and the Government has done this. The Taoiseach has convened meetings on the issue and we understand the need to continue with the policy because many people in small businesses are feeling the strain.

My Department is now finalising proposals to give effect to the commitment in the renewed programme for Government to introduce charges for water services. We intend doing this in a way that is fair, significantly reduces waste and is easily applied. The installation of water meters in households connected to public supplies will encourage householders to conserve water and will result in savings in the significant operational costs faced by local authorities in providing water and waste water services. It will also complement the significant increases in investment on water conservation measures in the water services investment programme 2010-12 which I announced earlier this year. I am proud to say that, even in these straitened times, this programme brings a fivefold increase in funding for conservation measures to €320 million.

The roll-out of meters to more than one million homes around the country will require significant resources and I will be analysing the various options to ensure the delivery of the metering programme in the most cost-effective manner. A number of funding options are being considered and the achievement of value for money will be a key factor in determining the approach to be taken. The programme will also provide a very significant job creation opportunity in the construction sector. It is estimated that every €1 million euro per year spent on installing water meters will provide employment for a minimum of ten people. The metering programme will take a number of years to complete, but every effort will be made to complete it in as short a time as possible. My aim is to ensure that, once meter installation commences next year, we will have a significant proportion of the programme completed in two to three years.

Also regarding water services, we have made available over €1.5 billion since 2008 and with this investment much has been achieved. In 2009, for example, we saw completion of 40 major water and wastewater schemes, with 108 other major schemes under way at year's end. In the period 2000 to 2009, we added the equivalent of over 1 million population to the capacity of water treatment systems and the equivalent of 3.7 million population in wastewater treatment capacity. This high level of expenditure reflects our commitment to protecting our water resources, meeting EU standards and putting critical infrastructure in place to support development and jobs.

In the housing area, we have made available a budget of over €4 billion since 2008 to spend on a range of measures. This reflects the high importance the Government attaches, in difficult times, to the provision of social housing and meeting the needs of homeless people and other vulnerable groups requiring housing support. Our strategy has been to maintain output through more flexible approaches, and to prioritise the most vulnerable and disadvantaged. We are shifting away from new build projects and towards initiatives such as leasing and the rental accommodation scheme. Available capital funding is increasingly targeted at special needs housing and improving the environmental performance of our housing stock.

We have also maintained a high level of ambition for local authority regeneration and improvement works in some of the most disadvantaged and neglected areas of the country, aimed at helping to replace failed estates with vibrant, sustainable communities. Nearly €200 million is being provided for this purpose in 2010 alone. Major improvement in recycling performance can be seen in the fact that the latest available statistics, for 2008, show the municipal waste recovery rate at 37.5%, 65% of our packaging waste is being recycled and 9 kg per capita of household electrical and electronic waste is being collected. All of these figures exceed European and national requirements.

My Department has also introduced a range of policy measures to help better target Exchequer investment and facilitate economic recovery. The national spatial strategy update and outlook sets out a revised implementation framework aimed at maximising the spatial planning and regional contribution to economic recovery, long-term national competitiveness and sustainability. A key element in the Planning Act 2010 is the introduction of a requirement for an evidence-based core strategy in development plans. The location, quantum and phasing of proposed development must be shown as well as growth scenarios, details of transport plans, retail development and policies regarding development in rural areas. This requirement will help target scarce Exchequer resources on sustainable economic development. We introduced this legislation to ensure we will never go back to those dark days of overzoning and ensure that we learn from the severe lessons of the past.

The multi-agency local government-led county development boards, CDBs, have established economic development sub-committees, made up of representatives from FÁS, Enterprise Ireland, the IDA and local business interests including chambers of commerce, to develop and co-ordinate economic plans and strategies for their areas. When required, they also act as the local-based inter-agency task force constituted in response to significant issues in the area and to provide a focal point for economic promotion of the county. I have agreed that these sub-committee will also operate as a business users forum in each county and city.

The CDBs also work closely with business support units or similar arrangements which have been put in place in all county and city councils at my instigation to act as a point of contact to ensure quick co-ordinated responses to businesses from local authorities in areas such as planning, water and roads. In this way, business interests will have the opportunity to discuss issues with a range of relevant bodies including the local authorities. The units provide assistance to individuals and businesses seeking advice and direction on business start-up and expansion and signpost them to the most appropriate organisations to ensure they get the necessary support.

Despite the very obvious difficulties, there have been significant achievements in recent years and these should be acknowledged. They give us confidence that even with the challenges we now face we can meet the objectives we have set. Ultimately, this work will also help set the country on the path to long-term sustainable growth but in the immediate term we have to face the challenges of completing the four-year programme and the budget for 2011. We in this House need to make common cause in facing these challenges. Unfortunately, to judge by some of the debate so far, it is adversarial politics as usual and sometimes these debates can produce more heat than light.

In this time of crisis we need to move beyond business as usual politics. We are far more likely to beat this recession earlier and better with some form of cross-party approach in the actions we must take. I have not given up hope of getting something moving in this direction. I state to the parties opposite in all sincerity that huge changes will be made in the coming years. They may well be in government and find the choices they have to make are extremely unpalatable. They may and will argue that they are in the national interest but if we have politics as usual those challenges will be extreme and it will be extremely difficult to implement. This is why I continue to ask for some form of consensual approach.

Comment on this

Sinn Féin stands as the real opposition in this debate. Deputy John Gormley's call for talks between party leaders and all that followed served one very useful purpose; it cleared away the smokescreen of false party rivalry and exposed the alignment that exists in Irish politics. It is now very clear that Fianna Fáil, the Green Party, Fine Gael and the Labour Party stand together in their economic approach. They form a consensus for cuts. Sinn Féin stands apart from that consensus for cuts but we do not stand alone. The Irish Congress of Trade Unions and its constituent unions, the community and voluntary sector, the ESRI and a range of economists have warned against the strategy of attempting to cut the budget deficit to 3% by 2014.

Sinn Féin joins with those seeking real recovery and a fair way forward and we are convinced that there is a better way. We recognise that the deficit caused by the disastrous policies of the Government has to be reduced. However, the plan to reduce it by 2014 by imposing savage cuts to front line services and social supports will be hugely damaging. It will further deflate the economy and worsen the recession. Furthermore, the approach the Government is taking in its four year plan of front line and capital spending cuts as well as flat regressive taxes is the same approach it has taken up to now and it has not worked. Deepening the cuts will only compound the problem.

We need a different strategy and a longer timeframe. We want a realistic deficit reduction strategy based on a fair taxation system that ensures the wealthy pay their share, on investment in jobs which will increase State revenue and reduce the social welfare bill, and on the elimination of wasteful public spending. Our approach is based on the reality that there is wealth in the State and that 1% of the population controls 20% of that wealth. If that inequality had been addressed a decade ago we would not now be in recession. It is possible to reduce the deficit to 3% over a longer timeframe, provide real stimulus for jobs in the short term, raise revenue from wealth, eliminate wasteful public spending and ensure the delivery of public services while protecting those on low income.

The Minister for Health and Children has threatened cuts to our public health services of between €600 million and €1 billion. Our health services face devastation if this is allowed to proceed. I have no doubt that cuts to services on this scale, especially as they affect our public acute hospitals will cost lives. In Sinn Féin's pre-budget submission we identify €600 million that can be saved in the health system without affecting patient care. Take the drugs bill for example; tackling profiteering, waste and over-prescription and increasing the use of generic drugs can make huge savings. However, what is the Government's approach? It is to target the patients, such as those on the medical cards who had prescription charges imposed on them.

The report of the Comptroller and the Auditor General earlier this year on the National Treatment Purchase Fund, NTPF, exposed the waste that is involved there. It stated that of the procedures performed in public hospitals in some cases the patient was treated privately in the same hospital where he or she had been on a public waiting list. Even more extraordinary, and surely a conflict of interest, is that in 8.5% of treatments arranged by the NTPF, the consultant referring and treating the patient is the same. In other words, in a public hospital a specialist can refer a patient under the NTPF to himself or herself, thus ensuring the consultant a higher rate of remuneration for the work because it is being done so-called "privately" even though the State pays the bill. This surely exposes the folly and waste that is the NTPF.

In a reply to a Dáil question received from the HSE last week, I was told that to date a total of 296 hospital consultants had been written to by clinical directors and hospital managers regarding the need for them to address excessive levels of private practice. These excessive levels are of course in breach of their contract. This is only the number of consultants that hospital management has detected. Here is another indication of the massive waste of public money involved in the two-tier public-private hospital system. In another reply, the HSE admits that in Carlow it is paying rent of €1,000 per day to a private landlord for a primary care centre rather than develop the centre rent-free on an existing HSE site in the town. The reason for this expenditure is purely ideological; it is because developing the centre on HSE premises would not be in line with the Government's policy of developing all new primary care centres through public-private partnerships, even if these cost more than the fully public method. Sinn Féin has demonstrated that elimination of waste and delivery of equity and efficiency can go hand in hand. We will set out our proposals in detail in our pre-budget submission next week and my colleague, Deputy Arthur Morgan, will refer to them further in his contribution to this debate.

The enormity of what has been done to this economy by the reckless policies of the past decade and a half is difficult to grasp. Yet the stark reality is that Fianna Fáil and the Greens have brought the country close to economic ruin since 2007, their so-called solutions having made the situation worse. They have introduced four successive budgets, as well as emergency measures in February 2009, and the result is as follows — a total of 450,000 people are now out of work; a total of 100,000 more will have emigrated by next year; tax revenues have collapsed; almost €90 billion between recapitalisation and NAMA has been promised to bail out the banks; the interest rates being paid by the Irish Government on the international bond market are three times those paid by Germany.

This Government is planning a budget in December that will attack people on low incomes and devastate vital public services. The Government has decided that someone who earns €300,000 a year contributes enough but a person on the minimum wage, or someone who has lost his or her job and is receiving €196 a week, must survive on less.

The Government has signed up to a four-year timeframe for deficit reduction which it knows it cannot meet and which the IMF, OECD and ESRI, know it will not meet. Fine Gael and Labour have once again followed the Government's lead, just as they did in the general election in 2007 when they, too, offered to cut taxes and just as they did in the Lisbon referendum in 2009 when they promised there would be jobs if people voted "Yes" to Lisbon.

This is not just a question of the 3% by 2014 target being too short in time; it is also about how the Government proposes to go about reaching that target. It is preparing a slash and burn approach to the economy that will cause untold damage. It will attack the least well off but it will also attack the overall economy and delay recovery. The consensus for cuts parties are determined to plough on, tying this State's future to a formula brokered with the EU Central Bank, regardless of the consequences. It is no coincidence that these are the same parties who campaigned for a "Yes" vote in the second Lisbon treaty referendum, having refused to implement the people's decision to reject that treaty when first put to them. In Lisbon Two they urged the people to, "Vote Yes for Jobs". We ask where are those jobs as we contemplate the reality of over 450,000 people on the dole queues and emigration on the rise. Those young people forced to emigrate, the hundreds of thousands unemployed and the people struggling on low incomes are ill-served by the capitulation of the so-called main Opposition parties. Slash and burn and all will be well by 2014 is the new mantra and anyone who does not accept it is being labelled as economically insane.

Sinn Féin was labelled as economically illiterate in 2007. Yet, had our policies been taken on board in 2007 and before it, we would not now be in the depths of this recession. Alone among the political parties in this Dáil, we did not call for tax cuts. We called for Government housing policy to be based on the need for decent housing for all the people, not a policy of inflating the property bubble. We called for wealth to be shared on the basis of a fair taxation system. We called for the banks to serve the economy and the customer and for the unbridled greed of financial institutions to be curbed by Government. Fianna Fáil-led Governments pursued exactly the opposite policies, driven by greed and totally devoid of any real vision for the future of the Irish people.

When we spoke of a golden circle we were derided but such a golden circle existed and what we have found out since shows that we and others actually underestimated the extent of the corruption and the avarice at the top of the ladder in this economy. The so-called regulators were in collusion with the bankers and developers. Ministers and top civil servants allowed it all to go on unhindered. The elite executives at the top of the public service and the semi-State companies were awarded massive salaries and perks on a par with the high-flyers in the private sector. Auditing and accountancy firms played their part and profited handsomely by it. What has changed? In many ways, very little. I will give one concrete example. Loan valuation for NAMA is being carried out by Ernst and Young. Last April in the Dáil I raised this issue with the Minister for Finance. Ernst and Young was the auditing firm for Anglo Irish Bank when accounts were published in February 2009. That report effectively gave Anglo Irish Bank a clean bill of health, yet we now know that the 2008 year-end figures included cash that had been transferred from Permanent TSB. We know that directors' loans were concealed and loans were given to shareholders to buy more shares. Loans were also given to directors, senior executive members of Anglo Irish Bank, to buy more shares, yet none of those matters was exposed in the end-of-year accounts presented by Ernst and Young. KPMG is now audit co-ordinator for NAMA. KPMG audited Irish Nationwide. Its 2008 results, announced in April 2009, showed a pre-tax profit of €300 million after having set aside €500 million for bad debts. In April it was confirmed that Irish Nationwide required €2.6 billion in funds from the Exchequer, a mere 11 months after KPMG gave it a clean bill of health. I asked the Minister for Finance at that time how it came about that these firms got the top contracts for NAMA, given the questionable role they played in presenting figures allegedly as facts when we now know they were nothing of the kind. I asked if those auditing and accountancy firms were being investigated for their specific roles in what some would suggest was an orchestrated cover up of the facts on those financial institutions.

The Minister replied that the questions raised by me were legitimate and that he would ask NAMA to examine what I said about the professional advice involved. He said the matters to which I referred are serious and will require investigation both by the accountancy bodies and the banking inquiry. Where stand those investigations now? If the situation were not so serious it would be amusing to listen to the Taoiseach and his Ministers talking about the need for us to preserve our economic sovereignty. Whenever we in Sinn Féin pointed to the erosion of economic sovereignty as a result of successive EU treaties, we were ridiculed.

Successive Governments have abandoned economic sovereignty. They have allowed international bondholders and the European Central Bank to determine how many euro go into the pockets of the least well-off in our society. We should not doubt that it comes down to that. In the last budget the Government, which is tied to a doctrine of fiscal rectitude, took €8.50 per week from the pockets of those who care for elderly, ill or disabled relatives in their homes. It halved the level of assistance given to the young unemployed. It took the Christmas bonus from social welfare recipients and cut welfare payments across the board.

Fitch Ratings recently called for more evictions in Ireland in order to enhance the reputation of the banks. This is what happened when we had landlord rule under the Union Jack. It is only one step removed from what the Government is doing to the least well-off. Far worse is planned in the next four budgets. I put it to the Minister for Finance last week that international bondholders are now more important than the Irish people in the consideration of this Government. The Minister indicated in May that he could not say who the bondholders are; I have a list of 80 possible suspects. I cited a number of them on the floor of this House last week. They include Alliance Global Investors France SA, Barclays Wealth Managers France, BlueBay Asset Management Limited, BNP Paribas Asset Management, Brown Shipley & Co. Limited, Credit Suisse Asset Management, Deutsche Asset Management Investmentgesellschaft, European Credit Management Limited, Frankfurt-Trust Investment, W & W Asset Management and WGZ Asset Bank Luxembourg.

I understand that this list of 80 suspects contains Anglo Irish Bank bondholders, and that the composite figure of the face value of the bonds they hold exceeds €4 billion. These people, rather than ordinary taxpayers, should have taken the hit from the collapse of Anglo Irish Bank. The Minister replied that many of them are also subscribers to Irish Government bonds. We rely on them for the Government's massive borrowings. I understand that Goldman Sachs, which advises the Government on its approach to bondholders, also appears on the list of Anglo Irish Bank bondholders. The next time Mr. Peter Sutherland, who is the chairman of Goldman Sachs International, descends on us from the clouds to give his advice, perhaps reporters from RTE and The Irish Times will ask him about the conflict of interest that is certainly involved. In the meantime, the Minister might like to address this conflict of interest in his contribution at the end of this discussion. The bondholders invested in a bank and not in a state. They should have read the disclaimer at the bottom of bank advertisements, which we all know off by heart. It states the value of one’s investment may go down as well as up. What part of that did they not understand?

The budget plan that the Government is working on has nothing to do with deficit reduction. For every cent that is cut from front line services next year, at least 10 cent will be redirected into the Government's bank bailout. If spending cuts could fix the deficit problem, we would not have a growing deficit. What has happened after we had three years of spending cuts? The deficit has grown. The Government, with the support of Fine Gael and Labour, is planning a savage four-year timeframe in which to fix the deficit problem. Sinn Féin is advocating a different six-year approach which could see the economy recover sooner. The consensus for cuts believes that to grow a little, one must cut a lot. We believe that to grow at all, one must invest. The relationship between jobs and the deficit is a clear one. If more people are in work, more tax is brought in and fewer welfare payments have to go out. It does not take a genius to work out that reductions in expenditure put people out of work, bring the tax take down and increase welfare spending.

The policy of cutting social welfare is a false economy that ultimately causes misery for those on the receiving end. People on social welfare spend every cent of their income in the local economy. If one cuts their welfare, one inflicts cuts on the local economy. Rather than targeting welfare, the Government should target wealth. It has been estimated that there are approximately 33,000 millionaires in this State. In the five years since 2005, they have been the main beneficiaries of approximately €20 billion as a result of tax break schemes introduced by Governments led by Fianna Fáil. The schemes in question include tax relief on pensions, a myriad of property tax reliefs, reliefs on private nursing homes and hospitals, capital allowances and the PRSI ceiling. On 17 October last, Dr. Michael Collins, who is a member of the Commission on Taxation, reiterated that 110 of these tax breaks are still in place and are costing the public purse €11 billion per annum. If this millionaire section of the Irish people paid a 1% wealth tax, the Government could receive €1.2 billion in 2011 and every year thereafter.

We believe that the parties of the left should be joining trade unionists, those involved in community and voluntary organisations and other progressive voices in demanding an alternative way forward. We are calling for the abandonment of the unrealistic and damaging target of 3% deficit reduction by 2014. We want revenue saving and raising to be based on fairness and efficiency. We demand stimulus measures to protect and create jobs. Vital front line public services, including health, education and social supports, should be supported. I thank the Minister for the Environment, Heritage and Local Government and the Minister of State with responsibility for children for staying to hear my contribution. I hope they will heed some of the arguments I have presented this morning. A consensus for real recovery is needed now more than at any time in our shared political experience as elected voices. We do not need a conspiracy of political parties against the people.

Comment on this
Brian Lenihan Minister for Finance Fianna Fáil

In the past two years, this Government has had to deal with the consequences of the most severe economic downturn in the history of the State. The crisis has primarily related to the public finances and the banking system. In a consistent way, the Government has acted swiftly and with determination to deal with each episode of the crisis as it emerged.

As a result of these actions, stability is being restored to the banking system, economic growth has resumed, albeit on a limited basis, and the economy has regained a considerable amount of the competitiveness it had lost. Notwithstanding these favourable trends, the interest demanded on Irish debt has risen and is set to remain high unless further decisive and credible action is taken soon to stabilise the public finances and establish the basis for sound economic growth for the years ahead.

The impact of the economic downturn has been severe. In the past two years, 2008 and 2009, gross national product per head is estimated to have fallen by more than 16%. Despite the severity of the downturn, however, I do not want to be negative about the economy because although last month's quarterly national accounts data were somewhat disappointing, they were not so in a uniform manner. For example, the quarterly GDP decline of 1.2% comes on the back of a very strong increase of 2.2% in the first quarter of the year, which essentially indicates that the level of economic activity has stabilised in the first half of the year.

The quarterly figures also point towards a bottoming out of gross national product, which is the most appropriate measure of Irish living standards. Gross national product fell by just 0.3% in the second quarter, a considerable improvement on the fall of nearly 11% last year. In summary, the national accounts figures for the first half of this year point to stabilisation as a prelude to growth.

The latest information on labour market trends also provides evidence of stabilisation. The Quarterly National Household Survey for the second quarter of this year showed that the downward trend in employment is slowing rapidly and that in some sectors the underlying trend has become positive. Even in unemployment, the latest figures point to stabilisation; in September the unadjusted live register fell by a record figure, and there was also a substantial fall when account was taken of seasonal factors.

In addition, the data confirmed another strong export performance in the second quarter of this year following a good performance in the first three months. This is encouraging. It is clear evidence that the improvements in competitiveness in recent years are having the desired effect. An especially welcome feature of the export figures was that they showed a broadening of our export performance, with strong growth recorded across a number of sectors.

Although the latest economic indicators point to a resumption of economic growth, this growth will — initially at least — depend on exports and will be at a modest pace because investment and consumption will take some further time to recover. We cannot rely on economic growth alone to stabilise the public finances in the short to medium term. In fact, and this is the key point, there is a structural gap in our public finances and without concerted action we will not repair the deficit and that would mean a continued drain on economic growth.

The impact to date of the downturn in growth on the public finances has been drastic. Despite the considerable efforts of the Government in the course of the last two years to bring stability to the public finances, additional and even serious adjustment measures are still needed over the next four years. A few figures will help to explain why so much adjustment is needed. Total current public expenditure increased by almost 150% in the period 2000-2010, with a near tripling in expenditure in the social protection and health areas as well as major increases in the education area. Over the same period the economy only grew by 40%, while consumer prices increased by just under 28%. Having recognised at an early stage in the downturn that action was needed to deal with the public finances, the Government has been engaged in a process of significant re-prioritisation and consolidation of all areas of expenditure since 2008. The measures introduced have reduced all aspects of Government spending, including public service pay and operating costs across Departments and State bodies. As a result, annual growth in public expenditure has fallen from 12.1% in 2007 to an estimated contraction of 1.8% this year. This major consolidation has been achieved in the face of significant pressures associated with rising numbers on the live register, increasing debt interest payments and a downturn in the economic cycle. This process of expenditure realignment has not been painless and has required a wide range of sometimes unpopular, but necessary, actions by the Government.

Ireland is now into the third year of a multi-annual consolidation period, and the Government is busily making preparations for the four year plan. It may be useful to recap the main initiatives undertaken by the Government over the past few years.

Shortly after coming into office, I put a range of efficiency and savings measures into effect in July 2008, including those identified as a result of the efficiency review process initiated by my predecessor in budget 2008. These savings included a 3% reduction in payroll costs for all Departments, State agencies and local authorities other than front line health and education services and a 50% reduction in expenditure on consultancies, advertising and public relations by Departments and agencies.

Budget 2009, which was brought forward to October of 2008, continued the objective of continuing to restore the sustainability of the public finances. A significant tax package to raise almost €2 billion in 2009 was introduced. I also announced the setting up of the special group on public service numbers and expenditure programmes in November of 2008 with a remit to identify potential savings in all areas of Government expenditure, including a thorough reduction in the number of staff working in the public service.

By the start of 2009, international forecasts for the global economy had been revised sharply downwards, reflecting the effects of the worldwide upheavals in the financial markets. In this context, the Government set out a multi-annual fiscal plan in January 2009, with the objective of bringing the overall deficit back within the 3% ceiling in a credible manner. That plan remains in effect today, and our subsequent policy actions have been designed to implement and to underpin our consolidation drive.

Accordingly, further programme and payroll savings of the order of €3.5 billion were announced in the first half of 2009. The main element of the February package of measures was the introduction of public service pension-related pay deduction. Additional capital and efficiency measures were also announced, including a 25% reduction in the rates of the domestic travel and subsistence allowances, and an 8% reduction in fees paid for professional services. The supplementary budget in April 2009 continued the process begun by these earlier measures, consolidating the expenditure reductions through a range of programme savings.

Budget 2010 continued the process of implementing a multi-annual plan, with an expenditure reduction of €4 billion delivered. This was achieved through a combination of payroll, social welfare and other programme reductions, reflecting the sharp fall in the price levels across the economy over the course of the year. The special group report, published in July 2009, has been a central point of reference in the Government's consideration of overall expenditure strategy in budget 2010, with savings of some €2.1 billion in 2010 arising from the report to date.

No doubt the Government has had to take some difficult measures in order to stabilise our budgetary position. Nonetheless, we are still well aware that it is vital for us to continue to invest in key infrastructure so that we can best position ourselves to take full advantage of the economic recovery.

Despite our straitened budgetary circumstances, the capital allocation for 2010 amounts to almost €6.5 million or 5% of GNP, which is very high by international standards. While it is inevitable that further adjustments in the capital allocations are now required, I still expect Exchequer capital investment to remain at a significant level and be a key source of infrastructural investment in this economy. This Exchequer capital programme will be supplemented by projects part-funded by private investment in the PPP programme and by the investment programmes of the commercial State-sponsored bodies.

Notwithstanding a scaling back of the investment programme, which will build on the high level of public sector investment which has taken place over the past decade, it still represents a major ongoing stimulus to the economy. The Government is determined that, in addition to scaling back on expenditure as necessary for fiscal correction, we continue to build the economic capacity for strong growth, to take full advantage of the recovery as and when it gathers strength. Government capital investment will, therefore, support those projects which will help the development of a productive and internationally competitive economy; the development of the smart/green economy; support sustainable long-term employment; and provide a modern social infrastructure.

Evidence that the Government's efforts to stabilise the public finances are now having a positive impact was provided by the most recent Exchequer returns of revenue and expenditure, covering the period to the end of September. These figures show that the overall Exchequer position is in line with target. Encouragingly, total tax revenue is exactly in line with profile, expenditure is approximately €1.6 billion down year-on-year and the underlying general Government deficit this year is expected to be in line with the budget target; in other words, after experiencing an unprecedented shock to the economy we have stabilised the public finances. The second phase of our task is to build on the measures we have taken, narrow the gap between day to day spending and what we earn and therefore bring longer-term sustainability to the public finances over the next few years.

Notwithstanding these encouraging figures, the position remains serious and a few crucial details clearly demonstrate why we need to change the path of the public finances. At the end of 2007, total national debt was only 23% of GNP and the Exchequer deficit in that year was only 1% of GNP. By contrast, in 2010, we expect revenues will be €35 billion and net expenditure is likely to be €54 billion, leaving a gap to be filled by borrowing of €19 billion — an average of over €4,200 for every man, woman and child in the country. As a result an underlying general Government deficit of 11.9% of GDP is expected this year.

On a purely headline basis, the general Government deficit this year will be extremely high — currently estimated at 32% of GDP. This is due to the accounting treatment of capital support being provided to some of the financial institutions. However, it should be stressed that no additional borrowing is required this year as a result of this large headline deficit and the Exchequer is already fully funded through the first half of 2011. In addition, the funding costs of the capital support are being spread out over the next ten or so years, thereby lessening the impact on the Exchequer and they are manageable in that context.

While these costs are manageable, the overall position is that the debt to GNP ratio is estimated to be 75% at the end of this year. With high interest rates, the annual interest bill is big and is getting bigger. If we were to allow this trend to continue, it would not be long before we were at debt levels last seen in the 1980s which, as we all remember, well exceeded 100% of GDP. This time, unlike in the 1980s, while we benefit from being a member of a strong global currency, the euro, we cannot unilaterally devalue. Furthermore, the prospect for strong global growth is mixed, inflation is low and, above all, the indulgence of the markets to build our rapid build up of debt levels is not available.

While substantial progress has been made in tackling our public finance difficulties, the Government is fully aware that the scale and speed of the deterioration in the public finances mean we have to make considerable adjustments now in order that we will not have to make even bigger ones later. We remain fully committed to reducing the general Government deficit to below 3% of GDP by the end of 2014. This means we have to take many essential decisions. Despite the scale and urgency of the necessary adjustments that have to be made, however, Irish people will still hold on to most of the gains built up in the many years of strong growth we have enjoyed since the mid-1990s. Over that period, we took many steps forward; we are now taking only one step back. Also, and most important, despite the urgent need for large-scale adjustments to the public finances, the Government is going about making these decisions to ensure they will be fair and will enhance the economy's growth prospects.

I have made officials from my Department available to the finance spokespersons of all the parties across the floor to explain to them and some of their colleagues the current macroeconomic position and the prospects and scale of the adjustment that needs to be made to the public finances over the next four years. I am pleased with the response from the main Opposition parties to this series of meetings in that they share with the Government a recognition of the scale of the adjustment that needs to be made, even if we do not have a shared view of the specific actions needed to achieve this adjustment. The first series of meetings on 18 October was followed by another meeting yesterday and I expect my officials and I will be available to Opposition parties between now and budget 2011.

Deputy Gilmore made a number of points this morning to which I would like to reply. However, in the time available I can address only a few of them. The Deputy makes the general point that insufficient figures have been provided to him by my Department and that the Government's proposals lack credibility. At this point, I can only reply that he will be provided with all the figures he could reasonably want when these have been finalised. I can also guarantee one thing about the Government's four year plan; it will not lack credibility.

On a more specific point, Deputy Gilmore cites a recent report identifying a claimed €11 billion of tax expenditures. More than 90% of these tax expenditures are the tax allowances from which all taxpayers benefit, such as the PAYE credit and basic income tax credits. It does not serve public debate well to misrepresent the basic PAYE credit or credits available to income taxpayers as in some way a tax shelter enjoyed by the very rich when they are a basic entitlement of every taxpayer.

Deputy Gilmore proposes the introduction of a 48% income tax rate. It should be borne in mind that such an increase would raise only €410 million in the next year. One of the great advantages of the multi-annual, four year plan approach is that one projects tax revenues over a four year period. If one thing is abundantly clear, it is that a 48% tax rate, in addition to the current levy and PRSI systems, would effectively mean an effective marginal tax rate of 62%, which would lead to a reduction in tax receipts in the subsequent years of the plan. The initial figure of €410 million would decline over the four year period as higher income tax earners, faced with income tax and impositions of tax from the State in excess of 60%, flee the jurisdiction. Deputy Gilmore needs to face reality when he claims that the deficit target of 3% can be met without examining any tax increases on incomes under €100,000.

A proposal for a strategic investment bank was referred to again. It is unclear from where the funding for such a bank would come. While the capital is to come from the National Pensions Reserve Fund, it is unclear from where the funds would come. In essence, the bank would compete with our two established banks and the State for increasingly scarce funding. The cost of borrowing to the State, as a sovereign, is at a very high level, while the cost of borrowing for the banks is at a higher level. The strategic investment bank, once capitalised, would face the same difficulty the banks and State already face. Every euro the bank would attract would mean one less euro for existing banks and the State which must now borrow €2 in every €5 spent on providing our public services. It makes little sense for the State to set up a new bank to perform the functions we are now correctly demanding of Bank of Ireland and Allied Irish Banks in return for the support given to these institutions by the taxpayer.

I will now address the proposed four year plan. The urgency, scale and duration of the adjustments required to stabilise the public finances demand a response that matches this challenge. It is vital that this response shows we have a clear, credible path for doing so. This response will be presented in the Government's four year growth and budget plan, which will be published in the next few weeks and presented to Dáil Éireann.

Yesterday, I announced the Government's decision that to achieve the 3% of GDP deficit target by 2014, an overall adjustment of €15 billion is now warranted and this figure will underpin the four year plan. The focus of the Government at this stage is on finalising the size of the necessary adjustment for 2011. The Government is conscious of the need to strike an appropriate balance between continuing to bring order to the public finances while, at the same time, taking account of the economic impact of budgetary adjustment. However, as I stated, there needs to be a significant element of front-loading in the 2011 budget given the scale of the adjustments.

In broad terms the plan will set out clearly the revised annual headline targets and necessary adjustments to adhere to a credible deficit reduction plan in the medium term. It will take on board the most up-to-date economic and fiscal data and the implications for the fiscal process. It will also chart the path of the economy and public finances towards recovery over the years 2011 to 2014. To underline the strength of our resolve, budget 2011 will contain a significant consolidation effort and the size of this, as well as the distribution of the adjustments over the remaining three years, will be also presented in the plan.

The plan will show in a detailed and credible manner how we can correct the imbalances in the public finances, while showing a pathway to sustainable increases in living standards and demonstrating to the markets that we have the vision and capacity to address our public finances problems and resume economic growth. As part of the budgetary plan, we will set out a strategy for underpinning and encouraging sustainable economic and employment growth in the medium term.

It is only through adopting policies that enhance our economic growth and job creation prospects and improve our competitiveness that we will achieve the necessary targets. To ensure the fiscal targets we set are delivered the four year plan will also feature reforms to the budgetary framework. I thank the Opposition parties for their participation at the Joint Committee on Finance and the Public Service on the proposed budgetary framework. I understand the joint committee is finalising its deliberations on that subject and look forward to receiving its report in that regard.

While the details of the plan have not yet been finalised, I can at this stage outline what I envisage it will contain. To begin with, the plan will outline the current economic position and outlook and explain why the necessary budgetary adjustments have to be made. This will be followed by a statement of the economic growth strategy, fiscal targets, details of the expenditure and tax adjustments as well as a statement of the principles that will underpin these adjustments. It will also include a review mechanism which can make adjustments to the plan as circumstances change.

An important element of the plan will focus on structural reform. This is an issue that has not received the attention it merits in recent years because of the need to deal with more imperative matters. Structural reform is about making the economy — both the private and public sectors — work better. It is not only about dealing with macroeconomic imbalances. It is not enough to sort out the public finances and leave untouched the way the economy works, particularly, as is evident, when it is in need of change. We, therefore, have to take action to ensure our policies support the restructuring of the economy in the wake of the present crisis. We have to ensure no sector will be a drag on economic growth, competitiveness will be maximised and that which is under the direct control of the Government — our tax system, public expenditure programmes, budgetary procedures and public services generally — will be reconfigured to achieve optimal efficiency, economy and effectiveness.

Structural reform measures often take several years to have full effect but announcing a set of wide-ranging structural reforms in the four year plan will have the immediate effect of adding further credibility to the macroeconomic and budgetary framework it will contain.

In the context of structural reforms, it is also relevant to mention that on 12 November next Ireland will submit an initial draft of its national reform programme under the EU 2020 strategy to the European Commission. This draft, which will be considerably influenced by the four-year plan, will contain the set of key structural reforms which can be implemented most quickly and which will address the main obstacles to economic growth. The final and more detailed plan will be submitted to the Commission in the spring of next year.

Being a member of the European Union has benefits but also involves responsibilities. The Government takes these responsibilities seriously and, accordingly, I have made considerable efforts to brief my fellow EU Ministers, as well as the Commission and the European Central Bank, on significant developments regarding our budgetary plans. Last Monday I visited Brussels to update Commissioner Rehn on the current economic position and on the progress being made in the preparations for budget 2011. As a result of these contacts with my colleagues, I am confident that they all have a clear and detailed understanding of Ireland's position and what the Government intends to do about it. The endorsement of the European Union Ministers, the Commission and the European Central Bank will be of key importance in demonstrating to the markets the soundness and credibility of our plan.

The language used in debating issues related to economics and public finances is often perceived by the public as lacking clarity, directness and impact. I wish to state the Government's position on its budgetary plans simply and as follows. The cost of the public services that we have been using is far higher than our current tax revenues. Economic growth will not on its own deliver sufficient revenue to close the gap for some years to come. This means that the difference between what we are spending and what we collect in revenue must be borrowed. The cost of borrowing is high and rising and unless we act soon to live within our means, those from whom we borrow may stop lending to us. Were this to happen, the continued provision of an adequate range of public services and social supports would be impossible to guarantee. Therefore, we must accept cuts in public expenditure and higher taxes. Even though these measures will be painful, we will continue to enjoy most of the substantial increases in living standards that were gained and secured in the past decade and they will provide the basis for regaining what we have temporarily lost.

There are those who, although they accept that strong corrective action must be taken to deal with the public finances, have argued that such action does not have to be taken now. Instead, they argue that it would be easier to put off the hard decisions which this action involves until economic growth has become established. There is, however, no better time than now to act. If we delay action, the problems will not only remain but will worsen and the necessary decisions will become harder to make and will have a more painful impact. Moreover, we will not fool the markets for an instant if we seek to defer any longer what evidently needs to be done now. We cannot backtrack on the commitments we have made to the European Commission and to the other European Union member states. In summary, in the real world in which we live, it is neither a credible nor a viable choice to defer the action that we now must take.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his speech and for his courtesy when my colleagues and I visited his Department yesterday. The Minister is always very courteous and easy to deal with and I thank him for this. Things are very bad and people are very down and depressed. When I went knocking on doors after the summer, people were angry but that anger has almost left them by now. They are down and do not see any hope of recovery. While this varies from family to family, I wish to stress at the outset how gloomy and down people are at present. Members of almost every family are out of work. Parents are deprived of the company of their adult children who are to be found everywhere in the world but in Australia, Canada, the United States and England in particular. Many grandparents have no contact with their grandchildren in far-flung places and their biggest thrill is to talk to them on Skype in the middle of the night. The statistics support the gloomy picture I am painting as 350,000 people are unemployed and more than 100,000 young people have emigrated. The banking system is crashed, banjaxed and in the hands of the State. Moreover, the country costs €20 billion more to run than is collected in taxes. The Government is swinging from crisis to crisis, there is no growth, no hope, no optimism and no economic plan. It was not always like this. When the rainbow Government left office in 1997, 100 people per day were starting work, there was a good standard of living, very good health services, fine schools and the budget under the guidance of Deputy Quinn was in surplus for the first time in two generations. Then Fianna Fáil came to power and the bubble economy was created by that party. Three years ago, the bubble burst and the rest is history. I do not intend to go through the high points as they have been rehearsed on many occasions.

The focus of today's debate is the economy and Fine Gael's priority is to grow the economy and to create jobs again. No country has cut its way out of recession or taxed its way out of recession but many countries have grown their way out of recession. Present Government policies are continuing the declining gyre and the downward vicious circle and it will require a major new initiative to shock the economy into reversing its downward spin, thereby spinning back up again in a growing economy in which the vicious circle becomes a virtuous circle. While I hope this can be done, it needs the dynamic of change and the dynamic of a new Government with new policies to begin the climb from despair to optimism and hope.

The first plank that must be put in place is that the public must be given absolute certainty about their future. I acknowledge that the Government now has started this process. While Fine Gael has been asking it to do so for the past three years, at least now it is setting and confirming the 2014 target and is committing to budgetary profiles to get there in instalments. Had some of the points contained in the today's speeches by the Taoiseach and the Minister been done three years ago, it would have given hope and optimism. However, the Minister's biggest problem when trying to provide certainty is that no one believes him any more. He has been wrong so often, his figures have been so outlandish so often and his forecasts have been so off the rails so often that no matter what he says now, he lacks credibility. I do not wish to personalise this but I make the point that the Government lacks the credibility to provide such certainty. However, the first plank is certainty and if Fine Gael can co-operate with the Government in providing some certainty by reconfirming the 3% target for 2014, then it will do that.

Once certainty has been established, the second thing that must be done is to restore confidence. Again, there is no confidence at present. The savings ratios in deposit accounts by Irish citizens used to average out at approximately 8% but now have risen to 11%. This constitutes an increase in saving of just under 40%. No one will spend or invest if they are unsure about the future. One fundamental of personal behaviour is that one does not take a punt in the dark unless one is a total gambler and one needs to be certain about what is happening in the future before spending one's money. Another amazing statistic demonstrates that in the words of the industry, Irish people have begun to deleverage or in other words, they are paying off their loans. A recent Central Bank report indicates that over the last 12 months Irish citizens, in a series of personal decisions in individual households, have paid off €6.8 billion in credit card balances, overdrafts in banks and so on. This is an amazing amount of money but when people fear the future, they pay their debts and save money and the consequence of people so doing is that very little money remains in circulation. I forget which eminent Sunday newspaper columnist referred to the origin of the word "currency". He observed it derives from the Latin verb currere, to flow. I note the Minister is a classical scholar and that there are very few of us left.

Comment on this

The Deputy is aware that the word "credit" is derived from the verb, credere, to believe.

Comment on this

The verb is currere. It is not a currency unless it flows. Unless money is flowing, it should not be described as a currency. If everyone is saving and paying off their debts, there is no flow. If the nationalised banks do not give credit to small and big businesses there is no flow, no current and no currency. That is the situation the Minister has got himself into.

I will try to be less gloomy and a little helpful. Fine Gael remains committed to reducing the budget deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014, as agreed with the European Commission. We believe that re-opening negotiations at this point with the EU to extend the period of fiscal adjustment beyond 2014 could lead to a further loss of international confidence in the Irish economy in 2011, with disastrous consequences. Ireland is already likely to borrow more than €60 billion over the coming four years — an awful lot of money — pushing our national debt to well over 105% of GDP. Irrespective of the views of the European Union, there is no guarantee that markets would be willing to lend to Ireland the additional resources required if we were to extend the period beyond 2014. I would say to the representatives of the trade union movement, whose views are sincerely held, and to our colleagues in Sinn Féin, whose views are also sincerely held, that to try to extend the target beyond 2014 could bring about a situation where we would not get the money to run the country next year.

We are taking in €30 billion and spending €50 billion. I do not know what the Minister's correction will be next year but if he pulls expenditure back by €4, €5 or €6 billion we will still be borrowing a significant amount. The bond markets are closed because, in the estimation of Irish financial authorities, if they were open we would not get investment. When they re-open in January, it is essential that they lend to us again. If the deadline is extended from 2014 to 2016, for example, there is a danger that Ireland will not get money when the bond markets re-open and instead of an adjustment of €4, €5 or €6 billion, or whatever the Minister has in mind, we will have to go for the whole lot. If we do not get the money we will have to bridge the gap and the gap is between €30 billion and €50 billion. That is a scenario I would not like to be exploring in January. We would have no sovereignty left if that were to take place.

The credibility of any growth path depends on the growth that is likely to take place. This is where the Minister's €15 billion comes in. This morning, the Taoiseach said the expenditure cut of €15 billion was a forecast. He is right. It is not a target; it is a forecast. While Fine Gael agrees to the 3% target we do not agree to the forecast of €15 billion, which is a forecast of the ways and means to get to the 3%. The forecast can shift, depending on what growth figures are put in. The Ministers for Justice and Law Reform and Finance have suggested that the €15 billion expenditure cut is based on an annual growth forecast of 2.75% for the next four years.

Comment on this

That is an average annual figure.

Comment on this

Yes, it is averaged out. We both know the predictions for next year are 2% and perhaps 3% annually from 2012 to 2014, inclusive. Three threes are nine and two makes eleven, and a quarter of that is 2.75. That is where we are getting the average. It is significant that the 2% figure for next year is not sufficient to allow the Minister to take a quarter of €15 billion as the correction for next year. The Minister will have to do more up front, as he says himself.

A very small variation has a huge effect here. Davy's growth forecast for 2011 is 1.9%, and 2.2% for the subsequent years up to 2014. That would drive the correction up to over €20 billion. On the other hand, the ESRI has updated its high growth target to assume an average annual growth of 4.5%. Maybe it is right or perhaps it is wrong. They have two scenarios of high growth and low growth. If its high growth scenario is right and instead of 2.75% the annual growth rates were 4.5%, a smaller package would be needed. We would achieve the 3% budget deficit target in 2014 with a cut of only €9 billion. That is a long way short of €15 billion.

I think the Minister can understand the position of the Opposition. When the €15 billion is a forecast and when minor adjustments in the growth rate can make such vast variations, would we not be desperate clowns to tie ourselves in to the Minister's figure, especially when the Taoiseach could not answer Deputy Gilmore this morning when he asked what was factored into the estimate of growth? Deputy Gilmore asked about all the elements of growth and the Taoiseach looked blankly at him. We do not know whether the Cabinet had a punt in the dark on their way out of Farmleigh and came up with €15 billion or whether it was handed down to them by the EU Commission when the Minister visited Brussels.

Comment on this

Neither hypothesis is correct.

Comment on this

Is it one of the Department of Finance scenarios? Departmental officials mentioned €15 billion fairly strongly, among other scenarios. Is it an ESRI prediction? It also mentioned €15 billion. The key element is the forecast for growth and there is a vast variation between Davy's forecast, which would take us over €20 billion, and the ESRI high growth forecast, which would bring us down to €9 billion. The Minister is on the mid point so maybe he is right, but we are not buying in. We need more information. We certainly need to know how the Minister built up his forecast and we need answers to Deputy Gilmore's questions on the elements and factors that were put in to build up that forecast.

The concentration is now on the €15 billion and the ways and means. The Minister says he will front-load the 2011 budget, which he will introduce on 7 December. A month ago a correction of €7.5 billion was announced, and look what has happened in a month. At that time, the Minister stated that he would make a €3 billion cut in the first budget. When he went to Galway on that infamous occasion, he said €3 billion was a minimum figure. The figure of €3 billion is 40% of €7.5 billion, so the front-loading was to have been 40%. An equivalent front-loading of €15 billion would be €6 billion. Will the Minister take €6 billion out on 7 December? Will he do the same proportion of front-loading as he intended a month ago, or will he do something less? If he is looking for some element of ongoing co-operation from the Opposition, that is an absolutely essential figure for us to know. We also need to know the other intermediary annual targets up to 2014.

What is the actual deficit for 2011? The ultimate target is 3% by 2014. However, when a race or contest is being organised, it is not enough to know the finishing line. One also needs to know the starting position. What will the starting position be on 7 December? It was Government policy to bring the deficit below 10%. In the last budget, the Minister announced that the deficit for 2011 would be less than 10%. This contained a suggestion that if we did not have a deficit low enough to convince the markets to lend, we would be in difficulty in January. Now that we have agreed that 3% in 2014 is the finish of the race, what is the Minister's starting point on 7 December? Will he go soft? Will the budget deficit be 11%, 11.5% or 10.5% of GDP? Will he go below 10%? He needs to come up with this figure pretty quickly. I will not press him any harder on this; I am simply speculating. I have no information as to his thinking on this but this is an essential piece of information. Unless we know the starting point we do not know where the Minister is going.

When we move away from the targets we can look at an economic strategy to get the country moving again and to give it the shock that will turn the declining circle into an ascending circle. The Minister falls down badly in concentrating all the time on fiscal correction. If the debate is only about how much we will cut and how much we will tax, all the people with money on deposit in the banks will neither spend nor invest. We have to get onto a more optimistic programme which provides jobs and economic growth in parallel with the fiscal correction.

The economic plan for jobs and growth will be along the lines of the NewERA document authored and published by Deputy Coveney. I appreciate that circumstances in the semi-State sector have changed since that document was published two years ago and it will have to be updated but the concept remains the same, namely, the need to invest in new infrastructure. This country needs to find the wherewithal to invest in all the things that are important to a modern economy.

We have resources, such the money that was put into the National Pensions Reserve Fund for a rainy day. I recall Charlie McCreevy's thinking when he established the fund. His assertion that it would preserve our pensions for the future was really a sales pitch for taking money out of circulation because he was afraid of inflation. I am not saying the money will not be needed for pensions but given the way the economy is going, there will be nobody around to draw pensions. The fund was always intended for investments in Ireland as well as in the four corners of the world. The reason it did not invest in this country, even when large sums of money were earmarked for the domestic economy, was because Ireland was awash with cheap money on the interbank market. That flow of money is what got Anglo Irish Bank and the rest of the financial institutions into trouble.

It is possible now to invest in domestic infrastructure on a commercial basis while giving a boost to the Irish economy. I will give one example from the greens around the House. People do not want domestic water charges but we are prepared to charge them for wasting water on a metered basis. One can boil the kettle, take a shower or use the bathroom for nothing but it is fair that one should pay for washing the car or running the hose over the allotment for three days to grow greener cabbage than the woman next door. The essential element of any pension fund is a revenue flow because that facilitates investment through a PPP scheme.

The NPRF is not the only solution. Some of our semi-State organisations have healthy balance sheets, despite the crazy politically driven investments in things like grids in Northern Ireland which upset the ESB's balance sheet. The advantage of semi-State companies is that they always have capital programmes and can invest in new infrastructure.

Another solution is suggested by the review conducted by Colm McCarthy to identify the State assets and agencies that are no longer essential or strategic and, as a result, can be sold off. I do not propose that we sell at the bottom of the market. We could use the NPRF money and, if we feel we have to replenish it subsequently, we can do so through the sale of assets. That was done on previous occasions.

Comment on this

Greece tried it with the Acropolis.

Comment on this

Funds for a stimulus package can also be found in the private pension funds which have been lobbying for changes to the law. They believe the restrictions currently in place on their investments in Ireland require them to take bigger risks abroad rather than spread them, which was the intention of the legislation, and they want more scope to invest domestically.

We are all in politics and we have been around a long time. The conclusion I have reached from knocking on doors is that we cannot sell hardship. No matter how good we may be, and the Minister is very convincing, the problem is that the jury keeps returning to the trial. The more they get used to him, the less convincing he becomes.

Comment on this

Eventually they convict.

Comment on this

They will convict soon.

Comment on this

That will happen. We cannot sell hardship but everything that has been said about fiscal adjustment is an attempt to sell hardship to the Irish people. It has to be accompanied by a strategy that gives a shock to the economy in order to get it growing again. We will have to take a sectoral approach to the economy and take what the economists call supply side initiatives. I am sure the Minister heard the business lads in Trinity speak about supply side economics while he was studying law and liberal arts. The stimulus package is a demand side measure but the advantage of supply side initiatives is that they are small and do not cost a lot of money.

I will outline a very simple example. London is full of Chinese tourists at present. The city is like the Ireland of 30 or 40 years ago, when one would get a belt of a camera from a Japanese tourist if one looked at the Blarney stone. Is Fáilte Ireland asking why these tourists are not adding three days in Ireland to their packages? The reason is the difficulty in getting visas. If there was a way of fast-tracking their visas, it would cost nothing because it would only be an administrative matter for the Department of Justice and Law Reform and the Department of Foreign Affairs and we could attract more tourists. It will not have cost anything even if it did not work.

I am aware the former Taoiseach, Deputy Bertie Ahern, was offended by being held up to ridicule in the advertisements that Michael O'Leary placed in the newspapers.

Comment on this

So was our friend, President Sarkozy.

Comment on this

The Deputy should not be upset because once he went into the press, Michael O'Leary could do no more to him. If the Government has a vendetta against Mr. O'Leary and is keeping the travel tax in place because it does not want to give him the satisfaction of saying it was wrong, that is bad politics. It could be a good supply side initiative, however. If one takes the tourism sector, five star hotels around the country are empty and nobody is using our golf courses other than the odd fox or rabbit. We have excellent self-catering accommodation and underutilised airports all over the country, including the second terminal at Dublin Airport. The investment has been made in the tourism infrastructure but it is not being used because the missing ingredients are the tourists. They have to be brought into the country. Was the Government to sit down with Michael O'Leary, the gentleman from Aer Lingus and the heads of the other carriers and offered to removed the travel tax if the airlines committed to deliver tourists, that would be a basis for negotiation. At a minimum, we could ask for €20 million to promote Ireland in Germany given that Germans are beginning to spend money again and they might fly here. These are the supply side initiatives to which I refer.

I will describe another initiative that would not cost money. The law states that rents can only be adjusted upwards. It always struck me as bizarre that a tenant cannot negotiate. Businesses are closing as a result of this law but nothing is being done about it. We will list these and other initiatives in our own policy programmes.

It appears the Government is suffering from paralysis whereby individual Ministers cannot come up with low cost, or no cost, supply side initiatives such as tweaking taxes.

Is he doing as his colleagues in Mr. Cameron's British Government are doing? There, since the election, they have had a "patent box" approach, which involves a new treatment of patents and intellectual property. If the Minister talks to those he knows in IDA Ireland and Enterprise Ireland, he will know we are already at a competitive disadvantage. The "patent box" involves only tweaking and changing the rules, which kicks into research and development and makes Britain more attractive for research and development than Ireland. It is a supply side initiative to fix this problem and it costs nothing because there is no great return on it in any case. It is very important that we would do this.

We need a credible fiscal policy going forward. I hope the Minister will, some time in November, bring forward the profiles for four budgets. He has said he will set targets for the individual budgets when he does so. I strongly suggest that when he is bringing out the budget, no matter how harsh it is, he accompanies it with a jobs and growth strategy for the economy. Otherwise, we are all going down the tubes together.

Comment on this

Like many Members of the House, when parents and citizens stop me in the street, they generally tell me about their worries for the future. They worry for the future of the country but, above all else, they worry for the future of their children. Most of us here are parents and we all went to see the best for our children. We want to believe and we want our children to believe that they are not being condemned to that old path of emigration by this Government. We are looking for a sign of hope, a ray of light and confidence that the sacrifices Fianna Fáil have laid out have some meaning.

We must remember that over the past two and a half years Fianna Fáil has already taken some €15 billion or €15.5 billion out of the economy. Like the hamster——

Comment on this

It is €14 billion, I believe.

Comment on this

It depends on how it is counted. Like the hamster on the wheel, people have given all that sacrifice to find out that after all the promises of green shoots and turnarounds from this Minister, and all the bag of tricks in regard to the cheapest bank bailout in the world and everything looking rosy in the garden, this particular gardener did not really do the spade work of laying the ground for real growth and real recovery.

Fianna Fáil suggests we are facing into an age of austerity. Perhaps it is the Japanese lost decade. That is the wrong way for Fianna Fáil to present it because it is to deprive of any hope thousands of young people who are out of work or on the verge of graduating from college. That is wrong. Our young people, with their quality of education, are world beaters. Many of the 400,000 people who are languishing in unemployment are shocked. These are people who have been used to looking after themselves and to having expectations. They now find that on Wednesday of any week, they may have to borrow from their parents or others to try to get to Friday or Saturday, when they will get some money again.

That kind of thing went out not in the 1980s but in the 1960s. It is why somebody like President John F. Kennedy was such a ray of hope to Ireland because he came here, wonderful looking and well dressed and, just as "The Cosby Show" did for black Americans, he represented something that came from us and something we could become, and which in due course we did become.

Fianna Fáil's sense of pervasive hopelessness is killing the country. This is why I had hoped to hear more about a balanced approach to the economy. We say "Yes" to cutting and pruning expenditure, getting better value for our money and having all of us work harder, whether in the public or private sector, but also "Yes" to growth, to stimulus, to the future, to the skills of our young people, to the education in which we have invested and to the fact we are in the EU. We have an attractive corporation tax rate. Our diaspora, particularly in regard to Irish America but also those of our people who have gone to live in Australia and New Zealand, want to be told by us that we have a plan for recovery and that they can help with that plan. I did not hear mention of any of this.

For all of the language about a smart economy, give me a smart Government that helps to generate hope and employment and I would settle for that. We seem to have one of the most pathetically stupid Governments of the recent period. It inherited a good economy and an easy task. For about five years it followed roughly what the Rainbow Government had done and then, once we went into the euro it lost the run of itself. Now, we must change from that.

Irish politics is now almost entirely dominated by the economy. Consider the business of Dáil Éireann. Already in this single year we have gone through two game-changing moments. First, in the week before Easter, the Minister made his shock and awe announcement about the first disclosure of the Anglo Irish Bank losses. Then, a few weeks ago, there was Black Thursday and yet another stunning set of losses that have been dumped on the citizens of this State. Today's debate is a foretaste of the pre-budget debate we must have in a few weeks when we get the details from the Government of the four-year plan to be sent to Brussels. Then, on 7 December, we will get the 2011 Budget Statement.

Even the most addicted of politically minded citizens have become numbed by the sheer scale of what has happened, while the economics profession has retreated into its own exclusive language of multipliers, deflators and technicalities that rivals the language of lawyers in its obscurity.

Comment on this

It far exceeds it, I suggest.

Comment on this

The Cabinet will make the budget decisions and will have to live with their consequences. Nobody can have any sympathy for the plight of this Cabinet. Members should read the report by Messrs Regling and Watson. Mr. Regling is now the man with the money in the stabilisation fund. He said that our problems were "home-grown". He has laid out the scale of the policy errors of the years since 2000, particularly the property tax shelters that drove the construction boom and the light touch regulation that encouraged the reckless lending practices of the banks. We know the impact of the Government's fiscal tightening will be to depress growth in the coming years. What we do not know yet is whether the country's credit rating internationally will be more affected by the evidence of weakening activity or by the stubbornly high level of the budget deficit. This is why it is a balancing act.

Portugal does not have anything like our fiscal problems, does not have a banking problem at all and has a forecast deficit for next year of below 5%. Why can it not borrow at reasonable rates and why is its borrowing limited? It is because it cannot show enough growth prospects in its economy.

Comment on this

It has a current account deficit on its balance of payments.

Comment on this

The point is that our difficulties are not unique. If one decides to follow the deficit hawks and kill the economy, one will not gain kudos from the bond markets. What they really want is a twin-track approach. Whatever option is chosen has immense risks. As the Taoiseach is fond of saying, we are where we are. It is where he and the Minister have brought us. The Minister does not like to be reminded of that but it is the undeniable truth. He does not deserve and will not get a moment's peace in this House from the Labour Party. This is his legacy.

Earlier today the leader of the Labour Party, Deputy Eamon Gilmore, reaffirmed the Labour Party's commitment to the four-year timetable for deficit reduction. He did so because we know the country needs to be able to return to borrowing at reasonable rates of interest between mid-January and mid-February. There is more than one timetable involved. In many ways, we do not just have a four-year timetable to meet but a four-month timetable.

The 3% deficit target has been the core of public policy since the starting round of emergency budgets in 2008. There have been four-year plans aplenty sent to Brussels. There is nothing unusual in this procedure as it is a long-standing part of the Stability and Growth Pact. We are subject to the excessive deficit procedure.

The plan that must be submitted in a few weeks will be subject to a tougher-than-usual stress analysis. This is because the last two budgets, despite the pain the people took as a consequence and despite the painful measures we all have had to endure on foot of the various special budgets since the summer of 2008, failed to reach the intermediate targets set out.

I have to hand the Minister's previous effort. One line refers to €2 billion for 2011, €2 billion for 2012, €1.5 billion for 2013 and €1 billion for 2014. This is why the Opposition has problems with the Department's arithmetic. What does such a line mean? I am referring to the book the Department of Finance presented to us. All I can say is that it is a short book and it is not convincing. We are seeking information that is credible, presented with conviction and which allows us to explain the position of the Government.

The dismal and repeated failures of Government banking and budgetary policies have left a cloud of international doubt over the capacity of the Government to deliver the goods. This is the Minister's problem. Only a change of Government, a new Administration, will make the bond markets feel Ireland is again on the up. This would be because the Government's mentality would be characterised by freshness, vigour and a desire for change. Credibility must be the principal feature of any revised four-year plan. The plan must not be about cuts and more cuts.

The most depressing feature of this debate is that our national predicament is presented in Parliament as a choice between one extreme and another. One side maintains the country must be purged of its crippling debt in a really tight timeframe regardless of social or long-term economic consequences while the other side refuses to acknowledge that international creditworthiness is an issue at all. Then there are those who wilfully ignore the continuing fragility of the banking sector, as if it were not an issue at all in budgetary calculations. In this regard, one should consider what the Bank of Ireland had to pay yesterday and today for raising some funding. It is paying the shadow rates the Irish Government is being asked for. The ordinary citizen watches in considerable bewilderment as the argument rages.

My party accepts the necessity for spending cuts yet remains alarmed at the prospect of a prolonged recession and social disruption. If the right balance is not struck in the coming budget and if public spending is cut by too much too fast, the knock-on effect on business and consumer confidence will surely make matters worse. One should remember that private businesses are the main beneficiaries of public investment. Private builders build and maintain our schools and hospitals and small private suppliers sell goods and services to local authorities and Departments. If this source of custom is cut off, businesses will fail in every county. People in both public and private sectors are not spending but hoarding cash, as is evident from the level of savings in the country. They are worried about their jobs, their children's jobs and whether they will have to help out by meeting extra mortgage repayments. Many mothers in my constituency tell me they are giving their children so much money per week to help with the food bill to allow them to concentrate on trying to pay the mortgage. This is a reality for many people in my constituency.

One can measure the loss of confidence in the Government through the RED C polls and others and one can note the same loss of confidence in the tales from the front line of businesses, big and small shops, hotels, suppliers and contractors, and from the anxiety of parents who are watching sadly as their qualified children, including graduates and apprentices, prepare to emigrate. The Government's economic policy is a wild gamble. Banking policy has failed utterly. The promissory notes tactic to fund the Anglo Irish Bank bailout has blown up in the Minister's face at a huge cost to the State.

If ever there ever were two rogue characters in this Hallowe'en horror story, they must be bankers FitzPatrick and Fingleton. We now have a €31 billion mortgage for this country, payable over a ten-year to 15-year period. The deficit has increased from €7.5 billion to €15 billion largely because the Minister or one of his advisers did not account for the approximately €1.5 billion per annum that the promissory notes would cost. This is the main reason the Minister's figures have gone adrift. He acknowledged this by talking about the rise in interest costs. If interest rates continue to rise as they are doing, the country may well be paying up to €6 billion in interest costs next year.

When I popped into the Minister's Department to meet the very pleasant and courteous officials, they were not able to pull out a sheet of paper stating the figures. I had to drag out of them the €1.5 billion annual interest charge on the promissory notes. That is not good enough. Perhaps the Minister told his officials to invite us but not to tell us too much. We do not know what their briefing was but we certainly wanted the kind of information I have outlined.

Comment on this
Sean Sherlock Deputy Seán Sherlock Labour Party

The Minister is not denying it.

Comment on this

They were not given any briefing.

Comment on this

He has such control he did not have to brief them.

Comment on this

Ministers insist that public spending cuts are vital to protect confidence in the country until our debts can be repaid. The other issue is that the negative impact of these cuts will be compensated for by a surge in private sector activity. How can that happen if business remains so deep in the doldrums? There is a simple equation being considered, particularly in right-wing circles, to the effect that when one cuts the State sector, the private sector surges. However, ours is a small complicated economy in that much of the private sector depends on public spending to keep its activity at a reasonable level.

Yesterday's announcement of the greater-than-expected hole in the public purse puts every Member of this House under pressure. The Labour Party will respond to the new situation when it has a reasonable opportunity to assess it and when it receives a considered answer to two vital questions. The first concerns the growth and employment anticipated for 2011. The other is the expected outturns in revenue for this year and next. It is amusing that journalists want instant answers from me and my colleagues in respect of what we will do. Are they seeking back-of-the-envelope calculations that would be carried out in the absence of proper analysis of the most recent data? Ministers are allowed time and space to consider their responses. However, Members on this side of the House are criticised if they indulge in the slightest hesitation. This really is a curious form of politics. I put it down to the Government's very skilful and well-paid advisers spinning very successfully on its behalf.

Comment on this

They are too busy preparing the national plan.

Comment on this

That is an awful reflection on the Minister's Department.

Comment on this

The national plan was launched three months ago.

Comment on this

I am sure it did not escape the Minister's notice that the individuals to whom I refer are earning handsome salaries and are doing a very good job spinning matters on his behalf.

The tax code requires a major overhaul in order to yield the additional revenue that will be needed to meet our debts and for investment. For over a decade, the tax code has been infected by the poison of the type of tax shelters which have facilitated the tax planners in ducking and weaving at will in order to evade and avoid paying their fair share. Regardless of the degree to which Ministers pretend that these shelters no longer exist, the truth is that they have left a long legacy which will continue to cost us billions in the years to come. This week, I obtained an admission from officials in the Department of Finance to the effect that the notorious property tax shelters will cost us close to €400 million this year alone. That amount is equal to the total cost of the free fees policy in the area of higher education. However, those who demand an end to this policy are curiously silent about and ignorant of the true cost of the tax breaks that have caused so much damage in the past decade.

Tax planners placed large advertisements on the front page of one of the Sunday newspapers last weekend and the weekend before in which those with spare cash were urged to hurry up and take the last remaining opportunity to use the tax shelters to which I refer in order to minimise their exposure for tax. These advertisements reminded me of the slogan employed by Moore Street traders in the week prior to Christmas and encouraging people to "buy the last of the Cheeky Charlies". Tax experts are exhorting people to avail of the last of the tax breaks while they remain in place. The figure of €400 million to which I refer is not insignificant.

I wish to refer to the absurd tax breaks that exist for very high income earners who have private pensions. Mr. Fingleton is the most famous case in this regard and he has a private pension pot of €27 million. All of this money has been carefully sheltered within structures put in place by the Government. These tax breaks are another cause of vexation on the part of ordinary PAYE workers and, in full, they cost the Exchequer between €1 billion and €2 billion each year. They must be amended in order that the costs to which they give rise can be substantially reduced. They must be focused on low and middle income earners rather than on those who earn high incomes. I am in favour of one measure that has been introduced by the new Conservative-Liberal Democrat Government in the UK, namely, the imposition of a cap on the amount of relief that can be claimed under this heading, regardless of whether it is contributed to taxpayers or by the owners of companies by which proprietary directors are technically employed. I urge the Minister for Finance to follow the lead provided by the UK Chancellor, Mr. George Osborne, MP, in this regard.

We are continually reminded that a high percentage of wage earners at the lower end of the pay scales pay no income tax at all. It may well be that there is scope for reform in this area and that a well-structured universal levy could have a significant role to play in order that savings might be achieved. The Minister previously referred to a universal social contribution, a matter in respect of which the ESRI recently compiled a paper. I would add the proviso that there is no change of securing consent under this heading when there is such rampant evasion and avoidance at the top end. Get that part of the equation right and we can then discuss a thorough application of the principle that everyone must pay a fair share.

It is astonishing to consider how the rampant organised tax avoidance to which I refer remains so embedded in our culture. One need only consider the recent stories relating to NAMA. All of the guys — and they are guys — whose loans were taken over by NAMA are each going to be given €200,000 per year in order that they might continue to live in the style to which they have become accustomed. A sum of €200,000 represents a large salary by most people's standards. The majority of those to whom I refer will not pay any tax on that money because they still have access to a range of tax shelters which they utilised in order to pay little or no tax during the period of the boom. It is all a question of balance. If one wants to cut child benefit, one must clearly show that one intends to act tough on this type of rampant tax avoidance.

In comparison to other eurozone countries, the overall gross tax take here, as a share of national income, is way below what it ought to be. The position in this regard must be changed in a planned and coherent way in the coming years. Many of those to whom I would refer as "deficit hawks", and who inhabit television and radio studios, do not want to acknowledge that this is the reality shown by all of the statistics produced by the OECD and other bodies in respect of Ireland. This reality is the result of the various tax breaks and tax shelters and the way in which our tax system evolved under Charlie McCreevy. Essentially, we should have moderate taxes, the effective tax rate should not be distorted by tax shelters and everyone should contribute. In this way, we could raise our tax revenues to reasonable heights without the necessity to have excessively high marginal rates.

The IMF has a fearsome reputation as an institution that will take whatever action is considers necessary if it is called upon to manage a failed economy. When I worked in a number of different countries in Africa, I witnessed the kind of restructuring the IMF tends to employ. It is not a pretty sight. The IMF's template is very simple: get to a zero-based budget in something of the order of one to three years.

When I visited the Department of Finance, I became depressed as a result of the quietistic mood that appears to obtain among the staff there. When I visit a school, I can nearly gauge, as I walk in the front door, the vibrancy of the children and the levels of hope and expectation that obtain. I did not feel that kind of vibrancy when I visited the Minister's Department. I am sure the officials who work there are the reservoirs of vast levels of knowledge and expertise in respect of public expenditure. However, none of them stated "Joan, we can do this. We can pull matters out of the fire. We know we are going to do it." Far be it from me to state that someone with a salesperson's approach should go into the Department. However, it is obvious that the Government is not inspiring the officials to whom I refer to come forward with serious plans to regenerate this country.

Comment on this

That is very unfair.

Comment on this

Why is it the case that when I — I am sure the other Opposition spokespersons did the same — inquired about——

Comment on this

It is a monastery, not a supermarket.

Comment on this

——the Croke Park agreement, no figures could be provided? Why did the officials not state that they are driving the process relating to the agreement?

Comment on this

Fine Gael and Labour supported the agreement.

Comment on this

The Minister and his absent colleagues are the leaders of the various Departments.

Comment on this
Sean Sherlock Deputy Seán Sherlock Labour Party

I do not believe that the Minister of State, Deputy Calleary, and his colleagues require affirmation from Members on this side of the House.

Comment on this

When we met the officials, we were informed that there are no real plans. Ministers are meant to lead their Departments. They are supposed to inspire civil servants and encourage them to develop ideas. I am quite convinced that there are many ideas and a high level of capacity among civil servants. However, the staff of the Minister's Department have been allowed to become utterly depressed by what lies in store for the future. If those who are making the plans are suffering from depression, they are not going to generate the kind of ideas that will assist in getting the country back on its feet. It is the Minister's responsibility, as the leader of his Department, to inspire civil servants to give of their best.

Last week the IMF stated, "Fiscal plans should be fair. There should be specific measures to protect the most vulnerable from the effects of the consolidation." A similar bias lies at the core of the Labour Party's approach to the coming four years. Unless there are reforms affecting the very wealthiest in the country, people on lower income levels cannot be asked to shoulder the bulk of the burden.

The Minister responded in a very negative way to Deputy Gilmore's contribution and the Labour Party proposal for a strategic investment bank. We did much research on this and considered models in four or five European countries. Coincidentally, today's leading article in The Guardian is related to this. The Minister used to quote all the time flattering comments from the Financial Times before it cottoned on to him.

Comment on this

And The Guardian.

Comment on this

Not any more.

Comment on this
Sean Sherlock Deputy Seán Sherlock Labour Party

The Manchester Guardian.

Comment on this

The Deputy will not quote last week's Irish Times.

Comment on this

It states "Far better would be a state development bank along the lines of Germany's KfW." The Minister is averse to new ideas and changes because he is addicted to whatever happened in the salad days of having money to throw at everything. That may have been new centres in Punchestown or the Bertie Bowl. Those days are gone but we need realistic and fresh hope to turn this economy around. What depresses me about today's speeches is that although we accept the smart economy, where is the smart and inspirational Government? Where is it giving leadership, to the public service in particular, that will enable public servants to believe that a reform programme will be adopted giving value for money, making savings, keeping public service jobs and, in particular, giving the people who are using our services the quality and standard of service in health and education that they are entitled to expect?

Comment on this

I thank the Minister and his officials for their courtesy on the number of visits we paid to the Department of Finance recently with regard to the ongoing budgetary process. The information has been useful although it is certainly far from complete. I regard this as a small step to opening the budgetary process and I hope there is substantially more of it in coming years. There is certainly room for a more comprehensive approach to the business.

I suppose we should be grateful because at least the Minister today avoided the reference to patriotism. I am sure he recalls the reference from a couple of years ago when he told youngsters going across the border to Newry or Enniskillen to buy a can of beer that they needed to be patriotic. There was no mention of patriotism when it came to wrecking the economy of the State for a generation.

Comment on this

They are not going to Newry now.

Comment on this

That was the Minister's reference and if we want to measure the patriotism of the people of this island or this State, we must recognise the reality and have some level of proportionality. The Government has betrayed the trust of the Irish people, or at the very least the people of this State who voted for it. The Government decisions in recent years and particularly over the past two years have amounted to economic treason. It watched as gangsters masquerading as bankers shovelled billions of euro out to corrupt speculators and developers to build houses where planning permission was often acquired through corrupt payments to councillors, although not all councillors are corrupt by any means. The rezoning of such land for housing purposes should not have happened. It is no wonder that there are consequences for the tolerance or encouragement of corruption by this Government.

Some context is needed as a backdrop to the clamour for cuts to the welfare and low-income families from the whole consensus for cuts brigade, which will take place in the days just before Christmas next December. The consensus parties are preparing to impoverish the poorer people of this State for decades. The Government has no mandate to do so because it and the other parties in the consensus for cuts cluster went into the 2007 election promising the people of this State tax cuts and sunshine forever more. The Government was elected on that mandate and was not elected on a mandate of impoverishing swathes of people on welfare and low or middle incomes.

The Government has no mandate, although the Minister may indicate that the Government will squeeze through on a technical aspect of democracy and how it works. The Minister knows his Government does not have a mandate. Coming up to the NAMA business last year I called for a referendum on the agency and the vast sums it would cost our people. The Government did not hold it because it knew the result that would come out. Sinn Féin put down a motion as a parliamentary device to force that referendum but there was no support, particularly from the Labour Party, and I remain disappointed in it.

There is an economic nightmare bearing down on people so this Government should immediately seek a fresh mandate before it does any more damage to the economy. We can think of the details of the consequences of what will happen after the 2011 budget. Who will pay for it? Those who will pay for it in the first instance are the people who are currently languishing in hospital accident and emergency units. People who need acute hospital beds will be staying for two or three days on a hospital trolley — or at least that is the current rate — before getting into the system. It will probably be double or triple this number by the time cutbacks are felt.

I was in an accident and emergency department with a relative approximately six weeks ago for most of the day and into the night. It was Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda. At one point there were 38 people on trolleys and when the trolleys ran out, the staff had to get chairs. The staff asked the family of the ill people if they would mind going to the public area and bringing back a chair. There were not even enough chairs to hold those people. My heart went out to the older people in particular, who are very proud and are conscious of their dignity. They had blankets across the chairs barely covering them and they slipped off the people as they dozed off. It is a nightmare scenario that is now occurring and I hope the Minister will tell us at the conclusion of the debate what the scenario will be for those people after the December budget.

I do not want to make this a health debate as other people will pay for it. Children with special needs will pay for this and already are paying because special needs assistants are being laid off. The consequences of that are that teachers in the classroom pick up the slack and bring children to the toilet and ensure that the children keep up to some degree. The other children in the classroom will suffer enormously as well. There are people with disabilities, with families already carrying substantial burdens, and others with mental health issues. They are already suffering isolation and torment, very often in Victorian buildings and grossly inadequate conditions. Those people will suffer.

When a Minister tells us the measures will be widely spread and the poor will be protected, we can see it as nonsense. These are the very people being attacked by this Government. Almost everybody, except the wealthy, must contribute in a disproportionate way. That is a scandal.

This is not about the people but the economy. It is flat and there is no prospect of growth in the immediate future. The strategy is to hang on in there and hope there will be a global bounce, with some growth here on the coat-tails of that growth. There will not be any substantial growth in this economy——

Comment on this

The Deputy's party would need to cut €20 billion.

Comment on this

——for at least 18 months. If there is more than 2% growth in the next 18 months, it will be good going. That will not be enough because even a substantial global bounce will have a lag of 12 to 18 months before it will impact on the huge numbers of unemployed people in this State.

It is wonderful that as we come up to Hallowe'en the Minister is appropriately scaremongering to some degree. In the course of his contribution he said that a higher rate of tax for top earners would cause them to flee the jurisdiction. That is interesting. It is causing the Minister substantial worry. Is the Minister worried about the people who have just graduated leaving the State? They are leaving in droves every month. Fully qualified nurses are leaving the jurisdiction every month but neither the Minister nor any of his colleagues has expressed concern about those people leaving the jurisdiction. However, if there is a marginal tax rate on very wealthy people the sky will fall in because they may leave the jurisdiction. I do not buy into that hypothesis for a moment.

I will refer to the Minister's speech because it was fascinating. In it he told us, "Irish people will still hold onto most of the gains that we have built up over many years of strong growth and that they enjoyed since the mid-1990s. Over that period we took many steps forward. We are now only taking one step back". If the Minister thinks that somebody losing his or her home is one step back from where he or she was five or six years ago, I can tell him it is several more steps than that. That is another of his phrases which I can no longer accept, any more than the phrase, "the worst is over" or the other comments he made which I will not go back over because I will waste everybody's time and I want to give the Minister some of our perspective on the economy.

On the phrase, "one step back" the Minister should go out onto the doorsteps and canvass if people are not coming into his constituency office. I do not mean to personalise the debate to the Minister, but his backbenchers should be telling him what is going on in the real world if the Government does not know because I can tell him what is happening. There is a high level of poverty out there. Substantial numbers of people are struggling to feed their children. I am meeting people and dealing with some of their issues and I can assure the Minister that what I said is absolutely correct. To talk about taking one step back is missing the point regarding the level and extent of the deprivation which is out there.

There may be a bounce in the economy but the real test of the economy is employment, growth in employment and a reduction in unemployment. We see the huge numbers of unemployed, some 449,000. We know that figure will continue for some substantial time and that is the real measure of the economy. We have economic indices and all the rest of it but if the Government wants to count it in real terms, it should count it in human terms because we are dealing with society.

The Government has cut and slashed in the past three budgets. It has imposed levies and taxes on low income families and what were the consequences? I will tell the Minister what they were. We now have a flat economy, huge unemployment, revenue is still falling and there is no strategy in place to deal with it. The cost of borrowing is 6% or more and still growing. Why is there is no market confidence in Ireland? It is because the markets know that the Government has told lies and bluffed for so long that they have no confidence whatsoever in it.

We need to get back to a point where politicians have some integrity and when they speak people will at least believe what they say. There is no respect out there for politicians generally, and certainly none for the Government side and what has been wrought on the people of this State. Is it any wonder that the international markets do not have confidence in the Government? It started off with €4.5 billion to bail out Anglo Irish Bank, which increased to €9 billion, then €12 billion and the Minister now claims it is €29 billion but I estimate it will cost €37 billion, as have a number of other people including Peter Matthews and other people of integrity.

Whatever measures the Minister puts in place, until we get to a point where the characters on the Government side of the House can be believed — they cannot be believed at the moment — the markets will have deep suspicions about our capacity to work our way out of this economy. People out there believe that the Government could not lie straight in bed at night, much less exercise some integrity regarding the economy.

I will briefly deal with the Sinn Féin proposals. I thank Deputy Ó Caoláin for agreeing to bring forward our pre-budget submission to Monday of next week because we want to ensure that the Government has the maximum amount of time possible to examine our proposals. Unlike the Minister we do not think that there will be a huge flight of very wealthy people from the economy if we introduce a 40% tax band on individual incomes in excess of €100,000. The proposal was in our pre-budget submission last year and will be there this year. We are not expecting the Minister to accept that given his comments today.

We want to see a 1% wealth tax but only on assets in excess of €1 million which is income linked. What is the thrust of that? It is asking the wealthy and those who can afford it to pay rather than what happened in the budget last year. We know what is coming this year. The Government is going after people on €15,000 per annum with levies and taxes. That is grossly unfair on the people who cannot afford to pay. We will standardise discretionary tax reliefs which will raise over €1 billion.

We will have some very sensible measures for a stimulus. A stimulus is absolutely essential for growth and we will be offering a substantial proposal in regard to it. I do not often agree with Fine Gael but I have to agree with Deputy Noonan on the pension fund. To use some of it to invest in the stimulus package to try to make sure we get the economy moving again is a sensible move. Government blather about protecting the less well off when it means the complete opposite will not wash with me or my colleagues.

What is the Government talking about? We hear some rumbles about potentially having a property tax. Swathes of people are struggling to pay their mortgages. I hear in my constituency office on a weekly basis that people are going to the St. Vincent de Paul. I have gone to negotiate some kind of moratorium for constituents who were being threatened with foreclosure by the banks. That is a growing problem; it is not reducing. To talk about the prospects of a property tax in this environment is nonsense. We heard the Minister, Deputy Gormley, refer to prepping for water charges. I know he can wrap it up, as he did with the carbon tax, in some kind of green cloak but he is once again affecting poorer people from low-income families. In doing so, he will squeeze the life out of the economy.

People refer to front loading the so-called adjustments. I will have to get some explanation of what the word "adjustment" means. In this context it seems to be a cut but the Government will not call it that. The next time I need a haircut and go into the barber I will ask for a hair adjustment. I guarantee that he will produce a pair of scissors and hair will fall to the floor in no time. Whatever about the terminology, what the budget is really about is going after the poor and using language to disguise the savage cuts which will take place.

The people who advocate front-loading are those who are invariably on incomes well in excess of €200,000 per annum. Does an income like that not soften the blow of these adjustments? I believe it does. However, those people being on salaries of €200,000 will not soften the blow for the person on €196 euro per week, as Deputy Ó Caoláin rightly referred to in his contribution. That will be no comfort for them and they will be scrimping and scraping and trying to barely make ends meet, yet we are told the less well-off will be protected.

The Government's policies will undoubtedly lead to a significant economic contraction. The fairest people to quote are those at the ESRI, a Government-funded independent body. The ESRI stated that its calculations suggest that savings of up to €15 billion could be needed, which is twice the sum under discussion at the time Ireland and the Commission agreed to the 2014 deadline. It expressed concern about the potential negative impact on the economy of this scale of adjustment over the period of time while accepting that the 2014 deadline is unlikely to change. This will be particularly punitive.

The ESRI states that when the package was signed off with the 2014 date the debt was only half of what it is now; it was €7.5 billion and not €15 billion. A sum of €500 million either way matters little to those who will face these cuts. The ESRI also accepts that it is unlikely to change. This is because the Government has indicated to it that it will not go back to Europe to try to negotiate a more reasonable approach. There should be a reasonable timeframe for dealing with the financial crisis bearing down on us. No person in his or her senses would undertake a huge mortgage over a 15 year period, he or she would want to repay it over a substantially longer period, such as 30 years.

I was going to deal with the behaviour of the auditors of some of the banks but I thank Deputy Ó Caoláin for dealing with Ernst & Young and a number of others in his contribution. There is no accountability whatsoever because those auditors, like the bankers, are working in the economy and getting paid huge sums of money like the developers and the speculators who are on €200,000 each from NAMA to keep them in luxury, this after what they have done to wreck the lives of so many people in this land. On it goes. We know the bankers have gone off with their huge pensions and bonuses. Michael Fingleton was mentioned. He is supposed to be returning his bonus of €1 million. However, he has not yet done so. He is still flying around the world enjoying himself with no sign of him giving us back that money.

In his speech, the Minister stated that the people will have to accept cuts in public expenditure and higher taxes. I agree with that sentence and he is right. However, where should those higher taxes be? The Minister for Finance tells us he will widen the tax net. He will bring those on the minimum wage into the net. When I state that I agree with him, I agree with the sentiment of the statement but we should be taxing higher income families because they can afford to pay. Higher income individuals are those earning in excess of €100,000 per annum. The current levy system will mean a substantial contribution from this category but those in it are better able to carry it than somebody on €196 per week. We hope it will be for a relatively short period, we estimate it will be for six years. We would make cuts in the public sector in particular and we would put a cap on people earning in excess of €100,000. We would also trim the salaries of Ministers, Deputies and Senators.

Two years into its purge, Ireland has a budget deficit of 32% of GDP. It is 11.9% if one strips out the bank bailouts. Ireland's debt is ballooning while its capacity to pay has collapsed. The current debate is on implementing a programme of extreme austerity versus austerity. However, moving towards austerity is an ideological choice and not an economic reality. There is a need for sustained, substantial and smart stimulus instead of "timely cuts" as they are called. When we are told that the economy is shrinking significantly, that Government spending is far too high and Government borrowing is becoming unsustainable, that the economy is becoming uncompetitive, that workers are being paid too much, that the minimum wage must be lowered and that social welfare rates are too high, we should know that this is not common sense, it is the agenda of an ideology that serves the interests of a small wealthy class in our society.

The establishment is united in the need for cutbacks in workers' pay — although it is much more hesitant about cutting executive pay — for cutbacks in Government expenditure including in health and education, for cutbacks in social welfare rates and for increases in taxation that affect those on the lowest incomes, to the extent of drawing low income earners previously outside the tax net into it. This is because it wishes to preserve the present system.

The demand that countries balance their budgets is a euphemism for selling off the public domain and slashing pensions and public spending on education, medical care and the other basic preconditions for raising labour productivity. The drain of payments to creditors and absentee investors forces countries to balance their budgets by selling off their public domain. Credit rating agencies threaten to downgrade countries that do not play ball by giving up their basic infrastructure, along with their gas, water and other natural resources on the cheap. That has happened in plenty in this State.

Under austerity, Government revenue is used to pay debt service, bail out banks and make other transfer payments or subsidies to the finance sector at home and abroad rather than being spent to raise productivity. Banks and financial institutions should have been let fail. Private deals were made between them. As Deputy Ó Caoláin stated, the value of one's investment may go down as well as up. The Government is indifferent to real businesses and the SMEs, which are failing, but has made every concerted effort to help the financial pirates. It seems we have a banks' spokesperson rather than a Minister for Finance.

NAMA is using large amounts of the wealth produced by taxpayers to bail out the stakeholders of the banks and the speculators who invested in them now that their reckless lending has left them facing huge losses. This reckless speculation was also socially destructive as it drove up house prices creating the now collapsed property bubble, leaving many households with punishing debt.

Pension funds need to be used productively to lessen the reliance on fickle foreign investors. We need to have in place instruments that are fit for investment. That we are dependent on bond vigilantes and international capital markets is perverse. Countries should not be brought to their knees because of the whims of these international players.

It may seem astonishing that we face such economic and social deficits after 15 years of boom but these are the consequences of pursuing a failed low-tax, low-spend model which sought short-term gains from the speculative activity of a small but very powerful golden circle. Choices were made in the late 1990s and in the early 2000s by Fianna Fáil which diverted the economy away from industrial upgrading and new investment priorities, onto a path of speculative booms, a weakening tax base and public finances that were dependent on boom-time growth rates.

Supporters of Government policy argue that there is no alternative, having learnt their economics from Mrs. Thatcher. The Government wants all stakeholders to accept its assumptions and policies — the expenditure cuts and the recapitalisations — all of which the Government deems to be necessary to mitigate recent policy mistakes and excesses which occurred on its watch. This happened over the past 13 years on its watch. To date, the Government has introduced three austerity budgets. On each occasion it has argued that we are living beyond our means and that it has no option but to cut public spending.

It is argued that cutting spending will reduce the State's borrowing requirement and that fiscal rectitude will also convince the markets that the Irish State is a sound investment and in turn, will reduce the cost of borrowing. Some chance. Unfortunately, none of this is supported by the facts. With each austerity budget the Government has pushed the economy further into recession. Cuts to wages and social welfare mean less money in people's pockets. Less money in people's pockets means less money spent in the real economy. Less money spent in the real economy, means more people out of work. As unemployment rises, tax revenues plummet, from €47.8 billion in 2007 to an estimated €30 billion in 2010, pushing up the deficit and the State's borrowing requirement. There is a clear disparity between the economic policies of the Irish Government and those of the other industrialised countries. While most countries in the G20 adopted some form of stimulus measures, Ireland's unique experiment in contraction continues to depress activity and tax receipts, boosting only the unemployment level and the budget deficit.

Rather than realise the error of its ways, the Government, supported by Fine Gael and the Labour Party — I hope that situation changes — is determined to continue cutting public spending in order to reduce the deficit to the agreed 3% of GDP by 2014. These kinds of policies squeezed into a four-year timeframe will have a devastating impact on both our economy and society. Unemployment will continue to rise. Tax revenues will continue to fall. The deficit will grow larger. The cost of borrowing will increase. Hundreds of thousands of people will be pushed further into poverty. It is happening on a daily basis. Ultimately, such policies will jeopardise the economic viability of the State itself. When it becomes apparent that the Government will be unable to meet the 2014 deadline and that the efforts to do so have caused great damage to the long-term capacity to recover, there will be another convulsion of confidence. The international markets may well choose to come back after us at that point. Is the Government approach feasible in terms of where the economy is now situated, and should the emphasis continue to be on deflating demand?

Comment on this