Macroeconomic and Fiscal Outlook: Statements
Contributions 94–183 of 183. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
I will conclude with this point. Sinn Féin has put forward an alternative approach to this mess, the Government-created economic mess. Our alternative is sensible and does not involve a policy of slash and burn. It involves a greater contribution from those people at the top who can afford to pay. We will give the Government our submission next week and I hope the Minister will take heed of at least some of the very sensible, well-costed proposals.
Comment on this
The Minister for Transport, Deputy Noel Dempsey, and Deputy Seán Haughey are sharing a time slot of 20 minutes.
Comment on this
I am pleased to have this opportunity to address the House on the macroeconomic and fiscal outlook. In reference to what Deputy Morgan said, I look forward to Sinn Féin submitting its plan to the Department of Finance for costing. We can then have a debate on real issues on how to tackle this crisis. I am particularly interested in seeing a justification for the introduction of a 48% tax rate for individuals earning over €100,000 a year. Deputy Morgan did not have time to outline fully his party's proposals but I ask him to explain how two people living in the same house both earning €99,999 would escape this 48% tax rate while one household with an income of €101,000, will face the full hit of that rate. I wonder how this will work out and how fair it would be.
Comment on this
I welcome the fact that Sinn Féin has indicated it will publish that plan. I hope other parties will do likewise and that the Government will be in a position to put its plans forward so that the House can have a real and balanced debate. The scale of the commitment we have made in the House to reduce the deficit to 3% of GDP in 2014, will be a very difficult one. As has been said by many speakers today, it equates to an adjustment of €15 billion over the next four years. We do not need to tell anybody either inside or outside the House how big a challenge this will be but it is a challenge we must manage and to which we must face up as a country. The process will not be painless nor can it be painless, despite what some people might like the public to believe, but it is manageable. If I had been told two years ago in 2008 when the scale of this crisis began to emerge in Ireland and around the globe, that just two years later I would be able to tell this House that we had €14 billion of adjustments in that two-year period, I would not have believed it. That is the scale and the measure of what has already been achieved. At a time when people are worried and concerned and many are probably depressed about the situation, we should take some heart from how people have responded. The public has shown its mettle. People have dealt with very difficult decisions which the Government has had to take. What has happened in the recent couple of years underlines the fact that people will accept difficult decisions if they understand them, if they think they are fair and if they think they are the right decisions for the country in the longer term. People know that without the decisions taken by the Government, the country's situation would be significantly worse than it is. If we had not taken those decisions, the country would lack any credibility when trying to convince the markets that we are capable and willing to work out our own affairs. This message has to be constantly repeated. We have to show by example that we are prepared to take on the difficult decisions.
It is most important that having taken those difficult decisions, we continue on a credible path to show we propose to meet this commitment of a 3% deficit in 2014. This will be evident in the four-year budgetary and growth plan to be announced early in November. This will incorporate annual measures and information. It will not make pretty reading as it will involve a number of very difficult decisions and difficult measures will be required to be implemented. The certainty it will bring will help people to plan for the future.
The four-year plan will need to strike the correct balance between reducing the deficit through targeted spending cuts, increasing taxation, obviously, and trying to put in place a package to allow for growth in the economy. This is a very delicate balance. I agree with the leaders of Fine Gael and the Labour Party that we must try to strike the correct and delicate balance between the spending reductions and cuts and increases in taxation. We need to try to do that in a way that does not hinder growth. It is obvious that in the first year or so, the expenditure reductions and the removal of moneys from the economy will have an effect. In the longer term, it will be extremely important to get the balance right.
I was somewhat amused by some of the coverage I saw, as well as some of the statements I heard in the House earlier, to the effect that the Government has all the answers at this stage, having had just two meetings on this issue. The Government has been meeting twice a week for some weeks now to work through the plan and the budget. We intend to make the difficult choices with which we are faced. We will look at all aspects of the matter to try to ensure our decisions are fair to everybody. We have to meet our economic responsibilities. We have to protect the fabric of our society, which involves protecting the most vulnerable to the greatest extent possible.
It is important that we facilitate economic growth, which is the best guarantee for the future of this country and its people. We are focused on getting people back to work as quickly as possible, and economic growth is the optimum way of achieving this. That is why, when we hit the full force of the fiscal crisis in 2008, we set out a four-cornered plan which involved restoring the banking system, getting the public finances in order, protecting and creating jobs, and restoring competitiveness. Despite many distractions and difficulties since then, the Government has focused on each of the four objectives. Our approach has been consistent and methodical. We have been creating the conditions in which economic growth can drive employment and reduce the debt burden.
The various steps we have taken have been working. The circumstances are changing. It is important that our four-year plan continues to deal with the four issues I have mentioned. We hope the banking issue is largely settled at this point. We have to give our constant attention to the other three issues. It is important to try to reach as much consensus as possible in this House. I do not expect the Opposition to decide to take the odium for the decisions we will take. I accept that the first step it has taken in accepting the 3% deficit is an important one. There could be a great deal more consensus in this House. The Government will take the decisions that are needed. The Irish people, and those further afield who are watching this country, should be certain that the four-year plan that is to be put in place will send the right messages to the markets, nationally and internationally. I believe it should receive the support of this House.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this pre-budget debate. I will mention some of the initiatives in which I am involved as Minister of State with responsibility for lifelong learning. The Government's proposed four-year budgetary strategy, which will last until 2014, has been the subject of widespread commentary in recent days. The Government moved swiftly yesterday to reveal the amount of money involved in the planned correction. It is conscious that the financial markets now expect significant reductions in this country's deficit. If we fail to deliver those reductions, it will have negative consequences for the economy, including high interest rates.
The creation and protection of jobs is a political priority for the Government. The four pillars of our approach to the jobs issue are as follows: activation measures, employment schemes, training and upskilling; the promotion of exports and inward investment; the targeting of improved competitiveness and productivity; and reductions in the cost of doing business. There is a consensus among the major political parties about the need to achieve the 3% deficit target by 2014. If we are to demonstrate to the international community that we are competent to manage our own affairs, it is of the utmost importance that we plan for this deadline.
The projected growth in the economy is not expected to be as positive as previously forecast. Consumer demand is likely to be affected as households and businesses prepare to save scarce resources or reduce personal debt. Tax revenues might not be as buoyant in future years aswe previously anticipated. Despite these uncertainties, the Government is committed to restoring sustainability to the public finances in order to underpin future economic growth and recovery.
Unemployment, which continues to impinge on families in this State, remains a political priority for the Government. Unemployment is an attack on self-esteem. A lack of employment opportunities can lead to heartbreak and hardship for people who are out of work, regardless of whether they are young or old, married or single. As the level of unemployment increases, it has a double impact on the public finances. Not only does the income tax take decrease as the number of people in work declines, but the number of people who depend on State unemployment payments and other allied benefits increases, which places a huge strain on limited Government resources.
I wish to concentrate on aspects of my ministerial responsibility, such as training and upskilling, that are relevant to this debate. I will also outline the steps the Government is taking in this respect to tackle the unemployment crisis. Following the Taoiseach's restructuring of Government Departments, responsibility for the training aspects of FÁS has moved to the Department of Education and Skills and is now within my remit. This allows for a more co-ordinated alignment of activation measures and training policy. The Government has moved swiftly to improve the plight of the unemployed. FÁS has introduced measures to double the annual JobSearch referral capacity to 154,000 places per annum. My Department will fund the provision of more than 160,000 training and work experience places for the unemployed in 2010. This represents an increase on the 66,000 such places that were provided in 2008.
We are prioritising four categories of the unemployed in order to minimise the drift into long-term unemployment. These are as follows: those who have low skills or education levels; those who have been on the live register for more than a year; those who are under the age of 35; and those who used to be employed in sectors like construction, manufacturing and retail. Employment levels in the three sectors I have mentioned, which have been severely affected by the downturn, are unlikely to return to their previous levels in the short to medium term. Last March, my Department launched the labour market activation fund, which will target the specific priority groups I have mentioned. Following a tender process which received 370 entries, 59 organisations in the private, not-for-profit and public sectors successfully secured funding. The organisations in question will provide up to 12,000 training places.
An additional 500 community employment training places were announced earlier this year, bringing the number of places that are available to 23,300. Community employment is designed to give the long-term unemployed and other disadvantaged people an opportunity to engage in useful work in their communities on a fixed-term basis. The programme helps the unemployed to return to the labour market by breaking their experience of unemployment and giving them a work routine. It helps them to enhance and develop their technical and personal skills. This year, Skillnets and FÁS will provide almost 10,400 training places to the unemployed and those on short hours.
The issue of youth unemployment is of particular concern. In light of the increase in the number of unemployed people who are under the age of 25, the Government has decided this category will receive preferential access to State supports such as FÁS employment and training services. This agency is prioritising services for the under 25s and an initiative has been put in place to immediately activate measures for 18 to 19 year olds without needing to wait the usual three months for automatic activation. The main provision continues to be at community training centres and VECs under the Youthreach programme. Some €110 million is being invested in Youthreach and will provide 6,000 places.
The work placement programme provides up to nine months work experience to 2,000 unemployed persons, including graduates. The Government also introduced a range of measures that will enable 4,000 redundant apprentices to progress their apprenticeships. Among these are 30 apprentices formerly employed by SR Technics who are being taken on by the Air Corps to complete phases five and seven of the on-the-job training element of their apprenticeships. I am delighted this specialist branch of the Defence Forces has had the vision and willingness to engage in partnership with FÁS to initiate this programme.
An estimated 166,000 learners, including those who are unemployed, will benefit from full-time and part-time further education opportunities. The total number of full-time enrolments in universities and institutes of technology will be in excess of 140,000 this year. Investment in further education provided by the VECs has increased by 60% between 2002 and 2010 to €426 million, enabling 170,000 learners to participate in a range of part-time and full-time courses in 2009. An additional 1,500 new places were provided on post-leaving certificate courses from September 2009, bringing the total number of places nationwide to 31,688. Adult literacy is extremely important in this context and the budget for that is now €30 million.
The back to education allowance is very important for those wishing up-skill and reskill and return to education and training. There are approximately 21,000 people in receipt of the back to education allowance.
The European globalisation fund is another imaginative fund being utilised in an Irish context. The Government is moving to reskill redundant workers formerly employed in large-scale operations by availing of EU co-financing support under the European globalisation adjustment fund. In recent weeks, I was able to announce that up to €11.5 million in funding will be available for former workers in SR Technics for measures implemented since their redundancies. An application for the construction sector, based on 8,000 workers and for €63 million, was submitted in June 2010 to the European Commission.
The Government is acutely aware that positive measures to promote employment are essential if economic recovery is to proceed sooner rather than later. If we have learned anything from the 1980s, it must surely be that selected developmental measures to stimulate the economy must run parallel to any programme to tackle the crisis in the public finances. The national skills strategy and the activation and training measures outlined also have an important role to play if the economy is to recover quickly.
The Government has already shown it has the capacity and resolve to address our current economic difficulties. Since July 2008 budgetary savings of €14.4 billion have been achieved. Positive growth has been forecast for 2011. Economic recovery will lead to a strong export performance, which continues to exceed expectations. That we face intimidating difficulties is not disputed but this Government, led by the Taoiseach, has shown that it is ready and willing to meet the tough economic challenges. It has moved to take corrective action, it has the drive and commitment to implement further necessary measures and it will not be influenced by short-term political or any other sectional considerations.
The Government continues to put the country first and I have no doubt history will judge that it is doing the right thing at the right time and in a forthright and fair-minded manner. The Government remains committed to its budgetary strategy to protect our economy for future generations. It will not be deflected from its course of action.
Comment on this
I am glad to speak in this debate, although it is frustrating that I only have seven minutes. I will endeavour to try to make some points which I hope will hit home with the Deputies opposite. Everyone in this House accepts Ireland is on an unsustainable path as unemployment continues to increase and businesses find the going tougher. Ireland spends approximately €55 million per day more than it earns and we need to borrow the difference. Currently, we are surviving on reserves because of money we borrowed earlier in the year and, potentially, the reserves in the National Pensions Reserve Fund, which will not last forever.
Everybody recognises Ireland will need to go back to the bond markets in the first quarter of next year, as the Department Finance has confirmed, to borrow money, regardless of the level of cutbacks in the first of four tough budgets. I find it extraordinary that nobody from the Government side dealt with the key issue in regard to our capacity and ability to borrow from the bond markets next year. My understanding from the briefing from the Department of Finance is that the key requirement from bond markets to allow Ireland to issue bonds is that we will need to bring our deficit below 10% of GDP next year from our current position. No Government speaker, including the Taoiseach and the Minister for Finance, addressed that issue as to what figure will be necessary in the 2011 budget to bring down the deficit to 10% or less of GDP. That is the guideline figure we have been given to issue bonds and raise money in order that we can keep Ireland functioning and keep our economic and political independence in terms of budgetary decision-making. Nobody on the Government side addressed that point and perhaps Ministers who will speak later in the debate will do so.
There must be a twin track approach, about which many Deputies, including Government Ministers and Deputies, have spoken. We need to bring our deficit down and the Government has set itself a figure of €15 billion over four budgets, but we do not agree with that yet because we do not have the full figures, in particular the growth figures. However, we agree that by 2014, we need to get the deficit down to 3%, or less, of GDP. Time will tell whether €15 billion will be enough or perhaps too much. Fine Gael will make its position clear well in advance of the budget. However, at the same time, there can be no future with optimism in Ireland unless we can get growth into the economy as we are dealing with structural deficit problems which are the result of insane Government policy over a number of years.
I wish to comment on some recent Government policy. There are two problems here — first, there is the policy itself and, second, there is the execution of policy which is an even greater problem. Even when the Government gets something right in principle, the execution of that policy is incompetent, inefficient or does not meet targets. I refer to the Croke Park agreement, for example. In principle, it was a good idea to get agreement among unions and employers to try to bring stability in a time of recession. What has happened? Six months later there has been no delivery. The Government still cannot give the Opposition a figure on how much it estimates it will save by public sector reform next year.
I refer to NAMA. The principles behind it made some sense, although there were problems. It required the banks to crystalise their losses and their bad lending. It was to provide capital to banks in order that we could get liquidity back into small business and so on. What has happened? There has been an absolute freeze on liquidity. Banks are being financed on a week-to-week basis by the lender of last resort in Europe, the European Central Bank. They do not even have money to lend, never mind a willingness to take risks again and lend money to the marketplace. That is largely because of NAMA which, we were told at the start, would attach a hope value to certain properties. It is now undervaluing properties so that it can get headlines such as those in the past week stating that it is making a profit of €130 million on a property that it acquired from Anglo Irish Bank. Such news is not a win for the country. It means that the bank has crystalised an even bigger loss that taxpayers need to bail out because we own Anglo Irish Bank. Either way, the taxpayer is losing.
On deficit reduction policies, Ministers, one after the other, have complimented themselves on the great achievement of reducing the deficit by €14.5 billion over the past two and a half years. I would like to check the figures.
Comment on this
The calculations of those figures have been wildly inaccurate. Up until two months ago there was talk of the need to reduce the deficit by €7.5 billion over the next four years but now it is to be by €15 billion. Some in the European Union state the figure should be €20 billion. We need to concentrate, not only on getting policies right in this House but also on their execution, which is crucial.
On banking policy, a new CEO will be appointed to AIB. I would like a Minister to tell this House what is that person's job remit. I am not sure whether it is to run AIB as a commercial entity in the interests of a future bank system or for the benefit of the economy. If a CEO going into AIB were to run it for the shareholders of the bank he or she would probably cut the staff by one third, raise interest rates and do away with the existing defined pension schemes for staff, but the State will not allow a CEO to do that because it now has a majority stake in the bank. Banking policy in Ireland has totally distorted the market because now politics is determining banking policy, which means that there will be no new banks without capitalisation problems coming into Ireland to lend into the Irish economy in the foreseeable future. We have a totally false banking system, which is a false economy and which cannot work. I hope Ministers will try to address some of the issues that I have only had seven minutes to raise.
Comment on this
Ministers are coming in here stating that the people can take bad news, they will put their shoulders to the wheel and they have taken €14 billion of cuts already. I do not accept the latter point, certainly not in the past two years. That needs to be corrected. It may be the case over three years, if the Government wants to go into that, but I still do not think there were such cuts. There were many cutbacks in capital projects and maybe the Government is including private capital spend in those cutbacks. On my figures, that is not the Government spend.
The people of this country can accept tough news. They know we have problems and they are willing to help out but they and I have a serious issue with believing anything the Government says. Even now, with the €15 billion figure, there is a lack of data on how that was achieved. I have a fair idea because I went to the confidential briefings at the Department Finance. I can add a few figures together and I know exactly from where they got it but we are not allowed to say.
The Government will not state what it will do in the budget yet it brings us all in here for a two-day debate to discuss cutbacks without the figures we need to achieve. There is no finishing line. It is like running a marathon at the weekend without knowing where it will end and running all day for fun. I will not do it, and nobody else will do it either. Let the Government give us the figure because the Minister knows what it is.
Deputy Coveney is correct in stating that we must bring the deficit down below 10% of GDP next year, and I ask the Government to give us the figure now. Tell us what it is, whether it be €5.5 billion, €6 billion, €5 billion or €4.5 billion, and let us work to that. The people need to believe what the Government is telling them, and they do not believe the Government. It is difficult for me to believe the Government because it is still only opinion unless the Government gives us the facts to back it up.
In trying to figure out how we got here, I looked at the figures for total expenditure from 2000 to 2008. For example, the health spend went from €5.3 billion to more than €15.3 billion in eight years, an increase of 187%. The Exchequer pay bill went up by 118%, from €8,880 million to €19,330 million. The figures go on. Those eight years of writing cheques without proper reform or proper policy are the root of the problem, and the people need to be told that.
There is a need to explain what this figure of €15 billion is about. It is separate to the banking bailout, although part of it is the interest on bailing out the banks. The bulk of it is to address the wrong decisions made from 2000 to 2008 to spend money on public services built on false foundations or once-off revenues from housing, as if the Government applied for a mortgage based on overtime earnings only. It does not add up.
I question what was going on in Government during those eight years. Deputy Bertie Ahern needs at some stage to come in here and explain what he was doing as Taoiseach, as does Deputy Brian Cowen as the former Minister for Finance, and every other Minister who sat around the Cabinet table and watched these figures rise and rise. Nobody shouted stop. That is why we are here. When people have made their commitments, borrowed money, and got credit card and other personal debts, they will be hit with massive cutbacks over the next couple of years because of the decisions taken wrongly during those years.
I question what was going on in the Department of Finance as well. I can only assume they were told to keep quiet by Ministers and Taoisigh because nobody with financial training would sit back, watch this happening and not ask, "Hold on a minute, what is going on here?"
I accept there were improvements in some services, but these should have been achieved based on sound foundations, reform of the public sector and savings, rather than by continuing to write cheques left, right and centre. The Department of Finance blames the partnership process and states many of these demands for increases in services were in the context of the social partnership process and reflected in programmes for Government. Ministers and the Government are in charge, not the social partnership process. The social partners are not in charge. They do not run the country. They were there to discuss issues, iron out difficulties, etc. They are not to be blamed for matters going wrong.
On numerous occasions during my nine years in the House, I tried to introduce minor amendments to various Bills and Ministers told me that they could not accept them without going back and checking with the partnership process. That is a joke, and now the Government is trying to blame them. Those are matters that will be confined to history. The people know who is at fault here. They know it is Fianna Fáil and they will deal out that punishment.
The problem is that we in this House are always left trying to close the gap and fix this, and we need the will of the people to do so. That will be difficult to achieve with Fianna Fáil still over there calling the shots because the people do not believe them.
We understand we must try to work with this and we have agreed to the consensus to reduce the deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014. We accept that and we will put forward our ideas to achieve it, and we will work with that. However, the Government must understand that the people do not trust it and we will have a difficulty, even when we know we have the answers, in believing that the Government can implement them.
Comment on this
Hopefully, we will get a chance to go through all the ideas. I could not do so in seven minutes.
We accept the adjustment must be front-loaded and we must try to take on an extra chunk of the deficit in year one, but we must also front-load growth in the first two years. These are the toughest budgets in terms of seeking to protect growth and jobs. There must be a front-loaded growth strategy. We in Fine Gael have plans for that and the Government knows them. The Government has read them but has never tried to discuss them properly. I would ask the Government to read them and let us have a proper debate on them. We have more plans to add to them. We can use private and public pension funds, among other initiatives, to fund growth. The Government must not close the door on good ideas when it is calling for a consensus. Let us debate these ideas properly, as we have tried to do in recent weeks. I ask the Government to give a commitment that the budget will include proper growth strategies alongside cutbacks and other changes.
Comment on this
While I am the first to admit that I have no formal education in the area of finance, as a housewife and mother, I have learned the art of running a home and family on a budget and the cold, hard fact that one can only spend what one has in one's purse and not one penny more. The Government has spent the contents of many a household purse and makes no apology for doing so. Every man, woman and child must now pay the price for its reckless spending and greed.
A generation of people will have to leave home to work abroad because they cannot afford to stay. Our youngest and brightest will leave these shores and many will never return. Fear has become a familiar word, one I hear on the doorsteps of every street as people relate to me their fears for the future. They fear for their children and whether they can afford their education. They fear for their health and whether they can afford to pay medical expenses. They fear they will not be able to pay back bank loans. They fear old age and whether they will have any money to live on in the years ahead. Senior citizens are afraid they will not be able to pay their bills or keep themselves warm and that services, such as home help provision, which allow them to live independently will be removed. Above all, they are afraid the State pension will shortly be cut. Nobody deserves to live in fear, especially when he or she is not responsible for creating the problem.
Those who are guilty of creating the economic crisis have got away scot free. They have been allowed to go abroad, leaving behind their responsibilities and debts. They are enjoying holidays in the sun while their greed and dishonesty have left the country in a shambles. It is not fair that ordinary people have been left to clean up their mess and pay their bills. The reason people are so angry is they want fairness above all else.
As we face into budget 2011 this December, we know the economic outlook is very bleak. Members of the public want to know that we, their representatives in Dáil Éireann, are doing everything we can to improve the economy and lighten the burden on individuals and families who are struggling with bills and debt.
We all know the banking and economic policies pursued by the Government caused a major financial crisis. It is time to put in place a plan for recovery. People want to believe there is light at the end of the tunnel. We need to give them hope but hope is in short supply from the Government benches. The billions of euro in expenditure cuts and tax increases we need to be found by 7 December must not come at the expense of low income families and those on social welfare. The budget must be fair and must protect those who are most vulnerable, namely, the old, sick, young and disabled and those who cannot find employment.
Demands on social welfare assistance are increasing by the day and the annual social welfare bill now stands at an unsustainable €21 billion. We need to address unemployment head on and create new opportunities for young people who are completing school or college and for older people who want to return to the workplace.
The number of people on the live register stands at approximately 450,000, which is a substantial figure. We must get people back into employment. The Government must give a commitment to attract investment and enterprise and support home-grown enterprise. Banks must also open their doors again to small businesses.
I take issue with the manner in which FÁS treats young apprentices who cannot complete their training and obtain the certification they require to move abroad.
The current crisis was summed up for me and my family at the weekend when my young grand-niece was taken as an emergency case to Tallaght hospital where she was resuscitated and placed on a ventilator. She could not be transferred to Our Lady's Children's Hospital in Crumlin because staff were not available there and had to be transferred to Temple Street Hospital where she has been in intensive care for the past five days. Diagnostic tests could not be analysed in the laboratory because staff were not available to do so over the bank holiday weekend, which means we still have not received any results. This is but one story arising from the crisis caused by the Government's poor management of the national finances.
Comment on this
Ba mhaith liom mo chuid ama a roinnt leis an Aire, an Teachta Padraig Ó Ciardha.
The Government strategy to deal with our current economic challenges and put Ireland back on the road to growth has three main elements. These have been set out in previous debates on this issue. The most important of them is the element that is currently under consideration, namely, the stabilisation of the public finances. The second element is the restoration of the banking system to ensure it is operational and we are able to do business international as a small, open economy. There is widespread acceptance that the measures taken in this regard have been necessary. The third element is to restore and enhance Ireland's competitiveness.
In the context of the four year plan, which is the background against which this debate is being held, one of the questions frequently asked relates to the growth figures that will underpin the programme. These figures are determinants in setting the €15 million target we must meet in reducing the Government deficit. It is worthwhile recalling that the growth targets on which every Government operates are based on figures provided by bodies such as the ESRI, Central Bank, International Monetary Fund, European Central Bank and other central banks, the European Commission and a host of banks and brokers active in this area. Officials at the Department of Finance analyse the figures provided by these institutions and, on the basis of the available evidence, produce a likely scenario against which decisions must be made.
Many people have been seeking definitive trends and forecasts. Anyone who does not accept that the business of forecasting is based on the best available information and data is refusing to face reality. We must also remember that Ireland has commitments under the Stability and Growth Pact which predate our current difficulties. This is the background against which measures will be taken.
The current shortfall in the public finances is of the order of €19 billion. This raises two difficulties. First, we must access funding of €19 billion to be able to provide services to the standards we currently enjoy. The second difficulty, which is extremely important in the current climate, is that we must be able to access funding at a reasonable cost. One of the difficulties we have encountered in recent times is that the cost of borrowing has increased dramatically. This has an impact on our capacity to provide the type of services we need.
On the positive side, we do not generally give ourselves credit for the fact that we have, over the past two and a half years, managed to make adjustments amounting to approximately €14.5 billion. This figure is close to the cumulative value of the adjustments we must make in the coming four years. We made the previous adjustments successfully, although I concede that they created difficulties for people and had an impact on growth projections. Nevertheless, we have de facto reached the halfway point in terms of achieving our objectives in that regard, which is highly encouraging. A host of other encouraging figures also need to be considered.
It should be acknowledged that we are trying to achieve growth and address the nation's finances against a difficult economic climate. Across the world, growth levels are negligible and in some cases negative. This creates difficulties for small, open economies such as Ireland. That we need to export 90% of the goods and services we produce — in some sectors the figure is higher — makes the challenge even more difficult for us. In addition, it is an external factor over which we do not have control.
We must also acknowledge that Ireland's GDP figures are in deficit to the tune of approximately 12%. The banking crisis has a once-off impact in 2010 and will not arise in subsequent years. If one considers the historical position in 1986, the GDP deficit then was in excess of 13%. Two years later, however, in 1988 on foot of the adoption of strong measures and of cuts in particular, that deficit had been reduced to 3.3% with a negligible impact on growth. There are counterintuitive indications that, in some circumstances, addressing the fundamentals of a country's finances has the opposite effect to what one might expect in respect of elements of growth. However, in the case of other elements it is clear that cutbacks in expenditure in particular are likely to have a negative impact on growth and this is a judgment that must be made as one goes along.
In another positive feature, particularly when one considers the late 1980s, it must be borne in mind that at present, 1.8 million people are employed in Ireland, which is very close to twice the number who were in employment at that time.
The projections, which are based on there having been little or no growth internationally and less growth in Ireland than was expected, have led to the position whereby we face €15 billion in adjustments. If one looks back at the reasons for the different forecasts made last year, one does not even need to look back that far to find considerable growth, because in the first quarter of 2010, GDP grew at the extraordinary rate of 2.25%. This rate then was followed by a fall in GDP of 0.25% in the second quarter. It is clear, therefore, that a trend did not emerge of growth either quarter on quarter or year on year. However, if one considers the impact on GDP during the recession, I note the decline in GDP in 2008 was approximately 4% while it declined by a further 10% in 2009. This year, in 2010, this fall in GDP value will have reversed and the figure will come out roughly even, that is, either slightly above or below the zero mark. However, this is a strong indication that notwithstanding the removal from the economy of the huge sum of approximately €14.5 billion in real terms, we experienced that change from a decline of 10% to the zero mark.
At one level, therefore, highly encouraging signs are evident. They are even more encouraging if one considers manufacturing output or the growth in exports. There have been quite extraordinary achievements in that regard, particularly given that many Irish exports go to economies in which there is no real growth or that face extraordinary challenges regarding their capacity to buy goods and services. Moreover, one must take into account the currency fluctuations that have created enormous difficulty in some markets for Irish exporters. While it must be acknowledged that the decline in the value of the euro has benefited exporters to the United States market and some others, there has been considerable volatility in the world markets.
When one considers the events of the past year, the cost of addressing the banking crisis has been established, satisfied, done and dealt with. For the next decade or so, there will be an additional ongoing cost of approximately 10% arising therefrom. However, this means the cost of addressing the country's finances constitutes approximately 90% of the problem. Therefore, the great bulk of the problem relates to the issues arising from our own national finances and this is an issue with which one must deal and to which one must face up.
An important element in respect of growth is translating such growth into job creation with as much speed as possible. Against the highly difficult background in which we have operated last year and during the first half of this year, a little more than 50 foreign direct investment announcements, accounting for more than 4,000 jobs, have been made, which is a positive achievement. Moreover, the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Innovation is on a three-city tour of the United States at present to meet foreign direct investors and he will go on to the Middle East next week with the agencies. One must bear in mind that the impact of such visits and the work of the State agencies is highly positive and succeeds in bringing people into Ireland with foreign direct investment, thereby giving rise to huge job creation opportunities.
One must balance the message. One must realise that notwithstanding the difficult and somewhat daunting challenges we face, the experience of the last two and a half years demonstrates that the policies pursued by the Government have brought us a considerable number of steps along the way. Moreover, continuing to adhere to such policies undoubtedly will address the difficulties that have beset the national economy and will return us both to appreciable GDP growth and to a jobs spin-off therefrom.
Comment on this
Cuirim fáilte roimh an deis seo labhairt faoin bplean eacnamaíochta atá againn chun tabhairt faoi na dushláin ollmhóra atá romhainn mar thír. Mar Rialtas, ní chuireann muid aon fhiacal ann faoi na fadhbanna seo agus míneofar go beacht cad atá le déanamh agus cén fáth. Tá an plean seo bunaithe ar an tír iontach seo a chur ar bhóthar a leasa arís. Is é an plean ceart agus is é an t-aon phlean atá inchreidte má tá fúinn na dúshláin atá romhainn a shárú. I welcome the opportunity to speak on this important issue. It certainly is the most important period in the economic and social life of Ireland since I first entered the Dáil in 1997. I listened with interest to as many previous speakers as possible and thought that most contributions were both reflective and thought-provoking and that they will contribute to a greater consensus on the serious plight with which the Government must deal.
The Government has stated its intentions clearly to the people. It has outlined its goals and has explained its reasoning and will continue do so in the coming weeks. It has been up-front about the magnitude of the challenges we face. It has engaged constructively with the Opposition and has been clear that there are no easy options or soft decisions, as to pretend otherwise would be to mislead the people about the seriousness of the challenge we face. It would be an unthinkable failure of government to pretend that we somehow can wish away our current difficulties. This is not a challenge that we can put off until some magical tomorrow but we must act swiftly and decisively. While the Government has listened to various alternative views, both inside and outside the House, on how it should approach the task that now faces our country and people, the plan it has set out is the only credible one. It will not be a painless task but any attempt to postpone that pain or sugar the pill would put the economic future of our country at risk. This is not a risk the Government is prepared to take and I do not believe the people wish to do so either. I am not being condescending but wish to comment positively on the worthwhile solutions I have heard thus far. They will feed into the Government's discussions both in respect of the four-year framework plan and regarding the preparation of the budget later this year.
Recently, the Government drew a line under the uncertainty in the banking sector, thereby allowing it to concentrate on getting the public finances back on track. This is not just about gaining the trust of the international markets and ensuring our ability to borrow, but also is about job creation. We have learned from our experiences in the 1980s that unless businesses have faith in the viability of the Exchequer's long-term position, they will not create new jobs. This is the reason the Government is stressing, above all else, the credibility of its plan. Its ability to get people back to work and return the economy to growth depends on that credibility. Again, this is not just about impressing the faceless markets but is about creating jobs for citizens and securing their future. In order to create employment and growth, we must show that we have the courage to be credible and that we have the courage of our convictions. In so doing, we must get the balance right to ensure that our potential to return to growth is not damaged. However, the consequences of failing to act now cannot be ignored.
There is no question but that the Government will strive to be as fair as possible in the decisions it will make. As Minister for Community, Equality and Gaeltacht Affairs, I have seen at first hand the important role played by communities across Ireland in developing the economy. Our communities are the building blocks of our economy and society and the strength of such communities always will depend on their ability to protect their most vulnerable. Both the House and the Government will strive to protect the most vulnerable among us and I reject the simplistic notion that a severe budget is by necessity going to be an unfair budget or one that targets the most vulnerable. Research by the ESRI has analysed the distributive impact of the tax and welfare changes of the 2009, 2009 supplementary and 2010 budgets, and while those budgets were characterised in some quarters as unfair or as excessively targeting the less well off that is simply not the case.
That research shows that households in the bottom half of the income distribution maintained their position and in some cases recorded modest income gains of between 1% and 3%. By contrast, better-off households saw falls in their income of around 3%, with the richest households losing the most, at 6%. This shows that Government budgetary policy during the fiscal crisis has protected the living standards of lower income groups and placed the burden of the tax and welfare adjustments on better-off households. We will continue to make every effort to protect the most vulnerable. So, while we must all bear the burden of these necessary savings, our economic priorities will continue to be informed by our social priorities.
A recent report commissioned by my Department has shown that in recent years Government intervention through social transfers has made a real difference to the lives of the marginalised and has helped to tackle poverty and social inequality. While all sectors of society will have to bear some of the burden of budgetary savings we are also conscious of the need to ensure that the significant progress made in tackling inequality is not squandered.
The Irish people have shown great backbone and resilience in dealing with this crisis. As a people we have held our nerve and as a Government we must continue to hold our nerve. There is no point whatsoever in giving people unrealistic hope about the scale of the challenge we face. The Irish people deserve better than that. There is no point in peddling wishful thinking. We are not playing fantasy budget here. This is a very real crisis that requires a decisive and pragmatic response.
The Opposition parties now accept the need to return to the 3% of GDP deficit figure by 2014. We are also, I believe, in agreement that this target has to be achieved without jeopardizing the ability of our economy to return to growth. That consensus is welcome but we should not now return to the type of posturing that only adds to our problems. Our present situation demands more than platitudes about change and making a new start. I welcome what I have heard today.
We need real solutions to real problems. We know that the best way to get people back to work is to get our house in order and we are doing that by fixing the banking system, restoring order to the public finances, regaining our competitiveness and creating jobs. As my colleague, Deputy Killeen, has said, our economy is emerging from recession with the prospect of stronger growth next year. Our return to competitiveness has been led by our export performance with new figures today showing a 12.8% growth in merchandise exports in the third quarter of this year and a 9% increase in total exports.
Our stability plan is vital to our efforts to return to growth but it is important to stress that it is not being undertaken in isolation from our growth strategy, our smart economy plan, our jobs strategy and our plan for structural economic reform. Our growth and jobs strategy is a comprehensive plan to get people across Ireland back to work and to secure the jobs of those currently in employment.
In my own Department, for example, we have responsibility for the Leader programme which will create 12,000 jobs in rural Ireland. I have seen this programme at work all over the country and I am determined that every last cent of the €440 million available will be spent on job creation in rural Ireland. Leader has the potential to transform rural Ireland, village by village, parish by parish, town by town and job by job. We can see the benefits of Leader already, for example in the work of Farrelly Willow, Ireland's leading company in willow production, based in Kells, County Meath. I visited it recently. The company will be among the biggest producers of biomass in the country and will be selling biomass into the new electricity generating plant in Ferbane in County Offaly. One of the problems which I freely acknowledge we need to resolve, is the excessive regulation faced by such companies. Other companies benefiting from Leader are Spring Water in Lisseycasey, County Clare; McCarthy's Ice-cream in Ballybunion, County Kerry; Dooley Wool Limited in County Offaly; and O' Donnell's Crisps in Clonmel in Tipperary. These are real examples of putting enterprise to work.
In my Department, we are also currently reviewing our White Paper on rural development to ensure that it meets the changing needs of rural Ireland. In the last two weeks I met the EU Agricultural Commissioner and the EU Commissioner for Regional Development about the many issues that face rural Ireland. I am convinced that we are getting a very good hearing from the Commission.
In 2009, Údarás na Gaeltachta, which also comes under the remit of our Department, created 710 new jobs, despite the change in the economic climate and total full-time employment in Údarás na Gaeltachta-assisted companies at the year end was 7,472.
In the coming weeks, I hope to finalise the Government's ambitious 20 year strategy for the Irish language. This strategy is not just about promoting and preserving the Irish language, it is also about ensuring that we benefit from one of our great natural resources.
The Government will ensure that the great qualities of the Irish people continue to flourish. That is the reason we are taking these difficult steps. Our guiding motivation is to return our country to the levels of stability, employment and growth that the Irish people deserve.
Cuímhním ar an seanfhocal cáiliúil: Ní neart go cur le chéile. Tuigeann muintir na hÉireann fírinne an ráitis sin. Tuigimid mar Rialtas chomh maith é agus déanfaimid beart de réir ár mbriathar.
Comment on this
With the agreement of the House, I wish to share my time with Deputies O'Dowd and Clune.
Let me put some scale on the deficit we face. If we pay back one euro every single second it will take us 465 years to pay back the €15,000,000,000 deficit we will face next year, and that is only one year's deficit. Things are not beyond hope. In the 1980s, the International Monetary Fund was at our door and there was much doom and gloom, perhaps even more than now because everything seemed impossible to overcome. However, we did overcome and we had sustainable job creation throughout the 1990s. Then of course, we had the Progressive Democrat philosophy of the noughties, which was shared by some of the leaders of Fianna Fáil who led us down the road of destruction to where we are today. I remember the comments that were made about my colleague, Deputy Richard Bruton, who was ridiculed when he raised genuine questions about what was happening. A former leader of the country told Opposition Members they should consider committing suicide because we were asking genuine and real questions that needed to be asked.
The blame game will not get us out of the mess we are in. Our job, as politicians, must be to give a future to young people. The Government is currently focused on the urgent and not on the important. We need to focus on the future, on jobs and on medium-term growth plans not just on the fire brigade action. Without this we cannot provide hope. The most vulnerable in our communities, the working poor, those who cannot work, children, disabled people and the elderly must not be sacrificed to address the budget stabilisation measures. They did not cause the problems or the mess we are in today and they did not benefit from the boom.
We need a Government that is willing to make a real difference and help those who want to help themselves. We have enough of Government being run for the people who are in it. Instead, we need a Government that will work for the people who elect it and pay for it. Deputies and those who are not covered by the Croke Park agreement must lead by example and have their wages cut significantly. We will get absolutely no thanks, or even an acknowledgment, for it but we need to be seen to lead by example. This must be done.
I look to my own constituency of Roscommon-South Leitrim, which is similar to every other rural constituency. The likelihood of creating jobs by bringing a big multinational player into the constituency is slim. In the current climate, we need to focus on what we are good at by supporting local indigenous employment, small businesses and the agri-food and tourism sectors. For example, we should use the public tendering process to support indigenous businesses by making it easier for Irish SMEs to win public tenders. It is critical that an environment be created in which SMEs can cost-effectively participate in public tendering processes. If the system is cost-effective for the small or medium enterprise, it will also benefit the purchasing agency. The tendering process has been structured in such a manner across Europe but this Government never considers indigenous companies.
We need to promote entrepreneurship at all levels of our education system and support access to loans and bureaucracy-free public funding. The Minister spoke about the Leader programme, the problem with which is one needs a degree to complete the application process. Surely it makes sense to streamline the 70 agencies which are at present involved in supporting small businesses.
We need to acknowledge that our agri-food sector is a vital part of the indigenous economy and, with 20,000 people dependent on it for employment, crucial to small and medium enterprises. These are real businesses. We need to get rid of the unnecessary bureaucracy and red tape that surrounds the food industry. A legally binding code of practice should be put in place for the grocery sector to promote fairness, balance and transparency.
Other speakers will address aspects of the tourism industry, such as the air travel tax, but I will focus on the contribution that the artistic and creative economy can make to our economic recovery and to counteracting the negative image fostered by the Government's gross economic mismanagement. On the basis of the report of the Western Development Commission thousands of jobs can be created in this sector, which employs more than 600 people in County Leitrim and a further 500 in County Roscommon. Irish artists can help to portray more positive images of Ireland and its capacity to create and innovate. One of the winners of the Your Country, Your Call competition, a screen writer and digital media consultant called Neil Leyden, proposed a global media hub which would foster the development of an Irish content industry association and anchor the creative economy in this country.
We have to focus on our strengths because we will never balance the books until we create employment. The fundamental flaw of the Government's policy was that it ignored the issue of job creation while writing whatever cheques were required to support the banks in the hope of getting us out of our economic mess. However, this strategy has made our situation even worse and it is galling for the most vulnerable in society to see reductions in the small amount of money they receive simply to bankroll those who got us into the mess in the first place. It is time we focused on the indigenous companies that can get us out of the mess by becoming the international players of tomorrow.
Comment on this
This is one of the most important debates to have taken place in this House for a long time. Our country was never before in such dire difficulties and never was there such a need for leadership from Government and Opposition Members and everybody else associated with public life.
Regardless of who was in power since the foundation of the State, former taoisigh were patriots who had fought in parliamentary elections or, indeed, on the battlefields of the 1916-22 period. They were held up as icons of the nation. Our State was founded on the struggles of Pearse and Connolly and the ideals of Wolfe Tone and others. Now, however, instead of the image of Pearse and Connolly in the office of the Taoiseach, the IMF and the European Central Bank are stalking the corridors of power. The Government has ceded our sovereignty with the bankrupt policies it introduced during the boom to benefit builders and bankers. Now we are left at the mercy of international bankers and the European Union, which, thankfully, are being positive and constructive towards us as we address our difficult financial challenges. We are no longer in control because of the Government's policies in the Galway tent. The Minister can smile if he wants.
Comment on this
The close relationship between the rich and powerful and successive Fianna Fáil Governments over the past 20 years has destroyed this country and left ordinary people at the side of the road.
Comment on this
Tens of thousands of people are facing negative equity or have loans which they will never be able to repay because they were in effect sub-prime borrowers. There is no getting away from that fact.
The IMF is deciding the limits of what we can do and the next budget will have massive impacts for those who have the least in our society. The Government's policies during the boom fed the avarice of a small number of rich people.
Comment on this
Read the ESRI reports on social policy.
Comment on this
The Minister may not want to listen to me but he will have to listen to the people when he knocks on their doors. We will insist that the Government produces the facts in advance of the budget so that we can understand the basis of its €15 billion projection and hold a transparent and open debate. As the Taoiseach noted today, the €15 billion figure is a forecast but we do not know the basis for it. Fine Gael will set out our budget proposals in this House but only when the Government has given us the full facts. As we cannot base our future on forecasts, we need to know the truth. The Government should not expect us to go along with policies about which we do not have full knowledge.
It is my responsibility to address issues pertaining to education, including FÁS. If anything broke the link between unemployed people and their retraining needs, it was the policies that allowed FÁS to waste much of its €1 billion budget during the boom, both at the top and in the system. We now know that training contracts were often corrupt. We will transform the training system for young people, something which this Government has abysmally failed to do.
Let us have an election in which the Government and the Opposition can present their budgets so that the people can make up their minds. The Government has no mandate and the people want change. Its time is up. Tá súil agam nach mbeidh a leithéid de Rialtas — cosúil leis an Rialtas atá againn anois — againn arís go deo.
Comment on this
This debate is probably the first of many as we head into very difficult times in trying to get the economy back on track. Fine Gael is committed to the target deficit of 3% of GDP by 2014 and in the coming weeks we will be outlining our plans for implementing change and economic policy, particularly in terms of job stimulus and getting this country working again.
It is a sad fact that the recent reckless policy pursued by the Government and the banks means we now find ourselves at the mercy of the faceless markets. We must act now, as we face budget 2011, to ensure we can access funding from these markets in the future, given they are dictating our budgetary policy. The Taoiseach stated earlier today that the figure of €15 billion that must be found between now and 2014 was arrived at by Government decision. However, it is merely a forecast and we do not know what growth factors were included, what decisions were involved, how the Government forecast growth and unemployment or how the money is to be found.
Earlier today, the leader of my party, Deputy Enda Kenny, outlined Fine Gael's plans in various areas, with a focus on an enterprise-led economy. The export figures released today are very good, as noted by many Government speakers, and exports will remain our focus. While competitiveness has improved, it has not improved due to anything the Government has done but because of the relationship of the euro to the pound and dollar, and because wages in this country have decreased voluntarily. However, Government charges, local authority charges and red tape all contribute to a distinct lack of competitiveness. It does not matter whether one is exporting a pound of butter or financial services, all the products and services we hope to export from this country are competing in European and global markets and the weight attached to them by excess Government charges is that of a millstone.
Now is the time to support the indigenous SME sector. Last week in this House, Fine Gael put forward a well thought-out motion, proposed by Deputy John Perry, outlining a State-backed loan guarantee facility for small and medium businesses throughout the country but it was rejected by the Government. We have been asked to come forward with positive suggestions and this is supposed to be an era of consensus. Last September the Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Innovation, Deputy Batt O'Keeffe, stated publicly that he wanted to introduce such a scheme yet he rejected Fine Gael's scheme last week. Why not take it on board? Not every aspect was perfect, but why not work with the Opposition in terms of implementing a measure that would give succour and support to small and medium enterprises?
The return to global growth will be crucial to achieving our targets but that is outside the control of whoever governs this country. What is within our control must be acted upon, however, and barriers to activity must be tackled. For a small open economy such as ours, particularly when domestic confidence is so low and will drop further, our exports are the key component that has the potential to provide growth and to bring known benefits and create jobs in the local economy, thereby creating a ripple effect for small and medium enterprises and resulting in increased revenue for Government. This is the track we should follow but we have allowed ourselves to come off the rails in this area. Property, development and land acquisition was too easy and, as a result, we lost much expertise across the economy in the last decade. We lost expertise in our banking system in regard to dealing with small business and enterprise and we lost the ability to manage a small, open economy that depends on the European and global market to sell its goods and services.
The Taoiseach in his earlier contribution referred to exports. I hope this was not mere rhetoric or grasping at straws but a serious intent to manage this area. Many reports have been produced, including those of the innovation task force and the recent Forfás report entitled "Making It Happen", and these have outlined the areas where local indigenous enterprises can be supported in terms of productivity, research and development, innovation and education attainment. We must develop an approach across certain viable sectors, such as communications, business, finance and insurance services. We have strength in these areas on which we need to build. The area of health care services is one where we have developed much expertise. We must also recognise that there are growth areas, including in regard to clean energy, green technology, the marine and maritime services, health care, particularly e-health care services, and IT, in which we have developed huge expertise. We need to tap into these and sell those services abroad, as well as supporting development in those areas. The area of education services is important and was highlighted today by Deputy Kenny. We can sell this nation as an education island in terms of exporting those services and bringing foreign students here.
Small and medium enterprises are the key to the growth of this country. The Government has the responsibility to create and develop the environment in which those enterprises can function and thrive.
Comment on this
Tá áthas orm deis a bheith agam labhairt ar an ábhar tábhachtach seo. I am pleased to have an opportunity to speak in what is a very important debate. There is no question but that we face huge challenges. However, we should analyse all of the issues we face in a dispassionate manner because, if we do so, we might find solutions to the very difficult problems we face.
On the credit side, the budget targets that were laid out last year in terms of income and expenditure of the State will be achieved. The big challenge we face, however, is that both internationally and nationally the growth forecast for the next four years is not as was expected. What will happen in the future is, of course, unknown and a matter of conjecture. What is important is that whatever budgetary strategy we have for the next four years is based on figures that are credible at home and abroad. For that reason, we have had to change the growth forecast.
It was Galbraith who said that economic forecasting makes astrology look respectable. Nonetheless, the big challenge we face is that no matter what we think of economic forecasting, it has a huge effect on the markets and, therefore, we have had to readjust our tack. I compliment the Fine Gael Party for recognising that there is no going beyond the budget deficit target of 3% of GDP by 2014. That is a very important consensus. There is no need for consensus on every issue and a bit of debate and difference is healthy. However, it is important that people can agree on the basic fundamentals and particularly important that this fundamental is agreed upon.
With regard to the extrapolation from there to the figure of €15 billion, the position is quite simple. A forecast of growth has been made — it is no big secret what that forecast is — and that inevitably leads us from where we are at present to a €15 billion amount to be made up. Again, on the credit side, it is important to recognise that Ireland's economic performance has improved dramatically in the past year. We have gone from negative growth of 9% to zero or slightly better growth this year, which is very important.
I listened to Deputy Fergus O'Dowd ask where the money went. It is important to recognise that whereas financial issues arose that we would all have preferred did not arise, the main expenditure increases are very clearly identifiable. Nowhere are they identifiable more clearly than in my Department, which makes transfers to pensioners, those with disabilities, lone parents and the unemployed
The increase in the social welfare budget since 2000 is very significant. In 2000, the expenditure of my Department was €6.7 billion whereas it is €21 billion this year. This represents a threefold increase over a period during which there was nothing like a threefold increase in the rate of inflation. Thankfully, the social welfare rate improved dramatically over the period in question. People will say that is easily explained because there is much more unemployment but when one examines the unemployment cost, one will note the unemployment bill for jobseeker's benefit and jobseeker's allowance is €4.3 billion. Allowing for the fact that there were always approximately 200,000 people on the live register, the extra cost would be somewhere in excess of €2 billion. This explains a small fraction, approximately 10%, of the extra expenditure. The vast majority of the extra moneys spent by the Department of Social Protection were spent because we improved the system.
Carers are very dear to my heart because all of us have family members who are involved in caring for loved ones, relatives and others we know. Caring is a very arduous task. The figures in this regard are very dramatic. In 2000, we were spending €99 million on caring. This year, the figure will be €726 million, which represents a sevenfold increase. When people ask where the money went, they must analyse the figures and recognise that the bulk of it was spent on additional investment in education, health and social protection. These are worth protecting and securing for the future. This is where we face the challenge. If we were to arrive in circumstances in which we could not borrow the money required for day-to-day expenditure while reducing the deficit on a scaled basis and opting for growth, the cut we would have to impose would be horrendous altogether. Therefore, the Government is endeavouring to find a middle way, that is, by trimming expenditure now and encouraging growth to try to find a way to reduce the deficit over time with the minimum impact on our vastly improved services.
When one takes into account the statistic that approximately one in every three euro allocated for day-to-day expenditure is borrowed, it becomes obvious to one what would happen if one's ability to borrow money at a reasonable price on the market were to diminish or, as the Taoiseach said this morning, if one could not borrow at all. Therefore, it is imperative that we make the tough decisions required, even though they are really difficult to make, particularly in my Department, given that one is more than conscious of the effects of those decisions on people. In this case it is a question of the old adage that a stitch in time saves nine. By making the adjustments now and front-loading them, we will save the people from much greater cuts and adjustments in the future.
With regard to my Department, there are other ways of saving money. We must work increasingly harder on control measures. I am introducing many more control measures. I hope to have the identity card in the new year. Every euro saved through keeping social welfare away from somebody who is not entitled to it is another euro that can be paid to somebody who is entitled to it. One of the messages we must get across to the people is that conniving with or supporting people who are defrauding the social welfare system is literally taking money out of the pockets of those who are disabled, old or genuinely unemployed. The black economy can and does do great damage to us. It also has a great effect on those in the legitimate economy because they cannot compete.
I have received support from Members of different parties for ensuring that we employ ever-better activation and control measures in order to abolish opportunities to cheat the social welfare system. I have been working very hard on the question of activation whereby a win-win scenario is achieved and whereby opportunities are given to those who are genuinely unemployed and want to be involved in community work. There is an opportunity to identify those who are not interested in working because they already have an income. We are currently running a number of pilot schemes in this regard and doing much more intensive activation work. It will be very interesting to see the results.
Let me make an analogy concerning what we must do, one which my colleagues in the Green Party will like because it is derived from nature. Often, if one wants a tree to grow, one must prune it. If one does not prune it, it will not grow the following year. On the other hand, if one prunes the tree too tightly, one might kill it. Our challenge is to prune correctly such that we will stimulate maximum growth. The means of stimulating maximum growth are those that will allow us to borrow cheaply on the international markets so we will not waste taxpayers' money on unnecessary interest and which will earn international credibility such that people will invest in our country. Such a method of pruning will, in the longer term, achieve the best balance and allow us to maintain the fundamental systems we have put in place.
This leads me to a point about which Fine Gael is particularly exercised and on which I agree, namely, that employment growth and economic growth comprise the key to emerging from our problems in the longer term. I agree with Fine Gael in this regard although I do not agree with every detail of its plans. It is telling us there is money that is not available.
Comment on this
I believed Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael were thinking of a merger.
Comment on this
The Labour Party was quick enough to jump into bed with Fianna Fáil——
Comment on this
The Deputy would probably find it was a bit to the left of the Labour Party, not to mind being left of Fine Gael.
Comment on this
Does the Minister want an application form?
Comment on this
No, because there are aspects of the Labour Party with which I do not agree. It is not looking after ordinary people. I fully agree with the Deputy in that regard. I will stand over my record of over 30 years in this respect.
As I stated, growth is the key. When we consider growth and attempt to create jobs, we must realise there are a number of basic requirements other than grants and other instruments. The first is that foreign investors must believe we have sustainable and stable growth. It is imperative that we get the message across that we do not intend to change the rate of corporation tax. This country has been very successful, over very many years, in attracting foreign direct investment, and we need to continue to do be so.
The second area of growth is within indigenous industry. In recent years, despite the difficulties with the sterling exchange, which were a great impediment to our indigenous industries, we have seen considerable resilience in the agriculture, forestry and marine industries. We must continue to support these industries and encourage native entrepreneurship. One of the great advantages of these industries is that they provide employment of good quality in every corner of the country. We have not exploited fully the potential to upskill and improve the quality of products in these industries. There is a lot of work we can do in this regard although much good work has been done in recent years.
Another industry with potential is the tourism industry. There has been a major growth in people's interest in rural recreation and marine leisure activities. Tourism is an area in which we have an abundance of natural resources. People from a number of nearby tourism markets wish to come and visit this country. By continuing to invest, through various schemes, including the Leader programme, in the natural resources to which I refer, we can create a large number of jobs.
There are good and bad aspects to the position in which we currently find ourselves. We face both challenges and opportunities. On the downside, we are facing into a huge budget deficit. It is fair to point out that this deficit is far more down to the decline in incomes than to the direct cost of the banking crisis. The international banking crisis led to the collapse of many countries' economies, while the crisis at home led to the collapse of the economy here. When one considers the direct cost in this regard, one discovers that the collapse in tax incomes to the State was the major factor. I accept that it is a significant imposition on taxpayers to oblige them to pay for the restructuring of the banks. The latter is perhaps one of the greatest challenges we face.
A second challenge relates to the need to ensure that the banking system proceeds to function once again. Businesses cannot operate without access to funding. The road in this regard has been slow and rocky. However, I am of the view that we are getting there.
I always believe that one should consider one's strengths. On the upside, therefore, we should consider our most important resource, namely, the number of young and well-educated people living in this country. It is important that we should continue to invest in education in the future. The second positive factor I would highlight relates to the strength of our balance of payments. Of course, this is led by the performance of our exports, which is a huge plus because it helps offset some of the problems we face.
People may not want to admit it, particularly as it is a legacy of the Celtic tiger, but the third positive for Ireland is the physical infrastructure that has been put in place. Deputy Ring and I have on many occasions been lobbied by the owners of factories in the west, including those in County Mayo, with regard to the condition of the roads. All of those involved in industry will admit that their ability to transport goods throughout the country has been transformed in recent years. There is now a motorway in place from Galway to Dublin. The motorway runs all the way to Mullingar and the remainder of the road includes some highly improved sections. I am as anxious as Deputy Ring to ensure that roads in counties Mayo and Sligo will continue to be improved.
Comment on this
The N5 from Westport to Longford must be improved.
Comment on this
Yes. De réir a chéile a thógtar na caisleáin.
There are also motorways to Limerick, Cork and Waterford. In addition, there are motorways which run almost all the way to Wexford and the Border. All of these roads have more or less been connected to each other and this has led to two major transformations. The first of these relates to the physical advantage of being able to transport goods and people from east to west.
The second transformation to which I refer involves the psychological advantage — this is incredibly important in my opinion — that has arisen in the context of foreign companies that are considering establishing operations here. Setting up a factory or whatever in any of the regions of this country is similar to establishing operations in the outer part of a city in the United States of America. I have often stated that the motorway system we have constructed means that the position is completely different from that which obtained ten years ago. When representatives from companies in the US consider establishing operations in Galway, Cork, Waterford or Limerick, they are of the view that asking people to travel to these places is similar to requesting that individuals in their home country travel from Chicago to Milwaukee, from New York to New Jersey or from San Francisco to San Jose. In other words, if one is travelling on a good-quality road, one's journey time is reduced. The Americans do not see the satellite cities to which I refer as being in any way isolated or difficult to service. This has made a major difference to our economy.
We must work through the difficult circumstances in which we find ourselves. Those in the farming community recognise more than most that there are good times and bad times. The times in which we are living are extremely difficult. The challenge we face is to build on our strengths and deal with the difficulties that have arisen. I am of the view that this country has major strengths. It is a complete misreading of the situation to compare our current position to that which obtained in the 1970s and 1980s. The country and the services that are provided within it have been transformed.
In the 1990s or early 2000s, if one had informed people that we would have anything similar to the social welfare system that is currently in place, they would have stated that it would never come into being. We have taken huge strides forward and what we want to do is retain, to the best of our ability, the ground we have gained. If this means making short-term adjustments in order to preserve our long-term future, then that is the correct route to take. I appreciate the support the Opposition has given to the main propositions we have put forward in respect of the basic targets which must be achieved, particularly in the context of reducing the deficit to 3%.
I do not doubt that as those in opposition study the position, they will realise that €15 billion in savings will be required. Any amount below that would not be viewed as credible internationally. I have a very simple message for those who ask why we are pandering to the markets rather than to the people of Ireland. If we cannot borrow money at a reasonable rate, we will not be in a position to pay for education, health or social welfare.
Ba mhaith liom buíochas a ghabháil as ucht deis a bheith agam an cúpla focal seo a rá. Creidim gur am dúshlánach é i saol phobal na hÉireann. Credim go mbeidh an pobal tuisceanach ar na fadhbanna ata romhainn. Tá jab mór le déanamh againn iad a mhíniú. Déanfaimid ár ndícheall é sin a dhéanamh chomh maith agus is féidir linn. Tá mé buíoch don tacaíocht atá le fáil ón bhFreasúra don bhunréasúnaíocht atá ag baint leis sin. Tá súil agam gur féidir linn tuilleadh comhoibriú a chothú agus muid i mbun gnóthaí na tíre.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputy Costello.
Comment on this
The starting point for the current debate on the economic crisis is centred on the 2014 target for cutting the budget deficit to 3%. I do not believe that the Government has yet made any kind of economically persuasive case in respect of the 2014 deadline. As Deputy Gilmore stated, we simply do not possess enough information to frame a one-year budget not to mention a four-year fiscal programme. Why has the Government not presented a proper cost-benefit analysis for the 2014 deadline, as well as alternative growth scenarios including a longer time period for the achievement of this massive proposed adjustment to the national economy? I am glad that ESRI and ICTU economists, among others, are now also questioning the reality of a 2014 target.
Everybody agrees that there is clearly a structural budgetary gap that must be bridged. However, we must not forget the devastation that has already been wreaked on our economy and society by senior bankers and their friends in Fianna Fáil. The September 2008 blanket bank guarantee given by Fianna Fáil and the Green Party has resulted in the absolute ruination of our national accounts for the better part of a decade. We will be obliged to spend billions, year on year, to pay just the interest bill for the zombie banks that acted in such a criminally dangerous manner during the past ten years.
Almost 450,000 of our citizens are unemployed and thousands of our younger citizens are once again emigrating. Canada, Australia, the US and the UK, among other countries, are again benefiting from the skills and talents of our educated young people. Core education, health and transport services have been under sustained attack for the past two years. As the Taoiseach stated, the Government has already taken an astonishing €14.5 billion out of the economy in that time. There is a very real danger that the its new €15 billion cutbacks plan could have a further devastating deflationary impact. It is not possible to just slash a further €15 billion out of the economy — on top of the previous €14.5 billion — and expect to see economic growth and jobs to magically appear. There is always the grave danger that a total of almost €30 billion in cuts will fatally injure and enfeeble the Irish economy for half a generation.
This discredited Government is extremely keen to encourage everyone to sign up to a four-year budgetary plan. However, it continues to hide the true total cost of its shocking mistakes from the people. The interest bill alone for the national debt repayments over the next decade will be an incredible financial burden. The Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, recently informed me that the forecast for the 2011 interest repayment on the national debt is €5.7 billion — that is, of course, if we are lucky in the international markets after Christmas. Let us consider the current position in the context of the fact that debt servicing interest cost in 2007 was just €1.6 billion and only €1.5 billion in 2008.
My colleague, Deputy Burton, has repeatedly raised the long-term cost to the State of the use of promissory notes, particularly in respect of the recapitalisation of Anglo Irish Bank, Irish Nationwide and the EBS. I understand that a total of €30 billion will be injected into these three financial institutions. As Deputy Burton has noted, the annual promissory note payments of perhaps €3 billion, plus the interest payments of at least 5%, will turn the ten-year payment plan into a financial noose around the necks of the people for the next 15 years at least. To listen to the Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, last week, it was as if the cost of these promissory notes were some sort of a virtual accounting exercise. The Fianna Fáil and Green Party Government seems determined to make ordinary low and middle income households pay for the disastrous approach to bailing out the banks.
There are credible alternative ways to address the economic crisis. I commend the many groups in civil society, the many academic economists, constituents and citizens who contact me regularly with their valuable ideas on how to address the crisis. The think-tank TASC, for example, has submitted a pre-budget document that sets out a path for recovery through job creation, an economic recovery fund and a fundamental rebalancing of the taxation system grounded in fairness and equality for all citizens. The recovery fund echoes our consistent Labour Party plans for investment, jobs and a strategic investment bank, which this Government has ignored since early 2009.
Analysts like Michael Taft and Fr. Seán Healy have produced proposals that envisage bringing as many as 100,000 new jobs on stream to assist citizens leaving the live register, modelled on Labour's part-time job opportunities programme from our last time in Government in the middle 1990s. Economist Dr. Tom O'Connor of the Cork Institute of Technology has provided a very valuable analysis of the current economic disaster as well as a comprehensive range of suggestions for stimulating the economy and getting people back to work. It is clear that our core focus should be on employment, infrastructural development and rebalancing taxes rather than swingeing cuts.
We repeatedly hear the mantra from Fianna Fáil, the Green Party and their supporters in the media asking what would we do. Ministers talk of there being no sacred cows in budget 2011 in terms of front-line health, education and transport services, social welfare benefits and infrastructural investment. Let me once again state my bitter opposition to further cuts to social welfare benefits, public sector pay and pensions given the sacrifices that have already been made and the likely pay freezes well into the future. There should be no untouchables or sacred cows on the taxation side either.
For example, if necessary we should at least have a cost-benefit review of the corporation tax rate. Economist Dan O'Brien of The Irish Times and formerly of The Economist has suggested that an increase of 2% or 2.5% would generate up to €650 million in tax revenue per annum without harming inward investment. TASC has also estimated that we could raise €1.5 billion on an annual basis by reducing the current exorbitant number of property and pensions-based tax reliefs. We know that the standardised rating of pension tax relief would yield perhaps at least €1.3 billion.
A constant mantra of would-be economist journalists, the modern equivalent of Noel Browne's public house dialecticians, is the demand for a site value tax or for a residential property tax. Such a tax, as always in Ireland, would in real terms impose most heavily on families in modest urban homes like those in the constituencies of the Acting Chairman and myself. Yet that commentariat will never consider an assets tax levied on the most wealthy or a simple wealth tax, which Dr. O'Connor estimates would raise at least €1 billion and which I believe should be part of the solution.
Most tax experts agree that by closing ongoing loopholes in the taxation system to reduce the numbers of tax fugitives we could raise at least a further €300 million. I note that the UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr. George Osborne, has reached a new and tighter agreement to access funds of UK tax fugitives in Switzerland, following a similar deal with Liechtenstein. On a comparable basis to the UK, is there perhaps another €1 billion of Irish tax fugitive funds escaping our Irish tax system? Have we made a similar agreement with Switzerland? There is an EU agreement but is there a specific agreement between Ireland and Switzerland dealing with tax fugitives? There is also a clear argument for a new third rate of tax for the highest earners, perhaps at 50%, and we know from the response of the Minister today to Deputy Eamon Gilmore that Labour's proposed new 48% rate will raise a very valuable €410 million.
The current crisis must be used to thoroughly reform the market economy. One of the more significant areas in need of reform is that of excessive pay in both the public and private sectors. The new leader of the UK Labour Party, Mr. Ed Miliband, has put a high pay commission at the heart of his agenda for reforming the dysfunctional compensation system. It is obscene that senior management in any organisation can earn a salary that is a multiple of a couple of hundred of the lowest paid worker in that organisation. As the great Polly Toynbee long ago noted, the cancer of outrageous pay and bonuses comes directly from the private sector and especially from financial services.
There should be a cap on public sector and semi-State salaries at a maximum of perhaps €150,000. Clearly we want effective, dynamic people leading our commercial semi-State and public sector organisations but a high pay commission that invigilates and regulates pay in the public and private sectors could be a mechanism for curbing excessive salaries that may discourage dynamic people from considering leading public sector positions.
At the opposite end of the public pay spectrum are many low and middle income public and civil servants who signed up to the Croke Park agreement because they believed it would protect them from any further devastating pay cuts and new income levies. As a past member of the Committee of Public Accounts for eight years I am aware of major savings which can be made in enhancing efficiencies in the delivery of public services, which the Government has been incredibly lethargic in addressing. The Croke Park agreement should be adhered to and the pay of hard-pressed low and middle income public servants should not be targeted for a further savage attack in the 2011 budget. It is true there remains an astonishing level of inefficiencies and waste throughout the system of governance and administration. The Parliament and Government could clearly work just as effectively with the Dáil as a single Chamber, with 12 Ministers and five junior Ministers.
To get out of this recession and to create jobs there simply has to be continued investment in key infrastructure, including our critical communications and transport networks. I therefore welcome the Minister's comment this morning that he expects Exchequer capital investment to remain at a significant level in the budget on 7 December, and that PPP investment would continue. There is a clear case for using the metropolitan area networks project to develop a publicly-owned national fibre optic backbone to be fleshed out by Eircom and other providers. I have had debates with the Acting Chairman on the area in the past. We should ensure that small, medium and big enterprises in every part of the country have access to the highest quality broadband services. The construction of major transport projects, in themselves, provides a massive economic stimulus and jobs boost to the economy. As a long-time northside supporter of metro north, I note that €140 million has been spent on the project so far; that the enabling works for metro north will cost just €80 million in 2011; that CPO costs have been wildly exaggerated by vested interests; that the first implementation payment will not be incurred until late 2012 or early 2013 at the earliest; that the detailed cost-benefit analysis is massively positive and that both final bidders have strong Irish-connected companies. The Government would probably be sued by the bidders, as was the case in Slovakia recently, if the metro is axed or badly delayed.
I strongly believe in terms of the ratio of tax adjustments to cutbacks, it is fairer to aim for a balance which is strongly loaded towards tax adjustments given the €14.5 billion already taken from the economy. I reiterate my total opposition to the Government's policy of making low and middle income households take the biggest brunt of the economic pain it is currently doling out. The balance must be tilted towards those who can afford to pay and also the senior banking and developer interests who got us into this mess in the first place. Economic recovery must be centred on a stimulus package that includes an economic recovery fund, as well as the major infrastructural projects that include broadband and transport.
Comment on this
I thank Deputy Broughan for sharing his time and welcome the opportunity to speak on this debate on the macroeconomic and fiscal outlook for Ireland. The economic outlook over the past two years has been very dire indeed and with every day that passes, unbelievably it gets worse. Financial statistics and economic projections emanating from the Department of Finance and the Central Bank have been so wide of the mark as to be virtually worthless. The plethora of economists and ESRI pundits are so hit and miss that they almost sound like astrologers.
The entire banking system, including Anglo Irish Bank, AIB and Irish Nationwide, have been telling such porkies and acting so criminally irresponsibly that the Criminal Assets Bureau should be mobilised and directed to their respective boardrooms. The taxpayer is the beast of burden pressed into service to bail out the private sector which controls the financial pillars of the economy. That elite sector worked in tandem with Fianna Fáil and Progressive Democrat allies, who turned a blind eye to the activities and smoothed the legislative and regulatory path for these actions.
In the past two years the debt burden placed on the taxpayer from defaulting banks has been over €50 billion. The deficit shortfall in the balance of payments for 2010 alone is close to €20 billion, and we have been told after the Farmleigh meeting that €15 billion of cuts rather than €7.5 billion must come from the taxpayer and the unemployed over the next four years if we are to reach the 3% stability pact deficit agreed with the European Union.
Some €14.5 billion, an incredible sum, has already been taken from the economy and the pockets of the Irish people in the past two budgets. To compound the surreal scenario, the Government is proposing after Farmleigh an even more austere front-loading budget for 2011 to reassure bond markets so they can lend billions to the same financial institutions which got the country into a financial mess in the first place. This is capitalism at its worst and is the legacy of Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher to the world.
We thought we had a regulated mixed economy in Ireland with checks and balances that would protect our economy and people from the excesses of the marketplace. It was, as we now know, a mirage.
However, we must now learn the hard lessons and move forward. We must resolve that we will never allow a similar meltdown of our financial system to occur again with the consequent impoverishment of our people for a generation. We must make common cause with our allies in the European Union and elsewhere to exert benevolent political regulation and control of the global marketplace. People must come before profit and we must agree the national and international mechanisms to achieve that. We must rewrite the rules of international finance so that the entire population of the country is not suddenly plunged into crisis and poverty by powerful forces within that country, or, indeed outside of it, beyond its control.
The first step for the Irish people is to elect a new Government——
Comment on this
—— with a fresh five-year mandate. Those who have been in charge of the country the past 13 years have ruined the economy. They created the problems and are unable to resolve them. The chauffeur driven cavalcade of Ministers to Farmleigh this week shows just how out of touch they are with the recession-hit lives of ordinary people throughout the length and breadth of the island.
Hope, vision and leadership can only come from a Labour Party led Government which has the interests of the ordinary people of the country at heart and will regain their confidence. A Labour Party led Government will ensure that the full rigours of the law would be brought to bear on those responsible for this amount of collapse with imprisonment the penalty for the main perpetrators. It is essential that justice is done and seen to be done where white collar criminal antisocial behaviour is involved. We would review existing commercial law with a view to strengthening investigative powers and increasing penalties. Our Labour Party led Government would introduce an effective regulatory framework for our financial institutions.
The current Government's budgetary policy of front-loading cuts across the board is flawed because it squeezes money out of the economy, reduces spending and consumer confidence and deflates the economy. Its assumption that the crisis is a global one and that once world trade picks up Ireland will be able to export itself out of the recession is flawed. Ireland retained a substantial export surplus of €39 billion in 2009 over 2008 figures according to recent CSO figures. Yet, Ireland remained in recession.
Figures provided by the Irish Exporters Association to date indicate a healthy export market in 2010 but there appears to be little or no impact on the economy or employment. Foreign direct investment produces high volumes of exports in pharmaceutical and information technology goods and they are holding up well. However, they produce a poor return on jobs created and tax garnered. The recent revelation that Google made €3 billion extra profit because it was able to manipulate the Irish corporation tax regime to such an extent that instead of paying the exceedingly low 12.5% corporation tax it only paid 2.5% is totally unacceptable. It is a scandal and it has to be dealt with. The Labour Party in Government would ensure that no foreign or domestic business paid less than 12.5% corporation tax.
Export led growth is not the panacea that the Government expects and it has little effect on employment unless indigenous small and medium enterprises can get involved. Our small and medium enterprises are starved of credit and find it difficult to survive at the current time. The Labour Party in Government would target that sector through our new proposed strategic investment bank, availing of the European investment bank funds. We would ensure that small and medium enterprises were sufficiently funded to retain the existing workforce of 800,000, which is well over 50%, and expand into new enterprises and markets including overseas markets in emerging countries which would create real worth and real jobs.
State capital funding would be directed into labour-intensive projects that would breathe new life into the construction industry. Urban regeneration projects, school building projects, home energy, retrofitting, public transport projects and wind and wave renewable energy projects are ready to go. They are only awaiting a stimulus package which the Labour Party would provide by cherry-picking the national development plan and capital investment programme.
The extent of the recession is evidenced by the fact that the haulage of goods throughout the country declined from 246,000 tonnes in 2008 to only 148,000 tonnes in 2009 according to recent CSO figures. This marks a colossal drop of 40% in a single year. The distribution of goods throughout the country is a very good indication of the state of the economy. The economy is not just flat, it is in freefall. Our stimulus package for small and medium enterprises and our capital funding for labour-intensive projects would rapidly pick the country out of the recession and restore consumer confidence.
In the meantime, while this Government remains in office we must seek to protect the less well off, the 450,000 social welfare recipients on the live register, including the 100,000 on disability, and those on low wages and the minimal wage. Ireland remains a wealthy country. Any new taxes must be directed at 33,000 Celtic millionaires, or what is left of them, the 400,000 tax exiles and those with salaries and pensions above €100,000. The new 48% tax which the Labour Party proposes can raise close to €500 million and should be introduced for those who are well off.
The 148 tax reliefs identified by the Commission on Taxation, which have been recently estimated amount to approximately €11 billion annually, need to be reviewed urgently. Property tax relief should be abolished entirely. If we take 50,000 people off the live register it will save the State €1 billion annually. There are 288,000 people who have lost their jobs since 2007. Clearly, a restoration of the 2007 figures would amount to approximately €6 billion which would be €6 billion less of a burden on the social welfare system.
There can be substantial savings from the Croke Park agreement. It is high time the Government put in place mechanisms to quantify and achieve the savings. Unfortunately, the Government has taken no action to date on any of these issues. It is rudderless and leaderless. It is incapable of action and can only claim to seek consensus on the way forward from the Opposition at the 11th hour of its term in office. The Fianna Fáil and Green Party coalition cannot do the job and should step down.
Comment on this
At least we learned something from the last contribution, namely, that Labour Party Ministers would do without cars and drivers to drop them at meetings to do with the budget.
Comment on this
You will see us on our bikes.
Comment on this
The purpose of this debate is to clarify the choices we have to make over the next four years and the fundamental reasons for them. There are, unfortunately, no relatively painless exits from the situation in which we find ourselves. To clear up one persistent misrepresentation, State underpinning of the banks, while adding tens of billions of euro to the national debt, is not a main contributor to the general Government deficit that has to be reduced from an underlying 11.9% of GDP this year to 3% by 2014. Interest on those payments to the banks do, however, add to the problem, and have been one of the reasons for the markets' focus on Ireland, not least because the capital injections have led to a spike in the deficit to 32% this year.
Some 90 years ago, between the Government of Ireland Act, 1920 and the Treaty, the two parts of Ireland went their separate ways. By majority choice, Northern Ireland remained part of Britain, with devolution since restored after a long breakdown on a much different and consensual basis. Northern Ireland faces serious difficulties, in terms of allocating expenditure with a budget much short of what all would claim it was promised by the previous British Prime Minister. The Executive and Assembly have almost no responsibility for raising taxes or the public finances as a whole, for banking supervision or the health and well-being of the much larger economy of which it is a region.
In 1920, Home Rule was also put in front of the people of the 26 counties on the Statute Book. Instead, the people chose, and fought, to become separate and independent, to be ultimately responsible for their and our own economic viability and financial creditworthiness. For a long time, we were relatively poor and fiscally conservative, but we lived within our means, so there was never any question of default no matter what the pain, neither following the Civil War, during the economic war nor the Second World War, although in 1925, as part of the boundary agreement, Britain agreed to write off our estimated share of their national debt. For a long time, we were even a creditor nation.
Partial default is not an alternative to pain. The measures taken two years ago and since to underpin our banking system have so far succeeded, albeit at a previously unimaginable cost. As former President Clinton said on a recent visit to Ireland, "If you do not have a banking system, you're toast". Unless we want to reclassify ourselves as a Latin American country of the 20th century, we have to stick to the hard road. In future crises across the western world, the treatment of bondholders may well be handled differently, by agreement among the EU and the G20, but we cannot change the rules now, unilaterally and midstream acting as a guinea-pig, except at great cost to ourselves and to our reputation as a country in which to invest and to which it is safe to lend. Even the valid and reasonable distinction between senior debt and subordinated debt is, as we have seen, not entirely unproblematic for everyone concerned.
There are three reasons we need to achieve the 3% deficit target by 2014. The most fundamental reason is that it is the level that equals stabilisation of the public finances. At 3%, given minimal levels of growth and inflation, the economy is growing faster than the debt. For 20 years from 1988 to 2007, when the Exchequer was borrowing 3% or less or was in surplus, the national debt reduced steadily in gross terms as a percentage of GDP from a peak of 118% to a low of 23% in 2006 and 2007. The cost of servicing the debt, which was a third of all tax revenue and a quarter of the current expenditure in 1987, declined to a low of approximately 5% in both cases 20 years later. The main reason for reducing both debt and deficit is that otherwise we pre-empt and sterilise large amounts of taxpayers' resources for interest payments, which could be better used for economic and social purposes.
One does not have to be a member of the eurozone to be concerned to bring down the budget deficit to 3% of GDP or under. The British Government has announced a four-year plan to achieve the same in order to stabilise its public finances. As a eurozone member, we do not have the same degree of discretion. The second reason we have to reach the 3% target by 2014, which is already a one-year extension, is that we have agreed to do so with the EU Commission in the first instance and as a commitment vis-à-vis our eurozone partners. It has been clear, particularly since the sovereign debt crisis erupted earlier this year, in the first instance with Greece, that the health, indeed survival, of the eurozone depends on each individual member state, regardless of its size or centrality, taking the appropriate action.
As part of the criteria for membership of economic and monetary union, a deficit of no more than 3% of GDP has been a critical component. That figure first emerged from an informal Finance Ministers' meeting during Ireland's EC Presidency in 1990 in Ashford Castle, County Mayo. It was subsequently written into the Maastricht treaty of 1992, and ratified by the Irish people, with part of the package consisting of very substantial Structural and Cohesion funds, which we have well absorbed.
As a result of the global financial crisis, many countries are in deficit far in excess of that figure. It is not a valid argument to say that because France and Germany marginally exceeded that figure in the early years of the previous decade, the rule no longer applies. It clearly does, since we and others have to find a path back to complying with it. We have been given reasonable, but not unlimited latitude, as our situation cannot simply be attributed to external factors, but was as a result of imprudent behaviour by this country. The third, and even more compelling reason, is the expectation of markets, from whom we will be looking for borrowed funds again from January to be able to maintain public services, incomes and income supports, on which our people and the quality of our society depend.
I welcome the commitment of the main Opposition parties to the 3% target by 2014. It is an acknowledgement by them of the political reality that would immediately face them in Government. There is a public expectation that their approach be set out in more detail. The only comment I would make is that it would be unwise for them to rule out too much in advance, as otherwise there is a risk, as happened with the British Government recently, of having to accept apologetically that in certain particulars they would have misled the country.
The economic argument made by ICTU and the ESRI is that the pain should be more spread out over time. There would be a significant financial cost to that but more importantly, the approach would not be accepted by the Commission, our EU partners, or the financial markets. Heavily indebted states are unfortunately not as in complete control of their affairs as those which are relatively unencumbered. Nevertheless, we want to make the detailed consequential decisions ourselves, not leave them to the IMF.
There is no convincing evidence that Keynesianism works in an Irish context. It did not work in the middle or late 1970s, it did not work in 1980 and 1981, nor was it going to work in the initial phase of our present crisis in 2007 and 2008. The best boost to our economy and to confidence will be to put our finances in order, and take full advantage of recent improvements in Irish export competitiveness, together with any measures we can take to support jobs and improve performance.
Among more extreme and defeatist solutions put forward by one or two commentators are that we should leave the eurozone to permit devaluations, or leave the EU, or become the 51st state of America. Attempting any of those things would be far more damaging and disruptive than anything we must do now. They would effectively spell an end to Irish sovereign independence. We do not have the natural advantages of Norway and Switzerland to stay outside the EU. Few of us want to become an Anglo-American dependency or island tax haven. Geographically, culturally, and politically, we belong to Europe. How few of us would volunteer to apply to join a nuclear superpower militarily engaged all over the world, with the large divides in wealth that characterise the US, and, for all we know in the future, with a "Tea Party" President in the White House? The reality we must face for the moment is that we are closer to Frankfurt and Brussels than Boston or even Berlin. The social market economy patented by Ludwig Erhard and refined by Helmut Schmidt in post-war Germany is a good and successful model for us to adhere to. Unlike the editor of the Sunday Independent, and apologies to one of its columnists, I have no phobias about Ireland becoming more like Germany, as we belatedly internalise the logic, disciplines, and advantages, short-term and long-term, of eurozone membership.
Comment on this
I shall pass on the apologies of the Minister of State to the editor of the Sunday Independent. I must state that I do not necessarily share all the ideas put forward in the editorial section of the Sunday Independent.
Comment on this
Incidentally, I must compliment the Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh, on stating he learned something from the contributions of the Labour Party Members. I have to state he is a smarter man than I am; I did not learn anything because I heard nothing except the usual lack of specifics. The game of hide and seek continues.
An interesting debate has taken place on whether the deficit should be reduced to 3% by 2014 or possibly extended to 2016. This is interesting but largely irrelevant. Whether the 3% deficit can be achieved by 2014 or 2016 without running the risk of deflating the economy to destruction depends almost exclusively on the level of growth in the Irish economy in the years in between. If the level of growth is not sufficient to enable us to do what we have promised to do then it may be possible to acceptably stabilise the deficit at a higher level. However, as Deputy Noonan mentioned earlier today, if the growth turns out to be in the higher range projected in the recent ESRI report then it may be possible not only to stabilise the deficit to 3% by 2014 but to do so for much less than the €15 billion figure put forward.
The point is that we have committed not only to the EU Commission but also to the European Central Bank that we will achieve this target in the timescale we have agreed, which is 2014. It is also a fact that the people from whom we will borrow money, the international bond markets, expect us to honour and reach that target. We are in a position where the European Central Bank, which guarantees the massive borrowing we have already undertaken and the people from whom we will borrow in the future, demand we adhere to this timetable, so we have no choice but to try and be seen to try.
It would be the height of folly for this or any Government to think an austerity package on its own will be acceptable to the people or that it will work. What we want and what the country needs is an austerity package accompanied by an appropriate stimulus package. I am not speaking about the stimulus package introduced by a Fianna Fáil-led Government in the 1970s, which was clearly unworkable and which the country could not afford. Such a package introduced today would be even more unworkable in the present circumstances and it would certainly be unaffordable. However, there is a type of stimulus we can use. We can target certain areas and do certain things that are not of themselves very expensive — some of them will cost nothing — to stimulate and re-ignite growth and create hope again among the people of the country. We must do this and we are morally and politically obliged to do so for two reasons. The first is that growth is an essential part of the equation. We will not stabilise our debt in 2014, 2016 or 2020 or at all unless we create sufficient growth in the Irish economy.
There has been insufficient emphasis in this debate on the fact that in the interests of the people, we now have to confront the scourge of unemployment. Prolonged, mass unemployment is catastrophic, not just for its victims but for society as a whole. Several learned studies attest to this fact. One of the most notable and most interesting I have read was done by the great Harvard sociologist, William Wilson. He demonstrated graphically how the disappearance of low skill jobs in the United States during the 1970s led to the social collapse of the black ghettos. In this country, we have seen this process in reverse. Rising employment turned what had been sink estates into decent, if not wonderful places to live. Finding a job does more for a person than an army of social workers. It restores a person's dignity and sense of self-worth.
The benefits of the Celtic tiger, despite protestations to the contrary, did not go exclusively to the wealthy; they went overwhelmingly to ordinary people in the form of abundant employment opportunities in their own region, something this country had never experienced before. I have mentioned some of those studies and there have also been interesting studies on the effect of the last decade on the psyche of the Japanese people. However, there is now a danger that we will soon be able to produce our own studies because this country stands on the threshold of an unplanned and unwelcome social experiment. The social experiment will be how mass unemployment impacts on crime, on domestic violence, drug abuse, suicide and a litany of other social calamities.
Along with other people I have been promoting incentives which include a proper workfare programme, not a punitive programme such as a local scheme for cutting grass or cleaning footpaths and if a person does not participate, he or she will lose their dole. It must be something that gives people dignity. Such jobs could be paid for by the State, by a premium on top of the standard social welfare payment, to enable people to be gainfully employed in their own area of expertise and not just a social type of employment. I am referring to everybody, to those with doctorates, for example, a considerable number of whom are unemployed. It could mean everybody could be taken off the live register by postponing one particular capital project I have in mind, called metro north, which is a ludicrous project. The very notion that it is going ahead is ludicrous——
Comment on this
——at a time when we are talking about cutting social welfare.
Another idea would be to look at the banking situation. There is a continuing credit crunch and this is likely to continue for the foreseeable future. Apart from anything else, and apart from the capitalisation and the banks trying to repair their balance sheets, there is the imperative that the Irish banking system will have to bring loans back into line with deposits. This will involve considerable deleveraging. If somebody were to ask me today at what point in time would the Irish banking system be able to give sufficient credit to enable us to get the proper level of growth to reach this target by 2014, I could not honestly answer but I could say that there are alternative sources of funds available. For example, the system has been used in the United States whereby business owners have been allowed to temporarily tap into their own personal pension funds to source much-needed working capital without penalty from the tax authorities. In this country, small and medium enterprises are failing almost daily. Their failure is not the result of unprofitability in the medium term but rather because they cannot source the necessary cash flow. I estimate that approximately €80 billion is in Irish managed pension assets. Having a temporary and regulated access to this money now would help thousands of viable but struggling small to medium businesses to survive.
A new approach to mortgage repayments has been put forward. I support this approach and I have written about it and I understand it is now the subject of representations to the National Treasury Management Agency and to NAMA. Many people who bought their homes at the peak of the property market are now in negative equity. It is likely, if more remedial action is not taken now, that thousands of families will have high debt levels over the coming decade. Such widespread debt levels will have considerable social and economic consequences so it is vital we take action now to alleviate it for everybody's sake.
A number of solutions have already been suggested, including allowing people to extend their mortgages over longer periods and giving some people the option of renting back their houses from the bank. We need to look at this problem differently. It appears there are two distinct and independent identifiable component parts to a house purchase: the house structure itself and the land on which the house is built. By separating the two parts we can devise a solution where the mortgage can be reasonably discharged on the house structure within an acceptable period but the house builder continues to pay a lease on the land on which the house sits for a 90-year period. This approach, or an adaptation of this approach, would not only help to re-ignite the housing market but it would protect people who are trapped in negative equity.
On the subject of turning intellectual property into profits, the path from research and development to economic success is first, research, second, invention, third, intellectual property and fourth, commercial success. Ireland should now adopt a policy of becoming a world leader in the latter half of this path, specifically in the process of commercialising intellectual property and making Ireland a centre of excellence in turning intellectual property into profits. We have the structures, the reputation, the expertise and the people to take intellectual property which has already been developed and turn it into a real income stream.
Time does not allow me to speak about other proposals in detail but I will articulate them both here in the House and elsewhere. I refer to encouraging immigrants to invest in new businesses here; turning the migration of graduates into a positive rather than a negative which it is at the moment; radical reform of the bankruptcy laws; a study of the tax systems of other countries to see where tax changes are being made which would benefit us if we adapted our taxation system, such as the recent measures outlined by the United Kingdom Government regarding a tax on video games. Cash on deposit amounts to €100 billion and it could be a source of business credit. The Institute of Taxation has advanced very interesting proposals in this regard.
This austerity package is needed by the country but it has to be accompanied by measures to create hope and which will give people the belief there is a future in this country. It has to be accompanied by an appropriately targeted stimulus package otherwise, instead of the light at the end of the tunnel, we will be talking about the tunnel at the end of the light.
Comment on this
I came into this House in 1994 from a by-election and in 1995 we were in Government until 1997. Every time a Fine Gael or a Labour Party Minister would rise to speak on the budget, the Fianna Fáil backbenchers would go back in history about what Fianna Fáil had done when they were in Government. I want to put a history lesson on the record of the House about the Government from 1995 to 1997. The media sometimes forget that it was the first time since the foundation of the State that a Government actually had a surplus. This meant we were not borrowing money for the day to day running of the country. We were creating 1,500 jobs a day, from 1995 to 1997. I remember that general election when the Irish Independent headline read, “It’s Payback Time”. The newspaper was 13 years ahead of its time because it is payback time now——
Comment on this
——and we will be paying back for the next 30 years as a result of what this Government has created. It is sad because we had it so good. We had a good country and a great workforce and a great economy. The Irish Independent and its like, with their economic policies, has got us into this mess. The great leader of the day, the then Leader of the Opposition, Deputy Bertie Ahern, adopted the policies of the Irish Independent and now we are in this mess. Low-paid workers are being asked to pick up the tab. Those who are struggling are about to be attacked in the forthcoming budget.
Some journalists have suggested that Fine Gael should say what it would do in government. We will do so when we are in a position of power on the other side of the House and have Ministers. During those times over the last 13 years when the economy was going well, no Minister for Finance, education or agriculture asked Fine Gael or the Labour Party to outline their ideas of what would be good for Ireland. When there was money in the country, we were not asked what it should be spent on.
I remember the day the Fianna Fáil choir applauded the then Minister, Charlie McCreevy, at length after he had made his Budget Statement. They nearly broke the place down in celebration of the wonderful budget the Minister had given to the people of this country. Many people, including journalists, have short memories. The following year, the then Minister said the giveaway budget was going to be one of many. Again the choir got up to clap. Given that he was probably one of those clapping, I am sure the Acting Chairman, Deputy O'Flynn, remembers the day of the decentralisation announcement. Those who were applauding Mr. McCreevy thought he was the greatest Minister they ever had — the Houdini this country needed — but look at the mess this country is in now.
It has been suggested that the Queen will come to Ireland on a state visit next year. Although we have our independence now, perhaps we should hand the country back to the Queen and apologise for the mess we have made of it. When Britain was running the country, at least it did not leave us in such a mess or in the hock we are in now.
I am sick and tired of people saying that we are all the same and that we all created this problem. We are not all the same. I was one of the Fine Gael backbenchers who criticised the Labour Party Minister for Finance, Deputy Quinn, for not opening the purse strings more, or for not doing more in areas like taxation and social welfare. If the coalition had not lost five or six seats in 1997, we would still be in government and this country would not be in the mess it is in now. Deputy Deenihan, who was a Minister of State in that Government, will agree that it acted responsibly and put the country first. We are putting the country first again.
I remind the various commentators that since the foundation of the State, Fine Gael has always put this country first when it has been in government. We will do it again. We will not be dictated to by those who think we should put everything on the table even though we do not know what the Government will put on the table. We were told last week that there might be an over-run of €15 billion. It seems this week that it might be €20 billion.
Comment on this
A figure of €30 billion has been mentioned.
Comment on this
We do not know what the level of growth will be. Other figures will be published by the Department. I know what Fianna Fáil, the media and the Government are doing. They are trying to spread the blame game. They want people to believe we are all the same so that when the election takes place, they can compare what the Government has done with what Fine Gael and the Labour Party proposed in their pre-budget estimates.
I know this country is in a serious position. Like every citizen in the State, I want to get this country back to where it was. We want to get our people working. We want to give a bit of hope, create a bit of employment and get rid of the depression that exists at present. People are frightened out of their lives about the proposals that are coming down the tracks. As my party's spokesman on social protection, I want to make sure those who did not cause the mess we are facing are not penalised most. I ask the Minister of State, Deputy Mansergh, to ensure marginalised people who need to be protected are protected. They did not create the problem.
The Government should go after the bankers and their wives, who have billions of euro. They are enjoying themselves in the sun, reading newspapers and drinking wine and champagne. We are doing nothing about it. We need a few bankers to go to jail to show there is law and order in this country.
Comment on this
I agree with Deputy Ring that those of us on this side of the House are prepared to share the pain but not the blame. If just one thing comes from this debate, it should be that this House needs to retake responsibility for the running of this country. When it comes to job creation, this House does not have any say as IDA Ireland is responsible for the matter. When it comes to tourism, we have to defer to Fáilte Ireland and Tourism Ireland. If one goes right across the spectrum, one will always find other agencies to which these duties have been devolved. This House does not have any responsibility in most areas. When one is in opposition, one does not get an opportunity to contribute. I agree with Deputy Ring that when the country was going well, nobody asked us for ideas
I had a good experience when I was my party's spokesperson on defence. Every question I asked of the Minister for Defence had to be answered in the House. By contrast, when I ask a question in my current capacity as spokesman on tourism, culture and sport, I find that an agency is responsible for the matter. The sooner this House reclaims total responsibility for public affairs, the better. The Minister for Health and Children, for example, should have to answer to this House when there is a problem in a hospital. When things go wrong, Ministers should take responsibility and resign if necessary. This country's public service will not function properly until that happens. This House has reneged on its responsibility to those who elected its Members to do a job. We are allowing others to do the job we should be doing. We take the credit when they do something good and we run when things are going bad. That is what is really happening in this House.
I would like to mention the latest independent indicator of how well we are doing. The figures we get from the Government are inaccurate because they are all over the place. We do not know what the position is. An adjustment of €30 billion was mentioned this evening following the bond market review. It was suggested that we should provide for such a cut in public expenditure over the next four years. I suppose the company in question, Davy, is fairly neutral in this regard. It has been reasonably accurate to date. It was quite optimistic last year. According to the account it published yesterday, GNP is expected to decrease by 1.5%, in volume terms, in 2010 and to revive slightly in 2011. GDP will be almost flat this year, with growth of just 0.3%. Next year could see volume growth of 1.9%, supported by demand for exports. If those figures are correct, we face major trouble as we attempt to sustain the services we currently provide.
As Fine Gael's spokesman on tourism, culture and sport, I would like to focus on tourism before I conclude. If leadership is shown in Ireland and in overseas markets, we can regain some of the tourism market share we have lost. Ireland is not realising its full potential as a tourist destination. If its wide range of natural and cultural assets were developed in a sustainable manner, Ireland could acquire a clear position in the market and be re-established as an outstanding tourist destination. The significant downturn in overseas tourism demand since 2007 has had a detrimental impact on the tourism sector and the wider Irish economy. In the three years since 2007, Ireland has lost 2 million overseas visitors and at least €1 billion in revenue, with a consequential loss to the Exchequer of approximately €500 million in tax revenue. That is an indictment of those who are supposed to be attracting tourists to this country.
The difficulties currently being experienced by the tourism sector go back further than the current recession. Marginal growth rates in overseas tourism since 2000, allied to a net decline in overseas holiday trips, have resulted in the loss of profit share to key competitors. It is all about competitiveness. One of the reasons people are not coming here is due to competitiveness. In its Travel & Tourism Competitiveness Report 2009, the World Economic Forum benchmarked the tourism and travel sectors of 133 economies. While Ireland is the 18th ranked country in terms of overall competitiveness, a closer examination of these rankings reveals issues of concern for Ireland. These issues can be summarised as follows. Ireland is ranked seventh out of nine countries in overall competitiveness within the north western European competitor set behind Sweden, the UK, the Netherlands, Denmark, Finland and Iceland.
In regard to access, as we know the €10 travel tax is definitely having an effect on the number of people coming to this country, and I have mentioned it on a number of occasions. Whether one agrees with Michael O'Leary of Ryanair or not, he stated that if it was removed, he could bring an additional 6 million tourists to this country over a five year period and create 6,000 jobs.
I heard Deputy Noonan mention that a large number of Chinese people are visiting the UK but they cannot use the same visa to come to Ireland. Surely, given the relationship between both islands, that visa, which will have been well checked by British intelligence and so on for security purposes, should entitle them to come to Ireland as well. Those are two very simple initiatives which the Government could take in the morning that would certainly boost the number of tourists coming to this country.
Comment on this
I am pleased to speak in this very important debate. Arising directly from the incompetence of a succession of Fianna Fáil-led Governments, our country has been hit by a savage economic crash. The consequences of the failure of Fianna Fáil are visible everywhere in the country, including in the record unemployment levels, in the resumption of forced emigration of a new generation of well-educated young people, in the massive drop in the standard of living for ordinary citizens, in the closed down factories, in the empty housing estates and in cutbacks in health and education and services for the disadvantaged in society. No part of the economy and no public service is safe from Fianna Fáil cutbacks and close downs. There is no confidence and credit in the economy.
We had a budget in October 2008 which was presented as a minor adjustment to facilitate a soft landing for the economy. Then in April 2009 we had a supplementary budget. It is now clear that this budget was also based on an evasion of reality. The April 2009 supplementary budget was followed by the NAMA legislation and then by the 2010 budget. For some national and international commentators, the 2010 budget was acknowledged as the first budget to truly face the reality of the economic crisis now engulfing both the national economy and the Government finances. The 2010 budget was followed by the emergence of the true scale of the banking disaster and the cost of bailing out the banks, which is immense at €50 billion. There have also been indirect costs in that it has stifled enterprise and closed the economy. As we await the 2011 budget, we see that everything until now was just the calm before the storm.
This debate is a lead-in to the toughest budget in the nation's history, not only for 2011 but for the next four years. With the emerging picture for the 2011 budget, we all clearly see how far Fianna Fáil has failed. This budget is almost exclusively about starting to fix the Government finances, with little or no reference to protect existing jobs and create new jobs.
In terms of specific policy areas, I would like to see more attention being given to the local small business sector which employs one to 50 people. From the small acorn, the large oak grows but there is no respect in this country for the business person and entrepreneur who is creating a small number of jobs. There is nothing for them.
If the economy is to grow again, we must create jobs in small companies and especially in the six emerging sectors of health care, creative industries, bio-technology, post modern agriculture, green energy and tourism, all of which are full of potential. Small and medium sized local companies are of central importance in economic policy because of their degree of integration into the national economy. Our party leader dwelt very much on the role of small companies in his contribution.
There is an urgent need to review the effectiveness of the policies and incentives used in the development of the small business sector. The Government must bring forward a range of measures to tackle the challenges faced by the small business sector. These policies must unlock their potential for long-term sustainable growth and job creation. We are back to the acorn and the small company.
There must be an environment in which entrepreneurs and family businesses can thrive and be rewarded. We must put the interests of small companies at the top of the political agenda. Over the past number of years, the emphasis has been on Enterprise Ireland and IDA backed companies. We must have a new direction for small enterprises and companies. We must think big in regard to small business. The significance of the sector must be formally recognised and we must examine closely the structure of the support service delivery for the sector.
To make self-employment a potentially attractive career option for young people, we must provide them with the necessary supports and skills to turn their ambitions into successful ventures. Successful transfers of existing businesses preserve more jobs on average than those created by new start-ups. The transfer of businesses and the skills associated with them should be simplified and should, therefore, be given the same support as setting up a new business. We must look again at issues around taxation policy to ensure that it supports the transfer of businesses from father to son or otherwise.
A large number of small companies are going out of business in the current recession. Each of these business owners has a worthwhile re-start potential and that must be recognised. We must give them a second chance. Making a new start, however, is a lengthy and complicated procedure — it is almost impossible. We must urgently reform our bankruptcy laws in order that in the case of non-fraudulent bankruptcy, entrepreneurs quickly get a second chance and are treated on an equal footing with new start-ups.
The biggest complaint from small business is about compliance with administrative regulations. Small companies believe they bear a disproportionate red tape burden in comparison to larger companies. Urgent Government action is required to eliminate the red tape burden on small business. In addition, there are a range of other costs arising from direct and indirect Government imposed charges on the small business sector, such as energy costs, rates, leases, rents and dispute resolution procedures. To date, Government efforts have not delivered lower costs for business. The Government must take action to save small companies time and money, thus freeing resources and time for innovation, business growth and job creation.
Raising the right kind of finance can be a major difficulty for small companies and entrepreneurs. The Private Members' motion last week related to support for small companies but it was voted down by this Government. Risk aversion often makes investors and banks shy away from financing firms in their start-up and early expansion stages. Small companies must be better assisted to fully unlock their potential for long-term sustainable growth. Access to finance for small companies must be facilitated.
In addition, small companies are often undermined by a late payment culture. Much insolvency is directly due to late payment. There is an urgent need for Government action on late payments and a credit guarantee facility. So far, all we have is talk but no action.
Given the expected weak state of domestic demand over the next few years, small manufacturing and service companies will have to look to export markets for growth. The Government must give more support and encouragement through identifying business opportunities, providing advisory and networking services and upgrading of personal skills in the areas of market development and management competence. That is very important. These are some of the policy areas where the Government can bring forward practical proposals for the development of small companies and job creation. There are other opportunities in other areas.
Fine Gael is the only party with a sense of urgency that the country needs bold new approaches to tackle the growing jobs crisis. It is the only party to present concrete, effective measures to protect existing jobs and create new ones as well as bringing down business costs and helping struggling companies to stay afloat. What the country needs most of all right now is an election, not a budget.
Comment on this
There is 20 minutes in this slot. I understand the Minister of State, Deputy Peter Power, is sharing time with Deputies O'Brien and Byrne.
Comment on this
That is correct, ten minutes for me and five minutes for each of my colleagues, with the permission of the House.
Comment on this
I very much welcome this debate in Dáil Éireann.
It is hard to think of many debates in Dáil Éireann which have assumed greater importance than the debate we are having today and tomorrow. What needs to emerge from all parties, irrespective of our differences, is a clear pathway which has credibility and can be executed with confidence.
Firstly, I want to put on the record of the House my absolute conviction that we, as a nation, have the wherewithal to deal with all of our own issues, independently and without outside intervention. I, for one, am tired of the complete sense of defeatism, which is propagated throughout the media on even an hourly basis, when any sense of objectivity or impartiality has been long since abandoned, even by former respected pillars of the Irish media.
There is another reason I welcome this debate, that is, that it provides us with an opportunity to have a real contest of ideas between the Government parties and the Opposition. The politics of being against everything and for nothing are over. The fact is that it is decision time now and hard choices need to be made.
Nobody is asking for the Opposition to set out exactly where every cut should be made and where every euro of tax will be imposed, but rather to set out a macroeconomic position which has real credibility and is capable of execution, whether we agree with it or not. That said, I welcome the Opposition's firm commitment to the target of cutting the deficit to GDP ratio to 3% by 2014.
For those outside the House who do not subscribe to this target, I would say the following. First, it is simply not credible at this stage, when every other European country has agreed, to abandon the 3% target by 2014. This is a simple issue of credibility which is not negotiable.
Second, to abandon that target now would, not alone close the bond markets to Ireland in the new year but, effectively, close off any opportunity for foreign direct investment. We should remember that even in the midst of an extremely difficult recession, Ireland still remains perhaps the most highly attractive place for global companies to do business. Unless we send the clearest of clear messages that we will credibly address our budget deficit issues, global investors will simply not invest here. I would appeal to those who suggest that there is an easier longer way of doing it to reflect on the reality of the position in which we find ourselves.
As a nation and as a people, we must stand up, be totally honest and state that we are serious about this business. My own view is that if the crisis is tackled head on and we take much of the pain up front, then the burden will lighten over the four years of the programme. The opposite is also true. If we take the easy option at the outset, the burden will get increasingly difficult over the latter years of this programme.
I accept others hold a radically different view. They state that this programme should be suspended or expanded out over for another three or four years. That has no basis in reality and flies in the face of the position in which we find ourselves.
It is not as if we are in unknown territory here. One may draw direct comparisons between the perilous state of the public finances in the mid to late 1980s and where we are now. At one stage in the 1980s our debt to GDP ratio stood at 129%. We are nowhere near that figure now, and yet within a relatively few short years we brought the situation under control and below the 60% debt to GNP ratio in the Stability and Growth Pact guidelines. If we adopt fair, but tough, and equally-spread policies, we can achieve that success again.
Equally, the public and business particularly will respond if we demonstrate in the clearest possible way that we are serious about this. If there is a clear pathway towards getting our own house in order, it will provide a major injection of confidence into the economy, both in terms of inward investment on which we rely so much in these times and also in terms of indigenous business.
The simple reality confronting the country is not so much the extent of the adjustment which needs to be made, although that will undoubtedly be profound, but rather the message we wish to send to those who invest in Ireland and those from whom we borrow, that we have a clear understanding of the nature, size, magnitude and scale of the problem and the measures necessary to correct it, and then, most importantly, to execute those measures with decisiveness and authority.
The question of whether to front load or not to front load the fiscal adjustment has been much discussed in the media in recent days. I am firmly of the view that we need to front-load this adjustment and make bigger corrections at the outset of this path of economic recovery. As I mentioned, our own economic history in the 1980s proves this to be the best way of doing so. More importantly, not to do so at this time would be to take a risk in terms of the global confidence in this country. It is my strong conviction that this would be an unacceptable risk for a Government of any colour to take, and the initial correction needs to be in the region of a reduction to 10% in the deficit to GDP ratio.
Having said that, it is also my view that if we take sharp corrective action in the short term, the fundamentals, which have caused so many problems for us, for example, in the banking system, the bond market and the world economy, and which cost us so much on a weekly basis, will being to stabilise and improve. In these circumstances, we could easily foresee a lessening of the load in the latter part of the plan, in other words, much can be gained by taking very decisive action now.
In my view each party needs to set out, over the coming two weeks, how this front-loading should be done. As this is a macro economic debate, no party should be asked — would it be realistic to do so — to set out exactly where they would make cuts on a Department-by- Department basis.
However, it is absolutely vital for each party to set out its position in four broad areas: first, the extent to which it would cut capital expenditure; second, the extent to which it would cut current expenditure; third, revenue raising and taxation; and fourth, which is linked to the third one, pro-growth policies which promote increased revenue. In this respect, I have a real issue with the Fine Gael position and I have been critical of it. The Fine Gael leader has consistently ruled out tax increases. His finance spokesman has consistently stated that the capital budget will be protected. That can only leave the bulk of adjustment to be made on the current expenditure side, in areas such as health, education and welfare which make up by far the biggest proportion of Government spending.
Comment on this
The Minister of State must not be listening to them.
Comment on this
The Fine Gael position is unbalanced. The Fine Gael Party will have to adjust this position because——
Comment on this
——while over 50% of the adjustment will have to come from reductions in current expenditure, the balance should be divided more or less equally between reductions in capital and increases in revenue. The Fine Gael position is very unbalanced in this respect.
Comment on this
The Minister of State should check what it is before he——
Comment on this
I am reluctant to increase personal income taxes too much. It has not worked in the past and it has always proven to be a disincentive to work.
This debate is properly called a macroeconomic debate, but we simple cannot ignore the core values which we have as a society in making the choices which confront us. We must have uppermost in our minds the need to provide the greatest possible protection to the poorest and most vulnerable in our society, especially the elderly, consistent with a solid foundation upon which to protect the vulnerable in the future.
The Government is rightly proud of the major gains in social protection and support for vulnerable people in recent years, especially in the area of the State pension. Of course, a key part of the plan should be incorporate a total focus on a return to growth and jobs, but — this is where we fundamentally differ with the Fine Gael Party — to not reduce expenditure and to not increase taxes does not give enough room in which to bring about required economic and fiscal adjustments. This means also that we need to increase our competitiveness, continuing to reduce our unit labour costs — huge progress has been made here — and providing a business environment conducive to foreign direct investment.
Each party must credibly demonstrate four key ingredients. First, it is an absolute prerequisite that the plan is credible to the international markets. Second, it must convey a message of determination to the international community. Third, it needs to protect the most vulnerable and, fourth, it must have the protection and creation of jobs at its core.
Comment on this
This debate is being watched by members of the public who want answers. They want us to seek consensus and show generosity to the Opposition. I believe the Government has shown such generosity in listening to ideas from the Opposition and providing its spokespersons with figures and information. I note with interest the welcome statement by the Minister for Finance that the Opposition will be given access to any figures or information it requires.
The Government side does not have a monopoly on wisdom. Some of the ideas presented by the Opposition must be taken into account. A job of work remains to be done to convince people of the scale of the challenge facing us. This applies equally to parliamentarians and public representatives. Have we asked ourselves what €15 billion in savings will mean over four years? Will we all be shocked by the extent of the four-year plan that is vital for economic recovery? It is difficult to imagine €15 billion in cuts and tax increases.
The most important part of the four-year programme is economic growth. Cutting expenditure and taking a creative approach to the tax system present opportunities to secure economic growth. Without wishing to take a Thatcherite view, I believe the private sector would do better in some areas in which the State is involved. In doing so, it could contribute to economic growth and reduce costs to the State.
As the Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Éamon Ó Cuív, stated when he visited Kells in my constituency, we must protect the poor, the weak and the most vulnerable and examine in a creative manner those areas in which the private sector could do a better job than the State. We must focus specifically on areas of current expenditure in which the Government should not be involved. If the private sector could become involved in these areas, it would generate economic growth while reducing costs to taxpayers.
There is no doubt that we face massive problems in terms of our budgetary strategy for the coming years. The announcement of €15 billion in savings was shocking. I do not have any desire to make cuts for the sake of it. We must, with determination and without any doubt in our hearts, meet head on the challenge of bridging the gap of €15 billion over the next four years. To do otherwise would be to derail the hopes, dreams and aspirations of future generations.
We must treat the challenge facing us as an opportunity to get our house in order. We have to ensure we balance our books and avoid national bankruptcy. The prize at the end of the process will be to restore hope and confidence to citizens. While the task ahead is a cause of worry and concern, people should be conscious of the ultimate goal which, as the Minister stated, is the maintenance and improvement of our living standards.
Failure to reduce our deficit would undermine confidence in Ireland's ability to meet its obligations and responsibilities and delay a return to growth. It is vital that we do not delay because to do so would stall growth. On the other hand, getting our financial house in order will facilitate economic and employment growth.
We have choices to make. We can increase the tax burden on those who are working or we can cut expenditure. While neither option is palatable, the gap must be bridged. The Fianna Faíl Party, the Green Party, Independent Deputies, Fine Gael and the Labour Party have given a commitment to the European Commission and other European countries that the deficit will be reduced to 3%. This figure must remain our target and cuts in expenditure must be the main mechanism by which we achieve it, although there is scope for tax increases.
I concur with the Labour Party's proposal to introduce a higher rate of income tax of 48%. The problem, however, is that such a measure would close the gap by only 3%, leaving a balance of 97%. While the proposed initiative would grab headlines, the Government would still have 97% of the work to do to achieve the €15 billion target. Calls to tax the rich may sound great but the Labour Party's proposal would only solve 3% of the problem over four years. The party must accept that the problem is much broader than simply taxing the rich. If we had more rich people, perhaps we would not face such severe problems.
The Labour Party also points out that tax reliefs amount to €11 billion. However, tax credits or tax free allowances as they were known account for most of this figure. These reliefs are not shelters for hotels or property development but part of the tax code for ordinary people.
We should work together constructively to address the problem before us. The Government has taken a constructive approach and I welcome the fact that the Opposition is becoming more constructive by the day.
Comment on this
I am pleased to have an opportunity to speak in this important debate. I welcome the decision of the main Opposition parties, Fine Gael and the Labour Party, to sign up to the need to reduce the deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014. I listened with interest to Deputies argue that they do not have sufficient information to make decisions. All the information required is available and can be sought. Consensus, which I hope is attainable, is important because it would result in a reduction in the cost of borrowing for the State. While I do not expect to achieve consensus on every aspect of the forthcoming budget, a general consensus on the four-year budgetary plan to be published in mid-November would send out the correct message. In contrast, Portugal today sent out a message that it could not achieve consensus, a failure that affected the bond markets and the cost of borrowing.
In recent years, corrections amounting to €14.5 billion have been made, while a further €15 billion in adjustments is required. As Deputy Thomas Byrne and many other speakers noted, our job is to ensure that the vulnerable and those most in need are protected. This requirement must be the cornerstone of the forthcoming budget and all other budgets in the four-year plan. None of the decisions the Government makes will be easy.
The purpose of the corrections we have made and will make in the coming four years is to return the country to economic growth. While economic growth forecasts have been revised downwards, the situation has stabilised. Unemployment rates, although high, are lower than previously anticipated. Last year, for instance, the unemployment rate was forecast to reach 15% this year but currently stands at 13.5%. We must ensure the unemployed are given opportunities to return quickly to the workforce.
There are many positives. Costs have reduced and foreign direct investment in 2009 amounted to almost €20 billion or half of the total figure for the United Kingdom. Many more new investments are in the pipeline and I commend the IDA and Enterprise Ireland on the work they have done in this regard. The county enterprise boards have also provided support for the small and medium enterprise sector which employs more than 800,000 people.
We must be creative with regard to the SME sector in the budget by supporting indigenous businesses. This can be done in several ways, including through expenditure under the capital programme. In my constituency of Dublin North, I can see the benefits of the work being done to build new schools and work done by local contractors under the summer works scheme. The State is getting more for less, which must be at the centre of its efforts over the next four years. It is crucial, therefore, that we press ahead with the capital programme.
I concur with Deputy Burton on the need to cap tax relief on pension contributions. It is, however, incorrect to argue that €2.7 billion is given to wealthy people through tax relief on pensions. We should also liberalise the options available to PAYE workers on retirement. At present, a PAYE worker who receives a tax free lump sum on retirement must effectively put the remainder of his or her pension into an annuity. Annuity rates have not improved and many people ask why the system cannot be liberalised to allow retiring PAYE workers to avail of other options. For example, they should be able to access the guaranteed returns available under the national solidarity bond. These are measures on which I believe broad agreement can be reached across the House and that would get more money for the State from the €80 billion that is sitting there. However, we must be creative on such matters.
One final area concerns procurement, as this State spends €15 billion per year on procuring goods and services. It would not take much to derive savings of 10% in this regard and many private sector experts believe this could be done. This also should be at the forefront of this budget, as 10% of €15 billion would yield €1.5 billion.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputies Creed, Connaughton and possibly McEntee.
Comment on this
At the outset, I congratulate my party leader, Deputy Kenny, for insisting on this necessary open debate regarding the crisis facing our country. Many young people now live in homes and have large mortgages that were based on the property boom. Consequently they now live in negative equity with either decreased income or with no job at all in some cases. During the boom, the Government transferred the national debt to personal debt. While all Members appreciate that the Taoiseach at last appeared to tell them a little more today than he has been in the habit of doing, the possibility of a necessary reduction of €15 billion over the next four years is extremely serious. Although it is vital to meet our commitments with Europe and elsewhere, equally it is vital to do so in a way that does not destroy growth but gives an impetus towards job creation, which is our only way out of the present mess. In the limited time available to me, I wish to concentrate on two areas, namely, the wanton waste in the health care system and the need to recognise the value of the agriculture and food industry to our nation.
As a supporter of the Monaghan General Hospital project in County Monaghan, I note the county has been the guinea pig for the removal of services to local people. While the HSE has cut the cost of running Monaghan General Hospital, it has increased the number of staff at management level right across its structures. No matter where one meets an individual in the HSE, one finds at least ten other people in the room, all of whom have great titles and travelling expenses. Although the Minister for Health and Children, Deputy Harney, has stated that up to €1 billion must be cut from the health budget, she has refused to deal with the cost of medicine. Can she explain the reason that a drug in a pharmacy north of the Border costs one third or less than the same drug south of the Border? Clear savings of up to €200 million can be made in the HSE with regard to this area alone.
Despite all the high technology that has been available to the HSE for the past 20 years, doctors on call in either a home or their dispensaries cannot get information from an aged person's medical cards. As a result, such an aged person in Monaghan will finish up on a trolley in Cavan General Hospital, if it still is on call, or much further afield. However, had the basic history of the patient been available, a doctor may have been able to prescribe accordingly and save all the hassle. The list of areas in which savings could be made within the HSE is endless but this will require leadership. I assure the Leas-Cheann Comhairle that there would be an enormous change within a very short period under Deputy Reilly. The Dutch and others have shown this to be possible.
As for the farming issue, with proper leadership and new thinking, the Food Harvest 2020 vision outlined by the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Deputy Smith, could become a reality, thereby retaining employment in agriculture and increasing employment in the food industry. We have a green industry of which we should be proud. It is vital that the Minister, Deputy Smith, and the Government recognise the farming industry is just emerging from an horrendous period of low incomes, due to the problems arising on foot of three years of extremely bad weather and prices. Farmers acknowledge that if they earn a reasonable income, they are liable to pay tax like everyone else. However, it is important for such tax to be based on actual income and not on gross output. It is important that the Government should think twice before introducing a property tax or similar measure that would completely undermine any possibility of growth in farming. For instance, in an area such as my constituency of Cavan-Monaghan, many farmers were obliged recently to invest major borrowings to ensure that all cattle were removed from the land during the winter. Such farmers would be much more heavily penalised by a property tax then would some of the farmers in the deep south. The agriculture and forestry sectors are key to the economy and must be supported.
Comment on this
I wish to advise the House that I understand that Deputy O'Mahony will replace Deputy McEntee in this slot. I call Deputy Creed.
Comment on this
There are many indicators that should send a clear signal to all Members that this is not a time for politics as usual. One such indicator to which reference was made repeatedly today is that more than 450,000 people are unemployed and this is the human face of the crisis that Members are attempting to confront. However, another statistic emerged on the news this evening. It is an abstract point with which people have had difficulty in grappling but is of great significance, namely, today the bond markets sought a yield of 6.9% or in other words, the cost for Ireland to borrow money has returned right to its peak. In itself, this is a clear signal that we cannot have politics as usual. The real challenge faced by the country is how to bridge the gap between annual spending of €50 billion and income of €30 billion. This debate is useful regarding the ideas that are put into the mix because unless the bond market can be reassured that Ireland will be able to effectively borrow at sustainable rates in January, it will not be a question of whether we must cut €5 billion or €7 billion. We would be obliged to bridge the entire gap in a single quantum leap, which would not be sustainable for the long-term viability of the economy or when balancing the need for growth with the need to get our fiscal policies correct. Our sovereignty, that is, our capacity to manage our own affairs is at stake, with the IMF at the door waiting to come in. Today I tabled a parliamentary question to the Minister for Finance on what the procedures would be in such an eventuality.
I have heard repeatedly in recent days from absent friends in the Green Party and more recently in tweets from the vanguard in Fianna Fáil about the need for consensus, to stretch the hand across the floor and to have greater co-operation on this national crisis. While I agree with that approach to politics, its cornerstone should not be another Tallaght strategy from Fine Gael. Its cornerstone should be that the same policy that applies to bankers, directors and chief executive officers of banks also applies to the Government in respect of accountability. I could hold my nose and countenance the idea, not of another Tallaght strategy, but of a national approach to government with Fine Gael members taking Cabinet seats. I could do so if I saw real intent on the backbenches of Fianna Fáil to have a palace coup and to tell Deputy Cowen and his cohorts, who have lead us into the mire we are in at present, that it is time to go, that democratic accountability applies to them as much as it does to Mr. FitzPatrick, Mr. Goggin and others in the banking sector, as well as directors. If the Government pursues that line with such individuals, it must apply the same or higher standards to its own members. I take with a grain of salt the tweets and public statements I read and hear on consensus when I do not discern the willingness for a palace coup within Fianna Fáil to have that level of accountability.
Were one to need any reassurance regarding the Government's culpability, one should consider the report by Professor Honohan on the banking crisis in which he states, "in short although international pressures contributed to the timing, intensity and depth of the Irish banking crisis, the essential characteristic of the problem was domestic and classic". He then continues with further evidence which, due to time constraints, I will not go into in greater detail.
Within the one minute that remains to me, I wish to deal with the Croke Park agreement. There has been much talk on the sustainability of that agreement, which obviously is something that comes into sharp focus today. However, one should make haste slowly as far as tearing it up is concerned because it contains much that is good. For example, it refers to how the parties will work together to implement it and how the introduction of new, improved technology service provision, and on-line and electronic fund transfers will be the norm. It also says merit-based competition and promotion policies will be the norm and promises significantly improved performance management across all public service areas. It contains a host of things that we have long advocated for the public service.
The number employed in the public service in 2000 was 247,343. In 2008, there were 319,000. That is an increase of 73,000 in eight years, built substantially on the basis of unsustainable tax revenues from the construction sector. We have a real problem there.
The missing chapter in the Croke Park agreement is any commitment to timelines or targets for savings. A document that is full of good intentions is being thwarted by the heavy hand of unaccountability. People who are charged with its implementation are thwarting the benefits that could accrue. When we are looking for billions in savings there is no commitment to timelines for achieving this. Trade unions and employers, whose interests it serves, would need to wake up to this fact. We need targets for its implementation.
Comment on this
This is a serious debate. I listened intently to every word the Taoiseach had to say this morning. I was extremely disappointed and I will tell the House why. In the last two or three weeks, I had already heard every word he had to say today. I heard nothing new whatever today. With the build-up to this debate, I thought alternatives would be put forward and proposals made, loose though they might be, to raise the necessary tax. We did not get that. We got the same ráiméis we get all the time. The Taoiseach does not seem to be able to get across to the Irish people just how serious this is and what will have to be done.
In the last couple of days the only topic on people's lips is the sum of €15 billion, where it will come from and how it will be raised. We are all agreed that by 2014 our budget deficit must be 3% of GDP. I understand that in the last couple of hours an agency in London has suggested that we may not have any growth at all next year. I do not know where this came from but I am told it is currency around the world at present.
The Taoiseach goes to great lengths to describe any proposal that emanates from the Department of Finance, or wherever else, as a forecast. I did not hear too much about forecasts until lately. Before now, we were told that so much research was put into these matters that what was being said was likely to be the figure that would eventually turn up. We are now told these are forecasts. This brings us to the weather forecasting business. It could be right and it might not be right. Unfortunately, over the last two years the weather forecasts have been terribly wrong.
When I hear of the sum of €15 billion, I have no idea on a personal level whether that will be the figure or not. Unfortunately for most people in the country, I do not think anyone on the Government side of the House knows it either. It is against that background that Irish people are extraordinarily worried about what will happen in the first week of December.
There are so many variables in this matter. If there is average annual growth of 2.75% over four years we are told certain things will happen. What will happen if the growth rate is far less than that? What will happen with the bond holders and the interest rates? I heard the Minister for Tourism, Culture and Sport, Deputy Hanafin, on the radio this morning saying that while €15 billion is a terrible crucifixion on the Irish people we have already taken out €14.5 billion over the last two years. We did not get too many brownie points from the bond holders and bankers throughout the world for the €14.5 billion we took out because, as of this evening I understand the rate has gone up again.
This is a very difficult time for every Irish person. Various sectors must be protected in some shape or form. The Taoiseach mentioned that today. I am talking about the elderly and the disabled. I am also talking about one specific cohort, and I am sure everyone in the House will agree with what I say. They are the young people who bought houses at three times their value. Not alone are they not able to pay back their loans, they are not even able to pay the interest on their loans. Whatever deal is made on 7 December will have to ensure that some help is given to these people. They are hugely important to the country and we will ruin their lives forever if something is not done for them.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this debate. The majority of the 4 million people in this island are not economists or fiscal experts and they are probably fed up hearing about deficits, front-loading, GDPs, GNPs, €5 billion, €30 billion, etc. The only thing they know for certain is that in four weeks time they will face one of the harshest budgets in the history of the State. They are desperate for clarity and certainty as to how the budget will impact on them and their families. Along with that clarity and certainty, they have to be given some hope of a brighter future they can look to with confidence. Instead of clarity, certainty, hope and confidence, PAYE workers, business people and the unemployed are confused and uncertain. Many are in despair and lack any belief in their future.
I will illustrate with an example of a small businessman who telephoned me about two hours ago. He is a sole trader in a village in my constituency who breathed life into that community — I would call it a crossroads — 13 years ago when he opened a small grocery shop, adding to it gradually and sensibly over the years and increasing the number of his employees to 14 people overall. He never reneged on one debt or to any of his suppliers. He had an overdraft facility of €50,000 and facilities for direct debits to be paid to suppliers. At all times, he has been in communication with his bank and has done all the things bankers tell their customers to do. Last week, the overdraft and direct debit facilities were withdrawn without notice. The first he heard of it was when some of his suppliers telephoned him to say they had got a letter from his bank. He contacted his local bank manager, who knows nothing about it. It had been done from headquarters. When contact was made with the decision maker that night, not only did he refuse to explain, he stated that he would sleep easily in his bed that night and accused the man of trying to put him on a guilt trip.
Is that giving hope to that sole trader, all of whose possessions are on the line, even though he is giving employment to 14 people in his local parish and breathing life into his community? Is it any wonder that small business people like him feel a disconnect with what is going on at Government level. I asked if I could use him as an example and promised not to use his name. He said I could give his name if I wished. I will not do so, for obvious reasons. He is willing to come before any committee and explain his case.
The Government has asked for consensus in this House in order to deal with the massive financial crisis. That would be a reasonable request, if the Government would put their hands up and say they got us into this mess. It is also reasonable for that businessman, whose example I have outlined, to look for a consensus approach from his bank on how he can face his problems. It is not acceptable for his bank guru, whom the taxpayer has saved from extinction, to act in such a high-handed and arbitrary manner. How dare he? Perhaps that hard-working shopkeeper would have got a better hearing if he had belonged to a large company that walked away and disowned a few hundred million pounds worth of debt. This is why there is such a disconnect between the people and politics. Let us have a consensus here, forcing the banks to be fair to our small businesses.
We in Fine Gael recognise the need to apply corrective measures sooner rather than later. We have committed to the 3% target for 2014 but the Government must send a clear signal that it is playing to the same rules as the people. That has not happened in the past. The waste and squander mania continues. Parliamentary questions I tabled in recent weeks have revealed that a number of Departments are not observing the job embargo. Twelve Departments paid out almost €70 million in hiring 4,268 agency staff over the past two years. This includes €16 million from the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government but does not include the Department of Health and Children, which was reported to have spent €100 million on agency staff. Is that living by the same rules as the aforementioned businessman? I say "No".
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputies Niall Collins and Michael McGrath.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this debate. It is clear that both sides of the House have reached a consensus that we are in a difficult situation with limited wriggle room. I pay tribute to Opposition Members who are prepared to leave politics to one side and put their shoulder to the wheel to reach agreement on addressing our problems. We owe that to the people we represent. We must develop a coherent policy framework and, even if we do not agree on the specific elements, we will go a long way towards giving confidence to the markets and to those from whom we seek to borrow if we can agree on the broad principles.
I agree with the previous speaker on the necessity to deal with the banks in concise and clear language. There is too much mumbo jumbo in circulation and Government Deputies owe the people an admission that mistakes were made in the past. However, we must also recognise the nature of the advice that was available to us at the time. We cannot dwell in the past or continue to flog ourselves for mistakes that were made in good faith.
We must work together to develop policies that will get us out of our mess. Deputy Connaughton spoke about the projections on which we must base a four year strategy that will give confidence on the market. Clearly projections can be wrong on occasion. The growth levels predicted for this year have not held up but the projections behind them were not picked out of the air to suit the Minister for Finance. They were based on international trends and expected growth in European economies. The global economy has not recovered to the extent we hoped. We should not blame politicians for getting economic forecasts wrong. Forecasts are scientific and are based on certain facts and assumptions.
While our current difficulties are often explained in economic terms, the biggest impact on many of our citizens and their families is the loss of employment. I agree with Deputy Connaughton that the most vulnerable elements of our society are families in which both breadwinners are unemployed. Their lifestyle was supported by single or double incomes and often they owed significant amounts on mortgages and loans. I hope specific measures are introduced in the budget to deal with these families. While those who are on social welfare are certainly in difficult circumstances, many have built lifestyles around their incomes, meagre as they may be, and have been able to support themselves. A similar argument may be made in respect of pensions. If an individual knows how much his or her pension will be, a change of 3% or 4% will not be the end of the world. However, the loss of a significant income can create a crisis for a family. The burden is on the Minister to introduce measures to support such people.
We must create a framework for job creation. I pay tribute to the tremendous efforts of IDA Ireland, Enterprise Ireland, the county enterprise boards, local authorities and the Leader companies in this regard. Improved competitiveness is contributing to job creation, particularly in the export sector, but we must introduce additional measures to get people back to work. Deputy Joe Carey and I have witnessed significant job losses in the Shannon region in recent weeks and we want to see measures that give fresh opportunities to the hardworking people who have lost their jobs.
Comment on this
The straightforward and frank exchange of views in tonight's debate has been very valuable. As public representatives, the feedback we get from people is that they are sick of bickering and populism. The blame game is important because someone must be made accountable. The sooner the ongoing Garda investigation results in people being brought before the courts to answer for the reckless behaviour of our banks, the better. However, there will also be political accountability. Members on this side of the House have accepted responsibility and, as public representatives, we are all accountable at election time. Judgment day comes to all of us, regardless of whether we are in Government or in Opposition.
I was appalled to hear the case outlined by Deputy O'Mahony in respect of the difficulties one of his constituents faced in getting credit. I was also appalled to learn that a mere 20 people made formal applications to the Credit Review Office for a review of credit refusal or reduction. We have a responsibility to make people aware of this independent agency. Last week I received a telephone call from a business person who was coming under heavy pressure from the banks but was not even aware the office existed.
Closing the gap between what we take in and what we spend will require a mixture of taxes and cuts. More importantly, we must encourage growth by stimulating areas of the economy. The National Pensions Reserve Fund can play a vital role in this regard and I would like to see its money being invested in Ireland. Much of the funds is invested in projects based outside the country. We need to invest it internally to have the money in circulation.
We need to see a sustained focus on the sale of some of our State assets. There are many assets that are in State ownership which are huge corporations and we need to expedite the process Mr. Colm McCarthy is examining at present in terms of moving on those assets and offering them to the market. Some of the major international corporations — the world players — will consider taking these off the State's hands for a fair price, which will give the citizen a fair return.
In the meantime, we need to see in the budget a clear focus on the salaries paid to some of the CEOs and senior management within these State organisations. We know of some who are paid a salary three times that of the Taoiseach. Nobody in the civil or public service, or any of the State agencies, should be paid a salary higher than the Taoiseach. Nobody in a Department should be paid a salary which exceeds that of the senior Minister of the Department. We have allowed that situation to pertain. These staff did not come under the pension levy or any of the different reductions in salary that have happened over the years. That sector is getting away scot free and we need a focus on it.
We must have a capital programme and, while it might have to be reduced, I would like more emphasis placed on public private partnerships, a model which has not been utilised enough. We have seen the delivery of some roads, school and hospital projects but we need to roll this out more and break it down into smaller projects and get the model working. The Department of Finance and the National Development Finance Agency are taking years to process these projects. I do not understand why it takes so long to cost a project or a model. We should bring it to delivery and get on with it. We are sitting back and the process is taking years. For example, sewerage schemes are often put into bundles. Six schemes were bundled in my county of Limerick and 15 years later we are still waiting for them to arrive. Why not give them a fast track model, get them out there and get them working?
With regard to the HSE, society wants to see a voluntary early retirement scheme for staff. We know it is a bloated administration. Much good has been done by the HSE, which has improved in many ways. It gets much criticism, which is unfair in that it works better than the old health board structure, but at the same time it is a very big organisation and it needs to be more streamlined. We need to get out that layer of middle management and administration which is not contributing to the overall goal of the HSE.
We need to consider other areas. The tribunals were mentioned on the Order of Business today. Tribunals of inquiry have been operating in this country for more than 15 years. At this stage, whatever they will find is irrelevant or confined to history. They were established by this House and we should have a serious debate about them in this House and work towards shutting them down. It is dead money. What they will tell us, we know already, and they will not inform us further.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to speak in this important debate. It is important to acknowledge that all of the political parties accept the need to reduce the deficit, and the main Opposition parties accept the target of reducing it to 3% by 2014, although the Sinn Féin Party does not subscribe to that view.
We need to acknowledge just how dependent we are, as a country, on Europe for support at present. Our banks are relying almost exclusively on support from the European Central Bank, though I note Bank of Ireland successfully managed to raise some funding on the international markets today. The support of the EU is critical to Ireland's ability to continue to raise funds on bond markets and we can continue to bridge the deficit between income and expenditure with borrowing.
We have to accept that no one owes Ireland a living. At the end of the day, we have to show a commitment across the political system to reduce and over time eliminate the fiscal deficit that has built up. The cost of borrowing, which has crept back up again today to approximately 6.9%, is a crippling level of interest and underlines the scale of the enormous challenge we face, as politicians, in the weeks before the NTMA returns to the bond markets in the new year to raise money to ensure this country can continue to function. Clearly, those interest rates will have to come down because that is not a sustainable cost of borrowing for a sovereign country to pay. It needs to come below 6% and we need to do whatever is required in the coming weeks to convince the international markets of our commitment in that regard.
I want to be as practical as possible in my contribution and will cover some key areas of policy. First, I welcome the recent allocation of funding of €3.3 million for the enterprise boards. However, I was surprised how little money the Government is giving to enterprise boards in general — I understand the €3.3 million was on top of €15 million provided already in 2010. Given the intention is that the €3.3 million will create 450 jobs, that works out at a cost per job of €7,300, whereas if one is paying somebody jobseeker's benefit or allowance, one is paying a single person €10,000 a year. It represents excellent value for the Government to invest a lot more money in the city and county enterprise boards if they are delivering a return of that level of employment. I would like to see a far greater focus and emphasis in that area. Perhaps some of the money invested in the national solidarity bond, which has in the region of €260 million already invested since May, could be diverted to enterprise support across the country. We would benefit from a very significant dividend if we were to do that.
We need to divert as much capital spending as possible next year to labour intensive projects and, rather than focusing on a small number of large iconic projects, we should spread that money across as many individual projects as possible. When one considers the return we are getting from the home energy savings scheme, for example, which is an exceptionally efficient and effective scheme, as well as the housing grants that are made available, such as the adaptation grants for people with disability and the mobility aids for the older person scheme, we get a great return from those investments. If we spread the capital investment across schemes such as those, we will get a far better return in terms of employment and in terms of generating activity in the economy. I firmly believe that if we give people a small incentive to spend money, even if it is only a few hundred euro, they will end up spending multiples of that.
The other major issue I want to touch on is the black economy. My sense is that at present the black economy is thriving in this country. We have to devise a system to capture as much of the activity happening in the black economy as possible. It is impossible to quantify the loss of revenue to the Exchequer by the amount of activity in the black economy but it almost certainly runs into hundreds of millions of euro a year. One idea to tackle this would be for the end customer who can produce a valid VAT receipt for work done to be given a small refund of VAT, which would incentivise more people to ensure the work carried out is done through the system and, as a result, the Exchequer would benefit.
With regard to the Croke Park deal, we need to see real savings, a timeline, deliverables and the objectives being achieved. In general, we will have to aggressively tackle the issue of bureaucracy and red tape, which has become almost an industry in recent years. It is very difficult for anyone with a business idea to get up and running and to tackle all of the bureaucracy and red tape that must be confronted.
I have raised the issue of local authority costs in the House previously. We must be radical in this area and do something really ambitious in regard to local authority rates, water rates and development charges, which are stifling the enterprise culture that is in every community. If we do not get to grips with this, we will not come out of the economic downturn as well as we should. I welcome the very positive report today in regard to exports, which are doing exceptionally well, but we need to focus on stimulating domestic demand. We must try to rebuild consumer confidence and improve consumer sentiment. It is clear a lot of money is being saved and we need to give people targeted and imaginative incentives to spend that money, or at least some of it, such as the car scrappage scheme, which has proven very successful.
The Minister for Social Protection, Deputy Ó Cuív, is seeking to reform the social welfare system. He will have to ensure it is worth people's while to go to work. The reality is that a married couple with two or three children relying completely on welfare would need to be earning approximately €35,000 to €40,000 per year to make working worthwhile. We must ensure that, in whatever we do with taxation and welfare, we do not reduce the gap further between welfare and work and that we incentivise people to go to work. The economy in general will benefit if we do so.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputy Tuffy.
Comment on this
This debate presents a welcome opportunity to consider the economic emergency we face as a society. People are desperately anxious about the burden they face not just in the coming budget, but also for years to come. They are looking for leadership and direction from those charged with running the country.
I took the time to read the Taoiseach's speech closely. I was at a committee meeting when he was delivering it. I regret that there was not much in his speech to inform us as to how the Government intends to lead us out of the mess. The Taoiseach promised us there would be a clear plan but we were none the wiser by the end of his speech as to what plan he has in mind. Instead of offering a plan, the Taoiseach stated: "We must be hopeful, optimistic and energetic, and yet we must be clear-eyed, realistic and thoughtful." This reads like an extract from the Little Book of Calm. Such an entreaty is actually an insult, coming as it does from the man who, as Minister for Finance, led us blindly into a financial sewer largely created by him and his predecessor, Deputy Bertie Ahern. Today, instead of providing clarity, the Taoiseach gave us clichés. The people deserve strategic leadership in these dark times. Surely, if that is not on offer, they deserve decent rhetoric at the very least.
The lack of ideas on the part of the Government is deeply worrying. It has battalions of civil servants, experts and consultants to advise it on the way forward. However, there was nothing concrete in the Taoiseach speech about public finances, job creation or economic stimulus. The Government is clearly past its sell-by date and should be thrown out of office.
In desperation, Ministers and their spin doctors endlessly criticise the Labour Party for not having proposals. Today's debate has shown that, despite our limited research capacity on this side of the House, and the limited information provided to the Labour Party by the Government, there were more clear-eyed, realistic and thoughtful solutions in Deputy Gilmore's is speech than in any speech from the Government side. It is time for the media, in particular, to bury the canard about Labour not having policies and to start scrutinising the paucity of solutions emanating from Government Buildings.
We may be down as a country but we are not out. We have natural resources that can be harnessed to create jobs and get people off welfare. I refer to construction jobs in particular. The first step to recovery, however, must be a general election. A new Government with a mandate from the people will have the energy and drive to do what the current Government is incapable of doing.
We need a fresh start. The severe economic problems will still have to be tackled but the Labour Party in government will work more smartly to resolve them. There are opportunities. Curtailed funding will be a real limitation on future growth but if we change the way in which public policies are delivered, without necessarily spending extra money, we can deliver on growth and jobs. In the energy sector, for example, there are continual complaints about bureaucratic slowness in responding to innovation. The wave and wind sectors, particularly the offshore wind energy sector, are hampered by the lack of a strategic approach and a streamlined planning process. A recent study by the European Wind Energy Association showed that the onshore wind farm developers in Ireland experience average delays in planning of 33 months. They are required to contact, directly or indirectly, 14 governmental or local authorities on average before they can proceed. This is simply unsustainable.
Another renewable resource is geothermal energy. It is also held back by the lack of legislation, despite a promise made by the Minister of State, Deputy Conor Lenihan, that legislation would be published early this year. There is no sign of it yet and I doubt that it will be published until well into next year.
According to Forfás, the global environmental goods and services sector is expected to be worth $800 billion by 2015. This presents real opportunities for the economy to capitalise on the growth of the clean technology sector. In order to reap the benefits of the renewable energy revolution, there must be a co-ordinated, planned approach to maximise potential. We need a new Government but also a smart one.
I was struck by the extent of the measures and proposals made today by the leader of the Labour Party in his speech, but the key must still be job creation. The bulk of people who are unemployed have skills, many in the construction sector. Thousands of them could be put to work immediately if the Government lived up to its own commitments. In his budget speech of 2009, the Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, promised a national retrofit programme. There is still no sign of it although we are now approaching the 2010 budget. Thousands of people could be put to work under such a programme and energy bills would decrease. Energy efficiency would increase in every home, school and hospital if the Government had the drive and focus to deliver on its promises.
If one looks at the record, one will note circumstances are worse than one might imagine. The reality is that the Government could not even spend the money that it allocated for energy efficiency programmes last year. Some €35 million was handed back into the maw of the Department of Finance at the end of 2009 because the Minister for Communications, Energy and Natural Resources, Deputy Ryan, a Green Party Minister, was not up to the job of delivering on his own policy of energy efficiency.
We must ensure that our competitiveness is not hampered by a lack of IT infrastructure. The Minister, Deputy Ryan, promised a one-stop shop to enable the development of fibre connectivity across the country. It does not cost money and only requires Government intent, yet it has not materialised. Broadband speeds are disturbingly poor in large parts of Ireland, that is, in the parts where broadband is actually available. Good regulation, targeted investment and streamlined public processing can make a real difference in the growth of information technology.
All the main parties in the House agreed to the framework for reaching a reduction in our deficit of 3% by 2014. There will be hard decisions to be made but, as Deputy Eamon Gilmore said, they must be the right hard decisions. The first that should be made should be to allow the people to exercise their electoral mandate and choose who will govern them in these challenging times. This is the first stimulus we need to see to ensure we get the good governance, forward thinking and clear plan this country so desperately needs.
Comment on this
Politics should be about progress; that is the whole point. Why are we here only to make things better than they are? For voters, politics is about hope. At least these are what politics should be about. Politics is about optimism and it is an incremental activity. One does not achieve progress overnight but builds on the progress that has been made by our predecessors in the Dáil, Seanad, local authorities and local communities. Now when politics is discussed, the opposite of what I have described is regarded as a virtue.
People receive kudos in respect of the cuts they propose to introduce and the amount of dismantling they promise to do. When Deputy Varadkar announced that he would make €7 billion rather than €4 billion in cuts, he was the hero of the day as far as some members of the press were concerned. That is not the type of political discourse with which I wished to be involved when I became a member of the Labour Party. Politics has become so denigrated and people are so cynical about it because we have forgotten the fact that it is about progress. The latter is the aspect which is absent from the debate.
We are in a bad situation and it is difficult to resist the temptation to be extremely pessimistic about the future. However, progress can be achieved. This has been done in Ireland and other countries in the past. I am of the view that the greatest example in this regard is what the British Labour Party did in 1945. When Britain was in ruins at the end of the Second World War, that party won a landslide victory and went on to establish the National Health Service, NHS, introduce the idea of people making social contributions in order to pay for pensions and set up the comprehensive education system. These developments still stand as a testament to that particular Government and the fact is that the initiatives which brought them about were launched in extremely difficult circumstances.
The debate on ideas which took place in Britain both during and after the Second World War was quite different from that which is occurring in Ireland today. Such a debate did take place in this country in the past. Universal children's allowance was first introduced here in 1943. Ireland was not wealthy at that time and there was rationing of food, etc., but still the progressive move to which I refer was made. The welfare state was established — out of the ruins of two world wars — in very difficult times in Sweden and other Nordic countries. Those examples have stood the test of time.
If, during the Celtic tiger years, we had focused more on politics as a way to make social progress as opposed to any old type of progress, we would have built homes rather than constructed houses which we just do not need. My party and I have a social democratic view of what constitutes progress. However, whether one favours the type of politics espoused by the former Progressive Democrats or by the Labour Party, there is no doubt that all politics should be about progress.
Politics should also be about ideas. I do not refer here to a "Your country, your call" type of approach. A very good article was published in The Sunday Tribune during the summer. Even though it related to politics, the article in question was written by that newspaper’s television critic and focused on the concept of people coming up with an idea that will solve all of our problems. It states:
For some time, we've been encouraged to think like consumers, not citizens (we've been calling the state Ireland Inc for over a decade now). It stands to reason that we might think we could remove our recessionary stains with some form of New Daz idea . . .
There is a need to reinstate the concept that politics is about ideas. One such idea relates to the type of society we might build out of politics. Lately, however, the debate has focused on numbers rather than ideas. Everything now appears to be about sums, subtraction, number crunching and reductionism. The debate appears to be an ideology-free zone but that is not the case. In reality, it is the same old ideology we have had for the past 13 years and which has led us into ruin.
There is a need for a new approach based on old ideas. We must reintroduce the concept of social solidarity to our society. It does not come down to whether some judge or other is being paid child benefit, it is about whether it is good for society to invest in its children. We must focus on the idea that equality is a good thing and that we should do our best, through politics, to bring about equality in society. There is major evidence which shows that citizens — even the wealthy — in societies with more income equality do better over a range of indicators. Those to whom I refer live longer, have better lifestyles and quality of life and enjoy a better environment. In addition, fewer of these people go to prison and there are fewer teenage pregnancies. The societies in question also have better education systems, etc.
Everyone benefits from a public health service. People also benefit from investment in a good education system which takes individuals through from preschool to third level. It does not matter whether we or our children enjoy the upside of such a system. Everyone benefits if a society encourages people to think, develop and create. Some great cross-party ideas have been introduced to Irish society in the past. This could be the case again in the future. However, the current debate features very little ideology. What, for example, is the ideology which underpins what we are doing at present?
The budget should not focus on numbers. Rather, it should focus on the ideology which underpins it and the progress we are intent on achieving. As Deputy Gilmore stated, when the Canadians contemplated this matter, the question they asked related to the type of services they wished to provide. What services do we believe should be part of the public realm and what things should be a matter for the private sector or the markets? Asking this question is the starting point from which the debate on the budget should be launched. It is certainly the point from which the newspapers should start. However, they are not doing so. They are more interested in what cuts people will introduce and what they will dismantle or abolish.
We need to begin to consider the type of society we can build out of that which we possess. Our country has been brought to ruin but politics will extricate us from the mess. In that context, we must contemplate the type of society we wish to construct and the type of health system we want to develop. We must ask ourselves whether we are of the view that we should have a public health system or whether there should there be universal health care. We have been well served by our investment in education. Before it draws up the budget, the Government should consider the amount it is going to invest in education. It should also give consideration to the type of skills it wishes people to learn and the type of training it wants to provide. Instead, the debate is focusing on the amount we intend to cut from the education budget.
The Government appears to believe that there is nothing wrong with people being on the dole. Much of the discourse in the media reflects the same view. It is all about satisfying the markets and then hoping the markets will solve all our problems. Forget about the human side of what it means to be unemployed. I have been unemployed in the past and it is not a good place to be. When I was unemployed, I would much rather have been working for nothing. We must focus our imagination on how we can ensure that there are opportunities for those on social welfare to move into the workforce. This could be done through community employment schemes, graduate placement, the creation of new jobs or whatever. Such considerations must be central to whatever budget is passed by this House.
Unfortunately, it does not appear that the approach I am advocating reflects the thinking of the Government. I read a number of newspaper reports this morning which highlighted the Taoiseach's comments to the effect that the focus is going to be on cuts rather than on changes in taxation. During the Celtic tiger period, it was all about the level to which taxes could be reduced. The same old philosophy is still being adhered to and certain people state that the tax system should not be reformed. Who is the Government afraid of offending by reforming the tax system in order that it brings about more income equality and a fairer society? What is its problem? The more we focus on cuts, the more people will become unemployed and the more those who vote for us to represent them in this House will suffer.
We need to bring back the passion for politics in this House. We must remember that politics is not about numbers or about being the most macho in respect of how much one can cut or the amount of things of which one can get rid. Politics should revolve around making social progress and should focus on the type of society we wish to build. It should also give people hope.
Comment on this
I wish to share time with Deputy McGuinness.
Comment on this
I welcome the opportunity to contribute to this debate. Slowly but surely we are getting some degree of consensus, which is very welcome, although there are still people who want to throw criticism around. That is the nature of politics.
Today I listened to Deputies Enda Kenny and Eamon Gilmore; in his opening remarks to the Taoiseach Deputy Kenny said the days of bluffing are over and Deputy Gilmore argued that today's debate should be about solutions. I fully agree with those sentiments. The time has moved on from bluffing, spoofing and not offering solutions. It was quite ironic that Fionnan Sheehan in the Irish Independent today had a headline which read “Fine Gael’s proposals for savings lack the ring of truth.” He also criticised Deputy Gilmore for speaking out of both sides of his mouth.
We must move on as the country is in a fairly severe crisis. Criticising each other on what happened five years, ten years or 20 years in the past does not achieve anything and certainly does not provide a solution. The public has moved on and wants to hear solutions from this Chamber to the problems which they are experiencing, whether it is with a mortgage, a job or pay. On this side of the House we accept a share of the blame for the mistakes made with tax on property sales. I put on the record my abhorrence of the reckless banking decisions which led to buildings in the middle of nowhere; such decisions were wrong but they should be acknowledged and we should move on. Society expects us to formulate solutions to those problems.
I welcome the commitment given by the Minister for Finance, Deputy Brian Lenihan, that he would give all financial data to all parties, including facts on taxation, employment, etc. I would like to think that on 1 December, all the facts relating to VAT receipts and the self-employed tax receipts which have a deadline at the end of this month will be made available to the Opposition. It can then put forward a realistic four-year plan that we have all agreed with a target of a 3% of GDP deficit by 2014. It should be upfront and the people should be able to see exactly what each party is doing.
This is not just about answering questions from constituents and we must realise that the money men and women in Europe who lend us the €20 billion per year now are watching us. If they are not satisfied that, as a country, we are taking corrective action, they will either increase interest rates or not give us the money. We need that money now.
In returning to a healthy economy we must be innovative in how we consider solutions and job creation. We agree that the tough budgets to come, irrespective of who will be in Government over the next three to four years, must be fair. We all agree that we must protect vulnerable people. I have made the case before and will make it again that we should not cut old age State pensions. That is one group which has put so much into Ireland, people who have worked all their lives, paid their taxes and built up the country.
On the jobs front, having a reasonable capital budget is absolutely vital. I am not being parochial in mentioning metro north, as it not only applies to my constituency of Dublin North but includes all constituencies north of the Liffey, including Meath and south Louth. It is the single biggest contract in Europe currently and I hope and have requested that the Government sanctions the metro north project. I am slightly disappointed in the attitude of Deputy Eamon Gilmore in a recent interview, as he said he would not be in favour of the project now. That is slightly contradictory given that Labour is rightly making the case on jobs, with an unemployment figure of 440,000. This project will create 4,000 jobs directly, and as per the Indecon report prepared for Fingal County Council, it will create another 37,000 jobs indirectly.
This is the single biggest project that would create 4,000 jobs overnight, costing in the order of €3 billion. There would be substantial VAT payments and significant direct employment. It would be of major benefit to the country not just the Dublin North region. We cannot ignore the need to have proper modern infrastructure that a country like Ireland requires. We are one of the few European cities without a rail link to an airport.
On the jobs front, the Government might take cognisance of a delegation that came in here from the Insurance Brokers Association, which made a presentation about using private pension money to put into the Irish economy; there are currently restrictions in legislation in this regard. The Minister for Finance and the Government should give serious consideration to getting every avenue they have available to them in people willing to invest in Irish infrastructure and development.
One of the big problems we have on the jobs issue is the lack of spending. There is over €80 billion saved in personal bank accounts and if only 2.5% of that could be released into the economy, it would amount to €2 billion, which would be a substantial spend in all our local communities. We must come up with innovative ways to make this happen. I do not blame people for not spending as they constantly hear doom and gloom day in and day out. I recommend that the Government consider a voucher scheme in which the Government and retailers would put forward €10 each for every €100 spent by a consumer. This would be a great fillip for consumers, who never look good value in the mouth.
The car scrappage scheme introduced this year has proved a point as motor sales have increased by over 60%. This does not simply apply to cars over ten years old, and through good marketing and innovation on the part of the motor industry, people have changed their cars. There has been a significant uptake in car sales this year as a result. I believe that the voucher scheme I propose, with €20 from the Government and retailers for €100 spent by shoppers, would be self-financing. It is something I hope will be considered.
I have always felt the €10 travel tax was a reasonable proposal by the Government and it is taking in over €120 million. At this stage I would call Michael O'Leary's bluff and give him the incentive to bring millions of passengers to the country, along with Aer Lingus and other airlines, by dropping it. We must get to grips with the significant pay packets in our semi-State bodies, the political arena and in the Judiciary, which I have mentioned before. Only 75% of judges pay the levy, which is unacceptable in this day and age. We must all play our part and show leadership.
We have heard much about the Government getting forecasts wrong. I read a report yesterday indicating that the OECD advised President Obama that there would be a 3.2% growth rate in the US this year but that has been revised down to 2.6%. Ireland is not the only country getting forecasts wrong.
Comment on this
I welcome the debate, although it is about three years too late. We seem to be rehashing what has gone on in the economy and what we are prepared to do in the forthcoming four-year plan. The only reason we are at this point is that the IMF, the European Central Bank and many others in Europe are now dictating the trend of play in Ireland and they, along with Germany, are demanding that we do this and enforce this austerity package in the budget if we are to get things right or be credible as a country. We need to focus on what we want as a country and as political parties.
I have listened carefully to this debate and while I was impressed by what people said, I question the commitment of political parties to enter into the type of reform that is necessary in the context of correcting the fiscal position from 2011-14. That is the real challenge with this House, namely, to connect the brains of the House to some sort of political backbone to make the decision. However, political backbone has been absent, not only in this debate but in the context of the decisions which have been taken up to now. People were confronted with this problem three years ago. It did not just happen today. It did not just happen with the banks. Prior to that was a huge downturn in terms of how business was being conducted, the volume of business and particularly the small and medium enterprise sector.
It down-sized, and got on with it, and what we did here, as a Government and an Opposition, was talk about it and did very little. The same thing is happening today. Sometime in 2009, Mr. Colm McCarthy delivered his report on what should be done and set out quite clearly that the game was up and we needed to have the reforms which were necessary to make this country get back to work again, create efficiencies and cost effectiveness and give value for money to the taxpayer. Nothing has happened
The Croke Park deal was signed and very little has happened in any Department. If we want to get real value for money and get people back to work we need to have a back office or public service which is the envy of Europe, that is efficient, that is streamlined and that is delivering on a daily basis for this country. That requires real public sector reform. I am not talking of doctors, nurses, gardaí or those on the front line because when I raised this question in 2008 the Labour Party jumped on it and said I was piling pressure on the lower paid in the civil and public sectors. That is not my position. I would protect those people.
However, I ask the middle and senior managers what they are doing to implement the Croke Park deal and from where the €1 billion in savings will come, because not one cent has been saved since the deal was signed. If we are to be real in this debate while protecting lower paid workers, with which I agree, we must recognise that the greater part of the deal is simply not workable or sustainable. It was agreed at a time when the economy was not facing the type of downtown or measures which we now propose to bring our fiscal position back into line. We need to consider it.
I was delighted to read today that the Minister for Finance is looking for a greater reform package in the public sector reform part of the Croke Park deal. If we do not get it immediately, as every other business is getting from its enterprise, then we will simply want more from the taxpayer. What is happening regarding the taxpayer? We are getting the Revenue Commissioners to collect taxes and squeeze everyone in terms of what they owe it, and we are then handing that money over to the soft centre which is spending it on what, having looked at the Committee of Public Accounts, are outrageous inefficiencies in the State.
There is poor value for money and it is giving this House a bad name in how we govern this country. We have to correct that or we are not correctly serving the people that we represent and we are not bringing in the reforms necessary to save the kind of money we want. We need to examine governance and ask ourselves what senior civil servants are doing. That little group, comprising 600, managed to exempt itself from the levies last year when push came to shove. That is not leadership. How much is it getting and is it giving value for money? What decisions is it taking? What management skills does it have? How is it pressing for reform? They are the questions we need to ask in what needs to be done in terms of the governance of the country. This is central to the recovery of Ireland. Such staff will be the drivers of the country regardless of what political party is in power. We have had umpteen reports stating 2,000 to 6,000 people are surplus to requirement in the management of the HSE. The report compiled by Colm McCarthy, who has done a service to the State, detailed the savings that can be made and nothing has happened. How much of that money could have been channelled to front line workers, patients or clients of the services to make things better for our citizens? They could have received much more than they got until now. This is about the Government implementing political policies agreed by the people, driven by the Secretaries General of every Department. If they are not up to the job then we should get somebody else. I have examined the recruitment of those people and I found that there are very few, if any, who have been taken directly into positions from the private sector. If one looks at the implementation body of the Croke Park deal one will find the taxpayer is not represented. I find that remiss, in terms of how we deal with the sector.
In terms of business, most speakers in this debate have said that the small business sector will take us out of the economic crisis we are in. It employed 800,000 people at one stage, a figure which has now dropped significantly. It has cut its costs to a minimum. The owners of small firms and businesses work 24 hours a day, seven days a week just to keep their doors open. The one cost which has not reduced is the cost of doing business here. Businesses are strangled with red tape and bureaucracy. The costs of local authority rates should be cut by 25% this year, which would certainly force efficiencies in the delivery of local government. Planning fees and charges should be examined to enable anyone who is willing to take a risk to get planning permission sorted out at real value.
The cost of doing business has not reduced in the State even though the reports from ISME and other national representative bodies of business state that the only cost which has not been touched has been the cost of local government and national Government. That, in a time of crisis, is nothing short of a disgrace. The Government could easily make the decision and make it happen. In terms of job creation we should look to nuclear energy and other forms of energy. I note the Minister, Deputy Gormley, dealt with Poolbeg. One talks about political correctness. He should have stood back from the issue. It was in his constituency. We should have examined the issue in the context of job creation and what could be done for Ireland but that did not happen.
My message is that it cannot be "business as usual". We have to take political decisions and risks in the context of those decisions. We can get advice but we need to follow it. We can look to county enterprise boards and Enterprise Ireland. I find it hard to stomach that the Government would say it is reviewing the role of county enterprise boards. I do not mind reviewing the efficiencies within the boards but it should pump money into county enterprise boards to improve local economies, give businesses that are in trouble a different focus and direction and be involved in mentoring. It need not necessarily involve a grant; it could involve financial assistance of some kind. Enterprise Ireland should be supported and put out into the markets of the world 24 hours a day, seven days a week with Government support, to ensure that people who are doing business abroad can do more to sustain the jobs which they are creating at home.
On NERA and the minimum wage, we need to examine the entire area. NERA is closing down small businesses up and down the country. It cannot cope with the red tape. I listened to Deputy Tuffy who said it would be better to work for nothing rather than be unemployed. I am not attacking the minimum wage; I am simply saying that there has to be an economic basis for the value we put on it in the context of where we currently stand as a country.